David Vrooman Antigone Unit Plan Week 1 Day 1 Day 2 Day 3 Day 4 Day 5 Context Intro & History Lesson/Dramatic Structure Summary of Theban Trilogy up to “Antigone” and Aristotle’s “Poetics” Initial Discussion of the Play Text Major Themes and Characters Differences in Translation Hemingway short story “HLWE” Homework: Homework: 1. Students will read pages 2324, 69-70, and 125 of The Theban Legend. Week 2 DoubleEntry Journals 2. Vocab list Homework: 3. 2 Qs and comments (2+3 are ongoing) Students will read Antigone, pages 126132 (up to the Sentry’s entrance). Day 6 Day 7 The Prophet The Tragedy Homework: Students will read pages 157162, and finish the play. Homework: Students will read pages 132142 (up to the Chorus). Day 8 Going Over Key Terms and Themes Homework: from the Play in 1 Students Preparation will write for the their introductory Exam paragraph Homework: as to who they think Review for the tragic Exam hero is and why. Homework: Students will read pages 142152 (up to Teiresias’s entrance). Students will read pages 152-157 (up to “Enter Messenger”). Day 9 Day 10 More Review and Essay Assignment Exam Homework: Prepare for Exam Homework: Students should continue working on their papers. Overarching Essential Questions: 1. How do the themes in mythologies from the past still apply today? Essential Unit Questions: 1. How does human and divine law function in Antigone, and how does it relate to your life? 2. What is a tragedy in the Classical/Aristotelian sense, and how do we define tragedy today? 3. Who is/are the tragic figure(s) in Antigone and why? STATE STANDARDS (CONNECTICUT COMMON CORE OF TEACHING): I. Composing, Responding, and Interpreting English language arts teachers use their knowledge of the ways people build understandings through reading and writing, speaking and listening, viewing and acting, when they design instruction, interpret student performance and evaluate their teaching to help students reach understandings. II. Writing English language arts teachers help students consider the many elements which influence a writing process – among them the writer’s purpose and audience, models in the genre, and conventions of standard written English – and work through the steps, which are part of a complex composing process. III. Reading Literature English language arts teachers help students respond to a variety of texts, ideas, perspectives and styles as they study literature and expand their knowledge of themselves and the world. IV. Reading for Information English language arts teachers help students develop, recognize, and expand their reading strategies and adjust them to suit the purpose, task, and text. V. Language Study English language arts teachers help students understand the nature of language, apply the conventions of standard English language in oral and written communications, and adapt their use of language to meet the needs of different situations. VI. Materials for Instruction English language arts teachers select and create materials based on instructional purpose, literary merit, impact of the medium, parameters of the curriculum, and students’ developmental needs. VII. Knowledge of Students English language arts teachers use their knowledge of the development, backgrounds, interests, and abilities, which influence students’ thinking, learning, and use of language to make decisions. VIII. Teaching Strategies English language arts teachers use a variety of teaching strategies to guide students in developing literacy, critical thinking, and problem‐solving abilities. IX. Curriculum English language arts teachers help students develop concepts and skills that make them better able to respond, interpret, and compose with increasing degrees of control and responsibility for their own learning. X. Environment English language arts teachers maintain environments that provide students with opportunities to work together to build understandings as they provide experiences with language similar to those they may encounter outside the classroom. Note: Standards are noted next to each objective (I‐X). Daily Schedule: Day 1: Context Intro, History, & Dramatic Structure/Elements of Greek Tragedy Lesson Note: Each objective will correlate to one of the six Facets of Understanding listed in parentheses. Daily Objectives: 1. Students will be able to explain why an understanding of context is important when reading (III). 2. Students will be able to identify Sophocles and explain why he was writing plays (III). 3. Students will be able to differentiate that though Antigone is chronologically last in a cycle of three plays, Sophocles wrote it first (I). 4. Students will be able to discuss the dilemmas associated with Sophocles having written the sequence of plays out of order (I). 5. Students will be able to discuss the dramatic structure so they can later relate it to the play text (I, VIII, IX). Activities: 1. (Perspective) Introductory activity focusing on the importance of context. 2. (Perspective) PowerPoint presentation of Classical Greek society and play festivals. 3. (Perspective) Discussion will be held about the plays Oedipus Rex and Oedipus at Colonus, and their relation to Antigone, and why this relationship is significant. Summary: Class will begin with an activity demonstrating the importance of context and how without it a person can easily be confused. This will flow into a history lesson about Classical Greece in the time of the playwright Sophocles and the festivals he competed in. The class will then be informed about how plays were often written in trilogies and that though Antigone is last in the trilogy, it was written first, and that there are anachronisms in the trilogy because of this. This will lead to a lesson on dramatic structure and elements of Greek tragedy, which will be part of the framework of comprehending the play text. Resources: 1. Laptop for PowerPoint presentation 2. Copies of The Theban Legend for the students to be passed out. 3. Index cards for context activity with names of obscurely famous people written on them. 4. Dramatic Structure and Greek vocabulary Inspiration handouts. Homework: 1. Students will read pages 23‐24, 69‐70, and 125 of The Theban Legend. 2. Students will list all, if any, unfamiliar words from the reading in their vocabulary list in their journals. 3. Each student will write down two questions from the reading Day 2: Summary of Theban Trilogy up to “Antigone,” Aristotle’s “Poetics,” and Double Entry Journals Lesson Daily Objectives: 1. Students will be able to define and discuss key terms from Aristotle’s Poetics, including, but not limited to, tragedy, hubris, hamartia, and catharsis (I, IV). 2. Students will contrast the Classical idea of tragedy with how the word is used in contemporary times (I, V, X). 3. Students will demonstrate they have done their homework by explaining the events preceding Antigone in a group/teacher‐directed discussion (I, VIII). 4. Students will be able to describe a double‐entry journal and will apply their knowledge by keeping them while doing their homework readings (VI, VIII). Activities: 1. (Explanation) There will be a question and answer session about the reading where students will be able to demonstrate they have interpreted the text and try to predict what they think might happen. 2. (Interpretation) Next students will try to collectively illustrate the events preceding Antigone together in a discussion. 3. (Explanation) Aristotle and the Poetics will be discussed and students will begin to derive meaning about what he is trying to convey by use of key terms and their relation to the text. 4 (Application) Students will go through the process of the double‐entry journal to familiarize them with a during reading study technique. Summary: Any questions about the text will be addressed and then students will work in groups and try to piece as many of the events preceding Antigone together by memory. The class will then regroup to talk about Aristotle’s Poetics and the key terms from it. Homework: 1. Students will read Antigone, pages 126‐132 (up to the Sentry’s entrance). 2. Students will list all, if any, unfamiliar words from the reading in their vocabulary list in their journals (double‐entry style now) along with the terms from Aristotle’s Poetics. Day 3: Initial Discussion of the Play Text Daily Objectives: 1. Students will be able to ask any questions they have about the reading (I). 2. Students will answer several non‐assessed questions including some questions that ask their opinion regarding the text in order for them to comprehend what is expected of them in reading assignments (I, II, III). 3. Students will judge what drives both Antigone and Ismene (I). Activities: 1. (Self‐Knowledge) There will be a chance for students to ask questions about the reading. 2. (Interpretation) Students will try to make sense of what they have read thus far through several short/paragraph‐length writing prompts. 3. (Perspective) Students will split in to pairs and analyze why Antigone acts one way and Ismene another. Summary: Class will start with a question and answer session about the reading assignment. Then students will be given a series of short answer questions that they will have to write responses to. After the writing prompt, students will pair up to discuss the differences between the sisters Antigone and Ismene, which they will already have written about for one of their questions. Homework: 1. Students will read pages 132‐ 142 (up to the Chorus). 2. Students will list all, if any, unfamiliar words from the reading in their vocabulary list in their journals along with the terms from Aristotle’s Poetics. 3. Students will write two questions they have and make two short comments about the reading. Day 4: Major Themes and Characters and Ernest Hemingway’s short story “Hills Like White Elephants.” Daily Objectives: 1. Students will make sense of why the Sentry is afraid of Creon and what Creon represents (I, III). 2. Students will propose ideas as to what ideas Antigone embodies, and ask whether these are qualities they should embody and why (I, VII). 3. Students will be able to distinguish the difference between human and divine law as it relates to Antigone as well as order versus civil disobedience as it relates to their lives (I, III, VII). 4. Students will read and discuss the short story “Hills Like White Elephants” and how a director might stage the story for a film to get students thinking about how Antigone might be staged (I, VII, VIII). Activities: 1. (Perspective) The class will circle up to talk about the differences between Creon and Antigone. 2. (Self‐Knowledge) Students will independently write about how they feel they relate to Creon and/or Antigone and why. 3. (Perspective) The class will be split in half for an activity that will help to shed light on the idea of human versus divine law, as well as the idea of order versus civil disobedience. 4. (Application) Students will read “Hills Like White Elephants” and will put on a production of the short story in class. Summary: Class will start with a discussion in the round as to the differences between Creon and Antigone. Each student will then write independently about how they feel they do or do not relate to Creon and/or Antigone. After the solo writing activity, the class will be split in half for an activity that will address the ideas of human versus divine law as well as order versus civil disobedience and how these themes relate to specific characters. From here, class will begin work on the short story and acting it out. Homework: 1. Students will read pages 142‐152 (up to Teiresias’s entrance). 2. Students will list all, if any, unfamiliar words from the reading in their vocabulary list in their journals along with the terms from Aristotle’s Poetics. 3. Students will write two questions they have and two short comments about the reading. Day 5: Differences in Translation Daily Objectives: 1. Students will be able to critique how a translator’s translation of a foreign text can impact the reader (V, VI). 2. Students will read two different translations of a passage from Antigone in order to compare the similarities and differences (I, VI). 3. Students will adapt a passage from the play so that it is different from how it was, but still resembles the passage (II, VI). 4. Students will demonstrate how a translator has choice when translating and what that entails (I, VIII). 5. Students will read between the lines of the argument between Creon and Haemon and try to predict what will happen (I, III). Activities: 1. (Perspective) There will be a direct instruction lecture about translating and choice. 2. (Perspective) Half the class will be given one translation of a speech from the play while the other half will be given a different translation. One student will read his/her translation out loud while the other students try to follow along reading their own. This activity will be repeated by a student with the other translation so that each student will get to see what happens from both perspectives. 3. (Application) Students will take a passage from the play and rewrite it so that it is different, but still can be inserted back into the play and work. 4. (Interpretation) Students will then make sense of the problems associated with translation based on the prior activity in a discussion. 5. (Application) Students will propose an ending for the play after discusses the argument between Creon and Haemon. Summary: Class will start with a short direct‐instruction lecture about translations and how translators make decisions that impact the outcome of a text. Class will then be given two different translations of the same passage, which will be read aloud, and thereby elucidate the ideas talked about within the lecture. After this there will be a discussion of the father and son argument between Creon and Haemon respectively. Students will make proposals as to how they think the play might end. Homework: 1. Students will read pages 152‐157 (up to “Enter Messenger”). 2. Students will list all, if any, unfamiliar words from the reading in their vocabulary list in their journals along with the terms from Aristotle’s Poetics. 3. Students will write two questions they have and two short comments about the reading. Resources: 1. Enough copies of two translations of the play introduction for each student. 2. Students will need their Antigone texts. Day 6: The Prophet Daily Objectives: 1. Students will evaluate the effect the prophet Teiresias has on Creon (I, II). 2. Students will discuss whether they find Creon’s change of heart believable when he has spent the majority of the play arguing the same ideas with others. They will ask why, or why not, and what makes Teiresias’s impact different to Creon (I, VII)). 3. Students will analyze the role of the prophet in the play and how he showed Creon his mistake (I). Activities: 1. (Explanation) Class will start with a question and answer session about the reading. 2. (Self‐Knowledge) Students will write individually about how they think Teiresias impacted Creon, and if they can think of a situation in their own life when they either held onto their opinion or had it swayed and what happened as a result. 3. (Interpretation) In small groups, students will discuss whether they find Creon’s change of heart believable, why or why not. 4. (Application) Students will share the ideas from their small groups with the class. 5. (Interpretation) Their will be a final class discussion on the role of the prophet. Summary: After the question and answer session from the reading, students will write individually on the impact of the prophet on Creon as well as a about a situation in there own life where the held onto an idea or were swayed and what resulted. Then in small groups students will discuss whether they find Creon’s change of heart believable. Students will share their small group ideas with the class. Finally the class will discuss what they think Teiresias’s role is in the play. Homework: 1. Students will read pages 157‐162, and finish the play. 2. Students will list all, if any, unfamiliar words from the reading in their vocabulary list in their journals along with the terms from Aristotle’s Poetics. 3. Students will write two questions they have and two short comments about the reading. Day 7: The Tragedy Daily Objectives: 1. Students will evaluate why they think that the Messenger tells what happened to Antigone and Haemon instead of the scene where they die being acted out (I). 2. Students will describe how Creon is illuminated at the play’s end (I, IX). 3. Students will pick a character they think is the tragic hero and will begin backing their argument up in a writing (I, II, IX). 4. Students will demonstrate an initial sense of what happened at the end of the play and why through short answer quiz (VI). Activities: 1. (Interpretation) There will be a short‐answer quiz on what happened at the end of the play. 2. (Explanation) There will be a discussion on what happened to Creon at the end of the play specifically. 3. (Interpretation) Students will discuss who the tragic hero(es) is/are and why. 4. (Application) There will be an individual writing session where students will begin arguing as to who they think the tragic hero is whether it is an outline, an introductory paragraph to an essay, or a flow chart of some kind. Summary: Class will begin with a short‐answer quiz on the final reading. The class will then discuss the end of the play and specifically what happened to Creon. The discussion will segway into another discussion of who the tragic hero is and why. Students will then have the rest of the class to begin working on an essay about who they feel the tragic hero is and why so that individual students can begin organizing their thoughts. Homework: 1. Students will write their introductory paragraph as to who they think the tragic hero is and why. 2. Students should study the key terms from Aristotle’s Poetics and should spend time reflecting as to how they apply to the play. Day 8: Going Over Key Terms, Characters, and Themes from the Play in Preparation for the Exam Daily Objectives: 1. Students will exhibit and build meaning on the themes of the play (I, IX). 2. Students will relate the key terms from the Poetics to Antigone (I, IX). 3. Students will reflect on the classical idea of tragedy versus how students feel the word is used today (IX). Activities: 1. (Explanation) There will be a class review session as to what will be on the exam and a discussion of the major themes from the play. 2. (Application) As part of the review, students will take key terms from the Poetics and apply them to the play. 3. (Application) Each student will write about how s/he feels the word tragedy is used today and whether that is different or similar to Aristotle’s definition. Summary: Today is set aside as a review session for the exam, which will reexamine the major themes, key words, and how they relate to the play. Students will also work on the idea of tragedy today and how it relates to Aristotle’s definition. Homework: 1. Review for Exam Day 9: More Review and Essay Assignment Daily Objectives: 1. Students will review and revisit the problems with translation ideas (II, VI). 2. Students will produce questions they have left in a review session (I). 3. Students will decide on a few choices of topics for papers (I, II). Activities: 1. (Interpretation) Students will then make sense of the problems associated with translation based on the prior activity in a discussion. 2. (Self‐Knowledge) Students will work together as a class for a final review so that each student knows where he/her is at and what questions they still have. 3. (Application) The class will be given their essay assignment, which will be due during the next unit. Summary: The class will review problems associated with translating. Students will either review for the exam or begin working on their essay assignments. This will be a last minute chance for students to get clarification and to ask questions. Homework: 1. Prepare for Exam Day 10: Exam Daily Objectives: 1. Students will demonstrate, make sense of, and use their knowledge of Antigone by composing responses to essay questions. Activity: 1. Exam Summary: There will be an exam. Homework: 1. Students should continue working on their papers. Essay: Choose the character you think best exemplifies the tragic hero as defined by Aristotle and write a persuasive essay using your knowledge of Antigone and the Poetics. Be sure to use examples from these texts when making your argument. There is no right or wrong answer so long as you back up your position, though choosing a character like the Sentry would be considerably off target. Part II – Turn your paper into a podcast, or work with another student and create a debate on who is the tragic hero and why, or both if you feel so inclined. If you choose to do the debate section consider working with a student who chose a different tragic hero. This way both of you can use your papers as the background for who you think is the tragic hero and why and thereby considerably reducing your workload. The debate would work best in podcast form, but can be done as written dialog. Note: Class time will be taken during the next unit on poetry so that students can work together and have access to the recording software to make the podcasts. I. Antigone Identification Choose ten of eleven and identify the following terms and people (30 points): A) catharsis ‐ B) poetry vs. history ‐ C) chorus – D) epic poetry – E) Eurydice – F) Ismene – G) Haemon – H) Polyneices – I) Thebes – J) mimesis – K) Dionysia – I. Antigone Identification (Answers) Choose ten of eleven and identify the following terms and people: A) catharsis – the purging and cleansing of an audience’s pity and fear brought about in drama to produce pleasure B) poetry vs. history – Poetry is concerned with events that are universal and could therefore happen to anyone while history is concerned with a specific event that is narrow in whom it effects C) chorus – the expository element of drama that explains what is happening, moves the action forward, acts as a combined agent, and makes omens as to the events that will still come. It also makes moral judgments, usually as a group of citizens D) epic poetry –like Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey are different from tragedy in that it is narrative, not scripted dialogs, which was told or sung by a bard and not acted, and takes place over a wide range of time unlike drama, which usually occurs within a twenty‐four hour period. E) Eurydice –the wife of Creon who kills herself when she learns her son Haemon has committed suicide. Her death adds to Creon’s suffering F) Ismene – the sister of Antigone, and the symbol of moderation and prudence, who is too afraid to go against Creon’s edict not to bury their brother, Polyneices. She is considered an appropriate character because a woman is supposed to be obedient and fearful in the ancient Greek world. G) Haemon – is the son of Creon who is betrothed to Antigone. Haemon defies his father’s edict and tries to dissuade his father’s tyrannical pride in order to save Antigone. Creon is not moved. Haemon kills himself upon finding Antigone’s dead body thereby bringing about Creon’s suffering H) Polyneices – the brother of Antigone who was left unburied. He came to Thebes with a foreign wife to take his rightful place as king of Thebes, which he was supposed to share with his brother Eteocles by switching every year. Polyneices ended up leading an attack on the seven gates of Thebes wit seven warriors. The attack was repulsed, but the two brothers ended up killing each other. Power then passed to Creon who declared Polyneices a traitor. I) Thebes – is the setting of Antigone. Creon was made ruler of Thebes after the two brothers Eteocles and Polyneices killed each other for the throne where Oedipus and Jocasta had ruled. J) mimesis – the imitation of an action or representation of reality K) Dionysia – an annual festival to the god Dionysus where playwrights had their works acted. ‐it was held during the Spring so people could sail there ‐its political significance was that it affirmed the Athenian citizens as a collective democratic body II. Antigone ShortAnswers 1. What deed sets the action of the play? 2. Identify and discuss the role of Teiresias – 3. What is the conflict inherent in this tragedy? II. Antigone ShortAnswer (Answers) (30) 1. What deed sets the action of the play? Antigone’s decision to bury Polyneices because t defies Creon’s edict. 2. Identify and discuss the role of Teiresias – Teiresias is a blind prophet who comes to tell Creon that he is not steering the ship of state well. He tells Creon to make amends for what he has done wrong, but Creon takes this news as an insult to his pride and insults Teiresias by saying he is only out for money. Teiresias is angered and tells Creon that his mistakes will twice haunt him and be the downfall of him and those he cares about. Teiresias predicts what will happen when Creon goes in the cave. Shortly after Teiresias exits Creon realizes his mistake and repents. Creon decides to set things right, but he ends up being too late. 3. What is the conflict inherent in this tragedy? Civil authority versus divine authority Order versus civil disobedience Human law versus divine law Or Or III. Antigone Essay Exam Directions: Choose one of the two topics from Section A below and write a five paragraph essay. Make sure you use examples from the text, and key terms whenever necessary. You must do essay number three. Each of the two essays should use at least one of the terms: hubris, hamartia, and catharsis, in a manner that shows what the words mean. Section A: 1. How does human and divine law function in Antigone? 2. How are the themes of order and civil disobedience portrayed in Antigone? Section B: 3. What is a tragedy in the Classical/Aristotelian sense, and how do we define tragedy today? Note: Points will not be deducted for minor punctuation errors such as commas so long as your writing is able to be understood. III. Antigone Essay Exam: The Holistic Guide to Assessing Directions: Choose one of the two topics from Section A below and write a persuasive essay. Make sure you use examples from the text, and key terms whenever necessary. You must do essay number three. Each of the two essays you write should use at least one of the terms: hubris, hamartia, and catharsis, in a manner that shows what the words mean. Section A: (20 points) 1. How does human and divine law function in Antigone, and how do these themes apply to the tragic hero? Answers should include what is meant by human and divine law, and which characters are the embodiment of which law and why. ‐An answer to the second part of the essay should include either human and divine law and how it brings about the associated hero’s downfall. 2. How are the themes of order and civil disobedience portrayed in Antigone, and how do these themes apply to the tragic hero? ‐The key to this essay is the writing of a character contrast between Creon and Antigone. ‐The second part of the essay should Section B: (20 points) 3. What is a tragedy in the Classical/Aristotelian sense, and how do we define tragedy today either similarly or differently? This essay should be done in no more than five paragraphs and should have at least two comparisons between Classical and contemporary views of tragedy. An “A” example answer to what is a tragedy in the Classical/Aristotelian sense would be: ‐Tragedy as defined in Aristotle’s Poetics is the imitation of an action told in a pleasurable form that is serious, has magnitude, is complete in itself, is told in language with the pleasurable excess of rhythm and harmony, and takes the form of drama with incidents of undeserved misfortune brought about by the hero’s error in judgment, hamartia, that cleanse and purge the audience/reader’s emotions of pity and fear producing pleasure. ‐The second part will be opinion based and students will get more points the more they can compare or contrast tragedy today versus Aristotle’s view. Note: Points will not be deducted for minor punctuation errors such as commas so long as your writing is able to be understood. Direct Instruction Plan for Antigone Unit Day 5: ‐Objectives and Standards: 1. Students will be able to critique how a translator’s translation of a foreign text can impact the reader (V, VI). 2. Students will read two different translations of a passage from Antigone in order to compare the similarities and differences (I, VI). 3. Students will adapt a passage from the play so that it is different from how it was, but still resembles the passage (II, VI). 4. Students will demonstrate how a translator has choice when translating and what that entails (I, VIII). ‐Anticipatory Set: Students will be each be handed a printout of the same set of passages from the play. Half of the class will be given one translation of a speech from the play while the other half will be given a different translation. One student will read his/her translation out loud while the other students try to follow along reading their own. There should be some confusion amongst the students as the texts will not correspond. This is intentional. This activity will be repeated by a student with the other translation so that each student will get to see what happens from both perspectives. ‐Input: I will illuminate what is going on and expose why this has happened. I will then take a passage and rewrite it so that it is slightly different, but maintains the integrity of the passage. Note: in case of my absence the substitute will skip this section as it is not completely necessary. Students will be prompted to work with a partner with the other passage and to discuss what kinds of differences they see and why they think these differences occur. The will write their responses to these questions down and submit it at the end of class. ‐Modeling: Students will then select a different passage from their books and also rewrite it in similar fashion. ‐Check for Understanding: Students will talk about and identify the passage they changed, and then read their passage out loud and other students will critique what they did well and what could be improved. ‐Closure: There will be a class discussion focusing on how translators make choices that impact the translation, and the implications of these choices. What could go right or wrong? ‐Independent Practice: Students will continue their rewrite of a play passage and pass it in at the end of class. 1. Antigone: Ismene, my sister, true child of my own mother, do you know any evil out of all the evils bequeathed by Oedipus that Zeus will not fulfill for the two of us in our lifetime? There is nothing‐‐no pain, no ruin, [5] no shame, nor dishonor‐‐that I have not seen in your sufferings and mine. And now what is this new edict that they say the general has just decreed to all the city? Do you know anything? Have you heard? Or does it escape you that [10] evils from our enemies are on the march against our friends? Ismene: To me no word of our friends, Antigone, either bringing joy or bringing pain has come since we two were robbed of our two brothers who died in one day by a double blow. [15] And since the Argive army has fled during this night, I have learned nothing further, whether better fortune is mine, or further ruin. Antigone: I knew it well, so I was trying to bring you outside the courtyard gates to this end, that you alone might hear. Ismene: [20] Hear what? It is clear that you are brooding on some dark news. Antigone: Why not? Has not Creon destined our brothers, the one to honored burial, the other to unburied shame? Eteocles, they say, with due observance of right and custom, he has laid in the earth [25] for his honor among the dead below. As for the poor corpse of Polyneices, however, they say that an edict has been published to the townsmen that no one shall bury him or mourn him, but instead leave him unwept, unentombed, for the birds a pleasing store [30] as they look to satisfy their hunger. Such, it is said, is the edict that the good Creon has laid down for you and for me‐‐ yes, for me‐‐and it is said that he is coming here to proclaim it for the certain knowledge of those who do not already know. They say that he does not conduct this business lightly, [35] but whoever performs any of these rites, for him the fate appointed is death by public stoning among the entire city. This is how things stand for you, and so you will soon show your nature, whether you are noble‐minded, or the corrupt daughter of a noble line. 2. Antigone: O sister! Ismene dear, dear sister Ismene! You know how heavy the hand of God is upon us; How we who are left must suffer for our father, Oedipus. There is no pain, no sorrow, no suffering, no dishonour We have not shared together, you and I. And now there is something more. Have you heard this order, This latest order that the King has proclaimed to the city? Have you heard how our dearest are being treated like enemies? Ismene: I have heard nothing about any of those we love, Neither good nor evil – not, I mean, since the death Of our two brothers, both fallen in a day. The Argive army, I hear, was withdrawn last night. I know no more to make me sad or glad. Antigone: I thought you did not. That’s why I brought you out here, Where we shan’t be heard, to tell you something alone. Ismene: What is it, Antigone? Black news, I can see already. Antigone: O Ismene, what do you think? Our two brothers…Creon had given funeral honours to one, And not to the other; nothing but shame and ignominy. Eteocles has been buried, they tell me, in state, With all honourable observances due to the dead. But Polynices, just as unhappily fallen – the order Says he is not to be buried, not to be mourned; To be left unburied, unwept, a feast of flesh For keen‐eyed carrion birds. The noble Creon! It is against you and me he has made this order. Yes, against me. And soon he will be here himself To make it plain to those that have not heard it, And to enforce it. This is no idle threat; The punishment for disobedience is death by stoning. So now you know. And now is the time to show Whether or not you are worthy of your high blood. Vocabulary Lesson Plan (Day 1 of unit plan) I. Objectives: 1. Students will be able to identify the elements of Gustav Freytag’s Dramatic Structure (I, III). 2. Student will view a music video in order to identify the elements of Dramatic Structure (I, VI, IX) 3. Students will be able to explain the elements of Greek tragedy (I, III). 4. Students will work in small groups and apply the elements of Greek tragedy to the same music video as before in order to develop deeper appreciation for the new vocabulary within a context (I, VI, IX, X). II. Standards: The standards cited in parentheses above reflect the standards within the Connecticut Common Core of Teaching. III. Anticipatory Set: Students will be told they are going to watch a music video, but that before they can watch the video I will go through explaining Freytag’s outline of the Dramatic Structure, which students will have a handout for. We will then watch the video and they will be able to discuss where they think they saw the different elements of the dramatic structure within the video if they see them at all. IV. Input: Students will also be given a handout with terminology (vocabulary words) from Greek tragedy. I will go over the terms with the students, and they will try to recall the music video and if they can apply these terms to it. If students want they will be able to view the music video again and discuss it together. V. Checking for Understanding: There will be a third handout incorporating the Dramatic Structure and the students will have to apply the Greek terminology to it. Students will work in pairs and watch the video filling in where the Greek terminology fits within the Dramatic Structure. Whether or not the students are able to fill out the last handout together will reveal whether the have understood not only the vocabulary from Greek tragedy, but also the dramatic structure. VI. Materials: The music video can be found at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sq3HYT4Bry4 Dramatic Structure (according to Gustav Freytag): Exposition – plot; In the exposition, the background information that is needed to properly understand the story is provided. Such information includes the protagonist, the antagonist, the basic conflict, the setting, and so forth. The exposition ends with the inciting moment, which is the single incident in the story’s action without which there would be no story. The inciting moment sets the remainder of the story in motion beginning with the second act, the rising action. Rising Action ‐ During rising action, the basic conflict is complicated by the introduction of related secondary conflicts, including various obstacles that frustrate the protagonist’s attempt to reach their goal. Secondary conflicts can include adversaries of lesser importance than the story’s antagonist, who may work with the antagonist or separately, by and for themselves. Climax (high point/turning point)‐ The third act is that of the climax, or turning point, which marks a change, for the better or the worse, in the protagonist’s affairs. If the story is a comedy, things will have gone badly for the protagonist up to this point; now, the tide, so to speak, will turn, and things will begin to go well for him or her. If the story is a tragedy, the opposite state of affairs will ensue, with things going from good to bad for the protagonist. Falling Action ‐ During the falling action, the conflict between the protagonist and the antagonist unravels, with the protagonist winning or losing against the antagonist. The falling action might contain a moment of final suspense, during which the final outcome of the conflict is in doubt. Denouement or Catastrophe/Resolution ‐The comedy ends with a dénouement (a conclusion) in which the protagonist is better off than at the story’s outset. The tragedy ends with a catastrophe in which the protagonist is worse off than at the beginning of the narrative. Elements of Greek Tragedy hamartia – a mistake tragic flaw – the quality of a character that brings about that person’s downfall hubris – excessive pride or arrogance; the quality in a character that most often brings about their downfall in tragedy anagnorisis – the tragic hero’s recognition of his/her mistake peripeteia – the reversal of fortune from high to low catharsis – the emotions of pity and fear in the audience, which the play resolves, in order to produce pleasure. “Hills Like White Elephants” Lesson Plan (Day 4 of unit plan) I. Objectives: 1. Students will identify what the issue the man and woman in the story are talking about and discuss who they think ‘won’ the argument (I). 2. Students will discuss how they think they would stage this play for a performance or to be filmed (I, VIII). 3. Students will experiment with what they discussed about how they would perform the story by doing an in‐class skit of the play (I, VII, VIII). 4. Students will relate what they did to how they predict they might stage Antigone (I, VIII). II. Standards: The standards cited in parentheses above reflect the standards within the Connecticut Common Core of Teaching. III. Anticipatory Set: Students will first be told that they will be able to do some acting or directing today. The class will silently read the Ernest Hemingway short story “Hills Like White Elephants.” The class will then discuss what they think happened in the brief story and how the use of dialog drives the action of the story. IV. Input: Students will be told that they will stage the short story in class. They will decide who the actors are going to be and everyone else will get to add their directorial input. The class will decide whether they want to work as one large group or be split into smaller groups and have several productions. V. Checking for Understanding: Students will work on and then perform their production in class. The assessment of the students’ work will be informal and will take into account participation and student interaction with the short story. VI. Closure: Students will guide the closing assignment with an analytical discussion of what the challenges were of taking a text and trying to make it ‘come to life.’ They will also discuss how they think this lesson may relate to Antigone. VII. Materials: Copies of “Hills Like White Elephants” for the class. Double‐Entry Journal Lesson Plan (Day 2 of unit plan) I. Objectives: 1. Students will be better able to both organize their thoughts from homework readings and interpret what they have read (I, VI). 2. Students will be able to apply the skill of the double‐entry journal to their homework reading assignments for the semester (VI, VIII). 3. Students will increase their repertoire of note taking skills to help them become better readers (I, VI, VIII) II. Standards: The standards cited in parentheses above reflect the standards within the Connecticut Common Core of Teaching. III. Anticipatory Set: Instead of trying to hook my students, I will rather bluntly tell students that we are about to run through a method that will help them with their reading homework assignments. IV. Input/Modeling: Students will have the double‐entry journal demonstrated to them so that they can see an example of what one should look like. I will read aloud a short selection from the previous night’s reading homework and students can follow along in their books. I will distinguish between important and minor ideas from the reading and restate them in my own words in the first column. I will think out loud for students to be able to see how and why I chose to write what I did and then place that in column two. V. Checking for Understanding: Students will then practice the double‐entry journal with their homework reading for that night, which they will begin in class. VI. Continued Practice: This during reading skill will go along with homework reading assignments for the remainder of the unit. VII. Materials: Students will need their Antigone texts, a piece of paper, and something to write with. Summary of Unit Plan The Antigone unit will begin with a history lesson about how theater developed, the Greek god Dionysus, some art and architecture, a short biography of the playwright Sophocles, and an introduction to the ideas surrounding tragedy. The ideas surrounding tragedy will be greatly expanded upon in an introductory vocabulary lesson on both dramatic structure and the elements of Greek tragedy so that students can see how the Greek terms apply from the onset. Included in this lesson will be a music video, which students will be able to apply the dramatic structure they just learned and the Greek vocabulary to immediately. From this point students will read the background story leading up to the beginning of the play, and then begin the play itself. A double‐entry journal technique will be taught and used by the students for each reading assignment of the play text. Students will talk about the ideas of tragedy as put forth by Aristotle in the Poetics, but special emphasis will be placed on related Classical ideas about tragedy to ideas of tragedy today. Due to the difficult nature of the text itself plenty of time will be devoted to discussion about the play and the meaning within. This discussion time will include applying the terms from the Poetics and how they manifest in the play, as these terms are highly abstract and not relating them to the text will render them meaningless. Students will also read a Hemingway short story and then attempt to stage it so that they can begin to see what it takes to make a text come to life. A short day project on translation will be included in the unit as well. This project will provide students with a grasp of the artistic and interpretative nature of translating a text. The paper will focus on the essential unit question of who is the tragic hero and why. Students will write a persuasive essay on the subject and back up their opinions with examples from the text. The exam will be in three parts, and due to its length the identification and/or short answer section may potentially be given as take home exam work. The classroom setting that this unit will be used within will be a 10th grade urban magnet school. The entire school centers around a Classical curriculum whereby students are required to take Latin and have the option of taking ancient Greek. A great emphasis is also placed on Classical literature such as epic and drama. Due to the fundamental nature of the Classical curriculum, teaching the play Antigone in a 10th grade classroom is highly appropriate. The essential questions for the unit are listed after the calendar and each day’s objectives are fleshed out within the unit instead of in the calendar. The reason for this will be addressed in the unit reflection. Unit Reflection Overall I am please with the unit. I feel there are many valuable activities, which hopefully are effective and engaging. I manage to incorporate reading skills, writing, acting, and history as well as various individual, group, and class activities with some direct instruction when and where necessary, but not too much in order to reflect a constructivist approach to teaching. My largest issue with the creation of the unit is that it is supposed to be designed for a ten‐day period whereas I have two months slotted for teaching the unit and am working in a seventy‐five minute block scheduling framework. Therefore, creating a calendar that is ten days long only served as a reference to say what part of the unit goes where chronologically if it even stays in that order once I get to the classroom. So I definitely had reservations about placing everything within ten days when I need to actually begin planning for two months. This is why the unit appears to have far too much content crammed into the ten day period. I am not planning for ten days here. Also I included the objectives within each fleshed out day of the unit. This is because: one, I was supposed to for the first semester of working on this unit and decided to continue doing it that way instead of erasing; and two, because I decided spending the time placing the objectives into the actual calendar would likely prove to be a large waste of time as I expect all manner of changes occurring to the unit in the Fall that I cannot at the moment foresee. I find it valuable to be able to foresee that there are likely going to be things I cannot foresee. The essential questions are listed after the calendar, and the assessments are also contained within the fleshed out days where appropriate and at the end of the unit.
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz