http://www.theiet.org/cpd Electricity Storage A Briefing provided by the Institution of Engineering and Technology www.theiet.org/factfiles About This Briefing Contents The Institution of Engineering and Technology acts as a voice for the engineering and technology professions by providing independent, reliable and factual information to the public and policy makers. This Briefing aims to provide an accessible guide to current technologies and scientific facts of interest to the public. Introduction������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 3 Does the electricity supply system need storage?������������������������������ 3 Does wind generation strengthen the case for storage?��������������������� 3 What storage technologies are available or being developed?������������ 4 Are some storage technologies better than others?���������������������������� 6 How can storage help electricity networks?��������������������������������������� 6 Are there any structural barriers to the deployment of storage?���������� 8 What other benefits can storage plants deliver? ���������������������������� 8 What role can heat storage play in the operation of the system?�������� 8 Conclusion��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 9 Additional reading���������������������������������������������������������������������������� 9 End notes���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 9 For more Briefings, Position Statements and Factfiles on engineering and technology topics please visit http://www. theiet.org/factfiles. The Institution of Engineering and Technology The Institution of Engineering and Technology (IET) is a global organisation, with over 150,000 members representing a vast range of engineering and technology fields. Our primary aims are to provide a global knowledge network promoting the exchange of ideas and enhance the positive role of science, engineering and technology between business, academia, governments and professional bodies; and to address challenges that face society in the future. As engineering and technology become increasingly interdisciplinary, global and inclusive, the Institution of Engineering and Technology reflects that progression and welcomes involvement from, and communication between, all sectors of science, engineering and technology. The Institution of Engineering and Technology is a not for profit organisation, registered as a charity in the UK. For more information please visit http://www.theiet.org © The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2012 The Institution of Engineering and Technology is registered as a Charity in England & Wales (no 211014) and Scotland (no SC038698). Cover images (clockwise from top left) 20 MW Flywheel energy storage plant, Stephentown, USA courtesy of Beacon Power, LLC 600 kW Vandium Redox flow battery, Oxnard, USA courtesy of PD Energy Compressed air energy storage plant, Huntorf, Germany courtesy of E.ON Kraftwerke GmbH Pumped hydro plant, Dinorwig, UK courtesy of First Hydro Company Enquiries [email protected] Electricity Storage A Briefing provided by The Institution of Engineering and Technology © The IET 2012 www.theiet.org/factfiles 2 1. Introduction There is a growing interest in the use of energy storage to enable electricity supply systems to operate more efficiently and securely. The main drivers for this interest are the need to integrate a significant capacity of wind power, and other intermittent renewable generation, into the system and to make more efficient use of the transmission and distribution networks. Storage capacity can be deployed in the form of electricity storage devices connected at strategic points of the system and/or the use of thermal storage devices that are directly linked to the system. For the purposes of this briefing , the electricity supply system includes the generating stations and the transmission and distribution system right down to consumer metering points. For simplicity it is simply referred to as “the system”. This briefing answers some key questions about the role of storage in the system. 2. Does the electricity supply system need storage? To answer this question, it is necessary first to understand the particular characteristics of the system. The system combines a process industry with a commodity supply chain like many others. It takes a raw material (the primary energy in, for example, coal, gas or wind), converts it to a product (electricity) and distributes it to customers over the transmission and distribution networks. This is no different in principle from the supply chain for petrol, paper, food and so on. However, there is one very significant difference in practice. Most products can be stored as they move from production to consumption. Whether it’s liquid fuels in tanks or food in warehouses and freezers, storage is used to decouple production from consumption. This is very beneficial as it allows the production processes to be made very efficient potentially operating on a continuous basis rather than flexing with short-term changes in demand. In contrast, because it has always proved very difficult to store electricity, (pumpedhydro is the only widely used technology), the system has been developed so that production and consumption are balanced, second-by-second, on a continuous basis. The electricity supply chain is unique in this respect. Whilst, in engineering terms, operating the system in this way is a remarkable achievement, it means that the assets employed are not used as effectively as in other process industries and their related supply chains. This can be quite easily demonstrated. The annual average electricity demand is currently about 60% of the peak demand. As a margin of generating capacity is needed above the peak demand to allow for planned and unplanned outages, say 20%, we need generating capacity of 120% of peak demand. It follows therefore that the installed generating capacity is twice the average demand so that, on average, it is only utilized for 50% of the time. In other process industries asset utilisation would typically exceed 90%. This low utilisation does not only affect generation. It has even more of an effect on transmission and distribution assets. This is primarily because network capacity margins have to be provided ‘locally’ as they can’t be pooled nationally as generation can. The cost of this low utilization of the system has to be reflected in the price of electricity. So, in answer to the question, “Does the electricity supply system need storage?”, the answer is as follows. Storage is not an absolutely essential part of the electricity supply system as the services it provides can be delivered in alternative ways, in particular by controlling generation and/or demand. However, as demonstrated by the use of pumped hydro, storage can form part of the overall portfolio necessary to securely meet system demand. In the future, if storage could be deployed at a lower overall cost (capital and operating costs) than the competing alternatives then it would be a beneficial addition to the system. It should also be noted that, depending on the particular technology employed and its location on the system, storage can offer services to the system over and above capacity replacement. These services can strengthen the economic case for its deployment. One example of these services is back-up generating capacity either for very fast response (i.e. within seconds) or with some notice period. Given the projected increase in wind generation and the prospect of larger nuclear power stations, these ‘ancillary services’ are expected to become increasingly sought after by power system operators. 3. Does wind generation strengthen the case for storage? The growth of wind generation and other intermittent, essentially uncontrollable, sources of electricity, results in a less predictable world for the system operator who has to balance supply and demand. There are a number of ways of dealing with this. The ‘conventional’ way is to provide higher levels of reserve or back-up generation so that any shortfalls can be quickly met and any excesses are managed by constraining generation output or exporting electricity to another country’s system using interconnectors. An alternative way is to encourage consumer demand to be either responsive to changes in generation output or directly controllable by the system operator. A more radical way is to do what most supply chains do, as already described. Intermittent generation can be effectively decoupled from the system using storage as a buffer. Importantly, the store does not have to be co-located with the wind farm. It can provide this buffer wherever it is connected provided there are no network constraints. It is generally accepted that it will be necessary to use a combination of these solutions to address the challenge of having large amounts of variable output wind generators on Electricity Storage A Briefing provided by The Institution of Engineering and Technology © The IET 2012 www.theiet.org/factfiles 3 the system. However, economics and the practicalities of deploying these solutions will determine how successful each one is. The ‘conventional’ solution of reserve generation is within the control of parties directly involved in the supply chain. Typically, gas-fired generation could be built to fulfill this role. Use of the demand side will ultimately depend on the willingness of consumers to change their patterns of behavior, or the evolution of sources of demand that are relatively insensitive to some degree of interruption, such as the charging of electric vehicles, or electrically supplied heating. The success of storage will depend on a number of factors including cost, the ability to deploy it where it is needed, and its environmental impact. So, the deployment of wind generation does strengthen the case for storage but storage will still have to compete with other sources of flexibility. 4. What storage technologies are available or being developed? Superconducting magnetic energy storage (SMES) - the electrical resistance of certain materials reduces to zero when cooled to very low temperatures. This allows very high currents to be passed through them without loss. This property is applied in a SMES plant. A coil of superconducting wire is cryogenically cooled. By passing a DC current through the coil a magnetic field is produced which acts as the energy store. The superconducting device is connected to an AC system using an inverter/rectifier in a similar way to a conventional battery plant. The import and export of energy by the device can be controlled in a number of ways. This is primarily a device to enhance power quality. Though its response time is close to zero it cannot store very much energy. These devices are commercially available and have been used in the US to support grid systems. Power quality is the term given to the quality of the power supply from the grid system. It is described in terms of its continuity (lack of supply interruptions), voltage stability (the voltage should always remain within upper and lower limits) and harmonic content (a more complex characteristic involving distortion of the voltage waveform). The US-based Electricity Storage Association maintains a very good web site with details of most of the leading storage technologies. This can be found at its websitei. The following notes provide a summary of this information. Cost and performance data for most of the developing technologies is available from a number of sources. However, it is difficult to ensure the accuracy of this data and so it is not included in this briefing. It is helpful to understand the difference between energy and power when considering storage. The energy in a storage device is equivalent to the petrol in a car’s petrol tank - so the bigger the tank the more energy can be stored. The power that a storage device can deliver is equivalent to the size of the car’s engine. With some storage technologies, such as conventional lead-acid batteries, the relationship between energy and power is fixed so if you want more storage you also get more power. With others you can specify the power output and the storage capacity independently. Examples of this include pumped-hydro and flow batteries. Energy storage technologies can be divided into three main categories: Primary - superconducting and capacitor technologies; Mechanical - pumped-hydro, compressed air, flywheels; Electrochemical - conventional and flow batteries. The key performance characteristics of storage technologies are summarised in Table 1. Primary In primary storage devices the electrical energy is stored without conversion to another form (as is the case in a battery or pumped hydro plant). Superconducting magnetic energy storage (SMES) courtesy of Bruker Advanced Supercon Capacitors - there have been significant developments in capacitor technology in recent years. These are referred to as “ultra” or “super” capacitors and use new techniques to dramatically increase the energy density of these devices. Capacitors have the ability to discharge very rapidly and in this respect are superior to some competing technologies. However, they do not yet offer solutions in the utility-scale storage market (i.e. of a scale suitable for the grid system) and so are not discussed further here. Electricity Storage A Briefing provided by The Institution of Engineering and Technology © The IET 2012 www.theiet.org/factfiles 4 Mechanical Pumped hydro - this is the most widely used storage technology at present. There is an excellent example of it in North Wales - the Dinorwig plant which can provide power within seconds and generate up to 1700MW for some 5 hours. A pumped hydro plant consists of two reservoirs, one higher than the other, and a pumping/generating plant. Energy is stored by pumping water from the lower to the upper reservoir giving it potential energy. The energy can be stored in the upper reservoir for considerable periods of time subject to losses through leakage and evaporation. When energy is required by the grid, water is allowed to flow from the upper to the lower reservoir through a turbine which then drives a generator to produce electricity. This is a tried and trusted technology. There are four such plants in the UK, however, further deployment has been constrained by the lack of suitable sites and the high capital cost. Huntorf compressed air energy storage plant courtesy of E.ON Kraftwerke GmbH Flywheels - a flywheel device stores energy (kinetic) in a rotating mass. A motor/generator is able to either drive the flywheel, inputting energy, or be driven by it, extracting energy. Losses are reduced by using very sophisticated bearing technology (e.g. magnetic levitation) and a vacuum enclosure to reduce drag and corrosion. Like SMES, these devices are essentially low energy and are primarily used in power quality applications rather than bulk storage. Dinorwig power station, Wales courtesy of First Hydro Company Cryogen-based energy storage - electricity is used to liquefy air or nitrogen which can be stored at cryogenic temperatures (i.e. extremely low) in large volumes at atmospheric pressure. A low grade heat source (e.g. ambient air) can then be used to heat the cryogen that boils and produces a high pressure gas to drive a turbine which then drives a generator. Compressed air energy storage (CAES) - this is in many ways similar to a pumped hydro plant. However, rather than pumping water ‘up a hill’, air is pumped into a cavern or vessel and compressed. This compressed air can then be used directly in a gas turbine (GT), effectively replacing the compression stage of the GT. This is really a hybrid between a storage plant and a conventional prime mover plant as primary fuel is required. A CAES plant can be built on a similar scale to pumped hydro. Commercial plants are in operation in the US and Germany. Flywheel energy storage plant, Stephentown, USA courtesy of Beacon Power, LLC Electrochemical Batteries - there are a number of battery technologies, some commercially available and others in various stages of development. The best known technology is of course leadacid. This is certainly a proven technology but has never gained acceptance for utility-scale applications. Newer battery technologies include: Nickel-based batteries - nickel cadmium and nickel metal hydride (NiMH) batteries are commercially available; the latter being used particularly in portable electronic devices and power tools. They are also used in electric vehicle (EV) applications. Electricity Storage A Briefing provided by The Institution of Engineering and Technology © The IET 2012 www.theiet.org/factfiles 5 Lithium-ion (Li-ion) - currently used in small portable electronic devices because of their very high energy density. One company is pursuing this technology for large scale energy storage systems. Metal-air - in this system metal is actually ‘consumed’ to produce electricity. A number of companies are developing variations of this technology but again, utility scale application is not a near-term prospect. Sodium sulphur - a high temperature device (300 degrees Celsius) employing liquid sodium and sulphur separated by a ceramic electrolyte. This technology is commercially available from NGK, Japan and many installations are now in service. Multi-MW storage plants have been built, mainly in Japan, but a fire at an installation in 2011 has raised concerns about its safety. then be used as a primary fuel if required. Alternatively, it can be converted back to electricity by combining it with oxygen in a conventional fuel cell. Flow Batteries - flow batteries offer a development of conventional batteries. Whereas in a conventional battery the electrolyte is contained within the battery, in a flow battery the electrolytes flow through the battery and can be stored in separate vessels. The advantages of this system include: the ability to specify the energy storage capacity independently from the power output of the device; significantly reduced self-discharge, as most of the electrolyte is stored away from the ‘active’ part of the device. The basic arrangement of a flow battery is shown in Figure 1. Electrolyte tank Ion-selective membrane Electrode - Electrolyte tank + Regenerative fuel cell Electrolyte Electrolyte Pump Vandium-Redux Flow battery, USA courtesy of Prudent Energy 5. Are some storage technologies better than others? As discussed above, there are a number of storage technologies competing to be deployed in electricity supply systems. They all have different characteristics and could potentially meet different needs in the operation of the system. These different needs are essentially time-related. So, for example, storage could be used to help balance the system on a second-by-second basis, over a daily cycle or even between seasons. These are very different applications and would require very different technologies. As a general rule, short term applications (i.e. second-bysecond balancing) require high power outputs and longer term applications require high energy capacities. In Table 1, the key performance characteristics of a number of technologies are provided. They include the expected power rating, storage time and efficiency. It is important to understand that no storage technology is 100% efficient, so you will always get less energy out than you have put in. Pump Power source/load Figure 1: Schematic overview of a Redox-Flow-Battery courtesy of ISEA, RWTH Aachen University (original image) There are several competing flow battery technologies currently under development. They all employ the same basic arrangement but use different chemical ‘couples’. Regenerative hydrogen fuel cells This is a fundamentally more complex approach to storage compared with the other systems described here. Electricity is used to electrolyse water into hydrogen and oxygen. The hydrogen is stored in pressurised tanks. The hydrogen can In order to fully address the asset utilisation issue explained earlier it would be necessary to store energy between seasons. This is not expected to be commercially viable in the foreseeable future, though long term storage of heat is possible under some circumstances - see section 9. 6. How can storage help electricity networks? Storage can also help address the challenge of using networks more efficiently. In fact, the closer storage is located to consumers the greater its value. This is because it can potentially increase the utilisation of all the assets ‘above’ it in the supply chain (i.e. network and generation assets). It could be argued that ideally all consumers should own a storage device so that the demand presented to the system is less uneven and thus requires less system capacity. It is possible Electricity Storage A Briefing provided by The Institution of Engineering and Technology © The IET 2012 www.theiet.org/factfiles 6 Table 1 Comparison of Storage Technologies (All data sourced from “Pathways for energy storage in the UK” - Centre for Low Carbon Futures) Technology Indicative rated capacity (MW) Nominal duration1 Cycle efficiency (%)2 Maturity Likely scale of application Pumped hydro 100 - 5000 1 - 24+ hrs 70 - 87 Mature & Commercial Large Grid Compressed air energy storage 50 - 300 1 - 24+ hrs 70 - 89 Commercial Large Grid Cryogen-based energy storage 10 - 200 1 - 24+ hrs 40 - 90+ Early Commercial Grid/EV3/ Commercial UPS4 Flywheel 0.4 - 20 1 - 15 mins 80 - 95 Demo/Early Commercial Small Grid/House/ EV Hydrogen storage and fuel cell 0 - 50 seconds - 24+ hrs 20 - 85 Demo Grid/House/EV/ Commercial UPS Battery (Flow) 0.03 - 3 seconds - 10 hrs 65 - 85 Research/Early Demo Grid/House/EV/ Commercial UPS Battery (Lithium) 1 - 100 0.15 - 1 hr 75 - 90 Demo Grid/House/EV/ Commercial UPS Battery (Metal-air) 0.01 - 50 seconds - 5 hrs ~75 Research/Early Demo Grid/House/EV/ Commercial UPS Battery (Sodium sulphur) 0.05 - 34 seconds - 8 hrs 75 - 90 Commercial Grid/House/EV/ Commercial UPS Battery (Nickel) up to 40 seconds - hrs 60 - 90 Early Commercial Grid/House/EV/ Commercial UPS Battery (Lead-acid) up to 40 seconds - 10 hrs 63 - 90 Mature & Commercial Grid/House/EV/ Commercial UPS Superconducting Magnetic Energy Storage 0.1 - 10 milliseconds seconds 90 - 97+ Early Commercial Small Grid/ Commercial UPS Supercapacitor 0 - 10 milliseconds - 1 hr <75 - 98 Early Demo Small Grid/House/ EV Mechanical Electro-mechanical Primary Table Notes: 1 The typical period that the technology can maintain its rated output from a fully charged state. 2 The proportion of the energy used to charge the device that can will be returned to the system. 3 EV = Electric vehicle 4 UPS = Uninterruptible Power Supply Electricity Storage A Briefing provided by The Institution of Engineering and Technology © The IET 2012 www.theiet.org/factfiles 7 that the storage capacity of electric vehicles at domestic premises could be used in this way. There is expected to be a tension here between small scale distributed storage, which offers the greatest system benefit, and larger scale storage plants which could benefit from economies of scale and simpler, more predictable control. While it is theoretically possible to co-ordinate the operation of thousands or millions of distributed resources, this has never been done in a power system context (with the exception of some load control schemes). As discussed in section 8, storage plants can also provide additional ancillary services, such as voltage control, that further assist the operation of networks. They can also potentially enhance the resilience of the system either locally or, if there is sufficient capacity, more widely. 7. Are there any structural barriers to the deployment of storage? This question is much discussed at present and has to be considered on a market-specific basis. In the UK, there are a number of small scale distribution network-connected storage projects, most of which have been undertaken using funds from the Innovation Funding Initiative (IFI) or Low Carbon Network Funds. However, it is argued that the commercial and regulatory structure of the electricity supply system (i.e. under the Third Energy Packageii) does make it more difficult to promote storage projects. In particular, the disaggregation of the supply chain (i.e. compared to a fully vertically integrated structure) makes it more difficult for the owner of a storage plant to be properly rewarded for all the services that the plant provides. DECC and Ofgem are now actively considering the commercial and regulatory issues impacting on storage. It is also notable that, at present, storage developers do not have access to the subsidies that renewable generators do. It is important to understand that the most effective storage deployment strategies need to consider the operation of the system as a whole. It is valid to argue that this is more difficult to achieve in a disaggregated market. However, if this is recognised, market mechanisms can be developed to address this. 8. What other benefits can storage plants deliver? This does depend on the specific characteristics of the technology involved. However, a number of storage technologies are connected to the system with equipment that can also help control the voltage at different parts of the system. In theory these devices can connect to the system at any voltage and so a domestic solar panel can have one in the same way that a large store connected to the high voltage transmission system could. Voltage control can be very beneficial and can attract ancillary service payments from the system operator. Storage could also help improve continuity of supply, for example in microgrids, when generation shortfalls occur. (The term “microgrid” is used here to mean a local grid that has sufficient generation to meet its own needs that may or may not be connected to the main grid system.) 9. What role can heat storage play in the operation of the system? Thermal storage is much less costly than electricity storage. It can also operate over long timescales and is very efficient. However, unlike electricity or chemical storage which can easily be used to produce heat, the process cannot be reversed without high costs and inefficiencies. Hence the primary benefit of thermal storage comes from time shifting electricity demand for heat to avoid peaks and higher prices by consuming at periods of lower demand and lower electricity prices. The primary role that heat storage can play in the operation of the electricity system is to provide demand that can be supplied at times that benefit the operation of the system, such as when surplus renewable electricity is available. Thermal storage can be considered at a local (or distributed) level and at a network level. Local Heat Storage Essentially there are two categories hot water; storage heating. Hot water storage in the UK is substantial, circa 14 m households each with 100 litre hot water cylinders. However, this is declining due to the increase in combination boilers being installed. Electric storage heating is mainly restricted to flats (due to safety concerns with gas in such buildings) and represents circa 7% of the building stock. Both hot water and storage heating present a significant opportunity for demand side management. Network Heat Storage Large scale thermal storage can be used to support heat networks to meet peak demands and as back-up or for planned and unplanned plant outages. Generally they are designed for short term storage (hours/days) although longer term or seasonal storage using underground reservoirs can also be used. Very substantial thermal storage systems can be constructed but they are constrained by the size of the heat load connected to the heat network. Hence the scope for such systems in the UK is very limited without a large increase in heat loads supplied by heat networks. In Denmark where 60% of space and water heating is supplied by heat networks, storage capacities of 70,000m3 have been constructed (comparable to an average gasometer) which Electricity Storage A Briefing provided by The Institution of Engineering and Technology © The IET 2012 www.theiet.org/factfiles 8 can store nearly 4 GWhth of heat energy with an output of 600MWth. Such systems are heated by conventional CHP plants or conventional gas boilers. However, Denmark plans to increase electric heating using very large heat pumps thereby developing a substantial demand side management opportunity. End notes 10.Conclusion i http://www.electricitystorage.org/about/welcome ii http://ec.europa.eu/energy/node/50 iii http://www.ofgem.gov.uk/Networks/ElecDist/lcnf/Pages/lcnf.aspx So, in conclusion, the growth of storage technologies could be very significant provided that they: become economically competitive with alternative solutions; can be located without undue constraints; can offer a wide range of power and energy ratings; are environmentally acceptable. It is recognised that achieving the first of these ‘success criteria’ may only be achieved with support of some kind to acknowledge that new technologies typically follow a ‘learning curve’ that leads to lower unit prices as volumes increase. A number of demonstration projects are being pursued internationally. In the UK, Ofgem’s Low Carbon Networks Fundiii has resulted in a number of network storage trials being funded. It is also likely that the development of storage for transport applications could result in technologies that are deployable on power systems. There will be international sales potential for cost-effective storage technologies and their associated control and management systems. 11.Additional reading Four recent reports are recommended as additional reading: ‘Energy Storage Systems in the UK Low Carbon Energy Future: Strategic Assessment’, Carbon Trust http://www.carbontrust.com/resources/reports/technology/ energy-storage-systems-strategic-assessment-role-andvalue ‘The Future Role of Energy Storage in the UK’, The Energy Research Partnership http://www.energyresearchpartnership.org.uk/tiki-index. php?page=page12 ‘Pathways for Energy Storage in the UK’, Leeds University Centre for Low Carbon Futures http://www.electricitystorage.co.uk/ Electricity System: assessment of future challenges, DECC, August 2012 https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/electricitysystem-assessment-of-future-challenges Electricity Storage A Briefing provided by The Institution of Engineering and Technology © The IET 2012 www.theiet.org/factfiles 9 The Institution of Engineering & Technology Michael Faraday House Six Hills Way Stevenage SG1 2AY 01438 765690 - Policy Department email: [email protected] http://www.theiet.org/policy http://www.theiet.org/factfiles This content can contribute towards your Continuing Professional Development (CPD) as part of the IET’s CPD Monitoring Scheme. http://www.theiet.org/cpd © The IET 2012 The Institution of Engineering and Technology is registered as a Charity in England & Wales (no 211014) and Scotland (no SC038698).
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz