A review of the literature
regarding fictional film and television
portrayals of mental illness
Jane Pirkis1, R Warwick Blood2, Catherine Francis1 and Kerry McCallum2
1. Program Evaluation Unit, School of Population Health, The University of Melbourne
2. School of Professional Communication, The University of Canberra
April 2005
Table of contents
2
2
2
3
!
" #
$%
&' "
(&
)
4
# *
*
4
+ ,
4
-
4
*
" #
%
" (.
/
5
!
!
5
!
" #
0%1 "
& 3 33&
"
&2
&
&. &
(& 3 2 3
&.
(2 #(
3 (2
3
(& # ('
4
5
6
+
7
" #
)%
"
. &
"
#(
33&
&2
(& 3 2 3
&.
3
"
"
2 3 22
4
3 (2
(& # ('
&
3
&
$0
13
+
15
" #
/%
33&
&2
"
#(
"
. &
"
#(
(& 3 2 3
&.
3
22
4
+
3 (2
(& # ('
&
3
&
$6
17
18
" #
5%.
(&
7
20
88
!
!
20
21
2
22
!
2
&
0
Executive summary
Background
!
"
!
#
"
!
Method
$
%
"
&
'
(
)
%
%
Key findings
What is the extent and nature of portrayal of mental illness in fictional films and television
programs?
&
&
*
.
+
,
-
/
*
0
+
1
( %
2
)3
4
*
+
Is there evidence that portrayal of mental illness in fictional films and television programs
can have harmful effects?
%
%
$
*
,
+5
5
)
%
Is there evidence that portrayal of mental illness in fictional films and television programs
can have positive effects?
6
$
,
%
%
Conclusions
6
1
"
%
7
%
%
8
#
Chapter 1: Setting the context
Background
"
$
%
:
%
%
,
# 9
,
;
Purpose and scope of the review
%
,
"
,
*
+
Research questions
!
"
!
#
"
!
Structure of the current report
3
3
# 9
;
3
1%
<
% ,
,
9
Chapter 2: Method
Search strategy
$
*3
/
(
/
&
$
/
3
@
(
$(=) $
(
$
3
+
)
&
(
(
&
3
$
(
+ )>$3:
*3
+?
(
(@3 *
*7
$
$
&
+
A
BB; (
"
"
•
•
/)8 ('7)(' 7 */)8 ('7)(' 7 &@:/: ":8 /)8 ('7)(' 7
)?C3( ":8 /)8 ('7)(' 7 '" )@(3D+ /)8 ('"''8)$$*/)8 ('
?"$:@?)@E &$D37"( @E ?)&@)$$":8 $37"F:&7@)8"( (8G") D
/::? ?"$:@?)@E :>$)$$"6),3:/&C'$"6) ?"$:@?)@E )( "8=
?"$:@?)@E (8:@)G"( >C'"/"(+5
/)?"( */)?"( )')6"$E "'/E /:6")E &'(DE+
&
"
"$"
$
3
"
Critical analysis of the literature
(
2
.
8
%
%
;
Chapter 3: What is the extent and nature of portrayal of
mental illness in fictional films and television programs?
8
?
,
,
,
(
2
Sources and strength of evidence
Small-scale descriptive studies, anecdotal reports and commentaries
,
<,
H
$
"
%
*
-
-
+ 7
%
Larger-scale descriptive studies
*
+
%
,
*
+ "
$
&
#B
#<
#
/
#
@ %
##
=
#9 #;
=
,
*
*
BBB,B +
#I
)3 +
#J
*
>
+ / ?
=,
&=,
?
+ "
*
,
$
>
(
*
9
?
9#,9;
C$
H<H, HJ;
,
@
9 9
8
CK
% $
9<
* 3
CK #H 9B+ :
BBB
F
I
HH;,H<+ $
*
,
C$
,
%
1
%,
9I
8
F
+
<
:
%
,
.
7
#
%
*
<
+
(
=
#9 #;
=
"
(
9
#
Key findings
Portrayal of people with mental illness
/
,
"
"
3
>
@
"
#H 9B
CK
J
9J
5
9L
99 9;
C$ ?
L
%
,
5
@
9H
,
5/
;B
;B
5
9<
%
;
3
#
%
9I
$
,
1
*
JBL
" 8
+
F
%
;
9H
*9L+
#9
1
'%
?
H#I
BBB, BB
'
BB
;#
J;L
L
>
%
:
6
0
1
,
I J 9 9J ;9
10
10
& 10 % 10
0 M 10
2
10
% 1
10
0
% % 12
I
#I 9I ;;
9I
J
7
•
,
8
*
+
%
#H,9 99 9; 9J 9H ; ;;,;I
,
J
7
0
1
;<
!" &
>
%
#
$
1
%
•
$
1
,
*
+,
%
!- . /0
+ )
&$
% #
-
%
$ #
' ( )'*
&&
1
%1
%
0
J H #J ;J
1
•
2 3 45
,
""
(
J
•
C
(
.
$ 2
$
J
%
•
,
*
•
,
"1
,
J
M
" #$ /
0 M 1
%
%
J
%
J
M
7
1
1
%
J # 9 ;
%
$
%
+
*
%
.
#I 9 99,9< ;H
(
%
K
%
B
/
99 9;
(
$
M
4 *
-!
(
M
4 $6
*
+
(
< I
7 7 3
, # # <B
0
#
+'*
7
<B <
7
I
$
A
?
8
;J
7
<
>
8
7#
4
9
?
$
7
>
H
>
/
@
;
(
=
< I
0 % 1
Portrayal of mental health professionals
3
2
2
1#9 #;
=
%
,
?
%
1
$
9BB
B*HL+
=
%
BI C$
,
,
(
%
J H #9 #;
H
B #B
$
,
•
? ?
2
. &&+
/
(
3
(
$
HB< :
$ $
$ !
6. / 48
" 5
,
.
%
? ?
35
)
.
# 0, )
!
(
J B, # #B 9# < ,<<
•
? )
2
:
,
4.
0
? )
3
*
+ '
•
7
$ 2
# 9#
%
,3/
.
$
' ( )'*
%!
&0 $
!-1 J
+,
B
?
%-
#B 9# ;9 < <9
*
.
+
%
*
9
1
% 7 )
%
+
? ?
(
?
/
(
+
?
(
*
1
<
$
1 ? /
%
&
*/
$
?
+
%
;
, )/
.
?
"
(
4 *
-!1 J
B
1 B #B
$
&
#B 9# ;9 < <9
%
:
&
&
6
F
%*%
K
1 B #B ? ?
$
? )
?
+ $
0
1
.
*
+
*
$
8
<I
1 B #B
<
2
*
? ?
? ?
*
?
? )
? ) +
,
1<
+
$
$
*
+
2
? ?
1
1 B #B
+
'%
,
B
*
? ) +
*
,
:
*
<
/
?
I
N
#;
=
1<
+ (
#<
,&
$ %J+
? $
? $
,
:
=
,
$
1
#9 #;
=
0
1
6
=
2
H#B
0
? ?
#9 #;
=
H9B
1
?
H;B
? )
H<B
#<
,&
,
(
=
#9
=
<#
$
0
1
+ ?
*
0
4.
3
9#
?
?
,
? ?
,
? )
? ?
? $
0
)
1
?
%
%
,
=
'$
*
&
"
#B
2 6, *
/ $9
=
; $< 5
3
:
!1 )
H
=
0
1
(
+
9#
?
&
,
; $
!!
Portrayal of treatments for mental illness
$
2
'%
,
>
"
=
#9 #;
=
9BB
8
,
*
+
%
>
,
/ ?
*)3 +
;9
)3
)3
5
,
5
*
+5
M
5
,
)3
,
M
+ "
,
5
%
=
7#
*A
4
8
$
=
8 1
)3
"
,
%#
$8
"
7#
4
$
1H 9;
Chapter 4: Is there evidence that portrayal of mental illness
in fictional films and television programs can have harmful
effects?
%
,
5
,
,
5
,
,
%
Sources and strength of evidence
Small-scale descriptive studies, anecdotal reports and commentaries
(
; J H
,
# ;
H #; 9< <J
<H
.
%
Larger-scale descriptive studies involving cross-sectional surveys and focus groups
$
,
,
,
%
%
IB
8
8
C$
1IB
M
'
C$
I
M
I I#
=
M
%
" *3(/"+
/
7
*6/7&+
/
%
:
(
3
/
(
*:/"+
"
I9
C$ 3
)3
/
6
(%
6
" >
1
($
I;
'
%
I<
&
$
&
%
%
7
,
#
#
%
,
"
*
,
+
Larger-scale experimental studies
$
,
(
%
3(/" $
,+
,*
$
II
=
,(
* CK
+
0
%
,
% 1
CK
%
1
:
,
IJ
,
(
%
:
+,
CK
'=
!-
#*
%
)3 (
% '$
"*
5 $
5 0
&
' ( )'*
)3 +
%
%
(
)3
$
IH
$
*
,
,
"
:
,
' %
*
MJB
,
C$
,
$ ># :
%
-
+
$
+
'
&
!% *
3(/"
,
?
46
,
J
' ( )'*
+,
!?
J
C$
(
)
9
$
,
3
7
#
$
# BBB
,(
1II
=
,
Key findings
Perpetuation of stigma associated with mental illness
8
; J # ;
9< <J
IB
8
%
*
,
+5
5
I ,I<
I#
=
%
%
2
'
MI =
I
,
I;
'
I;
'
M
4
0
/0
(
#
7
1&
1I<
&
!
$
)
)3
3
I9
1
@
J
?
' ( )'*
$ ># :
&
+,
46
!'%
-
JB
'
%
$
'
!%
;
/
1
)3
1IJ
)3
;BL
,
,
$
(
=
,
II
Impacts on help-seeking behaviour by people with mental illness
(
,
%
; J H # H #; 9< <H
%
=
#;
&
)3
' ( )'*
+,
!$
>
4 $6
M
2 ;, 9
M
,
%
$
IH
1
*
"
$
$
%
<
Chapter 5: Is there evidence that portrayal of mental illness
in fictional films and television programs can have positive
effects?
-
0
1
* 3
9+
%
,
,
,
%
Sources and strength of evidence
Small-scale descriptive studies, anecdotal reports and commentaries
(
,
,
"
H J ,JH
-
H <I HB,H
# H#,H<
,
#
%
,
8
Larger-scale descriptive studies involving cross-sectional surveys
,
2
,
C$2
%
HI
/ 7
K
HJ
,
$
Larger-scale evaluative studies
$
,
,
HH, B<
7
I
Key findings
Promoting mental health literacy in the community
(
$
?
9
3
CK H# HH
'% /
8
# < $ #
?
'% /
$* CK
+ B;
BB
8
/
B#
F
7
B
3
B
:
+ B9
* C$
,
CK
B<
1
(
6
%
H9
H;
Educating trainee mental health professionals
(
,
J J; JI JJ BI
@
"6, @
J9
%:
4
$
8
1J9
@
%
1JH
J# J<
*
?$/,
JH
@
+
*
@
%
> *
3
JH
%
#+
H
=
,
Encouraging help-seeking behaviour in people with mental illness
/ 7
HI
K
HJ
,
:
/ 7
%
1HI
:
K
%
*
,
1HJ
%
%+
J
Providing an adjunct to conventional therapy for people with mental illness
$
*
-
+
*
+
%
H <I HB H
7
6
:
HB
) (/
$
+
3>? 3 &
% 7
*
&
,
(
?
/
$
)
&
H
%
H
0
1
%
%
"
H
"
%
H
&
0
H HB
7
1
%
H
H
Chapter 6: Discussion
Summary of findings
&
*
-
+
.
*
+
0
,
/
1
( %
2
)3
4
*
+
%
%
$
*
,
+5
5
)
%
6
$
,
%
%
Methodological issues
(
,
,
B
.
7
,
*
+
%
%
%
0
1
*
+ 3
%
BJ BH
%
,
%
( 3
B
0
O P
%
QO 0
1
Future directions
%
%
*
,
%
+
*
,
+
%
R
*
<B
+
"
$
* 0
3
1
+
B
=
B
3
0
1
%
%
%
%
; J <B
@
$
;
, 9
>
M
(
B
M
(
%
:
%
,
%
-
Conclusions
6
1
"
%
7
%
%
8
References
A
#
9
;
<
I
J
H
B
#
9
;
<
I
J
H
B
#
9
;
<
( /
&
%
#
8
4
1 BBB5 II #H<,9B
C$?
7
7
$
5
>7 : & 4
3
;
1@ %
/? C$?
7
7
$
5 HHH
3 & % A?
? >
@
5
$6
$ >7 : * ) 4
13
3
?
7
(
3 5 BB
)
?@
$ $
6 >7
: * )1
3
/
7
(
5 BB9
: /
'&
18
BB 5 9*<+ ;#B,
;#
& &
7
1 A BB 5 B*+ IJ
$ )/ /
8
4
5
1 A BB#5 *#+ ;H, <H
7
$) =
=: $
" 7
$
M
5 &
$ //
1
HH 59 *B+ B99, B9J
? 8
@/
8
4
31 BB#5;H*+ BI, ;
5 ) $@
1 H9<5 ;9, ;J
=
7@ ' ,
?$/,"6
* 1 BB#5;9*<+ JBI,JBJ
>
& $ M
/ /
"
#
1
BBB5 9 #<9,#<;
@
(
= &
$
/
?
(
8 F
$ 8
47
1
HHI5 <I <9B,<99
'?
K 0 7 $
.
1/
$ M
/
(
5 BB9
(
/ S
:
S/
8
4
$
5
,
31 BB#5 B*#+ HI,#B<
@
(
=
'
$
7
$
, )A
$8
4
1 BBB5#9*+ #I, 99
@
(
=
7
$, )A
$8
4
1 BBB5#9*;+ JI;
=
7@ &
'
%8
4 & (/
$ * 1 HH 5 B*+ H, ;
=
7@ "
* 1 BB#5;9*J+ <<
$
"
7/
8
4
1
HJI5 99*J+ HH<, BB
& @&
6
K
F
%8
4 $ # * 1 BB 5
=
/A &
(
/ 1
HHJ5 ;*#+
A% " /
'&
18
BB 5 9*<+ ;# ,;#
=
&
@
#
8
4
&1 HH95
9 , 9;
=
7@ (
:
7/
8
4
1?
BBB5<B*9+ # H,##H
&
5 ) $@
1 H9I5
J,
#
I
J
H
#B
#
#
##
#9
#;
#<
#I
#J
#H
9B
9
9
9#
99
9;
9<
9I
9J
9H
;B
;
N
33
7
(/
$ 1 HH<5
;, J
$ %$ 7
! 7/
3 7
1 HHJ5
H
/
&( )
(
8
45 /
3 $
$. * &/ 1 ?
HHH5#J*+ IB,IH
$
" "
&
7/
8
4
1 HII5 #9 < #,< H
:
$
$ > 0 6/ 3 4
6
8 >
% 8A @
C
& 5 HH;
/ /
@ 6/ 3 4 $ >
46
(
(/ 3
8A (
C
& 5 HJ;
@ % 'D
$
>7 7
$6
(/3& 4
5
4
* $ *
4/ #3 3
'
/?
$
&
" 5 HHJ
=
=: =
K
$
/
?3 (
&
&
" 5 HHH
=
= &
7
7
1?
BB 5H*9+ #<;,#<H
,&
>A 7 $ 4
4
5
4
( / 4/
3
3
( M C
5 BB
:
( F
& ?
%( /
>/
S
8
4 //
31 8
BB#5# *<+ ;;#,;<B
>
( "
?
#
1
HH<5 B< J,< B
3
@/ >
& 3
)@S
%
<
8
4 $ 1
BBB5 I#*#+ ;<, ;I
3
@/ >
&
%
%
#
$ 8
1
BBB5# B*I 99+ J , J<
38
@3
A&
( 3
(
7
$, ) A
$8
4
1 HHH5##*+ 9B, 9I
38
@3
A&
( /
,
"
7
$, )A
$8
4
1
HHH5##*+ # , #H
?
?' >
8A $
M('
5
4
7 $3
/B />
7
&
7
1(
C
8
3
(
5 HHJ
?
?'
4:
>
4
6
$C
/
*
$
8D ?
/ 3
$
C
5 HH;
?
?'
,
8
4
//
31 HHI5 ;*#+ JH,#B
$
8
8
4# $
3 $
$ 1 HJH5##*#+ # ;,##
38
@3
A&
( 7
S
#
8
4
1 BBB5 I< 99B,99#
@ ?
8
4 //
$7&& $
31 HHJ5J #, J
: @ @
@
8
4# $
31 HJ 5 < ;HH,<B;
/
& /
3 $ 1 HHJ5 #9
3
/> $% ? >
$: "
%
8
4 //
1
HIH5 H*9+ I#,JB
9
;
;#
;9
;;
;<
;I
;J
;H
<B
<
<
<#
<9
<;
<<
<I
<J
<H
IB
I
I
I#
I9
I;
: ?
S
8
4
5
1A
BB#5 *#+ 9H, ;J
'
(
= /
?
$ 8
4
:*
$
$
1 BB959H*;+ # B,# 9
/ ?
(
=
)3
(
8
4
1
BB 5 I*9+ <9, I9
=
>K
*
4
. 0$. *
/B /
D.
*
. / C
8 /
5 HIH
&
= / '
= 7
'/
" &
=
$ $
.
8 D %(
'
'
5 HH<
'&
( &
8
/
@
1 HJ;5< #J9,#J< 99H
7
$) ?$/,"""
/
/&
*
1
HJJ5 H H;, B<
=
= 3
" 7
)
'
? @
&
//
//
>
$
'
5 HH;
7
'$
/
" &
=
$
$
.
8 D %(
'
'
5 HH<
&
= C
" &
=
$ $
.
8 D %(
'
'
5 HH<
/
$(
7
S
?
S
!7
1
A BB95 *+ I<, IJ
$
" ?
!8
4 & (/ $ * 1
HHB5 J*+ #<,#H
3
(
7
#3 1
HH;5H; I, ;
% "?
,
31 HII5 9 <;,<J
=
(
H9 , HHB 7
$ * 1
HH 5J; <I, I
? >
/(
* $
6 >? 3( / ? $
$
&
3
>
/ = ,7 5 HHH
: /
(
8
4
//
31 HH 5 B#9#,#;
% A< / ( / $
>
3:
/
C
/
& 5 HH#
8
A
(
# *
1
H;I5
, #B
' M'@ (
S
(
7 * 4
,
31 HH 5;*;+ I , JB
=
?7 &
&$
8
4
5
31 BBB5 *+ < , I;
=
?7 &
&$ 3
( @
8
45 /
3 $
$. * &/ 1 ?
HHH5#J*+ HJ, B
3
A'
$
'/
%
)3
8
4
1 A BB 5 I*+ HH, B
'
38
3
'@
?
!
& 7 * 4
$
,
1
BB#5 ;#*;+ 9J, ;
;
I<
II
IJ
IH
JB
J
J
J#
J9
J;
J<
JI
JJ
JH
HB
H
H
H#
H9
H;
H<
HI
HJ
HH
BB
&
=
D %(
$
,(
" &
=
$ $
.
8
5 HH<
A=
>)
6
3 : & 1 HH95I9*+ <#, IJ
= / ?
( @ A/ @
( /
%
)3
)3
P
Q
8
4
1 BB 5 J*+ 9#,9<
$
7
A@
K 3
)
3 : & 1 HHB5<I #HH,9B
: ' %
AD "
7/
8
4 //
31 HJH5 I*9+ ; ,; J
?
= "
S
:
:
3 % S8 S
3 : & 1 HJ#5;# IH, J
>
?
#
18
BB#5 I* + 9 H,
9#B
M
@= )
/7 @ &
/
&
&
3
8
4
1(
BB95<;*J+ ;
@
?A :
> *
4
$
& 7
/
@
&
& 5 BB#
/ %A &
' ,' '
* 1 BB#5;9*J+ <;, <<
N
3@
/
7
$
, )A
$8
4
1?
BB95#J*<+ 9J
>
& 3
* >
C
+
#
18
BB#5 I* + 9# ,9#
:
3
* >
C
+
#
18
BB#5 I* + 9##
>/ @
)K /
,
$
1 BB95 H*+ #<,9B
7
A 7
A= :
) (/ $ E
3>? 3 &
*
& 8 D %A
$
" 5 HHJ
7
$) @
' S %
/
C
&
/
&
7/
8
4
&1 HHH5;#*+ #J, 9
> ,3
'A
& >
@3
&
*
1 HHB5J #;, ;<
3
( /
8
4
5
1 HH 5 ,
7
= 3
5
7
1
HH;5A
?
#I,9
7
??
8= >
6' (
6
5 &
$ //
1
HJ 5##*9+ #B9,#B;
(
'$ 7
K 3 ,
* 1 HHJ59H*<+ JBJ,J
/ 7
$7
$
7 * 4
,
31 BB 5 <*<+ <#, I9
K
D
%= K
7 )
$
,
1 HHH5;#*9+ ; #,; <
& % )$
(
( &
@= @ $ 7 ?
?
?
&
7/
8
4
1 HHI5 ;9*<
*$
++ ;H,<<
& % )$ 7 ? &
@= 3
?
?
#
8
4
1 HHJ5 I# ; H,;
'
'
<
B
B
6 $
B#
$
3
6
B9
BB95 *+ #, I
/
'>
@C
B;
B<
BI
BJ
BH
B
#
9
;
(
(A
5
6
%
= 7
3S
'%
8
/
:
/
$
8
5
%
7
3
HH & "
1 HH;5 B*#+ ;I, <<
7
3
HH & ""
$
:
1 HH;5 B*#+ <I, IJ
S( 8 F
7
1
8
47&& $
31 HHB5 B* *++ J<#, JIJ
> % 3&
8 $
?( ?
$$
" D
/
(
#
8
4
31 HH#5# J , H#
A5
$ 5
7 )*> 4
4 4
%E
5
3 // /& 31 '
"
>
(
@
?
5 HJH
/ 3
':
K( $
7
P
Q8
4
31
BB95<B*J+ J9 ,J;
=
@ //
35
$6
'
$ 5 BB
A'
?
*
76.
$: $
(
C
5 HHI
3
$6
/
*
$, )
$ 1 BB95;*#+ HI, <
=
$.
$: &
>6/ 3 46
4/ $
76. "
8D
3
C
& 5 HJJ
&
= 3
#
1
HHI5
I , I
7
'&
" &
=
3 : *$ 8 D %
(
'
'
5 HHH
$
/ &
#
1(
BB#5 I*9+ #, ;
@
( $
%
M
#
$ 8
1 HHI5# 9 ;9<
I