Name:________________11(1) Composition Research Paper
·
Mrs. Kirk
Deductions____________________​MLA Format​ ​and basic requirements
❏ the research portion is a full eight pages-​excluding bibliography, afterward, charts, appendices
(-40 per page)
❏ double-spaced, 12 TNR font, one-inch margins—​no​ extra spaces ​ (-10 or more, see above)
❏ heading, title, and header are correctly formatted
(-1 to -10)
❏ Google Classroom and printed copy submitted on time (-50)
·
​______________50 points: Focus and Organization
(48+) Exceptional
●
●
●
●
●
·
(38- )Adequate
(33- )Inadequate
(29-)Incorrect/Incomplete
​______________75 points: Content and Strength of Argument
(71+) Exceptional
●
●
●
●
●
·
( 47-)Effective
A clear thesis that states an opinion or position guides the paper
Interesting narrative introduction providing focus and conclusion that clinches argument
Sections, paragraphs, and ideas are logically arranged and connected with transitions
Clear focus in each body paragraph (topic sentences) and clear connection to thesis; no
material irrelevant to the thesis is presented
Repetition avoided; like ideas are combined
(64-)-Effective
(56-) Adequate
(49-) Inadequate
The position or opinion is convincing and well-supported
Ideas are explained fully and clearly and advance the argument of the paper
No major questions regarding the topic are left unanswered
Critical thinking is evident. Alternate views or counterarguments are addressed and
conceded or refuted
Writer’s analysis, thoughts, opinions, connections to the topic are clear (NOT simply a
report of the research)
​______________75 points: Use of Research
(71+) Exceptional
●
●
●
●
●
(44-) Incorrect/Incomplete
(64-)-Effective
(56-) Adequate
(49-) Inadequate
(44-) Incorrect/Incomplete
Parenthetical citation of all researched information. Not citing others’ words and ideas is
a form of plagiarism. Omission of quotation marks from direct quotes and insufficient
paraphrase are forms of plagiarism.
Minimum of twelve pieces of research from six sources included
Correct parenthetical citation format according to MLA guidelines. ( Incorrect
parenthetical citations can lead to perceived omissions from bibliography)
Use of research to support ideas and strengthen thesis t​ hroughout​ the paper
Successful integration: embedding or introducing research to boost credibility, providing
commentary or explanation on the research used (TIQCA)
·
​______________50 points: Annotated Bibliography
(48+) Exceptional
●
●
●
●
●
·
( 47-41)Effective
(38- )Adequate
(29-)Incorrect/Incomplete
Includes all sources, a minimum of eight, including a book, website, two periodicals, a
non-traditional source. Not listing one source will result in a D; omission of more than
one source will result in a zero for this section, and possible paper failure.
Source citations follow MLA guidelines
Sources are scholarly and varied and credible
Annotations are clear and complete and show critical thinking (summary, assessment,
reflection)
Format of page is correct (alphabetical, correct spacing and indentation, title)
​______________25 points: Style
(24+) Exceptional
●
●
●
(33- )Inadequate
( 21-)Effective
(19- )Adequate
(16- )Inadequate
(15-)Incorrect/Incomplete
Clear and varied sentences; readable and concise
Precise and vivid word choice
Appropriate, engaging tone
_________________ ​25 points: Mechanics
● Correct grammar, mechanics, punctuation (see errors noted in margins) -______
Score:__________/ 300 = ________________