Why are we so Punitive? - Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice

!
"
'
&
#
$%
"
# $(%
"
)
*
+
#
+
011 %
-
)
"
,
-
.
/
*
"
"
"
"
2
+
+
3
4
511 #
#6
7
8 *
0
+ %
0111 0111 9' " :
!
0110% ;
<<
01
" 7
.1 ?
>1 #-
11111
=
>5
0111@> 9*
*
A
.
011 %
=
/
,
"
?
5(9*
B
19&
.<9
=
5 9&
.$9
=
19
11#
=
)
519C
%9
=
11 #:
,
$19
,
011 %
>51
>11111
. #;
011>@0> %
D
2
D
;
)*
)*
2
"
#*
'
)
(
011(%
)*
*
=
=
5<
2
?
.1
+
.1
'
..
<< <
'
(
E '
.1
1
0
EF G
;
0<
0111
?
0
5<
'
5<
$11H
=
"
+
2
1H
.( 0.H
19
<
.1
$$H
! "#$%#&& '
&&!
&&&
(
)
*
+
0<
><
(<
<<
$<
5<
.<
<
011
*
;
$$
(( .1
>>$(
.< 5.1
0 1. <
0(1< >
(.1<$.
1.< >$>
(1< <>
@:
/
A-@) * A
C
7
5
>
.
0
1.
010
(
(50
$
< .97
7
!!"#
$
% &
$
7' " C
0111
>9)
# /
7
- :
;
A-@'
' ( #>
% '
- @;
I ;
A - @'
7
*
&
/ % )
*
- @7
0111
<9
/ !
DC
7
/
*
0110
&
C
7
#
!
*
;
,
$$
(( .1
>>$(
.< 5.1
0 1. <
0(1< >
(.1<$.
1.< >$>
>0 >5
) *A
-
5
>
.
0
1.
(
05
>
05
0>
001
>5
5$
<
010
(
(5.
@: /
A-@) * A
C
-
#
7
%
011 #
#
$
.
.
.
.
5
(.
<
)
%
2
$05
+,,,#
%
.0
(
5(
.0
<<
.(
.0 .1
(9
$0
$1
5
..
#<.$H%
2
(1
11111
# 11111%
&
1
&
=
#2
01
>$ A
(
>>
9
*
+,,,&
7' "
011 D
! "#$%#&&&
*
0<
><
(<
<<
$<
5<
.<
<
0111
02(9
D
.@ >96
D
'
*
< 111
0111 %
1111
#
0110@0<2 > %
%9
<
1
0.5
# 0<
<11
#.1
015
>5<
%
5
<$
A
2
*
(
.
(
;
E J"
.@ 5 %
#K
5@ <5%
01
=1
<
5
5(
#/
10
A
<<H
> 0111
#
$> 1
0<
)*
$ A
# .H%
+ %
(
/
"
2
.
#*
'
011>%
+
+
B
2
<
*
01
C +
2
+
0<
;
>1
1
A>1
51#;
"
1
2
0
$1
0110
011>@%
A
0.H
"
#L
#
7
011
>>H
011>% J
"
/
2
D
"D
M
"
K
2
"
"
<1
M
N
+
'
(0H
< H
H
0<H J
.<
H
2
.5
#'
.
2
5%
"
/
"
;
*
-
?
-
"
;
"
"
B
"
D
D
"
D
D
J
?
#
%
D
A '
3
4
?
O
"
D
3
4
K
"
D
D ;
D
2
D
#/
@(0%
0H
"
@
.1
)*
" K
N
2
1
2
>H
#
%
><
5(H
$11
.1
<11
1
?
.1
11111
1
-
+
111
$ >H
C
5<1H
9 8
(1
$1
2
+
+
. C
.
11111
#A B
$@ <9
DB
<9/
.>
.
>1
/
(2
2
D
!
"
2
#
"
D
$2
" P%
/
"
?
K
>11H
D
+
2
"
C +
011
$<
.>
D
D
!
<11
!
2
/
2A
C
*
D
- "-
*
A
D
#'
C
.1H
#*
011>% ;
D
D
1H
.% *
6
D
2
D
/
2
52
@# %
"
D
D
9#0%
D
D
D
?
2
D
D
#
%9#>%
D9 #(%
D
D
2
2
#*
0111%
A
1
D
+
D
"
0<H
% ;
0.H #
#
%
(.H #
D
%
D
+
D
7
11H #) * A
+
+
011>@5%
+
+
+
/
/
5#
"
%
"
;
"
"
"
.
9
"
+
"
"
"+
*
9
"
"
5>5
(
"
'
*
@
+
($
9
.
"
#*
011>@>(<%
N
"
$1 @D
=
B
9
"
=
"
9
=
"
"=K
=
D
"
J
=
#
!
"
% )
# $
D
/
%
0 0
"
+
%
/
1 (
D
;
"
D
D
+
D
D '
D
D
D
D
D
D
C
;
D
9
D #N "
$@$5%
C
2
2
2
/
"
B
#N "
$@$.% J
"
N "
D
D /
D
D
D
=
9
2
"
2
;
"
"
D+
$@5(25<%
#N "
2
2
D
+
+
+
*
#
%
"
2
2
"
2
D
D
D
D
"
B
B
;
"
L
"
D
=
"
2
'
D
DK
D
=
D
D
K
)
D
"
" D #!
5%
D
2
K
'
"
&
D
" D
$1 D
$( *
D
"
#/
B
011 %
D
D
K
=
D
D
"
D ?
*
C
/
DC
,
D
"
"
#;
<.%
&
+
2
+
#
1H
A
=
/
<@0<2 0$%
#
;
D
=%9
9
2
D% &
; '
E #-
C
"
?
"
"
*
&
*
"
"
Q "
.
DC
D
"
0(
/
"
D
D#
"
# &
%
5 9;
C
D
"
'
D
0(
#*
011>%
"
"
K
#/
011 @ $%
B
D
"
D
D
2
D #/
011 @ <%
2
"P
J
= "
=
/
+
@
#011 @52.% ;
2
51
)
2
*
L
5
1
#
%
?
)
0111
<11
#*
*
'
"
O
011>% /
>12
+
"
;
)
*
#011 @.2 <%
"
D
;
"
D
2
D
2
D
#
%
"
B
/
"
"
"
J
6
&
/
;
@D?
"
"
" "
=
A
=
#
)
;
@ 0% ,
K
,
*
*
-
2
D*
O
&
D
"
?
+
D
K
"
"
"
2
2
"
"
!
D
2
2
2
#
011 @ 1%
#
D
%
2
D
"
7
D
"
+
#K
0 &)
D
D
N
(
5%
3
3
/
"
"
D
"
D
+
;
"
#
%
+
D
*
:
D
/
D
D ;
+
PL
#
+
;
"
*
%
@
#*
'
0111% *
011 %
#;
#
%
"
2
(1
5
01
5$
.1 #
0<H
>$H
011194
5
%
1><>
*
%A
#
L "
#
/
@ *"
.9-
*"
9!
0111% J
1
"
$1 ;
$
@ 1<%
B
2
51
1(0<
)
B
#/
&
*
"
#( 0(
"
J
>12
11111
5
0111
2
#*
0111
( $<
5%
'
011>%
L
"
+
"
+
+
2
/
1
-
2N
<1
&
"
D
D
#-
2
2
N
*
011(@015% ;
"
>1
.
#
0 <%
+
K
;
+
'
D
+
;
!
"
/
D #
0 .%
+
"
D
D
;
2"
7
%
D
2
@
1
2
K
2
1
+
2
"
#011(%
D#
%
'
"
J
?
#
%
/
+
DJ
L
D
D
D ?
+
0
"
/
+
" *
.
*
#
%
D)
*
"
C
C
D
?
,
K
"
C
*
!
"
+
+
!
P
O
J
"
L
D
* 03 . 0
=
@, ./ 0 .
@D
J
1 +.
<
?
,
D
" D
D
@DN
" D
JL
D
"
E
2.
"E
&
C
,
J
=?
*
"
;
/
P;
P;
P
E
'
'
/
#
<2
;
"
D
*
2
* J
D
J
!
)
%
#
*
%
+
;
@
P
=
/
J
;
*
"
"
+
J
B
/
'
"
?
.
-
"
# $% ;
6
8
"
"
K
$1
"
D
"
L "
"
D
'
"
>(
"
@
2
"
Q
D
D
@
+
+
#-
"
$ @(2<%
8
"
'
C
D
"
D
0
D
D
D
D
/
D
D
>1
"
D
;
-
@
D
"
@
9
+
=
2222222222222222222222222222
(
'
7
7
- @;
'
N
A #
5%
'
M' "'
' "
7
)
#0110% 7
6
:
'
7 #011>% D*
-
2N
%'
7
8
' ( #>
(
C / '
#
<% D
'
7
*
#>
%C + !
' "
' ;
*
; #
&%
&
%
'
@
' "
' "
7 7- :
011 D ;
A-@'
-
%
%
/
- @;
D
C / !
7
*
011 D&
C
D
K & *
#0110% =
C
0110
*
7
9
) * !
: N@;
C
/
)
#011(% 2
@K
# % %
7
/
@;
>@(>2<
D %
9
C
& C
(
'
9
0
*
<
-J@;
5
-0
-
#>
#
" ? #0110%
-
" ? #
2
- ' N
(
8
.
6
# ?
L "@
?
C
$%
<% :
-
-
;
, #
>%1
222222222222 #
.% )
(
;
2;
2 # '
L "
'
1
/
! *"
@)
#
/ ,@%
(
# ?
(9
)
#
&%
L "@
9
# ?
&
L "@/
$(%
N@*
-
C
,
<
(&
-
?
C
0111
?
L "@!
' "
)
C
#
.>>%
A B
)
* #
?
/ #
!
B7 ?
# #<
$% % 1
L "@!
:
0
#011 %D
%
L "@
?
$% 6
C
/
;
:
N C
A - @A
/
/ #
.
#
)
%#
7
$%
'
?
>@ 201
-
;
7 #
)
?
-
L "@8
#011 %%
&
2
C
;
C
)
&8
%1
N
1
,
B
K
L "@J
?
& #
& N
C
C
5%DC
B
@A
M
%
12 0
22222222222222#011 % D
&%
&% '
# ?
, #
#/
/
;
)
5%
!
N"
)
8
C
D
/
#
0 0 :
L "@
D
1
7# -
-
@
!!"
*
?
C
.% )
%
;
)
7
C
C
&
)
)
'
*
D
- @
/
-
7#
/
)
$%
&
)
C
/
C
/ /
C
" 7 / #0110% 8
K
'
7 #011(% %
K
C
K
C
-
& #
*
=
#
9
! & N
#
5% )
; ' '
(
@
J
/ #
)
22222222222
C
)* A
-0
)
(
'
.% D$
#5
.%DN
@)
-
#011 %
7
# '
@
/
"
D ; >( )
/
;
&1
>(
10
@K
>@0 2>>
9)
#?
%
9
0
7
D ;
/
D
1
J
!!A;
>
( .
N
( .(
?8@ -
& )
, - " D ?6 ( @
<% 6
C
@
)
=
N
L "@J
%'
-
P*
*
&
-
)
"
)
#
- @;
' "
#011>% )
)
! #
?
8
7 #011 % D
*"
%'
#0
5%
222222222222 #0111% D*
*
)
-
.
2
222222222222222222222222222222 #0111% D
*
C
D)
2222222222222 #
-
)
=
2 1
K & #011 % )
)
# '
2222222222
'
% %
9
1
6
7
A-@) * A
# ?
%
?
L "@J
A
7
C
7
L "@
)
#011>%
;
N #011 % DA
*
>@ <2 >>
;
/ #
;
/ #
<.% %
6
J
<
-
8 *
)
10
@ K
$@00520(1
?
*
-
/
D
A
++ M
%
L "@*
%%
C
-
"
%
-
)*
#0111 % DC C
D;
A - @7
2222222222222222222222222222222222222222 #
6
#;
A-@7
2222222222222222222222
/
J " - @*
A #011>% D!, AN ?,@>1H
#
++ M
M "R
7
C
)
22222222222222222222222222222222222222222 #0111 % D
N
* * D;
+
&
%
2222222222222 #011>% D
D)
L
@;
@
C
P
A - @7
(
+ D %
#
2
C
&
-
<