!rans&or(ational -earning and 1ritical Re&lection
1o(piled b6 7eter 8ol&
!rans&or(ational -earning
"#$%&'(#)$*+(%$, ,-$#%+%. /#-0+/+*$*-& 1--/ $%1 ,$&*+%. /-#&(%$, 02$%.-3 $%1 ('*-% +%4(,4-& $ /$#$1+.)
&2+'* +% /-#0-/*+(% (' &-,' +% *2- 5(#,16
!"# %"&' ()*+',")-*./"+ 0112)3
7-#&/-0*+4- *#$%&'(#)$*+(% +%4(,4-& $ &-89-%0- (' ,-$#%+%. $0*+4+*+-& *2$* :-.+%& 5+*2 $ !"#$%"&'("')
!"+&,,- $%1 0(%0,91-& 5+*2 $ 02$%.-1 &-,';0(%0-/* *2$* -%$:,-& $ #-+%*-.#$*+(% +%*( (%-<& ,+'- 0(%*-=* (%
*2- :$&+& (' 0(%1+*+(%& 1+0*$*-1 :> $ %-5 /-#&/-0*+4-6 ?@-A+#(53 BCCDE6
"#$%&'(#)$*+(%$, ,-$#%+%. $& 1-&0#+:-1 :> F#$%*(% ?BCCGE (009#& *2#(9.2 0#+*+0$, #-',-0*+(% $%1 -%$:,-&
+%1+4+19$,& *( #-4+&- $%1 1-4-,(/ %-5 $&&9)/*+(%& $%1 5$>& (' &--+%. *2- 5(#,16
1ritical Re&lection
F#+*+0$, #-',-0*+(% +& *2- /#(0-&& (' 0#-$*+%. (# 0,$#+'>+%. *2- )-$%+%. (' -=/-#+-%0- ?/#-&-%* $%1 /$&*E +%
*-#)& (' &-,' ?&-,' +% #-,$*+(% *( &-,' $%1 &-,' +% #-,$*+(% *( *2- 5(#,1E6 ?H(>1 I J$,-&3 BCDKE
4.5' 677 68"2. 9+1":&)/+; 6''2-<./"+'
MN%- 5$> *( *2+%O $:(9* $&&9)/*+(%& +& *2$* *2-> $#- *2- *$O-%;'(#;.#$%*-1 :-,+-'& 5- 2$4- $:(9*
#-$,+*>6 P%(*2-# +& *( &-- $&&9)/*+(%& $& *2- ?('*-% 9%$0O%(5,-1.-1E #9,-& (' *29): *2$* .9+1- (9#
$0*+(%&6 P *2+#1 5$> +& *( &-- $&&9)/*+(%& $& *2- 0())(% &-%&- :-,+-'& $%1 0(%4-%*+(%$, 5+&1()& *2$*
5- +%4(O- 52-% $&O-13 M52> 1+1 >(9 &( *2+&QR MS2> 1( >(9 *2+%O *2$*QR T' (9# #-/,> *( *2-&- 89-&*+(%& +&
&()-*2+%. ,+O- MS-,,3 +*<& 0())(% &-%&- *2$*UR ?H#((O'+-,13 BCCLE6
9ene&its o& 1ritical Re&lection
! '#$)- $%1 #-'#$)- *2- /#(:,-) (# 02$,,-%.- $009#$*-,>3 &+%0- 0()/,-= +&&9-& $#- &-,1() 52$* *2->
'+#&* &--)
! +1-%*+'>3 0,$#+'>3 $%1 *-&* (%-<& /-#&(%$, +%&+.2*& $%1 V*2-(#+-&< $:(9* *2- /#(:,-) (# 02$,,-%.! 0(%*+%9$,,> ,-$#% 2(5 *( ,-$#%3 :(*2 +%1+4+19$,,> $%1 52-% %$*9#$,,> +%*-#$0*+%. 5+*2 (*2-#& +% .#(9/&
$%1 *-$)&
! +%0#-$&- *#$%&'-# (' ,-$#%+%. '#() *2- 0,$&& *( *2- V#-$, 5(#,1<
-e:els o& Re&lection:
<= F#+*+0$, W-',-0*+(%X *$O-& $00(9%* (' *2- &(0+(;/(,+*+0$, 0(%*-=* +% 52+02 -4-%*& *$O- /,$0- $%1
1-0+&+(%& $#- )$1- ?#(,-&3 #-,$*+(%&2+/&3 #-&/(%&+:+,+*+-&3 .-%1-#3 -*2%+0+*>3 -*06E
<<= Y+$,(.+0 W-',-0*+(%X 1+&0(9#&- 5+*2 (%-&-,'3 )9,,+%. (4-# #-$&(%& $%1 -=/,(#+%. $,*-#%$*+4-& ?T
5(%1-#UQ @$>:-UQE
<<<= Y-&0#+/*+4- W-',-0*+(%X /#(4+1-& #-$&(%& ?('*-% :$&-1 (% /-#&(%$, Z91.-)-%*E3 $,*2(9.2 (%,> +% $
#-/(#*+4- 5$> ?T 1+1 . :-0$9&- /E
<>= Y-&0#+/*+4-X )-#-,> #-/(#*+%. -4-%*& 5+*2 %( $**-)/* *( /#(4+1- #-$&(%& ?T 1+1 .[ 2- &$+1 /E ?\$**(% I
])+*23 BCC^E
(=)&& (><&' ", ?)/./1*7 @&,7&1./"+
AB F(%*-%* #-',-0*+(% _ #-',-0*+(% (% 52$* 5- /-#0-+4-3 *2+%O3 '--, (# $0* 9/(%
CB 7#(0-&& #-',-0*+(% _ 0(%0-#%-1 5+*2 *2- )$%%-# (# )-*2(1 +% 52+02 5- *2+%O
DB 7#-)+&- #-',-0*+(% _ 2+.2-# ,-4-,6 T%4(,4-& 9& :-0()+%. $5$#- (' 52> 5- /-#0-+4-3 *2+%O3 '--, (# $0*
$& 5- 1(6 ?@-A+#(53 BCCDE
!echni@ues &or Bostering 1ritical Re&lection
! /#+4$*- #-',-0*+(%
! Z(9#%$,&
! /(#*'(,+(& ?1(&&+-#&3 &*$*-)-%*& (' /2+,(&(/2>E
! )-%*(#`/--# #-,$*+(%&2+/&
! /--#`/--# #-,$*+(%&2+/&
! 0(%'-#-%0-&3 &-)+%$#&3 -*06
! .#(9/ 1+&09&&+(%&
Re&lecti:e Approaches
0$1% #(-)& %&2+&3("$' 4%$3&##5
T6
P#*+09,$*+(% (' $ /#(:,-) (# 02$,,-%.TT6
P%$,>&+& (' *2- /#(:,-) (# 02$,,-%.]-4-% 7#($0*+4- W-',-0*+4- a9-&*+(%&X
! S2$* 2$//-%-1Q ?S2$* 1+1 >(9 &--3 52$* 5-#- >(9 '--,+%.3 52$* 5$& *2- )(&* +)/(#*$%*
*2+%.QE
! S2$* +& *2- '9%1$)-%*$, ,+O-%-&& (' *2+& /#(:,-) (# 02$,,-%.- *( (*2-#&Q
! S2$* +& *2- '9%1$)-%*$, 1+''-#-%0-Q
! S2> 5$& *2$* &+.%+'+0$%* *( >(9Q
! S2> 1( >(9 *2+%O +* 2$//-%-1Q
! \(5 0$% >(9 1( +* 1+''-#-%*,> %-=* *+)- '(# 1+''-#-%* #-&9,*&Q
! \(5 0$% >(9 9&- *2+& +%'(#)$*+(%Q ?S2$* 0(%0-/*& $%1 /#+%0+/,-& 5+,, .9+1- >(9 '9*9#$//#($02QE
TTT6
"-%*$*+4- *2-(#> *( -=/,$+% *2- /#(:,-) (# 02$,,-%.Tb6
P0*+(% *( :- *$O-% +% *2- '9*9#T% b-,,$<& 1+&09&&+(% (' 6%-."# ?$0*+(% 5+*2 #-',-0*+(%E3 &2- &9..-&*& '(9# (/-%;-%1-1 89-&*+(%& )(4*2#(9.2 *2-&- &*-/&X
B6 S2$* 1( >(9 &-- 2$//-%+%. 2-#-Q ?Y-&0#+/*+(%E
L6 S2> 1( >(9 *2+%O +* +& 2$//-%+%.Q ?P%$,>&+&E
K6 S2-% +* 2$//-%& +% >(9# &+*9$*+(%3 52$* /#(:,-)& 1(-& +* 0$9&-Q ?P//,+0$*+(%E
G6 S2$* 0$% 5- 1( $:(9* +*Q ?T)/,-)-%*$*+(%E
7&#3%"4("$' $2 8.4&%"&'3&5
!
Y-&0#+:- *2- V2-#- $%1 %(5< -=/-#+-%0!
S2$* -&&-%*+$, '$0*(#& 0(%*#+:9*-1 *( *2+& -=/-#+-%0-Q
!
S2$* $#- *2- &+.%+'+0$%* :$0O.#(9%1 '$0*(#& *( *2+& -=/-#+-%0-Q
!
S2$* $#- *2- O-> /#(0-&&-& ?'(# #-',-0*+(%E +% *2+& -=/-#+-%0-Q
W-',-0*+(%X
!
S2$* 5$& T *#>+%. *( $02+-4-Q
!
S2> 1+1 T +%*-#4-%- $& T 1+1Q
!
S2$* 5-#- *2- 0(%&-89-%0-& '(# )> $0*+(% '(# )>&-,'Q N*2-#&Q
!
\(5 1+1 T '--, $:(9* *2+& -=/-#+-%0- 52-% +* 5$& 2$//-%+%.Q
!
\(5 1+1 (*2-#& '--,Q
!
\(5 1( T O%(5 2(5 (*2-#& '-,*Q
T%',9-%0+%. J$0*(#&X
!
S2$* +%*-#%$, '$0*(#& +%',9-%0-1 )> 1-0+&+(% )$O+%.Q
!
S2$* -=*-#%$, '$0*(#& +%',9-%0-1 )> 1-0+&+(% )$O+%.Q
!
S2$* &(9#0-& (' O%(5,-1.- 1+1`&2(9,1 2$4- +%',9-%0-1 )> 1-0+&+(% )$O+%.Q
P,*-#%$*+4- P0*+(%&X
!
S2$* (*2-# 02(+0-& 1+1 T 2$4-Q
!
S2$* )+.2* *2- 0(%&-89-%0-& :- (' *2-&- 02(+0-&Q
c-$#%+%.X
!
\(5 1( T '$9 '--, $:(9* *2+& -=/-#+-%0-Q
!
\(5 2$4- T )$1- &-%&- (' *2+& -=/-#+-%0- +% *2- ,+.2* (' /$&* -=/-#+-%0-& $%1 '9*9#- /#$0*+0-Q
!
\(5 2$& *2+& -=/-#+-%0- 02$%.-1 )> 5$>& (' O%(5+%.Q
9ibliograph6
H(>13 d6 @63 I J$,-&3 P6 S6 ?BCDKE6 W-',-0*+4- ,-$#%+%.X e-> *( ,-$#%+%. '#() -=/-#+-%0-6 :$1%'-+ $2
;1,-'"#("3 6#/3<$+$)/= >?@AL3 CC;BB^6
H#((O'+-,13 ]6 Y6 ?BCCLE6 f%0(4-#+%. P&&9)/*+(%&X "2- O-> *( #-',-0*+4- /#$0*+0-6 B!1+( C&-%'"')= @?GE3 BK;
BD6
F#$%*(%3 76 ?BCCgE6 6%$2&##"$'-+ 7&D&+$4,&'( -# (%-'#2$%,-("D& +&-%'"')E ]$% J#$%0+&0(X h(&&->;H$&&6
Y$91-,+%3 @6S63 I \$,,3 Y6 "6 ?BCCiE6 f&+%. #-',-0*+(% *( ,-4-#$.- ,-$#%+%.6 F%-"'"') -'! !&D&+$4,&'(6
GH?LE3 BK;BG6
\$**(%3 j6 I ])+*23 Y6 ?BCC^E6 W-',-0*+(% +% *-$02-# -190$*+(%X *(5$#1& 1-'+%+*+(% $%1 +)/,-)-%*$*+(%6
F&-3<"') I F&-3<&% 8!13-("$'>HHAB3 KK;GC6
h(2%&3 F6 ?BCCGE6 k9+1-1 #-',-0*+(%6 T% P6 7$,)-#3 ]6 H9#%&3 F6 H9,)$% ?d1&6E J&2+&3("D& 4%-3("3& "'
'1%#"')E N='(#1X H,$0O5-,, ]0+-%*+'+06
@->-#3 ]6 ?BCCLE6 F9,*+4$*+%. #-',-0*+(%;+%;$0*+(% +% *#$+%-# 1-4-,(/)-%*6 B!1+( C&-%'"')E >@AG3 Bg;KB6
@-A+#(53 h6 ?BCCDE6 N% 0#+*+0$, #-',-0*+(%6 B!1+( 8!13-("$' K1-%(&%+/= >LMAK3 BD^;BCi6
@((%3 h6 ?BCCCE6 C&-%'"') N$1%'-+#5 - <-'!O$$P 2$% -3-!&,"3#= #(1!&'(# -'! 4%$2&##"$'-+ !&D&+$4,&'(E
c(%1(%X e(.$% 7$.-6
N<j-+,3 h6 I @$#&+0O3 b6 h6 ?BCCGE6 H-0()+%. 0#+*+0$,,> #-',-0*+4- *2#(9.2 $0*+(% #-',-0*+(% ,-$#%+%.6 F<&
&,&%)"') 4$9&% $2 -3("$' "'Q1"%/ (&3<'$+$)"&#E ?//6 Bi;KlE6 j-5 Y+#-0*+(%& '(# P19,* $%1 F(%*+%9+%.
d190$*+(%3 j(6 gK6 ]$% J#$%0+&0(X h(&&->;H$&&6
]02m%6 Y6 ?BCDiE6 d190$*+%. *2- #-',-0*+4- /#$0*+*+(%-#6 T% $ &/--02 *( *2- B,&%"3-' 8!13-("$'-+ J&#&-%3<
B##$3"-("$'6 S$&2+%.*(%3 YF6 W-*#+-4-1 h$%9$#> LB3 LllL '#()
2**/X``20+6&*%'(#16-19`(*2-#`]02m%Di62*),
b-,,$3 h6 ?BCCGE6 C&-%'"') ($ +"#(&' +&-%'"') ($ (&-3<6 ]$% J#$%0+&0(3 FPX h(&&->;H$&&6