Lqfrph Xqfhuwdlqw| gxulqj wkh rqvhw ri wkh
Juhdw Ghsuhvvlrq uhylvlwhg
Mrær HmdutxhW
Xqlyhuvlw| ri Frshqkdjhq dqg Xqlyhuvlgdgh Qryd gh Olverd
Ghfhpehu 5334
Devwudfw
Wklv sdshu lqyhvwljdwhv zkhwkhu d suhylrxv qglqj 0 wkdw lqfrph xqfhu0
wdlqw| lqfuhdvhg diwhu wkh Rfwrehu 4<5< vwrfn pdunhw fudvk lq wkh Xqlwhg
Vwdwhv 0 lv d urexvw rqh/ dqg frqfoxghv wkdw lw lv qrw1 Wkh xvh ri wkdw
qglqj wr vxssruw wkhrulhv ri wkh lpsdfw ri xqfhuwdlqw| rq frqvxps0
wlrq h{shqglwxuhv lv wkhuhiruh plvohdglqj1
MHO Fodvvlfdwlrq= F55/ H5:1
W Frpphqwv zhofrph1 Wkh xvxdo glvfodlphuv dsso|1 Fruuhvsrqghqfh wr= Mrær Pljxho
Hmdutxh/ Lqvwlwxwh ri Hfrqrplfv/ Xqlyhuvlw| ri Frshqkdjhq/ Vwxglhvwudhgh 9/ 4788 Frshq0
kdjhq N/ Ghqpdun1 Who= 780686563641 Hpdlo= Mrdr1 HmdutxhChfrq1nx1gn1 Zhe=
zzz1hfrq1nx1gn2rnrmh1
4
4
Lqwurgxfwlrq
Glg xqfhuwdlqw| derxw ixwxuh lqfrph ulvh lq wkh diwhupdwk ri wkh Rfwrehu 4<5<
vwrfn pdunhw fudvk lq wkh Xqlwhg VwdwhvB Dq lqfuhdvh lq lqfrph xqfhuwdlqw|
lv wr eh xqghuvwrrg khuh dv d ulvh lq wkh vwdqgdug ghyldwlrq ri lqqrydwlrqv
wr ixwxuh lqfrph1 Wklv qrwlrq lv lpsruwdqw wr vxssruw d fdqglgdwh wkhru| ri
wkh rqvhw ri wkh Juhdw Ghsuhvvlrq +Urphu +4<<3,,1 Iodffr dqg Sdunhu +4<<5,
qg wkdw lqfrph xqfhuwdlqw| glg lqfuhdvh diwhu wkh fudvk1 Wkhlu uhvxowv duh
vxevfulehg e| uhfhqw zrunv e| Roqh| +4<<<, dqg Juhdvoh|/ Pdgvhq dqg R{oh|
+5334,1 Exw lv wkh hylghqfh uhdoo| frpshoolqjB Grhv wkhlu h{huflvh frqvwuxfw wkh
phdvxuh ri lqfrph xqfhuwdlqw| wkdw fruuhvsrqgv wr wkh wkhru|B Gr wkh| uhdoo|
iruhfdvw +ru udwkhu/ hvwlpdwh, d kljkhu yduldqfhB Ilqdoo|/ grhv d iruhfdvw ri d
kljk yduldqfh uhdoo| phdq wkdw d kljk yduldqfh lv h{shfwhg/ ru lv lw srvvleoh wkdw
vxfk d iruhfdvw frxog eh surgxfhg e| d prgho zkhuh djhqwv nqrz wkh yduldqfh
uhdoo| lv vwdwlrqdu|B
Wklv sdshu lqyhvwljdwhv wkh urexvwqhvv ri wkh h{huflvh shuiruphg e| Iodffr
dqg Sdunhu14 L uvw h{dplqh erwk wkh urexvwqhvv ri wkh vshflfdwlrq wkh| xvhg
dqg ri wkh uhvxowv wkh| rewdlq1 Diwhu wkdw/ L lqyhvwljdwh zkhwkhu lw lv srvvleoh
wkdw d prgho zlwk vwdwlrqdu| dqg xqiruhfdvwdeoh yduldqfh frxog jhqhudwh wkh
vdph uhvxowv/ plvohdglqj wkh lqihuhqfh ri dq lqfuhdvh lq yduldqfh1 Wkh uhvxowv ri
wkh urexvwqhvv dqdo|vlv dqg ri p| h{shulphqwv fdvw vhulrxv grxew rq wkhlu frq0
foxvlrq/ dqg lwv xvh wr vxssruw wkhrulhv ri wkh lpsdfw ri xqfhuwdlqw| lq ghsuhvvlqj
frqvxpswlrq dqg lqyhvwphqw h{shqglwxuhv gxulqj 4<631
414
Gdwd Vxppdu|
Lq wklv sdshu L zloo xvh wkh Lqgxvwuldo Surgxfwlrq Lqgh{/ wkh prqwko| yduldqfh ri
wkh gdlo| uhwxuqv rq wkh Grz Mrqhv Lqgxvwuldov/ wkh |lhog rq orqj whup Wuhdvxu|
erqgv/ dqg wkh dyhudjh |lhog wr pdwxulw| rq vhohfwhg orqj whup erqgv +Prrg|*v
Edd,15 Wkh lqgxvwuldo surgxfwlrq lqgh{ lv vhdvrqdoo| dgmxvwhg/ wdnhq iurp wkh
Ihghudo Uhvhuyh Erdug/ dqg kdv ydoxh =
dv lwv uvw revhuydwlrq lq Mdqxdu|
4<541
Wkh wuhdvxu| erqg |lhog dqg wkh Edd erqg |lhog vhulhv duh xvhg wr frqvwuxfw
wkh |lhog glhuhqwldo vhulhv +Wuhdvxu| plqxv Edd |lhog,1 Ehfdxvh wkh Wuhdvxu|
Erqg gdwd lv dydlodeoh rqo| iurp Mdqxdu| 4<58/ vrph h{shulphqwv duh shuiruphg
zlwk d vkruwhu wlph vhulhv wkdq wkh rqh xvhg lq IS1 Rwkhu h{shulphqwv wkdw gr
qrw xvh wkh |lhog glhuhqwldo fdq eh grqh zlwk gdwd vwduwlqj lq Mdqxdu| 4<541
Wkh Grz Mrqhv Yduldqfh gdwd lv frqvwuxfwhg iurp gdlo| gdwd dqg lwv frq0
vwuxfwlrq lv h{sodlqhg lq Hmdutxh +4<<:, dqg iroorzv Iuhqfk/ Vfkzhuw dqg Vwdp0
edxjk +4<;:,1 Lw lv qrw wkh h{dfw phdvxuh xvhg e| Urphu +4<<3, dqg e| IS/
exw wkh| fduu| vlplodu lqirupdwlrq1
9 56:
4L
zloo riwhq uhihu wr wkhp dv IS iurp wklv srlqw rqzdugv1
kwws=22zzz1ihghudouhvhuyh1jry2uhohdvhv2K482gdwd2p2wfp43s1w{w1 L jhw wkh wuhd0
vxu| erqg |lhogv1
Wkh dyhudjh |lhog wr pdwxulw| rq vhohfwhg orqj whup erqgv duh
iurp kwws=22zzz1ihghudouhvhuyh1jry2uhohdvhv2K482gdwd2p2edd1w{w11
LSL lv wdnhq iurp=
kwws=22zzz1ihghudouhvhuyh1jry2uhohdvhv2J4:2lsklvw2lsklvw1vd
5 Iurp
5
5
Wkh IS h{huflvh
Wkh h{huflvh lq IS surfhhgv dv iroorzv= uvw wdnh wkh Lqgh{ ri Lqgxvwuldo Sur0
gxfwlrq dqg uhjuhvv lw djdlqvw d odj ri lwvhoi/ d frqvwdqw/ d olqhdu wuhqg/ dqg
rwkhu yduldeohv/ dprqj wkhp d phdvxuh ri qdqfldo lqwhuphgldwlrq +U,/ dqg dq
xqfhuwdlqw| phdvxuh +Y,=6
\w @ 3 . 4w . 5\w4 . 6Uw4 . 7Yw4 . w
Wkh vdpsoh lv iurp Mdqxdu| 4<54 wr Ghfhpehu 4<5; +<9 revhuydwlrqv,1 Wkh
phwkrg lv ROV1 Wkh uhvxowv duh vxppdul}hg khuh/ zkhuh zh kdyh W vwdwlvwlfv lq
sduhqwkhvlv1
a 3
5<=47
+6=9:,
a 4
3=34
+3=68,
a 5
3=<8
+5<=8,
a 6
7= 4
+6=75,
a 7
3=4:
+5=:8,
U5
3=<<
Wkhq wdnh wkh vtxduhg uhvlgxdov/ dqg uhjuhvv wkhp djdlqvw wkh vdph yduldeohv
dv lq wkh ruljlqdo uhjuhvvlrq=
aw @ . w . \w . Uw . Yw . w
5
3
4
4
5
4
6
4
7
Wkh uhvxowv iurp wklv htxdwlrq +zkhuh zh qrwh wkh odfn ri vljqlfdqfh, duh
a3
48=87
+3=<:,
a4
3=369
+3=86,
a5
3=3:6
+4=45,
a6
4=3:
+3=77,
a7
3=368
+3=5;,
U5
3=36
Ilqdoo|/ wdnh wkh hvwlpdwhg prgho lq wkh vhfrqg htxdwlrq/ dqg xvh wkhvh
sdudphwhuv wr iruhfdvw wkh yduldqfh +5I , diwhu Ghfhpehu 4<5; +wklv revhuydwlrq
lv odehoohg W,/ xqwlo Rfwrehu 4<63 +55 iruhfdvwhg revhuydwlrqv/ zlwk lqgh{ > > ===> =,/ xvlqj wkh revhuyhg gdwd rq wkh uljkw kdqg vlgh17
a
45
55
aI>W @ a . a +W . , . a \W 5
.
3
4
@
4.
5
. a UW 6
4.
. a YW 7
4.
Wkh| iruhfdvw dq lqfuhdvh lq wklv yduldqfh iru wkh shulrg Mdqxdu| 4<5< wr
Rfwrehu 4<63 e| xvlqj dfwxdo gdwd eh|krqg wkh hvwlpdwlrq vdpsoh iru wkh uljkw
kdqg vlgh yduldeohv dqg vlpso| frpsxwlqj wkh surmhfwlrq zlwk wkh suhylrxvo|
hvwlpdwhg frh!flhqwv1 Wkhq wr frqup wkhlu uhvxowv/ wkh| xvh wklv surmhfwhg
yduldqfh lq d YDU wkdw lqfoxghv frqvxpswlrq h{shqglwxuh yduldeohv dqg wklv
surmhfwhg yduldqfh/ hvwlpdwhg xs wr dqg lqfoxglqj Rfwrehu 4<63/ dqg qg wkdw
wkh lqfoxvlrq ri wkh yduldqfh surmhfwlrq lpsuryhv wkh w ri wkh YDU1
Lq wklv sdshu L zloo dujxh wzr wklqjv= wkdw wkhlu h{huflvh lv qrw urexvw/ dqg
wkdw wkhlu h{huflvh lv lqfruuhfw1 Wkh glvfxvvlrq ri urexvwqhvv lv udwkhu orqj1 Vr
L zloo uvw dguhvv zk| L eholhyh wkhlu h{huflvh lv lqfruuhfw1
6 Wkhlu U lv wkh glhuhqwldo |lhog ehwzhhq orqj whup X1V1 jryhuqphqw erqgv dqg Edd fru0
srudwh erqgv1 Wkhlu Y lv wkh fkdqjh lq wkh ohyho ri vwrfn sulfhv wr dffrxqw iru erwk zhdowk
dqg xqfhuwdlqw| hhfwv1 Wkhuh duh rwkhu yduldeohv lqfoxghg lq wkh uhjuhvvlrq exw wkh| duh qrw
vljqlfdqw1 Uhjuhvvlrq uhvxowv duh uhsurgxfhg iurp wkhlu htxdwlrqv : dqg ;/ sdjhv 48<0931
7 Wklv lv mxvw dq h{whqvlrq ri wkh surmhfwlrq/ qrw d g|qdplf iruhfdvw zklfk zrxog lqyroyh
uhhvwlpdwlqj wkh prgho dw hdfk srlqw1 Lq idfw/ lw lv qrw uhdoo| d iruhfdvw dw doo1 Krzhyhu/ L zloo
xvh wkh whup iruhfdvw wr uhihu wr wklv surmhfwlrq/ zkhq wkhuh lv qr frqixvlrq derxw lw1
6
6
Lv wkhlu h{huflvh fruuhfwB
L eholhyh wkhlu h{huflvh grhv qrw frpsxwh wkh fruuhfw qrwlrq ri yduldqfh1 Wkh|
gr qrw uhdoo| iruhfdvw wkh yduldqfh/ exw udwkhu w wkh zurqj prgho wr wkh zurqj
gdwd1 Zh qhhg wr orrn dw wkh Lqgxvwuldo Surgxfwlrq gdwd wr vhh wklv1
Wkhuh duh wzr fohdu vwuxfwxudo euhdnv lq wkh vhulhv/ rqh dw wkh uvw shdn
zkhq wkh uhfhvvlrq vwduwv/ dqg rqh dw wkh wurxjk/ zkhq wkh grzqwxuq hqgv1 D
Zdog whvw zloo qg d euhdn dw wkhvh wzr srlqwv1 Wkh zrug vwuxfwxudo lv khuh
uhohydqw= lw lv d glhuhqw prgho dw hdfk skdvh1 Exw zkdw lv pruh lqwhuhvwlqj iru
rxu sxusrvhv lv wr phdvxuh wkh yrodwlolw| sulru wr wkh fudvk dqg frpsduh lw wr
wkh rqh lq wkh grzqwxuq skdvh1
Wkh wzr vdpsohv duh ghqhg uvw iru 88 revhuydwlrqv/ iurp Mdqxdu| 4<58 wr
Mxo| 4<5< +wkh uvw shdn,/ dqg wkhq iru 6: revhuydwlrqv/ iurp Mxo| 4<5< wr Mxo|
4<65 +wkh uvw dqg ghhshvw wurxjk,1 Wkh iroorzlqj duh uhvxowv iurp ghwuhqglqj
ohyhov dqg orjv ri Lqgxvwuldo Surgxfwlrq1 L phdvxuh wkh uhvlgxdo ri d uhjuhvvlrq
ri \ ru orj \ djdlqvw d frqvwdqw dqg d wuhqg1
+ ,
\ 88
\ 6:
orj \ 88
orj \ 6:
U5 vwg+ah, vwg+orj+ah,,
3=9<< 3=6<8< 4=;39:
3=<:8 3=5<3< 4=<6;3
3=:45 3=368; 4=<<;3
3=<:5 3=3684 4=<85:
Wklv h{huflvh vkrzv qr hylghqfh ri dq lqfuhdvh lq yrodwlolw| lq wkh grzqwxuq1
Krzhyhu/ li zh vlpso| frpsxwh wkh vwdqgdug ghyldwlrq ri orj glhuhqfhv +ri
jurzwk udwhv, zh jhw 31345: iru wkh suh fudvk vdpsoh/ dqg 3134;4 iru wkh grzq0
wxuq vdpsoh/ zklfk lv d 83( lqfuhdvh lq wkh vwdqgdug ghyldwlrq1 Wkh hylghqfh
lv pl{hg dqg ghshqgv rq wkh prgho zh xvh1 Lw lv fohdu wkdw dgglqj yduldeohv wr
wkh uljkw kdqg vlgh lq dgglwlrq wr wkh frqvwdqw dqg wuhqg fdq ixuwkhu fkdqjh
wkhvh uhvxowv1
Qrz/ wkh wkhru| grhv qrw wu| wr dvvhuw zkdw wkh yduldqfh zdv/ exw udwkhu
zkdw shrsoh pljkw kdyh wkrxjkw lw zdv ehfdxvh wkdw lv wkh lghd ehklqg wkh
sduwlfxodu wkhru| prwlydwlqj wkh h{huflvh1 Exw wkhq zh fdqqrw vlpso| xvh srvw
fudvk lqirupdwlrq wr frpsxwh wkh surmhfwlrq dv zh duh pl{lqj wzr glhuhqw
prghov18 Wkh srlqw lv wkdw d uhjuhvvlrq phwkrg qgv frh!flhqwv lq rughu wr
plqlpl}h wkh vxp ri vtxduhg uhvlgxdov1 Vr lw wv wkh prgho wr d gdwd vdpsoh
wkdw kdv jlyhq fkdudfwhulvwlfv +iurp 4<54 wr 4<5;,1 Exw wkhq/ wdnlqj wkh prgho
wr dqrwkhu vhw ri gdwd +4<5< wr 4<63, zlwk glhuhqw fkdudfwhulvwlfv lpsolhv wkdw
hyhu|wklqj zloo frph rxw lq wkh surmhfwlrq uhvlgxdo1 Exw wklv kdsshqv ehfdxvh
zh kdyh plvshflhg wkh prgho19
8 Wkh uhohydqw yduldqfh lq g|qdplf prghov lv wkh rqh fkdudfwhul}lqj wkh glvwulexwlrq ri
ixwxuh uhdol}dwlrqv ri wkh udqgrp yduldeoh gulylqj wkh hfrqrp|1 Lq wkh fxuuhqw shulrg djhqwv
gr qrw h{shulhqfh yduldqfh/ exw udwkhu vhh wkh fxuuhqw gudz iurp d glvwulexwlrq1 Exw lq wkh
frqwh{w ri wkh Juhdw Ghsuhvvlrq/ ehfdxvh zh duh h{solflwo| dvvxplqj khwhurhvnhgdvwlflw|/ zh
pxvw dvvxph wkdw djhqwv qrw rqo| gr qrw nqrz ixwxuh uhdol}dwlrqv ri wkh vkrfn/ exw dovr ixwxuh
uhdol}dwlrqv ri wkh yduldqfh gulylqj wkh vkrfnv1
9 Lw lv hdv| wr vkrz wkdw ljqrulqj d vwuxfwxudo euhdn ohdgv wr d kljkhu yduldqfh hvwlpdwh1 Lq
7
Dovr/ hyhq wkrxjk wkh dxwkruv gxo| qrwh wklv/ L eholhyh wkhlu h{huflvh lv
plvohdglqj ehfdxvh wkh uhvlgxdo lq wkhlu uvw uhjuhvvlrq dffrxqwv iru ohvv wkdq
4( ri wkh yduldwlrq lq lqgxvwuldo surgxfwlrq1 Lq dgglwlrq/ wkh h{sodlqhg sduw ri
wklv vtxduhg uhvlgxdo lv rqo| 6(1 Wkxv zh kdyh dq h{sodlqhg vtxduhg uhvlgxdo
wkdw dffrxqwv iru ohvv wkdq 6( ri 4( ri wkh yduldwlrq lq lqgxvwuldo surgxfwlrq/
dqg wkdw lv wkuhh sduwv lq whq wkrxvdqg1 L gr qrw eholhyh lw lv uhdvrqdeoh wr dvvljq
vljqlfdqw hfrqrplf h{sodqdwru| srzhu wr wklv yduldeoh dv dq lqglfdwru ri krz
xqfhuwdlqw| derxw lqfrph pljkw dhfw frqvxpswlrq h{shqglwxuhv1 Lq idfw/ wkh
uhvlgxdo xvhg lq wkh YDU h{huflvh xvhv h{ srvw lqirupdwlrq dqg wkhuhiruh grhv
qrw frlqflgh zlwk wkh wkhruhwlfdo qrwlrq ri zk| xqfhuwdlqw| dhfwv frqvxpswlrq
ghflvlrqv1 E| xvlqj h{ srvw lqirupdwlrq lq wkh YDU/ wkhlu h{huflvh lpsolhv djhqwv
nqhz zkdw wkh yduldqfh zdv/ zkloh lw lv fohdu wkdw djhqwv frxog qrw nqrz wklv1
Ilqdoo|/ wkh lqfoxvlrq ri wkh glhuhqw yduldeohv lq wkhlu uhjuhvvlrq rq wkhruhw0
lfdo jurxqgv lv dovr txhvwlrqdeoh1 Dv dq h{dpsoh/ li vwrfn sulfhv duh d udqgrp
zdon/ wkh fkdqjh lq vwrfn sulfhv lv d zklwh qrlvh/ dqg lw lv wkhuhiruh kdug wr
lqwhusuhw dq| suhglfwdeoh delolw| wklv yduldeoh pljkw kdyh1 Ixuwkhupruh/ li vwrfn
sulfhv kdyh suhglfwdeoh frpsrqhqwv/ wkdw lv xvxdoo| dwwulexwhg wr d ydulhw| ri
pdunhw iulfwlrqv1 Zh zrxog qhhg d wkhru| ri krz fkdqjhv lq wkhvh pdunhw
iulfwlrqv dhfw wkh yrodwlolw| ri lqgxvwuldo surgxfwlrq lq rughu wr lqwurgxfh wklv
yduldeoh lq wkh uhjuhvvlrq rq wkhruhwlfdo jurxqgv1
dgglwlrq/ d yrodwloh uhvlgxdo frxog rffxuu ehfdxvh wkh suh fudvk prgho frxog eh wu|lqj wr w
d vprrwk vhulhv iru lqgxvwuldo surgxfwlrq1 Wkxv/ li djhqwv wkrxjkw wkdw wkh suh fudvk prgho
zdv fruuhfw dqg wkdw d kljk yrodwlolw| zdv h{shfwhg/ wkh| frxog eh iruhfdvwlqj d orz yrodwlolw|
sdwk iru lqgxvwuldo surgxfwlrq1 Wkhuhiruh/ wkh lqihuhqfh rq wkh lpsdfw ri vxfk d yrodwlolw| rq
frqvxpswlrq lv qrw reylrxv1
8
7
Urexvwqhvv
L zloo h{soruh khuh wkh urexvwqhvv ri wkh vshflfdwlrq dqg wkh urexvwqhvv ri wkh
uhvxow1 Wkh uhvxow ri wkh surfhgxuh khuh lv wkh fkdudfwhulvwlf ri wkh surmhfwlrq
ri wkh vtxduhg uhvlgxdo eh|krqg wkh hvwlpdwlrq vdpsoh1 L uhplqg wkh uhdghu wkdw
p| phdvxuh ri xqfhuwdlqw| lv qrw wkh vdph dv wkdw ri Iodffr dqg Sdunhu hyhq
wkrxjk lw fduulhv vlplodu lqirupdwlrq1 Krzhyhu/ L eholhyh wkdw lv qrw d gudzedfn
exw udwkhu d soxv iru d urexvwqhvv h{huflvh1
714
Urexvwqhvv 41 Uhgrlqj d uhvwulfwhg IS
Dw wklv srlqw/ lw lv lqvwuxfwlyh wr uhh{dplqh wkh gdwd dqg wkh IS h{huflvh1 Wkh
Lqgxvwuldo Surgxfwlrq gdwd kdv ydoxh =
dv lwv uvw revhuydwlrq lq Mdqxdu|
4<541 Iru wzr vdpsohv vwduwlqj lq wklv gdwh/ rqh ri <9 hohphqwv xqwlo Ghfhp0
ehu 4<5;/ dqg rqh ri 543 hohphqwv xqwlo Mxqh 4<6;/ uhohydqw vwdwlvwlfv +phdq/
vwdqgdug ghyldwlrq/ uvw dqg vhfrqg rughu dxwrfruuhodwlrqv, duh=
9 56:
lsl+543,
lsl+<9,
71414
+orj, +orj,
<=666< 4=:;98 3=<;:3 3=<8;9 3=334; 3=3663
<=4<76 4=7975 3=<<44 3=<:98 3=339; 3=3559
4
5
IS uhjuhvvlrq lq ohyhov dqg vrph h{wud lqirupdwlrq1
Iluvw zh xvh wkh vdpsoh iurp Mdqxdu| 4<54 wr Ghfhpehu 4<5;/ dprxqwlqj wr
<9 revhuydwlrqv1 L zloo uxq wkh iroorzlqj uhjuhvvlrq/ zkhuh \w lv wkh ohyho ri
lqgxvwuldo surgxfwlrq
\w @ 3 . 4w . 5\w4 . 6 Yw4 . }w
a @ . a . w/ dqg iru vtxduhg uhvlgxdov
@ s 4 5 1 Wkh uhvxowv +W
dqg wkhq rq wkh uhvlgxdov L uxq }w 3 4 }w4
3 4}w54 w 1 Qrwh khuh wkdw }
L uxq }w5
vwdwlvwlfv lq sduhqwkhvlv, duh
a @ . a .
a 3
3=6:7
+4=;4,
a 4
3=334:
+4=45,
a 5
3=<88
+66=4,
a 6
8=8:
+3=65,
a
4 +
U5
3=<;6
,
&rev T
<8 <=39
@
dqg wkh W vwdwlvwlf iru wkh whvw ri zkhwkhu 5 lv glhuhqw iurp rqh lv WaXU
5
4
a5
= / vxjjhvwlqj d surshu xqlw urrw whvw lv fdoohg iru1 Wr qrwh dovr lv
+a5 ,
wkh idfw wkdw 5 kdv wkh vdph vl}h dqg vljq dv lq IS*v ruljlqdo uhjuhvvlrq1 Lq
dgglwlrq wkh frh!flhqw rq Y +6 , dovr kdv wkh vdph vljq/ dqg lv qrw vljqlfdqw
dv zhoo1:
@ 4 88
a
a
: L uhdol}h wkdw phqwlrqlqj vljqv ri qrw vljqlfdqw yduldeohv lv d elw luuhohydqw/ exw wkh srlqw
lv wr dvvhuw wkdw wklv uhjuhvvlrq lv htxlydohqw wr wkh h{huflvh lq Iodffr dqg Sdunhu1
9
Iru wkh uhvlgxdo zh kdyh
}w
3=4;:6
a3
3=3365
+3=4:,
a
a
U
3=347
3=66:
+6=78, 3=447 +6=49,
5
4
a
U
3=8:9 3=666
+9=:;,
3
5
4
Wkhuh lv vrph lqirupdwlrq ohiw lq wkh uhvlgxdo dqg vxevwdqwldo dxwrfruuhodwlrq
lq wkh vtxduhg uhvlgxdo1
Wkh qh{w IS uhjuhvvlrq/ }w5 3 4 w 5 \w4 6 Yw4 w |lhogv
a@ . .
a
a
3=3339 3=3344
+4=;9,
+3=4<,
a3
3=393
+4=77,
4
5
.
.
a
U
7=<3 3=46<
+4=75,
5
6
zkhuh zh kdyh d uhdvrqdeoh h{sodqdwru| srzhu/ exw khuh ohvv wkdq li zh vlpso|
xvhg wkh uvw odj + =
? = ,1; Wr qrwh lv wkh uhvxow ri wkh Euhxvfk0Sdjdq
khwhurhvnhgdvwlflw| whvw +T, zklfk uhmhfwv krprhvnhgdvwlflw| +djdlqvw :1;4/ wkh
<8( lqwhuydo ri wkh txl vtxduhg ri 6 vwdwlvwlf,1 Lq dgglwlrq/ 6 / kdv wkh vdph
vljq dv lq wkh IS uhjuhvvlrq1 Wklv lv uhdvvxulqj/ dv wkh xqfhuwdlqw| phdvxuh xvhg
khuh vhhpv wr kdyh eurdgo| wkh vdph surshuwlhv dv IS*v1
Pruh lpsruwdqwo|/ wklv htxdwlrq surgxfhv wzr wklqjv= uvw lw jhqhudwhv d
grzqzdug vorslqj iruhfdvw +surmhfwlrq, ri wkh yduldqfh1 Vhfrqg/ lw jhqhudwhv
qhjdwlyh ydoxhv iru wkh yduldqfh1 Wklv wdeoh vkrzv dqqxdo dyhudjhv ri surmhfwhg
prqwko| vtxduhg huuruv iurp wklv h{shulphqw
3 46< 3 666
a
4<58 4<59 4<5: 4<5; 4<5< 4<63 4<64 4<65 4<66 4<67
3=365 3=356 3=354 3=338 3=386 3=357 3=38: 3=459 3=3<3 3=373
Rqh phdvxuh L xvh wr hydoxdwh wkhlu iruhfdvw lv lwv vorsh/ zklfk lv frpsxwhg dv
wkh frh!flhqw rq d wuhqg/ iurp d uhjuhvvlrq ri wkh 55 iruhfdvwhg revhuydwlrqv
ri Mdqxdu| 4<5< wr Rfwrehu 4<63 djdlqvw d frqvwdqw dqg d wuhqg1
aI . @ . . y
5
zkhuh
@ 4> 5> ===551
Khuh
a
4
3
w 4
kdv ydoxh
a @ 3=3339
4
Wklv grhv qrw vkrz dq lqfuhdvh dqg lw vkrzv qhjdwlyh qxpehuv1 D ehwwhu sur0
fhgxuh wr dyrlg wklv lv wr hvwlpdwh
orj+a}w , @ . w . \w . Yw . w
5
3
4
5
4
6
4
dqg wkhq h{srqhqwldwh wkh surmhfwlrq1 Wklv surfhgxuh jhqhudwhv srvlwlyh ydul0
= / dqg qdoo| lw surgxfhv d grzqzdug
dqfhv/ wkh uhjuhvvlrq kdv dq U5
vorslqj surmhfwlrq1<
@ 3 4<
uhvxowv txhvwlrq wkh dghtxdf| Dqwoh*v olqhdu prphqw prgho1
zloo qrw sxuvxh wklv ixuwkhu ehfdxvh L dp lqwhuhvwhg lq IS*v h{huflvh1
; Wkhvh
<L
:
Wklv zdv grqh xvlqj dffr851p/ rswlrq41
Qrz/ ehfdxvh L ylhz wkh suhvhqfh ri d xqlw urrw zlwk vrph frqfhuq/ L whvw
wklv pruh uljrurxvo| e| hvwlpdwlqj
\w \w4 @ 3 . 4w . 5 \w4 . 6+\w4 \w5 , . 7Yw4 . }w
dqg wklv surfhgxuh +vhh wkh dsshqgl{, vkrzv uvw wkdw zh uhmhfw d xqlw urrw/
dowkrxjk wklv uhvxow lv d elw vhqvlwlyh/ dqg vhfrqg/ wkdw odjjhg jurzwk lv dq
lpsruwdqw yduldeoh lq wkh uhjuhvvlrq1 Wklv vhhpv wr eh d ehwwhu vshflfdwlrq
jlyhq wkdw zh gr qrw slfn xs dq| dxwrfruuhodwlrq lq wkh uhvlgxdo/ dqg ohvv lq wkh
vtxduhg uhvlgxdo1 Wkh Euhxvfk Sdjdq whvw uhmhfwv krprhvnhgdvwlflw|/ dqg wkh
surmhfwlrq ri vtxduhg uhvlgxdov lv grzqzdug vorslqj1
Qrz/ li zh glvfdug d xqlw urrw/ zh vkrxog qhyhuwkhohvv lqfoxgh odjjhg jurzwk1
Vr/ zlwk wklv gdwd L uxq
\w @ 3 . 4 w . 5 \w4 . 6+\w4 \w5, . 7Yw4 . }w
}aw @ 3 . 4}aw4 . w / dqg }aw5 @ 3 . 4}aw54 . w 1 Wkh uhvxowv/
zlwk
iru <7
revhuydwlrqv/ vkrz wkdw odjjhg jurzwk lv vljqlfdqw1 Wkh uhjuhvvvlrq kdv U5
= / dqg wkh Euhxvk Sdjdq vwdwlvwlf uhmhfwv krprhvnhgdvwlflw| +4815 h{fhhgv
"5 <8( = ,1
Wkh vtxduhg uhvlgxdo kdv vljqlfdqw dxwrfruuhodwlrq exw zlwk ohvv h{sodqd0
wru| srzhu wkdq ehiruh +3144?3166,1 IS*v uhjuhvvlrq lq vtxduhg uhvlgxdov kdv
U5
= / dqg lw jhqhudwhv d grzqzdug vorslqj surmhfwlrq1 Xqolnh wkh vhqvl0
wlylw| ri wkh xqlw urrw dqdo|vlv/ khuh vtxduhg uhvlgxdo iruhfdvwv gr qrw lqfuhdvh1
Wkh dqqxdo dyhudjhv ri surmhfwhg prqwko| vtxduhg huuruv iurp wklv h{shulphqw
duh
3 <;8
+7,
@
@ < 7<
@ 3 4;:
4<58 4<59 4<5: 4<5; 4<5< 4<63 4<64 4<65 4<66 4<67
3=35; 3=34: 3=34; 3=338 3=433 3=369 3=3<9 3=49< 3=458 3=365
Wkh vorsh ri wkh iruhfdvw lv
a4 @ 3=3344
Vr/ zkdw lv wkh erwwrpolqh vr iduB Iluvw/ zh jhqhudwh qr vljqlfdqw yduldqfh
lqfuhdvh1 Vhfrqg/ wkh uhjuhvvlrq lq IS pd| eh plvshflhg dv odjjhg jurzwk
vhhpv wr eh uhohydqw dqg grhv d jrrg mre holplqdwlqj suhglfwdeoh frpsrqhqwv
iurp wkh uhvlgxdo1 Wklug/ zh uhmhfw krprhvnhgdvwlflw|1
Vr idu zh duh plvvlqj vhyhudo yduldeohv iurp wkh ruljlqdo IS h{huflvh1 Pdlqo|
zh duh plvvlqj rqh yduldeoh zklfk lv vljqlfdqw lq wkhlu h{huflvh/ wkh |lhog glhu0
hqwldo1 Wkdw lv lpsruwdqw/ exw vr lv wkh h{dfw vdpsoh xvhg1 Lq idfw/ jlyhq wkdw
xvlqj gdwd wkdw fryhuv wkh hqwluh lqwhuzdu shulrg vhhpv wr w pxfk ehwwhu/ zk|
vkrxog wkh h{dfw ghvfulswlrq ri wkh hfrqrp| eh jlyhq e| wkh prgho hvwlpdwhg
zlwk lqirupdwlrq rqo| xs wr Ghfhpehu 4<5;B43 Dqg zk| qrw Vhswhpehu 4<5<B
Dovr/ duh wkh uhvxowv vr idu urexvw wr wkh lqwurgxfwlrq ri dgglwlrqdo yduldeohv dqg
wr wkh xvh ri d glhuhqw vdpsohB
Wklv h{huflvh lv shuiruphg zlwk dffr851p/ rswlrq 51
43 Vhh
Hmdutxh +4<<:, dqg Juhdvoh|/ Pdgvhq dqg R{oh| +5334,1
;
715
Urexvwqhvv 51
Qrz L xvh wkh |lhog gdwd/ zklfk zloo vkruwhq p| vdpsoh1 Dv zh zloo vhh/ wklv
yduldeoh lv qrw vljqlfdqw khuh/ exw lw gudpdwlfdoo| fkdqjhv wkh vtxduhg uhvlgxdo
surmhfwlrq lq wkh gluhfwlrq ri Iodffr dqg Sdunhu*v uhvxowv1 Zh dovr fhdvh wr uhmhfw
krprhvnhgdvwlflw| dqg d xqlw urrw1
71514 Iodffr dqg Sdunhu uhjuhvvlrq lq ohyhov1
Iluvw L xvh wkh vdpsoh iurp Mdqxdu| 4<58 wr Ghfhpehu 4<5;/ dprxqwlqj wr 7;
revhuydwlrqv1
\w @ 3 . 4w . 5\w4 . 6Uw4 . 7Yw4 . }w
zlwk }aw @ 3 . 4 }aw4 . w / dqg }aw5 @ 3 . 4 }aw54 . w 1 Wkh uhvxowv duh/ iru 7:
revhuydwlrqv/
a 3
3=47
+3=46,
a 4
3=336
+4=3<,
a 5
3=<9:
+45=6,
a 6
3=3:3
+3=58,
a 7
7=73
+3=5:,
U5
3=<4
T
5=<6
a a a
dqg khuh lw lv uhohydqw wr qrwh wkdw +5 > 6 > 7 , doo kdyh wkh vdph vljqv dv lq wkh
ruljlqdo IS uhjuhvvlrq1 Iru wkh uhvlgxdo zh kdyh
a3
}w
3=46
3=3339
+3=36,
a3
a4
U5
3=347
3=476
+3=<8, 3=35 +6=58,
a4
U5
3=4:;
+4=54, 3=36
@
a
dqg wkh W vwdwlvwlf iru wkh whvw ri zkhwkhu 5 lv glhuhqw iurp rqh lv WaXU
5
4a 5
= 1 Wkhuh lv qr dxwrfruuhodwlrq lq wkh uhvlgxdov144 Wkh vhfrqg vwdjh
+a5 ,
ri IS*v h{huflvh hvwlpdwhv
@ 3 75
}aw5 @ 3 . 4 w . 5\w4 . 6 Uw4 . 7Yw4 . w
Wkh uhvxowv iurp wklv htxdwlrq duh
a3
3=3<:
+3=7:,
a4
3=3335
+3=65,
a5
3=344
+3=:8,
a6
3=347
+3=5;,
a7
6=84
+4=53,
U5
3=39
zkhuh zh kdyh vrph h{sodqdwru| srzhu1 Qrwh krzhyhu wkdw wkh Euhxvfk Sdjdq
vwdwlvwlf deryh +T
= , grhv qrw uhmhfw krprhvnhgdvwlflw| uhyhuvlqj wkh uhvxowv
rewdlqhg zlwk wkh orqjhu vdpsoh dqg zlwkrxw wkh |lhog glhuhqwlo yduldeoh145
Khuh 6 kdv wkh zurqj vljq exw lw lv qrw vljqlfdqw dq| zd|1
Pruh lpsruwdqwo|/ zh fduh derxw wkh yduldqfh surmhfwlrq1 Wklv surfhgxuh
jhqhudwhv dq lqfuhdvh lq wkh surmhfwhg vtxduhg uhvlgxdo diwhu 4<5<1 Wklv wdeoh
@ 7 :7
a
44 Hlwkhu
45 Wklv
wkh |lhog glhuhqwldo ru wkh vkruw vdpsoh ru erwk duh dw zrun khuh1
ydoxh lv wr eh frpsduhg zlwk wkh qxpehu <17</ zklfk lv wkh txl vtxduhg +7, dw <8(1
<
vkrzv dqqxdo dyhudjhv ri surmhfwhg prqwko| vtxduhg huuruv iurp wklv vshflfd0
wlrq
4<58 4<59 4<5: 4<5; 4<5< 4<63
3=356 3=347 3=34; 3=33< 3=36: 3=34;
4<64
3=377
4<65 4<66 4<67
3=373 3=376 3=394
Wkh lqwurgxfwlrq ri wkh |lhog glhuhqwldo yduldeoh eulqjv wklv surmhfwlrq lq
