Why negative interest rates are not a solution for
Japan or the eurozone
16 May 2016
.B?Ê;HEÊI@Ê$;J;HÊƧI$ƨÊB;MÊHIQÊ<??HÊ=IH>O=NCHAÊKO;HNCN;NCP?Ê?;MCHAÊ
Ƨ+ƨÊ@ILÊDOMNÊIP?LÊNBL??ÊS?;LMƙÊQBCF?ÊNB?ÊOLIJ?;HÊ?HNL;FÊ;HEÊƧƨÊ
B;MÊ<??HÊ=IH>O=NCHAÊ+Ê@ILÊDOMNÊIP?LÊIH?ÊS?;LŸÊ#HÊH?CNB?LÊ=;M?Ê=;HÊNB?Ê
L?MOFNMÊ<?ÊM;C>ÊNIÊ<?ÊM;NCM@;=NILSŸÊ#HÊNBCMÊ;LNC=F?Ê#Ê?RJF;CHÊQBSÊNB?M?ÊNQIÊ
=?HNL;FÊ<;HEMÊB;P?Ê;=BC?P?>Ê@;LÊF?MMÊMO==?MMÊNB;HÊ?CNB?LÊNB?Ê/-Ê ?>?L;FÊ
,?M?LP?ÊƧ ?>ƨÊILÊNB?Ê;HEÊI@ÊHAF;H>ÊƧIƨŸÊ#Ê;FMIÊMJ?FFÊIONÊQBSÊNB?Ê
H?A;NCP?ÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?ÊJIFC=C?MÊJOLMO?>Ê<SÊNB?ÊI$Ê;H>ÊNB?ÊÊ;L?ÊHINÊ
;ÊMIFONCIHÊNIÊNB?ÊJLI<F?GMÊI@ÊNB?Ê$;J;H?M?Ê;H>Ê?OLITIH?Ê?=IHIGC?MŸ
John Greenwood
BC?@Ê=IHIGCMNƙÊ#HP?M=IÊ&N>Ÿ
Two types of quantitative easing (QE) implemented
CAOL?ÊƂÊ
Two types of QE operation
Central bank
?>?L;FÊ,?M?LP?Ê
;HEÊI@ÊHAF;H>Ê
;HEÊI@Ê$;J;HÊ
ÊÊOLI;L?;Ê(;NCIH;FÊÊ
?HNL;FÊ;HEM
Ê Ê Ê
Ê
Targeted securities
Holders
';CHFSÊFIHA>;N?>Ê/-Ê.L?;MOLC?MƛÊÊ
MIG?Ê.CFFMÊ
(IH;HEMÊ
'ILNA;A?Ê;=E?>ÊM?=OLCNC?MÊ
(IH;HEMÊ
&
Ê IHAÊ>;N?>Ê!CFNMÊÊ
(IH;HEM
ÊIGG?L=C;FÊJ;J?LÊ
(IH;HEMÊ
$!MƙÊ CH;H=?Ê<CFFMÊÊ
;HEMÊ
. MƙÊ$,#.MÊ
(IH;HEMÊ
-IP?L?CAHÊ>?<NÊ
;HEMÊ
ILJIL;N?Ê<IH>MÊƧ@LIGÊ$OH?ÊƃƁƂƇƨÊ
(IH;HEM
GIHAÊNB?ÊG;DILÊ>?P?FIJ?>Ê?=IHIGC?MÊƧ/-ƙÊ/%ƙÊNB?Ê?OLITIH?Ê;H>Ê$;J;HƨÊNQIÊ>C@@?L?HNÊ
NSJ?MÊI@Ê+ÊB;P?Ê<??HÊ=IH>O=N?>ÊCHÊL?=?HNÊS?;LMŸ
.B?Ê+ÊIJ?L;NCIHMÊ=IH>O=N?>Ê<SÊNB?Ê ?>Ê;H>ÊNB?ÊIÊB;P?ÊF;LA?FSÊ<??HÊMO==?MM@OFÊ
<?=;OM?ÊƧƂƨÊNB?SÊQ?L?ÊN;LA?N?>Ê;NÊNB?ÊJOL=B;M?ÊI@ÊM?=OLCNC?MÊ@LIGÊHIH<;HEMƙÊƧƃƨÊNB?SÊ
NB?L?@IL?ÊCH=L?;M?>ÊNB?ÊMNI=EÊI@ÊGIH?SÊILÊJOL=B;MCHAÊJIQ?LÊB?F>Ê<SÊ@CLGMÊ;H>ÊBIOM?BIF>MÊ
>CL?=NFSƙÊ;H>ÊƧƄƨÊQ?L?Ê=IHMCMN?HNÊQCNBÊ;ÊL?>O=NCIHÊCHÊJLCP;N?ÊM?=NILÊF?P?L;A?Ÿ
SÊ=IHNL;MNƙÊNB?Ê+ÊIJ?L;NCIHMÊ=IH>O=N?>Ê<SÊNB?ÊI$Ê;H>ÊNB?ÊÊB;P?ÊB;>ÊGO=BÊF?MMÊ
MO==?MMÊ<?=;OM?ÊƧƂƨÊNB?SÊQ?L?ÊN;LA?N?>ÊF;LA?FSÊ;NÊNB?ÊJOL=B;M?ÊI@ÊM?=OLCNC?MÊ@LIGÊ<;HEMƙÊ;H>Ê
;MÊ;ÊL?MOFNƙÊƧƃƨÊNB?SÊ>C>ÊHINÊCH=L?;M?ÊNB?ÊMNI=EÊI@ÊGIH?SÊILÊJOL=B;MCHAÊJIQ?LÊB?F>Ê<SÊ@CLGMÊ
;H>ÊBIOM?BIF>MƙÊ;H>ÊƧƄƨÊQ?L?ÊHINÊ=IHMCMN?HNÊQCNBÊ;HSÊL?>O=NCIHÊCHÊJLCP;N?ÊM?=NILÊF?P?L;A?Ÿ
.IÊL?MNIL?Ê?=IHIGC=ÊALIQNBÊ;H>ÊL;CM?ÊCH@F;NCIHÊ=FIM?LÊNIÊNB?ÊN;LA?NÊ;L?;ÊI@ÊƃžÊCHÊ<INBÊ
$;J;HÊ;H>ÊNB?ÊOLI;L?;ƙÊJIFC=SG;E?LMÊH??>ÊNIÊ;=BC?P?ÊNQIÊM?NMÊI@ÊL?MOFNMŸÊ CLMNÊ
NB?SÊH??>ÊNIÊ?H=IOL;A?Ê;H>Ê?HMOL?ÊNB?ÊL?J;CLÊI@ÊJLCP;N?ÊM?=NILÊ<;F;H=?ÊMB??NMÊMCH=?Ê
MJ?H>CHAÊQCFFÊHINÊL?MOG?ÊHILG;FÊILÊJIN?HNC;FÊALIQNBÊL;N?MÊOHF?MMÊ?R=?MMÊF?P?L;A?ÊCMÊ
?FCGCH;N?>ŸÊ-?=IH>ƙÊNB?Ê?=IHIGC?MÊH??>ÊNIÊ<?ÊL?FCKO?@C?>ƙÊILÊJLIPC>?>ÊQCNBÊ;>>CNCIH;FÊ
JOL=B;MCHAÊJIQ?LÊ<ONÊQCNBIONÊ;>>CHAÊNIÊF?P?L;A?Ÿ
1BSÊH?A;NCP?ÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?MÊ;L?ÊHINÊ;ÊMIFONCIHÊ@ILÊ$;J;HÊILÊNB?Ê?OLITIH?ÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊƂ
.B?L?Ê;L?ÊNQIÊLOF?MÊ@ILÊ=?HNL;FÊ<;HEMÊNIÊ
@IFFIQÊQB?HÊ>?MCAHCHAÊ;Ê+ÊJLIAL;GG?Ÿ
CLMNƙÊNB?Ê=?HNL;FÊ<;HEÊMBIOF>ÊIHFSÊ<OSÊ
M?=OLCNC?MÊ@LIGÊHIH<;HEMŸÊ.B?ÊL?;MIHÊCMÊ
NB;NÊNB?ÊJLCG;LSÊJOLJIM?ÊI@Ê>ICHAÊ+ÊCMÊÊILÊ
MBIOF>Ê<?ÊÊNIÊ?RJ;H>ÊNB?ÊGIH?SÊMOJJFSŸÊ
#@ÊNB?Ê=?HNL;FÊ<;HEÊ<OSMÊM?=OLCNC?MÊ@LIGÊ
<;HEMƙÊNB?L?Ê=;HÊ<?ÊHIÊ;MMOL;H=?ÊNB;NÊ
NB?ÊGIH?SÊMOJJFSÊQCFFÊCH=L?;M?ŸÊ"IQ?P?LƙÊ
C@ÊCNÊ<OSMÊM?=OLCNC?MÊ@LIGÊHIH<;HEMƙÊNBCMÊ
AO;L;HN??MÊNB;NÊH?QÊ>?JIMCNMÊQCFFÊ<?Ê
=L?;N?>ƙÊ?RJ;H>CHAÊNB?ÊGIH?SÊMOJJFSŸÊ
)@Ê=IOLM?ƙÊC@Ê@CLGMÊILÊBIOM?BIF>MÊ;L?Ê
>?F?P?L;ACHAÊƧL?J;SCHAÊ>?<NƨƙÊNB?Ê=?HNL;FÊ
<;HEÊG;SÊH??>ÊNIÊ=IH>O=NÊ?P?HÊF;LA?LÊM=;F?Ê
;MM?NÊJOL=B;M?MÊNIÊ=IOHN?LÊ;HSÊL?>O=NCIHÊI@Ê
>?JIMCNMÊ>O?ÊNIÊNB?ÊL?J;SG?HNÊI@Ê>?<NŸ
A well designed asset purchase plan
CAOL?ÊƃÊ
Liquidity-enhancing QE
MM?NM
&C;<CFCNC?M
Central Bank
ƂŸ
Government securities (+)
ƄŸ Reserve deposits of banks (+)
Commercial bank balance sheets
ƄŸ
Reserve deposits at
central bank (+)
0;OFNÊ=;MBÊƧHIN?MÊ;H>Ê=ICHMƨ
&I;HMÊ;H>ÊCHP?MNG?HNM
ƃŸ Deposits (+)
(?NÊQILNB
Balance sheets of non-bank public
-?=IH>ƙÊNB?Ê=?HNL;FÊ<;HEÊMBIOF>Ê<OSÊIHFSÊ
FIHAN?LGÊM?=OLCNC?MŸÊ.BCMÊCMÊIHFSÊJ;LNFSÊNIÊ
<LCHAÊ>IQHÊSC?F>MÊ;NÊNB?ÊFIHA?LÊ?H>ÊI@ÊNB?Ê
=OLP?ÊƧ@F;NN?HCHAÊNB?ÊSC?F>Ê=OLP?ƂƨŸÊ'IL?Ê
CGJILN;HNFSÊCNÊG?;HMÊNB?Ê=?HNL;FÊ<;HE¤MÊ
JILN@IFCIÊCMÊHINÊ?LI>?>Ê<SÊM?FFCHAÊILÊLOHHCHAÊ
>IQHÊCNMÊBIF>CHAMŸÊMÊ;ÊL?MOFNÊNB?ÊPIFOG?Ê
I@Ê@OH>MÊCHD?=N?>ÊCHNIÊNB?Ê?=IHIGSÊ=;HÊ
L?G;CHÊMN;<F?Ê@ILÊ;ÊFIHAÊJ?LCI>ÊI@ÊNCG?Ÿ
.B?ÊI$ÊB;MÊL?J?;N?>FSÊ<LIE?HÊ<INBÊ
NB?M?ÊLOF?MƛÊNB?ÊÊB;MÊGIMNFSÊPCIF;N?>Ê
NB?Ê@CLMNÊLOF?ŸÊSÊ=IHNL;MNƙÊQB?HÊNB?ÊIÊ
;HHIOH=?>ÊCNMÊ+ÊJLIAL;GG?ÊCHÊ ?<LO;LSÊ
ƃƁƁƊÊCNÊM;C>Ê?RJFC=CNFSÊNB;NÊNB?SÊQIOF>Ê<OSÊ
ACFNMÊQCNBÊFIHA?LÊG;NOLCNC?MÊƧƂƁƂƆÊS?;LMƨÊ
JL?=CM?FSÊMIÊNB;NÊNB?M?ÊJOL=B;M?MÊQIOF>Ê<?Ê
@LIGÊHIH<;HEMŸÊ#HÊ>ICHAÊMIÊCNÊAO;L;HN??>Ê
NB?ÊMO==?MMÊI@ÊCNMÊJLIAL;GG?ŸÊ¡.B?Ê;CGÊ
I@ÊNB?ÊJIFC=SÊQ;MÊNIÊCHD?=NÊGIH?SÊCHNIÊ
NB?Ê?=IHIGSÊCHÊIL>?LÊNIÊ<IIMNÊHIGCH;FÊ
MJ?H>CHAÊ;H>ÊNBOMÊB?FJÊ;=BC?P?ÊNB?ÊƃžÊ
CH@F;NCIHÊN;LA?NŸ¢ÊƧIÊ+O;LN?LFSÊOFF?NCHÊ
+ƄÊƃƁƂƂƨŸ
Ƃ
Ê Ê';HSÊ=IGG?HN;NILMƙÊCH=FO>CHAÊI@@C=C;FMÊ
;NÊNB?ÊI$Ê;H>ÊƙÊGCMN;E?HFSÊ<?FC?P?Ê
NB;NÊNB?ÊJLCG;LSÊJOLJIM?ÊI@Ê+ÊCMÊNIÊ
FIQ?LÊFIHAN?LGÊL;N?MŸ
M3
increases
;HEÊHIN?MÊ;H>Ê=ICHM
2. Deposits (+)
1. Government securities (-)
)NB?LÊ;MM?NM
&I;HMÊ@LIGÊ<;HEM
IH>ÊCMMO?M
(?NÊQILNB
-IOL=?ƚÊ#HP?M=IƙÊ@ILÊCFFOMNL;NCP?ÊJOLJIM?MÊIHFSŸ
.IÊ?RJF;CHÊNB?Ê>C@@?L?H=?Ê<?NQ??HÊNB?ÊIÊƧILÊ ?>ƨÊIJ?L;NCIHMÊIHÊNB?ÊIH?ÊB;H>Ê;H>Ê
NB?ÊI$ÊƧILÊƨÊIJ?L;NCIHMÊIHÊNB?ÊINB?LƙÊCNÊCMÊB?FJ@OFÊNIÊL?PC?QÊNB?ÊCGJ;=NÊI@ÊNB?CLÊ+Ê
NL;HM;=NCIHMÊIHÊNB?Ê<;F;H=?ÊMB??NMÊI@ÊNB?Ê<;HEMÊ;H>ÊNB?ÊHIH<;HEÊJO<FC=Ÿ
.B?ÊHOG<?LMÊ;<IP?Ê;H>Ê<?FIQÊL?F;N?ÊNIÊNB?ÊJ;CL?>ÊNL;HM;=NCIHMÊM?NÊIONÊCHÊNB?Ê.@ILGÊ
<;F;H=?ÊMB??NMÊ;<IP?ŸÊ
ƂŸ .
Ê B?Ê=?HNL;FÊ<;HEÊJOL=B;M?MÊAIP?LHG?HNÊM?=OLCNC?MÊ@LIGÊHIH<;HEÊ?HNCNC?MŸÊ(IH
<;HEÊ?HNCNC?MÊƧ?ŸAŸÊCHMOL;H=?Ê=IGJ;HC?MƙÊJ?HMCIHÊ@OH>MƙÊCH>CPC>O;FMƙÊILÊ@IL?CAH?LMƨ
M?FFÊAIP?LHG?HNÊM?=OLCNC?MÊNIÊNB?Ê=?HNL;FÊ<;HEŸ
ƃŸ .
Ê B?ÊM?FF?LMÊL?=?CP?ÊH?QÊ>?JIMCNMÊ@LIGÊNB?Ê=?HNL;FÊ<;HEÊCHÊM?NNF?G?HNÊI@ÊNB?CLÊM;F?Ÿ
.B?ÊM?FF?LMÊ>?JIMCNÊNB?CLÊH?QFSÊ;=KOCL?>Ê@OH>MÊCHÊ=IGG?L=C;FÊ<;HEÊ>?JIMCNÊ;==IOHNMŸ
ƄŸ .
Ê B?Ê<;HEMÊ>?JIMCNÊNB?ÊJ;SG?HNÊ>L;@NMÊNB?SÊL?=?CP?Ê@LIGÊNB?ÊM?FF?LMÊI@ÊAIP?LHG?HN
M?=OLCNC?MÊQCNBÊNB?Ê=?HNL;FÊ<;HEŸÊ;HEM¤ÊBIF>CHAMÊI@Ê>?JIMCNMÊƧL?M?LP?MƨÊ;NÊNB?
=?HNL;FÊ<;HEÊ;L?ÊCH=L?;M?>Ê<SÊ;HÊ;GIOHNÊQBC=BÊ?R;=NFSÊG;N=B?MÊNB?Ê=?HNL;FÊ<;HE¤M
CHCNC;FÊJOL=B;M?Ÿ
(IN?ÊNB;NÊ;@N?LÊNB?M?ÊNL;HM;=NCIHMÊ<INBÊMC>?MÊI@ÊNB?Ê=?HNL;FÊ;H>Ê=IGG?L=C;FÊ<;HEM¤Ê
<;F;H=?ÊMB??NMÊB;P?Ê?RJ;H>?>ƙÊQCNBÊCH=L?;M?MÊCHÊ;MM?NMÊG;N=B?>Ê<SÊCH=L?;M?MÊCHÊ
FC;<CFCNC?MƙÊ;H>Ê=LO=C;FFSƙÊNB?ÊGIH?SÊMOJJFSÊƧ?ŸAŸÊ'ƃƙÊ'ƄÊILÊ'ƅƨÊB?F>Ê<SÊNB?ÊHIH<;HEÊ
JO<FC=ÊB;MÊ?RJ;H>?>ŸÊFNBIOABÊNB?Ê<;F;H=?ÊMB??NMÊI@ÊNB?ÊHIH<;HEÊJO<FC=ÊB;P?ÊHINÊ
CH=L?;M?>ÊÊNB?SÊB;P?Ê<?=IG?ÊGIL?ÊFCKOC>ƙÊ;MÊAIP?LHG?HNÊM?=OLCNC?MÊB;P?Ê<??HÊL?JF;=?>Ê
QCNBÊH?QÊ>?JIMCNMŸÊ.B?ÊE?SÊJICHNÊ;<IONÊNBCMÊM?LC?MÊI@ÊNL;HM;=NCIHMÊCMÊNB;NÊNB?ÊGIH?SÊCHÊ
NB?ÊB;H>MÊI@ÊNB?ÊHIH<;HEÊJO<FC=ÊB;MÊHIQÊCH=L?;M?>ŸÊ!CP?HÊNB;NÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?MÊ;L?Ê;NÊNB?Ê
T?LIÊ<IOH>ƙÊNB?ÊBIF>?LMÊQCFFÊ;FGIMNÊ=?LN;CHFSÊQCMBÊNIÊMJ?H>ÊNB?ÊJLI=??>MÊ?CNB?LÊIHÊH?QÊ
CHP?MNG?HNMÊILÊIHÊ=IHMOGJNCIHƙÊEC=EMN;LNCHAÊNB?ÊJILN@IFCIÊL?<;F;H=CHAÊJLI=?MMŸ
1BSÊH?A;NCP?ÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?MÊ;L?ÊHINÊ;ÊMIFONCIHÊ@ILÊ$;J;HÊILÊNB?Ê?OLITIH?ÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊƃ
An asset swap operation
CAOL?ÊƄÊ
Non-liquidity-enhancing QE
MM?NM
&C;<CFCNC?M
Central Bank
ƂŸ
Government securities (+)
&I;HMÊNIÊ<;HEM
IL?CAHÊ;MM?NM
ƃŸ Reserve deposits of banks (+)
Commercial bank balance sheets
ƃŸ
ƂŸ
Reserve deposits at
central bank (+)
0;OFNÊ=;MBÊƧHIN?MÊ;H>Ê=ICHMƨ
Government securities (-)
&I;HMÊ;H>ÊCHP?MNG?HNM
OMNIG?LÊ>?JIMCNM
(?NÊQILNB
Balance sheets of non-bank public
No change
in M3
;HEÊHIN?MÊ;H>Ê=ICHM
?JIMCNM
!IP?LHG?HNÊM?=OLCNC?M
)NB?LÊ;MM?NM
&I;HMÊ@LIGÊ<;HEM
IH>MÊCMMO?>
(?NÊQILNB
-IOL=?ƚÊ#HP?M=IƙÊ@ILÊCFFOMNL;NCP?ÊJOLJIM?MÊIHFSŸ
(?RNÊ=IHMC>?LÊNB?Ê?@@?=NMÊI@Ê;HINB?LÊNSJ?ÊI@Ê+ÊMO=BÊ;MÊNB;NÊ=IH>O=N?>Ê<SÊNB?ÊI$ÊILÊ
ƙÊ?CNB?LÊPC;Ê+ÊILÊOH>?LÊNB?ÊFIHAN?LGÊL?@CH;H=CHAÊIJ?L;NCIHÊƧ&.,)ƨÊ;H>ÊN;LA?N?>
&.,)ÊJLIAL;GG?MŸÊ)H=?Ê;A;CHÊNB?ÊHOG<?LMÊB?L?ÊL?F;N?ÊNIÊNB?ÊJ;CL?>ÊNL;HM;=NCIHMÊM?NÊ
IONÊCHÊNB?Ê.@ILGÊ<;F;H=?ÊMB??NMÊ;<IP?Ÿ
ƂŸ .
Ê B?Ê=?HNL;FÊ<;HEÊ<OSMÊAIP?LHG?HNÊILÊINB?LÊM?=OLCNC?MÊ@LIGÊNB?Ê=IGG?L=C;FÊ<;HEMŸ
IGG?L=C;FÊ<;HEÊBIF>CHAMÊI@ÊM?=OLCNC?MÊ>?=FCH?ƛÊ=?HNL;FÊ<;HEÊBIF>CHAMÊCH=L?;M?Ÿ
ƃŸ Ê IGG?L=C;FÊ<;HEMÊL?=?CP?Ê;Ê=L?>CNÊ@LIGÊNB?ÊI$ÊILÊÊ@ILÊNB?CLÊM;F?ÊI@ÊM?=OLCNC?Mƛ
L?M?LP?Ê>?JIMCNMÊI@Ê<;HEMÊ;NÊNB?Ê=?HNL;FÊ<;HEÊCH=L?;M?Ÿ
(IN?ÊNB;NÊ;@N?LÊNB?M?ÊNL;HM;=NCIHMÊNB?Ê=?HNL;FÊ<;HE¤MÊ<;F;H=?ÊMB??NÊB;MÊ?RJ;H>?>ƙÊQCNBÊ
CH=L?;M?MÊCHÊ=?HNL;FÊ<;HEÊ;MM?NMÊG;N=B?>Ê<SÊCH=L?;M?MÊCHÊFC;<CFCNC?MŸÊIGG?L=C;FÊ<;HEMÊ
B;P?ÊG?L?FSÊOH>?LN;E?HÊ;HÊ;MM?NÊMQ;JƛÊNB?SÊHIQÊBIF>ÊF?MMÊAIP?LHG?HNÊM?=OLCNC?MƙÊ
<ONÊGIL?ÊL?M?LP?Ê>?JIMCNMÊ;NÊNB?Ê=?HNL;FÊ<;HEŸÊ"IQ?P?LƙÊIHÊNBCMÊI==;MCIHƙÊNB?Ê<;F;H=?Ê
MB??NMÊI@ÊNB?ÊHIH<;HEMÊ;L?ÊOH;@@?=N?>ŸÊ
.B?ÊE?SÊJICHNÊCMÊNB;NÊNB?ÊGIH?SÊMOJJFSÊƧ'ƃƙÊ'ƄÊILÊ'ƅƨÊILÊJOL=B;MCHAÊJIQ?LÊCHÊNB?Ê
B;H>MÊI@ÊNB?ÊHIH<;HEÊJO<FC=ÊB;MÊHINÊCH=L?;M?>ŸÊ'IL?IP?LƙÊACP?HÊNB?ÊMN;LNCHAÊJICHNÊI@Ê
LCMEÊ;P?LMCIHÊ<SÊNB?Ê<;HEMÊ;H>Ê<SÊ@CLGMÊ;H>ÊBIOM?BIF>MƙÊNB?L?Ê=;HÊ<?ÊHIÊ;MMOL;H=?ÊNB;NÊ
ŸÊ;@N?LÊNB?M?ÊIJ?L;NCIHMÊÊNB?Ê<;HEMÊQCFFÊ?RJ;H>ÊNB?CLÊF?H>CHAÊILÊNB;NÊ;HSÊH?QÊ>?JIMCNM
QCFFÊ<?Ê=L?;N?>ŸÊKO;FFSƙÊH?QÊCHP?MNG?HNÊILÊ=IHMOGJNCIHÊMJ?H>CHAÊCMÊOHFCE?FSÊNIÊ@IFFIQŸ
P?HÊC@Ê<;HEMÊQ?L?ÊNIÊ?RJ;H>ÊNB?CLÊF?H>CHAƙÊNBCMÊQIOF>Ê<?Ê;==IGJ;HC?>Ê<SÊ;ÊJ;L;FF?F
CH=L?;M?ÊCHÊF?P?L;A?Ê<SÊ@CLGMÊILÊBIOM?BIF>MʟÊNB?ÊIJJIMCN?ÊI@ÊNB?Ê<;F;H=?ÊMB??NÊL?J;CL
JLI=?MMÊNB;NÊJIFC=SG;E?LMÊMBIOF>Ê<?ÊM??ECHAÊNIÊ;=BC?P?Ÿ
#HÊMBILNƙÊIHFSÊJOL=B;M?MÊI@ÊM?=OLCNC?MÊ@LIGÊHIH<;HEMÊ;L?Ê=IHMCMN?HNÊQCNBÊ<;F;H=?ÊMB??NÊ
L?J;CLÊ;H>Ê?HB;H=?>ÊFCKOC>CNSÊCHÊNB?ÊB;H>MÊI@Ê@CLGMÊ;H>ÊBIOM?BIF>MŸ
1BSÊH?A;NCP?ÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?MÊ;L?ÊHINÊ;ÊMIFONCIHÊ@ILÊ$;J;HÊILÊNB?Ê?OLITIH?ÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊƄ
Major central banks in Japan and Europe have moved to negative policy rates
CAOL?ÊƅÊ
Negative policy rates
ƃƁƁƈ
ƃƁƁƉ
ƃƁƁƊ
-QCNT?LF;H>
$;J;H
OLITIH?
-Q?>?H
?HG;LE
ƃƁƂƁ
ƃƁƂƂ
ƃƁƂƃ
ƃƁƂƄ
ƃƁƂƅ
ƃƁƂƆ
ƃƁƂƇ
Ƈ
Ɔ
ƅ
Ƅ
ƃ
Ƃ
Ɓ
-IOL=?ƚÊ';=LI<IH>Ê;MÊ;NÊƂƇÊ';SÊƃƁƂƇŸ
OLL?HNFSÊNB?L?Ê;L?Ê@CP?Ê?=IHIGC?MÊ?GJFISCHAÊH?A;NCP?ÊJIFC=SÊL;N?MƚÊ$;J;HƙÊNB?Ê
?OLITIH?ƙÊ;H>ÊNB?ÊNBL??Ê?OLIFCHE?>Ê?=IHIGC?MÊI@Ê?HG;LEƙÊ-QCNT?LF;H>ƙÊ;H>Ê-Q?>?HŸÊ
.B?Ê@CLMNÊG;DILÊ?=IHIGSÊNIÊCGJF?G?HNÊH?A;NCP?ÊL;N?MÊQ;MÊ?HG;LEÊCHÊƃƁƂƃƙÊ@IFFIQ?>Ê
<SÊNB?Ê?OLITIH?ÊCHÊƃƁƂƅŸÊ(?RNÊ-QCNT?LF;H>Ê;H>Ê-Q?>?HÊ@IFFIQ?>ÊMOCNŸÊ.B?HÊCHÊ$;HO;LSÊ
ƃƁƂƇÊNB?ÊI$ÊCHNLI>O=?>ÊH?A;NCP?ÊL;N?MŸ
#HÊ?MM?H=?ƙÊNB?Ê=?HNL;FÊ<;HEMÊI@ÊNB?M?Ê?=IHIGC?MÊ=B;LA?ÊNB?Ê=IGG?L=C;FÊ<;HEMÊ@ILÊL?M?LP?Ê
>?JIMCNMÊB?F>Ê;NÊNB?Ê=?HNL;FÊ<;HEƙÊ;FNBIOABÊCHÊMIG?Ê=;M?MÊIHFSÊ;ÊJ;LNÊI@ÊNB?M?Ê<;F;H=?MÊ;L?Ê
MO<D?=NÊNIÊH?A;NCP?ÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?MÊƧILÊJ?H;FNSÊ=B;LA?MƨŸÊ.B?Ê=IHP?HNCIH;FÊGINCP;NCIHMÊ@ILÊ
NB?ÊJIFC=SÊ;L?ÊNQI@IF>ƚÊ@CLMNƙÊNIÊMNCGOF;N?Ê?=IHIGC=ÊALIQNBÊƧ<;M?>ÊIHÊNB?ÊPC?QÊNB;NÊFIQ?LÊ
HIGCH;FÊL;N?MÊQCFFÊMIG?BIQÊ?H=IOL;A?ÊBCAB?LÊMJ?H>CHAƨƙÊ;H>ÊM?=IH>ÊNIÊ>?N?LÊ=;JCN;FÊ
CH@FIQMÊ;H>Ê=OLL?H=SÊ;JJL?=C;NCIHŸÊ$;J;HÊ;H>ÊNB?Ê?OLITIH?Ê@;FFÊCHNIÊNB?Ê@CLMNÊ=;GJƙÊQBCF?Ê
NB?ÊNQIÊ(IL>C=Ê=IOHNLC?MÊ;H>Ê-QCNT?LF;H>Ê@CNÊNB?ÊM?=IH>ŸÊ.BCMÊG?;HMÊNB;NÊ;FGIMNÊ;ÊKO;LN?LÊ
I@ÊNB?ÊQILF>¤MÊ!*ÊCMÊJLI>O=?>ÊCHÊ?=IHIGC?MÊQCNBÊH?A;NCP?ÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?MŸ
?HNL;FÊ<;HE?LMÊ;JJ?;LÊNIÊ<?FC?P?ÊNB;NÊC@Ê<;HEMÊ@;=?Ê;Ê=B;LA?ÊIHÊNB?CLÊ>?JIMCNMÊ;NÊNB?Ê
=?HNL;FÊ<;HEÊNB?SÊQCFFÊ<?ÊCH>O=?>ÊNIÊBIF>ÊFIQ?LÊL?M?LP?Ê>?JIMCNÊ<;F;H=?MƙÊ;H>ÊMIG?BIQÊ
¡F?H>ÊION¢ÊMIG?ÊI@ÊNBIM?Ê@OH>MŸÊONÊNB?L?Ê;L?ÊNQIÊ@OH>;G?HN;FÊ@;FF;=C?MÊB?L?ŸÊ CLMNƙÊ
<;HEMÊ>IÊHINÊF?H>ÊIONÊL?M?LP?MŸÊ-?=IH>ƙÊNB?ÊNIN;FÊPIFOG?ÊI@ÊL?M?LP?Ê>?JIMCNMÊCMÊM?NÊ<SÊ
NB?Ê=?HNL;FÊ<;HEƙÊHINÊ<SÊNB?Ê=IGG?L=C;FÊ<;HEMŸÊ#@ÊNB?Ê=?HNL;FÊ<;HEÊ<OSMÊGIL?Ê;MM?NMÊƧ?ŸAŸÊ
PC;Ê@IL?CAHÊ?R=B;HA?ÊCHN?LP?HNCIHÊILÊOH>?LÊ;Ê+ÊJLIAL;GG?ƨƙÊNIN;FÊL?M?LP?Ê>?JIMCNMÊQCFFÊ
LCM?ƙÊ;H>Ê=IHP?LM?FSÊC@ÊNB?Ê=?HNL;FÊ<;HEÊM?FFMÊ;MM?NMƙÊNIN;FÊL?M?LP?Ê>?JIMCNMÊQCFFÊ>?=FCH?ŸÊ
MM?NMÊ;H>ÊFC;<CFCNC?MÊGOMNÊG;N=BŸÊFNBIOABÊCH>CPC>O;FÊ<;HEMÊ=;HÊL?>O=?ÊNB?CLÊL?M?LP?Ê
<;F;H=?MƙÊ=IFF?=NCP?FSÊNB?SÊ=;HHINÊL?>O=?ÊNB?Ê;AAL?A;N?ÊL?M?LP?Ê<;F;H=?ŸÊ.B?ÊL?>O=NCIHÊ
CHÊ;HSÊIH?Ê<;HE¤MÊ<;F;H=?MÊƧ?ŸAŸÊNIÊJ;SÊ@ILÊ;ÊM?=OLCNSƨÊQCFFÊ<?ÊG;N=B?>Ê<SÊNB?ÊCH=L?;M?ÊCHÊ
;HINB?L¤MÊƧNB?ÊM?FF?L¤MƨÊ<;F;H=?Ÿ
1BSÊH?A;NCP?ÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?MÊ;L?ÊHINÊ;ÊMIFONCIHÊ@ILÊ$;J;HÊILÊNB?Ê?OLITIH?ÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊƅ
In Switzerland, Sweden and Denmark negative rates result from pegging to the euro
" Ê*,Ê/,)ÊƧ,"-ƨ
%%Ê*,Ê/,)ÊƧ&"-ƨ
-%Ê*,Ê/,)ÊƧ&"-ƨ
CAOL?ÊƆÊ
SEK, DKK and CHF vs EUR
ƃƁƁƁ
ƃƁƁƃ
ƃƁƁƅ
ƃƁƁƇ
ƃƁƁƉ
ƃƁƂƁ
ƃƁƂƃ
ƃƁƂƅ
ƃƁƂƇ
ƂŸƈ
ƂƃŸƁ
ƂŸƇ
ƂƂŸƁ
ƂŸƃƁÊ/,"
?CFCHAÊCGJIM?>ƚ
ƇÊ-?JÊƃƁƂƂÊNI
ƂƆÊ$;HÊƃƁƂƆ
ƂŸƆ
ƂŸƅ
ƂƁŸƁ
ƂŸƄ
ƊŸƁ
ƂŸƃ
ƂŸƂ
ƉŸƁ
ƂŸƁ
-IOL=?ƚÊ';=LI<IH>Ê;MÊ;NÊƂƇÊ';SÊƃƁƂƇŸ
.B?Ê;HCMBÊ%LIH?ÊƧCHÊFCABNÊ<FO?ƨÊCMÊ?RJFC=CNFSÊJ?AA?>ÊNIÊNB?Ê?OLIÊ;NÊ%%ƈŸƅƇÊQCNBÊ;Ê
NL;>CHAÊ<;H>ÊI@ÊƃŸƃƆžÊIHÊ?CNB?LÊMC>?ƙÊQBC=BÊG?;HMÊNB;NÊ?HG;LEÊCGJILNMÊNB?ÊGIH?N;LSÊ
JIFC=SÊI@ÊNB?ÊŸÊ#@ÊNB?L?ÊCMÊ;ÊNBL?;NÊI@Ê%%Ê;JJL?=C;NCIHÊÊ;MÊNB?L?ÊQ;MÊCHÊƃƁƂƃÊ;H>Ê
ƃƁƂƆÊÊNB?HÊ?HG;LEÊGOMNÊ=ONÊCNMÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?MÊ<?FIQÊNBIM?ÊI@ÊNB?ÊŸÊ.BCMÊCMÊCHÊ
?MM?H=?ÊQBSÊ?HG;LEÊ<?=;G?ÊNB?Ê@CLMNÊ=IOHNLSÊCHÊOLIJ?ÊNIÊGIP?ÊNIÊH?A;NCP?ÊL;N?MŸ
#HÊ-Q?>?HÊNB?L?ÊB;MÊ<??HÊ;Ê@FI;NCHAÊ?R=B;HA?ÊL;N?ÊMCH=?ÊƂƊƊƃÊQB?HÊNB?Ê,CEM<;HEÊQ;MÊ
@IL=?>ÊNIÊ<L?;EÊCNMÊ@CR?>ÊJ?AÊQCNBÊNB?Ê>?ONM=B?G;LEŸÊ"IQ?P?LƙÊGIH?N;LSÊJIFC=SÊCMÊ;CG?>Ê
;NÊE??JCHAÊCH@F;NCIHÊ;NÊ;ÊN;LA?N?>ÊƃžƙÊPCLNO;FFSÊNB?ÊM;G?ÊCH@F;NCIHÊN;LA?NÊ;MÊNB?ʤMƙÊ
QBC=BÊG?;HMÊCHÊ?@@?=NÊNB;NÊNB?ÊNQIÊ=OLL?H=C?MÊB;P?ÊNIÊGIP?ÊNIA?NB?LÊCHÊ<LI;>ÊG?;MOL?ŸÊ
.B?L?@IL?ÊG;HSÊCHÊNB?ÊG;LE?NMÊM??ÊNB?Ê-Q?>CMBÊELIH?ÊƧMBIQHÊCHÊAL??HƨÊ;MÊ;Ê>?Ê@;=NIÊ
G;H;A?>Ê?R=B;HA?ÊL;N?ÊL?ACG?ŸÊ LIGÊNB?ÊCH=?JNCIHÊI@ÊNB?ÊMCHAF?Ê=OLL?H=SÊCHÊƂƊƊƊÊNB?Ê
-Q?>CMBÊ=OLL?H=SÊQ;MÊL?F;NCP?FSÊMN;<F?Ê;A;CHMNÊNB?Ê?OLIÊOHNCFÊƃƁƁƉÊQB?HÊCNÊ>?JL?=C;N?>Ê
NIÊƂƂŸƇƆÊCHÊ';L=BÊƃƁƁƊÊ;H>ÊNB?HÊL?=IP?L?>Ê@LIGÊGC>ƃƁƁƊÊ;H>ÊNBLIOABÊƃƁƂƁŸÊ-CH=?Ê
ƃƁƂƂÊNB?Ê-%ÊB;MÊNL;>?>ÊCHÊNB?ÊL;HA?ÊƉŸƄƁƊŸƇƁƙÊ;ÊQC>?LÊL;HA?ÊNB;HÊCHÊƃƁƁƃƁƈƙÊ<ONÊ
HIH?NB?F?MMÊ;ÊNL;>CHAÊL;HA?Ÿ
.B?Ê-QCMMÊ@L;H=ÊB;MÊ;FMIÊB;>ÊNIÊ<?ÊG;H;A?>Ê;A;CHMNÊNB?Ê?OLIŸÊ1BCF?ÊCNÊL?G;CH?>Ê@;CLFSÊ
MN;<F?ÊOHNCFÊƃƁƁƈÊNB?L?ÊQ;MÊFCNNF?ÊJLI<F?GƙÊ<ONÊ;@N?LÊNB?ÊION<L?;EÊI@ÊNB?ÊAFI<;FÊ=LCMCMÊ
CHÊƃƁƁƈƁƉÊNB?Ê" ÊQ;MÊQC>?FSÊPC?Q?>Ê;MÊ;ÊM;@?ÊB;P?HƙÊ;H>Ê;JJL?=C;N?>ÊMNLIHAFSƙÊ
?P?HNO;FFSÊ@IL=CHAÊNB?Ê-QCMMÊ(;NCIH;FÊ;HEÊƧ-(ƨÊNIÊCGJIM?Ê;Ê=?CFCHAÊI@ÊƂŸƃƁÊ?OLIMÊJ?LÊ
" ÊCHÊ-?JN?G<?LÊƃƁƂƂŸÊ"IQ?P?LƙÊQB?HÊNB?ÊÊQ;MÊ=IHN?GJF;NCHAÊNB?Ê;>IJNCIHÊI@Ê+Ê
CHÊF;N?ÊƃƁƂƅÊ;H>ÊNB?Ê?OLIÊMN;LN?>Ê@;FFCHAÊMN??JFSƙÊNB?Ê-(Ê;<;H>IH?>ÊNB?ÊƂŸƃƁÊ=?CFCHAÊIHÊ
$;HO;LSÊƂƆƙÊƃƁƂƆŸ
1BSÊH?A;NCP?ÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?MÊ;L?ÊHINÊ;ÊMIFONCIHÊ@ILÊ$;J;HÊILÊNB?Ê?OLITIH?ÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊƆ
Negative policy rates and expectations of deflation have created
negative bond yields
CAOL?ÊƇÊ
Government benchmark yield curves (Japan,
Sweden, Denmark, Switzerland and Germany)
3?;LM
Ɓ
-QCNT?LF;H>ÊƧƂƁƁƆƃƁƂƇƨ
$;J;HÊƧƂƁƁƆƃƁƂƇƨ
!?LG;HSÊƧƂƁƁƆƃƁƂƇƨ
-Q?>?HÊƧƂƁƁƆƃƁƂƇƨ
?HG;LEÊƧƂƁƁƆƃƁƂƇƨ
ž
Ɔ
ƂƁ
ƂƆ
ƃƁ
ƃƆ
ƃŸƁ
ƂŸƆ
ƂŸƁ
ƁŸƆ
ƁŸƁ
ƁŸƆ
-IOL=?ƚÊ';=LI<IH>Ê;MÊ;NÊƂƇÊ';SÊƃƁƂƇŸ
.B?ÊNL;>CNCIH;FÊILNBI>IRSÊB;MÊ<??HÊNB;NÊC@Ê<;HEMÊCHNLI>O=?>ÊH?A;NCP?ÊL;N?MÊIHÊ>?JIMCNMƙÊ
>?JIMCNILMÊQIOF>ÊMBC@NÊNB?CLÊGIH?SÊ@LIGÊ>?JIMCNMÊCHNIÊJBSMC=;FÊ=;MBŸÊ-IÊ@;LƙÊBIQ?P?LƙÊ
NBCMÊECH>ÊI@ÊF;LA?M=;F?ÊMBC@NÊB;MÊHINÊI==OLL?>ƙÊ;NÊF?;MNÊ;NÊ=OLL?HNÊF?P?FMÊI@ÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?MŸ
(?P?LNB?F?MMƙÊNB?ÊEHI=EIHÊ?@@?=NÊI@ÊH?A;NCP?ÊJIFC=SÊL;N?MƙÊFIQÊCH@F;NCIHÊ?RJ?=N;NCIHMÊ
;H>ÊQ?;EÊ=L?>CNÊ>?G;H>ÊCMÊNB;NÊSC?F>Ê=OLP?MÊB;P?Ê<?=IG?ÊH?A;NCP?Ê@ILÊNB?Ê;@@?=N?>Ê
?=IHIGC?MÊ;NÊNB?ÊMBILNÊ?H>ÊI@ÊNB?Ê=OLP?Ÿ
FMIÊCHÊ?HG;LEÊNB?L?ÊB;MÊ<??HÊNB?ÊL?G;LE;<F?ÊMCNO;NCIHÊI@ÊGILNA;A?ÊBIF>?LMÊ
<?CHAÊ=L?>CN?>ÊQCNBÊCHN?L?MNÊJ;SG?HNMÊ<SÊNB?CLÊ<;HEÊƧ;F<?CNÊI@@M?NÊ<SÊMIG?Ê¡@??M¢ƨŸÊ#HÊ
-QCNT?LF;H>ÊGIMNÊ<;HEMÊB;P?ÊL?MCMN?>ÊJ;MMCHAÊIHÊH?A;NCP?ÊL;N?MÊNIÊNB?CLÊ>?JIMCNILMŸÊ
"IQ?P?LÊIH?Ê<;HEƙÊFN?LH;NCP?Ê;HEÊ-=BQ?CTÊ!ƙÊCMÊ=B;LACHAÊ=FC?HNMÊ@ILÊBIF>CHAÊNB?CLÊ
GIH?SÊIHÊ>?JIMCNŸÊ#HÊ!?LG;HSƙÊCHMOL;H=?Ê=IGJ;HC?MÊ;L?Ê@??FCHAÊNB?ÊJCH=BŸÊ==IL>CHAÊNIÊ
NB?ÊOH>?M<;HEƙÊ¡MIG?Ê5CHMOL;H=?7Ê=IGJ;HC?MÊH??>ÊNIÊA?H?L;N?ÊCHP?MNG?HNÊL?NOLHMÊI@Ê
GIL?ÊNB;HÊƆžÊNIÊMOLPCP?¢ÊƧ1;FFÊ-NL??NÊ$IOLH;FƙÊƃƆÊ';L=BÊƃƁƂƆƨƙÊQBC=BÊCGJFC?MÊM?LCIOMÊ
>IO<NMÊIP?LÊNB?ÊMOMN;CH;<CFCNSÊI@ÊNB?CLÊ<OMCH?MMÊGI>?FMÊCHÊNB?Ê=OLL?HNÊ?HPCLIHG?HNŸÊÊ
MBC@NÊCHNIÊLCMEC?LÊ;MM?NMÊCMÊJL?P?HN?>Ê<SÊ-IFP?H=SÊ##ÊLOF?MÊNB;NÊ;=NÊ;MÊ;ÊG;DILÊ=IHMNL;CHNÊIHÊ
NB?ÊNSJ?MÊI@Ê;MM?NÊNB?SÊ=;HÊ;=KOCL?ŸÊ#HÊ$;J;HÊNB?Ê;>IJNCIHÊI@ÊH?A;NCP?ÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?MÊ;NÊ
NB?Ê<?ACHHCHAÊI@ÊNB?ÊS?;LÊB;MÊ=;OM?>Ê;ÊMJCE?ÊCHÊNB?ÊJLC=?ÊI@ÊƅƁS?;LÊ$!MÊ;MÊCHMOL;H=?Ê
=IGJ;HC?MÊ;H>ÊJ?HMCIHÊ@OH>MÊB;P?ÊMBC@N?>ÊNB?CLÊJILN@IFCIMÊNIÊN;E?ÊIHÊAL?;N?LÊLCMEƙÊCHÊNBCMÊ
=;M?Ê;>>?>Ê>OL;NCIHÊLCMEŸ
1BSÊH?A;NCP?ÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?MÊ;L?ÊHINÊ;ÊMIFONCIHÊ@ILÊ$;J;HÊILÊNB?Ê?OLITIH?ÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊƇ
The failure of the ECB’s LTRO plan, 2011 – 2014
.IN;FÊ;MM?NMÊI@ÊÊƧOLIÊ.(ƙÊ&"-ƨÊ
;HEÊ&I;HMÊNIÊOLIÊL?;Ê,?MC>?HNMÊ
Ƨž3)3ƙÊ,"-ƨ
CAOL?ÊƈÊ
Eurozone: Total assets of ECB and
commercial bank lending
ƃƁƂƁ
ƄŸƃ
ƃƁƂƂ
ƃƁƂƃ
ƃƁƂƄ
ƃƁƂƅ
ƇŸƁ
&.,)MÊ?RJ;H>
Ê<;F;H=?ÊMB??N™
ƄŸƁ
ƅŸƁ
ƃŸƉ
ƃŸƁ
ƃŸƇ
ƁŸƁ
ƃŸƅ
ƃŸƁ
ƃŸƃ
ƃŸƁ
™<ONÊ=IGG?L=C;FÊ<;HE
FI;HMÊ>?=FCH?Ê@LIGÊƀƄž
NIÊH?A;NCP?ÊN?LLCNILS
ƅŸƁ
-IOL=?ƚÊ;N;MNL?;GÊ;MÊ;NÊƂƈÊ)=NI<?LÊƃƁƂƅŸ
1?ÊHIQÊNOLHÊNIÊNB?ÊCGJF?G?HN;NCIHÊI@Ê<;F;H=?ÊMB??NÊ?RJ;HMCIHÊ;H>Ê+ÊIJ?L;NCIHMÊ<SÊ
NB?ÊÊ;H>ÊI$Ÿ
.B?ʤMÊ&.,)ÊJLIAL;GG?ÊCHCNC;N?>ÊCHÊƃƁƂƂƙÊMIIHÊ;@N?LÊ';LCIÊL;ABCÊNIIEÊIP?LÊ;MÊ
*L?MC>?HNÊ@LIGÊ'ŸÊ.LC=B?NƙÊ;H>ÊNB?ÊGIL?ÊL?=?HNÊN;LA?N?>&.,)ÊJLIAL;GG?Ê;L?ÊNQIÊ
P?LSÊAII>Ê?R;GJF?MÊI@ÊNB?Ê@;CFOL?ÊI@Ê=?HNL;FÊ<;HEÊ<;F;H=?ÊMB??NÊ?RJ;HMCIHÊQB?HÊƧ;ƨÊ
>IH?ÊCHÊ;HÊ?HPCLIHG?HNÊI@ÊLCMEÊ;P?LMCIHƙÊ;H>ÊƧ<ƨÊQB?HÊCNÊN;LA?NMÊIHFSÊNB?Ê=IGG?L=C;FÊ
<;HEMŸÊ.B?Ê&.,)MÊCHÊƃƁƂƂƂƃÊCH=L?;M?>ÊNB?ʤMÊ<;F;H=?ÊMB??NÊ@LIGÊNQIÊNLCFFCIHÊNIÊ
NBL??ÊNLCFFCIHÊ?OLIMÊ<ONÊF?H>CHAÊ<SÊ=IGG?L=C;FÊ<;HEMÊ>?=L?;M?>Ê@LIGÊ;ÊALIQNBÊL;N?ÊI@Ê
ƄŸƃžÊS?;LIHS?;LÊCHÊ-?JN?G<?LÊƃƁƂƂÊNIÊƅŸƁžÊ<SÊ-?JN?G<?LÊƃƁƂƄŸÊ-IÊIHÊNBCMÊMCGJF?Ê
G?;MOL?ƙÊ&.,)MÊ>C>H¤NÊQILEŸÊƧ)@Ê=IOLM?ÊCNÊ=IOF>Ê<?Ê=F;CG?>ÊNB;NÊNB?Ê=IHNL;=NCIHÊI@Ê?OLI
;L?;Ê<;HEÊ<;F;H=?ÊMB??NMÊQIOF>ÊB;P?Ê<??HÊ?P?HÊAL?;N?LÊQCNBIONÊNB?Ê&.,)MƙÊ<ONÊ?KO;FFSÊ
;MM?NÊJOL=B;M?MÊ@LIGÊHIH<;HEMÊQIOF>ÊB;P?ÊAO;L;HN??>Ê;HÊCH=L?;M?ÊCHÊ=IGG?L=C;FÊ<;HEÊ
>?JIMCNMƙÊB?FJCHAÊNIÊI@@M?NÊJLCP;N?ÊM?=NILÊ>?F?P?L;ACHAŸƨ
/HFCE?ÊNB?ÊIÊILÊ ?>Ê;MM?NÊJOL=B;M?MÊ@LIGÊHIH<;HEMƙÊ&.,)MÊQ?L?Ê<;MC=;FFSÊ;HÊ¡;MM?NÊ
MQ;J¢ƚÊNB?ÊÊG;>?ÊFI;HMÊNIÊ<;HEMÊ;A;CHMNÊ=IFF;N?L;FÊ@LIGÊNB?GŸ
#HÊLCN;CHƙÊ<;HEMÊA?H?L;FFSÊ>IÊHINÊBIF>ÊFIHAN?LGÊACFNMÊ<?=;OM?ÊNB?Ê=;JCN;FÊLCMEÊCMÊNIIÊ
AL?;NŸÊ#HÊ<OSCHAÊFIHAN?LGÊACFNMÊNB?ÊIÊQ;MÊNB?L?@IL?Ê<OSCHAÊ;MM?NMÊ@LIGÊHIH<;HEMƙÊ
;H>Ê;PIC>CHAÊ;HÊ¡;MM?NÊMQ;J¢ŸÊMM?HNC;FFSÊCNÊQ;MÊ=L?;NCHAÊH?QÊ>?JIMCNMƙÊILÊCHD?=NCHAÊH?QÊ
GIH?SÊCHNIÊNB?ÊB;H>MÊI@ÊBIOM?BIF>MÊ;H>ÊHIH<;HEÊ@CLGMƙÊ;H>ÊB?H=?ÊCHNIÊNB?Ê<LI;>?LÊ
@CH;H=C;FÊMSMN?GƙÊNB?L?<SÊ=L?;NCHAÊGIL?ÊL;JC>ÊGIH?SÊALIQNBÊCHÊNB?Ê/%ÊÊDOMNÊ;MÊNB?Ê ?>Ê
>C>ÊCHÊNB?Ê/-ŸÊFN?LH;NCP?FSƙÊNB?ÊIÊQ;MÊI@@M?NNCHAÊILÊJL?P?HNCHAÊQB;NÊGCABNÊINB?LQCM?Ê
B;P?Ê<??HÊ;ÊGIH?N;LSÊ=IHNL;=NCIHƙÊMO=BÊ;MÊI==OLL?>ÊCHÊNB?Ê/-ÊCHÊƂƊƄƂƄƄŸ
1BSÊH?A;NCP?ÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?MÊ;L?ÊHINÊ;ÊMIFONCIHÊ@ILÊ$;J;HÊILÊNB?Ê?OLITIH?ÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊƈ
The contraction of bank balance sheets in the eurozone needs to be reversed
CAOL?ÊƉÊ
Spain: Composition of commercial bank assets (Eur bn)
';L=BÊƃƁƂƄÊŸÊ ?<ÊƃƁƂƇÊ
IH>ÊBIF>CHAMƚÊƂƁƊ<H
ƃƁƁƁ
ƃƁƁƃ
ƃƁƁƅ
ƃƁƁƇ
ƃƁƁƉ
ƃƁƂƁ
ƃƁƂƃ
;MBÊ;H>ÊINB?LÊ
IH>MÊ;H>Ê?KOCNC?M
&I;HM
.IN;FÊ;MM?NM
ƃƁƂƅ
ƃƁƂƇ
ƅƁƁƁ
ƄƆƁƁ
ƄƁƁƁ
ƃƆƁƁ
ƃƁƁƁ
ƂƆƁƁ
ƂƁƁƁ
ƆƁƁ
-IOL=?ƚÊ';=LI<IH>Ê;MÊ;NÊƂƇÊ';SÊƃƁƂƇŸ
.B?Ê>?MCAHÊI@ÊNB?Ê+ÊJLIAL;GG?MÊI@ÊNB?ÊI$Ê;H>ÊÊCGJFSÊNB?SÊQCFFÊ<?ÊF?MMÊMNCGOF;NCHAÊ
NIÊ@CH;H=C;FÊG;LE?NMÊ;H>ÊNIÊNB?Ê<LI;>?LÊ$;J;H?M?Ê;H>ÊOLI;L?;Ê?=IHIGC?MÊNB;HÊNB?SÊ
MBIOF>Ê<?ÊC@ÊNB?SÊQ?L?Ê>C@@?L?HNFSÊ>?MCAH?>ŸÊ#NÊCMÊHIÊ=ICH=C>?H=?ÊNB;NÊNB?ÊNQIÊG;CHÊ;L?;MÊ
QBC=BÊ;L?Ê?RJ?LC?H=CHAÊH?A;NCP?ÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?MƙÊMO<J;LÊALIQNBÊ;H>ÊH?;L>?@F;NCIHÊÊCŸ?ŸÊ
$;J;HÊ;H>ÊNB?Ê?OLITIH?ÊƧJFOMÊNB?ÊNBL??Ê?OLIFCHE?>Ê?=IHIGC?MÊI@Ê-Q?>?HƙÊ?HG;LEÊ
;H>Ê-QCNT?LF;H>ƨʟÊ;L?Ê;FMIÊNB?Ê?=IHIGC?MÊQB?L?ÊNB?ÊNQIÊG;DILÊ=?HNL;FÊ<;HEMÊB;P?Ê
CGJF?G?HN?>Ê@F;Q?>Ê+ÊJLIAL;GG?MŸÊ
.B?Ê@OH>;G?HN;FÊJLI<F?GÊCMÊNB;NÊNB?ÊÊ;H>ÊNB?ÊI$Ê;L?ÊNLSCHAÊNIÊCGJF?G?HNÊ+Ê
NBLIOABÊNB?ÊHILG;FÊ=L?>CNÊ=L?;NCIHÊ=B;HH?FMÊI@ÊNB?Ê<;HECHAÊMSMN?GŸÊONÊNB?M?ÊNL;>CNCIH;FÊ
NL;HMGCMMCIHÊ=B;HH?FMÊ;L?ÊHINÊQILECHAʟÊ?CNB?LÊ<?=;OM?Ê<;HEMÊ;L?ÊLCMEÊ;P?LM?Ê;H>Ê>IÊ
HINÊQCMBÊNIÊF?H>ƙÊILÊ<?=;OM?ÊBIOM?BIF>MÊ;H>Ê@CLGMÊ;L?ÊMNCFFÊMCAHC@C=;HNFSÊF?P?L;A?>Ê;H>Ê>IÊ
HINÊQ;HNÊNIÊ<ILLIQŸÊ#HÊNB?M?Ê=CL=OGMN;H=?MƙÊNB?ÊJIFC=SÊI@ÊL?FSCHAÊIHÊ?P?LÊFIQ?LÊCHN?L?MNÊ
L;N?MÊ=;HHINÊ<?Ê;MMOL?>ÊI@ÊMO==?MMƙÊ?P?HÊC@ÊL;N?MÊ;L?ÊH?A;NCP?ŸÊ!CP?HÊNB;NÊNB?ÊMN;H>;L>Ê
NL;HMGCMMCIHÊMSMN?GÊ@ILÊGIH?N;LSÊJIFC=SÊNBLIOABÊNB?Ê<;HECHAÊMSMN?GÊCMÊ<LIE?HƙÊ=?HNL;FÊ
<;HEMÊH??>ÊNIÊ=CL=OGP?HNÊNB?Ê<;HEMÊC@ÊNB?SÊ;L?ÊNIÊ=L?;N?ÊH?QÊJOL=B;MCHAÊJIQ?LƙÊL?MNIL?Ê
HILG;FÊ?=IHIGC=ÊALIQNBƙÊ;H>ÊL?NOLHÊNIÊƃžÊCH@F;NCIHÊ;H>ÊHILG;FÊF?P?FMÊI@ÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?MŸ
.B?ÊLCABNÊQ;SÊNIÊ>IÊNBCMÊCMÊHINÊNIÊ@I=OMÊJIFC=SÊIHÊ?P?L>?=L?;MCHAÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?MƙÊ<ONÊ
CHMN?;>ÊNIÊ=L?;N?ÊGIH?SÊ>CL?=NFSÊ<SÊJOL=B;M?MÊI@ÊM?=OLCNC?MÊƧILÊCH>??>Ê;HSÊINB?LÊ;MM?NƨÊ
@LIGÊHIH<;HEMÊÊNB?L?<SÊ=L?;NCHAÊH?QÊ>?JIMCNMÊCHÊNB?ÊB;H>MÊI@Ê@CLGMÊ;H>ÊBIOM?BIF>MŸÊ
FNBIOABÊNB?SÊ>C>ÊHINÊ?RJFC=CNFSÊ;LNC=OF;N?ÊNB?CLÊJIFC=C?MÊCHÊNBCMÊQ;SƙÊNBCMÊCMÊCHÊ?@@?=NÊQB;NÊ
NB?Ê ?>Ê;H>ÊNB?ÊIÊ>C>ÊCHÊƃƁƁƉƂƃŸÊ#HÊINB?LÊQIL>MÊCNÊQIOF>Ê<?Ê<?NN?LÊ@ILÊNB?ÊI$Ê;H>Ê
NB?ÊÊNIÊ@I=OMÊIHÊNB?ÊKO;HNCN;NCP?Ê?@@?=NMÊI@Ê+ƙÊHINÊNB?ÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?Ê?@@?=NMŸÊ.IÊJONÊCNÊ
>C@@?L?HNFSƙÊ+ÊCMÊƧILÊMBIOF>Ê<?ƨÊ;<IONÊ?RJ;H>CHAÊJOL=B;MCHAÊJIQ?LÊCHÊNB?Ê?=IHIGSÊILÊ
GIH?SÊCHÊNB?ÊB;H>MÊI@ÊNB?ÊHIH<;HEÊJO<FC=ƙÊHINÊFIQ?LCHAÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?MÊ;H>ÊBIJCHAÊNB?Ê
<;HEMÊQCFFÊ?RJ;H>ÊF?H>CHAŸ
1BSÊH?A;NCP?ÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?MÊ;L?ÊHINÊ;ÊMIFONCIHÊ@ILÊ$;J;HÊILÊNB?Ê?OLITIH?ÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊƉ
ECB buying securities mainly from banks; Italian bank holdings of securities falling
IG?MNC=ÊM?=OLCNC?MÊ
IG?MNC=ÊFI;HMÊ
;HEM¤ÊNIN;FÊ;MM?NM
CAOL?ÊƊÊ
Italy: Commercial bank assets %YOY
ƃƁƁƁ
ƃƁƁƃ
ƃƁƁƅ
ƃƁƁƇ
ƃƁƁƉ
ƃƁƂƁ
ƃƁƂƃ
ƃƁƂƅ
ƃƁƂƇ
ƆƁ
ƅƁ
ƄƁ
ƃƁ
ƂƁ
Ɓ
ƂƁ
-IOL=?ƚÊ';=LI<IH>Ê;MÊ;NÊƂƇÊ';SÊƃƁƂƇŸ
.B?Ê=B;LNÊIHÊJ;A?ÊƁƉÊƧ@CAOL?ÊƉƨÊMBIQ?>ÊNB;NÊ-J;HCMBÊ<;HEM¤ÊNIN;FÊ;MM?NMÊ;L?ÊMNCFFÊ>?=FCHCHAƙÊ
QBCF?ÊNB?CLÊFI;HMÊ;H>ÊBIF>CHAMÊI@ÊM?=OLCNC?MÊÊNB?CLÊNQIÊG;DILÊ;MM?NÊ=F;MM?MʟÊ;L?Ê;FMIÊMNCFFÊ
>?=FCHCHAŸÊ"IF>CHAMÊI@ÊM?=OLCNC?MÊB;P?Ê>?=FCH?>Ê<SÊƗƂƁƊÊ<CFFCIHÊƧILÊƂƈžƨÊMCH=?Ê';L=BÊƃƁƂƄÊ
;H>Ê<SÊƗƅƈ<HÊƧILÊƉŸƉžƨÊMCH=?Ê';L=BÊƃƁƂƆÊQB?HÊNB?ÊÊMN;LN?>ÊCNMÊ+ÊIJ?L;NCIHMŸ
.B?ÊM;G?ÊCMÊ<LI;>FSÊNLO?ÊI@Ê#N;FC;HÊ<;HEMÊMBIQHÊCHÊ@CAOL?ÊƊÊ;<IP?ŸÊ.B?ÊLCMEÊ;P?LMCIHÊ
I@Ê#N;FC;HÊ<;HEMÊCMÊMBIQHÊƧ;ƨÊNB?ÊMFOGJÊCHÊ<;HEÊF?H>CHAÊNIÊ=ILJIL;N?Ê;H>ÊBIOM?BIF>Ê
=OMNIG?LMÊMCH=?Ê)=NI<?LÊƃƁƁƉƙÊ;H>ÊƧ<ƨÊNB?ÊLCM?ÊCHÊBIF>CHAMÊI@ÊM?=OLCNC?MÊƃƁƁƉƂƁÊ;H>Ê
;A;CHÊCHÊƃƁƂƃƂƄŸÊ#HÊJ;L;FF?FÊQCNBÊNB?Ê-J;HCMBÊ<;HEMƙÊBIF>CHAMÊI@ÊM?=OLCNC?MÊ;NÊ#N;FC;HÊ
<;HEMÊB;P?Ê>?=FCH?>Ê<SÊƗƂƈƁÊ<CFFCIHÊƧILÊƂƈžƨÊMCH=?ÊNB?CLÊJ?;EÊCHÊOAOMNÊƃƁƂƄÊ;H>Ê<SÊ
ƗƅƆ<HÊƧILÊƆŸƃžƨÊMCH=?Ê';L=BÊƃƁƂƆÊQB?HÊNB?ÊÊMN;LN?>ÊCNMÊ+ÊIJ?L;NCIHMŸ
*LIMJ?=NMÊ@ILÊ<;HEÊF?H>CHAÊQCFFÊ>?J?H>ÊB?;PCFSÊIHÊNB?ÊMO==?MMÊI@ÊNB?ʤMÊ+ŸÊ.IÊ?HMOL?Ê
;HÊCH=L?;M?ÊCHÊF?H>CHAƙÊ+ÊGOMNÊ@CLMNÊCH=L?;M?ÊNB?ÊMOJJFSÊI@Ê>?JIMCNMÊƧ@ILÊQBC=BÊNB?Ê
=IOHN?LJ;LNÊ;MM?NÊ;NÊ<;HEMÊCHCNC;FFSÊQCFFÊ<?ÊHINÊ<?ÊFI;HMƙÊ<ONÊ<;HEÊL?M?LP?MÊ;NÊNB?Ê=?HNL;FÊ
<;HEƙÊNB?L?<SÊB?FJCHAÊNIÊL?>O=?ÊF?P?L;A?ƨŸÊ#@ÊMO==?MM@OFƙÊNBCMÊCH=L?;M?ÊCHÊ>?JIMCNMÊƧILÊ
'ƄƨÊQCFFÊCHÊNOLHÊF?;>ÊNIÊCH=L?;M?>Ê<OMCH?MMÊ;H>Ê=IHMOG?LÊMJ?H>CHAƙÊF;N?LÊ?H;<FCHAÊ#N;FC;HÊ
<;HEMÊNIÊIP?L=IG?ÊNB?CLÊLCMEÊ;P?LMCIHÊ;H>ÊMN;LNÊF?H>CHAÊ;A;CHŸ
#HN?LH;NCIH;FÊ'IH?N;LSÊ OH>Ê>;N;ÊMBIQMÊNB;NÊH?;LFSÊƂƉžÊI@Ê#N;FC;HÊ<;HEM¤ÊFI;HMÊQ?L?Ê
>IO<N@OFÊILÊHIHJ?L@ILGCHAÊCHÊƃƁƂƆƙÊCGJFSCHAÊ;HÊOLA?HNÊH??>Ê@ILÊ;ÊJLIJ?LÊ=F?;HOJÊI@Ê
NB?Ê#N;FC;HÊ<;HECHAÊMSMN?GŸ
-O=BÊ;Ê=F?;HOJÊCMÊAICHAÊNIÊA?NÊB;L>?LÊCHÊ;ÊGO=BÊNIOAB?LÊL?AOF;NILSÊ?HPCLIHG?HNÊ@LIGÊ
NBCMÊS?;LÊ;MÊNB?ÊOLIJ?;HÊ/HCIHÊƧ/ƨÊ<;CFCHÊLOF?MÊ;L?ÊN;ECHAÊ?@@?=NƙÊQBC=BÊG?;HMÊNB?Ê
#N;FC;HÊAIP?LHG?HNÊQCFFÊHIÊFIHA?LÊ<?ÊJ?LGCNN?>ÊNIÊ<;CFÊIONÊ<;HEMŸÊ#HMN?;>Ê?KOCNSÊ;H>Ê
<IH>BIF>?LMÊGOMNÊJ;SÊOJÊ@CLMNŸÊ.B?L?ÊB;MÊ<??HÊ;Ê>?;FÊMNLO=EÊQCNBÊNB?Ê/Ê;FFIQCHAÊNB?Ê
AIP?LHG?HNÊNIÊAO;L;HN??ÊNB?ÊM?=OLCNCM;NCIHÊI@Ê<;>ÊFI;HMŸÊ"IQ?P?LÊCNÊL?G;CHMÊNIÊ<?ÊM??HÊ
C@ÊNBCMÊQCFFÊ<?Ê?HIOABŸ
1BSÊH?A;NCP?ÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?MÊ;L?ÊHINÊ;ÊMIFONCIHÊ@ILÊ$;J;HÊILÊNB?Ê?OLITIH?ÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊƊ
BoJ buying securities mainly from banks; bank holdings of JGBs have declined by
66 trillion yen since March 2013
3?HÊ.LCFFCIH
CAOL?ÊƂƁÊ
Japanese bank holdings of JGBs
$*3ƙÊNLCFFCIH
Ɗƅ
ƊƇ
ƊƉ
ƁƁ
Ɓƃ
Ɓƅ
ƁƇ
ƁƉ
ƂƁ
Ƃƃ
Ƃƅ
ƂƇ
';L=BÊƃƁƂƄ
ƂƈƆ
ƂƆƁ
ƂƃƆ
ƂƁƁ
ƈƆ
ƆƁ
ƃƆ
-IOL=?ƚÊ';=LI<IH>Ê;MÊ;NÊƂƇÊ';SÊƃƁƂƇŸ
.OLHCHAÊNIÊNB?ÊI$ƙÊNB?L?Ê;L?ÊNQIÊG;CHÊL?;MIHMÊQBSÊNB?Ê?RJ;HMCIHÊI@ÊNB?ÊI$Ê<;F;H=?Ê
MB??NÊB;MÊHINÊNL;HMF;N?>ÊCHNIÊ@;MN?LÊALIQNBÊI@Ê'ƃÊILÊ'ƄÊ;H>Ê<;HEM¤Ê<;F;H=?ÊMB??NMŸ
CLMNƙÊCHMN?;>ÊI@ÊN;LA?NCHAÊHIH<;HEÊBIF>CHAMÊI@Ê$;J;H?M?ÊAIP?LHG?HNÊM?=OLCNC?MÊ@ILÊ
JOL=B;M?ƙÊNB?ÊI$ÊB;MÊJOL=B;M?>Ê;Ê=IHMC>?L;<F?Ê;GIOHNÊI@ÊNB?M?ÊM?=OLCNC?MÊ>CL?=NFSÊ
@LIGÊNB?Ê<;HEMŸÊMÊMBIQHÊCHÊ@CAOL?ÊƂƁÊ;<IP?Ê$;J;H?M?Ê=IGG?L=C;FÊ<;HEM¤ÊBIF>CHAMÊI@Ê
$!MÊB;P?Ê@;FF?HÊ@LIGÊƂƇƇŸƇÊNLCFFCIHÊS?HÊCHÊ';L=BÊƃƁƂƄÊNIÊƂƁƁŸƃÊNLCFFCIHÊCHÊ ?<LO;LSÊ
ƃƁƂƇƙÊ;Ê>?=FCH?ÊI@ÊƇƇŸƅÊNLCFFCIHŸÊ#HÊINB?LÊQIL>MƙÊCHÊL?MJ?=NÊI@Ê;ÊNIN;FÊI$Ê<;F;H=?ÊMB??NÊ
?RJ;HMCIHÊ;GIOHNCHAÊNIÊƃƆƁÊNLCFFCIHÊS?HÊMCH=?Ê';L=BÊƃƁƂƄƙÊ<?NQ??HÊIH?ÊKO;LN?LÊ;H>Ê
IH?ÊNBCL>ÊCMÊ;==IOHN?>Ê@ILÊ<SÊ=IGG?L=C;FÊ<;HEÊM;F?MÊI@Ê$!MŸÊ;HEMÊB;P?Ê?R=B;HA?>Ê
BIF>CHAMÊI@Ê$!MÊ@ILÊCH=L?;M?>ÊL?M?LP?ÊILÊ=OLL?HNÊ;==IOHNÊ>?JIMCNMÊ;NÊNB?ÊI$ŸÊ.B?L?Ê
B;MÊMCGJFSÊ<??HÊ;HÊ;MM?NÊMQ;JŸÊ.BCMÊ>I?MÊHINÊCH=L?;M?ÊNB?ÊGIH?SÊMOJJFSÊCHÊNB?ÊB;H>MÊI@Ê
@CLGMÊILÊBIOM?BIF>MŸ
-?=IH>ƙÊ;ÊF;LA?ÊJLIJILNCIHÊI@ÊNB?ÊGIHNBFSÊJOL=B;M?MÊB;P?Ê<??HÊCHÊNB?Ê@ILGÊI@Ê
.<CFFMƙÊ;A;CHÊG;CHFSÊJOL=B;M?>Ê@LIGÊNB?Ê=IGG?L=C;FÊ<;HEMŸÊ-CH=?ÊNB?M?Ê;L?ÊMBILN
N?LGÊM?=OLCNC?MÊNB?SÊB;P?ÊNIÊ<?Ê=IHNCHOIOMFSÊLIFF?>ÊIP?LÊIHÊG;NOLCNSÊNIÊG;CHN;CHÊ
NB?Ê?RJ;HMCIH;LSÊ?@@?=NŸÊ ILÊ?R;GJF?ƙÊCHÊNB?Ê@CM=;FÊS?;LÊ?H>?>Ê';L=BÊƃƁƂƆƙÊQBCF?Ê
JOL=B;M?MÊI@Ê$!MÊ;GIOHN?>ÊNIÊƊƇŸƇÊNLCFFCIHÊS?HÊ;H>ÊF;LA?FSÊL?G;CH?>ÊIHÊNB?Ê<;F;H=?Ê
MB??NƙÊ.<CFFÊJOL=B;M?MÊ;GIOHN?>ÊNIÊƂƁƂŸƉÊNLCFFCIHÊS?HÊ<ONÊIHFSÊMBIQ?>ÊOJÊ;MÊ;HÊ
IONMN;H>CHAÊ<;F;H=?ÊI@ÊƅƊŸƈÊNLCFFCIHÊS?HŸ
1BSÊH?A;NCP?ÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?MÊ;L?ÊHINÊ;ÊMIFONCIHÊ@ILÊ$;J;HÊILÊNB?Ê?OLITIH?ÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊƂƁ
Summary and conclusion
Ÿ
Ê?HNL;FÊ<;HEÊJOL=B;M?MÊI@Ê;MM?NMÊILÊM?=OLCNC?MÊ@LIGÊ=IGG?L=C;FÊ<;HEMÊ;L?Ê@;LÊF?MMÊ
?@@?=NCP?ÊCHÊ?RJ;H>CHAÊNB?ÊGIH?SÊMOJJFSÊILÊJOL=B;MCHAÊJIQ?LÊCHÊNB?Ê?=IHIGSÊNB;HÊ
JOL=B;M?MÊ@LIGÊHIH<;HEMŸ
Ÿ
*
Ê OL=B;M?MÊ@LIGÊHIH<;HEMÊ>CL?=NFSÊ?RJ;H>ÊNB?ÊPIFOG?ÊI@Ê>?JIMCNMƙÊ?RJ;H>ÊNB?Ê
GIH?SÊMOJJFSƙÊ;H>ÊNB?SÊ>IÊNBCMÊQCNBIONÊ;>>CHAÊF?P?L;A?Ÿ
Ÿ
/
Ê H@ILNOH;N?FSƙÊ@ILÊCHMNCNONCIH;FÊILÊINB?LÊL?;MIHMƙÊ<INBÊNB?ÊI$Ê;H>ÊNB?ÊÊ;L?Ê
MNCFFÊ=IH=?HNL;NCHAÊGO=BÊI@ÊNB?CLÊ;MM?NÊJOL=B;M?MÊIHÊ<;HEMÊL;NB?LÊNB;HÊHIH<;HEMƙÊ
?@@?=NCP?FSÊOH>?LGCHCHAÊILÊ>CFONCHAÊNB?Ê?@@?=NCP?H?MMÊI@Ê+Ÿ
Ÿ
(
Ê ?A;NCP?ÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?MÊ;L?Ê;Ê@OH>;G?HN;FFSÊGCM>CL?=N?>ÊMNL;N?ASÊ<?=;OM?ÊNB?SÊ;CGÊ
NIÊCH>O=?Ê<;HEMÊNIÊCH=L?;M?ÊF?H>CHAÊ;H>Ê?RJ;H>ÊNB?CLÊ<;F;H=?ÊMB??NMÊ<SÊ;>>CHAÊNIÊ
F?P?L;A?ÊCHÊNB?ÊHIH<;HEÊJLCP;N?ÊM?=NILŸ
Ÿ
.
Ê B?ÊJIFC=SÊI@ÊL?>O=CHAÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?MÊNIÊH?A;NCP?ÊN?LLCNILSÊQCFFÊHINÊH?=?MM;LCFSÊ
?RJ;H>ÊGIH?SÊ;H>ÊJOL=B;MCHAÊJIQ?LƙÊ;H>Ê=IOF>ÊMCGJFSÊF?;>ÊNIÊ?P?HÊFIQ?LÊL;N?MÊ<SÊ
JONNCHAÊJL?MMOL?ÊIHÊ<;HEMÊƧNBLIOABÊL?>O=?>ÊH?NÊCHN?L?MNÊG;LACHMƨÊNIÊ=IHNL;=NÊNB?CLÊ
<;F;H=?ÊMB??NMÊMNCFFÊ@OLNB?LŸ
John Greenwood
BC?@Ê=IHIGCMNƙÊ#HP?M=IÊ&N>Ê
ƂƇÊ';SÊƃƁƂƇ
1BSÊH?A;NCP?ÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?MÊ;L?ÊHINÊ;ÊMIFONCIHÊ@ILÊ$;J;HÊILÊNB?Ê?OLITIH?ÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊƂƂ
Important information
1BCF?ÊAL?;NÊ=;L?ÊB;MÊ<??HÊN;E?HÊNIÊ?HMOL?ÊNB;NÊNB?ÊCH@ILG;NCIHÊ=IHN;CH?>ÊB?L?CHÊCMÊ;==OL;N?ƙÊHIÊL?MJIHMC<CFCNSÊ=;HÊ<?Ê;==?JN?>Ê@ILÊ;HSÊ?LLILMƙÊGCMN;E?MƙÊIGCMMCIHMÊ
ILÊ;HSÊINB?LÊ;=NCIHÊN;E?HÊCHÊL?FC;H=?ÊNB?L?IHŸÊ
1B?L?Ê$IBHÊ!L??HQII>ÊB;MÊ?RJL?MM?>ÊIJCHCIHMƙÊNB?SÊ;L?Ê<;M?>ÊIHÊ=OLL?HNÊG;LE?NÊ=IH>CNCIHMÊ;H>Ê;L?ÊMO<D?=NÊNIÊ=B;HA?ÊQCNBIONÊHINC=?ŸÊ.B?M?ÊIJCHCIHMÊG;SÊ>C@@?LÊ
@LIGÊNBIM?ÊI@ÊINB?LÊ#HP?M=IÊ*?LJ?NO;FÊJLI@?MMCIH;FMŸÊ
FFÊ>;N;ÊJLIPC>?>Ê<SÊ#HP?M=IÊ*?LJ?NO;FƙÊMIOL=?Ê@LIGÊ';=LI<IH>ƙÊOHF?MMÊINB?LQCM?ÊMN;N?>ŸÊ
;N;Ê;MÊ;NÊƂƇÊ';SÊƃƁƂƇƙÊOHF?MMÊINB?LQCM?ÊMN;N?>ŸÊÊ
.BCMÊ>I=OG?HNÊB;MÊ<??HÊJL?J;L?>ÊIHFSÊ@ILÊNBIM?ÊJ?LMIHMÊNIÊQBIGÊ#HP?M=IÊB;MÊJLIPC>?>ÊCNÊ@ILÊCH@ILG;NCIH;FÊJOLJIM?MÊIHFSŸÊ.BCMÊ>I=OG?HNÊCMÊHINÊ;HÊI@@?LCHAÊI@Ê
;Ê@CH;H=C;FÊJLI>O=NÊ;H>ÊCMÊHINÊCHN?H>?>Ê@ILÊ;H>ÊMBIOF>ÊHINÊ<?Ê>CMNLC<ON?>ÊNIƙÊILÊL?FC?>ÊOJIHƙÊ<SÊG?G<?LMÊI@ÊNB?ÊJO<FC=ŸÊCL=OF;NCIHƙÊ>CM=FIMOL?ƙÊILÊ>CMM?GCH;NCIHÊ
I@Ê;FFÊILÊ;HSÊJ;LNÊI@ÊNBCMÊ>I=OG?HNÊNIÊ;HSÊJ?LMIHÊQCNBIONÊNB?Ê=IHM?HNÊI@Ê#HP?M=IÊCMÊJLIBC<CN?>ŸÊ
.BCMÊ>I=OG?HNÊG;SÊ=IHN;CHÊMN;N?G?HNMÊNB;NÊ;L?ÊHINÊJOL?FSÊBCMNILC=;FÊCHÊH;NOL?Ê<ONÊ;L?ÊŻ@ILQ;L>FIIECHAÊMN;N?G?HNMƙŻÊQBC=BÊ;L?Ê<;M?>ÊIHÊ=?LN;CHÊ;MMOGJNCIHMÊ
I@Ê@ONOL?Ê?P?HNMŸÊ ILQ;L>FIIECHAÊMN;N?G?HNMÊ;L?Ê<;M?>ÊIHÊCH@ILG;NCIHÊ;P;CF;<F?ÊIHÊNB?Ê>;N?ÊB?L?I@ƙÊ;H>Ê#HP?M=IÊ>I?MÊHINÊ;MMOG?Ê;HSÊ>ONSÊNIÊOJ>;N?Ê;HSÊ
@ILQ;L>FIIECHAÊMN;N?G?HNŸÊ=NO;FÊ?P?HNMÊG;SÊ>C@@?LÊ@LIGÊNBIM?Ê;MMOG?>ŸÊ.B?L?Ê=;HÊ<?ÊHIÊ;MMOL;H=?ÊNB;NÊ@ILQ;L>FIIECHAÊMN;N?G?HNMƙÊCH=FO>CHAÊ;HSÊJLID?=N?>Ê
L?NOLHMƙÊQCFFÊG;N?LC;FCT?ÊILÊNB;NÊ;=NO;FÊG;LE?NÊ=IH>CNCIHMÊ;H>ILÊJ?L@ILG;H=?ÊL?MOFNMÊQCFFÊHINÊ<?ÊG;N?LC;FFSÊ>C@@?L?HNÊILÊQILM?ÊNB;HÊNBIM?ÊJL?M?HN?>ŸÊ
.B?ÊCH@ILG;NCIHÊCHÊNBCMÊ>I=OG?HNÊB;MÊ<??HÊJL?J;L?>ÊQCNBIONÊN;ECHAÊCHNIÊ;==IOHNÊ;HSÊCHP?MNIL¤MÊCHP?MNG?HNÊI<D?=NCP?MƙÊ@CH;H=C;FÊMCNO;NCIHÊILÊJ;LNC=OF;LÊH??>MŸÊ
?@IL?Ê;=NCHAÊIHÊNB?ÊCH@ILG;NCIHÊNB?ÊCHP?MNILÊMBIOF>Ê=IHMC>?LÊCNMÊ;JJLIJLC;N?H?MMÊB;PCHAÊL?A;L>ÊNIÊNB?CLÊCHP?MNG?HNÊI<D?=NCP?MƙÊ@CH;H=C;FÊMCNO;NCIHÊ;H>ÊH??>MŸ
3IOÊMBIOF>ÊHIN?ÊNB;NÊNBCMÊCH@ILG;NCIHƚ
z G;SÊ=IHN;CHÊL?@?L?H=?MÊNIÊ;GIOHNMÊQBC=BÊ;L?ÊHINÊCHÊFI=;FÊ=OLL?H=C?Mƛ
z G;SÊ=IHN;CHÊ@CH;H=C;FÊCH@ILG;NCIHÊQBC=BÊCMÊHINÊJL?J;L?>ÊCHÊ;==IL>;H=?ÊQCNBÊNB?ÊF;QMÊILÊJL;=NC=?MÊI@ÊSIOLÊ=IOHNLSÊI@ÊL?MC>?H=?ƛ
z G;SÊHINÊ;>>L?MMÊLCMEMÊ;MMI=C;N?>ÊQCNBÊCHP?MNG?HNÊCHÊ@IL?CAHÊ=OLL?H=SÊ>?HIGCH;N?>ÊCHP?MNG?HNMƛÊ;H>
z >I?MÊHINÊ;>>L?MMÊFI=;FÊN;RÊCMMO?MŸ
FFÊG;N?LC;FÊJL?M?HN?>ÊCMÊ=IGJCF?>Ê@LIGÊMIOL=?MÊ<?FC?P?>ÊNIÊ<?ÊL?FC;<F?Ê;H>Ê=OLL?HNƙÊ<ONÊ;==OL;=SÊ=;HHINÊ<?ÊAO;L;HN??>ŸÊ#HP?MNG?HNÊCHPIFP?MÊLCMEŸÊ*F?;M?Ê
L?PC?QÊ;FFÊ@CH;H=C;FÊG;N?LC;FÊ=;L?@OFFSÊ<?@IL?ÊCHP?MNCHAŸÊ.B?ÊIJCHCIHMÊ?RJL?MM?>Ê;L?Ê<;M?>ÊIHÊ=OLL?HNÊG;LE?NÊ=IH>CNCIHMÊ;H>Ê;L?ÊMO<D?=NÊNIÊ=B;HA?ÊQCNBIONÊ
HINC=?ŸÊ.B?M?ÊIJCHCIHMÊG;SÊ>C@@?LÊ@LIGÊNBIM?ÊI@ÊINB?LÊ#HP?M=IÊCHP?MNG?HNÊJLI@?MMCIH;FMŸÊ
.B?Ê>CMNLC<ONCIHÊ;H>ÊI@@?LCHAÊI@ÊNBCMÊ>I=OG?HNÊCHÊ=?LN;CHÊDOLCM>C=NCIHMÊG;SÊ<?ÊL?MNLC=N?>Ê<SÊF;QŸÊ*?LMIHMÊCHNIÊQBIM?ÊJIMM?MMCIHÊNBCMÊG;LE?NCHAÊG;N?LC;FÊG;SÊ
=IG?Ê;L?ÊL?KOCL?>ÊNIÊCH@ILGÊNB?GM?FP?MÊ;<IONÊ;H>ÊNIÊ=IGJFSÊQCNBÊ;HSÊL?F?P;HNÊL?MNLC=NCIHMŸÊ.BCMÊ>I?MÊHINÊ=IHMNCNON?Ê;HÊI@@?LÊILÊMIFC=CN;NCIHÊ<SÊ;HSIH?ÊCHÊ;HSÊ
DOLCM>C=NCIHÊCHÊQBC=BÊMO=BÊ;HÊI@@?LÊCMÊHINÊ;ONBILCM?>ÊILÊNIÊ;HSÊJ?LMIHÊNIÊQBIGÊCNÊCMÊOHF;Q@OFÊNIÊG;E?ÊMO=BÊ;HÊI@@?LÊILÊMIFC=CN;NCIHŸÊ
1BSÊH?A;NCP?ÊCHN?L?MNÊL;N?MÊ;L?ÊHINÊ;ÊMIFONCIHÊ@ILÊ$;J;HÊILÊNB?Ê?OLITIH?ÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊÊƂƃ