Is Workforce Time Accounting Really Important? By Sherry Evens, Evens Time, Inc. What is the big deal about “time accounting”, aka “time and attendance”, or “timekeeping”? Isn’t that a thing of the past – a “pre-digital” age business practice? After all, with today’s geo-stamping, virtual offices, and global workforce, why worry about such triviality? Let’s look at what a seemingly innocent 5 minutes a day equates to, either in the eyes of the employer, OR in the eyes of the employee. This chart illustrates how an hourly rate and number of employees adds up to dollars either paid out for no work, or in the case of the employee who, for instance, works into a lunch hour or after hours without proper time accounting, loses in wages. Hourly Rate $7.15 $7.50 $8.00 $8.50 $9.00 $9.50 $10.00 $10.50 $11.00 $11.50 5 10 25 Employees Employees Employees $1,519.38 $1,593.75 $1,700.00 $1,806.25 $1,912.50 $2,018.75 $2,125.00 $2,231.25 $2,337.50 $2,443.75 $3,038.75 $3,187.50 $3,400.00 $3,612.50 $3,825.00 $4,037.50 $4,250.00 $4,462.50 $4,675.00 $4,887.50 $7,596.88 $7,968.75 $8,500.00 $9,031.25 $9,562.50 $10,093.75 $10,625.00 $11,156.25 $11,687.50 $12,218.75 The Fair Labor Standards Acts mandates specific requirements for employers. While extensive, we have chosen just an excerpt here to show the critical items every employer must adhere to. Clearly, keeping accurate records AND ARCHIVING THEM PROPERLY is the law! What are the laws regarding my labor force? They are extensive, but here is an excerpt about archiving requirements: Department of Labor 29 CFR Part 516. • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • What Records Are Required: Every covered employer must keep certain records for each nonexempt worker. The Act requires no particular form for the records, but does require that the records include certain identifying information about the employee and data about the hours worked and the wages earned. The law requires this information to be accurate. The following is a listing of the basic records that an employer must maintain: Employee's full name and social security number. Address, including zip code. Birth date, if younger than 19. Sex and occupation. Time and day of week when employee's workweek begins. Hours worked each day. Total hours worked each workweek. Basis on which employee's wages are paid (e.g., "$9 per hour", "$440 a week", "piecework") Regular hourly pay rate. Total daily or weekly straight-time earnings. Total overtime earnings for the workweek. All additions to or deductions from the employee's wages. Total wages paid each pay period. Date of payment and the pay period covered by the payment. How Long Should Records Be Retained: Each employer shall preserve for at least three years payroll records, collective bargaining agreements, sales and purchase records. Records on which wage computations are based should be retained for two years, i.e., time cards and piece work tickets, wage rate tables, work and time schedules, and records of additions to or deductions from wages. These records must be open for inspection by the Division's representatives, who may ask the employer to make extensions, computations, or transcriptions. The records may be kept at the place of employment or in a central records office. • The Fair Labor Standards Acts mandates specific requirements for employers. While extensive, we have chosen just an excerpt here to show the critical items every employer must adhere to. (read highlighted text). Clearly, keeping accurate records AND ARCHIVING THEM PROPERLY is the law! How about that moving target named, “The Affordable Care Act”? Now for everyone’s subject du jour: the Affordable Care Act, or as it is affectionately known, “Obamacare”. Any employer with more than 50 employees MUST provide healthcare coverage to their staff members working 30 or more hours per week, beginning January 1 of next year. As I’m sure you’ve heard, many employers are faced with re-arranging schedules, changing work patterns, and even sadly having to let good employees go because they can’t afford to provide the mandated coverage. But how will you know where your pylons are if you can’t accurately keep records NOW? Under the ACA, a portion of your workforce could be reclassified as full time employees for purposes of the act. How will you determine which employees now qualify for benefits? And do you know the projected costs? Whether you decide to “play” or “pay,” there are costs you will face: Play — the average cost to provide healthcare is about $10,000 per employee per year Pay — penalties for not providing coverage and/or “affordable” coverage range from $2,000 to $3,000 per employee Ignoring the new ACA is not an option for employers; they must choose between providing coverage for their qualifying staff, or pay the penalties for not providing it. How will the government know if you’re in compliance or not? By providing reports, of course. And how will you manage that? Manually combing through timecards or timesheets to see who and who does not qualify? Even more labor intensive is the benefits administration that is the outcome of these diagnostics. How are you currently performing benefits administration? Is employee information centralized, and can you run reports across your entire organization? Right now, could you produce the required documentation? New Compliance Challenges You must determine which employees are eligible for coverage, using the “look-back” period (a 3-12 month time frame to determine which part-time employees (PTEs) should be reclassified as full-time). Organizations must then provide coverage for eligible employees for a minimum of the longer of 6 months or their look-back period. How much labor will it take on your staff’s part to go through each team members’ current records to accurately determine this eligibility? Workforce management is MORE than just timekeeping, that is, adding up the hours between when an employee starts and ends his or her workday. Proper workforce management involves forecasting schedules to avoid overtime, managing schedules to minimize employee fatigue, and budgeting by departments to improve the company’s bottom line, to name just a few factors. Do your current systems give you the necessary visibility to determine which employees are FT/PT? And once determined, can you proactively manage your workforce to obtain an optimal mix of full-time and part-time employees? Workforce management is MORE than just timekeeping, that is, adding up the hours between when an employee starts and ends his or her workday. Proper workforce management involves forecasting schedules to avoid overtime, managing schedules to minimize employee fatigue, and budgeting by departments to improve the company’s bottom line, to name just a few factors. Does the “Honor System” work? “American workers are wasting more than twice the time Human Resource managers expect.” -by: Dan Malachowski, Salary.com Let’s take a look at a joint study undertaken by AOL and Salary.com magazine. No one expects people to work for 8 hours straight with absolutely not breaks or socialization. However, workers admitted in this study to astoundingly wasting away over 2 hours during an 8 hour workday! This fact surprised even those who conducted the study. Employees are wasting TWICE as much time as their employers expect. • For many American workers today, time's a wastin' - literally. According to a new survey by America Online and Salary.com, the average worker admits to frittering away 2.09 hours per 8-hour workday, not including lunch and scheduled break-time. As a matter of practice, companies assume a certain amount of wasted time when determining employee pay. However, the America Online / Salary.com survey indicates that employees are wasting about twice as much time as their employers expect. Salary.com calculated that employers spend $759 billion per year on salaries for which real work was expected, but not actually performed. • The biggest distraction for respondents? Personal Internet use. 44.7% of the more than 10,000 people polled cited web surfing as their #1 distraction at work. Socializing with co-workers came in second at 23.4%. • • • • • • Conducting personal business, "spacing out," running errands, and making personal phone calls were the other popular time- wasting activities in the workplace. As you might expect, many activities claim workers’ “non-working time”, and also not surprisingly, the biggest distraction is personal internet use. Top Time-Wasting Activities (%) • • • • • • • • • • 1 Surfing Internet (personal use) 44.7% 2 Socializing with co-workers 23.4% 3 Conducting personal business 6.8% 4 Spacing out 3.9% 5 Running errands off-premises 3.1% 6 Making personal phone calls 2.3% 7 Applying for other jobs 1.3% 8 Planning personal events 1.0% 9 Arriving late / Leaving early 1.0% 10 Other 12.5% Top Time-Wasting Excuses (%) Don't have enough work to do 33.2% Underpaid for amount of work 23.4% Co-workers distract me 14.7% Not enough after-work time 12.0% Other 16.7% As mentioned previously, it is unrealistic to expect that NO time will be wasted by workers. Human Resource professionals estimate just under 1 hour of “frittering time” per employee per 8 hour day; however, they SUSPECT that in reality, employees actually waste a little over an hour and a half. Imagine their surprise that in this study, employees admitted to over 2 hours of non-productive time! Time Wasted During an 8 Hr. Workday Assumed by HR 0.94 hours Suspected by HR 1.60 hours Admitted by Employees 2.09 hours Who Wastes the Most Time At Work? Men and women are about equal; however, the age of workers has an impact: Year of Birth: wasted per: Time 1930-1949 0.50 hours 1950-1959 0.68 hours 1960-1969 1.19 hours 1970-1979 1980-1989 1.61 hours 1.95 hours Generational differences were revealed in the study as well. Not surprisingly, older workers wasted LESS time than younger workers. As you can see from the chart, the older the worker, the more diligent the worker! Top 5 Time-Wasting Industries Job Category Time Wasted per Insurance 2.5 hours Public Sector (non-education) 2.4 hours Research and Development 2.3 hours Education Software and Internet 2.2 hours 2.2 hours Now for the top five time-wasting states: to MY surprise, the Midwest was the worst! My home state of Indiana andneighboring Kentucky claim two of the top five worst time wasting states! UGH! Top 5 Time-Wasting States State Time Wasted (Hours/day) Salary Dollars Wasted (Per year) Missouri 3.2 28.1 billion Indiana 2.8 25.1 billion Kentucky 2.8 15.1 billion Wisconsin Nevada 2.8 2.7 23.8 billion 9.8 billion Are Simple Handwritten Timesheets Sufficient? The United States Department of Labor states that any timekeeping method is acceptable for record keeping. Why invest in a “system”, or even a time clock? Aren’t handwritten timesheets OK? Over 40 years ago, and independent study by Robert Half agencies identified 5 factors in showing why handwriting, or manual timekeeping, was fraught with inaccuracies. The first factor was simply unavoidable; we humans DO make mistakes once in awhile, no matter how seasoned we may be. Here are the five most common payroll errors: 1. Human Error Errors in payroll calculation are inevitable with traditional timecards. The American Payroll Association data shows an error rate of between 1 and 8% of total payroll in companies that use traditional timecards. 2. Traditional Time Clock Errors The time clock itself, is another source of inaccurate payroll data. Traditional time clocks allow missed punches, duplicate punches, and smudged, illegible timecards. With traditional timecards and clocks, missed punches will not be caught until the timecards are being manually tallied. Then supervisors or managers are required to supply the missing information based on their memory of “who was at work, when.” Even if a “timeclock” is used (a step up from handwritten timesheets), the timeclock methods can have “gotcha’s”, as we shall see in a few slides when we cover various time clock methodologies. 3. Overpayment According to the American Payroll Association, the average overpayment of work time (long lunches and breaks, tardiness, early departures, etc.) is 10 minutes per day, per employee. Who reports to payroll when they’ve been overpaid vs. when they’ve been underpaid? I think we all know the answer to that! This slide shows a “close-up” of the earlier slide we saw. Look at what is paid out to only 25 employees making $7.50 an hour in a year if only 10 minutes are unaccounted – almost $8,000, Mr. Employer, for NOTHING! 4. Calculation Errors for Taxes, Insurance and Benefits An employer’s federal tax liability can include: federal income tax, employee social security withholding/contribution, Medicare withholding/contribution, Earned Income Credit (EIC), and Unemployment taxes (FUTA). There are also state and local income taxes and state unemployment insurance (SUI). When disbursed, disability benefits are counted as taxable income for federal tax withholding, FICA and FUTA. Payroll isn’t just paying out dollars for work earned. Other business factors, such as unemployment taxes and government taxes, are based upon your payroll figures. Don’t you want those to be as accurate as possible? Workers’ compensation - insurance for on-the-job injury is often overpaid by employers. Since the basis of premiums is payroll, companies must ensure that the payroll being reported to the insurance company is correct. Vacation, sick time, tuition reimbursement, travel allowances, COBRAS, pensions, and other employee benefits which depend on salary rate and/or accrual of hours can also affect the insurance premium rate 5. Inefficiency and Wasted Time How much time does it take a bookkeeper to manually add up timecards and calculate pay, taxes, and benefits? How much time is spent investigating and making corrections, answering employee questions about alleged discrepancies and manually cutting checks to compensate for underpayment? By now you’re saying, “OK, Sherry, you’ve convinced me! I NEED to do SOMETHING about my timekeeping, but I don’t know where to start”! Let’s begin with the simplest timekeeping device, the good ‘ol manual time clock. The next several slides will show representative images of the concepts, and by no means will be exhaustive of all the many options available on the market today. This model is a good example of a “side printer”. “Side Printers” accept timecards that must be lined up under an indicator where the time and date stamp will print. Manual or automatic printing is available. Errors can occur by employees “overpunching” one stamp on top of another. These units are mechanical, in that the stamp is made from individual metal wheels that rotate the month/date/time format, so they can only be changed by wheel replacement. Electromechanical side printers produce the same results on the timecard as the mechanical side printers, but they offer more flexibility for the date and time stamp, i.e. changing one’s mind. Electromechanical “side printers” have the advantage of changing formats, as they use dot matrix internal printers. Switching between AM/PM and continental hours, choosing day, date, month, and year is simply a programming function much like setting an alarm clock; however, they still have the disadvantage of being able to “overstamp”. Top Loading time card units eliminate the “overstamping” problem, as the print heads are programmed to partially or fully move across and/or down the timecard each time the card is inserted. The programming is only by linear dimension; it does not read optical characters, Hollertih encoding, or bar codes. Think of a primitive “excel sheet”, where the timecard is segmented into cells. This type of card is referred to as a “job costing” card, because workers insert the card in a slot at the top of the machine. The internal print head will stamp the date and time in the first upper left cell, and then subsequent punches are made in the next cell to the right as the printhead has been programmed to move a certain number of inches so it will stamp in the next cell. The “semi-automatic” units march across the card only; the fully automatic units will not only march ACROSS the card, but drop down to the next line to begin printing a new line. Totalizing time clocks total hours and produce some limited reports without communicating to software, so they are “standalone” units. Barcoded or Hollerith encoded timecards identify individual employees only during a specific pay period, so care must be taken to not assign a duplicate numbered card to more than one employee. The totalizing unit shown here, the MJR-8000, uses a “Hollerrith” (punch) style encoding. Some totalizing units use barcoded cards. With either style, the unit recognizes the card by its encoding and “posts” hours, totaling them, throughout the pay period. The one “gotcha” is that the timecards are packaged in sections of 50, 100, or 250 cards, 2,000 cards to a box. Hence, there are duplicate numbers in the box, so one must use the cards in order to avoid accidentally handing out two cards with the same encoding to two different employees, because those two records would be merged to one, as the clock only sees it as one record. This is only true during any given pay period; once a new pay period starts, the numbering associated with the employee starts over as well. This is a colorful and busy slide, isn’t it? But I believe it best illustrates the overall “system” from a 10,000 ft. view. The heart of the system is the software, in which YOUR unique pay rules and policies are configured by a professional reseller like Evens Time. The software may reside on your server (“selfhosted”), an individual computer, OR “in the cloud”, meaning it resides at another site (usually the manufacturer’s) and you access it through the Internet. If you have used AOL or another email service, you have used “cloud services” – you don’t have the software installed in your home or business, but with proper online credentials, you use, or “rent” the software application for a monthly fee. That is how cloud-based, or “software-as-a-service (saas) are used as well. Your data is stored in a safe facility remotely, but you OWN your data. Step #1 may be skipped, but let me explain why the author of this diagram probably started with scheduling. Most workforce professionals want attendance information, like tardies and unexcused absences, from their time and attendance system (it is a part of the name, after all!). In order for an automated system to KNOW when a person’s tardy, it has to be programmed with the scheduled time and then compare it with the ACTUAL time to know if that employee is clocking in or out within the given parameters. If the transaction is indeed outside the parameters, then the system will know to post that to the TARDY list. Schedules are then uploaded to the host software (first yellow downward arrow). Data collection can be accomplished in many ways, which will examine in detail shortly, but step #2 is the actual “logging in/out” of the system (that’s the politically correct way to say, “clocking in/out”). Electronic clocks, smart or non-smart phones, keyboards, and biometric devices are all options for logging in/out. The transactions are then uploaded to the host software, either in “real time” or by a polling process, where the rules are applied and hours totaled, and reports are generated. The hours data, after proper auditing, can then be exported to the payroll software (Step #4), either “in-house” or to a third party. The data can also be exported to Human Resource systems or other applications as well. If desired, management can enable employees in Step #5 to see their own schedules, check their accrual balances, and even request time off. If we move to a software-based system, what are the data collection options? Simple PIN or card swipe options The “credential” is a card, fob, badge, or similar item that contains an “electronic key” (barcode, magnetic stripe, proximity chip, etc.) that is identified by a man-readable number that represents the encoding on the card. That number is mapped in the time and attendance software to the employee’s permanent payroll ID number; therefore it does not necessarily, and in fact should NOT be the same number for security reasons, and also in case of loss or damage. Cards can be re-used simply by remapping them to a different employee in the software. In the above example the reader is a horizontal reader; vertical readers are probably more common. Credentials aren’t absolutely required; a PIN can also be used in lieu of a credential. RSI Handpunch (hand geometry) – Stores hand geometry As an algorithm (non-reproducible) Biometric devices have become very popular because they prevent “buddy punching”. Employees can tell each other PINs, or give their badges or fobs to a buddy to “clock them in”, but they cannot duplicate their biometric features, of course! One of the most ubiquitous biometric units, used by almost all time and attendance manufacturers’ software is the RSI brand “handpunch”. This photo shows a lady placing her hand on the platen, digits placed between the posts, for logging in/out of the system. It is important to note, for employees’ peace of mind, that the software stores the hand geometry pattern as an algorithm; no reproducible image is possible. The handpunch readers can also be fit with a credential reader in addition to reading the hand geometry. Lumidigm reader above reads the capillary pattern under the skin instead of the fingerprint (a plus for older workers or those whose prints have eroded) Fingerprint readers have not always enjoyed a great reputation, as they had read rates only in the lowto mid 90% as recently as 5 years ago. However, the technology has vastly improved to the point that the read rates are about equal to the handpunch units (99%), depending of course, on the quality of the reader. In the lower right above is an example of a “rugged” terminal with a protective hood over the fingerprint reader. The upper left terminal example has the reader at the bottom center of the unit, but it is not a fingerprint reader; it is a capillary pattern reader, so those individuals whose fingerprints have been exposed to harsh environments, or have enjoyed many birthdays, needn’t worry about the lack of a good “read”. Fingerprint reader above allows for multiple digits to be enrolled Would you like to skip terminals altogether? If your environment is conducive to “no clocks”, then you certainly can! Above is an example of a “timesheet” entry, which uses the server time as the employee’s “log in/out” time. In other words, he or she cannot type the time into the entry fields. The employee simply clicks on the icon (the black arrow is pointing to “clock in”), and the time printed is the server time. Other timesheet formats are available, depending on the brand of your system, that MAY allow for bulk hours entries or project entries. Think of a law firm, for instance, in which a paralegal may spend two hours on Project A, then 3 hours on Project B, etc. Obviously, certain types of worker classifications would dictate which timesheet format would be appropriate for them. Keyboard entry Telephony and Smart Devices Telephony and Smart devices are the latest and greatest data collection methods. Telephony allows “non-smart” phones to simply call a preset local or 800 telephone number, and through the prompts, “clock in”, change cost centers, etc. There is a small fee, usually a few cents, associated with each call. This works well for mobile workers who don’t have smartphones. Those who DO have Smart devices, however, can download an app on their phones or tablets and record worked time as in the example on the right. Many of these apps offer the ability to request time off, check accrual balances, and schedules as well. Additional Modules Profile Lockout features enable you to prevent unauthorized clock use How about some other helpful management tools? A Profile Lockout type feature will prevent employees from logging on to, or out of, their shifts outside their predetermined parameters. EXAMPLE: A factory shift starts at 7 AM, but some workers like to arrive about 6:15, clock in, and then get breakfast in the company cafeteria before actually started to work at 7. Imagine the savings a company could garner from controlling even just a few workers, who may make $20/hour, in just a few pay periods! Occurrence Ratings/Disciplinary modules automatically alert you to those employees who cross your predetermined thresholds So many organizations we talk to would love to have some sort of disciplinary policy, but quite frankly, it’s too much hassle to monitor. Why not let the time and attendance system do it for you? It knows when folks are coming and going, so just “tell” it (configure it!) what thresholds you want, and it will keep track of those, point out when and who reaches the thresholds, and in many instances, can even issue warning letters! HR modules automate the recruiting, onboarding, insurance, and retirement benefits administration Some time and attendance systems have additional Human Resources modules, which may cover the gamut of recruiting, applying online for a job, document uploading (I-9s, resumes), onboarding, and employee handbooks and benefit plan comparisons! Whew! What a great help! Cloud or self-hosted software? Do you want to “rent” or “buy” your workforce management system – Buying upfront is a larger investment, but the ongoing costs are minimal (software updates, annual maintenance agreements for support) – Outright purchase of a workforce management system will be more initially, but unless you need more employee capacity or software user licenses, your ongoing costs will only be maintenance agreements on your hardware and/or software (usually these are optional). When operating systems change and/or your WFM versions move forward, you will need to move forward with them for a small fee (as opposed to a cloud-based system, where that is all done in the background). Will your software users (managers and administrators) have access to your server to get to the WFM application? If not, then you may want to consider a cloud-based system, since the only requirement is access to the internet. Cloud-based systems are “pay-as-you-go” and offer a monthly payment based on active employees ONLY, and the software is always up-to-date, since you are “renting the application” – – There is no hard and fast rule on whether you should get a self-hosted system or a cloud system. Do you outsource your IT services, or is your IT staff stretched thin? Would you like to expense your new workforce management system as an operational expense? Or is cash flow tight or unpredictable, or does your workforce count vary significantly? These are all factors that lend themselves to a cloud-based system, since after the initial startup costs, you pay per active employee per month. Okay, you may say, Sherry, this is all well and good, but I don’t believe in MY case the savings would be that great. You don’t know my business, my employees, or our environment! Well, let’s examine it on YOUR level. Above is an actual analysis we did for a prospect. We cover the “path of a timecard”; everyone who touches that card gets recorded and the time they spend touching the card. In this example, the total time spent per pay period on collected cards, calculating them, and double-checking them totaled just over 6 hours for the entire process in one pay period. – One Size Does Not Fit All! Proposed Method of Timekeeping (based on prep time PER EMPLOYEE RECORD) No. of minutes per card 1. No paper timecards used - employees can use PIN to clock in and out No. of employees Extended Time 0 200 0 2. Calculations performed by system, based upon pre-configured rules set up by Evens Time per your policies; however, some exceptions will occur (such as missing punches), so Adrienne will have to deal with EXCEPTIONS ONLY (typically, not more than 10% of employee base). 1.2 20 24 3. The software will automatically keep track of multiple overtime, so Penny can run a report at will. If the payroll software can accept a properly formatted file, Penny will not have to key in the data (it will be transferred automatically). However, Penny will want to look at the Timecard Reports and Overtime Reports before authorizing the payroll file transfer. 0.15 200 30 TOTAL TIME SPENT PER PAY PERIOD IN MINUTES 54 TOTAL TIME SPENT PER PAY PERIOD IN HOURS 0.9 Current Method of Timekeeping (based on prep time PER EMPLOYEE RECORD) 1. Cards are pulled weekly from both locations (Hodson Commons and the Grille) and laid on Adrienne's desk No. of minutes per card No. of employees Extended Time 0.05 200 10 2. Adrienne calculates all cards 1.2 200 240 3. Penny double-checks (reviews), including creating "hot sheet" for overtime, and keys into payroll software 0.6 200 120 TOTAL TIME SPENT PER PAY PERIOD IN MINUTES TOTAL TIME SPENT PER PAY PERIOD IN HOURS 370 6.166666667 We then took each step and explained what could be automated in the system (automated does not mean “unattended” . . . Someone still has to steer that car on cruise control!). Those same steps, when automated were cut from 6 hours per pay period collectively to just under one hour. Imagine not only the wage savings for those workers every pay period, but the time savings in the manual calculations! A needs analysis of your workforce management where it is and where you’d like to be is essential. Remember: number of employees is NOT the critical factor. Complexity of pay rules and company culture ARE the most important factors! With the proper solution in place, you, too, will be proud to wear this shirt (and mean it!) The author would like to recognize those companies whose products and logos were featured as examples in this article: Robert Half Agencies, Salary.com Magazine, AOL, RSI, Inc., Qqest/Infinisource, Amano Cincinnati, Identatronics, Acroprint, Time America, and SaaShr.com.
© Copyright 2025 Paperzz