The promise of
ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\
oge]fÌk]ehgo]je]fl
What does the evidence say?
February 2014
Contents
L`]hjgeak]g^ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\
oge]fÌk]ehgo]je]fl
)
What does the evidence say?
01
02
03
04
05
06
07
L`]\]n]dghe]flg^ea[jgÕfYf[]
*
L`][`Yf_af_j]hmlYlagfg^
ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\l`]f]]\^gj
j]daYZd]]na\]f[]
.
L`]aehgjlYf[]g^ja_gjgmk]nYdmYlagfk
1
Ea[jg[j]\al
))
Ea[jgkYnaf_k
),
Ea[jgafkmjYf[]
)/
;gf[dmkagfYf\gmldggc
)1
9Zgmll`]9ml`gjk
*(
=Q
*(
Gl`]j=QhmZda[Ylagfk
*)
=Q;gflY[lk
**
The promise of
ea[jgÕfYf[]
Yf\oge]fÌk
]ehgo]je]fl
O`Yl\g]kl`]]na\]f[]kYq7
February 2014
L`]ea[jgÕfYf[]j]ngdmlagf`YkljYfk^gje]\Y[[]kklgÕfYf[aYd
k]jna[]k^gjdgo%af[ge]hghmdYlagfkogjd\oa\]&9kYj]kmdl$al
`YkZ][ge]gf]g^l`]egkllYdc]\%YZgmlaffgnYlagfkaf_dgZYd
\]n]dghe]flafj][]fl\][Y\]k&@go]n]j$alk]phYfkagf`YkfglZ]]f
oal`gml[gfljgn]jkq&O`ad]eYfq`Yad]\alYkYoYqlg]f\ogjd\
hgn]jlqYf\hjgegl]^]eYd]]ehgo]je]fl$gl`]jk[gf\]ef]\alYk
Y\akYkl]j^gjl`]hggj&>]eYd]]ehgo]je]fl`Ykg^l]fZ]]fk]]f
Ykgf]g^l`]c]qhjgeak]kg^l`]af\mkljq&AfhYjl$l`akakZYk]\gf
l`]^Y[ll`Ylegj]l`Yf0(g^alkhggj]kl[da]flk$a&]&$l`gk]o`gdan]
gfd]kkl`YfMK)&*-'\Yq$Yj]oge]f&1L`akhYh]j\ak[mkk]ko`Yl
o]`Yn]d]Yjf]\kg^YjYZgmll`]hgl]flaYdYf\daealkg^ea[jgÕfYf[]
Yf\`goafka_`lk^jgej]k]Yj[`Yf\hjY[la[][Yf`]dhj]^gjel`]
af\mkljqÌk[mjj]flhjg\m[lk$hgda[a]kYf\^mlmj]\]n]dghe]flk&
)&BYfH&EY]kYf\DYjjqJ&J]]\$ÉKlYl]g^l`]Ea[jg[j]\alKmeeal;YehYa_fJ]hgjl*()*$ÊMicrocredit Summit Campaign,OYk`af_lgf<;$*()*&
(ooo&ea[jg[j]\alkmeeal&gj_'!
L`]hjgeak]g^ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\oge]fÌk]ehgo]je]fl
)
01
The development of
ea[jgÔfYf[]
L`]ea[jgÕfYf[]af\mkljqhjgna\]kÕfYf[aYdk]jna[]k^gjea[jg%]flj]hj]f]mjk$keYdd%Zmkaf]kkgof]jkYf\gl`]j
af\ana\mYdko`ggl`]joak]dY[cY[[]kklg^gjeYdZYfcaf_Yf\j]dYl]\k]jna[]k&=n]flg\Yq$YdYj_]k`Yj]g^Y\mdlk
ogjd\oa\]\gfgl`Yn]km[`Y[[]kk k]]Õ_mj]afl`]f]plhY_]!&:Yjja]jk^gjoge]fYj]hYjla[mdYjdqdYj_]&
O`ad],.g^e]fYjgmf\l`]ogjd\j]hgjl`Ynaf_Y[[]kklg^gjeYdÕfYf[aYdk]jna[]k$l`]Õ_mj]akgfdq+/^gj
oge]f&9\\alagfYddq$oge]faf\a[Yl]\ka_faÕ[Yfldqegj]g^l]fl`Yfe]fl`Yll`]qo]j]mkaf_kge]gf]]dk]Ìk
Y[[gmfl&2L`akdY[cg^Y[[gmflgof]jk`ahakl`gm_`llgaf`aZaloge]fÌkYZadalqlghYjla[ahYl]afk]d^%]ehdgqe]fl
ghhgjlmfala]k&Oal`gmlY[[]kklg^gjeYdÕfYf[aYdk]jna[]k$oge]f`Yn]lgj]dqgfaf^gjeYde]YfklgY[[memdYl]
kYnaf_k$_jgoYZmkaf]kk$keggl`]f[gfkmehlagfaf[Yk]g^af[ge]Öm[lmYlagfkgjafkmj]Y_Yafkl]e]j_]f[a]k&
L`]k]e]l`g\k[YfZ][gkldq$jakcqYf\mfhj]\a[lYZd]$Yf\g^^]j^]o]jghlagfklgl`gk]o`gYj]j]klja[l]\lg
l`]ajmk]&
*&9kda<]eaj_m[%CmflYf\D]gjYCdYhh]j$ÉE]Ykmjaf_>afYf[aYdAf[dmkagf2L`]?dgZYd>af\]p<YlYZYk]$ÊDevelopment Research Group,L`]Ogjd\:Yfc$*()*&
*
L`]hjgeak]g^ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\oge]fÌk]ehgo]je]fl
K`Yj]g^Y\mdlkoal`Y^gjeYdÕfYf[aYdY[[gmfl3
Adults with an account at a formal
ÕfYf[aYdafklalmlagf !
0–15
16–30
31–50
51–80
81+
No data
L`j]]k]jna[]k2[j]\al$kYnaf_k
Yf\afkmjYf[]
Ea[jgÕfYf[][YfZ]\ana\]\aflgl`j]]ZjgY\[Yl]_gja]k2
ea[jg[j]\al$ea[jgkYnaf_kYf\ea[jgafkmjYf[]&L`]ajhgl]flaYd
Yf\daealk^gjaf[j]Ykaf_][gfgea[o]dd%Z]af_Yf\^]eYd]
]ehgo]je]flYj]\ak[mkk]\afegj]\]lYadafK][lagfk,Ç.Z]dgo&
L`]^gddgoaf_hjgna\]kYima[ckmeeYjq^gj]Y[`&
 L`]hjgeak]g^microcreditaklghjgna\]keYdddgYfklgea[jg%
]flj]hj]f]mjklgafn]klafl`]ajZmkaf]kk]k$j]afn]kll`]j]lmjfk
Yf\Yddgol`]elg_jgogmlg^hgn]jlq&L`]`gh]akl`Yll`ak
oaddhjgna\]Zgl`ÕfYf[aYdj]kgmj[]kYf\h]jkgfYdY_]f[qlg
^]eYd]ea[jg%]flj]hj]f]mjk&K]n]jYdj][]flklm\a]kaf\a[Yl]
l`Ylo`ad]ea[jg[j]\al[YfZ]Ymk]^mdÕfYf[aYdlggd^gjkge]
]flj]hj]f]mjk$al`Ykfgllqha[Yddq_]f]jYl]\\jYeYla[af[j]Yk]
afaf[ge]&Kge]g^l`]c]q[`Ydd]f_]k^gjea[jg[j]\all`]j]^gj]
af[dm\]l`]im]klagfkg^`goY[[]kklgea[jg[j]\al[YfZ]ll]j
[gfljaZml]lghgn]jlqj]\m[lagfYf\o`Yl[j]\alhjg\m[l
\]ka_f[`ga[]kYf\k[j]]faf_e][`Yfakek[gmd\af[j]Yk]l`]aj
]^^][lan]f]kk$Yko]ddYkl`]ajÕfYf[aYdnaYZadalq&
+&AZa\&$)*
L`]hjgeak]g^ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\oge]fÌk]ehgo]je]fl
3
 Microsavingshjg\m[lkYaelghjgna\]Y[[]kkaZd]Yf\kY^]
Yn]fm]klgkYn]$]al`]j^gj^mlmj]afn]kle]flkgjYkY
hj][YmlagfY_Yafkl][gfgea[k`g[ck&Ea[jgkYnaf_khjg\m[lk[Yf
af[dm\]kaehd]fg%^jaddkZYfcY[[gmflkYko]ddYk[geeale]fl%
ZYk]\hjg\m[lkl`Yl]f[gmjY_]\]hgkalkgjdaealoal`\jYoYdaf
gj\]jlg`]dhkYn]jkj]Y[`l`]ajkYnaf_k_gYdk&J][]flj]k]Yj[`
k`gokhjgeakaf_]^^][lkg^Y[[]kklgkYnaf_khjg\m[lkZgl`gf
l`]YZadalqlgkeggl`]f[gfkmehlagfZqk]d^%hjgl][laf_Y_Yafkl
][gfgea[k`g[ckYf\lgafn]klegj]afl`]ajea[jg]fl]jhjak]k&
9Za_[`Ydd]f_]aklgeYc]km[`hjg\m[lk[gkl%]^^][lan]^gj
ea[jgÕfYf[]afklalmlagfk E>Ak!$Yf\lgmf\]jklYf\o`]l`]j$
_an]fl`]hjgeakaf_]na\]f[]$l`]j]akY[Yk]^gj_gn]jfe]fl
kmZka\a]k&
 Microinsurancehjg\m[lkYj]\]ka_f]\lgeala_Yl]\a^^]j]fl
lqh]kg^jakck$km[`YkY_ja[mdlmjYdgj`]Ydl`jakck&Af]e]j_af_
eYjc]lk$l`]hjgnakagfg^km[`afkmjYf[]ak^Y[]\oal`log
[`Ydd]f_]kg^Ykqee]lja[af^gjeYlagf&>ajkl$Ykaf]klYZdak`]\
eYjc]lk$l`][`Ydd]f_]^gjYfqafkmjYf[]hjgna\]jaklgegfalgj
l`Yl[dYaekYj]bmklaÕ]\$Yf\lgYnga\k]d][lagfg^hYjla[mdYjdq
jakcq[mklge]jkaflgl`]aj[mklge]jZYk]&K][gf\$aff]o
eYjc]lk$l`]j]akYfY\\alagfYd[`Ydd]f_]lg]klYZdak`ljmkl
Yegf_hgl]flaYd[mklge]jkl`Yll`]ajafkmjYf[]oaddaf\]]\hYq
gmlafl`]]n]flg^Y^mlmj]f]_Ylan]k`g[c&;mjj]flj]k]Yj[`
Yf\affgnYlan]ea[jgafkmjYf[]eg\]dk]phdgj]`golggn]j[ge]
l`]k][`Ydd]f_]k&
L`]]ngdmlagfg^ea[jgÕfYf[]
Ea[jgÕfYf[]klYjl]\g^^YkY_jYkkjgglkegn]e]flafl`])1/(k
Yf\gn]jl`]dYkl,(q]Yjk`Yk_jgofafkar]$eY_falm\]Yf\
_]g_jYh`a[j]Y[`&9kg^<][]eZ]j*()($gn]j+$.((E>Ak
j]hgjl]\egj]l`Yf*((eaddagf[da]flkogjd\oa\]$g^o`a[`gn]j
)+-eaddagfo]j]danaf_gfd]kkl`YfMK)&*-Y\Yq&4
:YfcYf\^gjhagf]]jaf_eg\]jfea[jgÕfYf[]&Egj]l`Yf1.g^
l`]?jYe]]f:Yfce]eZ]jkYj]oge]f&5E>Akg^l]flYj_]l
oge]f$kaf[]l`]qYj]l`gm_`llgZ]egj]dac]dqlgj]hYqdgYfk
Yf\afn]kll`]af[ge]_]f]jYl]\afl`]o]dd%Z]af_g^l`]aj^Yeada]k
Yf\l`]]\m[Ylagfg^l`]aj[`ad\j]f&
Gn]jl`]dYkl^]oq]Yjk$oal`jYha\[`Yf_]kafl][`fgdg_q$
ea[jgÕfYf[]`YkZ]]f]ngdnaf_Yf\gj_YfarYlagfkYj]]phYf\af_
l`]ajk]jna[]kafaffgnYlan]oYqk&9[Yk]afhgaflakl`]\]dan]jqg^
ea[jgÕfYf[]hjg\m[lkmkaf_egZad]h`gf]k&9^Yegmk]pYehd]
akE%H=K9$YegZad]%ZYk]\hYqe]flYf\egf]qljYfk^]jk]jna[]
dYmf[`]\af*((/ZqKY^Yja[ge$l`]dYj_]klegZad]f]logjc
gh]jYlgjafC]fqY&E%H=K9$o`a[`oYkafalaYddq[gf[]an]\YkY
lggdlg`]dhE>Ak[gdd][ldgYfhYqe]flk$akg^l]fYdkgmk]\Zq
[mklge]jk^gjljYfk^]jjaf_egf]q&6Mk]jk[Yf\]hgkalegf]q^gj
fg[`Yj_]$ljYfk^]jZYdYf[]kYf\oal`\jYoegf]qYlfgegfl`dq
eYafl]fYf[]^]]$Yddl`jgm_`l`]ajegZad]h`gf]&7L`]fmeZ]jg^
E%H=K9mk]jk`Y\_jgoflgf]Yjdq)(eaddagfaf*()(&
E>AkYj]d]n]jY_af_l`ak\jYeYla[h]f]ljYlagfg^egZad]
l][`fgdg_qYf\egZad]hYqe]flklgaehjgn]\]dan]jqg^
ea[jgÕfYf[]k]jna[]kYf\hjg\m[lklgl`]aj[da]flk&EmkgfaC]fqY$
^gj]pYehd]$o`a[`[dYaeklgZ]Él`]Õjkl)((egZad]E>Aaf
l`]ogjd\$Ê`Yk\akZmjk]\egj]l`YfMK)-edgYfkafbmkl^gmj
q]Yjk&?gn]jfaf_Zg\a]kYj]Ydkgafl]j]kl]\af\]n]dghaf_l`]
egZad]ZYfcaf_khY[]Èl`]J]k]jn]:Yfcg^Af\aY$o`a[`akAf\aYÌk
[]fljYdZYfc$`Ykj][]fldqk]lmhY[geeall]]lg]phdgj]l`]e]jal
g^afljg\m[af_Yl]pl%e]kkY_]%ZYk]\egZad]hYqe]flkqkl]e^gj
^mf\ljYfk^]jkhjaeYjadq^gjmfZYfc]\Af\aYfk&0
Gf]g^l`]egklo]dd%cfgofYf\]klYZdak`]\E>Akakl`]?jYe]]f
:Yfc$o`a[`hjgna\]k[j]\aloal`fg[gddYl]jYdj]imaj]e]flklg
l`]hggjafjmjYd:Yf_dY\]k`&<j&Em`YeeY\Qmfmkogfl`]*((.
FgZ]dH]Y[]Hjar]^gj`akogjcYkl`]^gmf\]jg^l`]?jYe]]f
Afl`]j][]flhYkl$l`]Yhhda[Ylagfg^Z]`YnagjYd][gfgea[kYf\
gl`]jaffgnYlan]j]k]Yj[`e]l`g\k$af[dm\af_l`]_jgoaf_mk]
g^jYf\gear]\]nYdmYlagfk$`Yn]\jan]feYfqfgn]dla]kafl`]
ea[jgÕfYf[]khY[]$af[dm\af_YfmeZ]jg^\a^^]j]flkYnaf_k
[geeale]fl\]na[]k$l]ple]kkY_]j]eaf\]jkYf\_gYdk]llaf_&
:gl`l][`fgdg_a[YdY\nYf[]e]flkYf\Z]`YnagjYdafka_`lk[Yf
d]Y\lgka_faÕ[Yflj]kmdlkYf\hjgna\]em[`k[gh]^gjhjg_j]kkaf
l`]af\mkljq&Ja_gjgmkj]k]Yj[`hdYqkY^mf\Ye]flYdjgd]afl`]
\]n]dghe]flg^km[`fgn]dhjg\m[lk&
,&BYfH&EY]kYf\DYjjqJ&J]]\$ÉKlYl]g^l`]Ea[jg[j]\alKmeeal;YehYa_fJ]hgjl*()*$Ê
Microcredit Summit Campaign,OYk`af_lgf<;$*()*& ooo&ea[jg[j]\alkmeeal&gj_'!
-&?jYe]]f:YfcKlY^^$É?jYe]]fEgfl`dqMh\Yl]afMK<2<][]eZ]j*()+$Ê?jYe]]f:Yfc$
BYfmYjq*(),&
.&JgZ]jl;mdd$ÉE%H]kY2EgZad]HYqe]flk$Aehjgn]\Dan]k^gjC]fqYfk$ÊDevelopment Research
Group,L`]Ogjd\:YfcEYq*()(& `llh2''_g&ogjd\ZYfc&gj_'MND-HBIP.(!
/&Gd_YEgjYo[rqfkca$ÉO`qE%H]kYK`gmd\G^^]jKYnaf_k9[[gmflk$ÊConsultative Group to Assist
the Poor Blog,K]hl]eZ]j*0$*((1& ooo&[_Yh&gj_'Zdg_'o`q%e%h]kY%k`gmd\%g^^]j%kYnaf_k%
Y[[gmflk!;ghqja_`l;?9H$;gfkmdlYlan]?jgmhlg9kkakll`]Hggj&
0&ÉJ:AK]lkmhEgZad]:Yfcaf_;geeall]]$ÊConsultative Group to Assist the Poor Blog,ooo&[_Yh&
gj_'f]ok'jZa%k]lk%egZad]%ZYfcaf_%[geeall]]$G[lgZ]j)($*()+&;ghqja_`l;]fljYdZYfcaf_&[ge&
,
L`]hjgeak]g^ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\oge]fÌk]ehgo]je]fl
L`]jgd]g^oge]faf
ea[jgÕfYf[]
9ke]flagf]\YZgn]$egj]l`Yf0(g^l`]ea[jgÕfYf[]
af\mkljqÌkhggj]kl[da]flkYj]oge]f&L`akdYj_]k`Yj]g^^]eYd]
hYjla[ahYflkakl`gm_`llgg^^k]lkge]g^l`]aeZYdYf[]kg^[mjj]fl
Y[[]kklgÕfYf[aYdk]jna[]k^gjoge]f&AfeYfq[gmflja]kYjgmf\
l`]ogjd\$[mdlmjYd^Y[lgjk$Yf\kge]lae]kj]_mdYlagf$`Yn]
ljY\alagfYddqj]klja[l]\oge]fÌkYZadalqlgY[[]kkYf\mk]ÕfYf[aYd
k]jna[]k&L`]Õ_mj]Z]dgok`gok`go^gjeYdY[[gmflh]f]ljYlagf
nYja]kZq_]f\]jYf\j]_agf&L`]_]f\]j_YhakdYj_]klaf
Kgml`9kaY$l`]Ea\\d]=YklYf\Fgjl`9^ja[Y&
9[[gmflH]f]ljYlagfZq_]f\]j
9\mdlkoal`YfY[[gmflYlY^gjeYdÕfYf[aYdafklalmlagf !
Hjgna\af_ÕfYf[aYdhjg\m[lkl`YlZ]f]Õll`]hggj[gmd\]ehgo]j
oge]faflogoYqk&>ajkl$a^l`]hjg\m[lkYj]eYjc]l]\Yf\
\]ka_f]\afYoYql`Ylhjgna\]koge]fYf]YkqY[[]kkYf\\aj][l
Z]f]Õlk$l`akeYqaf[j]Yk]l`]ajZmkaf]kkghhgjlmfala]k$YZadalq
lg[gh]oal`k`g[ck$ZYj_Yafaf_hgo]joal`afl`]`gmk]`gd\Yf\
gn]jYddaf\]h]f\]f[]&K][gf\$_]f\]jaf]imYdalql]f\klg\][daf]
Ykhgn]jlqj]\m[]k&10>gjl`]k]j]Ykgfk$hjgna\af_ÕfYf[aYd
hjg\m[lkl`Yl`]dh`gmk]`gd\k]k[Yh]hgn]jlq[gmd\YdkgY\nYf[]
_]f\]j]imalq&
Afl`]dYkllog\][Y\]k$k]n]jYdE>AkYf\eg\]dk`Yn]lja]\lg
Y\\j]kkl`]_]f\]j_YhafY[[]kklgÕfYf[aYdk]jna[]kZqhjgna\af_
lYj_]l]\k]jna[]klgoge]f&L`]mf\]jdqaf_Ykkmehlagfkg^l`ak
^g[mkYj]l`Yloge]fl]f\lgZ]egj][j]\al[gfkljYaf]\l`Yf
e]f$[Yfgj_Yfar]Z]ll]jYkY_jgmh$Yj]egj]dac]dqlgj]hYqY
dgYf$Yf\eYqZ]egj]dac]dqlgafn]kll`]j]lmjfkafl`]aj^YeadqÌk
Middle East
and North Africa
Sub-Saharan
Africa
South Asia
Latin America
and the Caribbean
13 23
22 27
25 41
35 44
Female
Europe and
Central Asia
East Asia and
HY[aÕ[
High-income
economies
40 50
52 58
87 92
Male
`]Ydl`Yf\]\m[Ylagf&O`ad]alakljm]l`Yloge]f`Yn]hggj]j
Y[[]kklg^gjeYdÕfYf[aYdk]jna[]kl`Yfe]f$]na\]f[]gfl`]
aehY[lg^l`]k]k]jna[]kgf[`ad\j]fÌk`]Ydl`Yf\]\m[Ylagfak
eap]\&11>mjl`]jj]k]Yj[`Yf\affgnYlagfYj]f]]\]\lgÕf\gml
`golg]^^][lan]dq_]f]jYl]km[`\]kaj]\Z]f]Õlk&
Kgmj[]2L`]Ogjd\:Yfc1
1&9kda<]eaj_m[%CmflYf\D]gjYCdYhh]j$ÉE]Ykmjaf_>afYf[aYdAf[dmkagf2L`]?dgZYd>af\]p
<YlYZYk]$Ê<]n]dghe]flJ]k]Yj[`?jgmh$L`]Ogjd\:Yfc$*()*&
)(&=kl`]j<mÖg$ÉOge]f=ehgo]je]flYf\=[gfgea[<]n]dghe]fl$ÊJournal of Economic
Literature,*()*$-( ,!$hh&)(-)Ç/1&
))&AZa\&
L`]hjgeak]g^ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\oge]fÌk]ehgo]je]fl
5
02
L`][`Yf_af_j]hmlYlagf
g^ea[jgÔfYf[]Yf\
l`]f]]\^gjj]daYZd]
evidence
=Yjdq]fl`mkaYke
9^l]jalk]Yjdqq]Yjk$Yf\hYjla[mdYjdqafl`]]Yjdq*(((k$kljgf_]fl`mkaYke^gjea[jgÕfYf[]oYkoa\]khj]Y\&
Af*((-$l`]Mfal]\FYlagfkdYmf[`]\l`]ÉAfl]jfYlagfYdQ]Yjg^Ea[jg[j]\al$ÊYf\eYfqj]fgof]\Õ_mj]k
dYm\]\ea[jgÕfYf[]&
.
L`]hjgeak]g^ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\oge]fÌk]ehgo]je]fl
ÉEa[jg[j]\al`YkZjgm_`lYem[`%f]]\]\
j]ngdmlagfafYfla%hgn]jlqhjg_jYek&Á
Ea[jg[j]\al_g]k\aj][ldqlghggjh]ghd]&
Al[j]Yl]kbgZkafnaddY_]k&Al`]dhkoge]f
\]n]dgh[gfÕ\]f[]Yf\af\]h]f\]f[]&Ê
È New York Times,)11/
ÉEa[jgÕfYf[]akYfa\]Yo`gk]lae]`Yk
[ge]&Ê
È CgÕ9ffYf$Mfal]\FYlagfkK][j]lYjq%?]f]jYd$*((-
ÉEa[jgÕfYf[]klYf\kYkgf]g^l`]egkl
hjgeakaf_Yf\[gkl%]^^][lan]lggdkafl`]
Õ_`lY_Yafkl_dgZYdhgn]jlq&Ê
È BgfYl`YfEgj\m[`$;`Yaj$MF=ph]jl?jgmhgfHgn]jlq
KlYlakla[kYf\hjg^]kkgjYlF]oQgjcMfan]jkalq$*((-
L`]ZjgY\Yj_me]fl^gjea[jgÕfYf[]$Yf\afhYjla[mdYj
ea[jg[j]\al$oYkl`Yl_anaf_keYdddgYfklg[YhalYd%[gfkljYaf]\
ea[jg%]flj]hj]f]mjkoYkYoaf%oafkalmYlagf^gjZgl`Zgjjgo]jk
Yf\d]f\]jk&O`ad]Yfaf\ana\mYd[gmd\mk]l`]dgYflgafn]klaf
l`]ajZmkaf]kk$af[j]Yk]l`]ajaf[ge]Yf\]k[Yh]hgn]jlq$l`]
d]f\af_gj_YfarYlagf[gmd\]YjfY`a_`j]lmjfkaf[]l`]eYjc]l
oYkdYj_]dqmf\]jk]jn]\Yf\Zgjjgo]jko]j]oaddaf_lghYqY
`a_`afl]j]kljYl]&L`]j]oYk]fl`mkaYke^jgeÕfYf[aYdeYjc]lk
lggÈaf*((/$:Yf[g;gehYjlYegk$YfE>AdYmf[`]\af)11($
[gehd]l]\YfAHGg^alkklg[cYf\l`][gehYfqÌkkljgf__jgol`
Yf\hjgÕlYZadalqd]\lgl`]klg[cZ]af_)+lae]kgn]jkmZk[jaZ]\&12
<akaddmkagfe]flgn]jdaeal]\
Z]f]Õlk
Afj][]flq]Yjk$l`]afalaYd]fl`mkaYkeYjgmf\ea[jgÕfYf[]`Yk
Z]]fj]hdY[]\Zqkge]\]_j]]g^kc]hla[ake&9faf[j]Ykaf_
fmeZ]jg^[jala[Ydnga[]kbgaf]\l`]hmZda[\ak[gmjk]gf
ea[jgÕfYf[]&L`]k][jalaim]ko]j]ZYk]\$afhYjl$gfY[Y\]ea[
j]k]Yj[`k`goaf_daealkg^l`]]^^][lan]f]kkg^[]jlYafhjg\m[lk$
Yf\afhYjl$gfYfmeZ]jg^`a_`%hjgÕd]hgdala[Ydk[Yf\YdkYf\Y
j]_agfYd[jakakafl`]ea[jg[j]\aleYjc]l&
ÉL`]j]Yj]eYfqklgja]kg^l`]
ljYfk^gjeYlan]]^^][lg^ea[jgÕfYf[]gf
af\ana\mYdZgjjgo]jkZmlmfladj][]fldq
l`]j]`YkZ]]fkmjhjakaf_dqdalld]ja_gjgmk
j]k]Yj[`l`YlYll]ehlklgakgdYl]l`]
aehY[lg^ea[jgÕfYf[]^jgegl`]j^Y[lgjk$
gjlga\]fla^q`go\a^^]j]flYhhjgY[`]klg
ea[jgÕfYf[][`Yf_]gml[ge]k&Ê
È ;]fl]j^gj?dgZYd<]n]dghe]fl$*((/
ÉL`]af\mkljqk]]eklgZ]hmehaf_\]Zl
\gofh]ghd]Ìkl`jgYlk&Alakfgdgf_]j
kg[aYddqj]khgfkaZd]Yf\\g]kfglZ]dgf_af
\]n]dghe]flYd^mf\k&Ê
È 9f\j]o;Yfl]j$>mlmj]_jgol`9kk]lEYfY_]e]fl$
Kgml`9^ja[Y$*()+
)*&Ja[`Yj\Jgk]fZ]j_$É;?9HJ]Ö][lagfkgfl`];gehYjlYegkAfalaYdHmZda[G^^]jaf_$Ê
Consultative Group to Assist the Poor Blog,Bmf]*((/& ooo&[_Yh&gj_'hmZda[Ylagfk'[_Yh%
j]Ö][lagfk%[gehYjlYegk%afalaYd%hmZda[%g^^]jaf_!
L`]hjgeak]g^ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\oge]fÌk]ehgo]je]fl
/
O`ad]k]n]jYdjYf\gear]\]nYdmYlagfkaf\a^^]j]fl[gfl]plk
`Yn]k`gofl`Ylea[jg[j]\alakYmk]^mdÕfYf[aYdlggd^gjkge]
ea[jg%]flj]hj]f]mjk$afegkl[Yk]kal`YkfglZ]]fk`goflg
af[j]Yk]af[ge]Yf\j]\m[]hgn]jlq&Gml[ge]k`Yn]YdkgZ]]f
^gmf\lgnYjqka_faÕ[YfldqYegf_Zgjjgo]jk&AfY\\alagf$\m]lg
l`]Y^gj]e]flagf]\af^gjeYlagfYkqee]ljqhjgZd]ek$_jgol`
afl`]ea[jgafkmjYf[]eYjc]l`YkZ]]fmf]ph][l]\dqkdgoYf\
[`Ydd]f_af_&
L`]f]]\^gjYZYdYf[]\$
]na\]f[]%ZYk]\YhhjgY[`
>jgeZ]af_dYm\]\Ykl`]eY_a[Zmdd]llg]jY\a[Yl]hgn]jlqYf\
af[j]Yk]oge]fÌk][gfgea[]ehgo]je]fl$lgZ]af_Z]jYl]\
YkY^Yadmj]gj]n]fY\akYkl]j^gjl`]hggj$l`]j]hmlYlagfg^
ea[jgÕfYf[]`Yk_gf]l`jgm_`Yjgdd]j[gYkl]jg^ghafagfk&Em[`
g^l`]k]\]ZYl]k`Yn]Z]]f\geafYl]\Zqa\]gdg_a[Ydhgkalagfk
Yf\Yf][\glYd]na\]f[]l`Ylmf\]jk[gj]hj][gf[]an]\fglagfk
Yf\Y_]f\Yk&
Afj]Ydalq$f]al`]jg^l`]k]]plj]e]na]ohgaflkak]flaj]dqY[[mjYl]&
Ea[jgÕfYf[]hjg\m[lk`Yn]l`]hgl]flaYdlgeYc]YdYj_]hgkalan]
aehY[l^gjoge]fo`]fYhhda]\o]dd$Yf\o`]j]l`]j]akY_gg\
eYl[`Z]lo]]fl`]hjg\m[lYf\l`][mklge]jf]]\&9ll`]kYe]
lae]$l`]j]`Yn]YdkgZ]]fafklYf[]kg^dgogj]n]ff]_Ylan]
]^^][lk&9f`gf]kl$\a^^]j]flaYl]\afimajqakf]]\]\lgd]Yjf
o`a[`Z]klhjY[la[]kd]Y\lgl`]egkl]^^][lan]gml[ge]k$Yf\lg
\]l]jeaf]`gohjg\m[lkYf\k]jna[]\]dan]jq[YfZ]aehjgn]\lg
Y[`a]n]l`Yl_gYd&
Ja_gjgmkj]k]Yj[`$Yko]ddYk`gf]klafljgkh][lagf$[Yfhjgna\]
_ma\Yf[]lghjgegl]affgnYlagfYf\[gflafmgmkd]Yjfaf_^gjl`]
ea[jgÕfYf[][geemfalqogjd\oa\]&=^^gjlk^gjhgn]jlqj]\m[lagf
Yf\^gjoge]fÌk]ehgo]je]floaddZ]egkl]^^][lan]a^l`]qYj]
eY\]^jgeYhjY_eYla[$^Y[lk%ZYk]\h]jkh][lan]&
8
L`]hjgeak]g^ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\oge]fÌk]ehgo]je]fl
03
L`]aehgjlYf[]g^
ja_gjgmk]nYdmYlagfk
J][]flaffgnYlagfkafj]k]Yj[`e]l`g\gdg_a]kl`Yle]Ykmj]aehY[lYf\]nYdmYl]]^^][lan]f]kkafl`]kg[aYd
k][lgj`Yn]gh]f]\mh]p[alaf_f]oghhgjlmfala]k^gjd]Yjfaf_Yf\aehjgn]e]fl^gjgj_YfarYlagfkoal`Ykg[aYd
_gYd$af[dm\af_ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\^]eYd]]ehgo]je]fl&JYf\gear]\]nYdmYlagfkhjgna\]Yn]jqja_gjgmkYf\
j]daYZd]oYqlgYkk]kkaehY[lk&
Mk]g^jYf\gear]\]nYdmYlagfkafea[jgÕfYf[]`Yk_jgof\jYeYla[Yddqgn]jl`]hYkl\][Y\]&Km[`]nYdmYlagfk
Yj]g^l]f[gf\m[l]\af[dgk]hYjlf]jk`ahoal`E>AkYf\[YfZ]lYadgj]\lgk]jn]l`]ajkh][aÕ[f]]\k&Klm\a]k
mkaf_jYf\gear]\]nYdmYlagfe]l`g\gdg_q[Yf\]egfkljYl]`go[`Yf_af_kh][aÕ[^]Ylmj]kafnYjagmk
ea[jg[j]\al$ea[jgkYnaf_kYf\ea[jgafkmjYf[]hjg\m[lk[Yfd]Y\lgka_faÕ[Yfldq\a^^]j]flj]kmdlk&E>Ak[Yf
mk]l`]]nYdmYlagfklgY\bmklYf\aehjgn]hjg\m[l\]ka_f$k]jna[]\]dan]jqgj[`ga[]g^l`]ajlYj_]l[mklge]jk
afgj\]jlgaehjgn]l`]kg[aYdaehY[lkYf\l`]ÕfYf[aYdnaYZadalqg^l`]ajhjg\m[lk&L`]j]kmdlkg^k]n]jYdkm[`
klm\a]kYj]\ak[mkk]\afK][lagfk,Ç.Z]dgo&
L`]hjgeak]g^ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\oge]fÌk]ehgo]je]fl
1
:]f]Õlkg^jYf\gear]\
]nYdmYlagfk
AfYjYf\gear]\]nYdmYlagf$af\ana\mYdkgj_jgmhkg^h]ghd]Yj]
jYf\gedqYkka_f]\lg]al`]jhYjla[ahYl]afY_an]fea[jgÕfYf[]
hjg_jYe$gjfglhYjla[ahYl]Zmlk]jn]YkhYjlg^l`][gehYjakgf
_jgmh&Gn]jYh]jag\g^lae]$j]k]Yj[`]jkljY[cl`]\a^^]j]f[]af
gml[ge]kZ]lo]]fl`]hYjla[ahYlaf_Yf\l`][gehYjakgf_jgmhk
lge]Ykmj]l`]aehY[lg^l`]hjg_jYe&L`akYhhjgY[`akkaeadYj
lgjYf\gear]\[gfljgdljaYdk^gjf]oe]\a[af]kYf\9':l]klaf_af
l`]l][`]flj]hj]f]mjk`ah[gfl]pl&
<m]lgl`]jYf\geYkka_fe]fl$af\ana\mYdkafl`]lj]Yle]fl
Yf\[gehYjakgf_jgmhkYj]a\]fla[Yd$gfYn]jY_]$]p[]hl^gj
l`]aj]phgkmj]lgl`]ea[jgÕfYf[]hjg_jYe&A^Yklm\qafkl]Y\
[gehYj]\h]ghd]o`gmk]l`]E>Ak]jna[]oal`h]ghd]o`g\g
fgl$l`]log_jgmhkeYq`Yn]ka_faÕ[Yflhj]%]paklaf_\a^^]j]f[]k
^gj]pYehd]afl]jekg^]flj]hj]f]mjaYdYZadalq$jakclgd]jYf[]$
eglanYlagfgjo]Ydl`&JYf\gear]\]nYdmYlagfk]daeafYl]l`ak
hjgZd]e&L`]\a^^]j]f[]afgml[ge]kZ]lo]]fl`]log_jgmhk[Yf
Z][d]YjdqYlljaZml]\lgl`]hjg_jYegjafl]jn]flagfYf\fgllg
gl`]j^Y[lgjk&
L`]j]Yj]logoYqkafo`a[`YjYf\gear]\]nYdmYlagf[YfZ]
mk]^mdlgYfE>AgjlgY_gn]jfaf_Zg\ql`Ylk]]cklg\]Õf]
j]_mdYlagf2
)&=na\]f[]^jge[gehd]l]\]nYdmYlagfk[YfZ]lYc]faflg
Y[[gmflo`]f\]ka_faf_f]ohjg\m[lkgjhgda[a]k&L`]9Z\md
DYla^BYe]]dHgn]jlq9[lagfDYZ B%H9D!$^gjafklYf[]$`YkY
dYj_]Yf\_jgoaf_j]hgkalgjqg^klm\a]kYZgml\a^^]j]flYkh][lk
g^ea[jgÕfYf[]l`Yl[YfZ][gfkmdl]\gfdaf]&13
*&Gj_YfarYlagfk[Yfaehd]e]fll`]ajgofklm\a]klg]nYdmYl]
hYjla[mdYjYkh][lkg^l`]ajeg\]dgjk]jna[]k&:gl`Y[Y\]ea[
hYjlf]jkYf\kh][aYdar]\]nYdmYlagfÕjek$km[`YkA<afka_`l$
[Yf`]dhl`]E>Aaehd]e]flkm[`Yklm\q&
AlakaehgjlYfllgd]Yjf^jgel`]\an]jkalqg^]ph]ja]f[]kYnYadYZd]
afl`]ea[jgÕfYf[]kh`]j]Yf\[Yj]^mddqYfYdqr]d]kkgfkkh][aÕ[
lgl`][gfl]plo`]f\]ka_faf_Yfafl]jn]flagf&9kl`]fmeZ]jg^
l`]k]ja_gjgmkklm\a]k_jgok$egj]Yf\egj]af^gjeYlagfoaddZ]
YnYadYZd]lgd]Yjf`golgZ]klklj]f_l`]fYf\lYj_]lea[jgÕfYf[]
k]jna[]klgeYpaear]l`]ajkg[aYdaehY[lYko]ddYkl`]aj][gfgea[
naYZadalq&
L`]^gddgoaf_l`j]]k][lagfkYfYdqr]j]k]Yj[`j]kmdlk^gj]Y[`
lqh]g^ea[jgÕfYf[]hjg\m[l2ea[jg[j]\al$ea[jgkYnaf_kYf\
ea[jgafkmjYf[]$j]kh][lan]dq&
)+&B%H9DÌkj]hgkalgjqg^klm\a]kgfea[jgÕfYf[][YfZ]^gmf\`]j]2 `llhk2''ooo&
hgn]jlqY[lagfdYZ&gj_'ÕfYf[]%ea[jgÕfYf[]!B%H9D$É>afYf[]Yf\Ea[jgÕfYf[]$ÊAbdul Latif Jameel
Poverty Action Lab,*(),&
)(
L`]hjgeak]g^ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\oge]fÌk]ehgo]je]fl
04
Microcredit
=na\]f[]gfl`]aehY[lg^ea[jg[j]\al
9^l]jl`]afalaYd]fl`mkaYkeYZgmlea[jg[j]\al$l`]j]kmdlkg^ja_gjgmkjYf\gear]\]nYdmYlagfk[gf\m[l]\af
\a^^]j]flj]_agfkYjgmf\l`]ogjd\d]\lgY[]jlYaf\]_j]]g^\akaddmkagfe]fl&Af[j]Ykaf_Y[[]kklg[j]\al\a\
fgld]Y\lgl`]\jYeYla[j]\m[lagfkafhgn]jlql`Ylhjghgf]flk`Y\`gh]\^gj&F]n]jl`]d]kk$l`]]ph]jae]flYd
]na\]f[]k`gokl`Ylea[jgdgYfk[Yf`Yn]gl`]jaehgjlYflaehY[lk&9dYj_]jYf\gear]\klm\qYegf_YZgml
.$0-(`gmk]`gd\kaf@q\]jYZY\$Af\aY$k`go]\l`Ylaf[j]Yk]\Y[[]kklgea[jg[j]\al\a\fglj]kmdlafYfq
ka_faÕ[YflaehY[lgfoge]fÌk]ehgo]je]flgj`meYf\]n]dghe]flgml[ge]k&@go]n]j$l`]j]o]j]gl`]j
_Yafk$af[dm\af_af[j]Yk]\hjgÕlk^gjl`gk]oal`l`]`a_`]klhj]%]paklaf_hjgÕlkYko]ddYkdgo]j]ph]f\almj]gf
l]ehlYlagf_gg\k$km[`YklgZY[[ggjYd[g`gd$Yf\`a_`]jafn]kle]flaf\mjYZd]_gg\kYf\Zmkaf]kk]kYegf_
kge]`gmk]`gd\k&14
),&9Z`abal:Yf]jb]]$=kl`]j<mÖg$JY[`]d?d]ff]jkl]jYf\;qfl`aYCaffYf$ÉL`]EajY[d]g^Ea[jgÕfYf[]7=na\]f[]^jgeYJYf\gear]\=nYdmYlagf$ÊBREAD [Bureau for
Research and Economic Analysis of Development] Working Paper 278,*()(&
L`]hjgeak]g^ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\oge]fÌk]ehgo]je]fl
))
9kaeadYjaehY[loYkYdkg^gmf\afYjYf\gear]\]nYdmYlagf
[gf\m[l]\afjmjYdEgjg[[g$o`]j]af[j]Yk]\Y[[]kklg[j]\al
\m]lgZYfcgh]faf_kafhj]nagmkdqmfZYfc]\Yj]Ykaf[j]Yk]\l`]
ngdme]g^]paklaf_^Yjeaf_Y[lanalqYf\l`]ajhjgÕlk^jgel`]k]
Y[lanala]k&@go]n]j$YkaklgZ]]ph][l]\oal`Yfqjakcqafn]kle]fl$
l`]j]oYkka_faÕ[YflnYjaYZadalqafl`]gml[ge]k$Yf\o`ad]
j]lmjfklgafn]kle]flko]j]]plj]e]dq`a_`^gjkge]$Yeafgjalq
g^`gmk]`gd\keYq]n]f`Yn]`Y\f]_Ylan]j]lmjfk&9ll`]kYe]
lae]$l`]j]oYkj]\m[]\dYZgjaf[ge]$k`goaf_l`Ylh]ghd][`gk]
af[j]Yk]\k]d^%]ehdgq]\Y[lanalqgn]joY_]dYZgj&15
Oal`j]kh][llgkg[aYd[YhalYd$e]Ykmj]\Zql`]fmeZ]jg^nakalk
Yf\\ak[mkkagfkYZgmlh]jkgfYdYf\Zmkaf]kkeYll]jkoal`gl`]j
_jgmhe]eZ]jk$16YjYf\gear]\]ph]jae]flaf]Ykl]jfAf\aY
gZk]jn]\l`Yll`]j]oYk`a_`]jkg[aYd[YhalYdYegf_l`]oge]f
o`ge]lo]]cdq^gjdgYfj]hYqe]flk[gehYj]\oal`l`gk]o`g
e]legfl`dq&17L`]k]klm\a]kkm__]kll`YlalakaehgjlYfllg
k`a^ll`]^g[mk^jgehmj]hjgÕl_]f]jYlagfYf\[gfka\]jgl`]j
Z]f]ÕlkY[[jm]\lgl`]hggjl`jgm_`ea[jg[j]\al&AfhYjla[mdYj$al
akaehgjlYfllg_Yafegj]afka_`laflgo`Yllqh]g^[da]flZ]f]Õlk
^jgeo`a[`Ykh][lk&
:]qgf\k`]\\af_da_`lgfl`]aehY[lg^Y[[]kklgea[jg[j]\al
j][]flj]k]Yj[``YkYdkgklm\a]\oYqklgaehjgn]hjg\m[l\]ka_f
ZYk]\gfafka_`lk^jgeZ]`YnagjYd][gfgea[kYf\gl`]jkg[aYd
k[a]f[]k&>gjafklYf[]$afeYfq]Yjdqeg\]dkg^ea[jgd]f\af_$
[j]\aloYkhjgna\]\lgY_jgmhg^af\ana\mYdk$oal`_jgmhdaYZadalq
Z]af_l`][gj]g^Yh]]jhj]kkmj]eg\]d&L`]h]]jhj]kkmj]
eg\]doYk[gfljgn]jkaYdYf\`YkZ]]fZdYe]\^gjkge]g^l`]
`Yj\k`ahYf\klj]kk^gje]eZ]jkg^E>Ak$o`g^gmf\l`]ek]dn]k
mfYZd]lgj]hYqYdgYf&9jYf\gear]\klm\q[gf\m[l]\afl`]jmjYd
H`adahhaf]k$afYkkg[aYlagfoal`?j]]f:Yfc$[`Ydd]f_]\l`]_jgmh
daYZadalqeg\]dYf\k`go]\`goYegn]lgoYj\af\ana\mYddaYZadalq
\a\fglY\n]jk]dqY^^][ldgYfj]hYqe]fl&)0Af^Y[l$al]phYf\]\
l`]ZYfcÌk[mklge]jZYk]$km__]klaf_l`Ylf]o[mklge]jko]j]
YlljY[l]\Zql`]af\ana\mYddaYZadalqeg\]d&
)-&:jmfg;j]hgf$>dgj]f[aY<]nglg$=kl`]j<mÖgYf\OaddaYeHYja]fl]$É=klaeYlaf_l`]AehY[l
g^Ea[jg[j]\algfL`gk]O`gLYc]alMh2=na\]f[]^jgeYJYf\gear]\=ph]jae]flafEgjg[[g$Ê
Massachusetts Institute of Technology Working Paper,<][]eZ]j*()+&
).&JgZ]jl<&HmlfYe$JgZ]jlD]gfYj\aYf\JY^^Y]ddYQ&FYf]lla$ÉEYcaf_<]eg[jY[qOgjc2;ana[
LjY\alagfkafEg\]jfAlYdq$ÊHjaf[]lgfMfan]jkalqHj]kk$)11,&
)/&=ja[Y>a]d\$Jg`afaHYf\]$K`YqYcKYjcYjYf\FYlYdaYJa_gd$É<g?jgmh<qfYea[kAfÖm]f[]
Kg[aYd;YhalYdYf\>]eYd]=ehgo]je]fl7=ph]jae]flYd=na\]f[]^jgeEa[jgÕfYf[]$ÊHarvard
University Working Paper,*()+&
)0&PYna]j?af†Yf\<]YfKCYjdYf$É?jgmhn]jkmkAf\ana\mYdDaYZadalq2K`gjlYf\Dgf_L]je
=na\]f[]^jgeH`adahhaf]Ea[jg[j]\alD]f\af_?jgmhk$ÊJournal of Development Economics,*(),$
107$hh&.-Ç0+&
)*
9fgl`]jj]Õf]e]flg^l`]ljY\alagfYdea[jgÕfYf[]eg\]doYk
l]kl]\ZqYjYf\gear]\]nYdmYlagf[gf\m[l]\Yegf_[da]flk
g^YfE>AafCgdcYlY$Af\aY&L`]klYf\Yj\ea[jg[j]\aleg\]d
j]imaj]khYjla[ahYflklgklYjlj]hYqe]flaee]\aYl]dqY^l]jl`]
j][]ahlg^l`]dgYf&@go]n]j$eYfqafn]kle]flghhgjlmfala]klYc]
kge]lae]lg_]f]jYl]ÕfYf[aYdj]lmjfk&L`]klm\q[gehYj]\
gml[ge]k^gjZgjjgo]jkaflog\aklaf[ldgYfkljm[lmj]k&Gf]
_jgmhoYkjYf\gedqYkka_f]\lgYkljm[lmj]l`Ylj]imaj]\l`]e
lgklYjlj]hYqe]flaee]\aYl]dq$o`ad]l`]gl`]joYk_an]fY
log%egfl`_jY[]h]jag\&)1J]kmdlkk`go]\l`Yll`ak_jY[]h]jag\
`Y\ka_faÕ[YflaehY[l&Ea[jg]fl]jhjak]afn]kle]floYk.`a_`]j$
l`]dac]da`gg\g^klYjlaf_Yf]oZmkaf]kkoYkloa[]Yk`a_`$Yf\
]n]fYZgmll`j]]q]YjkY^l]jj][]anaf_l`]dgYf$o]]cdqZmkaf]kk
hjgÕlkYf\egfl`dq`gmk]`gd\af[ge]o]j]gfYn]jY_],)Yf\
)1&-^gjl`gk]_an]fY_jY[]h]jag\[gehYj]\oal`l`gk]o`g
o]j]fgl&L`]k]`a_`]jj]lmjfko]j]gZlYaf]\Zq]flj]hj]f]mjk
eYcaf_jakca]jafn]kle]flk&Afl`]k`gjljmf$l`]qo]j]l`j]]
lae]kegj]dac]dqlg\]^Ymdl$l`mkaf\a[Ylaf_YljY\]%g^^Z]lo]]f
hjgÕlk^gjl`]E>AYf\kg[aYdj]lmjfk&L`]k]Õf\af_kk`gol`Yl
keYdd[`Yf_]kafYhjg\m[l\]ka_f[Yfd]Y\lgdYj_]\a^^]j]f[]kaf
l`]gml[ge]k&
=nYdmYlaf_l`][j]\alogjl`af]kkg^YZgjjgo]j`YkYdoYqkZ]]f
Y[`Ydd]f_]^gjYfqd]f\af_gj_YfarYlagf&L`akakhYjla[mdYjdq
l`][Yk]^gjE>Ak\m]lgl`]^Y[ll`Yll`]aj[da]flkdY[cY^gjeYd
[j]\al`aklgjq&AffgnYlan]e]l`g\kg^[j]\al]nYdmYlagf`Yn]Z]]f
]e]j_af_g^dYl]oal`l`]_gYdg^Y\\j]kkaf_l`ak[`Ydd]f_]&Gf]
klm\ql`Ylmk]\[da]flkg^YdYj_]h]]j%lg%h]]jd]f\af_hgjlYd
[Ydd]\Hjgkh]jYkk]kk]\l`]h]j^gjeYf[]g^gfdaf]d]f\af_
eYjc]lkYf\^gmf\l`Ylh]]jd]f\]jko]j]YZd]lga\]fla^ql`]
dac]da`gg\g^\]^Ymdloal`,-`a_`]jY[[mjY[ql`Yfl`][j]\al
k[gj]af\a[Yl]\$k`goaf_l`Ylfgf%klYf\Yj\af^gjeYlagf[gmd\
d]Y\lg`a_`]j]^Õ[a]f[q&20L`]mk]g^hkq[`ge]lja[lggdk`Yk
YdkgZ]]f]nYdmYl]\lga\]fla^qhjgÕlYZd]$]flj]hj]f]mjaYd
Zgjjgo]jkafgj\]jlgaehjgn]j]lmjfklgE>Ak&;gehYfa]k$
)1&=ja[Y>a]d\$Jg`afaHYf\]$Bg`fHYhhYf\FYlYdaYJa_gd$É<g]kl`];dYkka[Ea[jg%>afYf[]Eg\]d
<ak[gmjY_]=flj]hj]f]mjk`ah9egf_l`]Hggj7=ph]jae]flYd=na\]f[]^jgeAf\aY$ÊThe American
Economic Review,*()+$103 .!$hh&*)1.Ç***.&
*(&JYbcYeYdAq]j$9kaeAbYrC`oYbY$=jrg>HDmlle]jYf\C]ddqK`m]$ÉK[j]]faf_H]]jkKg^ldq2
Af^]jjaf_l`]ImYdalqg^KeYdd:gjjgo]jk$ÊNBER Working Paper 15242,*(),&
L`]hjgeak]g^ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\oge]fÌk]ehgo]je]fl
km[`Ykl`]=flj]hj]f]mjaYd>afYf[]DYZ$\]hdgql`]k]lggdk
Yf\l][`faim]klg`]dhZYfcklYj_]lhjgÕlYZd]Zgjjgo]jk]n]f
oal`gmlY[j]\al`aklgjq&>mjl`]j$h]jkgfYda\]flaÕ[Ylagf[YfYdkg
hdYqYfafkljme]flYdjgd]afc]]haf_l`]d]n]dg^\]^Ymdljakcaf
[`][c&>gjafklYf[]$YjYf\gear]\]nYdmYlagfafEYdYoa^gmf\
l`YlÕf_]jhjaflaf_dgYfYhhda[YflkZggkl]\j]hYqe]fljYl]k
^gjZgjjgo]jkoal`l`]`a_`]kl]p%Yfl]\]^Ymdljakc^jge
./lg1*&21
<a^^]j]flaYdaehY[lk^gjoge]f
Ea[jg[j]\al`Ykg^l]fZ]]fl`gm_`llg`gd\kh][aYdhjgeak]^gj
oge]f&AfhYjl$l`akoYkZYk]\gfl`]^Y[ll`Ylkm[`YdYj_]k`Yj]
g^ea[jg[j]\al[da]flko]j]oge]f&AloYkYdkg`qhgl`]kar]\
l`Yll`akY[[]kklg[j]\alogmd\k`a^ll`]ZYdYf[]g^hgo]jaf
l`]`gmk]`gd\Yf\hjgna\]oge]foal`egj]YmlgfgeqYf\
af\]h]f\]f[]&>afYddq$aloYk]ph][l]\l`Yl[j]\al_an]flgoge]f
ogmd\`Yn]egj]Z]f]Õ[aYdaehY[lkgfl`]aj[`ad\j]fYf\^Yeada]k
l`Yf[j]\al_an]flge]f&
L`]_]f]jYdÕf\af_kgfea[jgÕfYf[]\ak[mkk]\YZgn]g^[gmjk]
Yhhdqlgoge]fYko]dd$hYjla[mdYjdq_an]fl`]dYj_]k`Yj]g^
^]eYd]ea[jgÕfYf[][da]flk&@go]n]j$dalld]]na\]f[]]paklklg
kmhhgjll`][dYael`Ylea[jgÕfYf[aYdk]jna[]kg^^]jY\\alagfYd
Z]f]Õlklg^]eYd]gn]jeYd][da]flk&9klm\q[gf\m[l]\afl`]
H`adahhaf]k^gmf\fg]na\]f[]l`Ylea[jgdgYfk_an]flgoge]f
`Y\dYj_]jaehY[lkl`Yfl`gk]_an]flge]f&22AfKjaDYfcY$_jYflk
_an]flgea[jg%]flj]hj]f]mjko]j]]n]f^gmf\lg`Yn]YZ]ll]j
aehY[l^gje]f2l`]qk`go]\Y-j]lmjfgf[YhalYd]Y[`egfl`$
o`ad]^gjoge]f$l`]j]oYkfg]^^][lgfhjgÕl&23L`ak\a^^]j]flaYd
j]kmdlea_`lhgl]flaYddqZ]YlljaZmlYZd]lgl`]]fnajgfe]flaf
KjaDYfcY$o`]j]gfdq+-g^oge]fYj]hYjlg^l`]ogjc^gj[]
Yf\eYfqogjcafdgo]j%j]lmjfk][lgjk&24;d]Yjdq$l`]aehY[lkg^
ea[jgÕfYf[]k]jna[]kgfoge]foaddafl]jY[loal`gl`]jYkh][lk
g^l`]_]f\]j_Yhafl`]aj]fnajgfe]fl&
*)&PYna]j?af†$B]kka[Y?gd\Z]j_Yf\<]YfQYf_$É;j]\alEYjc]l;gfk]im]f[]kg^Aehjgn]\
H]jkgfYdA\]flaÕ[Ylagf2>a]d\=ph]jae]flYd=na\]f[]^jgeEYdYoa$ÊAmerican Economic Review,
*()*$)(* .!2*1*+Ç-,&
**&<]YfCYjdYfYf\BgfYl`YfRafeYf$É=phYf\af_;j]\al9[[]kk2Mkaf_JYf\gear]\Kmhhdq
<][akagflg=klaeYl]l`]AehY[lk$ÊReview of Financial Studies,*()($*+ )!$hh&,++Ç,.,&
*+&Kmj]k`<]E]d$<Yna\E[C]fra]Yf\;`jaklgh`]jOgg\jm^^$É9j]Oge]fEgj];j]\al
;gfkljYaf]\7=ph]jae]flYd=na\]f[]gf?]f\]jYf\Ea[jg]fl]jhjak]J]lmjfk$Ê9merican Economic
Journal: Applied Economics,*((1$hh&)Ç+*&
*,&BgfYl`Yf:Ym[`]l$;jaklgZYdEYjk`Ydd$DYmjYKlYjalY$B]Yf]ll]L`geYkYf\9ffYQYdgmjak$
ÉDYl]kl>af\af_k^jgeJYf\gear]\=nYdmYlagfkg^Ea[jgÕfYf[]$ÊAfAccess to Finance Forum,*())&
L`]hjgeak]g^ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\oge]fÌk]ehgo]je]fl
)+
05
Ea[jgkYnaf_k
=na\]f[]gfl`]aehY[lg^ea[jgkYnaf_k
Ea[jgkYnaf_k`Yn]Z]]fem[`d]kkYll`]^gj]^jgflafl`]hmZda[\ak[gmjk]YZgmlea[jgÕfYf[]l`Yfea[jg[j]\al&
AfhYjl$l`akeYqZ]\m]lgl`]^Y[ll`Yl^gjl`]d]f\af_afklalmlagf$ea[jgkYnaf_kYj]_]f]jYddqd]kkg^YÕfYf[aYddq
hjgÕlYZd]hjghgkalagfl`Yfea[jg[j]\al&Mfd]kkkYn]jkhYq^gjl`]ajY[[gmfl$`gd\af_Y[[gmflkoal`n]jqkeYdd
\]hgkalkl]f\klgZ][gkldq&AfY\\alagf$ZYfcaf_j]_mdYlagfkeYc]alafklalmlagfYddq[`Ydd]f_af_^gjE>AkafeYfq
[gmflja]klgZ]Yddgo]\lg`gd\kYnaf_k\]hgkalk^gjl`]aj[da]flk&@go]n]j$Yf]e]j_af_Zg\qg^j]k]Yj[`k`gok
l`Ylea[jgkYnaf_keYq`Yn]ka_faÕ[Yflhgkalan]kg[aYdj]lmjfk&Al$l`]j]^gj]$k]]ekogjl`o`ad]lghmjkm]f]o
Zmkaf]kkeg\]dkl`YleYc]ea[jgkYnaf_khgkkaZd]$hgl]flaYddql`jgm_`hmZda[kmZka\a]k$gjZqZmf\daf_l`]eoal`
gl`]jk]jna[]k&
),
L`]hjgeak]g^ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\oge]fÌk]ehgo]je]fl
J]k]Yj[`gfea[jgkYnaf_k[YfZ]ZjgY\dq_jgmh]\aflglog
[Yl]_gja]k2 )!klm\a]kl`YlYfYdqr]l`]aehY[lg^Y[[]kklg
kYnaf_khjg\m[lkgfY[da]flÌk][gfgea[Y[lanalqYf\o]dd%Z]af_$
Yf\ *!klm\a]kl`YlYhhdqd]kkgfk^jgeZ]`YnagjYd][gfgea[k
lg`]dh[mklge]jkkYn]egj]$^gj]pYehd]$l`jgm_`l`]mk]
g^kYnaf_k[geeale]fl\]na[]k&O]oadd\ak[mkk]Y[`g^l`]k]
aflmjf&
Hjgna\af_l`]hggjoal`Y[[]kklgYkY^]hdY[]lgc]]hl`]aj
egf]q`YkZ]]f^gmf\ZqYfmeZ]jg^klm\a]klg`Yn]hjgeakaf_
]^^][lk&AfC]fqY$YjYf\gear]\]ph]jae]fll`Ylogjc]\oal`))+
JglYlaf_KYnaf_kYf\;j]\al9kkg[aYlagfk JGK;9k!25 observed
l`Yll`gk]o`go]j]_an]fY[[]kklgkaehd]kYnaf_k\]na[]k$km[`
YkYkY^]Zgp Ye]lYdZgplgo`a[`l`]kYn]j`]d\l`]c]q!$kYo
YkmZklYflaYdafn]kle]flafhj]n]flan]`]Ydl`afl`]^gddgoaf_
q]Yj&26Af;`ad]$Y[[]kklgY^j]]Yf\]Ykq%lg%mk]kYnaf_kY[[gmfl
^gjdgo%af[ge]E>A[da]flkoYk^gmf\lgj]\m[]l`]\]h]f\]f[]
g^l`]k][da]flkgfk`gjl%l]je\]Zl^jgeZgl`af^gjeYdf]logjck
Yf\egf]qd]f\]jk$Yf\lgaf[j]Yk][gfkmehlagfkeggl`af_Yf\
gn]jYddo]dd%Z]af_g^hYjla[ahYflk&27KaeadYjdqafF]hYd$jYf\gear]\
Y[[]kklg^j]]Yf\]Ykq%lg%mk]kYnaf_kY[[gmflk^gj^]eYd]
`]Y\kg^`gmk]`gd\kd]\lgaf[j]Yk]\kYnaf_kYf\Ykk]lk$Yko]dd
Ykafn]kle]flkaf`]Ydl`Yf\]\m[Ylagf&*0AfEYdYoa$hjgna\af_
Y[[]kklgkYnaf_kY[[gmflklgjmjYd^Yje]jkj]kmdl]\afaf[j]Yk]\
afhmlmkY_]$`a_`]j[jghkYd]kYf\_j]Yl]j`gmk]`gd\]ph]f\almj]
gn]jl`]kmZk]im]flY_ja[mdlmjYdq]Yj&*1@go]n]j$l`]kh][aÕ[k
g^l`]Y[[gmflkYf\l`][gfl]plk]]elgeYll]jka_faÕ[Yfldq&
Afo]kl]jfC]fqY$Yklm\qgZk]jn]\l`Yll`gm_`l`]j]oYk.+
lYc]%mhg^Y[[gmflkY^l]jl`]gh]faf_^]]oYkoYan]\$gfdq)0
Y[lan]dqmk]\l`]Y[[gmflk&9mk]jkmjn]qj]Ö][l]\ljmklakkm]k$
[gf[]jfkYZgmlhggjk]jna[]Yf\`a_`oal`\jYoYd[gklkYkZYjja]jk
lgY[[gmflmkY_]&30
*-&JGK;9kYj]_jgmhkg^af\ana\mYdko`g[gf_j]_Yl]lg_]l`]jgfYj]_mdYjZYkaklgeYc]
[gfljaZmlagfklgY^mf\$o`a[`aflmjfoaddZ]_an]flggf]af\ana\mYd]Y[`lae]afjglYlagf&Afl`]
[Yk]g^l`ak]ph]jae]fl$egj]l`Yf/(g^l`]JGK;9hYjla[ahYflko]j]oge]f&
*.&HYk[Ydaf]<mhYkYf\BgfYl`YfJgZafkgf$ÉO`q<gfÌll`]HggjKYn]Egj]7=na\]f[]^jge
@]Ydl`KYnaf_k=ph]jae]flk$ÊThe American Economic Review,*()+$103 ,!$hh&))+0Ç/)&
*/&>]dah]CYklYf\<afYHge]jYfr$É<gKYnaf_k;gfkljYaflkD]Y\lgAf\]Zl]\f]kk7=ph]jae]flYd
=na\]f[]^jge9[[]kklg>gjeYdKYnaf_k9[[gmflkaf;`ad]$ÊHarvard Business School Working
Paper 14-001,*()+&SHd]Yk]hjgna\]l`]fYe]g^l`]ogjcaf_hYh]j&U
*0&KadnaYHjafY$É:Yfcaf_l`]HggjNaYKYnaf_k9[[gmflk2=na\]f[]^jgeY>a]d\=ph]jae]fl$ÊCase
Western Reserve Working Paper,*()+&
*1&DYkk]:jmf]$B]kka[Y?gd\Z]j_$PYna]j?af†Yf\<]YfQYf_$É;geeale]flklgKYn]29>a]d\
=ph]jae]flafJmjYdEYdYoa$ÊBureau for Economic Analysis of Development Working Paper,*()+&
+(&HYk[Ydaf]<mhYk$KYjY`?j]]f$9fl`gfqC]YlkYf\BgfYl`YfJgZafkgf$É;`Ydd]f_]kaf:Yfcaf_
l`]JmjYdHggj2=na\]f[]^jgeC]fqYkO]kl]jfHjgnaf[]ÊNBER Working Paper 17851,*()*&
L`]k]Õf\af_kkm__]kll`YlY[[]kklgkYnaf_kn]`a[d]k[Yf`Yn]
Yka_faÕ[YflaehY[lgfhYjla[ahYflkÌgn]jYddkYnaf_k&Afj][]fl
q]Yjk$eYfqklm\a]k`Yn]YfYdqr]\e][`Yfakeklg`]dhl`]hggj
kYn]egj]&EYfqg^l`]kYnaf_k[geeale]fl\]na[]kYnYadYZd]lg
l`gk]af`a_`dq\]n]dgh]\][gfgea]k$km[`Yk\aj][l\]hgkalk^jge
oY_]kaflgkYnaf_kY[[gmfl$Yj]fglYnYadYZd]lgl`]hggjYf\
hYjla[mdYjdql`gk]ogjcaf_Ykaf\]h]f\]fl]flj]hj]f]mjkgjafl`]
af^gjeYd][gfgeq&
K]n]jYd[geeale]fl\]na[]k^gjdgo%af[ge]hghmdYlagfk`Yn]
Z]]fYfYdqr]\&Oal`\jYoYd[geeale]fl\]na[]kj]klja[ll`]
lae]kYf\'gjkalmYlagfkafo`a[`egf]q[YfZ]oal`\jYof&
<]hgkal[geeale]fl\]na[]k]f[gmjY_]j]_mdYj\]hgkalkaflgl`]
Y[[gmflk&9jYf\gear]\]ph]jae]floal`YZYfcafl`]H`adahhaf]k
k`go]\l`YlYn]jY_]kYnaf_kaf[j]Yk]\Zqegj]l`Yf0(^gj
[da]flko`go]j]g^^]j]\Yoal`\jYoYd[geeale]fl\]na[]$
o`a[`j]klja[l]\Y[[]kklg\]hgkalklgkh][aÕ[hmjhgk]kgjlae]
h]jag\k$ZYk]\gfl`][da]flÌkhj]%kh][aÕ]\afkljm[lagfk&L`]
]^^][lh]jkakl]\^gj)*egfl`kY^l]jl`]klm\q$k`goaf_YdYklaf_
[`Yf_]\m]lgl`]afl]jn]flagf&31Af;`ad]$Y\]hgkal[geeale]fl
\]na[]oYk]nYdmYl]\$o`]j]hYjla[ahYflkeY\]Y[geeale]fl
^gjj]_mdYj\]hgkalklgl`]ajh]]j_jgmhafl`]E>A$Yf\j]_mdYjdq
egfalgj]\]Y[`gl`]jÌk\]hgkalY[`a]n]e]flk&L`akd]\lgY
+&-%^gd\af[j]Yk]afl`]ZYdYf[]g^l`]Y[[gmflk&32
L`]kYe]klm\qYdkg]nYdmYl]\l`]mk]g^[]ddh`gf]l][`fgdg_q
afl`ak[gfl]plYf\^gmf\l`Yll]ple]kkY_]khjgna\af_^]]\ZY[c
gf[da]flkÌkm[[]kklgoYj\l`]ajj]_mdYj\]hgkal_gYdkqa]d\]\
YdegklYkkljgf_Yj]kmdlYkl`]h]]j_jgmhegfalgjaf_&L`j]]
jYf\gear]\]nYdmYlagfk[gf\m[l]\oal`ZYfc[mklge]jkafH]jm$
:gdanaYYf\l`]H`adahhaf]kYdkgl]kl]\l`]aehY[lg^j]_mdYj
e]kkY_]k&9egfl`dql]ple]kkY_]gjd]ll]jj]eaf\]jj]kmdl]\
afY+`a_`]j[`Yf[]g^j]Y[`af_YkYnaf_k_gYdYf\.`a_`]j
kYnaf_kd]n]dk&33
+)&FYnY9k`jY^$<]YfCYjdYfYf\O]kd]qQaf$ÉLqaf_G\qkk]mklgl`]EYkl2=na\]f[]^jgeY
;geeale]flKYnaf_kHjg\m[lafl`]H`adahhaf]k$ÊQuarterly Journal of Economics,*((.$)*) )!$
hh&.+-Ç./*&
+*&>]dah]CYkl$Kl]h`YfE]a]j$Yf\<afYHge]jYfr$ÉMf\]j%KYn]jk9fgfqegmk2=na\]f[]gf
K]d^%@]dh?jgmhkYf\H]]jHj]kkmj]YkYKYnaf_k;geeale]fl<]na[]$ÊNBER Working Paper No.
18417,*()*&
++&FYnY9k`jY^$<]YfCYjdYfYf\O]kd]qQaf$É>]eYd]=ehgo]je]fl2AehY[lg^Y;geeale]fl
KYnaf_kHjg\m[lafl`]H`adahhaf]k$ÊWorld Development+0&+ *()(!2+++Ç+,,&
L`]hjgeak]g^ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\oge]fÌk]ehgo]je]fl
)-
<a^^]j]flaYdaehY[lk^gjoge]f
AfeYfqkg[a]la]k$oge]feYq^Y[]Y\\alagfYdZYjja]jklg`Ynaf_
Yk][mj]hdY[]^gjkYnaf_k$km__]klaf_l`Yll`]qea_`lhgl]flaYddq
Z]f]Õlegj]^jgeY[[]kklgkYnaf_khjg\m[lkl`Yfe]f&9klm\q
[gf\m[l]\afC]fqYl`Ylhjgna\]\ZYfcY[[gmflkoal`fggh]faf_
^]]kZml`a_`oal`\jYoYd^]]klg^]eYd]eYjc]ln]f\gjkYf\
eYd]lYpa\jan]jkgZk]jn]\l`Yloge]fmk]\l`]ajY[[gmflegj]
Y[lan]dql`Yfe]fYf\af[j]Yk]\l`]ajlglYdkYnaf_ko`ad]e]f
\a\fgl&34>gmjlgkapegfl`kY^l]jgh]faf_l`]Y[[gmfl$oge]f
o`gj][]an]\l`]Y[[gmflk`Y\+0Ç-.`a_`]j\Yadqafn]kle]fl
afl`]ajZmkaf]kk]kYf\+/`a_`]j\Yadq]ph]f\almj]kl`Yfl`]
[gehYjakgf_jgmhl`Yl\a\fglj][]an]YfY[[gmfl&9kaeadYj]^^][l
oYkfglgZk]jn]\^gje]f&L`]oge]foal`kYnaf_kY[[gmflk
o]j]Ydkgd]kknmdf]jYZd]lg`]Ydl`k`g[ckkaf[]l`]q\a\fgl`Yn]
lgj]\m[]l`]ajZmkaf]kkafn]kle]fllg[gh]oal`l`]k`g[c&
9fgl`]joYqafo`a[`_]f\]jakj]d]nYfl^gjkYnaf_kYj]
\a^^]j]f[]kafafljY%`gmk]`gd\hj]^]j]f[]kYf\ZYj_Yafaf_hgo]j
Z]lo]]fe]fYf\oge]f&Mf\]jklYf\af_l`]k]\qfYea[k[Yf
`Yn]aehgjlYflaehda[Ylagfk^gjhjg\m[l\]ka_f&Afl`]H`adahhaf]k$
oge]fo`g`Y\Z]]fg^^]j]\Y[[]kklgY[geeale]flkYnaf_k
+,&HYk[Ydaf]<mhYkYf\BgfYl`YfJgZafkgf$ÉKYnaf_k;gfkljYaflkYf\Ea[jg]fl]jhjak]
<]n]dghe]fl2=na\]f[]^jgeY>a]d\=ph]jae]flafC]fqY$ÊAmerican Economic Journal: Applied
Economics,*()+$- )!$hh&).+Ç)1*&
).
Y[[gmflo]j]YZd]lgka_faÕ[Yfldqaf[j]Yk]l`]ajhgo]jaf
`gmk]`gd\\][akagf%eYcaf_&359fgl`]jklm\qafC]fqY_Yn]
[gmhd]kl`]ghlagfg^[`ggkaf_Z]lo]]faf\ana\mYdYf\bgafl
kYnaf_kY[[gmflk&L`]afl]j]kljYl]]Yjf]\gfl`]k]Y[[gmflk
oYkjYf\gear]\&L`]klm\q^gmf\l`Yl[gmhd]koal`kaeadYj
hj]^]j]f[]kYf\\ak[gmfl^Y[lgjkY\bmkl]\l`]aj[`ga[]lglYc]
l`]Y[[gmfloal`l`]`a_`]klj]lmjf&@go]n]j$[gmhd]ko`g
`Y\\akkaeadYjhj]^]j]f[]kl]f\]\lghj]^]jaf\ana\mYddqgof]\
Y[[gmflk$]n]fa^l`]afl]j]klgfl`]bgaflY[[gmfloYk`a_`]j$
l`mk^gj_gaf_egj]l`Yf-0g^l`]hgl]flaYdafl]j]kll`]q[gmd\
`Yn]]Yjf]\gfl`]ajkYnaf_k&36AfljY%`gmk]`gd\hj]^]j]f[]kl`mk
ka_faÕ[YfldqaehY[l]\kYnaf_kZ]`Ynagj&
Kaf[]eYfq[gmflja]kkladdj]imaj]`mkZYf\klgka_f^gj^]eYd]
ZYfcY[[gmfl`gd\]jk$Yf\Y[[]kklgkYnaf_kn]`a[d]kakmf]n]fdq
\akljaZml]\$_]f\]j]imYdalqakkladdYfaehgjlYfl[gfka\]jYlagf
afl`akYj]Y&L`akakhYjla[mdYjdqj]d]nYfl_an]fl`]^Y[ll`Yle]f
Yf\oge]fg^l]f`Yn]kmZklYflaYddq\a^^]j]flhj]^]j]f[]kgf
`goem[`lgkYn]Yf\`golgmk]l`]egf]q&Mf\]jklYf\af_
l`]k]akkm]k[Yf`]dhE>Akl`YlYj]Y[lan]afl`]ea[jgkYnaf_k
khY[]lgaehjgn]l`]ajhjg\m[lklgZ]ll]jk]jn]l`]aj^]eYd]
[mklge]jkÌf]]\k&
+-&<]YfCYjdYf$9ak`oYjqYJYlYfYf\BgfYl`YfRafeYf$ÉKYnaf_kZqYf\^gjl`]Hggj2
9J]k]Yj[`J]na]oYf\9_]f\Y$ÊReview of Income and Wealth,*()+&
+.&K[`Yf]j$K&?&$É<gGhhgkal]k<]ljY[l7AfljY`gmk]`gd\Hj]^]j]f[]@]l]jg_]f]alqYf\
Af]^Õ[a]flKljYl]_a[KYnaf_k$ÊDartmouth College Working Paper,Bmdq*()+&
L`]hjgeak]g^ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\oge]fÌk]ehgo]je]fl
06
Ea[jgafkmjYf[]
=na\]f[] gf ea[jgafkmjYf[]
L`]hggj^Y[]YdYj_]\]_j]]g^jakcYf\afklYZadalqlgZgl`l`]ajaf[ge]Yf\]ph]f\almj]f]]\k&Km[`
Öm[lmYlagfk[Yfkl]e$^gj]pYehd]$^jge`]Ydl`Yf\o]Yl`]jk`g[ckYf\^j]im]flmf]ehdgqe]flkh]ddk&9ll`]
kYe]lae]$l`]hggj`Yn]em[`d]kkY[[]kklg^gjeYdafkmjYf[]hjg\m[lkl`Yfl`gk]danaf_Yf\ogjcaf_af`a_`dq
\]n]dgh]\eYjc]lk&Ea[jgafkmjYf[]hjg\m[lkYj]afl]f\]\lgÕddl`akeYjc]l_Yh&@go]n]j$]n]fl`gm_`l`]qYj]
l`gm_`llg`gd\ka_faÕ[Yflhjgeak]^gjl`]hggj$lYc]%mhg^l`]k]hjg\m[lk`Ykkg^YjZ]]fj]dYlan]dqdgo&Gf]
j]YkgfeYqZ]l`]\gmZd]%ka\]\Ykqee]lja[af^gjeYlagfhjgZd]e\ak[mkk]\YZgn]l`Ylafkmj]jkYj]^Y[]\oal`&
9_jgoaf_j]k]Yj[`Yj]Yakk]]caf_lg]pYeaf]l`]mf\]jdqaf_j]Ykgf^gjdgolYc]%mhYf\hgkkaZd]kgdmlagfk&
AfAf\aY$YjYf\gear]\Õ]d\]ph]jae]fll`YlYae]\lgl]kll`]aehgjlYf[]g^hja[]Yf\fgf%hja[]^Y[lgjkaf
\]l]jeafaf_\]eYf\^gjjYaf^YddafkmjYf[]^gmf\l`YldY[cg^ljmkl$hggjÕfYf[aYddal]jY[qYf\[gfkljYaflkgf
daima\alq[gmd\Z]ZYjja]jklgl`]lYc]%mhg^ea[jgafkmjYf[]hjg\m[lk&379fgl`]jklm\qafAf\aY^gmf\l`Yl^Yje]jk
o`go]j]g^^]j]\afkmjYf[]afn]kl]\afjakca]j$jYaf%k]fkalan][jghkl`Ylqa]d\`a_`]jYn]jY_]hjgÕlk&+09klm\q
oal`.((keYdd%k[Yd]^Yje]jkafAf\aYo`go]j]g^^]j]\jYaf^YddafkmjYf[]Ydkg]pYeaf]\ZYjja]jklg\]eYf\Zq
jYf\gearaf_ÕfYf[aYdljYafaf_lgYkmZk]lg^^Yje]jk&L`akoYk^gmf\lg\gmZd]l`]lYc]%mh^jge0lg).&+1
L`]k]j]kmdlkkm__]kll`YlYkk]kkaf_`gmk]`gd\kÌf]]\kafY[gehj]`]fkan]eYff]jYf\lYadgjaf_hjg\m[lklgÕl
[da]flkÌ[aj[meklYf[]k[YfZggkl\]eYf\^gjkm[`afkmjYf[]hjg\m[lk&
+/&K`Yof;gd]$PYna]j?af†$B]j]eqLgZY[eYf$H]laYLghYdgnY$JgZ]jlLgofk]f\Yf\BYe]kNa[c]jq$É:Yjja]jklg@gmk]`gd\JakcEYfY_]e]fl2=na\]f[]^jgeAf\aY$Ê
American Economic Journal: Applied Economics,*()+$- )!$hh&)(,Ç)+-&
+0&K`Yof;gd]$PYna]j?af†Yf\BYe]kNa[c]jq$É@go<g]kJakcEYfY_]e]flAfÖm]f[]Hjg\m[lagf<][akagfk7=na\]f[]^jgeY>a]d\=ph]jae]fl$ÊHarvard Business
School Working Paper,*()+&
+1&KYjl`Yc?YmjYn$K`Yof;gd]Yf\B]j]eqLgZY[eYf$ÉEYjc]laf_;gehd]p>afYf[aYdHjg\m[lkaf=e]j_af_EYjc]lk2=na\]f[]^jgeJYaf^YddAfkmjYf[]afAf\aY$ÊJournal
of Marketing Research,0&KHD *())!2K)-(%K).*&
L`]hjgeak]g^ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\oge]fÌk]ehgo]je]fl
)/
Jakc[YfYdkgZ]Y^Y[lgjl`Yldaealkafn]kle]flkafaf[ge]%
qa]d\af_Ykk]lk$Zmkaf]kkghhgjlmfala]kgjf]ol][`fgdg_a]k$l`mk
^mjl`]jdaealaf_l`]k[gh]^gjaf[ge]_jgol`&AfjmjYd?`YfY$Yf
]ph]jae]fl[gf\m[l]\oal`egj]l`Yf)$)((^Yje]jk^gmf\l`Yl
\]eYf\^gjjYaf^YddafkmjYf[]oYkkljgf_Yf\afkmjYf[]d]\lg
ka_faÕ[Yfldq`a_`]jY_ja[mdlmjYdafn]kle]flYf\jakca]jhjg\m[lagf
[`ga[]k&9_Yaf$l`]]na\]f[]km__]kl]\l`Ylaeh]j^][lljmkll`Yl
hjgeak]\hYqgmlkogmd\]n]flmYddqZ]\]dan]j]\[Yfdaeall`]
\]eYf\&9^l]jj][]anaf_l`]hYqgmlk$l`]hmj[`Yk]g^afkmjYf[]
af[j]Yk]\&40L`]k]Õf\af_k[Yf`Yn]nYdmYZd]aehda[Ylagfk^gj
E>AkYf\hgda[qeYc]jkgfhjg\m[l\]ka_f$jakcklg[gn]jYf\
afl]jn]flagfklghjgegl]afn]kle]fl&
07
<a^^]j]flaYdaehY[lk^gjoge]f
Hggjoge]f`Yn]mfaim]Yf\kh][aÕ[f]]\kl`Ylj]imaj]
[gn]jY_]È^gjafklYf[]$oge]f[gmd\Z]egj]kmk[]hlaZd]
lgkh][aÕ[`]Ydl`jakckYjakaf_^jgehj]_fYf[qYf\[`ad\Zajl`
Yf\Yj]g^l]fegj]nmdf]jYZd]lg\ge]kla[nagd]f[]Yf\dgkk
g^af[ge]\m]lgl`]\]Yl`g^l`]ajkhgmk]&41AfkmZ%KY`YjYf
9^ja[Y$YogeYf`YkY)af+)[`Yf[]g^\qaf_^jgehj]_fYf[q
Yf\[`ad\Zajl`[gehda[Ylagfk$o`ad]l`]jakcak)af,$+((afl`]
\]n]dgh]\ogjd\&42
L`mk$_]f\]j%k]fkalan]ea[jgafkmjYf[]hjg\m[lkl`YlY\\j]kk
l`]k]kh][aÕ[f]]\kY^^gj\YZdqhj]k]flYdYj_]mf\]j]phdgj]\
hgl]flaYd^gjl`]ea[jgÕfYf[]af\mkljq&:Yf[gKgd$YfE>AZYk]\af
:gdanaY$^gj]pYehd]$g^^]jkY`]Ydl`ea[jgafkmjYf[]hjg_jYel`Yl
af[dm\]k^mddeYl]jfalq[gn]jY_]&Oal`.*lYc]%mh$l`akhjg\m[lak
^gmf\lg`Yn]`a_`]j\]eYf\Yegf_oge]f[gehYj]\lgY,-
k`Yj]g^oge]fYegf_:Yf[gKgd[j]\al[da]flk&43
,(&<]YfCYjdYf$JgZ]jlGk]a$AkYY[Gk]a%9cglgYf\;`jaklgh`]jM\jq$É9_ja[mdlmjYd<][akagfk9^l]j
J]dYpaf_;j]\alYf\Jakc;gfkljYaflk$ÊYale University Working Paper,*()+&
,)&9fbYda:Yfl`aY$KmkYfBg`fkgf$Ea[`Y]dBE[;gj\Yf\:jYf\gfEYl`]ok$ÉEa[jgafkmjYf[]
l`YlOgjck^gjOge]f2EYcaf_?]f\]j%K]fkalan]Ea[jgafkmjYf[]Hjg_jYek$ÊAfl]jfYlagfYdDYZgj
Gj_YfarYlagf$*((1&
,*&Ogjd\:YfcKlY^^$ÉOgjd\<]n]dghe]flJ]hgjl*()*2?]f\]j=imYdalqYf\<]n]dghe]fl$Ê
L`]Ogjd\:Yfc$*())&
,+&9fbYda:Yfl`aY$KmkYfBg`fkgf$:jYf\gfEYl`]ok$Yf\Ea[`Y]dBE[;gj\$ÉEa[jgafkmjYf[]
l`YlOgjck^gjOge]f2EYcaf_?]f\]j%K]fkalan]Ea[jgafkmjYf[]Hjg_jYek$ÊAfl]jfYlagfYdDYZgj
Gj_YfarYlagf$*((1&
)0
L`]hjgeak]g^ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\oge]fÌk]ehgo]je]fl
;gf[dmkagf
Yf\gmldggc
L`]ea[jgÕfYf[][geemfalqak[mjj]fldqmf\]j_gaf_Yhjg^gmf\
]ngdmlagf&9^l]j]Yjdq]pmZ]jYfl]fl`mkaYke$hYjla[mdYjdq^gj
ea[jg[j]\al$Yf\dYl]j\akaddmkagfe]fl$f]ol][`fgdg_a]kZgl`
afl`]e]l`g\kg^]nYdmYlagfYf\afk]jna[]\]dan]jqeYc]Y
fmYf[]\$hjY_eYla[Yf\affgnYlan]f]oYhhjgY[`hgkkaZd]&
;gehYj]\oal`gl`]jkg[aYd]fl]jhjak]k][lgjk$ea[jgÕfYf[]`Yk
`Y\Yhagf]]jaf_jgd]af]eZjY[af_Yf\hjgeglaf_l`]mk]g^
ja_gjgmkjYf\gear]\]nYdmYlagfklgYkk]kkl`]]^^][lan]f]kkg^alk
hjg\m[lkYf\lg[gflafm]aehjgnaf_alkk]jna[]k&
O`ad]Yf][\glYd]na\]f[]`YkZ]]fhml^gjoYj\Zgl`^gjn]jq
ghlaeakla[na]okgfea[jgÕfYf[] ]&_&$YeYraf_É^jgejY_klg
ja[`]kÊklgja]k!Yf\^gj\akeYdh]jkh][lan]k ]&_&$[Yk]kg^kma[a\]k
Zqea[jg[j]\al[da]flk!$ja_gjgmkjYf\gear]\klm\a]kYddgo^gjY
fmYf[]\$j]daYZd]YfYdqkak&KaeadYjlg9':l]klaf_afl`]klYjl%mh
]flj]hj]f]mjk`ah[mdlmj]$jYf\gear]\[gfljgdd]\ljaYdkhjgna\]
Yja_gjgmkoYqlggZlYafj]daYZd]j]kmdlkl`Yl_gZ]qgf\o`Yl
[YfZ]d]Yjf]\^jgeYf][\glYd]na\]f[]gjj]ljgkh][lan]\YlY
YfYdqkak&Gl`]jkg[aYdk][lgjk[Yfd]Yjf^jgel`akd]Y\af_jgd]g^
l`]ea[jgÕfYf[]af\mkljq&
EYfq]pYehd]kafl`]ea[jgÕfYf[]af\mkljqk`gol`]_j]Yl
j]kmdlkl`Yl[YfZ]Y[`a]n]\o`]fd]Y\]jk^jgeZgl`j]k]Yj[`Yf\
hjY[la[]ogjclg_]l`]jlg_]f]jYl]emlmYddqZ]f]Õ[aYdafka_`lk
Yf\Y[`a]n]e]flk&L`]k][gddYZgjYlagfk`Yn]dYj_]hgl]flaYd
lghmk`l`]]^^][lan]f]kkg^\a^^]j]flea[jgÕfYf[]k]jna[]klg
f]od]n]dk&O]`Yn]d]Yjf]\l`Yl[`Yf_af_keYdd^]Ylmj]kg^l`]
hjg\m[lk$km[`Ykl`]j]hYqe]flk[`]\md]g^ea[jgdgYfk$^gddgo%
mhl]ple]kkY_]klg]f[gmjY_]\]hgkalkgjnYjqaf_kljm[lmj]k
g^l`]h]]j_jgmhdaYZadalqYf\kmhhgjl[Yf`Yn]aehgjlYfl
aehY[lkgfZgl`l`]kg[aYdaehY[lYf\l`]ÕfYf[aYdnaYZadalqg^
ea[jgÕfYf[]hjg\m[lk&
Egj]affgnYlagfg^l`aklqh]akf]]\]\$hYjla[mdYjdqafda_`l
g^f]o[`Ydd]f_]kYf\ghhgjlmfala]kl`Yl^Y[]ea[jgÕfYf[]
lg\Yq&Im]klagfkg^l`]j]_mdYlgjq]fnajgfe]flYj]Yll`]
^gj]^jgfljYf_af_^jge[gfkme]jhjgl][lagfafea[jg[j]\alYf\
ea[jgafkmjYf[]hjg\m[lk$lgZYfcaf_j]_mdYlagfl`YloaddYddgo
E>AklglYc]kYnaf_k\]hgkalk^gjl`]aj[da]flkYf\^Y[adalYl]
l`]mk]g^egZad]ZYfcaf_&Eg\]jfl][`fgdg_a]kl`jgm_`[]dd
h`gf]k$afl]jf]lYf\kg[aYde]\aYgh]ff]oYf\hjgeakaf_
hgkkaZadala]k&L`]k]ghhgjlmfala]k`Yn]hYjla[mdYjdqdYj_]
hgl]flaYdo`]f[geZaf]\oal`f]oafka_`lk^jgeZ]`YnagjYd
][gfgea[kgfakkm]kjYf_af_^jgek]d^%[gfljgdeYfY_]e]fllg
ljmkl%Zmad\af_^]Ylmj]klg^Y[adalYl]lYc]%mhg^ea[jgafkmjYf[]
Yf\hkq[`ge]lja[[Yd[mdYlagfkg^[j]\aljakck&
L`]fmYf[]\j]kmdlkgfl`]aehY[lkYf\]^^][lan]f]kkg^
\a^^]j]flea[jgÕfYf[]k]jna[]kk`gol`Ylo`ad]l`]af\mkljq
[YfhdYqYka_faÕ[Yfljgd]af[dgkaf_l`]_]f\]j_Yhogjd\oa\]$
alakbmklgf]Ykh][lYegf_eYfql`YlYj]f]]\]\lgY[`a]n]
l`Yl_gYd&Gn]jYddlj]f\kgfl`]_]f\]j_YhYj]hjgeakaf_&
Afl`]dYkl]a_`lq]Yjk$kaf[]l`]?dgZYd?]f\]j?YhAf\]p
`YkZ]]fe]Ykmj]\Zql`]Ogjd\=[gfgea[>gjme$l`]j]
`Yn]Z]]feYjc]\aehjgn]e]flk$hYjla[mdYjdqafl`]Yj]Yk
g^hgdala[Yd]ehgo]je]fl$][gfgea[hYjla[ahYlagfYf\
ghhgjlmfala]k&@go]n]j$l`]j]akkladdYdgf_oYqlg_glg
Y[`a]n]]imYdghhgjlmfala]k^gjoge]fYf\e]fogjd\oa\]&
L`jgm_`[gflafm]\affgnYlagf$[geZaf]\oal`[Yj]^md
]nYdmYlagfYf\]na\]f[]%ZYk]\d]Yjfaf_$l`]ea[jgÕfYf[]
af\mkljq[YfhdYqYfaehgjlYflhYjllg[gfljaZml]lgl`ak_gYd&
L`akakhYjla[mdYjdql`][Yk]kaf[]ea[jgÕfYf[]akgf]g^l`]
n]jq^]oafklalmlagfkl`YlYlljY[lYfgn]jo`]deaf_k`Yj]g^
oge]f$Yf\[Yfl`]j]^gj]$k]jn]YkYhgl]flaYdn]`a[d]^gj
^]eYd]]ehgo]je]flafeYfqoYqk&
L`]hjgeak]g^ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\oge]fÌk]ehgo]je]fl
)1
9Zgmll`]
Yml`gjk
EY
L`akl`gm_`ld]Y\]jk`ah
hYh]jZq<afYHge]jYfrak
hmZdak`]\Zq=QYkhYjlg^gmj
dgf_klYf\af_]f_Y_]e]floal`
ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\kmhhgjl^gj
^]eYd]]flj]hj]f]mjk
9kY_dgZYdd]Y\]jafYkkmjYf[]$lYp$ljYfkY[lagfYf\Y\nakgjq
k]jna[]k$o]kmhhgjlgmj[da]flkafYoa\]jYf_]g^af\mklja]k$
hdYqaf_Y[jala[Ydjgd]afZmad\af_YZ]ll]jogjcaf_ogjd\^gj
gmjh]ghd]$[da]flkYf\[geemfala]k&O]^gddgoYfafl]_jYl]\
YhhjgY[`l`Yl`]dhkgmj[da]flk\jan]_jgol`Yf\afljg\m[]
affgnYlagfafY_dgZYdar]\ogjd\&9dgf_oal`l`]ljY\alagfYdk]jna[]
g^^]jaf_$o]hjgna\]lYadgj]\kgdmlagfkafaffgnYlan]Õ]d\k$km[`
Ykea[jgÕfYf[]$]flj]hj]f]mjk`ah$]fnajgfe]flYd$kg[aYdYf\
_gn]jfYf[]&
<afYHge]jYfrakY^Y[mdlqe]eZ]jYll`]@YjnYj\:mkaf]kk
K[`ggd$o`]j]k`][gf\m[lkj]k]Yj[`gfhmZda[hgda[a]k
lgoYj\ÕjekYf\]flj]hj]f]mjkaf]e]j_af_eYjc]lk&Af
hYjla[mdYj$k`]`Ykaehd]e]fl]\dYj_]%k[Yd]jYf\gear]\Õ]d\
]ph]jae]flkYZgml\]l]jeafYflkYf\aehY[lkg^ea[jgkYnaf_k
^gjdgoaf[ge]ea[jg%]flj]hj]f]mjkYf\YZgmlÕjelYp
]nYkagf&Af`]j[mjj]flogjc$k`]akYfYdqraf_l`]aehY[l
g^lYpkmZka\a]kYf\hmZda[hjg[mj]e]flj]_mdYlagfkgf
afn]kle]flYf\_jgol`g^keYddYf\e]\ame]fl]jhjak]kaf
]e]j_af_eYjc]lk&
=Qakafngdn]\afea[jgÕfYf[]^jge\a^^]j]flh]jkh][lan]k&O]
kmhhgjleYafea[jgÕfYf[]afklalmlagfk E>Ak!oal`[gehj]`]fkan]
[da]flg^^]jaf_kjYf_af_^jgeYkkmjYf[]lgkh][aYdar]\Y\nakgjq
k]jna[]k&Egj]gn]j$=QakYk]jna[]hjgna\]jlgÕfYf[aYdk]jna[]k
gj_YfarYlagfkY[lan]afl`]ea[jgÕfYf[]af\mkljq&F]pllg
ea[jgÕfYf[]Z]af_YZmkaf]kkhjghgkalagf$alYdkgÕlkafgmj
kmklYafYZadalqgZb][lan]k&O]ogjcoal`eYfqgj_YfarYlagfkgf
^mf\jYakaf_Yf\hjgZgfgafalaYlan]kafl`]Õ]d\g^ea[jgÕfYf[]
Yf\kg[aYd]flj]hj]f]mjk`ah&AfY\\alagf$kaf[])10.$o]`Yn]
Z]]f[]d]ZjYlaf_km[[]kk^md]flj]hj]f]mjkYddgn]jl`]ogjd\
l`jgm_`l`]=Q=flj]hj]f]mjG^L`]Q]Yj¢Hjg_jYe&
Hjg^]kkgjHge]jYfrakY^Y[mdlqj]k]Yj[`^]ddgoYll`]FYlagfYd
:mj]Ymg^=[gfgea[J]k]Yj[` F:=J!$YfY^ÕdaYl]hjg^]kkgj
Yll`]9Z\mdDYla^BYe]]dHgn]jlq9[lagfDYZ B%H9D!$Yf\
Ye]eZ]jg^l`]Afl]jfYlagfYd?jgol`;]flj] A?;!ZYk]\
YlDK='Gp^gj\$Yf\g^l`]@:KKg[aYd=fl]jhjak]AfalaYlan]&
Hjagjlgbgafaf_@YjnYj\:mkaf]kkK[`ggd$k`]k]jn]\YkY
hgkl\g[lgjYd^]ddgoYlEALÌk9Z\mdDYla^BYe]]dHgn]jlq9[lagf
DYZ$Y^l]jklm\qaf_afl]jfYlagfYdj]dYlagfkYll`]?jY\mYl]
Afklalml]g^Afl]jfYlagfYdKlm\a]kaf?]f]nYYf\gZlYafaf_Y
H`<af][gfgea[k^jge@YjnYj\Mfan]jkalq&
O]Yj]YoYj]g^l`]jgd]g^]flj]hj]f]mjk`ahYkY\jan]j^gj
affgnYlagfYf\[`Yf_]$Yf\o]Y[cfgod]\_]l`]jgd]g^oge]f
afhjgeglaf_][gfgea[Yf\kg[aYd_jgol`&O]]f\gjk]oge]fÌk
]ehgo]je]fll`jgm_`nYjagmkafalaYlan]kkm[`Ykl`]=QYffmYd
Afl]jfYlagfYdOge]fÌk<Yq[YehYa_f$l`]=Q=flj]hj]f]mjaYd
Oaffaf_Oge]f¢Hjg_jYeYf\\]\a[Yl]\]n]flkkm[`Ykl`]
=QYf\>gjZ]kj][]hlagflg[]d]ZjYl]oge]fÌkd]Y\]jk`ahYll`]
9ffmYdOgjd\=[gfgea[>gjmeE]]laf_&
<afYHge]jYfr
:]ka\]k`]jY[Y\]ea[afl]j]klk$<afYHge]jYfr`YkZ]]f
Y[lan]afYnYja]lqg^gj_YfarYlagfk$af[dm\af_YkY[gfkmdlYfl
lgl`]Ogjd\:Yfc$l`]KoakkKlYl]K][j]lYjaYl^gj=[gfgea[
9^^Yajk$Yf\l`];`ad]YfYf\=[mY\gjaYfLYp9ml`gjala]k&
K`]akYdkgY[lan]dqafngdn]\afYfmeZ]jg^kg[aYd]fl]jhjak]
n]flmj]k[geeall]\lgljYfkdYlaf_j]k]Yj[`aflghjY[la[]&Af
l`ak[YhY[alq$k`]k]jn]kgfl`]ZgYj\g^=na\]f[]9[lagfYf\
L9EL9EÈLg_]l`]j9_YafklEYdYjaYYf\gfl`]Y\nakgjq
ZgYj\g^Afkla_dagYf\A<afka_`l&
*(
Afgj\]jlgk`Yj]gmjafka_`loal`gmjklYc]`gd\]jkYf\ZjgY\]j
[geemfalq$o]`gklYnYja]lqg^]n]flk$hmZdak``a_`%imYdalq
l`gm_`ld]Y\]jk`ahYf\ojal]Yjla[d]kafl`aj\%hYjlqhmZda[Ylagfk&
>gjl`]ÕfYf[aYdk]jna[]kk][lgj$o]g^^]j^j]k`h]jkh][lan]kgf
c]qaf\mkljqakkm]kl`jgm_`l`]=Q?dgZYd>afYf[aYdK]jna[]k
Afklalml]l`Yloal`alkhmZda[Ylagf$The Journal of Financial
Perspectives,Zjaf_klg_]l`]jl`]egklhjgeaf]flhjY[lalagf]jk
Yf\Y[Y\]ea[kafl`]Õ]d\lg\ak[mkkl`]^mlmj]g^l`]af\mkljq&
L`]hjgeak]g^ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\oge]fÌk]ehgo]je]fl
Gl`]j=QhmZda[Ylagfk
=flj]hj]f]mjk`ah
L`]=Q?*(
=flj]hj]f]mjk`ah
:Yjge]l]jk]ja]k
9nga\af_Ydgkl
_]f]jYlagf
?dgZYdbgZ[j]Ylagf
kmjn]qk
Oge]fÌk
]ehgo]je]fl
=e]j_af_eYjc]lk
KmklYafYZadalq
Oge]f2L`]f]pl
]e]j_af_eYjc]l
9lljY[lan]f]kk
kmjn]qk
=E=A9>afYf[aYdK]jna[]k
KmklYafYZadalqJ]hgjl
Oge]fg^9^ja[Y2
9hgo]j^mdmflYhh]\][gfgea[
^gj[]^gjl`][gflaf]fl
JYha\%?jgol`EYjc]lk
>gj][Yklk]ja]k
L`]hjgeak]g^ea[jgÕfYf[]Yf\oge]fÌk]ehgo]je]fl
*)
=Q[gflY[lk
>gjegj]af^gjeYlagfgf=QÌkafngdn]e]flafea[jg^afYf[]$hd]Yk][gflY[l2
RYafY9`e]\%CYjae
G^Õ[]2#+)00,(/)(-)
EgZad]2#+).*1(0+0,0
rYafY&cYjae8fd&]q&[ge
EY t9kkmjYf[]tLYptLjYfkY[lagfkt9\nakgjq
9Zgml=Q
=QakY_dgZYdd]Y\]jafYkkmjYf[]$lYp$ljYfkY[lagfYf\Y\nakgjq
k]jna[]k&L`]afka_`lkYf\imYdalqk]jna[]ko]\]dan]j`]dhZmad\ljmklYf\
[gf^a\]f[]afl`][YhalYdeYjc]lkYf\af][gfgea]kl`]ogjd\gn]j&O]
\]n]dghgmlklYf\af_d]Y\]jko`gl]Yelg\]dan]jgfgmjhjgeak]klgYdd
g^gmjklYc]`gd\]jk&Afkg\gaf_$o]hdYqY[jala[Ydjgd]afZmad\af_YZ]ll]j
ogjcaf_ogjd\^gjgmjh]ghd]$^gjgmj[da]flkYf\^gjgmj[geemfala]k&
=Qj]^]jklgl`]_dgZYdgj_YfarYlagf$Yf\eYqj]^]jlggf]gjegj]$g^
l`]e]eZ]j^ajekg^=jfklQgmf_?dgZYdDaeal]\$]Y[`g^o`a[`akY
k]hYjYl]d]_Yd]flalq&=jfklQgmf_?dgZYdDaeal]\$YMC[gehYfqdaeal]\
Zq_mYjYfl]]$\g]kfglhjgna\]k]jna[]klg[da]flk&>gjegj]af^gjeYlagf
YZgmlgmjgj_YfarYlagf$hd]Yk]nakal]q&[ge&
¡*(),=Q?EDaeal]\&
9ddJa_`lkJ]k]jn]\&
=Q?fg&;I()(,
;K?'?K;*(),')+(*/*.
=<())L`akeYl]jaYd`YkZ]]fhj]hYj]\^gj_]f]jYdaf^gjeYlagfYdhmjhgk]kgfdqYf\akfglafl]f\]\
lgZ]j]da]\mhgfYkY[[gmflaf_$lYp$gjgl`]jhjg^]kkagfYdY\na[]&Hd]Yk]j]^]jlgqgmj
Y\nakgjk^gjkh][a^a[Y\na[]&
]q&[ge
BmklafY9d\]jk%K`]qY
G^Õ[]2#+)00,(/).*+
EgZad]2#+).*)*-*+1/
bmklafY&k`]qY8fd&]q&[ge