About ETPs
Technology Platforms are set up for bringing together companies, research
institutions, and any other organisations, with a view to defining, at European
level, a common strategic research agenda (SRA) which should mobilise a
critical mass of national and European public and private resources. They also
address technological and non-technological issues for implementing this
agenda.
ENIAC –
from the European Technology Platform
to the Joint Technology Initiative
The benefits of European Technology Platforms (ETPs) include: improved
structure and coordination of research activities, partnership building for
resources, consensus building on strategies for technology development and
on measures for exploitation of research results, and acceleration of
innovation processes.
The main goals are to improve the impact of public and private research, to
increase investment in European research, and to facilitate common
approaches to technology progress and uptake.
Peter Caldera
Wien 9. Mai 2007
The SRAs will be considered as an important input in preparing the Work
Programmes of the IST thematic priority of the EU Framework Programmes.
Source: Norbert Lehner
Chairman of the ENIAC Support Group
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
Which ETPs exist / are planned in the ICT domain ?
•
Embedded Systems (ARTEMIS)
•
The Mobile and Wireless Communications Technology Platform (eMobility)
•
ENIAC - European Nanoelectronics Initiative Advisory Council
•
EUROP, the European Robotics Platform
•
Photonics21 - The Photonics Technology Platform
•
The Integral Satcom Initiative (ISI)
•
Networked European Software and Services Initiative (NESSI)
•
The NEM Initiative - European Initiative on NETWORKED and ELECTRONIC
MEDIA
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
EpoSS:
EpoSS:Smart
SmartSystems
Systems
……
……
Otherplatforms
platforms
Other
ERTRAC
ERTRAC
RoadTransport
Transport
Road
ACARE
ACARE
Aeronautics
Aeronautics
…
…
OtherICT
ICTplatforms
platforms
Other
NEM
NEM
NetworkedNew
NewMedia
Media
Networked
Which ETPs exist / are planned in other domains ?
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
The European Hydrogen and Fuel Cell Technology Platform (HFP)
NanoMedicine - Nanotechnologies for Medical Applications
Plants for the Future
Water Supply and Sanitation Technology Platform (WSSTP)
The European Technology Platform on Photovoltaics
Technology Platform on Sustainable Chemistry
Forest Based Sector Technology Platform
European Technology Platform for Global Animal Health (GAH)
ERTRAC European Road Transport Research Advisory Council
ERRAC European Rail Research Advisory Council
WATERBORNE Technology Platform
Innovative Medicines for Europe
ACARE - Advisory Council for Aeronautics Research in Europe
The European Space Technology Platform (ESTP)
ESTEP - The European Steel Technology Platform
The European Technology Platform for the Future of Textiles and Clothing (ETP-FTC)
MANUFUTURE - Platform on Future Manufacturing Technologies
The European Construction Technology Platform (ECTP)
EuMaT - European Technology Platform for Advanced Engineering Materials and Technologies
The European Technology Platform on Industrial Safety
Food European Technology Platform "Food for Life"
European Technology Platform on Smart Systems Integration (EpoSS)
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
3
Some of the European Technology Platforms ….
E-mobility
E-mobility
MobileCommunications
Communications
Mobile
2
4
Present funding scenarios in Europe (simplified)
European funding
EUREKA
FP7
• Upstream R&D
•
•
•
•
National funding
IST collab. R&D
ERC
Marie Curie
Research infrastr.
• Downstream R&D
• MEDEA+ & Beyond
MEDEA+
• National contracts
• Industry driven
National and
Regional
Programmes
Poles de Competitivite
ARTEMIS:
ARTEMIS:Embedded
EmbeddedSystems
Systems
ENIAC:
ENIAC:Nanoelectronics
Nanoelectronics
Cross-boarder
co-opoeration (Europe)
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
5
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
National co-operation
6
1
Increased cooperation towards the European research area ….
ENIAC in 1946 was the first electronic computer …
ENIAC
(European Technology Platform)
...it is now
a powerful
industry
group aiming
at increasing
Europe’s
competitiveness
in nanoelectronics
Industry-driven long-term vision
Common pan-European Strategic Research Agenda
Overall coordination and policy alignment in ERA
Joint programme assessment
Joint Technology
Initiative ENIAC
FP7
• Upstream R&D
• IST collab. R&D
• ERC
• Marie Curie
• Research infrastr.
•
•
•
•
Downstream R&D
Unified processes
National contracts
National and EC cofunding
• Common office with
MEDEA+
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
EUREKA
• Downstream R&D
• MEDEA+
• National contracts
• No EC financial
contributions
National and
Regional
Programmes
Poles de Competitivite
Moore School of Electrical Engineering
University of Pennsylvania
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
7
ENIAC strategic objective: preparing for the European
nanoelectronics future
Implementing the Strategic Research Agenda, the JTI has a
longer time horizon than individual programs
Joint Technology Initiative
• Serve the European Semiconductor value chain
– Include suppliers, producers and users
• Connect and strengthen European high-quality competencies
– Enabling critical knowledge, including SMEs
• Identify disruptive technologies to solve blocking points
– Guided by SRA Domain Teams
• Focus on research leading to industrial innovation
• Enhance cooperation between industry and academia
– Strong R&D ecosystems in each sub domain
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
8
SRA implementation path
“Upstream”
R&D
“Downstream”
R&D
Near-market
R&D
Mainly FP7,
some national
Eureka/national,
industry
partnerships
EIB, …
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
9
10
The road to implementation
From a Vision …
to a Strategic Research Agenda
e
Th
en
m
ple
Im
n
tio
ta
SRA
June 2004
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
November 2005
11
November 2006
Vision
2020
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
ENIAC
e
Th
gic
te
ra
St
P
g
nin
lan
Research
Projects
Research
Programmes
Stakeholders
ENIAC Strategic Research
Agenda
(2nd ed November 2006)
The Report of the
High Level Group
(June 2004)
e
ut
Ro
Public
(EC,
MEDEA+, National) and
Private (Industry)
e
ut
Ro
12
2
Nanoelectronics is the underlying resource
R&D Effort
more than 20% R&D
Telecom,
Internet, Broadcast
> $ 6,000B
Services
Consumer, Medical,
Transport, Security, Space
$ 1,340B
Products
$ 265B
Semiconductors
Materials and equipment
$ 75B
Cornerstone of
high-tech economy
2005 worldwide market figures
Source: Future Horizons IFS2006
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
13
is serving society’s needs: visionary examples
Health
‘The Doctor in your Pocket’
Real-Time Diagnostics
Bio-Chips / Body-Sensors
Mobility / Transport
100% Safety on the Road
Integrated Transport Systems
Prevention of Pollution
Security
Personal Emergency Systems
Protection against Crime and Terrorism
Secure Home Environment
14
The ENIAC SRA domains are application driven
Complex digital circuits
(compute)
Enabling technology into
manufacturing
Society Needs
Effective platform-based
system design
Energy
Ultra low power systems
Energy saving illumination
Energy saving motors
Communication
Seamless Wired / Wireless Access
Mobile Services without Compromise
Protection of Privacy
Education / Entertainment
Learning Anywhere, Anytime
Content with Best Quality (e.g. HDTV)
Content Protection
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
15
Pushing the physical limits of
Applicationscaling
Domains
Total system integration
(“System-in-Package”)
EPoSS
ARTEMIS
Design
Automation
Heterogeneous
Integration
More Moore
More than Moore
Equipment and Materials
Beyond CMOS
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
ENIAC’s multi-dimensional technology roadmap
Non-digital functions and
human interface (interact)
16
Intelligent systems need Moore’s Law, but they
also need more …
10µ
µm
More than Moore
1µ
µm
100nm
M
oo
re
’s
Mi
c ro
H
me
Ra igh
ch
-V
an
di
o
ics
oFr ltag
e
eq
ue
nc
La
y
w
Processor
Storage
10nm
Power
Radio
Sensor
Actuator
More Moore
Beyond CMOS
More than Moore
1nm
1960
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
1980
2000
17
2020
2040
2060
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
18
3
Applied intelligence example: safety cocoon
Ambient Intelligence
Environments that are
sensitive and responsive to
the presence and needs of
people
Many invisible distributed devices
throughout the environment,
Embedded
Context aware
that know about their situational state
that can be tailored towards your needs
and can recognize you,
Personalized
Source: Philips
Adaptive
that can change in response to you
and your environment
Anticipatory
that anticipate your desires without
conscious mediation
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
Infrared
Video
Ultra sonic
Video
Long range
≤ 150 m
Night Vision
≤ 150 m
Mid range
≤ 60 m
Short range
≤3m
Rear zone
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
19
Applied intelligence example: all in the pocket
Personal Map
-Compass
-GPS
-Altitude
Personal Health Monitor
-Heart activity
-Blood pressure
-Glucose level
Personal Weather Station
-Humidity
-Pressure
-Ozone
-UV exposure
Gaming
Mouse
Decibel Meter
Identification
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
77 GHz
Radar
Applied intelligence example: Si meets carbon
Semiconductor
systems inside
can improve the
quality of life
Implanted hearing aid
Still a long way
to go, technical
and societal,
e.g., regulations,
approval,
liabilities,
reimbursement,
…
SMS pacemaker
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
21
20
Artificial vision
Identification
Insulin dispenser
22
The process toward a Joint Technology Initiative
The ENIAC Organization
Up to now only bilateral funding contracts:
Forum
Forumof
ofStakeholders
Stakeholders
PA
PAMirror
MirrorGroup
Group
(20
(20countries)
countries)
Scientific
ScientificCommunity
Community
Council
Council(~50
(~50members)
members)
Working Group
Working Group
SRA
SRA
Domain Team
Domain Team
More Moore
More Moore
Domain Team
Domain Team
Beyond CMOS
Beyond CMOS
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
Contract with EC:
Support
SupportGroup
Group
Steering
SteeringCommittee
Committee
(9+4
(9+4members)
members)
RTD
Performers
EC
Office
Office(Paris)
(Paris)
or with the countries:
Working Group
Working Group
Organization
Organization
Working Group
Working Group
Education & Training
Education & Training
Domain Team
Domain Team
More than Moore
More than Moore
23
Domain Team
Domain Team
Hetero Integration
Hetero Integration
Working Group
Working Group
Research Infrastructure
Research Infrastructure
Domain Team
Domain Team
Equip&Materials
Equip&Materials
RTD
Performers
Countries
Domain Team
Domain Team
Design Automation
Design Automation
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
24
4
The process toward a Joint Technology Initiative
‘PRINS’ research infrastructure bridge
New is the trilateral contract to form the JTI …
RTD
Performers
Joint
Undertaking
Association
‘AENEAS’
Countries
Early 2007
Back-to-back with:
ENIAC ETP
Office an
services
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
Scientific
knowledge
ARTEMIS
nan
“Highway to
ENIAC JTI
Projects
Society
needs
ostructures”
industry
ENIAC / MEDEA+
Office
academia
Other
Stakeholders
EC
2008 ?
25
ENIAC achievements
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
26
The AENEAS industrial association
• Vision document released in 2004
• Established to execute the ENIAC SRA and JTI ambition
• Association contract accepted by the initial signing partners
• High-level Steering Committee with commitment from major industries
• Still growing Forum of Stakeholders
• Working Groups on four key topics
– SRA, Organization, Research Infrastructure, Education
• ENIAC Office opened last year in Paris (co-located with MEDEA+)
• Public Authorities Mirror Group
• Strategic Research Agenda released Nov 2005, updated Nov 2006
• Scientific Community Council
• PRINS R&D infrastructure proposal on ESFRI draft roadmap
• JTI preparations reaching final phase (a.o. AENEAS Association)
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
27
• Registration very soon open for all stakeholders in Nanoelectronics
– Large corporations
– SMEs
– Public research organizations, universities
– Pôles de Compétitivité, national platforms, industry organizations, …
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
AENEAS – Legal & Contractual Framework
28
Governance
• AENEAS is ruled by:
Articles of Association
Supplementary Agreement
Governing Board
General Assembly
• signed by the founding Active Corporate Members:
ASML
INFINEON
NXP
Robert BOSCH
S.O.I.TEC
STMICROELECTRONICS
THALES
THOMSON
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
29
Steering Board
Working Groups
EC
Industry &
Research
Committee
Executive
Director &
secretariat
Public
Authorities
Board
MAS
Member &
Associated
States
Industry
(incl. SME)
Research
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
30
5
An improvement in the process selection procedure
MEDEA
Evaluation
by MEDEA
Evaluation
by Public
Authorities
Common strategic
selection of themes
Defined budget
Published Calls
Project Outline
Common evaluation
against pre-set criteria
Full Proposal
Label
Individual contracts by
member states
Individual
funding decision
per country
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
JTI Financing
JTI
31
AENEAS – Legal Status
– Industrial:
• at least 50% in-kind
+ cost JTI operation
Open innovation ecosystem
> 50%
– Participating States:
• national contracts
• Yearly marked budgets
• possibility of cross-border
funding & subcontracting to
other JU member participants
33%
17%
– European Commission:
• In addition to
national payments
• on top → flat rate
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
Target 2008: 42,5 M€ EC
Target 2013: 440 M€ EC
32
+10 M€ EC Admin
AENEAS – Funding the Association and JTI Projects
Fixed yearly contributions:
Established in France under the legal status of an Association according
to law of July 1st, 1901 (a flexible organisation structure used for nonprofit goals)
10 K€ for Corporate Big
5 K€ for Corporate (group <500 M€ turnover)
1 K€ for SMEs
1 K€ for Public Research
Provides 3 categories of Active Members («Big Corporate », SMEs and
Public Research Organisations) + Associated Members (invited actors: i.e.
Eurêka clusters)
Variable contributions:
Object: to promote R&D + innovation in the field of nanoelectronics in
order to strenghten the competitiveness of the European Industry
Other incomes from provision of services
Based on participation in JTI Projects (person.year)
1 K€/py, with first 5 py for free, to encourage small players
Other funding TBD for JTI Projects directly from:
Industry actors
Members States + EC
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
33
Finally ….
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
34
A success story for European industry
The European Technology Platform ENIAC and
ist planned Joint Technology Initiative offer
unprecedented chances for the European competitiveness.
The challenges are to make ENIAC
transparent
open
as simple as possible
effective
successfull
Let´s try it !
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
35
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
36
6
Structure and outputs
Backup
Industry
Academia
Member States
European Technology Platform ENIAC
Strategic Research
Agenda
SRA
Joint Technology Initiative ENIAC
Funded Projects
(Calls, selection,
monitoring
Governance principles
AssociationAENEAS:
AENEAS:
Association
Industry
Industry
Transparency & openness in
participation & operations
Industry-led public-private partnership
Public Authorities decide when public
money is involved
SME
SME
Academia
Academia
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
37
EC
38
3. Call text and
A scenario for a detailed process flow for Selection of JTI projects
ENIAC
mobilises
Who ?
Domain Team
Domain Team
Heterog. Integration
Heterog. Integration
Domain Team
Domain Team
Beyond CMOS
Beyond CMOS
Domain Team
Domain Team
Equip&Materials
Equip&Materials
Domain Team
Domain Team
More than Moore
More than Moore
Dr
Board (IB)
IB experts
Resources
Resources
Domain Team
Domain Team
More Moore
More Moore
Executive
Director (ED)
and
Secretariat
Know How
Know How
Finances
Finances
PAs Board (PAB)
9. Strategic evaluation by PAs of selected
projects on pre-set criteria.
PAs score added to technical score.
2. Selected themes for
year Y call
Industry
What ?
Working Group
Working Group
SRA
SRA
Budget
1. Public budget commitment for
year Y
10. List of ranked JTIs proposals
and recommendations sent to ED
EC
aft
–
MS
PAB experts
in
7. Technical Evaluation
PAB and IB experts evaluate
the incoming project proposals
against pre-set criteria, report to ED
who organises a panel session for
consolidation of scores.
8. List of
selected
projects with
scores
communicated
to PAB
dis
cu
ssi
on
11. Individual
contracts
according to
MS procedures
6. Proposals sent to JTI Secretariat
forwarded to Evaluation committee
4. Call published
Domain Team
Domain Team
Design Autom.
Design Autom.
Infrastructure
Infrastructure
JTI Call n
size: X M€
5. Proposers
prepare
Project
proposals
Note: a 2-step process is preferred
(but not mandatory) for proposals
evaluation (i.e. POs, then FPPs)
themes: 1,2,3
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
39
ENIAC will change it´s character….
40
AENEAS - Governance
ENIAC
Industry-driven long-term vision
Overall coordination and policy alignment in ERA
Forum
Forumof
ofStakeholders
Stakeholders/ /General
GeneralAssembly
Assembly
PA
PAMirror
MirrorGroup
Group
Working Group
Working Group
SRA
SRA
Support
SupportGroup
Group
Steering
Steering
Committee
Committee
Scientific
Scientific
Community
Community
Working Group
Working Group
Organization
Organization
FP7
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
Office
Office
Working Group
Working Group
Education &
Education &
Training
Training
EUREKA
Working Group
Working Group
Research
Research
Infrastructure
Infrastructure
Steering Board (SB):
15 Members proposed by the Active Members (3 by SMEs, 3 by PublicResearch, 9 by Corporate) through lists of nominees drawn up by each
category
JTI
Association
AENEAS
EC
Appointed by the General Assembly
Presidium (1 President, 2 Vice-Presidents, 1 Treasurer, 1 Secretary)
Member
States
In charge of administration, management & representation of the
Association
National and
Regional
Programmes
41
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
42
7
AENEAS – Governance
Basic principles of the planned ENIAC JTI :
strong link to the application domains
General Assembly
Composed by all:
Health
Mobility & Transport
Active Members
Associated Members
SB Members
Security
Communication
Each Active Member has:
Education / Entertainment
at least 1 vote per 1 K€ of contribution
SMEs joint with at least the same number of votes than
joint Public Research
Corporate Members with at least 3 x number of votes of
Joint SMEs
Energy / Environment
Link Technology and
Appl. Requirements
DESIGN
PLATFORM
Takes decisions on simple majority of Active Members
Decides on matters over the powers of the SB (i.e. significant contracts,
appointment of SB Members, modification of ENIAC SRA)
Approves annual report & accounts priorily reviewed by an external
auditor
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
43
MANUFACTURING SCIENCE
CMOS
TECHNOLOGIES
P. Caldera, Wien Mai 9th 2007
COMPACT
SYSTEMS
44
8