How did World War One affect the lives of people in Britain? A project designed and delivered by Ditton Park Academy and Wexham School in partnership with the Maidenhead Heritage to develop knowledge and understanding of World War One for mixed ability Year 7 and Year 9 students. Project report by: Karl Fenn, Classroom Leader of History, Slough Paulina O’Neill, Classroom Leader of Humanities, Slough Virginia Jenner, Head of Education, Maidenhead Heritage Centre, Maidenhead This project undertaken as part of Stronger Together, a regional partnership development project for Museum Learning in secondary schools led by the River & Rowing Museum and The Langley Academy Stronger Together Project supported by a major grant from: “Museum learning means involving ourselves with our rich and diverse heritage in enriching and transformational experiences. Museum learning provides distinctive opportunities for learning. Museum learning can transform our lives and should be accessible, relevant and enjoyable to everyone.”- Student from Wexham School ‘This project has enriched its participants. It is clear that a love of learning was developed whilst taking part in this project, a love which soon transmitted into the classroom. The students have developed a series of key skills that they can use across the curriculum over their remaining time in school. Museum learning has allowed are students to be critical thinkers who thrive when undertaking an enquiry. The questions they realised after each session is testament to just how much of an impact their curiosity had on their enjoyment and engagement.’- Ditton Park Academy 2 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? CONTENTS 1. Executive summary 2. Introduction and context 3. Planning the project 4. Delivering the project 5. Impact on students of participating in the project 6. Impact project managers of running the project 7. Impact of the project for Ditton Park Academy, Wexham School and Maidenhead Heritage Centre 8. Conclusion and key learnings 9. Appendices 3 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? 1. Executive summary About the project The aim of our project was to deepen pupils’ understanding of the First World War through the use of objects from the Maidenhead Heritage Centre. The project was delivered at Ditton Park Academy and Wexham School. Our unit focused on a central question ‘How did the First World War affect the lives of people in Britain?’ Both Ditton Park Academy and Wexham School visited the Maidenhead Heritage Centre with students participating in the project to spark their curiosity. In each lesson or extra-curricular meeting students used information and objects to answer our central question. At the end of the unit students created a museum workshop and was assisted by Virginia and Brian from the Maidenhead Heritage Centre. Students also wrote an evaluation to see how much progress they had made in the unit. Impact of the project on participants, project managers and supporting organisations At Ditton Park Academy the average level improved way above what was expected and the majority of the project participants are currently working above their end of year target grade, in part as a result of their participation in this project. In addition, Year 7 students demonstrated that, providing work is sufficiently challenging and stimulating, they can work as well independently and collaboratively as GCSE students. The project participants frequently worked together in groups to solve mysteries or problems. In addition, they developed their investigative skills by developing the ability to ask questions and then discuss potential answers with peers, before going home to independently research something. From the evaluation at Wexham School it is clear that many students did make progress during the unit. The amount of students who are below target reduced from 88% of the class to 63% of the class showing that many students did improve their level. I decided to look at how many students made progress and how their progress improved from their first assessment 38% of students improved their progress by one sublevel and 29% of students improved their progress by two sub levels. The majority of students from Ditton Park Academy and Wexham School responded well to the localized history of Maidenhead stating they felt a connection to a person or place they learned about in Maidenhead through the artefacts they used. Conclusion and key learnings Museum learning has had a positive impact on project managers. Museum learning is a name for good teaching practice. Museums and schools can form stronger partnerships to deliver a more customized learning experience for pupils. It can focus on local history, which our students enjoyed. Through stronger partnerships between schools and museums there can be newer and more innovative ways to incorporate museum learning that doesn’t involve a traditional class trip. It can involve museum visits to the schools and loan boxes of artefacts to improve student engagement. 4 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? 2. Introduction and context About the Stronger Together project “How did the First World War affect the lives of people in Britain?” was part of a wider regional project to enable museums and schools to collaborate in developing and delivering museum learning partnership projects. The umbrella project, Stronger Together, was set up and run by The River & Rowing Museum and The Langley Academy and funded by a major grant from Arts Council England. The purpose of the Stronger Together project is to understand how the Museum Learning developed at The Langley Academy can be replicated in other contexts. At the core of this project are 30 bursaries for museum and education professionals from across the Berkshire, Buckinghamshire and Oxfordshire region. The grant has been primarily awarded on the basis of the project’s potential to shape how the museum sector understands secondary education. About Ditton Park Academy, Wexham School and Maidenhead Heritage Centre and the project managers Ditton Park Academy is a newly established mainstream comprehensive academy in Slough. The school opened in 2014, with just the one cohort, Year 7. There are currently 114 students on roll at the school. The school is a diverse school and reflects local community in school. There are twelve students on free school meals, and 41 students with English as an additional language. Karl Fenn - As Head of Humanities at Ditton Park Academy I was also the Project Lead for the Museum Learning Project. It was my responsibility to plan, deliver and evaluate the sessions. I did this collaboration with the two other people who were part of my project. Wexham School is a slightly smaller-than-average non-selective secondary school with a sixth form in a grammar school area. The proportions of students for whom the school receives pupil premium funding (additional government funding for students known to be eligible for free school meals, those who are looked after by the local authority and the children of services families), and of students eligible for the Year 7 catch-up premium, are well above the national averages. The proportion of disabled students and those with special educational needs supported by school action is above average, as is the proportion supported by school action plus or with a statement of special educational needs. The school currently has a specially resourced provision for 19 students with autism. The provision caters for the same age range as the main school. The majority of students are from minority ethnic backgrounds. About two-thirds of the students have a first language other than English. (Ofsted Report 2013) Paulina O’Neill - I am a Classroom Leader of Humanities and I have worked at Wexham School since September 2013. Staff at Wexham School was informed about the Museum Learning Project and 5 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? was encouraged to apply to participate in the project. I was interested in the project and became a successful candidate. Maidenhead Heritage Centre - Maidenhead Heritage Centre is a non-profit charity that has been celebrating the history of Maidenhead and surrounding villages for over twenty years. The museum is situated just off Maidenhead High Street and is open to the public 5 days a week. The museum is supported by two members of staff and around 70 volunteers, the majority of whom are local retirees. Alongside a permanent free exhibition exploring the history of Maidenhead, the museum also puts on a range of free temporary exhibitions each year and has a dedicated wartime aviation gallery with a Spitfire Simulator. Virginia Jenner - I have been co-ordinating the museum’s schools and families programme on a part-time basis since January 2014. The position of Education and Learning Officer was newly created at this time, and prior to my appointment education was managed on an ad hoc basis by volunteers. Our current schools offer is targeted at primary schools and historically the museum has not had much involvement with local secondary schools. I was keen to apply for this project to develop the museum’s contacts with secondary schools and to discover how our collections could be made relevant to the KS3 curriculum. As a museum we were excited by the opportunity to embark on an extended project that would strengthen our involvement with the community. About the ‘How did the First World War affect the lives of people in Britain?’ project Driver - To deepen pupils’ understanding of the First World War through the use of objects from the Maidenhead Heritage Centre. Activity Summary - Students visited the Maidenhead Heritage Centre at the start of the unit. Throughout the unit students analysed different objects to investigate how people’s lives were affected during The First World War. At the end of the unit students wrote a written evaluation and created a workshop to tell a story about people’s lives during The First World War. The project was delivered from November 3rd to December 19th at Wexham School. Purpose - Students developed their research and analytical skills through the interpretation of different objects from THE FIRST WORLD WAR. Students also thought independently about how people’s lives were affected during THE FIRST WORLD WAR. Project Managers - Helen Cook and Katherine Rose Project Sponsor - Arts Council England End User(s)- Year 7 students from Ditton Park Academy and Year 9 students from Wexham Secondary School. Stakeholder(s)- Maidenhead Heritage Centre, Mary Sparrow, Nick Caulfield, Leaders of Humanities, Leader of History, Subject Leaders and students from Ditton Park Academy and Wexham Secondary School. 6 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? Ditton Park Academy - There were twelve students participating in the project from Ditton Park Academy. This was to be carried out on a Friday afternoon after school, outside of curriculum time. The project was a voluntary one and was open to students from across the ability range. It was supported by parents, who gave their children permission to stay after school every Friday for four months. Pictured below: A group photo of the participants of the project from Ditton Park Academy Wexham School - 28 Year 9 students were part of the Museum Learning Project. Paulina O’Neill is the geography teacher for these students and had to switch teaching them history for a half term for this project. There was a mixture of high, mid and low ability students. The project was delivered for 50 minutes twice a week during their history lessons. Pictured below: A group photo of the participants of the project from Wexham School 7 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? 3. Planning the project Our initial reaction to the pairing, or rather grouping, within the Stronger Together project was one of surprise. Our project was unique when compared to the others, in the sense that we were the only group of three from the entire cohort. To make things more interesting, each of us had proposed projects focusing on completely different areas of study and completely different time periods. A further logistical challenge was presented when it was discovered that the two teachers involved were also going to be delivering this project to different year groups. However, all of these logistical issues were soon resolved. Although none of the partners had particular preconceptions about each other, there was some element of concern on Virginia’s part as to how the museum’s collections could be made relevant to students from Slough. However, she was prepared for this scenario as she had been made aware at the interview stage of the project that no schools from Maidenhead had applied. Finalising the concept of the project was quite easy, and we were left in no doubt that the sum of our final project was far greater than what the project would have been had we pressed ahead with each of our individual aims. Without doubt, our collective planning ensured the delivery of a very successful and enjoyable project. Our final project concept was essentially an amalgamation of the best ideas from each project. Initially the two schools partners had hoped for projects focusing on the medieval period, perhaps tying in with the 800th anniversary of Magna Carta in 2015. However, following initial discussions Virginia had to admit that the museum would struggle to support this idea based on its collections. She was also concerned that this would draw focus away from Maidenhead, which would be detrimental to the long-term usefulness of the project to the Heritage Centre. As an alternative, Virginia suggested a project focusing on the First World War to tie in with the 1914-1918 Centenary. At this time Virginia was heavily involved with preparations for a major First World War exhibition at the Heritage Centre, meaning greater resources and expertise could be offered to support the project. Although this worked out to be a successful compromise, initially Virginia was concerned about the ramifications of the shift in focus from the World War Two aviation project the Heritage Centre had proposed during the application process for the project. We decided to measure the impact this project had on the students academically by combining the ideas from the teachers of Wexham Park School and Ditton Park Academy. This involved setting the students an essay at the end of the project, as well as having the students themselves work together and deliver a First World War exhibition to other students. Deciding on the project objectives was a very straightforward process. The three of us met very early on (July 2014) at Maidenhead Heritage Centre. During this meeting we physically looked at the objects available to us and discussed ways we could build and enquiry around these objects which would stimulate curiosity and deepen learning. An important focus of the meeting was matching artefacts from the museum’s collections to anticipated curriculum topics. This was more of a concern for Paulina, as Karl’s group would be involved with the project as an extra-curricular activity. The two teachers involved then discussed a potential scheme of work based around these objects. We decided each individual session was going to have smaller objectives, based on 8 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? blooms’ taxonomy, but that the overall aim of the project was going to be: ‘To what extent were peoples’ lives on the Home Front affected by the outbreak of the First World War’. Following on from this meeting we shared regular and constant emails, which always had a different focus. Early on, these emails tended to focus on the creation and implementation of a scheme of work. Once the students started school in September, the three of us again met to put dates in diaries for the visit/s of our students to the Maidenhead Heritage Centre. As part of our project, we were also fortunate to have a member of staff from the Maidenhead Heritage Centre visit each of our individual schools to deliver a workshop to our students, with great success. The obvious challenge was not only working as a three, but also the aspect of two teachers delivering the project to two different year groups posed a challenge. Email exchanges proved the most effective way to stay in touch with each other and make plans during this stage, as it ensured the same information was sent to all parties and enabled group discussions. The planning stage would have been much more tricky to manage, particularly from Virginia’s perspective, if she had been communicating separately with each teacher, for example via phone. Meetings were held with appropriate staff members within our own school to deliver the project. The trip to the museum needed to be approved by our line managers and they were also kept up to date with the progress of the planning of the project. Another aspect of our planning process that was perhaps more difficult for us than for other groups has been finding times in which to meet that suited all three of us. Although both Karl and Paulina work at schools in Slough, we usually met in Windsor, as this was more convenient for getting home afterwards. Although it was a little challenging finding times that suited everyone, especially as Virginia only works in Maidenhead part-time and does not live locally, we were usually successful in arranging meetings as needed. Our initial meeting at the Heritage Centre had allowed us to identify most of the resources we would require for the project in terms of historic artefacts. Virginia was able to advise which artefacts could be loaned to the schools and which could be removed from display for supervised sessions in the classrooms. For Virginia, this process involved an extra logistical challenge, as we wanted both schools to experience the same artefacts as far as possible. Virginia therefore sought to find duplicate artefacts from the museum’s collections. Photographic resources were also shared with the two teachers via Dropbox so that they were available for teaching if desired. In preparation for each class to visit the museum Virginia organised a number of resources, including additional volunteers, a KS3 appropriate quiz and seating. This was a little challenging from the museum’s perspective, as usually primary classes who visit can sit on the floor. Luckily the museum had enough chairs as they run a monthly lecture series, but Virginia had not anticipated how full the main gallery would feel once 30+ chairs had been placed in it! The volunteers Virginia recruited were Beryl (Schools/Front of House volunteer) and Brian (Curator), both of whom had previously worked with school groups at the museum. 9 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? Virginia also identified resources that the museum could supply for workshops carried out either at the museum or in a classroom, e.g. clipboards, speakers etc. On her second visit to Wexham School she spoke to each group of pupils and asked them what they would need to run their workshops, to determine if the museum would need to source extra equipment. For example, some of the groups requested historical costumes. This stage of the project went very well, but it did soon start to feel a little as if the Museum Champion from Maidenhead Heritage Centre was working almost independently, and perhaps even separately, with two individual schools. 10 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? 4. Delivering the project Delivering the project became two separate projects with the Maidenhead Heritage Centre, however, both projects focused on the same objects. Ditton Park Academy and Wexham School visited the Maidenhead Heritage Centre on two separate trips, it was being delivered to two different year groups and it was delivered through extracurricular time at Ditton Park Academy and class time at Wexham School. Project activities Ditton Park Academy - A detailed scheme of work is listed in Appendix D. Wexham School - A detailed scheme of work is listed in Appendix E. The unit began to be delivered the week of November 3rd 2015. The first two lessons focused on background knowledge of the First World War. The students visited Maidenhead Heritage Centre on November 13th for sessions delivered by Virginia Jenner. For the rest of the unit each lesson was focused on a different artefact. The students were asked to explore a key question that related to the artefact. Through these lessons the students deepened their knowledge on how the First World War affected the lives of people in Britain. Maidenhead Heritage Centre - The structure of the museum sessions for Ditton Park Academy and Wexham School are listed in Appendix F and Appendix G. There are pictures of objects used for the project are listed in Appendix H. Following both of the museum workshops Virginia visited both groups at school. Ditton Park Academy I visited the Ditton Park students on a Friday afternoon during their history club. As the students had not been able to see the trench art artefacts at the museum I brought these along to show them for the first part of the session. I then talked the students through the process of making their own workshops, highlighting the main factors they would need to think about and asking them to write down their ideas. I was really pleased that one of the students had brought along his own artefact to show the group, and overall they seemed very excited and I heard some good ideas going around the room. Wexham School I made two visits to Paulina’s class following the museum workshop. During the first visit two students gave me a tour of the school before I entered the classroom ready for their history lesson. During the lesson I ran through the same presentation I had prepared for Ditton Park, asking the students to record their ideas on large pieces of paper as we went through each topic. As Paulina 11 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? wanted her class to compete for the chance to run a workshop, we also tasked the students with getting themselves into teams and coming up with a team name. During the second visit I spoke to each group in turn about their plans and offered advice and suggestions. I was impressed by their ideas and pleased to see that characters like “The Pudding Lady” had resonated from the museum session. Reviewing the activities Ditton Park Academy - There were a huge number of successes that I had not accounted for. As a classroom teacher, I took great pride in seeing an increased and visible level of engagement, passion and enthusiasm from the students involved in the project. Without doubt, this had been sparked by their curiosity following on from the Friday project sessions. Students would come to me on a Monday with floods of voluntary research, facts, ideas and suggestions. Some even went as far as buying replica artefacts and others began pestering parents for trips to the Imperial War Museum. It is testament to the success of the project that I managed to deliver this project outside of curriculum time on a voluntary basis. My students stayed back for one hour every Friday from early September. As can be seen from the data, I feel comfortable in concluding that the students’ level of engagement had a direct impact in lessons. I had not accounted for the improved level of effort I would get from the cohort of students doing the project when setting homework. The standard was visibly higher than other students from the class. This sort of impact is something I have seen very rarely in my teaching career, and I feel privileged to have seen it this year. However, there were of course some challenges. Firstly, being paired with a museum that is a sixtyminute round trip away made visits difficult. This is because it is very difficult to justify more than one trip to the same location when it means taking students out of lessons. When planning the project in the summer, I was not aware of how my new school’s timetable would afford me little flexibility, in the sense that the only days I could realistically take students out were on a Wednesday and on a Friday. Sadly, it was only therefore possible to visit Maidenhead Heritage Centre on a Wednesday, as my Museum partner only worked Monday through to Wednesday at the centre. Another difficulty I had was that I had to deliver the project to the students on a Friday afternoon. Although this wasn’t an issue at first, by the end, at the crucial stage of sessions, increasing numbers of students started to make excuses about issues concerning attendance and even punctuality. Wexham School - Before delivering the activities the history teacher and myself had to switch teaching our subjects. This was a difficult challenge because the students became confused as to why I was delivering the history instead of the geography curriculum. Throughout this process the school was very supportive. My line managers and my co-worker were supportive of the project and knew that this unit would be beneficial to our Year 9 students. Our trip to the Maidenhead Heritage Centre was successful as it engaged the students and sparked their curiosity for the unit. Delivering the project then became difficult in regular lessons. Each lesson was focused on a specific object but for a few weeks there were no objects for delivering the project. I relied on 12 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? primary sources from the internet or pictures of the objects from the museum. Maidenhead Heritage Centre did bring in artefacts to use later on in the delivery of the project. This allowed me to re-focus my lessons on the objects, however, students lost interest because they were working with the same objects that they used during their visit to the museum. It became challenging to keep them focused and engaged in the project. If I were to deliver a museum learning project again it would be in the subject area that I teach my class in because that would avoid disruption and confusion at the start of the project. I would also need to ensure that if we are focusing on object based learning that I have the objects prior to the start of the unit. I would also try to use new objects every lesson to keep students engaged. Overall, the project had a positive impact on their progress, however, they became disengaged near the end of the unit. Maidenhead Heritage Centre Session with Ditton Park Academy The timetable for the session was created with the intention of giving a small snapshot of as many topics as possible, with the idea that these could be expanded out in the classroom as the Friday sessions progressed. However, I quickly realised that the students’ enthusiasm to ask questions meant we were getting behind schedule. I wanted the students to feel that their questions were valued and welcomed rather than shutting this process down. I was also intrigued to discover which aspects of the topic were catching their interest. 13 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? Following the activity with Beatrice and Dolly’s stories, during which both groups chose to give verbal presentations, I realised that we would not have time to complete both the rationing and trench art handling activities. I decided to focus on rationing and then skip to the gallery exploration task. This involved a quiz and postcard writing activity, but as we were very pressed for time the students weren’t able to complete these. Nevertheless, I was glad that the students’ had time to explore the exhibition freely. Session with Wexham School The plan for Wexham’s session varied significantly from the initial workshop with Ditton Park, mainly due to the fact that the group were able to visit for a longer period of time. My main concerns when planning the Wexham visit were the number of students and the fact they were an older year group. This led to some logistical difficulties. Ditton Park’s smaller group were able to sit around a circular table in the gallery, but with 30 students the entire gallery had to be filled with chairs. Luckily we had hosted a lunchtime lecture at the museum that morning so the chairs were already in place, but this did have a major impact on the amount of space available in the gallery. I was a little intimidated about beginning the initial talk, as I was worried about potential behavioural problems or disruptions, as well as simply holding the attention of 30 Year 9s, all of whom were much bigger than me! Similarly to with the Ditton Park group, I tried to keep the 14 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? atmosphere fairly relaxed and informal. I wanted to encourage the students to ask questions and to feel welcomed and valued in the space. Due to the large size of the group I decided to split the class into two smaller groups for the next activities, which were exploring the exhibition and object handling. A downside of this arrangement turned out to be the difficulty of communicating with my volunteer, Beryl, who became frustrated by the students’ attempts to use their iPads to help them research answers to the quiz. While Beryl felt that the iPads were a disruptive influence on the activity, meanwhile I was encouraging students’ in the object-handling group to use Google and their iPad cameras to help them investigate the function and history of the artefacts. I discussed these issues with Beryl at the end of the session, and was concerned that the students’ had been given mixed messages about their iPads. This experience has made me realise that I need to address our attitude to technology like mobile phones/iPads/tablets etc. during training with volunteers. I subtly changed the emphasis of the handling activity to focus on the students’ investigative skills, rather than me feeding them information. I asked the students to work out what the artefacts were used for, who they were used by, etc., and I also included a mystery object – a hot cross bun crosser (Item #1 in Appendix H). I was surprised how difficult the students’ found this latter task, as it had not occurred to me that their diverse cultural backgrounds would mean many of them had never eaten a hot cross bun. Another concern during the object handling was the way in which a minority of students handled artefacts without due care and attention. I saw some postcards being bent by the students’ handling them, no doubt absent-mindedly, but I realised through talking to them about it that they hadn’t appreciated either how old the postcards were, or the fact that they were real, and not replicas. This made me think about how I could reinforce this message in future. The final activity saw a re-vamped version of the postcard activity, which I scheduled a separate timeslot for. I wanted the activity to be more challenging for a KS3 group and so I hit on the idea of giving each student a “character” to write from the perspective of. The “characters” were a mixture of real and imagined people living in Maidenhead in THE FIRST WORLD WAR. I was happy that several of the students’ asked to swap their character, which showed that they were interested and invested in the activity. 15 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? 5. Impact on students of participating in the project Ditton Park Academy Our aim was for students to undertake an enquiry in to the impact the First World War had on people’s lives living on the Home Front. Using blooms, we broken these down by skills (interpret, describe, explain, justify and analyse). As can be seen through looking at the scheme of work, these aims would be met by using artefacts and objects as a basis for the enquiry. Each session contributed towards building up to answering the final question, which was an extended essay question. It is without doubt that these sessions had a great cognitive impact on the students involved. The best way of measuring this impact is to compare the cohort of students involved in the museum learning project against peers from their normal teaching sets, who were not part of the project. One achievement that I thought would be difficult to measure was engagement and enthusiasm. It is hard to prove the look on the faces of students as they handled the objects, or describe the sheer volume of questions they would ask (and often go away and answer for themselves independently. Average H/W grade of project participannts when compared to the average grade of their classmates Above However, the pie chart (left) illustrates just how much more effort they put into all aspects of their History homework. Each of the 12 students achieved a homework effort grade that was at least as good as the rest of their peers from their normal teaching groups. Below Each of the pictures, though hard to validly and truly capture, should serve to illustrate just how enthusisatic the students were as well, as can be seen through the sheer volume of smiles and hands up. Within one term, or two assessment points, it became clear that those students taking part in the museum learning project were making more progress compared to the rest of their class peers from their normal teaching sets. Within these sessions students were able to develop and refine their curriculum skills, which was to have a huge impact in lessons and assessments. Specifially, students learnt to question the provenance of written sources and assess them for utility and reliablkilty. These are skills are techniques that are usually associated with GCSE students. However, though difficult at first, the students proved they were up to the task. Then, during 16 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? normal curriculum time, project students were able to apply these GCSE skills in a different context, with great success. This is why every single student from the project was at least already on their end of year target grade by the December assessment. Pleasingly, a total of eight students were actually already working above their end of year target grade by this point. Clearly other factors played a role, such as natural porgression and understnading, but I am confident this project was one of the leading causes of this rapid amount of progress. These points are illustrated in the table below. The project students are outperforming their peers in both assessments, progress and homework effort levels (with 1 being the highest grade and 4 being the lowest grade). Such has been the extent of progress, I have now extended the project ever so slightly. I have have a total of four out of the twelve students who stay behind every Monday and Tuesday to help support students who are below their current levels of progress in History. These students are able to use their expertise, and theoretically pass it on to others, during these sessions. These sessions would perhaps have not been considered had the project not afforded me the opportunity of seeing just how well some students worked as group leaders. Pre-museum visit survey Which statement do you most agree with? Statement Museums are boring, but you can learn lots from them. Museums are not usually relevant to what I am studying. I would only ever visit a museum on a school trip. Museums are fun and you can learn lots from them. Tally II IIIII IIIII 17 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? Pre-museum visit survey – Additional student comments Statement Learn things from museums They are for old people Not exciting / are boring Generally negative comment Generally positive comment Tally III III IIIIIII IIIIIIIII III Post-museum visit survey Which statement do you most agree with? Statement Museums are boring, but you can learn lots from them. Museums are not usually relevant to what I am studying. I would only ever visit a museum on a school trip. Museums are fun and you can learn lots from them. Tally I I IIIIIIIIII Post-museum visit survey – Additional student comments Statement Learn things from museums They are fun or interesting or cool Generally negative comment Generally positive comment Tally III IIIIIIII 0 IIIIIII In terms of the impact the project had on the students’ views of muesuems, this is perhaps the area where the most drastic change is visible. As can bee seen from the tables below, prior to the trip, the vast majority of students had something negative to say about museums. The students, in their own words, tended to describe museums as boring or not exciting. When given statements to choose from, the majority of students said the museums tended to be a place where they would only visit on a school trip, with some also ticking that mueseums tended to not be relevant to what they are studying at school. However, having visited the museum, student comments completely changed. When choosing from a lsit of statements, all but two students indicated that ‘Museums are fun and you can learn lots from them’. This marks a significant shift from the more negative responses from the pre visit survey. When asked to add their own comments and elaborate, every single student responded with a positive comment. Interestingly, no one student made a negative comment here. As can be seen from the table, the consensus was that museums are fun and lots of information can be taken from them. 18 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? Wexham School Our scheme of work was built around a central question ‘How did the First World War affect the lives of people in Britain?’ Each lesson focused on a different object or topic that helped to answer that central question. At the end of the unit students wrote an extended essay answering this central question. At the start of the delivery of the unit I gave a survey for students to complete. The survey asked students to define museum learning and asked them to describe their knowledge of the First World War. I gave the same survey to the students at the end of the unit to see the changes in their responses. I have included the questions asked and examples of student responses below: Question 1- What does museum learning mean to you? Prior to the Project “Museum learning means to me that you go to a museum and learn about history.” “That you learn about artefacts if it is a museum like the natural history museum.” “You learn while you are walking around the museum.” After the Project “It means learning and having resources to help us learn.” “It means interactive learning and fun.” “Involving ourselves with our rich and diverse heritage in enriching and transformational experiences. Museum learning provides distinctive opportunities for learning. Museum learning can transform our lives and should be accessible, relevant and enjoyable to everyone.” Question 2- From a scale from 1-5 (1 being the most excited) are you excited about the museum learning project? 19 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? Question 3- What can you learn from a source/artefact? Prior to the Project “Information about the history and artists.” “There's more detail and you can see it for yourself.” “You can learn about the conditions that it's was in.” After the Project “I can learn what they used it for and why.” “You can learn about what the place was like (where it originated from) what its importance is and what it resembles.” “We can learn what happened in the past and how they lived.” Question 4- What do you know about the First World War? Prior to the Project “It is a war.” “People died.” “That it was the first war.” After the Project “It was a global war starting in Europe.” “I know that it started because a man was killed and then allies and axis started fighting.” “It started in 1914 and finished in 1918.” Question 5- What were conditions like for soldiers who fought in the First World War? Prior to the Project “It was bad.” “It was disgusting and horrific.” “The conditions were not good.” After the Project “The conditions were bad and people died from diseases from rats in the trenches.” “There was nothing glamorous about trench life. World War 1 trenches were dirty, smelly and riddled with disease. For soldiers life in the trenches meant living in fear. In fear of diseases (like cholera and trench foot) and of course, the constant fear of enemy attack.” “The conditions for soldiers were very bad because they had to sleep and fight in trenches and there were infestations of rats and mice.” Question 6 - What was life like for people who stayed in England during the First World War? Prior to the Project “It was generally peaceful.” After the Project “At the outbreak of war in 1914, the British Army had 700,000 available men. Germany’s wartime army was over 3.7 million. When a campaign for volunteers was launched, thousands answered the call to fight. Among them were 250,000 boys and young men under the age of 19, the legal limit for armed service overseas.” 20 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? “They were in fear of being bombed.” “Poor conditions.” “More women were able to work.” “People had food rationing cards.” The students changed their opinion of what museum learning meant. Most responses prior to the project identified going to a museum whereas after the project there was more of a focus about learning in a fun way and it being a resource. Most students identified that they were excited about the project. Their opinions about artefacts remained similar before and after the project indicating that they understand how to use artefacts to enhance their learning. Their general knowledge of the First World War improved as responses changed from them just knowing it was a war to identifying some causes of the war and the timeline of the war. Their knowledge of the conditions soldiers lived in improved significantly. Overall, their general knowledge of museum learning and the First World War improved and this can be shown through these survey responses. The students also completed a written assessment to see if the knowledge they had gained could translate into students making progress. The students were asked to answer the question ‘How did the First World War affect the lives of people in Britain?’ and draw upon their knowledge from lessons throughout the unit. End of Year Target Grade Term 1 Assessment Museum Learning Test 7c 5a 6c 6b 5c 5a 7c 5a 5a 7c 5a 5a 6c 5b 5c 6c 5c 5c 6b 4a 5c 4b 4b 4a 6b 5b 6c 6c 5c 5a 5a 4c 4a 7c 5a 6c 21 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? 6c 5b 5b 6b 5b 5a 6a 5c 5c 6c 4a 5b 6c 4a 5b 6a 5b 5a 6c 4c 4b 5c 4a 4a 7b 6c 6b 7b 5b 6c 6b 4c 4b 6c 4c 4b 22 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? From the evaluation it is clear that many students did make progress during the unit. The amount of students who are below target reduced from 88% of the class to 63% of the class showing that many students did improve their level. I decided to look at how many students made progress and how their progress improved from their first assessment 38% of students improved their progress by one sublevel and 29% of students improved their progress by two sub levels. This shows that many students were able to make progress during the project. There are 33% of students who did not make progress so it is questionable as to whether this project translates into a student’s ability to translate their knowledge through objects into high order thinking that is needed to achieve higher levels. There are different factors that could influence these results. The data prior to the project is from their original history teacher’s data and I was not their history teacher during that term. It would be 23 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? interesting to see a more sustained long-term impact on student data as the delivery of the project occurred over 7 weeks. Maidenhead Heritage Centre Ditton Park Academy - Enjoyed Enjoyed (9 individual responses) Learning about nurses 2 The quiz 1 The daily mail cookery book 1 The exhibition 2 Looking at artefacts 2 Looking at pictures 1 Everything 1 Learning about rationing 1 "I enjoyed looking at the pictures and the things here" "Learning about Beatrice because she works where my dad lives now" Ditton Park Academy - Inspired Inspired (10 individual responses) To learn more about World War One 5 "I would like to learn more about soldiers" "To research more about World War One instead of World War Two" By the army 3 "To join the army" "To stand up for my country" "This inspired my to never give up like the people of the army" By women in World War One 1 "I am inspired by the fact that women fought for their rights" By the postcards 1 "The postcards inspired me to learn more" 24 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? PARTICIPANTS WERE INSPIRED... An attitude/emoti onal response 40% To learn more 60% Ditton Park Academy - Learnt Learnt (10 individual responses) The short soldiers were called Bantems About Dolly/Beatrice That food was disgusting 6 4 1 Wexham School - Enjoyed Artefacts 7 "I enjoyed handling the objects from World War One" The mystery object 1 “It was fun when we were looking at World War One objects” “I enjoyed feeling the souvenirs” “I enjoyed the hands on action” 2 Learning new facts about World War One 2 “One thing I enjoyed about today was learning about World War One and how it affected people” Doing the quiz 6 Activities 1 Interacting with Brian 2 “I enjoyed sir’s jokes” Writing postcards 3 “I enjoyed the place” 1 The coach 1 Total 26 25 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? PARTICIPANTS' ENJOYED... Interacting with museum staff 5% Learning (inc quiz) 19% Other 5% An activity (quiz/handling/p ostcards) 47% Artefacts 24% Wexham School - Surprised Surprised (18 individual responses) Brian’s facts/jokes 2 That Maidenhead was a safe place during the war 1 “I was surprised by the fact that Maidenhead was a safe haven for civilians” The mystery object 4 “I was surprised that hot-cross buns were individually crossed” “I was surprised when I found out what the mystery item was” “I was surprised by the old things” Artefacts 3 Learning about the poppy appeal 2 “I was surprised by how funny Brian was and by the 2 women who started the poppies” “I was surprised by the nicknames people had – the pudding lady” 1 Rationing 2 “Something that surprised me was that you had to pay for and have rations to buy food.” “The thing that surprised me was they made a pomato” About soldiers 1 “Something that surprised me is how boys WANTED to go to war” 1 “I was surprised by the amount of people that died” 1 “I was surprised that they have a skeleton from a human” 1 Being asked to write feedback 1 Total 18 26 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? PARTICIPANTS' WERE SURPRISED BY... Local facts 16% Artefacts 31% Other 21% General WW1 facts 32% Wexham School - Learnt Learnt (25 individual responses) About World War One “I learned about World War One more than I learned at school” That people only ate hot cross buns at Easter About Beatrice Kay, a nurse at Cliveden “I learnt a lot of things about the nurse” About the Pudding Lady “I learnt quite a lot about the Pudding lady” “I learnt that the Pudding Lady did demonstrations on war cooking” About the woman from Maidenhead who was arrested as a German spy twice About the poppy appeal About World War One artefacts “Hands on action” That the museum exists “I learnt that there is a history museum here” About the struggles of people/conditions of life “I learnt that life was tough in the war” That people were forbidden to talk about the war That Maidenhead was a safe place during the war About soldiers “I learnt that all soldiers slept on the floor except the sergeant” That Tom Ayer was the first person to die “I learnt who Arthur Upson was” Total 5 1 2 2 1 2 2 1 3 1 1 2 1 1 25 27 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? PARTICIPANTS' LEARNT ABOUT... Artefacts 8% Other 4% General WW1 facts 52% Local people & facts 36% Overall Impressions PARTICIPANTS' ENJOYED... Interaction Other 4% 6% Activities 43% Learning 21% Artefacts/collec tion 26% 28 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? PARTICIPANTS LEARNT ABOUT... Other Artefacts 3% 5% General WW1 facts 56% Local people & facts 36% General Observations One of the most unexpected outcomes of the project was how positively the Wexham students would react to the Heritage Centre’s Curator, Brian, who helped out with the museum workshop. Brian represented a different kind of adult to those usually found within the students’ home and school environments. Brian also served in the army in his younger days, meaning he had direct experience to draw from when discussing topics such as the life of a soldier with the group. The class specifically requested that Brian accompany Virginia to the school for her first visit. From the data, we can see that Brian also had a big impact on the Ditton Park group. 6 out of 10 pupils answered that they had learnt about the nickname for short soldiers, “Bantems”, which was a fact that Brian had shared with the group, and not something we had planned on discussing. However, it seemed to resonate with them, and clearly by the end of the session it was one of the more memorable facts. I am really pleased to see how much of an impact “local” people and stories made on the students during their visits. While the data shows they did not have as much of an impact as “general” World War One facts on students’ learning, the fact that Paulina’s group in particular had not experienced much teaching on the subject prior to the visit made this not unexpected. It should also be considered that all the 5% of correspondents who said they had learnt about artefacts were handling objects that, in most cases, had a direct connection with a person from or place in Maidenhead. Good Quotes “I learned about World War One more than I learned at school” – this respondent clearly articulates that the museum workshop had enhanced her learning about the topic compared to her classroom experience. 29 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? "To research more about World War One instead of World War Two" – a lot of students responded that they had either learnt about World War One or would like to learn more, but this student seems to have compared the topic to that of World War Two, perhaps suggesting that the museum experience had made World War One a more interesting or approachable topic in some way. "Learning about Beatrice because she works where my dad lives now" - I was really excited to see this response, as one of my worries at the start of the project had been how to make our collections relevant to students from Slough. “I was surprised by how funny Brian was” – while we were surprised at Brian’s popularity with the class, it was a great feeling to know that he had succeeded in breaking through the perception of museums (and by association their staff) as boring, old, etc. Despite the huge generational gap between Brian and the students, they clearly related with each other. “I learnt that there is a history museum here” – one of the major challenges for the Heritage Centre is local awareness, so I was not surprised to read this response! Summary of key benefits and lessons learnt At Ditton Park Academy the average level improved way above what was expected and the majority of the project participants are currently working above their end of year target grade, in part as a result of their participation in this project. In addition, Year 7 students demonstrated that, providing work is sufficiently challenging and stimulating, they can work as well independently and collaboratively as GCSE students. The project participants frequently worked together in groups to solve mysteries or problems. In addition, they developed their investigative skills by developing the ability to ask questions and then discuss potential answers with peers, before going home to independently research something. From the evaluation at Wexham School it is clear that many students did make progress during the unit. The amount of students who are below target reduced from 88% of the class to 63% of the class showing that many students did improve their level. I decided to look at how many students made progress and how their progress improved from their first assessment 38% of students improved their progress by one sublevel and 29% of students improved their progress by two sub levels. The majority of students from Ditton Park Academy and Wexham School responded well to the localized history of Maidenhead stating they felt a connection to a person or place they learned about in Maidenhead through the artefacts they used. 30 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? 6. Impact on project managers of running the project Karl Fenn - The project had an overwhelmingly positive impact on the project manager running the project. Paulina O’Neill - Through this project I have developed my professional practice. During this project I organized my first school trip to a museum and this has given me the confidence to arrange more trips for my students. My view of museum learning changed throughout the project. At first I considered museum learning to be object-based learning in the classroom in partnership with a museum. During the delivery of the project this changed into relying on primary resources from various sources on the internet to encourage curiosity in my lessons. Museum learning became a way of teaching to spark curiosity through the use of primary sources. This, however, is the way our history department delivers the history curriculum but we do not define it as ‘museum learning.’ I have determined that museum learning is just good teaching practice in a lesson as it is based on using curiosity to engage students and have them discover information through exploring this curiosity. Prior to this project I believed that schools would just visit a museum, participate in some workshops and that would be the end of the learning experience. Throughout this project my views have changed and I believe that you can work in partnership with a museum to tailor workshops to suit the needs of a class. I also believe you can teach museum learning by working with local museums to rent loan boxes with objects to deliver a unit. Virginia Jenner - The main impact for me has been the boost in experience and confidence to work with older year groups. I have gained valuable experience in planning content to make it engaging and relevant to KS3 year groups, and also in the skills and attitude required to deliver a workshop successfully. Each time I met with the groups I felt more confident in my role and my ability to handle the class. Although I found both groups challenging in different ways – and Paulina’s group more challenging in particular simply due to the number of students – I found myself wanting to rise to the challenge and develop a rapport with the students, rather than feeling negative or inadequate. Another impact on my professional practice has been the experience of working on an extended project with Karl and Paulina. I have really enjoyed this process and it has provided me with a unique, invaluable insight into the working life of a secondary class and the circumstances that might prevent a teacher or school from visiting museums. I will certainly be reflecting on what I have learnt from them when I consider how I can engage with local secondary teachers after this project. For example, I am now much more aware of the challenges secondary teachers face in terms of budgeting and timetabling for off-site visits compared to primary teachers. As our project followed a relatively traditional museum learning format, focusing on history and artefacts rather than unusual cross-curricular links, I don’t feel that it has drastically changed the way I think about Museum Learning. To a certain degree it has alleviated my perception of a gaping chasm between primary and secondary museum learning, as I have witnessed the KS3 students enjoying and benefiting from very similar workshop activities to those I have run with much 31 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? younger students, with only minor imaginative tweaks needed to make them relevant and engaging (e.g. writing postcards and the mystery artefact game). Summary of key benefits and lessons learnt Museum learning has had a positive impact on project managers. Museum learning is a name for good teaching practice. Museums and schools can form stronger partnerships to deliver a more customized learning experience for pupils. It can focus on local history, which our students enjoyed. Through stronger partnerships between schools and museums there can be newer and more innovative ways to incorporate museum learning that doesn’t involve a traditional class trip. It can involve museum visits to the schools and loan boxes of artefacts to improve student engagement. 32 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? 7. Impact of the project for Ditton Park Academy, Wexham School and Maidenhead Heritage Centre Ditton Park Academy One key benefit was obviously the impact the project had on the History results. The average level improved way above what was expected and the majority of the project participants are currently working above their end of year target grade, in part as a result of their participation in this project. In addition, Year 7 students demonstrated that, providing work is sufficiently challenging and stimulating, they can work as well independently and collaboratively as GCSE students. The project participants frequently worked together in groups to solve mysteries or problems. In addition, they developed their investigative skills by developing the ability to ask questions and then discuss potential answers with peers, before going home to independently research something. Perhaps most importantly, the project gave members of staff from Ditton Park Academy the chance to work with colleagues from other local schools. This was particularly important to Ditton Park Academy given that it is a new school in its first year. It was great to meet other teaching staff from the local area and discuss curriculum ideas with these experienced colleagues from successful schools. It also gave the History department the opportunity to establish extra-curricular contacts, which can be used in future years. Across Humanities at Ditton Park Academy, the ethos of the museum learning project seeks to be implemented. We aim to foster a sense of discover and curiosity via an enquiry in our schemes of work, and within lessons themselves. Wexham School It is early to determine the impact this project will have for Wexham School. This project is forming part of an action research project that I am completing for my professional development. At the end of the year staff members who are involved in action research projects will be presenting to the school what their project was about and how it has impacted progress, engagement and our teaching practice. I will be presenting to all staff members about what museum learning is, how the project was delivered, the results it had on progress and how it can