Lesson Plan Causes of the Civil War: The Role of Westward Expansion and the Abolition Movement in the 1850s Winner: 2nd place, 2012 Civil War in Art Lesson Plan Contest Author: John P. Duckhorn, Eisenhower High, Blue Island Illinois Grades/Subject: 10-12, Social Studies Schedule: 2-3 class periods, 50 minutes in length Lesson Summary: This lesson is intended to follow lessons on Westward Expansion. It engages students in the analytical study of the causes of the Civil War through the use of art. The lesson begins with Western expansion and the issues that arose from the country’s excitement over the potential for economic prosperity in the West. The lesson then focuses on the demand for slavery in the cotton industry in the South, discussing how the future of slavery in the West was a major economic concern amongst Southerners. The lesson concludes with the violent events involving John Brown and the struggle between pro- and anti-slavery citizens in Kansas. Artworks on Which Lesson is Based: Image 1 William S. Jewett The Promised Land—The Grayson Family, 1850 Oil on Canvas 50 ¾ x 64 in. Terra Foundation for American Art, Daniel J. Terra Foundation Collection 1999.79 Image 2 A. Hill Cotton Pressing in Louisiana, 1856 Ballou’s Magazine, April 12, 1856 Wood engraving from sketches Chicago History Museum ICHi-52448 Image 3 Edward Atkinson (1827–1905) The Cotton Kingdom, 1863 Map 42 x 37 cm Newberry Library, H 42 .052 Image 4 (optional) Samuel Colman, Jr. (1832–1920) Ships Unloading, New York, 1868 Oil on canvas mounted on board 41 5/16 x 29 15/16 in. Terra Foundation for American Art, Daniel J. Terra Collection, 1984.4 2 Image 5 John Steuart Curry (1897–1946) John Brown, 1939 Lithograph on off-white wove paper 14 ¾ x10 7/8 in. Terra Foundation for American Art, Daniel J. Terra Collection 1995.30 Image 6 Martin L. Lawrence (photographer), (1808–1859) The Harper's Ferry Insurrection [John Brown, Now Under Sentence of Death for Treason and Murder, at Charleston, VA.], November 18, 1859 Engraving from photograph Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper. No. 207 Vol. 8, page 383 Newberry Library, Oversize A 5 .34 Vol. 8 Big or Main Ideas Students Will Understand: • • • How did America’s expansion westward serve as a cause for the Civil War? How did the cotton industry encourage the growth of slavery in America? How was radical abolition viewed by the white public during the 1850’s? 3 National Standards and Lesson-Specific Objectives: National Center for History in Schools U. S. History Content Standard 1: The causes of the Civil War. Objectives—Students will… Identify and explain the economic, social, and cultural differences between the North and the South. Era 5, Standard 1A: The student understands how the North and South differed and how politics and ideologies led to the Civil War. Explain how events after the Compromise of 1850 and the Dred Scott decision in 1857 contributed to increasing sectional polarization. Historical Thinking Standard 3 The student engages in historical analysis and interpretation. Analyze cause-and-effect relationships bearing in mind multiple causation including: (a) the importance of the individual in history; (b) the influence of ideas, human interests, and beliefs; and (c) the role of chance, the accidental and the irrational. Explain the causes of the Civil War and evaluate the importance of slavery as a principal cause of the conflict. Vocabulary Students Will Learn: See Civil War in Art Glossary, http://www.civilwarinart.org/glossary for definitions and information. History terms: Art terms: • • • • • • • • • • • • • Abolition John Brown Cotton Deep South Free Labor Free Soil Harpers Ferry Popular Sovereignty Sectionalism Slavery Staple Crop Symbolism Lithograph Key Information for Understanding the Artworks: About the Time Period • Westward Expansion brought excitement nationally about the potential for economic growth in the West. Citizens migrated from both the North and the South to the Kansas territory. With territories left to decide on their own through the popular vote whether to enter the Union as a Free or Slave state, the potential for political conflict was high. Source: Civil War in Art Website, http://www.civilwarinart.org/items/show/97 4 • Cotton had become “king” in the South by the 1850s. Though cotton was important to the industrial North, slavery, a key part of the labor force on Southern plantations, was looked upon as an evil by some Northern reformers: “That COTTON WAS KING was now well understood in the south. It became the foundation of southern economy, southern culture, and southern pride.” Slavery was central to that foundation and any effort to abolish the peculiar institution would be of great concern to white Southerners. Source: US History.org website: http://www.ushistory.org/us/27a.asp • John Brown and the events surrounding Bleeding Kansas exemplified how Western Expansion and economic concerns fueled the tensions that led to the Civil War. There was tension between pro-slavery activists and abolitionists and tension between Free Soil settlers and plantation owners. The bloody conflict out West rolled over to Washington, D.C., where a physical altercation occurred in the Senate during debates about whether Kansas should be admitted to the Union as a slave state or a free state. (South Carolina Congressman Preston Brooks savagely beat Massachusetts Senator Charles Sumner with a cane after Sumner delivered a scathing anti-slavery speech.) Source: PBS website: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/aia/part4/4p2952.html About the Artwork Image 1: The Promised Land—The Grayson Family, 1850 Painted eleven years before the start of the Civil War, this painting speaks to the concept of Manifest Destiny. It shows the abundant land and resources that drew families like the Graysons, depicted here with their land, to the West. The Graysons were wealthy pioneers to California. The promise of land and wealth led legislators to debate whether slavery should be allowed to spread into the Western territories and ultimately led to conflict. Source: Civil War in Art website http://www.civilwarinart.org/items/show/97 Image 2: Cotton Pressing in Louisiana, 1856 This image depicts cotton pressing, a step in the process of preparing cotton for sale. It illustrates how slave labor was integral to the manually-intensive process of growing cotton. After cotton was planted, tended, and picked, a machine called a cotton gin was used to separate the fluffy fibers from the seeds. The enslaved men working at the cart on the left move cotton into the press. At the right, they walk in a circle pushing a lever, providing power to the press. Innovations like the gin and press, along with the cheapness of slave labor, enabled some white Southerners to become incredibly wealthy. Source: Civil War and Art website: http://www.civilwarinart.org/items/show/67 Image 3: The Cotton Kingdom, 1863 In this 1863 map, abolitionist and businessman Edward Atkinson makes an economic argument (rather than a moral argument) about slavery. He argues that the end of slavery would boost the Southern economy rather than harm it. Using statistics, he 5 counters the argument that cotton planters could not pay their workers and still profit from cotton. Source: Civil war and Art website: http://www.civilwarinart.org/items/show/22 Image 4: Ships Unloading, New York, 1868 (optional) Highlighting free-labor, post-war cotton, this image illustrates how cotton was a vital commodity not only to the American South, but also to merchants in New York and other Northern cities that sold the cotton to Great Britain and other destinations. This ship, the Glad Tidings, was known to have carried free-labor cotton during the Civil War. The painting reinforces the vital role of cotton in the global economy. Source: Civil War and Art Website: http://www.civilwarinart.org/items/show/95 Image 5: John Brown, 1939 This image of passionate abolitionist John Brown captures both his fury over slavery and the controversy that surrounded him as a public figure. Created in 1939 by Kansas artist John Steuart Curry, the image is suggestive of Brown’s capacity for violence in service of his ideals and also positions Brown as a martyr to the antislavery cause. It also illuminates Brown’s bloody role in the history of the Kansas territory. Created 74 years after the end of the Civil War, the lithograph also draws symbolic connections between John Brown’s violent actions and the violent Civil War that began less than two years after his execution. Source: Civil War and Art website: http://www.civilwarinart.org/items/show/96 Image 6: The Harper's Ferry Insurrection [John Brown, Now Under Sentence of Death for Treason and Murder, at Charleston, VA.], November 18, 1859 Abolitionist leader John Brown was depicted on the front page of Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper, a widely read source of news during the Civil War, after being convicted of treason. Brown led an attack on the Federal Armory at Harpers Ferry, Virginia in 1859, with the intent of arming a slave rebellion. Brown was executed for this attack, but it made him a martyr to many involved in the anti-slavery movement in the American North. The portrait was copied by an engraver after a photograph of Brown by Martin M. Lawrence, a well-known photographer. Source: Civil War and Art Website: http://www.civilwarinart.org/items/show/14 About the Artists Biographies below are from the Civil War in Art glossary: http://www.civilwarinart.org/glossary Image 1: William S. Jewett (1821—1873): American painter who focused on portraits, landscapes, and genre paintings (scenes of everyday life). Jewett became one of California’s leading artists. Image 2: A. Hill (active, 19th Century): Lithographer who created images for Ballou’s Magazine, a nineteenth-century periodical published in Boston, Massachusetts. Image 3: Edward Atkinson (1827—1905): American political leader and economist who began his political career as a Republican supporter of the Free Soil movement. Atkinson fought slavery before the Civil War by helping escaped slaves and raising money for John Brown. 6 Image 4: Samuel Colman, Jr. (1832—1920): American landscape painter influenced by the Hudson River school, America’s first native landscape painting movement. Image 5: John Steuart Curry (1897—1946): American artist who created paintings, prints, drawings, and murals, that portrayed the American rural heartland as a wellspring of national identity. A Kansas native, Curry made several decorative mural commissions and Kansas scenes, including a large mural depicting John Brown at the Kansas statehouse. The designs proved controversial because they included what many Kansans regarded as unflattering depictions of their state. Image 6: Frank Leslie’s Illustrated Newspaper: Popular publication during the Civil War that featured fiction, news, and illustrations of battlefield life. Frank Leslie is the pseudonym (fake name) adopted by English illustrator and newspaper editor Henry Carter. Carter worked for the Illustrated London News and circus man P. T. Barnum before moving to America and founding his first publication using the name Frank Leslie. Resources and Materials Needed for Lesson: • • • • Copies of documents inserted inside manila folders Overhead projector (optional) to project documents on screen or dry erase board* Analysis worksheets Handouts *If you have the capability to project your documents on the dry-erase board in the front of your classroom, this often enhances participation by enabling the students to approach the board and interact with the picture/photo by underlining or circling points of interest. Classroom Activities Aligned with Standards and Objectives: Day 1 Objective: To review the reasons for America’s Expansion Westward and the impact that they had in causing the Civil War Set Up: 1. Students can be placed in groups. 2. Copies of Image 1 (William S. Jewett’s painting The Promised Land—The Grayson Family, 1850) should be passed out to each student/group. 3. Image 1 should be projected by going to http://www.civilwarinart.org/items/show/97. The teacher should model for the students how to interactively navigate by clicking on images to enlarge, zoom, and scan them left, right, up, and down. Process: 1. Unveil Image 1 and allow students to observe silently for 1 minute. 2. Open discussion and analysis of image: • What do you notice about the people depicted here? • What are they or have they been doing? What do you see that makes you say that? • What do the objects in the painting suggest? • Notice the clothing. Is this the kind of clothing you would expect people to wear in the wilderness, or does it seem fancier? • What direction are they heading in? How can you tell? • Notice the setting and the background. Where might this place be? • The painting is titled “The Promised Land”. Is that idea represented in the painting? What makes you say so? • What time period is depicted in the painting? How can you tell? 7 3. Review Westward Expansion themes and events that were covered in previous unit with focus on economic opportunity. 4. Background of Image 1 and 1850’s American History: Inform the class about the background of the painting emphasizing the year it was painted, why this family (and other families) moved West, and the idea that the West could make you wealthy. Ask: • Are there any clues in the painting that signal their prosperity (i.e. dress or poses)? • This painting was commissioned by Mr. Grayson four years after his family made their westward journey. What do you think the artist and Mr. Grayson wanted this painting to communicate? • What can we assume about the financial stature of someone who commissions an artist to paint his or her picture? 5. Discuss what was going on in America in the 1850s. http://www.civilwarinart.org/exhibits/show/causes/introduction/introduction • Compromise of 1850 • Henry Clay’s Compromise Measures of 1850 http://www.nationalcenter.org/CalhounClayCompromise.html • Uncle Tom’s Cabin (1852) • Kansas Nebraska Act (1856) 6. Predictions: Ask the students to predict any future problems that might arise from America’s expansion westward. • Where did most people live before they moved West? Could the issue of slavery bring about similar conflicts in the West as it did back East? • Could those who were in favor of slavery and those who opposed it become more hostile towards each as they attempted to coexist in the same territories, such as Kansas? • What do you think happened when those who favored slavery and those who opposed slavery attempted to coexist? Day 2 Objective: To understand the economic role that the cotton industry had in causing the Civil War. Set Up: 1. Copies of Image 2 (A. Hill’s print Cotton Pressing in Louisiana, 1856) should be passed out to each student or computers may be used to analyze the image by going to http://www.civilwarinart.org/items/show/67. 2. Copies of Image Analysis Worksheet: Cotton Pressing in Louisiana 3. Copies of (or web access to) Image 3 (Edward Atkinson’s map The Cotton Kingdom, 1863) 4. Copies of reading “The Peculiar Institution: The Crowning of King Cotton” http://www.ushistory.org/us/27a.asp. 5. (Optional) copies or web access to Image 4 (Samuel Colman Jr.’s painting Ships Unloading, New York, 1868), if using. Process: 1. (Optional) This activity can be opened with discussion on the economy and how economic factors often influence one’s political beliefs. (5 minutes) 2. Unveil Image 2 and allow students to observe silently for 1 minute. 3. Pass out Image 2 analysis worksheet and allow students10–12 minutes to answer questions. This can be done individually or with partners. 8 4. If computers are available, students may interactively use the map titled “The United States of America on the Eve of the Civil War” (http://www.civilwarinart.org/items/show/152) to better answer questions about Place. The map can also be projected on an overhead to enhance class discussion. Class discussion: • Time—Based on the evidence of slavery in the engraving students should plot their answers prior to the Civil War but sometime after the first industrial revolution. • People—The ratio of workers here is 13 slaves: 1 overseer. Students should be able to recognize that out of 14 members of the labor force here, only one person had to be paid, which made slave labor a valuable generator of economic profit. Be sure to stress to the students that in some situations an enslaved person worked with one paid white laborer, in other instances tens of unpaid enslaved laborers worked under the supervision of one paid overseer. The image demonstrates how enslaved labor was the predominant economic model of the American South at this time. • Place—Louisiana’s location, having access to both the Mississippi River and the Gulf of Mexico, made cotton not only a valuable part of the state’s agricultural economy, but also one of its most valuable exports. • Significance—As the cotton industry grew along with the development of technology, so did the demand for slave labor. The cotton industry and the institution of slavery went hand and hand. 5. Pass out reading “The Peculiar Institution: The Crowning of King Cotton” (see sources for web link); however, alternate sources can be used. 6. Class Discussion: Show students the Atkinson map (Image 3). Facilitate a discussion about the belief of the Southerner Atkinson that the economy of the South could benefit through the abolition of slavery. http://www.civilwarinart.org/items/show/22 Another optional point you may want to bring into the discussion is how textile mills in both the American North and the free nation of England relied on cotton from the South to employ their white workers—it complicates the discussion of slavery even further. Have students closely examine the painting Ships Unloading, New York, by Samuel Colman Jr. (Image 4). The image shows huge ships unloading giant bales of cotton in the North. The painting was created after the conclusion of the Civil War in 1868, so the cotton depicted was made by free labor. Yet the painting can be used to discuss the scale of the cotton economy and how cotton produced with slave labor was intertwined with the Northern and global economies before the war as well. Be sure to zoom in and bring attention to the fact that the men working with the cotton bales in North are white. http://www.civilwarinart.org/items/show/95 7. Assign Journal Entry. Assessment: Journal Entry: Based on what you’ve learned from these images, how valuable was the cotton industry in America? Explain the different ways in which the North and the South benefitted economically from the cotton industry. Day 3 Objective: To understand how Westward Expansion and economic potential led to violent tension between pro-slavery and antislavery citizens. Set Up: 1. Copies of Image 5 (John Steuart Curry’s lithograph John Brown, 1939) should be passed out to each student or computers may be used to analyze the image. 2. Copies of Image Analysis Worksheet: John Brown 9 3. Copies of Assessment Activity: Newspaper Headlines worksheet. Process: 1. Discuss what symbolism is and how it can be used by an artist. 2. Discuss how people in history can be viewed both as villains and heroes. Anticipatory Hook: List at least one historical figure who was viewed as a villain by one group and a hero by another. (5 Minutes) 3. Unveil Image 5 and allow students to observe silently for 1 minute. 4. Have students circle and number 3 details in the image that spark their curiosity. 5. Pass out the Image Analysis Worksheet and allow students10–12 minutes to answer questions. This can be done individually or with partners. 6. Class Discussion • What details did you circle and why? What message was the artist trying to convey? • How does the artist convey a sense of violence in his image? • How does the artist use symbolism in the lithograph? • Location: What features in the print gives a sense of the geographical location? What location might that be? o Covered wagons moving to the left in the image background should lead the students to the region of the West. o Students might narrow the location answers to Kansas if they know who John Brown is prior to this lesson. • Time: Students should use evidence of covered wagons and the suggestion of slavery to narrow their answers about the time period depicted to the era of Expansion Westward and pre Civil War. If they have knowledge of John Brown, students may narrow their answers further to the period of Bleeding Kansas. • Who: Depending on students’ prior knowledge of John Brown, your approach to this lesson can vary. 1. If students are familiar with John Brown, continue the discussion by reviewing the events of Bleeding Kansas and Harpers Ferry. For additional reading students can be assigned the source below. 2. If students have not been introduced to John Brown, you can use this part of the lesson to introduce these events. A. Prior to passing out Image Analysis Worksheet: John Brown, fold it just below the Time and above the Who sections. B. John Brown can be introduced through lecture, class discussion, or outside reading. Teachers can use the following resources or another on John Brown. • Image 6 (Frank Leslie’s Illustrated Newspaper’s The Harper's Ferry Insurrection [John Brown, Now Under Sentence of Death for Treason and Murder, at Charleston, VA.], November 18, 1859) http://www.civilwarinart.org/items/show/14 • Bordewich, Fergus M. “John Brown’s Day of Reckoning: The abolitionist’s bloody raid on a federal arsenal at Harpers Ferry 150 years ago set the state for the Civil War.” Smithsonian magazine, October 2009. Smithsonianmag.com, July 29th, 2012. http://www.smithsonianmag.com/history-archaeology/Day-ofReckoning.html • Kansas Historical Society, “Bleeding Kansas”, September 2011, Kansas Historical Society Website December 28th 2012. http://www.kshs.org/kansapedia/bleeding-kansas/15145 10 • • Main Idea: Knowledge of John Brown and his arrival in 1855, the use of symbolism, and specific detail will stimulate some excellent discussion about what the artist wanted to say about the events in Kansas in 1856. Villain or Hero: Discussion on whether the artist depicts John Brown as a villain or hero can lead to a discussion about how John Brown was actually viewed by the whites in the South and North in 1856. Be sure to inform students about Northerners’ varied opinions about Brown during this period and how many whites viewed Brown’s actions in Kansas as acts of violence as opposed to acts of heroism. Students can also benefit in knowing that opinions of John Brown in the North changed as time progressed. (John Steuart Curry made this lithograph from a drawing in 1939. Around that time he was commissioned to paint murals representing Kansas history in the Kansas State House. In one of the murals he included a similar image of Brown, which became very controversial. Many Kansans did not feel that John Brown was an appropriate symbol for the state.) Assessment: 1. Pass out copies of the Assessment Activity: Newspaper Headlines worksheet. Students are to write three headlines to newspaper articles that discuss the events of John Brown in Kansas. Each newspaper headline should reflect the attitudes of its geographic region and the issue an author in that region might want to highlight. Resources Bordewich, Fergus M. “John Brown’s Day of Reckoning: The abolitionist’s bloody raid on a federal arsenal at Harpers Ferry 150 years ago set the state for the Civil War.” Smithsonian magazine, October 2009. Smithsonianmag.com, July 29th, 2012. http://www.smithsonianmag.com/history-archaeology/Day-of-Reckoning.html “Growth and Entrenchment of Slavery”: Public Broadcasting Station PBS.org Website: July 29th 2012. http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/aia/part3/3narr6.html “The Peculiar Institution: The Crowning of King Cotton” US History: Pre Columbian to the New Millennium. US History.org website: http://www.ushistory.org/us/27a.asp Glaser, Leah S. “United States Expansion 1800—1860.” Virginia Center for Digital History Miller Center of Public Affairs, A Guide to Primary Resources http://www.vcdh.virginia.edu/solguide/VUS06/essay06a.html “People & Events Bleeding Kansas 1853 –1861”: Public Broadcasting Station PBS.org Website. August 13th, 2012. http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/aia/part4/4p2952.html Rothman, Adam. Slave Country: American Expansion and the Origins of the Deep South. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press, 2005. “Bleeding Kansas”: Kansas Historical Society, September 2011, Kansas Historical Society Website. December 28th 2012. http://www.kshs.org/kansapedia/bleeding- kansas/15145 11 Image Analysis Worksheet: Cotton Pressing in Louisiana Time: Can you make an educated guess about what year this engraving was made? What within the image helped you make that decision? Year: Explanation: People: Compare the action of the white man with that of the black men. What does his body language communicate? Who is doing the labor? What is the ratio of black to white men in the engraving and why might this be important? Ratio ____(white):____(black) Explanation: (over) 12 Place/Location: The title “Cotton Pressing in Louisiana” indicates the location of the image. Is there anything in the image that hints at the size of the cotton industry there? Explanation: How might have cotton been particularly valuable to the Louisiana economy? Consider the geographical location of the state on the map below: Explanation: Purpose: Why do you believe the artist focused so much attention on the pressing of cotton in the engraving? Explanation: Significance: How did the industrialization of cotton and the cotton gin impact the institution of slavery in the American South? Use information gathered from your previous questions to inform your answer. Explanation: 13 Image Analysis Worksheet: John Brown What details do you see in this print that could be symbolic? What message was the artist trying to convey with his choice of symbolism in this image? Detail 1 Detail 2 Detail 3 Location: What features in the image give us a sense of the geographical location the artist wanted to depict, and what location is that? Location: Explanation: Time: What time period is depicted in this print? How do you know? Time: Explanation: Who: Who is the focal point of the print? What was he known for and what details in the image lead us to these answers? Who: Explanation: (over) 14 Main Idea: What event was the artist trying to represent? What message was he trying to convey about John Brown and his actions prior the Civil War? Event: Message: Do you think the artist depicts John Brown as a villain or a hero? Why? Circle One: Villain or Hero Explanation: 15 Assessment Activity: Newspaper Headlines Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper The Harper's Ferry Insurrection [John Brown, Now Under Sentence of Death for Treason and Murder, at Charleston, VA.] November 19, 1859 The Newberry Library *article reflecting John Browns Actions after Harpers Ferry Directions: Write three headlines for articles in different newspapers that discuss the actions of John Brown in Kansas, 1856. Each headline should reflect the prevailing point of view present in the region where each newspaper was published. Make sure the headline aligns with the view that each publication wants to highlight. Each headline should include one sub headline that elaborates on the topic of the article. Choose three from the following: Newspaper: Lawrence Kansas Daily News (Abolitionist News Paper) Headline: ___________________________________________________________________________ Sub headline: _______________________________________________________________________ Newspaper: Franklin County, Kansas Tribune (Pro Slavery Paper) Headline: ___________________________________________________________________________ Sub headline: _______________________________________________________________________ Newspaper: Charleston South Carolina Gazette (Cotton Industry) Headline: ___________________________________________________________________________ Sub headline: _______________________________________________________________________ Newspaper: Chicago News Herald (Political Tension) Headline: ___________________________________________________________________________ Sub headline: _______________________________________________________________________ Newspaper: St. Louis Post (Western Expansion) Headline: ___________________________________________________________________________ Sub headline: _______________________________________________________________________ 16 Examples of Student Work
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz