“Amending the U.S. Constitution”

vu
Charlottesville Area
League of Women Voters
Newsletter
Office Phone and Fax:
(434) 970-1707
E-mail:
Visit Our Website:
[email protected]
lwv.avenue.org
November 2015
Attention All Leaguers! You are invited to
attend a Two-Session Study and Consensus
Meeting on
“Amending the U.S.
Constitution”
On Consecutive Tuesdays, November 10 and 17
Noon to 2 pm each date
In Room 235, Albemarle County Office Building
McIntire Road
Constitutional Background
In 1787, delegates from twelve of the thirteen states then in existence met in Philadelphia to revise the
Articles of Confederation. Instead, they drafted a totally new document, what we know as the U.S.
Constitution. It was unanimously ratified by the states. While this all seems very long ago, how the
Constitution began and how the 1787 Convention was convened and conducted are cited in the current
debate about calling a Convention under Article V.
Here’s what Article V of the U.S. Constitution says about amending the Constitution:
The Congress, whenever two thirds of both houses shall deem it necessary, shall propose amendments to
this Constitution, or, on the application of the legislatures of two thirds of the several states, shall call a
convention for proposing amendments, which, in either case, shall be valid to all intents and purposes, as
part of this Constitution, when ratified by the legislatures of three fourths of the several states, or by
conventions in three fourths thereof, as the one or the other mode of ratification may be proposed by the
Congress; . . .
So Article V provides two ways of proposing amendments to the nation’s fundamental charter. Congress, by
a two-thirds vote of both chambers, may propose constitutional amendments to the states for ratification.
OR, the legislatures of two-thirds of the states (34 at present) may ask Congress to call a convention to
propose amendments to the Constitution; this is commonly called an Article V Convention. Amendments
proposed by either method must be ratified by three-fourths of the states, 38 at present.
Continued on next page
This page is sponsored by Joan Jay of Loring Woodriff Real Estate Associates
Phone: (434) 906-1806 or Email: [email protected]
Continued on the next page
Page | 1 - November 2015
“Amending the U.S. Constitution” – a League Study and Consensus Meeting over two Sessions,
November 10 and 17, Noon to 2 pm, Room 235, Albemarle County Office Building, McIntire Road.
Continued from the front page of this newsletter…
The first method has been used by Congress to submit 33 amendments to the states, beginning with the Bill
of Rights. Of these, 27 were approved; 26 are currently in effect, while one – the 18th Amendment
(Prohibition) — was ultimately repealed by a second amendment, the 21st. The 21st Amendment was also
the only one ratified by conventions in the states, rather than by state legislatures. In June 1920, the
Supreme Court ruled unanimously that the U.S. Constitution provided for state legislatures, not citizen
referendum campaigns, to ratify amendments.
The second method, an Article V Convention, has never been successfully invoked.
League Background
Perhaps it goes without saying that the League of Women Voters believes it is right and permissible to
amend the Constitution of the United States when circumstances demand. The League was born from the
successful, decades-long effort to pass the 19th Amendment.
The question for us today is: what are the shared values and beliefs within the League – what consensus do
we have – regarding the circumstances that might allow or compel the League to endorse a constitutional
amendment or an Article V Convention?
If we do find that we have consensus on some of the principles that should guide us, mobilizing the
organization to advocacy for or against a particular amendment would fall under the established protocol by
which the League determines its advocacy agenda, as laid out in Impact on Issues.
We might support an amendment that was in concert with League positions, but we might not support
every amendment that was in concert with League positions. In other words, having a position on the issue
is necessary but might not be sufficient for the League to endorse a constitutional amendment.
The first question to ask is whether League positions support the proposed amendment, but even if the
answer is an unqualified “yes,” we need to examine other factors. Those factors will be the center of
discussion at a two-session meeting on this study and will set the stage for possible consensus by our
League. So please join us on both these dates and participate in the ongoing work of the League of
Women Voters to take a position on this important topic of “Amending the U.S. Constitution”!
Put Tuesday, November 10 and Tuesday November 17 on your calendar!
Noon to 2 pm, Room 235, Albemarle County Office Building, McIntire Road
Here are some LWV US links you might want to explore in preparation for this meeting:
http://forum.lwv.org/member-resources/article/constitutional-amendment-study-guide
this has the consensus questions with background info for presentation
http://forum.lwv.org/category/member-resources/our-work/constitutional-amendment-study
this has a lot of background, with links, and then the consensus questions at the end.
Page | 2 - November 2015
Vote! on Tuesday, November 3
What’s on your ballot? Go to sbe.virginia.gov
Are You a Registered Voter in the State of
Virginia? You can check your voter registration
status and polling place and find out what is on
your ballot for this election at the Department of
Elections website, www.sbe.virginia.gov.
If you vote in the City of Charlottesville or
Albemarle County, you may download the Voter’s
Guide for candidates on your ballot: click on City
of Charlottesville or Albemarle County.
Don’t forget: Our LWV CVA Website will link
you to all important area Voter and Election
information on your computer or mobile phone.
Go to: lwv.avenue.org and click on Voter and
Election Information.
Need a ride to the polls? Here's the link to
the form if someone wants a ride:
bit.ly/CAR2VoteFall2015
If someone wants to volunteer to drive, that
link is bit.ly/Drive2VoteFall2015
Want to talk to a real live person about any
voter questions? Here are the LWV CVA
area Voter Registrar Office phone numbers:
 City of Charlottesville – 434 970 3250
 Albemarle County – 434 972 4173
 Fluvanna County - 434 589 3593
 Greene County - 434 985 5213
 Louisa County – 540 967 3427
 Nelson County – 434 263 4068
Voting Deadlines
Last day to register to vote or update
registration: October 13 by 5 pm.
Absentee Voting at your Voter
Registration Office is available
September 18 to October 30 during
office hours—contact your local
registrar’s office. Do you need an
Absentee Ballot mailed to you?
You may apply online for an
Absentee Ballot. Click here.
Your absentee application may be
submitted NOW, and must be
received no later than Tuesday,
October 27 (5 pm). But don’t delay—
your voted ballot must be received by
the registrar’s office by election day
or it cannot be counted.
Other sources of nonpartisan candidate
information:
1. Senior Statesmen Sept 13 Candidates
Forum: Podcast:
http://www.seniorstatesmen.org/2015/08/1
2/local-candidates-forum/
2. Sept 10 Albemarle Board of Supervisors
Rivanna District. Podcast available at
http://bit.ly/1OZFeKQ
3. Sept 17 Charlottesville City Council. Audio
available at http://bit.ly/1Vj7hVo
4. Sept 21 Albemarle County Scottsville
Supervisor Forum. Audio available at
http://bit.ly/1VgUVCr
Page | 3 - November 2015
5. Sept 22 Charlottesville City Council.
Podcast available at http://bit.ly/1KGD9xb
President’s Message
Your Board at its summer planning meeting decided that voter registration in the city of Charlottesville,
Albemarle County, and Fluvanna are very well covered by the Registrars of those entities as well as
myriad other organizations. Perhaps current registration efforts reflect how well the LWV has set an
example over the years. The end result of this status led us to turn our “registration energies” to
getting out the vote and voter education. According to our Voter Service Chair, Dena Imlay, our League
has been involved in thirteen forums in various capacities in Greene, Fluvanna, and Albemarle counties
and the City of Charlottesville. The Parent Council [PTO] of the Albemarle County School System
specifically asked that the LWV conduct and moderate forums for the school board candidates.
As part of the “Get Out the Vote” effort, the Board voted to purchase and the Mary Stamps White
Committee voted to pay for a new banner, which is scheduled to fly across Market Street the week
prior to the election. It is not date specific and should therefore be useful for many years. The banner
prominently displays our logo, our mantra, “Democracy is not a spectator sport”, our website address,
and the word “VOTE”.
In addition to election activities, our League, as all the Leagues in the USA, has two issues coming up
that were voted for study at the National Convention two years ago. The first due by December 1 is on
the process of amending the US constitution, and our League will hold two meetings on November 10
and 17 on this study. The second due by February 1 is Money in Politics. Plan now to attend these
study/consensus meetings: These meetings determine if and on what we will lobby as a League.
The Voter Guides for the City of Charlottesville and for Albemarle County are available now
electronically on our website, lwv.avenue.org. These were produced by Charlottesville Tomorrow and
The Daily Progress. The LWV CVA provided our League logo and funds to assist with the significant cost
of this effort. In addition to the electronic version, the guides will be mailed first class to every
registered voter in the City of Charlottesville and Albemarle County. Some may wonder why the League
does not as in the past produce the guide alone. The answer is simply due to changing times, costs, and
the lack of League personnel. Be assured the Voter Guides for Charlottesville and Albemarle still remain
nonpartisan and should still be a valuable educational tool for all voters.
Last but definitely not least – I highly suggest you become a regular reader of The Virginia Voter
produced by your State League of which you are automatically a member by being a local league
member. The Voter holds very useful news and information for all League members and you are
missing a lot the LWV offers if you pass it by. If you are receiving the Voter, take the time to read it. If
you are not receiving the Voter, e-mail Flo Marks at [email protected] . Flo will e-mail The Virginia
Voter to you as an attachment. Those of you still without e-mail can have a copy mailed to you by
calling our office.
The mission of the League is to educate our citizens. We have provided various venues to do that.
Remind those educated citizens TO VOTE. Make it happen. You are on the front line.
Happy Election Day!
Kerin Yates
President
League of Women Voters of the Charlottesville Area
Page | 4 - November 2015
The League of Women Voters of Virginia
Invites You to Attend
PRE-SESSION WOMEN’S LEGISLATIVE ROUND TABLE
On Capitol Square -- Wednesday, December 2, 2015
General Assembly Building, House Room D,
The GAB is at the corner of 9th and Broad Street; entrance is on the side of
the building opposite of Broad Street
Speakers: Non-Profit Representatives & Governor’s Cabinet Members
Topic: Legislation in the 2016 General Assembly
MORNING: Free and Open to the Public
9:00 A.M. - 12:00 P.M.
Coffee and Tea Will be Available
******
LUNCHEON: $30
Luncheon Guest Speaker TBA
Note: Registration for Luncheon: Deadline: November 25, 2015
******
For more information visit our website www.lwv-va.org or contact: [email protected]
**Parking and Directions and Features:
http://virginiageneralassembly.gov/virginiaStateCapitol.php?secid=7&activesec=1#!hb=1&mainContentTabs=1
&content=1,includes/contentTemplate.php%3Ftid%3D44%26ctype%3Db%26cid%3D23
___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___
Luncheon Reservation Form: Deadline: November 25. No Refunds.
Please Print: Name __________________________________________ Phone: ___________________
Email: _________________________________________________ Number of Reservations _______
League or organization _____________________________________ Vegan choice needed? _________
Add names on back of this form as needed. Detach and mail completed form with your $30 check made payable
to: LWV of Virginia - Address: LWV-VA c/o Pat Hurst, 12 Georgetown Green, Charlottesville, VA 22901
Page | 5 - November 2015
International Relations /Federal Government Committee News
by Gerry Kruger
Deborah Brooks hosted the September 23 International Relations/ Federal Government meeting. Looking
through her living room window at the beginning of fall, we discussed Gerry Kruger’s report on the
unintended consequences of charter and magnet schools, or “school choice.” Although both types of
schools give underprivileged children a chance for rich experiences that come with better equipment,
fewer discipline problems, more challenging material, and more involved parents, this comes at a high cost
to the children who are left behind.
Many charter and magnet schools have lotteries if there are not enough slots for all the children that choose
to go to them. Those that are left behind must cope with a denser population of less motivated students,
dangerous neighborhoods, less supportive parents, more discipline problems, and teachers, who, as a result
of these problems, often burn out quickly, or are simply not equipped to handle them.
Research shows that the large number of students being allowed to transfer to and from these schools of
“choice” place a huge burden on the traditional public schools, which must accept all transfers at any time
in the year. These transfers create disruption and distraction at a time when students are at the greatest risk
of dropping out of school and interrupt routines, learning, and relationships with other students and
teachers. Experts say this disruption is linked to lower achievement and graduation rates, and school
choice tends to promote the idea that students can change schools at will.
The Virginia House of Delegates has passed a bill to allow Title I money to move with disadvantaged
students if they transfer out of inner city schools, and to allow resources from failing schools to be shifted
to charter and magnet schools. This bill is on the calendar to come before the State Senate at this time.
Again, the traditional public schools will suffer if this bill becomes a law.
Another concern is the conflict that school choice creates for cities that have created Cities of Promise,
considered one of the most ambitious anti-poverty programs in a generation. The City of Promise goal is
to improve the neighborhood schools so that families will be drawn back to them. Federal money is
pouring into these neighborhoods to help with tutoring, literacy programs, early childhood education,
parenting, after-school programs, mental health help, housing, and other services.
If the best students are pulled out of the target school to attend charter or magnet schools, they cannot take
advantage of all that is offered by the Promise program. The scattering of students also makes it harder to
gather data and monitor the program’s success. The Education Department tracks progress in target
schools, but little information is available about students who leave to attend charters and magnets.
Parents are faced with the dilemma of taking advantage of programs that are offered a few steps away from
their homes or sending their child farther away to take advantage of opportunities that charter or magnet
schools offer.
At Susan Roberts’ home on October 14, Lydia Peal reported on five hostages who were captured by
ISIS in Syria. The oldest, 44-year-old Theo Padnos, was the only one who survived. This was due to the
efforts of David Bradley, owner of the Atlantic Media company.
On May 13, 2014, Bradley convened the five families of the hostages and told them not to tell anyone. He
made use of the many contacts he has to research where the hostages might be held. In spite of his
widespread contacts and influence, he was only able to have Theo Padnos released. Also one rescue
attempt by the U.S. was unsuccessful.
Continued on next page
Page | 6 - November 2015
International Relations/Federal Government Committee News
Continued from previous page
Most of the hostages were journalists who wanted to cover stories and help people. They
provided medical aid and helped wherever they could. They were tortured, beaten, and shocked with
tasers. Steven Satloff was an Israeli citizen while Peter Kasing was from Indianapolis. Jim Foley
was kidnapped prior to this and escaped. Then he returned only to be kidnapped again. Kayla
Mueller was the only woman in the group and was also killed.
The kidnappers asked for $100,000,000 and all Muslim prisoners worldwide to be set free. All the
families raised some money, but not nearly enough to meet demands. They also met with Obama
about coordinating efforts to free them.
It is against the law to give into terrorists’ demands for ransom. This is because paying ransoms
would encourage more kidnappings. So far there is no record of anyone being prosecuted for
breaking this law. The US policy is now under review.
Deborah Brooks’s report was on the Kurds, one of the largest ethnic groups in the world
without a country. They live in Turkey, Syria, Iraq, and Iran and are culturally closest to Iran, but
their religion is Sunni while Iran is 95% Shia. We were surprised to learn that the largest population
of Kurds in the US is in Nashville, Tennessee, where as many as 15,000 live.
The Kurds are fierce fighters, and there is a revolutionary group of Kurds called the PKK. They are
quite violent and were put on a list of terrorists by the US, NATO, the United Kingdom, but not the
United Nations. They even engage in civil wars among themselves.
In 1920 when the treaty that divided the Ottoman Empire was made, the Kurds were tribes that
inhabited Western Asia. Turkey eliminated most of them by deporting as many as they could or
killing them. Iran treated them differently, giving them autonomy. Then Saddam Hussein attacked
them with chemical weapons. Syria has routinely discriminated against the Kurds. Now they have an
elected representative in the Turkish parliament because they passed the 10% limit required to having
voting rights used them to elect their first representative.
Our committee welcomes new members at every meeting. Please join us as we study the complex
problems that our world is facing. As a League we are empowered to make a difference. See the end
of this newsletter for meeting times and places.
In Memoriam: Francis Fife
“Francis H. Fife, a well-known and highly respected
leader in Charlottesville and beyond, died on Oct. 16. He
was 95 — and active to the last. He remained a familiar
figure around the city, continuing to circulate among
political, civic, social and cultural communities. His tall
figure commanded attention wherever he went, but he
never demanded attention or sought recognition.” [The
Daily Progress, Oct. 20, 2015] He was a long-time
member of the League of Women Voters and regularly
attended Legislative Luncheon and Annual Meetings. His
presence will be sorely missed.
Page | 7 - November 2015
Welcome New LWV Members!
Jody Forman
370 Fence Road
Earlysville, VA 22936
434 295-0456
[email protected]
Elaine Longerbeam
39 Quail Hunt Place
Zion Crossroads, VA 22942-6979
540-832-7296
540-550-5998cell
[email protected]
League of Women Voters
1932 Arlington Blvd. #111
Charlottesville, VA 22903-1560
LWV CVA
President
Kerin Yates
Newsletter
Editor
Michele Kellermann
Meetings and Events for October/November 2015: Mark Your Calendars Now!
Date/Time
Event
Place
Contact
Wed., Oct. 28, 9:30
am
International Relations/Federal Gov't.
Committee Meeting
Home of Liz Kutchai, 126
Bollingwood Rd., 296-0541
For further information, contact Natalie
Testa, 589-4067
Thurs., Oct. 29, 7
pm
Albemarle At-Large, Samuel Miller,
Rivanna, and Scottsville School
Board Candidates Forum
Monticello High School
Forum
For further information, contact Dena
Imlay, 296-6651
Tues., Nov. 3
ELECTION DAY! VOTE
For your polling place go to:
sbe.virginia.gov
Go to our website: lwv.avenue.org for
election information
Tues., Nov. 10 –
Noon to 2 pm
Study: “Amending the U. S.
Constitution”
Albemarle County Office
Bldg., Room 235, McIntire
Rd.
For further information, contact Sue
Lewis, 295-1485
Wed., Nov. 11, 9:30
am
International Relations/Federal Gov't.
Committee Meeting
Home of Molly O’Brien, 250
West Main St., #602, 2459806
For further information, contact Natalie
Testa, 589-4067
Wed., Nov. 11, 4 – 6
pm
LWV CVA Board of Directors Meeting
Virginia Foundation for the
Humanities (Boar's Head Inn
complex)
For further information, contact Kerin
Yates, 964-1840
Tues., Nov. 17 –
Noon to 2 pm
Study Consensus: “Amending the
U.S. Constitution”
Albemarle County Office
Bldg., Room 235, McIntire
Rd.
For further information, contact Sue
Lewis, 295-1485
Wed., Nov. 18, 4:30
pm
LWV CVA Natural Resources
Committee Meeting
Virginia Foundation for the
Humanities (Boar's Head Inn
complex)
For further information, contact Linda
Goodling, 296-9865
Wed., Dec. 2, 9 am12 noon; followed
by luncheon
LWV VA Pre-Session Women’s
Legislative Roundtable – Capital
Square Richmond
General Assembly Bldg.,
House Room D, Richmond
See page 5 of this newsletter or contact
Sue Lewis, 295-1485
Page | 8 - November 2015