be incorporated into our teaching practice at the school. There is a potential for ‘museum learning’ to be implemented in some capacity by individual teachers. I believe mostly the history department will implement it and perhaps the humanities department as museum learning would be much easier to implement in those lessons. While there are no next steps firmly in place there are aspects of museum learning at Wexham School. Our subject leader of history, Laura Cole, has worked with local museums to have loan boxes of objects for teachers to use in their history lessons. Our school has also visited various museums for different subjects to increase student engagement. I believe that museum learning at Wexham School will continue to grow through the use of loan boxes and trips, however, it is not as personalised as this project was. 33 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? Maidenhead Heritage Centre From my perspective, the Heritage Centre has learnt a lot about working with secondary schools through this project. Secondary students can enjoy the museum, it isn’t boring! Brian is a great asset, and his ability to relate across the generations needs to be captured across the museum, which is mostly staffed by retirees. Before this project I would have said I was concerned how my volunteers would cope with secondary students, and I know Beryl was fairly apprehensive about the Year 9s. What other potential do we have among our volunteer body for inter-generational projects or collaboration? I have been cherishing an idea of recording oral histories with primary children and some of my volunteers, but now I am thinking why not get older students involved as well - they shouldn’t miss out. There are logistical challenges to organising secondary visits: neither of the schools could visit on our preferred day of Monday, which meant my working pattern had to be very flexible. Luckily the bursary made this possible, but for future projects this might be an issue. At the moment, as all education takes place in the main museum gallery we are restricted in what we can do by the need to give older students chairs to sit on. During the planning stages I was enthusiastic about incorporating drama activities into the workshops, but I realised that there simply wasn’t room. It was useful to work with the two different sizes of group as this clearly demonstrated the benefits of working with smaller groups in our museum environment. At the time of writing, as we have not yet completed all the steps of our project the main focus is on finalising the arrangements for the students’ to deliver their workshops. From my perspective, I am still very interested to see the students’ workshops as one of the outcomes of the project we were hoping for was an insight into what KS3 students thought would make a good workshop. This question has been answered to some extent by the students’ planning, but I would love to capture the feedback of their peers/participants after the workshops as well to see if their ideas were successful. From my perspective, I would have to think carefully about repeating a similar project in terms of the limitations of our museum space and also my work schedule. I would certainly look to work with smaller groups to make the project more manageable, and I would also ideally want to work with Maidenhead schools within walking distance. This in particular would make sense for a future repetition of the project as it would eliminate much of the cost of an extended collaboration, and would mean that students could deliver their workshops at the museum. This was initially discussed for Karl’s group but the cost was found to be too prohibitive, and for Paulina’s group was difficult due to the size of the group. 34 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? Summary of key benefits and lessons learnt The ethos of museum learning will be implemented at Ditton Park Academy. At Wexham School the project had a positive impact, however, if and how ‘museum learning’ will be incorporated in lessons is still being determined. At the Maidenhead Heritage Centre they have learned a lot about working with secondary schools but the structure of how to replicate this model in the future is still being determined. Working with local organisations helped to build strong connections that will be useful in the future. 35 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? 8. Conclusion and key learnings Overall the Stronger Together Project had a positive impact on Ditton Park Academy, Wexham School and the Maidenhead Heritage Centre. At Ditton Park Academy the average level improved way above what was expected and the majority of the project participants are currently working above their end of year target grade, in part as a result of their participation in this project. In addition, Year 7 students demonstrated that, providing work is sufficiently challenging and stimulating, they can work as well independently and collaboratively as GCSE students. The project participants frequently worked together in groups to solve mysteries or problems. In addition, they developed their investigative skills by developing the ability to ask questions and then discuss potential answers with peers, before going home to independently research something. From the evaluation at Wexham School it is clear that many students did make progress during the unit. The amount of students who are below target reduced from 88% of the class to 63% of the class showing that many students did improve their level. I decided to look at how many students made progress and how their progress improved from their first assessment 38% of students improved their progress by one sublevel and 29% of students improved their progress by two sub levels. The majority of students from Ditton Park Academy and Wexham School responded well to the localized history of Maidenhead stating they felt a connection to a person or place they learned about in Maidenhead through the artefacts they used. Museum learning has had a positive impact on project managers. Museum learning is a name for good teaching practice. Museums and schools can form stronger partnerships to deliver a more customized learning experience for pupils. It can focus on local history, which our students enjoyed. Through stronger partnerships between schools and museums there can be newer and more innovative ways to incorporate museum learning that doesn’t involve a traditional class trip. It can involve museum visits to the schools and loan boxes of artefacts to improve student engagement. The ethos of museum learning will be implemented at Ditton Park Academy. At Wexham School the project had a positive impact, however, if and how ‘museum learning’ will be incorporated in lessons is still being determined. At the Maidenhead Heritage Centre they have learned a lot about working with secondary schools but the structure of how to replicate this model in the future is still being determined. Working with local organisations helped to build strong connections that will be useful in the future. 36 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? 9. Appendices Appendix A: Project plan Stronger Together Project Management Plan Project name: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? Project partners: Ditton Park Academy, Wexham Secondary School and the Maidenhead Heritage Centre STAGE ONE: INITIAL PLANNING Rationale Driver To deepen pupils’ understanding of World War One through the use of objects from the Maidenhead Heritage Centre. Activity summary Students will visit the Maidenhead Heritage Centre at the start of the unit. Throughout the unit students will analyse different objects to investigate how people’s lives were affected during World War One. At the end of the unit students will create a workshop to tell a story about people’s lives during World War One and they will compete to deliver this workshop at both schools and the Maidenhead Heritage Centre. 37 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? Purpose Key people Results Students will develop their research and analytical skills through the interpretation of different objects from World War One. Students will also think independently about how people’s lives were affected during World War One. Project Manager Helen Cook and Katherine Rose Project Sponsor Arts Council England End User(s) Year 7 Students from Ditton Park Academy & Year 9 Students from Wexham Secondary School Stakeholder(s) Maidenhead Heritage Centre, Mary Sparrow, Nick Caulfield, Leaders of Humanities, Leader of History, Subject Leaders and students from Ditton Park Academy and Wexham Secondary School. Success Criteria Output (s) Outcome To visit Maidenhead Heritage Centre to develop an understanding of how lives were affected by the war. A visit by Ditton Park Academy and Wexham Secondary School to Maidenhead Heritage Centre to see the WW1 exhibit and participate in different workshops on WW1. To learn about how peoples’ lives were affected by WW1. To learn about different types of workshops hosted by a Museum. To use objects from Maidenhead Heritage Centre to evaluate how people's lives were affected by THE FIRST WORLD WAR. Maidenhead Heritage Centre will provide objects and pictures to Ditton Park Academy and Wexham School for delivering the unit. Students will develop their research and analytical skills by investigating what the objects show about peoples’ lives in WW1. Students will create a workshop on one aspect of how people’s lives were affected WW1. They will compete to host their Students will improve their communication and leadership skills by creating and delivering a To create a workshop for students outside the school community. 38 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? workshop at Maidenhead Heritage Centre for students in the area and to students at participating schools. workshop. STAGE TWO: FURTHER PLANNING Resources People Paulina O’Neill, Virginia Jenner, Additional Volunteers for the Maidenhead Heritage Centre and Staff members from Ditton Park Academy Money Coach travel to the Maidenhead Heritage Centre, admission and workshop costs for the students and the cost of materials for the students to lead a workshop. Time Teachers to visit Maidenhead Heritage Centre to see the exhibit in September, a school trip the week after the October half term and a trip at the end of the four-week project for the students leading a museum workshop. Materials/ equipment The objects being provided by Maidenhead Heritage Centre and materials to create and lead a workshop for students outside the school community. Risk Likelihood Impact Object Handling Medium/High Have clear rules on how to handle objects. Provide gloves to students for handling objects. Supervise students who are handling an object. Students getting hurt by an object Low Have clear rules on how to handle objects. Tell students how to handle objects safely. Have a first aid kit readily available. Student misinterpretations Low to Medium Have differentiated material for analysing objects. Model answers when explaining objects. Have mixed ability groups for 39 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? workshops. Poor Behaviour Low to Medium Set high expectations and clear rules for the project. Poor confidence for leading workshops Low to Medium Have a competition among groups so the best groups are selected to lead a workshop for students outside the school community. STAGE THREE: DELIVERY Ditton Park Academy How were the lives of people on the Home Front affected by the outbreak of the First World War? Lesson 1. The personal stories of WW1 – What happened to Private Fenn? Objects Tasks Official records of the death of Private Fenn (enlistment document, enlistment photo, Hayes newspaper article, death certificate and finally the Menim Gate letter and photo). - A photograph of FF’s jacket - A photo of the assassination of FF - Students circle map what they already know about WW1 Students complete investigation, looking at 5 primary sources to 12/09/14 help them solve the mystery. 2&3. How did one bullet kill 20 million - Map work people? - Role play - Causation debate 19/09/14 - Newspaper article on the spark of 26/09/14 World War One. 4. Why did so many people enlist to fight - Recruitment posters - Group work to find the common in the First World War? - Official records of recruitment characteristics of recruitment posters. provided by MHC - Students answer questions on the 3/10/14 posters. - Students create a poster. 5. School visit to Maidenhead Heritage Centre. The following artefacts were looked at, which will drive the future focus on out sessions. 22/10/14 6. How were children’s lives affected by - Evacuation photos - What can we learn from pictures and the First World War? - Evacuee stories/ diary entries written sources? - Evacuee name tags - Circle map 24/10/14 - Extended writing – how were children’s lives affected by WW1? 7. Did the First World War improve the - Personal stories of Maidenhead nurses - What can we learn from pictures and lives of women? and factory workers, provided by MHC written sources? - Circle map 7/11/14 - Extended writing – how were women’s lives affected by WW1? 8. Visit from Maidenhead Heritage Centre, workshop led by Virginia (museum curator). 14/11/14 9. Did the First World War improve the - Personal stories of Maidenhead nurses What can we learn from pictures and lives of women? and factory workers, provided by MHC written sources? - Circle map 21/11/14 - Extended writing – how were women’s lives affected by WW1? 10. Trench warfare - Trench art, provided by MHC 40 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? 28/11/14 11. Rationing and DORA - Ration and recipe books, provided by MHC. 5/12/14 13. Planning for extended writing All previous objects to be used for drive student planning 12/12/14 14. Extended writing - How were the lives of people on the Home Front affected by the outbreak of the First World War? Wexham School Topic Lesson Title Lesson Objectives Resources Differentiation Learning Aims: To develop an understanding of how lives were affected by the war. To evaluate how people’s lives were affected by WW1. To create a workshop for students outside the school community. How did WW1 What is 1. To know Starter: Students will match long-term causes of WW1 to their definition. affect the WW1? what WW1 is. Students will create a map of WW1 European lives of people alliances. 2. To in Britain? Students will complete a card-sort on the longunderstand term effects of WW1. They will indicate if the the main cause is related to France, Britain or Russia. events of Students will then learn about the assassination of WW1. Franz Ferdinand. Students will write a paragraph to explain what the most important cause of WW1 was. Plenary: Students will write what went well and even better if in green pen. How did WW1 Why did 1. To know Starter: Students analyse a picture of people in front of Buckingham Palace when the war was affect the people join why people announced in 1914. lives of people the army? joined the Students are taught about the different reasons in Britain? army. why men joined the army. Students analyse different recruitment posters 2. To analyse from WW1 and link it to the different motives. propaganda Students create their own propaganda poster. posters from Plenary: Students share their posters with the WW1. class. Artefact: Recruitment posters found online. 3. To create a propaganda poster to join WW1. How did WW1 affect the lives of people in Britain? What was life like in the trenches? 1. To know what life in trenches were like. 2. To Starter: Students analyse a picture of soldiers in the trenches and describe how they would feel in that position. Students watch two videos describing the challenges faced by soldiers in WW1. During each video they write down two video facts. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FvYIIuxh2kY Sentence starters for writing a paragraph. Translations for EAL students. Students are given a list of things to include in their poster with examples of recruitment posters. High ability students will need to explain the reasoning behind their poster and how that would persuade men to join the army during the war. Translations for EAL students. There will be a list of things to include in the diary entry such as rations, rats, lice, diseases, etc. 41 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? understand how it affected the war effort. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xyFCmwgCU vU Students will read an information sheet from the BBC website about trench conditions. This information sheet will include first-hand accounts about the trenches. Students will write a diary entry from the perspective of a soldier living in the trenches and describe the different conditions. Plenary: Students will write in green pen what they did well and even better if. A writing frame for low ability students. Translations for EAL students. Artefact: First-hand accounts about the trenches on the BBC website. How did WW1 affect the lives of people in Britain? How did people communicate during WW1? 1. To know how soldiers communicate d with their families. 2. To analyse postcards from WW1. Starter: Students will create a spider diagram to list the different ways we communicate today. Read the information sheet on communication in WW1. Students will write a post card imagining they are either in the trenches or on the home front. Plenary: Students will peer-assess post cards. Artefact: Postcards from the museum. Starter: Students will analyse a picture from a grocery store. Students will look at food rationing cards and books and answer questions to determine what they believe the artefact is and why it was used. Students will then read an information sheet about rationing in the local area during WW1. Students will watch a video to learn about rationing with soldiers in the trenches. Students will write a paragraph explaining how rationing affected the home front and soldiers in WW1. Plenary: Students will summarise what they learned in 10 words or less. Artefact: Food rationing cards from the museum. Starter: Students will look at a picture of Beatrice Kay and guess what she did during WW1. Explain to students that women replaced men who had joined the army for the war. Students will watch a video showing the different roles women took to help with the WW1 war effort. Students will read an information sheet about how many women worked in the war. Students will write a paragraph to explain how women contributed to the war effort. Translations for EAL students. Sentence starters for different perspectives. Suggested comments for peerassessment. 3. To create a postcard for a soldier. How did WW1 affect the lives of people in Britain? What could they eat? 1. To know about food rationing during WW1. 2. To explain how food rationing affected people during WW1. How did WW1 affect the lives of people in Britain? What did women do in WW1? 1. To know how women contributed to the war effort in WW1. 2. To understand how the role of women Sentence starters for writing tasks. Writing frames provided on how to write a PEE, PEEL and PEEEL paragraph. Translations for EAL students. Extension: students will write about how they would feel if they were limited in the groceries they could purchase today. Translations for EAL students. Sentence starters for writing tasks. Writing frames provided on how to write a PEE, PEEL and PEEEL paragraph. 42 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? changed in WW1. How did WW1 affect the lives of people in Britain? ASSESSMENT How did WW1 affect the lives of people in Britain? Create a workshop! 1. To create a workshop on one aspect of WW1 that you learned about in this unit. Plenary: Students will write down 3 jobs women were employed in during WW1, 2 things they learned and 1 thing they are still wondering about. Artefact: Photo album of a nurse from Maidenhead called Beatrice Kay. Students will answer the question: How did WW1 affect the lives of people in Britain? They will use their knowledge about food rationing, trenches, women and communication in their answer. Writing frame for the essay. Sentence starters. Students will create a workshop for Ditton Park Academy students and the Maidenhead Heritage Centre. One group will be chosen. STAGE FOUR: EVALUATION Review Monitoring Evaluation Surveys We will use surveys before and after the unit to see if students have made progress and understand what they think museum learning is about. Post-It Notes At the end of a museum workshop or lesson students will write down what they learned, what surprised them and what they enjoyed. Quizzes Students will complete a quiz at the museum to test their knowledge of World War One. Written Assessment We will have students write an essay answering the question ‘How did World War One affect the lives of people in Britain?’ These essays will be marked to 43 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? check student progress. Museum Workshop Students will produce a museum workshop to show their understanding of a World War One topic. Sign off 44 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? Appendix B: Student resources created Ditton Park Academy - Student resources are available to download on Dropbox. https://www.dropbox.com/sh/kpf9u2p26q9dyqv/AABq6PIKDnybTNoQGLNAGFjUa?dl=0 Wexham School All lessons, hand-outs, resources and evaluation tools are available on Dropbox. https://www.dropbox.com/sh/bq67khvkoqk6ya7/AACoXgamtZaHODBP1AHbPVE2a?dl=0 Maidenhead Heritage CentreDitton Park Worksheet 45 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? Wexham worksheet 46 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? Appendix C: Evaluation tools Ditton Park Academy Museum Survey Analysis Pre-museum visit survey Which statement do you most agree with? Statement Museums are boring, but you can learn lots from them. Museums are not usually relevant to what I am studying. I would only ever visit a museum on a school trip. Museums are fun and you can learn lots from them. Tally II IIIII IIIII Post-museum visit survey Which statement do you most agree with? Statement Museums are boring, but you can learn lots from them. Museums are not usually relevant to what I am studying. I would only ever visit a museum on a school trip. Museums are fun and you can learn lots from them. Tally I I IIIIIIIIII Pre-museum visit survey – Additional student comments Statement Learn things from museums They are for old people Not exciting / are boring Generally negative comment Generally positive comment Tally III III IIIIIII IIIIIIIII III 47 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? Post-museum visit survey – Additional student comments Statement Learn things from museums They are fun or interesting or cool Generally negative comment Generally positive comment Tally III IIIIIIII 0 IIIIIII % O F ST U D E N T S O N O R A B OV E TA R G E T I N H I STO RY F R O M P R O J EC T C O H O RT On end of year target Above end of year target % of students from project who above, on or below the average grade of the rest of their set Above Below 17% 33% On 50% Above On Below 48 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? Average H/W grade of project participannts when compared to the average grade of their classmate Above Below An excel table showing the progress of the students participating in the project over time Wexham School Assessment - https://www.dropbox.com/sh/wxicejj3qoac8fj/AACiowv5evIvq9oAOhijRveqa?dl=0 Survey - https://www.surveymonkey.com/s/GRZ9VGR 49 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? Appendix D: Scheme of Work for Ditton Park Academy How were the lives of people on the Home Front affected by the outbreak of the First World War? Lesson 2. The personal stories of WW1 – What happened to Private Fenn? Objects Tasks Official records of the death of Private Fenn (enlistment document, enlistment photo, Hayes newspaper article, death certificate and finally the Menim Gate letter and photo). - A photograph of FF’s jacket - A photo of the assassination of FF - Students circle map what they already know about WW1. Students complete investigation, looking at 5 primary sources to 12/09/14 help them solve the mystery. 2&3. How did one bullet kill 20 million - Map work people? - Role play - Causation debate 19/09/14 - Newspaper article on the spark of 26/09/14 WW1. 4. Why did so many people enlist to fight - Recruitment posters - Group work to find the common in the First World War? - Official records of recruitment characteristics of recruitment posters. provided by MHC - Students answer questions on the 3/10/14 posters. - Students create a poster. 5. School visit to Maidenhead Heritage Centre. The following artefacts were looked at, which will drive the future focus on out sessions. 22/10/14 6. How were children’s lives affected by - Evacuation photos - What can we learn from pictures and the First World War? - Evacuee stories/ diary entries written sources? - Evacuee name tags - Circle map 24/10/14 - Extended writing – how were children’s lives affected by WW1? 7. Did the First World War improve the - Personal stories of Maidenhead nurses - What can we learn from pictures and lives of women? and factory workers, provided by MHC written sources? - Circle map 7/11/14 - Extended writing – how were women’s lives affected by WW1? 8. Visit from Maidenhead Heritage Centre, workshop led by Virginia (museum curator). 14/11/14 9. Did the First World War improve the - Personal stories of Maidenhead nurses What can we learn from pictures and lives of women? and factory workers, provided by MHC written sources? - Circle map 21/11/14 - Extended writing – how were women’s lives affected by WW1? 10. Trench warfare - Trench art, provided by MHC 28/11/14 11. Rationing and DORA 5/12/14 13. Planning for extended writing - Ration and recipe books, provided by MHC. All previous objects to be used for drive student planning 12/12/14 14. Extended writing - How were the lives of people on the Home Front affected by the outbreak of the First World War? 50 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? Appendix E: Scheme of Work for Wexham School Topic Lesson Title Lesson Objectives Resources Differentiation Learning Aims: To develop an understanding of how lives were affected by the war. To evaluate how people’s lives were affected by World War One. To create a workshop for students outside the school community. How did WW1 What is 1. To know what Starter: Students will match long-term causes of WW1 to their definition. affect the the First WW1 is. Students will create a map of WW1 European lives of people World alliances. 2. To understand in Britain? War? Students will complete a card-sort on the longthe main events term effects of WW1. They will indicate if the of WW1. cause is related to France, Britain or Russia. Students will then learn about the assassination of Franz Ferdinand. Students will write a paragraph to explain what the most important cause of WW1 was. Plenary: Students will write what went well and even better if in green pen. How did WW1 Why did 1. To know why Starter: Students analyse a picture of people in front of Buckingham Palace when the war was affect the people people joined the announced in 1914. lives of people join the army. Students are taught about the different reasons in Britain? army? why men joined the army. 2. To analyse Students analyse different recruitment posters propaganda from WW1 and link it to the different motives. posters from Students create their own propaganda poster. WW1. Plenary: Students share their posters with the class. 3. To create a Artefact: Recruitment posters found online. propaganda poster to join WW1. How did WW1 affect the lives of people in Britain? What was life like in the trenches? 1. To know what life in trenches were like. 2. To understand how it affected the war effort. Starter: Students analyse a picture of soldiers in the trenches and describe how they would feel in that position. Students watch two videos describing the challenges faced by soldiers in WW1. During each video they write down two video facts. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FvYIIuxh2kY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xyFCmwgCU vU Students will read an information sheet from the BBC website about trench conditions. This information sheet will include first-hand accounts about the trenches. Students will write a diary entry from the perspective of a soldier living in the trenches and describe the different conditions. Plenary: Students will write in green pen what they did well and even better if. Sentence starters for writing a paragraph. Translations for EAL students. Students are given a list of things to include in their poster with examples of recruitment posters. High ability students will need to explain the reasoning behind their poster and how that would persuade men to join the army during the war. Translations for EAL students. There will be a list of things to include in the diary entry such as rations, rats, lice, diseases, etc. A writing frame for low ability students. Translations for EAL students. 51 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? Artefact: First-hand accounts about the trenches on the BBC website. How did WW1 affect the lives of people in Britain? How did people communic ate during WW1? 1. To know how soldiers communicated with their families. 2. To analyse postcards from WW1. Starter: Students will create a spider diagram to list the different ways we communicate today. Read the information sheet on communication in WW1. Students will write a post card imagining they are either in the trenches or on the home front. Plenary: Students will peer-assess post cards. Artefact: Postcards from the museum. Starter: Students will analyse a picture from a grocery store. Students will look at food rationing cards and books and answer questions to determine what they believe the artefact is and why it was used. Students will then read an information sheet about rationing in the local area during WW1. Students will watch a video to learn about rationing with soldiers in the trenches. Students will write a paragraph explaining how rationing affected the home front and soldiers in WW1. Plenary: Students will summarise what they learned in 10 words or less. Artefact: Food rationing cards from the museum. Starter: Students will look at a picture of Beatrice Kay and guess what she did during WW1. Explain to students that women replaced men who had joined the army for the war. Students will watch a video showing the different roles women took to help with the WW1 war effort. Students will read an information sheet about how many women worked in the war. Students will write a paragraph to explain how women contributed to the war effort. Plenary: Students will write down 3 jobs women were employed in during WW1, 2 things they learned and 1 thing they are still wondering about. Artefact: Photo album of a nurse from Maidenhead called Beatrice Kay. Students will answer the question: How did WW1 affect the lives of people in Britain? They will use their knowledge about food rationing, trenches, women and communication in their answer. Translations for EAL students. Sentence starters for different perspectives. Suggested comments for peerassessment. 3. To create a postcard for a soldier. How did WW1 affect the lives of people in Britain? What could they eat? 1. To know about food rationing during WW1. 2. To explain how food rationing affected people during WW1. How did WW1 affect the lives of people in Britain? What did women do in WW1? 1. To know how women contributed to the war effort in WW1. 2. To understand how the role of women changed in WW1. How did WW1 affect the lives of people in Britain? ASSESSME NT Sentence starters for writing tasks. Writing frames provided on how to write a PEE, PEEL and PEEEL paragraph. Translations for EAL students. Extension: students will write about how they would feel if they were limited in the groceries they could purchase today. Translations for EAL students. Sentence starters for writing tasks. Writing frames provided on how to write a PEE, PEEL and PEEEL paragraph. Writing frame for the essay. Sentence starters. 52 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? How did WW1 affect the lives of people in Britain? Create a workshop ! 1. To create a workshop on one aspect of WW1 that you learned about in this unit. Students will create a workshop for Ditton Park Academy students and the Maidenhead Heritage Centre. One group will be chosen. 53 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? Appendix F: Structure of Maidenhead Heritage Centre session with Ditton Park Academy 2-2.10 Introduction as a group 2.10-2.20 Recruitment (10 mins) Measure height Boot polish Discuss why men might volunteer Read JG poem and look at Upson postcards 2.20 – 2.35 Women / war work (15 mins) Discuss women’s rights Discuss munitions work and handle badges Divide into 2 groups and look at Dolly & Beatrice photos (print outs & touchscreen PC) Task – tell story to other group in a creative way 2.35 – 2.50 Rationing (15 mins) Discuss what foods were rationed etc Look at ration books Handle old money Look at recipe books 2.50 – 3.05 Trench art/memorials Explore trench art as a way of remembering the dead Divide into 2 groups – look at Upson’s story and handle trench art – SWAP 3.05 – 3.20 Gallery exploration Quiz worksheet Postcards 3.20 – 3.30 Wrap up and evaluation Ask students to fill out post-its for what they learnt, enjoyed and were inspired by 54 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? Appendix G: Structure of Maidenhead Heritage Centre session with Wexham School 10 – 10.20 Intro talk as a class covering remembrance/centenary, what they already know about the war, what maidenhead was like at the start of the war, etc Break into two groups of 15: 10.20 – 10.50 A) Explore the exhibition and do quiz - no postcards! B) Get into 5 x groups of 3 and rotate around different object stations. E.g. rationing, mystery item, postcards, trench art, badges. Groups have 6 minutes at each station to investigate their items and fill out a worksheet answering key questions. VJ or BB will be on hand to float around the piles and encourage investigation, and keep an eye on time. 10.50 – 11.20 Groups swap 11.20 – 11.50 Postcards: discuss postcards as a class and why they were important. Each student is given the name of a character. Write their postcard from the perspective of the character - how would they be thinking and feeling? Encourage students to investigate their character using the prompt on their slip of paper. 11.50 – 12 noon Wrap up, what have we learnt, evaluation post-its - what learnt - what enjoyed - what surprised 55 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? Appendix H: Objects used from the Maidenhead Heritage Centre Item 1: A hot cross bun maker Item 2: A pre-censored postcard Item 3: Postcards made in France and sold to British soldiers 56 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? Item 4: Food rationing books Item 5: Pin from World War One 57 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain? Item 6: Trench Art 58 | Stronger Together project report: How did THE FIRST WORLD WAR affect the lives of people in Britain?
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz