Carl Van the Vechten Harlem The : His Role Renaissance Literary Salon----Hisao It is difficult to accurately :alias the :ment but an extraordinarily with define the Negro Renaissance, Harlem in Kishimoto so called Harlem Renaissance, because it was not merely a literary moveexciting general cultural movement as it center. The Harlem Renaissance :from many points of view, but basically, that arose can be approached a conglomeration of six factors are responsible for its emergence : the Negro vogue in the world ; second, the birth of a black intelligentsia ; third, the Great Migration and World vVar I ; fourth, the New Negro Movement ; fifth, the Jazz Age; and sixth, the relationship between black and white intellectuals. Considering the American social conditions before 1920, relationship -bet ween black and white intellectuals were rare. By 1920, however, these _relationships had changed and expanded :.seriously and sympathetically ras Eugene O'Neill's Emperor Wings (1924) ; Waldo Frank's and naturally, white writers described the black situation in such works Jones (1920) and All God's Chillum Holiday (1923) ; Dubose Heyward's Got Porgy <1925) ; Carl Van Vechten's Nigger Heaven (1926) ; and E.C.L. Adams' ,Congaree Sketches (1927) and Nigger to Nigger (1928) . Thus, closer and more expansive relations between black and white intellectuals were formed. George S. Schuyler, the author of Black No More (1931), was a disciple -~- 67 --- of H. L. Mencken, and his writing reflected his literary debt to that impor-tant literary McKay, a prominent terrible," erator personage. made The Jamaican-born figure in the Harlem a lot of friends Zora Neale Hurston of the Harlem Renaissance, mentioned; role. at Home (1937). in that there During he associated._ have been only a few- home and abraod, especially, from theIn the general only his name and novel, Quite recently, . however, Lib- and assisted them. Renaissance. no one paid much the New Negro" with the A Long Way from until the present essays on Carl Van Vechten Harlem Claude_. called "l'enf ant; his association role was unique of black intellectuals It is safe to say that viewpoint novelist, owed not a few white persons a great deal. these days, Carl Van Vechten's with a multitude Renaissance. through according to his autobiography, poet and studies Nigger on the- Heaven, were attention or devoted much space to his, two essays, "Carl Van Vechten Presents. in Studies in the Literary Imagination (Georgia State- University, 1974) by Leon Coleman and "Carl Van Vechten and the Harlem. Renaissance" in Negro American bling, were published. portance; Literature Forum These recent essays testify to Van Vechten's and paticularly from the viewpoint Van- Vechten (1976) by Mark Hel-- must be reconsidered of the Harlem im- Renaissance,. as a significant literary figure. Van_ Vechten said the following in his oral history of Columbia University : It was almost following the publication began to get violently interested because it was almost in Negroes. an addiction. of Peter Whiffle that I' I would say violently,_ I had been brought up to be- very respectful to Negroes.1) Naturally, in Negroes. there was a basis for Carl Van Vechten's His parents were cosmopolitan — 68 — being interested'. and humanistic. At a time: -when black people had only a rare chance to go to school was co-founder sippi. of the Piney Woods School for black children in Missis- Moreover, woman's , his father his mother's friend Lucy Stone, was an adovocate suffrage, and his mother was under her influence. of She was re- sponsible for the public library in her town, raising the sum required by 'Carnegie before he would build a library •city government sufficient income for its continued support. basic attitude his father, toward and securing from state and Van Vechten's blacks was one of respect, partly learned through who addressed all blacks, including the laundryman and the man who cut the grass, as Mr. or Mrs. 2) Needless to say, his father's activities and attitude toward black people affected the young Van Vechten strongly, though his actual association with black people was rare in his youth. Carl Van Vechten's in Chicago, where association with black people began at a nightclub he became acquainted known as Carrie Washington) ,singer. who with Carita Day" (previously later became quite a celebrity as a He would often dance with her and reminisced that : Nobody in Chicago and afterwards in Nevt York had any objection to dancing with Negroes at that epoch. I don't probably because I never asked them whether understand it. It's or not they did object. This Ixas hem een 1903 and 1910. She was a Negro and her husband was a Negro. She was obviously a Negro although she wasn't very dark but she was handsome.4j When Van Vechten moved to New York in 1906 and became a music ,critic for the New York Times and Broadway Magazine , he naturally _.many actors, actresses, singers and dancers . Bert Williams, met a singer and .actor who usually appeared in the Ziegfield Follies, became Van Vechten's - 69 - black friend and remained his good friend even after he became very popular and successful. So Van Vecten's "violent interest twenties did not really occur all that suddenly. been laid through in the- The foundation had already- these early friendships. After Alfred A. Knopf published Van Vechten's e in Negroes" in 1922, he published Walter White's novel, Peter first novel, Whiffle The Fire in the Flint, a story about Atlanta riots, in 1924. Van Vechten was very interested the book and asked Knopf to introduce him to White. White became friends,5) and White subsequently in Thus, Van Vechten introduced Van Vech- ten to many other blacks. A week or so after their first meeting, White introduced Weldon Johnson, who was to become a life long friend. White took him to a N. A. A. C. P. fund-raising Rhone's Club, where Neale Hurston, Wallace Thurman, George Schuyler. .... Walter lunches, he met Langston him to James.. Johnson and dance party at the Happy- Hughes, Jessie Fauset, Countee Rudolph Cullen, Fisher, Zora_ and. Van Vechten noted : was very good to me. to dinners, every educated and so forth, person in Harlem. He asked me to parties, and in about two weeks I knewI knew from Paul Robeson to—well, Joe Louis didn't known him too, but that's them by the exist at that hundreds.. time ; I_ later.6) After meeting Langston Hughes, first book of poetry, to, Weary Blues, Van Vechten helped him publish and wrote the introduction. hisy Hughes said in his autobiography : What Carl Van Vechten did for me was to submit my first book of of poems to Alfred A. Konpf, put me in contact with the editors of - 70 - Vanity Fair, who bought my first poems sold to a magazine, caused me to meet many editors and writers who were friendly and helpful to me, encouraged me in my writing of my first short stories, and otherwise aided in making . life for me more profitable and enter-. tainin.g.8 The N. A. A. C. P. party Carl Van Vechten . attended was of singular importance to him, as well as to the blacks, since it marked the turning point of a drastic change in his focus and activities. He became a vital link for young poets and novelists who had no connections with white publishers, and parhaps, even more importantly, an understanding and compassionate intermediary between white and black people. Johnson describes Van Vechten's efforts and attitude in his autobiography, Along This Way : Carl Van Vechten had a warm interest in colored people before he ever saw Harlem. In the early days of the Negro literary and artistic movement, no . one in the country did more to forward it than he accomplished in frequent magazine articles and by his many personal efforts in behalf of individual Negro writers and artists. Indeed, his regard f or Negroes as a race is so close to being an affectionate one, that he constantly joked about it by his most intimate friends." Van Vechten's principal contribution toward race relations, however, was in arranging for blacks and whites get to know each other at his salon parties. This literary salon, modeled after Mabel Dodge Luhan's earlier endeavor, provided a warm, free atmosphere in which artists and intellectuals could break down their prejudices. At the same time Van Vechten was entertainining at his salon, there --- 71 -- were other parties most important to which of these gatherings which were not exclusively Jessie Fauset, celebrities, there Gordon, also. subway and the literary Langston was a curious bankers Hughes, and "stock mixture with Aaron Douglas, and Van Vechten At Jessie Fauset's Charles S. Johnson, of would usually be as the New York parties, and Langston Most of her parties were held exclusively racketeers", Muriel Draper, but she was always prepared some drink. parties of black and exchange Her parties, it is said, were as crowded hour, The of the Herlem Renaissance.") and Countee Cullen, Witter Bynner, at the rush elbowing there numerous poets and novelists; Taylor for intellectuals, get-togethers, were invited. were the parties, of A'Lelia Walker," one of the black novelists At A'Lelia's white the black intelligentsia to enliven the Walter White, Hughes would attend. for black people, and the few that were not were open only to very distinguished whites. While her literary parties were unique and valuable because black people there could speak about everything to the limitation There in an invigorating atomsphere, they were chained of being held mostly for blacks. were ' two important factors about Van Vechten's parties : one, was the mutual association of black and white people ; two, was the breakdown of prejudice. place where party In the 1920's, considering black people could associate with white people, this kind of was rare and valuable for both against black people was rampant, was vigorously races. At that time prejudice and the practice of strict segregation pursued even in New York, which was considered to be a fairly free city for black people. was a Jim Crow club. Wings was performed prohibited the fact that there was no When Even the famous Cotton Club in Harlem Eugene in Manhattan O'Neill's in 1924, the All God's Chillun Mayor Got of New York white and black children from appearing together on the stage. - 72 Furthermore, it was very difficult for blacks to get tickets to the theater, and many restaurants also shut their doors on blacks. "Everybody told me th at Harlem was very dangerous,'" later said. f riends' Despite the social advice, Van Vechten situation continued of those going Van Vechten years and to the nightclubs his white and enjoy- ing life in Harlem. In 1924 Van Vechten West Fifty-fifth Street. he had become wealthy. Vechten /cantly, many dared decided to move In gave well-known a whites. lowing passage clearly party other There were plenty gather poetry. people too. Langston At another Hughes Mr. And when politan Opera D'Alvarez, but, time, Van Vechten's painters, enjoy it seems Van arose and sang liking her voice, -- talking, parties, Margarita an aria. she went 73 -- black The fol- his parties : parties, I snobbish. there.12) talented people and writers singing, Bessie Smith Smith up to her and to would reading : D'Alvarez Bessie of young very in his autobiography Vechten's she finished, editors, invited given very, to introduce dancing, also all-colored people Van been about gave sculptors, reminisced but and Signifi- celebrities. attitude white novels had never white on 150 apartment. particularly I never Otherwise three blacks blacks with determination and blues. for of very well-known actors , actresses, parties exculsively all colored, of his unshakable at his apartment neighborhood, salon at this new acquainted shows wasn't asked upper-class It was the chance, and poets to became Peach other, of the Up to that writers Because spite party this kind of opportunity. The a small By this time he had published to open his literary he never from sang of the the Metro- did not know when she had ceased and cried : "Don't let nobody tell you you can't sing ! " Carl Van Vechten and A'Lelia Walker were great each of their . parties many of the same but more writers were present people friends, were to be seen, at Carl Van Vechten's. At cocktail time, or in the evening, I first met at his house Somerset Hugh Walpole, Clark, William Fannie Seabrook, Hurst, Witter Arthur Bynner, Davison and at Isa Maugham, Glenn, Emily Ficke, Louis Untermeyer, and George Sylvester Viereck.'3) It was characteristic that the white fluence upon the white population; to writers and poets. guests were persons who had in- the black guests ranged from porters, As an ex-musical critic turned well-known writer, Van Vechten had many friends, which was a great help in giving parties. Through judice. his parties he succeeded in breaking down some barriers of preHe never used oppressive means to do so, however. A little- known fact, for example, is that at the end of one party William ner badgered Vechten never Van Vechten finally did, though used black people think of people as Negroes. won him the further into taking against him his will. for propaganda to Harlem, Moreover, purposes. ' He Faulk- which Van Van Vechten said "I never I think of them as friends. " 14) His attitude trust of many blacks and whites as well, and as a result, his parties were packed to the ceiling. His method of breaking down prejudice was unique for his day : I never tried to get anybody to stop hating Negroes. If they want to, it's their business, but it's damned silly. like that. You can't change people They sometimes change; one girl I know, and still . I know now, was so bitter about Negroes, I can't tell you ; and I didn't do anything except invite her to my house occasionally when there were --74- Negroes here. Gradually, she changed, and one night there was a Negro here who simply captivated her, because he was so extraordinary. Then she become very interested in George Schuyler because George Schuyler is no fool and can talk. Now she receives Negroes at her house and goes to their houses.1s' Through this association with black writers, talents, white people became interested ciaton of their potentialities had a revolutionary in blacks and developed an appre- and contributions. people. days "reconciliatory" On the surface, for being really implied his behavior unswerving that he must contribute him. Van Vechten's small torch ten's achievements Willi Muenzenberg what parties, weak-willed his actions signified and the best means available to enlightened both races One of the people who used George Schuyler, as revolutionary but in must be eliminated of humanism during the days of the Harlem Renaissance. to go to Van Vechten's have seemed belief that prejudice to this cause through reconciliatory, To be blind obedience to white might and impotent to some people, but in actuality was a steady, In this sense, his parties impact unlike the other parties of those days. sure, his way might now be denounced the those poets, and people of various and compared described them Van Vech- with those of in Germany : With far different objectives but similar techniques, Van Vechfen won over the same class in this country to acceptance of the Negro and appreciation of his potentialities were the minority and contributions. that tell the majority what to think, and hear, and they have multiplied tremendously century. It has now become and appreciative His disciples interracially, smart -- see in the past quarter to be tolerant, and if any one person ---- 75 wear, understanding can be credited. with bringing not have about equality this revolution unless it is desired, less the idea is first accepted, until it first happens Van Vechten with flowers. While Vechten take. Filling novelists glasses to white in the guests, phere. sideration, :more. and celebrities. white guests Langston Hughes Carl Van Vechten ities. But he lives them giving created atmosphere began parties, and going bottom from modest introduced aroused smiles, black moderate Van to parpoets atmos- and mutual black and seriousness and congenial of friendliness appreciating person honey from who wished a comfortable people con- more and out : with black sincerity—and a fetish and Vechten of those qual- humor. were reported writers Van He never talks grandiloquently Nor makes that is why his parties interracial he sincerity or Americanism. to helping un- Fania .Marinoff, , dedicat- for those is like that party. democracy In addition wife, pretty host, His pointed about Perhaps her playing this natural his actress liquid refreshment and his homor Through at the of zest just like two bees drawing dispensed gaily dispensed will not happen in a most active fashion, the greatest Fania and it will not be desired which pretty to his parties -to person You can- at the top.") and his tiny, ,ed themselves it is Carl Van Vechten. poets in the Harlem become also helped press.f 7) published black people and through the N. A. A. C. P. From the fact that Walter White opened the office of -the midtown branch of the N . A. A. C. P. in the same building where the Van Vechtens assistance. Weldon lived, we can Furthermore, Johnson, like imagine at that White, the time, Van was also - 76 - importance Vechten's a leading of Van Vechten's best friend, staff member James of the N. A. A. C. P. The problems the N. A. A. C. P. brought were varied. His opinion about people was often to Van Vechten_ solicited, and some_. times individual blacks brought him their problems through the N. A. A. C. P. his role with. It should be noted that Van Vechtenn ever flaunted the N. A. A. C. P., and even in his oral history he doesn't mention his. specific activities but merely suggests that he had a close connection with_ the group. To the quetion, "what kind of problems did the N. A. A. C. P. bring you ? " he answered. I can't remember important, people. now, because they were various sometimes Very often unimportant. they wanted They were my opinion and sometimes, very often on certain about. men, that they were going to use in some way.18' In the beginning his love upon of his long relationship everyone of them. more correct appreciation Soon, of them. with black people he lavished_ however, One night he came to have a. he rushed back to his home from Harlem and told his wife in great glee that he finally hated.. a black person; that is, at least he had found one black person he hated.. As a result of this, he felt completely emancipated. It had nothing he was a Negro. to do with prejudice. I didn't dislike I disliked him for other reasons ... they were now—perhaps him becauseI forgot what he was unkind to his mother or kicked his.. dog or something, I don't know. But. I disliked him. gotten who the man was, so I can't only remember He later remarked describe I've even for- the feeling really. I-. coming home and saying, " at last I hate a negro. Because up to that time, I had considered them all as one. Now I feel about him e)actly the way I feel about white people---I like some,. 77 -- am uninterested in others, and some of them I find very distasteful. But at that time I hadn't Van Vechten's got around to that.19) personal assistance was not a foregone situation—in in f act, his help was often refused. "give and take" His friendships with blacks were not foregone conclusions either ; rather they were strengthened step by step and enhanced by personal and those of the people he associated with. in his autobiography, A Long meeting with Van Vechten Way from idiosyncrasies, both his own Claude McKay, for example Home, described his unique in Paris in the summer of 1929 as follows : When we met at that late hour the world's cosmopolites, said "What will you take ? " at the celebrated rendezvous Mr. Van Vechten was full and funny. I took a soft drink of He and I could feel that Mr. Van Vechten was shocked. I am afraid that as a soft drinker I bored him. The white author and the black author of books about Harlem could not find much of anything to make conversation. loaded .with vegetables ten, pointing The market were rolling by for Les Halles, and suddenly Mr. Van Vech- to a truck-load of huge carrots, would like to have all of them !." esting than coversation. trucks Perhaps exclaimed, "How I carrots were more inter- But I did not feel in any way carroty .. . But he excused himself to go to the men's room and never came back.2o) Van Vechten later sent sorry for not returning, discovered himself McKay a message explaining but he was so high that, ruuning along the avenue after after that he "was leaving us, he a truck load of car- rots. "21) Mabel Dodge Luhan said, concerning. his character, ~. 78 —. "How Carl loved the grotesque ? He loved to twist and squirm with laughter of strong contrast." 22) A white non-admirer McKay that Van Vechten "patronized the Harlem who found "Mr. all right.” 24) Attesting that when of Van Vechten's had told Negroes in a subtle way, to which elite were blind because they were just learning sophistica- tion." 23) After their Paris McKay at the oddty Claude meeting this presumption was eradicated Van Vechten not a bit patronozing, to their McKay friendship, died in Chicago beyond words, by and quite is the fact in 1948, Van Vechten was one of the pallbearers. Van Vechten's pansive than might Van Vechten's sociation association with black people was deeper and more be expected. Naturally, role in the Harlem Renaissance with black people. His "indirect it is not enough ex- to judge only in terms of his asrole" must also examined, that is, the opening of his literary salon in 1924 after the Harlem Renaissance had gotten underway. Moreover, the New Negro or the Harlem Movement modest and sincere. However, he had no intention his dedicated Renaissance efforts of leading because he was in the "know the Negro" . campaign were great and, according to George S. Schuyler, "revolutionary" . Because his close friends during the Renaissance, for example, Langston Hughes, Rudolph Fisher, Wallace Thurman, Walter White, Jessie Fauset, Countee Cullen, Claude McKay, Aaron George Schuyler, Douglas, Bessie seem like an all-star cast of the Renaissance, Smith, Zola Neale Hurston, and oil of the Renaissance. Rebeson, it is easy to have the mis- taken view that he had a leading role in that movement. salon activities were tremendous, Paul Although his in reality they were only the lubricating According to Robert A. Bone : -- 79 - The influence ought not New Negro leaves of intellectuals to be overestimated. Movement no doubt ment white was not a serious Some with white Negro by the Negro artist overestimating the by Negro critics The white to Renaissance have but character. initiated attempt the domination, of its indigenous a "vogue" on charged a sober New appraisal Negro "literary the Move- faddists", interpret his but own group intellecutuals such life. 25) In other as Van of the Vechten black Alain words and others writers, Locke poets, pointed out, "collaboration intellectuals was ten, in providing and white minds, of the may and as white key lead one artists the role factor the in in to discredit the their behalf. own the "serious Harlem the was role of Renaissance. for the all, as vital in the Van meeting of literature—white efforts" After intellectuals artists",26) environment cause of white of white Amercan a stimulating served influence Vech- of black as well black and as black. -NOTES 1) Carl Van Vechten, History Collection "Reminiscences," of Columbia Memoirs University, of Carl Van Vechten, 1960 (hereafter referred Oral as CVV, OH). 2) Ibid. 3) Carita Day many years afterward to found the James and Letters ters, 4). CVV, Johnson at Yale University. Van Vechten Memorial when Collection he attempted of Negro She sent him many materials Arts such as, let- and photographs. OH. 5) Van Vechten and Walter ten felt that Walter 6) CVV, Weldon assisted White later became had become a show-off estranged because Van Vech- and a blowhard. OH. 7) Langston Hughes, The Big Sea (New York: — 80 --- Hill and Wang, 1940), p. 272. 8) James Weldon Johnson, Along This Way (New York: Viking Press, 1933), p. 382. 9) Hughes, The Big Sea, op. cit., p. 245: "A'Lelia Walker was a gorgeous dark Amazon, in a silver turban. She had a town house in New York .(also an apartment where she preferred to live) and a country mansion at Irvingtonon-the-Hudson, with pipe organ programs each morning to awaken her guests gently. Her mother made a great fortune from the Madame Walker Hair Straightening Process, which had worked wonders on unruly Negro hair in the early nineteen hundreds—and which continues to work wonders today. The daughter used much of that money for fun. A'Lelia Walker was the joy-goddess of Harlem's 1920's ... When A'Lelia Walker died in 1931, she had a grand funeral. It was by invitation only. But, just as for her parties, a great many more invitations had been issued than the small but exclusive Seventh Avenue funeral parlor could provide for. Hours before the funeral, the street in front of the undertaker's chapel was crowded." 10) Ibid., p. 247: "At the novelist, Jessie Fauset's parties there was always quite a different atmosphere from that at most other Herlem good-time gatherings. At Miss Fauset's, a good time was shared by talking literature and reading poetry aloud and perhaps enjoying some conversation in French." 11) 12) 13) 14) 15) CVV, OH. Ibid. Hughes, The Big Sea, op. cit., pp. 251-252. CVV, OH. Ibid. 16) George S. Schuyler, "The Van Vechten Revolution," Phylon: Atlanta University Review of Race and Culture (Fourth Quarter, 1950) p. 365. 17) 18) 19) 20) Hughes, The Big Sea, op. cit., p. 255. CVV, OH. Ibid. Claude McKay, A Long Way from Home (New York : Harcourt, Brace & World, 1970), p. 320. 21) Ibid., p. 320. 22) Mabel Dodge Luhan, Movers and Shakers (New York : Harcourt, Brace --- 81 -- and Company, 1936), p. 79. 23) McKay, A Long Way from Home, op. cit., p. 319. 24) Ibid, p. 319. 25) Robert A. Bone, The Negro Novel in America (New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1958), p. 61. 26) Addison Gayle, Jr., ed., The Black Aesthetic Company, Inc., 1971), p. 18. * This Japan essay is based on the report of (1978). —82---- the (New York : Doubleday American Literature Society & of
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz