Characterization of a Tropical Estuarine System: The Placencia Lagoon Technical Report by Eugene Ariola CZMI Water Quality Monitoring Program Coastal Zone Management Authority and Institute Princess Margaret Drive, Belize City Reference: Ariola, E. A. 2003. Characterization Of A Tropical Estuarine System: The Placencia Lagoon. Report prepared under the Coastal Zone Management Authority and Institute. Work in Progress for Public Discussion. i Table of Contents Acknowledgement iii List of Figures iv List of Tables iv List of Plates iv Abbreviations and Notations v Executive Summary 1 Introduction 2 Objectives 3 Hypotheses 3 Study Area 3 Materials and Methods 5 Characteristics of the terrestrial zone of influence on the Placencia Lagoon 7 Characteristics of the Belize Barrier Reef Lagoon (Coastal oceanographic zone of Influence) 10 Importance of the Placencia Lagoonal Estuarine System 11 Major Land use and Activities in the Placencia Lagoon and surrounding areas 14 Results 17 Discussions 26 Conclusions 29 Recommendations 29 Bibliography 30 Appendices 33 ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENT The preparation of this technical report would not have been possible without the assistance of several persons. Special recognition is due to the members of the survey team especially Captain Kirk Rodriquez, Hampton Gamboa, Trenton Samuels and Alexander Garbutt. These gentlemen worked diligently to collect confident data and made each survey a memorable experience. Thanks to the CZMAI Administrative Staff especially Melissa Almendarez for providing the logistical support for the field monitoring surveys. Thanks are also due to Ian Gillett for providing assistance in resolving the software glitches that were experienced in processing and analyses of the data presented in this report. I am indebted to Natalie from the Belize National Meteorological Service and Rigoberto Quintana of the Belize Fisheries Department for providing valuable information for this report. iii List of Figures Figure 1. Geographic location of the Placencia Lagoon Figure 2. Extent of the terrestrial zone of Influence on the Placencia Lagoon Figure 3. Villages in the Catchments Surrounding the Placencia Lagoon Figure 4. Shrimp Mariculture Operations Near the Placencia Lagoon Figure 5. Bathymetric Map of the Placencia Lagoon Figure 6. Mean Temperatures for the Placencia Lagoon Figure 7. Mean pH Measurements for the Placencia Lagoon Figure 8. Mean Specific Conductivity Measurements for the Placencia Lagoon Figure 9. Mean Salinity measurements for the Placencia Lagoon Figure 10a. Mean D.O. mg/L Figure 10b. Mean D.O. % Saturation Figure 11. Mean Turbidity Measurements for the Placencia Lagoon List of Tables Table 1. Summary of the characteristics of villages in the Placencia Catchment Table 2a. Shrimp Mariculture Production & Export Data 2001. Table 2b. Shrimp Mariculture Production & Export Data 2002. Table 3. Mean Measurments of Several Parameters in the Placencia Lagoon Table 4. Variation between Surface and Bottom Salinities of the Placencia lagoon List of Plates Plate 1. Photographs (a)-(h) iv EXECUTIVE SUMMARY There is growing concern about the current status and fate of the Placencia Lagoon amidst the changing land use in the adjoining catchments. The destruction of natural vegetation to construct dwellings, resorts, roads, and aquaculture development is a major issue in the study area. Another issue that is frequently echoed and poorly substantiated is the contamination of the lagoon by domestic and industrial effluent. The first part of this report focuses on the Placencia Lagoon not solely from the perspective of its immediate borders but rather in the context of the catchments and the Southern Shelf Lagoon that bear influence on its health. Knowledge about the geological, hydrological, meteorological and oceanographic characteristics of the zone of influence on the Placencia Lagoon is essential to understanding its structure and function. Furthermore, appreciations of the biological and chemical processes that operate therein are fundamental to determine the lagoons ability to cope with the rising influx of sediment and effluent loadings. It is in this light that a conscious effort was made to characterize the lagoon. The results generated by this research substantiate that the Placencia Lagoon can be classified as a moderately stratified estuary based on its salinity distribution and circulation patterns. In addition to this, there is a notably low water exchange rate between the upper section of the lagoon and the sea. These finding signals how vulnerable the ecological and environmental conditions of the lagoon are to the impacts of developmental activities in the area of influence. Without cause for alarm, it is strongly recommended that future developments be planned to ensure the lowest possible impacts on the estuarine system. The second part of this report is an assessment of the water quality in the Placencia Lagoon. Several water quality surveys were conducted in the lagoon in 2001 and 2003. Key water quality indicators used to determine the status of the Placencia Lagoon reveal that it is a healthy estuarine system. This signifies that the conditions therein are conducive to unimpaired growth and reproduction of estuarine organisms. It is envisaged that this report will stimulate public discussion about the fate of the Placencia Lagoon and trigger future monitoring, research and management initiatives in the area. 1 INTRODUCTION There are 30 coastal lagoons distributed along the mainland coastline of Belize. Most of these lagoons remain in pristine condition. This may be attributed to the fact that most of these lagoons are remote and isolated from direct human impacts. The Placencia Lagoon is one of the larger coastal lagoons in Belize. It is currently a focal area for human settlement, tourism, fisheries and aquaculture development. The rapid expansion of the human settlements in the area augments the perception of loss of critical habitats associated with destruction of natural vegetation and increase discharge of untreated domestic wastewater. The constant upgrading of roads that link one settlement with another is a potential source of sediment to the nearby waterways and the Placencia Lagoon. The tourism industry is an integral component of the socio-economic situation in the communities of the Placencia Peninsula. The current trend to expand tourism development in the area could increment economic benefits in the short term to the detriment of the fragile environs of the Placencia Lagoon. Resultant impacts of tourism development include mangrove destruction and structural modifications such as dredging and marina development. Other impacts include wastewater discharge, euthrophication and increase in boat traffic. Evidently, there is the need to for planned tourism development that is environmentally benign. Shrimp mariculture development is a viable activity around the Placencia Lagoon. Since the inception of the mariculture industry, this activity has rendered significant socioeconomic benefits to the local communities. The continued expansion of the shrimp mariculture operations around the lagoon will destroy natural vegetation and enhance the salinization of the already poor grade soils. The potential impacts to the coastal lagoon include increase loadings of nutrients and organic material, euthrophication, sediment accretion and the spread of pathogens. There is overwhelming concern about the status of the Placencia Lagoon especially considering its intrinsic value and the fact that many coastal lagoons around the world are under threat of damage, severely damaged or already destroyed consequent to anthropogenic impacts. Thus far there is no comprehensive study that documents the status and health of the Placencia Lagoon. To this end, a new approach was undertaken to (1) collate as much information as possible regarding the physical characteristics of the entire estuarine system and (2) conduct a limited time scale water quality monitoring in the Lagoon. It is expected that the information presented in this report will be used to initiate future monitoring and research initiatives to further contribute to informed management of developmental activities in the Placencia Lagoon and its adjacent catchments. 2 OBJECTIVES To identify and document the characteristics of the estuarine system of the Placencia Lagoon within the context of influences from adjoining catchments and the Belize Barrier Reef Lagoon. To elucidate the vulnerability of the Placencia Lagoon to the potential impacts of land use changes including human settlement and aquaculture development. To assess the current status of the Placencia Lagoon based on key water quality indicators. HYPOTHESIS The spatial and temporal fluxes of pollutants within the Placencia Lagoon are regimented largely by the physical characteristics of the lagoon coupled with the attributes of the terrestrial and coastal oceanographic zones of influence. Water quality deterioration and habitat degradation in the estuarine system can be accelerated by improper waste disposal and effluent discharge. STUDY AREA The Placencia Lagoon is a semi-enclosed coastal lagoon located in Southern Belize between 16°30’ and 16°40’ N latitude and 88°20 and 88°25’ W longitude (Fig. 1). The Placencia Lagoon is 3.4 km wide at its widest extent, 20 km long and covers a surface area of 30 km2. At mean sea level (MSL), the average depth of the lagoon is about 1.5 m. The lagoon is physically influenced by the coastal oceanographic conditions of the Southern Barrier Reef Lagoon and the terrestrial conditions of the surrounding catchments. 3 4 MATERIALS AND METHODS The Coastal Zone Management Authority and Institute provided the equipment and materials that were utilized in this study. These include the following: (a) a 28 feet skiff equipped with two 115 hp outboard engines, global positioning system (GPS) and echo sounder. (b) Two water quality multiparameter sonde [H20 and DataSonde 4a manufactured by Hydrolab Corporation]. (c) A unidirectional current meter manufactured by Qualimetrics Inc. (d) Graduated PVC pipe (The measuring Pole) The objectives of this research were accomplished using the methods and data analyses described below. Comprehensive Literature Review Throughout the duration of this study, the author was fully engaged in reviewing literature pertinent to the Placencia Lagoon. This step was necessary to collate relevant information and identify the information gaps. It is believed that the existing information gaps limit our understanding of how the lagoon functions as a system, how it reacts to hydrological, meteorological and tidal forces. Furthermore, it is not clear how the lagoon responds ecologically to anthropogenic inputs of sediment, nutrients and pollutants. Data Collection Water Quality Four water quality surveys were conducted in the Placencia Lagoon on the following dates: Survey 1 April 5, 2001 Survey 2 May 31, 2001 Survey 3 March 12, 2003 Survey 4 July 17,2003 Sampling stations were randomly selected in the study area on all surveys. At total of 59 stations were sampled on Survey 1; 65 stations on Survey 2; 53 stations on Survey 3 and 25 stations on Survey 4. The water quality multiparameter sonde were used to record surface and bottom measurements of temperature, pH, Specific conductivity, salinity, dissolved Oxygen, depth and turbidity. Prior to any measurement in the field the sonde was properly calibrated in the CZMAI Laboratory. The salinity sensor was calibrated using the synthetic seawater method described in section 1.1H of Parsons et al. (1984). The accuracy of the salinity sensor is ± 0.1 parts per thousand. The pH probe was calibrated using a three-point calibration procedure with pH buffers 5, 7 and 10. The accuracy of the pH probe is ± 0.2 units. 5 The turbidity sensor was calibrated with known concentrations of formazine solution. The accuracy of the sensor was ± 2.0 NTU. The depth sensor (a pressure transducer) was regularly calibrated in the field to compensate for changes in water level, wave height and barometric pressure. Unlike the aforementioned sensors, the temperature sensor is factory calibrated with an accuracy of ± 0.05 °C hence, there was no need to calibrate this senor in the laboratory or the field. Bathymetry A special field bathymetric survey was conducted on July 18, 2003 in which 202 soundings were recorded in the Placencia Lagoon. The depth measurements were taken using the pressure transducer installed on the multiparameter sonde and the echo sounder aboard the CZMAI research vessel (Submarine 2). A graduated PVC pipe was used to measure the depths in extremely shallow but critical parts of the lagoon. As with the water quality stations, all bathymetric soundings were geo-referenced using the global positioning system. Data Analyses The data recorded on paper and on the multiparameter sondes were uploaded to Microsoft Excel worksheets. Using this software, basic mathematical operations were conducted to prepare several charts and tables. Furthermore, water quality variables were analyzed with descriptive statistics to determine means, ranges, standard deviation and variance. A non-drift krigging interpolation method was used to create contour maps using Surfer 7.0. Maps of this type illustrate the bathymetry, spatial distribution of temperature and salinity within the study area. Considering that most of the data obtained in this research are geo-referenced data, the final maps and graphic illustrations were produced using ArcView GIS 3.1. 6 Characteristics Of The Terrestrial Zone Of Influence On The Placencia Lagoon Geology The Placencia Lagoon catchments (Santa Maria, August Creek and Big Creek) are part of the Central Coastal Plain as described by King et al. (1989). Within this portion of the coastal plain are relict marine terraces and alluvial fans (Pleistocene sediment) overlain by more recent floodplains and terraces of the Toledo Flood Plains Land System. The Placencia Peninsula, which is an appendage of the Santa Maria Creek Catchment, is a striking geomorphological feature. In fact, the peninsula is the largest sand spit along the Belize coast. This barrier spit that is comprised of few Holocene beach ridges and is only a few hundred feet wide, separates the Placencia Lagoon from the Caribbean Sea (High, 1969). Based on the geology of the area it is understood that the quaternary alluvium deposited in the terrestrial zone bearing influence on the Placencia Lagoon, is poorly consolidated and readily erodible. This could be a major source of sediment influx to the lagoon especially in light of changing land use, deforestation and desertification. Hydrology Three catchments namely the Santa Maria Creek, August Creek and Big Creek border the lagoon (Figure 2). The Santa Maria Creek watershed has an area of 347 km2. The terrain is relatively low-lying with a maximum elevation of 500 meters on its westernmost boundary. Based on a flood risk analysis (Ariola et al., 2000), approximately 12.7 km2 of the basin is permanently inundated and 32.7 km2 is prone to flooding. Santa Maria and Hemsley Creeks debouches directly into the Placencia Lagoon. However, Silver Creek and several small creeks in this watershed flow into wetlands that display connectivity to the Placencia Lagoon. The vegetation cover within the watershed includes pine ridge savannah and mangrove swamps in the upper and lower reaches respectively. The August Creek Catchment has an area of 250 km2. The low relief of the catchment makes it very vulnerable to annual flooding events. Approximately 16 km2 of the basin is permanently inundated and while 93.2 km2 is prone to flooding during the usual rain season. The major waterways in this watershed are Mango Creek and August Creek that converge at the lower section of the catchment and flow into the Placencia Lagoon. Flour Camp Creek, Jenkins Creek and several minor waterways also contribute to the net discharge of Mango Creek. Pine ridge savannahs dominate the higher portions of the catchment. The lower portion is limited to marshland and mangrove swamps. The Big Creek Watershed is the smallest of the three catchments adjacent to the Placencia Lagoon and has an area of 59 km2. Most of the lands in this basin are less than 20 meters in elevation. This basin exhibits low relief and a moderate flood risk potential. An area of approximately 5.4 km2 is permanently inundated and 15.4 km2 are subject to 7 8 inundation during the rain season. The principal waterway, Big Creek, is fed by numerous small streams and debouches at the southernmost end of the Placencia Lagoon. The vegetation cover within this catchment includes marshlands, mangroves, grass meadows and pine ridge. It is worth pointing out that none of the watercourses that flow into the Placencia Lagoon are gauged, hence there are no time series on the discharge and water levels (Hydrology Service, 2003). However, Grimshaw (2000) purports that the combined low flow for August and Mango Creeks is 0.7 CMS. Furthermore the low flow for Jenkins and Flour Camp Creeks was estimated at 0.8 CMS. Silver Creek was estimated to have a low flow of 1.3 CMS. The ground water resources map of Belize divides the country into ten regions based on water availability and quality (Buckalew et al., 1998). The terrestrial zone of influence on the Placencia Lagoon falls into two of these regions. (1) The Placencia Peninsula and the western margin of the lagoon are classified as areas where small to large quantities of brackish to saline water are available. Also, meager to very small quantities of fresh water are available from quaternary alluvium and coastal deposits along the coast. Depth to water is 2 to 50 meters. (2) The wider extent of the terrestrial zone of influence is that part of the Central Coastal Plain composed of sandy shales, shales, claystones, mudstones, and alluvium. These deposits bear meager to moderated quantities of freshwater. Depth to water is generally less than 60 meters. Although, there is limited information about the ground water distribution in the terrestrial zone influencing the lagoon, it is envisaged that ground water might have some effects on the water budget of the Placencia Lagoon. Meteorology The Placencia Lagoon and adjacent catchments fall in a tropical climatic zone. Walker (1973), King et al. (1989, 1992) documented the rainfall distribution for Belize and indicate that the annual rainfall for the Placencia area varies between 80 inches (2032 mm) and 100 inches (3048 mm). The mean annual temperature for the region is 28°C and the mean relative humidity is 80%. The predominant winds are out of the Southeast at a mean speed of 4 knots. The Belize National Meteorological Service (BNMS) has a countrywide network of climatological stations. Station 28 located at Rum Point Inn and station 29 located at the Savannah Forest Station are the stations nearest to the Placencia Lagoon. 9 Characteristics Of The Belize Barrier Reef Lagoon The Belize Barrier Reef Lagoon is divided into the Northern and Southern Shelf Lagoons based on differences of physical, chemical, geological and biological characteristics of the area (Purdy et al., 1975; Purdy, 1974). The immediate coastal oceanographic zone that exerts influence on the Placencia Lagoon is that portion of the Southern Shelf Lagoon adjacent to the Placencia Peninsula. Bathymetry The bathymetry in the Southern Shelf Lagoon is very irregular due in part to the tectonic activity that formed the shelf in the first place (Lara, 1993). Subsequent growth of coral assemblages, the formation of incised valleys, channels and shoals also add to the complexity of the bathymetry of the southern Shelf. Seaward of the Placencia Peninsula is the Inner Channel with depths ranging from 10 –20 meters. East of the Inner Channel is the Victoria Channel with depths of 20- 30 meters. Sediments The Southern Shelf is comprised of both biogenic and terrigenous sediments. The biogenic sediment is derived from the remains of marine organisms such as corals, coralline algae and mollusk (Purdy et al., 1975; Purdy, 1974). The terrigenous material includes quartz sand, muds, and clay minerals derived from the Maya Mountains, the Central and Southern Coastal Plains (Esker, 1998). The fact that the Southern Shelf Lagoon shows high influence of terrigenous sediment highlights the influence of terrigenous material on the Placencia Lagoon, which is in closer proximity to the Central Coastal Plain. Currents Thus far there is no comprehensive study of the current patterns near the Placencia Peninsula or the Placencia Lagoon. The Watershed Reef Interconnectivity Scientific Study (2001) purports that water within the barrier reef lagoon flows predominantly from north to south at a rate of 0.05 to 0.15 m/s and rarely exceed 0.3 m/s. The Regional Monitoring and Environmental Information System component of the MBRS is in the process of completing a 3-dimensional ocean circulation model of the continental shelf of the MBRS (Ariola, 2002). In addition to this, a 2-dimensional circulation model is also being prepared. Undoubtedly, these models will enhance present knowledge about circulation patterns in Belize. Tides Tides of the Caribbean and along the Belize Barrier Reef are microtidal and of mixed semidiurnal type with a mean range of 15 cm (Kjerve, 1981). PASCO (2002) mentions that the tidal fluctuations on the windward side of the Peninsula range from 0.40 to 1.5 feet. 10 Salinity The salinity of the Southern Shelf Lagoon is affected on a seasonal basis by the precipitation and river discharge in the southern province. The salinity of the Southern Shelf Lagoon fluctuates range between 33 to 35 parts per thousand (Gibson et al., 1993). The Importance of the Placencia Lagoon Like most tropical and subtropical estuarine systems, the Placencia Lagoon has ecological and environmental significance. The lagoon per se has a diverse amount of planktonic life that makes it an ideal nursery ground for a myriad of marine and estuarine organisms. Many of the fish that are caught for food or fun in the higher parts of the estuary or within the Belize Barrier Reef complex depend on the Placencia Lagoon for portions of their life cycles. Furthermore, the Placencia Lagoon provides adequate ecological and environmental conditions for the endangered and threatened West Indian Manatee (Trichechus manatus). The lower portion of the lagoon is relatively shallow with extensive beds of seagrass Thalassia testudinum that these creatures feed on. In close proximity to the lagoon are the mouths of several streams that are adequate source of freshwater for the manatees to drink. The inner portions of the Placencia Lagoon have areas that are completely protected from wind and wave activity that offer a safe and tranquil resting place for adult manatees and their calves. During the surveys, dolphins were sighted feeding in the middle and lower portions of the Placencia Lagoon (Plate 1). Fishers from Seine Bight Village confirmed that dolphins are sighted regularly throughout the year in the lagoon (pers. com., Javier Maritinez). Morelet’s crocodiles (Crocodylus moreletii) are also a threatened species that have been sighted in various parts of the Placencia Lagoon system. Platt et al. (1997) found no evidence of nesting activity in the Placencia Lagoon however, spoil banks in the Maya Beach area are considered potential nesting habitats. Grimshaw (2000) reported that the Morelet’s crocodiles use the habitats in the lower reaches of the Placencia Lagoon for nesting sites. The vegetation fringing the lagoon supports nesting sites for several marine birds. Quite frequently pelicans, gulls and bobbies are seen feeding in the lagoon and roosting on the natural vegetation. In addition to this, the marshlands surrounding the Placencia Lagoon serve as natural filters for sediment and pollutants. ESTAP (2000) report that the Mango Creek Special Development Area Development Plan approved in 1997, identified the need to protect the mangrove wetlands that surround the Placencia Lagoon. The intention is to ensure that water quality in the lagoon, together with manatee and other wildlife, is not negatively affected by inappropriate development. Some residents from Placencia and Seine Bight in conjunction with organizations such as BTIA and Friends of Nature express concern about the fate of the Placencia Lagoon. 11 In addition to the aforementioned benefits, the lagoon also provides unparalleled recreational opportunities for residents of the nearby communities and visitors. During the storm advisories, many shallow draft watercrafts (including catamarans) are moored in the safe heaven of the Placencia Lagoon. The aesthetics of the Placencia Lagoon fringed with mangroves and coupled with its high biological diversity makes it a focal point of tourist related activities for coastal communities such as Independence, Placencia, Seine Bight and Maya Beach. Undoubtedly, there are many more benefits that could be used to elucidate the importance of the Placencia estuarine system. However it is clear that this water body could be classified as a gem that could not be replaced and hence is priceless. Plate 1. Photographs: (a) Profiling the water column with a multiparameter sonde (b) Validating ground control points for the surveys (c) Local fisherman seeking the catch of the day (d) Mangrove fringed channel of the lagoon (e) & (f) Dolphins feeding in the lagoon (f) Manatees (g) Shrimp Mariculture Operation 12 13 Major Land Use and Activities in the Placencia Catchments Human Settlements There are eleven villages distributed within the catchments that adjoin the Placencia Lagoon (figure 3). Even though the villages located towards the westernmost boundary of the catchments might appear to be isolated from the lagoon, there is connectivity via the network of streams in the sprawl of the catchment. Therefore some of the activities in and around these communities such as agriculture, logging, and improper waste disposal could have direct and indirect impacts on the lagoon. The villages in closer proximity to the lagoon are generally larger in scale and population density. The activities in these settlements including destruction of natural vegetation, improper disposal of sewage and residual water, land reclamation, and road construction pose more direct ecological and environmental impacts to the waterway. A summary of the characteristics of the villages in the Placencia catchments is presented in table 1. Residential Development In September 2001, the wrath of Hurricane Iris devastated communities of the Placencia Peninsula and surrounding areas. The National Emergency Management Organization (2001) reported significant damage to major infrastructure and natural vegetation; and noted an extraordinary amount of debris scattered on the peninsula. Subsequent to this event most homes were reconstructed and new areas were also clear and filled to construct new dwellings. Currently there are several subdivisions on the Placencia Peninsula. These subdivisions are primarily for residential areas that would provide the necessary amenities for local and foreign retired persons. 14 15 Table 1. Summary of the Characteristics of villages in the Placencia Catchments (Source: ESTAP, 2000; Central Statistical Office, 2001) Villages Population Potable Water Waste Disposal facility Sewage Disposal Electricity Santa Rosa San Roman Maya Mopan Georgetown Cowpen San Juan 185 351 427 763 399 415 2,881 ? 831 458 30 RWS / Pumps RWS/ Pumps RWS RWS None None None None None None None None None Fair None Latrines Latrines Latrines Latrines Latrines Latrines yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes Independence Maya Beach Seine Bight Placencia Riversdale RWS RWS Cisterns RWS RWS Cisterns Septic tanks /Latrines Septic tanks /Latrines Septic tanks /Latrines Septic tanks / latrines Latrines Marinas Closely linked with the major subdivisions is the need for marinas to dock and safeguard the boats. Traditionally, boat owners on the Peninsula would dock their vessels in natural and man-made channels nearest to their homes. The Department of the Environment and the National Environmental Appraisal Committee are currently reviewing proposals for the construction of several marinas in the Placencia Lagoon. Shrimp Mariculture Operations Coastal lagoons in the world are recognized as suitable sites for aquaculture development (Contreras, 1993). The western margin of the Placencia Lagoon forms the nucleus of the Shrimp Mariculture Industry in Belize (Figure 4). Currently there are six shrimp farms located in this area namely Nova Laguna, Belize Aquaculture Ltd., Royal Mayan, Tex Mar Ltd., Crustaceans Ltd, and AquaMar. All the farms are functional with the exception of Nova Laguna. Collectively, these farms contributed 51 % of the total national farmed shrimp production with a corresponding export value of approximately 23 million dollars in 2001(Table 2a). It is estimated that during that same year, the farms within the Placencia Lagoon Catchments employed approximately 200 permanent staff and 230 temporary staff from the nearby communities. In 2002 the collective production of the mariculture operations in the Placencia area was 38 % of the total national farmed shrimp production valued at 17 million dollars (Table 2b). These farms provided approximately 231 fulltime employment and 247 part time employment to residents of communities in the vicinity. 16 17 Table 2a. Shrimp Mariculture production and export data 2001 (Data Source: Belize Fisheries Department) Mariculture Sites Nova Laguna Belize Aquaculture Royal Mayan Tex Mar Crustaceans Aqua Mar Production Area (acres) 94 324 158 116 1,000 Production Heads on lbs/yr 1,689,307 609,535 782,000 239,509 1,753,215 Export lbs of tails 1,142,812 391,000 512,000 156,000 1,131,790 Table 2b. Shrimp Mariculture production and export data 2002 (Data Source: Belize Fisheries Department) Mariculture Sites Nova Laguna Belize Aquaculture Royal Mayan Tex Mar Crustaceans Aqua Mar Production Area (acres) 180 318 128 195 1,000 Production Heads on lbs/yr 1,612,903 543,909 251,241 262,467 1,006,884 Export lbs of tails 369,452 348,102 196,655 170,606 944,768 Tourism Development Tourism is the base of the economy on the Placencia Peninsula. In order to further develop this industry there is an urgent need to construct resorts and hotels with the necessary amenities to host local and international tourists. Some of these amenities include (but is not limited to) beaches, piers, marinas, and parking lots. In view of this, there is a notably higher occurrence of land clearing, land reclamation and dredging activities in the area. Sport fishing (Fly fishing) and recreational fishing are popular tourist activity in the Placencia Lagoon. Special tours to observe manatees, birds and crocodiles are also on the list of things to do in the Placencia Lagoon. The Department of the Environment has received several applications for Environmental Clearance to develop Jet Ski rental operations in the Placencia Lagoon. Thus far all applications of this nature have been looked at unfavorably due to the potential negative impact on wildlife. 18 RESULTS Bathymetry The bathymetry of the Placencia Lagoon was computed based on 202 geo-referenced soundings that were registered within the lagoon. The depth varies from near zero at the boundaries of the lagoon to approximately 5.8 meters below MSL in the deepest channels and the mouth of the lagoon. The average depth of the lagoon is 1.5 meters (Figure 5). The water quality data from each survey was vertically and horizontally averaged to provide an initial perspective on the water quality of the lagoon. The results of the mean measurements of temperature, pH, specific conductivity, salinity, dissolved Oxygen and turbidity are summarized below (Table 3). Table 3. Mean measurements of several parameters in the Placencia Lagoon Survey 1 Temp °C pH units SpCond mS/cm Salinity ppt D.O. % Sat D.O mg/l Tubidity ntu 29.42 8.32 38.86 24.79 122.09 8.02 5.73 29.69 8.08 48.98 32.09 92.40 5.79 4.32 29.30 8.39 41.45 26.66 116.56 7.58 7.89 30.08 8.57 37.65 24.00 112.54 7.55 10.64 (Apr. 5, 01) Survey 2 (May 31, 01) Survey 3 (Mar. 12, 03) Survey 4 (Jul. 17, 03) Temperature The temperatures recorded in the lagoon during the four surveys varied between 29.30 and 30.08 (figure 6). Although lagoonal temperatures are controlled principally by solar radiation intensity, it is usually influenced by the influx of cooler water from the adjacent catchments and the water exchange with the Belize Barrier Reef Lagoon. The spatial temperature distribution in the lagoon for the four surveys can be observed in Figures AD in Appendix 1. 19 20 30.20 30.08 Temperature °C 30.00 29.80 29.69 29.60 29.40 29.42 29.30 29.20 29.00 28.80 APR, 01 MAY, 01 MAR, 03 JUL, 03 Survey Dates Figure 6. Mean temperatures of the Placencia Lagoon during four independent surveys. pH pH The pH determines the acidity or alkalinity of the water by measuring the hydrogen ion activity. Pure water is described as neutral and has a pH of 7. In the Placencia Lagoon the mean pH varied from 8.08 to 8.57 (figure 7). 8.70 8.60 8.50 8.40 8.30 8.20 8.10 8.00 7.90 7.80 8.57 8.39 8.32 8.08 APR, 01 MAY, 01 MAR, 03 JUL, 03 Survey Dates Figure 7. Mean pH in the Placencia Lagoon during four independent surveys. 21 Specific Conductivity The specific conductivity in the Placencia Lagoon showed some variations on the surveys. The mean specific conductivities varied between 37.65 and 48.98 miliSiemens per centimeter (figure 8). Specific Conductivity mS/cm 60.00 50.00 48.98 41.45 40.00 38.86 37.65 30.00 20.00 10.00 0.00 APR, 01 MAY, 01 MAR, 03 JUL, 03 Survey Dates Figure 8. Mean Specific Conductivity in the Placencia Lagoon Salinity The salinity is derived from the measurements of specific conductivity and is expressed as parts per thousand (‰). The salinity variation is between 24.00 ‰ and 32.09 ‰. (figure 9). The spatial distribution of mean surface and bottom salinities for the four water quality surveys can be observed in figures A-D in Appendix 2. 35.00 32.09 30.00 26.66 Salinity ‰ 25.00 24.79 24.00 20.00 15.00 10.00 5.00 0.00 APR, 01 MAY, 01 MAR, 03 JUL, 03 Survey Dates Figure 9. Mean Salinity in the Placencia Lagoon for four independent surveys 22 The salinity measurements within the Placencia Lagoon were looked at very closely during the analysis especially since several persons report high salinity gradients and stratification in the water body. Surveys 1 to 4 indicate that the difference between surface and bottom salinities were 0.31, 0.62, 0.28 and 2.87 parts per thousand respectively (Table 4). Table 4. Variation between Surface and Bottom Salinities of the Placencia Lagoon MONITORING SURVEYS SURFACE SALINITY Average Min Max Range BOTTOM SALINITY Average Min Max Range Survey 1 (Apr. 5, 01) 24.63 21.2 35.2 14 24.94 21 35.1 14.1 Survey 2 (May 31, 01) 31.78 18.2 35.5 17.3 32.4 26.7 35.6 8.9 Survey 3 (Mar. 12, 03) 26.52 20.5 34.2 13.7 26.80 20.5 34.3 13.8 Survey 4 (Jul. 17, 03) 22.59 4.9 30 25.1 25.46 13.3 34 20.7 23 Dissolved Oxygen The dissolved oxygen concentration in the lagoon varied between 5.79 mg/l (92.40 % saturation) and 8.02 mg/l (122.09 % sat) in the four surveys that were conducted in the lagoon. Figures 10 a, b illustrate the mean dissolved oxygen levels distributed in the Placencia Lagoon. 9.00 Dissolved Oxygen mg/L 8.00 8.02 7.58 7.55 7.00 6.00 5.79 5.00 4.00 3.00 2.00 1.00 0.00 APR, 01 MAY, 01 MAR, 03 JUL, 03 Survey Dates Dissolved Oxygen % sat Figure 10a. Mean dissolved oxygen concentrations (mg/L) in the Placencia Lagoon 140.0 120.0 100.0 122.1 116.6 112.5 92.4 80.0 60.0 40.0 20.0 0.0 APR, 01 MAY, 01 MAR, 03 JUL, 03 Survey Dates Figure 10b. Mean dissolved oxygen concentrations (% saturation) in the Placencia Lagoon 24 Turbidity The mean turbidity levels of the lagoon were relatively low on all the surveys ranging from 4.32 to 10.63 NTU. The following is a graphic representation of the turbidity levels in the lagoon. 12.00 10.64 Turbidity [NTU] 10.00 8.00 6.00 7.89 5.73 4.32 4.00 2.00 0.00 APR, 01 MAY, 01 MAR, 03 JUL, 03 Survey Dates Figure 11. Mean turbidity measurements for the Placencia Lagoon 25 DISCUSSIONS The depth variations of the lagoon floor bring to light several depressions. It is highly probable that these depressions serve as receptacles for organic material that settle and undergo decomposition within the lagoon during calm conditions. In windy and stormy conditions the depressions are perturbed and sediment and organic matter are resuspended into the water column. The water temperature is an important parameter given that it controls the rate of biological and chemical activity to some extent. Furthermore, several marine and estuarine organisms synchronize important events such as reproduction and migration with optimal water temperature. The observed mean water temperatures for two distinct dry seasons in the lagoon varied between 29.30 and 30.08 °C a difference of less than 1°C. Notwithstanding the fact that the ecological composition of the lagoon was outside the scope of this study, one could infer that the nektonic and benthic organisms in the lagoon are adapted to the aforementioned temperature range. The temperature of the lagoon is dependent on natural conditions such as solar radiation, season, wind action, storms, tides, level of stratification and river discharge. Estuarine pH levels generally average from 7.0 to 7.5 in the fresher sections to 8.0 and 8.6 in the more saline areas. Most marine organisms prefer conditions with pH values ranging from 6.5-8.5 (U.S. EPA, 1993). The average pH conditions observed in the Placencia estuarine system varied between 8.1 and 8.6. The observed pH are well within the acceptable range for most marine organisms and healthy estuarine environment. The slightly alkaline pH of this estuary could be attributed to the natural buffering from the carbonate and bicarbonate dissolved in the water. Under natural conditions, processes such as photosynthesis and respiration are known to influence pH levels. High nutrient loadings from domestic wastewater of untreated effluent could exacerbate the levels of primary productivity and respiration that could lead to drastic short-term shifts in pH. This situation can be extremely harmful for many organisms. Despite the fact that such a condition was not encountered during the monitoring surveys, it is not at all far fetched for the Placencia Lagoon. The review of all the anthropogenic activities in the Placencia catchments did not identify any potential source for long-term acidification of the lagoon. The salinity is a crucial parameter that helps to define the biological and physical character of an estuary. The salinity in combination with other critical parameters (e.g. temperature) controls the types of plants and animals that could inhabit the different zones of an estuary. The freshwater species may be restricted to the upper reaches of the estuary while the marine species inhabit the estuarine mouth. In the lower section of the Placencia Lagoon there is a high density of Thalassia testidinum that declines rapidly towards the middle portion of the lagoon. Other plant species become dominant in the middle and upper portions of the lagoon. Euryhaline fish species including snook, jack, mullet and tarpon are frequently seen in most parts of the lagoon. 26 The salinity maps presented in Appendix 2 display shifts in salinity distribution within the lagoon. This could be attributed to the effects of evaporation, freshwater influx from the Placencia catchments and the net water exchange between the entire estuarine system and the sea. The fact that the salinity is a conservative parameter allows us to make certain conclusions about the character of the lagoon. For instance, the monitoring surveys in the peak of two dry seasons (2001 & 2003) indicate that the upper section of the lagoon maintains a much lower salinity relative to the mouth of the lagoon. In effect this is a clear indication that the flushing rate of the upper part of the lagoon during the dry season is very low and is strongly dependent on wind and tidal forces. This is one natural attribute of the lagoon that highlights its vulnerability to the impacts of human settlement and aquaculture developments. Hypothetically, if large volumes of wastewater or untreated effluents were discharged into the upper section of the Placencia Lagoon, its water quality would rapidly decline and affect the natural ecological balance. Another characteristic of the lagoon is that during the dry season there are minimal differences between surface and bottom salinities. Based on this observation, the Placencia Lagoon is classified as a moderately stratified estuary. Dissolved Oxygen concentration is one of the best indicators of an estuary’s health. An estuary with little or no oxygen cannot support healthy levels of animal or plant life. The aerobic bacteriological decomposition of organic matter requires Oxygen. Quite often this process depletes the water of oxygen and makes the environment uninhabitable for other organisms. Most animals and plants can grow healthy and reproduce when DO levels exceed 5 mg/L. However, when DO levels falls to 3-5 mg/L living organisms may become stressed. The results of the surveys indicate that the Placencia Lagoon is a healthy environment displaying a wide range of dissolved oxygen concentration (between 5.79 and 8.02 mg/L). Several studies in estuaries have shown that although excess nutrients from human activities are a major cause of hypoxia and anoxia, these conditions may also occur in estuaries relatively remote from human impact. However, the severity of low DO and the length of time that low oxygen conditions persist are less extreme. This is another good reason for a proactive approach to manage the impact of anthropogenic activities in the lagoon catchments. Offsetting the balance of the healthy Placencia Lagoon towards an anoxic and unproductive environment can be avoided. During the monitoring surveys the turbidity levels in the lagoon were influenced primarily by the intensity and duration of the wave action. The amount of mixing ultimately controlled the re-suspension of silt and organic matter into the water column. The perturbation in the extremely shallow parts of the lagoon was more vigorous as opposed to deeper parts and this was reflected in the heterogeneous turbidity levels. Generally, the turbidity levels were low as indicated by the averaged values ranging between 4.32 and 10.64 NTU. During the final survey (July, 03), some parts of the 27 lagoon exhibited a golden-brown coloration (Plate 1(g)). This was probably a phytoplankton bloom triggered by some runoff. High turbidity levels over prolonged periods can diminish the heath and productivity of an estuarine system. Turbid waters reduce the availability of light to underwater plants and inhibit growth. Organisms that filter feed in an estuary are usually affected by high turbidity. In such conditions, suspended particles would accumulate on the gills of the organisms and impair breathing. The ability of marine birds and some fish to sight and track their prey is greatly reduced in a turbid estuary. The turbidity levels of the Placencia Lagoon could be exacerbated by agricultural runoff, aquaculture effluent, spoil from dredging and land reclamation sites; erosion and boat traffic. Considerable attention was given to the impacts of shrimp mariculture operations in the margin of the Placencia Lagoon. At the time of this study, the upper portion of the lagoon was not affected by aquaculture effluent. Nova Toledo has been non functional for several years (Tunich Nah, 2001). On the other hand, Belize Aquaculture Ltd. is a fully functional super intensive, closed system operation with a zero effluent discharge (Boyd et al., 2002). Royal Mayan, Tex Mar and Crustaceans Ltd. are three operations that are in close proximity to each other. Each of these operations meet the settling pond requirements (10% of the production area) stipulated by the Department of the Environment. Effluents discharged from these operations are subjected to mangrove wetlands for nutrient and sediment reduction prior to entry into the lower portions of the Placencia Lagoon. The fact that the lower portion of the lagoon has a much higher water exchange rate with the sea (as opposed to the upper portion) is the reason why there is no significant impact on the ecological and environmental conditions of the lagoon. Aqua Mar is located at the southern boundary of the lagoon and its effluents are released into wetlands in the northeastern tip of the Sennis River Catchment. Taking into account the predominant southerly coastal currents, the impacts of this operation on the Placencia Lagoon are questionable. Similarly, attention was also given to the impacts of human settlement on the Placencia Lagoon. The current growth trends of the communities pose two outstanding threats to the lagoon: (1) increasing sediment input consequent to destruction of natural vegetation and (2) increasing nutrient loadings from improper disposal of domestic wastewater. 28 CONCLUSIONS The characterization of the Placencia Lagoon was essential to put into perspective all the natural and anthropogenic factors that could affect the health and function of the estuarine system. The spatial, vertical and temporal variations in salinity distribution confirms that the Placencia Lagoon may be classified as a moderately stratified estuary. The small-scale water exchange in the upper section of the lagoon brings into prominence the vulnerability of the water body’s natural ecological and environmental conditions to excessive loadings of nutrients, organic matter and sediment. The upper section of the lagoon is not impacted by direct effluent discharge from the adjacent shrimp mariculture operations. The water quality indicators assessed in this study indicate that during the dry seasons 2001 and 2003 the Placencia Lagoon displayed healthy environmental conditions. The data and results obtained in this study strongly support the hypotheses postulated. However, there is the need for more research to quantify impacts in terms of budgets for conservative and non-conservative parameters. RECOMMENDATIONS Cognizant of the invaluable natural ecological services and socioeconomic benefits provided by the Placencia estuarine system, it is appropriate to make several recommendations. Firstly, a reliable environmental quality-monitoring program needs to be implemented and sustained in the Placencia Lagoon. However, most regulatory authorities are faced with both financial and human resources constraints hence, it is incumbent on the local NGOs and residents to be involved in such a program. Secondly, the local village councils should liaise closely with the Department of the Environment to ensure that the major developments are compliant with mitigatory measures and national effluent regulations. Thirdly, the environmental NGOs should assume the lead role in educational programs to heighten the residents’ awareness about the importance and also the vulnerability of the Placencia Lagoon. Lastly, in view of the low water exchange in the upper portion of the Placencia Lagoon, it is imperative that future development are planned to ensure the lowest possible impact on the estuary. 29 BIBLIOGRAPHY Ariola, E. and Morgan P. (2000). A Review of Hydrology in the Southern Region of Belize. Environmental and Social Technical Assistance Project. Ministry of Economic Development and the Interamerican Development Bank. Ariola, E. (2002) National Consultancy Report for Modeling and Physical Oceanography-Belize. Report submitted to the Mesoamerican Barrier Reef Systems Project. Boyd, C. E and J.W. Clay. (2002). Evaluation of Belize Aquaculture Ltd: A Superintensive Shrimp Aquaculture System. Report prepared under the World Bank, NACA, WWF and FAO Consortium Program on Shrimp Farming and the Environment. 17p. Buckalew et al (1998). Water Resources Assessment for Belize. US Army Corps of Engineers District Office in Mobile, Alabama, and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Topographic Engineering Center in Alexandria, Virginia. Central Statistical Office (2001). Abstracts of Statistics Belize 2001. Central Statistical Office, Ministry of Finance; Government of Belize. Coastal Zone Management Authority and Institute (2000). State of the Coast Report Belize. 76pp. Contreras, F. (1993) Ecosistemas Costeros Mexicanos. Comision Nacional Para el Conocimiento y Uso de la Biodiversidad. Universidad Autonoma Metropolitana Unidad Iztapalapa, 415 pp. Environmental & Social Technical Assistance Project (2000). Regional Development Plan for Southern Belize. A Plan for the Southern Region of Belize Developed in collaboration with Communities, the Government of Belize and the Inter-American Development Bank Esker, D. Eberli, G.P., and McNeill, D.F. (1998) The structural and sedimentological controls on the reoccupation of Quaternary incised valleys, Belize Southern Lagoon. AAPG Bulletin, v. 82, no. 11 (November 1998) p. 2075-2109. Gibson, J.P., Price, A.R.G. & Young, E. (Comps). 1993. Guidelines for Developing a Coastal Zone Management Plan for Belize: The GIS Database. A Marine Conservation and Development Report. IUCN, Gland, Switzerland. vi +11pp; 9 maps Gibson, J. and Ariola, E. (1999). Coastal Zone Adaptation to Climate Change, UNDP/GEF Climate Change Project. High, Lee R. JR (1969) Geomorphology and Sedimentology of Holocene Coastal Deposits, Belize. Department of Geology, Oberlin College, Oberlin, Ohio. 30 Huntington, T., Dixon, H. 1997. A Review of the Environmental Impact of Aquaculture in Belize and Guidelines for Sustainable Development. Coastal Zone Management Programme/ Government of Belize. King, R.B. et al. (1986). Land Resources Survey of Toledo District, Belize. Overseas Development Administration, Land Resources Development Center, Tolworth Tower, Surbton, England. King, R.B., et al. (1989). Land Resources Assessment of Stann Creek District, Belize. Natural Resources Institute, Bulletin No. 19. King, R.B. et al. (1992). Land Resource Assessment of Northern Belize. Overseas Development Administration, Natural Resources Institute, Bulletin No. 43. Kjerfve, B., (1981) Tides of the Caribbean Sea. Journal of Geophysical Research 86 (C5) Kjerfve, B., Rutzler, K., Kierspe, H.G., 1981. Tidal Analysis for a Caribbean Barrier Reef Location: Carrie Bow Caye, Belize. Smithsonian Contribution to the Marine Sciences. Lara, M.E. (1993) Divergent wrench faulting in the Belize Southern Lagoon: implications for Tertiary Caribbean Plate movements and Quaternary reef distribution: AAPG Bulletin, v.77, no.6, p.1041-1063. Lee, M.D., Stednick, J.D., Gilbert, D.M. (1994). Environmental Water Quality Monitoring Programme. Final Report, USAID/GOB. Co-operative Agreement 596-0150A-00-978-00. McField M., Wells S. and Gibson J. (Eds) (1996). State of the Coastal Zone Report, Belize 1995. Coastal Zone Management Programme, UNDP/GEF BZE/92/G31 Myvett, G. and Quintana, R. (2002). The Status of Aquaculture In Belize 2001. Report produced by Aquaculture and Inland Fisheries Unit (AQUIF), Belize Fisheries Department. National Emergency Management Organization (2001). Preliminary Report on Assessment of the Environmental Impacts by Hurricane Iris on Southern Belize. Environmental Committee of NEMO. Department of the Environment, Ministry of Natural Resources, Belmopan. PASCO (1997). Environmental Impact Assessment of the Plantation Limited PASCO (2002). An EIA Addenda for a proposed excavation of a channel at the Placencia Peninsula. 31 PASCO (2003). An EIA Addenda for a Proposed Construction of a Boat Docking Facility at the Plantation on the Placencia Peninsula. Professional Agriculture Service Company in Association with the Wilderness Group. Platt, S. G. and Thorbjarnarson, J.B. (1997). Status and Life History of the American Crocodile in Belize. Final Project Report submitted to United Nations Development Programme /Global Environmental Facility Coastal Zone Management Project (BZE/92/G31) Purdy, E.G., (1974) Karst-determined facies patterns in British Honduras: Holocene carbonate sedimentation model: AAPG Bulletin, v. 58, p 825-855. Purdy, E.G., W.C. Pusey III, and K.F. Wantland, (1975) Continental Shelf of Belizeregional shelf attributes, in K.F. Wantland and W.C. Pusey III, eds., Belize Shelfcarbonate sediments, clastic sediments and ecology: AAPG Studies in Geology 2, 1-39. Schroeder, W.W., Dinnel, S.P. and Wiseman Jr, W.J. (1990). Salinity stratification in a salinity dominated estuary. Estuaries 13,145-154 Tunich Nah Consultants (2000). Environmental Impact Assessment of Nova Toledo Aquaculture Venture Expansion Project. Tunich Nah Consultants (2001). Environmental Impact Assessment of Nova Laguna Shrimp Mariculture Expansion Project, Stann Creek District, Belize. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (1993) Volunteer Estuary Monitoring: A Methods Manual. EPA 842-B-93-004, Washington, DC. United Tropical Aquatics (2000). An Environmental Impact Assessment Of : Crustaceans Limited. Commercial Shrimp Farming Venture Located in Stann Creek District, Belize C.A. United Tropical Aquatics (2000). An Environmental Impact Assessment Of: Royal Mayan Shrimp Farms Limited. A Commercial Shrimp Farming Venture Located In Stann Creek District, Belize C.A. United Tropical Aquatics (1997). An Environmental Impact Assessment of ‘Tex Mar Limited’. A Shrimp Farming Venture to be Located In: Stann Creek District, Belize C.A. Walker, S.H. (1973). Summary of Climatic Records for Belize Supplementary Report, Land Resources Division, U.K. Ministry of Overseas Development No. 3. WRIScS, 2000. An Investigation of the Impact on Reef Environments of Changing Land Use in the Stann Creek District of Belize. Technical Report (Module 3 of report series). Watershed Reef Interconnectivity Scientific Study. 32 APPENDIX I Temperature Distribution for four independent surveys of the Placencia Lagoon 33 34 35 36 37 APPENDIX II Salinity distribution for four independent surveys of the Placencia Lagoon 38 39 40 41 42 Abbreviations and Notations BNMS Belize National Meteorological Service BTIA Belize Tourism Industry Association CSO Central Statistical Office CZMAI Coastal Zone Management Authority and Institute DoE Department of the Environment ESTAP Environmental & Social Technical Assistance Project FoN Friends of Nature GIS Geographic Information Systems GPS Global Positioning System MBRS Mesoamerican Barrier Reef Systems Project NEMO National Emergency Management Organization NGO Nongovernmental Organizations NTU Nephelometric Turbidity Units RWS Rudimentary Water System °C Degrees Centigrade CMS Cubic meter per second DO Dissolved Oxygen Concentration Hp Horse power mg/L Milligrams per liter mS/cm MilliSiemens per centimeter MSL Mean Sea Level % sat Percent Saturation ppt Parts per thousand v
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz