*65 %:,-<3 ,8<(;065:
(@ +(
25/&$4(' 02.$- /$-83,3
04$4,0/
. # . 0 ! 0 0
3! 0 0 0 0 2
0
0 0
0
0
0
0
6):,9=, ;/(;
0 #
0 #
0 #
0 #
0/',4,0/$- 20%$%,-,48 (/3,48 5/&4,0/
$/, *65+0;065(3 796)()030;@ +,5:0;@ -<5*;065 6- .. 0 0: .0=,5 )@
3!!# D ,;
D
D
0
0
D
D 0
$9<5*(;,+ #;(5+(9+ 694(3 ,5:0;@ <5*;065
1.6
p.d.f .
p.d.f .
p.d.f .
p.d.f .
p.d.f .
Conditional p.d.f. of Truncated Z ~ N(0,1)
1.4
1.2
of
of
of
of
of
Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
|
|
|
|
|
Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
>
>
>
>
>
-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1
1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
-2
-1
0
1
2
Z
. # 3
4
5
6
+( 0.(/4 (/(2$4,/* )5/&4,0/
$/, 64,5; ,5,9(;05. -<5*;065 0: 6);(05,+ )@ " !!# > 2,! . 0
'
D
1D
0
#
' ,1 2 2
1D
,
0 #
' 1 ,1, ,
2
1D
0 #
2,! . 0 2,1
,
'
1,
2
1D
2
0
#
'
2 1
2
0
#,
'/,9, D >
0 >
2
0
> 0 2 0
+(
25/&$4(' 4$/'$2' 02.$- 71(&4$4,0/
$/, ;9<5*(;,+ :;(5+(9+ 5694(3 ,?7,*;(;065 0: +,C5,+ )@ .. 0
(5+ *(5 ), *(3*<3(;,+ <:05. ;/, 464,5; .,5,9(;05. -<5*;065 ,8<(;065:
" !!# >
.. 0 ,
> ,# # 2 ,
>
> 0
> 0
,
> 2 2 0
0
,; 0 ),
0
0
0
0
0 .. 0 0
0
$9<5*(;,+ #;(5+(9+ 694(3 ?7,*;(;065
4
3.5
3
E(Z|Z>c)
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
-4
-3
-2
-1
0
c
. # 1
2
3
4
; 0: (3:6 76::0)3, ;6 >692 >0;/ ;/, *6473,4,5; ;9<5*(;065
.. 0 . . 0 " !!# >
,
>
,# # 2
>
,
> 0
> 0
,
> 2 2 0
0
0
0
0
0
) 0 ),
,; ) 0 .. 0 0 0
):,9=, ;/(;
) 0 0 .. 0 .. 0
+<, ;6 :@4,;9@ 6- . # ):,9=, ;/(;
.. 0
0
*
0 0
0
0
0
+
0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0
0
0
0 0 0
0 .. 0 0
0 . 0. 0 :05*, 0 (5+ . 0. 0 +(
25/&$4(' 4$/'$2' 02.$- "$2,$/&(
* &.. 0 . . 0 .. 0
" !!# >
.. 0
,
>
>
2 ,#
#
>
0
2
2 ,#
#
, 0
> > 0 , 0
> 0 > 0
0 0 0 > 0 , 0
0 0 0 $9<5*(;,+ #;(5+(9+ 694(3 &(90(5*,
1
v ar(Z|Z>c) = 1-(E(Z-c|Z>c)*(E(Z|Z>c)
0.9
0.8
0.7
var(Z|Z>c)
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
-4
-3
-2
-1
0
c
. # 1
2
3
4
):,9=, ;/(; )@ +,C50;065 6- =(90(5*, >, 6);(05
* &..
0 0 0 0 0 0 0
.. 0
0
.. 0
0
.. 0
0
.9(7/0*(33@ >, 6);(05
4
E(Z|Z>c)
E(Z-c|Z>c)
3.5
3
E(Z|Z>c)
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
-4
-3
-2
-1
0
c
1
2
.. 0 (5+ . 0. 0
3
4
<;
.. 0
0
0 0 0
.. 0 . 0. 0
2
E(Z|Z>c)
E(Z-c|Z>c)
E(Z|Z>c)*E(Z-c|Z>c)
1.8
1.6
(E(Z-c|Z>c)*(E(Z|Z>c)
1.4
1.2
1
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
-4
-3
-2
-1
0
c
1
2
.. 0 (5+ . 0. 0
3
4
+( 74(/3,0/ 0) 4+( !/,6$2,$4( $3(
$/, ;9<5*(;,+ ,?7,*;(;065 ),;>,,5 *699,3(;,+ 5694(3 =(90()3,:
, ,
" #
# !
, , , '/,9, ! 4,(5: ;/, 7961,*;065 05 ;/, :7(*, .,5,9(;,+ )@ . (5+
! 4,(5: ;/, 7961,*;065 05 ;/, 69;/6.65(3 :7(*, .,5,9(;,+ )@ ;/,
.
5 ;/, 5694(3 *(:, >, /(=,
,
, @ @ ,
* &, * &@
* &@ (5+ @ $/, *65+0;065(3 ,?7,*;(;065
, , 0 , @, 0
, , 0 @
0
$/, *65+0;065(3 =(90(5*,
* /<, ,
0 * /< , @, 0
)<; 0 0 0
* /<, , 0 * /<@
0 0 0 0 0 0
(39,(+@ 796=,+
* /<, , 0 +(
25/&$4(' 20%$%,-,48 (/3,48 5/&4,0/ 7
4(/'('
):,9=, ;/(;
, :<776:, -
#
" #
!
,- 0 3 B
'
B
BC
C
,
1C
! C #
!
, :<776:, ,- 0
/
C /
!
'
#
,
!
C B
,
/#
!
0
" #
, - 0
,- 0 3 B
#
!#
0 0
! 1C
/
! !
-
/
!
#
#
p.d.f. of X conditional on Y>0; [X,Y] ~ Standard Normal
$9<5*(;,+ #;(5+(9+ 694(3 ,5:0;@ <5*;065
0.8
X
X
X
X
X
0.7
0.6
|
|
|
|
|
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
>
>
>
>
>
0,ρ
0,ρ
0,ρ
0,ρ
0,ρ
=
=
=
=
=
-0.9
-0.75
-0.5
-0.25
0
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
-4
-3
-2
-1
0
X
1
2
3
, " #
#
!
4
p.d.f. of X conditional on Y>0; [X,Y] ~ Standard Normal
$9<5*(;,+ #;(5+(9+ 694(3 ,5:0;@ <5*;065
0.8
X | Y > 0,ρ = 0
0.7
X | Y > 0,ρ = 0.25
X | Y > 0,ρ = 0.5
X | Y > 0,ρ = 0.75
0.6
X | Y > 0,ρ = 0.9
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
-4
-3
-2
-1
0
X
1
2
3
, " #
#
!
4
p.d.f. of X conditional on Y>0; [X,Y] ~ Standard Normal
$9<5*(;,+ #;(5+(9+ 694(3 ,5:0;@ <5*;065
0.8
X| Y>0,ρ=0.5, μ =0, μ =0
X
Y
X| Y>0,ρ=0.5, μ =0.5, μ =0
0.7
X
Y
X| Y>0,ρ=0.5, μ =1, μ =0
X
0.6
Y
X| Y>0,ρ=0.5, μX=1.5, μY=0
X| Y>0,ρ=0.5, μ =2, μ =0
X
0.5
Y
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
-3
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
4
5
X
, " #
#
!
6
p.d.f. of X conditional on Y>0; [X,Y] ~ Standard Normal
$9<5*(;,+ #;(5+(9+ 694(3 ,5:0;@ <5*;065
0.8
X| Y>0,ρ=0.5, μ =0, μ =0
Y
X
X| Y>0,ρ=0.5, μ =0.5, μ =0
0.7
Y
X
X| Y>0,ρ=0.5, μ =1, μ =0
Y
0.6
X
X| Y>0,ρ=0.5, μY=1.5, μX=0
X| Y>0,ρ=0.5, μ =2, μ =0
Y
0.5
X
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
-4
-3
-2
-1
0
X
1
2
3
, " #
#
!
4
+( 14,0/ "$-5( 0) +0,&(3
647<;(;065 6- ! - - - 6;(;065
,
* &- - ! - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - #
"
! #
" ! >/,9, 0:<<- - - (5+ 0:<<- - - 74(/'(' 08 0'(-
- , )
- , )
. *
-
- -
.
) ) *
4,(5: 05+,7,5+,5*,
#64, 7(9;: 6- ;/0: /(5+6<; <:, ;/, (::<47;065 6- 5694(30;@
) ) * # >/0*/ 0: :7,*0C,+ 05 :,*;065 " " # ! +( 201(/3,48 &02(
$/, 7967,5:0;@ :*69, 0: +,=,367,+ *65+0;065(3 65 .
. * $/, 7967,5:0;@ :*69,
% . .
. * .
,C50;065
* ) ) ) ):,9=, ;/(;
!967,9;@ 6- *65; 9(5+64 =(90()3,:
. * . )
. * % . )
):,9=, ;/(; . 0: ( 9(5+64 =(90()3, . 3! D >/0*/ (3:6
4(2, ;/, 7967,5:0;@ :*69, ( 9(5+64 =(90()3, >0;/ +0:;90)<;065
.
3! D
% .
.
% . 3 ! ;
3 ! ;
! ;
3! D
- * #
% ;
3! % ; ;
! % ;
D
3!
. * $/, 7967,5:0;@ :*69,
% . ::<4,
.
.
. # ! !
$/, 7967,5:0;@ :*69, +,5:0;@
! ; . ;
. ;
! ;
; !
!
; !
!
; !
3 ! ; !
!
;
+( $2*,/$-
2($4.(/4 9(&4
" ( @ - - * @
, ) ) * @
( ) ) * @
$/, 4(9.05(3 ;9,(;4,5; ,F,*; *(5 ), >90;;,5 05 ;,94: 6) * " ( @ - - * @
- - * @
- - ) ? , ) ) ) ? " ( ? ( ) ) ) ? +( 02.$-,48 335.14,0/
6> :<776:, ;/(; ) ) * # $/, *65+0;065 5694(3
,8<(;065: (9, <:,-<3 05 ;/0: *(:, (5+ (9, >90;;,5 ),36>
, "# C ,- C " # , "# C , - C " # 69 ;/, <50=(90(;, *(:,
, #
@/<, #).
#).
C
."* ."* ,- C " # C
,- C " # C
,- C " #
#6 >, /(=,
" #
" #
"
#
) ) * # # " #
!
" #
) ) #
!
*
) ) " #
# !
*
#
#
!
) ) * @ #
@ '/,9, 0:<<) ) * -
"
'90;05. 05 ;,94: 6- )
" ( @ ( @
*
* ) * " ( ? ( ?
" ( ? ( ?
" ( ? ( ?
$/0: 56;(;065 >033 ), <:,+ 05 ;/, 9,:; 6- ;/0: 56;,:
+( 6(2$*(
2($4.(/4 9(&4
( - - , 69,6=,9 >, /(=,
( - - * @
" ( @ * @
%
" ( @ A @ 3. @ 1@
A @ %:05. ;/, 7967,5:0;@ :*69, (7796(*/ >, 6);(05
* )
( " ( @ ) ? ( %
" ( ? A ? 1?
A ? +(
2($4.(/4 0/ 4+(
2($4('
$/, 9,3(;065:/07 ),;>,,5 ;/, ;9,(;4,5; 65 ;9,(;,+ 7(9(4,;,9
(5+ ;/, 4(9.05(3 ;9,(;4,5; ,F,*; 0: 6);(05,+ ),36>
((
- - - - )@ 3(> 6- 0;,9(;,+ ,?7,*;(;065:
- - . @ * @
. * )<; - - * *
<:05. ;/, <)050D: ;/,69,4
- - * @ . @ * @
. * . @ * @
" ( @ . * %
" ( @ A @ 3. @ 1@
A @ . @ * @
. @ * @
. * . @
%
! @
. 3! D 1D
. @
. @
$/, :(4, (5(3@:0: *(5 ), +65, >0;/ ;/, 7967,5:0;@ :*69,
((
- - - - )@ 3(> 6- 0;,9(;,+ ,?7,*;(;065:
- - % . ? ) ? % . ) ) * ) )<; - - ) <:05. ;/, <)050D: ;/,69,4
- - ) ? % . ? ) ? % .
% . ? ) ? " ( ? % .
%
" ( ? A ? 1?
):,9=, ;/(; ) ) 953 :<8 A ? % . ? ) ? % .
%
! ? - 3 ! ; 1;
% .
% .
- ) ) * # (: +,C5,+ 05 ;/, :,*;065 >, >6<3+
/(=, ( ( . *65+0;065(3 65 . (5+ , (: -6336>05.
( ( .
+,C5, - - , ) ) . * ( ) ) . * *
) )
.
( .
( D
D
D
-
( ( . , '/,9,
B
.
B
B
B
B
$/, <5*65+0;065(3 ( ( 0: .0=,5 )@
((
- - , ) ) . * ( ) ) . * ! ) ) . ! *
( '/,9, ! 69 ! ! ( ( ( ) ) . ! *
0:<<
! ( ( ( $/, 7967,5:0;@ :*69, 0: +,C5,+ (: . >/,9, ;/,
*65+0;065(3 65 . 0: 56; <:,+ ),36> 05 69+,9 ;6 :(=, 56;(;065 (:,+
65 ;/, 5694(30;@ (::<47;065: >, *(5 6);(05 ;/, -6336>05. -694<3(:
% . . * *
.
.
):,9=, ;/(;
% .
.
.
)<; .
!
!
):,9=, (3:6 ;/(;
.
!
!
% .
!
% .
.
% .
% .
!
!
5*3<+05. ;/0: ,8<(;065 05 ;/, $9,(;4,5; 65 ;9,(;,+ ,F,*;
>, 6);(05
.
( ( . ( % .
( ( % . ( % .
9
( ( % . ( !
!
% .
$/, >,0./;: *(5 ), *(3*<3(;,+ (:
A @ . @ * @
. @ * @
@ * %
! @
. 3! 1
+(
2($4.(/4 0/ 4+( !/42($4('
$/, 9,3(;065:/07 ),;>,,5 ;/, ;9,(;4,5; 65 <5;9,(;,+ 7(9(4,;,9
(5+ ;/, 4(9.05(3 ;9,(;4,5; ,F,*; 0: 6);(05,+ ),36>
()(
- - - - )@ 3(> 6- 0;,9(;,+ ,?7,*;(;065:
- - . @ * @
. * )<; - - * *
<:05. ;/, <)050D: ;/,69,4
- - * @ . @ * @
. * . @ * @
" ( @ . * %
" ( @ A @ 3. @ 1@
A @ . @ * @
. @ * @
. * . @
%.
! @
3! D 1D
. @
. @
$/, :(4, (5(3@:0: *(5 ), +65, >0;/ ;/, 7967,5:0;@ :*69,
(7796(*/
()(
- - - - )@ 3(> 6- 0;,9(;,+ ,?7,*;(;065:
- - % . ? ) ? % . ) ) * ) )<; - - ) <:05. ;/, <)050D: ;/,69,4
- - ) ? % . ? ) ? % .
% . ? ) ? " ( ? % .
%
" ( ? A ? 1? ):,9=, ;/(; ) ) 953 :<8 A ? % . ? ) ? % .
% -
! ? 3 ! ; 1;
% .
% .
- ) ) * # (: +,C5,+ 05 :,*;065 >, >6<3+ /(=,
( ) ( . *65+0;065(3 65 . (5+ , (: -6336>05.
( ) ( . - - , ) ) . * ( ) ) . * +,C5, ) ) *
.
( ( D
D
D
-
.
( ) ( . , '/,9,
B B
B
B
B
.
$/, <5*65+0;065(3 ( ) ( 0: .0=,5 )@
()(
- - , ) ) . * ( ) ) . * ! ) ) . ! *
( ! ) ) * . ! ( '/,9, ! ( ) ( ( ! ) ) * . ! 0:<<
( ) ( ( !
):,9=, (.(05 ;/(;
% .
.
.
)<; .
!
!
!
!
):,9=, (3:6 ;/(;
!
!
% .
!
.
% .
!
% .
.
% .
!
5*3<+05. ;/0: ,8<(;065 05 ;/, $9,(;4,5; 65 ;9,(;,+ ,F,*;
>, 6);(05
.
( ) ( . ( % .
( ) ( % . ( % .
9
( ) ( % . ( !
+( 0&$- 6(2$*(
2($4.(/4 9(&4
!( . . - - . . - - . . . . - - . * . . * . )@ 3(> 6- 0;,9(;,+ ,?7,*;(;065:
- - . * . * @
. * . )<; - - * *
<:05. ;/, <)050D: ;/,69,4
- - * @ . * . * @
. * . . * . * @
" ( @ . * . A @ !
% !
" ( @ A @ 3. @ 1@
. * . * @
. * . . * * @ . * * @
. . $/, :(4, (5(3@:0: *(5 ), +65, >0;/ ;/, 7967,5:0;@ :*69,
(7796(*/
!( . . - - . . - - . . . . - - . * . . * . - - % . ) % . % . ) % . )@ 3(> 6- 0;,9(;,+ ,?7,*;(;065:
- - % . ? % . ) ? % . ) % . )<; - - ) ) <:05. ;/, <)050D: ;/,69,4
- - ) ? % . ? % . ) ? % . ) % . ):,9=, ;/(;
% . ) % . % . % . 65+0;065(3 65 . .
% . ? % . % . ? % . ) ? % . ? % . !( . . " ( ? % . % . A ? ! %
! " ( ? A ? 1?
% . % . - ) ) * # 0: +,C5,+ (: 05 :,*;065 >, >6<3+
6);(05
!( . . - - . . , ) ) . * . ( ) ) . * . .
*
) ) .
( *
+ !
!
)
)
( !
!
*
!
+
*
!
+
) ) ( !
!
*
+
!
!
#
" +
!
*
!
!
( !
!
*
+
!
!
#
" +
!
*
!
!
( !
!
!
!
( !
!
! !
!
( !
!
! !
!
( !
!
):,9=, ;/(; ;/, 7967,5:0;@ :*69, 0: .0=,5 )@ !
>/0*/
04730,:
.
.
5*3<+05. ;/0: ,8<(;065 05 ;/, $ ,F,*; >, 6);(05
!
!
!
!( . . , !
!
! !
!
( !
!
( ( ', (3:6 /(=,
.
% . ! !
! !
% . % . ! ! !
!
. . !( . . ( % . % . . . +( /3425.(/4$- "$2,$%-( #(,*+43
$/, & 7(9(4,;,9 0: +,C5,+ )@
*
+
. . ) . #).! #).&! ,;D: +,C5, ) . *
+
)
0:@ . - . - - +
*
) . - - - +
*
+
*
) . - ) . - - )<; . - -
*
+
*
+
) . - ) . - - *
+
) . - - )@ 3(> 6- 0;,9(;,+ ,?7,*;(;065:
++
* *
) . - - *
++
* *
) . . @ - - * @
*
)<; - - * <:05. ;/, <)050D: ;/,69,4
+
* *
+
) . . @ * @ - - * @
*
*
++
" ( @ ) . . @ * @
)<; *
0:@ . - 0:@ 6. *
A @ %
" ( @ A @ 3 @ 1@
*
+
) . . @
% %
.
0:@ 6. , .
. 3!! 6 > 161>
0:@ 6. > . . >
$/, & 7(9(4,;,9 *(5 (3:6 ), *65:;9<*;,+ <:05. ;/, 7967,5:0;@
:*69, (7796(*/
*
+
0:@ . - ) . - - )@ 3(> 6- 0;,9(;,+ ,?7,*;(;065:
++
* *
) . - - ) ?
++
* *
) . % . ? - - ) ?
) )<; - - ) <:05. ;/, <)050D: ;/,69,4
+
+
* *
) . % . ? ) ? - - ) ? *
*
" ( ? ) . % . ? * @
0:@ . - 0:@ 6. %
" ( ? A ? 1?
* *
+
) . % . ? @ 0:@ . % %
, . . 3! ! 6 ; 161;
)<; *
A
++
-
0:@ . > . % . ;
- ) ) * # 0: +,C5,+ (: 05 :,*;065 (5+
. # ! ! >, >6<3+ 6);(05
* +
) - - 0:@ . - .
+
* ) . * - - .
)@ 3(> 6- 0;,9(;,+ ,?7,*;(;065:
++
* * ) . @ - - * @
.
*
)<; - - * <:05. ;/, <)050D: ;/,69,4
<; . @ 0:@ . - * * +
+
) . @ * @ " ( * .
* * +
+
) . @ * @ . @ * @ " ( * .
! @
@ !
* * !
+
+
) . @ * @ . @ * @ " ( * .
) . . 6> :<776:, . .,C5, .
* * *
+
++
)
0:@ . - ..
@ . @ " ( @* @
"
0:@ . .
*
.
" ( @* @
#
!
+
) . * .
* *
++
) . @ * @
.
* *
+
+
)
@ . @ * @
..
* @
* *
*
6> :<776:, . % . !
+
" ( * +
. . * * * *
+
++
0:@ % . - % .. @ . @ " ( @* @
. @
!
#
"
!
" ( @* @
!
!
% ! ' ' 1D !
1
%
0:@ % . - .
.
"
(
@
1@
*
+
0:@ . %
. . * %
0:@ . * *
++
% . . @ * @
* *
+
+
% .. @ . @ * @
.
!
! @
! . @ * @ !
! !
!
! 1
' ' .
D
@
!
%
1D ! 1@
.
'
* ' .
1
1D ! " ( @ %
.
'
' .
! 1
%
1D
1@
.
1@
$/, 9,3(;065:/07 ),;>,,5 ;/,
# 7(9(4,;,9 (5+ ;/, 4(9.05(3
;9,(;4,5; ,F,*; 0: 6);(05,+ ),36>
$!' - - ( ) . * ) . * ( ) . * ) . * . * . * ( !. .
! !. .
!
!. .
(
@
! !. .
! !. .
A
@
"
.! #
" ( @ !
" ( @ !. .
.! " !. .
.! !. .
.! %
" ( @ A @ #
!
" ( @ A @ 3. @ 1@
A @ ) . @ * @ ) . @ * @
" ( @ . * " ( @ . * ) ) * .
) . @ * @ ) * @
) . @ * @ ) * @
'
'. .
3! D 1D
3! D 1D
$/, :(4, (5(3@:0: *(5 ), +65, >0;/ ;/, 7967,5:0;@ :*69,
$!' - - ( ) % . ) ) % . ) !- - (
?
! !- - ! !- - " - ! #
" ( ? !
!- - - ! " ( ? A ? A ? %
" ( ? A ? 1?
) % . ? ) ? ) % . ? ) ? " ( ? % . ) " ( ? % . ) - ) ) * # (: +,C5,+ 05 :,*;065 >, >6<3+
/(=, $!'. *65+0;065(3 65 . (5+ , (: -6336>05.
$!' . - . * - . * ( ) . * ) . * )
*
.
) .
*
( .
.
( $/, <5*65+0;065(3 $!' 0: .0=,5 )@
$!' - . * - . * ( ) . * ) . * ) . *
) . *
( .
.
( ! 69 ! $/, 7967,5:0;@ :*69, 0: +,C5,+ (: . >/,9, ;/,
*65+0;065(3 65 . 0: 56; <:,+ ),36> 05 69+,9 ;6 :(=, 56;(;065
% . . * *
.
.
$/0: 0: ;/, 7967,5:0;@ :*69,
):,9=, (.(05 ;/(; ;/, 7967,5:0;@ :*69, *(5 ), >90;;,5 (:
% .
.
.
.
)<; !
!
):,9=, (3:6 ;/(;
!
!
% .
!
.
% .
!
% .
.
% .
!
5*3<+05. ;/0: ,8<(;065 05 ;/, $9,(;4,5; 65 ;9,(;,+ ,F,*;
>, 6);(05
!
!
!
!
% .
% .
% .
% .
( % .
% .
$!' % . ( (3*<3(;05. ;/, >,0./;:
) . @ * @ ) . @ * @
" ( @ . * " ( @ . * ) * @ . @ ) * @ . @
" ( @ . * " ( @ . * .
.
@ @ " ( @ " ( @ A ? 0.( $2$.(4(23 $/' 2$1+3
,; ;/, 7(9(4,;,9: ),
" , #
" #
! # !
,
. . .
" #
" . #
! # !
.
. # $9,(;4,5; 7(9(4,;,9:
( , ?
( ) ( ? ( ?
? ( ( ? ( ?
$/, !(9(4,;,9: ',0./;: $ $ $$ $%$
0.4
ATE(U )
D
MTE(U )
D
0.35
TT(U )
D
TUT(U )
D
ATE, MTE, TT, TUT
0.3
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
U
0.8
D
) * ( <2/>829> " ( ? A *$",'$(, ? %
" ( ? A *$",'$(, ? 1?
1
$ 0: ( 7(9(4,;,9 ;/(; +6,: 56; +,7,5+: 65 ;/, 7967,5:0;@
:*69, $/, $ 7(9(4,;,9 0: ;/, 9,;<95 >/,5 ;/, (.,5; 0: 05+0F,9,5;
),;>,,5 6<;*64,: $/, $$ 7(9(4,;,9 0: ;/, 9,;<95 >/,5 ;/, (.,5;
0: ;9,(;,+ <, ;6 )0(: :,3,*;065 ;/0: 7(9(4,;,9 0: 56; ,8<(3 ;6 $
(5+ 0;: =(3<, 0: ()6=, $ $/, $%$ 7(9(4,;,9 0: ;/, 9,;<95 >/,5
;/, (.,5; 0: 56; ;9,(;,+ .(05 >, :,, ;/, )0(: :,3,*;065 9<5505.
$/, 9,;<95 -69 56; ;9,(;,+ (.,5;: 0: :4(33,9 ;/(5 -69 ;9,(;,+ (5+ (:
;/, (.,5; 0: 469, 7967,5:, ;6 .,; ;9,(;,+ (33 .(05 +,*9,(:, $ 0:
),;>,,5 ;/, ;9,(;,+ (5+ <5;9,(;,+ *(:,:
$/, &:
# *6,E*0,5;: (5+ >,0./;: (9, 736;;,+ ),36>
$/, 05:;9<4,5;: <:,+ (9, ;/, 7967,5:0;@ :*69, (5+ . . (5+ . $/, 6);(05,+ *6=(90(5*,: (9, 05 ;/, -6336>05. ;()3,
5:;9<4,5;
:@. - :@. *
.
.
% . !
D
(U )
weights
D
IV (U )
θ1
0.6
θ2
propensity Score
D
IV
propensity Score
0.5
OLS
weights
(U )
D
(U )
D
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
D
MTE(U ), IV
θ1
D
(U ), IV
θ2
D
(U ), IV
D
IV (U )
D
(U ),OLS
MTE(U )
0
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
U
D
0.8
1
2'(2(' 40&+$34,& 02.$- $3(
65:0+,9 C9:; ( =(90(;065 "6@ 46+,3 ,*6564@ >0;/ ;/9,, :,*;69: ,;
- - (5+ -
), ;/, ;>6 76;,5;0(3 6<;*64,: (5+ 3,; + +,56;, ;/,
)05(9@ =(90()3, +,C505. ,(*/ :,*;69 = $/, -6<9 9(5+64 =(90
()3,: >/0*/ +,C5, ;/, 46+,3D: 05;,9=(3: (9, .0=,5 )@ + + + +
$/, 9(5+64 =(90()3,: (9, *65:;9(05,+ ;6 ;/, :,8<,5*, 6- 05,8<(30;0,:
+ + + +
', (::<4, ;/, -6336>05. :;9<*;<9, -69 ;/, 46+,3
- )
- )
-
)
&
- -+
+
+ ++ D @ ++ ) ) )
* B# .
! !
+ "# "
!
+
! #
! # ! ! + +
6> . 0: (336>,+ ;6 ), ( =,*;69 (5+ ),05. *699,3(;,+ >0;/ + $/, 05:;9<4,5;(3 =(90()3, 0: .0=,5 )@ ( 305,(9 *64)05(;065 6=(90()3,: .
+( $2*,/$-
2($4.(/4 9(&4
- - * @
) ) * @
0:@) ) * ,
@
@/<* - - * @
) ) * @
@
-
- * @
)
) * @
@
+( 6(2$*(
2($4.(/4 9(&4
- - -
- +(
2($4.(/4 0/ 4+(
2($4('
0=,5 * ) . + ++ -+ -+ + -+ -+ . ++ * . ++ . -+ -+ . ++ * . ++ * @
. -+ -+ * . ++ * . ++ * @
* . ++ * . ++ * @
. -+ -+ * @ + +<, * )
. +
* . ++ * . ++ * @
. " ( ++ @ + $/, 05,8<(30;@ 9,:;90*;065 +++ ++ +6,: 56; (336> ;6 <:, ;/,
-694<3(:
++
'
++ @
@ . .
1@
. + +
.! "
(
@
#
"
"*! .
! + .! "*! * @
'
.
@ ! +
@ ! +
,
,
1@
!
!
'/,9,
!
!
(
! (
!
!
(
! (
69,6=,9 ;/, *647<;(;065 *(5 ), +65, <:05. 5694(3 796)()030;@
+,5:0;@ -<5*;065: >0;/ ( *(9,-<3 :7,*0C*(;065: 6- ;/, 3040;: 6- 05;,
.9(;065:
69 ;/,
++ -+ -+ + -+ -+ . ++ * . ++ . -+ -+ . ++ * . ++ * @
,; + . ++ ++ ++ + + *
*
@
.
+
+ +
+
++
'
-+ -+ + * + * @ 3 @1@
'
-+ -+ + @ + 3 @1@
%
" ( ++ @ + @ + 3 @1@
+ 5 ;/, ,?(473, 6- ;>6 9(5+64 =(90()3,: + + $/, -694<3(: (9,
)(:,+ 65 ;/, 796)()030;0,:
!96)()030;0,:
. + * . + * . + * . + (5+ (9, .0=,5 )@
- - . - - . + * . + * @
. - - * * @
%. %
%
"
(
@
. 3 1
1
3 @1@
% %
. %
. 3 1
1
1@
%. %
%
"
(
@
. 3 . + . + 1. + 1. + 3 @1@
%
%
. %
. 3 . + . + 1. + 1. + 3 @1@
" . + ( ! ( ( ! ( #
):,9=, ;/(; "#
!
. + (
! ( ( ! (
:<*/ ;/(; + + 3 % % 1
1
0: ;/, 5659,:;90*;,+ )0=(90(;, 5694(3 +,5:0;@ 6
" . + ( ! ( ( ! ( #
#
!
. + ( ! ( ( ! (
( ( 3 %
'
%
' 1
1
% 0- + + (9, :@44,;90*
'/,9,
-
- . -
- * . + * @ . -
- * * @
%%
%
"
(
@
.
3 1
1
3 @1@
% %%
.
3 1
1
3 @1@
%%
%
"
(
@
.
! 3 . + . + 1. + 1. + 3 @1@
% %%
.
! 3 . + . + 1. + 1. + 3 @1@
+(
2($4.(/4 0/ 4+( !/42($4('
%:05. ;/, 79,=06<: 56;(;065 ;/, ++ *(5 ), *647<;,+ (:
++ -+ -+ + - - . - - * . + * @
. - - * * @
% %.
%
" ( @ 3 1
1
3 @1@
% % % .
3 1
1
3 @1@
% %.
"
(
@
! 3 . + . + 1. + 1. + 3 @1@
% % %.
! 3 . + . + 1. + 1. + 3 @1@
%
-
- . -
- . + * . + * @
. -
- * * @
%. %
%
"
(
@
. 3 1
1
3 @1@
%
%
. %
. 3 1
1
3 @1@
%. %
%
"
(
@
. 3 . + . + 1. + 1. + 3 @1@
%
%
. %
. 3 . + . + 1. + 1. + 3 @1@
+( " $2$.(4(2 )02 40&+$34,&
+2(3+0-' 0'
(-3
65:0+,9 ;/, *64465 9,.9,::065 6- 65 - :<*/ ;/(; 0: ,8<(3 ;6
= = 69 ,; + . * ) (5+ 3,; ;/, 05:;9<4,5; ), . .
*
-
. . ." - :@ . - "
:@ . . . . &
&
+ -+ (5+ =+
0.154,/* 4+( /5.(2$402 &06$2,$/&(
0:@. - . . &
. ++ * . ++ -+ . . +
.
.
+<, * )
&
." &
. ++ * . ++ -+ +
-+ * @ +
* @
"
. . ++ * . ++ * @
. +
&
.
-+ * @ ." . ++ * . ++ * * @
+
.
&
-+ * @ ." . ++ * . ++ * * @
+
." . ++ * * @ "&
.
"
+
. . ++ * * @
#
-+ * @!
$/, ()6=, 0: ,8<(3 ;6
"
.. ++ * * @ . ++ * * @
"&
.
"
+ ..
++ * * @ . ++ * * @
#
-+ * @!
&
-+ * @ +
>/,9,
+ @
+ @ *
@ "
++ @ . ++ @ -69 = '
..
&
-+ -+ * @ + @* @
+ @
'
+
&
" ( ++ @ +
&' +
" ( ++ @ + @
3. @1@
+ @
3. @1@
+ @
"
++ @ . ++ @ ..
3 :< ++ ++ + . ++ . ++ +
#6 >, 5,,+ ;6 <:, ;/, 5655694(3: 4(9.05(3 +,5:0;@ -<5*
;065:
0.154,/* 4+( '(/0.,/$402 &06$2,$/&(
0:@. - . . . . . . &
. . = . ++ * . ++ +
.
.
+<, * )
&
." =
&
+
= . ++ * . ++ * @
"
. . ++ * . ++ * @
+
&
. +
&
.
= ." . ++ * . ++ * * @
+
=+
$
= ." . ++ * * @ #
#
+
!
"
. . ++ * * @
&
." . ++ * * @
.
"
. "
+
.
&
+
.
&
"
++ * * @ . ++ * * @
..
+ @
+
5 ;/, ,?(473, 79676:,+ ;/, ,?7,*;(;065: (9, )(:,+ 65 ;/9,,
=(90()3,:
,; ( (5+ ( ( :6 >, /(=,
"
"
.
.
"
#
"
"
#
"
" # " . +
"
" #
!
. +
#
#
#
#
!
$
$
$
( ! ( ( ! ( ( ! ( #
#
$
$
$
#
( ! ( ( ! ( ( ! ( #
!
$
$
$
(
. + ! ( ( ! ( ( ! (
"
"
#"
" . + ",:;90*;,+ ;6 ++ ++ + . ++ . ++ +
3! % % % '/,9,
1
1
1
0: ;/, 5659,:;90*;,+ )0=(90(;, 5694(3 +,5:0;@ 6-
"
"
#"
" . + (
3! %
(
$
!
(
(
$
!
(
$
$
( ! ( ( ! (
$
$
(
(
(
. + !
! (
( %
' ' ' (
$
( #
#
$
#
( ! ( #
!
$
(
! (
!
1
1
1 % 0- + + (9, :@44,;90*
$/, 3(:; 796)()030;@ *(5 (3:6 ), *(3*<3(;,+ )@ ;/, 4(9.05(3 +0:;90)<;065 6- >/0*/ .0=,: ;/, :(4, 796)()030;@ % +,:*90),+ 05 $$ :,*;065
$-&5-$4,0/ 0) 4+( 120%$%,-,4,(3
65+0;06505. 05 @ @ . + @ @
' '
3 1
1
. @ . + @ @
' '
3 1
1
. '/,9, 3 >(: +,:*90),+ 05 $$ :,*;065
$-&5-$4,0/ 0) 4+( 71(&4$4,0/3
"
@ ..
+ @
. .. + @
. .
@
' ' '
. . 3! 1
1
1
. "
+ @
@ ..
. .. + @
. .
@
' ' '
. . 3! 1
1
1
. " #(,*+43
@
@ @
@
@ @
" 34,.$4023
$
'
+
$
+
'
++ 7+ @
7+ @
1@
1@
/04+(2 $1120$&+
0:@. - . . &
. . . ++ * . ++ -+ +
.
.
+<, * )
&
." &
. ++ * . ++ -+ +
-+ * @ +
* @
"
. . ++ * . ++ * @
. +
&
.
-+ * @ ." . ++ * . ++ * * @
+
.
&
-+ * @ ." . ++ * . ++ * * @
+
"
. . ++ * * @ "&
.
+ ." . ++ * * @
#
-+ * @!
$/, ()6=, 0: ,8<(3 ;6
"
..
++ * * @ . ++ * * @
"&
.
"
+ ..
++ * * @ . ++ * * @
#
-+ * @!
"
.. ++ * * @ . ++ * * @
" "&
. "
+
.. ++ * * @ . ++ * * @
&
+
-+ * @ + @ *
@ "
>/,9, + @ .. ++ @ . ++ @ -69 = '
&
-+ -+ * @ + @* @
'
+ @
+
&
+
" ( ++ @ + @
3. @1@
##
-+ * @ ++ A+ !!
&' +
+ @
" ( ++ @ + @
3. @1@
"
++ @ . ++ @ ..
3 :< ++ ++ + . ++ . ++ +
/ 7$.1-(
<;*64,:
/60*, 6+,3
- )
+ ++ . * ++ - )
= -
)
!(9(4,;90A(;065
) ) )
* # . + +
# ! ! (5+ + + ! (5+ ! 0:@) ) * 0:@)
) * !(9(4,;,9
&(3<,
!(9(4,;,9
&(3<,
( ( ) (
( ( ) (
( (
*!
( (
*
TT21, TUT21, Weights and MTE21, Stochastic Case
$/,
9+,9,+ /60*, "6@ 6+,3 <5+,9 694(30;@
MT E21
ω
T T 21
0.4
ω
T UT 21
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
-0.1
-4
-3
-2
-1
0
v
1
( ( ( ) ( -69 2
3
4
TT21, TUT21, Weights and MTE21, Stochastic Case
$/,
9+,9,+ /60*, "6@ 6+,3 <5+,9 694(30;@
MT E32
ω
T T 32
0.4
ω
T UT 32
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
-0.1
-4
-3
-2
-1
0
v
1
( ( ( ) ( -69 2
3
4
IV
IV21, IV32 Weights and MTE21, MTE32 Generalized Case, (W2 )
$/, 9+,9,+ /60*, "6@ 6+,3 <5+,9 694(30;@
MT E
MT E
0.6
ω
ω
0.4
21
32
IV21
IV32
0.2
0
-0.2
-0.4
-4
-3
-2
-1
0
v
1
2
* + (: 5:;9<4,5;
3
4
9+,9,+ /60*, "6@ 6+,3 <5+,9 694(30;@
IV
IV21, IV32 Weights and MTE21, MTE32 Generalized Case, (Z )
$/,
MT E
MT E
0.6
ω
ω
0.4
21
32
IV21
IV32
0.2
0
-0.2
-0.4
-4
-3
-2
-1
0
v
1
2
* . (: 5:;9<4,5;
3
4
0..(/43 $%054
+( 3,*/ 0) 4+( #(,*+43 $/' 0
6$2,$/&( 0) $/' 65:0+,9 C9:; ( =(90(;065 "6@ 46+,3 ,*6564@ >0;/ ' :,*;69: ,;
- % ), ;/, 76;,5;0(3 6<;*64,: (5+ 3,; + +,56;, ;/, */60*, =(90
()3, +,C505. ,(*/ :,*;69 = ' $/, ' 9(5+64 =(90()3,:
>/0*/ +,C5, ;/, 46+,3D: 05;,9=(3: 6- */60*, (9, .0=,5 )@ + + + + $/, 9(5+64 =(90()3,: (9, *65:;9(05,+ ;6 ;/, :,8<,5*, 6- 05,8<(30;0,:
+ + + + + + ', (::<4, ;/, -6336>05. :;9<*;<9, -69 ;/, 46+,3
-+ + )+
&
- -+ +
+
+ ++ . * ++ ) ) ) * B# . B# ! ! + + "
+
) * . +
+( " $2$.(4(2 )02 40&+$34,&
+2(3+0-' 0'(-
,; ;/, 05:;9<4,5; 6- (5 & ,:;04(;065 ), . .
*
-
. . ." - :@ . - :@ . . . ." &
&
+ -+ (5+ =+
647<;05. ;/, 5<4,9(;69 *6=(90(5*,
0:@. - . . - &
. ++ * . ++ -+ . . +
3,; . . ."
773@05. ;/, (> 6- ;,9(;,+ ?7,*;(;065
." &
. ++ * . ++ -+ * . +
+
<; ) * . + ." &
. ++ * . ++ -+ * +
<, ;6 <)050D: $/,69,4 (5+ (> 6- ;,9(;,+ ?7,*;(;065:
&
." &
. ++ * . ++ *
-+ * +
." . ++ * . ++ * *
+
-+ * &
." . ++ * *
." . ++ * *
-+ * +
$/, ()6=, ,8<(;065 0: ,8<(3 ;6
.
&
"
+
"
"
..
++ * * . ++ * * ##
!!
"
..
++ * * . ++ * * @ -+ * +
&
-+ * @ +
+ @ A+ + @ A+ *
@ + A "
..
A+ @ . A+ @ -69 = '
"
+ @ A+ .. @ A+ . @ A+ &
-+ -+ * @ + @ A+ * @ + A >/,9,
+ @ A+ +
%:05. ;/, 4(9.05(3 +0:;90)<;065 6- ,(*/ ++ >, /(=,
+ @
&
-+ -+ * @ +
+ @*
@
"
..
++ @ . ++ @
647<;05. ;/, & >, /(=,
*
&
-+ -+ * @ A+ @ * @
+
A+ @ + @
"
..
++ @ . ++ @
:@. :@. @
.
+
+
"
++ @ A+ @ ..
:@. #6 >/(; +,;,9405,: ;/, +0F,9,5*, 05 ;/, :0.5: 6- ;/, & >,0./;:
"
0: ;/, ,?7,*;(;065 .. ++ @ +(02(. . + = ' @ =549A+ @ =549A+ @ =549
! .
). !
"
=549 ..
++ @ "
..
++ @
"
..
@ A+ ++ A+
'
"
..
@ A+ 1
'
! @ A+ . 1
. @ A+ . . ++ @
=549A+ @ =549
:@ . =549
!
=549
. '
. @ A+
1
@ A+ . " = @
020--$28 . + = ' @ =549
+ @
0.154,/* 4+( '(/0.,/$402 &06$2,$/&(
0:@. - . . . . . . &
. . = . ++ * . ++ +
&
+
&
." &
= . ++ * . ++ +
=
= ." . ++ * *
+
=+
*
." . ++ * . ++ *
&
." . ++ * *
&
." . ++ * *
+
&
"
..
++ * *
+
&
. ++ * * + @*
@
+
020--$28 . + = ' @ A+ @ !
A+ @ + @
:@. $
+
+ @
+ @*
@
" ! # #