Subaqueous debris flows

.
& Jacques Locat and Homa J. Lee
-?
;61F@6F;
!"<"" @ #" @ #
# #
# #" "#"
9
@ '' 7
;
<" "
# "
) #"
) #"# # # # @444 ) #
DA
@ '..S 3# 3@ 44E " "
# 1" ) + "
#
# 2 DA
@ '.E , # #" J# (# # :) "<"" #" # # # # #
# 44 @ # 7" :# #
D!# @ ''*S 3# @ ''*E + !
D@$44 E J # 1
) D;
) @ 44E@ ; ='$ J ! D3
@ 44E@ !
J :
##F:"
# D: @ ''E +
# " #<"# "
)
A" 1 7" " ''. ) ) I
<" , ) " # " @$44 D @ 44E
!"
#( " ) D:"
#@ ''*S 3# 3@ 44E + " #
"<"" ) "<"" # # #
" ) " ## #@ # ## )@ "
) #"
: 5 8 -"
DE@ &'( ) * +
# A
!
;
-
44$
4
.
& V '
#
"<"" @ @ )# #@ @ ;
##"@ "
"# + "
) # "
"<""
) " #<"#
-?
DF1#6F; FD .@>H@)F@. #.. DF2
0 J
"<"" H (
" J
# # #
"
@ ) (# # @ "@
9
@ :
D'''E "
#
"
) #@ <" #" #
#<"# ) # # "<""
, @ "<"" # # " D1
@ ''4E + @
"# #@ # "
) #"
D RR#"== #E #@ @444 # 7
; DA
@ '..E # J
# "# " " # 8 : "
" #
# #
# # 44 D!# @ ''*E # 4 + "
#@ # #("
@ "
) "
# # "@ @ ) #
# ! # <"
"
"
@ ) # ## "
#
"
) ) " ## # + # )
:"
D''E D9"
'E@ # #) #
) ? D) #)) E D) #) E "
"
) "# # ) :"
D''E J
"<" ) #"
" )# # " #(# "<"" ?
"
D@ E # D E >
"
(@ # #
"@ @ # 1
D''4E ( ) #? "@ "# #@ " "
" # D9"
'E
!# 'W
-? D
& 4$
D -?? #" #
"
# 9
:"
D''E
D -?? ;"
) # "
"<"" " #
) # # "
"
# 4*
-??
.
& V '
6 "<"" D #"
E #
)
##
@ "
# "# "L# " " @ ### "
# # 0 #" ) "
# "<"" ) ##
# #" # ##"
!"
) #
D
E @ #
# D
E@ # D9"
'E ) #
Earthquakes
/
<" # " #" ) " "
"
D@ - @ ''*S 3 /
@ '.*E 8 <""# <" f )
( )D9!E d
h i l "
l d D -?? #
) J# "# 9!
9
3# 3 D44E
!# 'W
-? D
& 4&
") "
# #" <"
" ##
#" #" /
<" # "
" #)## #
"# <"# D@ 7
;
@ A
@ '..E + " )
"
!") 9I
D>
@ 44S 3# @ 44S 3<" @ 44 E <") )
# #
("
"<"" # "# <" # )
" ( # )
#
)
"# #"#)
D2"@ '''E ( #
) @ "
# # " "
!"# "
# # ) "
# # "
Waves
+ #" ")@ # "
"
) "
J
"
-"
# '*' D; @ '.E
!
"# "
#") + "I# #
#
"
#
" DA" @ '.$E "
"
( "#
"
#
" # @ # <") "
# " " 3 /
D'.*E # # # #) # "I# ,
) "# ) ) #
J
)@ # ") D'.$E #
# J# + "# "
" "@ # <"# + "@ #"
#)
#
) #
+##
)@ @
#)## @ "
) "
" # #"
"# D
A" @ '.$ 3 @ 44 E
Tides
9"
##"
I
# # "
D@ A
@ '.E "
##"
#" RR
== D3 0@ '*'@ &&E 0 )@ "
# # I" <"#) "
" #) I# # "
##
"
" # RR #==@ J#) @ #
4.
.
& V '
"
"# J# #
+ "# 2 ) A
D'.E
Sediment accumulation
% ##"" #
" "
) 9
@ ##"" )@ ) #
) "
) #
#" ) <" "@ #L# #
, D@ ) #
)E -
@ # #
) #
"# ) "
) #
#" ) + # " "
? @ #
#" # )@ #
#" #
! 9
%
) D
@ ''& @ '' E
Erosion
3# # #@ "
#)@ # ) 0 "
#"@ # #
) ) #
# #
:
) ) J
D7
@ 44E ) "# "
8 "
#) "<" "
) #"
"
) ) #
"
# D3 @ 44 E
Volcanoes
# "
- ,
"I# $4 )
D1
@ ''E :)
## @ #" -@ " " # @ #) #" "# )
D
#@ '..E # # "
@ " )
" " )
: "
" " ) ,
D''$E # "
Gas and gas hydrates
7 #
"# ) # ) 7 #
# J# ) #
!# 'W
-? D
& 4'
" # "
) #
)
"# # #)## , # #
"# @
#" #" "
) #
"# <"
# )
# #
#" " # ! " )
2) 3 D''E "
# ;"
! "
"# ) "
J" # !" D44E " # ) # #
"
"
# # # #
") "# # )
)
)
# ) #
" !
D;
) @ 44E
Groundwater seepage
!
) D'&&E #"@ # ) @ "
# # "
" "
# RR
) # J
) (# #==
#" "
8
;
D''E " " #
" ""# #" "# "
#) :) D@ !J
;@ '''E ) # ""# " " #
"
"# ## ""# 7
"
" # <"
) ; )@ % D'. E " D@ # ) "
E ) ##"
# J 1 5
) "
, "
"@ % D'. E ) " # 44 J 1 5
)
# - " ##"
D- @ 44E #
J A C
A" !"
)
"
D; 7
@ 44 E
Diapirism
+) ## # " "# 9! #
"
7" :# # # I
#" "
# D:
;"@ '.E #
"#"
#" # #" # ) #@ @ ) #
#) ) @ @ ) "
# ) D! @ 44 E
.
& 4
V '
Human activity
-"#
"# #@ # #" # "
"
)#) #"
) # " # #
# 8 " "# #" ) #" " " @ I"
@ <" )#) "
"
J#
" " #" ! # 1# '&' D! @ '..E !)
D+E '' D%# @ '''E
-??
6
"
@ )@ # " ) + # #
" # #<"
#
) , ) ?
.
.
.
, "
" # "
## " 7
"
) #"
" "# RR#"== " D 9"
'E
"
" "
) !
D;
) @ 44E
9"
' , # #
D9"
' D@ EE # # D;
) @ 44E " (# #
) !
<" ) " ) " D9"
' D@ EE 9
!
@ "# 44 D ; @ 44E
"
#"
"<"" D
"
E@ # ) # # # "L#) # D9"
'$E ,
"
# "
@
+ # " # ) # + #@ "
#
" ) "
9"
'$@ # ##")
" @ #@ ) " " #
#
# ,
-? D
& !# 'W
DE
DE
.44 4
D#E
DE
DE
#
, % )
D -? ? :## "
DE / "
!
# #
# D# D#EE DE !# @ @ DE DE !## )# "
( )
# # DE ## # # " #
# @ @ DE@ DE@ D#E 1
-)
!
" # <"# #)@ " #
# # #
0
# "
@ # " ) D- E :) ) .
& V '
D -?"? !## " D# E #
" ) #
#
@ #"? DE ) " # @ @ "
S
DE # " #
# # D3
" @ ''*S @ 444ES DE
) #" J# # # D@ #
# # /S -"#@ '..E D9@ '.S
@ '.E
-?
1#)6)1. ; 1F)16). FD )>1. DF2.
, #"# )@ @ @ #
##" " #
) "
#
# 9"
'* # " # A C
# D3# @ 44 E # !# '* # ( ) @ ) #
"
) "@ @ :
" "
#
) ) <"
#(# ' " #
#" ) "
) !# 'W
-? !! D -?'? 8
# ) "<"" #
<"# !) ' D# 3% "" #@ - @ / )E
-??
# "
"<""
@ " ""##" D!) !#
@
'.'S 3# @ ''4S !)@ ''S ""
@ ''$E # #
"
# )# )
:
D44E " ;"@ @ ) " "
"# ( #" ## ) "
# #
" "
# ") D@ " A"@ '' S 3#@ ''&E , #@ "
#
" " "
) #
@ " ) "
D3# @
'..E ! @ ) ##" " #
<" # # # #
#
# !@ #)
"
" (
###" " @ ##
3# D'..E@ ) "
J
# #
( D3# 3@ 44E + @ )
# "
") " "" # .
& V '
6
-?? 3 <"
" "
"
)
DQ )S #
) #S %8 " " )S "
"
) #"
S
!" "# )S #S > "
#E
!" "
D( E
#"
"
A
!)
>
>
%
"
%8 "
! D E
! DE
7## )
!
)
0
# DXE
A# DXE
3<" DXE
3<") >
DAE
% "
DAE
!)
0 J# DAE
A
# "
DAE
8
# !)
9
# D E
DAE
A
"
DAE
/# "
DAE
7 "
D)
E DAE
A
"
/
<" ##
C#) DAE
T DAE
/
D1E
-)
"# #"#) D#FE
(
(*
(
0
1
1
,
1
%
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
-??
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
Q
>
9 ,
# "
# ) @ # )@ "
) ( + ) # "# # # "
!# D''*E 3# D''*E : ) 3# D44 E A C
D !# '*E # "# )
) # '
!# 'W
-? !! $
6
-?? / # # " ( ) /
A
)
9 # %" "
"
+##"" #) T 3# #)
C"
C ) " "
:" T @ <") "
3<") @ -??
)!
!
, ) #@ #
"
) " # # ) ) #)
, ) #) #
D#
#"E "
#" <") D0 S 3# @ '..S 3#@ ''&S 3# 3@ 44E <") 4 D@ # # E / 9"
'& # #
) " " ## ## " 9"
'&DE ## <") "# 9"
'&DE <") D0 E ( ?
( (*
0 '
( (*
( # D" 44X "
E@ ( (* @ <" # @ #) 9"
'&DE ) J
#) ##
# , # )
) " <") @ " <") ) " ) #" # ") D3#@ ''&E
:) ) ) 3# D''&E # "
# ) "# ) # )
) # ) + )
3# D'..E ) @ #)) "
@ #
" " @444 #) D E # "S # #
44 ) "
D5 @ 44 E <") # ) 3# D''&E #?
*
.
& V '
D -?(? ! " <") "
<") #
" ( J
#)) ##
D, E # D(E
3# D''&E
$.
0
4$
0
'&
0
$$
'
) " 4 F3
'
) " 4 F3
' A
4$ A
'$
"##") " ) /
D''&E )
# 1
) ) 7"
D44 E !
9
" #
@ - D'&E
" # D @ E # # ( ) ?
'*
D 1F S #" " ##E "
" D " AE ;) ) /< D' E@ @ #
" A ?
-? !! !# 'W
0 &
'&
# /< D'*E ) "# <") ?
0 ( '.
( #)@ " "
/<" D'.E # )
!# D''*E 7" :# #
#
) )# , /< D'.E@ # ) # #
" <") ) # " ###"
) #
# D9"
'.E " # # # # !"# #@ - D'&$E@ " "##") ) !# D''*E ) ) 7" :# - D'&$E
#
"
; " # D 7 E # # "
) #)
"
) ##" ?
3<") :
? (* $*X@ ( .X@ . &
? ( 4X
T DAE
D -?*? > <") ) #
, #" ("
D(* # S ( <" S . )@
( "
# #E
.
.
& V '
7
..
''
##
" )@ "
"
# @ #) D !# @ ''*E
" /< D''E #" ) <") @ " @ " /< D'E D' E
" ) @ ) ") #
#) # # # " # " "
) " ) 9"
'.@ ;# ! )#
# ("
0 #"
<") ) D
/< D'E D' EE@ # # " <") ) + 9"
'. #" /< D''E J
" 7 D
#
E 9
@ " # 4 # D
)# # ("
E@ ) <")
) " " " ) # ( #"
!@ " # 4 #@ # " 44$44 A ) #) &4 &4 A D" /< D'EE
:
@ 0 #) " #
@ " # ) "# " # <" "" ) # # "
# " #
D
# # # # @ #" )E
-?
+G. .)6. FD .@>H@)F@. )>1. DF2.
) "
)# #"
5 D'&4E #) ,
D''&S *E 0 # #
"
) # "<"" @ ) "# # #) " " # "<"" 0 ##
# ##
"
) #@ " @ )
-? ?
>
A "
) # "
"
9"
' + # D1
@ ''4E@ #? " # # 4 D!# @ ''*E %#)@ :
D'''E
# #
# #) #@ " $* F@ )
!# ' W
-?
! & '
#" "# ) ) "# # D9"
'E # )
" ) 3 D'..E ) "
"
) #"
-)
# # " # # #" D
E %# " "
9" )# D9QE "# RR"
"
== # D7"
@ 44 E + "
"
#@ # ) " # # "
) #"
D1
@
''4S 9"
'E
"
@ " # #
" #
") "
# , D@ 7" :#E@ # @ # ( # #
#
@ # # # D5@ '&4S !# @
''*E
-? ?
D !
8# " @ #) #
"# "
"
#
, #@ #
@ #
) " ## ## , # " ") @ #" ) ) " D3#@ ''&E?
DE + ; " D 5@ '&4S -" 7
#@ '''E?
'4
DE + -
#;") " D " A"@ '' E?
N
'
DE + " D 8=;
5"@ '..S 3#@ ''&S ,
@
44E?
'
#@ ) @ #)@ @
1 ; D9"
''E N " <" #) # "
) )
" " /< D'E D'E <"( "
@ "# @ " @ ; " "##") + 9Q " #" " )# ) +) ,# " " ## #" " .
& !
DAE
4
V '
1 "
; "
!
DFE
D -?-? ;
3# D''&E "
) # " ;,17 D
"
# D,
@ 44EE@ )
# " "
D,
44E
, # @ 1
D''4E ) ) "<"" ) " ## #
)?
'
@ "
D
E # #" <" )
@ ) !") A
D'&.E (
<"
#" # @ /< D'E@ D'E@ D'E
# #) #
) J# #
+ # "# # # I" "
# 9
@ #
) D"
E "
" ) " /< D'E " RR==
, # " D"
E@ /< D'E
" " " " RR== /< D'E " <" 9
#) "# # "
# @ # " <" "
# # ) -"# D'.*E "
## "
# 9
# #@ /<
D'E " #
-? ?
#
, #
) D9"
'4E@ # "
#? DE "" # DE - D'E
(
) ) !# ' W
-?
! & D -?/? ) DE ;# ) " / DE A C
@ D#E !
DE # " " 9
6#" D! DE@ # I #
" # # ) 9
6#" #) " #
#
) ,
"# (@ D 9"
'4DEE@ " #" <") D0 E ) 3" D'.E
# # " #
#
"#"
- D'E "
@ " ! )
" DIE /
2
"
D'.E (
"<"" # "
! I "<"" # " )
.
& V '
- D''*E 9"
'4DE " # @ # # " "# "" # , #
"
@ "<"" "# " D9"
'4DEE ) #
<"
#" (
#
? "" # <"
" <"? " H
-?"
#F);C 6FF.
"<"" ) ) "
"
# "" # # "
""
#@ # #
# # "<"" -?"?
, #@ " ) )# D@ )#E@ #
A)# "<"" "@ "
) #"
@ )#) #
" 9" " , #@ ) " 44 @ @ "
+ # " "# #<" # " :
D''.E "
)
@ :
D44E #) ) ) D9"
'E
" @ " <" "
"
D"
A@ 44S A @ 44 E@ ) "" "
-?"?
;
1"
# ) /
2
"
D'.E " ; # C,9380 !"<")@
(# # ) #) "
) " # # Viscous models
,
D44E " "
# # ;,17 # #
#
) "? ;@ -
#;")@ #
) 3# D''&E D@ /< D'EE@ "
#
) ,
D44E ?
-?" # !# '$W
DE
DE
D#E
D -?? / " " ( "
D# E
:
D44E
' ( ?
?
'$
'*
8 " )@ ) @ # ( ##"" .
& V '
" #) D@ @ E
# ) ( " # # ( # #
#
# "" C,9380@ " ") : )
D3# @ ''4@ ''*E@ "
# " " ) #) "# @
" # <" # D
E " #" <" D/
2
"@ '.E?
,
'&
# S ) S # #)S # #S D,E #) # , " ; ;,17
Viscoplastic models
+ @ "
) ) 1
D''4E
" ## @ ) #@ /< D'E #
# 1,!
D !2%/@ # RR== 1
E (J
# # "" # D1
@ ''4E , #
#
" "
0
"
@ 1
D''4E ##" 1,!
#" #) "" " "
)
"# $X #" ) ##" #
) Model using two phase ¯uids with a CFX ¯ow solver
9Q "##") #) "
) "
D7"
@ 44 E , #
@ #") <" #
"
" #
1 "
D;
@ 44E D@ ; " ) ) #)E ) "
# "# #) "# #" "# "# ) "
! #
# ) " # #
D " #
)E # " <" " D7"
44 E? 8 ) D( E?
-?' )A
!
!# '*W
$
,( ( I(
,( ( I( I( ,( ,( ( I( ,( ( '.
D E?
, I
, I I , , I , ''
# ( # ?
( 1 , ,( ( , ,( I( I I( I '4
I #)S # )S ,( , " # @ #)S "
S ##
#@ 1,!@ " ( " #@ " " / ) 7"
D44 E
-?'
)B#).
, # #) "<"" @ #
# #) " ) A C
# D !# '*E # 9"
'* "
# " ( D@ )E@ )@ "
#
) " D@ 'E # "" ) # " #
" #
# L#" #)
-?'?
#!! = C #A
Feature
: " ) D;" @ '.$S 0
3@ ''E ) "
"
# ""
# " "
#@ # ##"
"
"# A#
" " @444 )
;A D!# @ ''*E 3
)
" : :
@ "
@ I# D0
:@ '&4S 7 A
@ '.'E # D''E
" 738%,+ " #"# # ( #) ( "
# ""
# : )
( D9"
'DEE : #) "
# ) "
#
# "
" 4 @ # D7 A
@ '.'E
.
& V '
+
# DE
*
, # DE
D -?? DE 3# : # ") # 9
" :
%
DE % # # D " !2%/E
9
3# D''*E
9
#)@ # )" #
D0
3@ ''E # ) *44 : #)@ " @.44 @ @$ " 4 44* "
"
"
#) ) 7 A
D'.'E 3 ) " " # & 4' " #) 4$ D;" @ '.$S #
@ ''E
Sediment properties
A
" "
# D!# @ ''*S 3# @ ''*E " ' " %# ) D!# @ ''*E D3# @ '..E ) " ) #
) " ") # " $ # " #L# # D, E "
" @ )
#
<" " 4X@ 4 $ F
-?' )A
!
!# '*W
&
6
-?? %# ## @ #@ " "
#
: A
)
C"
3<" DXE
A# DXE
A#) DXE
0
# DXE
3<") DXE
C ;") " D1F E
!F" T DAE
)# #) DAE
L# # , D FE
L# # D E
'
'4
$
$
$4
4 &
44$
44444
4 $
D3 0@ '*'E #L# # " D'.'E
-
Analysis of the mobility
(
#
"
#) (# # "# # H # <"@ # ) D1,!E #
" " # ' J
# " #
" # 44 @ " #) 6
-? ? A
" : A
!)
C,9380
!2%/
9
# +
# A
"
L# #
J" #L#
#L#
!#(# A# #)
T ; # D E
D E , D FE
1 D F E D1F E
DAE
DAE
D E
$4
4444 4
444$
44*
$4
4444 4
4''& *
4 $
4 $
44
$4
+
# @ + #( 3# D''*E
.
.
& 44*
44
4$
V '
44
4$
44
C#) DFE
C#) DFE
, #
9 # DE
$
4 $4 # DE
D -?? DE 9 # ) #) # " #
( " C,9380 DE C#) "
" # " " !2%/ # ) $$4 9
3# D''*E
"
@ "
"
@ #@ $@444 @ # ) #
#) D7 A
@ '.'E %" 9"
'DE " " "" # D"
*44 E 9
" 44 #@ # " $ @ # # #L# D S # #)E # 4 # 4 @ "
#) " " $4 ( # #) (
#) !"# "
#
#) ) 7 A
D'.'E " # # " $4 # "
# #
" 4444 %"" # " C,9380 D9"
'DEE 1,!
D9"
'DEE , #@ " #)
C,9380 " # # 4 4
#" # ) #) " 4 F + # 4 @ @ " # #) " 4 F + ( 4 @ 4 @ #) " $ F # # <" #
!# '*W
-?' )A
!
'
# #
# " @ " /< D'*E@ # $ D!# @ ''*E
" (
# # (@ " ) #) # # # #" "# "
"# "
" D3# @ ''*E
1,! "
# " 9"
'DE #
$$4 9"
'DE # #) $ . F
# $ $4 9
@ # $ 4 " # $ 4 F @ @ #) $ F !"# # "
"
D1
@ ''4S - @ ''*E 0 # $ @ # " ) : # "
"
# " #
@ #@ #) # # " $ F !"# " ) !# D''*E
3# D''*E @ #
( "
#)@ "
D" 4* )E " " # ) # J# "
D@ (# #
) #)E
-?'?
6 0 = Features
A C
D; 7
@ 44 S 3 @ 44S 9"
' E # ! A
#
I" J
3 + ) #
! A
) # 4 $ ) " # ## # ! A
" D; 7
@ 44 E #
#
@ # #
" . " I# D9"
' DEE #
" *44 44 9"
' DE 9
# #
# " 4 # . ) @ # $4 D9"
' DEE ##"
" &@444 )
D1
@ 44 E #" # "
) " "
)
#
#"
"
+
) "" # @ # " "L# ) " #
"" # D3# @ 44 E
4
.
& V '
D -? ? DE ! " ) A C
3
+@ @ "
DE + <" 9
3 D44E
Selecting the parameters
;
" ;,17@ " <"
@ #"
@ ) D E # ) ) + ) 5 D'. E@ " /< D'*E@ ") "
$ 1F @ " ) # ) ; "@ # " ( " )
%" "# # ) 9"
'$ -
@ ##" ) " # ) 9"
'$ ) ( # ) 4 $ ; )@ )
$@444 A " #" 0 " " ) # -
@ " $@444 A #
"
" "
) @ " "
@$44 A
# " ) D
@ /< D'*E D'&EE " "" # ) #
#" " ;,17 #? &4 @ $@444 A@ @444 ( #
4 # @
" ) ;,17 +##
,
D44E@ #" " #"
@ " # @ #
# 9
@ )
" " @444 %" 9"
'*DE # " # 4@ #" "" # # "# + " #
+ # " " +" " <" 4@ " " @444 " <"#) " -?' )A
!
T DAE
!# '*W
9 #@ DE
D -?"? > # D E "" )
" ) 5 D'. E A C
#
%"" #@ DE
9
3# D44 E
!
@ DFE
DE
% DE
DE
D -?'? A
# ) " D
E @ " "" # #
A C
#
9
3# D44 E
) #" " "" # D9"
'*DEE , "
)@ )@ " " 4 " @444
;
# ( # @ "
#) ) J# # ) @ #" " ""
# %" 9"
'&DE ) " 9
" 9"
'&DE@ @ .
& V '
%"" #@ DE
%"" #@ DE
, #@ DE
DE
, @ DE
DE
D -?(? /J# # D E D E "" # D E A C
#
9
3# D44 E
" @ # ) (# J# #" " "" # 8 @ " ) @ " "# "" #
9)@ " "@ 9"
'&DE@ J# #" "
" # D9"
'&DEE %" # ""
# #" # @444 @$44 9
) 9"
'&@ ? # "" #@ <" "# "
) @ @ Mobility analysis
) A C
# #
# " ? @444 @
&4 @ 4 @ $@444 A@ 4@ @444
9
"
) @ " ;,17 D,
@ 44E
, "
)@ " # A C
# #" #
) # " 1 D 9"
''E @ # " D
E@ ;) D
9"
''E
#) 9"
'.DE #)
# ) ;,17 # " " $ F ) " @444 -?' )A
!
# DE
DE
# DE
C#) DFE
0
DE
!# '*W
# DE
DE
D -?*? /" DE #) DE "
A C
#
9
3# D44 E
D9"
'.DEE #
"
) " # # " *@444 D"
#
E +
@
#) ) ) " # "
.@444 + #@ # # ( # D E &. " D9"
'.DEE ( # " 4 " #" " ( # ) 0 " ;,17 @ " #
"
( # # ) $ " , ) "# D9"
''E + ) D@ 1
@ ''4E@ # @ ##
# " "
") #
# @ " "# D9"
''DEE 9
##
@ ) D@ # "# ##
#E -
@ ##
" $ F @
" 4&$ F , "
)@ # "" #@ " " ) @ <"
" )@ # "
# #@ ( # " .
& V '
+##
DF E
#) DFE
9
: DE
DE
9
: DE
DE
D -?-? C#) DE ##
DE # 9"
'* A C
#
9
3# D44 E
-?(
.@>H@)F@. )>1. DF2. +<1. ; F;.)H@);).
0 # #<" DA
)@ ''S 3# @ '''S 3# !#]@ 44E "
" "<""
" D3#
:
@ 44S :
0
@ 44S :#+ @ 444E 9
@
+# >!+@ ; D''E 4
"
@444 *4X # , )
@ "# 7" :#@ ) J
# D! @ 44 S 8
@ 44S T" @ 44E 0 #
" D@ J# "# E@ # "#"
@
J
# "
# @ # #"# #
+ @ # # " "
) "
) # "#"
#"
-?(?
.
& $ 3
,
"
<"
#@ (
) ) 9
D''E :) # ) " 9 D''&E "
" ) " "
D3
" @ 44S -"
@ 44 E C
D'. E ( " ##"
# , # #
) <"?
S I
'
!# '&W
-?( .
& 3
&
$
# ##"
# ) D@ # # @ RR
== 9
#E S D
E @ ) ) S I "
) # ) 4 D E D E + # )
3
" D44E -"
D44 E # D 3
" @ 44E@ ) D E@ "
#"
?
'
, ) " #
@ ) # "# ) " D E " ?
' + I
" <"#) # # " D3#@ 44E@ #
# " <"
" #<"
# " # #
#
) 9
@ #)
# ( " #
) % " <"
#" # #@ @ , #@
<"#) L#" "@ # #
) ) "#) @ ) 3 D'''E
J
3 +
9
# @ # # <"# " # #@ ) ) "
#
D@ "
@ @ E # # ##
" !@ #@ ) ) "
" :"# J
<"
#
3
" D44E # " # "
#<"# # "
9"
'4 !"# # #
# @ #@ "@ @
! # " -"+
"
) ) P D44E 9
-"
+
@ ## ) " ; "
#
# )
) # # "
"
) )
# ) ##
#
# ) !# ##"
" )
@ #<"# "#
, )= " #" " "# *
.
& V '
#
# " )
#
"
)@ )# "
)@ @ / ##
#
#
"
7
# #
#
#
/ "
)
/ ## #
#
"
C#)
%"" #
" H
# ##
#
#
#
/ "
)
D -?/? % #"
"
9
3
" D44E
!# '&W
-?( .
& 3
&
&
"#"
@ @ ) " #
-?(?
& #<"# # "
) "
) #? 1# +
D'&'E@
!) + D'' E@ A" 1 7" D''.E
Nice, France
# J
1# 9
# '&' C
") ( "
#
"# D! @ '..E # " 4 ( ##"
" " # @ J
#) () " ) @ ")
""
# 4 J
1# ,
"
@
"# " #
"# + " "#
4 # " " !
#
# #" "
)
# "
1#? DE #
"# (
@
#" #
"# #)@ # @ "
#" #) #"
#" "
#
) "
DE "
"
#" " " #" RR
== #@ #" @ "# "
)
#
"# ( ! D'..E # "
# :) "
(
@ #
#(# "
#"
Skagway, Alaska
# # # @ @ # # ##"
!)@ +@ '' @ # "
#
"# I
D
3@ ''*E ##"
"
#"
) ## ) " !"<" "
) "
##"
+ ##
# #
"#
#" "
#" # %
# D'''E " #" ) # "
) "
8
D@
:
@ ''&E " #
) + ""@ @ ) " ( .
.
& V '
Seattle, USA
+ ( ""# "
##"
'.$ " - !@ 0 D2
@ ''E ##"
"
"
^" " " A" !" ##"
"
@ 44@444 " #
# @ #" # <"# #
)
) @ " "
) #"
8 # "" D@ "
E <"
I#@ <" )
-?*
F;@.F;.
!"<"" ) <"@
) # ##?
.
.
) " # " D;@ -
#
;")@ E
/
# " <") #
# " "##")
!@ "<"" #"
# ") J
) #@ #"?
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
# # #" @ @ )
S
"
"
"
# "# S
# )
"
)
" ( # )
#
)
"# #"#)S
) "" D)
ES
) # S
) # # ) #@ # # $44 "
# " #
##" # ")#)S
# # " "
) #"
) ") ##"
) S ) ) "<"" "
"
# ) " "
!# '4W
-?/ 1
'
0 #
@ #
" "<""
# ) <"
(# <" ) ( "
#<"# ) ) " #
## "
"
"
# @ #"# # )@ # #"@ # -?-
E;F2)C)#);6.
#
"<"" " ) )
#
"
) ) ? >! 8L# 1 %
#@
1 !## /
%
# "# @ 9
<"PP# "
#
# ## "
# D9K%1E
) ( #
" ) #" " " "
I# )
-?/
1)D)1);).
;
@ 15 @ %C D44E 7)# # 1 "
## ,? 15 ;
+ A
DE@ . !
D3#"
1 A)# 1 $.E !
C
@ 1 T
;@ %7@ 0
@ !7@ !
#
@ A@ 1
@ +0 D'.E 0"# !"
A ;# &4@ : . -@ /-@ *'* ;@ %7 7
@ 5C D44 E !"
! A
/#
@
" 3 ;#@ .@ /@ **.
;"@ +-@ !@ /@ @ 5: D'.$E : 9@ 7" :# ,?
+- ;"@ 0% 1
1/ ;
DE@ ! D $4E !
C
@ 1 T
;
)@ A@ !@ +@ ;
@ 2@ 3@ %@ 9
@ 9@ -@ -@ 8@ @ %@ 3 D44E !
#? % " ## #)##) ,? 5 3# 5 :
DE@ , 18 D2"
+# 1"
## -
%
#
1 '@ $E 2"
+##@ ;
@ C+@ :
@ 1%@ %
@ A2@ @ -+ D''&E !
) " <"# 9
%
1 .
@ @ $4$
@ -+@ :"
@ @ "
)@ %@ :
@ @ ;
@ 5C@ "
@ %7@
8))@ -0@ :@ A+ D'' E ! ) 9
%
@ C#"
@ ;
" * S@ 1 .
13 7 D $$*$E ;)# A"
")@ /@ 2")@ 9-@ 3"@ A39@ @ 7; D'.$E # "
.& @
"@ &&.
4
.
& V '
@ - 3@ 5+ D''*E '' "<"" "
!)@
+ ,? 2 ! DE@ * @ 0 &
DC @ $&$E ++ ;@ %
"
@ !/ A@ % D44E !" "
) "
#
" ,? 5 3# 5 :
DE@ , 18 D2"
+# 1"
## -
%
# 1 '@ '*E 2"
+##@ ;
"@ A A"@ 5: D'' E 8 ( " " @
@ &$. ""
@ %@ 2
@ 5:@ 3#@ 5 D''$E +) <"P# " #
P " 2" D
I +9/QE 1 .
@ @ &$$ V 9
#W
"@ : 9@ % D''&E D& E ++ ;@
%
@ %@ :#!)@ :5@ -@ 2+ D444E + "" # # 1 . @ '@ 4'*4
;@ 9C@ ,
@ @ /
@ +@ -
@ ;@ ,@ @ ;
)@ A@ 3@ %@ 3@ 9 D44E )#@ #) " " !
,? 5 3#
5 :
DE@ , 18 D2"
+# 1"
## -
%
# 1 '@ 4E
2"
+##@ ;
P@ A@ 3#@ 5@ 3@ -@ 3
"@ ! D44E 3 " -" +
? "
=# #
#P
PP#<" " * =S 1 . 13 13 D .*.E
#@ 5- D'..E 7
# - .
@ -@ $. &4
/
@ 3 2
"@ 2 D'.E I !( D%
$4&@
E 1
7## ,"@ 1
)
/
@ 3 2
"@ 2 D'.E ! ) "<"" ? "
#<"# ,? ) 55 DE@ * 5 0 1 , F D $ &E
-
A" @ >!+
/
@ +@ 1
@ -@ +
@ /!@ @ 5+@ 9@ ,@ -@ -@
2)@ 1-@ 3
@ 5!@ 2@ /3@ !I
"@ -A@ !@ +@ C
@ D''&E 8 "<"" 1
;
! # .& @ (@ '$
9
@ 53@ ;
@ ;@ T@ !-@ 9
#@ 8 D''E :N <" ,? - ; DE@ > 0 &
D '&' E ++ ;@ %
V 9
#W
9@ A D'.E /P
P
#"P =
:!# @
/
@ 3 >
)@ K"P#@ V 9
#W
7"
@ A@ 2@ 5@ 9
@ 9@ ;
)@ A@ ;
@ 2 D44 E !
? !" )# #
##
) . D E
7@ %-@ A
@ ; D'.'E 7
) <"# :
)@ 7" :# *@ "-@ .'
!# '4W
-?/ 1
7
@ -7@ :
@ 1:@ A"@ 2 D44E A)
) :
) ;)
:
!#"
) # " # .@ *@ $$.
-@ :+ D'&E "<"" "
) #"
*@ @ &&$&'
-@ :+ D'&$E # ( *@ "@
. . -@ :+@ 3@ -5@ 3#@ 5 D''*E !"<"" ,( .&
@ @ $'
-@ :+@ 2
@ -+@ :"
)@ 5 D44E +#"# ( A C
? ,# ##
0= A "
1 @ @ . .$.
-@ + D'E ) D. E 9
" 0" C
@ B"
#@
!
V 7
W
-
@ 5% "@ 0+ D'.'E : # @
7" :# *3 F 1@ DE@ *&&*..
-"@ Q 7
#@ :- D'''E : )
" #
.@ " @ -"
@ 8 D44 E 7#<" * =@
1 . 13 %B
1 DA
7 @ ! @ 4E
-"#@ 51 D'.*E + # 1 .
@ @ $*
-"#@ 51 D'..E :
) ## ) )
) * = 0 3
DC @ $E
,
@ 5@ A
@ 7@ 3#@ 5@ 3@ -5 D44E "
# ") "
<"" "
1- -@ (@ '$'
'*.
,
@ %: D''$E I# "
# #" - #H I . @ ''@ '$4.
,
@ %: D''&E )# ,( .@ "@ $'*
5@ !0@ 3#@ 5@ 3
"@ ! D44 E + ) ) #
" (
# ) "
* =@ 1 . 13
%
1 DA
7**@ ! &@ $E
5@ +: D'&4E * * . D$$& E 0- 9
@ 1 T
5@ +: D'. E ,? ;
" ; A
DE@ 0
D $&*E 5 0) M !@ 1 T
2)@ %/ 3@ -5 D''E A# ) )
"
.@ /@ $ 2"@ 92 D'''E 0
( <"( J# . ., -@ "@ .&.*
2
@ 3:@ 7@ :@ ;
"@ 5 D''E !"
A" !"
1- . -@ *@ $&&$'
3@ 0 0@ %C D'*'E D$$ E 5 0) M !@ 1
T
3
@ 7@ @ :@ >
@ % D44E 3 "
) ; ='$ #
,? 5 3# 5 :
DE@
.
& V '
, 18 D2"
+# 1"
## -
%
# 1 '@ $ E 2"
+##@ ;
3@ +@ @ :@ ;@ A@ %@ D'..E ) "
? @ "@ &. 3"@ 5@ %
@ 5:@ %@ A D'.E % K"P# 13 3 ( D%
1 &@ 4$
*E ! 7## ,"@ !
3@ -5 /
@ ; D'.*E % J
) . -@ @ .'$4'
3@ -5@ 3#@ 5@ @ A@ ,
@ 2 0@ 9 D'''E % ) )? +# / @ .@ " @ 4$
3@ -5@ 2)@ %/@ 7
@ 5C@ 3#@ 5 D44E #
# "# "
,? 5 3# 5 :
DE@ , 18 D2"
+# 1"
##
-
%
# 1 '@ $&**E 2"
+##@ ;
3@ -5@ 3#@ 5@ P@ A@ A
@ 5@ :#+@ ;@ 8
@ @ A"@ A@ 0@ 9@
@ A@ ;"
@ / D E !"
,? 1
"
DE@ 1& 2 8 D E
3
"@ !@ C"@ 5@ A#
@ 3@ 3#@ 5@ 3@ -@ 9"
@ % D''*E 7##
#
#
* @ 0 3 3 /3 >5R@S@ ;@ %
3
"@ !@ 3#@ 5@ 3<"@ @ 3@ -5 D44E # # "
,? 5 3# 5
:
DE@ , 18 D2"
+#
1"
## -
%
# 1 '@ $'*&E 2"
+##@
;
3<"@ @ 3#@ 5@ 3
"@ !@ >
@ % D44 E A
) ) !") 9I
#"
* =@ 1 . 1 DA
7*$4@ ! *7@
4E
3#@ 5 D''&E 1
# ( " "# &'( ) 2 3 *3 &
D *4*'E 0
%"
# /
@ +
# !#) /
@ 1 T
3#@ 5 D44E , # ? + # ##
# * .@ *@ $4$
3#@ 5 @ D'..E C#)@ ) @ @ <")
#) 1 . @ "@ &''.4*
3#@ 5 3@ -5 D44E !"
? +# # 1
. @ -@ '
3#@ 5 :
@ 5 D44E , 18 D2"
+# 1"
## -
%
# 1 '@ $ 4 E 2"
+##@ ;
3#@ 5 !#]@ % D44E :" "
)? + I
## @ 5"@ ' &
3#@ 5@ 1
@ -@ !#
"@ 1 D''4E :P )<" "
* > 1 0 - .3 D . '.$$E V 9
#W
!# '4W
-?/ 1
3#@ 5@ !)@ 5A:@ 1
@ +@ -)@ +@ 3@ ;@ 3;@ A@ !#
@ @ ;
"@ 7 D''4E > # N =" )<" #"P "
?
I# +9/Q * S5 1 . 1 DC @
4$E V 9
#W
3#@ 5@ 3@ -5@ 1@ -@ !#@ 0@ #@ D''*E +) ) # : 9@ 7" :# ,?
2 ! DE@ @ 0 D $$$$*4E ++
;@ %
3#@ 5@ 7
@ 5C@ 3@ -@ :)
@ 3@ -"
@ 5/@ 2
@ / D'''E
> " "
) "<"" ,? 1 T DE@
- D & E ++ ;@ %
3#@ 5@ :
@ 9@ 3<"@ @ 3#@ A@ 3
"@ !@ 2
@ 5:@ >
@ %@
@ :@ "#@ : D44E !"
>
!") 9I
@ DK"P#@ E@ ) ** <" ,? 5 3# 5 :
DE@ , 18 D2"
+#
1"
## -
%
# 1 '@ $4'$'E 2"
+##@
;
3#@ 5@ 3@ -5@ 3#@ A@ ,
@ 5 D44 E +) A C
!@
@ # " .@ /@
*'.4
:
@ 3 D''&E : '' !) " 4 )@ "@
.
:
@ 5@ -
J@ A@ !"@ 7@ A
@ 7 D44E /
"<""
) ? #) # )# "#"
. @ D4E
:
@ %7 ;"@ +- D'.E +# @ 7"
:# # .@ "@ *'
:@ 7@ -"@ K5@ ;
"@ D''E "
# "
!
#" "<"" # @
/@ $.$'.
:#+@ ;7@ A
@ 39@ 8
@ 3 D444E !"
)@
>! # .@ '-@ 4*
:"
@ : D''E (# * * 0&
., , 3 1-.-!3 .
3
! D *E /:+71/9@ 7
:
@ 5 0
@ A D44E - D4' E !
C
@ 1 T
:
@ @ 0@ 2Q@ -@ :@ /@ @ A
@ 7 D''.E -)
"<"" . @ /@ .&' :
@ @ /
@ +@ A
@ 7 D'''E /
) ") "<"" "
@ ##) #
.@ " @ &'
:"
@ #@ A D''*E (# J
@ ''@ $&
1
@ -@ 3#@ 5@ !#
@ ; D''4E + # )# "<"" .@ -@ '
1
@ 0%@ :
@ 57@ @ :/ D''E 7 #
- , ,? 0 !#@ -5 3@ .
& V '
# DE@ 2 A++ -7, - ? D>!7! !"
) ;" 44@ . '*E >! 7# !"
)@ %@ C+
1
@ 0%@ :#7@ :@ !
@ % D44 E + A C
"
#@ "
.@ /@ &$'
8=;
@ 5! 5"@ AT D'..E 3
) ) " 1 -@ @ .&&..&
8
@ 3 ;
@ 1+ D''E J# " # ##
) ,,?
#@ "
@ "<"" #) .&
@ -(@ '&&''$
8
@ 3@ !J
@ @ 5I@ A@ +2I@ B@ %)@ 7@ -"
)@ 7 D44E
:"
"
! /#
? !"##" # "
"
" "
* F 1 D%8:@ E
A@ %@ "
@ !/@ "@ : D44 E /
<" "
8%/ ## #
" * =@ 1 . 1&
3 %B
1 DA
7*'.@ ! &7@ &E
A
@ 50@ !
@ +1@ -"
@ 5/ D'..E /O6O . -83
1 D7!+ !# A
'@ &&'E 7# !#) +
#@ ;"
@ 8
A"@ !7@ @ 7@ 9
#@ 50 D'.$E 3<"# " #"
. -@ @ &&&'
A
@ ; )@ /- D''E !"
? " "
)# "
) * - 1 ) ( * , 13 3 + >@RQ6+
A
@ ;@ ;
@ ;@ @ 5:@ ;
)@ 0% D'.E :
) "<"" @ 2 +
@ ;
" .@ /@ $..$'
%#@ +;@ @ %/@ 2"@ /+@ ;
@ ;@ 9@ ,C D'''E " 1
@ '' @ !) . @ '@ 44'4
%@ 5: D'. E !
# @ J
1 5
)
.@ @ &..
!J
@ : ;@ ;+ D'''E 9" " #
? ,#
"
" .@ -@ 4'$4'.
!
)@ @ '&& :
#) :
7#)@ ? $.4
!#@ 0@ 3@ -5@ #@ @ 3#@ 5@ 1@ -@ :#+
"
@ :@ 2)@ 1- D''*E ! # @ "
:
9 @ ''@ '*'&
!@ -;@ !@ %;@ !#
@ 9@ ;"@ 9@ 5"
@ , D'..E * # />3 /O@O D%
1 >;F//%..F4@ *. E /
<"
/
%
# @ >
) ;
)
!@ +5@ ;
@ A@ 3%@ A@ ;
)@ 0% D44 E , # .@ /@ $$**
!")@ 51 A
@ ; D'&.E / "<"" ) )
) ) # * /K F 13 DC @ 4&$4.E
!"@ 1@ #@ A@ 9"#
@ 5A@ :
@ 5@ -@ -@ !I
"@ -A D44E
/J# )
# ) ,? 5 3# 5 :
!# '4W
-?/ 1
$
DE@ , 18 D2"
+# 1"
## -
%
# 1 '@ 4E 2"
+##@ ;
!)@ 5A: !#
@ D'.'E !-T2 -, 0 9-0:
D7! 8( %
@ . E 7# !"
) @ C#"
!)@ 5A: D''E +9/Q? + J
)#
# 6O 0 . 13 N3 3
6SR 53 /OO6 DC @ '*E
@ %@ 0@ A@ :"@ D44E +
##"
"
# J
" ''. A" 1 7" " ,? 5 3# 5
:
DE@ , 18 D2"
+# 1"
## -
%
# 1 '@ ..'E 2"
+##@
;
@ 9@ 9@ A@ 3
"@ !@ 3"@ 5 D'.E % ) #) 13 3 (
D%
1 &@ $ E ! 7## ,"@ !
#@ @ 2)@ 1-@ A
@ 3:@ :#7
@ ;+ D''E : 9 "
#? /# 738%,+ ,, "
# ( ,? A 0
:- 3 DE@ ! * ! D '*E !
C
@
1 T
>
@ %@ 3#@ 5@ 3@ -@ :
@ 9 D44E !") 9I
@ K"P#@ ?
,
## )# # )
.@ *"@ ' 4
C
@ 5 ,+7/ 3 : : !
D'. E ) ?2 ,( * * >1/!8@
A
0
@ 5% :@ 5C D'&4E !" "
: 9@ 1
7" :# . @ *@ 44.
0
@ A@ 3 :- D''E ! * ! D & E !
C
@ 1 T
T"@ +7@ ;
)@ 0%@ !)@ 1@ ;
@ 5%@ 7
@ ! D44E + "
! /#
+ : * F 1 D%8:E