Estimating the Effect of Unearned Income on Labor Earnings

,t|4@|?} |i ,giU| Lu N?i@h?i_ W?UL4i
L? w@MLh ,@h??}tc 5@?}t @?_ L?t4T|L?G
,_i?Ui uhL4 @ 5hi) Lu wL||ih) *@)iht
B_L ` W4Mi?t Nw2 @?_ ,+
#L?@*_ +M? O@h@h_ N?iht|)
hUi 5@Uih_L|i #@h|4L| L**i}ie
a*) 2fff
a*) .c 2fff
4 Zh
duh judwhixo iru vxssruw e| wkh Qdwlrqdo Vflhqfh Irxqgdwlrq wkurxjk judqwv VEU <75634; dqg
VEU <;4538:/ d Vordq Ihoorzvkls/ dqg iru vxssruw dqg frrshudwlrq iurp wkh Pdvvdfkxvhwwv Vwdwh Orwwhu|
frpplvlrq lq jhqhudo/ dqg Ghluguh Fr|oh lq sduwlfxodu1 Zh duh dovr judwhixo iru frpphqwv e| Mrvkxd Dqjulvw/
Jdu| Fkdpehuodlq/ Nhl Kludqr/ Oduu| Ndw}/ Dodq Nuxhjhu/ dqg sduwlflsdqwv lq vhplqduv dw PLW/ Sulqfhwrq
Xqlyhuvlw|/ Froxpeld Xqlyhuvlw|/ dqg wkh QEHU vxpphu lqvwlwxwh1 Ilqdoo| zh zlvk wr dfnqrzohgjh vxshue
dqg wluhohvv uhvhdufk dvvlvwdqfh iurp Gdylg Jurvvpdq/ Dglwl Vkulnkdqgh/ dqg Hgxdugr Idmq}|oehu1 Zh dorqh
duh uhvsrqvleoh iru huuruv1
5 Ghsduwphqw ri Hfrqrplfv/ ;589 Exqfkh Kdoo/ XFOD/ 738 Klojdug Dyhqxh/ Orv Dqjhohv/ FD <33<81
6 Ghsduwphqw ri Vwdwlvwlfv/ Vflhqfh Fhqwhu :3</ Kduydug Xqlyhuvlw|/ Fdpeulgjh/ PD 3546;1
7 Ghsduwphqw ri Hfrqrplfv/ 9439 Urfnhqihoohu Kdoo/ Gduwprxwk Froohjh/ Kdqryhu/ QK 36:881
.t|6B|A} |j .uujW| Nu PAjBiAja YAWN6j
NA wBONi 7VV,+e .BiAA}te 7BA}t BAa NAt6V|NAH
.ajAWj uiN6 B 7ij+ Nu wN||ji+ ,B+jit
Y6OjAte -OA BAa 7BWjiaN|j
k?L*i_}i Lu |i igiU| Lu ?i@h?i_ ?UL4i L? iUL?L4U Mi@Lh Lu ?__@*t ? }i?
ih@*c @?_ L? *@MLh tTT*) ? T@h|U*@hc t Lu }hi@| 4TLh|@?Ui |L TL*U) 4@!iht ,t|4@|L?
Lu ?UL4i igiU|tc Liihc t Lu|i? UL4T*U@|i_ M) |i u@U| |@| i L}i?Lt U@?}it ? ?
i@h?i_ ?UL4i @hi _U*| |L _i?|u) Oihi i i T*L| |i h@?_L43i_ @tt}?4i?| Lu *@h}i
@4L?|t Lu 4L?i) Lih *L?} TihL_t Lu |4i |hL} *L||ihit ì U@hhi_ L| @ thi) Lu
TiLT*i L T*@)i_ |i *L||ih) ? |i 4_i}|it @?_ it|4@|i |i igiU| Lu *L||ih) ???}t
L? |ih tMtiî?| i@h??}tc UL?t4T|L? @?_ t@?}t
ì ?_ |@| ?i@h?i_ ?UL4i hi_Uit *@MLh i@h??}tc | @ 4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|) |L
UL?t4i *ithi Lu @TThL 4@|i*) ffc uLh 4i? @t i** @t L4i? W?__@*t Mi|ii? DD
@?_ SD )i@ht L*_ i? ???} |i *L||ih) hi_Ui |ih *@MLh i@h??}t 4Lhi t@hT*) |@?
L*_ih Lh )L?}ih ?__@*t W?__@*t | }ih i@h??}t MiuLhi ???} |i *L||ih)
@*tL tL }hi@|ih hi_U|L?t ? *@MLh i@h??}t
5L4i Lu |i ?i@h?i_ ?UL4i t tTi?| L? U@ht @?_ Lt?} *|L} |i ???}t _L
?L| @TTi@h |L @giU| hi|hi4i?| t@?}t 4Uc L|ih t@?}t }L T M) @ML| D |L 2f TihUi?|
Lu |i ???}t |L _@|i ALti L L? *L?}ih @}L @hi t@?} @| @ }ih h@|i |@? hiUi?|
??iht
YA|iNaW|NA
k?L*i_}i Lu |i igiU| Lu ?UL4i L? iUL?L4U Mi@Lh ? }i?ih@*c @?_ L? *@MLh tTT*)
? T@h|U*@hc t Lu }hi@| 4TLh|@?Ui |L TL*U) 4@!iht 6Lh i @4T*ic ? t ?|hL_U|L?
|L @ _tUttL? Lu |i ?i}@|i ?UL4i |@ i Tih4i?|tc Lhh**c ttt|@?| 5iUhi|@h) uLh
*@???} @?_ ,@*@|L? ? |i #iT@h|4i?| Lu Oi@*|c ,_U@|L? @?_ ì*u@hi _h?} |i
L? @_4?t|h@|L?c hL|i UL?Uih??} |i _iM@|i Lih igiU|t Lu i |i?_?} U@t @ttt|@?Ui
|L |i Lh!?} TLLhG Ri?|h@* |L |t _iM@|i @t Mii? |i ît|L? Lu *@MLhtTT*) Lu tU
u@4*it `L*_ |i hiUiT| Lu @ttt|@?Ui T@)4i?|t U@ti |i4 |L Lh! *ittc Lh ? tL4i U@titc
^| Lh! @*|L}i|ihq ELhh**c b.ec T DS ,t|4@|L? Lu ?UL4i igiU|tc Liihc t
UL4T*U@|i_ M) |i u@U| |@| hi@*t|U @4L?|t Lu ?UL4i @hi @*4Lt| ?iih h@?_L4*) @tt}?i_
@?_ i L}i?Lt U@?}it ? ?UL4i @hi _U*| |L _i?|u) W? Th@U|Uic hiti@hUiht @i Lu|i?
|@!i? tTLt@* Lh ThLTih|) ?UL4i @t i L}i?Lt uLh |i ThTLtit Lu it|4@|?} |i igiU|t Lu
?i@h?i_ ?UL4i
W? |t T@Tih i @__hitt |i ThLM*i4 Lu _i?|u)?} i L}i?Lt @h@|L? ? ?i@h?i_
?UL4i M) i T*L|?} |i h@?_L43i_ @tt}?4i?| Lu *@h}i @4L?|t Lu 4L?i) Lih *L?} TihL_t
Lu |4i |hL} *L||ihit ì thi)i_ ?__@*t L T*@)i_ |i *L||ih) ? @tt@Uti||t
? |i 4_i}|itc ?U*_?} ML| ??iht Lu *@h}i Th3it @?_ TiLT*i L L? t4@**c L?i
|4i Th3it ì ?it|}@|i |i hi*@|L?tT Mi|ii? |i @4L?| L? @?_ iUL?L4U Mi@Lh
@t 4i@thi_ M) tMtiî?| i@h??}tc UL?t4T|L? @?_ t@?}tc @?_ hiTLh| it|4@|it Lu |i
4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|) |L @**LU@|i |i ?i@h?i_ ?UL4i |L @hLt U@|i}Lhit @ti_ L? @ t|@|U
4L_i* Lu *@MLh tTT*) | 5|L?iBi@h) Thiuihi?Uit i it|4@|i |i 4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|)
|L UL?t4i *ithi |L Mi @hL?_ fI At _Lit ?L| _gih t}?U@?|*) Mi|ii? 4i? @?_
L4i? W| t t}?U@?|*) }ih uLh ?__@*t U*Lti |L |i hi|hi4i?| @}ic M| ?L| uLh
?__@*t @*hi@_) Lih |i hi|hi4i?| @}i @| |i |4i Lu ???} 5L4i Lu |i *L||ih)
???}t @hi tTi?| L? U@htc | @ 4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|) |L UL?t4i Lu eIc @?_ Lt?}c
| @ 4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|) |L UL?t4i @hL?_ .I t}?U@?| TLh|L? }Lit ?|L }i?ih@*

Eic ?L?hi|hi4i?| t@?}tc | @ 4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|) |L t@i @hL?_ SI W?__@*t
L L? 4Lhi hiUi?|*) @hi it|4@|i_ |L @i *Lih t@?}t h@|it UL4T@hi_ |L ?__@*t
L L? |i *L||ih) *L?}ih @}Lc M| |i t@?}t h@|it _L ?L| @TTi@h |L @h) M) @}i
@ti_ L? Lh i_i?Ui i ?|ihThi| |i hit*|t @t it|4@|it Lu |i U@t@* igiU| Lu *L||ih)
Th3it L? *@MLh i@h??}tc t@?}t @?_ UL?t4T|L? AL U@i@|t tL*_ Mi !iT| ? 4?_c
Liih 6ht|c hitTL?tit |L *L||ih) Th3it ?ii_ ?L| Mi |)TU@* Lu hitTL?tit |L L|ih uLh4t Lu
?i@h?i_ ?UL4i u Th4@h) ?|ihit|c @t ?_U@|i_ ? |i ht| T@h@}h@T ? |t tiU|L?c t
|i hitTL?ti Lu ?__@*t |L }Lih?4i?|ThL_i_ U@t @ttt|@?Ui W? }i?ih@* hitTL?tit |L
?i@h?i_ ?UL4i 4@) i** _gih M) |i tLhUi Lu |i ?i@h?i_ ?UL4i @| A@*ih Ebbf
hiuiht |L @t u?}M*|) W| t *!i*)c Liihc |@| |i hitTL?ti |L *L||ih) Th3it t ?_U@|i
Lu |i hitTL?ti |L L|ih |)Tit Lu ?i@h?i_ ?UL4i tU @t U@t @ttt|@?Ui 5iUL?_c *L||ih)
T*@)iht ?ii_ ?L| Mi hiThiti?|@|i Lu |i TLT*@|L? Lu ?|ihit| W? M)?} *L||ih) |U!i|tc
|i) hii@* @? @|||_i |L ht! |@| _giht uhL4 |@| Lu |i TLT*@|L? @| *@h}i OLiihc
| t @}@? *!i*) |@| |ih hitTL?ti t @| *i@t| t}}it|i Lu |i hitTL?ti Lu |i }i?ih@*
TLT*@|L?
4 w|jiB|ij
Aihi t @ *@h}i *|ih@|hi UL?Uih?i_ | it|4@|?} |i igiU| Lu ?i@h?i_ ?UL4i L?
*@MLh tTT*) 5ii i?U@i* EbHSc @?_ *?_i** @?_ @h_) E2fff uLh thi)t uLh 4i?c
@?_ k**?}tLh| @?_ OiU!4@? EbHS uLh L4i? Lt| Lu |i *|ih@|hi |*3i_ _@|@ uhL4
*@h}i thi)t tU @t |i @?i* 5|_) Lu W?UL4i #)?@4Ut E5W#c |i @|L?@* wL?}|_?@*
5hi) Ew5c Lh |i hhi?| LT*@|L? 5hi) E5 4@Lh |i4i Lu |t *|ih@|hi t
|i _U*|) ? UL?t|hU|?} i L}i?Lt 4i@thit Lu ?i@h?i_ ?UL4i u|i? U@T|@* ?UL4ic
Lh tTLt@* *@MLh ?UL4i t ti_ W? @** U@tit |i @tt4T|L? |@| |t tLhUi Lu ?i@h?i_
?UL4i t i L}i?Lt |L *@MLh tTT*) _iUtL?t Lu |i ?__@* t |i?Lt @| Mit|
?L|ih t|h@?_ Lu |i *|ih@|hi L? it|4@|L? Lu ?UL4i igiU|t @t @?@*)3i_ i Tih4i?|@*
_@|@ | U*i@h*) i L}i?Lt _i|ih4?@?|t Lu ?i@h?i_ ?UL4i W? |i i@h*) tii?|itc tiih@*
2
?i}@|i ?UL4i |@ i Tih4i?|t EWA ihi UL?_U|i_ ihi ti*iU|i_ ?__@*t hiUii_
h@?_L4*) @tt}?i_ |@ tUi_*it U@h@U|ih3i_ M) @ }@h@?|ii *ii* UL4M?i_ | @ |@ h@|i
5ii uLh i @4T*i +iit Eb.e @?_ |i hiuihi?Uit ? i?U@i* EbHS Ai WA i Tih4i?|t
ihi *4|i_ ? |i _h@|L? Lu |i ?UL4i tTT*i4i?|c h@?}?} uhL4 |hii |L i )i@ht W|
t |ihiuLhi TLttM*i |@| hitTL?tit |L |i _gihi?| |@ hi}4it _L ?L| hiThiti?| *L?} h?
hitTL?tit |L @ Tih4@?i?| U@?}i ? hi}4i W? @__|L?c |i @4L?|t Lu ?UL4i h@?_L4*)
@tt}?i_ ihi hi*@|i*) 4L_it| W? UL?|h@t|c |i *L||ih) T@)t L| tMt|@?|@* Th3it Lih
i |i?_i_ TihL_t Lu |4i
|h_ t|h@?_ Lu |i *|ih@|hi UL?tt|t Lu @ ?4Mih Lu U@ti t|_it ? U *@h}i
@4L?|t Lu 4L?i) ihi @**LU@|i_ t?} _t|hM|L? h*it |@| ihi @h}@M*) ?_iTi?_i?|
Lu Thiuihi?Uit @?_ L|ih _i|ih4?@?|t Lu iUL?L4U Mi@Lh , @4T*it Lu |iti tLU@**i_
?@|h@* i Tih4i?|t Etii ?}ht| @?_ khi}ih EbbH uLh @ thi) Lu |t *|ih@|hi @hi
khi?? EbS @?_ w@?_tMih}ih EbSc b.fc L *LL!i_ @| L?i|4i @h hiT@h@|L?t T@_
|L Wth@i* U|3i?t M) |i Bih4@? }Lih?4i?|c L_!? EbDbc bSc L *LL!i_ @| L?i|4i
T@)4i?|t M) |i N5 }Lih?4i?| |L ti*iU|i_ tihUi 4i? @u|ih `Lh*_ `@h WWc @?_ OL*|3
,@!?c aL*u@@? @?_ +Lti? Ebb L *LL!i_ @| |i igiU|t Lu ?ih|@?Uit L? i4T*L)4i?|
W? @** |iti U@titc |i i L}i?i|) Lu |i ?UL4i tTT*i4i?|tc |@| tc |ih ?_iTi?_i?Ui
Lu Thiuihi?Uit @?_ UL?t|h@?|tc t t|** tMiU| |L _iM@|ic M| 4U 4Lhi T*@tM*i |@? |i
@tt4T|L? Lu i L}i?i|) Luc uLh i @4T*ic tTLt@* *@MLh ?UL4i Lh U@T|@* ?UL4i
6?@**)c @t ? |i Uhhi?| T@Tihc k@T*@? EbHD @?@*)3it @ thi) Lu *L||ih) ??iht k@
T*@?c Liihc L?*) UL**iU|i_ _@|@ L? iUL?L4U Mi@Lh 44i_@|i*) ThLhc @?_ 44i_@|i*)
tMtiî?|c |L |i *L||ih) ???}c @?_ i t |ihiuLhi ?@M*i |L it|4@|i *L?} |ih4 igiU|t
ihi@t i @i |i?|) )i@ht Lu @UUh@|i i@h??}t _@|@ uhL4 |i tLU@* tiUh|) @_4?t
|h@|L? W? @__|L?c k@T*@? L?*) thi)i_ TiLT*i L L? @4L?|t *@h}i i?L} |@| |i
Th3it ihi T@_ ? )i@h*) t4tc ihi@t i @*tL @i @ UL?|hL* }hLT Lu t4@**c L?i|4i
Th3i ??iht 6?@**)c @t ? 4@?) Lu |i L|ih ?@|h@* i Tih4i?| t|_it hiuihi?Ui_ @MLic
k@T*@? _Lit ?L| @i _i|@*i_ _@|@ hi}@h_?} |i ?__@*t< iUL?L4U UhU4t|@?Uit @?_
Mi@Lh ThLh |L |i ?@?|UT@|i_ ?utL? Lu ?UL4i
Cj 7ij+
h _@|@ ti| UL?tt|t Lu |L t@4T*itc |i R??iht t@4T*i @?_ |i R*Ltiht t@4T*i Ai
hi*i@?| TLT*@|L? uLh |i ??iht t@4T*i UL?tt|t Lu TiLT*i T*@)?} |i i}@MU!t *L||ih)
? @tt@Uti||t _h?} |i )i@ht bHe |hL} bHH @?_ ???} @ 4@Lh Th3i @Lh
Th3it uLh |i ThTLtit Lu |t t|_) @hi Th3it |@| @hi T@_ L| ? )i@h*) ?t|@**4i?|t Lih
|i?|) )i@ht Ai |L|@* Th3it h@?}i uhL4 m22cfff |L mbcSbScfffc | |i t@4T*i 4i@? @?_
4i_@? i^@* |L mcfecfff @?_ mSDcfff hitTiU|i*)2 Ai R*Ltiht t@4T*i UL4it uhL4 |i
TLT*@|L? Lu ti@tL? |U!i| L*_iht Mi|ii? bHe @?_ bHH L @i L? @| *i@t| L?i t4@**c
L?i|4i Th3ic h@?}?} uhL4 uhL4 mff |L mDcfff( i _L ?L| !?L uLh |iti ?__@*t
|i i @U| @4L?| Lu |i Th3i Ai TiLT*i ? |t t@4T*i @hi hiuihhi_ |L @t |i R*Ltihtc
@*|L} | tL*_ Mi t|hitti_ |@| |i) __ @U|@**) ? t4@**c L?i|4ic Th3it
Ai thi) ît|L??@hic @@*@M*i ? TTi?_ ? W4Mi?tc +M? @?_ 5@Uih_L|i
Ebbbc UL?tt|t Lu |hii ti|t Lu ît|L?t Ai ht| ti| UL?Uih?t |i Uhhi?| E|4i Lu thi)
t|@|L? Lu |i hitTL?_i?| @?_ t Lh ih LtiL*_ Aiti ?U*_i ît|L?t hi}@h_?}
|i *@MLh 4@h!i| t|@|t Lu |i hitTL?_i?| @?_ tTLtic |ih ?@?U@* @tti|tc |ih Lt?}
t|@|L? @?_ U@h @*it 5iUL?_c |ihi @hi @ ?4Mih Lu ît|L?t hi}@h_?} |i t|@|L? @|
|i |4i |i) L? |ih Th3i ? |i *L||ih) W? Th?UT*ic |ihi t ?L tMt|@?|i ?|ihit|
? |i @?tiht |L |iti Thi*L||ih) ît|L?t Ai hi@tL? uLh ?U*_?} |i4 ? |i thi)
t |hiiuL*_ 6ht|c @?_ 4Lt| 4TLh|@?|c |i) @ttt| ? 4@!?} |i ?uihi?Uit 4Lhi Uhi_M*i
@?_ ThL_i t | UiU!t L? |i @*_|) Lu |i ?uihi?Uit W? Th?UT*i |i h@?_L43@|L?
tL*_ i?thi |@| |i _gihi?| }hLTt Lu ??iht @?_ *Ltiht @hi UL4T@h@M*i @| |i |4i
Lu T*@)?} |i *L||ih) W? Th@U|Ui |ihi @hi |hii hi@tL?t ) |t ?ii_ ?L| Mi |hi ?
Lh t@4T*i 6ht|c ?__@*t M) _gihi?| ?4Miht Lu |U!i|tc @?_ |i h@?_L43@|L? t
5 Doo
groodu dprxqwv duh lq 4<;9 grooduv1
orwwhu| grhv qrw kdyh klvwrulfdo uhfrugv iru shrsoh zlqqlqj vpdoo sul}hv zkr erxjkw vlqjoh wlfnhwv/
ru iru vhdvrq wlfnhw kroghuv zkr glg qrw zlq dq|wklqj1
6 Wkh
e
Lih |U!i|t h@|ih |@? ?__@*t 5iUL?_ |ihi @hi L?*) ti@tL? |U!i| L*_iht ? |i
*Ltiht t@4T*ic @?_ @? ?!?L? 4 Lu ti@tL? |U!i| L*_iht @?_ t?}*i |U!i| M)iht ? |i
??iht t@4T*i Ah_c |ihi t ?L?hitTL?ti U t TL|i?|@**) ULhhi*@|i_ | ?__@*
_gihi?Uit @t i** @t |i @4L?| Lu |i Th3i 54*@h UL?Uih?tc ? |@| U@ti Th4@h*) _i |L
?L?hitTL?tic @hLti ? |i @?@*)tt Lu |i WA i Tih4i?|t EO@t4@? @?_ `tic bHD Ai
@h@M*it _itUhM?} |i t|@|L? Lu |i hitTL?_i?| @| |i |4i Lu T*@)?} |i *L||ih) U@?
Mi ti_ |L i*T @_t| uLh tU _gihi?Uitc @?_ @**L t |L i@*@|i |i ThLUi_hit ti_ uLh
|iti @_t|4i?|t Ai tiUL?_ hi@tL? uLh ?U*_?} |i ît|L?t UL?Uih??} |i ?__@*<t
t|@|L? @| |i |4i Lu ???} t |L ?it|}@|i |i i|ihL}i?i|) Lu |i ?UL4i igiU|t M)
?__@* U@h@U|iht|Ut tU @t }i?_ihc Thi*L||ih) *@MLh 4@h!i| t|@|tc @?_ @}i 6?@**)c
|i ?U*tL? Lu UL?|hL* @h@M*it Lh hi}hittLht U@? 4ThLi |i ThiUtL? Lu |i it|4@|itc
t| @t ? @ h@?_L43i_ i Tih4i?| Ah_c i @t!i_ hitTL?_i?|t |L @|Lh3i |i hi*i@ti Lu
|ih tLU@* tiUh|) i@h??}t hiULh_t |L t ì _i*Mih@|i*) ULti |L @t! uLh tLU@* tiUh|)
i@h??}t hiULh_tc h@|ih |@? ?^hi @ML| i@h??}t uhL4 |i hitTL?_i?|t _hiU|*)c ? Lh_ih
|L }i| 4Lhi @UUh@|i hiULh_t Lih @ *L?}ih TihL_ Lu |4i 6Lh |Lti L t}?i_ |i tLU@*
tiUh|) hi*i@ti uLh4t i @i @UUh@|i i@h??}t hiULh_t uLh @| *i@t| t )i@ht ThiUii_?}
@?_ t )i@ht uL**L?} |i |4i Lu ???} *|L} i __ ?U*_i ît|L?t UL?Uih??}
tTLt@* *@MLh 4@h!i| t|@|t ML| Uhhi?| @?_ @| |i |4i Lu *L||ih) T*@)?}c i __ ?L| @t!
uLh tTLt@* i@h??}t ?uLh4@|L?c L| Lu UL?Uih? uLh |i hitTL?ti h@|it
Ai thi) @t UL?_U|i_ ? |hii t|@}it W? a*) bbDc i ti?| L| M) hi}*@h 4@*
T*L| thi)t |L Df ??iht @?_ Df *Ltiht |L @ttitt hitTL?ti h@|it @?_ @hLt @TThL@Uit |L
?Uhi@t?} |i4 W? a*) bbS i ti?| L|c @}@? M) hi}*@h 4@*c thi)t |L .D2 ??iht @?_
S. *Ltiht 6?@**)c ? 5iT|i4Mih bbS i ti?_ L| hi4?_iht |L 2b. ?L?hitTL?_?} ??iht
@?_ 2b. ?L?hitTL?_?} *Ltiht Ai hi4?_iht ihi ti?| M) 6i_ih@* , Thitt |L ?Uhi@ti |i
*!i*LL_ Lu TL|i?|@* hitTL?_i?|t T@)?} @||i?|L? |L |i thi) W? |i T*L| thi) @?_
|i 4@? 4@*?}c hitTL?_i?|t ihi Lgihi_ |i ULUi Mi|ii? *L||ih) |U!i|t | @ ?L4?@*
ULt| Lu ff _L**@ht Lh }u| Uih|U@|it ? 4@Lh _iT@h|4i?| t|Lhit | @ ?L4?@* ULt| Lu
D
Df _L**@ht W? |i uL**LT T@h| Lu |i thi)c eb ??iht @?_ eb *Ltiht hiUii_ | |i
thi) @ f _L**@h ?L|ic @?_ ihi Lgihi_ @ UiU! uLh @? @__|L?@* ef _L**@ht ? i U@?}i uLh
hi|h??} |i thi) Ai L|ih 2eH ??iht @?_ 2eH *Ltiht @TThL@Ui_ ? |i uL**LT ihi
Lgihi_ @ UiU! uLh Df _L**@ht uLh hi|h??} |i thi) W?Ui?|i tUi4it ihi TL|i?|@*
hitTL?_i?|t @hi T@_ ThLh |L hitTL?_?} @i Mii? ThiLt*) 4T*i4i?|i_ ? *TtL?
Ebb.c L _tUttit |i 4ih|t Lu tU tUi4it ? _i|@*
A@M*i t44@h3it |i hitTL?ti h@|it uLh |i _gihi?| 4@*?}t Ai Lih@** hitTL?ti
h@|i t @TThL 4@|i*) eSIc t*}|*) }ih uLh *Ltiht @| ebI |@? uLh ??iht @| e2I W|
tL*_ Mi ?L|i_c Liihc |@| |i uL**LT 4@*?} __ ?L| ?U*_i @** ?L?hitTL?_i?|t
uhL4 |i ThiLt 4@*?} uLh M_}i|@h) hi@tL?t O@_ i uL**Li_ T L? @** ?L?hitTL?_i?|t
? |i 4@? 4@*?} t?} |i f_L**@hU@t%ef_L**@hUiU! ?Ui?|i tUi4ic |i i TiU|i_
Lih@** hitTL?ti L*_ @i Mii? EfH n E fH f2 ffI' DI L?tt|i?| |
*TtL?<t Ebb. ?_?}tc |i ?Ui?|i tUi4i | mf T uhL?| @?_ @ ThL4ti Lu mef
4Lhi h@|ih |@? @ ThL4ti Lu mDf __ *i@_ |L @ }ih hitTL?ti h@|i E2I ihtt SI |it| Lu |i ?** )TL|itt |@| |i |L hitTL?ti h@|it @hi i^@* }it @ |t|@|t|U Lu Hc
| @ T@*i Lu ffH
g Cj $B|B
h M@tU t@4T*i uLh |i @?@*)tit Thiti?|i_ Mi*L UL?tt|t Lu ?__@*t | UL4T*i|i
@?tiht |L |i ît|L?t L? Thi*L||ih) UL?_|L?t E|@| tc ?4Mih Lu |U!i|t ML}|c @}ic
)i@ht Lu } tULL*c )i@ht Lu UL**i}ic }i?_ihc i|ih |i ?__@* @t Lh!?} @| |i
|4i Lu T*@)?} |i *L||ih)c @?_ L @|Lh3i_ |i hi*i@ti Lu |ih tLU@* tiUh|) i@h??}t
At *i@it t | @ t@4T*i Lu ebS LMtih@|L?tc 2Db *Ltiht @?_ 2. ??iht 6Lh @?@*)tit
ihi ?L*?} @__|L?@* @h@M*it Ei}c t@?}t Lh UL?t4T|L? i ti*iU| tMt@4T*it Lu
|t M@tU t@4T*i | UL4T*i|i @?tiht |L |i ît|L?t hi}@h_?} |i @__|L?@* @h@M*it
?L*i_ W? _L?} tL i _tU@h_i_ ?__@*t L hitTL?_i_ |L tL4i Lu |i ît|L?tc @?_
|ihiuLhi TLttM*) ?|hL_Ui_ M@tit Lh @| *i@t| *Lt| tL4i ThiUtL? W? u|hi Lh! i ?|i?_
S
|L uL**L @ 4Lhi Th?UT*i_ @TThL@U |L 4tt?} _@|@ ?L*?} 4L_i**?} |i ?L?hitTL?ti
@?_ 4*|T*) 4T|?} |i 4tt?} _@|@ Ew||*i @?_ +M?c bH.
A@M*i 2 Thiti?|t t44@h) t|@|t|Ut uLh |i @h@M*it ti_ ? |i @?@*)tit 6Lh i@U
@h@M*i |i 4i@? @?_ t|@?_@h_ _i@|L? uLh |i i?|hi t@4T*i @hi }i? ? |i ht| |L
UL*4?t ì @*tL Thiti?| @ih@}it tiT@h@|i*) uLh |i *Ltiht @?_ ??ihtc @t i** @t |
t|@|t|Ut uLh |i ?** )TL|itit |@| |i @ih@}it uLh |i *Ltih @?_ ??ih tMTLT*@|L?t
@hi _i?|U@* 6?@**) i Thiti?| @ih@}it uLh |i t@4T*i Lu eS RM} ??ihtc L ? 4Lhi
|@? mffcfff Tih )i@h E4Lhi |@? m2cfffcfff |L|@*c @?_ |t|@|t|Ut uLh |i ?** )TL|itt
|@| |i @ih@}it uLh |i M} ??iht @hi _gihi?| uhL4 |Lti uLh |i Rt4@**< ??iht E??iht
Lu Th3it *itt |@? 2cfffcfff |L|@* ì UL?t_ih |t }hLT tiT@h@|i*) MiU@ti ? tL4i Lu |i
hi}hittL?t Mi*L i i U*_i |i M} ??iht |L ?it|}@|i |i ti?t||) |L |ih Thiti?Ui
? @ih@}i |i ?__@*t ? Lh M@tU t@4T*i L? )i@h*) Th3it Lu m2Scfff A)TU@**)
|i) L? |i? )i@ht @}Lc 4T*)?} |i) @hi L? @ih@}i @*u @) |hL} |ih |i?|) )i@ht Lu
*L||ih) T@)4i?|t ì @t!i_ @** ?__@*t L 4@?) |U!i|t |i) ML}| ? @ |)TU@* ii!
? |i )i@h |i) L? |i *L||ih) iU@ti |ihi ihi tL4i i |hi4i*) *@h}i ?4Miht ET |L
2ff |U!i|t Tih ii!c i |h@?tuLh4i_ |t @h@M*i M) |@!?} |i 4?44 Lu |i ?4Mih
hiTLh|i_ @?_ |i? t i TiU|i_c |i ?4Mih Lu |U!i|t ML}| t UL?t_ih@M*) }ih uLh
??iht Ei Tih ii! uLh |i |h@?tuLh4i_ @h@M*ic ??i Tih ii! uLh |i h@ 4i@thi |@?
uLh *Ltiht E|L Tih ii! @UULh_?} |L ML| |i h@ 4i@thi @?_ |i |h@?tuLh4i_ @h@M*i
? @ih@}i |i ?__@*t ? Lh M@tU t@4T*i @hi Df )i@ht L*_ @| |i |4i Lu ???}c Uc
uLh |i @ih@}i TihtL? @t ? bHS DI Lu |i t@4T*i @t Lih DD )i@ht L*_ @| |@| |4ic
@?_ DI @t Lih SI Lu |i t@4T*i @t 4@*i Ai @ih@}i *ii* Lu tULL*?}c U@*U*@|i_
@t )i@ht Lu } tULL* T*t )i@ht Lu UL**i}i T*t Hc t i^@* |L . SeI U*@4i_ @| *i@t|
L?i )i@h Lu UL**i}i W? Th?UT*i |iti U@h@U|iht|Ut tL*_ ?L| _gih Mi|ii? *Ltiht @?_
??iht OLiihc *Ltiht @hi t}?U@?|*) 4Lhi i_U@|i_ |@? ??ihtc @?_ |i) @hi @*tL
L*_ih At t *!i*) |L hiiU| |i _gihi?Uit Mi|ii? ti@tL? |U!i| L*_iht @?_ t?}*i |U!i|
M)iht L|i |@| |i _gihi?Uit Mi|ii? @** ??iht @?_ |i M} ??iht |i?_ |L Mi t4@**ihc
.
@*|L} |ihi @hi tL4i *@h}i _gihi?Uit ? |i ti h@|L @?_ @}i
ì LMtihi uLh i@U ?__@* ? |i M@tU t@4T*i tLU@* tiUh|) i@h??}t uLh t )i@ht
ThiUii_?} |i |4i Lu ???} |i *L||ih)c uLh |i )i@h |i) L? E)i@h 3ihLc @?_ uLh t
)i@ht uL**L?} ???} ih@}i i@h??}tc ? |ih4t Lu bHS _L**@htc hti Lih |i Thi???}
TihL_ uhL4 mcbf |L mScfc @?_ |i _iU*?i M@U! |L m2bf 6Lh |Lti | TLt|i
tLU@* tiUh|) i@h??}tc @ih@}i i@h??}t hti Lih |t TihL_ uhL4 m2fcHf |L m2ecff
@h|UT@|L? h@|itc @t 4i@thi_ M) TLt|i tLU@* tiUh|) i@h??}tc }h@_@**) _iU*?i Lih
|i |h|ii? )i@htc t|@h|?} @| SbI @?_ hi@U?} @t } @t .I MiuLhi }L?} _L? |L DSI
6}hit @?_ 2 Thiti?| }h@Tt uLh @ih@}i i@h??}t @?_ |i ThLTLh|L? Lu ?__@*t |
TLt|i i@h??}t uLh |i |hii }hLTtc *Ltihtc @** ??iht @?_ M} ??iht ?i U@? tii
@ 4L_it| _iU*?i ? i@h??}t @?_ ThLTLh|L? Lu ?__@*t | TLt|i i@h??}t uLh |i
??ih t@4T*i UL4T@hi_ |L |i *Ltihtc @?_ @ t@hT @?_ 4U *@h}ih _iU*?i uLh M} ??iht
Ai |t|@|t|Ut ? A@M*i 2 |it| |i i^@*|) Lu |i @ih@}it ? |iti }h@Tt
? @ih@}i |i @*i Lu @** U@ht @t mHc2ffc | @? @ih@}i _iM| Lu mcfffc *i@_?}
|L @? @ih@}i ?i| U@h @*i Lu mDc2fff 6Lh Lt?} |i @ih@}i @*i @t mSScffc |
@? @ih@}i 4Lh|}@}i Lu meec2ff L|i |@| |t t @ih@}i_ Lih |i i?|hi t@4T*ic |
3ihLt ?U*_i_ uLh |i .I hitTL?_i?|t L hiTLh|i_ ?L| L??} |ih L4it ?*) 2
hitTL?_i?|t L| Lu |i M@tU t@4T*i Lu ebS __ ?L| hiT*) |L |i Lt?} ît|L?c tL |
t ?*!i*) |@| |i } TihUi?|@}i Lu L4iL?iht t _i |L UL?ut?} ?L| L??} |
?L?hitTL?ti ì @}}hi}@|i_ |i hitTL?tit |L ?@?U@* i@*| ?|L |L U@|i}Lhit Ai
ht| UL?Uih?t hi|hi4i?| |)Ti @UUL?|tc ?U*_?} W+<tc efk T*@?t @?_ L|ih hi|hi4i?|
hi*@|i_ t@?}t Ai tiUL?_ UL?tt|t Lu t|LU!tc ML?_t @?_ 4|@* u?_t @?_ }i?ih@* t@?}te
ì UL?t|hU| @? @__|L?@* @h@M*i @__?} T |i |L t@?}t U@|i}Lhit @t R|L|@* ?@?U@*
i@*|D 6Lh |i *Ltihtc i@*| ? |i @hLt t@?}t @UUL?|t t UL?t_ih@M*) }ih |@?
7 Vhh wkh dsshqgl{ lq Lpehqv/ Uxelq dqg Vdfhugrwh +4<<<, iru wkh txhvwlrqqdluh zlwk wkh h{dfw irupxodwlrq
ri wkh txhvwlrqv1
8 Wr uhgxfh wkh hhfw ri lwhp0qrquhvsrqvh iru wklv odvw yduldeoh/ wrwdo qdqfldo zhdowk/ zh dgghg }hurv wr
doo plvvlqj vdylqjv fdwhjrulhv iru wkrvh shrsoh zkr uhsruwhg srvlwlyh vdylqjv iru dw ohdvw rqh ri wkh fdwhjrulhv1
H
i@*| ? Lt?}c m.Scfff ihtt meecfff Ai _t|hM|L?t Lu |iti ?@?U@* i@*|
@h@M*it @hi ih) t!ii_c | uLh i @4T*i i@*| ? 4|@* u?_t uLh |i ee hitTL?_i?|t
h@?}?} uhL4 3ihL |L m.D 4**L?c | @ 4i@? Lu mDcfffc @ 4i_@? Lu mfcfff @?_ DI
3ihLt
F NAWjV|B, 8iB6jNi" BAa 7VjWuWB|NA
t @ uh@4iLh! uLh @?@*)3?} |i _@|@ uhL4 Lh thi) i ti @ t|@|U 4L_i* uLh *@MLh
tTT*) ihi @? ?__@* @**LU@|it t @@*@M*i |4i |L Lh! @?_ *ithic @?_ |i |L|@*
Lu i@h?i_ @?_ ?i@h?i_ ?UL4i |L @ ?4Mih Lu U@|i}Lhitc ?U*_?} UL?t4T|L? @t i**
@t t@?}t AL hiiU| |i u@U| |@| i _L ?L| @i @}it @?_ ThUitc i ti @? @}4i?|i_
5|L?iBi@h) |*|) u?U|L?c | |i tTiUU@|L?G
L E,c % c c %g ' E, f f
q
\ E%
g
&
&'
& q& c
ihi , t |i @4L?| Lu *ithic @?_ % c c fg @hi |i @4L?|t Lu @hLt UL44L_|itc
?U*_?} t@?}t @t L?i Lu |i UL44L_|itc @?_ |i q& @?_ & @hi |i Thiuihi?Ui T@h@4i|iht
Ai @}i?| t @tt4i_ |L 4@ 43i |t |*|) u?U|L? i@U TihL_ tMiU| |L |i M_}i|
UL?t|h@?|
[R %
, n
g
&
&'
&
' A n u n tc
ihi t |i @}i h@|ic R& |i ThUi Lu UL44L_|) &c A |i 4@ 44 ?4Mih Lu Lht
Lh!i_c @?_ t n u t |L|@* ?i@h?i_ ?UL4ic i^@* |L |i *L||ih) Th3i u T*t L|ih
?i@h?i_ ?UL4i t Ai i Ti?_|hi u?U|L? uLh UL44L_|) & M@ti_ L? |t |*|) u?U|L?
t
.& ' R& %& ' & R& n q&
[R
EA n u n t g
6'
&
&
& c
E
Wkdw lv/ li vrphrqh uhsruwv srvlwlyh vdylqjv lq wkh fdwhjru| _uhwluhphqw dffrxqwv%/ exw glg qrw dqvzhu wkh
txhvwlrq iru pxwxdo ixqgv/ zh lpsxwh d }hur iru pxwxdo ixqgv lq wkh frqvwuxfwlrq ri wrwdo qdqfldo zhdowk1
Iru wkh 795 revhuydwlrqv rq wrwdo qdqfldo zhdowk/ }hurv zhuh lpsxwhg iru 5: lqglylgxdov iru uhwluhphqw
vdylqjv/ iru 63 lqglylgxdov iru pxwxdo ixqgv dqg jhqhudo vdylqjv1 Dv d uhvxow/ wkh dyhudjh ri wkh wzr vdylqjv
fdwhjrulhv grhv qrw dgg xs wr wkh dyhudjh ri wrwdo vdylqjv/ dqg wkh qxpehu ri revhuydwlrqv iru wkh wrwdo
vdylqjv yduldeoh lv odujhu wkdq wkdw iru hdfk ri wkh wzr vdylqjv fdwhjrulhv1
b
@?_ |i *@MLh i@h??}t u?U|L?
+ ' , ' f n qf EA n u n t [R
g
6'
&
&
& E2
h !i) @tt4T|L? t |@|c @| *i@t| UL?_|L?@* L? tL4i ?__@* U@h@U|iht|Utc |i
@4L?| Lu *L||ih) ???}t t ?_iTi?_i?| Lu |i @}itc L|ih ?i@h?i_ ?UL4i @?_ L|ih
_i|ih4?@?|t Lu i Ti?_|hit @?_ *@MLh tTT*) ,i? |L| _hiU| 4i@thit Lu ThUit @?_
@}it i U@? ? |@| U@ti it|4@|i |i q& c |i 4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|it |L UL?t4i
Ai ht| hi}hittL? u?U|L? i it|4@|i t
+| ' k| n qf| t n B| f n 0| c
E
ihi +| t tLU@* tiUh|) i@h??}t uLh ?__@*L ? )i@h | @u|ih ???} |i *L||ih)c
t t |i )i@h*) @4L?| T@_ M) |i *L||ih) Ei^@* |L |i |L|@* *L||ih) Th3i __i_ M)
|i?|)c @?_ f t @ ti| Lu UL?|hL* @h@M*it ì it|4@|i |t hi}hittL? u?U|L? uLh |i
)i@h Lu ???} |i *L||ih) @t i** @t uLh |i t tMtiî?| )i@h E| ' fc c c Sc @?_ uLh
|i @ih@}i Lu |i t TLt|*L||ih) )i@htc
SS
|'
+| *Sc ? tii? _gihi?| tTiUU@|L?t
6ht| i it|4@|i |t i^@|L? |L| @?) UL?|hL* @h@M*it t?} |i i?|hi t@4T*i
Lu ebS LMtih@|L?t 5iUL?_c i it|4@|i |i hi}hittL? u?U|L? L? |i t@4i t@4T*i M|
?U*_?} @ t4@** ti| Lu ?__@* U@h@U|iht|Ut |)TU@* Lu |i |)Ti Lu ?__@* U@h@U|ih
t|Ut L?i 4}| Mi @M*i |L UL?|hL* uLh t?} @ |)TU@* *@h}i thi) _@|@ ti|G @ _44) uLh
4i?c )i@ht Lu i_U@|L?c @ _44) uLh tL4i UL**i}ic @}ic @?_ _44it uLh Mi?} Lih DD @?_
Lih SD W? |i |h_ tTiUU@|L? i tM|h@U| uhL4 |i L|UL4i @h@M*i i@h??}t ? |i *@t|
Thi*L||ih) )i@hG
+c| +c
3

' k| n qf| t n B| f n 0| c
Ee
t|** @**L?} uLh ?__@* _gihi?Uitc U ?L UL*_ @giU| |i }hL| h@|it W? |i uLh|
tTiUU@|L? i i T@?_ |i ti| Lu UL?|hL* @h@M*it |L ?U*_i *@}}i_ i@h??}t @?_ ?_U@|Lht
uLh TLt|i *@}}i_ i@h??}tc uLh @** t Thi*L||ih) )i@htc @t i** @t @? ?_U@|Lh uLh Thi*L||ih)
f
T@h|UT@|L? ? |i *@MLh uLhUic ?4Mih Lu |U!i|t ML}|c @?_ |4i t?Ui ???} Bi?
|@| *@}}i_ i@h??}t @hi ?U*_i_ | t 44@|ih@* i|ih |i L|UL4it @hi _gihi?Ui_ Lh
?L| W? |i u| tTiUU@|L? i ?U*_i @ ^@_h@|U |ih4 ? |i *L||ih) Th3i Oihi i ti_
|i i T@?_i_ ti| Lu UL?|hL* @h@M*it @?_ |i t@4i M@tU t@4T*i Lu ebS LMtih@|L?t W?t|i@_
Lu hiTLh|?} |i it|4@|i Lu |i ^@_h@|U |ih4c i hiTLh| |i _ih@|i Lu |i hitTL?ti
u?U|L? @| |L @*it uLh |i *L||ih) Th3ic ?@4i*) @| 3ihL @?_ @| |i 4i_@? Lu |i )i@h*
Th3ic m2cfff
Ai *@t| |hii tTiUU@|L?t ti |i *@h}i ti| Lu UL?|hL* @h@M*it M| _gih ? |i t@4T*i
ti_ 6ht|c ? |i t | tTiUU@|L? i hit|hU| |i t@4T*i |L ??iht L?*) At i*4?@|it
@?) M@tit |@| 4}| @hti uhL4 _gihi?Uit Mi|ii? ti@tL? |U!i| M)iht @?_ t?}*i |U!i|
M)iht W? |i tii?| tTiUU@|L? i @}@? ?U*_i |i *Ltiht M| ?L ti L?*) ??iht
| )i@h*) Th3it *itt |@? mffcffc |t i U*_?} |i eS M} ??iht iU@ti tL4i Lu
|ih Th3it @hi tL *@h}ic |iti hi*@|i*) ui M} ??iht 4@) i ih| @ _tThLTLh|L?@|i igiU|
L? |i it|4@|it 6?@**) i i U*_i ML| *Ltiht @?_ M} ??ihtc *i@?} t | @ t@4T*i
Lu b ??iht | @ Th3i *itt |@? mffcfff Tih )i@h
Ai tiUL?_ ti| Lu hi}hittL? u?U|L?t i it|4@|i t
.& ' kf n q& A n k f n 0c
ED
ihi .& t |i @4L?| tTi?| ? @hLt U@|i}Lhit Oihi i ti Uhhi?| @*i Lu U@htc ML|
|L|@* @?_ ?i| Lu *L@?tc @?_ Uhhi?| @*i Lu Lt?}c @}@? ML| |L|@* @?_ ?i| Lu 4Lh|}@}it
`i @*tL it|4@|i |t hi}hittL? u?U|L? | Uhhi?| @*it Lu @hLt t@?}t U@|i}Lhit L?
|i *iu|@?_ t_i Ai |hii t@?}t U@|i}Lhit @hi hi|hi4i?| t@?}tc L|ih t@?}tc @?_
|L|@* t@?}t 6Lh @** |iti L|UL4it @** i LMtihi t |i @*i Lu |iti |i4t @| |i |4i
Lu |i thi) +@|ih |@? @||hM|i @ i_ TLh|L? Lu |@| |L UL?t4T|L? ? |@| )i@hc i
ti |i |L|@* @*i L? |i *iu|@?_ t_i @?_ ti |i |L|@* @4L?| Lu |i *L||ih) Th3i T@_
T |L |@| |4i L? |i h}|@?_ t_i EA 5?Ui L? @ih@}i TiLT*i @i Mii? hiUi?}
*L||ih) T@)4i?|t uLh |i? )i@htc |i @4L?| hiUii_ t @hL?_ DfI Lu |i |L|@* Th3i AL

?it|}@|i |i ti?t||) |L |t tTiUU@|L? i @*tL it|4@|i L?i hi}hittL? ihi |i |L|@*
E|i?|))i@h Th3i t |i h}|@?_ t_i @h@M*i `|i |i @4L?| T@_ L| T |L ?L @t
|i i T*@?@|Lh) @h@M*ic |i it|4@|it U@? Mi ?|ihThi|i_ @t |i uh@U|L? Lu |i 4L?i) |i
*L||ih) @t T@_ L| T |L |@| TL?| |@| t @**LU@|i_ |L U@htc Lt?} @?_ t@?}t
Ai |h_ @?_ uLh| ti| Lu hi}hittL?t ULhhitTL?_ |L |i ht| @?_ tiUL?_ ti| M| @**L
uLh ?|ih@U|L?t Lu |i *L||ih) Th3i | t M@U!}hL?_ U@h@U|iht|Ut `i ti tTiUU@|L?
VWWWc M@ti_ L? |i t@4T*i Lu b ??iht | Th3it *itt |@? mffcfff L?*)c @?_ ?U*_i
|i *@h}i ti| Lu UL?|hL*t `i ?|ih@U| |i *L||ih) Th3i | @? ?_U@|Lh uLh TLt|i i@h??}t
? |i )i@h ThLh |L ???} |i *L||ih)c @? ?_U@|Lh uLh 4i?c @? ?_U@|Lh uLh Mi?} Mi|ii?
DD @?_ SD )i@ht L*_ @| |i |4i Lu ???} |i *L||ih)c @? ?_U@|Lh uLh tL4i UL**i}ic @?_
|i ?4Mih Lu )i@ht t?Ui ???} |i *L||ih) ** ?|ih@U|L?t @hi ?U*_i_ ? |i t@4i
hi}hittL?
U -jt,|t
U Bi}AB, iNVjAt|+ |N .BiA N| Nu PAjBiAja YAWN6j
W? A@M*i i Thiti?| |i hit*|t uLh |i 4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|) |L i@h? E4Ti L| Lu
?i@h?i_ ?UL4ic Lh 4?t |i 4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|) |L UL?t4i *ithi t _tUtti_ MiuLhic
|i i T*@?@|Lh) @h@M*i t |i )i@h*) *L||ih) Th3i W? |i ht| hL |i L|UL4i t |i
@ih@}i tLU@* tiUh|) i@h??}t Lih |i t TLt|*L||ih) )i@htc @h}@M*) |i 4Lt| hi*@M*i
4i@thi Lu |i *L?}|ih4 ?UL4i igiU| Ai ht| UL*4? }it |i hit*| | ?L UL?|hL*
@h@M*itc @? it|4@|i Lu ffD | @ t|@?_@h_ ihhLh Lu ffe Ai it|4@|i U@?}it ih)
*||*i i? i ?U*_i |i t4@** Lh *@h}i ti| Lu hi}hittLhtc Lh ht| _gihi?Ui |i i@h??}t
@h@M*i At hLMt|?itt 4@) UL4i @t tL4i@| Lu @ thThti }i? |@| A@M*i 2 tLt |@|
@ih@}i U@h@U|iht|Ut ?U*_?} *@}}i_ i@h??}t _gih UL?t_ih@M*) M) Th3i OLiihc |iti
t}?U@?| _gihi?Ui _L ?L| 4T*) |@| |iti U@h@U|iht|Ut @U|@**) i T*@? 4U Lu |i
@h@|L? ? Th3it Ai -t^@hi_ ? @ hi}hittL? Lu Th3it L? @** ?__@* U@h@U|iht|Ut
@?_ *@}}i_ i@h??}t t L?*) f.c @?_ u |i ?4Mih Lu |U!i|t ML}| t i U*_i_ |i -
2
t^@hi_ _hLTt |L ffH 5?Ui |i ?4Mih Lu |U!i|t ML}| |ti*u t ?L| t}?U@?|*) ULhhi*@|i_
| i@h??}tc | 4@) Mi *itt thTht?} |@| |i UL?|hL* @h@M*it _L ?L| @giU| |i hit*|t ih)
4U iU@ti tL4i Lu |i UL?|hL* @h@M*itc ?L|@M*) *@}}i_ i@h??}tc @hi }*) ULhhi*@|i_
| |i L|UL4i ihic |i t|@?_@h_ ihhLht ? |i tTiUU@|L?t WWW @?_ WV @hi 4U *Lih
|@? |Lti ? |i ht| tTiUU@|L? |L| @?) UL?|hL* @h@M*it
W? |i u| tTiUU@|L? i @__ @ ^@_h@|U |ih4 ? |i Th3i +@|ih |@? hiTLh| |i
ULiUi?| L? |i ^@_h@|U |ih4 i hiTLh| |i _ih@|i Lu |i i TiU|i_ i@h??}t @t @
u?U|L? Lu |i Th3i @| |L @*it Lu |i Th3ic 3ihL @?_ |i 4i_@? Th3i Em2cfff Tih
)i@h Ai it|4@|it Lu |i 4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|) |L i@h? M@ti_ L? |t tTiUU@|L? @hi 4U
*@h}ihc i^@* |L fe EffD @| @ Th3i i^@* |L 3ihLc @?_ ffb. Eff2 @| @ Th3i i^@*
|L m2cfff *|L} |iti it|4@|it @TTi@h ih) U*Ltic |i ^@_h@|U |ih4 t ? u@U| }*)
t}?U@?|c | @ |t|@|t|U i^@* |L eH iU@ti |i _t|hM|L? Lu Th3it t tL t!ii_c
| @ 4i_@? )i@h*) Th3i i^@* |L m2cfff @?_ @ 4@ 44 i^@* |L mDffcfffc |i ui ih)
*@h}i LMtih@|L?t _tThLTLh|L?@**) @giU| |i *?i@h hi}hittL? it|4@|it
Ai ?i | tTiUU@|L? i U*_it |i 2Db *Ltihtc 4Lhi |@? @*u |i t@4T*i At tTiU
U@|L? @L_t TL|i?|@* M@tit uhL4 |i _gihi?Uit Mi|ii? ti@tL? |U!i| L*_iht @?_ t?}*i
|U!i| M)ihtc @?_ |t t|@)t U*Ltih |L |i _i@* i Tih4i?| Ai hit*|t uLh |t tTiUU@
|L? @hi ih) t4*@h |L |Lti uhL4 tTiUU@|L? WV | |i t@4i ti| Lu UL?|hL* @h@M*it
, U*_?} |i M} ??iht E??iht | @ )i@h*) Th3i *@h}ih |@? mffcfff _Lit U@?}i
|i hit*|t UL?t_ih@M*) @?_ }i|t |i4 4U U*Ltih |L |i ^@_h@|U tTiUU@|L?c | @?
it|4@|i uLh |i 4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|) |L i@h? Lu f22 Eff2f 6?@**) i i U*_i ML|
*Ltih @?_ M} ??iht At @}@? *i@_t |L @ 4U *@h}ih it|4@|i |@? |i t4T*i *?i@h
tTiUU@|L? uLh |i i?|hi t@4T*i 6hL4 |i u** ti| Lu it|4@|it | @TTi@ht |@| |i *?i@h
tTiUU@|L? @t |hLM*i ||?} |i hitTL?ti u?U|L? uLh |i M} ??iht At U@? Mi i_
M) i|ih ?U*_?} @ ^@_h@|U |ih4 ? |i Th3ic Lh M) i U*_?} |i M} ??iht ?Ui i
i U*_i |i M} ??iht ?U*_?} @ ^@_h@|U |ih4 ? |i Th3i *i@_t |L @ |t|@|t|U t fSc
t}}it|?} |@| |i *?i@h tTiUU@|L? |t u@h*) i**

Ai ?i | tii? hLt Thiti?| |i hit*|t uLh |i )i@h Lu ???} |i |i t tMtiî?|
)i@ht ì 4@?*) UL?t_ih tTiUU@|L? VWWW 5?Ui i _L ?L| @i ?uLh4@|L? L? _tL? Lu
i@h??}t ? |i )i@h Lu ???} Mi|ii? i@h??}t ThLh |L @?_ @u|ih ???}c L?i 4}| i TiU|
|i 4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|) |L i@h? |L Mi U*Ltih |L 3ihL uLh |t )i@h |@? uLh tMiî?| )i@ht
At t UL?h4i_ M) |i _@|@ | @? it|4@|i_ 4Ti Lu fffe OLiihc ii? _h?} |i
ht| u** )i@h @u|ih ???} |i *L||ih) |i it|4@|i_ 4Ti t 4U *Lih |@? ? tMtiî?|
)i@htc @| ffDS Ef2D W| @TTi@ht |L |@!i ?__@*t tL4i |4i |L @_t| |ih *@MLh tTT*)
|L |i _ithi_ *ii* u|ih |i ht| TLt|*L||ih) )i@h |i 4Ti t|@M*3it @hL?_ ffc | @
|)TU@* t|@?_@h_ ihhLh Lu @hL?_ ff
Ai it|4@|it uLh |i 4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|) |L i@h? Lu @hL?_ ff @hi ?L| L| Lu *?i |
|Lti ? |i *|ih@|hic U t ?L| thTht?} }i? |i _i h@?}i Lu it|4@|it hiTLh|i_
|ihi i?U@i* hiTLh|t L? |h|ii? t|_it t?} ?L?i Tih4i?|@* _@|@ uLh N5 4i?c h@?}?}
uhL4 f.f |L ffH ,t|4@|it M@ti_ L? |i ?i}@|i ?UL4i |@ i Tih4i?|t h@?}i uhL4 f2b
|L ff2 ? t thi) *?_i** @?_ @h_) ?_ it|4@|it h@?}?} uhL4 fbD |L fff2 uLh
4i?c @?_ uhL4 f |L f2. uLh L4i?
W? A@M*i e i Thiti?| |i hit*|t uLh |i 4Ti | ?|ih@U|L?t uLh TLt|i ThLh i@h??}tc
4i?c @}i @| ???} Mi|ii? DD @?_ SDc @}i @| ???} }hi@|ih |@? SDc tL4i UL**i}i @?_
)i@ht t?Ui ???} 6Lh |i .I Lu |i t@4T*i L @i TLt|i i@h??}t ? |i )i@h ThLh
|L ???} |i *L||ih) |i 4Ti M@ti_ L? |i @ih@}i TLt|*L||ih) i@h??}t t f2fb EffHe
*Lih |@?4 uLh |i hi4@?_ih Lu |i t@4T*i L @_ 3ihL i@h??}t 54*@h hit*|t @hi
uL?_ uLh |i tii? TLt|*L||ih) )i@ht tiT@h@|i*) Lhi thTht?}*) i ?_ ?L t}?U@?|
_gihi?Uit Mi|ii? 4i? @?_ L4i? ? |ih4t Lu |i 4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|) |L i@h? L| Lu
?i@h?i_ ?UL4i ** it|4@|it @hi i |hi4i*) U*Lti |L 3ihLc | tL4i ?i}@|i @?_ tL4i
TLt|ic @?_ ?L?i @hi t}?U@?| uLh |i @ih@}i Lu TLt|*L||ih) )i@ht Lh uLh @?) Lu |i TLt|
*L||ih) )i@ht tiT@h@|i*) i? @?_ L4i? _L @i ih) _gihi?| *@MLh 4@h!i| i Tihi?Uitc
| ? |i *@t| Thi*L||ih) )i@h .DI Lu |i 4i? Lh!?}c | @ih@}i i@h??}t uLh |Lti
| TLt|i i@h??}t i^@* |L m2Sc.ffc @?_ SDI Lu |i L4i? Lh!?}c | |ih @ih@}i
e
i@h??}t i^@* |LmDceff Aiti _gihi?Uit _L ?L| *i@_ |L _gihi?| it|4@|it Lu |i 4@h}?@*
ThLTi?t|) |L i@h? ì _L ?_ _gihi?Uit M) @}i ì i Tih4i?|i_ | t| @}i ?|ih@U|i_
| |i Th3ic @?_ | _44it uLh @}i Mi|ii? DD @?_ SD @?_ @}i Lih SD Ai *@||ih
tTiUU@|L? t |i L?i hiTLh|i_ ihi W?__@*t Mi|ii? DD @?_ SD @| |i |4i Lu ???}
|i *L||ih) hi_Ui |ih *@MLh i@h??}t t}?U@?|*) 4Lhi |@? )L?}ih Lh!iht wLL!?}
@| |i @ih@}i TLt|*L||ih) i@h??}tc |ih 4Ti t *Lih M) fS. Eff.f W?__@*t ii?
L*_ihc |@| t L*_ih |@? SD @| |i |4i Lu ???} _L ?L| hi_Ui |ih i@h??}t @t 4U Ai
igiU| Lu |i *L||ih) ???}t M) @}i t}}it|t |@| tL4i ?__@*t hi_Ui |ih *@MLh tTT*)
i@h*ih |@? |i) 4}| L|ihti @i +i}hittL?t t?} L?*) @ t4T*i ?|ih@U|L? Lu @}i
@?_ Th3i _L ?L| tL @?) i_i?Ui Lu @}i _gihi?Uit ? |i 4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|) |L UL?t4ic
TLttM*) 4tt?} |i ?i}@|i igiU| uLh |i 4__*i @}i }hLT O@?} tL4i UL**i}i i_U@|L?
_Lit ?L| @giU| |i 4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|) |L i@h? L| Lu ?i@h?i_ ?UL4ic @?_ ?i|ih _Lit
|i |4?} Lu |i Th3i W? ML| U@tit |i ?|ih@U|L?t @hi t4@** @?_ ?t}?U@?| ? @** tii?
)i@ht @t i** @t ? |i @ih@}i i@h??}t 4i@thi
U4 NAt6V|NA BAa 7BA}t
W? A@M*i D i hiTLh| |i hit*|t uLh i Ti?_|hit L? U@ht @?_ Lt?} @?_ t@?}t +iU@**
|@| ihi |i i T*@?@|Lh) @h@M*i t |i U4*@|i *L||ih) Th3i T |L |i |4i Lu |i
thi) 6Lh U@ht i ?_ |@| |ihi t @ t4@** M| }*) t}?U@?| igiU| Lu *L||ih) Th3i
t *L?} @t |i t@4T*i ?U*_it |i M} ??iht |i 4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|) |L UL?t4i t ih)
ThiUti*) it|4@|i_ |L Mi fffb Efff2c 4i@??} |@| L| Lu |i |L|@* @4L?| L? tL u@h ?
|i |i *L||ih) fbI t tTi?| L? U@ht ELh f.I L? U@h @*it ?i| Lu *L@?tS Wu i i U*_i |i
M} ??iht |i 4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|) |L UL?t4i }Lit T |L @ML| eI Ef.I 6Lh Lt?}
|ihi t @ t4*@h t|Lh) t *L?} @t |i t@4T*i ?U*_it |i M} ??iht |i @*i Lu Lt?} t
t}?U@?|*) @giU|i_ M) |i *L||ih) Th3ic | @ 4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|) |L UL?t4i Lu @hL?_
I EI Wu i i U*_i |i M} ??iht |i igiU| t t|** Lu t4*@h t3ic M| | t ?L *L?}ih
9 Wklv
lv lq idfw qrw wrwdo h{shqglwxuh rq fduv/ dv zh rqo| revhuyh wkh fxuuhqw ydoxh dv uhsruwhg e| wkh
lqglylgxdo1
D
t}?U@?| L|i |@| u i ti Lt?} @*it ?i| Lu 4Lh|}@}itc |i igiU| _t@TTi@ht ? @**
tTiUU@|L?t u|ih ???} |i *L||ih) TiLT*i @TTi@h |L Mi M)?} 4Lhi i Ti?ti Ltitc
M| |i) _L ?@?Ui |i4 |hL} ULhhitTL?_?}*) *@h}ih 4Lh|}@}it
i |c UL?t_ih |i t@?}t L|UL4it 6ht| i *LL! @| |i hi|hi4i?| @UUL?|t Ai
M@tU tTiUU@|L?t t}}it| @ *@h}i @?_ t}?U@?| ?i}@|i igiU| Lu ?i@h?i_ ?UL4i L?
hi|hi4i?| t@?}t OLiihc |t igiU| _t@TTi@ht i?|hi*) u i _hLT |i *Ltiht uhL4 |i
t@4T*i W| @TTi@ht |@| |i *Ltih t@4T*i t@it UL?t_ih@M*) 4Lhi ? hi|hi4i?| @UUL?|t
|@? |i ??iht ,_i?Ui Lu |t U@? @*hi@_) Mi tii? ? |i t44@h) t|@|t|Ut ? A@M*i
2 ihi |i *Ltiht L? @ih@}i @i mb2cfff ? hi|hi4i?| t@?}tc UL4T@hi_ |L mecfff uLh
|i ??iht @h| Lu |t t LMLt*) _i |L |i t )i@h _gihi?Ui ? @ih@}i @}i Mi|ii?
|i |L }hLTt OLiihc |ihi t @*tL @ |hii )i@h @}i }@T Mi|ii? |i M} ??iht @?_
|i L|ih ??ihtc M| |t _Lit ?L| tL T ? @ _gihi?Ui ? @ih@}i hi|hi4i?| t@?}t
@h| Lu |t t@?}t _gihi?|@* 4@) |ihiuLhi Mi hi@*c M| tL4i Lu | 4@) @*tL Mi _i |L
_gihi?Uit ? |i TLT*@|L? Lu ti@tL?|U!i| L*_iht @?_ t?}*i |U!i| M)iht |@| i _L ?L|
@_i^@|i*) UL?|hL* uLh wLL!?} @| L|ih ?@?U@* t@?}t i _L ?_ @ TLt|i hi*@|L? |
?i@h?i_ ?UL4i 6Lh |i t@4i hi@tL? i @hi t!iT|U@* Lu |i hit*|t uLh hi|hi4i?| t@?}t
|@| hi*) L? |i *Ltih t@4T*ic i Thiuih |i it|4@|it M@ti_ L? ??iht L?*) W?U*_?} |i
M} ??iht i ?_ @ 4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|) |L t@i L| Lu ?i@h?i_ ?UL4i Lu ffb Effb
, U*_?} |i M} ??iht |i it|4@|i t 4U }ihc @| fH EffS Bi? UL?Uih?t
@ML| |i hi*@M*|) Lu |i hiTLh|t L? t@?}t uLh |i M}}it| t@ihtc U @hi *!i*) |L @*tL
Mi |i M}}it| ??ihtc i i |i it|4@|it L? |i t@4T*i i U*_?} |i M} ??iht @t
|i 4Lt| hi*@M*i __?} T |i |L t@?}t 4i@thit *i@_t |L t4*@h hit*|tc | Lh
Thiuihhi_ it|4@|i Lu |i 4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|) |L t@i L| Lu ?i@h?i_ ?UL4i M@ti_ L? |i
t@4T*i |L| *Ltiht @?_ M} ??iht i^@* |L DHI EDSI
W? A@M*i S i hiTLh| it|4@|it uLh |i t@4i L|UL4it M@ti_ L? ?|ih@U|?} |i *L||ih)
Th3i | |i t ?__@* M@U!}hL?_ @h@M*it EThLh i@h??}t TLt|ic 4i?c @}i Mi|ii?
DD @?_ SDc @}i Lih SDc UL**i}ic @?_ )i@ht t?Ui ???} O@?} TLt|i ThLh i@h??}t
S
hi_Uit |i igiU| Lu ?i@h?i_ ?UL4i L? U@h @*it W| 4@) Mi |@| ?__@*t | TLt|i
i@h??}t ThLh |L ???} |i *L||ih) ihi *itt UL?t|h@?i_ ? |ih UL?t4T|L? Mi@Lh
i? @TTi@h |L Mi t@?} 4Lhi uhL4 ?i@h?i_ ?UL4ic | |ih 4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|) |L t@i
EL|ih |@? ? hi|hi4i?| @UUL?|t *@h}ih M) HI ES.I Aihi t ?L i_i?Ui |@| L*_ih
TiLT*i t@i *itt L| Lu ?i@h?i_ ?UL4i 6Lh |i DDSD )i@h L*_ }hLT |i it|4@|it @hi
?i}@|i @?_ U*Lti |L t}?U@?|c M| uLh |i L*_ih }hLT |i) @hi ? u@U| TLt|ic @*|L}
u@h uhL4 t}?U@?| O@?} tL4i UL**i}i _Lit ?L| @giU| |i 4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|) |L tTi?_
L? U@ht Lh Lt?}c Lh |i 4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|) |L UL?t4i Ai *L?}ih @}L tL4iL?i @t
L? |i *L||ih)c @?_ |t |i U*Ltih |L |i i?_ Lu |i |i?|) )i@ht Lu *L||ih) T@)4i?|tc |i
*@h}ih |i 4@h}?@* ThLTi?t|) |L t@i At t UL?tt|i?| | tL4i UL?t4T|L? t4LL|?}
ihi *@h}i |i4t @hi ThU@ti_ i@h*) L? _h?} |i TihL_ Lu *L||ih) T@)4i?|tc uL**Li_ M)
@ TihL_ | }ih t@?}t
0 NAW,tNA
.
-jujijAWjt
A}it|e ce BAa lij}jic EbbHc R,4ThU@* 5|h@|i}it ? w@MLh ,UL?L4Utc uLh|
UL4?} ? O@?_MLL! Lu w@MLh ,UL?L4Utc ti?ui*|ih @?_ @h_c i_t
tjAuj,|jie e BAa QjW"6BAc Eb.ec RAi ,t|4@|L? Lu W?UL4i @?_ 5Mt|||L?
,giU|t ? @ L_i* Lu 6@4*) w@MLh 5TT*) ,UL?L4i|hU@c VL* e2c .HD
,Aaj,,e -e BAa C Bia+c E2fffc Rw@MLh 5TT*)c O@?_MLL! Lu w@MLh ,UL?L4Utc
ti?ui*|ih @?_ @h_c i_t
Na"Ae -c EbDbc R`?_u@** W?UL4i @?_ L?t4T|L?c 4ihU@? ,UL?L4U +iic VL*
ebc Sf2Se
QBt6BAe ce BAa $ btjc EbHD RAiU?U@* hLM*i4t ? 5LU@* , Tih4i?|@|L?G Lt|
ihtt ,@ti Lu ?@*)ttc ? O@t4@? @?_ `ti Ei_t 5LU@* , Tih4i?|@|L?c T H.2bc
U@}L N?iht|) hitt
Y6OjAte De $ -OA BAa 7BWjiaN|jc Ebbbc R,t|4@|?} |i ,giU| Lu N?i@h?i_
W?UL4i L? w@MLh ,@h??}tc 5@?}t @?_ L?t4T|L?G ,_i?Ui uhL4 @ 5hi) Lu wL||ih)
*@)ihtc ,+ `Lh!?} @Tih .ff
lBV,BAe
l,,A}tNi|e e BAa c QjW"6BAc EbHSc R6i4@*i w@MLh 5TT*)G 5hi)c ?
ti?ui*|ih @?_ w@)@h_c Ei_tc O@?_MLL! Lu w@MLh ,UL?L4Utc T f2fe
lijAAe c EbSc R`?_u@** W?UL4i @?_ L?t4T|L?__|L?@* ,_i?Ui 4ihU@?
,UL?L4U +iic VL* Dc HHbf
wBAatOji}jie c EbSc R`?_u@** W?UL4i @?_ L?t4T|L?c 4ihU@? ,UL?L4U +i
ic VL* Dc DeDef
w||,je - c e BAa $ -OAc EbH.c 5|@|t|U@* ?@*)tt | tt?} #@|@c `*i)G
i vLh!
Nii,,e bc Eb.ec RW?|hL_U|L?c 5TiU@* Wtti L? i}@|i W?UL4i A@ c aLh?@* Lu
O4@? +itLhUitc VL* bc DSD.
H
,VtNAe Cc Ebb. RMtih@|L?@* }i?U) @?_ 5TT*)5_i ,UL?L4i|hUtc ,+ AiU
?U@* `Lh!?} @Tih 2f
-jjte c Eb.ec R544@h) Lu +it*|t L? i}@|i W?UL4i A@ c aLh?@* Lu O4@? +i
tLhUitc VL* bc DHbf
-OAe $ c Eb..c tt}?4i?| |L @ Ahi@|4i?| BhLT L? |i @tt Lu @ L@h@|ic
aLh?@* Lu ,_U@|L?@* 5|@|t|Utc 2c 2S
7BWjiaN|je c EbbSc RAi wL||ih) `??ih 5hi)c h4i @?_ 5LU@* W?|ih@U|L?tc @?_
`) t |ihi 4Lhi h4i ? |itc # Aittc #iT@h|4i?| Lu ,UL?L4Utc O@h@h_ N?
iht|)
CB,jie -c Ebbfc R5@?}tc 6?}M*|)c @?_ i?|@* UUL?|tc aLh?@* Lu ,UL?L4Ut
ihtTiU|itc VL* ec L c b2fD
b
A@M*i G -jtVNAtj -B|jt O+ B,A}
pdlolqj
Vhqw
zlqqhuv orvhuv
Uhvsrqvhv
zlqqhuv orvhuv
Uhvsrqvh Udwhv
zlqqhuv orvhuv wrwdo
slorw
pdlq
iroorz~xs +'83 fkhfn,
iroorz~xs +'43 fdvk/ '73 fkhfn,
83
:85
57;
7<
83
96:
57;
7<
4:
5:5
6<
44
58
595
73
45
3167
3169
3149
3155
3183
3174
3149
3157
3175
316;
3149
3156
wrwdo
;35
9;:
66<
66<
3175
317<
3179
2b
A@M*i 2G 766Bi+ 7|B|t|Wt BtW 7B6V,j
Yduldeoh
Doo
+Q@7<9,
Orvhuv
Zlqqhuv
Elj Zlqqhuv
+Q@58<,
+Q@56:,
phdq
+v1g1,
phdq
phdq
w0vwdw
phdq
w0vwdw
5917
+831;,
3
8815
^4717`
49313
^5317 `
\hdu Zrq
<1;
+415,
<19
<1<
^613 `
4314
^414 `
Wlfnhwv Erxjkw
616
+51<,
515
719
^4315`
813
^31< `
831548:
+4619;78,
86153;8
791<784
^0815585`
8316589
^41:;73`
31685;
+317:;6,
317657
31598;
^061<643`
316<86
^514698`
3147<5
+316899,
314<64
314346
^051;;74`
3153<6
^519554`
3196
+317; ,
319:
318;
^0514 `
31;7
^61< `
\hduo| Sul}h
Djh
Djh
Djh
A88
A98
Pdoh
+Q@79,
\hduv ri Vfkrrolqj
461:
+515,
4717
4613
^0:1;`
451;
^0319 `
Froohjh
3198
+317;,
31:;
3184
^0919`
3186
^317 `
Zrunlqj Wkhq
31:;
+3174 ,
31::
31;3
^31< `
31;9
^414 `
Hduqlqjv \hdu 09
461;759
+46168;6,
4818939
441<984
^06134;:`
4718:<5
^419457`
Hduqlqjv \hdu 08
4714539
+461:8;3,
481<88:
4514486
^061465;`
4814:87
^41;8<4`
Hduqlqjv \hdu 07
47153;<
+4713886,
4914<8;
45136:7
^0616579`
4913<5<
^5178;;`
Hduqlqjv \hdu 06
471;36:
+471:995,
49194<5
451;4<9
^051;;69`
4:1457;
^517<63`
Hduqlqjv \hdu 05
48194<9
+48159;6,
4:18:;:
4617:;:
^0613448`
491;67:
^41;;96`
Hduqlqjv \hdu 04
4916445
+481:34;,
4:1<<;5
47179:9
^051847<`
4:15884
^417;9;`
Hduqlqjv \hdu 3
4913857
+481:<<<,
4;157<8
4619848
^06159;<`
461::;:
^3139<4`
Hduqlqjv \hdu 4
48173;6
+491548:,
4;17<7<
4513685
^07184::`
<17878
^0417487`
Hduqlqjv \hdu 5
4719;8<
+491678:,
4:19833
4417798
^0715<8;`
;176<7
^04194:7`
Hduqlqjv \hdu 6
4714;47
+4915;88,
4:14739
431<7:7
^071637;`
;1:6:4
^0414<96`
Hduqlqjv \hdu 7
461:<94
+4915974,
491;<37
4317479
^0718487`
:1864;
^04193<:`
Hduqlqjv \hdu 8
461957:
+4916488,
4919837
43164;4
^0716<9;`
:1:<34
^0416<7;`
Hduqlqjv \hdu 9
4615635
+491753<,
481:9;3
431789;
^0619758`
91;396
^041<:47`
Srv Hduqlqjv \hdu 09
319<68
+317948,
319;:6
31:337
^3164:3`
319<::
^0313766`
Srv Hduqlqjv \hdu 08
31:3<:
+317877,
319:<8
31:759
^418799`
319845
^04184:4`
Srv Hduqlqjv \hdu 07
31:44:
+317867,
319<44
31:675
^413898`
31:53<
^0315497`
Srv Hduqlqjv \hdu 06
31:369
+3178:4,
319:8:
31:675
^417585`
31:775
^314968`
Srv Hduqlqjv \hdu 05
31:3::
+317886,
319:8:
31:759
^4196;7`
319<::
^031:75;`
Srv Hduqlqjv \hdu 04
31:46:
+317858,
319<44
31:6;7
^41495:`
319<::
^03199<6`
Srv Hduqlqjv \hdu 3
31:3<:
+317877,
319;:6
31:675
^4147<4`
319<::
^0318<9;`
Srv Hduqlqjv \hdu 4
319:<7
+3179:5,
319:<8
319:<6
^0313383`
317;;7
^06133<4`
Srv Hduqlqjv \hdu 5
319643
+317;63,
31973<
319536
^0317:8;`
3174;9
^06138:;`
Srv Hduqlqjv \hdu 6
31933;
+317<35,
3194:;
318;56
^031;37<`
316<86
^051:;34`
Srv Hduqlqjv \hdu 7
318;5:
+317<69,
319433
31885:
^0415<54`
316589
^0616:96`
Srv Hduqlqjv \hdu 8
318;9:
+317<5<,
318<79
318:;4
^0316:5<`
3167;;
^061765:`
Srv Hduqlqjv \hdu 9
Fdu Ydoxh
318958
+317<99,
318:47
31885:
^03174;6`
316589
^0616:96`
4;15638
+4:1:<48,
491985:
4<1<87<
^51355<`
5<19583
^617;97`
Qhw Fdu Ydoxh
48184<3
+471;85;,
4816653
481:479
^3158<8`
581:536
^713666`
Krxvlqj Ydoxh
49915<;9
+4441884<,
4:71<475
4891;956
^041:;55`
54;144<3
^717694`
Qhw Krxvlqj Ydoxh
4551457:
+<81786;,
47719468
<:18<47
^08176<9`
44515833
^4168;7`
Uhwluhphqw Dffrxqwv
9719973
+4351:;88,
<51957:
67175<3
^0914779`
671893<
^313499`
Rwkhu Ilqdqfldo Dvv1
;716378
+4841<793,
<41:;48
:913<:5
^0413<84`
45:13;38
^5133:6`
Wrwdo Ilqdqfldo Dvv1
466169:6
+4<517<34,
49717874
<<16<7;
^061;443`
4831<3;5
^5137;4`
A@M*i G .t|6B|jt Nu Bi}AB, iNVjAt|+ |N .BiA N| Nu PAjBiAja YAWN6jH vjBi,+
wN||ji+ B+6jA|t Bt -}|BAa 7aj XBiBO,j
Dyh Srvw Orwwhu| Hduq
\hdu 3 Hduq
\hdu 4 Hduq
\hdu 5 Hduq
\hdu 6 Hduq
\hdu 7 Hduq
\hdu 8 Hduq
\hdu 9 Hduq
Lqglylgxdo Frqwurov
Odjjhg Hduqlqjv
Orvhuv
\hduo| Sul}h A433
Txdgudwlf lq Sul}h
Glhuhqfh Rxwfrphv
L
LL
LLL
LY
031384
+31347,
03134<
+31347,
03137;
+31347,
031385
+31347,
031384
+31347,
031389
+31347,
031385
+31347,
031383
+31347,
031385
+31346,
031355
+31346,
03137<
+31347,
031387
+31347,
031386
+31347,
03138:
+31346,
031383
+31346,
03137<
+31346,
03137;
+3133<,
03134:
+31337,
031378
+3133:,
031383
+3133<,
03137;
+31343,
031385
+31343,
031379
+31344,
031378
+31345,
031384
+3133;,
031353
+31337,
031383
+3133:,
031387
+3133<,
031386
+3133<,
031388
+31343,
031383
+31344,
031379
+31344,
Qr
Qr
\hv
\hv
Qr
Qr
\hv
Qr
\hv
\hv
Qr
Qr
\hv
Qr
\hv
\hv
Qr
\hv
\hv
\hv
\hv
\hv
Qr
\hv
Y
031447
+31348,
03136;
+3133;,
031436
+31347,
031447
+31349,
03144;
+3134:,
03145:
+3134<,
03144:
+31353,
031439
+31354,
0313<:
+31345,
031366
+3133:,
0313;<
+31344,
0313<;
+31346,
031433
+31347,
03143:
+31348,
0313<<
+31349,
0313<3
+3134:,
\hv
\hv
\hv
\hv
\hv
\hv
YL
YLL
YLLL
031376
+31343,
031348
+31339,
03136;
+3133<,
031378
+31344,
031376
+31345,
031377
+31345,
031374
+31346,
03137:
+31346,
031455
+31353,
031357
+31343,
0313<7
+3134:,
03144:
+31354,
031467
+31356,
031484
+31357,
03146:
+31359,
031434
+3135:,
031434
+3135<,
31337
+31348,
031389
+31358,
0313<5
+31364,
03144:
+31366,
031466
+31367,
031449
+31369,
0313<7
+3136:,
\hv
\hv
Qr
\hv
Qr
\hv
\hv
\hv
\hv
Qr
Qr
\hv
\hv
\hv
Qr
Qr
Qr
\hv
A@M*i eG .t|6B|jt Nu Bi}AB, iNVjAt|+ |N NAt6j | Nu PAjBiAja YAWN6jH YA|ji
BW|NAt | iNi wBONi Bi"j| Qt|Ni+e 7j!e }je .aWB|NA BAa C6j 7AWj bAAA}
Rxwfrph
Sulru Hduqlqjv
Pdoh
Srvlwlyh
Dyh Srvw Orwwhu| Hduq
\hdu 3 Hduq
\hdu 4 Hduq
\hdu 5 Hduq
\hdu 6 Hduq
\hdu 7 Hduq
\hdu 8 Hduq
\hdu 9 Hduq
?
?@98
88 Djh
A98
Djh
Froohjh
\hduv Vlqfh
Zlqqlqj
03153<
031335
03149:
031334
3136:
031343
+313;7,
+3138:,
+313:3,
+313<3,
+31394,
+31355,
031347
31348
0313<7
031337
03135:
31339
+31378,
+31364,
+3136;,
+3137<,
+31366,
+31345,
03143;
03138:
031537
031378
31376
31334
+313:6,
+31383,
+31394,
+313:<,
+31386,
+3134<,
0314:8
031353
031548
03136<
313;9
031358
+313;;,
+31393,
+313:6,
+313<8,
+31397,
+31357,
031558
3138;
0314:;
31336
31373
031337
+313<:,
+31399,
+313;4,
+31437,
+313:3,
+31359,
03148;
031338
031433
313<<
3133<
031357
+31436,
+313:3,
+313;8,
+31443,
+313:7,
+3135:,
031568
31333
03145:
31365
031334
031335
+3143;,
+313:7,
+313<3,
+31449,
+313:;,
+3135<,
031688
3133<
0314::
03138:
31378
03133<
+31443,
+313:8,
+313<4,
+3144;,
+313:<,
+3135<,
A@M*i DG .t|6B|jt Nu Bi}AB, iNVjAt|+ |N NAt6j N| Nu PAjBiAja YAWN6jH WW
6,B|ja wN||ji+ B+6jA|t Bt -}|BAa 7aj XBiBO,j
L
Ydoxh Fduv
3133;
+31334,
Qhw Ydoxh Fduv
31339
+31334,
Ydoxh Krxvh
3135:
+3133<,
Qhw Ydoxh Krxvh
03133<
+3133;,
Uhwluhphqw Dffrxqwv 031359
+3133<,
Rwkhu Ilqdqfldo Dvv1 31364
+31345,
Wrwdo Ilqdqfldo Dvv1
3133;
+31349,
Lqglylgxdo Frqwurov
Odjjhg Hduqlqjv
Orvhuv
\hduo| Sul}h A433
Txdgudwlf lq Sul}h
Glhuhqfh Rxwfrphv
Qr
Qr
\hv
\hv
Qr
Qr
LL
LLL
LY
3133;
+31334,
31339
+31334,
31367
+3133<,
031335
+3133;,
031348
+3133<,
31374
+31345,
3135:
+31348,
3133;
+31335,
31339
+31334,
31365
+3133<,
031338
+3133;,
031348
+3133;,
3136<
+31346,
3135;
+31349,
3133<
+31336,
31339
+31336,
31345
+3134<,
031358
+31349,
03137:
+3134:,
31398
+3135:,
31356
+31365,
\hv
Qr
\hv
\hv
Qr
Qr
\hv
Qr
\hv
\hv
Qr
\hv
\hv
\hv
\hv
\hv
Qr
\hv
Y
3133<
+31336,
31339
+31336,
31346
+3134;,
031358
+31349,
031379
+3134:,
31397
+31359,
31356
+31364,
3133<
+31335,
3133:
+31335,
31374
+31343,
31343
+3133;,
031336
+31339,
3136<
+3134<,
31375
+3134<,
\hv
\hv
\hv
\hv
\hv
\hv
YL
YLL
31344
+31337,
3133:
+31337,
31344
+31356,
03134<
+31354,
03137<
+31355,
313<7
+31367,
31375
+31373,
31347
+3133:,
31346
+31339,
3136:
+3135:,
31357
+31357,
031335
+3134<,
314;6
+31394,
3148;
+31389,
\hv
\hv
Qr
\hv
Qr
\hv
\hv
\hv
\hv
Qr
Qr
\hv
YLLL
\hv
\hv
Qr
Qr
Qr
\hv
A@M*i SG .t|6B|jt Nu Bi}AB, iNVjAt|+ |N NAt6j | Nu PAjBiAja YAWN6jH YA|ji
BW|NAt | iNi wBONi Bi"j| Qt|Ni+e 7j!e }je .aWB|NA BAa C6j 7AWj bAAA}
Rxwfrph
Sulru Hduqlqjv
Pdoh
Srvlwlyh
Ydoxh Fduv
Qhw Ydoxh Fduv
Ydoxh Krxvh
Qhw Ydoxh Krxvh
Uhwluhphqw Dffrxqwv
Rwkhu Ilqdqfldo Dvv1
Wrwdo Ilqdqfldo Dvv1
?
?@98
88 Djh
A98
Djh
Froohjh
\hduv Vlqfh
Zlqqlqj
031359
031334
31346
031345
03133;
031333
+31345,
+3133;,
+31343,
+31346,
+3133;,
+31336,
031334
31345
031337
31345
031338
31338
+31343,
+3133;,
+3133<,
+31345,
+3133:,
+31336,
313;3
03134;
31335
031345
31339
031346
+31396,
+31377,
+31383,
+313:;,
+3137;,
+3134;,
31357
031349
31366
031394
031338
031334
+3138;,
+31373,
+31378,
+313:4,
+31377,
+31349,
031348
031363
31346
031365
031398
031353
+31397,
+31379,
+31388,
+313;8,
+3137:,
+3134:,
0313;3
314;5
031465
3135;
31338
31438
+313<5,
+3139:,
+313:<,
+31453,
+3139<,
+31359,
03137<
31465
0313<5
0313:3
0313:4
31397
+31443,
+313::,
+313;:,
+31469,
+313;6,
+31363,
Earnings in Thousands of Dollars
4
2
Figure 1: Average Earnings for Losers, Winners and Big Winners
x 10
1.5
1
0.5
0
−6
−4
−2
0
Year Relative to Winning
2
4
6
4
6
Proportion with Positive Earnings
Figure 1: Average Earnings for Losers, Winners and Big Winners
1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
−6
−4
−2
0
Year Relative to Winning
2

Download Report

Estimating the Effect of Unearned Income on Labor Earnings

Paperzz.com

Your Paperzz