"#$%&"'"(%)*$+"&#",%-)'*45;*!!n<!4k=*46!4
>*&?3*$3/:@/8ABC0*"@9A:?/0/DABC0*7/BA3:E
!"#$)(-#$(X$+(8*#!%!%('$%'$/!)0+!0)%'.$!)(*%+,-$9%)W$
+(880'%!%#/
EQNN$#A$E>LeFUGeQ52:2$+>CI@=QL@$"A$.=>I>Oc2$EK>L$-KQG$*>==>62$/?FCC$SA$)FPQLGFL:2$'>CI>NQ@$
/@MMFLg2$E>L@@L@$8A$!FK?ICFLi2j2$D$EFG@HI$,A$!FPQ>Gg
9-)0-+#&*-%6'R#*#,&28'"#$%&#.'N$-+#&*-%6')('9&-%-*8'")5174-,.'k,$2)1+#&.'",$,0,H''
!"#$%&''f,$_)d*_K4-)0-+#&*-%6H142H2,'
F
M5)&-0,']1*#17')('=,%1&,5'l-*%)&6.'N$-+#&*-%6')('M5)&-0,.'p,-$#*+-55#.'N3OH'
C
B#J,&%7#$%')('/2)5):6',$0'/+)51%-)$.'3%)$6'9&))_'N$-+#&*-%6.'=r.'N3OH'
Y
;$*%-%1%)'0#'9-)5):U,.'N$-+#&*-0,0'0#'O$%-)Q1-,.']#0#55U$.'")5)74-,H'
a
/0d,&0'p&#6';$*%-%1%#.'B#J,&%7#$%')('>))5):6.'N$-+#&*-%6')('Tb()&0.'N$-%#0'^-$:0)7H$
j
B#J,&%7#$%')('/2)5):6',$0'/+)51%-)$,&6'9-)5):6.'?&-$2#%)$'N$-+#&*-%6.'?&-$2#%)$.'N3OH'
G
],b<?5,$2_';$*%-%1%#'()&'T&$-%8)5):6.'3285)**,55##'F.'GXC!a'R,0)5([#55.'p#&7,$6H
!
)@GKO@LA$ c$ #N$ H>H@N$ M@$ N>$ ?FOH@C@L?Q>$ @L$ N>$ @GC=K?CK=>$ M@$ ?FOKLQM>M@G$ M@$ >B@G$ C=FHQ?>N@GA$ c$ O'
J#*,&'0#'7128,*'0g2,0,*'0#'-$%#$*)'#*%10-).'#5'J,J#5'0#'5,'2)7J#%#$2-,'2)7)'1$,'(1#&[,'#*%&12%1&,0)&,'
0#'2)71$-0,0#*'#2)5\:-2,*'2)$%-$V,'*-#$0)'2)$%&)+#&*-,5H'/$'#*%#',&%U215)'&#*17-7)*'5,*'J&#*#$%,2-)$#*'
0#'1$'*-7J)*-)'#$()2,0)'#$'#b,7-$,&'#5'#(#2%)'0#'5,'2)7J#%#$2-,'-$%#&#*J#2U(-2,'#$'5,'0-*%&-412-\$'6',41$<
0,$2-,'0#'5,*'#*J#2-#*'0#',+#*'#$'#2)*-*%#7,*'%&)J-2,5#*.'#$'5)*'21,5#*'J)*-45#7#$%#'5,*'-$%#&,22-)$#*'
4-\%-2,*' *)$' 5,*' 7`*' -$%#$*,*' 0#4-0)' ,' 5,' ,5%,' 0-+#&*-0,0' #$' ,74-#$%#*' #*%,45#*H' B#*2&-4-7)*' 1$,' *#&-#'
0#' #*%10-)*' -$0#J#$0-#$%#*.' 2,0,' 1$)' #$(&#$%,$0)' J&#:1$%,*' ,V$' $)' &#*1#5%,*' 1%-5-[,$0)' )' 2)74-$,$0)'
%g2$-2,*'7)0#&$,*'6'&#21&*)*'Q1#'$)'#&,$'0-*J)$-45#*'#$'5,*'0g2,0,*',$%#&-)&#*H'/*%)*'%&,4,f)*'-$2516#$'
#*%10-)*','5,&:)'J5,[)'Q1#'7)$-%)&#,$'2,74-)*'#$'5,',41$0,$2-,'6'#5'2)7J)&%,7-#$%).'J&1#4,*'#bJ#&-7#$<
%,5#*'0#'*#:&#:,2-\$'7#0-,0,'J)&'2)7J)&%,7-#$%).'5,',J5-2,2-\$'0#'7,J#)'-$%#$*-+)'0#'%#&&-%)&-)*.'#5'1*)'
0#'-*\%)J)*'#*%,45#*'6'0,%)*'0#'*#$*)&#*'&#7)%)*'J,&,'21,$%-(-2,&'$-28)*'6'8`4-%,%*.'6'7g%)0)*'0#'2)71$-<
0,0#*'#$'1$'2)$%#b%)'(-5):#$g%-2)'J,&,'#+,51,&'J,%&)$#*'0#'2)<)21&&#$2-,'0#$%&)'0#'25,0)*H'")5#2%-+,7#$%#.'
#*%,*' ,J&)b-7,2-)$#*' )(&#2#$' ,5%#&$,%-+,*' J,&,' #+,51,&' 5,' -7J)&%,$2-,' 0#' 2)7J#%#$2-,' #$%&#' #*J#2-#*' 6'
25,&-(-2,&'*1'#(#2%)'*)4&#'5,'#*%&12%1&,'0#'2)71$-0,0#*','#*2,5,*'5)2,5#*'6'&#:-)$,5#*H
,PGC=>?CA'c'B#*J-%#'*#+#&,5'0#2,0#*')('-$%#$*#'*2&1%-$6.'%8#'&)5#')('2)7J#%-%-)$',*','()&2#'*%&12%1&-$:'#2)5):-<
2,5'2)771$-%-#*'&#7,-$*'2)$%&)+#&*-,5H'l#&#'d#'*177,&-[#','*67J)*-17'()21*#0')$'#b,7-$-$:'%8#'#((#2%'
)('-$%#&*J#2-(-2'2)7J#%-%-)$')$'%8#'0-*%&-41%-)$',$0',41$0,$2#')('4-&0'*J#2-#*'-$'%&)J-2,5'#2)*6*%#7*.'d8#&#'
4-)%-2'-$%#&,2%-)$*',&#'5-_#56'%)'4#'7)*%'-$%#$*#'4#2,1*#')('8-:8'0-+#&*-%6'-$'*%,45#'#$+-&)$7#$%*H'E#')1%5-$#','
*#&-#*')('-$0#J#$0#$%'*%10-#*.'#,28'%,2_5-$:'5)$:<*%,$0-$:'Q1#*%-)$*'46'1%-5-[-$:')&'2)74-$-$:'7)0#&$'%#28<
$-Q1#*',$0'&#*)1&2#*'%8,%'d#&#'5,&:#56'1$,+,-5,45#'-$'J&#+-)1*'0#2,0#*H'L8#*#'-$2510#'5)$:<%#&7'0,%,*#%*'
%&,2_-$:'28,$:#*'-$',41$0,$2#',$0'4#8,+-)&.'#bJ#&-7#$%,5'%#*%*')('4#8,+-)&,556<7#0-,%#0'*#:&#:,%-)$.',J<
J5-2,%-)$')('-$%#$*-+#'%#&&-%)&6'7,JJ-$:.'*%,45#'-*)%)J#*.',$0'&#7)%#56'*#$*#0'0,%,'%)'7#,*1&#'8,4-%,%'$-28#*.'
,$0'2)771$-%6'J865):#$#%-2'7#%8)0*'()&',**#**-$:'J,%%#&$*')('2)#b-*%#$2#'d-%8-$'5,&:#&'25,0#*H'")55#2%-+#56.'
%8#*#',JJ&),28#*')((#&'&-28'J)%#$%-,5'()&'#+,51,%-$:'%8#'*%&#$:%8')('2)7J#%-%-)$'4#%d##$'-$%#&,2%-$:'*J#2-#*'
,$0'25,&-(6-$:'-%*'#((#2%')$'%8#'*%&12%1&#')('2)771$-%-#*',%'5)2,5',$0'&#:-)$,5'*2,5#*H
S@T$UF=MGV$,+-,$.'2)771$-%6',**#7456.'#5#+,%-)$,5':&,0-#$%.'-$%#&*J#2-(-2',::&#**-)$.'$,%1&,5'#bJ#&-7#$%.'
=#)%&)J-2,5'()&#*%.'$-28#'*#:&#:,%-)$.'J865):#$#%-2'*%&12%1&#
!!n
!"#$%&'$()!"#$%&
%$&#"LS-&%"$
7KH VWXG\ RI LQWHUVSHFLÀF FRPSHWLWLRQ DV DQ
3B/0/DABC0*23B?C9AI2*?CI*C*0/9D*?AI:/@E*RLC@H
KA9* !bnNT=* E3:* :?3@3* AI* 0A::03* B/9I39I1I* CM/1:*
A:I*@/03*A9*I?C8A9D*B/2219A:E*I:@1B:1@3O*_1B?*
@3B39:*K/@[*?CI*I?/K9*:?C:*80C9:*B/2219A:E*
CII32M0E*BC9*M3*3W80CA93G*ME*931:@C0*2/G30I=*
/@*30I3*ME*G3:3@2A9AI:AB*2/G30I*:?C:*328?CIAQ3*
QLFKHEDVHGSURFHVVHVVXFKDVKDELWDWÀOWHULQJ
C9G*GAI83@IC0*0A2A:C:A/9*R`1MM300*466!=*#/IA9H
G300*&4*.#E*46!!=*l3A?3@*&4*.#7KHVHÀQGH
A9DI* I1DD3I:* :?C:* B/283:A:A/9* AI* C* @30C:AJ30E*
K3C[*3B/0/DABC0*F/@B3*C:*:?3*B/2219A:E*03J30O*
+RZHYHUWKHLUJHQHUDOLW\LVGLIÀFXOWWRDVVHVV
CI*2C9E*:3I:I*I:@1DD03*:/*GAIB@A2A9C:3*M3:K339*
2/G30I*R-?AI?/02*z*,CBC0C*46!6T=*C9G*A9*C9E*
BCI3* B/283:A:A/9* I332I* 0A[30E* :/* M3* 303JC:3G*
A9* /:?3@* IEI:32I=* I1B?* CI* J3@:3M@C:3IO* %9* 8C@H
:AB10C@=* :@/8ABC0* MA@GI* 2CE* B/283:3* I:@/9D0E*
M3BC1I3*/F *FCB:/@I*I1B?*CI*0/K*GAI83@IC0=*9C@H
@/K*9AB?3I=*0C@D3*912M3@I*/F *IE28C:@AB*B/9H
JHQHUV DQG LQWHQVH LQWHUVSHFLÀF WHUULWRULDOLW\
C9G*CDD@3IIA/9*R_CB)@:?1@*!Nrk=*-/GE*!Nsk=*
(@CJ3I*z*(/:300A*!NN5=*&/MACI*z*73GG/9*466N=*
XC9[/KI[A* &4* .#E* 46!6TO* _/I:* /F * :?3I3* FCB:/@I*
C@3* K300* 3I:CM0AI?3G=* E3:* :?3* 3W:39:* :/* K?AB?*
WKH\ LQÁXHQFH UDQJH ERXQGDULHV DQG SDWWHUQV
/F *GAJ3@IA:E*C9G*CM19GC9B3*A9*:@/8ABC0*CJAFC1H
9CI*@32CA9I*B/9:@/J3@IAC0*RlA39I*46!!TO
):* 03CI:* :?@33* 8C::3@9I=* K?AB?* ?CJ3* /F:39*
M339* G/B1239:3G* A9* :?3* $3/:@/8ABI=* ?CJ3*
?AI:/@ABC00E* M339* B/9IAG3@3G* 3JAG39B3* /F * A9H
WHUVSHFLÀFFRPSHWLWLRQRYHUWLQWHUVSHFLÀFDJH
D@3IIA/9* C:* I8C:AC00E* B/9B39:@C:3G* @3I/1@B3I=*
@3I/1@B3* 8C@:A:A/9A9D* C2/9D* B/3WAI:A9D* I83H
BA3I=* C9G* I3D@3DC:A/9* /F * 3B/0/DABC00E* IA2A0C@*
I83BA3I* C0/9D* 39JA@/9239:C0* D@CGA39:IO* &?3I3*
/MI3@J3G* 8C::3@9I* BC8:1@3* GAFF3@39:* CJ3913I*
ME*K?AB?*B/283:A:AJ3*A9:3@CB:A/9I*C2/9D*I83H
BA3I*B/10G*3A:?3@*83@2A:*/@*8@3J39:*I83BA3I*B/H
3WAI:39B3* R3ODO=* F/@MAGG39* B/2MA9C:A/9I* )&6)(*
'LDPRQG ,QWHUVSHFLÀF DJJUHVVLRQ DW
I8C:AC00E* B/9B39:@C:3G* @3I/1@B3I* C9G* 8C::3@9I*
/F * @3I/1@B3* 8C@:A:A/9A9D* C@3* 93B3IIC@A0E* /MH
!!r
I3@J3G* C:* 0/BC0* I8C:AC0* IBC03I* C9G* C@3* :E8ABC00E*
I:1GA3G*A9*:?3*B/9:3W:*/F *B/2219A:E*CII32M0EO*
&?3* I3D@3DC:A/9* /F * 3B/0/DABC00E* IA2A0C@* I83H
BA3I* C0/9D* 39JA@/9239:C0* D@CGA39:I* /BB1@I* C:*
M/:?* 0/BC0* C9G* @3DA/9C0* IBC03I=* G3839GA9D* /9*
:?3*I8C:AC0*3W:39:*/F *C*DAJ39*D@CGA39:O*)BB/@GH
A9D0E=*8C::3@9I*/F *I3D@3DC:A/9*BC9*M3*3WC2A93G*
LQWKHFRQWH[WRI WKHLQWHUDFWLRQVLQÁXHQFLQJ
B/2219A:E*CII32M0E=*:?3*2CA9:39C9B3*/F *0/BC0*
GAI:@AM1:A/9I*CB@/II*?CMA:C:I=*C9G*:?3*@3A9F/@B3H
239:*/F *@C9D3*M/19GC@A3I*C:*0C@D3@*IBC03IO
7/23* /F * :?3* 3C@0A3I:* I:1GA3I* /F * :@/8ABC0*
CJAC9*D1A0GI*I?/K3G*3JAG39B3*B/9IAI:39:*KA:?*
B/283:A:A/9* 80CEA9D* C* @/03* :/* I:@1B:1@3* I83H
BA3I*CII32M0CD3I*C:*0/BC0*IBC03IO**%9*:?3A@*I:1GE*
/F * C@2EHC9:* F/00/K3@I=* lA00AI* z* "9A[A* R!NsbT*
VKRZHGWKDWLQWHUVSHFLÀFGRPLQDQFHEDVHGRQ
M/GE*IAQ3*39CM03G*I/23*I83BA3I*:/*DCA9*8@3F3@H
39:AC0*CBB3II*:/*:?3*2/I:*8@/G1B:AJ3*2AB@/?CMH
A:C:I*C:*:?3*03CGA9D*3GD3*/F *C@2E*C9:*IKC@2IO*
Z3:=*:?3@3*KCI*C0I/*@3I/1@B3*8C@:A:A/9A9D*KA:?A9*
:?3* C9:* F/00/KA9D* D1A0G* MCI3G* /9* GAFF3@39:AC0*
1I3* /F * 83@B?* :E83IO* $3B:C@AJ/@/1I* ?122A9DH
MA@GI* C0I/* I?/K* C* B/2MA9C:A/9* /F * 8C::3@9I*
B/9IAI:39:*KA:?*C*B/283:A:A/9HI:@1B:1@3G*MA@G*
B/2219A:E=* KA:?* M3?CJA/@C00E* G/2A9C9:* I83H
FLHV PRQRSROL]LQJ FOXPSHG ÁRZHUV H[SORLWH
DWLYHFRPSHWLWLRQIRUPRUHGLVSHUVHGÁRZHUV
C9G* B/3WAI:39B3* /F * I83BA3I* KA:?* GAFF3@39:* MA00*
W\SHVWKDWHQDEOHWKHPWRXVHGLIIHUHQWÁRZHUV
RU3A9IA9D3@* !Nsb=* U3A9IA9D3@* z* -/0K300* !Nsb=*
,A22*&4*.#E*!NbnTO*7/23*/F *:?3*2/I:*I83BAC0H
AQ3G*F/@CDA9D*M3?CJA/@I*/MI3@J3G*C@3*:?/I3*/F *
A9I3B:AJ/@/1I* :@/8ABC0* MA@GI=* 3I83BAC00E* C2/9D*
VSHFLHV WKDW IRUDJH LQ PL[HGVSHFLHV ÁRFNV
R79/K* z* 79/K* !Ns!=* X/93I* !Nsb=* ,3C@I/9*
!Nss=*_199*!Nbn=*$C/[A*466sTO*71B?*I83BAC0H
AQC:A/9*?CI*M339*C@D13G*:/*@3G1B3*B/283:A:A/9*
ZLWKLQ ÁRFNV DQG PD\ GHWHUPLQH WKH ´UXOHVµ
19G3@0EA9D* B/2219A:E* CII32M0E* A9* K?AB?*
HDFK ÁRFN FDQ RQO\ FRQWDLQ RQH VSHFLHV SHU
F/@CDA9D* 9AB?3* R3ODO=* A9I3B:AJ/@3I* :?C:* I3C@B?*
I1I839G3G*G3CG*03CJ3Ia*_199*!Nbn=*,A3@8/9:*
!Nbr=*(@CJ3I*z*(/:300A*!NN5TO*+W:@323*F/@CDH
A9D*I83BAC0AQC:A/9*?CI*C0I/*M339*CII/BAC:3G*KA:?*
!"#$%&'&'"()'()&*"$'!+,)-'*.)!"##/('&'%0
:?3*3J/01:A/9C@E*GAJ3@D39B3*/F *0A93CD3I*KA:?A9*
WKHPHJDGLYHUVHÁ\FDWFKHU7\UDQQLGDHIDPH
A0E*A9*K?AB?*2/@8?/0/DABC0*CGC8:C:A/9I*CII/BAH
C:3G*KA:?*8C@:AB10C@*F/@CDA9D*:CB:ABI*I1B?*CI*MA00*
I?C83*RUA:Q8C:@AB[*!NbnT*C9G*GAJ3@D39B3*A9*GA3:*
6KHUU\ PD\ HQDEOH DV PDQ\ DV Á\H
BC:B?3@*I83BA3I*:/*B/3WAI:*A9*C*IA9D03*B/2219AH
W\ZLWKRXWRYHUODSSLQJVLJQLÀFDQWO\LQUHVRXUFH
1I3O*l?3:?3@*B/283:A:A/9*KCI*C*8@A2C@E*G@AJ3@*
/F *I1B?*GAJ3@D39:*F/@CDA9D*M3?CJA/@=*J3@I1I*C*
23B?C9AI2*A9J/0J3G*A9*3B/0/DABC0*I/@:A9D=*@3H
2CA9I*C*B/9:39:A/1I*AII13O
)GGA:A/9C0* B/@@30C:A/9C0* 3JAG39B3* F/@* C9*
LPSRUWDQW UROH RI LQWHUVSHFLÀF FRPSHWLWLRQ
?CI* B/23* F@/2* I:1GA3I* I?/KA9D* I3D@3DC:A/9*
/F *B0/I30E*@30C:3G*I83BA3I*C0/9D*39JA@/9239:C0*
D@CGA39:I*A9*:?3*:@/8ABI*R&3@M/@D?*!Ns!=*!NbnTO*
7:1GA3I* /F * I83BA3I* @380CB3239:I* C0/9D* 303JCH
:A/9C0*D@CGA39:I*A9*:?3*)9G3I*I1DD3I:*:?C:*GAH
@3B:*A9:3@F3@39B3*B/283:A:A/9*0A2A:I*303JC:A/9C0*
GAI:@AM1:A/9I* /F * /93H:?A@G* /F * I83BA3I* C0/9D*
:?3I3* D@CGA39:I* R&3@M/@D?* !Ns!=* &3@M/@D?* z*
l3I[3* !NsnTO* U1@:?3@2/@3=* C* B/28C@AI/9* /F *
:?3*8@A9BA8C0*)9G3C9*D@CGA39:*KA:?*C9*AI/0C:3G*
2/19:CA9* @C9D3* A9* K?AB?* ?AD?H303JC:A/9* B/9H
D393@I*K3@3*CMI39:*@3J3C03G*:?C:*3J39*I83BA3I*
KA:?/1:* I83BA3I* @380CB3239:I* C0/9D* :?3* 8@A9H
BA8C0*D@CGA39:*I?/K3G*C9*3W8C9IA/9*/F *@C9D3I*
18I0/83=*I1DD3I:A9D*:?C:*M/:?*GA@3B:*B/283:AH
:AJ3*A9:3@CB:A/9I*CI*K300*CI*GAFF1I3*B/283:A:A/9*
C2/9D* I83BA3I*2CE*0A2A:*18* :/* :K/H:?A@GI*/F *
2/9:C93* MA@GIO* -/28C@CM03* @380CB3239:* /F *
IA2A0C@HIAQ3G*B/9D393@I*C0/9D*I1BB3IIA/9C0*D@CH
GA39:I*R&3@M/@D?*!NbnT*C0I/*8@/JAG3I*3JAG39B3*
IRUDUROHLQWHUVSHFLÀFFRPSHWLWLRQLQFOXGLQJ
3W83@A239:C0*3JAG39B3*:?C:*?CMA:C:*I3D@3DC:A/9*
C0/9D*:?3*D@CGA39:*AI*2CA9:CA93G*ME*A9:3@I83BAFH
AB*:3@@A:/@AC0A:E*R#/MA9I/9*z*&3@M/@D?*!NNnTO*
)0:?/1D?*3CB?*/F *:?3I3*I:1GA3I*?CI*G32/9H
I:@C:3G*8C::3@9I*B/9IAI:39:*KA:?*B/283:A:A/9*CI*
C*G/2A9C:A9D*F/@B3*A9*:@/8ABC0*MA@G*B/2219AH
:A3I=*9/93*/F *:?3I3*I:1GA3I*?CI*8@/JAG3G*8@//F *
WKDW LQWHUVSHFLÀF FRPSHWLWLRQ VWUXFWXUHV ELUG
B/2219A:A3I*/@*:?C:*A:*8@/2/:3I*/@*2CA9:CA9I*
$3/:@/8ABC0*MA@G*I83BA3I*GAJ3@IA:EO*&?1I=*3J39*
CF:3@*F/1@*G3BCG3I*/F *@3I3C@B?=*:?3I3*\13I:A/9I*
UHPDLQHOXVLYHZLWKLQÀHOGVRI WURSLFDOHFRORJ\
C9G*3J/01:A/9O*`3@3*K3*G3IB@AM3*C*912M3@*/F *
A99/JC:AJ3*C88@/CB?3I*C9G*://0I*:?C:*?CJ3*C0H
ORZHGXVWRUHÀQHRXUDVVHVVPHQWRI WKHUROH
/F *B/283:A:A/9*/83@C:A9D*:/*I:@1B:1@3*B/221H
QLWLHV2QHRI WKHVHDSSURDFKHVLVWKHLGHQWLÀH
BC:A/9*/F *0C9GIBC83I*:?C:*?CJ3*19G3@D/93*0/BC0*
3W:A9B:A/9* /F * I83BA3I=* K?AB?* 2CE* A9B01G3* :?3*
0/II*/F *G/2A9C9:*B/283:A:/@IO*"F *B/1@I3=*:?AI*
/88/@:19A:E*AI*B/9GA:A/9C0*18/9*:?3*CJCA0CMA0A:E*
/F *C*?AI:/@ABC0*BC:C0/D13*/F *B/2219A:A3IO*":?H
3@*C88@/CB?3I*A9B/@8/@C:3*:?3*1I3*/F *AI/:/83I*
DQG UHPRWHO\ VHQVHG GDWD IRU EHWWHU TXDQWLÀH
BC:A/9* /F * 9AB?3* C9G* ?CMA:C:* /J3@0C8* M3:K339*
I83BA3I=*I:1GA3I*/F *M3?CJA/@*:?C:*BC9*I3@J3*CI*
I1@@/DC:3I* /F * B/283:A:AJ3* 8@3II1@3=* C9G* :?3*
C880ABC:A/9* /F * 8?E0/D393:AB* @30C:A/9I?A8I* C9G*
:@CA:* A9F/@2C:A/9* :/* :3I:* ?E8/:?3I3I* /F * ?/K*
B/2219A:A3I*I?/10G*M3*CII32M03G*AF *B/283:AH
:A/9* B/9I:@CA93G* I83BA3I* B/3WAI:39B3O* U1@:?3@*
C880ABC:A/9* /F * I1B?* 23:?/GI* CB@/II* :@/8ABC0*
B/2219A:A3I* I?/10G* 83@2A:* C* 2/@3* B/28@3H
?39IAJ3* IE9:?3IAI* /F * :?3* @/03* /F * B/283:A:A/9*
A9* I?C8A9D* B/2219A:E* B/28/IA:A/9* C9G* I83H
BA3I*GAI:@AM1:A/9IO
1$785$/(;3(5,0(176(&2H
'"(%-)'*",,"#&S$%&Z*U"'H
/2:,1*(;7,1&7,21
&?1I*FC@=*21B?*/F *:?3*3JAG39B3*8@3I39:3G*F/@*
B/283:A:A/9* CI* C* G/2A9C9:* F/@B3* I:@1B:1@A9D*
:@/8ABC0* MA@G* B/2219A:A3I* ?CI* M339* 8@/JAG3G*
:?@/1D?* A9GA@3B:* 23CI1@3IO* "93* GA@3B:* :3I:*
/F * :?3* A28CB:* /F * B/283:A:A/9* AI* :/* 83@F/@2*
I83BA3I* CGGA:A/9* /@* @32/JC0* 3W83@A239:I* C9G*
3WC2A93*I1MI3\139:*I?AF:I*A9*@3I/1@B3*1I3*/F *
I83BA3I* R3ODO=* _C@:A9* z* _C@:A9* 466!=* ]/09AB[*
&4* .#E* 46!6Ta* ?/K3J3@=* I1B?* 3W83@A239:I* C@3*
I30G/2* @3C0AI:AB* A9* :@/8ABC0* MA@G* B/2219A:A3I=*
CI* 0C@D3HIBC03* C0:3@C:A/9I* /F * MA@G* B/2219AH
:A3I*C@3*D393@C00E*0/DAI:ABC00E*19F3CIAM03*C9G*C@3*
/F:39* B/9IAG3@3G* 193:?ABC0O* )9* 19G3@JC013G*
C0:3@9C:AJ3* :/* I1B?* @32/JC0* 3W83@A239:I* AI* :/*
!!s
!"#$%&'$()!"#$%&
:C[3* CGJC9:CD3* /F * I83BA3I* 0/II3I* G13* :/* F@CDH
239:C:A/9=* 8C@:AB10C@0E* A9* 0/BC:A/9I* :?C:* ?CJ3*
8@3JA/1I*MCI30A93*GC:C*/9*B/2219A:E*I:@1B:1@3*
R&3@M/@D?* &4* .#E* 466!TO* +WB38:A/9C00E* JC01CM03*
C@3*C@3CI*:?C:*C0I/*B/9:CA9*\1CIAHB/9:@/0I*ä*0/H
BC:A/9I*:?C:*GAG*9/:*19G3@D/*:?3*IC23*I83BA3I*
0/II* CI* 93C@ME* 3W83@A239:C0* F@CD239:IO* &?3*
@3I8/9I3I*/F *@32CA9A9D*I83BA3I*A9*I1B?*\1CIAH
3W83@A239:I*39CM03*C9*CII3II239:*/F *:?3*G3H
D@33*:/*K?AB?*B/283:A:/@I*2CE*B/9I:@CA9*9AB?3*
M/19GC@A3I*/F */:?3@*I83BA3IO*
%9*:?AI*IE28/IA12=*&/1B?:/9*8@3I39:I*C9*
3WC2803*/F *C*\1CIAH3W83@A239:*KA:?A9*C*:?@33H
I83BA3I* D1A0G* /F * C9:HF/00/KA9D* MA@GI* :?C:* ?CG*
M339*I:1GA3G*3W:39IAJ30E*A9*0/K0C9G*F/@3I:I*/F *
,C9C2i*/9*M/:?*]C@@/*-/0/@CG/*%I0C9G*R]-%a*
lA00AI* !Nrs=* !Ns4=* !Ns5T* C9G* /9* :?3* 93C@ME*
2CA90C9G*A9*7/M3@C9^C*$C:A/9C0*,C@[*R7:E@I[E*
4665TO* "9* ]-%=* I/BAC00E* G/2A9C9:* "B300C:3G*
)9:MA@GI* R@3.&6$)4/24()* 82#&.66.6/T* K39:* 3WH
:A9B:*A9*!NrN*RlA00AI*!Nsk=*lA00AI*z*+AI392C99*
!NsNT*M1:*@32CA93G*B/22/9*/9*:?3*2CA90C9GO*
&?3* /:?3@* :K/* I83BA3I=* ]AB/0/@3G* )9:MA@GI*
R,"86$%/43")* #&(2.)%/)T* C9G* 78/::3G* )9:MA@GI*
R!"#$%3"#.D* 6.&L/$/0&)T=* ?CJ3* @32CA93G* C:* M/:?*
IA:3I* R#/MA9I/9* &4* .#E* 4666=* #/MA9I/9* 466!TO*
&?AI*IA:1C:A/9*83@2A:I*C*GA@3B:*B/28C@AI/9*/F *
]AB/0/@3G*)9:MA@G*C9G*78/::3G*)9:MA@G*8/81H
0C:A/9*G39IA:A3I*C9G*2AB@/?CMA:C:*1I3*M3:K339*
B1@@39:*]-%*RG/2A9C9:*D1A0G*232M3@*CMI39:T*
C9G* :?3* 2CA90C9G* RG/2A9C9:* D1A0G* 232M3@*
8@3I39:T*:/*?AI:/@ABC0*GC:C*DC:?3@3G*F@/2*]-%*
A9* :?3* !Nr6I* K?39* :?3* G/2A9C9:* D1A0G* 232H
M3@* KCI* 8@3I39:O* &/1B?:/9* F/19G* :?C:* :?3*
AI0C9GHKAG3* G39IA:E* /F * 78/::3G* )9:MA@GI* ?CI*
2/@3*:?C9*G/1M03G*IA9B3*:?3*0/II*/F *"B300C:3G*
)9:MA@GI=*G3I8A:3*IA2A0C@*03J30I*/F *F/@CDA9D*@3H
I/1@B3I* R&/1B?:/9* z* 72A:?* 46!!TO* )GGA:A/9H
C00E=* 78/::3G* )9:MA@GI* F19B:A/9C00E* /J3@B/2H
839IC:3G* F/@* B/9I128:A/9* /F * @3I/1@B3I* :?C:*
K3@3* ?AI:/@ABC00E* 2/9/8/0AQ3G* ME* "B300C:3G*
)9:MA@GI*R&/1B?:/9*z*72A:?*46!!TO*%9*/@G3@*
:/*3W80/A:*:?3I3*93K0E*CJCA0CM03*E3:*8C:B?E*@3H
I/1@B3I=* I/23* 78/::3G* )9:MA@G* A9GAJAG1C0I*
@30CW3G* :?3A@* :3@@A:/@AC0A:E* ME* 3W8C9GA9D* :?3A@*
!!b
?/23* @C9D3I* C9G* 3W?AMA:3G* ?AD?3@* @38@/G1BH
:AJ3*/1:81:*:?C9*:?3A@*B/19:3@8C@:I*3J39*A9*:?3*
FCB3*/F *2/G3@C:30E*?AD?3@*@C:3I*/F *93I:*8@3GCH
:A/9* R&/1B?:/9* z* lA[30I[A* A9* 8@38TO* L3I8A:3*
?CJA9D* C* F/@CDA9D* I:@C:3DE* 2/@3* IA2A0C@* :/*
"B300C:3G*)9:MA@GI*:?C9*:/*78/::3G*)9:MA@GI=*
]AB/0/@3G*)9:MA@GI*GAG*9/:*@3I8/9G*KA:?*@AI3I*
A9*G39IA:E*/@*2AB@/?CMA:C:*I?AF:I*C[A9*:/*78/:H
:3G*)9:MA@GI=*83@?C8I*C*@3I10:*/F */:?3@*0A2A:A9D*
FCB:/@I*I1B?*CI*8@3GC:A/9*R&/1B?:/9*z*72A:?*
7KHVHUHVXOWVLQGLFDWHWKDWLQWHUVSHFLÀF
B/283:A:A/9*BC9*@3I:@AB:*F/@CDA9D*9AB?3I*A9*B/H
3WAI:A9D*MA@G*I83BA3I=*C9G*?AD?0AD?:*:?3*@/03*/F *
B/283:A:A/9*A9*2AB@/3J/01:A/9C@E*8@/B3II3IO
%(+$9,25$/(;3(5,0(176
-"_,+&%&%.+*%$&+#)-&%"$7=*
#)$(+*]"S$L)#%+7*)$L*#+H
(%"$)'*L%7&#%]S&%"$7
,QWHUVSHFLÀF FRPSHWLWLYH LQWHUDFWLRQV DV H[H
8@3II3G* :?@/1D?* :3@@A:/@AC0* CDD@3IIA/9=* 2CE*
80CE* C* @/03* A9* @3A9F/@BA9D* :?3* GAI:@AM1:A/9C0*
0A2A:I* /F * B/283:A9D* I83BA3I* C:* 0C@D3* I8C:AC0*
IBC03I=* 8C@:AB10C@0E* K?39* @C9D3I* /F * B/283:AH
:/@I* C@3* 0C@D30E* 8C@C8C:@AB* RXC9[/KI[A* &4* .#E*
46!6TO*%9*MA@GI=*I1B?*303JC:A/9C0*@380CB3239:I*
C@3* F/19G* @383C:3G0E* C0/9D* :@/8ABC0* 2/19H
:CA9IAG3I*C9G*?CJ3*0/9D*M339*:?/1D?:*:/*M3*C*
8@/G1B:* /F * GA@3B:* B/283:A:A/9* R&3@M/@D?* z*
:HVNH 8VLQJ KHWHURVSHFLÀF SOD\EDFN
3W83@A239:I* C0/9D* C9* 303JC:A/9C0* D@CGA39:* A9*
:?3*&A0C@i9*@C9D3*/F *-/I:C*#ABC=*XC9[/KI[A*&4*
.#E*R46!6T*I?/K3G*:?C:*M3?CJA/@C0*A9:3@CB:A/9I*
M3:K339*I83BA3I*KA:?*303JC:A/9C0*@380CB3239:I*
K3@3*8@3I39:*A9*:K/*D393@C*/F *2/9:C93*MA@GIO*
)GGA:A/9C00E=* :?3* @3I8/9I3I* :/* B/9D393@* I/9D*
I:A210A* B?C9D3G* /J3@* I2C00* I8C:AC0* IBC03I=* GAH
2A9AI?A9D* CI* /93* 2/J3G* CKCE* F@/2* B/9:CB:*
Q/93I*:/*@3DA/9I*KA:?A9*:?3*303JC:A/9C0*@C9D3I*
/F *3A:?3@*B/9D393@O*&?AI*K/@[*I1DD3I:3G*:?C:*
M3?CJA/@C0* A9:3@CB:A/9I* K3@3* 0A[30E* C* 03C@93G*
@3I8/9I3=*K?AB?*KCI*B/9GA:A/9C0*18/9*?CJA9D*
VXIÀFLHQW HQFRXQWHU UDWHV EHWZHHQ VSHFLHV LQ
/@G3@*:/*G3J30/8*C9G*M3*2CA9:CA93GO*
!"#$%&'&'"()'()&*"$'!+,)-'*.)!"##/('&'%0
%9* :?AI* IE28/IA12=* XC9[/KI[A* C9G* #/MH
A9I/9*F/00/K*18*/9*XC9[/KI[A*&4*.#E*R46!6T*:/*
G32/9I:@C:3*:?C:*CB@/II*:K/*303JC:A/9C0*D@CGAH
39:I*R/93*A9*-/I:C*#ABC*C9G*/93*A9*:?3*I/1:?H
3CI:3@9* ,3@1JAC9* )9G3IT=* :?3@3* AI* B/9IAG3@H
DEOH YDULDWLRQ LQ WKH VWUHQJWK RI LQWHUVSHFLÀF
CDD@3IIA/9*F/19G*M3:K339*I83BA3I*F/@*C*@C9D3*
/F *:@/8ABC0*2/9:C93*D393@C=*@C9DA9D*F@/2*J3@E*
I:@/9D* @3I8/9I3I* :/KC@G* B/9D393@* I:A210A* :/*
9/* G3:3B:CM03* @3I8/9I3O* SIA9D* :?3* 2/G303G*
8@/MCMA0A:E*/F */BB1@@39B3*F/@*B/9D393@I*C:*:?3*
B/9:CB:*Q/93*CI*C*I1@@/DC:3*F/@*0A[30E*39B/19H
WHUUDWHVEHWZHHQVSHFLHVWKH\ÀQGDQHJDWLYH
@30C:A/9I?A8* M3:K339* CDD@3IIA/9* :/KC@G* B/9H
D393@I* C9G* 8@/MCMA0A:E* /F * /BB1@@39B3* /F * :?3*
FRQJHQHU&DVHVRI VWURQJLQWHUVSHFLÀFDJJUHVH
IA/9*K3@3*/90E*/MI3@J3G*K?39*:?3*8@/MCMA0A:E*
/F * /BB1@@39B3* /F * :?3* B/9D393@* C:* :?3* @C9D3*
M/19GC@E*KCI*D@3C:3@*:?C9*C88@/WA2C:30E*k6uO*
&?AI*039GI*I188/@:*:/*:?3*AG3C*:?C:*:?3*I:@39D:?*
/F * B/283:A:AJ3* A9:3@CB:A/9I* CI* C* 23B?C9AI2*
2CA9:CA9A9D*303JC:A/9C0*@380CB3239:I*2CE*G3H
839G*18/9*0/BC0*G39IA:A3I*/F *I83BA3I*C:*B/9:CB:*
Q/93I=*C9G*CBB/@GA9D0E=*C9E*39JA@/9239:C0*FCBH
WRUVWKDWDIIHFWWKRVHGHQVLWLHVE\LQÁXHQFLQJ
I83BA3I*@3I8/9I3I*:/*39JA@/9239:C0*D@CGA39:IO*
U1@:?3@2/@3=* C0:?/1D?* B/283:A:A/9* 2CE* CFH
F3B:* @C9D3* M/19GC@A3I* /F * B/22/9* I83BA3I=*
:?AI*K/@[*I1DD3I:I*:?C:*I1B?*A9:3@CB:A/9I*2CE*
?CJ3*0A::03*A28CB:*/9*GAI:@AM1:A/9I*/F *@C@3*I83H
BA3I=*K?AB?*@38@3I39:*C*B/9IAG3@CM03*8/@:A/9*/F *
:@/8ABC0*B/2219A:A3IO
$+l*%$7%(`&7*%$&"*&`+*LZH
$)_%-7*"U*-"_,+&%&%"$*)$L*
$%-`+*7+(#+()&%"$*)&*'"-)'*
7-)'+7
,@3JA/1I*C1:?/@I*?CJ3*B?C0039D3G*:?3*JA3K*:?C:*
I8C:AC0* I3D@3DC:A/9* C9G* M3?CJA/@C0* CDD@3IIA/9*
DUHVXIÀFLHQWWHVWVRI FRPSHWLWLRQHJ0XUUD\
!Nsr=*-CG39C*466sTO*&?3*2CA9*C@D1239:I*C@3=*
ÀUVWWKDWVSDWLDOVHJUHJDWLRQHJORZWHUULWRU\
RUUDQJHRYHUODSFDQUHÁHFWVXEWOHKDELWDWSDUH
:A:A/9A9D=*C9G*I3B/9G*:?C:*CDD@3IIAJ3*@3I8/9I3I*
WRVRFLDOVLJQDOVHJVRQJFDQUHÁHFWUHFHQW
C9B3I:@E*C9G*2AIGA@3B:3G*CDD@3IIA/9*R8?E0/D3H
93:AB*B/9I3@JC:AI2TO*+J39*K?3@3*:?3*A9:39IA:E*
/F * CDD@3IIAJ3* @3I8/9I3I* 83C[I* C:* :3@@A:/@E* /@*
@C9D3* M/19GC@A3I=* 8@3I12CM0E* CI* C* @3I10:* /F *
03C@93G*@3B/D9A:A/9*23B?C9AI2I=*A:*BC9*M3*C@H
JXHG WKDW VWURQJHU LQWHUVSHFLÀF DJJUHVVLRQ LV
23@30E*C*B/@@30C:3=*@C:?3@*:?C9*C*BC1I3=*/F *I8CH
:AC0*8C::3@9IO*&?AI*@CAI3I*:?3*\13I:A/9*/F *K?3:?H
3@*I8C:AC0*8C::3@9I*C9G*B/283:A:AJ3*A9:3@CB:A/9I*
DFWXDOO\UHÁHFWXQGHUO\LQJQLFKHRYHUODS
%9* :?AI* IE28/IA12=* &/MACI* 8@3I39:3G* C*
@C9D3* /F * GC:C* F@/2* C* 210:AHE3C@* I:1GE* /F *
C9:MA@G* B/2219A:A3I* A9* )2CQ/9AC9* ,3@1=*
F/B1IA9D* /9* :?3* \13I:A/9* /F * K?3:?3@* CDD@3IH
IA/9* M3:K339* :?3* ,3@1JAC9* lC@M0A9DH)9:MA@G*
R!"%$26&8/)* %&-(L/.6.T* C9G* :?3* Z300/KHM@3CI:H
3G* lC@M0A9DH)9:MA@G* R+ VXEÁDYDT* AI* GA@3B:0E*
I?C83G* ME* @3I/1@B3* B/283:A:A/9O* ,@3JA/1I*
K/@[*?CI*I?/K9*:?C:*:?3I3*:K/*F/@2I*B/H/BB1@*
ZLWKVWURQJLQWHUVSHFLÀFUHVSRQVHVWRWHUULWRH
@AC0* I/9DI* R&/MACI* z* 73GG/9* 466N=* &/MACI* &4*
.#E*46!!TO*&?3*03J30*/F *CDD@3IIA/9*8@3GAB:I*:?C:*
:3@@A:/@E*/J3@0C8*I?/10G*M3*0/K=*C9G*:?AI*AI*B/9H
ÀUPHGE\PDSSLQJRI !*36SRLQWORFDOH
A:A3I*B/003B:3G*/J3@*n*E3C@IO*73J3@C0*:3B?9A\13I*
K3@3* CG/8:3G* :/* CII3II* 9AB?3* /J3@0C8O* 7:CM03*
AI/:/83*C9C0EI3I*I1DD3I:3G*:?C:*GA3:C@E*9AB?3I*
/F *:?3*:K/*F/@2I*K3@3*GAJ3@D39:=*C0:?/1D?*A:*
LVOLNHO\WKDWWKLVUHÁHFWVGLIIHUHQWLVRWRSLFVLJH
9C:1@3I*/F *MC2M//*C9G*WHUUDÀUPH*F/@3I:*@C:?3@*
:?C9* GAFF3@39:* A9I3B:* 8@3EO* U/@CDA9D* M3?CJA/@=*
A9B01GA9D*F/@CDA9D*I:@C:C=*I?/K3G*M@/CG*/J3@H
0C8*M3:K339*I83BA3IO*.3D3:C:A/9*I1@J3EI*RB/9H
GXFWHG DW QXPHURXV SRLQWV ZLWKLQ a WHUULH
:/@A3I* 83@* I83BA3IT* I1DD3I:3G* :?C:=* C0:?/1D?*
B/@3*?CMA:C:I*K3@3*GAFF3@39:=*:?3@3*KCI*C*0C@D3*
G3D@33*/F *?CMA:C:*9AB?3*/J3@0C8=*C*@3I10:*B/9H
ÀUPHGE\DQDO\VLVRI UHPRWHO\VHQVHGOLJKWGHH
:3B:A/9*C9G*@C9DA9D*R'AGC@T*GC:C*B/003B:3G*F@/2*
DHULDO RYHUÁLJKWV E\ * $VQHU DQG FROOHDJXHV
R-C@93DA3* )A@M/@93* "MI3@JC:/@ETO* .3D3:C:A/9*
SURÀOHV H[WUDFWHG IURP DOO *36 ORFDOLWLHV UHH
J3C03G* :?C:* C0:?/1D?* 23C9* ?CMA:C:I* K3@3* IADH
QLÀFDQWO\GLIIHUHQWEHWZHHQVSHFLHVWKHUDQJH
!!N
!"#$%&'$()!"#$%&
/F * ?CMA:C:I* 1:A0AQ3G* KCI* M@/CG0E* /J3@0C88A9DO*
LA@3B:* B/283:A:A/9* M3:K339* I83BA3I* KCI* F1@H
:?3@*G32/9I:@C:3G*ME*I3\139:AC0*/BB18C:A/9*/F *
:3@@A:/@A3I A9*:K/*A9I:C9B3I=*/93*I83BA3I*KCI*@3H
80CB3G*ME*:?3*/:?3@*/9*:?3*IC23*:3@@A:/@EO*&?3E*
B/9B01G3G*:?C:*M/:?*I83BA3I*B/283:3*GA@3B:0E*
F/@* C* M@/CG* @C9D3* /F * A9:3@23GAC:3* ?CMA:C:I*
I1B?*CI*I3B/9GC@E*D@/K:?=*@AJ3@A93*J3D3:C:A/9=*
C9G*MC2M//HF/@3I:*3B/:/93IO
)0:?/1D?* B/283:A:A/9* M3:K339* ,3@1JAC9*
C9G* Z300/KHM@3CI:3G* lC@M0A9DH)9:MA@GI* AI* A9H
:39I3=*:?3*I8C:AC0*8C::3@9*/F *:3@@A:/@E*/BB18C9BE*
AI*C*0//I30E*8CB[3G*2/ICABO*&?AI*8C::3@9*/FF3@I*
A9IAD?:I*F/@*I:1GA3I*/F *B/283:A:A/9*A9*D393@C0O*
UA@I:=*A:*I1DD3I:I*:?C:*I:@/9D*B/283:A:A/9*G/3I*
9/:*93B3IIC@A0E*8@3GAB:*CM@18:*8C@C8C:@AB*@C9D3*
M/19GC@A3I=* 8C@:AB10C@0E* K?3@3* ?AD?* ?CMA:C:*
?3:3@/D393A:E* C00/KI* B/283:A:/@I* :/* /BB1@*
M@/CG0E* A9* IE28C:@EO* 73B/9G=* A:* G32/9I:@C:3I*
:?C:* I:@/9D0E* B/283:A9D* I83BA3I* BC9* 3WB01G3*
HDFKRWKHUDWÀQHVFDOHVHJKRPHUDQJH\HW
B/3WAI:*0/BC00EO*]/:?*I83BA3I*K3@3*/F:39*C1GAM03*
F@/2*:?3*IC23*8/A9:*C9G*:?1I*3II39:AC00E*B/3WH
AI:*C:*:?3*IA:3*/@*80/:*IBC03O*&?AI*I/19GI*C*9/:3*
/F *BC1:A/9*@3DC@GA9D*:?3*IBC03HG3839G39B3*/F *
CII128:A/9I*A9*B/2219A:E*3B/0/DEO*%:*AI*/F:39*
8@/8/I3G* :?C:* B/283:A:A/9* ?CI* 0A::03* 3W80C9CH
:/@E*8/K3@*C:*0C@D3@*IBC03I=*C9G*:?C:*:?3*0A[30AH
?//G*/F *B/283:A:AJ3*3WB01IA/9*AI*2CWA2AQ3G*C:*
I2C00*IBC03IO*l/@[*/9*:?3I3*lC@M0A9DH)9:MA@GI*
?CI*I?/K9*:?C:*3J39*K?39*I1@J3E*80/:I*C@3*/F *
2A9A212*IAQ3*RAO3O=*C*IA9D03*8/A9:*A9*I8CB3T*:?3*
8@3I39B3*/F *:K/*81:C:AJ3*B/283:A:/@I*G/3I*9/:*
93B3IIC@A0E*A280E*:?C:*B/283:A:A/9*AI*K3C[O*
,`Z'"(+$+&%-*7%($)'7*"U*
-"_,+&%&%"$;*%$U+#+$-+7*
U#"_*+."'S&%"$)#Z*#+')H
&%"$7`%,7*)$L*&#)%&7*"U*-"H
"--S##%$(*7,+-%+7
,?E0/D393:AB* B/2219A:E* I:@1B:1@3=* 3I83BAC00E*
K?39* B/2MA93G* KA:?* A9F/@2C:A/9* /9* F19BH
:A/9C00E* @303JC9:* :@CA:I=* BC9* 8@/JAG3* I/23* A9H
IAD?:*A9:/*:?3*@30C:AJ3*A28/@:C9B3*/F *MA/:AB*A9H
!46
WHUDFWLRQVHQYLURQPHQWDOÀOWHULQJDQGUDQGRP
B?C9B3*A9*I:@1B:1@A9D*0/BC0*CII32M0CD3I*Rl3MM*
&4* .#E* 4664TO* ]A/:AB* A9:3@CB:A/9I=* I1B?* CI* B/2H
83:A:/@* /@* 3932EH23GAC:3G* 93DC:AJ3* G39IA:E*
G3839G39B3=*I?/10G*@3I10:*A9*B/H/BB1@@A9D*I83H
BA3I* :?C:* ?CJ3* @30C:AJ30E* GAFF3@39:* :@CA:* JC013I=*
K?AB?*I?/10G*03CG*:/*3J390E*I8CB3G*2/@8?/0/H
DA3I*KA:?A9*C*0/BC0*CII32M0CD3*R#AB[03FI*z*&@CH
JAI*!Nb6TO*%F *:@CA:I*A28/@:C9:*A9*MA/:AB*A9:3@CBH
:A/9I* RI1B?* CI* M3C[* 039D:?* A9* ?122A9DMA@GIT*
C@3* B/9I3@J3G=* I1B?* :?C:* B0/I3* @30C:AJ3I* ?CJ3*
IA2A0C@* :@CA:* JC013I=* :?39* CII32M0CD3I* B/2H
8/I3G* /F * @30C:AJ30E* GAI:C9:0E* @30C:3G* I83BA3I*
RAO3O=*I?/KA9D*C*8C::3@9*/F *8?E0/D393:AB*3J39H
93IIT* K/10G* ?CJ3* @30C:AJ30E* GAFF3@39:* :@CA:* JC0H
13Ia* C* 8?39/239/9* :?C:* K/10G* M3* B/9IAI:39:*
ZLWKELRWLFLQWHUDFWLRQVLQÁXHQFLQJDVVHPEODJH
I:@1B:1@3*Rl3MM*&4*.#E*4664TO*%F *F19B:A/9C0*:@CA:I*
C@3* 9/:* B/9I3@J3G=* ?/K3J3@=* :?39* :?3@3* AI* 9/*
3W83B:3G* 2C:B?* M3:K339* 8?E0/D393:AB* C9G*
8?39/:E8AB*I:@1B:1@3O
)2/9D* MA@G* D@/18I=* ?122A9DMA@GI* 8@/H
JAG3*C9*AG3C0*IEI:32*F/@*I:1GA3I*/F *B/2219A:E*
3B/0/DE* C9G* MA/:AB* A9:3@CB:A/9I* M3BC1I3=* F/@*
E3C@I=*/@9A:?/0/DAI:I*?CJ3*BC@3F100E*G/B1239:H
3G*:?3A@*M3?CJA/@=*2/@8?/0/DE*C9G*8C::3@9I*/F *
B/H/BB1@@39B3=* EA30GA9D* M/:?* C* @AB?* 328A@ABC0*
GC:CI3:*CI*K300*CI*C*I:@/9D*:?3/@3:ABC0*MCIAI*F/@*
?E8/:?3I3I*:3I:A9D*R3ODO=*U3A9IA9D3@*z*-/0K300*
!Nsb=*)0:I?103@*&4*.#E*466k=*(1:AY@@3QHPC2/@C*
&4* .#E* 466k=* _B(1A@3* &4* .#E* 466r=* 7:A03I* 466b=*
&32303I* &4* .#E* 466NTO* SIA9D* A9F/@2C:A/9* /9*
45r* ?122A9DMA@G* CII32M0CD3I* R!4r* I83BA3IT*
CB@/II*:K/*2Cj/@*D@CGA39:I*A9*9/@:?3@9*7/1:?*
)23@ABC;*303JC:A/9*C9G*8@3BA8A:C:A/9=*(@C?C2*
C9G* ,C@@C* 3JC01C:3G* K?3:?3@* :@CA:* I:@1B:1@3*
B/10G* M3* 8@3GAB:3G=* CII12A9D* :?C:* 39JA@/9H
PHQWDOÀOWHULQJRUELRWLFLQWHUDFWLRQVDUHZRUNH
A9D* 8@A2C@A0E* /9* 8?E0/D393:ABC00E* B/9I3@J3G*
F19B:A/9C0*:@CA:IO*&?3E*F/19G*:?C:*:?3*GAI:@AM1H
:A/9* /F * :@CA:* JC013I* KA:?A9* CII32M0CD3I* D39H
3@C00E* GAG* 9/:* B/@@3I8/9G* :/* :?/I3* 8@3GAB:3G*
MCI3G*/9*8?E0/D393:AB*IAD9C0*C9G*8?E0/D393:AB*
I:@1B:1@3O* U/@* I/23* :@CA:I=* ?/K3J3@=* :?3A@* @3H
I10:I*I188/@:3G*C*[3E*8@3GAB:A/9*A9*B/2219A:E*
!"#$%&'&'"()'()&*"$'!+,)-'*.)!"##/('&'%0
3B/0/DE* :?C:* GC:3I* MCB[* :/* LC@KA9a* :?3* 2/@3*
B0/I30E* @30C:3G* I83BA3I* C@3=* :?3* 2/@3* I:@/9D0E*
:?3E*KA00*B/283:3*R(@C?C2*&4*.#E*A9*8@3IITO*U1@H
:?3@2/@3=* ME* B/2MA9A9D* 8C::3@9I* F@/2* M/:?*
8?E0/D393:AB* I:@1B:1@3* C9G* :?3* I8CBA9D* /F *
2/@8?/0/DABC0* :@CA:I=* :?3E* B/10G* M3::3@* 3JC01H
DWHSRWHQWLDOPHFKDQLVPVLQÁXHQFLQJORFDODVH
I32M0E*I:@1B:1@3*RC0I/*I33*7K39I/9*z*+9\1AI:*
0D\ÀHOG/HYLQH
)I*C*BC1:A/9C@E*9/:3=*C0:?/1D?*@3I10:I*F@/2*
8?E0/D393:AB* C9G* :@CA:HMCI3G* C9C0EI3I* BC9* M3*
B/9IAI:39:* KA:?* 8/:39:AC0* 23B?C9AI2I=* I1B?*
CI* B/283:A:A/9=* :?3E* C@3* ME* 9/* 23C9I* 8@//F *
:?C:*I1B?*23B?C9AI2I*C@3*D/J3@9A9D*8C::3@9I*
/F * CII32M0CD3* I:@1B:1@3* R3ODO=* d32M30* 466NTO*
71B?*@3I10:I=*?/K3J3@=*G/*8@/JAG3*:?3*MCIAI*F/@*
D393@C:A9D*93K*?E8/:?3I3I*CM/1:*A9:3@CB:A/9I*
DPRQJVSHFLÀFVSHFLHVDQGLQGLIIHUHQWUHJLRQV
RAO3O=* C0/9D* 39JA@/9239:C0* D@CGA39:Ia* ,C@@C* &4*
.#EWKDWFDQEHVWXGLHGZLWKÀHOGEDVHG
/MI3@JC:A/9C0*/@*3W83@A239:C0*I:1GA3I*I1B?*CI*
:?/I3*?AD?0AD?:3G*30I3K?3@3*A9*:?3*IE28/IA12*
R&/MACI*z*73GG/9*466N=*XC9[/KI[A*&4*.#E*46!6TO
US&S#+*L%#+-&%"$7*U"#*)77+77H
%$(*&`+*#"'+*"U*-"_,+&%&%"$
&?3* B/2803239:C@E* 8@3I39:C:A/9I* /F * :?AI*
IE28/IA12* I?/K* :?C:* B/2MA9A9D* ://0I* C9G*
C88@/CB?3I*F@/2*GAFF3@39:*GAIBA80A93I*BC9*8@/H
JAG3*19A\13*C9G*8@/2AIA9D*CJ3913I*F/@*301BAH
GC:A9D*:?3*3B/0/DABC0*C9G*3J/01:A/9C@E*23B?CH
QLVPV WKDW LQÁXHQFH SDWWHUQV RI FRPPXQLW\
I:@1B:1@3* C9G* GAI:@AM1:A/9I* A9* :@/8ABC0* MA@GIO*
&?3@3* C@3=* ?/K3J3@=* C* 912M3@* /F * /88/@:19AH
:A3I*F/@*F1@:?3@*G3J30/8239:=*C9G*K3*239:A/9*
C*F3K*/F *:?3I3*?3@3O*
_1B?*/F *:?3*K/@[*8@3I39:3G*A9*:?AI*IE2H
8/IA12* ?CI* F/B1I3G* /9* A9:3@CB:A/9I* C2/9D*
B0/I30E* @30C:3G* I83BA3IO* )I* I1DD3I:3G* ME* (@CH
?C2*C9G*,C@@C=*?/K3J3@=*F19B:A/9C0*IA2A0C@A:E*
A9*I83BA3I*2CE*9/:*C0KCEI*?CJ3*C*I:@/9D*8?E0/H
D393:AB*IAD9C0=*I/*:?3*CII128:A/9*:?C:*:?3*2/I:*
0A[30E*B/283:A:/@I*KA:?A9*C*B/2219A:E*C@3*:?3*
FORVHVW UHODWLYHV PD\ QRW DOZD\V EH VDWLVÀHG
U1:1@3*K/@[*2CE*:?3@3F/@3*B/9IAG3@*CI83B:I*/F *
@3I/1@B3* /J3@0C8* CB@/II* GAI:A9B:* CJAC9* D@/18I*
:?C:* 93J3@:?303II* I?C@3* IA2A0C@* @3\1A@3239:IO*
'A[3KAI3=* C9* CII3II239:* /F * :?3* 3W:39:* /F * @3H
I/1@B3* /J3@0C8* KA:?* A9B@3CIA9D* 8?E0/D393:AB*
GAI:C9B3* C2/9D* I83BA3I* K/10G* GA@3B:0E* :3I:*
:?3I3*CII128:A/9IO
)I*B0A2C:3*B?C9D3*C9G*?CMA:C:*G3D@CGC:A/9*
FRQWLQXHWRDIIHFWVSHFLHVUDQJHVDQGUHVKXIÁH
:?3* B/28/IA:A/9* /F * B/2219A:A3I=* 0/9DH:3@2*
GC:CI3:I* :?C:* G/B1239:* GAI:@AM1:A/9C0* I?AF:I*
2CE*M3*3I83BAC00E*1I3F10*w9C:1@C0*3W83@A239:IÅ*
F/@* :3I:A9D* ?E8/:?3I3I* /F * :?3* A28/@:C9B3* /F *
B/283:A:A/9* A9* :?3* 3B/0/DABC0* I/@:A9D* /F * 0/H
BC0* CII32M0CD3I* C9G* @3A9F/@B3239:* /F * @C9D3*
M/19GC@A3I*R&/1B?:/9*z*72A:?*46!!=*U/@3@/H
_3GA9C*&4*.#E*46!!TO*U/@*3WC2803=*A9*BCI3I*/F *
18I0/83* @C9D3* I?AF:I* C0/9D* 303JC:A/9C0* D@CH
GA39:I=* 83@?C8I* K3* K/10G* 3W83B:* @C9D3* B/9H
:@CB:A/9I* /F * 0/KH303JC:A/9* 0A2A:I* :/* M3* 2/@3*
B/22/9*F/@*I83BA3I*:?C:*?CJ3*B/9D393@I*KA:?*
CM1::A9D* @C9D3I* G/K9I0/83* RXC9[/KI[A* &4* .#E*
46!6TO*&3I:I*/F *:?3*A28/@:C9B3*/F *B/283:A:A/9*
CB:A9D*/9*@C9D3*M/19GC@A3I*2CE*C0I/*M3*80CB3G*
A9* :?3* B/9:3W:* /F * 3W83B:3G* @C9D3* M@3CG:?I*
MCI3G* 18/9* A9G3839G39:0E* 23CI1@3G* CI83B:I*
/F * I83BA3I* F19GC239:C0* 9AB?3* RXC9[/KI[A* &4*
.#E*A9*@3JA3KT=*I1B?*:?C:*I83BA3I*K?/I3*@C9D3I*
CM1:*:?/I3*/F *B/9D393@I*I?/10G*3W?AMA:*2/@3*
B/28@3II3G*303JC:A/9C0*@C9D3I*:?C9*8@3GAB:3G*
ME* :?3A@* 8?EIA/0/DABC0* :/03@C9B3I* R(AFF/@G* z*
d/QC[*46!!TO
UA9C00E=* C9E* I:1GE* F/B1I3G* /9* :?3* @/03* /F *
B/283:A:A/9* A9* I:@1B:1@A9D* B/2219A:A3I* KA00*
EHQHÀWIURPLQFUHDVHGNQRZOHGJHRI WKHORFDO
C9G*@3DA/9C0*GAI:@AM1:A/9I=*9C:1@C0*?AI:/@E=*C9G*
VSHFLÀFUHTXLUHPHQWVRI VSHFLHVE\HQDEOLQJXV
:/*:3I:*8C::3@9I*/F *@3I/1@B3*/J3@0C8*C9G*9AB?3*
1I3*A9*81:C:AJ3*B/283:A:/@IO*+J39*F/@*:?3*M3I:*
[9/K9* :CW/9/2AB* D@/18I=* I1B?* CI* MA@GI=* :?3*
0CB[*/F *GC:C*/9*3B/0/DE=*M3?CJA/@*C9G*GAI:@AM1H
:A/9I*/F *I83BA3I*B/9:A913I*:/*M3*C*2Cj/@*?1@G03*
:/*CB?A3JA9D*C*B/9I39I1I*/9*:?3*KCE*:?C:*B/2H
83:A:A/9=* CI* K300* CI* /:?3@* MA/:AB* A9:3@CB:A/9I=*
I:@1B:1@3*:@/8ABC0*B/2219A:A3IO**
!4!
!"#$%&'$()!"#$%&
)-d$"l'+L(_+$&7
:HWKDQNWKH12&6FLHQWLÀF3URJUDP&RPH
2A::33* F/@* :?3A@* 3FF/@:I* A9* /@DC9AQA9D* :?3*
$"-* C9G* IE28/IAC* B/9:@AM1:A/9IO* &?3* K/@[*
8@3I39:3G* ?3@3* KCI* I188/@:3G* ME* C* @C9D3* /F *
F19GA9D*M/GA3I=*A9B01GA9D*:?3*)I/BACBAh9*8C@C*
0C*-/9I3@JCBAh9*G3*0C*-139BC*)2CQ/9ABC=*$CH
:A/9C0*)3@/9C1:ABI*C9G*78CB3*)G2A9AI:@C:A/9=*
$C:A/9C0*7BA39B3*U/19GC:A/9=*dC:?C@A93*"@GH
KCE*U19G*C:*:?3*U0/@AGC*_1I312*/F *$C:1@C0*
`AI:/@E=*C9G*:?3*#/EC0*7/BA3:EO*
#+U+#+$-+7
)0:I?103@=*LO*'O=*UO*(O*7:A03I=*z*#O*L1G03EO*466kO*"F *
?122A9DMA@GI*C9G*?30AB/8:3@I;*`/J3@A9D*B/I:I=*
B/283:A:AJ3*CMA0A:E=*C9G*F/@CDA9D*I:@C:3DA3IO*)2O*
$C:O*!r5;*!r−4nO
]/09AB[=*LO*%O=*&O*%9D@C2=*lO*+O*7:1:Q=*'O*dO*79/KM3@D=*
"O* 'O* 'C1=* z* XO* 7O* ,C100O* 46!6O* +B/0/DABC0*
UHOHDVHIURPLQWHUVSHFLÀFFRPSHWLWLRQOHDGVWR
G3B/1803G*B?C9D3I*A9*8/810C:A/9*C9G*A9GAJAG1C0*
9AB?3*KAG:?O*,O*#/EO*7/BO*]H]A/0O*7BAO*4ss;*!sbN−
!sNsO
&DGHQD&'7HVWLQJWKHUROHRI LQWHUVSHFLÀF
B/283:A:A/9* A9* :?3* 3J/01:A/9C@E* /@ADA9* /F *
303JC:A/9C0* Q/9C:A/9;* )9* 3WC2803* KA:?*
P(.--&8$6* ]@1I?HUA9B?3I* R)J3I=* +2M3@AQAGC3T*
A9* :?3* $3/:@/8ABC0* 2/19:CA9IO* +J/01:A/9* r!;*
!!46−!!5rO
-?AI?/02=* #O* )O=* z* 7O* lO* ,CBC0CO* 46!6O* $AB?3*
C9G* 931:@C0* 2/G30I* 8@3GAB:* CIE28:/:ABC00E*
3\1AJC039:* I83BA3I* CM19GC9B3* GAI:@AM1:A/9I* A9*
?AD?HGAJ3@IA:E* 3B/0/DABC0* B/2219A:A3IO* ,O* $C:0O*
)BCGO*7BAO*S7)*!6s;*!nb4!<!nb4nO*
-/GE=*_O*'O*!NskO*-/283:A:A/9*C9G*:?3*I:@1B:1@3*/F *
MA@G* B/2219A:A3IO* ,@A9B3:/9* S9AJ3@IA:E* ,@3II=*
,@A9B3:/9=*$3K*X3@I3E=*S7)O
LC@KA9=* -O* !bnNO* "9* :?3* "@ADA9* /F * 783BA3I* ME*
_3C9I*/F *$C:1@C0*7303B:A/9=*/@*:?3*,@3I3@JC:A/9*
/F * UCJ/1@3G* #CB3I* A9* :?3* 7:@1DD03* F/@* 'AF3O* XO*
_1@@CE=*'/9G/9=*SOdO
LAC2/9G=* XO* !Ns5O* LAI:@AM1:A/9C0* 3B/0/DE* /F * $3K*
(1A93C*MA@GIO*7BA39B3*!sN;*snN−srNO
!44
U3A9IA9D3@=*,O*!NsbO*+B/0/DABC0*A9:3@CB:A/9I*M3:K339*
80C9:I* C9G* ?122A9DMA@GI* A9* C* I1BB3IIA/9C0*
:@/8ABC0* B/2219A:EO* +B/0O* _/9/D@O* kb;* 4rN−
4bsO
U3A9IA9D3@=* ,O=* z* #O* dO* -/0K300O* !NsbO* -/2219A:E*
/@DC9AQC:A/9*C2/9D*93/:@/8ABC0*93B:C@HF33GA9D*
MA@GIO*)2O*P//0O*!b;*ssN−sNnO
U/@3@/H_3GA9C=*(O=*XO*&3@M/@D?=*7O*XO*7/B/0C@=*z*7O*
'O* ,A22O* 46!!O* +03JC:A/9C0* @C9D3I* /F * MA@GI*
/9* C* :@/8ABC0* 2/9:C93* D@CGA39:* 0CD* M3?A9G*
KC@2A9D* :3283@C:1@3IO* ,'/7* "93* r;* 34bn5nO*
G/A;!6O!5s!Vj/1@9C0O8/93O664bn5n
UA:Q8C:@AB[=* XO* lO* !NbnO* U/@2=* F/@CDA9D* M3?CJA/@=*
C9G*CGC8:AJ3*@CGAC:A/9*A9*:?3*&E@C99AGC3O*,CD3I*
kks<ks6*A9*$3/:@/8ABC0*"@9A:?/0/DEO*"@9A:?/0O*
_/9/D@O*5r*R,O*)O*]1B[03E=*_O*7O*U/I:3@=*+O*7O*
_/@:/9=*#O*7O*#AGD30E=*C9G*UO*(O*]1B[03E=*3GITO*
)23@ABC9* "@9A:?/0/DAI:It* S9A/9=* lCI?A9D:/9=*
L-=*S7)O
(AFF/@G=* _O* +O=* z* d/QC[=* dO* `O* 46!!O* %I0C9GI* A9*
:?3* I[E* /@* I\133Q3G* C:* :?3* :/8Ñ* +B/0/DABC0*
BC1I3I* /F * 303JC:A/9C0* @C9D3* 0A2A:I* A9* 2/9:C93*
IC0C2C9G3@IO*+B/D@C8?E*5k;*!−!!O
(@C?C2=* -O* `O=* XO* 'O* ,C@@C=* ]O* )O* &A9/B/=* UO* (O*
7:A03I=* z* XO* )O* _B(1A@3O* %9* 8@3IIO* S9:C9D0A9D*
WKH LQÁXHQFH RI HFRORJLFDO DQG HYROXWLRQDU\
FCB:/@I* /9* :@CA:* JC@AC:A/9* CB@/II* ?122A9DMA@G*
CII32M0CD3IO*+B/0/DEO
(@CJ3I=*(O*#O=*z*$O*XO*(/:300AO*!NN5O*)II32M0E*/F *
DYLDQPL[HGVSHFLHVÁRFNVLQ$PD]RQLD3URF
$C:O*)BCGO*7BAO*S7)*N6;*!5bb−!5N!O
(1:AY@@3QHPC2/@C=* )O=* 7O* .O* #/jCIH$/IIC=* z* UO* (O*
7:A03IO*466kO*)991C0*GE9C2ABI*/F *?122A9DMA@GH
ÁRZHULQWHUDFWLRQVLQKLJK$QGHDQHFRV\VWHPV
"@9A:/0/D^C*$3/:@/8ABC0*!n;*46n−4!5O
+XEEHOO 63 7KH 8QLÀHG 1HXWUDO 7KHRU\
/F * ]A/GAJ3@IA:E* C9G* ]A/D3/D@C8?EO* ,@A9B3:/9*
S9AJ3@IA:E*,@3II=*,@A9B3:/9=*$3K*X3@I3E=*S7)O
XC9[/KI[A=*XO*+O=*7O*dO*#/MA9I/9=*z*LO*XO*'3J3EO*46!6O*
6TXHH]HG DW WKH WRS ,QWHUVSHFLÀF DJJUHVVLRQ
2CE* B/9I:@CA9* 303JC:A/9C0* @C9D3I* A9* :@/8ABC0*
MA@GIO*+B/0/DE*N!;*!bss−!bbkO
XC9[/KI[A=* XO* +O=* (O* )O* '/9G/p/=* 7O* dO* #/MA9I/9=*
z* _O* )O* -?C88300O* %9* @3JA3KO* +W80/@A9D* :?3*
@/03* /F * 8?EIA/0/DE* C9G* MA/:AB* A9:3@CB:A/9I* A9*
!"#$%&'&'"()'()&*"$'!+,)-'*.)!"##/('&'%0
G3:3@2A9A9D* 303JC:A/9C0* @C9D3I* /F * :@/8ABC0*
C9A2C0IO*+B/D@C8?EO
X/93I=* 7O* +O* !NsbO* -/3WAI:39B3* A9* 2AW3GHI83BA3I*
DQWZUHQÁRFNV2LNRV−5snO
d32M30=*7O*lO*466NO*LAI39:C9D0A9D*9AB?3*C9G*931:@C0*
LQÁXHQFHV RQ FRPPXQLW\ DVVHPEO\ DVVHVVLQJ
:?3* 83@F/@2C9B3* /F * B/2219A:E* 8?E0/D393:AB*
I:@1B:1@3*:3I:IO*+B/0O*'3::O*!4;*NkN−Nr6O
_CB)@:?1@=* #O* `O* !NrkO* +9JA@/9239:C0* FCB:/@I*
CFF3B:A9D* MA@G* I83BA3I* GAJ3@IA:EO* )2O* $C:O* Nb;*
5bs−5NsO
_C@:A9=* ,O* #O=* z* &O* +O* _C@:A9O* 466!O* ]3?CJA/@C0*
A9:3@CB:A/9I* M3:K339* B/3WAI:A9D* I83BA3I;* 7/9D*
80CEMCB[* 3W83@A239:I* KA:?* K//G* KC@M03@IO*
+B/0/DE*b4;*46s−4!bO
0D\ÀHOG 0 0 - 0 /HYLQH 2SSRVLQJ
3FF3B:I* /F * B/283:A:AJ3* 3WB01IA/9* /9* :?3*
8?E0/D393:AB* I:@1B:1@3* /F * B/2219A:A3IO* +B/0O*
'3::O*!5;*!6bn−!6N5O
_B(1A@3=*XO*)O=*-O*-O*lA::=*LO*'O*)0:I?103@=*z*XO*.O*
#32I39O* 466sO* ,?E0/D393:AB* IEI:32C:ABI* C9G*
MA/D3/D@C8?E* /F * ?122A9DMA@GI;* ]CE3IAC9* C9G*
2CWA212* 0A[30A?//G* C9C0EI3I* /F * 8C@:A:A/93G*
GC:C*C9G*I303B:A/9*/F *C9*C88@/8@AC:3*8C@:A:A/9A9D*
I:@C:3DEO*7EI:O*]A/0O*nr;*b5s−bnrO
_199=* -O* )O* !NbnO* ,3@2C939:* BC9/8E* C9G*
XQGHUVWRU\ ÁRFNV LQ $PD]RQLD VSHFLHV
B/28/IA:A/9*C9G*8/810C:A/9*G39IA:EO*"@9A:?/0O*
_/9/D@O*5r;*r5b−s!4O
0XUUD\ -U % * $ FULWLTXH RI LQWHUVSHFLÀF
:3@@A:/@AC0A:E*C9G*B?C@CB:3@*B/9J3@D39B3O*-/9G/@*
sb;*n!b−n4nO
$C/[A=* dO* 466sO* )@:?@/8/G* @3I/1@B3* 8C@:A:A/9A9D*
C2/9D* /29AJ/@/1I* :C9CD3@* R>.69.-.* I88OT* A9*
l3I:3@9*+B1CG/@O*)1[*!4k;*!Ns−46NO
,C@@C=*XO*'O=*XO*)O*_B(1A@3=*z*-O*`O*(@C?C2O*46!6O*
%9B/@8/@C:A9D* -0CG3* %G39:A:E* A9* )9C0EI3I*
/F * ,?E0/D393:AB* -/2219A:E* 7:@1B:1@3;* )9*
+WC2803* KA:?* `122A9DMA@GIO* )2O* $C:O* !sr;*
ns5<nbsO
,3C@I/9=* LO* 'O* !NssO* +B/0/DABC0* @30C:A/9I?A8I* /F *
I2C00*C9:MA@GI*A9*)2CQ/9AC9*MA@G*B/2219A:A3IO*
)1[*Nk;*4b5−4N4O
3LHUSRQW 1 ,QWHUVSHFLÀF DJJUHVVLRQ
C9G* :?3* 3B/0/DE* /F * K//GB@3383@I* R)J3I;*
L39G@/B/0C8:AGC3TO* ,?OLO* GAIIO=* ,@A9B3:/9*
S9AJ3@IA:E=*,@A9B3:/9=*$3K*X3@I3E=*S7)O
,A22=* 7O=* _O* #/I39QK3AD=* z* lO* _A:B?300O* !NbnO*
&RPSHWLWLRQDQGIRRGVHOHFWLRQÀHOGWHVWVRI D
:?3/@EO*+B/0/DE*rr;*sNb<b6sO
#AB[03FI=*#O*+O=*z*XO*&@CJAIO*!Nb6O*)*2/@8?/0/DABC0*
C88@/CB?* :/* :?3* I:1GE* /F * CJAC9* B/2219A:E*
/@DC9AQC:A/9O*)1[*Ns;*54!−55bO
5RELQVRQ6.-7HUERUJK,QWHUVSHFLÀF
CDD@3IIA/9*C9G*?CMA:C:*I303B:A/9*ME*)2CQ/9AC9*
MA@GIO*XO*)9A2O*+B/0O*rk;*!−!!O
#/MA9I/9=*lO*466!O*-?C9D3I*A9*CM19GC9B3*/F *MA@GI*
A9*C*$3/:@/8ABC0*F/@3I:*F@CD239:*/J3@*4n*E3C@I;*
C*@3JA3KO*)9A2O*]A/GAJ3@IO*-/9I3@JO*4k;*n!−rnO
#/MA9I/9=*lO=*XO*]@CK9=*z*7O*#/MA9I/9O*4666O*U/@3I:*
MA@G* B/2219A:E* I:@1B:1@3* A9* B39:@C0* ,C9C2C;*
,QÁXHQFH RI VSDWLDO VFDOH DQG ELRJHRJUDSK\
+B/0O*_/9/D@O*s6;*46N−45nO
#/IA9G300=* XO=* 7O* ,O* `1MM300=* z* #O* 7O* +:A3993O* 46!!O*
7KH 8QLÀHG 1HXWUDO 7KHRU\ RI %LRGLYHUVLW\
C9G* ]A/D3/D@C8?E* C:* )D3* &39O* &@39GI* +B/0O*
+J/0O*4r;*5k6<5kbO
7?3@@E=*&O*lO*!NbkO*-/28C@C:AJ3*GA3:C@E*3B/0/DE*/F *
V\PSDWULFLQVHFWLYRURXVQHRWURSLFDOÁ\FDWFKHUV
R&E@C99AGC3TO*+B/0O*_/9/D@O*nk;*5!5−55bO
79/K=* ]O* dO=* z* LO* lO* 79/KO* !Ns!O* &?3* F33GA9D*
3B/0/DE* /F * :C9CD3@I* C9G* ?/93EB@3383@I* A9*
&@A9AGCGO*)1[*bb;*4N!−544O
7:A03I=* UO* (O* 466bO* +B/2/@8?/0/DE* C9G* 8?E0/D39E*
/F *?122A9DMA@GI;*GAJ3@D39B3*C9G*B/9J3@D39B3*
A9* CGC8:C:A/9I* :/* ?AD?* 303JC:A/9IO* "@9A:/0/DAC*
$3/:@/8ABC0*!N;*n!!−n!NO
7:E@I[E=* XO* 4665O* 'AF3H?AI:/@E* 3J/01:A/9* C9G*
8/810C:A/9* GE9C2ABI* /F * C* $3/:@/8ABC0*
F/@3I:* MA@G* R!"#$%3"#.D* 6.&L/$/0&)TE* ,?OLO* GAIIO=*
S9AJ3@IA:E*/F *%00A9/AI=*S@MC9C=*%00A9/AI=*S7)O*
7K39I/9=* $O* (O=* z* ]O* XO* +9\1AI:O* 466NO* "88/IA9D*
CII32M0E* 23B?C9AI2I* A9* C* $3/:@/8ABC0* G@E*
F/@3I:;* A280ABC:A/9I* F/@* 8?E0/D393:AB* C9G*
F19B:A/9C0* B/2219A:E* 3B/0/DEO* +B/0/DE* N6;*
4!r!<4!s6O
&32303I=*+O*XO=*-O*#O*d/10/1@AI=*7O*+O*7C9G3@=*z*lO*
-.UHVV(IIHFWRI ÁRZHUVKDSHDQGVL]H
/9* F/@CDA9D* 83@F/@2C9B3* C9G* :@CG3H/FFI* A9* C*
:@/8ABC0*?122A9DMA@GO*+B/0/DE*N6;*!!ks<!!r!O
!45
!"#$%&'$()!"#$%&
&3@M/@D?=* XO* !Ns!O* LAI:@AM1:A/9* /9* 39JA@/9239:C0*
D@CGA39:I;* :?3/@E* C9G* C* 8@30A2A9C@E*
A9:3@8@3:C:A/9* /F * GAI:@AM1:A/9C0* 8C::3@9I* A9* :?3*
CJAFC19C* /F * :?3* -/@GA003@C* .A0BCMC2MC=* ,3@1O*
+B/0/DE*n4;*45−k6O
&3@M/@D?=*XO*!NbnO*`CMA:C:*I303B:A/9*A9*)2CQ/9AC9*MA@GIO*
B6* -/GE=* _O* 'O* R3GOTO* `CMA:C:* I303B:A/9* A9* MA@GIO*
)BCG32AB*,@3II=*$3K*Z/@[=*$3K*Z/@[=*S7)O
&3@M/@D?=* XO=* z* XO* 7O* l3I[3O* !NsnO* &?3* @/03* /F *
B/283:A:A/9* A9* :?3* GAI:@AM1:A/9* /F * )9G3C9*
MA@GIO*+B/0/DE*nr;*nr4<nsrO
&3@M/@D?=* XO=* 'O* '/83Q=* ,O* $193Q=* _O* #C/=* (O*
7?C?CM1GGA9=* (O* "@A?130C=* _O* #AJ3@/I=* #O*
)IBC9A/=* (O* )G03@=* &O* 'C2M3@:=* z* 'O* ]C0MCIO*
466!O* +B/0/DABC0* 230:G/K9* A9* 8@3GC:/@HF@33*
F/@3I:*F@CD239:IO*7BA39B3*4Nk;*!N45<!N4rO
&/MACI=*XO*)O=*z*$O*73GG/9O*466NO*7AD9C0*G3IAD9*C9G*
83@B38:A/9* A9* !"%$26&8/)* C9:MA@GI;* 3JAG39B3*
F/@* B/9J3@D39:* 3J/01:A/9* JAC* I/BAC0* I303B:A/9O*
+J/01:A/9*r5;*5!rN<5!bNO*
&/MACI=* XO* )O=* .O* (C2C@@CH&/03G/=* LO* (C@BACH
"0C3B?3C=* ,O* -O* ,10DC@A9=* z* $O* 73GG/9O* 46!!O*
Z3C@H@/19G*@3I/1@B3*G3F39B3*C9G*:?3*3J/01:A/9*
/F * 2C03* C9G* F32C03* I/9D* A9* I1M/IBA93* MA@GI;*
I/BAC0* C@2C239:I* C@3* 21:1C0* /@9C239:IO* XO*
+J/0O*]A/0O*4k;*4!!b<4!5bO
&/1B?:/9=*XO*_O=*z*XO*$O*_O*72A:?O*46!!O*783BA3I*0/II=*
G30CE3G* 9123@ABC0* @3I8/9I3I=* C9G* F19B:A/9C0*
!4k
B/2839IC:A/9*A9*C9*C9:MA@G*D1A0GO*+B/0/DE*N4;*
!!4r<!!5rO
l3MM=* -O* "O=* LO* LO* )B[3@0E=* _O* )O* _B,33[=* z* _O*
XO*L/9/?13O*4664O*,?E0/D39A3I*C9G*B/2219A:E*
3B/0/DEO*)991O*#3JO*+B/0O*7EI:O*55;*ksn<n6nO
lA39I=* XO* XO* 46!!O* &?3* 9AB?3=* MA/D3/D@C8?E* C9G*
I83BA3I*A9:3@CB:A/9IO*,?A0O*&@C9IO*#O*7/BO*]*5rr;*
455r<45n6O
l3A?3@=* +O=* LO* U@319G=* &O* ]19:/9=* )O* 7:3FC9I[A=*
&O* '33=* z* 7O* ]39:AJ39DCO* 46!!* )GJC9B3I=*
B?C0039D3I* C9G* C* G3J30/8A9D* IE9:?3IAI* /F *
3B/0/DABC0* B/2219A:E* CII32M0E* :?3/@EO* ,?A0O*
&@C9IO*#O*7/BO*]*5rr;*4k65<4k!5O
lA00AI=* +O* "O* !NrsO* &?3* M3?CJA/@* /F * ]AB/0/@3G*
)9:MA@GIO* S9AJO* -C0AF/@9AC* ,1M0O* P//0O* sN;*
!<!54O
lA00AI=* +O* "O* !Ns4O* &?3* M3?CJA/@* /F * 78/::3G*
)9:MA@GIO*"@9A:?/0O*_/9/D@O*!6;*!<!nNO*
lA00AI=* +O* "O* !Ns5O* &?3* M3?CJA/@* /F * /B300C:3G*
C9:MA@GIO*72A:?I/9AC9*-/9:@AMO*P//0O*!kk;*!<nsO
lA00AI=*+O*"O*!NskO*,/810C:A/9I*C9G*0/BC0*3W:A9B:A/9I*
/F * MA@GI* /9* ]C@@/* -/0/@CG/* %I0C9G=* ,C9C2CO*
+B/0O*_/9/D@O*kk;*!n5<!rNO
lA00AI=*+O*"O=*z*+O*+AI392C99O*!NsNO*)*@3JAI3G*0AI:*
/F * MA@GI* /F * ]C@@/* -/0/@CG/* %I0C9G=* ,C9C2CO*
72A:?I/9AC9*-/9:@AMO*P//0O*4N!;*!<5!O
lA00AI=*+O*"O=*z*ZO*"9A[AO*!NsbO*]A@GI*C9G*C@2E*C9:IO*
)991O*#3JO*+B/0O*7EI:O*N;*4k5<4r5O