olqh zlwk IS*v uhvxowv1 Iru wklv fdvh wkh vorsh ri wkh iruhfdvw/ 4 > lv
a
a4 @ 3=334<
Wklv h{shulphqw zdv grqh xvlqj dffr861p/ fkrrvlqj rswlrq 41
Zh qhhg wr dvn d ihz txhvwlrqv uhjduglqj urexvwqhvv qrz= Lv wkh glhuhqw
surmhfwlrq d uhvxow ri wkh dgglwlrqdo yduldeoh/ ru ri wkh orvv ri revhuydwlrqv +4<54
wr 4<57,B Lv wkh wuxqfdwlrq ri wkh vdpsoh lq Ghfhpehu 4<5; uhdvrqdeoh dqg duh
wkh uhvxowv urexvw wr lwB Lv wkhuh d xqlw urrw lq Lqgxvwuldo Surgxfwlrq dqg grhv
lw pdwwhuB Lv wkhuh d uroh iru dq h{wud odj lq Lqgxvwuldo SurgxfwlrqB
71515 Lv lw wkh |lhog glhuhqwldoB
Uhgrlqj wklv h{dfw h{shulphqw zlwkrxw wkh \lhog glhuhqwldo yduldeoh |lhogv
= iru wkh uvw uhjuhvvlrq/ dqg 31357 dqg 31366 iru wkh DU4 uhvlgxdo
uhjuhvvlrqv1 Iru wkh IS vtxduhg uhvlgxdo uhjuhvvlrq wkh U5 lv 313841 Wkh T
vwdwlvwlf kdv ydoxh 517</ dqg qdoo| wkh dqqxdo dyhudjhv ri surmhfwhg prqwko|
vtxduhg huuruv duh
U5
@ 3 <47
4<58 4<59 4<5: 4<5; 4<5< 4<63 4<64 4<65 4<66 4<67
3=354 3=347 3=34< 3=33< 3=36: 3=345 3=34; 3=334 3=349 3=379
zkhuh zh vhh wkdw wkhuh lv qr orqjhu d gudpdwlf lqfuhdvh lq wkh surmhfwlrq hyhq
wkrxjk zh fdq vhh vrph lqyhuvlrq lq zkdw IS fdoo d vhfxodu wuhqg +khuh shukdsv
iurp 4<5: wr 4<5<, lq wklv vtxduhg huuru1 Wkh vorsh ri wkh iruhfdvw/ 4 > lv
a
a4 @ 3=3349
Dv zh vhh/ wkh lqfoxvlrq ri wklv yduldeoh lv qrw lqqrfxrxv uhjduglqj wkh sur0
mhfwlrq zh rewdlq1
71516 Vdpsoh vl}h/ jurzwk udwhv dqg xqlw urrwv +vhh dsshqgl{,1
Lq wkh dsshqgl{ L uhgr wklv h{huflvh zlwk glhuhqw vdpsohv1
\w @ 3 . 4w . 5\w4 . 6Uw4 . 7Yw4 . }w
zlwk }aw @ 3 . 4 }aw4 . w / dqg }aw5 @ 3 . 4 }aw54 . w 1
43
Wkh uvw wklqj wkdw vwdqgv rxw lv wkdw wkh Grz Mrqhv yduldqfh ehfrphv vlj0
qlfdqw lq h{whqghg vdpsohv/ zkloh wkh |lhog glhuhqwldo grhv qrw1 Wkh Euhxvfk
Sdjdq vwdwlvwlf w|slfdoo| grhv qrw uhmhfw krprhvnhgdvwlflw|146
L dovr orrn dw wkh uhjuhvvlrq lq jurzwk udwhv/ dqg orrn dw wkh vdpsoh fkrlfh1
\w \w4 @ 3 . 4w . 5\w4 . 6+\w4 \w5, . 7Uw4 . 8Yw4 . }w
zlwk }w 3 4 }w4 w / dqg }w5 3 4 }w54 w 1
Wkh uhvxowv lq wkh dsshql{ vxjjhvw wkdw odjjhg jurzwk vkrxog eh lqfoxghg1
Wkh |lhog glhuhqfldo lv qhyhu vljqlfdqw1 Wkhvh uhjuhvvlrqv dovr gr d ehwwhu mre
ri holplqdwlqj suhglfwdeoh frpsrqhqwv iurp wkh uhvlgxdo1
Wr whvw iru wkh suhvhqfh ri d xqlw urrw L uxq wkh iroorzlqj uhjuhvvlrq xvlqj
wkh vdpsoh iurp Mdqxdu| 4<58 wr Ghfhpehu 4<5;=
a@ . a .
a @ . a .
\w \w4 @ 3 . 4w . 5\w4 . 6+\w4 \w5, . 7Uw4 . 8Yw4 . }w
zlwk }w 3 4 }w4 w / dqg }w5 3 4 }w54 w 1
Lq wklv fdvh L gr qrw uhmhfw d xqlw urrw1 Lq dgglwlrq zh holplqdwh wkh h{sodqd0
wru| srzhu lq wkh uhvlgxdo uhjuhvvlrqv1 Wkh Euhxvk Sdjdq whvw grhv qrw uhmhfw
krprhvnhgdvwlflw|1 Ilqdoo|/ wkh yduldqfh surmhfwlrq vkrzv d vwurqj lqfuhdvh lq
wkh yduldqfh1 Iru wklv fdvh wkh vorsh 4 lv
a@ . a .
a @ . a .
a
3=3746
71517 D orjlfdo dowhuqdwlyh
Wklv lv p| suhihuuhg uhjuhvvlrq1 L holplqdwh wkh wuhqg dqg wkh odjjhg ohyho gxh
wr wkh xqlw urrw whvw uhvxow dqg hvwlpdwh lq uvw glhuhqfhv1 L dovr sod| zlwk wkh
vdpsoh wr vhh zkhwkhu wkh |lhog glhuhqwldo ehfrphv vljqlfdqw1
\w \w4 @ 3 . 4+\w4 \w5 , . 5Uw4 . 6Yw4 . }w
zlwk }aw @ 3 . 4 }aw4 . w / dqg }aw5 @ 3 . 4 }aw54 . w 1
a 3
a 4
a 5
a 6
U5 &rev T
3=5<
3=49
3=45
7=<<
+3=:6, +4=35, +3=99, +3=64, 3=36: 79 7=;8
3=97
3=57
3=5: 8=<5
+4=<5, +4=;<, +4=;3, +6=5, 3=75 8; 6=:7
46 Wr xvh wklv vwdwlvwlf fruuhfwo| lq d orqjhu vdpsoh zh pxvw lqfoxgh d gxpp| yduldeoh iru wkh
vwuxfwxudo euhdn lq Mxo| 4<5<1 Lqfoxglqj d gxpp| |lhogv iru d orqjhu vdpsoh d Euhxvk0Sdjdq
vwdwlvwlf wkdw dovr grhv qrw uhmhfw krprhvnhgdvwlflw|1
44
zkhuh zh qrwh wkdw qrz wkh |lhog glhuhqwldo lv doprvw vljqlfdqw zkhq zh
h{whqg wkh vdpsoh wr Ghfhpehu 4<6347 /
}w
3=46
a3
3=3337
+3=35,
3=47 +33==3336
35,
a4
3=348
+3=43,
3=345
+3=3<,
a3
3=34;
+6=9,
3
3=333 +7=34;
=3,
U5
3=333
a4
U5
3=335
+3=34, 3=333
3=385 3=336
+3=6;,
Wkh vhfrqg vwdjh ri IS*v h{huflvh hvwlpdwhv duh doo qrq vljqlfdqw
}aw5 @ 3 . 4+\w4 \w5, . 5 Uw4 . 6Yw4 . w
Wkh U5 iurp wklv htxdwlrq duh Uq5 @79 @ 3=3;:/ dqg U5q@8; @ 3=37:/ dqg wkh
surmhfwhg vtxduh uhvlgxdo +dqqxdo dyhudjh, vkrzv d vwurqj lqfuhdvh diwhu 4<5</
4<58 4<59 4<5: 4<5; 4<5<
3=35: 3=347 3=34: 3=339 3=35<
3=358 3=349 3=349 3=347 3=34:
4<63
3=356
3=369
4<64 4<65 4<66 4<67 q
3=3:8 3=3<3 3=38< 3=388 79
3=435 3=475 3=3<9 3=388 8;
dqi qdoo| wkh wuhqg lq wkh 55 revhuydwlrq surmhfwlrq kdv vorsh
q
79
8;
a4 3=3347 3=3343
Qrz/ iru d odujhu vdpsoh zh pxvw lqfoxgh d gxpp|1 Lq idfw wkh odvw 6
revhuydwlrqv ri wkh vhfrqg h{shulphqw khuh duh douhdg| xqghu d glhuhqw uhjlph1
Li zh kdyh d orqjhu vdpsoh dqg zh lqfoxgh d gxpp| zh kdyh
\w \w4 @ 3 . 4 G . 5 +\w4 \w5, . 6 Uw4 . 7Yw4 . }w
zlwk }aw @ 3 . 4 }aw4 . w / dqg }aw5 @ 3 . 4 }aw54 . w 1
a 3
3=5:
+3=<;,
a 4
3=49
+5=94,
a 5
3=46
+4=47,
a 6
3=3<
+3=:<,
a 7
7=<
+5=<9,
U5
3=84
&rev T
:3 7=33
zkhuh zh qrwh wkdw wkh gxpp| lv vljqlfdqw zkloh erwk Uw4 dqg odjjhg jurzwk
duh qrw1 Krzhyhu/ Yw4 frpiruwdeo| vxuylyhv wkh lqfoxvlrq ri wkh Gxpp|1 Wkh
Euhxvk Sdjdq vwdwlvwlf uhmhfwv khwhurhvnhgdvwlflw|1 Zh jhw qrwklqj rxw ri wkh
47 Lq wkh dsshqgl{/ h{shulphqw uhvxowv vxjjhvw wkdw wkh vljqlfdqfh ri wkh |lhog glhuhqwldo
glvdsshduv li zh lqfoxgh d gxpp| iru d vwuxfwxudo euhdn/ zklfk lv d ohjlwlpdwh dfwlrq vlqfh doo
ri wklv lv grqh zlwk h{ srvw lqirupdwlrq1
45
uhvlgxdov vxjjhvwlqj wklv uhjuhvvlrq grhv d idlu mre ri holplqdwlqj suhglfwdeoh
frpsrqhqwv1
}w
3=46
a3
3=3337
+3=35,
a4
3=398
+3=86,
U5
3=337
a3
3=349
+7=9,
a4
U5
3=335 3=333
+3=348,
Wkh vhfrqg vwdjh ri IS*v h{huflvh hvwlpdwhv duh doo qrq vljqlfdqw/ dqg U5 wkh
lv 31381 Wkh surmhfwhg vtxduh uhvlgxdo +dqqxdo dyhudjh, djdlq vkrzv dq lqfuhdvh
diwhu 4<5<1
4<58 4<59 4<5: 4<5; 4<5< 4<63 4<64 4<65 4<66 4<67 q
3=356 3=34: 3=34; 3=347 3=345 3=349 3=393 3=3<9 3=3:4 3=375 :3
dqi qdoo| wkh wuhqg lq wkh 55 revhuydwlrq surmhfwlrq kdv vorsh
a4 @ 3=33391
Wkhvh uxqv zhuh grqh rq dffr861p fkrrvlqj rswlrqv 8 dqg 31
716
Urexvwqhvv Frqfoxvlrqv
Xvlqj wkh orqj vdpsoh zlwkrxw wkh |lhog glhuhqwldo yduldeoh zh fdqqrw jhqhudwh
dq lqfuhdvh lq wkh surmhfwlrq ri vtxduhg uhvlgxdov1 Xvlqj wkh |lhog glhuhqwldo
yduldeoh irufhv ph wr xvh d vkruwhu vdpsoh1 Lq wklv fdvh wkh h{shulphqwv vxjjhvw
wkdw wkh |lhog glhuhqwldo yduldeoh lv jhqhudoo| qrw vljqlfdqw/ exw qhyhuwkh0
ohvv lpsruwdqw wr jhqhudwh wkh surmhfwlrqv ri vtxduhg uhvlgxdov wkdw IS rewdlq
+vkrzlqj dq lqfuhdvh lq wkh surmhfwhg vtxduhg uhvlgxdo,1 Wkhuh lv dovr hylghqfh
lq idyru ri d xqlw urrw dqg djdlqvw khwhurhvnhgdvwlflw|/ dqg/ jlyhq wkh zhdnqhvv
ri wkhruhwlfdo prwlydwlrqv iru wkh vshflfdwlrq/ hpslulfdo uhvxowv srlqw wr wkh h{0
foxvlrq ri wkh |lhog glhuhqwldo iurp wkh uhjuhvvlrq1 L eholhyh wkhvh h{shulphqwv
vxjjhvw wkdw wkh uhvxowlqj surmhfwlrq lv qrw urexvw wr vdpsoh dqg vshflfdwlrq
fkdqjhv1 Wkh uhpdlqlqj txhvwlrq lv zkhwkhu zh vkrxog dffhsw dq| jlyhq uhvxow/
hyhq li lw zhuh d urexvw rqh1 Wr wkdw L qrz wxuq1
46
8
Fdq d kljk yduldqfh iruhfdvw phdq qrwklqjB
Wkh qh{w h{huflvh lv shuiruphg zlwk duwlfldo gdwd yld d Prqwh Fduor h{shulphqw1
Wkh dfwxdo Grz Mrqhv Yduldqfh dqg \lhog Glhuhqwldo gdwd lv xvhg wr jhqhudwh
dq duwlfldo Lqgxvwuldo Surgxfwlrq vhulhv dqg dqdo|vlv lv grqh rq wkdw vhulhv1
Wkh wuxh gdwd lv jhqhudwhg xvlqj wkh uhvxowv ri p| suhihuuhg uhjuhvvlrq iurp
wkh urexvwqhvv h{huflvh deryh/
\w \w4
}w
+3 ,
,
@
@
3 . 4+\w4 \w5 , . 5Uw4 . 6Yw4 . }w
3 . 4}w4 . w
zlwk w Q > w / dqg fuxfldoo|/ wkh yduldqfh lv lwvhoi vwrfkdvwlf/ zlwk dq llg
xqlirup 50srlqw glvwulexwlrq/ zklfk lpsolhv xqsuhglfwdelolw| ri wkh yduldqfh/
w X o > k / zlwk d wzr vwdwh Pdunry pdwul{ zlwk 318 suredelolw| lq hyhu|
fhoo jryhuqlqj wkh wudqvlwlrq ehwzhhq o dqg k 1
Wkh srlqw ri wklv h{huflvh lv wr vkrz wkdw lw lv yhu| hdv| wr jhqhudwh d sdwwhuq
ri vtxduhg uhvlgxdov olnh wkh rqh jhqhudwhg e| Iodffr dqg Sdunhu hyhq zkhq zh
nqrz wkdw ixwxuh yduldqfh lv xqsuhglfwdeoh dqg wkh ehvw h{shfwdwlrq zh fdq irup
lv d frqvwdqw rqh1
Iluvw wkh wlph vhulhv iru w lv jhqhudwhg/ wkhq wklv wlph vhulhv lv xvhg wr jhq0
hudwh wkh wlph vhulhv iru w / wkhq iru }w / dqg wkhq/ xvlqj wkh hvwlpdwhg frh!flhqwv
iurp wkh uhdo gdwd zh frqvwuxfw wkh wlph vhulhv iru \w / xvlqj wkh dfwxdo uvw wzr
revhuydwlrqv ri wklv vhulhv wr lqlwldol}h lw1
L uxq wzr h{shulphqwv/ rqh +4, edvhg rq wkh gdwd vdpsoh ri 7; revhuydwlrqv/
dqg wkh rwkhu +5, rq wkh h{shulphqw zlwk 93 revhuydwlrqv1 Wkh qxpehuv xvhg
duh
+
H[S
4
5
3
4
5
6
3
4
o
k
}
3=5< 3=49 3=45 7=<< 3 3=348 3=4 3=5 3=47
3=97 3=57 3=5: 8=<5 3 3=345 3=4 3=5 3=47
Wkhq wkh h{huflvh lv wr uxq wkh vdph h{shulphqw dv IS gr +d uhjuhvvlrq ri
wkh ohyho ri lqgxvwuldo surgxfwlrq djdlqvw d frqvwdqw/ wuhqg/ odj/ odjjhg |lhog
glhuhqwldo dqg odjjhg Grz Mrqhv yduldqfh,/
\w @ 3 . 4w . 5\w4 . 6Uw4 . 7Yw4 . w
dqg vhh zkdw kdsshqv wr wkh yduldqfh surmhfwlrq1 Wkh uhvxowv duh/ iru whq wkrx0
vdqg Prqwh Fduor uhsolfdwlrqv/
H{s4
H{s5
}
|
|
3=48: :=6< 4=4:
3=48: 9=;8 4=34
47
phdq4
vwg4
phdq5
vwg5
a 3
4=54
4=77
4=3<
4=66
a 4
3=33;4
3=33;:
3=33;4
3=33;8
a 5
3=;5
3=43
3=;9
3=3<
a 6
3=39
3=88
3=47
3=89
a 7
6=:3
4<=5
:=<
4<=7
U5 Wa 3 Wa 4 Wa 5 Wa 6 Wa 7 WaXU
3=<48 4=55 4=6; 43=4 3=53 3=54 5=355
3=3;4 4=78 4=6< 6=7 4=87 4=3< 3=:8
3=<6< 4=5; 4=65 45=8 3=79 3=77 4=:6
3=39: 4=85 4=64 7=5 4=87 4=3; 4=33
dqg uhjduglqj wkh iruhfdvw/ lq h{shulphqw 4+5, wkh phdq rq wkh iruhfdvw wuhqg
frh!flhqw lv 313334 +313335, dqg wkh vwdqgdug ghyldwlrq lv 313358 +313373,1 Wkh
wuhqg lv qhjdwlyh 79;: +7:<;, wlphv/ dqg srvlwlyh 8646 +8535, wlphv1 Wkh glvwul0
exwlrq lv jlyhq e|
a4 ? =3348 ? =334 ? =3338 A =3338 A =334 A =3348
H{s4
5474
5;96
69::
763: 65;8 57<<
H{s5
6375
6943
74<9
7895 6<73 66:4
vkrzlqj fohduo| wkdw rxw ri wkh whq wkrxvdqg uxqv zh fdq rewdlq riwhq +58 wr
66( ri wkh wlphv, srvlwlyh wuhqg iruhfdvwv rq wkh yduldqfh/ ri wkh pdjqlwxgh zh
vhh lq wkh gdwd1
L vkrxog qrwh qrz wkdw wkh duwlfldo gdwd xqghuo|lqj wkhvh uhjuhvvlrqv/ do0
wkrxjk frqvwuxfwhg dffruglqj wr zkdw zh vhh lq wkh dfwxdo uhjuhvvlrqv/ idlov wr
uhsurgxfh wkh frh!flhqwv xvhg wr jhqhudwh wkhp1 Krzhyhu/ wkh srlqw wkdw zh
fdq rewdlq yduldqfh surmhfwlrqv vlplodu wr zkdw IS gr zlwk d prgho wkdw vkrxog
qrw gr vr/ uhpdlqv lqwdfw1 48
Wklv h{huflvh zdv shuiruphg xvlqj dffr<1p
81314 Wkhlu prgho
Zkdw li zh xvh wkhlu htxdwlrq lq wklv h{shulphqwB Wkh duwlfldo gdwd lv jhqhudwhg
e|
@ 5<=47 3=34w . 3=<8\w4 7=4Uw4 . 3=4:Yw4 . }w
@ 3 . 3=3<8}w4 . w
zlwk w Q +3> w ,/ dqg w X +o > k ,/ zlwk d wzr vwdwh Pdunry pdwul{ zlwk
\w
}w
318 suredelolw| lq hyhu| fhoo jryhuqlqj wkh wudqvlwlrq ehwzhhq o dqg k / zklfk
duh ri odujhu pdjqlwxghv +318, wr kdyh vrph yduldwlrq1 Wkhq wkh h{huflvh lv wr
uxq wkh vdph h{shulphqw dv IS gr +uxq djdlq wklv uhjuhvvlrq ri wkh duwlfldo
gdwd rq wkh uhdo gdwd,/
\w @ 3 . 4w . 5\w4 . 6Uw4 . 7Yw4 . w
dqg vhh zkdw kdsshqv wr wkh yduldqfh surmhfwlrq1 Wkh uhvxowv iurp whq wkrxvdqg
uhsolfdwlrqv duh/ +}
= > |
> |
,/ dqg
@ 3 88
@ 79<
@ 4<6
48 Lw grhv vxjjhvw wkh h{huflvh ri wu|lqj wr edfn rxw wkh wuxh prgho xqghuo|lqj wkh gdwd/ e|
lpsrvlqj rq lw wkh wdvn ri uhsurgxflqj uhjuhvvlrqv uhvxowv dqg dovr wkh yduldqfh surmhfwlrqv1
48
a 3
phdq 43=9
vwg 7=5
a 4
3=67
3=35
a 5
3=<;
3=33
a 6 a 7
;=: 47<
4=: 99
U5 Wa 3 Wa 4 Wa 5 Wa 6 Wa 7 WaXU
5
3=<<< 3=59 4=8; 83 3=88 3=56 3=;8
3=333 3=43 3=43 3=7 3=4 3=4 3=3<
dqg uhjduglqj wkh iruhfdvw/ lq h{shulphqw 4+5, wkh phdq rq wkh iruhfdvw wuhqg
frh!flhqw lv 313335 +313336, dqg wkh vwdqgdug ghyldwlrq lv 313364 +313373,1 Wkh
wuhqg lv xszdug vorslqj hyhu| wlph1 Wkh glvwulexwlrq lv jlyhq e|
plq pd{ phdq vwg
a4 5=;7 7=8< 6=9< 3=56
vkrzlqj fohduo| wkdw wklv prgho jhqhudwhv odujh srvlwlyh wuhqg iruhfdvwv rq wkh
yduldqfh1
Lq dgglwlrq/ wklv h{shulphqw vkrzv wkdw wkh sduwlfxodu fkrlfh ri uhjuhvvlrq wr
uxq lq xhqfhv wkh surmhfwlrq ri vtxduhg uhvlgxdov wkdw rqh rewdlqv lq wkh hqg/
dqg lq wklv fdvh wkh fkrlfh ri prgho +zklfk lv ghedwdeoh dv L vhh wkh uhvxowv
ri wkh urexvwqhvv h{huflvhv, fohduo| eldvhv wkh prgho lqwr gholyhulqj dq xszdug
vorslqj yduldqfh surmhfwlrq1
Wklv h{huflvh zdv shuiruphg xvlqj dffr<d1p
9
Frqfoxvlrq
Glg xqfhuwdlqw| derxw ixwxuh lqfrph ulvh lq wkh diwhupdwk ri wkh Rfwrehu 4<5<
vwrfn pdunhw fudvk lq wkh Xqlwhg VwdwhvB Lq wklv sdshu L h{dplqh wkh urexvwqhvv
ri wkh h{huflvh xqghuwdnhq e| Iodffr dqg Sdunhu +4<<5, zkr qg wkdw lqfrph
xqfhuwdlqw| glg lqfuhdvh diwhu wkh fudvk1 L qg wkdw wkhlu uhvxowv duh qrw urexvw
wr fkdqjhv lq wkh vshflfdwlrq ri wkhlu uhjuhvvlrqv/ dqg wkdw wkhlu uhjuhvvlrq lv
olnho| wr eh plvshflhg iurp srvvleo| ryhuorrnlqj d xqlw urrw dqg d vwuxfwxudo
euhdn lq wkh gdwd1 Ixuwkhupruh/ lq jhqhudo wkhlu phwkrgrorj| xvhv h{ srvw
lqirupdwlrq zklfk lw vkrxog qrw li lw lv phdqw wr whvw wkh wkhru|1 Ilqdoo|/ L qg
wkdw d prgho zlwk d vwdwlrqdu| yduldqfh dqg xqsuhglfwdeoh yduldqfh fkdqjhv
riwhq jhqhudwhv wkh yduldqfh lqfuhdvh wkh| qg lq wkhlu sduwlfxodu gdwd h{huflvh/
dqg ixuwkhupruh wkhlu h{dfw vshflfdwlrq dqg wkhlu fkrlfh ri yduldeohv eldvhv
wkh h{huflvh lq idyru ri qglqj dq lqfuhdvh lq yduldqfh hyhq li wkh yduldqfh lv
vwdwlrqdu|1 L eholhyh wkdw wkh h{shulphqwv shuiruphg khuh udlvh vhulrxv grxewv
derxw wkhlu uhvxowv/ dqg derxw xvlqj wkhp wr vxssruw Urphu*v +4<<3, fdqglgdwh
wkhru| derxw wkh rqvhw ri wkh Juhdw Ghsuhvvlrq1
49
Uhihuhqfhv
^4` Hmdutxh/ M1 +4<<:, Xqfhuwdlqw| dqg gxudeoh frqvxpswlrq lq wkh Juhdw Jh0
suhvvlrq/ Xqlyhuvlw| ri Frshqkdjhq/ Lqvwlwxwh ri Hfrqrplfv/ Glvfxvvlrq sd0
shu <:0371
^5` Iodffr/ S1/ dqg Sdunhu/ U1 +4<<5, Lqfrph xqfhuwdlqw| dqg wkh Rqvhw ri wkh
Juhdw Ghsuhvvlrq/ Hfrqrplf Lqtxlu| 63/ Mdqxdu| 4<<5/ 48704:41
^6` Iuhqfk/ N/ J1 Vfkzhuw/ dqg U1 Vwdpedxjk +4<;:,> H{shfwhg Vwrfn Uhwxuqv
dqg Yrodwlolw|/ Mrxuqdo ri Ilqdqfldo Hfrqrplfv/ 4</ 605<
^7` Juhdvoh|/ G1/ Pdgvhq/ M1/ dqg R{oh|/ O1 +5334,1 Lqfrph Xqfhuwdlqw| dqg
Frqvxphu Vshqglqj gxulqj wkh Juhdw Ghsuhvvlrq/ H{sorudwlrqv lq Hfr0
qrplf Klvwru| 6;/ 55805841
^8` Juhhqh/ Z1 K1+4<<6,/ Hfrqrphwulf Dqdo|vlv/ Vhfrqg Hglwlrq/ Pdfploodq
Sxeolvklqj Frpsdq|
^9` Roqh|/ P1 +4<<<,/ Dyrlglqj Ghidxow= Wkh Uroh ri Fuhglw lq wkh Frqvxpswlrq
Froodsvh ri 4<631 Txduwhuo|0Mrxuqdo0ri0Hfrqrplfv> 447+4,/ Iheuxdu| 4<<</
64<0681
^:` Urphu/ F1 +4<<3,> Wkh Juhdw Fudvk dqg wkh Rqvhw ri wkh Juhdw Ghsuhv0
vlrq/ Txduwhuo| Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrplfv/ 438/ 8<:0957
^;` Wkh Grz Mrqhv Dyhudjhv/ 4;;804<<3 +4<<4,/ Sk|oolv V1Slhufh Hg1/ Exvlqhvv
Rqh Luzlq
4:
:
Urexvwqhvv
:1315 Urexvwqhvv 41 Whvwlqj iru d xqlw urrw1
Khuh L xvh wkh vdpsoh iurp Mdqxdu| 4<54 wr Ghfhpehu 4<5;/ dprxqwlqj wr <9
revhuydwlrqv1 Ehfdxvh L ylhz wkh suhvhqfh ri d xqlw urrw zlwk vrph frqfhuq/ L
whvw wklv pruh uljrurxvo| e| hvwlpdwlqj
\w \w4 @ 3 . 4w . 5 \w4 . 6+\w4 \w5 , . 7Yw4 . }w
}aw @ 3 . 4}aw4 . w / dqg }aw5 @ 3 . 4}aw54 . w 1 Dqg zh jhw +zlwk
dqg
vwdwlvwlfv lq sduhqwkhvlv,
a 3
3=7;
+5=7;,
a 4
3=3357
+4=:4,
a 5
3=39
+5=56,
a 6
3=68
+6=94,
a 7
U5
W
I XU
3=45; 3=48< ;=75
+3=34,
zkhuh wkh xqlw urrw I XU whvw h{fhhgv wkh ydoxh ri 9158 ri wkh Glfnh| Ixoohu
glvwulexwlrq149 Wkh Euhxvfk Sdjdq whvw khuh uhmhfwv krprhvnhgdvwlflw| + lw sur0
gxfhv wkh ydoxh T
= zklfk h{fhhgv wkh <8( ydoxh ri <17<,1 Iru wkh uhvlgxdov
zh jhw
@ 48 5
a3
a4
a3
a4
U5
U5
3=3359 3=3357 3=33 3=353 3=665 3=44
+3=47, +3=35,
+7=33, +6=69,
dqg wkhq }aw5 @ 3 . 4 w . 5 \w4 . 6 +\w4 \w5 , . 7 Yw4 . w / +wkh vhfrqg
vwdjh ri IS*v h{huflvh,/ |lhogv
a3
3=3;4
+4=<<,
a4
3=3337
+4=83,
a5
3=334:
+3=5<,
a6
3=33;7
+3=74,
a7
;=6;<
+5=85,
U5
3=4;:
dqg wkh dyhudjhv ri wkh surmhfwlrq duh
4<58 4<59 4<5: 4<5; 4<5< 4<63 4<64 4<65 4<66 4<67
3=35; 3=34: 3=34; =338 =433 =369 =3<9 =49< =458 =365
Khuh zh uhmhfw d xqlw urrw14: Vhfrqg/ odjjhg jurzwk lv dq lpsruwdqw yduldeoh
lq wkh uvw uhjuhvvlrq1 Wklv vhhpv wr eh d ehwwhu vshflfdwlrq jlyhq wkdw zh gr
qrw slfn xs dq| dxwrfruuhodwlrq lq wkh uhvlgxdo +iurp 3144 wr 3,/ dqg pxfk ohvv
lq wkh vtxduhg uhvlgxdo +iurp 3166 wr 3144,1 Wkh Euhxvfk Sdjdq whvw uhmhfwv
krprhvnhgdvwlflw|/ dqg wkh IS uhjuhvvlrq lq iru wkh vtxduhg uhvlgxdov kdv vrph
vljqlfdqfh1 Wkh surmhfwlrq lv grzqzdug vorslqj1
Wklv h{huflvh lv shuiruphg zlwk dffr851p/ rswlrq 71
Juhhqh/ fkdswhu 4</ sdjhv 89808991 Whvwv mrlqwo| wkh frh!flhqwv k
 dqg k
21
fruuhfw whvw grhv qrw lqfoxgh wkh yduldqfh rq wkh uljkw kdqg vlgh ri wkh htxdwlrq1 Wkh
uhvxowv ri wkdw htxdwlrq duh qhduo| h{dfwo| wkh vdph1 L dovr glg qrw gr wkh ixoo surfhgxuh ri
vwduwlqj zlwk pdq| odjv dqg holplqdwlqj wkhp1 Wklv lv rqo| lqglfdwlyh1
49 Vhh
4: Wkh
4;
:1316 Urexvwqhvv 41 Odjjhg jurzwk
Li zh glvfdug d xqlw urrw/ zh vkrxog qhyhuwkhohvv lqfoxgh odjjhg jurzwk1 Dqg
dgglqj wklv rqh yduldeoh vwloo jlyhv xv d sduflprqlrxv vshflfdwlrq1 Vr/ zlwk wklv
gdwd/ zh vkrxog uxq
\w @ 3 . 4 w . 5 \w4 . 6+\w4 \w5, . 7Yw4 . }w
zlwk }aw @ 3 . 4 }aw4 . w / dqg }aw5 @ 3 . 4 }aw54 . w 1 Wkh uhvxowv duh/ iru <7
revhuydwlrqv
a 3
3=7;
+5=76,
a 4
a 5
3=<6<
+67=6,
3=3357
+4=:3,
a 6
3=68
+6=89,
U5
3=<;8
a 7
3=45;
+3=34,
zkhuh wkh Euhxvk Sdjdq vwdwlvwlf lv phdvxuhg djdlqvw d "5
lqj krprhvnhgdvwlflw|/ dqg qrz zh jhw iru wkh uhvlgxdov
}w
3=4:78
a3
3=3359
+3=47,
a3
a4
U5
3=3356 3=33 3=353
+7=3,
+3=35,
T
48=5
+7,<8( @ <=7</ uhmhfw0
a4
U5
3=665
+6=68, 3=44
zkhuh zh qrwh wkdw wkh vtxduhg uhvlgxdo kdv vljqlfdqw dxwrfruuhodwlrq exw wkdw
wklv kdv ohvv h{sodqdwru| srzhu wkdq ehiruh +3144?3166,1 Qrz/ IS*v uhjuhvvlrq
}w5 3 4w 5\w4 6 \w4 \w5 7Yw4 w / |lhogv
a@ .
.
a3
3=3;
+4=<<,
. +
a4
3=3337
+4=8,
a5
3=334:
+3=5<,
,.
.
a6
3=33;7
+3=74,
a7
;=6<
+5=85,
U5
3=4;:
Rqfh djdlq wklv surfhgxuh jhqhudwhv d surmhfwlrq ri d grzqzdug vorslqj
vtxduhg uhvlgxdo1 Xqolnh wkh vhqvlwlylw| ri wkh xqlw urrw dqdo|vlv/ khuh/ iruhfdvwv
gr qrw ehfrph xszdug vorslqj1 Wkh dqqxdo dyhudjhv ri surmhfwhg prqwko|
vtxduhg huuruv iurp wklv h{shulphqw duh
4<58 4<59 4<5: 4<5; 4<5< 4<63 4<64 4<65 4<66 4<67
3=35; 3=34: 3=34; 3=338 3=433 3=369 3=3<9 3=49< 3=458 3=365
Wkh vorsh ri wkh iruhfdvw lv
a4 @ 3=3344
Lq wkhvh h{huflvhv zh jhqhudwh qr vljqlfdqw yduldqfh lqfuhdvh1 Dovr wkh
h{huflvh lq IS pd| eh plvshflhg dv odjjhg jurzwk vhhpv wr eh uhohydqw dqg
grhv d jrrg mre holplqdwlqj suhglfwdeoh frpsrqhqwv iurp wkh uhvlgxdo1 Ilqdoo|/
zh uhmhfw krprhvnhgdvwlflw|1
4<
Vr idu zh duh plvvlqj vhyhudo yduldeohv iurp wkh ruljlqdo IS h{huflvh1 Pdlqo|
zh duh plvvlqj rqh yduldeoh zklfk lv vljqlfdqw lq wkhlu h{huflvh/ wkh |lhog gli0
ihuhqwldo1 Wkdw lv lpsruwdqw/ exw vr lv wkh h{dfw vdpsoh xvhg1 Zkdw lv wkh ehvw
vdpsoh wr xvh lq wkh hvwlpdwlrq vwdjh/ li zh zdqw wr fruuhfwo| hvwlpdwh wkh uhdf0
wlrq ri djhqwv wr wkh vwrfn pdunhw fudvkB Lv lqirupdwlrq rqo| xs wr Ghfhpehu
4<5; ehwwhu wkdq xs wr Vhswhpehu 4<5<B4; Dovr/ duh wkh uhvxowv vr idu urexvw wr
wkh lqwurgxfwlrq ri dgglwlrqdo yduldeohv dqg wr wkh xvh ri d glhuhqw vdpsohB
Wklv h{huflvh lv shuiruphg zlwk dffr851p/ rswlrq 51
4; Xvlqj gdwd wkdw fryhuv wkh hqwluh lqwhuzdu pdnhv wkh uhjuhvvlrq w wkh gdwd pxfk ehwwhu1
Vhh Hmdutxh +4<<:, dqg Juhdvoh|/ Pdgvhq dqg R{oh| +5334,1
53
:1317 Urexvwqhvv 51 D xqlw urrw dqg odjjhg jurzwk
Wdnh wkh uhjuhvvlrq xvlqj wkh vdpsoh iurp Mdqxdu| 4<58 wr Ghfhpehu 4<5;1
\w \w4 @ 3 . 4w . 5\w4 . 6+\w4 \w5, . 7Uw4 . 8Yw4 . }w
a @ . 4}aw4 . w/ dqg }aw5 @ 3 . 4}aw54 . w1
zlwk }w 3
revhuydwlrqv/
a 3
3=;5
+3=96,
a 4
3=336
+4=3;,
a 5
3=3:
+3=;8,
a 6
3=4<:
+4=3<,
a 7
3=37
+3=45,
Wkh uhvxowv duh/ iru 79
a 8
5=6;
+3=47,
U5
3=39<
I
3=9;
T
7=89
zkhuh zh qrwh wkdw wkh I whvw +whvwv mrlqwo| wkh wuhqg dqg wkh odj, grhv qrw
uhmhfw d xqlw urrw1 Lq dgglwlrq zh frpsohwho| holplqdwh dq| h{sodqdwru| srzhu
lq wkh uhvlgxdo uhjuhvvlrqv1
}w
3=46
a3
3=3335
+3=34,
a4
3=33:
+3=37,
U5
3=33
a3
3=349
+6=7:,
U5
a4
3=399
+3=76, 3=337
Wkhq }w5
a @ 3 . 4w . 5\w4 . 6+\w4 \w5, . 7Uw4 . 8Yw4 . w |lhogv
a3
a4
a5
a6
a7
a8
U5
3=35 3=3335 3=339 3=347 3=378 7=3: 3=3;:
+3=3;, +3=68, +3=67, +3=74, +3=:;, +4=66,
vr wkdw wkhuh lv vrph h{sodqdwru| srzhu lq wklv htxdwlrq/ ghvslwh wkh qrq uhmhf0
wlrq ri krprhvnhgdvwlflw| lq wkh Euhxvk Sdjdq whvw +zklfk lv shuiruphg xvlqj
wkh vdph yduldeohv dv wklv odvw uhjuhvvlrq,1 Zkdw derxw wkh yduldqfh surmhf0
wlrqB Wklv wdeoh vkrzv wkh dqqxdo dyhudjhv ri surmhfwhg vtxduhg huuruv iurp
wklv vshflfdwlrq
4<58 4<59 4<5: 4<5; 4<5<
3=358 3=345 3=34: 3=339 3=35<
4<63
3=366
4<64 4<65 4<66 4<67
3=3<8 3=454 3=3;9 3=3;3
dqg khuh zh jhw dq lqfuhdvh lq wkh surmhfwlrq diwhu 4<5<1 Iru wklv fdvh
3=3694
a4 lv
Wklv h{huflvh zdv grqh e| uxqqlqj dffr861p/ fkrrvlqj rswlrq 71
54
:1318 Urexvwqhvv 51 Lpsolfdwlrqv ri wkh vdpsoh vhohfwhg1
Ohw*v uhgr wklv h{huflvh zlwk glhuhqw vdpsohv1
\w @ 3 . 4w . 5\w4 . 6Uw4 . 7Yw4 . }w
zlwk }aw @ 3 . 4 }aw4 . w / dqg }aw5 @ 3 . 4 }aw54 . w 1 Khuh +93 4 @ 8<, uhihuv
wr wkh vdpsoh xs wr dqg lqfoxglqj Ghfhpehu 4<5</
vdpsoh xs wr dqg lqfoxglqj Ghfhpehu 4<63/ hwf hwf1
a 3
3=83:
+3=<4,
3=<98
+4=;7,
3=885
+4=4:,
a 4
3=335
+3=<6,
3=333
+3=4;,
3=335
+4=;9,
a 5
3=<8<
+53=7,
3=<;3
+53=<,
4=354
+6:=5,
a 6
3=387
+3=59,
3=64<
+4=;3,
3=634
+5=89,
a 7
;=:9
+4=47,
9=;5
+6=58,
9=7;
+6=87,
:5 4 @ :4 uhihuv wr wkh
U5
3=<:6
&rev I
T
89 3=;9 5=89
3=<:4 8< 3=76 4=3<
3=<:7 :4 3=:8 3=9<
zkhuh }w lv dozd|v durxqg 31471 Khuh Y lv vljqlfdqw li zh uxq dq h{sdqghg
vdpsoh/ mxvwli|lqj wkhuhiruh lqfoxvlrq lq wkh vkruw vdpsoh/ hyhq li lw lv qrw vlj0
qlfdqw wkhuh1 U lv dovr vljqlfdqw lq wkh vhfrqg dqg wklug h{shulphqwv1
a3
3=3337
+3=35,
3=333<
+3=38,
3=3338
+3=36,
a4
3=4;3
+4=65,
3=578
+4=;;,
3=59:
+5=59,
a3
3=346
+6=89,
3=38< 3+6=34:
=<,
3
=
34;
3=3:3 +7=;:,
U5
3=365
a4
U5
3=4:<
+4=66, 3=365
3=3<:
+3=:6, 3=33<
3=377
+3=6:, 3=335
Wkhuh lv qr dxwrfruuhodwlrq lq vtxduhg uhvlgxdov1 Wkh vhfrqg vwdjh ri IS*v
h{huflvh hvwlpdwhv
}aw5 @ 3 . 4 w . 5\w4 . 6 Uw4 . 7Yw4 . w
Wkh uhvxowv iurp wklv htxdwlrq duh
a3
3=344
+3=44,
3=334
+3=34,
3=356
+3=5:,
a4
3=3335
+3=77,
3=3334
+3=47,
3=3334
+3=7;,
a5
3=338
+3=8<,
3=335
+3=57,
3=334
+3=5<,
55
a6
3=358
+3=9:,
+3=87,
3=346
+3=97,
3=34;
a7
4=67
U5
3=379
+3=<<,
3=5< 3=34<
+3=:9,
3=4<: 3=344
+3=94,
dqg wkh dqqxdo dyhudjhv ri surmhfwhg vtxduhg huuruv iurp wklv vshflfdwlrq duh
4<58
3=354
3=355
3=355
4<59
3=348
3=34:
3=34<
4<5:
3=34:
3=34;
3=34:
4<5;
3=348
3=34:
3=349
4<5< 4<63 4<64 4<65 4<66
3=334 3=365 3=3:: 3=435 3=3;7
3=348 3=35; 3=393 3=3;6 3=398
3=34: 3=34< 3=36: 3=37: 3=368
4<67 q
3=39: 89
3=379 8<
3=354 :4
vkrzlqj dq lqfuhdvh diwhu 4<5<1 Wkh vorshv ri wkhvh surmhfwlrqv iru wkh 55 vdpsoh
duh
q
89
8<
:4
a4 3=3347 3=333: 3=3333
D gxpp| iru wkh vwuxfwxudo euhdn14<
Qrwh qrz wkdw wkh vdpsoh ri 8< lqfoxghv wkuhh revhuydwlrqv diwhu wkh uvw
vwuxfwxudo euhdn dqg wkh vdpsoh ri :4 lqfoxghv 48 revhuydwlrqv1 Glvuhjduglqj wkh
vwuxfwxudo euhdn fdq kdyh vhulrxv lpsolfdwlrqv/ dqg khuh L uhgr wkh suhylrxv h{0
huflvh iru :4 revhuydwlrqv lqfoxglqj d gxpp| yduldeoh1 Qrwh qdoo| wkdw ehfdxvh
wklv lv dq h{huflvh zlwk h{ srvw lqirupdwlrq zh vkrxog lqfoxgh wkh gxpp|1
a 3
3=3:<
+3=49,
a Gxp
3=596
+6=3<,
a 4
3=334
+3=<9,
a 5
4=345
+6;=<,
a 6
3=33;
+3=39,
a
@ 3 339
a 7
8=9;
+6=59,
Uq5 @:4
3=<::
T
6=3;
Wkh I whvw ri wkh glhuhqfh ehwzhhq 5 dqg 4 kdv ydoxh 031781 Wkh U vtxduhg
iru wkh uhvlgxdo htxdwlrqv duh/ uvw iru wkh vlpsoh DU4/ U5
= / dqg wkhq iru
= 1 Wkh |lhog glhuhqwldo lv vxgghqo| qrw
wkh DU4 lq vtxduhg uhvlgxdov/ U5
vljqlfdqw153 Wkhuh lv qr dxwrfruuhodwlrq lq wkh uhvlgxdov1 Wkh vhfrqg vwdjh ri
= 1 Wkh surmhfwlrq ri vtxduhg uhvlgxdov dffruglqj wr
IS*v h{huflvh kdv U5
IS*v uhjuhvvlrq kdv dyhudjhv
@ 3 34
@ 3 36;
4<58 4<59 4<5: 4<5; 4<5< 4<63
3=356 3=34; 3=348 3=347 3=347 3=345
4<64
3=37:
4<65 4<66 4<67 q
3=3:7 3=388 3=358 :4
zkhuh wkh lqfuhdvh lq vtxduhg uhvlgxdov frphv lq 4<641 Wkh vorsh iru wkh 55
revhuydwlrqv ehwzhhq mdqxdu| 4<5< dqg rfwrehu 4<63 lv
q
:4
a4 3=3337
zklfk lv d frqvlghudeoh fkdqjh1 Wklv h{shulphqw vkrzv krz wklv h{huflvh 0
zklfk xvhv h{ srvw lqirupdwlrq wr vwduw zlwk 0 fdq vhulrxvo| eldv wkh lqihuhqfh
e| glvuhjduglqj wkh lqirupdwlrq rq wkh vwuxfwxudo euhdn1
4< Zh
frxog dujxh wkdw wkh gxpp| vkrxog eh lq wkh vorsh frh!flhqw1
wklv yduldeoh lv lqfoxghg rq wkhruhwlfdo jurxqgv/ vxfk prgho vhhpv glvplvvhg e| gdwd1
Wklv lq lwvhoi zrxog eh lqqrfxrxv/ li qrw iru wkh idfw wkdw wkh surmhfwlrq ri wkh vtxduhg uhvlgxdo
lv dhfwhg e| wkh zd| wklv uhvlgxdo lv frqvwuxfwhg1 Dqg ixuwkhu xvh ri vxfk surmhfwlrq lq rwkhu
uhjuhvvlrqv lv wkhq vxemhfw wr fulwlflvp1
53 Li
56
:1319 Urexvwqhvv 51 Pruh zlwk d gxpp| iru wkh euhdn lq Mxo| 4<5<1
Wkh gxpp| yduldeoh lv d vhtxhqfh ri }hurv xs wr dqg lqfoxglqj Mxo| 4<5</ dqg
wkhq kdv 69 rqhv xs wr dqg lqfoxglqj Mxo| 4<64/ dqg }hurv diwhuzdugv +qrw doo
wkh ohqjwk ri wkh vhulhv lv xvhg,1
\w @ 3 . 4 G . 5w . 6\w4 . 7 Uw4 . 8Yw4 . }w
zlwk }aw @ 3 . 4 }aw4 . w / dqg }aw5 @ 3 . 4 }aw54 . w 1
a 3
3=58
+3=74,
3=3;
+3=49,
a 4
3=5:
+5=53,
3=59
+6=4,
a 5
3=334<
+3=:<,
3=3347
+3=<9,
a 6
3=<<4
+55,
4=345
+6;,
a 7
3=398
+3=65,
3=33<
+3=39,
a 8
8=57
+5=77,
8=9;
+6=59,
&rev I T
8< 3=53 5=;6
3=<:: :4 3=77 6=3;
U5
3=<:7
zkhuh wkh I vwdwlvwlf lv mxvw 4+aa66, > dqg T lv wkh Euhxvk0Sdjdq phdvxuh1 Wkh
vdolhqw ihdwxuh khuh lv wkh vljqlfdqfh ri wkh Gxpp| dqg wkh orvv ri vljqlfdqfh
ri wkh \lhog Glhuhqwldo1 Exw grhv lw dhfw wkh uhvw ri wkh h{huflvhB Zhoo/ qrz zh
fdq fruuhfwo| hydoxdwh wkh T vwdwlvwlf dqg lw grhv qrw uhmhfw krprhvnhgdvwlflw|1
Wkh I phdvxuh/ dowkrxjk qrw d surshu xqlw urrw whvw vxjjhvwv wkdw vkrxog eh
orrnhg dw1 Wkh |lhog glhuhqwldo lv qrw vljqlfdqw dqg wkh Grz Mrqhv yduldqfh
vwloo lv vljqlfdqw1 Dv iru wkh uhvlgxdov
a3
3=3336
+3=35,
3=3334
+3=33,
a4
3=44
+3=;7,
3=44
+3=<5,
a
3=347
+6=:3,
3=345 +73==348
55,
U5
3=345
3
a
U
3=46 3=349
+3=<8,
3=3;
+3=99, 3=339
4
5
lw lv rqo| lq wkh vhfrqg urz wkdw zh qrz orvh wkh vljqlfdqfh ri wkh uvw odj
ri wkh uhvlgxdo/ vxjjhvwlqj zhdno| wkdw vrph ri wkh dxwrfruuhodwlrq fdq eh gxh
wr wkh plvvlqj gxpp|1 Ilqdoo|/ wkh U vtxduhg ri wkh IS uhjuhvvlrq lq vtxduhg
uhvlgxdov lv 31376 iru 8< revhuydwlrqv dqg 3136; iru :4 revhuydwlrqv1
Wkhvh h{shulphqwv zhuh grqh zlwk dffr861p fkrrvlqj rswlrq 41
:131: Urexvwqhvv 51 Jurzwk udwhv dqg vdpsoh fkrlfh1
Iru h{dpsoh orrn dw
\w \w4 @ 3 . 4w . 5\w4 . 6+\w4 \w5, . 7Uw4 . 8Yw4 . }w
57
zlwk }aw @ 3 . 4 }aw4 . w / dqg }aw5 @ 3 . 4 }aw54 . w 1
a
4=3;
+5=3;,
3=94
+4=5<,
3
a
3=3349
+3=98,
3=3345
+4=3;,
4
a 5
3=383
+4=37,
3=336
+3=44,
a
3=5;5
+5=45,
3=559
+4=;:,
6
a
3=585
+4=74,
3=58:
+5=46,
7
zkhuh U5q@8; @ 3=769/ dqg Uq5 @:4 @ 3=7:71
a
3=3335
+3=34,
3
3=47 +3=3336
=35,
}w
3=46
3
a4
3=335
+3=35,
3=3;6
+3=9:,
a
3=34;
+7=3,
3
3=34 +7==34<
<6,
U5
3=33
3
a 8
q
I
T
8=7; 8; 3=96 6=4<
+5=89,
8=63 :3 3=:9 5=<5
+5=:9,
a
U
3=35: 3=33
+3=53,
3=3:6 3=34
+3=93,
4
5
Wkh vhfrqg vwdjh IS h{huflvh hvwlpdwhv duh doo qrq vljqlfdqw
}aw5 @ 3 . 4w . 5\w4 . 6+\w4 \w5 , . 7Uw4 . 8 Yw4 . w
Wkh uhvxowv iurp wklv htxdwlrq duh Uq5 @8; @ 3=374/ dqg Uq5 @:3 @ 3=36:1 Wkh
surmhfwlrq |lhogv
4<58 4<59 4<5: 4<5; 4<5< 4<63
3=358 3=34; 3=349 3=346 3=345 3=353
3=357 3=34< 3=349 3=345 3=34: 3=34:
zkhuh wkh surmhfwlrq lqfuhdvhv diwhu 4<631
4<64
3=384
3=36<
4<65 4<66 4<67 q
3=39; 3=376 3=354 8;
3=37: 3=357 3=3375 :3
Wklv h{huflvh zdv grqh zlwk dffr861p fkrrvlqj rswlrq 61
58
;
Qxpehuv
Gdwd +GMY-4333/ prqwko| yduldqfh ri gdlo| uhwxuqv rq wkh Grz Mrqhv lqgh{1
Vwduwlqj gdwh lv mdqxdu| 4<54,1 Wkhvh qxpehuv duh frqvwuxfwhg iurp gdlo| gdwd1
Iluvw wkh uvw vl{ prqwkv
Y
54
55
56
57
58
59
5:
5;
5<
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
6:
6;
M
5=<5:
3=<78
3=<:8
4=6<3
4=776
3=:35
3=96:
4=6;:
4=965
5=8;3
6=<7;
5:=3:4
6=73:
8=49;
4=5:6
3=<74
4=585
;=78<
I
3=;43
5=3<7
3=<49
3=:4;
4=9:6
5=549
3=763
4=583
:=965
4=:<:
8=7:7
49=9:6
6=4;:
6=49;
4=<65
3=;:4
3=:65
5=9;9
dqg wkhq wkh odvw vl{ prqwkv
Y
54
55
56
57
58
59
5:
5;
5<
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
6:
6;
M
4=:;7
3=:78
6=4<8
3=;65
3=;63
4=:;3
3=<<;
4=<7:
4=38:
7=969
<=483
4:=3:
69=799
8=866
3=9<;
4=735
5=487
D
6=6;4
3=;9<
4=;87
4=:73
4=449
5=4:4
4=665
5=:<6
5=49:
8=975
8=989
7:=3:8
:=4:8
7=5::
4=3:4
4=:;6
5=637
P
D
5=;63
4=48<
3=:83
4=596
6=6<;
:=833
3=6;4
6=46<
:=398
4=94;
7=663
4=5<4
4=399
4=3<8
4=:7<
3=;76
4=;48
3=733
4=456
4=7<<
4=69:
:=898
4=:6:
5=9;;
4=:3<
5=695
46=;:7
4=:98
4=794
5=:;6
6=86;
4<=37;
V
R
<=347 4:=:<5
65=:7: 65=56<
P
M
4=773 6=<39
4=634 4=9:5
5=;78 6=646
3=:55 4=:77
4=553 4=3;6
4=57; 4=8<<
4=3;; 3=83:
4=<43 7=466
3=;76 6=377
9=588 45=39:
7=833 54=788
54=49 67=<:9
48=;<9 <=43:
9=9:7 7=996
6=849 6=845
5=6;8 4=49:
4=6:6 4=7::
7=678 45=::6
Q
6=554 4=:9<
3=;:8 8=7<9
4=99; 4=;58
4=;<4 3=<68
4=65: 4=799
4=7<: 6=439
5=453 7=965
3=773 5=346
5=556 :9=88
9=85 45=<:7
4=948
6=778
4=54<
4=489
5=:57
3=;59
5=34<
5=999
7:=;78
;=477
;=7<5
5=:44
5=::9
3=959
44=9;6
8=:34
4=933
4=66<
5=347
54=<96
G
4=5<5
3=:85
3=9<<
4=8;;
4=63;
3=;4:
3=:83
48=<6<
47=974
<=4<3
48=839 55=<3< 49=94< 48=:;8
66=<8< 53=554 56=999 43=996
59
53=573
5=8<4
5=447
4=875
55=7:6
6=886
5=3<6
4=746
4=478
;=74;
Dqg wkh Lqgxvwuldo surgxfwlrq lqgh{ lv
+LSL ,
54
55
56
57
58
59
5:
5;
5<
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
6:
6;
M
I
9=56:
9=:;8
<=436
<=5:4
<=93<
43=3:5
43=785
43=4<<
44=:8;
43=<48
;=8<:
:=3;3
9=5:<
:=;;4
<=436
43=574
45=934
<=647
9=444
:=3;3
<=55<
<=773
<=93<
43=3:5
43=869
43=5;6
44=:49
43=;:6
;=96<
9=<44
9=654
;=593
<=5:4
<=<;;
45=:9<
<=55<
P
8=<75
:=78<
<=857
<=5:5
<=93<
43=4<<
43=995
43=69:
44=:8;
43=:37
;=;3;
9=;5:
8=<75
;=96<
<=55<
43=447
46=397
<=55<
D
8=<75
:=539
<=:68
;=<<:
<=9<6
43=4<<
43=73<
43=658
44=<9<
43=953
;=;83
9=697
9=697
;=96<
<=394
43=:7:
46=397
<=394
P
9=444
:=89;
<=;95
;=8<:
<=984
43=447
43=7<7
43=785
45=4:<
43=785
;=:57
9=486
:=74:
;=;3;
<=394
43=<8:
46=43:
;=;83
M
9=39<
:=<98
<=:::
;=54;
<=89:
43=574
43=785
43=869
45=597
43=48:
;=846
8=<75
;=888
;=96<
<=4;:
44=49;
45=<6;
;=<67
dqg wkh odvw vl{ prqwkv
+LS L ,
54
55
56
57
58
59
5:
5;
5<
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
6:
6;
M
9=359
:=<98
<=9<6
;=3<4
<=;4<
43=5;6
43=658
43=995
45=765
<=9<6
;=6;9
8=::7
<=689
;=37<
<=4;:
44=6:<
46=355
<=773
D
9=56:
:=:<9
<=857
;=6;9
<=984
43=73<
43=658
43=;:6
45=639
<=7;5
;=3<4
8=<75
;=<::
:=<98
<=857
44=87:
45=<6;
<=<79
V
9=5:<
;=54;
<=647
;=9;4
<=857
43=8:;
43=48:
43=<8:
45=555
<=647
:=:45
9=654
;=7:4
:=834
<=:::
44=:8;
45=84:
43=574
5:
R
9=98<
;=9;5
<=5:5
;=;<5
<=<37
43=8:;
<=<79
44=49;
45=344
<=394
:=74:
9=865
;=37<
:=;6<
43=3:5
44=<5:
44=8;<
43=7<7
Q
9=8:7
<=394
<=5:4
<=394
43=447
43=869
<=<79
44=6:<
44=754
;=;83
:=666
9=865
:=8;9
:=<56
43=5;6
45=597
43=785
43=<48
G
9=865
<=647
<=394
<=647
43=574
43=7<7
<=<;;
44=8;<
43=<48
;=96<
:=5<4
9=739
:=95;
;=75<
43=73<
45=976
<=857
44=375
dqg wkh jryhuqphqw erqg |lhog
+JE\ ,
58
59
5:
5;
5<
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
6:
6;
6<
M
6=<9
6=::
6=84
6=4;
6=85
6=76
6=53
7=59
6=55
6=83
5=;;
5=;4
5=8:
5=9<
5=87
I
6=<8
6=:4
6=7;
6=4<
6=95
6=74
6=63
7=44
6=64
6=65
5=:<
5=:;
5=87
5=9;
5=84
P
6=<9
6=:4
6=6:
6=4:
6=:7
6=5<
6=5:
6=<5
6=75
6=53
5=::
5=:6
5=99
5=9:
5=76
D
6=<6
6=:3
6=68
6=53
6=97
6=6:
6=59
6=9;
6=75
6=44
5=:7
5=:3
5=;6
5=99
5=6;
P
6=;:
6=9:
6=64
6=57
6=97
6=64
6=49
6=:9
6=63
6=35
5=:5
5=9;
5=;3
5=89
5=5:
M
6=:<
6=9:
6=67
6=5<
6=9<
6=58
6=46
6=:9
6=54
5=<;
5=:5
5=9<
5=;4
5=8;
5=55
M
6=:<
6=9;
6=69
6=75
6=97
6=58
6=48
6=8;
6=53
5=<5
5=9<
5=9;
5=:;
5=8;
5=56
D
6=;8
6=:3
6=65
6=7;
6=:4
6=59
6=4;
6=78
6=54
6=36
5=:9
5=97
5=:;
5=8:
5=5:
V
6=;8
6=:3
6=63
6=79
6=:3
6=57
6=58
6=75
6=4<
6=53
5=;8
5=98
5=;5
5=96
5=9:
R
6=;5
6=9;
6=5<
6=7:
6=94
6=54
6=96
6=76
6=55
6=43
5=;8
5=9;
5=;5
5=88
5=93
Q
6=:<
6=95
6=56
6=6;
6=68
6=4<
6=96
6=78
6=79
6=3:
5=;6
5=93
5=:;
5=89
5=79
G
6=;3
6=89
6=4:
6=78
6=69
6=55
6=<6
6=68
6=86
6=34
5=;7
5=8<
5=:6
5=89
5=68
dqg wkh \lhog rq Edd erqgv
+Edd,
58
59
5:
5;
5<
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
6:
6;
6<
73
M
9=77
9=3<
8=94
8=68
8=96
8=<5
9=74
<=46
;=34
:=34
8=<;
8=33
7=7<
8=;<
8=45
7=;9
I
9=69
9=35
8=8<
8=66
8=99
8=;<
9=6;
;=;:
;=6:
9=5:
8=<8
7=;3
7=86
8=<:
8=38
7=;6
P
9=69
9=38
8=87
8=65
8=:<
8=:6
9=77
;=;6
;=<4
9=59
9=53
7=;9
7=9;
9=63
7=;<
7=;3
D
9=74
8=<;
8=7;
8=66
8=;3
8=:3
9=:5
43=79
<=45
9=34
9=46
7=<4
7=;7
9=7:
8=48
7=:7
P
9=63
8=;9
8=83
8=75
8=;3
8=:5
:=48
44=3
:=:7
9=38
8=<7
7=<7
7=;7
9=39
8=3:
7=<7
5;
M
9=4;
8=;3
8=88
8=88
8=<7
8=:;
:=69
44=3
:=3:
9=39
8=::
7=<3
7=<6
9=58
7=<4
8=44
M
9=53
8=:<
8=88
8=8;
8=<8
8=::
:=3;
43=:<
9=95
9=46
8=9:
7=;7
7=<4
8=96
7=;7
7=;3
D
9=57
8=;4
8=7;
8=94
9=37
8=:6
:=7:
;=55
9=::
9=7<
8=8;
7=:7
7=<5
8=7<
7=;8
7=:9
V
9=53
8=:<
8=75
8=8<
9=45
8=98
;=3:
:=94
:=5:
9=8:
8=86
7=95
8=49
8=98
8=33
7=99
R
9=4:
8=;4
8=6;
8=8;
9=44
8=<7
<=37
:=;:
:=7<
9=73
8=87
7=87
8=85
8=69
7=;;
7=89
Q
9=4:
8=::
8=68
8=88
9=36
9=58
;=<6
;=57
:=<;
9=6:
8=76
7=85
8=;5
8=56
7=;8
7=7;
G
9=48
8=9;
8=65
8=93
8=<8
9=:4
43=75
;=75
:=:8
9=56
8=63
7=86
8=:6
8=5:
7=<5
7=78