立法會
Legislative Council
Ref : CB2/HS/2/14
LC Paper No. CB(2)2167/14-15
(These minutes have been seen
by the Administration)
Subcommittee on Proposals on
the Method for Selecting the Chief Executive in 2017
Minutes of the fourth meeting
held on Saturday, 16 May 2015, at 9:00 am
in Conference Room 1 of the Legislative Council Complex
Members
present
:
Hon TAM Yiu-chung, GBS, JP (Chairman)
Hon Paul TSE Wai-chun, JP (Deputy Chairman)
Hon Albert HO Chun-yan
Hon LEE Cheuk-yan
Hon CHAN Kam-lam, SBS, JP
Hon LEUNG Yiu-chung
Hon Emily LAU Wai-hing, JP
Hon Frederick FUNG Kin-kee, SBS, JP
Hon WONG Kwok-hing, BBS, MH
Prof Hon Joseph LEE Kok-long, SBS, JP, PhD, RN
Hon Jeffrey LAM Kin-fung, GBS, JP
Hon WONG Ting-kwong, SBS, JP
Hon Cyd HO Sau-lan, JP
Hon Starry LEE Wai-king, JP
Hon CHAN Hak-kan, JP
Hon CHAN Kin-por, BBS, JP
Dr Hon Priscilla LEUNG Mei-fun, SBS, JP
Hon WONG Kwok-kin, SBS
Hon IP Kwok-him, GBS, JP
Hon Alan LEONG Kah-kit, SC
Hon WONG Yuk-man
Hon Claudia MO
Hon Michael TIEN Puk-sun, BBS, JP
Hon James TIEN Pei-chun, GBS, JP
Hon NG Leung-sing, SBS, JP
Hon Steven HO Chun-yin
Hon Frankie YICK Chi-ming
Hon YIU Si-wing
Hon Gary FAN Kwok-wai
-
2
-
Hon MA Fung-kwok, SBS, JP
Hon Charles Peter MOK, JP
Hon CHAN Chi-chuen
Hon CHAN Han-pan, JP
Dr Hon Kenneth CHAN Ka-lok
Hon LEUNG Che-cheung, BBS, MH, JP
Hon Dennis KWOK
Hon Christopher CHEUNG Wah-fung, SBS, JP
Hon SIN Chung-kai, SBS, JP
Hon IP Kin-yuen
Hon Martin LIAO Cheung-kong, SBS, JP
Hon TANG Ka-piu, JP
Dr Hon CHIANG Lai-wan, JP
Hon CHUNG Kwok-pan
Hon Tony TSE Wai-chuen, BBS
Members
absent
:
Public Officers :
attending
Hon James TO Kun-sun
Dr Hon LAU Wong-fat, GBM, GBS, JP
Hon Abraham SHEK Lai-him, GBS, JP
Hon Ronny TONG Ka-wah, SC
Dr Hon LAM Tai-fai, SBS, JP
Hon Mrs Regina IP LAU Suk-yee, GBS, JP
Hon Albert CHAN Wai-yip
Hon WU Chi-wai, MH
Hon CHAN Yuen-han, SBS, JP
Hon Alice MAK Mei-kuen, JP
Dr Hon KWOK Ka-ki
Hon KWOK Wai-keung
Dr Hon Fernando CHEUNG Chiu-hung
Dr Hon Helena WONG Pik-wan
Dr Hon Elizabeth QUAT, JP
Hon Christopher CHUNG Shu-kun, BBS, MH, JP
Sessions One and Two
Mr LAU Kong-wah
Under Secretary for Constitutional and Mainland Affairs
Mr Freely CHENG Kei
Principal Assistant Secretary for Constitutional and
Mainland Affairs
-
3
-
Session Three
Mr LAU Kong-wah
Under Secretary for Constitutional and Mainland Affairs
Miss Anna LEUNG Wing-sum
Assistant Secretary for Constitutional and Mainland Affairs
Attendance by :
Invitation
Session One
Federation of Hong Kong Industries
Mr Stanley LAU
Chairman
Mr KWOK Chung-man
Mr NGAN Man-yu
Member of Kwun Tong District Council
Love China Hong Kong Alliance of Youth Cultural Societies
Miss Jenny CHAN
Founding Vice Chairman
Mr Alex WONG
Neo Democrats
Mr LAI Ming-chak
Community Officer
Friends of Tseung Kwan O
Mr LAI Wai-tong
Member
Chinese Academy of Governance (Hong Kong) Industrial
and Commercial Professionals Alumni Association Ltd
Mr LEE Yiu-sun
Chairman
-
4
-
Mr CHUNG Fong-chin
Mr Andy TSUI
Hong Kong Young Industrialists Council
Mr Eric YIM Chi-ming
The Association of Experts for Modernization
Ms Elizabeth TSE
Director
Mr Dominic LEE Sai-cheong
Hong Kong Specialist Care Foundation Ltd
Dr Benjamin LAU Shun-tung
Convenor
Mr KONG Kwok-ping
Mr CHAN Shui-on
Mr LEUNG Ka-wai
Mr WAI Tak-lun
Mr CHENG Cho-kwong
Member of Sha Tin District Council
Young Civics
Mr Joshua LI Chun-hei
Vice Chairman
Mr CHEUNG Fun-nin
Mr Tommy TAM Kwong-shun
Mr YEUNG Tung
The Association of Chinese Culture of HK
Miss Sylvia LAM
Chief Executive Officer
-
5
-
Mr NG Su-san
Citizens Radio
Mr MAK Kwok-fung
Mr FANG Wei-qi
Mr CHAN Wing-hong
Mr TSUI King-sing
Mr WONG Chin-hang
Miss CHAN Wing-ki
HK Human Rights Monitor
Mr LAW Yuk-kai
Director
Mr FUNG Tak-lee
Hong Kong Christian Institute
Mr FAN Lap-hin
Vice Director
Hong Kong Youth Development Society
Mr CHAN Chi-hing
Chairman
Mr TING Kong-ho
The Association of Zhuangzi Culture & Research of Hong
Kong
Mr CHONG Wai-cheung
President
Mr TONG Hok-leung
-
6
-
Mr Edwin YEUNG Chi-wai
Session Two
Mr CHUNG Chak-fai
Mr Felix SO Man-yuk
Miss Cynthia KWOK
The Overseas Indonesia Chinese of Guangxi United Reliance
Club Association (HK)
Mr WAI Man
President
Wing Lung Art
Mr FU Lou-yeung
President
New People's Party
Mr KAM Man-fung
Central Committee Member
Mr CHENG Chit-pun
Mr CHEUNG Sze-ngao
Mr YIP Ka-ming
Mr Alan LUNG Ka-lun
Hong Kong Starfire Network Association
Mr CHAN Kuen-hong
Vice Chairman
Mr CHAN Chung-kit
Mr FONG Sung-yau
-
7
-
The Chinese General Chamber of Commerce
Mr LAU Kar-wah
Committee Member
Wanchai and Central & Western District Industries and
Commerce Association
Mr Alan CHOW Kin-san
Vice-Chairman
Federation of
Organisations
Hong
Kong
Mr TSE Long
Mr LIN Kwong-sing
Mr WONG Kam-pui
Mr LAM Chun
Mr LEE Fung-lin
Mr HA Tak-kin
Miss LI Miu-fun
Mr WONG King
Mr Augustus LEE Kai-bun
Mr HOR Wing-kit
Mr Fanko WAN Cho-keung
Mr LAM Sik-wai
Miss TSE Hiu-hung
Mr WONG Choi-lap
Guangdong
Community
-
8
-
Mr LAM Sik-kin
Youngspiration
Mr CHOW Sai-kit
Session Three
Democratic Alliance for the Betterment and Progress of
Hong Kong
Mr LAI Jee-shing
Deputy Spokesperson (Constitutional Affairs)
Hong Kong Book & Stationery Industry Association Co Ltd
Mr WONG Kwong-ming
Secretary
The Federation of Hong Kong Trade Unions in Tourism
Mr LAM Chi-ting
Chief Executive Officer
Hong Kong All Youth Alliance
Ms Phoebe WONG
President
Miss TAM Wai-man
Mr POON Kwok-ching
Hong Kong Banking Employees Association
Mr TAM Kin-sun
Spokesman
Mr FU Ka-ho
Mr CHAN Kwok-hing
Mr Sammy IP
-
9
-
Miss Johannie TONG
Mr CHAN Kin-chun
Mr CHAN Tsz-kin
Partido Liberal Democats Hong Kong
Mr LEUNG Hoi-fu
Mr YUEN Ming-yeung
Miss HO Ka-yau
Mr MAK Tsun-kit
Miss CHO Wing-yin
Favorite Universal Suffrage and Civil Nomination Kai Fong
Association
Mr CHUNG Lai-him
Convener
Miss YIP Ka-yu
Mr Oscar LO
Mr CHAN Hiu-yeung
大專政關
Mr David CHU
Spokesperson
Mr CHENG Pui-lun
Mei Foo Home and Public Affairs
Miss LUK Wai-sum
Miss HON Kin-lam
-
10
-
Mr YEUNG Hiu-tung
Mr YU Chun-ning
Miss WU Sin-yan
Hong Kong Commerce and Industry Associations
Mr LO Kam-yam
Chairman of the Executive Committee
Mr Dennis TONG Tak-kit
Mr SHUM Tai-fung
Mr Victor CHAN
Mr LAU Yat-lung
We Care Resources Center
Mr KAM Hock-nin
Mr HUNG Pui-man
Mr Andrew FAN
Mr Dave HO
Mr William CHU
Ms Vincenza CHAN
Mr Johnny NG
Clerk in
attendance
:
Ms Joanne MAK
Chief Council Secretary (2) 3
Staff in
attendance
:
Miss Flora TAI
Assistant Secretary General 2
Mr Kelvin LEE
Assistant Legal Adviser 1
-
11
-
Miss Cindy HO
Senior Council Secretary (2) 3
Mrs Fonny TSANG
Legislative Assistant (2) 3
Action
I.
Meeting with deputations and the Administration
[Consultation Report and Proposals on the Method for Selecting the Chief
Executive by Universal Suffrage]
1.
The Subcommittee deliberated (index of proceedings attached at Annex).
2.
The Subcommittee received views from 111 deputations/individuals
attending the meeting, and noted that 13 written submissions had been received
from other organizations/individuals which/who did not attend the meeting.
3.
The Chairman reminded members that the next meeting would be held on
23 May 2015 at 9:00 am to continue to receive views from deputations on the
Administration's proposals on the method for selecting the Chief Executive by
universal suffrage.
II.
Any other business
4.
There being no other business, the meeting ended at 4:10 pm.
Council Business Division 2
Legislative Council Secretariat
30 September 2015
Annex
Proceedings of the fourth meeting of the
Subcommittee on Proposals on
the Method for Selecting the Chief Executive in 2017
on Saturday, 16 May 2015, at 9:00 am
in Conference Room 1 of the Legislative Council Complex
Time Marker
000805 - 001309
Speaker(s)
Chairman
Subject(s)
Action
required
Opening remarks
Meeting with deputations to receive views on the
Administration's proposals on the method for
selecting the Chief Executive ("CE") by universal
suffrage ("the Proposals").
Session One
001310 - 001630
Federation of Hong Kong Presentation of views
Industries
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1567/14-15(01)]
001631 - 001924
Mr KWOK Chung-man
Presentation of views
001925 - 002146
Mr NGAN Man-yu
Presentation of views
002147 - 002450
Love China Hong Kong Presentation of views
Alliance
of
Youth [LC Paper Nos. CB(2)1471/14-15(01)
Cultural Societies
CB(2)1666/14-15(01)]
002451 - 002652
Mr Alex WONG
Presentation of views
002653 - 002945
Neo Democrats
Presentation of views
002946 - 003252
Friends of Tseung Kwan O
Presentation of views
003253 - 003559
Chinese Academy
of Presentation of views
Governance
(Hong [LC Paper No. CB(2)1567/14-15(02)]
Kong) Industrial and
Commercial Professionals
Alumni Association Ltd
003600 - 003907
Mr CHUNG Fong-chin
Presentation of views
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1567/14-15(03)]
003908 - 004042
Mr Andy TSUI
Presentation of views
004043 - 004345
Hong
Kong
Young Presentation of views
Industrialists Council
004346 - 004614
The Association of Experts Presentation of views
for Modernization
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1471/14-15(02)]
and
Time Marker
Speaker(s)
2
Subject(s)
004615 - 004916
Mr
Dominic
Sai-cheong
LEE Presentation of views
004917 - 005225
Hong Kong Specialist Presentation of views
Care Foundation Ltd
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1471/14-15(03)]
005226 - 005458
Mr KONG Kwok-ping
Presentation of views
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1471/14-15(04)]
005459 - 005700
Mr CHAN Shui-on
Presentation of views
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1471/14-15(05)]
005701 - 005939
Mr LEUNG Ka-wai
Presentation of views
005940 - 010056
Mr WAI Tak-lun
Presentation of views
010057 - 010404
Mr CHENG Cho-kwong
Presentation of views
010405 - 010650
Young Civics
Presentation of views
010651 - 010954
Mr CHEUNG Fun-nin
Presentation of views
010955 - 011227
Mr
Tommy
Kwong-shun
011228 - 011403
Mr YEUNG Tung
011404 - 011651
The
Association
of Presentation of views
Chinese Culture of HK
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1499/14-15(01)]
011652 - 011958
Mr NG Su-san
Presentation of views
011959 - 012306
Citizens Radio
Presentation of views
012307 - 012556
Mr FANG Wei-qi
Presentation of views
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1499/14-15(02)]
012557 - 012834
Mr CHAN Wing-hong
Presentation of views
012835 - 013137
Mr TSUI King-sing
Presentation of views
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1471/14-15(07)]
013138 - 013305
Mr WONG Chin-hang
Presentation of views
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1471/14-15(08)]
013306 - 013430
Miss CHAN Wing-ki
Presentation of views
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1471/14-15(09)]
TAM Presentation of views
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1567/14-15(04)]
Presentation of views
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1471/14-15(06)]
Action
required
-
3
-
Time Marker
Speaker(s)
Subject(s)
013431 - 013746
HK Human Rights Monitor
Presentation of views
013747 - 014058
Mr FUNG Tak-lee
Presentation of views
014059 - 014408
Hong Kong
Institute
014409 - 014711
Hong
Kong
Youth Presentation of views
Development Society
014712 - 015019
Mr TING Kong-ho
015020 - 015330
The
Association
of Presentation of views
Zhuangzi Culture & [LC Paper No. CB(2)1499/14-15(03)]
Research of Hong Kong
015331 - 015556
Mr TONG Hok-leung
015557 - 015847
Mr
Edwin
Chi-wai
015848 - 020132
Chairman
Administration
Mr LEE Cheuk-yan
Mr CHAN Chi-chuen
The Under Secretary for Constitutional and
Mainland Affairs ("USCMA") thanked the
deputations for their views and comments. He
emphasized that for constitutional development to
move forward, it was necessary to seek common
ground, set aside the differences in view and
strive for consensus. The work of the Hong
Kong Special Administrative Region Government
was to formulate, in strict accordance with the
law, a package of proposals for selecting CE by
universal suffrage that was constitutionally and
legally in order, fair and reasonable, and at the
same time take heed of factors including political
reality and actual operation to strive for universal
suffrage through "one person, one vote" in 2017
as scheduled.
020624 - 020920
Chairman
Opening remarks
020921 - 021045
Mr CHUNG Chak-fai
Presentation of views
021046 - 021244
Mr Felix SO Man-yuk
Presentation of views
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1471/14-15(14)]
021245 - 021304
Miss Cynthia KWOK
Presentation of views
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1499/14-15(06)]
Christian Presentation of views
Presentation of views
Presentation of views
YEUNG Presentation of views
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1471/14-15(11)]
Session Two
Action
required
Time Marker
Speaker(s)
4
Subject(s)
021305 - 021502
The Overseas Indonesia Presentation of views
Chinese of Guangxi [LC Paper No. CB(2)1499/14-15(04)]
United Reliance Club
Association (HK)
021503 - 021704
Wing Lung Art
Presentation of views
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1567/14-15(12)]
021705 - 021956
New People's Party
Presentation of views
021957 - 022305
Mr CHENG Chit-pun
Presentation of views
022306 - 022529
Mr CHEUNG Sze-ngao
Presentation of views
022530 - 022717
Mr YIP Ka-ming
Presentation of views
022718 - 023005
Mr Alan LUNG Ka-lun
Presentation of views
[LC Paper Nos. CB(2)1471/14-15(17)
CB(2)1567/14-15(05)]
023006 - 023305
Hong
Kong
Starfire Presentation of views
Network Association
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1471/14-15(18)]
023306 - 023615
Mr CHAN Chung-kit
Presentation of views
023616 - 023921
Mr FONG Sung-yau
Presentation of views
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1567/14-15(06)]
023922 - 024228
The Chinese General Presentation of views
Chamber of Commerce
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1499/14-15(05)]
024229 - 024533
Wanchai and Central & Presentation of views
Western
District [LC Paper No. CB(2)1471/14-15(19)]
Industries
and
Commerce Association
024534 - 024835
Federation of Hong Kong Presentation of views
Guangdong Community
Organisations
024836 - 024922
Mr LIN Kwong-sing
Presentation of views
024923 - 025019
Mr WONG Kam-pui
Presentation of views
025020 - 025332
Mr LAM Chun
Presentation of views
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1471/14-15(15)]
025333 - 025559
Mr LEE Fung-lin
Presentation of views
Action
required
and
Time Marker
Speaker(s)
5
Subject(s)
025600 - 025655
Mr HA Tak-kin
Presentation of views
025656 - 025759
Miss LI Miu-fun
Presentation of views
025800 - 030052
Mr WONG King
Presentation of views
030053 - 030409
Mr Augustus LEE Kai-bun
Presentation of views
030410 - 030717
Mr HOR Wing-kit
Presentation of views
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1499/14-15(07)]
030718 - 031030
Mr
Fanko
Cho-keung
031031 - 031258
Mr LAM Sik-wai
Presentation of views
031259 - 031557
Miss TSE Hiu-hung
Presentation of views
031558 - 031845
Mr WONG Choi-lap
Presentation of views
031846 - 032140
Mr LAM Sik-kin
Presentation of views
032141 - 032511
Youngspiration
Presentation of views
032512 - 032937
Chairman
Mr CHAN Kam-lam
Mr CHAN Kam-lam considered that the specific
method for selecting CE by universal suffrage
should not be tailor-made for individuals or
individual political parties.
032938 - 033528
Chairman
Administration
In response to deputations' concern about the
future refinement to the method for selecting CE,
USCMA said that after achieving universal
suffrage, should there be a need to amend the
method for selecting CE after 2017, Article 7 of
Annex I to BL and the "Five-step Process" of
constitutional development had already provided
a clear legal basis for initiating such further
amendments to the method for selecting CE.
He emphasized that the Proposals could respond
to the strong aspiration of the different sectors of
the society to implement universal suffrage for
the selection of the CE as scheduled, and to allow
Hong Kong’s constitutional development to move
forward.
033529 - 034234
Chairman
Mr WONG King
Mr HOR Wing-kit
Mr Charles Peter MOK
Youngspiration
Discussion on the need to conduct a referendum
to gauge public views on the Proposals.
WAN Presentation of views
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1567/14-15(07)]
Mr Charles Peter MOK queried the
Administration's claim that there was mainstream
support in the community for the Proposals.
Action
required
Time Marker
034235 - 035114
6
-
Speaker(s)
Chairman
Dr Priscilla LEUNG
Mr CHAN Kam-lam
Subject(s)
Dr Priscilla LEUNG considered that there were
merits in forming the nominating committee
("NC") by following the same framework of the
four sectors of the Election Committee in order to
strike a balance among the interests of all sectors
and ensure the preservation of the capitalist
system in Hong Kong.
Mr CHAN Kam-lam emphasized that the
discussion had to be based on the legal
framework constituted by BL and the Decision of
the Standing Committee of the National People's
Congress ("NPCSC") on 31 August 2014 ("2014
Decision of NPCSC").
035115 - 035545
Chairman
Mr Augustus LEE Kai-bun
Mr LAM Sik-kin
Mr WONG King
Mr FONG Sung-yau
Discussion on whether the Proposals should be
supported and endorsed by the Legislative
Council ("LegCo").
035546 - 040358
Chairman
Youngspiration
Mr Charles Peter MOK
Mr CHAN Kam-lam
Mr Jeffrey LAM
Administration
Mr Charles Peter MOK stressed that the
Government should respond to Hong Kong
people's demand for genuine universal suffrage.
Mr Jeffrey LAM considered that debating over
whether the Proposals would allow Hong Kong
people to have genuine or fake universal suffrage
was meaningless. He agreed that the method for
selecting CE by universal suffrage should strictly
comply with the Basic Law and the relevant
Decisions of NPCSC. He believed that after CE
was selected by universal suffrage through "one
person, one vote" in 2017, the electoral method
could be refined in future.
In response to concern of some deputations,
USCMA
explained
the
constitutional
responsibility of NPCSC under the "Five-step
Process" of constitutional development.
Lunch Break
Session Three
050232 - 050554
Chairman
Opening remarks
050555 - 050837
Democratic Alliance for Presentation of views
the
Betterment
and
Progress of Hong Kong
Action
required
Time Marker
Speaker(s)
7
Subject(s)
050838 - 051145
Hong Kong Book & Presentation of views
Stationery
Industry [LC Paper No. CB(2)1499/14-15(08)]
Association Co Ltd
051146 - 051438
The Federation of Hong Presentation of views
Kong Trade Unions in [LC Paper No. CB(2)1499/14-15(09)]
Tourism
051439 - 051745
Hong Kong All Youth Presentation of views
Alliance
051746 - 052050
Miss TAM Wai-man
Presentation of views
052051 - 052333
Mr POON Kwok-ching
Presentation of views
052334 - 052621
Hong
Kong
Banking Presentation of views
Employees Association
052622 - 052924
Mr FU Ka-ho
Presentation of views
052925 - 053150
Mr CHAN Kwok-hing
Presentation of views
053151 - 053508
Mr Sammy IP
Presentation of views
053509 - 053813
Miss Johannie TONG
Presentation of views
053814 - 054001
Mr CHAN Kin-chun
Presentation of views
054002 - 054308
Mr CHAN Tsz-kin
Presentation of views
054309 - 054612
Partido Liberal Democats Presentation of views
Hong Kong
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1567/14-15(08)]
054613 - 054716
Mr YUEN Ming-yeung
Presentation of views
054717 - 054929
Miss HO Ka-yau
Presentation of views
054930 - 055257
Mr MAK Tsun-kit
Presentation of views
055258 - 055525
Miss CHO Wing-yin
Presentation of views
055526 - 055828
Favourite
Universal Presentation of views
Suffrage
and
Civil
Nomination Kai Fong
Association
055829 - 060058
Miss YIP Ka-yu
Presentation of views
060059 - 060333
Mr Oscar LO
Presentation of views
Action
required
Time Marker
060334 - 060531
Speaker(s)
Mr CHAN Hiu-yeung
8
Subject(s)
Presentation of views
The Chairman ruled that Mr CHAN Hiu-yeung
behaved disorderly and ordered him to withdraw
immediately from the meeting in accordance with
Rule 87 of the Rules of Procedure.
060532 - 060935
大專政關
Presentation of views
060936 - 061258
Mr CHENG Pui-lun
Presentation of views
061259 - 061530
Mei Foo Home and Public Presentation of views
Affairs
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1567/14-15(09)]
061531 - 061823
Miss HON Kin-lam
Presentation of views
061824 - 062137
Mr YEUNG Hiu-tung
Presentation of views
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1499/14-15(10)]
062138 - 062441
Mr YU Chun-ning
Presentation of views
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1499/14-15(11)]
062442 - 062748
Miss WU Sin-yan
Presentation of views
062749 - 063057
Hong Kong Commerce Presentation of views
and
Industry [LC Paper No. CB(2)1471/14-15(21)]
Associations
063058 - 063223
Mr Dennis TONG Tak-kit
Presentation of views
[LC Paper No. CB(2)1471/14-15(22)]
063224 - 063525
Mr SHUM Tai-fung
Presentation of views
063526 - 063823
Mr Victor CHAN
Presentation of views
063824 - 064101
Mr LAU Yat-lung
Presentation of views
064102 - 064358
We Care Resources Center
Presentation of views
064359 - 064458
Mr HUNG Pui-man
Presentation of views
064459 - 064545
Mr Andrew FAN
Presentation of views
064546 - 064638
Mr Dave HO
Presentation of views
064639 - 064843
Mr William CHU
Presentation of views
064844 - 065144
Ms Vincenza CHAN
Presentation of views
Action
required
Time Marker
Speaker(s)
9
Subject(s)
065145 - 065330
Mr Johnny NG
Presentation of views
065331 - 065637
Chairman
Ms Starry LEE
Ms Starry LEE pointed out that if the
constitutional reform proposal was voted down
by LegCo, the method of selecting CE in 2012
would continue to apply according to the 2014
Decision of NPCSC, and forming LegCo by
universal suffrage would be deferred.
065638 - 065941
Chairman
Ms Cyd HO
Ms
Cyd
HO
considered
that
the
"first-past-the-post' voting system might not
ensure that the CE-elect would have sufficient
legitimacy in the community as the candidate
who obtained the highest number of votes might,
in fact, have obtained only a small number of
valid votes. She said that she would vote
against the Proposals which were formulated
under the restrictive framework of the 2014
Decision of NPCSC.
065942 - 070254
Chairman
Mr Paul TSE
Discussion on meeting arrangements
070255 - 070600
Chairman
Mr Steven HO
In response to some deputations' concerns,
Mr Steven HO explained that the 1 200 members
of NC would be returned through direct or
indirect elections.
He considered that
constitutional development was a gradual,
evolving process.
070601 - 071134
Chairman
Administration
In response to deputations' views, USCMA called
on all Members to support the Proposals, so as to
meet the aspiration of the community for electing
the next CE through "one person, one vote" in
2017, thereby taking an important step forward in
the constitutional development of Hong Kong.
Council Business Division 2
Legislative Council Secretariat
30 September 2015
Action
required