When the wind changes direction: The impact of content shift on the

1
3
4
When the wind changes direction:
The impact of content shift on the cultivation effect
5
6
AMIR HETSRONI
7
E-Mail: [email protected]; [email protected]
10
Abstract
11
This study examines how the cultivation effect is impacted by a sudden
change in the content of news media reports. A content analysis of newspaper articles about Iceland published in Israel before and after the outbreak
of the 2008 economic crisis (N ⫽ 708) was used to detect changes in the
theme and tone of news reports regarding this country. It was followed by
a survey (N ⫽ 304) that asked Israelis to give their estimates and views
concerning the economic aspects of life in Iceland. Both first order and
second order cultivation effects, which correlated media consumption with
a positive view of Iceland’s economy and corresponded to the pre-crisis
image of Iceland in the Israeli media, were noticed. These findings are
supportive of the thesis that the long term frequency of media messages is
more significant than their recency in establishing a cultivation effect.
12
13
14
15
8
16
17
18
19
20
21
9
22
24
Keywords: cultivation; Israel; Iceland; content analysis; economy; news;
newspaper; heuristics
25
Introduction
26
36
What impact does a sudden change in the content and tone of the media
coverage of a certain topic have on people’s estimates and views of the
topic? This question, on which the current study focuses, challenges a
profound axiom of cultivation theory ⫺ that media content is largely
homogeneous and repetitive, and that therefore heavy media consumption carries with it greater exposure to recurring storylines, and leads to
an internalizing of the worldview they present (Gerbner, Gross, Morgan,
Signorielli and Shanahan, 2002).
Since cultivation theory was introduced in the late 1960s, it has become the subject of a heated public debate and a shrill academic discourse (see Potter, 1994 for a balanced review of arguments and
12
31
Communications 35 (2010), 439⫺460
DOI 10.1515/COMM.2010.023
23
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
03412059/2010/035⫺0439
쑕 Walter de Gruyter
Amir Hetsroni
1
440
37
counterarguments). The most consistent conclusion that stems from a
meta-analysis of over 80 studies confirms Gerbner’s proposition that
heavy television viewing is connected with a line of distorted estimates
and views in matters that are disproportionately represented on the
screen compared to their presence in daily life, as was summed up by
two of the theory’s proponents:
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
176
1
“Messages of power, dominance, segregation and victimization cultivate relatively restrictive and intolerant views regarding personal morality and freedoms, women’s roles and minority rights… Cultivation
theory contends that heavy exposure to television cultivates insecurity,
mistrust and alienation.”
(Shanahan and Morgan, 1999, p. 40).
Evidence of cultivation was found in different cultures ranging from
North America and Europe to South America, the Middle East and
South East Asia (Weimann, 2000), and in a wide range of topics from
the prevalence of crime (Gerbner and Gross, 1976; Potter, 1991; Hetsroni and Tukachinsky, 2006), through the popularity of certain occupations (Pfau, Mullen, Dietrich, and Garrow, 1995), beliefs about the demographic makeup of society (Fox and Philliber, 1978), and economic
evaluations (Frey, Benesch, and Stutzer, 2007), to views about life in
distant countries (Hetsroni, Elphariach, Kapuza, and Tsfoni, 2007).
Even though the cultivation effect is small in magnitude (around one
percent of the explained variance), it is cross-culturally consistent and
robust across different demographic sectors (Potter, 1994; Shanahan and
Morgan, 1999). Although Gerbner’s original proposition had related
solely to television, and particularly to the entertainment segment of
the programming (Gerbner, 1972), latter studies were able to attribute
significant cultivation effects to other types of media such as internet
(Peter and Valkenburg, 2006) and to non-fictional content like newspapers’ news section (Vergeer, Lubbers, and Scheepers, 2000).
While proving that cultivation occurs is relatively easy, exposing its
mechanism is a difficult task, partly because this mechanism is probably
unconscious to the individual (Shrum, 2009), and partly because the cultivation phenomenon itself consists of at least two types of effect: the
positive relationship between extended media consumption and a distorted estimation of the world e. g. erroneous assessment of the prevalence of certain occupations in direct correspondence with these occupations’ media presence, which is known as a first order effect; and the
correlation between extended media consumption and attitudes that can
be directly derived from media messages e. g. supporting severe punishment for crimes that are often depicted in the media as causing severe
1
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
1119
1
When the wind changes direction
441
damage, which is termed a second order effect (Hawkins and Pingree,
1982).
The most often cited model for first order effects is heuristic processing
(Shrum, 1995). This model sees reality estimates as memory based judgments. When asked to give such estimates people recall information from
memory. Unconsciously, they turn to the media, which provide them
with a bank of exemplars that were encoded in a much unelaborated
manner whilst viewing television, playing a video game, or browsing the
internet. Media exemplars are prompted in retrieval because they are
vivid, salient, frequent and recent (particularly when we speak about
heavy media consumers). In other words ⫺ first order effects result from
resorting to heuristics aides (Shrum, Burroughs and Rindfleisch, 2004).
In contrast, second order cultivation effects are the outcome of online
persuasion. These judgments are typically beliefs and values that follow
the direction of media messages but are not memory based (Shrum, Burroughs and Rindfleisch, 2005). They can be enhanced by media consumption that helps to activate and rehearse attitudes which can be assumed from the media content, and later become more accessible to the
individual (Fazio, Chen, McDonel and Sherman, 1982). In the case of
second order effects, it is a rather thoughtful attention to the messages
and not some superficial processing of the content that is responsible for
expanding their size (Shrum et al., 2005). However, Shrum (2009) adds
that not all the second order attitudes that are impacted by the media
are formed in this fashion. When the attitude objects are not common,
individuals may be motivated to search their memory for information to
compute their attitude. In such cases, the mechanism of second order
cultivation effects may be similar to that of first order effects i. e. be (at
least partly) the result of heuristic processing of media information.
Cultivation studies are composed of four phases: First, a content
analysis quantifies the world of media content to which the public is
exposed. Second, the findings of the content analysis are used as benchmarks to formulate statements about the frequency of phenomena whose
likelihood to occur in typical media content is substantially different
from their likelihood to occur in the real world (in order to measure first
order effects) and about views that can be directly derived from the media (that are used to measure second order effects). Third, a survey that
asks people for their estimates and views is conducted. Fourth and finally, heavy media consumers and light media consumers are compared
for their responses to the survey questions (Morgan and Signorielli,
1990). Cultivation is deemed to occur when under multiple controls,
such as demographics and personality traits, heavy media consumers still
give “cultivated answers” which represent the world of media content
but are not representative of the real world, and hold views that can be
Amir Hetsroni
1
442
120
directly derived from media content more frequently than light media
consumers do, while light media consumers give real world answers
which accurately reflect social circumstances, and hold views that are
not typical of media content more often than heavy media consumers
do (Shanahan and Morgan, 1999).
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
1160
1
The function of media content in cultivation research and the case of
Iceland’s economy
There is no doubt that the homogeneity and the consistency of mass
media content have a role in establishing the cultivation effect (Shanahan
and Morgan, 1999, pp. 191⫺197). This is so because the mass media are
the most popular storytellers of our time and a source of socialization
and knowledge about the world (Gerbner et al., 2002). Typical media
content consists of stories that are coherent in details and comprise just
a handful of frequently recurring narratives such as “crime does not pay
off ” and “justice wins.” These narratives are characterized by a high
level of integrity and realism, which are key qualities for accepting stories as a true reflection of reality (Fisher, 1999). The public lacks the
motivation and tools to appraise the truthfulness of media content (Shanahan and Morgan, 1999). This particularly applies to the mass media
description of foreign countries, which often turns into a string of monothematic stories that repeat themselves and portray remote cultures as
“single adjective nations” e. g. “peaceful New Zealand”, “exotic Hawaii”
and “industrial Japan” (McNelly and Izcaray, 1986).
Against this background, it is not a coincidence that questions about
a foreign land yield a stronger cultivation effect compared to questions
about the home country (Hetsroni et al., 2007). The respondents’ direct
experience of foreign countries is limited and they rarely have access
to reliable non-media sources of information on the topic in question.
Therefore, they tend to rely more often on the media as a source of
knowledge (Ball-Rokeach, 1985), and are more likely to accept the media
representation as an accurate reflection of the real world (Adoni and
Mane, 1984). When people are asked questions about their close surroundings, they are in a condition of experiential closeness, which facilitates a systematic “recount and count” that may decrease the size of the
cultivation effect. However, when the questions pertain to a distant culture about which the respondents have very little prior knowledge and
with which they have no first hand acquaintance, they undergo experiential remoteness, which facilitates the activation of cognitive shortcuts,
the retrieval of media exemplars without reference to their source, and
eventually a stronger cultivation effect (Bilandzic, 2006). But what happens when the content that sets the background to this stronger effect,
When the wind changes direction
1
443
188
changes all of a sudden? A deeply rooted axiom within cultivation research postulates that media content is homogeneous and repetitive,
thereby exposing the public, particularly heavy media consumers, to a
long line of similar narratives that basically teach an identical lesson
(Shanahan and Morgan, 1999).
The international image of Iceland’s economy supplies us with an exceptional case wherein the leading media narrative has dramatically
changed overnight. During the 1990s and the 2000s, Iceland was known
as the “Nordic tiger”. From a small economy based mostly on fishing,
Iceland developed into a financial stronghold and one of the fastest
growing markets for consumer goods. However, the heavy share of loans
(compared to a low value of personal assets) and the lack of sufficient
foreign currency reserves caused a major banking crisis, soaring inflation, the devaluation of the local currency and a sharp increase in unemployment. Within a few short weeks in mid 2008, one of the richest
countries in the world (in terms of its standard of living) found itself on
the verge of bankruptcy. At the time this study was conducted, the crisis
was about to enter its second year.
This work will examine the correlation between media consumption
and estimates and beliefs about the economic condition of Iceland
among Israelis. Since Iceland is geographically and culturally remote
from Israel, Israelis are prone to undergo experiential remoteness, which
facilitates the emergence of a cultivation effect with regards to estimates
and views about this country (Bilandzic, 2006). Because the economic
condition of Iceland is a not hot topic in the Israeli public agenda, beliefs
about it ⫺ which in cultivation terms are regarded as second order measures ⫺ are expected to follow the origination path of first order estimates i. e. stem from heuristic processing (Shrum, 2009).
189
Research questions
190
Will the cultivation effect conform to the longstanding pre-crisis media
presentation of Iceland as a thriving economy, or will it corroborate the
current negative image of Iceland’s economy? Cultivation-wise, this is a
contest between two heuristics ⫺ frequency and recency ⫺ which predict
contradicting effects: If the influence of frequency is stronger than the
influence of recency, there will be a positive correlation between media
consumption and a positive evaluation of the Icelandic economy (because for many years Iceland was portrayed in the media as a thriving
economy). However, if the influence of recency is stronger than the influence of frequency, there will be a positive correlation between media
consumption and a negative evaluation of the Icelandic economy (because the most recent media reports portray the Icelandic economy nega-
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
1201
1
Amir Hetsroni
1
444
202
tively). Of course, we will have to demonstrate, first, beyond doubt, that
since the outbreak of the economic crisis in 2008 the image of Iceland,
and particularly the way that the Israeli media represents the Icelandic
economy has changed significantly from positive to neutral or even negative.
Since the impact of a shift in media content on the cultivation effect
has not been heretofore examined, we will ask research questions rather
than posit directional hypotheses. The first research question (RQ1) examines changes in media content. The second research question (RQ2) is
concerned with first order cultivation effects. The third research question
(RQ3) asks about second order cultivation effects.
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
228
229
RQ1: Has there been a lasting change in the presentation of Iceland in
the Israeli media since the outbreak of the economic crisis in
2008 ⫺ manifested in more extensive coverage of the economy
and a more negative tone of the stories?
RQ2: Is there a significant correlation (and if there is ⫺ in what direction) between media consumption and a positive assessment of
Iceland’s economy (estimates of the the average salary level in
Iceland and estimates of the condition of the Icelandic economy)?
RQ3: Is there a significant correlation (and if there is ⫺ in what direction) between media consumption and the willingness to consider
immigrating to Iceland because of its economic appeal and the
belief that the person’s standard of living would improve as a
result of such immigration?
230
Method
231
237
Taking place in Israel, the study consisted of a content analysis of local
newspaper articles to determine the theme and tone of reports concerning Iceland before and after the outbreak of the economic crisis in 2008
and a survey that asked the respondents to provide their estimates (first
order cultivation measures) and views (second order cultivation measures) regarding the current state of the Icelandic economy and the economic aspects of immigrating to and living in Iceland.
238
Content Analysis
239
Sample
240
The data were obtained from a systematic coding of items about Iceland
that appeared in the online editions of Israel’s most highly circulated
general newspapers ⫺ Maariv and Yedioth Ahronot and in the country’s
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
232
233
234
235
236
241
1242
1
When the wind changes direction
1
445
269
leading economic newspaper Haaretz-The Marker between May 2003
(five years before the crisis started) and May 2009 (one year after the
crisis started). Approximately 80 % of the stories that appear in the newspapers’ printed edition can also be found in their internet editions, which
regularly rank among the 20 most highly browsed websites in Israel (Cohen, 2009). Thus, our sample provides an ample representation of news
items ⫺ both for the printed press and for online news. Seven hundred
and fifty seven stories were retrieved when using the words “Iceland”
and “Icelandic” as search-terms in search engines placed at the newspapers’ homepages. This number includes 49 items in which one of the
words ⫺ “Iceland” or “Icelandic” ⫺ was mentioned, even though the
article did not relate to Iceland. These items were not coded. The remaining 708 items which were analyzed consisted of 418 items from the two
general newspapers (Maariv, Yedioth Ahronot) and 290 items from the
economic newspaper (Haaretz-The Marker). The breakdown of items by
year was as follows: 93 items from 2003, 78 items from 2004, 76 items
from 2005; 96 items from 2006, 69 items from 2007 (altogether 412 items
dating to before the outbreak of the economic crisis); 182 items from
2008 and 114 items from 2009 (altogether 309 items dating to the time
of the crisis).
Using newspaper articles as raw material in message system analysis
is less common in cultivation research than using television programming, but such articles have been used before in a reliable manner (see
Vergeer et al., 2000). Moreover, in our case, newspaper articles constitute
the more ample source of media content to analyze since television news
reports in Israel contain only a meager portion of items about distant
countries such as Iceland (Avraham, First, and Elephant-Lepler, 2004).
270
Content categories
271
The unit of analysis was the article in its entirety. The coding book included 37 topics (adapted from previous analyses of foreign news ⫺ see
Markham, 1961; Donohew, 1967; Gans, 2005). Since the minute distinction between several of the topics, many of which do not appear even
once in the sample, has no significance to the study, we have grouped
together bunches of topics into five themes. These were (in parenthesis ⫺
the complete list of topics): politics (internal politics, foreign affairs and
security, crime and terror, immigration and inter-racial relations, demonstrations and rallies); economy (real estate, fishing and agriculture, stock
exchange, banking, currency, finances and inflation, heavy industry, high
tech, services, marketing, economic globalization, welfare and unemployment); sport; Israel and Iceland (stories about Israelis who live in
Iceland, Israel-Iceland bilateral relations); lifestyle and good life (land-
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
253
254
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268
272
273
274
275
276
277
278
279
280
281
282
1283
1
Amir Hetsroni
1
446
284
292
scape and environment, tourism, folklore, food, education, science and
medicine). When the theme was the economy, we further coded the tone
of the report as positive (i. e. as conveying the message that the country’s
economy ⫺ or a particular sector ⫺ was thriving or improving), negative
(i. e. as conveying the message that the country’s economy ⫺ or a particular sector ⫺ was experiencing a crisis), or unknown/neutral (when the
economic condition of the country ⫺ or a particular sector ⫺ could not
be inferred from the text, or when the article was conveying the message
that the economy was neither thriving nor was it in a state of crisis).
293
Coding reliability
294
299
The coding was performed by two students, who separately coded all
the items without being privy to the goals of the research. Inter-coder
reliability was computed for the overall sample and was measured
through Krippendorff’s Alpha coefficient. The values of this coefficient
for theme (α ⫽ 0.929) and tone (α ⫽ 0.813) indicate an adequate level
of reliability.
300
Survey
301
Sample
302
313
The respondents were MBA students attending an Israeli public university, who filled the questionnaire to receive extra credit in one of their
courses (response rate ⫽ 91 %). This group of respondents was intentionally picked because MBA students are likely to have some interest in
economic matters, which could assist in detecting small effects (which
are typical of cultivation) among consumers of less than popular economic media. Of the total of 304 respondents (all of them Jews), 144
(47.5 %) were males and 160 (52.5 %) were females. Their age ranged
from 21 to 57 with a median of 27. With respect to religion, half of the
respondents defined themselves as secular, while the other half was divided between those who considered themselves traditional (22 %), and
those who saw themselves as religious (28 %).
314
Instrument and Procedure
315
The survey was conducted in May 2009. The questionnaire asked the
respondents to give estimates regarding the current economic conditions
in Iceland and the average monthly salary in Iceland (first order cultivation measures), to express their view as to whether or not the economic
appeal of Iceland may persuade them to consider immigrating there, and
285
286
287
288
289
290
291
295
296
297
298
303
304
305
306
307
308
309
310
311
312
316
317
318
1319
1
When the wind changes direction
1
447
329
to decide whether such immigration would have positively affected their
standard of living (second order cultivation measures).
We also asked the respondents to assess the daily time they devote to
newspaper reading and to provide demographic details (sex, religiosity,
age, family status, whether or not they have any family members or close
friends living in Iceland, and whether or not they had ever visited the
country), which would serve as control factors. In order to avoid an
answering order bias, the items concerning Iceland had all been presented before the questions about media consumption were asked (see
Shanahan and Morgan, 1999).
330
Measures
331
Media consumption (newspaper reading)
332
338
The questionnaire asked open-ended questions “how much time do you
read [general newspapers /economic newspapers] on an average day?” Answers were given in hours and minutes. Examples of each kind of newspaper were provided as aides. Open-ended questions such as these were
used previously in cultivation studies to measure media consumption
(Gerbner, Gross, Jackson-Beeck, Jeffries-Fox and Signorielli, 1978; Morgan, 1983; Signorielli, 1989; Hetsroni and Tukachnisky, 2006).
339
Cultivation measures
340
Following the technique developed by Gerbner and his associates and
used intensively in cultivation research (Gerbner et al. 1978; Gerbner et
al., 1980; Signorielli, 1990; Hetsroni et al., 2007), each of the items that
asked for an estimate of the economic reality in Iceland (first order cultivation measures) presented two optional answers (with random re-ordering of the options to prevent a response set effect):
320
321
322
323
324
325
326
327
328
333
334
335
336
337
341
342
343
344
345
346
347
348
349
350
351
352
353
354
355
356
1357
1
1. A non-cultivated answer, which is a close approximation of the economic reality in Iceland as deemed from official statistics (Statistics
Iceland, 2009). This answer corresponds to what Gerbner and his
colleagues call “a real world answer.” A few of the numbers have
been rounded to look more reasonable in the eyes of “suspicious”
respondents (for an extended discussion of this rationale ⫺ see Shanahan and Morgan, 1999, pp. 53⫺54).
2. A cultivated answer, which is an exaggeration of the economic reality
in Iceland in the direction pointed to by the media’s presentation of
this country before the outbreak of the crisis. This answer corresponds to what Gerbner and his colleagues call “a TV answer” (Shanahan and Morgan, 1999, p. 24)
Amir Hetsroni
1
448
358
The first order cultivation items that appeared in our questionnaire were:
359
What do you think is the average monthly salary of a full-time time worker
in Iceland?
360
361
362
(a) 3,500 g (non-cultivated answer)
(b) 7,000 g (cultivated answer)
364
365
What do you think is the current economic condition in Iceland?
366
(a) Negative (non-cultivated answer)
368
Second order cultivation items offered the respondents the opportunity
to choose between two optional answers ⫺ one of which expressed a
negative view of Iceland’s economy, whereas the second expressed a positive view of the island’s economy (in line with the media representation
of Iceland prior to the crisis). The items, which appeared with random
re-ordering of the answers throughout the questionnaires, were:
369
370
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
378
381
382
383
(b) Positive (cultivated answer)
Would you consider immigrating to Iceland because of this country’s economic appeal?
(a) Surely no, or likely no
(non-cultivated answer)
(b) Surely yes, or likely yes
(cultivated answer)
Let’s say that you have just immigrated to Iceland. What, in your opinion,
would happen to your standard of living?
385
(a) It would not improve
(non-cultivated answer)
388
Results
389
RQ1
390
RQ1 asked how the economic crisis has affected the portrayal of Iceland
in the Israeli media. To answer this question, let us look at Table 1 which
shows the theme distribution for items that appeared in Israeli general
and economic newspapers before and after the outbreak of the economic
crisis in 2008.
Both newspaper categories show a considerable increase in the share
of articles devoted to Iceland’s economy during the crisis, compared to
the share of this theme prior to outbreak of the crisis. In the general
newspapers the share of stories about the economy increased from null
before the outbreak of the crisis to nearly 37 % after the crisis had
started. In the economic newspaper, the share of stories about the econ-
384
391
392
393
394
395
396
397
398
399
1400
1
(b) It would improve
(cultivated answer)
1
1
704
1
705
706
707
711
710
709
708
712
717
726
729
728
727
735
730
741
736
742
747
753
748
754
761
760
759
Table 1. Themes in articles about Iceland published in Israeli general and economic newspapers before the outbreak of the economic crisis
and during the crisis.
Theme
Politics
Economy
Lifestyle and good life
Sport
Israel and Iceland
General newspapers (N ⫽ 418)
Economic newspapers (N⫽290)
Before the crisis
(N ⫽ 248)
During the crisis
(N ⫽ 170)
Before the crisis
(N ⫽ 164)
During the crisis
(N ⫽ 126)
30.3 %
0.0 %
30.3 %
30.3 %
9.1 %
57.1 %
36.7 %
6.1 %
0.0 %
0.0 %
15.1 %
19.3 %
21.1 %
40.4 %
4.2 %
19.5 %
63.3 %
3.1 %
14.1 %
0.0 %
When the wind changes direction
449
1
450
Amir Hetsroni
764
765
766
770
769
768
767
771
774
Table 2. Tone of articles about Iceland’s economy published in Israeli newspapers before
the outbreak of the economic crisis and during the crisis.
Article tone
780
779
778
777
781
784
785
788
789
794
793
792
Positive
Negative
Neutral/Unknown
Period of publication
Before the crisis (N ⫽ 74)
During the crisis (N ⫽ 32)
0.0 %
12.5 %
87.5 %
3.4 %
92.2 %
4.4 %
427
omy more than tripled ⫺ going from 19 % prior to the crisis to 63 %
since the beginning of the crisis. At the same time, the prevalence of
stories about lifestyle and the good life decreased in general newspapers
from 30 % in the pre-crisis years to 6 % during the crisis. In the economic
newspaper this share decreased from 21 % before the outbreak of the
crisis to barely 3 % during the crisis. The distribution of the articles’
theme before the outbreak of the crisis is significantly different from the
2
respective distribution during the crisis {χ(4)
⫽ 30.5 P < .001 λ ⫽ .060
2
for the general newspapers; χ(4) ⫽ 77.5 P < .001 λ ⫽ .194 for the economic newspaper}.
As for the positive/negative tone of stories about the economy ⫺ we
were able to identify such tone in 137 items ⫺ of which 74 dated to
before the outbreak of crisis and 32 dated to the time of the crisis. Since
only five of the stories from the time of the crisis which had an identified
tone were published in general newspapers, for the purpose of statistical
inference we had to combine the figures from both types of newspapers.
Table 2 shows how the tone of stories about the economy was distributed
before the outbreak of the economic crisis and how it was distributed
during the crisis.
The sharp increase in the share of negative stories (from 12.5 % before
the outbreak of the crisis to 92 % during the crisis) is statistically signifi2
cant {χ(2)
⫽ 81.7 P < .001 λ ⫽ .580}.
To sum up, the answer to RQ1 is that the makeup of stories regarding
Iceland in the Israeli press changed significantly after the beginning of
the economic crisis ⫺ exhibiting an increase in the share of stories about
the economy which portray the economic condition in Iceland since
2008 negatively.
428
RQ2
429
RQ2 dealt with first order cultivation effects. To demonstrate the existence of these effects, we first look at the percent of cultivated exaggerated answers among light and heavy media consumers. This is a common
401
402
403
404
405
406
407
408
409
410
411
412
413
414
415
416
417
418
419
420
421
422
423
424
425
426
430
1431
1
1
1
798
799
800
804
803
802
801
805
808
Table 3. The percent of cultivated answers given by heavy media consumers and light media consumers.
Cultivation measures
813
818
821
820
819
822
828
829
830
836
837
845
838
846
847
General newspapers
Economic newspapers
Light readers
Heavy readers
Light readers
Heavy readers
First order
cultivation
measures
Estimation of average salary level in Iceland
Estimation of economic condition in Iceland
22.7 %
22.0 %
34.2 %
39.5 %
24.2 %
27.3 %
46.7 %
40.0 %
Second order
cultivation
measures
Willingness to consider immigration to Iceland
due to its economic appeal
Believing that the personal standard of living
would improve as a result of immigration to
Iceland
11.7 %
23.7 %
15.2 %
13.3 %
70.9 %
84.2 %
18.0 %
38.9 %
When the wind changes direction
857
856
855
Media consumption (newspaper reading)
451
Amir Hetsroni
1
452
432
mode of data presentation in cultivation research (see, for example,
Gerbner et al. 1978; Morgan, 1983; Hetsroni et al., 2007). The borderline
between light media consumption and heavy media consumption was
drawn at the sample’s median ⫺ which was 30 minutes per day for general newspapers and 15 minutes per day for economic newspapers. Table
3 shows, for all the items, the percent of exaggerated (cultivated) answers
elicited by heavy media consumers vs. light media consumers.
When responding to the first order items, heavy newspaper readers
give exaggerated cultivated answers which correspond to the pre-crisis
media image of Iceland more frequently than light newspaper readers
give. This pattern of cultivation differentials, i. e. consisted differences in
the share of cultivated answers between heavy media consumers and
light media consumers, holds for both types of newspapers.
To validate the significance of the relationship between media consumption and first order cultivation measures and to assess the size of
this effect, we built hierarchical logistic regression models, where the
predicted variable was the cultivation measure (first or second order).
The eight predictors were composed of the following groups: four sociodemographic indicators (age, sex, religiosity, family status) ⫺ all inserted
in block 1; two indicators of first-hand acquaintance with Iceland (previous visits to Iceland and whether or not the person has family members
or friends living in Iceland) that were inserted in block 2; and finally,
two measures of media consumption (daily reading of general newspapers, daily reading of economic newspapers) that were inserted in block
3. Logistic regression was chosen, since this procedure is ample to examine the combined and discrete impact of multiple interval measures on a
binary nominal variable, and because it can accept a limited number of
categorical predictors (like some of the demographic indicators) into the
equation (Hosmer and Lemeshow, 2000). Table 4 displays the results of
the logistic regression for all the cultivation items. This table includes a
notation of statistical significance for specific predictors (the regression
coefficients), for the blocks and for the complete model and lists the
values of Nagelkerke R square that point out the strength of the overall
effect and block effects.
The influence of newspaper reading on estimating the level of the
average salary in Iceland and on estimating the current economic condition in Iceland is statistically significant for economic newspapers but
not for general newspapers (see the significance level of the regression
coefficients in the newspaper reading block). Of all the control variables,
the only significant predictor is sex, which predicts estimation of the
economic condition in Iceland (women estimate it more positively than
men do).
433
434
435
436
437
438
439
440
441
442
443
444
445
446
447
448
449
450
451
452
453
454
455
456
457
458
459
460
461
462
463
464
465
466
467
468
469
470
471
472
1473
1
When the wind changes direction
1
453
862
863
864
868
867
866
865
Table 4. Logistic regression results for estimation of average salary level in Iceland ⫺
first-order cultivation measure (N ⫽ 304).
Block 1
875
882
885
884
883
889
886
897
890
905
898
906
913
914
921
922
923
924
930
931
936
940
937
941
945
950
946
951
955
960
956
961
965
966
972
971
970
973
974
975
976
980
979
978
977
Block 1: Demographics
Age
Sex
Religiosity
Family status
SE
B
SE
B
⫺.004
⫺.360
⫺.065
.403
.033
.438
.259
.476
⫺.012
⫺.291
⫺.124
.251
.033
.446
.283
.482
⫺.013
.149
⫺.410
.888
.036
.480
.316
.565
.438 .217
.363 .228
.934
.355
.525
.269
Block 3: Newspaper reading
General newspapers
Economic newspapers
Nagelkerke R2
.017
Nagelkerke R2 change per block
χ 2 value for block
1.569
χ 2 value for model
1.569
SE
1.285 1.272
2.450* 1.112
.223
.154
15.349****
21.693***
.069
.052
4.776
6.344
Note: % correctly predicted ⫽ 71.4
* p < .05 ** p < .01 *** p < .005 **** p < .001
Logistic regression results for estimation of the economic condition in Iceland ⫺ firstorder cultivation measure (N ⫽ 304).
Block 1
B
1
Block 3
B
Block 2: First-hand acquaintance with Iceland
Previous visits to Iceland
Family members or friends in Iceland
987
994
997
996
995
998
1001
1002
1009
1017
1010
1018
1025
1026
1033
1034
1036
1037
1043
1044
1045
1050
1051
1054
1055
1059
1060
1064
1065
1069
1070
1073
1074
1078
1079
1085
1084
1083
1086
1087
1
Block 2
Block 1: Demographics
Age
Sex
Religiosity
Family status
Block 2
SE
B
⫺ .046
.034 ⫺.042
1.362*** .437 1.381***
⫺.039
⫺.232
.103
⫺.414
.448 ⫺.317
Block 2: First-hand acquaintance with Iceland
Previous visits to Iceland
.774
Family members or friends
.088
in Iceland
Block 3: Newspaper reading
General newspapers
Economic newspapers
Nagelkerke R2
.181
Nagelkerke R2 change per block
χ2 value for block
20.683****
χ2 value for model
20.683****
Note: % correctly predicted ⫽ 64.6
* p < .05 ** p < .01 *** p < .005 **** p < .001
Block 3
SE
.338
.204
.035
.441
.248
.456
.888
.221
B
SE
⫺.042
2.573****
⫺.262
⫺.290
.036
.634
.322
.540
.295
.144
.345
.221
4.160**** 1.033
.206
.380
.025
.174
3.156
23.667****
23.838***
47.515****
1
454
Amir Hetsroni
1090
1091
1092
1096
1095
1094
1093
Table 4. Logistic regression results for willingness to consider immigration to iceland due
to its economic appeal ⫺ second-order cultivation measure (N ⫽ 304).
Block 1
1103
1110
1113
1112
1111
1117
1114
1125
1118
1133
1126
1134
1141
1142
1149
1150
1151
1152
1158
1159
1160
1166
1167
1168
1173
1169
1174
1178
1184
1179
1185
1189
1190
1195
1196
1203
1202
1201
1204
1205
1206
1210
1209
1208
1207
Block 1: Demographics
Age
Sex
Religiosity
Family status
1
1
B
SE
B
⫺.094
⫺.520
.642***
⫺.119
.044
⫺.107
.298
⫺.452
.189*** .614***
.376
⫺.142
Block 3: Newspaper reading
General newspapers
Economic newspapers
Nagelkerke R2
.091
Nagelkerke R2 change per block
χ 2 value for block
23.153****
χ 2 value for model
23.153****
Block 3
SE
Block 2: First-hand acquaintance with Iceland
Previous visits to Iceland
2.369*
Family members or
⫺.144
friends in Iceland
B
SE
.045
⫺.080
.303
⫺.478
.205*** .595***
.391
.035
.936
.166
.116
.025
6.422*
29.575****
1.334
⫺.116
.044
.321
.205***
.405
1.184
.169
.667*
.308
⫺.275
.456
.135
.019
4.991*
34.566****
Note: % correctly predicted ⫽ 86.4 * p < .05 ** p < .0 *** p < .005 * *** p < .001
Logistic regression results for believing that the personal standard of living would improve
as a result of immigration to Iceland ⫺ second-order cultivation measure (N ⫽ 304).
Block 1
1217
1224
1227
1226
1225
1228
1229
1230
1237
1245
1238
1246
1253
1254
1261
1262
1263
1264
1270
1271
1272
1278
1279
1282
1283
1287
1288
1292
1293
1298
1299
1304
1305
1310
1311
1318
1317
1316
1319
Block 2
Block 1: Demographics
Age
Sex
Religiosity
Family status
Block 2
Block 3
B
SE
B
SE
B
SE
⫺.056
.124
.400
⫺.047
.034
.440
.257
.486
⫺.085
.616
⫺.082
⫺.200
.037 ⫺.107
.488 1.483
.311 ⫺.208
.524 1.011
.044
.670
.348
.667
Block 2: First-hand acquaintance with Iceland
Previous visits to Iceland
Family members or friends
in Iceland
Block 3: Newspaper reading
General newspapers
Economic newspapers
Nagelkerke R2
.111
Nagelkerke R2 change per block
χ 2 value for block
10.507
χ 2 value for model
10.507
.835
.294
1.133**** .324
.288
.117
18.27****
29.334****
.696
.418
.875** .318
1.340* .532
1.951* .816
.482
.194
24.402****
53.736****
Note: % correctly predicted ⫽ 69.0 * p < .05 ** p < .01 *** p < .005 **** p < .001
When the wind changes direction
1
455
480
To sum up, our answer to RQ2 is that there is a pattern of first order
cultivation effects in the dataset for economic newspapers. The state of
the economy in Iceland is estimated more positively, in line with the
media image of Iceland before the outbreak of the economic crisis, by
Israelis who devote more time to reading economic newspapers. A similar trend exists for general newspapers, but it falls short of statistical
significance.
481
RQ3
482
Finally, we examine RQ3, which was concerned with second order cultivation effects. To demonstrate the existence of these effects, we look at
the lower part of Table 3 and see the differences in the share of cultivated
answers between heavy media consumers and light media consumers.
Heavy readers of general newspapers, who make up the upper half of
the sample in the amount of time they devote to newspaper reading, give
cultivated answers to second order questions more frequently than light
readers, who make the lower half of the sample in the amount of time
devoted to newspaper reading. This pattern of cultivation differentials
does not hold completely for economic newspapers: Heavy readers of
economic newspapers do give a cultivated answer to the question about
believing in improvement in the standard of living as a result of immigration to Iceland more frequently than light readers of economic newspapers give, but they do not give a cultivated answer to the question about
willingness to consider such immigration more often than light readers
give.
To validate the significance of the relationship between media consumption and second order cultivation measures and to assess the size
of this effect, we turn to the last two logistic regression models on Table 4.
The regression coefficients of general newspaper reading on willingness
to consider immigration to Iceland and on believing that such immigration would bring about improvement in the immigrant’s standard of living are statistically significant. However, economic newspaper reading
reaches significance only in one of the second order cultivation items
(believing that the standard of living would improve after immigration
to Iceland). In other words, the second-order cultivation effect is fully
significant for general newspapers and partly significant for economic
newspapers. This finding leads to the conclusion that there is a significant positive relationship between media consumption and an affirmative view of immigration to Iceland because of the country’s economic
appeal, but this relationship does not apply to all the measures of media
consumption. Of all the control variables, the only significant predictions
are noted for family status (secular respondents are more likely to con-
474
475
476
477
478
479
483
484
485
486
487
488
489
490
491
492
493
494
495
496
497
498
499
500
501
502
503
504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
513
1514
1
Amir Hetsroni
1
456
515
525
sider immigration to Iceland due to the country’s economic appeal) and
having family members or friends who live in Iceland, which positively
predicts believing that immigration to Iceland would bring about improvement in their standard of living.
Our results suggest the existence of partly significant first and second
order cultivation effects, correlating Israelis’ newspaper reading with a
positive estimation and an optimistic view of the current condition of
the Icelandic economy. This outlook is not in line with the presentation
of Iceland in Israeli newspapers at the time of the study, but it has affinity with the presentation of this country in local newspapers in previous years.
526
Discussion
527
In the main part, our findings confirm the cultivation prediction by demonstrating that heavy media consumers see a portion of the world (in
this case: the economy of a small foreign country) in a way that is similar
to the way this portion of the world was presented in the local media
for years. The effect is observed at the first order level (since the positive
estimation of the condition of the Icelandic economy is more common
among heavy readers of local newspapers) and at the second order level
(because Israelis are more willing to consider immigration to Iceland due
to its economic appeal and are more likely to believe that their standard
of living would improve if they immigrated ⫺ as their newspaper reading increases).
While we are not pioneers in demonstrating the cultivation effect of
newspaper reading (see Vergeer et al., 2000) by showing an effect on
beliefs about distant countries (see Hetsroni et al., 2007), and not even
by pointing at economic evaluations as a cultivation indicator (see ⫺
Frey et al., 2007) ⫺ the combination of all of the above pushes cultivation beyond the realms ordinarily covered. Furthermore, the conventional view of cultivation takes the unaltered homogeneous nature of
media content as an axiom and uses it to explain why people unconsciously accept this content as a true reflection of reality. we were able
to show that when the content and tone of media messages suddenly
change, the cultivation effect continues to respond to the former image.
The news about the severe economic crisis in Iceland was more recent
for Israelis when they took part in the study, yet they adhered to old
news about Iceland’s affluence, when determining their view of the
country’s economy.
This finding has implications at more than one level. First, from a
cultivation standpoint, it indicates that frequency (the positive reports
about Iceland stretched for a longer period than the recent negative re-
516
517
518
519
520
521
522
523
524
528
529
530
531
532
533
534
535
536
537
538
539
540
541
542
543
544
545
546
547
548
549
550
551
552
553
554
1555
1
1
When the wind changes direction
457
576
ports and outnumbered them) is more potent than recency in predicting
the direction of the cultivation effect. In other words ⫺ when there is
content incongruence between recent media messages and frequent media messages, the frequent messages are more likely to carry the cultivation effect in their direction. A similar trend was also noted in memory
studies that are not media-related (Higgins, Bargh, and Lombardi, 1985;
Wyer and Radvansky, 1999). Second, from a political point of view, our
results suggest that using the media to rapidly change the image of lesser
known countries is not an easy task. Third and last, from the viewpoint
of content analysts and media content researchers, our results indicate that
media stories leave lasting traces that impact judgments for years.
Even though a few of the media consumption measures that we used
in this study failed to reach significance, something that might have been
expected in light of the small cultivation effect (Shanahan and Morgan,
1999), none of the control variables performed better. In fact, newspaper
reading was the only block that consistently predicted evaluation of the
Icelandic economy. Interestingly, Israelis’ first-hand acquaintance with
Iceland had very little influence here ⫺ perhaps because of the small
variance in the predicting variables (only 10 of the 304 respondents had
ever visited Iceland and only 4 of them had close friends or family relatives who live on the island).
577
Study limitations and suggestions for further research
578
To avoid overly-comprehensive conclusions we should not forget the
weaker aspects of this work. We were given a unique opportunity to
examine the effect of a sudden change in the content and tone of news
media reports on the direction of the cultivation effect, but the topic that
we used as a case study is not necessarily representative of news media
and certainly not representative of the gamut of media contents. Specifically, the geographical and cultural remoteness of Iceland from Israel
made the Israeli public more prone to cultivation when asked questions
about Iceland, but this remoteness might also make the response to second order cultivation items more memory based and less an online judgment ⫺ unlike the common mechanism that sets the reaction to second
order cultivation items (Shrum, 2009).
As for the data analysis, we had statistical control over several potentially intervening factors. However, this is still a cross-sectional study, in
which any claim about causation remains in doubt. In addition to this
weakness, the non-representative composition of the respondents ⫺ although appropriately serving the purpose of detecting cultivation effects
among consumers of economic media ⫺ still puts limitations on the
capability to generalize the findings into more diverse populations.
556
557
558
559
560
561
562
563
564
565
566
567
568
569
570
571
572
573
574
575
579
580
581
582
583
584
585
586
587
588
589
590
591
592
593
594
595
1596
1
Amir Hetsroni
1
458
597
601
Therefore, the trends that were detected in this work should be further
tested in other topics and in other populations before we can safely
declare that the cultivation effect is shaped by frequent media representation from the past more than it responds to the most recent media
images.
602
Bionote
603
604
Amir Hetsroni is Senior Lecturer at the School of Communication, Ariel
University Center, Israel.
605
References
606
Adoni, H., & Mane, S. (1984). Media and the social construction of reality: Toward
an integration of theory and research. Communication Research, 11, 323⫺340.
Avraham, A. First, A., & Elephant-Lepler, N. (2004). The absentees and attendees on
primetime: Cultural variety in commercial television broadcasts in Israel. Jerusalem:
The Second Authority for Radio and Television.
Ball-Rokeach, S. J. (1985). The origins of individual media-system dependency: A sociological perspective. Communication Research, 12(4), 485⫺510.
Bilandzic, H. (2006). The perception of distance in the cultivation process: A theoretical consideration of the relationship between television content, processing experience, and perceived distance. Communication Theory, 16, 333⫺355.
Cohen, M. (2009, February 15). Totsahot Seker TIM le-shimush ba-Internet bechodesh Februar [TIM internet use survey results for February]. Haaretz ⫺
The Marker. Retrieved March 3, 2009, from http://www.themarker.com/tmc/
article.jhtml?ElementId⫽mc20090315_45450
Donohew, L. (1967). Newspaper gatekeepers and forces in the news channel. Public
Opinion Quarterly, 31(1), 6168.
Fazio, R. H., Chen, J., McDonel, E. C., & Sherman, S. J. (1982). Attitude accessibility,
attitude-behavior consistency, and strength of the object-evaluation association.
Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 18, 339⫺357.
Fisher, W. R. (1999). Narration as a human communication paradigm: The case of
public moral argument. In J. L. Lucaites, C. M. Condit & S. Caudill (Eds.), Contemporary rhetorical theory: A reader (pp. 265⫺287). NY: Guilford Press.
Fox, W. S., & Philliber, W. W. (1978). Television viewing and the perception of affluence. Sociological Quarterly, 19, 103⫺112.
Frey, B. S., Benesch, C., & Stutzer, A. (2007). Does watching TV make us happy?
Journal of Economic Psychology, 28(3), 283⫺313.
Gans, H. J. (2005). Deciding what’s news ⫺ the 25 th anniversary edition. Evanston, IL:
Northwestern University Press
Gerbner, G. (1972). Communication and social environment. Scientific American,
227(3), 152⫺160.
Gerbner, G., & Gross. L. (1976). Living with television: The violence profile. Journal
of Communication, 26, 173⫺199.
Gerbner, G., Gross, L., Jackson-Beeck, M., Jeffries-Fox, S., & Signorielli, N. (1978).
Cultural indicators: Violence profile No. 9. Journal of Communication, 28(3),
176⫺207.
598
599
600
607
608
609
610
611
612
613
614
615
616
617
618
619
620
621
622
623
624
625
626
627
628
629
630
631
632
633
634
635
636
637
638
639
1640
1
1
641
642
643
644
645
646
647
648
649
650
651
652
653
654
655
656
657
658
659
660
661
662
663
664
665
666
667
668
669
670
671
672
673
674
675
676
677
678
679
680
681
682
683
684
685
686
687
688
689
690
1691
1
When the wind changes direction
459
Gerbner, G., Gross, L., Morgan, M., Signorielli, N., & Shanahan, J. (2002). Growing
up with television: Cultivation processes. In J. Bryant & D. Zillman (Eds.), Media
effects: Advances in theory and research (pp. 43⫺67). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Gerbner, G., Gross. L., Signorielli, N., & Morgan, M. (1980). Aging with television:
Images on television drama and conceptions of social reality. Journal of Communication, 30(1), 37⫺47.
Hawkins, R. P., & Pingree, S. (1982). Television’s influence on social reality. In D.
Pearl, L. Bouthilet & I. Lazar (Eds.), Television and behavior: Ten years of scientific
progress and implications for the eighties: Vol. 2 ⫺ Technical reviews (pp. 224⫺247).
Rockville, MD: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
Hetsroni, A., Elphariach. H., Kaputa, R., & Tsfoni, B. (2007). Geographical proximity, cultural imperialism and the cultivation effect. Communication Monographs,
74(2) 181⫺199.
Hetsroni, A., & Tukachinsky, R. H. (2006). TV world estimates and real world estimates: A new scheme for cultivation. Journal of Communication, 56(1), 133⫺156.
Higgins, E. T., Bargh, J. A., & Lombardi, W. (1985). The nature of priming effects
on categorization. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and
Cognition, 11, 59⫺69.
Hosmer, D., & Lemeshow, S. (2000). Applied logistic regression. NY: Wiley
Markham, J. W. (1961). Foreign news in the United States and South American press.
Public Opinion Quarterly, 25(2), 249⫺262.
McNelly, J. T., & Izcaray, F. (1986). International news exposure and images of
nations. Journalism Quarterly, 63(3), 546⫺553.
Morgan, M. (1983). Symbolic victimization and real world fear. Human Communication Research, 9, 146⫺157.
Morgan, M., & Signorielli, N. (1990). Cultivation analysis: Conceptualization and
methodology. In N. Signorielli & M. Morgan (Eds.), Cultivation analysis: New
directions in media effects research (pp. 13⫺33). Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
Peter J., & Valkenburg, P. M. (2006). Adolescents’ exposure to sexually explicit material on the internet. Communication Research, 33(2), 178⫺204.
Pfau, M., Mullen, L., Dietrich, T., & Garrow, K. (1995). Television viewing and public
perceptions of attorneys. Human Communication Research, 21(3), 307⫺330.
Potter, W. J. (1991). Examining cultivation from a psychological perspective: Component sub-processes. Communication Research, 18, 77⫺102.
Potter, W. J. (1994). Cultivation theory and research: A methodological critique.
Journalism Monographs, 147, 1⫺35.
Shanahan, J., & Morgan, M. (1999). Television and its viewers: Cultivation theory and
research. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
Shrum, L. J. (1995). Assessing the social influence of television: A social cognition
perspective. Communication Research, 22(4), 402⫺429.
Shrum, L. J. (2009). Effects of Television Viewing, In M. Wänke (Ed.), The Social
Psychology of Consumer Behavior (pp. 251⫺272). New York: Psychology Press.
Shrum, L. J., Burroughs, J. E., & Rindfleisch, A. (2004). A process model of consumer
cultivation: The role of TV is a function of type of judgment, In L. J. Shrum
(Ed.), The psychology of entertainment: Blurring the lines between entertainment
and persuasion (pp. 177⫺192). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Shrum, L. J., Burroughs, J. E., & Rindfleisch, A. (2005). Television’s cultivation of
material values. Journal of Consumer Research, 32(3), 473⫺479.
Signorielli, N. (1989). Television and conceptions about sex roles: Maintaining conventionality and the status quo. Sex Roles, 21(5/6), 341⫺360.
Amir Hetsroni
1
460
692
693
Signorielli, N. (1990). Television’s mean and dangerous world: A continuation of the
cultural indicators perspective. In N. Signorielli & M. Morgan (Eds.), Cultivation
analysis: New directions in media effects research (pp. 85⫺106). Newbury Park,
CA: Sage.
Statistics Iceland (2009). Iceland in figures 2009. Reykjavı́k, Iceland: Statistics Iceland.
Vergeer, M., Lubbers, M., & Scheepers, P. (2000). Exposure to newspapers and attitudes toward ethnic minorities: A longitudinal analysis. Howard Journal of Communication, 11, 127⫺143.
Weimann, G. (2000). Communicating unreality: Modern media and the reconstruction
of reality. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Wyer, R. S., & Radvansky, G. A. (1999). The comprehension and validation of social
information. Psychological Review, 106, 89⫺118.
694
695
696
697
698
699
700
701
702
703
1320
1
1