MARTUJARRA PREHISTORY: VARIATION IN ARID ZONE ADAPTATIONS Peter Veth In this paper preliminary results from recent fieldwork in the Little Sandy and Great Sandy Deserts are discussed and placed in the context of other arid zone research. Three points are developed. Firstly, that the arid zone is environmentally diverse and therefore human adaptations within it are likely to be varied in space and through time. Secondly, that a distinction should be made between late Pleistocene and Holocene occupation patterns and finally, that there are changes common to many arid zone sites throughout the Holocene. The study area is located within semitropical desertlands experiencing a strongly seasonal climate with a dominant vegetation of hummocWshrub grassland (Beard and Webb 1974). It contains a wide range of landforms including longitudinal dunefields, ephemeral water courses often draining into salt lakes, extensive quartz sandstone ranges and one co-ordinateddrainage course -the Rudall River. The river is aligned along the axis of a paleodrainage system, last active in the Tertiary (Van de Graff et al. 197'7), and is the only mapr continuous drainage course wholly contained within the Western Desert (Fg. 1). These are traditional lands of the Martujarra: a collective term for four Western Desert dialectal groups (Tonkinson1978), some of whom left the desert as late as the sixties. Having knowledge of site function, seasonality, patterns of human movement and plant use, these people contributedto my field research. Archaeological data will be interpreted against a model for settlement and subsistence within a seasonal desert. In summary, a seasonally determined pattern of resource exploitation characterised by a flexible cycle of aggreavation and dispersion is defined. Social groupings tend to be larger and more complex as a function of water permanency. Most ephemeral water sources are used primarily in a transient mode by bands. The sequential loss of waters and staggered phenology of plant staples follows a seasonal cycle. Grass seeds ripen after summer rains and are most abundant from April to July. From July to September herbaceous species ripen and from this period on throughout all the warmer months Acacia seeds are available. Fruits are collected during the cooler months while rootstocks are generally available throughout the year although more palatable during the cooler months (Veth and Walsh in press; Walsh 1987). The climate of the study area falls between the strongly seasonal climate of the Gugadja of the northern Sandy Desert (Cane 1984) and the unseasonal climate of the Ngatatjarra to the south (Gould 1969, 1980). Martujarra conceptualize the year as a progression of seasons during which family groups aggregate or fragment. Maximum mobility occurred duringthe summer rains from Decernberto Februarywith small groups utilizing ephemeral waters on claypans and at small rockholes. People stated they used caves during the summer rains. By April ephemeral waters are lost and groups retreated towards more permanent soaks and rockholes. Plant resources are abundant during this cool midyear period. In September temperatures rise and only the most permanent soaks and rockholes remain. Family groups joined together and exploited plant patches around series of well known reliable water sources - these routes might follow the edges of rocky uplands or be part of a drainage line. 1. 2. 3. 4. Karlamilyi Rocksheher Karlamilyi Quarry Rocksheher Weenakurijuno Cave Yulpul Rocksheher 5. Jalpiairi Rocksheher Figure 1. Regionalcontext of study area. Stratified sites are shown as follows: Duringthe end of the dry season people from a number of adjoining dialectal groups often concentrated at a small number of permanent waters. These include springs and a small number of soaks. Meetings are said to be held at this time of the year. The availability of most plant foods is determinedby the structure of drainage and the seasonal rainfall regime as described in detail by Walsh (1987; Walsh, this volume). Approximately 85 open sites have been recorded in the study area, most being surface scatters near water. It is important to note, however, that these sites are not always directly adjacent to water. While sites are usually concentrated around claypans and soaks, they do not commonly occur at springs or rockholes in the ranges. Insteadthey are located near the richest and most diverse plant communities which occur along ephemeral creek courses draining from the ranges. No major site is located within an interior valley of the ranges. Repeated surveys of areas away from water revealed different offsite patterning to that suggested by Gould for the Gibson Desert (1977b) where he predicted the majority of artefacts by weight would occur away from major occupation sites. In my study area most materialclusters at water, and low density background material away from these clusters is rare. This difference in spatial patteming between the Gibson and Sandy deserts may be due to several factors. Gould views the Western Desert as a 'core desert' with a cuttural system based on non-seasonal and opportunistic movement in a risk minimizing mode (1974). He claims that a lack of permanent water (including springs), extreme unreiiabiiity of rainfall and the short list of plants and animals constituted an unreliable and impoverished environment. His observations on water and plant restrictions do not apply to the Sandy Deserts. For example, he described a settlement system by which people targetted distant complexes of waterholes after localised rains; some of these waterholes more ephemeral than others. By saving the more permanent waters for last and using satellite sources first, groups were characterised as 'eating their way into' a camp (Gould 1969:267). The direction of subsequent movements was conditioned most strongly by the locationof recent rainfall. Residentialmobility is high when ephemeral waters are used (Kelly 1983). This state of flux is likely to be repeated often during the year and is seen to be non-seasonal in its patterning. By contrast, in the Sandy Deserts, the staggered loss of ephemeral waters after summer rains, followed by the loss of semi-permanent sources and an evental reliance on permanent waters by the end of the dry season follows a seasonally determined pattern which will be replicated from year to year. In terms of settlement dynamics a predictablecycle of aggregation and dispersion occurs on a yearly basis. This dual system of aggregationfocusses on resource abundance during the middle of the year and the restrictionof waters by the end of the dry season. A similar system of gatherings based on either feast or famine is shared by the Pintubi (Hayden 1976:154) and Gugadja (Cane 198462) also of the northern deserts. It is, however, noticeably absent for the Ngatatjarraand their neighbours inthe Gibson Desert (Gould 1967:56). The period of highest group mobility folbwing summer rains is marked by transient, ephemeral use of widely scattered claypans, rockholes and soaks. From this period on group movement is targettedtoward known water sources. Therefore, following an initial period of high mobility, residentialmoves become less frequent as the year progresses. Thus in the Gibson Desert, we are possibly witnessing the archaeological expression of a high ratio of peripheral to core habitation base camps. By contrast, in the Sandy Deserts a high proportion of core habitation base camps characterises settlement patterns. Therefore, the widely scattered, ephemeral and randomly placed satellite camps in the Sandy Deserts are likely to have an archaeological imprint of low visibility. Alternatively, Gould's predictionsfor offsite patterning have never been tested in the Gibson Desert and may be unfounded. I have divided sites between the five major water types found in the region as there appears to be a relationship between permanency of water and nature of occupation debris. The largest sites (withthe highest number of artefacts and with greatest lithic diversity and formal tool component) occur at permanent springs and soaks. Grinding material is abundant at these sites. Tulas are heavily reduced and debitage size is generally small. Large sites also occur around claypans. Here however, lithic diversity is low with the predominant use of local materials. Grinding material is negligible or absent. Tulas and small modified flakes are rare at these sites which instead have numerous large retouchedflakes. Smaller sites tend to occur near ephemeral rockholes, soaks and pools. Lithic diversity is variable, ranging from almost exclusive use of local materials through to sites with a high number of non-local materials. Cane (1984) has demonstrated that interassemblage variability in Western Desert base camps can be great and that this can be explained by differences in site function. Iwill attempt to look at site function in further detail by examining the following factors: a) stone working processes, b) the place of sites in the seasonal subsistence cycle, c) permanency of site use, d) composition of groups using the site, and e) economic plants at sites and their accessibility, abundance and seasonality. For example, there are two major occupation sites on the Canning Stock Route: Kadaru (Well 24) and Wantili (Well 25). These sites are only 15 km apaR yet contain quite different stone tool assemblages. Wantili is a very large claypanwith ephemeral water; Kadaru is a permanent well. Data from seven informants agreed that the sites were used predominantly at different times of the year, for different lengths of time, and to exploit different plant resources. Wantili contains an estimated 500,000 artefacts made mainly from siliceous pebbles found on the periphery of the claypan. Large retouched flakes are common; tulas and backed blades rare. Only three grinding fragments were recorded. Kadaru is equally large having an estimated 1,000,000 artefacts. While outcrops of silcrete are available in adjacent ranges most material on the site is not local. There are over 1000 heavily reduced adzes, numerous small retouched flakes and backed blades. Over 100 whole grinding bases were recorded. These assemblage variations may be explainedby differences in the function of each site. Wantili claypan lies among homogeneous sandplains and holds water for several months after summer rain. Ethnographic data suggests this is the time of year when foraging groups size is small and site use is most transient. Plant foods are restricted - seeds are unavailable and the local staple, Cyperus bulbusis,requires little processing. Abundant siliceous pebbles provide a ready supply of flakes for wood working activities. The low degree to which retoucheditems are reducedwould seem consistent with the casual use and discard of local material by small groups during a season marked by high residential mobility. By contrast, Kadaru has permanent water and is surrounded by a number of different landforms. It was said to be used in both winter and summer, often for gatherings. It is one of several permanent water sources inthe region and is reliable during drought. From August through to January Acacia seed is abundant in addition to other seed staples. The use of these resources is seen to be reflected in the large numbers of seed grinding implements. Much non-local stone has been discarded at Kadaru. While basic wooden maintenance activities might be expected at most occupation sites the exotic stone at Kadaru is likely to have been recycled in response to an increase in specialised woodworking at a more sedentary base camp, marked by larger and more complex social groups. Variations in the morphologyand modification of artefacts at large habitation sites are seen therefore as the result of different stone working processes dependent on site function. Of approximately400 rocksheltersexaminedinthe regiononly 28 had some evidence of occupation. Five with well developed deposits were excavated (Fig. 1). Three of these are located within McKay Range, the other two are adjacent to Rudall River. The three from McKay Range had cuttural material to depths ranging from 50 to 90 cm below the surface. Grindstones, retouched implements and abundant charcoal are present in all excavations. Tula adzes and backed blades were recovered from the lower spits and continue to the surface. A marked increase in the density of artefacts and charcoal occurs in the upper spits. Charcoal samples from these sites are being processedand are all predictedto have basaldates rangingf mm 5000-3000 BP. (Karlamilyi has a basal date of 3,200 BP, WK1093). The first rockshelter from Rudall River is small with interior walls composed of chalcedony, which has been quarried. Predictably, debitage is dense extending to 50 cm below the surface. The site is expectedto yeild technological data which may be useful in providing relative chronologies for regional surface scatters containing chalcedony. The largest strztified site found in the region is Karlamilyishelter located 2 km north of permanent soakage on the Rudall River. Five cubic metres of this site were excavated with bedrock reached at 1.2 m. Significant changes at the site include the presenceof very large cores from the lower spits and then their bss, a reduction in core and flake sue through time and a significant increase inthe rate of discardinthe upper levels. An increase inthe density of artefacts in upper spits was common to all five excavations. A preliminary depthtage curve from Kariamilyi (Fig.2) shows a doubling in the rate of deposition over the last 1000years in comparisonto the preceeding2000 years. The large increase in numbers of artefacts after 1000 BP shown in the adjacent graph is therefore even more pronounced. These sites and those recorded by Cane to the north suggest mid Holocene occupation of the Sandy Deserts. When these and other mid Holocene sites are compared to those with Pleistocene dates from the arid zone, there appear to be marked differences in the nature of site use. Within the arid zone there are now nine sites with Pleistocene dates showing multiple occupationevents (Hiscock 1984; Lampert and Hughes 1987; Manrn 1974; Maynard 1980: Morse, pers. comm.; Smith 1987; Troilett 1982; Williams 1986 and Wright 1971). Excluding Lawn Hill and Koonalda these sites have occupation dates which straddle the range of the height of the last glaciation (18,000-14,000 BP). It can be argued that dates from KoonaMa indicate only task specific activities (such as stone quarrying) resulting from occasional foraging excursions by groups based on the coast. In a recent paper, Hiscock (n.d.) argues that the sequences at both Colless Creek and Louie Creek Caves clearly illustrate the retreat of inhabitantsfrom a vast arid landscape to gorge refugia during the height of the last arid phase. He believes a reduction in territory during a lengthy arid phase is evidence for the lack of extended social networks which are germane to the contemporary desert adaptation. During the glacial maximum, Pleistocene humans were unable to expki truly arid portions of their landscape. It may be that a similar contraction of territory also occurred towards the gorges and valleys of the Hamersley Plateau and Flinders Ranges. n 0 DEPTH -AGE CURVE No. of artefacts Age Depth below surface (cm) B.P (years) Figure 2. Karlamilyi Rocksheler: number of artefacts per splt for Square A There are no dates between 20,000 and 12,000 BP at Puritjara (Smith 1987) or the Hamersley Plateau sites (Maynard 1980; Troilet 1982). The Mandu Mandu Creek site at Exmouth has a hiatus from 19,000 to 2000 BP (Morse, pers. comm.) and site N I45 on the Nullarbor is unused from 17,000 to 13,000 BP (Marun 1974). This lack of dates combined with an extremely low rate of artefact discard raises questions about whether we are observing permanent occupation. For example, at Puritjarra the discard rate is three artefacts per 1000years from 22,000 to 6000 BP. At Newman Rocksheler it is five artefacts per 1000 years per square from 26,000 to 6000 BP. Occupationduring this periodat Newrnanis representedby 94 artefactswhich include 45 flakes and 14chips. There are only two retouched implements over a 20,000 year period and no hearths (Williams 1986). Later in the occupation of these two Pleistocene sites we see marked changes in the rate of discard of artefacts, their assemblage composition and the presence of features such as hearths. These later changes are paralleled in other Holocene sites. There appear to be three common features in the later use of arid zone sites during the Holocene. Firstly, the majority of sites date from the mid to late Holocene and are found in all landform and environment types. While early Holocene occupation probably occurred at eight of the nine sites with Pleistocene dates mentioned above, only two additionalsites, Puntutjarpa(Gould 1977a)and Balmramna Creek (Lampert and Hughes 1987),were occupiedduring the early Holocene. Most central Australian sites, including James Range East (Gould 1978) have unequivocal base dates from the mid to late Holocene (Napton and Greathouse 1985; Smith 1983). It is only by 6000 BP at Puritjarra that the artefact discard rate increases signlicantly by 30 fold from three to 105 pieces per 1000 years (Smith 1987). Evidence from other sites on Coopers Creek (Williams, in press), at mound springs (Florek 1987; Lampert 1985) and at wells in the Sirnpson Desert (Hercus and Clarke 1986) also supports mid to late Holocene occupation. Secondly, there is the addition of new technologies at sites from 5000-3000 BP. These include the introduction of micmliths, hafted adzes (if the Puntutjarpa micro-adzes are excluded - see Hiscock and Veth nd.) and formal grinding bases (Smith 1986). Thirdly, at most sites there is a significant increase in the rate of artefact discard over the last 1500 years. Duringthis periodthe artefact discard rate at Puritjana increases to 330 pieces per 1000 years (100 times that at 6000 BP). Similarly, over 60% of all implements from the 10,000 year occupation of Puntutjarpa come from spits encompassing the last 500 years (Gould 1980: Fig. 6). These increases are often accompanied by increases in other economic remains such as charcoal, fauna and grinding material (Smith 1983). Changes in site use can usefully be seen in the context of climate fluctuations over the last 40,000 years (Jones and Bowler 1980). Favourable conditions from 40,000-22,000 BP may have enabled earty (though Iwould argue ephemeral) use of the arid zone. Only three sites have evidence for occupation during the height of the last glacial maximum. During the glacial maximum there is widespread evidence for lowered temperatures and precipitation (Bowler and Wasson 1984). Occupation at Puritjarra andthe Hamersley Plateau duringthis periodof climatic stress is extremely sparse and suggests, at best, ephemeral use of sites. The Lawn Hill Caves show a restriction in economic range from 18,000-14,000 BP and several other arid zone sites evidence a hiatus in occupation during this same period. From approximately 12,000 BP in southeastern Australia to as late as 7000 BP inthe northwestof Australia (Wyrwoll et al. 1986) there is evidence for climatic amelioration. This is when Puntutjarpa is first occupied. During a longer favourable period from 7000-4000 BP (at least in southern and central Australia) increases in the rate of discard occur at Puritjarra. The majority of central Australian sites as well as Lake Frome are first occupied at this time. It is during more atid conditions from 4000-2000 BP that formal grinding slabs occur, that small tool components are widely adopted and desert occupation appears to expand. These strategies may have enabled the maintenance of population levels which had developedduring the favourable climate of the previous 3000 years (Smith 1986). Amelioration in climate over the last 2000 years coincides with a dramatic increase in the rate of discard at many sites including it seems the Sandy Deserts. It is perhaps the development of more efficient land exploiting strategies involving social readjustments corresponding with climatic relaxation over the last 2000 years that provided the catalyst for a recent desert efflorescence. I would suggest an early to mid Holocene expansion of humans from the well defined drainage lines and gorges of the Pilbara into the hummock grasslands of the Sandy Deserts. While it is likely that earlier colonising 'pulses' entered this region during favourable climatic phases these were not a permanent desert adaptation. The plant associations and continuous drainage courses of the Pilbara have much in common with central Australia and it is in both these regionsthat evidence for occupationbefore 20,000 BP has been found. The sandy and stoney deserts lying in between and lacking coordinated drainage, may have been more difficult to utilise during the last major arid phase due to a reduction in permanent water sources and the increased need to have a well defined seed grinding technology to exploit this major group of staples. It seems reasonable to argue that changes in social structure and economy were necessary before the arid zone could be occupied on a permanent basis and that the timing of permanent occupation of different regions varied. Sites are occupied more intensively after the intmduction of new technologies and markedly so in the last 1000 years. As Jones (1987) argues, this increase in site occupation 'might have been a reflection of other social transformations within prehistoric Aboriginal society'. Iwould hypothesise three changes in social structure during the occupation of the arid zone. Firstly, a permanent arid adaptation was established by the early Holocene, possibly featuring large tribavdialectal boundaries and extended social networks providing reciprocal access to vital resources in marginal environments. Secondly, a mid to late Holocene increase in the number of people and sites on the landscape is noted. This may be a result of greater permanency at major sites (perhaps in the form of ceremonial gatherings), more intensive use of resources and the utilisationof a wider range of desert habitats. Finally, a late Holocene increase in the intensity of occupation at sites can be demonstrated and possibly reflects an elaboration of previously established social relations (after Lourandos 1985). Assumptions basedon a conservative cultural system through time seem at odds with the archaeological evidence for change within the arid zone. It is likely that the social structure and economic behaviour of desert people changed at least several times from the earliest use of the desert through to the present. REFERENCES Beard, J.S. and J.Webb 1974 Vegetation survey of Western Australia. Great Sandy Desert University of Western Australia Press: Perth Bowler, J.M. and R.J. Wasson 1984 Glacial age environments of inland Australia. Pmeedings of an International Symposium heM by the South Afrn'can S0Ckt.v for Quaternary Research, Swaziland: 1 83-308. AA. Balkema: Ratterdam and Boston Cane, S. 1984 Desert camps: a case study of stone artefacts and Aboriginal behaviour in the Western Desert. Unpublished PhD thesis, Australian National University: Canberra Florek, S.M. 1987 The archaeologicalvariability of mound springs at Lake Eyre South, South Australia: work in progress. Australh Archaeology 2427-31 Gould, R.A. 1967 Notes on the hunting, butcheringand sharing of game among the Ngatatjara and their neighbours in the Western Australian desert. The Kmeber A n t h m p o b g ~ Society Papem 36:41-66 Gould, R.A. 1969 Subsistence behaviour among the Western Desert Aborigines of Australia. Oceania39(4)253-274 Gould, R.A. 1974 The Australian desert culture. Read at AAA Annual Meetings, Mexico City, Nov. 27 Gould, R.A. 1977a Puntutjarparockshetter and the Australian desert culture. Anthrqmbgical Papers of the Museum of Natural History (54): New York Gouki, R.A. 1977b Ethno-archaeology: or where do models come from? In R.V.S. Wright (ed.) Stone tools as cuhural markers: change, evolution, complexity pp.162-168. Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies: Canberra Gould, R.A. 1979 James Range East Rockshelter, Northern Terriiory, Australia: a summary of the 1973 and 1974 investigations. Asian Pespectives 21(1):86-126 GouId, R.A. 1980 Living Archaeology. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Hayden, B.D. 1976 Australian Western Desert lithic technology: an ethno-archaeological study of variability in material culture. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Toronto: Toronto Hercus, L. and P. Clarke 1986 Nine Simpson Desert wells. 21(l):51-62 Amhaeology in m a n i a Hiscock, P. 1984 Preliminary report on the stone artefacts from Colless Creek Cave, Northwest Queensland. Queensland ArchaeokqM Research 1:20-1 l 51 Hiscock, P. n.d. Pleistocene abandonment of arid central Australia Hiscock, P. and P. Veth n.d. The micro-adzes aint: a re-examinationof the Puntutjarpa adzes. Talk prepared for Technology Conference, Armidale, April 1988 Jones, R. 1987 Pleistocene life in the dead heart of Australia. Nature328:666 Jones, R. and J. Bowler 1980 Struggle for the savanna: northern Australia in ecological and NoRhem Austral&: optbns and imp/htions prehistoric perspective. In R. Jones (d.) pp.3-31. Research School of Pacific Studies, Australian National University: Canberra Kelly, R.L 1983 Huntergatherer mobility strategies. Journal of Anthmpokgicsll Reseamh 39(3)277-306 Lampert, R.J. 1985 Archaeological reconnaissance on a fiekitrip to Dalhousie Springs. Australian Archaeology 2 1:57-62 Lampert, R.J. and P.J. Hughes 1987 Flinders Ranges: a pleistoceneoutpost in the arid zone? Records of the South Australian Museum 2029-34 Lourandos, H. 1985 Intensificationand Australian prehistory. InT.D. Price andJ. Brown (eds.) PrehistorEchuntergatherers:the emergence of sockland cuIturalmmplexirypp.385-423. Academic Press: New York Marun, L.H. 1974 The Miming and their predecessors on the coastal Nullarbor Plain. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Sydney: Sydney Maynard, L. 1980 A pleistocene date from an occupational deposit in the Pilbara Region, Western Australia. Australian Archaeology 1:3-8 Napton, L.K. and E.A. Greathouse 1985 Archaeological investigation at Pine Gap (Kuyunba), Northern Territory. Australian Archaeology 20:9O-l08 Smith, M.A. 1983 Central Australia: preliminary archaeological investigations. Australian Archaeology 1627-38 Smith, M.A. 1986 The antiquity of seedgrinding in arid Australia. Amhaeobgy in Oceania 2 1(1) :29-39 Smith, M.A. 1987 Pleistocene occupation in arid central Australia. Nature 328:710-711 Tonkinson, R. 1978 The MardudjaraAborigines. Holt, Rhinehart and Winston: New York Troitett, G. 1982 Report on Ethel Gorge salvage project. Unpublished Report. Department of Aboriginal Sites, WA Museum: Perth Van der Graff, W.J.E., R.W.A. Crow, J.A. Bunting and M.J. Jackson 1977 Relict early Cenozoic drainages in arid Western Australia. Zeifschrift fur Geomorphobje 21:379-400 Veth, P.M. and F. Walsh (in press) Martujarra ethnobotany: the concept of staples in the Western Desert. Australian Aboriginal Studies Walsh, F.J. 1987 Patterns of plant resource use by Martujarra Aborigines. Unpublished M. Prelim. thesis, University of Western Australia: Perth Wasson, R.J. 1984 Late quaternary paleoenvironments in the desert dunefields of Australia. Proceedings of an International Symposium heM by the South Afrkan Society for Quaternary Research, Swaziland 419-432. A.A. Balkema: Rotterdam and Boston Williams, S. 1986 Analysis of the lithic component of the ethel Gorge collection, Newman, Western Australia. Unpublished Honours thesis, University of Western Australia: Perth Williams, E. (in press) The archaeology of the Cooper Basin, report on fieldwork. Recods of the South Australian Museum Wright, R.V.S. 1971 The archaeobgy of the Gallus Site, KmnaMa Cave. Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies: Canberra Wyrwoll, K.H., N.L. McKenzie, B.J. Pederson and I.J. Tapley The Great Sandy Desert of northwestern Australia: the last 7,000 years. Seatch 17(7-9): 208-210 Cent re for Prehistory University of Western Australia Nedlands WA 6004
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz