The Institute for Transnational Arbitration A Division of The Center for American and International Law Volume 31 Number 2 Second Quarter 2017 ITA-ASIL CONFERENCE ON THIRD PARTY FUNDING INTRODUCING THE NEW YOUNG ITA Amidst the blooming cherry blossoms in Washington, DC, on April 12, 2017, the ITA and ASIL co-hosted the 14th Annual Conference on Third-Party Funding in International Arbitration: Legal & Ethical Considerations. The conference was co-sponsored by ICCA and incorporated the preliminary draft of the ICCA-Queen Mary Task Force Report on Third Party Funding, attracting arbitration practitioners, academics, and third-party funders from around the world for the half-day of events. The conference explored the various legal and ethical considerations for practitioners as parties turn to third-party funding with increasing frequency. The conference was co-chaired by Professor Stavros L. Brekoulakis (Queen Mary University) and Ruth Teitelbaum (Tenor Capital Management Company). Raquel Sloan (White & Case) reports: We are re-launching our under-40-years-old arbitrators group, which is now called Young ITA. This new initiative will focus on expanding the global footprint and profile of the group and on creating new leadership opportunities for young arbitrators. Prof. Rusty Park and Prof. Catherine Rogers What factors should be considered when defining third-party funding? Following an introduction from ITA President Abby Cohen Smutny (White & Case), Professor William (Rusty) Park (R. Gordon Butler Scholar in International Law, Boston University School of Law) delivered the keynote address titled “Third Party Funding: Perception and Reality”. Underscoring the often emotional tone surrounding the (See CONFERENCE on page 2) INSIDE THIS ISSUE… ITA-ASIL Conference............................................... Pages 1-3 Young ITA membership, which is now free to all interested practitioners, academics, and students, grants several benefits, including: • • • • • • • Free membership in ITA as a Young ITA Member (does not include membership on the Advisory Board) Free attendance at Young ITA Talks# programs and the ITA Forum in Dallas Young ITA member discounts at the ITA Workshop, Young ITA Roundtables, and all other ITA programs, publications and online educational products Free subscription to the ITA e-newsletter News & Notes Opportunity to serve in the Young ITA leadership Opportunity to participate in Young ITA online fora Recognition as a Young ITA Member in publications There are also new opportunities for young professionals to join the ITA Advisory Board. ITA Sustaining Member and Supporting Member firms may now designate additional individuals under 40 years old to serve on ITA’s Advisory Board without additional cost and a limited number of additional persons under 40 years old for $300 each. More details, including new leadership opportunities, will be presented during the ITA Annual Meeting and 29th ITA Workshop in Dallas, June 14-16, 2017. We are excited about these new opportunities and we hope you are too. Join us! We look forward to seeing you in Dallas and at future Young ITA Talks# events. (Montserrat Manzano, Young ITA Chair, Silvia Marchili, Young ITA Vice Chair). Introducing the new Young ITA.................................. Page 1 Young ITA Talks #London..................................... Pages 3-4 Experts in the News.................................................Pages 5-7 ITA-Latin American Arbitration Forum......................Page 7 YOUNG ITA Talks #Miami.......................................... Pages 8 Conferences and Events in 2017............................... Page 9 Scoreboard of Treaty Adherence.................... Pages 10-13 ITA Community...................................................... Pages 14-16 Montserrat Manzano Silvia Marchili (CONFERENCE, cont’d from page 1) debate on the appropriate role of third-party funding in international arbitration, Prof. Park suggested that any attempt to define TPF should consider the four following themes: • Purpose: what purpose does defining TPF aim to serve? If guidelines are established, to whom should they be applicable? INSTITUTE FOR TRANSNATIONAL ARBITRATION Officers and Executive Committee of the Advisory Board 2016-2017 Abby Cohen Smutny............................................................................................................................ Chair Prof. Susan Franck....................................................................................... Chair – Academic Council Joseph E. Neuhaus.................................................................................................. Vice Chair –Finance José I. Astigarraga....................................................................................................................... Vice Chair Prof. Charles H. Brower, II..........................Vice Chair and Chair, Strategic Planning Committee Alan R. Crain.................................................................................................................................. Vice Chair Dietmar Prager............................................................................................................................. Vice Chair Eduardo Zuleta............................................................................................................................. Vice Chair Prof. Jack J. Coe, Jr........................................................................................................ Member at Large Dominique Brown-Berset............................................................................................. Member at Large Jennifer M. Smith............................................................................................................ Member at Large R. Doak Bishop..............................................................................................................................Past Chair The Hon. Charles N. Brower.....................................................................................................Past Chair Prof. David D. Caron....................................................................................................................Past Chair Donald Francis Donovan............................................................................................................Past Chair Ewell E. Murphy, Jr........................................................................................................................Past Chair Prof. Lucy F. Reed.........................................................................................................................Past Chair Jeswald W. Salacuse...................................................................................................................Past Chair Prof. Chiara Giorgetti..............................................................................Vice Chair, Academic Council Prof. Jarrod Wong....................................................................................Vice Chair, Academic Council Wade M. Coriell........................................................................................................Editor, News & Notes Prof. Roger P. Alford................ General Editor, ITA BoR/ITA Arb. Report/KluwerArbitration.com Elina Mereminskaya......Co-Managing Editor, ITA BoR/ITA Arb. Report/KluwerArbitration.com Monique Sasson............Co-Managing Editor, ITA BoR/ITA Arb. Report/KluwerArbitration.com R. Doak Bishop................................Co-Editor-in-Chief, World Arbitration and Mediation Review Prof. Andrea K. Bjorklund.............Co-Editor-in-Chief, World Arbitration and Mediation Review Dietmar W. Prager..........................Co-Editor-in-Chief, World Arbitration and Mediation Review Rafael T. Boza.....................................Managing Editor, World Arbitration and Mediation Review Andrés Jana....................................................................................................... Chair, Americas Initiative Montserrat Manzano........................................................................Chair, Young Arbitrators Initiative Tomasz J. Sikora........................................................................... Chair, Communications Committee James L. Loftis.................................................................................Co-Chair, Membership Committee Allan B. Moore.................................................................................Co-Chair, Membership Committee Laura M. Robertson........................................................................Co-Chair, Membership Committee Audley Sheppard................................................................................. Co-Chair, Programs Committee Laurence Shore.................................................................................... Co-Chair, Programs Committee Prof. Charles H. Brower, II .......................................................Chair, Strategic Planning Committee Epaminontas (Nontas) Triantafilou ...................................................... Chair, UNCITRAL Task Force Caline Mouawad.......................................................................................2017 ITA Workshop Co-Chair Jeremy K. Sharpe.....................................................................................2017 ITA Workshop Co-Chair Prof. Jarrod Wong.....................................................................................2017 ITA Workshop Co-Chair Michael J. Marchand...........................................................................................................CAIL President David B. Winn.............................................................................................................................ITA Director • Transparency and legitimacy: at what point should the existence of a third-party funder be introduced for the sake of transparency, and could the failure to disclose the existence of a TPF undermine the legitimacy of the arbitral process? • Privilege: how does the introduction of a thirdparty funder impact attorney/client privilege, and at what point can privilege be waived when information is shared with a TPF? • Costs: to what extent should the existence of a TPF be taken into account when allocating parties’ costs in the “loser pays” environment of international arbitration? Should the definition of third party funding be broad or narrow? In a world in which an increasingly sophisticated market continues to evolve to provide funding to parties involved in international arbitration disputes, the exact definition of TPF remains elusive. The second panel discussion, titled “Defining ‘Third Party Funding,’” included an introduction to the key findings of the ICCA-Queen Mary Task Force’s Report on Third Party Funding and commentary from panelists Ruth Teitelbaum (Tenor Capital Management Company, L.P.), Erika Levin (The Judge Americas LLC), Steve Jones (Arthur J. Gallagher), and Professor Victoria Sahani (Washington & Lee University, School of Law). Ruth Teitelbaum, Erika S. Levin, Steve Jones and Prof. Victoria Sahani The panelists – while coming from various backgrounds as arbitration practitioners, academics, and third-party funders – agreed that what makes defining TPF such a challenging task is that it depends on how broadly or narrowly one defines the term. • Is the broad definition too broad? TPF broadly encompasses instances where a non-party to the dispute enters into an agreement with a party to the arbitration (including the party’s affiliate or law firm) to provide material support or financing for the cost of the arbitration proceedings, either as a donation/grant or in exchange for remuneration dependent on the outcome of the dispute. • What forms of third-party funding should be included in the definition? The panelists identified the following sources of TPF: insurance companies (including classical before and after-the-event insurance); law firms (e.g., when operating on a contingency-fee basis); financial institutions such as private equity firms or venture capital funds; sources of crowd-funding (raising capital to fund litigation, typically for philanthropic purposes); patent monetization entities; and recourse financing. News & Notes is a quarterly publication of ITA. Subscriptions are free to members and $30 for non-members. NEWS & NOTES EDITORIAL BOARD Editor...............................................................................................................Wade Coriell King & Spalding LLP, Singapore, Singapore Associate Editor...........................................................................................Hansel Pham White & Case LLP, Washington, D.C. Americas Initiative Liaison............................................................ Elina Mereminskaya Bofill Mir & Álvarez Jana, Santiago, Chile Young Arbitrators Initiative Liaison............................................................. Tomas Vail White & Case LLP, London, UK Correspondence regarding News & Notes should be addressed to Editor Wade Coriell, King & Spalding LLP, 9 Raffles Place #31-01, Republic Plaza, Singapore, 048619, Singapore; [email protected]. Correspondence regarding ITA should be addressed to ITA Director David Winn at The Center for American and International Law, 5201 Democracy Drive, Plano, Texas 75024; [email protected]. Page 2 (See CONFERENCE on page 3) (CONFERENCE, cont’d from page 2) What are the various ethical questions raised by third-party funding in international arbitration? • What should states consider in defining their approaches to regulating TPF? Kim Rooney (Chair of the Hong Kong Law Reform Commission’s Subcommittee on Third-Party Funding for Arbitration), concluded with a discussion of the Commission’s choices in adopting a new “light touch” regulatory regime, in which the common law doctrines of maintenance and champerty have been abolished and the Commission will monitor the conduct of third-party funding for three years in order to make further recommendations. • Is ensuring some form of limited disclosure the solution? Though the panel addressed a wide range of issues, it was in agreement that – particularly in the investment treaty context – some form of limited disclosure and regulation of funding arrangements is necessary to ensure the interests of all stakeholders. During the third panel titled “Legal-Ethical Concerns and Regulation of Third-Party Funding” moderated by Prof. Brekoulakis (Queen Mary University), the panelists addressed the following questions: • Is limited disclosure the solution, and if so, how much disclosure is enough? The Subcommittee underlined the importance of limited disclosures – namely, the existence and identity of funders – for the proper conduct of proceedings. • Should policy-makers regulate TPF to ensure its consistency with investment treaties? Lise Johnson (Columbia Center on Sustainable Investment), proposed that policymakers should regulate TPF for its consistency with the object and purpose of investment treaties – namely, to advance sustainable development – explaining that TPF can impact the relationships between investors and host States by influencing the incentives of claimants, funders, and governments. • What impact, if any, do funding arrangements have on the proceedings TPF? Jeffrey Commission (Vannin Capital) provided an insider’s perspective on TPF, explaining how funding arrangements may affect the conduct of arbitrators, funded parties, and attorneys representing funded parties. In her closing remarks, Professor Susan D. Franck (American University, Washington College of Law) noted the inherent challenges to adopting a transnational, “one size fits all” definition of TPF. While practitioners and academics alike will surely continue to debate the many questions raised during the ITA-ASIL Conference, the draft report of the ICCA-Queen Mary Report on Third Party Funding served as the catalyst for important discussions on the topic. The Task Force will be revising the draft report and is expected to post a version for formal public comment this coming July. YOUNG ITA #LONDON Young ITA, in partnership with ArbitralWomen and Vinson & Elkins, presented Young ITA Talks # London on May 9, 2017 at Vinson & Elkin’s offices. This was Young ITA’s third program in its quarterly Young ITA Talks # series, following programs in Miami and Washington D.C., and its first in collaboration with ArbitralWomen and Vinson & Elkins. The event opened with introductions from ArbitralWomen by Louise Woods, (ArbitralWomen Board Member, V&E London) and a welcome and introduction of ITA YAI by Robert Landicho (Communications Liaison Young ITA). The first item for discussion, ‘Due Process in International Arbitration: Use or Abuse?’ was considered in a debate format, with two panellist submissions each advocating an alternative perspective on the issue, followed by questions and thoughts from the audience. The second item took the form of a panellist conversation, exploring the topic of ‘Damages in International Arbitration: Getting the Most Out of Your Expert’, again, with discussion from the floor concluding this section. Tomas Vail Tomas Vail and Cecily Higham (White & Case, London) report. Due Process in International Arbitration: Use or Abuse? The first session was introduced and moderated by Angeline Welsh of Matrix Chambers. Robert Landicho kicked off the debate with the contention that counsel have increasingly reached for frivolous procedural challenges based on due process, in order to manufacture appeal opportunities, with the net result of: a) threatening the arbitrator’s ability to manage proceedings (causing delay and additional costs); and b) undermining the finality of the award. In combating this behaviour, Landicho emphasised that arbitrators should be especially careful to distinguish decisions pertinent to issues of due process from those which are not. He also noted the important role to be played by national courts in ensuring that parties do not benefit from the use of such aggressive practices. Landicho’s concerns converged on the absence of a uniform moral Angeline Welsh, Robert Landicho and Jonathan Fernandes practice or code which would disincentivise such challenges. Without threat of ramifications, this kind of abuse is only set to continue. Jonathan Fernandes (Three Crowns, London) discounted the perception of counsel abusively capitalising on due process as ‘paranoia’. He coloured criticisms under this banner as hyperbole, and as having become fashionable arising from the Queen MaryWhite & Case 2015 International Arbitration Survey. Against this trend, Fernandes argued that even if a real problem of abuse existed, this would not justify dislodging the (conventional) primacy that needs to be afforded to hearing due process questions, over concerns as to efficiency; hasty arbitrations that skim over due process questions will undermine the enforceability of awards, which is the central mission of arbitration. Contrary to Landicho’s suggestion, a uniform set of rules governing the ethics of practitioners would, rather than deter, encourage more procedural challenges. Audience contributions began with a discussion regarding the ability of the courts to shut down vexatious set aside applications and (See LONDON on page 4) Page 3 (LONDON, cont’d from page 3) whether courts were sufficiently well-versed in arbitration and the proper powers of the tribunal. A subsequent point was raised that the issue may be seat-dependent: in a London-seated arbitration, for instance, one could rely on the courts to dismiss abusive challenges swiftly, whereas arbitral seats in other countries often present more expansive grounds for challenges on enforcement. The concern in London might be, conversely, that busy arbitrators may need reminding to stay live to the issue of due process. One way of dissuading spurious challenges could be to incorporate cost consequences into the institutional rules. Ultimately, arbitrators should adopt a both cautious and confident approach. Damages in International Arbitration: Getting the Most Out of Your Expert The second session was chaired by independent arbitrator, Juliet Blanch, who introduced the topic and the panellists, Clara Segurola of Nera Economic Consulting and Liz Perks of Haberman Ilet. Juliet Blanch, Liz Perks and Clara Segurola Segurola presented first, opening with the proposition: “lawyers are from Venus and experts are from Mars”; i.e. that lawyers need to understand their differences from, in order to get the most out of, their experts. Segurola’s presentation gave practical advice as to how lawyers can work most successfully with an expert at given phases of an arbitration. In terms of when an expert should be engaged, for Segurola, expert involvement as early as possible would aid the framing of arguments as well as identify strengths and weaknesses Page 4 in a particular case. When preparing submissions, lawyers should ensure they understand even the most technical expert points – if they are unable to understand fully, it is less likely that the Tribunal will do so. Segurola also emphasised the need to keep the expert focussed on the key points of the case, rather than allowing them to drift into territory outside the scope of their expertise. Further, lawyers should ask experts to review their memorials to ensure they have interpreted the expert opinion correctly. At the hearing stage, lawyers should take advantage of the experience of their own expert to help anticipate the opposing expert’s likely answers on cross-examination. Liz Perks highlighted the need to avoid a ‘two- ships-passing- in-thenight’ situation, where expert reports offer no reference point for comparison or agreement. Such circumstances expose the parties to uncertainty as a tribunal may either appoint its own expert or, even, embark on its own determination on the relevant matter, instead of siding with either expert. Drawing on her own experience, Perks stressed the need for an expert to address every aspect of their opposite number’s report, so as to minimise the risk of a tribunal having to defer to uncontested evidence (say, on quantum) if it finds in favour of the other side’s substantive arguments. Perks noted the merits of joint statements and, in particular, called upon lawyers to encourage their experts to agree on a model, if possible, setting out different outcomes. This would secure a greater degree of certainty as to the possible range of values a tribunal might come down on in rendering its award. Segurola agreed, citing her own experience of adopting this approach. Discussion opened up to the floor once again. The question was raised as to how often disagreement between experts arises out of genuine professional difference rather than by virtue of the mere fact of their instruction by one particular party. Panellists agreed that this would depend on the country – ‘party-advocates’ are more commonplace in some jurisdictions than others. Blanch observed that, from a tribunal’s perspective, an expert who is unwilling to budge tends to be less credible. Recalling the topic of the first session, the discussion concluded by considering aspects of due process in the expert context, such as the appropriate level of influence lawyers should have in shaping expert reports and whether a tribunal could make an order as to non-disclosure of communications between parties and experts. TRANSNATIONAL ARBITRATION EXPERTS… IN THE NEWS Sustaining Member Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer US LLP has added Brian King (New York) as a representative to the Advisory Board. Arbitral Institutions Member Arbitration Centre of the American Chamber of Commerce of Brazil (AmCham Brasil) has added Carolina Da Rocha Morandi (São Paulo) as a representative to the Advisory Board. Brian King Nicole Duarte Carolina Da Rocha Morandi Joshua Norris Gary Russo Krystal Scott New Supporting Member Jones Walker LLP has added Nicole Duarte (Houston), Joshua Norris (Houston), Gary Russo (Lafayette), Krystal Scott (Houston) as representatives to the Advisory Board. New Supporting Member The Claro Group, LLC has added Meredith Alfred (Houston) and Karl Killian (Houston) as representatives to the Advisory Board. Karl Killian Supporting Member Mayer Brown LLP has added Soledad G. O’Donnell (Houston) as a representative to the Advisory Board. Soledad G. O’Donnell Supporting Member Covington & Burling LLP has added Mary T. Hernandez (Washington, DC) as a representative to the Advisory Board. Mary T. Hernandez Dr. Crina Baltag ITAFOR Contributor Dr. Crina Baltag is set to join the University of Bedfordshire as a Senior Lecturer in Dispute Resolution in June 2017. She also recently served as editor for the book “ICSID Convention After 50 Years: Unsettled Issues,” published by Wolters Kluwer. ITA Advisory Board Member Philip L. Bruner, Director of JAMS Global Engineering and Construction Group and a construction arbitrator and mediator for JAMS and JAMS International, spoke in April on dispute resolution issues to the Annual Meeting of Britain’s Society of Construction Arbitrators in Alnwick, England. In May, he will present three days Philip L. Bruner of lectures on international construction arbitration to the University of Stuttgart’s Master’s Program on International Construction Practice and Law in Stuttgart, Germany. Mr. Bruner is co-author with Patrick J. O’Connor, Jr. of the twelve volume American treatise, Bruner & O’Connor on Construction Law (2002, updated annually). Young ITA Member Herman Duarte was recently ranked by Chambers and Partners, Global Guide 2017, as a foreign expert in Costa Rica with a focus on Complex Litigation and Arbitration practice. He was also selected by the Alumni of the ICAL Program of Stockholm University to receive the Herman Duarte “Outstanding Alumni” recognition in 2017, the first and only Latin American awarded. The private initiative “El Pais Que Viene” selected Duarte as one of the 60 most influential Salvadorans in the world under 35 years old. Advisory Board Member Wayne I. Fagan served as moderator of a panel of General Counsel from the energy sector at the 29th Annual International Law Institute held in Houston in February 2017. Paulo Flores Michelle Meriam David E. Sharp Philip R. Weems Wayne I. Fagan New Associate Members are Paulo Flores (Peckar & Abramson, P.C., Dallas), Paul J. McMahon, Esq. (Paul Joseph McMahon, P.A., Miami), Michelle Meriam (Ware, Jackson, Lee, O’Neill, Smith & Barrow, LLP, Houston), David E. Sharp (Law Offices of David E. Sharp P.L.L.C., Houston), and Philip R. Weems (International Energy Arbitrator, Katy). New Academic/Government/Nonprofit Member is Shola Oshodi-John (Nigerian Institute of Chartered Arbitrators, Lagos). (See EXPERTS on page 6) Shola Oshodi-John Page 5 (EXPERTS, cont’d from page 5) Advisory Board Member Mary T. Hernandez published the article “Windstream v. Canada: How Regulatory Winds of Change Affected a Clean Energy Project” alongside Miguel Lopez Forastier in Covington & Burling LLP’s Inside Energy & Environment. Mary T. Hernandez Advisory Board Member and ITAFOR Moderator Clifford Hendel was named as one of five practicing lawyers to the Executive Council of the European Advisory Board of The International Institute for Conflict Prevention and Resolution (CPR). He also recently published a chapter entitled “The Energy Charter Treaty and Clifford Hendel the Spanish Renewable Energy Awards” in the 2016 Investment Treaty Arbitration Review and an article entitled “Jurisdiction of the CAS” in a special issue ABA Section of International Law publication titled “CAS and Lex Sportive.” In addition, he was re-appointed as Moderator of ITAFOR. Young ITA Member Markian Malskyy, a partner at the Ukrainian law firm Arzinger, was recently empaneled with the International Commercial Arbitration Court at the Ukrainian Chamber of Commerce and Industry as a recommended Arbitrator and was more recently empaneled with Chisinau International Court of Commercial Markian Malskyy Arbitration. Jeswald W. Salacuse ITA Academic Council Member Victoria Shannon Sahani has joined Arizona State University’s Sandra Day O’Connor College of Law in Phoenix, Arizona as a tenured Associate Professor of Law. She will be teaching international arbitration, alternative dispute resolution, civil procedure, and Victoris Shannon professional responsibility. Sahani ITA Advisory Board Member David E. Sharp, a Fellow in the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators and a member of the London Court of International Arbitration, has announced his intention to shift his practice towards serving as an arbitrator. He is a Fellow in the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators, a member of the London Court of International Arbitration. Young ITA Member Alexander Marcopoulos was promoted to ‘Counsel’ at Shearman & Sterling LLP, effective January 1, 2017. Yaroslav Petrov Alexanader ITA’s Reporter for Ukraine Yaroslav Petrov was included Marcopoulosav in the list of recognized experts in Arbitration in Ukraine by Who’s Who Legal 2016 and included in the list of Arbitrators of the Lithuanian Arbitration Court. Advisory Board Member and ITA’s Reporter for Ireland Klaus Reichert SC of Brick Court Chambers has been elected as the first non-American, based in Europe, to the Fellowship of the College of Commercial Arbitrators. Established in the U.S. in 2001, the College promotes excellence in the field of international commercial arbitration. Klaus Reichert SC Election to Fellowship is by invitation only and the members of the College comprise the leading commercial arbitrators in the U.S. WAMR Associate Managing Editor Charles (Chip) B. Rosenberg was named a “Rising Star – Alternative Dispute Resolution” by DC Super Lawyers. Charles B. Rosenberg Page 6 Tufts University has named Jeswald W. Salacuse, former Chair of the ITA Advisory Board and Advisory Board Member at Large, a “Distinguished Professor,” one of only ten in the university. He has also been elected President of its all-university Faculty Senate. In July, Palgrave Macmillan will publish Salacuse’s new book “Real Leaders Negotiate! -- Gaining, Using, and Keeping the Power to Lead Through Negotiation.” Ewelina Wetrys David E. Sharp ITA’s Reporter for Poland Ewelina Wetrys, Associate in the Warsaw office of K&L Gates, has recently published the article “Applying the Concept of Rei Iudicatea to Domestic Arbitration Awards under Polish Law” (Arbitration Bulletin Young Arbitration, 2016 No. 24). She continues to represent corporate clients in international and domestic oil & gas, energy and construction disputes in arbitration and state courts. Stephan Wilske, ITA’s Reporter for Turkey, coauthored the following articles: “Arbitrator (Issue) Challenge: What’s the Real Issue?” in: Andreas Kulick (ed.) Reassertion of Control over the Investment Treaty Regime (Cambridge 2017); “The Effect of BREXIT on London as a Hub for International Disputes – From a Non-Local’s Perspective”, Corporate Disputes Magazine Stephan Wilske Jan-Mar 2017. In addition, he delivered a speech (together with Lars Markert) on “BREXIT, Trump and Other Political Earthquakes – Any Effects on Asian Business and Business Dispute Resolution?“ on the occasion of the 21st SIDRC Lecture Series on February 22, 2017 at the Center in Seoul. This lecture was nominated for “Best Speech or Lecture by Global Arbitration Review 2017.” He was also a speaker at the International Conference on International Arbitration on the occasion of the 25th Anniversary of the International Commercial Arbitration Court (ICAC) at the Ukrainian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (UCCI) where he delivered a speech on “An Arbitral Tribunal’s Rights and Duties to Fight Guerrilla Tactics in Order to Preserve the Integrity of Arbitral Proceedings” in Kyiv, Ukraine. (See EXPERTS on page 7) (EXPERTS cont’d from page 6) ITA’s Reporter for Egypt Dr. Karim A. Youssef was ranked in Who’s Who Legal – Arbitration, Egypt 2017, and he was ranked Band 1 in the Chambers Global Guide 2017, Egypt – Arbitration. Dr. Youssef was appointed to the ICCA-ASIL Task Force on Damages. In addition, his article titled “The Impact of the Arab Spring on International Dr. Karim Youssef Commercial and Treaty Arbitration in Egypt and the MENA Region” was published in Arbitration: The International Journal of Arbitration, Mediation and Dispute Management (83.1), which was published in honor of Ibrahim Shihata. Advisory Board Member Rodrigo Zamora E., formerly of Bufete Zamora Pierce, has moved to Galicia Abogados in Mexico City to open its commercial litigation and arbitration practice. Rodrigo Zamora E. ITA-LATIN AMERICAN ARBITRATION FORUM 2017 ANNOUNCEMENTS ITAFOR is a primarily Spanish-Portuguese language listserv designed to facilitate information sharing and discussion on arbitration and ADR topics pertinent to Latin America. Over 500 leading arbitration practitioners subscribe to ITAFOR. Subscriptions are free and open to all who wish to know or discuss the current developments, evolving issues, and key practitioners in this growing field of Latin American practice. ITAFOR subscribers are welcome to send messages in English as well. Since its creation in 2014, ITAFOR has provided a useful virtual space for Latin American practitioners to receive updates on local developments, discuss global arbitration-related news, and establish new professional relationships. In 2017, the growing maturity of the Latin American arbitration community and the additional inputs from new Moderators, Contributors, and Council members are expected to strengthen the exchange on ITAFOR. This year, the original moderators, active since 2014 (Fernando Cantuarias, Law School of Universidad Del Pacífico, Lima, Perú, Francisco González de Cossío, González de Cossío Abogados, S.C., Mexico, D.F., Mexico, Clifford J. Hendel, Araoz & Rueda Abogados, Madrid, Spain and Elsa Ortega, Ortega & Gómez Ruano, S.C., Mexico, D.F., Mexico), were joined by Elina Mereminskaya, Wagemann & Asociados, Santiago, Chile, and Giovanni Ettore Nanni, Nanni Advogados, São Paulo, Brazil. University of Chile. Elina worked at the Secretariat of the Arbitration and Mediation Center of the Santiago Chamber of Commerce (CAM Santiago) and at the Chilean law firm Bofill Mir & Alvarez Jana. Since 2012, Elina has worked as one of the Managing Editors of the ITA Reports for KluwerArbitration.com. She has recently joined Wagemann y Asociados – Lawyers and Engineers, a Chilean boutique firm specialized in Construction Law. She is a member of the arbitration roster forthe CAM Santiago and forthe Arbitration Center of the Lima Chamber of Commerce. Giovanni Ettore Nanni graduated from the Law School of the Pontifícia Universidade Católica of São Paulo (PUC-SP). He holds LL.M. and Ph.D. degrees from the same University, where he now teaches as Professor of Civil Law. From 2002 until 2016, he was partner at the law firm TozziniFreire in São Paulo, before setting up his own firm Nanni Advogados. Giovanni Giovanni Ettore has over two decades of experience in complex Nanni national and international disputes in various topics and industries. He acts as lawyer, expert and arbitrator in complex disputes, and is part of the arbitrator rosters for the main Brazilian arbitral institutions. Giovanni is also editor-in-chief of the Revista de Arbitragem e Mediação, published by Editora Revista dos Tribunais (Thomson Reuters) and Vice-President of the Brazilian Arbitration Committee CBAr. Elina Mereminskaya studied law in her country of origin, Russia. She later received LL.M. and Ph.D. degrees from the Georg-August University of Göttingen, Germany. Since 2003, she has taught conflict of laws and international arbitration at the Elina Mereminskaya Page 7 YOUNG ITA TALKS #MIAMI - CONQUERING NEW GROUNDS: THE FINANCE AND BANKING INDUSTRY Montserrat Manzano, Young ITA Chair, Von Wobeser y Sierra, S.C., Mexico City, reports: that arise. The panellists M. Cristina Cárdenas (Astigarraga Davis), Sergio Alvarez-Mena (Jones Day, Vice-Chair of Florida International Bankers Association) and Leyla Tavarez (Wells Fargo) each shared their perspectives on industry perceptions of the national court system vs. arbitration and the advantages that arbitration presents for the industry. On 24 February 2017, Young ITA presented the second in its new programs series – Young ITA Talks #Miami – in the White & Case offices located in Miami´s Southeast Financial Center. Advice and practical insights As Young ITA Chair, I welcomed participants, thanked our sponsors White & Case LLP (W&C), Miami International Arbitration Society (MIAS), and Future of Arbitration Miami (FAM), and took the opportunity to thank Samanta Fernandez Micone (W&C) for working jointly with Young ITA in the organization of this event. The topic raised considerable interest and the event met its aim to provide young arbitration stakeholders with a legal and market-oriented perspective on the challenges posed by the development of arbitration in the finance and banking industry, focusing in particular on the role of the region. Raoul Cantero (W&C, former Florida Supreme Court Justice), Manuel A. Gomez (Associate Dean of International and Graduate Studies, Florida International University College of Law, Miami), and Juan Pablo Moyano Garcia (ICDR International Case Director) enriched the discussion by offering the perspective of different arbitration players. The speakers shared their insights on what arbitration stakeholders may do to “conquer” the finance/banking industry and develop a successful arbitration practice in the region. The first item for discussion, ‘Finance and banking industry as “untapped” territory for arbitration, was moderated by Lauran San Roman Guijarro (W&C). The second item took the form of a panellist conversation, exploring the topic of ‘Advice and practical insights’, moderated by Katherine Sanoja (GST LLP). Discussion from the floor concluded each session. The panels were followed by a generous brunch with a spectacular view! Finance and banking industry as “untapped” territory for arbitration Diana Droulers (Arbitrator, Latin America Advisor for Dispute Resolution Data, and President of the International Federation of Commercial Arbitration Institutions (IFCAI)) opened the session by presenting case statistics and an overview of the industry and the types of disputes Page 8 The next Young ITA # programs will be in Mexico City on September 21 (with host Covington & Burling and co-sponsor Barra Mexicana de Abogados) and in Houston on October 5 (with host Hogan Lovells and co-sponsor Houston International Arbitration Club). If you would like to propose a Young ITA # event in your city, please contact Young ITA Chair Montserrat Manzano ([email protected]) or ChairElect Silvia Marchili ([email protected]). Upcoming ITA Programs in 2017-2018 29th ITA Workshop and Annual Meeting June 14-16, 2017 Dallas Young ITA Talks #Mexico City September 21, 2017 Mexico City Young ITA Talks #Houston October 5, 2017 Houston 5th Annual ITA-IEL-ICC Joint Conference on International Energy Arbitration January 2018 (TBA) Houston 15th Annual ITA-ASIL Conference April 4, 2018 Washington, D.C. 1st ITA-ALARB Joint Conference on International Arbitration in the Americas (11th Annual ITA Americas Workshop) May 3 - 4, 2018 Santiago de Chile 30th ITA Workshop and Annual Meeting June 20-22, 2018 Dallas Thanks to Our Sponsors ITA takes this opportunity to thank again and recognize the financial sponsor that helped make our 14th Annual ITA-ASIL Conference: Third-Party Funding in International Arbitration: Legal & Ethical Considerations – Commentary on the Report of the ICCA/Queen Mary Task Force on April 12, 2017 in Washington, D.C. possible: Luncheon Sponsor: Tenor Capital Management Company, L.P. Special Thanks ITA recognizes with appreciation our local hosts, co-sponsors and conference reporters for: 14TH ANNUAL ITA-ASIL CONFERENCE: THIRD-PARTY FUNDING IN INTERNATIONAL ARBITRATION: LEGAL & ETHICAL CONSIDERATIONS – COMMENTARY ON THE REPORT OF THE ICCA/QUEEN MARY TASK FORCE April 12, 2017 in Washington, D.C. Reporters: James Egerton-Vernon, Jones Day, Washington, DC Zain Jinnah, White & Case LLP, Washington, DC Raquel Martinez Sloan, White & Case LLP, Washington, DC YAI TALKS #MIAMI February 24, 2017 in Miami YOUNG ITA TALKS #LONDON May 9, 2017 in London Local Host: White & Case Co-Sponsors: Miami International Arbitration Society Future of Arbitration Miami Reporter: Montserrat Manzano, Von Wobeser y Sierra SC, Mexico City Local Host: Vinson & Elkins Co-Sponsor: ArbitralWomen Reporters: Tomas Vail, White & Case, London Cecily Higham, White & Case, London Page 9 The Institute for Transnational Arbitration A Division of THE CENTER FOR AMERICAN AND INTERNATIONAL LAW SCOREBOARD OF ADHERENCE TO TRANSNATIONAL ARBITRATION TREATIES (as of May 22, 2017) ABBREVIATIONS NY ICSID MIGA IA USBIT USFTA OPIC United Nations Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards (commonly, 1958 New York Convention) Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes (1965) Convention Establishing the Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency (1985) Inter-American Convention on International Commercial Arbitration (commonly, Panama Convention of 1975) United States Bilateral Investment Treaty United States Free Trade Agreement Agreements supporting programs of the Overseas Private Investment Corp. SYMBOLS S R A (*) N/A Signed, but not ratified Ratified, acceded or succeeded Subscribed, but not signed, ratified or paid Capital-exporting country under MIGA Not applicable CHANGES FROM PREVIOUS ISSUE NY ICSID MIGA IA USBIT USFTA OPIC None. None. None. None. None. None. None. NATION NY1 ICSID2 MIGA3 IA USBIT USFTA4 OPIC5 Afghanistan RRR R Albania RRR R R Algeria RRR R AndorraR Angola RRR Antigua and Barbuda RRR Argentina RRRRR R Armenia RRR R R Australia RRR* R/S19 Austria RRR* Azerbaijan RRR R R Bahamas RRR R Bahrain RRR R R Bangladesh RRR R R Barbados RRR R Belarus RRR S R Belgium RRR* BelizeS RR Benin RRR R BhutanR Bolivia 6 R RRR R Bosnia and Herzegovina 7 RRR R Botswana RRR R Brazil R RR R Brunei Darussalam R RS19 Bulgaria RRR R R Burkina Faso RRR R Burundi RRR R Cambodia RRR R Cameroon RRR R R Canada RRR* R8/S19 Page 10 NATION NY1 ICSID2 MIGA3 IA USBIT USFTA4 OPIC5 Cape VerdeR RR Central African Republic RRR R ChadR RR RRRR R/S19R Chile China (People’s Republic) RRR Colombia RRRR RR Comoros RRR R 9 Congo RR R R Congo (Democratic Republic of) Cook Islands R R R R RR Costa Rica RRRR R10R Côte d’Ivoire RRR R Croatia 7 RRR R R Cuba R Cyprus RRR R Czech Republic RRR* R R Denmark 11 RRR* Djibouti RRR Dominica RRR Dominican Republic RSRR R 10R Ecuador R RRR R Egypt RRR R R El Salvador RRRRSR 10R Equatorial GuineaRR EritreaRR Estonia RRR R R EthiopiaS RR Fiji RRR R Finland RRR* France 12 RRR* Gabon RRR R GambiaR RR Georgia RRR R R Germany RRR* Ghana RRR R Greece R R R*R Grenada RR R R Guatemala RRRR R 10R Guinea RRR R Guinea-BissauS R R GuyanaR RR Haiti RRR S R Holy See (Vatican City) R Honduras RRRRRR 10R Hungary RRR R Iceland RRR* India RRR Indonesia RRR R Iran R R Iraq RRR Ireland R R R*R Israel RRR R Italy RRR* Jamaica RRR R R Japan RRR* S19 Jordan RRR R R Kazakhstan RRR R R Kenya RRR R KiribatiR Korea (North) Page 11 NATION Korea (Republic) (South) NY1 ICSID2 MIGA3 IA USBIT USFTA4 OPIC5 RRR RR KosovoR RR Kuwait RRR R Kyrgyzstan RSR R R Lao People’s Democratic Republic RRR Latvia RRR R R Lebanon RRR R Lesotho RRR R Liberia RRR R Libyan Arab JamahiriyaR Liechtenstein R Lithuania RRR R R Luxembourg RRR* Macedonia, Former Yugoslav Republic of 7 RRR R Madagascar RRR R MalawiR RR Malaysia RRR S19R MaldivesRR Mali RRR R Malta RRR R Marshall Islands RR Mauritania RRR R Mauritius RRR R Mexico R RR R8/S19R MicronesiaR RR Moldova RRR R R Monaco R Mongolia RRR R R Montenegro R S RR Morocco RRR RRR Mozambique RRR R R Myanmar (Burma) RRR NamibiaS RR Nauru R S Nepal RRR R Netherlands 13 RRR* New Zealand 14 RRR S19 Nicaragua RRRRSR 10R Niger RRR R Nigeria RRR R Norway RRR* Oman RRR RR Pakistan RRR R PalauRR Panama RRRRRRR Papua New GuineaR RR Paraguay RRRR R Peru RRRR R 18/S19R Philippines RRR R Poland R R R R Portugal R R R*R Qatar RRR Romania RRR R R Russian Federation RSR S R Rwanda ARR R R Saint Kitts and NevisR RR Saint LuciaR RR St. Vincent and the Grenadines R R R R SamoaR RR San Marino Page 12 R S NATION NY1 ICSID2 MIGA3 IA USBIT Sao Tome and Principe R S Saudi Arabia RRR USFTA4 S OPIC5 R Senegal RRR R R Serbia 7 RRR R SeychellesR RR Sierra LeoneR RR Singapore RRR RR Slovakia RRR R R R *R Slovenia 7R Solomon Islands R R SomaliaRR South Africa RRR South SudanRR Spain RRR* Sri Lanka RRR R R Sudan RR SurinameRR SwazilandR RR Sweden RRR* Switzerland RRR* Syrian Arab Republic RRR TaiwanR Tajikistan RRR Tanzania RRR R Thailand R S RR Timor LesteR RR TogoR RR TongaRR Trinidad and Tobago RRR R R Tunisia RRR R R Turkey RRR R R TurkmenistanR RR Tuvalu Uganda RRR R Ukraine RRR R R United Arab Emirates RRR United Kingdom 15 RRR* United States of America 16 RRR*RN/A N/A Uruguay RRRRR R Uzbekistan RRR S R VanuatuR Venezuela R RR R Vietnam RRR West Bank and Gaza 17R YemenR RR Zambia RRR R Zimbabwe RRR R Notes: (1) Extends to metropolitan and overseas constituent territorial subdivisions but not to overseas dependent territories. Consult UNCITRAL for definitive status. Under Art. I(3), 74 States have entered a “reciprocity reservation”. With regard to awards made in the territory of non-contracting States, 9 States have entered a “reciprocal treatment” reservation, and 46 States have entered a “commercial reservation”. (2) Extends to metropolitan and overseas constituent territorial subdivisions and to overseas dependent territories unless specifically excluded. (3) Extends to metropolitan and overseas constituent territorial subdivisions and to overseas dependent territories. www.miga.org/whoweare/index.cfm?stid=1789 (4) The free trade agreements listed are those signed by the U.S. with a chapter on investments. They are bilateral unless indicated otherwise. (5) Countries where OPIC programs are generally available will be listed as ratified. At times, statutory and policy constraints, such as Congressionally required certifications on labor practices, may limit the availability of OPIC programs in various countries. Under agreements with certain countries, the host government may be required to approve OPIC assistance for a project. www.opic.gov/doing-business-us/OPIC-policies/where-we-operate (6) The Government of the Republic of Bolivia signed the ICSID Convention on May 3, 1991 and deposited its instrument of ratification on June 23, 1995. The Convention entered into force for Bolivia on July 23, 1995. On May 2, 2007, the depositary received a written notice of Bolivia’s denunciation of the Convention. In accordance with Article 71 of the Convention, the denunciation took effect six months after the receipt of Bolivia’s notice, i.e., on November 3, 2007. The Government of Bolivia delivered notice to the United States on June 10, 2011, that it was terminating the “Treaty Between the Government of the United States of America and the Government of the Republic of Bolivia Concerning the Encouragement and Reciprocal Protection of Investment.” As of June 10, 2012 (the date of termination), the treaty ceases to have effect, except that it continues to apply for another 10 years to covered investments existing at the time of termination. (7) As of 4 February 2003, The Federal Republic of Yugoslavia has changed its name to “Serbia and Montenegro.” Montenegro declared itself independent from Serbia on June 3, 2006. Bosnia & Herzegovina, Croatia, the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, and Slovenia are separated successor states to parts of the former Yugoslavia and have succeeded to the NY. MIGA, ratified by the former Yugoslavia, is considered by MIGA as ratified by Serbia & Montenegro and by the aforementioned four separated successor states. OPIC programs are available in the four separated states. (8) Included in the North American Free Trade Agreement among the United States, Canada and Mexico. (9) NY and MIGA: includes Hong Kong Special Administrative Region. (10) Included in the Dominican Republic - Central America - United States Free Trade Agreement. (11) NY: includes Faeroe Islands and Greenland. (12) NY: includes, inter alia, French Guiana, French Polynesia, Guadeloupe, Martinique, Mayotte, New Caledonia, Réunion, and St. Pierre and Miquelon. OPIC programs available in French Guiana. (13) NY: includes Aruba and Netherlands Antilles. OPIC programs are available in Aruba and Netherlands Antilles. (14) ICSID: excludes Cook Islands, Niue and Tokelau. (15) NY: includes Bermuda, Cayman Islands, Gibraltar, Guernsey, Isle of Man, and British Virgin Islands. ICSID: excludes British Indian Ocean Territory, Pitcairn Islands, British Antarctic Territory and Sovereign Base Areas of Cyprus. ICSID: continues to include Hong Kong Special Administrative Region. OPIC programs available in Northern Ireland, Anguilla and Turks and Caicos. (16) NY: includes, inter alia, American Samoa, Guam, Northern Mariana Islands, Puerto Rico and U.S. Virgin Islands. (17) West Bank and Gaza are not recognized as states by the United States. (18) United States - Peru Trade Promotion Agreement. (19) Trans-Pacific Partnership signed on February 4, 2016. SOURCES: This issue was compiled by Co-Editors Elina Mereminskaya and Monique Sasson of The Institute for Transnational Arbitration based on the following sources: United Nations; ICSID; MIGA; Organization of American States; OPIC; and the Office of the United States Trade Representative. The Scoreboard is designed to be a convenient reference, but is not intended to be relied on as legal advice. Please consult the sources directly to confirm the status of any particular ratifications, reservations, changes, special conditions or new developments. Copyright 2014, The Center for American and International Law. Page 13 MEMBERS OF THE INSTITUTE FOR TRANSNATIONAL ARBITRATION SUSTAINING Baker Botts L.L.P. Chevron Corporation ConocoPhillips Debevoise & Plimpton LLP Dechert LLP Exxon Mobil Corporation Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer LLP King & Spalding LLP Norton Rose Fulbright US LLP Shearman & Sterling LLP Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP Sullivan & Cromwell LLP Three Crowns LLP Vinson & Elkins LLP White & Case LLP WilmerHale SUPPORTING Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP Arnold & Porter LLP Astigarraga Davis Baker Hughes, Inc. Berkeley Research Group (BRG), LLC Clifford Chance Compass Lexecon Covington & Burling LLP Curtis, Mallet-Prevost, Colt & Mosle LLP Greenberg Traurig, LLP Haynes and Boone, LLP Herbert Smith Freehills New York LLP Hill Schwartz Spilker Keller LLC Hogan Lovells US LLP Hughes Hubbard & Reed LLP Hunton & Williams LLP JAMS, Inc. Jones Walker LLP K&L Gates LLP Lalive Latham & Watkins LLP Locke Lord LLP Mattos Filho, Veiga Filho, Marrey Jr. e Quiroga Advogados Mayer Brown LLP Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP Reed Smith LLP Sidley Austin LLP The Claro Group, LLC Thompson & Knight LLP TozziniFreire Advogados Von Wobeser y Sierra Ware, Jackson, Lee, O’Neill, Smith & Barrow, LLP SPONSORING Advokat John Kadelburger AB Allen & Overy LLP Andrews Kurth LLP B. Cremades y Asociados Basham, Ringe y Correa S.C. Beretta Godoy Bofill Mir & Alvarez Jana BP America Inc. Brown&Page Burnet Duckworth & Palmer Cogan & Partners LLP Conway & Partners N.V. Conyers Dill & Pearman Gonzalez De Castilla Abogados, S.C. Hanotiau & van den Berg Law Office of John Burritt McArthur Legge, Farrow, Kimmitt, McGrath & Brown, L.L.P. Loperena, Lerch & Martin Del Campo Milbank, Tweed, Hadley & McCloy Navigant Consulting, Inc. Occidental Petroleum Corporation (OXY) Perez Bustamante & Ponce Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP Shipley Snell Montgomery LLP Solutions Economics LLC Page 14 Studio Legale Bisconti| Tenor Capital Management Company, L.P. Zuleta Abogados Asociados S.A.S. ASSOCIATE José María Alonso David Arias William G. Arnot, III Anne Ashby Eliana B. Baraldi Stacey L. Barnes Trey Bergman Pierre Bienvenu Erica Bramer Philip L. Bruner George Kevin Buchanan Michael Buhler Ricardo A. Cevallos John Allen Chalk, Sr. Maria Chedid Craig Chiasson Michael Collins, Q.C. Clint A. Corrie Paulo Rogério Brandão Couto Platt W. Davis, III René De Liux Campos Garcia Andrew de Lotbinière McDougall Robert J.C. Deane E.F. Mano DeAyala Charles H. Dick, Jr. Stephen L. Drymer Thomas A. Dubbs Alberto Echarri Ike Ehiribe Wayne I. Fagan Richard D. Faulkner Paulo Flores James M. Gaitis J. Richard Gallagher Lauro Gama, Jr. Manuel García Barragán M. Gerald W. Ghikas, Q.C. Luke J. Gilman Marc J. Goldstein Brody Greenwald Pierre-Yves Gunter Clifford J. Hendel John W. Hinchey James M. Hosking J. Martin Hunter Melinda Jayson John Judge Jean Kalicki Mark A. Kantor Lee L. Kaplan Michael S. Kim William H. Knull, III Steven G. Kobre Benoit Le Bars Giselle Leonardo David M. Lindsey Valerie Longmire-Jefferis David T. Lopez David Madsen Anton G. Maurer Carlos J. McCadden James D. McCarthy Gary V. McGowan Paul J. McMahon, Esq. Michelle R. Meriam Isabelle Michou Robert W. Mockler Mark C. Morril Christa Mueller Garcia Piotr Nowaczyk Suzanne Nusbaum Basil Ononbhara Odigie Alejandro Ogarrio Seyilayo A. Ojo Elsa Ortega Kathleen Paisley Lorena Perez McGill Daniel Posse Lisa Powell Noradèle Radjai James E. Redmond Klaus Reichert Kenneth B. Reisenfeld Matthew D. Richardson Javier Robalino Joshua M. Robbins William W. Russell Aníbal M. Sabater Gloria Saldaña Lawrence S. Schaner Lionel Schooler James Searby David E. Sharp Allison J. Snyder Jeffrey Sullivan Edna Sussman Greig Taylor Ruth Teitelbaum Sylvia Tonova Michael J. Truncale Andrew Tuck Eric van Ginkel Marc Veit Dr. Georg von Segesser David W. Waddell Richard E. (Rory) Walck Arnoldo Wald Jun Wang Philip R. Weems Carlton Wilde, Jr. Karen Willcutts Rodrigo Zamora ACADEMIC /GOVERNMENT /NON-PROFIT Arbitration Chambers Markham Ball Rosemary Barkett Gary L. Benton Ronald J. Bettauer Andrea K. Bjorklund Blakely Advocacy Institute Chester Brown Donald Earl Childress, III Magaly Cobian CPR: International Institute for Conflict Prevention & Resolution Tulio F. Cusman Cecilia Flores Rueda Susan D. Franck Shelby Grubbs O. Thomas Johnson M. Imad Khan Barry Leon Robert B. Matthews Luis Manuel C. Mejan Carrer Margaret L. Moses Lorena Perez McGill Nigerian Institute of Chartered Arbitrators Patricia Shaughnessy Frèdèric G. Sourgens Texas A&M University School of Law Nasiru Tijani University of Missouri School of Law University of Richmond School of Law Todd Weiler Jarrod Wong ARBITRAL INSTITUTIONS Arbitration and Conciliation Centre of the Bogota Chamber of Commerce (CCB) Arbitration and Mediation Center of the Santiago Chamber of Commerce CAM Santiago) Arbitration Center of Mexico (CAM) Arbitration Centre of the American Chamber of Commerce of Brazil (AmCham Brasil) Arbitration Center of the American Chamber of Commerce of Peru (AmCham Perú) Arbitration Centre of the Caracas Chamber of Commerce (CACC) Arbitraton Centre of the Lima Chamber of Commerce (LLC) Brazil-Canada Chamber of Commerce (CAM-CCBC) Conciliation and Arbitration Center of the Chamber of Commerce of Costa Rica ICC Dispute Resolution Services Inter-American Commercial Arbitration Commission (IACAC) International Center for Conciliation and Arbitration (AmCham Cost Rica) International Centre for Dispute Resolution (ICDR) International Centre for Settlement of Investment Dispute (ICSID) Mediation and Arbitration Center of the National Chamber of Commerce of Mexico City (CANACO) Stockholm Chamber of Commerce (SCC) ADVISORY BOARD Dr. Manuel A. Abdala Alvaro Aguilar Ojeda Roberto Aguirre Luzi Jay Alexander Prof. Roger P. Alford Meredith Alfred Arif Hyder Ali José María Alonso Gabriela Alvarez-Avila Steven K. Andersen Olivier P. André David Arias William G. Arnot, III Anne Ashby Alden L. Atkins John B. Attanasio Fernando Avila Antonio M. Barbuto Neto Rosemary Barkett Stacey L. Barnes C. Dennis Barrow, Jr. Charles Beach Julie Bédard Andrew M. Behrman Martin D. Beirne Gary L. Benton Levi J. Benton Ronald J. Bettauer Pierre Bienvenu Dr. Giuseppe Bisconti R. Doak Bishop Andrea K. Bjorklund Suzana M. Blades Juliet Blanch Karl-Heinz Bockstiegel Stephen R. Bond John P. Bowman Lorraine M. Brennan Prof. Charles H. Brower, II The Hon. Charles N. Brower Alice Brown Brit T. Brown Chester Brown Dominique Brown-Berset Philip L. Bruner George Kevin Buchanan The Hon. Thomas Buergenthal Michael Buhler Ryan Bull Henry G. Burnett Michael Burnett Kristin Campbell-Wilson René de Liux Campos Garcia David D. Caron ADVISORY BOARD CONT. James E. Castello Ricardo A. Cevallos John Allen Chalk, Sr. Maria Chedid Marney L. Cheek Richard Chernick Craig Chiasson Donald Earl Childress, III Magaly Cobian Prof. Jack J. Coe, Jr. John P. Cogan, Jr. Michael Collins, Q.C. Wade Coriell Clint A. Corrie Paulo Rogério Brandão Couto Bob Craig Alan Crain Bernardo M. Cremades Thomas L. Cubbage, III Tulio F. Cusman Robert B. Davidson Platt W. Davis, III Alexandre de Gramont René de Liux Campos Garcia Andrew de Lotbinière McDougall Robert J.C. Deane E.F. Mano DeAyala Santiago Dellepiane Andrew B. Derman Richard Deutsch Elizabeth McKee Devaney Paolo Di Rosa Charles H. Dick, Jr., Sashe Dimitroff Donald Donovan Stephen L. Drymer Nicole Duarte Thomas A. Dubbs James P. Duffy, IV Phillip Dye Alberto Echarri Ike Ehiribe Jeffrey Elkinson Alejandro A. Escobar Wayne I. Fagan Richard D. Faulkner John Fellas Mike Filla Steven Finizio Hal Fiske Kenneth Fleuriet Paulo Flores Cecilia Flores Rueda Susan D. Franck Elliot Friedman Mark W. Friedman Claudia Frutos-Peterson Stephanie Black Fuller Emmanuel Gaillard James M. Gaitis Alvaro Galindo J. Richard Gallagher Lauro Gama, Jr. Manuel García Barragán M. José-Manuel García Represa John L. Gardiner Barry H. Garfinkel Gaela K. Gehring Flores John T. Gerhart Gerald W. Ghikas, Q.C. Leonardo R. Giacchino Judith Gill Luke J. Gilman Chiara Giorgetti Teresa Giovannini Beverly B. Godbey Federico Godoy Michael S. Goldberg Marc J. Goldstein Christopher Goncalves Eduardo Damião Gonçalves Daniel E. González Katherine González Arrocha Emilio González de Castilla Brody Greenwald Nicholas Greenwood Shelby Grubbs Anne-Maria Guillerme Pierre-Yves Gunter Martin F. Gusy Hugh E. Hackney David R. Haigh Jonathan C. Hamilton Bernard Hanotiau John L. Hardiman David E. Harrell, Jr. Miriam Harwood Clifford J. Hendel Mary T. Hernandez John W. Hinchey James M. Hosking J. Martin Hunter Don Jackson, III Michael E. Jaffe Andrés Jana Melinda Jayson Alexandre Job O. Thomas Johnson John Judge Brent C. Kaczmarek John M. Kadelburger Jean E. Kalicki Mark A. Kantor Lee L. Kaplan William M. Katz David Kay Ed G. Kehoe Rachael D. Kent Karl Killian Michael S. Kim Louis Benno Kimmelman Brian King Meg Kinnear Michael Kitzen William H. Knull, III Steven G. Kobre Lea Haber Kuck Urs Laeuchli Hamish Lal Carolyn B. Lamm Robert Landicho Jim Lawrence Benoit Le Bars Clyde Lea Christian Leathley Mimi Lee Glenn R. Legge Mike P. Lennon, Jr. Barry Leon Giselle Leonardo Macarena Letelier Richard C.Levin David J. Levy David M. Lindsey Nicholas Lingard Guy Lipe Gregory A. Litt Rafael Llano Oddone Jim Loftis Valerie Longmire-Jefferis Carlos Loperena David T. Lopez Miguel López Forastier Ben Love Edward J. Lynch Dana C. MacGrath David Madsen Mark Mangan Fernando Mantilla-Serrano Montserrat Manzano E. Mike Marchand Noiana Marigo Jose Luis Martin Luis M. Martinez Robert B. Matthews Dr. Anton G. Maurer John Burritt McArthur Carlos J. McCadden James D. McCarthy Gary V. McGowan Paul J. McMahon, Esq. Mark S. McNeill Luis Manuel C. Mejan Carrer Andrew Melsheimer Andrea J. Menaker Nalleli I. Menéndez Cabrera Ian Meredith Elina Mereminskaya Michelle R. Meriam Carl Micarelli Isabelle Michou Craig S. Miles Robert W. Mockler Allan B. Moore Carolina Da Rocha Morandi Matthew Moran Flavia Cristina Moreira de Campos Andrade Mark C. Morril The Hon. Joseph W. Morris Margaret L. Moses Christa Mueller Garcia Ewell E. Murphy, Jr. Timothy G. Nelson Paul J. Neufeld Joseph E. Neuhaus Denton Nichols William J. Noble Michael D. Nolan Joshua Norris Piotr Nowaczyk Gary Nugent Suzanne Nusbaum Soledad G. O’Donnell Kevin M. O’Gorman Eileen O’Neill Basil Ononbhara Odigie Alejandro Ogarrio Seyilayo A. Ojo Liliana Orbegozo Elsa Ortega Shola Oshodi-John Kyle A. Owens Ryan Padden Kathleen Paisley R. Hewitt Pate Flávio Pereira Lima Sebastian Perez Arteta Lorena Perez McGill Jennifer L. Permesly Hansel Pham John V.H. Pierce Daniel Posse Lisa A. Powell Dietmar W. Prager Andrew P. Price Yanett Quiroz Valdovinos Noradèle Radjai John Jay Range Alberto Ravell Guilherme Recena Costa James E. Redmond Lucy F. Reed Daniel Reich Klaus Reichert Natalie L. Reid Kenneth B. Reisenfeld Tracie J. Renfroe Caroline Richard Matthew D. Richardson Francisco Rivero Javier Robalino Joshua M. Robbins Ann Ryan Robertson Laura M. Robertson John D. Roesser Zoila Rosa Volio Myriam Rosales Jiménez Roger Rubio Guerrero William W. Russell Gary Russo Christopher M. Ryan Aníbal Sabater Jeswald W. Salacuse Gloria Saldaña Claudia T. Salomon Ank Santens Monique Sasson Lawrence S. Schaner Marco Schnabl Michael E. Schneider, Esq. Edward T. Schorr Lionel Schooler Franz Schwarz Marc Schwartz Krystal Scott James Searby Sebastian SeelmannEggebert Fernando Eduardo Serec David E. Sharp Patricia Shaughnessy Audley Sheppard George T. Shipley Laurence Shore Tomas J. Sikora Eugene J. Silva, II Eduardo Silva Romero Laura Sinisterra José Luis Siqueiros William K. Slate, II Jennifer Smith Reginald R. Smith Abby Cohen Smutny Elizabeth Snodgrass Allison J. Snyder Luke A. Sobota Mariana Solís Frédéric G. Sourgens Pablo T. Spiller Margrete Stevens Dr. S.I. (Stacie) Strong Jeffrey Sullivan John Sullivan Edna Sussman Christopher K. Tahbaz James E. Tancula Greig Taylor Ruth Teitelbaum Nasiru Tijani Sylvia Tonova John Townsend John Trenor Elizabeth Trujillo Michael J. Truncale Andrew Tuck Timothy J. Tyler Adriana Vaamonde M. Thabiso van den Bosch Eric van Ginkel Marc Veit Marco Tulio Venegas Cruz Vincent Verschoor Odean L. Volker Dr. Georg von Segesser David W. Waddell Richard E. (Rory) Walck Arnoldo Wald David Waldron Stephen Wallace Thomas W. Walsh Jun Wang Anton Ware Philip R. Weems Todd Weiler Matthew Weldon Carlton Wilde, Jr. Karen Willcutts Justin Williams Wayne R. Wilson David B. Winn Peter Winship Jarrod Wong Louise Woods Alexander Yanos Rodrigo Zamora Eduardo Zuleta ACADEMIC COUNCIL Shahla Ali José E. Alvarez Andrea K. Bjorklund Stavros L. Brekoulakis Charles H. Brower, II Chester Brown The Hon. Thomas Buergenthal David D. Caron Donald Earl Childress, III John R. Crook Karen Halverson Cross Diane Desierto Christopher R. Drahozal Mark Feldman Susan D. Franck Chiara Giorgetti Manuel A. Gomez J. Martin Hunter Susan L. Karamanian Won Kidane Céline Lévesque Loukas Mistelis Julian D. Mortenson Margaret L. Moses Erin O’Hara O’Connor Pilar Perales Viscasillas Sergio Puig Catherine A. Rogers Victoria Shannon Sahani Stephan W. Schill Ben H. Sheppard, Jr. Linda J. Silberman Frédéric G. Sourgens Maya Steinitz Thomas J. Stipanowich S.I. (Stacie) Strong Louise Ellen Teitz Peter Winship Jarrod Wong BOARD OF REPORTERS ITA ARBITRATION REPORT GENERAL EDITOR Prof. Roger P. Alford CO-MANAGING EDITOR Elina Mereminskaya CO-MANAGING EDITOR Monique Sasson ITA DIRECTOR David B. Winn ASSOCIATE EDITOR Deen Kaplan DEVELOPMENTAL EDITOR Vincent Verschoor Page 15 MEMBERS OF THE INSTITUTE FOR TRANSNATIONAL ARBITRATION COUNTRY REPORTERS ARGENTINA Federico Godoy ITALY Stefano Azzali Benedetta Coppo AUSTRALIA Damian Sturzaker JAPAN Takiko Kadono Hisaya Kimura Koki Yanagisawa AUSTRIA Dr. Guenther J. Horvath BELGIUM Maarten Draye Bernard Hanotiau Charlotte Villeneuve BOLIVIA Bernardo Wayar Caballero Bernardo Antonio Wayar Ocampo BRAZIL Dr. João Bosco Lee BULGARIA Assen Alexiev CANADA Tina Cicchetti CHILE Cristian Conejero-Roos CHINA Arthur X. Dong Jingzhou Tao NAFTA Prof. Charles H. Brower II LATVIA Inga Kačevska ITA BOARD OF EDITORS WORLD ARBITRATION AND MEDIATION REVIEW LEBANON Jalal El Ahdab MEXICO José María Abascal Zamora Cecilia Flores Rueda NETHERLANDS Bo Ra Hoebeke NEW ZEALAND Stephen Hunter PAKISTAN Nudrat E. Piracha PANAMÁ Ryan Mellske PERU Fernando Cantuarias Salaverry COSTA RICA Ryan Mellske POLAND Dr. Wojciech Sadowski Ewelina Wetrys PORTUGAL José Miguel Júdice DENMARK Peter F. Thommesen QATAR Minas Khatchadourian DOMINICAN REPUBLIC Stephan Adell ROMANIA Nicolae Viorel Dinu ECUADOR Javier Robalino Orellana RUSSIA Andrey Panov EGYPT Dr. Karim Abou Youssef SCOTLAND David Scott EL SALVADOR Ryan Mellske SINGAPORE Michael Hwang S.C. ENGLAND Nicholas Fletcher QC SPAIN Esperanza Barrón Baratech Fernando Mantilla Serrano FINLAND Mika Savola Anna-Maria Tamminen SWEDEN John M. Kadelburger FRANCE Nataliya Barysheva Valentine Chessa Yves Derains Bertrand Derains SWITZERLAND Dr. Georg von Segesser, FCIArb GERMANY Thomas Kopp Dr. Richard H. Kreindler TURKEY Dr. Ismail G. Esin Stephan Wilske GREECE Ioannis Vassardanis UKRAINE Yaroslav Petrov HONG KONG Justin D’Agostino UNITED KINGDOM Nicholas Fletcher, Q.C. INDIA Dipen Sabharwal Aditya Singh UNITED ARAB EMIRATES John Gaffney IRELAND Klaus Reichert SC ISRAEL Tamar Meshel Page 16 INSTITUTIONAL REPORTERS ICSID Ina C. Popova Dietmar W. Prager Samantha J. Rowe KOREA Kun Hee Cho Kay-Jannes Wegner COLOMBIA Eduardo Zuleta CZECH REPUBLIC Ivo Janda Petr Polášek VENEZUELA Alfredo De Jesús O. SYRIA Dr. Abdulhay Sayed UNITED STATES Donald Francis Donovan Sonia R. Farber Natalie Reid William H. Taft V URUGUAY Sandra González EDITORS-IN-CHIEF R. Doak Bishop Andrea K. Bjorklund Dietmar W. Prager BOARD OF EDITORS The Hon. Charles N. Brower David D. Caron James E. Castello Donald Francis Donovan Christopher R. Drahozal Judith Gill Bernard Hanotiau Sally A. Harpole MANAGING EDITOR Rafael T. Boza ASSOCIATE MANAGING EDITOR Benjamin Jones EXECUTIVE EDITOR Charles B. Rosenberg ASSISTANT EDITORS Albina Gasanbekova Melinda Kuritzky Justin Lee Ignacial Madalena Elsa Paparemborder Matthew J. Weldon Kristen M. Young PUBLISHER Michael Kitzen ITA LATIN AMERICAN ARBITRATION FORUM (ITAFOR) Institute for Transnational Arbitration (ITA) Asociación Latinoamericana de Arbitraje (ALARB) Comitê Brasileiro de Arbitragem (CBAr) MODERATORS Fernando Cantuarias Universidad Del Pacìfico Lima, PERU Francisco González de Cossío González de Cossío Abogados, S.C. Mexico City, MEXICO Clifford J. Hendel ARAOZ & RUEDA Abogados Madrid, SPAIN Elina Mereminskaya Wagemann & Cia. Santiago, CHILE Giovanni Ettore Nanni Nanni Advogados São Paulo, BRAZIL Elsa Ortega Ortega & Gomez Ruano, S.C. Mexico, MEXICO COUNCIL José I. Astigarraga Founding Member Astigarraga Davis Miami, FL USA Flávia Bittar Neves CBAr President Grebler Advogados Belo Horizonte, BRAZIL Eduardo Damião Gonçalves CBAr Representative Mattos Filho, Veiga Filho, Marrey Jr. e Quiroga Advogados São Paulo, BRAZIL| Andrés Jana ITA Americas Initiative Chair Bofill Mir & Álvarez Jana Santiago, CHILE Abby Cohen Smutny ITA Chair White & Case LLP Washington, DC USA Guido S. Tawil ALARB Representative M. & M. Bomchil and Univ. of Buenos Aires Buenos Aires, ARGENTINA David B. Winn ITA Director Vice President, The Center for American & International Law Plano, TX USA Eduardo Zuleta ALARB President Zuleta Abogados Asociados Bogotá, COLOMBIA ARE YOU A MEMBER OF THE INSTITUTE FOR TRANSNATIONAL ARBITRATION? The Institute for Transnational Arbitration (ITA) provides advanced, continuing education for lawyers, judges and other professionals concerned with transnational arbitration of commercial and investment disputes. Through its programs, scholarly publications and membership activities, ITA has become an important global forum on contemporary issues in the field of transnational arbitration. The Institute’s record of educational achievements has been aided by the support of many of the world’s leading companies, lawyers and arbitration professionals. Membership in the Institute for Transnational Arbitration is available to corporations, law firms, professional and educational organizations, government agencies and individuals. MISSION Founded in 1986 as a division of The Center for American and International Law, the Institute was created to promote global adherence to the world’s principal arbitration treaties and to educate business executives, government officials and lawyers about arbitration as a means of resolving transnational business disputes. WHY BECOME A MEMBER? Membership dues are more than compensated both financially and professionally by the benefits of membership. Depending on the level of membership, ITA members may designate one or multiple representatives on the Institute’s Advisory Board, each of whom is entitled to attend, without charge, the annual ITA Workshop in Dallas or the annual Americas Workshop in Latin America. Advisory Board Members also receive a substantial tuition discount at all other ITA programs. Advisory Board members also have the opportunity to participate in the Institute’s leadership, professional initiatives, practice committees and a variety of other free professional and social membership activities throughout the year. Advisory Board Members also receive a free subscription to ITA’s quarterly law journal, World Arbitration and Mediation Review, a free subscription to ITA’s quarterly newsletter, News and Notes, and substantial discounts on all ITA educational online, DVD and print publications. Your membership and participation support the activities of one of the world’s leading forums on international arbitration today. THE ADVISORY BOARD The work of the Institute is done primarily through its Advisory Board, and its committees. The current practice committees of the ITA are the Americas Initiative Committee (comprised of Advisory Board members practicing or interested in Latin America) and the Young ITA Committee (comprised of Young ITA Members and Advisory Board members under 40 years old). The ITA Advisory Board and its committees meet for business and social activities each June in connection with the annual ITA Workshop. Other committee activities occur in connection with the Americas Workshop and throughout the year. PROGRAMS The primary public program of the Institute is its annual ITA Workshop, presented each year on the third Thursday in June in Dallas in connection with the ITA Annual Meeting. Other annual programs include the ITA Americas Workshop in Latin America, the ITA-ASIL Conference in Washington, D.C., and the ITA-IELICC Joint Conference on International Energy Arbitration in Houston. ITA conferences customarily include a Roundtable organized by young practitioners and an informal ITA Forum for candid discussion among peers on current issues and concerns in the field. For a complete calendar of ITA programs, please visit our website at www.cailaw.org/ita. PUBLICATIONS ITA is a founding sponsor of KluwerArbitration.com, the most comprehensive, up-to-date portal for international arbitration resources online. The ITA Arbitration Report, a free email subscription service available at KluwerArbitration.com and prepared by the ITA Board of Reporters, delivers timely reports on awards, cases, legislation and other current developments from over 60 countries, organized by country, together with reports on new treaty ratifications, new publications and upcoming events around the globe. The Institute’s acclaimed Scoreboard of Adherence to Transnational Arbitration Treaties, a comprehensive, report on the status of every country’s adherence to the primary international arbitration treaties, is published on ITA’s website and in its quarterly newsletter, News and Notes. All ITA members also receive a free subscription to ITA’s quarterly law journal, World Arbitration and Mediation Review, edited by the ITA Board of Editors. The Online Education Library on the Institute’s website presents a variety of educational videos, mock arbitrations, recorded webinars, oral history interviews and books, many of them produced by the Academic Council for the benefit of professors, students and practitioners of international arbitration. ITAFOR (the ITA Latin American Arbitration Forum), a listserv launched in 2014 has quickly become the leading online forum on international arbitration in Latin America. International dispute resolution instructors are welcome to explore the course curricula and other pedagogical materials shared by leading professors on the website’s Legal Educators Resources Collection and to participate in the accompanying ITA-LEL listserv. Please join us. For more information, visit ITA online at www.cailaw.org/ita. I wish to join the Institute for Transnational Arbitration in the following category: ☐ Young ITA Membership - $0 ☐ Sustaining Membership* - $6,000 (available to young professionals under 40 years old) ☐ Supporting Membership* - $3,000 ☐ Sponsoring Membership - $1,250 ☐ Associate Membership - $725 ☐ Academic / Government / Non-Profit Membership - $395 *Sustaining Members may designate six Advisory Board representatives and two additional representatives under the age of 40. Sustaining Members may designate an unlimited number of additional Advisory Board representatives for $500 each and up to four additional representatives under the age of 40 for $300 each. ---------*Supporting Members may designate three Advisory Board representatives and one additional representative under the age of 40. Supporting Members may designate additional Advisory Board representatives for $600 each and up to two additional representatives under the age of 40 for $300 each. See www.cailaw.org/ita for complete description of benefits. Member name (Individual, Corporation, Firm, Government Agency, Organization)________________________________________ Address __________________________________________________________________________________________ City / State / Postal Code / Country _______________________________________________________________________ Telephone __________________________ Fax ________________________ Email_______________________________ Name of person to serve on Advisory Board* _________________________________________________________________ (Please make a copy of this page if you will be designating more than one Advisory Board Representative or join online at www.cailaw.org/ita/join). Please make check payable to The Center for American and International Law. To join ITA using a credit card, please (a) enroll online at www.cailaw.org/ita/join, or (b) fax this application to +1.972.244.3401, or (c) call +1.972.244.3400. Page 17 ITAFOR ITA Foro de Arbitraje Latinoamericano ITA Fórum de Arbitragem Latino-americana ITA Latin American Arbitration Forum (ITAFOR) The Institute for Transnational Arbitration (ITA), the Asociación Latinoamericana de Arbitraje (ALARB) and the Comitê Brasileiro de Arbitragem (CBAr) are pleased to introduce the 2017 Moderators and Contributors of ITAFOR, the premier online forum for the arbitration community in Latin America. ITAFOR is a primarily Spanish-Portuguese language listserv designed to facilitate information sharing and discussion on arbitration and ADR topics pertinent to Latin America. Over 500 leading arbitration practitioners subscribe to ITAFOR. As a listserv, it is an easy-to-use medium. Subscribers simply send an email to the listserv address and the message is then automatically sent to all subscribers. Subscriptions are free and open to all who wish to know or discuss the current developments, evolving issues and key practitioners in this growing field of Latin American practice. Learn more and subscribe today at www.cailaw.org/ita-itafor. MODERATORS Fernando Cantuarias Lima, PERU Francisco González de Cossío Mexico City, MEXICO André Albuquerque Abbud São Paulo, BRAZIL Flávio Spaccaquerche Barbosa Rio de Janeiro, BRAZIL Clifford J. Hendel Madrid, SPAIN Elina Mereminskaya Santiago, CHILE Giovanni Ettore Nanni São Paulo, BRAZIL Elsa Ortega Mexico City, MEXICO CONTRIBUTORS Christian Albanesi Paris, FRANCE Cecilia Azar Manzur México City, MEXICO Crina Mihaela Baltag São Paulo, BRAZIL Alfredo Bullard Lima, PERU Cesar Coronel Jones Guayaquil, ECUADOR María Inés Corrá Buenos Aires, ARGENTINA Alfredo De Jesús O. Paris, FRANCE Roy Herrera San Jose, COSTA RICA Sofia Martins Lisbon, PORTUGAL Humberto Sáenz Marinero La Libertad, EL SALVADOR Prof. Katia Fach Gómez Zaragoza, SPAIN Daniel Fabio Jacob Noguerira Manaus, BRAZIL Felipe Moraes São Paulo, BRAZIL Pedro J. Saghy Caracas, D.C., VENEZUELA Dámaso Riaño Madrid, SPAIN María del Pilar Vásquez Yanis Panama City, PANAMA Carlos Suplicy Forbes São Paulo, BRAZIL Federico Godoy Buenos Aires, ARGENTINA Montserrat Manzano Mexico City, MEXICO Juan Manuel Marchán Quito, ECUADOR Rafael Rincón Bogotá, COLOMBIA Alberto Zuleta-Londoño Bogotá, D.C., COLOMBIA Roger Rubio Guerrero Lima, PERU Filipe Greco De Marco Leite Belo Horizonte, BRAZIL COUNCIL MEMBERS José Astigarraga Miami, Florida, USA Eduardo Damião Gonçalves São Paulo, BRAZIL Abby Cohen Smutny Washington, D.C., USA David B. Winn Plano, Texas, USA Flávia Bittar Neves Belo Horizonte, BRAZIL Andrés Jana L. Santiago, CHILE Guido Tawil Buenos Aires, ARGENTINA Eduardo Zuleta Bogotá, COLOMBIA FOUNDING INSTITUTIONAL CONTRIBUTORS Cámara Nacional de Comercio de la Ciudad de México, Comisión de Mediación y Arbitraje Comercial (CANACO) Centro de Arbitragem da Amcham Brasil (Amcham Brasil) Centro de Arbitragem e Mediação Câmara de Comércio Brasil Canadá (CAM-CCBC) Centro de Arbitraje y Conciliación de la Cámara de Comercio de Bogotá (CCB) Centro de Conciliación y Arbitraje Nacional e Internacional de la Cámara de Comercio de Lima (CCL - Arbitraje) Process 561 cvc Process 576 cvc Learn More and Subscribe at www.cailaw.org/ita-itafor ITA is an Institute of KluwerArbitration.com The leading online service for international arbitration Subscribe to the ITA Arbitration Report for free: The ITA Arbitration Report is a free email subscription service available at KluwerArbitration.com. Subscribers receive periodic concise updates on awards, cases and other current developments from over 60 countries and international arbitration organizations, prepared by the ITA Board of Reporters and organized by country. Also reported are new treaty ratifications, new publications and upcoming events around the globe. Subscribe for free at www.KluwerArbitration.com. No other resource comes close to providing the breadth and depth of KluwerArbitration.com With a subscription you gain access to a wealth of materials including: An essential arbitration library that encompasses over 100 authoritative books and journals Over 6,800 court decisions and over 1,900 arbitral awards Full text of more than 1,800 BITs, with signature and entry into force dates Over 500 laws for key jurisdictions Rules for over 400 major institutions Current developments, news and opinion from the ITA Arbitration Report and the KluwerArbitrationBlog.com Plus time saving practice tools to help make your research fast and efficient. These include: 5 Question and Answer comparative Smart Charts edited by Clifford Chance LLP that allow you to quickly compare specific arbitration topics by jurisdiction or institution. The Smart Charts include: Appointment and Challenge of Arbitrators: Confidentiality: Drafting Arbitration Agreements: Sovereign Immunity and Arbitral Institutions. IAI Arbitrator Tool developed in conjunction with the International Arbitration Institute which allows you to compare and select over 500 arbitration experts by specific criteria including language and expertise. Please visit www.KluwerArbitration.com for more information. Partners ICCA INTERNATIONAL C OUNCIL FOR COMMERCIAL ARBITRATI ON Announcing the ITA Online Education Library www.cailaw.org/Institute-for-Transnational-Arbitration/onlineeducation/index.html Combining mock scenes with expert commentary by the world’s elite international arbitrators and advocates As many as 13.0 participatory CLE credit hours for as little as $88 per person (including 1.5 credit hours of ethics) 2-for-1 Pricing and Steep Discounts for Multiple Viewers Save 30% this month (June) on all programs Promo Code: ITA30 | Valid through June 30, 2017 Preserving Perspectives: International Arbitrators in Their Own Words (available free for online viewing) A series of recorded interviews with key figures under the ITA Academic Council’s ongoing Preserving Perspectives oral history project to record the evolution of modern international arbitration in the words of those who have led it. The Practice of International Commercial Arbitration: Beginning, Middle and End (available for on demand online viewing or on USB) This 3-Part Set of video programs is designed to demonstrate and explain the beginning, middle and end stages of an international commercial arbitration with mock scenes, expert commentaries, study guides by Prof. Christopher Gibson and other supporting materials. Purchase the entire 3-Part Set (online or USB), or each Part individually (online or USB), or each Act individually (online only). Workshops on DVD Scenes from a mock international arbitration with expert commentaries, study guides by Prof. David Caron and other supporting materials: | Investment Treaty Arbitration in the 21st Century (2 DVD set) | Arbitral Advocacy (4 DVD set) | International Commercial Arbitration (6 DVD set) Restating the US Law of International Commercial Arbitration: “Between the “Domestic” and the “International”” (available for on demand online viewing) RECORDED WEBINAR The restatement of the US Law of International Commercial Arbitration is well on the road. Two chapters have been approved and are official. One is before the advisory committee at this time. And there remain two to go. ITA is an Institute of
© Copyright 2024 Paperzz