Writing a successful PhD proposal

Writing a successful
Ph.D. research proposal
Laetis Kuipers
©Taalcentrum-VU
1
Today’s plan
–
What makes a good proposal?
–
Five crucial questions you must answer
–
What’s the basic structure of a proposal?
–
How do you sell your project? Why language matters!
–
Exercise “A successful proposal?”
©Taalcentrum-VU
2
Successful Ph.D. research proposals
5 crucial questions you must always answer in any
research proposal or application:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Why this problem?
What do I plan to accomplish?
How am I going to do it?
Why me?
Does the application represent good value for money?
‘Better’ (more successful ) proposals (or applications) are
better written
©Taalcentrum-VU
3
Aim of a Ph.D. research proposal
AIM:
“Convince others that you have a worthwhile research
project and that you have the competence and the
work plan to complete it.”
(Wong, T.P. , Research Director Trinity Western University (CA), http://www.meaning.ca/archives/archive/art_how_to_write_P_Wong.htm)
©Taalcentrum-VU
4
Reader expectations
Overall structure of a paper
Logical order of information
Scannability and Readability
©Taalcentrum-VU
5
Reading Strategies
– Use the title to get an idea of the contents of the paper
– Use the summary to get an overview of the contents
– Read the Intro (problem definition), Purpose and Relevance
section first
– Scan headings and sub-headings
– Scan graphical information
– Notice any italicised or boldfase words or phrases
– Read topic sentences and concluding sentences of
paragraphs
– Glide over each paragraph to pick up key words
©Taalcentrum-VU
6
Structure of a Ph.D. proposal
– Title
– Summary
– Introduction (problem
definition)
– Research question(s)
– Research design &
methodology
– Expected results /
potential outcomes
©Taalcentrum-VU
–
–
–
–
–
Innovation
Relevance (impact)
Plan of work / timeline
Budget / cost estimates
Literature references
7
Introduction: information elements
– Review of the literature (the main contributors and
summarising the status of the field) / Background of the
problem
– Research gap / Statement of the problem
– Main purpose
– Hypotheses
– Statement of value / relevance (importance of the study)
©Taalcentrum-VU
8
Summary
– How important is the summary?
– First part to be read and it sets the first impression
– It’s often used, with the title, to route the application to the
appropriate review committee(s) and reviewers
– Key elements
– Background information (what’s the topic of your research?)
– Research objective (what do you intend to do?)
– Methodology (how are you going about doing it?)
– Expected results (what do you expect to find?)
– Conclusion / Significance (what does this mean?)
– Key words
©Taalcentrum-VU
9
Summary: key features
Key features?
–
Succinct and accurate
–
Must be self-contained
–
Structured? (cf. abstracts to texts published in medicine)
–
Maximum length
–
Must be understood by experts in your field as well as by
“generalists”
©Taalcentrum-VU
10
Selling your project: why language
matters!
‘Better’ (more successful ) proposals (or applications) are better written
↓
Use the English language well and enhance readability by:
– Writing well-structured and coherent paragraphs
– Writing effective sentences
– Being concise: don’t waste words
– Using active constructions, saving passive voice for M&M, Results
– Using modality to your advantage (can, could, may, might, should, etc.)
– Using appropriate vocabulary
©Taalcentrum-VU
11
Paragraph structure & coherence
12
Paragraph Structure
–
A topic sentence = main idea of paragraph (Level 1sentence)
–
Adequate development: elaboration
– Level 2-sentence: limitation or qualification of the TS
– Level 3-sentence: sentences that support level 2sentences: evidence, examples
–
A concluding sentence (optional)
conclusion to the argument presented in the elaboration
©Taalcentrum-VU
13
Paragraph Coherence Devices
-
Organisation of ideas
accepted to controversial, general to specific, problem – solution,
cause –effect, etc.
-
Linking words and phrases
to give examples, signal addition, compare and contrast, signal
alternatives, focus, discuss cause & effect etc.
-
Repetition of key words and phrases
Sentence patterns (word order, given-new)
Use of grammatically parallel constructions
Use of pronouns & reference words (= cohesion)
he, they, our, this, that, their, etc.
-
Effective punctuation
©Taalcentrum-VU
14
Writing effective paragraphs
1/2
Every year, approximately 900,000 adults worldwide experience major cardiac
complications after surgery, which are associated with increased mortality and
hospital stay. Preoperative non-invasive cardiac stress testing may help prevent
these complications. This strategy detects underlying ischaemic heart disease and
identifies individuals who might benefit from preoperative interventions,
aggressive intraoperative haemodynamic management, closer postoperative
surveillance, or avoiding surgery. Additionally, the results of stress testing can
guide the use of perioperative β blockade, which has greatest benefit in patients
with inducible ischaemia. Given these benefits, the American College of Cardiology
and American Heart Association guidelines recommend preoperative non-invasive
stress testing, but only in individuals with clinical risk factors for cardiac
complications.
(Duminda N Wijeysunderaet al. (2010). Non-invasive cardiac stress testing before elective major non-cardiac surgery: population based cohort study. BMJ 2010;340:b5526)
©Taalcentrum-VU
15
Writing effective paragraphs
2/2
[Background information] Every year, approximately 900 000 adults worldwide
experience major cardiac complications after surgery, which are associated with
increased mortality and hospital stay. [Topic sentence:] Preoperative non-invasive
cardiac stress testing may help prevent these complications. [Supporting
sentence 1:] This strategy detects underlying ischaemic heart disease and
identifies individuals who might benefit from preoperative interventions,
aggressive intraoperative haemodynamic management, closer postoperative
surveillance, or avoiding surgery. [Supporting sentence 2:] Additionally, the results
of stress testing can guide the use of perioperative β blockade, which has greatest
benefit in patients with inducible ischaemia. [Concluding sentence:] Given these
benefits, the American College of Cardiology and American Heart Association
guidelines recommend preoperative non-invasive stress testing, but only in
individuals with clinical risk factors for cardiac complications.
©Taalcentrum-VU
(Duminda N Wijeysunderaet al. (2010). Non-invasive cardiac stress testing before elective major non-cardiac surgery: population based cohort study. BMJ 2010;340:b5526)
16
Writing effective sentences
End Focus
End Weight
Textual Fit
Foregrounding & Backgrounding
©Taalcentrum-VU
17
Textual fit: given-new
1/2
Place new information towards the end of the clause,
thus creating a given-new order of information and
effective, natural flow:
GIVEN
NEW
SENTENCE 1
©Taalcentrum-VU
GIVEN
NEW
SENTENCE 2
GIVEN
SENTENCE 3
18
Writing effective sentences: end
focus & textual fit
The fact that many refugees encounter a lot of hostility and aggression has caused
many of them to return home. However, enormous problems occur when they
return. In Iran, for example, …
The fact that many refugees encounter a lot of hostility and aggression has caused
many of them to return home. However, their return leads to enormous
problems. In Iran, for example, … … …
–
End focus: Make your point at the end of the sentence: most important
information in final position.
–
Textual fit: given – new pattern. Advantage: coherence between sentences)
©Taalcentrum-VU
19
Writing effective sentences: end
focus & textual fit
To examine the status in HCL of another gene, DAPK1, we have
applied the COBRA screening procedure. DAPK1, located at
9q34, is ….
We have applied the COBRA screening procedure to examine the
status in HCL of another gene, DAPK1. This gene, located at
9q34, is …
©Taalcentrum-VU
20
Writing effective sentencing: end
weight & end focus
The possibility that the patterns shown by our study persist because of
factors associated with the social structure of the delivery system is far
more likely.
–
Frontal overload: too much information at the beginning and nothing
of communicative significance at the end.
Far more likely is the possibility that the patterns shown by our study
persist because of factors associated with the social structure of the
delivery system.
–
–
End weight: place shorter parts towards beginning of sentence and
most complex parts (long, weighty elements) in final position.
End focus: Make your point at the end of the sentence: most important
information in final position.
©Taalcentrum-VU
21
Clause combining: position of dependent
clauses
Dependent clause in initial position
“With the successful construction of a tumor-specific system,
we can now address the issue of effective in vivo delivery” [1].
A dependent clause in initial position presents information that has been
mentioned before or the writer wants the reader to take it for granted.
Dependent clause in final position
“The positive control was provided by 293 cells, stably
expressing E1A” [1].
A dependent clause in final position presents something new.
1. Adapted from original sentences in Marie C. Chia, Wei Shi, Jian-Hua, et al. Conditionally Replicating Adenovirus for Nasopharyngeal Carcinoma Gene Therapy. Molecular Therapy. 2004; 9: 805.
©Taalcentrum-VU
22
Being concise
It is expected that there will be an increase in the number of genetic
screening tests offered to society during the years. Therefore, views
expressed by society regarding future genetic screening possibilities will be
investigated in this qualitative study, aiming to inform policy makers on the
topic. (46 words)
The number of currently available genetic screening tests is expected to
increase fast. This qualitative study will investigate societal views regarding
future genetic screening possibilities, aiming to inform policy makers. (29
words)
©Taalcentrum-VU
23
Tips to write concisely
–
Avoid repetition.
–
Avoid obvious statements and unnecessary detail.
–
Choose a verb where you can
1/2
(reach a decision= decide, have an effect = affect / cause)
–
Choose the short form
(with the exception of = except, at all times = always)
–
Avoid unnecessary determiners and modifiers (“very”, “really”, “kind of”,
“basically”
(exactly the same = the same, completely unanimous = unanimous)
©Taalcentrum-VU
24
Tips to write concisely
2/2
–
Replace prepositional phrases (in an efficient manner = efficiently)
–
Avoid “there are” or “it is” sentences
there is an increase in the number of X = the number of X increases
it is important to consider X = considering X is important / we should
consider X here
–
Avoid phrasal verbs (cf. formality) (cut down = reduce, go up = increase,
find out = determine)
©Taalcentrum-VU
25
Using active constructions
– Poverty has been defined in relative terms.
 We have defined poverty in relative terms.
 Jones (2005) defines poverty in relative terms.
 In this paper, poverty is defined in relative terms.
– The impact of different kinds of stressful marital situations on individual
levels of stress will be examined.
 This study examines the impact of different kinds of stressful
marital situations on individual levels of stress.
– It is expected that … / It is assumed that …
[only correct if you’re making a general statement]
©Taalcentrum-VU
26
Using the passive to your advantage
– Data obtained by this project will be cross-referenced with
expression profiles already performed in the same tissues
[compare active: ‘We will cross-reference…’]
– This work will extend methods for data integration and metaanalysis which have been devised for genome-wide linkage
family studies and single-cohort GWA studies.
[compare active: ‘Researchers devised methods …’ and ‘We
plan to extend those methods’]
©Taalcentrum-VU
27
Using the passive to your advantage
– Several preventive interventions for depression have been
shown to be acceptable, effective, cost-effective and scalable.
– There were four procedures. Each procedure was
characterised by …
©Taalcentrum-VU
28
Using modality to your advantage 1/2
– It may turn out to be the case that….
[you’re not sure, but it seems likely (there’s a very good possibility that
X is true]
– Numbsky (2005a) could have adopted a different approach….
[he didn’t, but in your view he should have]
 We believe that this study can lead to the discovery of
“personalized” androgen receptor inhibitors
[this can be improved/strengthened by replacing the modal]
©Taalcentrum-VU
29
Using modality to your advantage 2/2
 Efficacy of the generated Ad vector will be tested using human
in vitro as well as in vivo mouse melanoma models.
Modals are also very useful when you want to stress something
(e.g. some topic or approach):
– In this context, it should be stressed that….
– In this connection, it must be emphasised that….
[absolutely emphatic]
©Taalcentrum-VU
30
Overhedging
The cause of the degenerative changes is unknown but possibly
one cause may be infection by a presumed parasite.
Our belief is that this study may show an apparent link between
cigarette smoking and lung cancer.
(Taken from: Successful scientific writing by JR Matthews and RW Matthews (Cambridge University Press, 2009))
©Taalcentrum-VU
31
Using appropriate vocabulary
This project aims at assessing and re-evaluating the
methodological and theoretical frameworks for first language
attrition research, and in this way providing a good basis that
subsequent studies can draw upon.
 Avoid evaluative terms such as good and/or bad
 … a more UNIFIED and SOLID basis …
©Taalcentrum-VU
32
Using appropriate vocabulary
This project aims at assessing and re-evaluating the methodological and
theoretical frameworks for first language attrition research, and in this way
providing a unified and solid basis that subsequent studies can draw upon.
...
The crosslinguistic approach will make it possible to compare findings from
different languages and therefore come to more general conclusions. It will also
be possible to re-assess findings from previous studies of language attrition, and
come to a unified framework of research for subsequent studies to adopt. It is
hoped that the emphasis which this project places both on standardization of the
methods and on international cooperation will act as a stimulus that may bring
together researchers worldwide, and encourage them to contribute to the
development of a more unified framework of research.
©Taalcentrum-VU
33
Collocations
device
equipment
procedure
process
system
agency
need
careful
require
close
undergo
systematic
ensure
adequate
implement
proper
body
effective
committee
ongoing
team
unit
monitoring
vigilant
long-term
organisation
©Taalcentrum-VU
34
Assignment
Quick Quiz - collocations: which adjectives combine with
‘factor’?
Quick Quiz – collocations: which verbs combine with
‘sample’?
Exercise “A successful research grant proposal?”
©Taalcentrum-VU
35
Waltz, Kiss & Connect
Waltz = 1 – 2 – 3 patterns (repeated as often as necessary)
Text level
Paragraph level
Sentence level
introduction, body, end section
topic, elaboration, concluding sentence
[when, where, how, why]
SUBJECT - VERB(s) - OBJECT(s)
[when, where, how, why]
Kiss & Connect
Keep it short and simple (sentences and/or sentence constituents) &
use connectors/linking words/ signposting language for logic and
cohesion
©Taalcentrum-VU
36
Useful websites
http://oxford.so8848.com/ www.ozdic.com
1/3
Oxford collocations dictionary
http://www.merriam-webster.com/ E-E dictionary + thesaurus
www.englishpage.com
English grammar + online exercises
http://www.taalcentrum-vu.nl/taaltips/engelse-taaltips.html or
http://www.taalcentrum-vu.nl/taaltips/engelse-taaltips/useful-websites-for-english.html
http://www.phrasebank.manchester.ac.uk/ Manchester Academic Phrasebank:
useful phrases for writers of theses and dissertations
http://writing.wisc.edu/Handbook/Transitions.html link words
©Taalcentrum-VU
37
Useful websites
2/3
http://en.bab.la/ and http://en.glosbe.com/ or http://www.interglot.nl/ online dictionaries for many
different languages (items in context; scroll down the page)
www.howsay.com
pronunciation dictionary
www.visuwords.com
http://lexipedia.com/ visual dictionary + thesaurus
http://nufficglossary.nuffic.nl/
NUFFIC glossary (D-E): higher education
http://www.englishpage.com/modals/modalintro.html tutorials + online exercises modal verbs
(can/could/may/might/would/should/must etc…..)
punctuation + online exercises (menu on the left):
http://www.bristol.ac.uk/arts/exercises/grammar/grammar_tutorial/page_03.htm
http://www.bristol.ac.uk/arts/exercises/grammar/grammar_tutorial/page_41.htm
©Taalcentrum-VU
38
Useful websites
https://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/
http://www.uefap.com/
3/3
Purdue online writing lab
Andy Gillet’s ‘Using English for Academic purposes’
http://www.uefap.com/writing/writfram.htm
http://elc.polyu.edu.hk/cill/eap/
UEFAP’s writing tips + exercises
Hong Kong Polytechnic: Centre for Independent
Language Learning, English for Academic Purposes
(EAP, useful for Business students)
http://elc.polyu.edu.hk/cill/
CILL’s home page + links to email and letter writing,
presentations, report writing and much more
©Taalcentrum-VU
39