Customer Experience Capability Maturity Assessment for the Contact Centre Industry in Malaysia CCAM CX Summit 2016 Presenter Bijuraj Sarangi Principal Consultant – Lead Customer Experience Frost & Sullivan, APAC 23rd November 2016 Objective and Approach Strategic Imperative and Objective of the Assessment Strategic Imperative for customer experience maturity assessment for contact center organizations? • Contact centres have become epicentre of all types of customer interaction channels • Contact centre plays a strong role in integrating and aligning organization’s marketing, sales and service capabilities Customer Experience Journey Discover Exit/ Retained Contact Center Decide Objective • To assess the customer experience maturity level of contact center organizations in Malaysia using Frost & Sullivan’s proprietary maturity model and diagnostic framework. • The assessment aims to provide the current maturity level of contact centers across 14 capability areas that can be assessed on an on-going basis to drive improvements in customer experience capabilities. Complaint Buy Get Service Pay Frost & Sullivan believes that small changes in the way organizations operate and offer services can make big impacts on end customer experience 3 Scope of the Assessment The assessment was designed with 30 Critical Success Factors (CSFs) identified across people, process, technology and organization alignment areas to gauge maturity level of customer experience capabilities for the industry as well as across organizations. Carefully selected from Frost & Sullivan proprietary CX maturity model, these 30 CSFs correspond to 14 CX capability areas for contact center organizations. Core Customer Experience Enablers Customer Centricity Enablers 1 Customer Experience Design 9 Operation Function Alignment 2 Customer Process Enablement 10 Customer Support Alignment 3 Customer Service Technology 11 Human Resource Alignment 4 People Enablement 12 IT Function Alignment 5 Service Excellence & Continuous Improvement 13 Culture Alignment 6 Customer Management 14 Brand Alignment 7 Service Performance Management 8 Customer Feedback Management 4 Participant Industries Industry No of participant organizations Banking 7 Consumer Goods and Services 3 Insurance 7 Transportation 3 IT, Services and Outsourcing 10 Utilities and Public Sector 3 Ecommerce 3 Telecommunication 2 Hospitality 1 Pharmaceutical 1 Total 40 5 Approach Maturity assessment framework used for analysis is built using Frost & Sullivan proprietary Customer Experience maturity framework which is a comprehensive framework covering both core customer experience enablers and customer centricity elements in an organization Define Core CX Capabilities CX Functions Organization Alignment Design Deliver Discover Customer Journey Mapping Customer Process Enablement Service Operations Management Service Performance Management Customer Experience Design Customer Service Technology Service Excellence and Continuous Improvement Customer Feedback Management Comparative Service Differentiation People Enablement Customer Management Service Partner Management Marketing Sales Customer Support Operation Leadership Human Resource IT Culture Brand A four step approach undertaken to complete the exercise across 40 companies in 10 different industries 4 Weeks 1 2 3 4 Participant Identification CX Assessment Area Identification Maturity Assessment and Analysis Organization and Industry Maturity Reporting 6 Frost & Sullivan Customer Experience Maturity Model Moving from traditional to digital channels Traditional channels in place Customer engagement is shared responsibility No idea about CXM Customer engagement is partially proactive Dedicated CE function Basic G 1 Connected systems. Unified technology/ process experience Advanced Evolving 2 No Exposure Limited digital presence 3 CE is a business objective and growth agenda Aligned Organization and processes Digital presence with cross channel capability Unified customer experience (360 degree customer view) Leading 4 Customer analytics drives customer strategy Omni channel capability Customer selfhelp enabled (moving towards zero contact) Unified Customer Experience Alignment to Business Objectives Do you know where you are? Next Gen 5 Integrated and connected smart systems NBA enabled services Customer experience is the culture Customer Centricity 7 An effective contact centre operating framework helps companies inch a step closer to end customers and enable desired experience Customer Interaction Journey Channels Pre Purchase Phone Operation Structure Or Process Structure Post Purchase Purchase IVR SMS Website Web-chat Social Media Email Fax Command Center Incident Management Scheduling Query/ Complaint Management Problem Management Capacity Planning Escalation Management Staff Management Technology Shared Services Or Functions People ACD Campaign Management IVR/VP Quality Front Line Representatives CTI CRM HR IT Support Staff Agent Desktops BPM Systems Operation Leadership 8 Executive Summary Frost & Sullivan assessment positions the Malaysian Contact Center industry at an Advanced Stage on the customer experience maturity curve As per Frost & Sullivan Customer Experience maturity analysis, the contact center Industry is placed at an advanced stage with well-connected and synchronized backend and frontend processes, clear visibility into service performance management and increased focus on customer feedback driven service enablement. However, partial use of digital capabilities for customer engagement, scope for improvement in customer experience design across touch points and unavailability of a 360 degree view in to customer interactions and intentions are some of the key bottlenecks that the industry need to address to move to the next level of maturity No Exposure Basic Evolving Advanced Leading Next Gen Industry CX Capability 10 Cross Industry Customer Experience Capability Maturity No Exposure Basic Evolving Advanced Leading Next Gen Banking Consumer Goods & Services Insurance Transportation IT Services and Outsourcing Utilities and Public Sector E-Commerce Telecommunication Hospitality Pharmaceuticals 11 Customer Experience Industry Heat Map Highlights The Gaps Across Core Customer Experience Enablers Across Industries Core Customer Industry Experience Enablers IT Consum Utilities Services ETelecom er Insuranc Transport and Hospitali Pharmac Banking and Commer municati Goods & e ation Public ty eutical Outsour ce on Services Sector cing Customer Experience Design Customer Process Enablement Customer Service Technology People Enablement Service Excellence & CI Customer Management Service Performance Management Customer Feedback Management 12 Although, the industry has started leveraging digital capabilities, there are still significant gaps in enabling customer preferred interaction medium and service capabilities with desired functional and technical features 1 45% Customer Experience Design 33% Customer Process Enablement 33% 37% People Enablement Service Excellence & CI 11% Service Performance Management Customer Feedback Management 28% 11% 37% 40% Customer Management 17% 17% 14% 92% 11% 2 of organizations believe they still have a lot to do to enable the right interaction channels with right capabilities for the right customers and 45% significantly lack in self service and cross channel capabilities 33% 61% Customer Service Technology 8% 1 47% 37% 14% 40% 11% 43% 40% 31% 37% Need Significant Improvement Need Improvement Doing Good Doing Great 11% 6% 26% 17% 2 89% believe they need to improve their customer engagement technology platform including both customer facing and backend operation technologies, 61% of which requires significant improvement 13 Moreover, enabling customer management capabilities that can provide a complete view into customer segments and their interaction patterns for better decision making requires improvement 45% Customer Experience Design 33% Customer Process Enablement 33% 37% People Enablement 11% Service Performance Management Customer Feedback Management 28% 11% 37% 37% 40% 40% Customer Management 17% 17% 14% 8% 33% 61% Customer Service Technology Service Excellence & CI 47% 43% 40% 31% 37% Need Significant Improvement Need Improvement Doing Good Doing Great 11% 3 83% of organizations believe their existing capability to enable a 360 degree view of customer 11% engagement requires improvement and 40% have 11% 6% 3 fragmented or no visibility into customer interactions with little 26% scope to align and derive insights out 14% 17% 14 Customer Centricity Enablers Heat Map Highlights The Gap Across Industries Core Customer Centricity Enablers Industry IT Consum Utilities Services ETelecom er Insuranc Transport and Hospitali Pharmac Banking and Commer municati Goods & e ation Public ty eutical Outsour ce on Services Sector cing Operation Function Alignment Customer Support Function Alignment HR Alignment IT Function Alignment Culture Alignment Brand Alignment 15 Challenges in internal functions, processes and brand promise alignment to customer requirements is a key bottleneck for enabling customer centricity 1 29% Operation Function Alignment Customer Support Function Alignment 18% 29% 50% 32% HR Function Alignment IT Function Alignment 34% 17% 31% 9% 24% Brand Alignment 28% 44% 9% 43% 9% 41% 17% 2 15% 18% 15% Culture Alignment 9% 42% 1 14% of organizations believe there are limitations from a technology and process perspective that hinders alignment between operation functions, while about 30% see scope for significant improvement 2 26% 3 Need Improvement Doing Good Doing Great 32% feel their hiring process may be able to address any skill or resource fitment needs, however, they are not sure about it 3 Need Significant Improvement 63% 28% believe there is no consistency in the experience offered and hence keeping brand promise is a challenge 16 … having said that, organizations to a certain extent have been able to imbibe a customer experience culture within organizations which is further bolstered by improved visibility into service performance 68% of organizations believe they have been 66% of organizations believe they are able to able to drive a customer experience culture track their service performance end to end and within their organization have a clear visibility into poor performing areas Customer experience is driven as a core value within the organization End to end service performance reporting through KPIs/ Scorecards and Dashboards CX is an enterprise agenda driven at the highest level by leadership Different performance measures for different levels – taking care of the operation and strategic reporting needs When it comes to organizational decision making, customer is the priority Automated online reporting and dashboards customized view for different stakeholders at different levels. 17 Industry Wise Customer Experience Strengths and Weaknesses Industries Strengths Weaknesses Banking 1. KPIs and scorecard based matrices, performance reporting 2. Employees alignment to organization CX program 1. Effective IVR, CRM and allied channel capabilities 2. Employee satisfaction measurement Consumer Goods & Services 1. Highly responsive internal service desks keeping systems up and running 2. A good mix of digital and non digital channels in play 1. Cross channel capabilities 2. Uniform and consistent information sharing across channels 3. Omni-channel capabilities Insurance 1. Cross functional complaint management process 2. KPIs and scorecard based matrices, performance reporting 1. Analytics driven differentiated experience for different customer segments 2. Employee empowerment through right tools, process and decision making Transportation 1. Advanced analytics driven 360 degree customer view 2. Employee empowerment through right tools, process and decision making 1. Effective CTI capabilities and gaps in voice and data sharing across systems 2. Usage of IVR for self service and contact deflection IT Services and Outsourcing 1. Quality management through advanced tools and solutions 2. Organization wide continuous improvement programs through six sigma, lean and TQM 1. Digital presence across touch points 2. Effective CRM solution to enable a 360 degree view of customers 18 Industry Wise Customer Experience Strengths and Weaknesses Industries Strengths Weaknesses Utilities and Public Sector 1. Quality, workflow and knowledge management processes 1. Cross and multi channel capabilities 2. Digital presence across touch points E-Commerce 1. Customer collaboration and feedback usage 2. Employees alignment to organization CX program 1. Analytics driven differentiated experience for different customer segments 2. Proactive customer connects and intimations Telecommunication 1. Self service capabilities across touch points 2. Appropriate channel capabilities across digital and non-digital platforms 1. Effective CRM solution to enable a 360 degree view of customers 2. Cross/Omni channel capabilities Hospitality 1. Uniformity in formation sharing as well as digital presence 2. Cross functional process and alignment of backend and frontend operations 1. Appropriate self service and human assistance services across channels 2. Effective IVR, CRM and allied channel capabilities Pharmaceuticals 1. Uniformity and consistency in formation sharing 2. Organization wide continuous improvement programs through six sigma, lean and TQM 1. Effective IVR, CTI and allied technology solutions 2. Proactive customer connects and intimations 19 CX Capability Maturity Maturity Level of Customer Experience Enablers No Exposure Basic Evolving Advanced Leading Next Gen Customer Experience Design Customer Process Enablement Customer Service Technology People Enablement Service Excellence & CI Customer Management Service Performance Management Customer Feedback Management 21 Maturity Level of Customer Centricity Enablers No Exposure Basic Evolving Advanced Leading Next Gen Operation Function Alignment Customer Support Alignment HR Function Alignment IT Function Alignment Culture Alignment Brand Alignment 22 Customer experience design is at an Evolving stage and needs significant improvement in terms how the customer experience journey is designed across different touch points No Exposure Basic Evolving Advanced Leading Next Gen Customer Experience Design Enabling cross/multi-channel capability, digital presence and customer interaction and self service capabilities represent the top three areas of improvement. While analytics driven differentiated experience is an area where the industry still needs to kick off its presence. 76% 70% 47% 33% of organizations need to enhance their self service offerings - largely dependent on agent assistance for customer interaction of organizations yet to enable an analytics driven differentiated experience for their customers of organizations need to build cross channel capabilities across touch points (only an 11% have initiated some measures) of organizations do not have digital customer engagement capabilities enabled on the ground 23 Pharmaceutical industry displays highest gap in customer experience design followed by Consumer Goods & Services and E-Commerce CX Capability Critical Success Factors Self service capability Core Customer Industry Experience Enablers Cross/ Multichannel Capability Customer Experience Design Differentiated customer experience Uniformity in information shared Digital customer interaction IT Consum Utilities Services ETelecom er Insuranc Transport and Hospitali Pharmac Banking and Commer municati Goods & e ation Public ty eutical Outsour ce on Services Sector cing Self service capability Cross/Multi channel capability Differentiated service experience Uniformity in information shared Digital customer interaction 24 Customer process enablement is at an Advanced as organizations are putting efforts to strengthen internal operation as well as external customer facing processes No Exposure Basic Evolving Advanced Leading Next Gen Customer Process Enablement The industry is doing relatively good in terms of streamlining operation and customer facing processes. Organizations have increased focus on strengthening quality management, workflow and escalation management and complaint management processes. Customer intimations and knowledge creation and management are few areas which still needs significant improvement. 33% 14% 11% Organizations do not have an incident management capability in place and hence struggle to manage incidents Do not have a defined customer intimation process in place and are very much reactive in information sharing Do not have a concept of knowledge creation and sharing. No knowledge repository, process/templates/ methods in place 25 Consumer Goods & Services industry displays highest gap in customer process enablement followed by Pharmaceutical, Transportation and Hospitality CX Capability Critical Success Factors Capability Area Quality Management Industry Knowledge Management Customer Process Enablement Workflow Management Complaint Management Customer Intimations IT Consum Utilities Services ETelecom er Insuranc Transpo and Hospitali Pharmac Banking and Commer municati Goods & e rtation Public ty eutical Outsour ce on Services Sector cing Quality management Knowledge management Workflow management Complaint management Customer Intimations 26 Customer service technology is placed at an Advanced stage and needs significant improvement in terms enablement of basic technology solutions including CTI and CRM No Exposure Basic Evolving Advanced Leading Next Gen Customer Service Technology Many organizations in the industry are in the process of identifying right technology solutions for their operation requirements as well as for customer engagement improvement, however, much more on the ground is yet to be achieved from an implementation perspective. Need for effective CRM, IVR and CTI solution are on top of the technology requirements of the industry. 63% 63% 62% 57% Organizations still have DTMF based IVR application with legacy systems, speech recognition enabled to a certain extent with cumbersome and heavy menus Organizations do not have an integrated agent desktop that can help improve agent productivity and operational efficiency of organizations need to revisit their computer telephony integration (CTI) technologies to enable smooth flow of voice and data of organizations still struggling with legacy CRM solutions. About 14% do not even have a true CRM solution implemented 27 Transportation Industry Displays Highest Gap in Customer Service Technology Followed by Consumer Goods & Services and Hospitality CX Capability Critical Success Factors Capability Area Building channel capabilities Industry Effective CRM solution Customer Service Technology Integrated agent applications Effective IVR solution Voice and data paths (CTI) IT Consum Utilities Services ETelecom er Insuranc Transpo and Hospitali Pharmac Banking and Commer municati Goods & e rtation Public ty eutical Outsour ce on Services Sector cing Building appropriate channel capabilities Effective CRM solution Integrated agent applications Effective IVR solution System enablement for voice and data paths 28 People Enablement is placed at an Advanced Stage as Employee Empowerment is Improving Across Industries No Exposure Basic Evolving Advanced Leading Next Gen People Enablement Capability Area 66% 31% Of organizations need to improve decision making capability of their workforce at different levels Of organizations do not measure or track employee satisfaction levels regularly Industry IT Consum Utilities Services ETelecom er Goods Insuranc Transpor and Hospitali Pharmac Banking and Commer municati & e tation Public ty eutical Outsourc ce on Services Sector ing Employee empowerment Employee satisfaction measurement 29 Continuous improvement is placed at an Advanced stage of maturity owing to increasing adoption of it by organizations as an enterprise wide program to improve customer experience No Exposure Basic Evolving Advanced Leading Next Gen Service Excellence and CI 51% 37% Of organizations have implemented enterprise wide continuous improvement strategies such as Six Sigma, lean, and TQM. These are not only mandated but also incentivized through recognition and rewards Drive continuous improvements across different functions in silo, an organization wide continuous improvement framework is still missing Capability Area Industry IT Consum Utilities Services ETelecom er Goods Insuranc Transpor and Hospitali Pharmac Banking and Commer municati & e tation Public ty eutical Outsourc ce on Services Sector ing Continuous Improvement 30 Customer management is placed at an Evolving stage as many industry players despite of efforts in technology and process improvements are struggling to obtain an end to end visibility into customer engagement No Exposure Basic Evolving Advanced Leading Next Gen Customer Management 43 % 40% Organizations have been able to implement right technologies and processes. However, there are gaps in implementation which is hindering that 360 degree view of customer engagement Organizations have fragmented or no visibility into customer interactions and engagements with little scope to align and derive insights out. About 9% have no visibility at all! Capability Area Industry IT Consum Utilities Services ETelecom er Goods Insuranc Transpor and Hospitali Pharmac Banking and Commer municati & e tation Public ty eutical Outsourc ce on Services Sector ing 360 degree customer view 31 Service performance management is placed at a Leading stage owing to a large number of industry players measuring and monitoring their performance through well defined KPIs and matrices No Exposure Basic Evolving Advanced Leading Next Gen Service Performance Management 68% 34% Organizations have implemented prioritized KPIs and scorecard based matrices with focus on key result areas which is able to provide true picture of business performance at different levels Organizations are still dependent on manual and partially automated reporting processes and dashboards Capability Area Industry IT Consum Utilities Services ETelecom er Goods Insuranc Transpor and Hospitali Pharmac Banking and Commer municati & e tation Public ty eutical Outsourc ce on Services Sector ing KPIs and Matrices Performance reporting and dashboards 32 Customer feedback Management is Placed at a Leading Stage as Organizations are Using Customer Feedbacks to a Great Extent to Optimize their Plans and Develop New Initiatives No Exposure Basic Evolving Advanced Leading Next Gen Customer Feedback Management 54% 31% Organizations are leveraging customer feedback to identify pain points in processes and systems and are able to derive meaningful and actionable insights for strategic initiatives Organizations leverage customer feedbacks but do not close loop with customers on their feedback implementation Capability Area Industry IT Consum Utilities Services ETelecom er Goods Insuranc Transpor and Hospitali Pharmac Banking and Commer municati & e tation Public ty eutical Outsourc ce on Services Sector ing Customer feedback usage 33 Operation function alignment is placed at an Advanced stage as a large number of organizations have either already enabled cross functional process capabilities or are in the process of enabling the same No Exposure Basic Evolving Advanced Leading Next Gen Operation Function Alignment 63 % 29% Organizations have enabled cross functional processes to link frontend and backend operations which in a way reduces or eliminates function/ business unit specific roadblocks Organizations believe they haven’t been able to enable cross functional processes to the required extent and hence encounter process execution challenges Capability Area Industry IT Consum Utilities Services ETelecom er Goods Insuranc Transpor and Hospitali Pharmac Banking and Commer municati & e tation Public ty eutical Outsourc ce on Services Sector ing Alignment of backend processes to frontend 34 Customer support function alignment is placed at an Advanced stage as larger section of the industry is putting efforts into workforce skill and competency enhancement on multiple fronts No Exposure Basic Evolving Advanced Leading Next Gen Customer Support Function Alignment 32 % Organizations are building their customer support function competencies by enhancing customer service attitude through simulation based trainings, user scenario workshops, eLearning, class rooms etc. Capability Area Industry 50% Organizations are planning to bring in more programs focusing on service attitude enhancement, however, are resorting to only soft skill improvement for the time being IT Consum Utilities Services ETelecom er Goods Insuranc Transpor and Hospitali Pharmac Banking and Commer municati & e tation Public ty eutical Outsourc ce on Services Sector ing Building customer service attitude 35 HR function alignment is placed at an Advanced stage owing to majority of the organizations clearly defining their customer engagement roles at different levels to ensure minimal or no skill mismatch No Exposure Basic Evolving Advanced Leading Next Gen HR Function Alignment 53 % 29% Organizations have clearly defined processes and frameworks in place to ensure skill fitment for new hire and existing workforce which reduces avenues for skill mismatch Organizations do not have clearly defined job descriptions for customer engagement roles and hence leaving gaps in the hiring process that can lead to skill mismatch Capability Area Industry IT Consum Utilities Services ETelecom er Goods Insuranc Transpor and Hospitali Pharmac Banking and Commer municati & e tation Public ty eutical Outsourc ce on Services Sector ing Customer engagement skill fitment 36 IT function alignment is placed at an Advanced stage owing to majority of the organizations clearly defining their customer engagement roles at different levels to ensure minimal or no skill mismatch No Exposure Basic Evolving Advanced Leading Next Gen IT Function Alignment 74% 44% Organizations have implemented service desks that is responsive all the time and is managed by service desk managers through real time latest tools and technologies Organizations have cross functional workflows in place driven primarily through technology to enable a smooth service work flow. While 41% are in the process of enabling cross functional workflows Capability Area Industry IT Consum Utilities Services ETelecom er Goods Insuranc Transpor and Hospitali Pharmac Banking and Commer municati & e tation Public ty eutical Outsourc ce on Services Sector ing Managing service desk responsiveness IT service workflow enablement 37 Culture alignment is placed at a Leading stage owing to a large section of the industry driving customer experience as an organization value and shared goal No Exposure Basic Evolving Advanced Leading Next Gen Culture Alignment 68% 68% Organizations drive customer experience as a core value and is being strongly driven by organization leadership. Customer are the top priorities across functions and roles Organizations have developed a compelling brand and employee proposition and are able to attract employees to the organizational philosophy. Employees are also cognizant of the fact that they are contributing even at individual levels to the broader goals Capability Area Industry IT Consum Utilities Services ETelecom er Goods Insuranc Transpor and Hospitali Pharmac Banking and Commer municati & e tation Public ty eutical Outsourc ce on Services Sector ing Customer experience culture Shared objective or goals 38 Brand alignment is placed at an Advanced stage as organizations have started building capabilities to bridge the gap between brand promise and experience delivered No Exposure Basic Evolving Advanced Leading Next Gen Brand Alignment 42 % Organizations have defined a customer preference drive customer experience journey which defines a differentiated brand identity and aligns brand promise to experience offered Capability Area Industry 28% Organizations do not exhibit consistency in the experience offered to end customers owing to gap in brand promise and experience offered IT Consum Utilities Services ETelecom er Goods Insuranc Transpor and Hospitali Pharmac Banking and Commer municati & e tation Public ty eutical Outsourc ce on Services Sector ing Brand alignment to experience offered 39 Key Opportunities for Improvement Customer experience being a very important differentiator in the industry, organizations would require to enable required and relevant capabilities to push themselves to the leading and next generation maturity levels [1/2] Enable self service capabilities across interaction channels, especially leveraging more of IVR service Enable cross and omni-channel capabilities for customer interaction Improve digital presence and increase digital customer engagement Optimize customer experience technologies that can enhance operational efficiency and improve customer visibility 41 Customer experience being a very important differentiator in the industry, organizations would require to enable required and relevant capabilities to push themselves to the leading and next generation maturity levels [1/2] Increase customer connect and collaboration [Need to leverage more of digital platforms] Implement customer analytics driven experience strategies for different customer segments Improve employee engagement to drive employee satisfaction and keep tracking and improving the same – “A happy employee can deliver a happy experience” 42 Thank You! “ Managing customer experience is as simple as managing the gap between what organizations offer and what customers perceive - smaller the gap, better the experience! ” Frost & Sullivan, the Growth Partnership Company, works in collaboration with clients to leverage visionary innovation that addresses the global challenges and related growth opportunities that will make or break today’s market participants. For more than 50 years, we have been developing growth strategies for the Global 1000, emerging businesses, the public sector and the investment community. Is your organization prepared for the next profound wave of industry convergence, disruptive technologies, increasing competitive intensity, Mega Trends, breakthrough best practices, changing customer dynamics and emerging economies? Contact Us: Start the Discussion www.frost.com
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz