Wealth and Justice Summary, Questions, and Recommended

Is free market capitalism good and just?
Our views of the best political and economic systems depend in large measure on the
way in which we understand human nature in the first place. The authors of Wealth and
Justice begin by examining three different views of human nature and the three
different political theories they inspire. The founding fathers of the United States
erected the architecture of democratic capitalism on a theory of human nature that
acknowledged on the one hand the tendency to abuse power—and therefore the need
for constraints and accountability and checks and balances—and on the other hand the
God-given rights and dignity of the human person and the potential to use liberty for
good. Capitalism does not seek to persuade the individual to forget about self-interest,
but to align the self-interest of the individual with the interest of society as a whole.
Prior to the rise of capitalism, very few enjoyed the benefits of prosperity, such as
health, literacy, and security. Capitalism in the early years of the Industrial Revolution
ignited historically unprecedented economic growth, largely due to technological
advances and an influx of labor and entrepreneurialism. Yet the benefits of this growth
were not always widely available, and such swift social change led to problems such as
increased child labor, environmental damage, and brutal factory conditions. It was
during this time of transition that Marx and Engels argued that capitalism itself was to
blame for the social dislocations of the nineteenth century. Their Communist Manifesto
suggested that the way to a better future was through revolution and the overthrow of
all social structures so that a classless society could enjoy the benefits of their labor.
Communism, however, was constructed on a flawed understanding of human nature,
and the implementation of its ideas in the twentieth century—under Lenin, Stalin, Pol
Pot, Mao, and others—led to horrific suffering. Once the state assumed control over
economic structures, it became increasingly invasive, controlling, and totalitarian. The
elites who controlled the levers of society set the parameters of life for everyone,
creating forced-labor requirements, vast relocation plans, and the elimination of
protections for privacy and rights. The state and the political elite gained power at the
expense of millions of citizens, many of whom—especially agricultural workers—lost
their lives.
While some of the concerns of the early socialists and communists were valid, their
solutions were misdirected. As capitalist structures continued to develop through the
nineteenth and twentieth centuries, markets tackled their own problems and rectified
them with a variety of systems designed to protect the wellbeing of citizens. In doing
so, capitalism made possible a flourishing free enterprise economy in which more and
more people thrived. Whether measured by human freedoms and rights, by
governments’ capacities to address natural disasters, infant mortality and lifespan, or
by technological advances, capitalism has vastly outperformed every other form of
economic organization and has brought extraordinary advantages to countries all over
the world.
Some criticisms leveled against capitalism are less economic than moral. Some feel
that capitalism fans the flames of greed, materialism, and consumerism; others argue
that it drives society to increasingly bankrupt ethical norms and cultural expressions.
Greed, corruption, and insipid materialism, however, are not unique or even especially
endemic to capitalist societies. They are human tendencies, and capitalism can
constrain them better than the alternatives if it cultivates social mechanisms of
transparency and accountability. Recent stories of fraud and “crony capitalism” are not
examples of capitalism corrupting moral character so much as they are examples of bad
moral character corrupting capitalism.
Moreover, capitalism’s moral accomplishments are significant. Capitalism has done
more to lift people out of poverty than any other economic system in human history. As
economic freedom creates powerful pressures toward political freedom, it empowers
individuals to make free choices and take responsibility for their lives. Capitalism
protects the rights and liberties of the individual and thereby creates the conditions for
morally meaningful choices. Capitalism seeks equality of opportunity, and thus
preserves the space for liberty and creativity, compared to other economic systems
that strive for equality of outcomes, but actually end up suppressing freedom and
ingenuity and privileging the political elites who control an increasingly invasive state.
For all these reasons and more, the authors argue, capitalism is the form of economic
organization that best expresses Judeo-Christian values.
2
Peter Wehner is a senior fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center and former Deputy
Assistant to the President and Director of the White House Office of Strategic Initiatives.
Arthur C. Brooks is president of the American Enterprise Institute. Previously, he was the
Lois A. Bantle Professor of Business and Government Policy at Syracuse University.
3
Question Bank and Other Resources
Short-Answer Questions
Chapter 1: Human Nature and Capitalism
1. Name the three views of human nature and a representative of each. Which did the
founders adopt and why?
2. The authors link a successful political and economic order based on capitalism and
democracy to a morality derived from Judeo-Christian teachings. What teachings are
pivotal to democratic capitalism? Why are they important?
3. What’s the difference between self-interest and selfishness? How can the former
contribute to the common good? Why does this distinction matter?
Chapter 2: The Economic Achievements of Capitalism
1. What were the results, both positive and negative, of the rise of a capitalist society?
2. What were the results of a communist society? Give examples.
3. In what ways did early capitalism adjust to the system’s flaws?
Chapter 3: Capitalism, Ethics, and Religious Faith
1. How are free markets and human freedoms linked?
2. Why do the authors believe that widespread economic and political freedom would
create global peace?
3. The authors point out several examples of dishonesty within capitalism. Wh at is their
solution to such situations of greed, selfishness, and dishonesty? What are the
antidotes to corruption?
Chapter 4: Is Capitalism Unjust?
4
1. Many contemporary critics argue that inequality is morally unjust. How do the
authors use Israeli kibbutzim to demonstrate the futility of government intervention to
create equality?
2. What are the problems inherent in systems of income redistribution?
3. What is the difference between equality of opportunity and equality of outcomes?
Multiple Choice Questions
1) Enlightenment philosophers who focused on the perfectibility of human nature
include:
a. Thomas Hobbes and Bernard Mandeville
b. Robert Owen and Charles Fourier
c. James Madison and Thomas Jefferson
d. Adam Smith and David Hume
2) Which of the following is not a tenet of communism?
a. The product of labor belongs to the laborers.
b. A proletarian revolution would lead to an abundance of goods and
products.
c. A violent revolution is necessary.
d. Private ownership should be protected.
3) Early capitalist societies corrected some of the problems it created through
which of the following measures?
a. Labor laws, unemployment insurance, restrictions against monopolies
b. Revolution and state appropriation of property
c. Government-managed redistribution of income
d. The creation of small communal societies
4) The problems of redistribution include all of the following except:
a. The encouragement of non-cooperation or laziness
b. An increase in corporate corruption
c. An increase in state power and centralization
d. A lack of recognition of gifts, talents, and ingenuity
5
5) Communist regimes tend to erode key contributions to a stable society. These
include which of the following?
a. Education and clubs
b. Culture and entertainment industries
c. Press and governmental accountability
d. Athletics and scientific research
Essay or Term Paper Suggestions
1. The authors mention the Enron scandal as an example of the corruption possible
under capitalism. Yet they point out that the Enron officials’ behavior was not a
problem with capitalism, but a problem with morality. Watch Enron: The Smartest
Guys in the Room (2005). Discuss: What went wrong with the capitalist venture in
this business? What were the consequences? How might a capitalist society prevent
further such acts of selfishness?
2. What business scandals are in the news today? Scan your national newspapers for
such accounts. How are they presented? Discuss the ways that they reflect on moral
institutions. Are the journalists blaming capitalism? Do they make suggestions
about remedies?
3. Read the accounts of the Occupy Wall Street movement. What was it all about?
What solutions did the protesters propose? In what ways does the capitalist
structure need to self-correct, or are there other issues that have created these
problems?
4. Which biblical passages do the authors use in this text? How do they demonstrate
the viability of free free-market capitalism as an economic system in meeting the
priorities of a God of justice and compassion?
6
For Further Reading
Bell, Daniel. The Economy of Desire: Christianity and Capitalism in a
Postmodern World (2012). Bell offers a Christian critique of capitalism and
compares it to an ethic derived from scripture.
Berger, Peter. The Capitalist Revolution: Fifty Propositions about Prosperity,
Equality, and Liberty (1986). This sociologist argues for free free-market
capitalism as the optimum method of ameliorating poverty.
Fulcher, James. Capitalism: A Very Short Introduction (2004). Fulcher describes
the development and effects of capitalism, comparing it to other economic
systems.
Landes, David. The Wealth and Poverty of Nations: Why Some Are So Rich and
Some So Poor (1999). Landes explores the history behind the rise and success
of democratic capitalism by looking at global cultures, economic systems,
religions, and philosophies.
Newman, Michael. Socialism: A Very Short Introduction (2005). Newman looks
at the historical accounts of cultures that have implemented socialism, and
compares social democracy to communism, and other contemporary forms of
socialism.
Novak, Michael. The Spirit of Democratic Capitalism (1990). Novak, a Catholic
theologian and philosopher, explores the history of capitalism, its compatibility
with Christian ethics, and its superiority to socialism.
Weber, Max, Peter Baehr, Gordon Wells. The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of
Capitalism: and Other Writings (2002). Weber’s classic theory of the influence of
Calvinism on the rise of a capitalist society, along with some of his other essays,
illuminated by commentary and introduction from two contemporary scholars.
7