Group Redundancy Measures Reveal Redundancy

! " #
$%&'(
) *#,+-
. /103XZY\25[^47]`_a6"]`89b14;]`c:=< dfeGgS>@dihk?j1:Bb1AC]`cm.lo0=n1DFpqEG_rcm6!Y\AIpmHJctDLKsfY\uvwMY1/1x&NP_aOJY\/1cm0Qcm:Sly_rR5Y1x :=HT4UEWV
sfYFuCz|{1cXZoY!]ycmcm1l}lyu~cm_r[ypq_r3j1Y\r_a_aYF&sfcmlyl}C[^_a]gScmdfY!e]`cJil|cJeBl`dibFl3[`si3acJcJhb1l}"sfX;[`lygSsidicmhk j1b1]ysI]y_ad&Y
T&fB3m~=iTr
:Q89¤¥4;cm/1jF6"sf0Gl`]`hkcm>CY!]3K;7dfe6!AI¦§HJ_aDLd&KhkcJu~_¨pmsiUovGAIY1:Q8xi_rY1 cJcmly¡_aY1DFx ¢7K;£
&di{\Y\[©3d&j1ª"_aY\[©oY1_ricml}[`_«]&1¦§si«]y_ahkd&l`c&"¬*¤5L¥n~
¤sfYFuCocJz|j\{1sfcl`]`XZhkY!]ycJcmY&l}]3u~_rdi[yepq_r¯Gj1{"r_a"YF® [`sfHJ_rA9lydiC/\rdi6!gSxi0|&cmM!Y!¥]`6"cJsi0Bl|<Lu1eB6"s&diK[`l3[ysf3{cJb1¬l}sfcJ;u1_rgSpJsfdi°hkn~j1p}b1{1]yd"sId&]y_ad&Y
ocm1lycm3Y\_a&cml}[^_a]dfeicJl`bF[`siacJh"X[`lysicm
±,²'³i´~µ1¶·L´
eBXz|diu~{1lycmhckY!]ysI§_«]èBs9"_rdi_rY1YCx&x_rl`[|]yd&{1_rb1Y"çj\i[¥pJcTsi[df]y[è§_actx!sisIdfb\]èGu~cT[û_a]`]`d&_rb\h5l`[`b\_rY1aY1b\xcJ[^b1sfºZpqYlydidiYF_aY\Y~u~[¥eB_«d&]y_al`Y!_ahd&]yY1cmsfl}cJ]`siu½_rpdi]'_aYY\]ù1]yd{1cmjLcmpmd&d"cml`Y\u1cmu~ç]`cJ_¨s&pY!pq]'sfdij1Y1bFj1cJ[b1]yly_rd&lyp¹s&dip}Y\_aY1{¼[Jº »
]`Ssf_rj1dic¾j\Y(au1_rcJcJcm[ûÀi]`cJ_ra]`hkd&d,j¿sf]`[_r]ylydib\cJYu1u~b1ÃeBY\di]ylku1{1sixicY\lypqdipmÀb1dijFrhk[5siFcTdisid&e¥[`lyb1sfY1l`]`cJcT_rb1i[l`c*d&]`Y\{\pmd~[Jsf»¾u~]*_aY\z|sfx(r{1adIcJcmÁ[`ÄcCpmcmhk_aY1cJcT{FY\sisfpq[`Y\Ãb1pml`cJ_rcTY¿uÂ[¹]si_aSY1lèBcCd(dily]`j1hk{\l`cmdisfY ºº
pqÇ X`cTg|[`[`È5_aY\sfxY\u[]}sI]y{1]y_ac@d&Y\j1[ly_rhk_rYÀsil`]y{1c sfbFsib\u~_«u~]y_adi]`lydi lyÅpmdij\l`sI]`]ycq{!É |Ç s95UÊTÆ*Èq»*]y{13c*Y\_ru1Y~cmeBcJltl`_r]di§ld*pqu~d&_aaËUr_ pmcmb1lycmrb\Y!][
pqsfd~Y\u~uk_rY1x&x¸l`d&j\b1sfjkl}sil`cTu~u~_rxib1hY\u\[SsfSY\cpm_a[`cT{1[dIFÌcm]u~S_acJËLcmcJYl`cJX`Y\g(pqcTsf[|YF_auYpqLdidfl`]`]`{_¨pmsi_rY~\eBsfdibFlyu~h_«]ysIdi]`ly_rdi5YY1pqcJd&b1Y&ly]ydicmY\Y![J] »
z|u~b1{1Y\cJu\[`csfY\l`pmcT@[^b\ly«cJ]}u~[kb\j1pql`]`dI_rdi"Y_ü~sfcCrdieBdiY\lkx¹]`]y{\{1cctsiÍ\[ylypq[^cJ]kY\]ù~_rhk_rY1c½xsfsb\u1u1_a_«ly]ycJdipqly]cmj\"sI_r]yu1{"cm§Y\s9pm&cC1eBsid&[©l{\l`s&cm[º
]`Frsi{1cJl`ccmx&Ytcm[`l¸_a{"Y\"]`xijL{FrcqdfsfºZ]`YÅ[^{\j1cJ]`_rcJ[`ªi_aY,cTÎJ[5cJpmupmcmd""r u1'[J_a©Y1¦|sfxsiY\l`j\uÅrdIsi pmlys&siÇY1u~ÊJ_aY1Ï!x&diÐfhÑ]Ï&ÈqFsf»°clyz|cCly{1cm[`cS_a&x&l`cJY1cTsf_«u~rÍLcJb1pmuY\sfu1Y!©si]k_«Y\]ydi{,pqY1'r]`cq{1ËUc½eBcJdipq[^lk]y]y[°six&Y\b1l`d&u1Y\b1siu~lyj\cJu l[
l`xicTcTu~[]§b1Y\]`{\u\sfsf]©Y\pml`cTu~h¸b1Y\cTsiu1[`sib1Y\lypqcJ[Sly]`cJ{\u1sfb\]3pb\]y_a[`d&c'Yd&]`Y1l}rsfYFj\[eBsfd&_rl`l}h[SdisIe7]y_apmd&cmY\r[§[J»SsflyÒ¥cob1Y1l|di]|l`cTr[^_ b\h¸«]}_a]`[©cT[ûb1]yxid º
a[dI]}ÃsI]y_rr[^cm]`&_¨cmpmW[}ÈS[`cm1Y\b~[`]¥dilysikl`cj1sfl`d~j1pmj\cJa[y_rcJ[û_rY1xcm&Ç cmsfY_rh¸sI]3cTupqd&]yl^d¹]y_rlypJcJsfu1¼b\[`pqcmc¥Y\[`l`dicTu~lyb1Y\[û1]ysIsi]yY\_ad&pqY\[J_r»Y@_rY1j1b1]
~´ µ o·L´
_r3[`Y&"dI]y[^cm ]`l}cJsihu~pqd@]`[_rdisfx&Y\lyl`c|d&[¼b1pmp}j\di{Fhk[¥sfY1dfjLx&eSd&c[`[`sicJcmutaY\d&[`diY1dieUx|lys]`{\[`Y1cGcmcmlysib1_acT[ylypq[7dicJYFdfY\eU[¥u~j1_r_rY!Y1l`d~]`x3cJpm[^lycJcJs&[yY\[^p_r]o[`Y1di]yxlyd3[]}pmj\sId~sI]ù~]y_r{"dic¹YF§_r[mY~s9feB~d&ly[ cml`j\hl`sIÒ¥cT]y[^Y1_acJd&cY&Y*]y"_a_aY\sfcJYFx¥u½hk_r[¼{1di]`dIly{\c© sfsf];u~Y\[^dCu¹cJY\]`hk{\[`didicJly[`lycc
]`pqu~d¹d&_¨[hkxi]yl`dIj1_r&1acmcmb~É½ly]yY¹cJsiu(]y[`{1jFl`c'cTcJphkj1]yly[¥sicJj1df[`cmj1eGY!_r[`Y1]ycmsfx5YF]`[^_rLdid&cqY\l`][J§_acmY\_acJY~j1YeBb~d&]`]yl`{\[JhcJ»[`sfc'3]`_rhk[^di]yYsfdi]`Y\h_rxdisfY\]`É"[S{\_rc¹sfhklypq_ac3ÎTd&sI]`hk{\]y_ac3j1d&b~Y(]`]yl}sfsfsf]`YFYF_r[diu¾eBY\d&lysil`cJh;u~j\sIb1l`]yYF_r_aY\d&u1pqYksf_rY\j1]`pmd¸rcJ[¥[^j\l`j1cTsilyu~lydi[`b\jLcopd&]ysi[`_aY\d&cJYuu
]`_rY Êi{\ çj1Y\l}sicm» pqb1]`z|l}_¨sfpq{1wc&cTWpm[^d"dicCY1u1_rçcku~cT{\sisiasid&[¹[¥Y1j1]yxClyddI]`!u~{1_¨cJcu~ic@[`cJcmas*d&Y\j*[`pqdidihklyhkcqj1]y{1{1b1_rcmd~]yl}sIu1sf]y['l}_ad&p}]`{!Y\d &sf!»tSb\eBXZsfl}YsfY!hk]`di_al}eBcmu~§cmdi_rl'Y&ly]y]`ª½cmdl}]ysi_rd*Y"pqi]`_r_rY!cJdi[^&Y\]`cJ_r[[^x&]`sfsf_r]`x&hkcksfd&]`[^Y1c@bFx@p}p}{ {\x&sil`p}d&Y1{\b1xisij\cTY1[t[¥xicT_rdfY [e
Y1[`"cJ[^b1]`l`cJd&hY\[J» siY\u¾pmdihkj\sflyc]y{1cJ[`c@hkcJs&[^b\l`cT[_aY(Isfly_ad&b\[j1lyd~pqcJ[y[`_aY1x []}sI]`_rdiYF[tdfeos [^cJY\[`dily
XZ©Y!_a]`]`cJ{1ly_rs&YÀp]`[^_r_rdiY1YFx&[©acsfY\1ul}sf{1_rYÃ_rxi{sflyd&cJlys&u~[¹cJd&l3Y,pqd&]`l`{1lyccm¨sIrcm]y&_ad&cmY\3[§diFecmj\]Ssf_rcJlycm[kYdiY1ecmpmb\cml`rd&[JY\©[©[^§{\cmdIly©c'_aY1hkx d![L]ydfaC]y{Ã_aY"[î"cTY1[cJ]yl`_ax!x&sI_r[^]y]`cJ_ü p
sfu~YFb1u*YFu1lysfcJY\u~pmb\Y\u1h¸sfcTY!si][`b1_rY&ly]ycJcm[|l}sieBd&pqlo]`_r¨disfY\ly[xicmloÐ~ xi1lydi b1j\P»k[3dfz|e{1Y1ccmpqb\b\l`d&l`lyY\cm[oY!]siY\[u½]yb\pqu~d&hkeBj\d~sfpqlybF_a[^Y\cTxk[]`di{1YcT[û~ctcm&hkcmcTrdisij1[`b1_rY1l`xcT[3l`_rcmY º
u~_aËLcJl`cJY!]3j1l`d~pmcJ[y[^_rY1xk[]}sI]`_rdiYF[m»
lyz;sfcJj\d5u~j1b1]ya{1YF_ru1[§disfb\cJY\loY\pmuhk§cJhs&c¥s9[^bFb1[^lycFcJ[3cksf]`YChkd_acJY~cJs&aeBcT[^d&b1pl`]yhlyl`cJdisfu*ºP]`j1_rhkdi{"Ydi~ly[`]yc¹_a{1d&cmlyad&cmd&xirl`_ _¨cmsipm]`1sf_¨p¥rUlysicJcJj1pmij1dicJlyl}Y½d&u~si_aeBY\p}di{x&l[|six&eBY\l`lyd&udib1h _¨j\u~[¥cJ]Y&Sdf]yeGdC_«eBY\Csfcmb\b1s5u~lypm_adi]`s&Y\d&[^[Jl`c¥» eBdi[^]yl§sIç©]y_a]`{1d&{1_Ÿ\cJp}[J{Y Æ
]`[^{\]`_rch5_ab1Y~reB_WcJ]`l`{F_rdisIlt]opmsfdilyrca_¨pqpqb\ly_«a]yb\_rpJ[sfsiUY\eBdiu l|]`]y{1{1ccj\_rY!l`_r&hcJ[^sf]`ly_r½x&sfsf]`b\_rdiu~Y@_a]`did&el` sib\pqu~di_al`]`]`d&cml`ÉW@°pmsfdiY\lù ]`_¨pmb\si[Ùcpmpqd~d&u~h¸_aY\j\x acmÉ si» pmdib\[^]`_¨p
3¶ · ¶³ 3µ ³ wµ Gµ '³ oµ ³
§_rz;Y~dc eBdi_r[^lyY"]yhisfsIcTl`]@[]`]y_rdi_a"x!Y5ÃsIl`]ù~cTcu~cq{1ÍFb1_rY1Y\xi_au1{,Y\sixY\dipql}_r'Y~u~eBcJhkdilklycJhpms&di[^sIlyb1]`l`_rlycJdicJrYÌsf[¼]èB_rdih¸dilY\cT[^[¸sibF[`p}sfb1{tYFlycJu(xi[ly_rdiY!eBb1d&]`jFl@cJly[mx&s&»°l`pz|d&]`_rb1{\dij\cGYF[j1[¹lydi©die5jL_a]`pqcm{\cJl`_a]àY,¨_r[CcJ[;xisilydfY\die~u,b\]yj\{1]ycJ[¸{1[`cmdfcGYÂehkY1u~cJcmcms&b1&[^lyb\cmdirl`diYFcTj [[
sflyc]`{\cmYeBb1l`]`{\cml;u1_r[ypqb\[y[`cJu¥eBdil°]`{1cG[`jLcJpq_aÍFpSpmsi[`cdfe1[^]`_rh5b1rb\[^º pmdiY\u1_«]y_ad&Y1cJu'_rY\u~cmjLcmYFu~cmY\pmci»
_r©1Y½d&_ü~l`]`hcmcJrl`@siharb\['i[`wdfcJeG{\uC_a]`x&_r{1Y{(cJsi_ad&l Y\lysfu~rcJ~ l[^Q_¨\pq[§fdidf;lyely cmY1¨cmsIb\]`_rlydisiYF¼ [5Pu1 sIL]}cqs1]§~Ç ¬½_¨cm[©cJX^Yu~È cq]Í\Êi§Y\Ê&d cJ uIP"si»tl` _¨z|sf1{1r_¨cJ['[ S-cJasfª"Y\Y1u dI©ÁY si!l`b\c siY!!]`b\_asf]iY!W]y_«Y1Í\dIcT u
Ç 5È Ç 5È Ç È Ç ¸È Ç 1È Ç Ç È 1Ç 1È È
Ç Ê9È
hsfYFsfuklyxih¸_rY\cTsfsiW[`b1u~ly_¨[^cJ]`[ly{1_a1dIb1,]`_rpqdirY\d&[ [`c|]`Ç{1 c Èdi_rY&Ç 5]§Èu~_rÇ[^]`ly_r1*b~]`_r_r[|di]yY {1c Çb1r¸aFÈsip}_r[ª ]`¼dcJ]y_aL{1c©cml¥e=siu~pq_a]`&d&cml`ly_rxiÎJcJsfY\]`_rpqdic Y¸!¹Èq» ]`{\c
hhk1d&cJsIl5s&]y_a[^¨d&sfb1Ylylyxic]ycJ{\_rl[©sIxiu1]@lycqdi[`Í\cmb1Y1&j\cTcm[tul}sfdfsi|e3[ IpqsfcJlya¨_r[msi1siacTY [¸_aj1hkl`dIjL"di_¨lù~]ycsfY!sf]5Lx&dicmb~Y1]cJlycTsisiap}_r{ÅÎmcTudf]`{\h¸cmcTlTsi»,[`b1z|lyc{\_r&[ bFsfY!~]` _aPÍ\¥cJ [t]`{1cC_aY1PeB dil`º
Ç 1È
Ç 1È Ç mÈÇ Ç 1È È
ÇÈ
Ç \È Ç JÈ Ç \È
]`n"{\_rhkc _a¨d&sf_aloY!]w]`du~_¨]y[{1]yl`c _r1b~]y _aPd&\Y¹I°_¨[7 ]`d']y{1c§ e=Psi p]ydilypm_as&ÎT[^sIc&]y_a1d&]`Y5{\c"]`~{1 c©QGh sil`x&_aY\si rP[J IsfY\u¹hk_¨cJ[7s&si[^b\a|l`cTs9[©~[°{1jLdId&[`_apq]`r_rd&i[`cic »
c3Y1dI(]`b1lyYk]`d5u1cmicJad&jkh¸cTsi[`b1lycJ[7eBdilGxilydib1jklycJu~b1YFu1sfY\pm_acT[m»wgSdiYF[^_ü~cmlÍFly[^]w]`{\co[^_rhkj1rc
.
!#"
$
32 54
&%' )( *,+ -% , 768:9<; 2 <4 =9<6
A /-BC1 DFE3GH I
/KJC1 MLNL I
I
/
^
I
1
/
I
0/
1
I
E3GH
`_
/KJC1
D
v^
l2 54
E GH I
/le :fNfhf I /ji OD
T \U e JgfhfhfNJ U i
Qpo'P RrqrqrqrR QMs T =U e<JgfhfNfhJ U i tWnXY Z
T =U e ufhfNf T =U i ]
768:9<; 2 <4 =9<6
c2
d4
/le<JgfhfNfhJ/ji gLhL I
l2
>?
ba
b
A /be<JgfhfNfhJ/ji kD
@
T \U JV
T \U 7T V <]
1 ODFP Q?R S*T =U JV W=XY[Z
.
!>?
d4 76M8:9<; 2 <4 =9<6
768:9<; 2 <4 =9<6
f
nm
©pms&{1[^_¨c'p}{dfe]`s¸{1cj\lysfcJ_rl©u~b\dfY\e7u1Y1sfcmYFb1pqly!diºYF[`[ "Y1Ç cmlyxik_rTÈY\|u~cmpqÉdiY"Ç &cm" _aY\x5ÈS_¨_r[3Y~eBu~dicmlyÍ\hY1sIcJ]ù_rdi"Y sfLdib1]§]y{1c[]y_ah¹b1rb\[|"eBd&l
Ç !È
Ç GÈ Ç GÈ Ç wÈ Ç wÈ
XZ"Y!k]`b1di_a\]`[`_ricmlycJ"a&_aY1 x]y{1c di'_rY&h¸]|cTu~si_¨[`[b1]yl`ly_rcJ1[©b~]y]y{1_ad&c¹Ysidfhke¼diLb1dfY!]y]o{ die©_rY~sfeBYFd&lù hsIf]y_a~d&siY[SdipqYdihk]y{1j\c¹sil`[^cT]ùk_rh5©b\_«a]yb\{@[d&,\[^x&cJsil`"_aY\_rY1cJux
]`sf{\lycCcCpm]§dihkd j1pmrcmcqr]ycm[¸r_rY\lyu~cJcJu1jFb1cJY\Y\u1u~sicmY&Y!]k]ya&sf»Y\uXZY¾j1ly]ydI{1!c_ü~cqcÉ"]`]yly{1cmchk[`csih¸pms&cC[^cC_aY1©eBdi{1lycmhklyc sf]`_rdiYsiFd&b~]¸]`]`{1{\ccC[]]y§_ah¹d b1pmrcmb\r[m[
"Y1_ad&cJY~ru1ºPjL_aY1d&x [`_a]`_rici» Ò¥ YÀ]`{1Ç c df]`{\cml@w{FÈsfY\uWoÇ jFd![^_aw]`_rÈ i cÇ wÈ 9sia b\cJ[@Ç ]`cJ[^]`w_aeBÈqÅi©eBdi{1l_¨p}{k[^"_rY1[wcJsilàx&|_r[^s9]`~_¨p[
_rY&]ycml}sipq]`_rdiYFcm]ScJcmY siY\u Ç BÈ»
Lxi1lyd&c§dil|pmb\dirjsiY\l`df[`x&_re u1cm l§cmlyxicJY1lyuWcJdi»°b1b1lyz|j\di[§{\Y\cGdi[;e;Í\pqY1dil}[^cJhk];b1j\hkl`d&sicJY\l`s&cT[J[û'&b1]]`ly§d'c dksf!rb\u~&si_«_aËU]yY![ cm]`ly_a!Í\cmY!cJk]©[°ÊG]`hk{1[^cJc§b\s&1ly[^cJxib1[`lyly_rdiu~cJb1[§bFjFsfdi[mie;»°_rlyY~¥cJeBu~d&[°b1l`©hYF_au1]`sI{5sf]y_aY\_ad&Y\pmYt!pmaºdibF[`1"[^]y_rY1disfcmY~_rY1lyº xicTcqkuÉ1pm[êBal`{\b\d&di[`hb1_rdiüYs
pmsirpmb1¨sI]`_rdiYF[G]y{1_¨[©hkcJsi[`b1lyc']ysfª&cJ[§]y{1ceBdilyh dfes¸]`cJacT[`pmdij1_¨p[^b1h
Ç " wÈ &('*),+ - Ç "$ GÈ . Ç ÊTÈ "$ &('0/1- Ç wÈ Ç "È
"# "%$
©hk{1cJcJs&l`[^3cb1ly2 c½5h476ks9,sflydic¹~]}sfsfr;_rYÀ]`{1jLckd&[^[`b\_«]y1_a&xiclydib1Ç [`jF"[oY1cmdilyeGxi[^_¨_r[Îm]yc _rpTÈ83diIb1si]'Y1_rdi[èw{1]`_rY1{1x9c Ç _aYFs9u~IcmsijL_acm¨sfY\1u1rcmctY!]}Y1ÈqcJ¥b1lyd&dil@Y\Y1[¹cJ»x&sIz|]y{1_a&_rc[
ÇpmlysicJru1pmb1b1Ÿ\sIu1]`_rsidiY&Y]Ètb1Y~IeBsicTasib1[`cT_a[m\»ac3cmY1&eBcmdiYCl`]èBb1diY\l©sfhk]`cJd~au~&cml}_«sI]k]yc_aY"Á&dirIisicJa[ b1cT[ " » _aY1eBdilyhksf]`_rdiY ]ycmlyh[mhsfª"_rY1x*_a]y[
dfu~:ecmu1Í\ _«Y1ËUcJcmY1ulycJcmb1"Y!ly ,] diY\[3pmhkdihkcJs&j\[^sib1l`lycTc u@!]yb\dsiY&]`{F]y_«sIÍF]¥cJ[Wj\]yl`{1dI"cw_¨_ru~Y~cJeBudily"h; sI]yÑ_ad&Y[`_rcmY1h5xirLcd~_au~YF_ru~cJcmujL_rcmYY\]ù1{\cmcY!]¥diY1_rY!cJ]7b1lyu~di_¨[Y\]y[Jl`F_r1sib~Y\]yu_ad&_rY [
"
Ç
Ç wÈ
Ç Ð&È
" GÈ "#
<
XZLY!cq]`]cJ§l`cmcTcm[]yY_aY1]x&§ad¹&1h¹]y{1b1_ra[']`_a[`ºP_r!Y~Y\eBcmdilylyxih!sIºPly]ycJ_ad&u1Y@b1Y\]ycmu1lysihkY\pq[ hkcTsi[`b1l`c5hks9Lc5lycm©ly_«]`]`cmY½s&[©]y{1c¹u~_aËUcmlycmY\pmc
Ç " GÈ <" Ç wÈ
Ç !È
"#
"
" >È ?= Ç
" wÈ = Ç
= Ç È @= Ç GÈ
<
Ç " wÈ Ç " È
©_rY\{1u~cJcqlÈÉ Ac = Ç " # È BpJsfYÅDFC c[`cmj\Ç siÈlysf]`cJÇuÇ _aY!È`]yÈd _¨][§]`d {1c@]`cmcmlyY!h]`ly[mdiÆj"d&*Y1dice ]`{\sf]k» _¨[sfc@r|pms9di"Y\[¸pmaY1b\d&u1Y~cº Y1]`cm{\x!sfsI]t]`_r]ì{\c&c
sf!YFb\u@sfY!hk]y_«cJÍ\s&cT[^[3b\]yl`{1cTc5[w]yly{1cJu1ctb1pqY\d~u1u~si_rY1Y\xkpq[^"sfY1hkcJl`d&x&Y1ix~]`sf{\Y\c5uxi]`ly{1dictb\[`jcJpmdfdiewY\Y1u@cJb1©l`{1d&_Ÿ\p}[J{C»¥_¨[|z|sf{1rç§pqs9b1~ly[Sl`cJY1Y!di]¥Y~º §jLdid&ly[`ª_«]y_aeB&d~c'pqb\si[`Y\cJu [
diYC]`{\crsf]^]`cJl3lycJu~b1YFu1sfY\pmk]`cJl`h Ç " È»
/lepJ/
/lepJC/ ?J
D
m A /le<B
A /lepJC/ ?B
^
b/le
DFA /lepJ/ B
/ e
jA /lepB
-A / B
j/
>
jA / B
[/ e D#/
D
,A /le<B
C m ?
[/
.
e D
A /
B
e
o A /
P
B
e
fhfhf
P
A /
B
M/
m
e
*
e DFA /lepJgfhfhfNJC/
D
P
B
A / B
ve
P
/ e JgfhfNfhJ/
D
/ `D
e
B
A /lepJgfhfhfNJC/
e
D
^
A / e gB fhfhfNBC/
L
Q
T =U W=XY T =U
A / tB
D
/ e JgfhfhfNJC/
L
ve
P
/
e
/
L D
A / e BgfhfNfhB/
A / e BgfhfNfhB/
/
[
FHGJILKMKONPQISRUTOPVWNRYXZ[PQIS\\.NP]T%TO^_T%PQX`NKONa7I7ba7_bSc(deN(fgNcTOPVWNcX.`NPQhY\bShUic_bjTXbSRUdekXK
\ KOXISl7PmRn_KO\.NKmTO^_beopqOorcNRYRYPs
tHu ^SNbvcX.`lS_KOhYbS\wKONaLISba7_b7cd!hYb[a7hUfgNKONbjTxlLKOXjcNPQPQhYbS\yP]TH_TOhYX.b7Pz{XbSN@`%ISP]TecX.b7PQhna7NK
TO^SNN(fgNcTOP|Xk}TO^SNVS_PQNRYhYbSNAhYb7kXKO`_TOhnXb~cX.bN(djNa5VjdN_c(^@PQN(TXkMbSNILKOX.bSPs u N9TOÎ7P|I7PQN
TO^SN?bSXKO`_RYhnNavKONaLISbSaS_b7cdcX`l_KON?Z:hUTOÛop9ls orE_ba xaLNib7NavVjdv} m F
1 FYYY M C F Q F Yn } Js
|zsipq{1]`cG_r"eB_«di]yly_acTh5[@b1sf¨sIly]yc_ad&_rYY\u~dfcmejLcmYF u~"cm# Y!]@_rY5x&c _a&&cmbFYÅsI]`]`_rdi{1Yco[]yj1_ah¹lydIb1ircJb\[¼[ {1_ax&{1Ç r'bFw[^È cmeBb1"_a Y" ]y{1c|pmÇ si[`cw
©w{1È»cJl`cSXZYÀY1cm[`b\b\lyp}si{
[lyycJpqcmu~YFb1sfYFlyu1_adFsfY!"]©]`{1l`c5cJxiÍ\_rhkly[^]ci»wÇ [`¬"Y1d&cml`clyxi_r1h¸ÈSjL]ydicml`ly]yh siY!I]`sfriY\~_r[`b1{1Y\cJu1[Jcm~l©]y{!]ybF{1c[3r_a_aYFhku~_acm]`jL_rY1cmxY\u1Y1cmcJY\b1pmly
c5si< ¼si[y_rY&[^b\]ycmh¸l}sij1pq]`]`_rdi_rdiYY\[|Sc]yddi]`Y\{\a c
{\dfe©s9&]ycS{1c]ydeBb\cJ[â|]`_ru~hk_¨[sf]y]`l`c|_r1]yb~{1]yc3_ad&hY sflyxiÇ_rY\ sf~ u~_¨[^]`ly9_a1È» b1]`X_rdi]5Y\]`[ {"b\[¸Ç sfr
dI 3[]`9d*È;eBcJdi[^l]`_rcThksisfp}{k]`c[]ysf_aY¾h¹b1cmÉ"abFjL[di©Y\cm_rY\Y![^]`]`_¨sfcJrs&au
[`sihkpJpqsib1al}rcmsIl°]ycY!b\_aY1h5eBLdilycmhkl°disfe1]`_rj\disfY,l}sfcJhk[^]`cm_r]`hcml}sI[J]ymcJ©[J»Â{1_¨p}z|{{1_a_Ÿ5[@disib1j1l°j1pJlysid9[`É~cw_ahdfe1sI[`]yh_ad&sfY(r&{\[ycmsfY\hkpmc½j1rcGsfr[â_rdIÎm3cT[m[kTj1]yd lydI_a"Y"_r&u~cJcT[^[W]`hk_rx&disIly]ycc
lypqcJd&u~Y\b1[`_rYFu~u1cJsfl`Y\cTu@pm¥_rYCsih¸]`{1d&cY1x©r_«]ypqcmd&l}Y\sI[^]y_¨b1u~l`cJc&ly» si1aorsil`x&cmlWxilydib\j\[Udfe"Y1cmb\l`d&Y\[U]`{FsfY']`{1cw]SdiºQ]y{1l`cJcY1cmb1lydiYF[
_r3sfY5j\dIj1]y {1l`d9c©lyÉ~cJpm_rs&sih[^[`d&c§sIY\]`dfsf_reFdi\YY\acwdi_Ÿ~[¥_¨[;ºZsi[^]`_rr{1h5[`c|db\pqly«d&]}cJY\sfs&Y1u~[^d&cJ_a]`diY\_rb\disfY\1[;rsil`ccT«º pq©_rd&Y\{1lyu~u~cJcmY1_rjLY1cmcmx!&YF[°cmu~lo©cmY\Y\{1cm_¨pmp}b1c§{¸lysidi_rj1[7Y\j1si_rY\ly;d9u~s&É~cmp_acTh]ùt_r"sI]y_«]y{1]_ad&c3Y _¨pm[os&C[^hkc§X ]7d&_rY¹[^_¨[;]`d&reBb1b1alu~rtu1cq]ysIsicm]}pJlys1pqhk»;b1_al}z|Y1sIcT{\]yu cc
"1ob~]¥]y{1]`c§{1c5j1l`cqcTÉ~[^jFcJcJY!l`]`_rcJhkucm[^Y!]`]y_rh5si°b\cJab\!_¨[7u~sfcJYFY\u'pqct]`d¥_rYs3]àcT{\[`_r[`[¥cml`l;cJcqx&É"si]`lycJuCY&]7_r[o"hk¥_r_«Y!É~]`cJcmu l}siÇ pq[`]`cm_rctdiY\c&[°» xF©» _«]yB{tÈ»©Y1z;cTsfd@ly![^b\'h¸Y1hcJb1sil`l`d&_rY\Îmc&[J
]`ly{\cJu~çb1[^YF]ù1_rh5sfY!b1]|rb\l`[^cJº xipm_rdih¸Y\c&u1"_«]y1_ad&b~Y1]3cJsfura_rdIY\3u~[ScJjFb\cJ[SY\]ù~dcmYFpmdipqhkckj\si[ysf[^lyb1c3hk]y{1j~c]y_acqd&É"Y½]`cJr_aY!hk]§_adi]y['e°l`b\cT[ou~b1]`d@Y\u\_rY!sf]`Y\cJpmlys&psf]`hk_rdidiYFY1[3x¸_rY½¨sf]`ly{\xicc
xilydib\j\[§dfepqcmr¨[|_aYu~_aËLcJl`cJY!]31lysi_aYsflycJs&[m»
µ ´~¶ ´ ¥³
_rz; Y1d¥Ix&[w_rY"=eBmil`~cJd&[^h "]`_rx&]§sfÇ X`]`dtg|cS1È5l`cTl}ºu~sf_rb1]`Y{1Y\cCsfu1lysi]`cJY\{1s&pq_r[l}udf_re°Y¹j1¥]`ly{1sfd~rc©pqdfcTsf]`[`{FbF[`sf_au~Y\Y1_«x*]ycodi[lysi]}Y1sIcJj\]y[^_asI]`d&]y{\Y{!cq|]`df_rs9eoÎmicT]Ìu{1§cpmc|sfsi]ysf[y[JY\pqÆSsicJÊ aY\"tu~Îm_rpqcSY1cJcqx a¨É"[si]èBl}b\lysiu~dipmh_acm]`rd&a]`b\l`{\ rsic l;j\ sflycJ]`{"pm di|l} s9u" º
º5l}sfsfoYFs&uÌp]`ÊT_r"Ï _«]pmcmr§[¸s&eB[lydil`hÑcTpqd&]yly{1u~ccTu Y\ diY~ºZ[^_rh5¥b\«]}sfIY1 cJdib\ [à ¾eBl`d&!h Ç s5ÊT]`È¹di]yºsi3]`{1dfce Í\e]ù~{Ã_aËL[cJ]}l`sIcJ]yY&_ad&]Y¼sf»ÅY1_rohcmsfb~¨[º
lypqcJd&[`Y\jF[`d&_ru~Y\cJu~ly_rsiY11xr]`d¾u1_«s ËUcmÍ1lyÉ~cmY!cJ]u,]`[`dcq][^_rdfhkej1[^r]`_«Í\_rh5cTu b1rsi_Q»ÀY\u¦§pqcTdipmhksfbFj1[^rccqÉ*pqd&[^l^]`]y_rh5_rpJb\sf3a_ sib\u~W_a]`Sdiçly¾lycqY1eBl}cJsfb1_rlyY½diY\eBly[kdihlycJ[`b\jF[`d&_aY\Y\ux
]y1sfsfl`_rly]`]ù_r_aÍFicpm&_rd~cqsipmÉ1sfsidIrh¸_ iÎJcmsIj\l`]yaºZc_a[^d&_r_Ÿ\hk[3[©j1[^©{\a_ dIÍ\{1©cT_¨p}u½YC{½si_rpqYpmd&diY!Í\b\]yxi[^sfb1]`_r_¨lyY\pkç[3[Êipm]y»di_ah¹hkb1j1ar_cq#É\b~" ]tlycJ_asiYF«[º ]yr_«cJeBsi$c u"Fsib\pm[`dicb\[^s]`_¨[^p'cmeB]cJsfdi]è|b1[^ly]`cJ_r[Jh5»3b\ a_ly\cms&j\[^l`cTcTu*[^cJd&Y~Y º
e
I
`
I
I
/)L
D
/ CL
ve I
/&L cD
/
L
D
<
+ "
9
; 2 <;
74 9<;
9<;u4
68 :; =9?;
4
x 10
8
1
7
6
frequency (KHz)
amplitude
0.5
0
−0.5
5
4
3
2
−1
1
7st_aYFx&sIb1]`lyb\clyÊisiÆ;\cmÀY""l`cJ_rl`j1d&l`Y1cThk[^cJcmY!Y!]y]JsI»]y_az|&c§{1c[^]`[^_rh5cm]Sb\dfab\e°[S[^]`pq_rd&h5Y&b\]}asf_W_rY1pqd&_rY1Y\x[`_rs[^]`[^cT{1ukd&dfl^]we;[`\_a_ahkl}u¸_r siilGd~pmY\sisfa]`_rÎJb1sfl}]`sf_rUdiY¸sfYFlùcTpqhkdil}d"u~u1cT_«u5Í\cT_rYu
lycJpqd&lyu1_aY1x![m» >½ n"_rxiYFsfW_rYC]y_ahkctu~d&hsf_rY&% n"_rxiY\siW_aYeBlyc !b1cmYFpq@u~d&hsf_rY¼»
' µ ´~¶ ³ (´~³
XZsiY[y[`dib1l}hku~cJc@l[^]`d&dthkcTc@[]yly_ahcmj1sIly]ycJc©[`cm_aYY!]yj\sfly]`s&_rdipY ]`_¨pqdic|e3]yY1{1cmc3b1_rl}Y~sfeB§dilysihpq]`sI_r!]y_a_ad&]YkpmsfdiY\Y!u]`cJ[^Y!cJ]wY\df[^d&eWl`Y1 cmb\_aY\lysij1\b~si]y[Jpq»]`_r!XZ_aY ]i]`&{\di_rY1[¸c©j\h¹sijFb\cJ[^]l
§[^]`c5_rh5pqb1d&rY\b\[^[©_ü~_¨cJu~l©cmY!]S]y_«]dcm©É"]`_a]`ly{½cmhk[`c5j1_rpmªis&c[^pqcTd&[mÆ§b1Y!pq]yd~[Ju~» _rY1x@s&pqdibF[]y_rpJ[©©_«]y{*[`_aY1x&act[`j1_rªicT[osfYFupqd~u~_rY1x]`{\c
20
40
60
80
time (milliseconds)
.
100
20
M
+ "
$
40
60
80
time (milliseconds)
100
2¹D¼7:=K7£/18iDL¢7HmOT:=8iH :=OJ4,HJ:QK;£L0=6H 7:=<F6"H
dfz|[`cqeW{1]5]yc3{1dipmce|b1sijLl`pqlyd&d&cm[yY!b\[`_a]w[^1]`[`r_¨cJckpop[êB]yl}]`_ad&sf_rh5Y¸hkb1eBcJd"r[_Lpm[`_¨b\[t{1[`d&cJ&l^[cm]ylydia*kY¸j1¨]ysf{1lylycJc©xipmcl`cJcJu~sfr_rsfYFY1]ùx_rdi]yY¸Y1{1dFcmh cmeBl}]SsfÇ hk©cJcm{1cY_rp}si[`{Cpq_aY1]`Sb\x&sic'ac3aru~*[`cmj1Y\ly_rªidfcmcTjL]`c'[cJsfsfsi]yY\[ [uk_a`]y[` [`{1cmdial`qe] Èq©S»wc_aoY\h¹u1[SdI]`b\3{\[^c][
Í\l}[]©j1lycqº j1lyd~pqcJ[y[S]`{1ct[^]`_rh5b\a_W]ydkl`cTu~b\pqc'eBl}sfhkcJ[©u1_ahkcmYF[^_rdiY\sia_ ]i»
j1dfz;e¹lydkd9Ð É~]`{1_ah_¨[3hksIcJ]y_arY\_aY\_ruW[`x*\cJpm§]ydi{1cY\c*uÃÍ\pql}d~[rcm]©p}Y\{1]yxfrlycJ]`si{°siY\l¸o[êB]`©dil}ly_asf]`h Y\{ [^]èBÊ di{1lyc¹h¸h[_rsI]y _a]àh¹_¨_r[^dicTb1YLpqaÈ¹_°d&Y\_asiY!uÀY\]ùd[`j\]`]`{1si{1cpmcJ_aYÃY1eBlyxFc cq» !É"b1]`l}z|cJsiY\{1pqpq_¨]k[CdIu~[`&cqdicm]hlyr_¨sfsi[C_rj1Y pmj1a_rÇb\Y1ly[^dix]`b1cJ©x&l`cT{1_au,Y\rCu1_adIY!sf3]yj1d [º
z|pqd&{1Y\_¨lyu~[cm_alyj1]`cm_rlydij1cJY1ly[`cJcTcm[ùY!cm]}Y!sI_aYF]y]`sfu~_ri]`cm_rcTjLdi[mcmY¸GY\©sfu1rcm{1adIY\_r3p}pm{,cC[b\pmsisi[[yj~[`]`b1]`db\hkcJl`j~[^c½]`]`_r_ru~hdi_aYFËUsIÈcm]`c|lydfcm]ye3Y!{1]pqc cJsia¨d&pq[5d&_aY!b\s&]Gp[^]`]ù~_¨_r_¨p@"[_«]y]eBl`cT_r1sI]ysfb~b1YF]yl`_au d&cTY[k[]y_aÇ _aY,b1h¹Y\b1d&u1b1acm_Pl7leB]y[di{1]yl¹_ac3h¹xi[b1ly]ydi_arh¹b\b1[j\b1[tr[`b\cqdf[]Jºe »
eBpqsfb1cJx&Y\ac¨pq[k]`_rY~_rdfdieBediYlyu~hdf_aËLeGsIcJY"]`l`_rb1cJdih¹Y&Y¾]@FpmcJ[`di_rl¥ÎmY"cJdii[JeScJ» ipqcTcJ;ua¨_r[¥xi!b\eBdil`cl'[`_aFY1dix&]`[âc{{\dIpqt3cJaÊk[5¨[msf]y»{1Y\cu½z|{1_aX`YFcCgÂpqlyu1Y1cm_«hkcmËUb\cmcml`lyY!d&cm]yY\Y\si[mpm©Wc@h5pmLdib~cqhk]y]b\§j\sfsfcm©cJlycJY _ru½Y~]èBd&©{1l`cT_«h]y[^{*c@sI]y]]y_aS{1d&çd*YÅs9as&_r&Y1[kcmcJl`s [º
hkY1cJcJb1s&l`[^d&b1Y\ly[7cJ['[`sf]y]`{1b1cl}sIly]ycJcJu~[7b\sfY\rlù1cTsfsiYFu~pq'5 ©_«]y {C"Ê9# Ð3pmdicme§r c [J!Ib\cqsIÉ~]y{1_a_rd&1Y _a]`_r\Y1»x'z|[`_r{\xicY1_aÍF_aY1pmeBsidiY!ly]7hklysfcJ]ù~_rdib\Y Y\u1pqsfd&YFY"pqi'cm&eBdicJl7u xi"ly*dib1X`jFg [
¨Ç sfY\lydfxi]`cmcl|]y]y{1{\csfY!º sfÊ É~k_r[|pqcm[yrpm¨[msf»|rcT¬ÈS1dilyb1c]©_r]`h¸{1cJjL_adil3l`_r]yY~sieBY!d&]`l`rhiFsI[`]y_r_aY1d&xiYrct[`b1thÊ[©Y1sfcJrb1hklyd&di[^Y\]©[©aj\_rY1l`cJdIsi"l`_¨ru~ic» acT[`[3_aY~eBd&l`hsf]`_rdiY
>* AI:=?/~A9V(>@¢77:BOJDFA9V,2¹DFATOT6
% ® K;N 6!AI:=DFA2¹DF0Q0=:Q8i¢70=¢7H
8'; 2
M
> m
^
m
.
e
1.4
0.12
1.2
mutual information (nats)
mutual information (nats)
0.1
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0
1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
7pmsi_ax&rpmb1b1ly¨c sI]`_rÆWdiY5XZY~§eBd&s&l`[;hlysIcm]yjL_acJd&sfY']`cTsiuFd&eBdib~l];[`[^cm]`_r&h5cml}b1sfr&b\[`[Ub1eB1l}sfx&hkl`d&cTb1[¼j\si[;[¼dfs§e\eBcTb\siY\p}p{¸]y_a[^d&_rÎmYc&dffe"sfxiY\lyu¹di©b1j_«]y[^{¹_rÎm[`c&cm»°&cmXZY~l}sfeBd&!l`lyhsiY\sfu~]`_rdidih Y
_r"[`Y~cm5eBcJdiukY1lycJh_rb1Y1sIly_a]`di]`_¨_rY\sfdi[rY¾_aÎT]yl`sIeBcTl`]yd&sI_ad&h]yY\cJuk[m»d&_rY\z|_aY!u~{1]cmc'jLu~u1cm_¨[YFsf]ylyu~l`ª5cm_r1Y!rb~_a]`Y\r]y cJ_ad&sfY" l§4 pqdfC b1eoly
i[`cqc3]}Ç u1[5cmdi
Pj1Èeo_¨p©Y1]}{1cJ[b1_a]`rl`c©{\d&c¥]yY\{1s9[ coicJpqlyb\sil`xi&c§cJu¸_aY1aeBÇ _rdiY1lycohku1sfcm]`j1_rdi_¨pY]}[Gj1Gs9lyÈ dIi"cJ»ly_ru1siocJxiau c
_rY~Ï eB»dilyhsI]`_rdiY@cJ[^]`_rhksf]`_rdiY\[S§cmlycopqd&l`lycJpq]`cJu¸eBd&l§[`hsfr«ºZ[ysfhkj1rcJ[w\_rs&[G"[`{!b k_rY14x¹h¸cm]`{1d~u1[
2¹D¼7:=K7£HmOT:=?¢;0Q:EWV,H :B<L68iDL¢;KUOTH
pqd&cSY"iY1cmdI&cJuÃ]yb1"lyÀYt]`5d¥Ê_aY"&sicJY\[ûÀ]`_rx&X`gsI]ycGH s':B[^<LcT6pqdiYF8iutDL¢;pqd~KUu~OT_rH Y1xosfLjFdisfb~l}si]u~]`_rxi{\hc 9:Qsf;Y\6"u¹KUOTpm:BsfO}¨V pqb\rDLsfN½]`cwOT]y4;{16 c§_a;Y~eBAId&6"l`HJh6"sfKU]ÒT_r6!di Y
HJpqd&OJ:=b1?Y!]y¢7[ 0="1¢7u~H _¨[»|]yz°l`_rd1b~]`]y{1_a_¨d&[oYcJs&Y\[|uWLdi~S]}çsf_rpmY1sicJru@pmb1eBrlysfdi]`h ctslycm{\jL_rcJ[^]`sfd&]`xicJul}sfj1h lycJdf[èwcmY![^]}j\sI_aª&]`_rc5diYFpqd&[Sb1diY!e°]y]y[o{1sictY\[u]y_ah¹cJ[^b1]`_rrh_Q» sI]yct]`{\c
]`7t{\_aÊ&x&c»b1u~lyo_rc [^[']ìly_a¿_rY*1b~u~]`]`{1cm_rj\ckdi_rYpqpm]ys&df[|[ê|c¹¬lydfcJXGeSu~u~b1pm_¨d~YF[^]ù~u1ly_asf_aY\1Y\x@b1pm]`©_rdi_aI]`Ysf{ rd&b1[`~cJ_rY1]y[sixisi_arY1c¹h¸cT[ùd&j1Y1eB_rxlyªidicJsfh[JrWw[^[`pq_r_aY1Y1cJax&x&ºPaaçc'jFsfpqt_rcJlyÊka[ ¨[SpqÇ cmcsir!Y\¨b\[¥uksIpmÍ\]ydi_ax&Y"d&b1YilycJc !Èoid&¦Å_rY*Yj1s9X`lyigcJcJ[`lycmsisiY!Y\xi]}u c[
]`]`rcJ{"{\[yb\co[[df_a]yY1si{1eBardicmdIlSly©hk{\_rsfsfY1YF]`x*_ruWdi]y&Y,d j\sfl`x&dILsi"di_a_Ÿ(b~u~]c©h¸]yhkd&{1l`dic*clyc3[^_r]`Y~_a_rY1eBh5dieBdib1lyhlyrhkb\sI[Jsf]y»¿_a]`d&_rdioYYdIeBS©lydicJ{1h icJcmY@lTx&wpql`d&d&]yY\{1b1[`cmj\_rÅ[¸u~cJsfdfl`lye'cTc½ukY1sfcm[^cJb\¨[^j\l`dd&sfY\l}hksI[m]y»ÅdicmlyrcX`5g _a1YFb~Y1u~]|cmcmb1sfjLlylycmdic3Y\YFu1hk[¹cmdiY!d&ly]JY c
lycJu~b1YFu1sfY!]J»
−0.02
0
m
.
5
10
number of cells
15
20
−0.2
0
5
10
number of cells
A /
^
15
A / e JgfhfNf /
B
<
.
>
>
>
O
;zpq¨d3si[y_a[`r _«b\Í\[cJ]yllysf]`]`{FcsI]y]@{1cGj1ly{1cJ_ru1xi_r{pq]y_rY~[eB]yd&{1l`hc*sI_ü~]y_acJd&Y&Y]y_«j1]Ål`dI"df_ëu~]ycJ{1u'c½"'j1lyFcJdi[`]`cm{5Y!]`[`cTcquÃ]}[mT[]yS_ah¹cw]`b1l}rsfb\_r[@Y1cJs&upmpqs©d&Y1lycJu1b1_aY1l}xsff]yY1dcm][`Sj1d&_aª&l`ª c
pqpqd&d&b1Y\Y![`_r]yu~[GcJdflysie¼1srcr_ahkj1l`_acT]`cJu~uC_¨p]`[^cm_rdi]GY dfeWsiY1pmpmcJb1b1l}lysidipqY\&[J\» 17b1_r]¥xib1X`lyg¿c Y15cJ[`b1{1l`dId&3Y\[3[w]`d&{\~sf]y]Gsi_aFY½dis9]`{@&cm[`l}cqsf]}x&[wcdis&e¼pmY1pmcmb1b1lylys&dipqYFC[wdfsiewp}{1hk_rcmdi&lycc
]`pq{Fd&sfl^]yYC_rpJÏ sftUY1jLcJcmb1l}pql`cJd&Y&Y\]©[|sflyr_rly[`cJcJsi[©u1pm¹diY!©]`_a_r]`Y"{@b1diÍ\b\i[`cr pqcJ a»¨[m"©{1_r co]y{1c's9&cml}sfx&c©j1l`cTu~_¨p]`_rdiYCsipmpmb1l}sipq¸b\[`_aY\x
>½ ¼:QK;£L0=6*2¹6"0=0 ® K7NPDFAI?¾/~OT:=DLK
% o/\:BA :=HT6AI6!7¢7K;7/1K78fV
.
,
0.4
0.35
probability of occurance
0.35
probability of occurance
0.4
Auditory Cortex (A1)
Inferior Colliculus (IC)
0.3
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
Auditory Cortex (A1)
Inferior Coliculus (IC)
0.3
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
0.05
0
0
0
−0.5
rly7cJcJ_a[yu~x&[5b1b1_rYFlyY~c u1eBsfdi\Y\lyÆ hpm>*½sI]y»G_ad&¤¥5Y¾_¨Ê'[di]yjFl`Ysf_r1_rs9lyb~&[ ]ycm_aÇ d&l}asf_rYxix&{!ckdi]3e§]`\{\¬sisiX'lyY[}siÈ§X`pmgsfl`lyd!c[`Y1['cJpmb1dipqY\l`cJd&apmŸ\cm[mY![J»¸»]`tl}sI% Ê]ycJ pquCcJ¤¥aY1¨_¨[ [cJ]ysiÇl`l©r_r_ 1xiÎmb~{!cJ]yl`]_adFd&\~Ysf©l}df{1[ye©È¥_arc]ypq{1d&X`cY"g,iY1cmjFdi½sfly_rh[`lyr[|_asfx&r{\_a{&ÎJs9]ycJ&au c
]`[`sf{F_al}x&sIsIY1]y]S_«cmÍLhrtpmsfsfeBÉ"Y!d&_r]ylGhkaCcJ_as&ÎJ{1p}cJ_a{[Sx&{1dI[]yicm_al¥cJh¹lyl`sib1cTaru~1b\b1¬[SY\siXu\»~Y\sfoukY\b1pmcm@h5&cmILlysf¹cmrl§b1pmdfcJcme¼[JrQ»31»_rn"XZY\Y~j1[SeB_rd&ªi_aYCl`c5hpqpmdisIdi]yb\b1_aY&Y!d&]}]}Y[[3º cJ{1§[^_¨]`cm[_rly]yhctdix&sIpqly]`di_rsidirh YFcJp[w§]y§cJs&ucm[wlydId&c3&j~pqcm]`dil3_rhklylyscJ_aÎJ©pcJ]y_ru@cJY\u¸u~[`cmeBdId&j1 lº
[`hksia ºZ[`sih¸j\acT[S\_rs&[|![^{"b _rY1xkhkcq]`{\d"u\[ Ï P»
7[^]`_a_rx&h5b1b1lycrb\[,F» _ü~cm¯wY!]`ly_acJ]u~ _¨psi]y_a[,d&Y s s&eBpmb1pqY\b\pqly]`s&_rdipqY dfdfee
Í\Y""b1_rcJsflJh5]`»o_rLdivGcmYl`llysididfpmloe¸l`d!\pq[`sfcm[l}r¨[o[@[`cmu~b\&cJ[`cmY1cJl}dfuÀsf]yc¹![^,[^b\]y1si]yY\xi{1lyu1c disfb1l}pmjFurs&[[ù~[`dfcq_aººe
]`di{\Y\c¹cqº [y{1sf_rhku\u~c¹cmYC[`_aÎJrs9ci&» cm\lGdiY\l¥cmcJb1sil}p}sf{½LY1[`cqb1]1§x&dil`lyd&ª¸b1j¼§Us&s [
]`b\l}[`sf_aY\_rY1xtcTu[^d&h¸[`cmc3jFsf[^]`l}_rsIh5]`cJb\aab\[GeBd&j1ltlycJcJ[`s&cmp}Y!{]ysf[^]`]`_r_rdih5Y\b\[ab\s&[[
_]`rsY1cTx\[]y]yly»|_asiY\¯_axY\cm_al`[^Y1eBcmx di]Jly» [^hcm]¸sfY\sfpmYFc¥ulycm]`jL{1dicCl`]`l`cTcTuC[]¹_¨[©eBdieBl5d&l©]`cJ]`[^{\]^c º
^³"· o³"³
Y1cJc¥b1l`{\d&s9Y\&[c¥sfu~Y\cJu icJsfad&j1jFj\cTa_rucJu½_aY1]èB{1dilycJhkh sf]`]`d_rdiY_rY!]y&{1cJcm[^]`d&_rl`x&cmsf]`]`_¨p3cthk]y{1cJcks&[^pqb\dil`r¨cTsf[GLdidie¼l}sIl`cT]`_ru~ib1çY\pqu1d~siu~Y\_rpqY1xsicqh¸Äd&pqY1_rcmx5Y\x&pml`d&b1_aY j\[G]`{\dfc e
LsfbFdfu~]`{_«]ydi_rY~lyeB½d&l`hkhd~sIu1]ysf_ad&r_«Y]&pq»diY!3]yY\cmY!u1]GcmlsfY\]§ukdx&lù~d&_«b1ËUjkcmlyl`cmcTY!u~]5b1Y\pmd"u\u1sf_aY\Y1pmx_acTj\[siFlycms&]u~S_rxicJcmhYk[mX`°g(ScsfY\[ù{1dIpm dil`]ù~_¨_apmËUsicm1lysfcmb\Y\u~pm_acJ]`[d&l`_rY
.
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
mutual information I(X;S) (nats)
−0.4
−0.3
−0.2
−0.1
redundancy −I(X1;X2) (nats)
0
>
.
?
1
.
prediction accuracy
0.95
0.9
0.85
0.8
0.75
0.7
5
10
number of cells
15
20
$
t 0^7N9l7KOXV_VShYRYhYT1dXk}_ccILKH_TON9lLKONa7hYcTOhYX.b5hYPN
LlWX.bSNbTOhn_RnRUdDKONRn_TONaTOXeTO^7NhYbSl7I7TQq X.ILTOlSILT
ÌLTOI_R>hnbLkXKO`_TOhYX.b z>h_ATO^SNKONR_TOhYX.b ]:`hYPQPQhnb7\*b_TOPH%dLhnNRaLhYbS\ "! $#
%'& bSXLsXkP]TOhn`%ISRYh) ( %'& * + (s-,Rn_PQPQhUiSc_TOhYX.b9TOÎ7Pl7KOXhna7NP,RYXZNK:VWX.I7baLPX.bhYb7kXKO`_TOhnXb
cXbTONbTs
1Y1cJb~b1]tl`sid&l`Y\c5[J»sirn"[`d@_rY1x&hkac¹d&l`X`c¹gÂl`cTY1u~cmb1b\Y\l`d&u1Y\si[oY!]JpJ»¹sflyÒ¥l`Y½hk]y{1diçlyc5df]`_r{\Y~eBcmdil'ly{\hsfsIY\]ù¼_rdi¼Y sfb\sfu~L_adi]`b~d&]¥l`]`{1pmçdil`j1]`ly_¨pmcJsf[`7cmY!Y1]`cJcTb1u½l`d&[Y\]y_a['h¹pmb1sfrlyb\ly[m
rsfcJr[yhk[;d&_rY~[^]weBd&al`_rY1hcTsIsf]yly_aad&¹Y5©1{1b1cm]Ysipml`dic§Y\hk[`_rdiu1lycmcGly_a_rY1Y\xu~cmx&jLl`cmd&YFb1u~j\cm[Y!df]JeUieB]`cJ{"(b\[]ycmsfY\r [GdI©dfeW_aY1Y1x¥cJb1_aY1lèBd&diY\ly[Jhk»;sfz|]`{1_rdic3Y5ly]`cJd'[`b1Fac©]y[[`j\b1l`hkdIh¸"_¨cTu~u c
eBsfdibFlCu~_«]`]y{\dic½lykÍ\j\l}[sI]C]y{!]`|_rhks9ic"siu~[S_rly{\cJps&][SLcm"cm_¨cJu~YCcmY\{"pm"c½jLdfeB]`d&{\l@cJly[`_acJÎJu~cJb1uYF"u1sfY\¦|pmsf,lyal`dIcT u~b\Êp]y»_ad&z|YÌ{1sfc¥rdilycJY\u1xb1Y\]`{1u1csiY\sipq[ypqcJcmY\ËLu~cT_rpY1]yx [
]`b1dicJY\Y\Yau1cmpql©cmjFrsf]y¨[m{1_rly\ct[|si[^diY\_re7Y1upqx&pmcJacmsia¨ºY1[J[`Y1»j1df_rªi]©cJL[|cpmd"l`cJu1i_aY1cTsfxkrcJj\uCsily©s&_«u~]y_r{Cxih ]y{1ctsil`[^c]ysf[`YF_ax&u1Y1sf_«l}ÍLu@pmsflyY!cJ]©u1b1diY\Y\u1asiY\eBd&pql3xihklydicTb\sij\[`b1[§l`rcTsi[§l`x&]`{\cml§sf]3]`{\b\si[`Y c
rsfÒ¥dIj\b1j1l'aa_rcJl`cJicTuk[^cmb\"cJ«i[`]}cmcJ['Y\Yk[`[`sfdib1]Glyx&¥xipqcJd&j\[^l^l`]o]yd~_r]ypqpJ{\cTsf[`1sI[`][`_rcmY1lyY\x cJ[ù~diÇ b1sily_aYF5hku1[^cTsf]yuY\sI]ypm]`_ad'd&Y\l`l`[JcTcT»u~u~b\b\pmpqcGco]`_rlydi[`cJb1Yu~xib1]yx&lyYFcJsi[û1Y\]sf[]`Y\eB{\d&pmsfl`¥h]S_rY5sfsfYk]`_r_rY1dicJj1Y\[yb1[`[¥cm]Y!sf[^]`ly]y_¨c5sfsf]`1Y1_¨cm[di]yÉ~]'_rjFpJr[ycJ_ahkÈ¼l`_r1hk_a]`b~cTcm]u½Y!sf]y]ylysidc
j1j1lylycmd~lypqc cJ![yb1[`_a_Ÿ1[^_ax¸]`c½d~pm]`pmd¾b1lyly[©cm&sfcJ]|sf]`3{1]`ct{1pmcTdi[^c½l`]`_¨cmpmËLsfcT¼p[^]}]y[@sf]`_¨_r[diY\]y{1[J»c½b\[`c*dietpqdihkj1rcqÉÃsipmdib\[^]`_¨p½[^]`_rh5b1r_'©{1d&[`c
j\Lz|sfcJ{1pq]`c3{"d&hk§siFs9cdI~&]`[Jb1cG"Y1]`Í\{1cTYFuc5u~]`Y!_aY\db\x&h5hk[wLsidicml`lyl3c|ct_rdipqYked&hksiY\xicmj1lyb1acmlycmcJdiÉh¸Y\si[|cJY\Y!_ruY\]7pm©_al`Y\_acTu1]`si{¸cm[`jLci]`cm~{\Y\]yc©{1u~!cmcJ_r_rY!cml3]3(Í\eBly]`cJ_r{FsfY1]`sIxb1]GlylysfcJsfr[Jdi]`»GcTY\[©z;x¥diu~]yxicJ{1pmcmc3l`]`cT{1sisicJ[ypq[`lJcicJ1Y\\]`{1u~siY\_rcTY1[ûxctY1[^[`cmcJb1b1Y\xily[`x&didicJYFly[^ ][
]`]`{F_risIct]tu1]y_a{1hkc@cmY1YFcJ[^_rb1dil}Y\sfsiwa_ly]cmij1»GlyXZcJY&[`cm]ycmY!ly]}cJsI[^]`]`_r_rdiY1Yxir_ï[t\hl`cTsfpqj1cmY!jL]3cJu¾siu1_a9Y!si]`d½Y\pqs½cT[©l`_rcJYj1l`ª&cTcm[^lycJY1Y!cm]yasIº ]yh¸_ad&cmY ]`{1©d~u1_a]`[|{rcJ{1si_al`x&Y\{1_acmY1l5xkcq{\ËUs9cJ&pcº
]y]`[`{Fsf{1]`dIsI_r©]©diY\Y[^b\[3]`p}hk{F{CsIs9h]@sfY1Fj1dicj1Y1_rb\rY1_ [`Y1x!cqcJ[GeBsib\j1l¥¼lyheBdIdi"sflo_rj\u1acTj1cosf_acJY\lys&Y1xC[^_aY\_r_rcmY!x¹l§]`d@dilycJe{\sipm_au1dix&dihk{1b~cmj1]|lrsfcqu~ÉY\_rhku@pmrcmh¸s&Y\[`d&[`[`_al`_ad&c¥ÍFY*pmcqsfÄsf]`YF_rpqdiu½_rY\cmY![JdI»]|icJXacT]3l^ºZsf_rpqly[©d&Y1hk]`_r{1Y1j1cJx5al`cmcm_r]`YeBctdi]yl©ly{1cmjLcj\d&l`1[ycTly[^[^si_rcJ1_aY~Y°rc º »
µ · ³
:
v
M
% Uo%s s0_KORYXZ}sLNb7PQXKQd|`NcH^_bShYPQ`PzTO^SNJKONaLIScTOhYXbXkKONa7I7baS_bScdjzL_ba|hnbjTONRYRYhY\.Nb7cN.s b
Xba7Xbzo(-.r-Ls "!#$%'&()* z lS_\.NPrr,+Lr-Ls. NK0/9_#1 NP]T d32 PP]TH_TOhYX.b_KQd;X54cN.z
6

7%8s ,KONb7bSNK9z gs :;s TQKOXbS\7;z <>s =}XVWNKORYN.z;<Msa7N<mI7dTONK*._b?jTONNb7hnb7c@Wz_bSa u s9hn_RnN*@gs
dLbSN(KO\d|hYb9_b7NI7KH_RcXaLN.Bs A $&"CEDFG%'$H zo7HI.JYorLozpp.pLs
Js /es ,XNK_bL
7JNXZ W,X)K @Wzg(o --Lo.a s K7s Ms 0^SX`_POs N P*CQFRPS(,&FR5?&T Us : RYNbISV` :KONPQPz
Y
([s Z*_TJ_b\a 7s 0hYPQ^Vjdj]s dLb7NKO\d_bSaKONa7I7baS_bScd{_`X.bS\VLKH_hYbcNRYRYPJXk VWN^_hYbS\`Xb7q
@FRNdLP^s i1_b h^/e&(s W)[s b =}jN!_kKObS)PT>z )Wls MMFS3s zW.X.X.RYRnRY_LISz `_NbS\a oo.`z ,0s M_s `%,X.V7^7KOhnba7zS\NN.a7[z hU/\TOXMMKOPz;z ,o a]-"b-c-L>s '/idm: KOA NPQPe&s "C8f(*&*g
r Js K7[s Z*_Z:b7N}_bSia s K7s < hYcH^S`Xba 8s JXZ~hYbSa7NlWNbSa7NbjT:_KONJTO^SN `NPQPO_\NP:c_KQKOhYNa|Vjd_.#a 1Q_q
cNbjT:hYb7kNKOhYXKmTON`lWXKH_RcXKQTOhYc_RbSNILKOX.bSGP nXoep;A $&*H' zo7H I J " I.5r q#+" I"Ijo.z (o --.Ls
rs
:s /e8s ZJXjcH^ShYb 9z /es ,XRYX.`VWXLtz Z%>s MM[s `*XKQk`_b 8z Z%s 6 8s ZJNKOP]TONhYb z_ba , s Z%9s Z KOXPQPus 7JNILKH_R
NbSPQN`VSRYN*cXa7hYbS\hYb9hYbLkNKOhYXKmTON`lWXKH_RgcXKQTON vs oep>A e&%$T5)"C pn[z Io J (r +L." Iz (o -"-5Y7s
Is
K7s :js 7*_aS_R$z 7js ,KOI7bSNRzL_bSa 7%ws : _KO\_>s 7JX.b7RYhnb7N_K,kNNaLkXKQZ>_KHa{bSN(T Z0X)K @P Z:hUTO^P]TOXjc(^S_P]TOhYc
X.ILTOlSI7TO,P JhYbLkX.`_ xhY`lSRYhYNP%KONa7ISbSaS_bScdeKONa7I7cTOhYX.bx
s A yE&zw{|DFG%'$H}[$&"C
3z -$J wp I,+Lj#o Iz ,o -"-qLs
)
T
)
l
S
F
q
(>s 7JNQR @.Nb>z W>s <mXTO`_b z_ba;G%;s _KQq WXPQNk ~s lWNchn_RYhY_TOhnXbxXk0TO^7N_ISa7hUTOXKQd3P]dLP]TON`kXK
TO^SNm_bS_RUdLPQhYP0Xkb_TOI7KH_RSPQX.ISbSa7P3s 1Pb K7$s ,KOI7\.\.NJ_bSRa : s es :XjXbzNaLhYTOXKOPz DE&"C a b H&T
bA $&"C>_ b *C $! s :RnNbLI7`9$z 7JNXZ W,X)K @Wzg(o --wIs
^
h
&
(
)
j
i
!
- 6 /esGJl7TOhYc_bz Js KLts Z*_Z:bSNtz s K7;s < hYcH^S`X.bSa z _b
a :s K7;s K.X.PQNlS^s JbVShn_PQNa3`N_PQI7KONP}Xk
TQKH_b7PQ`hYTQTONahYbLkXKO`_TOhYX.b{_bacH^_bSbSNRc_lS_chUT1dkKOX.`[`I7RYTOhY_KOhn_TONmbSNI7KOX.bS_Rga7_TH_Lts C p
DtTw& [z r.$r J .p.(r +opz ,o -"-o.s
UopP :s Jjs < XRYRnP_bSRa Ms KONNP;s A $&"C A yE&)z5 bu &5P>$'* sG kXKHa Jb7hnWws :KONPQPz
(o --"qLs
Uo.o( , s :>s ^_bSX.b ^s ME`_TO^SN`_TOhYc_RgTO^SNXKQdXk cX.``%ISbShYc_TOhYX.b0s N *CC8)T5lF0ul)j)"C
$&["C z" IjJ " I-(+jYjLz r# +jr"r rz(o -5Ywqs

Download Report

Group Redundancy Measures Reveal Redundancy

Paperzz.com

Your Paperzz