Watchdog - Money Smart

Financial Literacy
through English
Watchdog
A research unit for Stage 5 English
Writer: Ann Small
Acknowledgement
This project was funded by the Australian Government Department of Education, Science
and Training as a quality teacher initiative under the Australian Government Quality Teacher
Programme.
Disclaimer
The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent the views of the Australian
Government Department of Education, Science and Training.
1
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION .............................................................................................. 3
How to Use the Resource ............................................................................................. 3
BUILDING THE FIELD..................................................................................... 4
Content ......................................................................................................................... 4
Persuasive Language ................................................................................................... 6
Hypertext ...................................................................................................................... 7
DEVELOPING A RESEARCH QUESTION ..................................................... 8
Criteria for an effective research question..................................................................... 8
WRITING THE ADVERTISEMENT .................................................................. 9
THE RESEARCH PROCESS........................................................................... 9
CLASS PRESENTATIONS ............................................................................ 11
2
INTRODUCTION
In this unit students develop their skills of investigation and critical comparison,
focusing on the study of the techniques of persuasion to evaluate a range of related
goods and services or employment opportunities offered to teenagers. Students
identify and explain the financial implications, compare the available options and
critically evaluate the marketing, advertising or employment strategies adopted in
these products or jobs.
This unit of work consists of a collaborative, independent research project with
students presenting their findings as a hypertext.
Adopting the role of a ‘watchdog’ agency, students record the development of their
research, their analyses of the techniques of persuasion in student-selected texts
(techniques such as over-simplification, emotive language, false assumptions,
appeals to authority) and develop a community service advertisement for teenagers
regarding the worth of the product or job.
HOW TO USE THE RESOURCE
In this unit students respond to and compose texts in a variety of modes and media
and, through this, learn to think in ways that are imaginative, interpretive and critical.
Through the activities, students use language to communicate appropriately and
effectively, expressing their understanding of themselves and the world. This unit has
been designed to address these Stage 5 learning outcomes in the English Syllabus:
Stage 5 Outcomes
A student:
1 responds to and composes increasingly sophisticated and sustained texts for
understanding, interpretation, critical analysis and pleasure
3 selects, uses, describes and explains how different technologies affect and shape
meaning
4 selects and uses language forms and features, and structures of texts according to
different purposes, audiences and contexts, and describes and explains their effects on
meaning
7 thinks critically and interpretively using information, ideas and increasingly complex
arguments to respond to and compose texts in a range of contexts
8 investigates the relationships between and among texts
9 demonstrates understanding of the ways texts reflect personal and public worlds
10 questions, challenges and evaluates cultural assumptions in texts and their effects on
meaning
11 uses, reflects on, assesses and adapts their individual and collaborative skills for
learning with increasing independence and effectiveness.
Like all curriculum materials, adaptation to the local context is necessary. This unit
could be used in Year 9 in a range of ways according to what is relevant or appeals
to you:
• as a stand alone five week unit of work.
• as a research process staged throughout the term or year
• research activities and collaborative learning strategies could be adapted and
integrated into other areas of English learning
• integrated into a media unit
• integrated into a critical literacy unit
• could be adapted as a transition unit for Year 10 into Year 11 English learning
activities
3
BUILDING THE FIELD
CONTENT
The initial lesson sequence introduces students to the field of reference for the
research project. Students explore a range of texts used in marketing, advertising
and employment programs that target adolescents. Students learn about the
techniques of persuasion and the ways these techniques are used in texts. A key
feature of this sequence is that it introduces concepts, generates curiosity, and
makes connections to students’ prior knowledge. Students keep a record of their
research through these learning activities. It is also extremely important to develop
some file storage protocols and internet browsing records (see The Research
Process) for use later in the research project.
Website Resources
Goods and services
www.successfulteenageentrepreneur.com/
http://www.jobsforteens.com.au
http://www.consumersearch.com/music-downloads
http://victoria.ymca.org.au/cpa/htm/htm_article_detail.asp?article_id=77
http://www.xbox.com/en-AU/
http://au.playstation.com/
http://www.aussieprom.com/home.html
http://www.amcevents.com.au/event-services/school-discos.html
http://www.formalaffair.com.au/getstarted.htm
http://www.mcdonalds.com.au/careers/home/home.asp
http://www.kfcjobs.com.au/team/the-perks.aspx
http://www.bestadsontv.com/
http://helpcentre.carsales.com.au/buying-advice/2008/first-car-buyers-guide7507
Government & Watchdog Agencies
http://www.jobjuice.gov.au
http://www.thesource.gov.au/
http://www.scamwatch.gov.au/content/index.phtml/itemId/693900
http://www.youth.nsw.gov.au/youth_links/links/work_and_money/your_rights_
at_work
http://www.lawstuff.org.au
http://www.industrialrelations.nsw.gov.au/Young_workers.html
Through the learning experiences in this unit of work, students learn about the
contested, and at times unreliable, nature of consumer and financial advice. They
learn about their rights and responsibilities as consumers. Students learn to make
choices when comparative shopping, to evaluate different methods of payment and
to use critical thinking and problem-solving skills to make consumer and financial
decisions. Students demonstrate appreciation of the value and importance of ethical
behaviour.
Activities could include
Building the research field
1. Students identify areas in society that impact financially on teenagers and
collect examples of related texts. Areas might include:
4
Health and fitness club memberships
Car purchase and running costs
Banking fees
Driving lessons
Buying games consoles
Job opportunities
Mobile phones
Music downloading
Delivery jobs
Party planning eg formals
Charities and aid organisations
2. Trade fair simulation: students choose one of these areas, research the costs
and benefits of one product and transform the information into a ‘one minute
pitch’ for the product.
3. Students compare and contrast two products in one of the above areas
examining the extent to which they are value for money.
Identifying purpose and audience
Students analyse the audience and purpose of texts that are aimed at teenagers
(see resources) and establish the purpose of the texts and the target audiences.
1. Class discussion could focus on:
a. Which ads do you find effective? Why?
b. How are teenagers targeted in marketing?
c. When have you been vulnerable to advertising? Tell us about it.
2. In groups students collect examples of texts that have particular appeals and
identify the nature of the appeal and the targeted audience, such as
Statement
Socceroo, Tim Cahill,
always eats at ….
Nature of appeal
Celebrity endorsement
Targeted audience
Groups who admire a given
celebrity
You don’t need an expert to
tell you …
Clever people buy …
You too can look like
supermodel….
Sixteen 1st Prizes sold at
this newsagent. Buy your
lottery ticket here!
3. How are teenagers, particularly targeted in marketing? Students create a
grid, like that above, that identifies different representations of teenagers in
advertisements.
Building understanding of watchdog agencies and regulating authorities
Students read and view publications whose purposes are to educate teenagers (see
resources). Some of these publications are quite complex so active reading
strategies are necessary.
5
Suggested activities are:
1. In pairs students choose one document or site and complete the chart below
as they read
What I know about …
What I have learned
What I want to know more
about …
2. Through the use of a reciprocal teaching 1strategy, students develop
understanding of one of the texts. Reciprocal teaching involves the teacher
modeling summarising, questioning, clarifying and predicting strategies on a
short section of text. Through active teaching and often repeated modeling of
a single stage, students learn to ask significant questions of the text.
Luke and Freebody’s four resources model (www.myread.org) is another
approach for active and engaged reading.
PERSUASIVE LANGUAGE
Students explore how persuasive language techniques such as over-simplification,
emotive language, false assumptions, appeals to authority are used to construct
versions of reality.
Suggested approach:
Through class discussion, identify the ways the texts previously studied
create versions of reality
Identify these techniques at work in the website www.smartypig.com.au
Introduce the concept of the anti-ad using the Virgin Mobile ad at
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xEuicPh85aU&feature=related
Student activities
1. In what ways is this ad an anti-ad?
2. What techniques of persuasion does it use? Consider especially the role of
humour.
3. What connections can you establish between the product and the way it is
being presented?
1
Palincsar (1986), http://www.ncrel.org/sdrs/areas/issues/students/atrisk/at6lk38.htm
6
HYPERTEXT
Students will present their research as a hypertext. A hypertext is a non-linear text
that connects various elements through links - hyperlinks. It shows relationships and
connections between ideas and information and enables a multisensory dimension
for texts. Hypertexts allow a wide variety of links and connections to be made. Some
of these include elaboration, exemplification, commenting, metaphor, establishment
of cause and effect, links to other modes and media. Drawing connections between
texts is a key feature of Stage 5 and Stage 6 English teaching and learning.
Hypertexts can contain links of many kinds including simple word or button links, menu
bars, indexes, table of contents, concept maps. There are many different kinds of
hypertexts – CD Roms and virtual museums are obvious examples. One of the most
commonly used hypertexts is Wikipedia. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Main_Page.
Setting up the research presentation
1. Explore research report requirements
At the end of their research students are to create a short hypertext report
(300 words) that has the following elements:
The research question
Student’s written response to the question
Links
o to research texts
o that elaborate on an idea
o that show the same word in a different context
o that exemplify a point made
o to multimedia
o that show cause and effect (perhaps in the use of persuasive
language techniques)
o to a community service ad that they have designed.
Hypertext Report Checklist
Completed
Research question
Written response to the question (300 words)
Links to research texts
Links that elaborate on an idea
Links that show the same word in a different context
Links that exemplify a point made
Links to multimedia
Links that show cause and effect in the use of persuasive language techniques
Link to a community service ad that they have designed.
7
2. Explain technical processes
Show students how to store documents and create hyperlinks in your
software application. Navigating to the help menu in your word processing
application and searching for insert hyperlink will provide direction. Visit
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Main_Page to see how the final product might
operate.
How to insert a hyperlink
The easiest way for hyperlinks to work is to keep them all in a single folder with the main
document.
1. Highlight the phrase in the main document where you want to insert a hyperlink
2. Go to the Insert menu and select Hyperlink.
3. When the Insert Hyperlink dialog box opens it offers the option to select Existing
File or Web Page. Select File.
4. A Link to File dialog box opens which will allow you to browse to find the file.
5. Select the file
DEVELOPING A RESEARCH QUESTION
Students choose a product or job type that targets teenagers to investigate and then
frame a research question that challenges some assumptions or information typically
associated with the product or job.
CRITERIA FOR AN EFFECTIVE RESEARCH QUESTION
The question
is open – no definite answer
casts doubt on what appears to be self evident
is practical – it can be researched
allows students to analyse language techniques in particular texts
has an ethical dimension
leads to the development of a community service advertisement for
teenagers regarding the worth of the product or job.
Suggested approach
1. Model the development of a research question. For example: Living for today
– is this what shopping malls are all about?
2. Students design a research question.
3. Form small research teams to evaluate research questions against the
criteria established.
4. Students consult the teacher regarding the efficacy of the research question
5. Present research question to class
8
WRITING THE ADVERTISEMENT
Students have investigated advertisements related to watchdog agencies. The
advertisement, which will be an element of the hypertext, needs to be constructed
with a clear sense of purpose and target audience – adolescents. Students can be
directed to websites that define different types of persuasive language techniques to
assist with composition, such as
•
•
http://english.unitecnology.ac.nz/resources/resources/advertising.html
http://www.abc.net.au/tv/gruentransfer/adspeak_glossary.htm
The advertisement will include visual and verbal language features (spoken or
written).
THE RESEARCH PROCESS
1. Brainstorm some preliminary thoughts or hypotheses to answer the research
question.
2. Find a range of texts that meet these requirements:
link to one job or product
include multimedia
use persuasive language techniques
3. Using the planning timeline set a timetable and formulate short-term and
long-term tasks paying particular attention to the development of the
community service advertisement.
9
Planning Timeline
Task
Due date
Notes and Comments
Formulate Research
Question
Researching job or
product
Researching job or
product
Researching
multimedia
Researching
Hypertexts:
Drafting Hypertext –
main text
Establishing links in
hypertext
Conferencing with
teacher
Conferencing with
students
10
There are three key aspects in this phase: drafting and critiquing the hypertext so that it is a
coherent text, creation of the community advertisement and collaborative conferencing
throughout the process – teacher to student, student to student.
• Encourage students to date the versions of their work so they keep track of their
editing (for example filename 090401, 090402 – this also sorts files in calendar
order)
• Use research recording software such as Zotero (an add-on for the internet browser
Firefox) to keep records of and comments on internet research.
The community service advertisement needs to illustrate the key concepts of purpose and
target audience and demonstrate appreciation of the value of responsible and ethical
financial and consumer behaviour.
The following points are critical in drafting a hypertext:
the opening - readers using computers make immediate decisions to continue
reading based on the first twenty or so words
the paragraph - the powerhouse of the report
the layout - make sure the text fits on the screen or it may be missed
the ending - the reader may decide to navigate back up the page
hyperlinks – connections need to be clear and logical
conciseness - cut out all unnecessary words and ideas
editing – go through the text line by line for accuracy and cadence
Conferencing means listening carefully to the student’s intentions and offering suggestions
to achieve these. For reflection to occur students need response to their drafting. Some
prompts for conferencing, for use by teachers or students, could include:
Any problems?
Tell me more about …
Read it to me again …
What’s the most important thing you are trying to say?
What connection do you want to establish here?
What’s your favourite part?
Is all the information important?2
CLASS PRESENTATIONS
Publication of the hypertexts could happen in a range of ways including:
2
•
uploading to a webpage on the school network called Watchdog
•
presentations to students
•
inviting other experts to preview the hypertexts, for example people working in youth
employment, advertising, community service agencies.
•
inviting teachers from other disciplines to preview and feedback – for example
business studies?
•
reflection on the process of the research, its challenges and pleasures.
Adapted from Bridging English (p 354-360)
11