Harold B. Lee Library ACCESS SERVICES DEPT. 3445 HBLL, PROVO, UT, 84602 PHONE: (801) 422-8663 FAX: (801) 422-0471 EMAIL: [email protected] Thank you for using the Harold B. Lee Library! The document you requested is attached. If there is a problem with the content/quality of this document, please contact us with the following info: ILL Number Your OCLC Symbol Problem Description _____ This is the wrong article/material _____ The document is unreadable/illegible and should be resent _____ Some pages were missing: pp. ____ to ____ _____ Some edges were cutoff: pp. ____ to ____ _____ Other (explain): NOTICE: This material may be protected by copyright law Title 17 U.S. Code Polynesians and Mormonism The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in the “Islands of the Sea” Paul Morris ABSTRACT ؛Polynesia has a particular place in the history of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS Church). The region that heralded the Church’s first overseas missions includes seven of the world’s top ten nations in terms of the proportion of Mormons in the population, and it is home to six Mormon temples. The Polynesian Latter-day Saint population is increasing in both percentage and absolute numbers, and peoples in the Pacific “islands of the sea” continue to play a central role in the Mormon missionary imaginary. This article explores Polynesians in the LDS Church and critically evaluates different theories seeking to explain this growing religious affiliation. Scholars of Mormonism and commentators explain this growth in terms of parallels between Mormonism and indigenous Polynesian traditions, particularly family lineage and ancestity, and theological and ritual affinities. After evaluating these claims in light of scholarly literature and intertdews with Latter-day Saints, however, I conclude that other reasons-especially education and other new opportunities-may equally if not more si^ificantly account for the appeal of Mormonism to Polynesians. KEYWORDS ؛Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Mormonism, Polymesia, Samoa, Tonga, New Zealand Nova Religio: TheJournal ojAlternative and Emergent Religions,MoVuwve \&١k\e 4,١ا؟ﺣﺠﺎةل 83101־. ISSN 1092.90 (print), 1541-8480. (electronic). © 2015 by The Regents of the University of California. All rights reseived. Please direct all requests for permission to photocopy or reproduce article content through the University of California Press’s Rights and Permissions website, at http://www.ucpressjoumals.com/reprintinfo.asp. DOI: 10.1525/nr.2015.18.4.83. 83 Noi Religio οι^ΕΐΓίΗ^τ ;!f :: :¡E ::purch{::؛ Mormons haveCldentifiedTPolynesian ةﻟﻠﻤﺎًةذwith^the “island؛ Ρ of the sea”٤ marked in their scriptures for missionaiy activity. The region continues to be the focus of considerable Mormon missionaty ener^ and investment. Conversion to the LDS Church is associated with physical improvements in health (in the absence of alcohol and tobacco), fertility (families are larger), and cross-generational education and employment opportunities. Spiritual benefits are said to include enhanced fellowship, strengthened familial bonds and more positive views of the future. Polynesia currently is in the throes of extensive economic, political and religious change resulting from globalization.2 European missionaty churches, both Protestant and Catholic, long have been the guardians of traditional island cultures, integrating ecclesiastical structures with village and small-town cultures. The last three decades, however, have seen major challenges to this order by evangelical and Pentecostal churches and the LDS Church.s In this article I draw on academic studies and fieldwork, which ineludes meetings with LDS Church officials and former Mormon missionaries in the Polynesian islands including New Zealand, and in Utah at Brigham Young University and Salt Lake City. I conducted interviews with Latter-day Saints in the three largest LDS communities in Polynesia: Samoa (2009 and 2012), Tonga (2009), and New Zealand (2010-2013).* I asked Church officials, members and recent converts what attracted them to the LDS Church, how it differed from their previous churches, what Changed in their lives after joining the LDS ChuCh, and what their hopes and aspirations were for the ffiture. Analysis of the literature and intenlew data leads to the conclusion that while lineage and family rituals may well be important, there are significant parallels and differences between Polynesian and Mormon teachings and traditions. The attraction of Mormonism to- Polynesians more likely is located in the LDS Church approach to both transcendental and practical needs generated by rapid social and cultural transformation. Mormons tackle these pressing concerns by offering a communal and family way of life that offers social and educational opportunities presented as affirming valued ancestral Polynesian traditions. THE LDS CHURCH Founded in 1830, the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints holds distinctive beliefs and practices, and adheres to its own sacred texts as well as a system of temporal and spiritual governance. The LDS Church maintains that the original teachings of Jesus Christ were lost and the true gospel was restored by their prophet, Joseph Smith, Jr. 84 Morm: Polynesians and Momouhm (1805-1844). While Mormons historically have stressed their differences from mainstream American Protestantism, over the last three decades they have emphasized their linkages with, and participated in, interfaith groups and events.؟ There appear to be three discrete categories of Latter-day Saints: 1) those who are baptized but not active2 )؛those who regularly worship locally but do not currently hold a “temple recommend ^"؛and 3) those who worship locally and at a temple. Like other religions, the LDS Church has both exoteric and esoteric dimensions, with particular teachings and ceremonies aailable only to initiates. The ateence of a temple recommend corresponds to the exoteric level, where Mormons emphasize Jesus, scripture, hymns and Sunday services. The esoteric level includes “Temple Mormons” who participate in certain rituals in a Mormon temple and learn about hidden theologies. While temple worship is an aim for many, the proportion of Temple Mormonsand the rate at which LDS adherents may become Temple Mormons—varies greatly in different places, effectively creating segmented communities.? In Tonga, for example. Temple Mormons are a significandy higher proportion of all Mormons than in Samoa, where the rate of transition to Temple Mormon is slower, reflecting diversely structured communities with different characteristics.« Hierarchical membership levels notwithstanding, official LDS Church figures include all baptized and confirmed members without regard to current religious activity or self-identification, unless they have been excommunicated or-have asked to be removed. It is clear that the number of those in good standing and who tithe at the stipulated level necessary to obtain a temple recommend is considerably lower than official Church figures.^ Another issue is global LDS Church membership growth. In 1984 Rodney Stark developed two figures for potential future growth: the lower based on growth at 30 percent per decade, the higher at 50 percent. At the lower figure, by 2080 there would be more than 60 million Mormons worldwide, while at 50 percent there would be 250 million. زاStark later wrote more cautiously that Mormons were “destined to become a large religious group, with a significant membership around the world. لI Indeed, the LDS Church has experienced global growth, especially in Latin America, Africa and parts of Asia. Non-Europeans are now in the majority, and currently more than two of evety three Mormons are C0nverts.12 THE LDS CHURCH IN POLYNESIA LDS Church involvement in the Pacific Islands began in the 1840s as the first mission beyond the English-speaking world. Following other missionaries, from 1851 the LDS Church taught that Polynesians were 85 Νουα Religo descended from the ancient Israelites( LDS missionaries converted those who had earlier converted to other forms of Christianity or had some biblical knowledge, sought out community leaders, used native langages as vehicles for missionaty endeavors and lived among their new co-religionists. Samoa Samoa usually refers to the sovereign, independent nation-state of Samoa, formerly Western Samoa, which has the largest native Polynesian population at nearly 188,000.14 One-third of Samoans are members of the Congregational Christian Church Samoa (Ekalesia Faapotopotoga Kerisiano Samoa), and although this is still the largest denomination it has declined from nearly half the population. Methodist and Roman Catholic numbers have likewise shrunk. In 1981 tliese three Christian denominations made up more than 85 percent of the population. During the same period the LDS Church, whose members have a higher birth rate than members of other churches( has grown from eight to 15 percent according to census figures, although official LDS Church figures are three times higher. The Church reports 16 stakes (geographical ecclesiastical divisions), 134 congregations, a mission, and a temple. The Apia Samoa Temple is imposing against the skyline of the capital. This temple also serves the Latter-day Saints of nearby American Samoa( LDS missionaty work in Samoa dates from 1863, when a Hawaiian group estranged from other Mormons established a re-baptized community and reconnected to the LDS Church in Utah. LDS Church membership grew as Samoans became ordained elderc (adult priests in the Melchizedek priesthood) and left their villages to develop more remote communities. In the early 1900s, the Book of Mormon was translated into Samoan and the LDS Church established Sauniatu, outside Apia, as a refuge for Mormon converts expelled from their villages. Latter-day Saint numbers grew in the 1920s and 1930s with church schools playing an important role. Local Latter-day Saints were largely self-supporting during World War II, and direct missionary work restarted in 1946. Although many Latter-day Saints migrated to New Zealand and Hawaii in the 1950s, numbers grew steadily, as did the number of new churches. Samoa became an independent state in 1962, and in 1983 the Apia Samoa Temple was dedicated, creating a sense of stature and permanence for the LDS Church in Samoa( In the late 1980s, missionaty activity intensified and numbers grew considerably, causing tension in a number of rillages where local leadership councils excluded the LDS Church.18 Among recent LDS converts interriewed was a 37-year-old villager who had studied at a Methodist seminaty but had not been ordained. As a Seventhly Adventist who also 86 Má: Polynesians and Momonà had attended a Catholic church, he joined the LDS Church after praying about where he could best serve God, who told him to “־go to the Mormons.” He based his faith on Jesus and the scriptures and did not focus on any notable differences in beliefs between Mormonism and the earlier Christian denominations he had experienced, although he was “opposed to tattoos and alcohol.” He appeared to be more concerned about his children’s education than with his ancestors, and loyalty to the traditional "ways of Samoa” was less important to him than LDS “freedom of worship” and manageable tithing. Another interviewee, a 29-year-old female, had grown up in the Congregational Christian Church Samoa to which her mother belonged (her father was Catholic) before joining the Mormons. She had married in an LDS Church and more recently had been baptized. She reported that the 2009 Samoa earthquake and tsunami had prompted her attraction to the Mormon teaching about "families forever," which intensified after her maternity leave amid groWng financial pressures. She felt that the Latter-day Saints were distinctive for their “friendly and happy-tosee-you atmosphere,” and she liked the Sunday School classes for different age groups, including specific activities for women and children. She had good feelings about the LDS Church, and she appreciated the lower financial burden compared to her previous church. Developing “closer relationships with femily" and spending "more time together under one roof’ was important for her, so family relationships would continue after death. One 41־year־old male from a small village was a subsistence farmer with five children. His religious journey had taken him to the LDS Church via the Catholic Church, Assemblies of God, Seventh-day Adventist Church, and the Congregational Christian Church Samoa. He reported "feeling happiness all the time,” saying he “felt in my heart the teachings of the church.” His earlier life had been very stressful, with “money things all the time,” but a particular event set him on the path to the LDS Church. He had been shamed publicly in his previous church when names were announced from the pulpit of those who had given sufficiently and those who had not.19 The whole congregation, he recalled, looked at “me and my shame.” He found LDS tithing to be more manageable. Whereas before he had been required to pay for ministers and their families, and for funerals and other sebees, he appreciated the LDS Church’s encouragement of “free service” and was conrinced that his prerious churches were not the way “the l^rd wanted His church to be.” He understood the essential LDS Church difference to be in its liberation and freedom. His heart was now “lightened,” and he knew he was no longer “enslaved by the curse of stress and church leaders.” His family, particularly his children, were happier. The LDS Church difference, he said, was “in the faces, happiness.” He wanted his children to be educated,20 but he also felt personally empowered by the 87 Νοι Religo missionaries’ promise that he would preach in the LDS Church. To that end, he was learning to read with a focus on the Bible and the Book of Mormon. While approximately one-third of Latter-day Saints in Samoa are Temple Mormons,2! those quoted above were not. All emphasized the burdens of other churches’ tithing, the benefits of LDS Church education, positive family teachings, respect and dignity, and personal exampies—themes echoed by many new Latter-day Saints. Very few interàewees reported converting for theological reasons or the truth of LDS doctrine ؛in fact, few were capable of articulating any theological or doctrinal differences at all. They spoke mostly about Jesus and his teachings, with very little or no mention of specific Mormon scriptures. A major part of the appeal came from educational opportunities for themselves and their children and limited church financial demands. Samoan Latter-day Saints do not directly fund church buildings or pay for cler^—all men age 18 and older (and boys ages 12 to 18) are priests—and they are not expected to offer their ministers liuaana (gifts). Samoan Mormons effectively opt out of the traditional village system of reciprocal gift-giving. The movement of people from villages to Apia for paid work and other opportunities, including school for their children, has created a class of people beyond the safety of village protection.22 Young people particularly feel the lure of the capital city, and there is a groWng population of “mixed race”23 urban poor who are targeted by new churches, including the LDS Church. Their conversations give insight not only into their perceptions of the limitations of their former churches but also into their aspirations for themselves and their families. Becoming Latter-day Saints entails lifestyle changes, such as giving up alcohol, which have both health and financial benefits, and the LDS churches offer practical support for those in need. Mormon missionaty activity has continued to grow in recent decades, and LDS membership numbers in Samoa have doubled. In American Samoa, the LDS figure is approximately 20 percent and growing.2^ Tonga The Kingdom of Tonga is a constitutional monarchy that was part of the British Empire from 1901 to 1952. The population of just over 100,000 is almost entirely Polynesian, and enshrined in their constitution is mandatoty Sabbath Sunday observance “forever.”2 ؟Tongans are 98 percent Christian—37 percent Methodist, 17 percent Mormon and 16 percent Catholic. The LDS Church, however, is the only one of the three that enjoys continued and steady growth.2^ The LDS Church in Tonga began in 1891 with a Samoan mission, which was abandoned six years later after only fifteen converts. After 88 Μοέ: Polynesians and Mormonism several rocky decades, during which he government once banned LDS missionaries, in 1946 the Book of Mormon was translated into Tongan. During and after World War II, restrictions on non-Tongan missionaries led to local husband-and-wife missionary teams continuing the work.27 This local leadership lasted until the 1960s and resulted in a largely local church with high levels of retention and the highest percentage of members serving full-time missions worldwide. The LDS Church has a presence in evety settlement of more than a thousand inhabitants, and Tonga has the largest number of Mormons per capita of any nation. I was told by a Tongan Mormon elder that they were aiming for Tonga to be the first majority Mormon country.28 Schools feature largely in this success story. Tonga has near universal literacy and comparatively high rates of (largely overseas-trained) university graduates. Ninety percent of seconda^ education in Tonga is provided by religious schools. The first LDS school opened in 1907 and another in 1924, and the LDS Church currendy runs six middle schools, but it was the 1952 opening of Liahona High School that made a most significant impact, and it now is widely acknowledged as one of the biggest and best schools in Tonga, with 90 percent of students being Latter-day Saints.29 So important is education that so-called “School Mormons” join the LDS Church when their children are approaching high school age and remain until they graduate from Brigham Young University-Hawaii.3 ״The Nuku’alofa Tonga Temple, the county’s largest building, opened in the 1980s across from the Liahona High School and now is the focal point for Tongan Latter-day Saints. The site also contains a cultural resource center conserving traditional practices, music and dance, reflecting the LDS Church’s acknowledgment of the importance of culture to Tongan Latter-day Saints. The first member of the royal family. Princess ‘Elisiva Fusipala Vaha’i (1949-2014), joined the LDS Church in 1989 and the first Latter-day Saint government minister was appointed in 2006. The LDS Church plays a major role in the public and economic life of the kingdom as the largest private employer with responsibility for the county’s most extensive building projects. The LDS Church has invested considerable amounts of money in Tonga and there are sizeable Tongan Latter-day Saint communities in the United States, New Zealand, Australia and American Samoa. As across the Pacific in the United States, however, there are tensions between LDS Church norms and Tongan culture, such as the debate over whether kavcpx ceremonies and recreational consumption were forbidden under the “Word of Wisdom,” the scriptural guidelines for healthy physical and spiritual living. 32 There also are concerns about where the line between Mormon practice and Tongan culture is drawn. Nevertheless, Tongans are particularly receptive to the LDS claim that the Book of Mormon and genealo^ connect contempora^ Tongans, 89 Νοι Migio and more generally Polynesians, to the ancient Nephites, heirs of God’s promises to the people of Israel.33 New Zealand Mormon missionaries first landed in New Zealand in 1854. Early attention was on the European settlers but with limited results. There were fewer than a hundred baptized members by 1880 and these small numbers were depleted further by converts heading for Utah.34 Mormons were viewed as alien Americans by the dominant British cul. ture in New Zealand and were not welcomed by the churches already there. Such hostility led to censure in Parliament^ and even antiMormon riots as late as 1901. In the 1870s LDS Church attention turned to the Maori, with missionaries living in Maori villages and learning their language. These efforts bore fruit in the 1880s, due partly to the mis^ sionaries’ proximity to the Maori and partly to a number of Maori leaders foretelling the coming of a new dispensation,.^ a belief still held by many. Amore significantfactor, perhaps, was Maori disillusionment with the way the churches, particularly the Anglican Church, had sided with the government, militia and settlers during the New Zealand wars (18451872 )־over the appropriation of land the Maori deemed theire. Anglican minister Samuel Marsden (1764-1838), of the Church Missionary Society, introduced Christianity to the Maori of New Zealand in 1814. He subscribed to the then-standard missionaty view that all peoples were necessarily descended from Noah. Maori, for exampie, could be traced back to Noah’s son Shem. Marsden, however, went further. He believed Maori to have "sprung from some dispersed Jews, at some,period or other,” and he saw in them numerous biblical beliefs and practices now lamentably much C0rrupted.37 This probably novel view that Maori were descendants of Abraham led later missionaries to identify Maori increasingly with the biblical Lost Tribes of Israel, ^ile Lost Tribes discourse is evident earlier, for example when the Lost Tribes were “found” in Britain by proponents of British Israelism, Tudor Parfitt argues conrincingly that what we might call neo-Israelite identities and identifications found across South Asia, Sub-Saharan Africa and Oceania are an “innate feature of colonial discourse.’’38 Anglican missionaries thus presented biblical narratives in ways that highlighted Maori as descendants of the ten lost tribes of the Northern Kingdom of ancient Israel. Maori identified themselves with a range of biblical actors and events, such as the Israelites oppressed not in E^pt but in Aotearoa/New Zealand, and not by Pharaoh but by British colonists, and they longed for their own exodus, in their own holy land. Mormon elders developed this by by stressing kinship ties between ancient Israelites and Maori, and encouraged Maori to locate themselves 90 Moms: Polynesians and Mormonà and their contempera^ situation in the Mormon extended corpus of sacred stories. Maori responded most positively to tales of their coming redemption in the "lands of their inheritance" and in rites and cerem^ nies that included customaty and ritual practices and language.^ This conversion pattern was akin to that found throughout the Pacific where indigenous people, having already become Christians, converted to the LDS Church. The Mormon missionaity strate^ was to establish relationships with chiefs and nobles, and through their support baptize members of rillages and sub-tribes. In some areas there was mass transition from the Anglican, and to a lesser extent Methodist, churches to the LDS Church. By 1890 there were more than 3,000 Mormons consisting of eight percent of all Maori, and this number increased to 4,000 a decade later.40 In the ^entieth century the LDS Church in New Zealand continued to be predominantly Maori. The traditions of the Maori high god (Io) were assimilated into Mormon theolo^, reinforcing the links beUveen the god of their ancestors and the God of the Bible. There were ongoing tensions between LDS norms and Maori traditions, including tattooing, funerary rites, traditional prayers, ceremonial ground practices, alongside concerns about the level of commitment of some Maori to Mormon lifestyle restrictions. Traditional healing powers of the tohunga (traditional priests) proved to be the limiting case for LDS leadere when they officially denied the authority of these healing specialists. The Maori Agricultural College and later the Church College of New Zealand were established by the LDS Church at least in part to promote international Mormon cultural and spiritual norms among Maori. The opening of the Temple in Hamilton in 1958 also sewed to play an important role in this process. One of the strengths of the Mormon missionaity strate^ in New Zealand was that while their Church did not condemn the colonial land grab, unlike leaders of most other Christian denominations, they displayed little interest in acquiring land for themselves ؛in fact, this was simply seconda^ to their broader purposes. But this virtue cut both ways, as the focus on community, family and learning to be Mormon left out the political aspirations of Maori redemption, that is, the quest for justice in relation to Maori land. When such a movement did arise in the 1929s, combining spiritual and spatial salvation, led by the prophet TahupOtiki Wiremu Ratana (1873?-1939), the LDS Church quickly lost Maori adherents. There was the potential for Mormons to work closely with Ratana based on their shared pan-tribalism, opposition to the tohunga and some traditional forms of ritual, but this did not find favor with LDS Church authorities. More than 2,999 Maori Mormons became followers of Ratana.41 All the Christian churches, including the LDS Church, lost out to Ratana and other Maori movements. Debates at the time highlighted the significance of autonomous, indigenous Maori spiritual leadership rather than that of overseas missionaries. 91 No! Migio By the late 1920s, with some Maori having returned to Mormonism, the LDS Church opened positions in district presidencies«‘¿ to Maori men amid ongoing debates about the extent of acceptable levels of Maori cultural practices. The traditional Maori hui (gathering) was appropriated for local and national LDS Church conferences characterized by ceremony and Maori music with both the English and Te Reo languages used in testimonies and addresses. These hui linked different tribes and su^tribes in forging a discrete Maori Mormon identity. After World War II, biculturalism seemed to retreat with Mormon missions to European New Zealanders. The LDS Church, however, having pioneered a bicultural religious institution in New Zealand, offered important support for Maori urbanization in the 1950s and 1960s. The "Maori Renaissance" in the late 1970s and 1980s revived biculturalism in the LDS Church in New Zealand, which continues to reflect both the wider New Zealand culture and a renewed LDS Church commitment to Maori M0rm0ns.43 Although the LDS Church claims more than 190,000 members in New Zealand,«« the 2013 census records only 40,000, a decline of some 6.5 percent since 2006. However, while Mormon numbers are now down to less than one percent of the country’s population,« ؟Maori and Polynesians make up more than two-thirds of Mormons in New Zealand. While the membership numbers are relatively stable, there is an internal debate within the LDS Church about the as many as onethird of these who may be inactive, and there are growing concerns about youth retention. The number of new converts is small, with many coming from lower socioeconomic groups, including new migrants. Currently, Maori make up half of all Latter-day Saints in New Zealand with Pacific Islanders another quarter, so LDS Church membership is overwhelmingly Polynesian.« ؟There is still opposition among some Maori to converts’ accommodation to Mormonism and rejection of Maori practices. ANALYSIS A number of discrete phases in LDS Church history in Polynesia can be discerned. Phase one, “early missions” (184^1880s), was characterized by few riable Mormon communities being established, and efforts were curtailed by Catholics and Protestants. Latter-day Saints learned valuable lessons about living with indigenes and using their languages, the benefits of more remote locations, and building on earlier missionaty work by other churches. Phase two, “other empires” (1880s-1945), was a period of raising converts, schools and communities.«? The third phase, “American ascendancy” (1945-1980), witnessed a resurgence of missionaty effort and activity, with steady growth and consolidated gains. 92 MÉ: Polynesians and Monmism The current fourth phase, “global church” (1980-present), has seen rapid expansion and significant investment. Important as the earlier phases have been for LDS Church activity in Polynesia, it is this current phase that requires the most analysis to delineate the appeal of Mormonism to Polynesians. The LDS Church usually explains these successes in terms of parallels between Mormonism and Polynesian spiritual and cultural traditions. Mormonism developed a distinctive pattern of enculturation, promoting indigenous language and particular traditional practices (understood to be cultural rather than religious), coupled with a sustained rejection of religious rites and customs that breached the “Word ofWisdom” orwere deemed incompatible with LDS beliefs and practices. Although tension remains, this controlled embrace of indigenous cultures has been fostered in the sendee of wider LDS Church development. In terms of affinities between Polynesian traditions and the LDS Church, both are hierarchical and have continuing prophetic traditions. Both share concern with family, lineage and ancestty, including the uniformlyheld claim thatPolynesians can trace their ancestty back to ancient Israel via the Americas, and Polynesian Mormons incorporate this into their identity formation. Almost all Polynesians believe in a similar descent, the legacy of colonial European Christianity and its various accounts of the world’s peoples based on interpretations of biblical histoty. iile this is not exclusive to the LDS Church, it is more pronounced than in other churches and entails Mormon teachings being seen as cultural re-remembering or the retrieval of long-lost truths. These hermeneutical strategies include Polynesians within Mormon sacred narratives and entail that they share a common past with other Latter-day Saints. Mormons teach that ancient Israelites travelled to and settled in the Americas. They included the descendants of Nephi (Nephites) and Laman (Lamanites), the sons of Lehi, the Jerusalem prophet from the Book of Mormon. I was told in Salt Lake City in 2006 at a meeting of former LDS Church missionaries to the Pacific that the Lamanites were ancestors of natives of the Americas and the “islands of the sea”—the Pacific Islands. When I asked Samoan, Tongan and New Zealand Mormons whether they considered themselves Lamanites, they asserted their Nephite heritage. Polynesian patriarchal blessings often claim direct ties to the trite of Manasseh, son of the Patriarch Joseph (Genesis 41) via Lehi.48 Both Polynesians and Mormons believe that the self is not restricted to the individual but rather is found in terms of ancestty. For example, Maori lineage begins with generations of forebears, continues through traditional figures, then travels back to the atua (gods). This lineage is periodically recited as a ritual act that re-creates a family across time and links it authoritatively to a specific place. Mormon lineage relates to actual generational lines, and location is often a secondaty factor. 93 la Migio Genealog plays a major role in the attraction of Mormonism all over Polynesia, where lineage is so often connected to land title. In practice, this turns out to be a complex issue. There are diverse Polynesian understandings of lineage and its import, as well as different ways in which Temple and pre-Temple Mormons understand lineage. It has not been easy to get Temple Latter-day Saints to compare mythologies. Most Polynesians expect to be reunited with dead family membere, and they believe that the dead can positively and negatively affect people in the present. This is an area for further research into the different present and past understandings of ancestors across Polynesia, in terms of LDS Church orthodoxy, and by Polynesian Latter-day Saints. Maori Latterday Saints report that these different quests for the familial past are compatible and overlapping. Samoan and Tongan Mormons report something similar. Throughout Polynesia, persons are linked across space and time. Both Polynesians and the LDS Church understand there to be continuing relationships between living and dead and possibility of future re^atherin^. A number of Latter-day Saint authors have seen parallels between the LDS Church and ongoing Polynesian prophetic traditions. Prophetic insight is highly prized across Polynesia and attributed to the ubiquitous demi-god Maui. Local prophets were recorded as foreseeing the coming of the LDS Church, and these prophecies were recognized as true when the Mormons did arrive.. The prophecies lead LDS scholars such as Ma^orie Newton and Louis Midgley to talk of the “providential joining of two prophetic traditions.’^ Contemporary Polynesian Mormons across the Pacific tell of these risions received by their ancestors leading to their baptism as Mormons, thus creating sacred family histories linking their ancestors to the LDS Church.5٤ A further affinity is drawn between Mormon teachings and Maori esoteric knowledge, a parallel that was important to early LDS Church success among Maori in New Zealand. In the 1990s Latter-day Saint and Maori teacher Herewini Jones began exploring these parallels in partieular prophecy and theolo^. Jones’ “esoteric workshops” for Maori attracted existing Mormons and new converts, and were endorsed by the president of the New Zealand Auckland Mission of the LDS Church. These popular sessions are still running. Globalism and Personal Spirituality The breakdown of traditional cultures across Polynesia due to glob alization, urbanization and growing emphasis on the individual is refleeted in religious change. Alongside the global financial flows are the theological flows of globalized religi0ns.52 Transition from the dominance of the mainline Christian churches, embedded in traditional 94 Marris: Polynesians and Momonism culture, to the LDS Church (among others) is challenging the synthesis of nineteenth-centuty missiona^ Christianity and Polynesian societies. The new churches openly challenge existing social forms, such as the extended family and the village as principal identity markers, and under־ mine established rillage ecclesiastical authorities. Their stress is on incorporating individual experience and personal development into communal practices that reinforce indiridual empowerment and responsibility. New converts learn to articulate their new faith and individuality simultaneously in terms of a modernist discourse of personal spirituality, resulting in new practices, consumption patterns and behaviors-marked by adult baptism—underetood in novel language and C0ncepts.53 These global forces often are positively identified with American prestige and power. The loss of traditional village protections, the authoritarian nature of many of the forms of Polynesian Christianity, the financial burdens of required reciprocities, and the desire for a new life and opportunities for one’s family lead directly into the embrace of the LDS Church. Sociological literature on conversion emphasizes both demand (the appeal) and supply (what the missionaty churches offer), and it is important to acknowledge the LDS Church’s huge investments in Polynesia,^ manifest not only in transcendental teachings but also in programs of education, welfare and support. In many ways, the LDS Church has responded directly and effectively to the realities of poverty, marginality and spiritual and material dislocation. Sceptics might accuse the LDS Church of simply bribing its flock, but the Mormon Church demands high-level commitment of time and energy in a patterned transformation to being a Latter-day Saint. Across the Pacific, however, there is resistance to the LDS Church on the part of the now-established churches, which often seek to preserve select versions of Polynesian cultures. Objections include their American (i.e., non-Polynesian) origins, their rejection of the extended village family in favor of the nuclear or “white” family model, their attitudes toward tattooing and ceremonial use of kava, and their nonTrinitarian, hence heretical, theolo^, leading all too often to physical and legal disputes across Polynesia.^ CONCLUSION The LDS Church combines material support with temporal and transcendental hope for the future. Support of members’ long-term life plans include preferential educational opportunities, health care, business loans, upgrading of skills and employment assistance. The importance of such support cannot be overestimated ؛neither can the sense of dignity and empowerment offered by an alternative status system and social order. In addition, the effort put into correct practice and 95 Νουα Migio behavior, as well as the stress on purity, ensures a degree of conformity among converts that provides certainty and comfort, reinforcing their new Latter-day Saint identity. Lasdy, the LDS Church fosters a sense of being victims of oppression by the mainline churches, creating high levels of solidarity. The rapid growth of LDS membership in Polynesia in the current fourth, “global church” phase cannot be adequately explained by promotion of affinities between the LDS Church and Polynesian traditions and rituals, including concerns with ancestty and lineage, since these have been mainstream Mormon teachings to Pacific Islanders since the 1850s. If there are such deep parallels between Polynesian and LDS Church beliefs and practices, why did it take until the 1980s and 1990s for these to become apparent? So, what does explain the very recent significant growth? The LDS Church’s commitment to Polynesia is longstanding, and it has intensified in the last 25 years. The LDS Church has invested perhaps $1 billion in the Pacific to address the temporal and spiritual needs of a region being radically transformed from without and within. The support it offers makes tangible differences in people’s lives and olfers a genuine alternative to persons with limited choices. All this is presented under the rubric of a deep Polynesian affinity for a truth once theirs and now recovered as Latter-day Saints. I thank the Church ojJesus Christ ojLatter-da ׳؟Saints Jor arranging meetings with interviewees mho Imtiend ؟answered m ؟queries and. questions, and Jor providing access to LDS Church publications and other matzah. ENDNOTES ١ Doctrine and Covenants oj the Church ojJesus Christ oj latter-da ؟Saints, Containing Rotations Given to Joseph Smith, the Prophet, with Some Additions b ؟His Successors in the Presidency of the Church (Salt Lake City: The Church ofJesus Christ of Latterday Saints,1981), 1:1; The Book of Mormon, 2 Nephi 29:11. ﻵWcloriu >؟٠ Locbiood, eA., Globalisation and Culture Change in the Pacific Islands (Upper Saddle River, NJ.: Prentice Hall, 2004). 3 ١٥ile there are other Mormon groups in the Pacific, e.g. the Community of Christ (from 1872 to 2001 the Reorganized Church ofjesus Christ of Latter Day Saints [RLDS], still active in French Polynesia and in New Zealand), the focus in this article is the LDS Church. 4 Polynesia usually refers to the islands of Hawai‘؛, Samoa, Tonga, the Cook Islands, Tuvalu, Tokelau, Niue, Wallis and Futuna, French Polynesia and Easter Island (Rapa Nui). I also include in Polynesia New Zealand, which has a large population of Polynesian first people, the Maori, and Polynesian migrants mainly from Samoa and Tonga. In this article I do not discuss the minority Polynesian communities in the Solomon Islands, Papua New Guinea, the Caroline Islands, Fiji and Vanuatu, as these often raise different issues, aid I 96 Moà: Polynesians and Momonism make only passing reference to the growing Polynesian communities of Australia and mainland United States. 5 See Molly Worthen, “Sects Appeal: Evangelicals V. Mormons," New Republic, 20 November 2006, 21-25, available at www.newrepublic.com/article/evangelicals־ v-mormons־sects-appeal. 6 A temple recommend is an annual certificate of identification and personal “worthiness,” which includes tithing, that is signed by the applicant’s bishop and stake president. The temple recommend allows a Latterclay Saint to enter a ternpie and participate in rituals there. A bishop is the head of a congregation. A “stake" is a group of LDS congregations. The term refers to a tent support (see Isaiah 54:2). 7 Temple rituals include endowment and ordination ceremonies that require oaths, words and tokens to ensure spiritual progress. 8 This phenomenon is largely unstudied and may reflect different cultural, and perhaps economic, contexts in which the LDS Church is active. ٥ On tithing, see Doctrine and Covenants, 119:45־. Only 40 percent of Mormons who attend weekly services tithe. Ryan Cragun cited in Sean Patterson, “Mormon Church Rakes in Billions in Tithes,” WebProNews, 14 August 2012, at WWW. webpronews.com/mormon-church-rakes-in־billions־in-tithes08־2012־. 1° Rodney Stark, "The Rise of a New World Faith,” Revieiv ofReligiousResearch 26, no. 1 (1984): 1827־. 11 Rodney Stark, The Rise of Momonism, ed. Reid L. Neilson (New York: Columbia University Press, 2005), 17. See Rick Phillips’ discussion of how membership statistics globally have been inflated by the LDS Church in “Rethinking the International Expansion of Mormonism,” Nova Religio 10, no. 1 (August 2006): 52-68. 12 Tim B. Heaton, “Vital Statistics,” Encyclopedia of Momonism (New York: Macmillan, 1992 ؛digital publisher: Brigham Young University, 2001): 1518, at c0ntentdm.lib.byu.edu/cdm/c0mp0und0bject/c011ecti0n/E0M/id/4391/ show/4316. 13 R. Lanier Britsch, Unto thelslands of the Sea: A HisΙη of thelatterèy Saints in the Pacific (Salt Lake City: Deseret Book, 1986), 21. H Population and Housing !}ends Samoa Census 2011 (Apia: Samoa Bureau of Statistics, 2012), 2. 15 See “Fertility by Religion,” Population and Homing, Analytical Report (Apia: Samoa Bureau of Statistics, 2012): Sec. 4.9. In 2011 Latter-day Saints had the highest figure (5.1), followed closely by Assemblies of God (5), then Methodists and Seventh-day Adventists, Roman Catholics (4.3), and Congregational Christian Church Samoa (4.2). The Assemblies of God has had roughly similar growth albeit from a lower base. ١١٥ i G3LT\!rm, ei, The Building oj the Kingdom in Sil 1888-2005 (JTebet City, Utah: self-published, 2006), 3-35. ١٦ !cm. Building oj the Kingdom in Samoa. 18 Seemingly authorized by the 1990 Village Fono Act, despite its apparent contradiction to “The Constitution of the Independent State of Western Samoa” (1960), which guarantees freedom of religion to every citizen 97 la Religio (Sections 11 and 12), available at www.parliament.am/library/sabmanadru tyunner/samoa.pdf. 19 Folafola, the public naming in church of donations and donors, generates competitive giring and has been incorporated into Samoan church-village life. Besides the weekly collection, churches call on their congregants for taukga (annual donations) for the pastor’s house, church upkeep and additions. Large and often empty churches have teen built all over Samoa. This is in contrast to the LDS Church, where the tithe norm is a tenth of one’s income, and donations are private and anonymous. 20 LDS Church members can access the “Perpetual Education Fund,’’ and for a minimal monthly contribution they can obtain an interest-free loan for university study. In addition, an LDS Church employment center teaches computer and other skills. 21 The number of Temple Mormons as of 2009, provided by church officials in Apia; informants and interviewees were asked direcdy if they were Temple Mormons. 22 Note that the LDS Church facilitates land leases in Apia for Mormons. 23 Largely the result of Samoans married to non-Samoans but also including non-Samoan immigrants. 24 For LDS figures for American Samoa, see “United States Territoty: American Samoa,’’ Church News, 15 October 2009, at -.ldschurchnewsarchive.com/ articles/58091/United-States-territory-American-Samoa.html. Also see McKay Coppins, “Why Romney Will Dominate the American Samoa Caucuses,” BuzzFeed News, 9 March 2012, at www.buzzfeed.com/mckaycoppins/whyromney-will-dominate-the-american-samoa-primar#.td3bmzpx8. For Samoa see Samoa Bureau of Statistics atwvw.sbsgov.ws/index.php?option=com_content& vfew=article&id=35&Itemid=102, accessed 25 September 2014. 25 See "Tonga Population 2014,” World Population Review, 14 May 2014, at worldpopulationreview.com/countries/tonga-population/. On Tonga missionary and “government” schools, see “Education,” Tonga Department of Statistics, at www.spc.int/prism/tonga/index.php?option=com_content& view=article&؛d=24&Itemid=29, accessed 25 teptember 2014. 2“ ةSabbath Day to Be KeptHoly,” IhAcl ofConstitution ofTonga, Sec. 6 (Nukualofa: Ministty of Information and Communications, 1988), 8; for religious figures, see Census Report 2011, vol. 1 (Nukualofa: Tonga Department of Statistics, 2013), 39. 27 Savani Latai Toluta’u Aupiu, “Mormon Missionaries in the Kingdom of Tonga, 1891-1897,” Μ.Α. thesis. University of Utah, 2009. 28 The Tongan population is approximately 103,000 and the LDS Church 2011 census figure is 18,554, giving a proportional total of 18 percent, although the LDS figure is 32 percent. 29 I was informed of this by an LDS leader in Tonga; on the high social status of the school and its perceived values, see Niko Besnier, On the Edge of the Global: Modem Anxieties in a Pacific Island Nation (Redwood City, Calif.: Stanford University Press, 2011), 261. 39 An anodyne but enjoyable account of missionary life in Tonga in the 1950s is John H. Groberg, In the Eye of the Storm (Salt Lake City: Deseret Book, 1993). 98 Moms: Polynesians and Mormonum اﻷA local root-derived drink with an intoxicating effect. 32 See Doctrine and Covenants, 89:1-9, which forbids the use of tobacco, alc^ hoi, tea and coffee. 33 See Mette Ramstad, Conversion in the Pacific: Eastern Polynesian Latterèy Saints9 Conversion Accosts and Their Development oj a IDS Hit0\( ؟0*؟. ^ong،\؟Ltt Academic Press, 2003); and Tamar G. Gordon, “Inventing Mormon Identity in Tonga,” PhD. diss.. University of California, 1988. 34 See Maijorie Newton, llki and Temple: The Momon Mission in New Zealand, 1854-1958 (Draper, Utah: Greg Kofford Books, 2012)î and Maijorie Newton, “Mormonism in New Zealand: A Historical Appraisal,” Ph.D. diss.. University of Sydney, 1998. 35 New Zealand. Parliamentary Debates, vol. 11 (Wellington: G. Didsbury, 1871), 390-91. The censure took place during the proceedings of the House of Representatives on 18 October 1871. 36 In 1881 Wairarapa prophet Paora Te Potangaroa (d. 1881) foresaw the arrival of a new church that Mormons have understood to be the LDS Church. See \>؟τοηνίγ؛Λ Inore, Mai Jn Heaven: A Centur ؟of Maori Prophets in Neu) Zealand (Tauranga: Moana Press, 1989), 278-88. 37 Samuel Marsden, Journal of Proceedings at New Zealand, II, 29 July 1819-19 October 1819%; cited in Judith Binney, “.Papahurihia: Some Thoughts on Interpretation,” of the Polynesian Society 75, no. 3 (1966): 325. It is interesting to note that while Maori were often considered “sons of Shem,” Australian aboriginals and Melanesians were understood to be “sons of Ham.” 36 Tudor Parfitt, The Lost rpribes of Israel: The History of a Myth (London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 2002), 17. Parfitt added “racialised religious manifestations’’ as an alternative to or extension of his colonial discourse thesis in his later study. Black Jews in Africa and the Aàcas (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 2013), 4. See also Hillel Halkin, Across the Sabbath River: In Search of a Lost Tribe of Israel (New York: Houghton Mifflin, 2002) ؛Rivka Gotten, The Quest for the Ten Lost Tribes oj Israel: To the Lnds of the Earth (Northvale, NJ.: Jason Aronson, 2002) ؛and Zvi Ben-Dor Benite, The Ten Lost Iribes: A lid l،0ty (New York: Oxford University Press, 2009). On BritishIsiaekn, %ee lc\\ae\ Wám, Religion and the Racist Right: The Origins of the Christian Identity Movement (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1997), 3-45, 75.147־ وﻷSee Ian Rewi Barker, “The Connexion: The Mormon Church and the Maori People,” MA. thesis, Victoria University of Wellington, 1967. See also Britsch, Unto the Islands of the Sea, 253345 ;־Peter Lineham, “The Mormon Message in the Context of Maori Culture,” Journal of Mormon ΗήΙοη 17, no. 1 (1991): 62-93؛ Louis Midgley, “A Singular Reading: The Maori and The Book of Mormon,” in Mormons, Scripture, and the Ancient World: Studies in Honor ofJohn L Swenson, ed. Davis Bitton (Provo, Utah: Foundation for Ancient Research and Mormon Studies, Brigham Young University, 1998), 245-76 ؛Erik Gabriel Murimmer, “Mormonism in a Maori Village: A Study in Social Change,” Μ.Α. thesis. University of British Columbia, 1965 ؛Grant Underwood, “Mormonism, the Maori and Cultural Authenticity,” Journal of Pacific History 35, no. 2 (2006): 133־46 ؛Lawrence Barber, “Another Look at the History of the Church of 99 Νσυα Religio Latter-day Saints in New Zealand,” in Under the Southern Cross: Papers on rfheology, Pastoral Care, Education, History and Scriptural Exegesis, ed. ١o\\w YWwckWﺳﻸ ؟؟ Norman Simms (Auckland: University of Auckland Chaplain’s Office and Olrif:, \ו١ י*ו! יand Turning the Hearts ojthe Children: Earl ؟iori leaders in the Mormon Church, ed. Selwyn Katene (Wellington: Steele Roberts, 2014). 40 See Jennie Henderson, “The Trials of the Saints: Mormons in New Zealand, \1-\יי١١ UY Building God’s Oun County: Historical Essays on Reliions in Neu) Zealand, ed.John Stenhouse and Jane Thomson (Dunedin: University of Otago Press, 2004), 139-52; Underwood, “Mormonism, the Maori and Cultural Authenticity”; and Newton, rfiki and rfemple. 41 James Belich, Paradise Reforged: A History of New 'Zealanders (Auckland: Penguin, 2001), 198. 42 A “district” is an area in a mission LDS Church containing congregations termed “branches.” The district president selects two men (also members of the Melchizedek priesthood) to assist with his duties, the three of them comprising a “district presidency.” »؟eel،nl\\1t١ Zion in Neu) Zealand: A Hislo^ of the Church ojJesus Christ oj Latter-day Saints in 10 Zealand, 1854-1977 (Hamilton: Church College of New Zealand, 1977), 116ff. 44 LDS Church figures can be found at “Facts and Statistics,” Newsroom/Pacific, www.mormonnewsroom.orgnz/factand-statistics/, accessed 4Januaty 2015. 4 نSee New Zealand Census, “Religious Affiliation,” Table 28; at -.stats.govt. nz/Census/2013-census/data-tables/total-by-topic.aspx. 46 See Hirini Kaa, “Nga hahi-Maori and Christian Denominations,” page 5, “Mormon Church,” Te Ara/He Encyclopedia of Neio Zealand, 16 July 14, at WWW. TeAra.govt.nz/en/nga־hahi-maori-and־christian-denominations/page5־. 47 These are my attempts to delineate and characterize historical phases in LDS Church development in Polynesia. For example, in phase two. Mormons Operated within the context and restraints of the French, British and German empires, while increasing American influence and linkages in the region are evident in stage three. In the global fourth phase, there is much closer geographical coordination and a growing sense of becoming a significant denomination. 48 Book of Mormon, 1 Nephi 1:4. The Hebrew word/name is also found in Judges 15:17, as in Ramah Lehi (the hill of Lehi). 49 See Robert Joseph, “Intercultural Exchange, Matakite Maori and the Mormon Church,” in Mana Maori and Christianity, ed. Hugh Morrison, Lachy Paterson, Brett Knowles and Murray Rae (Wellington: Huia Publishers, 2012), 4S72. Matute (mata, commtmication with a spirit; kite, to see or recognize) refers to both seer and prophecy. Interestingly, sijnilar prophecies interpreted as foretelling the arrival of the LDS missionaries are recorded among Pueblo tribes in North America, especially the Hopi. 50 Louis Midgley, “Maori Latter-day Saint Faith: Some Preliminary Remarks,” Interpreter: Ajournai of Mormon Scripture 8 (2014): 45-65, quoted on p. 48. 51 See Newton, Tiki and 'Temple, 43; Midgley, “Maori Latter-day Saint Faith,” 51; ﺳﻶc\e\e k\d, Ttkhanga Whakaaro: Ke ؟Conceals in Maori Culture ^AvvcWawd*. Oxford University Press, 1991). 100 Morris: Polynesians and Momonism 52 See Manfred Ernst, Winds of Change: Rapidly Growing Religious Groups in the Pacific Islands (Suva, Fiji: Pacific Conference of Churches, 1994) ؛and Manfred 1٢\Λ1>؟١ edu, Globaliiation and the Re-Shading ojChnstiaml ؟in the Pacific Islnnds V>؟uva.١ Fiji: Pacific Theological College, 2006). ﻷجThe LDS Church shares this with other churches practicing adult baptism. 54 See Roger Finke and Laurence R. Iannacone, “Supply Side Explanations for Religious Change,” Annals of the Ανέαη Academy of Political and Social Science 527, no. 1 (May 1993): 27-39. 55 For example, a number of village councils in Samoa have declared their villages to be exclusively affiliated with a particular church, effectively disenfranchising all other churches and religious groups. In a few cases, councils have reclaimed property on behalf of the village, but these decisions have been legally challenged and mediated. 101 ATLV Copyright and Use: As an ATLAS user, you may print, downioad, or send articles for individual use according to fair use as defined by u.s. and international copyright law and as otherwise authorized under your respective ATLAS subscriber agreement. No content may be copied or emailed to multiple sites or publicly posted without the copyright holder(s)’ express written permission. Any use, decompiling, reproduction, or distribution of this journal in excess of fair use provisions may be a violation of copyright law. This journal is made available to you through the ATLAS collection with permission from the copyright holder(s). The copyright holder for an entire issue of ajournai typically is the journal owner, who also may own the copyright in each article. However, for certain articles, the author of the article may maintain the copyright in the article. Please contact the copyright holder(s) to request permission to use an article or specific work for any use not covered by the fair use provisions of the copyright laws or covered by your respective ATLAS subscriber agreement. For information regarding the copyright holder(s), please refer to the copyright information in the journal, if available, or contact ATLA to request contact information for the copyright holder(s). About ATLAS: The ATLA Serials (ATLAS®) collection contains electronic versions of previously published religion and theology journals reproduced with permission. The ATLAS collection is owned and managed by the American Theological Library Association (ATLA) and received initial funding from Lilly Endowment Inc. The design and final form of this electronic document is the property of the American Theological Library Association.
© Copyright 2025 Paperzz