Clay Minerals (1997)32, 21-28 Iodide, caesium and strontium adsorption by organophilic vermiculite J. B O R S , A. G O R N Y * AND S. D U L T Z t Centre of Radiation Protection and Radioecology, Hannover University, Herrenhiiuser Str. 2, D-30419 Hannover, Germany, *Dahlemer Str. 4, D-30982 Pattensen, Germany, and t lnstitute of Soil Science, Hannover University, Herrenhi~user Str. 2, D-30419 Hannover, Germany (Received 7 November 1995; revised 22 August 1996) A B S T R A C T: Distribution coefficients and isotherms for the adsorption of radioiodide, caesium and strontium ions (125I-, 134Cs+ and 85Sr2+) were determined in untreated vermiculite and in vermiculite treated with the chloride salt of hexadecylpyridinium (HDPy+). Experimental data reveal that some of the alkylammonium ions were incorporated as HDPyCI ion pairs into the vermiculite. The fraction of ion pairs adsorbed is reflected by an increase in distribution coefficients with increasing saturation levels. Consequently, a considerable part of the iodide adsorption could be attributed to an anion exchange process. At smaller amounts of Cs§ and Srz+ adsorbed, distribution coefficients of the modified clay mineral are significantly reduced in comparison with the original material. These differences are less pronounced when greater amounts of cations are adsorbed. Generally, larger distribution coefficients were found for the Cs+ compared with the Srz§ ion in the untreated and modified samples. Soils represent an important filter and buffer system for many cations and anions. Generally, their sorption properties are determined by the contents and compositions of clay minerals and humic substances. A great part of the soil organic matter is associated with clay minerals forming organomineral complexes (Greenland, 1965) which are of pronounced importance with respect to element transport and/or retention and to aggregate stability. Clay minerals also interact with organic cations. The replacement of inorganic cations by alkylammonium ions causes considerable modification in the hydration and swelling properties of the clays. Research in this area has significantly increased the knowledge on the physico-chemical behaviour of both clay minerals and organo clay minerals (Weiss, 1963; Mortland, 1970; Theng, 1974; Lagaly, 1981; Rausell-Colom & Serratosa, 1987). Cation exchange capacities (CEC) of naturally occurring organo-mineral complexes were determined by Leinweber et al. (1993). It was observed in samples extracted from nine different soils that the potential CEC decreased with increasing equivalent diameters of the separated particles (i.e. fine and medium clay: 489-813 mmolc kg-l; coarse clay: 367-749 mmolc kg-1; fine silt: 202-587 mmolc kg-l; medium silt: 63-345 mmolc kg-l). The CEC varied with factors associated with the soil genesis, the mineralogical composition of the <6.3 p.m sizefraction and the C and N contents of the particle size-fractions. It has been shown in extensive investigations that organophilic clay minerals can adsorb non-ionic organic compounds (Mortland et al., 1986; Jaynes & Boyd, 1991; Xu & Boyd, 1994) as well as iodide, which exists predominantly in the anionic form in terrestrial ecosystems (Lieser & Steinkopff, 1989). After modification of bentonite, vermiculite and Cretaceous clay by hexadecylpyridinium (HDPy +) and benzethonium (BE+), these organoclay minerals exhibited adsorption rates and amounts for iodide ions which are several orders of magnitude higher than those of untreated samples. Moderate increases in the adsorption parameters were found after cation exchange with hexadecyltrimethylammonium (HDTMA+), while the treatment with trimethylphenylammonium 9 1997 The Mineralogical Society 22 J. Bors et al. (TMPA +) and tetramethylammonium (TMA § were ineffective in this respect (Bors, 1990, 1992). Studies with partially saturated HDPy-vermiculite showed that the increased organic C content and the e x p a n s i o n of the basal spacing ( ~ 2 . 7 nm maximum) were related to the increased amounts of radioiodide adsorbed. The log-log plot of the adsorption and desorption isotherms exhibited linearity at equilibrium concentrations up to 10 -4 mol 1-1 or 10 -1 mol kg -1 and became nonlinear at higher I - loadings (Bors & Gorny, 1992). Adsorption experiments with different particle size-fractions (clay and silt fractions) of Cretaceous clay, the mineral fraction of a loess soil and vermiculite, each treated with HDPy +, revealed highest iodide adsorption in the medium clay fractions (0.2-0.6 gm and 0.6-2.0 gin, respectively). For Cretaceous clay and clay from loess, iodide adsorption was related to the amount of HDPy + incorporated, but in vermiculite no clear relationship between distribution coefficients and HDPy content of the different size-fractions was observed (Bors et al., 1995). Alkylammonium cations with ten or more C atoms in the aliphatic chain are adsorbed by montmorillonite in amounts greatly exceeding the CEC (Greenland & Quirk, 1962; Rausell-Colom & Serratosa, 1987). Such sorption of HDPy + beyond the CEC was observed in the experiments mentioned above with Cretaceous clay and with a clay from a loess soil also (Bors et al., 1995). These organic cations exchange inorganic cations at the external surface in a first step or exchange occurs simultaneously with the interlamellar cations. A portion of the organic cations is adsorbed, probably together with their gegen ions (Patzko, 1991; Lagaly, 1995). A different adsorption process may operate in organo-vermiculite. It has to be noted that in spite of the application of HDPy + in amounts equivalent to 100% of the CEC, the maximum adsorption of HDPy + represesented only ~ 5 0 % of the CEC (Bors & Gorny, 1992). In this case, C1- ions are adsorbed via HzO molecules around the alkyl chains (Holz & SOrensen, 1992; Lagaly, 1995). In both examples, the ion exchange of I - against C1- could be responsible, at least partially, for the iodide adsorption. In order to improve the understanding of iodide adsorption mechanisms, the contribution of HDPy-C1 ion pairs to the sorption behaviour was investigated. The ability of organophilic vermiculite to interact with inorganic cations was examined by batch experiments using 134Cs+ and 85Sr2+ as tracers with the corresponding carrier substances in different concentrations. MATERIALS AND METHODS Preparation and characterization of HDPy-vermiculite. A thermally expanded vermiculite from Russia (Thermax, A-3300 Greinsfurth) ground using an Ultra-Centrifugal Mill was used for the experiments; according to XRD measurements, the structure of the samples was not affected by this procedure. To determine the CEC, the samples were washed with a MgCI2 solution (three times with 0.5 tool 1- j , three times with 0.01 mol 1-1), and Ba(NO3)2 was used (six times with 0.1 mol 1-1) as an extracting agent. In each case, 100 ml of salt solution per g vermiculite was employed. The concentration of MgC12 in the solution was determined by measuring the C1- concentration by potentiometric titration, while that of the Mg 2+ ions was determined by atomic absorption spectrometry (AAS). The original vermiculite contained N85% of the exchangeable Mg 2+ and 15% of the Ca 2+. The charge per half unit-cell was determined by chemical analysis to be 0.755 and the CEC was 1.62 mole kg -I (Pesci, 1994). After dispersion of 20 g of the vermiculite in 1 1 of distilled water, the chloride salt of the quaternary alkylammonium ion of HDPy* was added in amounts equivalent to 100% CEC. Additionally, HDPy-vermiculites of different HDPy + loadings were prepared, adding the organic ion in amounts corresponding to 10, 20, 30, 50 and 100% of the CEC of the vermiculite. The suspensions were stored for 18 h and filtered. The filter residues were then washed at least eight times with water (1 1 total) or different mixtures of ethanol:water (10:90; 30:70; 50:50; 70:30; 90:10) to remove excess organic salt. The samples were air dried, and the uptake of HDPy + was determined by measuring the C content with a LECO C instrument (IR 12). The chloride concentration of the alkylammonium solution before and after adsorption was measured using a DIONEX DX 100 ion chromatograph. Adsorption experiments The adsorption of I - , Cs + and Sr 2+ was investigated using the batch technique and was Iodide, Cs and Sr adsorption by organophilic vermiculite 23 TABLE 1. Specifications of the HDPy-vermiculite and steady-state distribution coefficients. HDPyC1 applied [% CEC] [mg g-l] 10 20 30 50 100 58 116 174 290 580 HDPy+ adsorbed [mg g-l] H D P y C 1adsorbed [mg g--l] Kd [1 kg -1] 45 80 80 110 116 2 5 40 80 160 25 68 205 2630 3390 characterized by the distribution coefficient (Kd value). The Ko value is defined as the ratio between the concentration of solute sorbed on the solid matrix (tool kg -1) and the concentration of the solute in the equilibrium solution (mol l-l). According to the given guidelines, distribution coefficients are used frequently for presentation of data in experiments investigating and attempting to predict the long-term behaviour of radionuclides (Kim & Lang, 1982; Baeyens & Bradbury, 1995). For the anion adsorption experiments, ~0.5 g of the organo-vermiculite was dispersed in 10 ml of bi-distilled water containing 37 kBq of 1z5I( ~ 5 • 10 -12 tool 1-1) and KI in a concentration range of 1 • 10 -8 to 1 tool 1-1. The samples were incubated in 30 ml centrifuge tubes and shaken at 22~ for seven days, this time being sufficient to establish equilibrium conditions. Sorption isotherms were calculated using the formulae: [I-]1 = [I-] ~ aj/a ~ (1) 0-Is = Ka [l-]~ (2) where [I- h is the equilibrium concentration of iodide in the solution in tool 1-1, [I-] ~ the initial iodide concentration in the solution (tool l-l), AI is the radioactivity of 1251- in the liquid at the end of the adsorption e x p e r i m e n t measured in cpm rnl- l , A~ is the total radioactivity of 125I- at the beginning of the experiments in cpm ml - l and [I-]s is the amount of iodide adsorbed in mol kg -1. In the same manner, the adsorption of Cs + and Sr 2+ was determined using 10 kBq 13aCs+ ( ~ 1 x 10 -12 mol 1-1) and 10 kBq SSSr2+ ( ~ l x 10 -12 mol 1-1) and CsCI or SrCl2 solutions in initial concentrations of 1 x l0 -7 to 1 x l0 - l tool 1-1. The solid and liquid phases were separated by centrifugation (15 000 rpm, 20 000 g for 15 rain). The experiments were carried out in duplicate. In a double-labelling experiment with Cs + and Sr2+, the competing adsorption of the two elements by organo-vermiculite (with 276 mg HDPy + per g, resulted from 100% CEC application) and by untreated samples was tested. About 0.5 g of the vermiculite was dispersed in 10 ml of the equilibrium solution. The sum of the ion concentrations in equivalents was kept constant (1 x 10-3 mol 1-1), but the relation of Cs + to Sr2+ was varied (equivalents Cs:Sr = 1:4, 2:3, 3:2 and 4:1). After attaining equilibrium, the distribution coefficients were determined. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION The distribution coefficients for the iodide adsorption, the adsorbed amounts of HDPy + ions and HDPyCI ion pairs are listed in Table 1. The application of HDPy + in increasing concentrations results in increased organophilicity (total HDPy § content) and consequently in increased distribution coefficients of radioiodide. It is also obvious that a portion of the alkylammonium ions is bound as HDPyC1 ion pairs, the fraction of which increases with increasing saturation levels. The data of sorbed HDPyCI agree, at least qualitatively, with the distribution coefficients. In Fig. 1, distribution coefficients for the differently saturated HDPy-vermiculite are related to the concentrations of adsorbed iodide. They increase with increasing organophilicity in a wide range of iodide loadings and decrease very sharply from 4.000-6.000 to ~ 1 0 1 kg - l at loadings exceeding 10 -1 tool kg - l indicating saturation of adsorption sites. Considering these data, the adsorption capacity of the organo-vermiculite for iodide is estimated to be ,-~5 x 10-1 tool kg - l . As expected, the washing procedure with different mixtures of ethanol:water reduced the C 24 J. Bors et al. HDPY ~ ~ 10000t 1000 IX content 190 mg g-'j 120 mg gl 47mgg ~ 1 10~ I0 ~ 10 ~ lff z 10o iodideadsorbed[rnol kg-1] FIG. 1. Distribution coefficients for iodide ions on vermiculite treated with HDPy § in different concentrations as a function of the amount of iodide adsorbed. and C1 content of the HDPy-vermiculite (Fig. 2). The minimum organic C content of the HDPyvermiculite and the maximum CI- concentration in the washing solution were found for an ethanol: water ratio of 70:30 vol%. The samples washed with this ethanol:water mixture exhibited the lowest iodide sorption (Fig. 3). An adsorption maximum at an iodide concentration of ~ 1 0 -2 tool kg - t is observed for the samples with the lowest HDPy-content (47 mg g - l , Fig. 1), and in those washed with the most effective ethanol:water mixture (70:30 vol%, Fig. 3). Similar unexpected effects were reported previously for the HDPy + derivatives of vermiculite size-tractions of 0.6-2.0 and 2.0-6.0 Ixm (Bors et al., 1995). The XRD patterns of these samples showed distinct basal reflections with d-values of 3.0 nm and broad shoulders to higher d-values. These reflections were absent in the two smaller particle size-fractions which showed no sorption maximum. Changes in the interlayer arangement of the alkyl chains or/and in the adsorption mechanism of iodide ions at the 24 18 7__ 22 =m ~ 14 20 E g r 10 .~ I "5 m 16- "5 S (.~ 144 O 12- 2 10 20 40 Ethanol 60 contentof the washingsolution 00 8 0 100 [vol%] FIG. 2. Carbon content of the HDPy-vermiculite and C1- concentration of the washing solution as a function of the composition of the washing solution (ethanol:water). Iodide, Cs and Sr adsorption by organophilic vermiculite 800 25 ~ 70% E t h a n o h 600 t 2O .t 10 7 , - - ,it" 10 ,5 , , 10 ~ I0 -I - : : Q I0 ~ Iodide a d $ o r ~ d [mol kg~:% Fit. 3. Distribution coefficients for iodide ions as a funtion of the amount of iodide ions adsorbed in HDPyvermiculite (with 276 mg g-] HDPy § washed with different mixtures of ethanoL:water. relatively high loading may be responsible tbr the observed phenomenon. Considering that some of the alkylammonium ions are adsorbed together with their gegen ions (Table 1) and that the iodide sorption is low in samples washed with the ethanol:water ratio of 70:30 vol% (Fig. 2), ion exchange is assumed to be one of the processes controlling iodide incorporation. On the other hand, no substantial effects on the distribution coefficients were found for the organo-vermiculite washed with the other ethanol: water mixtures. These data and the strong decrease of Ka values at high loading (Fig. 1) indicate that besides ion exchange, another mechanism may be involved in iodide adsorption. It is likely that the organo-vermiculite contains different binding sites for iodide anions. More work is needed to clarify these hypotheses. The distribution coefficients (Ka) for Cs ~ and Sr2+ on original vermiculite and HDPy-vermiculite (with 276 mg HDI~ "+ g-a) as a function of the amount of Cs + and Sr2+ adsorbed are shown in Figs. 4 and 5. The distribution coefficients are distinctly different for the two materials. At higher concentrations (1 x 10 -4 moi kg - / for Cs + and 1 • 10 -2 mo ~. kg -~ for St2+), the distribution coefficients of vermiculite and HDPy-vermiculite become very similar. The adsorption of the untreated samples is reduced to the level of those of HDPy-vermiculite. The observed sorption of cations on the HDPy-vermiculite, especially evident in the case of Cs +, can be explained by the mixedlayered structure (the existence of altered and unaltered silicate layers) of this organophilic clay mineral ( B o r s & Gorny, 1992). The partial e x c h a n g e of i n t e r l a y e r cations by H D P y + (Table 1), support this assumption. One of the reasons for the incomplete exchange in the highlycharged vermiculite may be due to the relatively short reaction time of 18 h (Lagaly, 1982). Considerably higher Kd values are obtained for Cs + compared with the bivalent Sr 2+ for both vermiculites. The preferential adsorption of Cs + can be explained by its low hydration energy of Cs +. Figure 6 illustrates the adsorption isotherms for Cs + with unaltered and HDPy-vermiculite. The loglog plot of the isotherm of the original vermiculite is linear up to ~ 1 x 10 - 4 tool 1-~ or 5 x 10 -~ mol kg -1. The corresponding isotherm for HDPyvermiculite is probably not linear. The HDPyvermiculite adsorbed less Cs + up to 1 x 10 -5 i '~i ,oooi \\ origin=l vl~mk~jte ~ \ FIG. 4. Distribution coefficients for caesium ions related to the amount of caesium ions adsorbed, original vermiculite and HDPy-vermiculite (with 276 mg g-1 HDPy+). 26 J. Bors et al. 2SO- lO,] 10-1 50, ~l~ 100" 10 4 . SO, o lO" , 1o" 10" in~" 104 tn~2 102 ~ 10 -s. , t~~ 10 Sd" iclsorbedImol kg'~l // ~ < 10 .7. Fx6. 5. Distribution coefficients for strontium ions related to the amount of strontium ions adsorbed, original and HDPy+-vermiculite (with 276 mg g-~ HDPy+). t / lO-O 10 "11 I-~ 10 9 10 .5 rite HDPy -vermiculite J 10-2 10;1 Cs* c o n c e n t r a t i o n of t h e equilibrium solution [mol 1-1] m o l l -] or 1 • -3 tool kg -]. At higher Cs § concentrations the amount of Cs + sorbed becomes similar for both vermiculites. As Figs. 4 and 5 demonstrate, the differences in the isotherms appear more evident in the distribution coefficients. The isotherms for Sr 2+ are linear over almost the whole concentration range studied (Fig. 7). The HDPY+-treatment influences the sorption of Sr z§ much more than that of Cs +. Distribution coefficients obtained from a doublelabelling experiment confirm the preferential sorption of Cs in competition with Sr (Fig. 8). With increasing Cs+:Sr 2+ ratios the adorption of Cs § increases, whereas the value for Sr 2+ remains constant. The especially high values for Cs § in vermiculite with 120 mg g-1 HDPy+ content (corresponding to 25% of the CEC) are remarkable. This phenomenon is not well understood yet and needs further attention, considering different particle size-fractions. According to experimental results (Graf v. Reichenbach, 1973), basal spacing expansion and ion-exchange reactions are dependent on particle size. FJc. 6. Adsorption isotherms for Cs § in original and HDPY- vermiculite (with 276 mg g-1 HDPy*). mechanism may operate in iodide sorption which could not be identified on the basis of the experimental data obtained. Additional work 101 10 -1 , ~' E 10 -~ . "6 10 4 . < ite t I " - ~ HDPy'vermiculite t " 9 / lO-'r. CONCLUSIONS The incorporation of alkylammonium cations (HDPy § in vermiculite modifies the adsorption of anions as well as of cations. A considerable fraction of HDPy § is incorporated into the vermiculite as HDPyC1 ion pairs. As a consequence, iodide sorption is attributed, at least partially, to ion exchange processes. Besides ion exchange, another 10 -9 10"' 10" 1()~ 1()~ 1~1 Sr z* c o n c e n t r a t i o n o f t h e e q u i l i b r i u m solution [mot 1-1] FIG. 7. Adsorption isotherms for Sr2+ in original and HDPY- vermiculite. (with 276 mg g-1 HDPy+). lodide, Cs and Sr adsorption by organophilic vermiculite 27 t200 - 1000 9 HDPy* content 800 9 Cs* 9 276 m g g-~ 9 120 m g g-~ 9 0 mg g-1 -- ~-- 276 m g g-1 ~ 600 S~* ..i- 120 m g g-1 --*- O m g 9-1 2OO 0 :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: 1 2 3 4 CII * I S r 2" r a t i o F[(;. 8. Distribution coefficients for caesium and strontium as a function of the initial equivalent ratio of the two cations, original vermiculite and HDPy-vermiculite. The composition of the equilibrium solution was held constant (1 • 10 -3 eq 1-1). The solid and dashed lines represent best-fit curves. including structural analysis is necessary to improve the u n d e r s t a n d i n g of the i o d i d e s o r p t i o n mechanism. Cation adsorption is observed in original and HDPy-vermiculite. However, in HDPy-vermiculite, the cation adsorption is substantially reduced, especially for Sr 2+. Generally, Cs § ions exhibited a considerably higher affinity to the original and HDPy+-exchanged vermiculite than Sr 2+ ions. The adsorption of cations to the organophilic vermiculite can be attributed to the incomplete exchange of interlayer cations by HDPy § under the experimental conditions employed. As a consequence, a distinct number of sorption sites remains available for the sorption of inorganic cations. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The skilled technical assistance of Mr. K.-H. Iwannek is gratefully acknowledged. REFERENCES Baeyens B. & Bradbury M.H. (1995) A quantitative mechanistic description of Ni, Zn and Ca sorption on Na-montrnorillonite. PSI-Bericht Nr. 95-10, Wtirenlingen and Villigen, Switzerland. Bors J. (1990) Sorption of radioiodine in organo-clays and soils. Radiochim. Acta, S1, 139-143. Bors J. (1992) Sorption and desorption of radioiodine on organo-clays. Radiochim. Acta, 58/59, 235-238. Bors J, & Gorny A. (1992) Studies on the interactions of HDPy-vermiculite with radioiodine. Appl. Clay Sci, 7, 245-250. Bors J., Gorny A, & Dultz S. (1995) Sorption of radioiodide on different particle size fractions of hexadecylpyridinium-clays. Proc. lOth Int. Clay Conf. Adelaide, 74-78. Graf v. Reichenbach H. (1973) Exchange equilibria of interlayer cations in different particle size fractions of biotite and phlogopite. Proc. Int. Clay Conf. Madrid, 457-466, Greenland D.J. (1965) Interaction between clays and organic compounds in soils. Pt. 2. Adsorption of soil organic compounds and its effect on soil properties. Soils Fert. 28, 521-532. Greenland D.J. & Quirk J.P. (1962) Adsorption of 1-nalkyl-pyridinium bromides by montmorillonite. Clay Miner. 9, 484-499. Holz M. & S6rensen M. (1992) Direct detection of an attractive interaction between anions and hydrophobically hydrated unpolar groups. Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem. 96, 1441-1447. Jaynes W.F. & Boyd S.A. (1991) Clay mineral type and organic compound sorption by hexadecyltrimethylammonium-exchanged clays. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 55, 43-48. Kim J.L. & Lang H. (1983) Standardization of the batch experiment for the migration study of radionuclides in the geologic media. In: Proc. of the U.S./FRG Bilateral Workshop Berlin, Munich, (K.E. Maas & A. Huf, editors) Hahn-Meitner Institut ftir Kernforschung, Berlin. Lagaly G. (1981) Characterization of clays by organic compounds. Clay Miner. 16, 1-21. 28 J. Bors et al. Lagaly G. (1982) Layer charge heterogeneity in vermiculite. Clays Clay Miner. 30, 215-222. Lagaly G. (1995) Surface and interlayer reactions: bentonites as adsorbents. Proc. lOth Int. Clay Conf. Adelaide, 137-144. Leinweber P., Reuter G. & Brozio K. (1993) Cation exchange capacities of organo-mineral particle size fractions in soils from long term experiments. J. Soil Sci. 44, 111-119. Lieser K.H. & Steinkopff T.H. (1989) Chemistry of radioactive iodine in the hydrosphere and in the geosphere. Radiochim. Acta, 46, 49-55. Mortland M.M. (1970) Clay-organic complexes and interactions. Adv. Agron. 2 2 , 7 5 - 1 1 7 . Mortland M. M., Shaobai S. & Boyd S.A. (1986) Clayorganic complexes as adsorbents for phenol and chlorophenols. Clays Clay Miner. 34, 581-585. Patzko A. (1991) Ion exchange and molecular adsorp- tion of a cation active surfactant on montmoriUonite. Proc. 7th Euroclay Conf. Dresden, 827-830. Pesci N. (1994) Einflufl des Sr/K-Austausches auf die Struktur aufweitbarer Schichtsilikate. PhD thesis, Univ. Hannover, Germany. Rausell-Colom J.A. & Serratosa J.M. (1987) Reactions of clays with organic substances. Pp. 371-422 in: Chemistry of Clays and Clay Minerals (A.C.D. Newman, editor) Mineralogical Society, London. Theng B.K.G. (1974) The Chemistry of Clay-Organic Reactions. Hilger, London. Weiss A. (1963) Mica-type layer silicates with alkylammonium ions. Clays Clay Miner., Monogr. No. 12, 10, 191-223. Xu S. & Boyd S.T.A. (1994) Cation exchange chemistry of hexadecyltrimethylammonium in a subsoil containing vermiculite. Soil Sci. Soc Am. J. 58, 1382-1391.
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz