3
90656R
Level 3 History, 2012
90656 Analyse and evaluate evidence in historical sources
9.30 am Tuesday 20 November 2012
Credits: Five
RESOURCE BOOKLET
Refer to this booklet to answer the questions for History 90656.
Check that this booklet has pages 2 – 15 in the correct order and that none of these pages is blank.
YOU MAY KEEP THIS BOOKLET AT THE END OF THE EXAMINATION.
© New Zealand Qualifications Authority, 2012. All rights reserved.
No part of this publication may be reproduced by any means without the prior permission of the New Zealand Qualifications Authority.
2
TOPIC ONE: ENGLAND 1558–1667
SOURCE A1
The Parliamentary political system
For copyright reasons, this resource cannot be reproduced here.
Source (image): J Morrill (ed), The Oxford Illustrated History of Tudor and Stuart Britain, British Library E 1533 (Oxford:
Oxford University Press, 1996), p 368.
SOURCE A2
The parliamentary system
Parliament was a trinity of monarch, lords, and commons.
For copyright reasons, this resource cannot be reproduced here.
Source (adapted): C Campbell & R Childs, England 1558–1667, ‘NCEA Level 3 Student Topic Notes’ (Auckland:
Pearson Education, 2006), p 19.
3
SOURCE B1
King Charles I speech at his trial 1649
I would know by what power I am called hither ... I would know by what authority ...
For copyright reasons, these resources cannot be reproduced here.
... before sentence be given, that I may be heard ... before the Lords and Commons.
Source: The Constitution Society, September 2005, http://www.constitution.org/primarysources/charles.html
Source (image): http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/ca/King_Charles_I_by_
Gerrit_van_Honthorst.jpg
SOURCE B2
Judge John Bradshaw’s response
There is a contract and a bargain made between the King and ...
For copyright reasons, these resources cannot be reproduced here.
... and disown us, the Court needed not to have heard you one word.
Source: The Constitution Society, September 2005, http://www.constitution.org/primarysources/charles.html
Source (image): http://www.profimedia.si/picture/portrait-john-bradshaw-english-judge-president-high/0106527194/.
4
SOURCE C1
Archbishop Laud’s instructions
For copyright reasons, this resource cannot be reproduced here.
Archbishop Laud is seen (on the left) as preventing extempore prayer and free preaching and as being,
as one critic put it, “the little thief crept in by the window, to open the door for the Pope and his
cohorts” (right).
Top: Where Popery and Innovation doe begin, There Treason will by degrees come in.
Left panel:
Right panel:
Speech scrolls: only Canonical prayers
no afternoon sermons
Speech scrolls: Estote proditores (Latin – Be traitors)
Betraye your Country
Left side: Bishops – So we desire it
Left side: The Pope
Right side: Citizens – Then no Bishops
Right side: Jesuit, Fryer, and Papist
Bottom: If they had ruled still, where had we been? God keepe us from Prelates, Popish Prelates.
Source: J Morrill (ed), The Oxford Illustrated History of Tudor and Stuart Britain, British Museum BMC 220 (Oxford:
Oxford University Press, 1996), p 369.
5
SOURCE C2
The sentence of Archbishop Laud being executed on Prynne, Burton and Bastwick
30 June 1637
Dr Bastwick spoke first, and (among other things) said, had he a thousand ...
For copyright reasons, this resource cannot be reproduced here.
... went down; but being called up again he cut it quite off.
Source (adapted): J Rushworth, Historical Collections Volume Two, Abridged edition, 1706, p 293.
6
SOURCE D
The Newton Enclosure Rebellion 1607
On 8 June 1607 the tiny hamlet of Newton in Northamptonshire was the site ...
For copyright reasons, these resources cannot be reproduced here.
Text on the gravestone:
NEWTON REBELLION
8th June 1607
This stone commemorates the Newton
Rebellion of 8th June 1607.
During this uprising over 40
Northamptonshire villagers are
recorded to have been slain whilst
protesting against the enclosure of
common land by local landowners.
May their souls rest in peace.
... of the Newton Rebellion was identified more precisely, and a commemorative memorial stone
placed in St Faith’s Churchyard, Newton.
Source (adapted): Newton Rebels Local History Group, Newton, England,
www.newtonrebels.org.uk/rebels/history.htm
Source (image): http://liberalengland.blogspot.co.nz/2009/06/j-l-carr-and-st-faiths-newton-in.html
7
SOURCE E
Letter concerning the assassination of the Duke of Buckingham
To Queen Henrietta Maria
Saturday, 23rd August, 1628
Madam,
I am to trouble your Grace, with a most lamentable relation. This day
For copyright reasons, these resources cannot be reproduced here.
... I thought it my bounden duty to let your Majesty have the first intelligence of it, by the hand of,
Your sorrowful servant, Dudley Lord Carleton
Dudley Lord Carleton (1573–1632). At the time he was Viscount Dorchester, a
privy councillor ...
... death of Buckingham, he was named Secretary of State.
Source (adapted): A F Scott, Everyone a Witness: The Stuart Age (Hampshire: White Lion Publishers, 1974).
8
SOURCE F
The Armada Portrait of Queen Elizabeth I
For copyright reasons, this resource cannot be reproduced here.
George Gower (c. 1540–1596) was appointed to the position of Serjeant Painter to Queen Elizabeth I
in 1581. Gower painted this work in 1588 to commemorate the defeat of the Spanish Armada.
Source: P Padfield, Armada, (London: Victor Gollanez, 1988), p 167.
9
TOPIC TWO: NEW ZEALAND IN THE
NINETEENTH CENTURY
SOURCE A
The distribution of banks between 1870 and 1900
For copyright reasons, this resource cannot be reproduced here.
Source (adapted): M McKinnon (ed), Bateman New Zealand Historical Atlas (Auckland: David Bateman, 1997), plate 56.
10
SOURCE B
Hone Heke and the cutting down of the British flagpole at Kororareka in 1844.
SOURCE B1
New Zealander newspaper correspondent
On Thursday, the 4th July, 1844, the Chief Hone Heke of the Nga Puhi tribe, with ...
For copyright reasons, this resource cannot be reproduced here.
... the flag-staff was, because they said it prevented American vessels from coming into the harbour.
Source (adapted): New Zealander vol 1, Issue 1, (7 June 1845), p 2.
11
SOURCE B2
Father Felice Vaggioli
Because of Governor Fitzroy’s incompetence, European colonists’ greed, and the ...
For copyright reasons, this resource cannot be reproduced here.
... and took away shot used to signal ships’ arrivals in the harbour.
Source (adapted): D F Vaggioli, History of New Zealand and Its Inhabitants (Dunedin: University of Otago Press, 1896)
English translation from Italian, 2000.
12
SOURCE C
Kemp’s Purchase 1848
... even after 1840 Māori did not necessarily enter into land transactions on ...
For copyright reasons, this resource cannot be reproduced here.
... basis that their own needs would be met, then found their desires as to the lands they wished to
keep were disregarded.
Source: A Parsonson, ‘The Pursuit of Mana’, W.H. Oliver with B.R. Williams (eds.), The Oxford History of New Zealand
(Auckland: Oxford University Press, 1991), pp 179–180.
13
SOURCE D1
An address by Mr J. Vale of the Victorian Alliance
Mr Vale admitted that New Zealand had done so well in the fight against ...
For copyright reasons, this resource cannot be reproduced here.
... utterance of the voice of the people the terrible liquor traffic should be a thing of the past.
Source: Otago Daily Times, 20 April 1898, p 3.
SOURCE D2
SOURCE D3
For copyright reasons, these resources cannot be reproduced here.
14
SOURCE E
Dinner on board
For copyright reasons, this resource cannot be reproduced here.
Illustration of the interior of a sailing ship.
Source: T Simpson, A Distant Feast, 1890 (Auckland: Random House, 2008), p 62.
15
SOURCE F
Telegram from the Superintendent of Otago to his Excellency the Governor
regarding the proposed abolition of the provinces
Dunedin, 4th October, 1876
My Lord,
I have the honor to acknowledge the receipt, late yesterday, of your telegram ...
For copyright reasons, this resource cannot be reproduced here.
... for your permission to publish, which, I presume, applies to this communication also,
I have, &c., J. Macandrew
(To:) His Excellency the Governor of New Zealand, Wellington.
Source (adapted): Appendix to the Journals of the House of Representatives, 1876 Session I, A–07.