207 Molecular determinants of sink strength Karin Herbers and Uwe Sonnewald∗ The manipulation of sink to source relations has been subject to extensive plant breeding programs aiming to improve harvest index and thereby crop yield. The introduction of molecular and biochemical tools has enabled scientists to investigate the underlying principles. This has opened up the fascinating possibility of identifying molecular determinants of sink strength and to further increase yield on a rational basis. In the past, transgenic plants with alterations in the activity of only one putative molecular determinant have been created and this strategy has not resulted in substantial and reliable increases in yield. Yet, careful molecular and biochemical investigations have provided valuable insight about carbon flux into different metabolic pathways at different stages of sink development and it has become apparent that this metabolic channelling needs to be exploited by using stage- and cell-specific promoters in attempts to increase sink strength. Addresses Institut für Pflanzengenetik und Kulturpflanzenforschung, Corrensstrasse 3, D-06466 Germany; ∗e-mail: [email protected] Current Opinion in Plant Biology 1998, 1:207–216 http://biomednet.com/elecref/1369526600100207 Current Biology Ltd ISSN 1369-5266 Abbreviations AGPase ADP glucose pyrophosphorylase QTL Quantitative trait loci as a consequence, is a product of multiple molecular determinants. The problem of assigning specific function to molecular factors contributing to or determining sink strength is aggravated by the presence of sink organs with different functions. Sinks can be divided into utilization and storage sinks. The former, such as meristems, growing roots and developing leaves, import photoassimilates mainly for catabolism to sustain growth and development of the respective organ. The latter are organs such as growing tubers, tap roots, and seeds and fruits whose primary function is to store imported carbohydrate as sugars, starch or oil. Growth of storage sinks is characterized by at least two stages — increase in cell number and accumulation of storage compounds. Thus, molecular processes involved in determining sink strength may alter dynamically with development and also differ with the function of the respective sink tissue. A further level of complexity is associated with the fact that sink organs are part of the whole plant which leads to competition among different sink organs for assimilates produced in source leaves. The dependence on the rest of the plant strongly contributes to apparent sink strength defined as the net accumulation rate of dry matter in sink organs [3]. The overall complexity of ‘sink strength’ within the whole plant, parameters that determine carbon partitioning between competing sinks and the effects of environmental factors such as changing temperatures and water supply have recently been reviewed [1,4–6]. Introduction There have been long standing arguments about the definition of sink strength and its validity as a concept [1]. Nowadays, it has been widely accepted that sink strength can be defined as the competitive ability of an organ to import photoassimilates. This capacity has been proposed to be a product of both sink size and sink activity [2]. Ho suggested a more general viewpoint — sink size should be considered as part of the physical constraint and sink activity as the physiological constraint on an organ’s assimilate import capacity [3]. Together, the physical and physiological constraints are thought to determine the potential sink strength. It was further proposed that sink size could possibly be reflected by the number of cells in that sink, and one aspect of the physical constraint could thus be the genetic determination of cell number [3]. Sink activity is comprised of three important physiological features: firstly, the unloading of photoassimilates from the phloem, post-phloem transport and retrieval by sink cells; secondly, utilization, mainly by respiration, and thirdly, storage of imported carbohydrates. Thus, sink strength can be influenced by diverse metabolic processes and, Here, we will take a reductionist view by focusing on the sink organ itself and omitting the rest of the plant. We will describe recent findings related to the molecular parameters that might control or contribute to potential sink strength, not taking into account possible physiological constraints imposed by source and transport capacities. After a few basic considerations of how sink strength might be achieved in sink organs, recent approaches of manipulating sink strength will be discussed. As most of the work of the past two years has focused on tomato fruits, potato tubers, seeds of legumes, maize and cereals, this review has been sectioned accordingly. Cellular and physiological constraints of carbohydrate import into sink organs The basis for sink activity as an important component of overall sink strength resides in the model of Münch, which postulates that unloading and loading of the conducting tissue are mainly driven by concentration and/or osmotic gradients [7]. The efficiency of unloading in sink organs should, therefore, be determined by the 208 Physiology and metabolism capacity to remove the imported sugar from the same pool. Different possibilities exist: firstly, the removal of sucrose by chemical alteration, for example by hydrolysis thereby creating a concentration gradient, or by the building up of high molecular weight compounds, such as starch or oil, thereby creating both a concentration and an osmotic gradient; and secondly, the removal of sucrose from symplastic or apoplastic pools by compartmentation. Molecular approaches to understand the role of different enzymes associated with these processes have been presented [8]. It is obvious that enzymes involved in sugar transport and carbohydrate metabolism, in particular those that initiate sugar breakdown and those that are important in diverting flux into storage compounds, are possible molecular contributors to potential sink strength. The involvement of specific sugar transporting and sucrose degrading enzymes is strongly dependent on the unloading pathway which varies with type and, possibly, with the developmental stage of the sink organ [9•]. In addition to its breakdown, the resynthesis of sucrose has been discussed to be involved in phloem unloading in growing potato tubers. This seemingly futile cycle is driven by the activity of sucrose synthase and sucrose phosphate synthase (SPS) and is believed to act as a fine control on sucrose uptake. Thus it is tempting to speculate that the modulation of SPS activity during the storage phase in potato tubers might result in a higher flux of imported carbon into starch. Sieve element unloading and initial steps in the utilization of sucrose Four pathways exist for sieve-element unloading and post-phloem transport (Figure 1). Unloading of sucrose may exclusively use plasmodesmata forming a functional symplasmic route between the phloem and the sink parenchyma cells (Figure 1). Symplasmic transport is thought to be the general unloading route in many sink types, including root apices, expanding leaves and developing potato tubers [9•,10,11]. Control of symplasmic unloading could be exerted by changes in the structure and number of plasmodesmata (physical constraints) or by alterations in plasmodesmatal conductivities, possibly mediated by concentration or turgor differences between connected cells (physiological constraints). Despite intense efforts, no genes involved in the regulation of assimilate transport via plasmodesmatal conductivity have been isolated so far. Viral movement proteins, required for the short-distance movement of viral RNAs via plasmodesmata, may be used to trap host proteins [12]. As movement proteins have been localized to plasmodesmata, and in addition been found to alter carbon metabolsim, the possibility exists that plant proteins, interacting with movement proteins, are involved in assimilate transport via plasmodesmata. The other three pathways (Figure 1) contain an apoplastic step either directly at the boundary between the sieve element/companion cell complex and parenchyma cells or Figure 1 Suc (a) Suc Suc Suc Suc (b) Suc Suc Suc (c) Suc (d) Suc Hex Hex se/cc Hex Parenchyma Current Opinion in Plant Biology Models for the different unloading pathways. (a) Plasmodesmata forming a functional symplasmic route. (b) Leakage of sucrose from the sieve element/companion cell complex and uptake of sucrose into parenchyma cells, mediated by retrieval mechanisms of sucrose/proton symporters. (c) Endocytosis might be an additional route for the uptake of sucrose from the apoplastic space. (d) Sucrose leaked into the apoplast may encounter a cell wall invertase that hydrolyses the disaccharide into corresponding hexose sugars. The hexose sugars are then taken up by active hexose/proton symport into sink parenchyma cells. Circles with arrows represent active sugar transporters, circles with broken arrows indicate passive leakage and/or facilitated transport from the sieve element/companion cell complex. Broken arrows indicate passive leakage from the parenchyma cells. se/cc, sieve element/companion cell complex. Suc, sucrose; Hex, hexose. at the boundaries between different types of parenchyma cells during post-sieve element transport (for details see [9]). Sucrose efflux from the sieve element/companion cell complex is felt to occur by simple or facilitated diffusion down a concentration gradient. Uptake of sucrose into parenchyma cells might be mediated by active mechanisms involving sucrose/proton symporters. The sucrose transporters isolated to date have been immunolocalized to either companion cells in Plantago major or to sieve elements in tobacco, potato, and in minor veins of tomato in source and sink tissues [13,14•]. These data suggest that the sucrose/proton carriers isolated so far — in addition to their role in phloem loading — might be involved in sucrose retrieval along the unloading pathway. Recent work on the role of pyrophosphate in the phloem gives circumstantial evidence for an active retrieval mechanism in roots [15•]. Apical root tips of wild-type plants contain higher levels of soluble sugars than the more basal parts, especially under high light conditions. In transgenic tobacco plants expressing a phloem-specific pyrophosphatase the accumulation of sugars in the tip is abolished, whereas sugar levels are slightly elevated at the base [15•]. This observation suggests that, in the Molecular determinants of sink strength Herbers and Sonnewald 209 species and the expression of those analyzed has been localized to sink tissues [17•]. transgenic plants, leakage of assimilates in the basal part of roots cannot be compensated by active retrieval of sucrose into the phloem to maintain high levels in root tips. Depending on the unloading pathway in sink tissues there are different enzymatic routes for the breakdown of the incoming sugar (Figure 2). After being imported into the cytosol of sink cells (Figure 1) sucrose may be cleaved by either sucrose synthase or neutral invertase. In general it is assumed that sucrose may pass freely through the tonoplast membrane allowing sucrose import into the vacuole where it is hydrolyzed by vacuolar acid invertase. Hexoses in the cytosol (Figure 1) are either taken up into the vacuole or phosphorylated for further metabolism. Despite intense efforts, the proteins involved in sucrose transport of sink parenchyma cells have not been identified. An intriguing speculation is that endocytosis is a possible mechanism to import sucrose into sink cells (Figure 1). Indirect evidence in favour of this assumption stems from experiments where the fluorescent dye Lucifer Yellow was introduced to the apoplast of potato stolon cortex and was detected in the vacuoles of all cells within the tuber a few hours later whereas no fluorescence was observed in the cytosol [16]. Approaches to identify molecular determinants of sink strength Alternatively, sucrose leaked into the apoplast may encounter a cell wall invertase that hydrolyzes the disaccharide into its corresponding hexose sugars. The latter are then taken up by an active hexose/proton symport into sink parenchyma cells (Figure 1). Several hexose transporter cDNAs have been isolated from different plant The influence of the enzymes of carbohydrate metabolism on sink strength have been studied in various ways and correlations between parameters of sink strength and enzyme activities have been established. This has been performed with cultivars of the same species and more Figure 2 Sucrose Sucrose Invertase Hexoses Invertase Glc + Frc Susy Frc + UDPGlc Cell wall UGPase HK PGI/PGM H6P Glc1P Vacuole Glycolysis PGI/PGM HK Glc H6P Glc1P AGPase Starch ADPGlc Amyloplast Cytosol Current Opinion in Plant Biology Schematic drawing of carbohydrate metabolism in starch storing tissues. Sucrose in the cytosol may either be taken up into the vacuole, be hydrolyzed by neutral invertase to corresponding hexoses or be cleaved by sucrose synthase (Susy), forming fructose and UDP-glucose. Sucrose in the vacuole can be hydrolyzed by soluble acidic invertase. The hexoses are either taken up into the vacuole, or phosphorylated in the cytosol to enter glycolysis. Glucose and/or its phosphorylated intermediates may also be taken up into amyloplasts where starch is synthesized. ADPGlc, ADP-glucose; Frc, fructose; Glc, glucose; Glc1P, glucose-1-phosphate; H6P, hexose-6-phosphate; PGI, phosphoglucoisomerase; PGM, phosphoglucomutase; UDPGlc, UDP-glucose; UGPase, UDP-glucose pyrophosphorylase. 210 Physiology and metabolism recently with nearly isogenic lines of quantitative trait loci (QTL) mapping populations differing in sink strength. A few QTLs for yield seem to map with enzymatic activities suggested to be involved in sink strength [18•]. Comparisons were also made between carbon flux during distinct stages of sink development and the corresponding tissue enzyme activities. A number of mutants, particularly in maize, deficient in activities of primary metabolism were characterized with respect to their sink strength. Transgenic plants with elevated or reduced levels of enzymes possibly involved in sink strength were created and analyzed. The most important recent examples of the different approaches and the findings gotten through them will be presented in the following sections. Tomato fruit sink strength The development of tomato fruits can be divided into three stages: a slow growing stage lasting approximately up to 10 days after anthesis; a fast growing stage up to 40 days after anthesis; and a maturation phase where no further carbohydrates are imported. During the early stage, starch is the main carbohydrate stored and it has been suggested that the level of starch in the first stage determines the level of hexoses during later stages and the rate of fruit growth [19]. The starch-accumulating stage has been associated with symplasmic post-phloem sugar transport that shifts to apoplasmic transport during the phase of rapid hexose accumulation [20]. It is assumed that the switch from symplasmic to apoplasmic transport involves an extracellular invertase and that the action of this invertase influences the rate and extent of hexose storage. To study the effect of acid invertase on sugar levels and on fruit size the activity of the enzyme has been suppressed in antisense experiments [21,22]. About seven weeks after anthesis the reduction of total invertase activity was most pronounced in the antisense tomato plants. Three weeks after anthesis an increased ratio of sucrose/hexose in fruits was already observed. The accumulation of sucrose observed in the antisense plants resulted in a 30% decrease in fruit size [22]. The authors did not comment on total dry matter accumulation or yield per plant, therefore, the role of the acid invertase in sink strength cannot be judged from these experiments. It is apparent, however, that the acid invertase is responsible for maintaining high hexose concentrations which in turn might be responsible for cell expansion growth. A comparative study of two tomato genotypes differing in fruit hexose content revealed that the major difference between the two genotypes was not invertase activity but the rate of active hexose uptake from the apoplast to the symplast [23•]. The authors discussed the possibilities that the different uptake rates might be due to different hexose transporter activities which in turn could be regulated by the activity of plasma membrane H+-ATPases. Sucrose synthase activity has been reported to be positively correlated with final fruit size [24], starch content and tomato fruit relative growth rate [25] suggesting that this enzyme contributes to sink strength. Correlations between sucrose synthase activity and starch synthesis were relatively weak suggesting that other enzymes might also be involved in determining the rate of starch synthesis [25]. Recently, a careful investigation of the enzymes of the sucrose to starch biosynthetic pathway pointed to three enzymes co-ordinately regulated with sucrose synthase and potentially limiting in starch synthesis: fructokinase, ADP glucose pyrophosphorylase (AGPase) and starch synthase [26•]. The co-ordinate regulation of fructokinase and sucrose synthase could be important for maintaining flux to starch because sucrose synthase is inhibited by fructose. Unfortunately, to our knowledge neither of these enzymes has been studied in mutant plants. Recently, two cDNA clones encoding fructokinase have been isolated from tomato and the expression of one of these cDNA clones corresponded with the developmental period of starch accumulation [27]. Potato tuber sink strength The process of tuberisation represents the differentiation of a lateral shoot, the stolon, into a storage organ, the tuber. Tuber initiation involves a shift from stolon elongation to radial swelling of the sub-apical region. This process is accompanied by a decline of alkaline and acidic invertase and an increase of sucrose synthase and fructokinase activity [28]. Similar results were recently obtained with an in vitro synchronized tuberisation system [29]. The rise in sucrose synthase and fructokinase activities is positively correlated with the onset of starch and storage protein biosynthesis. Tuberisation is thus characterised by a switch from an invertase-sucrolytic to a sucrose synthase-sucrolytic system [28]. The hydrolysis of sucrose catalyzed by sucrose synthase could be made irreversible by immediate fructokinase action on the reaction product fructose. Estimations for rates of in vivo fructose phosphorylation in potato tuber discs compared with extractable maximum catalytic fructokinase activity revealed that fructokinase is highly regulated and could catalyze a near rate-limiting reaction and thus could represent a control point for starch synthesis [30]. To evaluate the different roles of invertases and sucrose synthase with respect to potato tuber sink strength, transgenic plants were created expressing a sucrose synthase antisense RNA [31] and either an apoplastic or a cytosolic yeast-derived invertase [32•]. The reduction of sucrose synthase in tubers resulted in an inhibition of starch and storage protein accumulation and a concomitant decrease in total tuber dry weight proving the assumption that sucrose synthase is a major determinant of sink strength in tubers. Surprisingly, the transgenic tubers exhibited elevated levels of hexoses which was paralleled by a 40-fold increase in invertase activities [31]. The fact that the induced invertase activity was not able to compensate for decreased sucrose synthase activity Molecular determinants of sink strength Herbers and Sonnewald 211 argues for metabolic channeling of sucrose via the sucrose synthase dominated pathway into starch. degradation and starch biosynthesis utilizes a sucrose synthase mediated pathway requiring pyrophosphate [33]. The expression of a yeast-derived invertase in the cytosol and apoplast of tubers revealed that size, number and morphology of tubers can be determined by apoplastic and cytosolic hexose levels [32•]. Expression of the invertase in the apoplast of tubers resulted in reduced tuber number, increased fresh weight and size per tuber and increased tuber fresh weight per plant. The dry weight, as a percentage of fresh weight, decreased possibly due to a reduction in the starch content, whereas the dry weight per plant was unaltered. In contrast, the cytosolic expression of invertase resulted in increased tuber number and reduced fresh weight per tuber. Thus far, it is unclear whether the impact on sink development is due to altered water potential by increased levels of hexoses in the apoplast or cytosol, respectively, and/or whether apoplastic glucose acts as a signal to induce cell division in the apoplastic invertase expressing tubers. In canola embryos, however, sucrose synthase activity was found to be much lower during early stages when starch is accumulating, compared with its activity after the switch to oil deposition [34•]. Because mature canola seeds contain 54% oil and an insignificant amount of starch, whereas maize kernels contain 66% starch and only 4% oil, it has been suggested that sucrose synthase activity reflects the synthesis of the predominant storage product whether it be starch in grains or oil in oilseeds [34•]. Both invertase expressing lines had reduced levels of sucrose but elevated levels of glucose indicating that sucrose was accessible in both compartments which argues for an apoplastic unloading route in tubers in addition to the generally accepted symplastic unloading [10] Interestingly, cytosolic invertase led to accumulation of hexose-phosphates, increased glycolytic flux and elevated respiration rates giving additional evidence that hexoses and hexose-phosphates resulting from the invertase-dominated pathway cannot be used for additional starch synthesis in tubers (Hajirezaei M, Takahata Y, Threthewey R, Willmitzer L and Sonnewald U, manuscript in preparation). The expression of apoplastic invertase, however, did not result in elevated hexose-phosphate levels during the storage phase despite glucose accumulation indicating that hexoses may not encounter the cytosol in these plants (Hajirezaei M, Takahata Y, Threthewey R, Willmitzer L and Sonnewald U, unpublished data). This is an exciting biochemical argument for an endocytotic uptake mechanism into the vacuole as suggested by Oparka and Prior [16]. Despite the presence of excess enzymatic activities and metabolites, sink strength in both invertase expressing lines was not increased. It seems that imported carbohydrates need to be channelled specifically in order to be appropriately utilized. Differential carbohydrate flux in maize kernels mediated by specific enzymes support this concept. Developing maize kernels accumulate primarily starch in the endosperm and oil in the embryo. Statistical analyses of enzymatic activities in different parts of the kernel suggested that glucokinase, fructokinase, and phosphofructokinase activities were primarily associated with oil accumulation, whereas AGPase and sucrose synthase were associated with starch accumulation. This indicated that oil biosynthesis utilizes invertase-mediated sucrose Fibers, seed coat and cotyledons of developing cotton seeds consist mainly of cellulose, starch, and storage proteins or oils, respectively. Studies on the differential expression of sucrose synthase in these different sink tissues similarly revealed that sucrose synthase did not play a role in starch synthesis, instead, its major role was carbon partitioning to fiber cellulose synthesis and to protein and lipid synthesis in the cotyledons [35]. In this system again starch does not appear to be a major storage form of carbohydrates. Efficient utilization of sucrose for starch synthesis as a factor for sink strength has been demonstrated in transgenic potato plants expressing reduced levels of AGPase [36]. These tubers did not form any starch, only sucrose. Total tuber dry weight per transgenic plant reached only 60–70% of total dry weight of a wild-type plant despite a significant increase of tuber number per plant. In the reverse approach, Stark et al. [37] tried to increase sink strength by the heterologous expression of a mutant Escherichia coli AGPase gene, the product of which was subject to reduced allosteric control under the tuber-specific patatin promoter in potato plants (cv. Russet Burbank). Tubers of transgenic plants contained on average 35% more starch than control tubers. More recently, the same construct has been transformed into potato plants (cv. Prairie [38•]). Transgenic plants had AGPase activity elevated by 4 to 5-fold with a concomitant increased flux into starch roughly proportional to the increase in AGPase activity [39•]. Despite increased flux into starch steady-state levels of starch in transgenic tubers were unaltered due to an increase in starch turnover possibly by amylolytic activity. There is no obvious explanation for the different results obtained with potato tubers expressing E. coli AGPase. Diverse control mechanisms of starch degradation in different potato cultivars might be speculated. One important message drawn from the work by Sweetlove et al. [39•] is that increased flux into starch does not necessarily result in starch accumulation. The work also shows that there is no simple way to ascribe molecular determinants of sink strength to utilization of imported carbohydrate as the latter is subject to regulation of synthesis and degradation. 212 Physiology and metabolism The approach to exploit an AGPase enzyme with reduced or altered allosteric control for strenghtening sink capacity has recently also been reported for maize [40•]. The endosperm-specific shrunken 2 (Sh2) gene encoding the large subunit of AGPase was modified in vivo by the excision of the tranposable element dissociation (Ds) from the region believed to be involved in allosteric regulation. Revertants with additional tyrosine and serine residues increased seed weight by 11 to 18% without altering the amount of starch. These revertants displayed reduced sensitivity to phosphate which is an allosteric inhibitor of AGPase [40•]. In contrast to the frequent finding that an increase in seed weight is associated with a reduction in seed number the revertant plants appeared not to possess reduced seed numbers and this should lead to increased yield. Besides AGPase, soluble starch synthase (SSS) has been implicated to strongly influence the formation of starch in wheat grain endosperm [41]. Antisense experiments with the major form of SSS, however, in potato did not alter starch content but instead had profound effects on starch granule morphology [42•,43•], indicating only a minor role (if any at all) for this isoform of SSS in sink strength, at least in potato. Phloem unloading and sucrose breakdown in seeds In developing seeds of legumes and cereals, the embryo is symplastically isolated from the maternal tissue and assimilates have to pass the apoplastic space before entering the developing seeds [44]. Tuber and seed sinks are similar in that both undergo a switch from invertase dominated to sucrose synthase dominated sucrose cleavage during early differentiation of the respective sink organ [28,29,45,46]. Moreover, this switch is accompanied by a shift from a high hexose to sucrose ratio (the prestorage stage in seeds) to a stage characterized by a low hexose to sucrose ratio followed by the accumulation of storage compounds such as starch, oil and storage proteins (storage stage). In storage tissues, invertase activity has been suggested to be correlated with developmental processes before storage starts [47]. The importance of hexoses in the development of a sink organ has not only been demonstrated in potato tubers [32•] and tomato [22] but also in the invertase-deficient miniature (Mn1) mutant of maize [48•]. The authors could show that below a threshold level of 6% wild-type activity the endosperm specific cell wall invertase controlled the developmental stability of maternal cells in the pedicel. In Faba bean a cell wall invertase is expressed during the prestorage phase in the seed coat where unloading of photoassimilates is known to take place [45]. It is assumed that hexoses are taken up by the embryo via a hexose carrier causing a high hexose/sucrose ratio in the cotyledons [49•]. By comparing two genotypes of Vicia faba differing in seed fresh weight it was observed that the large-seeded genotype formed a higher number of parenchyma cells [50•]. Furthermore, there was a positive correlation between cell wall invertase activity, a high hexose/sucrose ratio and mitotic activity leading to an extended phase of cell division in the large seeds. Similarly, in canola embryos it has been observed that acid invertase activity and hexose levels dropped during the transition from cell division to cell expansion [34•]. Altogether, the data indicate that invertase activity possesses the potential to contribute to the physical constraints of a sink organ. Cell wall invertase has long been assumed to be associated with rapidly growing tissues such as utilization sinks (e.g. meristems, sink leaves). Recently, it has been shown that an extracellular invertase and a hexose transporter were induced upon treatment of Chenopodium rubrum cells with cytokinins known to stimulate cell division [51•]. These results argue for the involvement of apoplastic unloading of sucrose, degradation by cell wall invertase with subsequent active hexose uptake in sink cells as one mechanism by which cytokinin influences cell division. Conclusions and perspectives During domestification of crops the ‘improvement’ of genetic loci was possibly associated with largely ‘optimized’ enzymatic equipment with most enzymes involved in primary metabolism being in excess. The finding that control of a pathway is shared by a number of components [52] and that sink strength is a quantitative trait [18•] suggests a priori that single enzymatic activities will not be exclusive molecular determinants of sink strength. Nevertheless, biochemical investigations during the last years have pointed to a few enzymes which, due to their key biochemical role, were considered possible contributors to sink strength. It has turned out that the expression of heterologous enzymes that are not subject to plant regulatory mechanisms are most promising for crop improvement strategies. Examples are the expression of mutant AGPases in maize or certain cultivars of potato that lead to increased seed weight or elevated levels of starch, respectively [37,40•]. Yet, there are several examples where the expression of enzymes expected to contribute to sink strength did not result in unequivocal improvements. Two reasons have been identified to account for these failures: the intricate regulatory networks of carbohydrate metabolism, and metabolic channeling. Thus, it has been shown that an increased rate of starch biosynthesis in potato plants was accompanied by increased starch degradation resulting in constant steady-state levels of starch [39•], and that despite elevated levels of hexose-phosphates in cytosolic invertase expressing plants these metabolites could not be used for additional starch biosynthesis (Hazirezaei M, Takahata Y, Threthewey R, Willmitzer L and Sonnewald U, unpublished data). In addition, inadequate timing of Molecular determinants of sink strength Herbers and Sonnewald transgene expression due to the lack of specific promoters may also be involved. The investigations of the past few years have also enlarged our understanding of how carbon flux is diverted into sink tissues at different stages of development. For instance, it has become apparent that sucrolytic pathways can be dominated either by invertase or sucrose synthase which, as a consequence, will lead to diverse biochemical fluxes. As a general finding about the distribution of invertase and sucrose synthase activities, it can be stated that high sucrose synthase activity is present in organs which have acquired their fate as storage sinks. High acid invertase has often been found in tissues where active cell elongation and high respiration is occurring. It seems that hexose accumulation during early developmental stages may influence the development of a sink organ. Knowledge about the molecular determinants of the physical constraints in sink organs is too scarce to judge their contribution to sink strength. The promotion of sink strength can be envisioned by additional approaches that modify higher levels of regulation governing both the physical and physiological constraints on sink organs. These could include plant hormones [53] and the signal transduction pathways regulated by them. Recently, mutant Arabidopsis plants defective in primary root development (designated pickle) have been described [54•]. It was shown that the mutation is involved in a gibberellin signaling pathway which regulates the transition from an embryonic seedling stage to a differentiated primary root. Pickle root tips accumulated oil bodies, storage proteins similar to those observed in seeds, and starch granules. It is reasonable to assume that the product of the wild-type pickle gene and related gene products might influence the development of a sink tissue and/or regulate biochemical pathways and, therefore, need to be included in any conceptual designs to improve sink strength and carbon flux into certain metabolic pathways. Knowledge of such regulation would also provide the opportunity to suppress the development of unwanted competing sink organs. Cloning of QTLs has become tractable due to the expanding repertoire of molecular mapping and cloning techniques. QTL analysis combined with advanced backcrossing, in particular including exotic germlines [55•], might lead to the identification and isolation of genes important for extending our knowledge about physical and physiological constraints of sink organs and their subsequent manipulation in transgenic plants. Another increasingly important aspect for sink strength is the role of sugars not only as energy and carbon sources but as signal molecules in gene expression. Carbohydrate supply is necessary for the repression of genes involved in photosynthesis, the glyoxylate cycle and mobilization of storage compounds, and for the induction of genes involved in defense and sink functions, i.e. in 213 the synthesis of storage compounds such as starch and vegetative proteins [56•]. There is increasing evidence that transduction of the sugar signal(s) to a variety of sugar-regulated genes is mediated by multiple signal-transduction pathways [57•,58•]. Thus, it has become conceivable to manipulate sink-specific gene expression independently from photosynthetic and stress-induced gene expression. Apoplastic expression of yeast invertase in transgenic potato plants resulted in enlarged tubers [32•]. This suggests a specific role for hexoses in cell division during early development of the respective sink organs. The transgenic tubers also revealed that invertase expression during the storage stage of tuber development leads to wasted carbon flux into respiration instead of starch (Hazirezaei M, Takahata Y, Threthewey R, Willmitzer L and Sonnewald U, unpublished data). These results call for highly specific promoters, such as a promoter conferring stolon specificity to allow expression of cell wall invertase protein when the overall cellular state (metabolic channelling) can comply with it. Acknowledgements K Herbers was funded by the European Communities Biotech Programme as part of the project ‘Biology of Tuber Dormancy and Sprouting’ PL960529. References and recommended reading Papers of particular interest published within the annual period of review have been highlighted as: • of special interest •• of outstanding interest 1. Farrar JF: Sinks — integral parts of a whole plant. J Exp Bot 1996, 47:1273-1279. 2. Warren-Wilson J: Ecological data on dry-matter production by plants and plant communities. In The Collection and Processing of Field Data. Edited by Bradley EF, Denmead OT. Sydney: Interscience; 1967:77-123. 3. Ho LC: Metabolism and compartmentation of imported sugars in sink organs in relation to sink strength. Annu Rev Plant Physiol Plant Mol Biol 1988, 39:355-378. 4. Marcelis LFM: Sink strength as a determinant of dry matter partitioning in the whole plant. J Exp Bot 1996, 47:1281-1291. 5. Minchin PEH, Thorpe MR: What determines carbon partitioning between competing sinks? J Exp Bot 1996, 47:1293-1296. 6. Geiger DR, Koch KE, Shieh W-J: Effect of environmental factors on whole plant assimilate partitioning and associated gene expression. J Exp Bot 1996, 47:1229-1238. 7. Münch E: Die Stoffbewegungen in der Pflanze. Jena: Gustav Fischer; 1930. [Title translation: Transport of Metabolites in Plants]. 8. Frommer WB, Sonnewald U: Molecular analysis of carbon partitioning in solanaceous species. J Exp Bot 1995, 46:587607. 9. • Patrick JW: Phloem unloading: sieve element unloading and post-sieve element transport. Annu Rev Plant Physiol Plant Mol Biol 1997, 48:191-222. The author gives an excellent overview of the possible cellular unloading pathways in different types of sink organs as well as control mechanisms for both symplasmic and apoplasmic transport routes. 214 Physiology and metabolism 10. Fisher DB, Oparka KJ: Post-phloem transport: principles and problems. J Exp Bot 1996, 47:1141-1154. 11. 12. 13. 21. Patrick JW, Offler CE: Post-sieve element transport of photoassimilates in sink regions. J Exp Bot 1996, 47:11651177. Ohyama A, Ito H, Sato T, Nishimura S, Imai S, Hirai M: Suppression of acid invertase activity by antisense RNA modifies the sugar composition of tomato fruit. Plant Cell Physiol 1995, 36:369-376. 22. Epel BL, Katz A, Padgett HS, Beachy RN: Isolation of plasmodesmata modified by virus movement protein fused with GFP. Abstract 1033 of the 5th International Congress of Plant Molecular Biology. 1997 September 21–27, Singapore. Klann EM, Hall B, Bennett AB: Antisense acid invertase (TIV1) gene alters soluble sugar composition and size in transgenic tomato fruit. Plant Physiol 1996, 112:1321-1330. 23. • Stadler R, Brandner J, Schulz A, Gahrtz M, Sauer N: Phloem loading by the PmSUC2 sucrose carrier from Plantago major occurs into companion cells. Plant Cell 1995, 7:1545-1554. 14. • Kühn C, Franceschi VR, Schulz A, Lemoine R, Frommer WB: Macromolecular trafficking indicated by localization and turnover of sucrose transporters in enucleate sieve elements. Science 1997, 275:1298-1300. In this study the authors report the immunolocalization of potato sucrose transporter (StSUT1) in plasma membranes of enucleate sieve elements of tobacco, potato, and tomato. The analysis was performed by fluorescent detection (see [13]) and by immunogold labelling of ultrathin sections using electron microscopy. In situ hybridization of StSUT1 mRNAs revealed signals both in the companion cells and the sieve elements, and they were preferentially associated with plasmodesmata. As the StSUT1 mRNA and protein were shown to be diurnally regulated the authors suggest that trafficking of StSUT1 mRNA and perhaps of transporter protein from the companion cell to the sieve element is likely to occur. The seemingly contradictory localization results [13] might be due to different loading mechanisms in different species. 15. • Geigenberger P, Lerchl J, Stitt M, Sonnewald U: Phloemspecific expression of pyrophosphatase inhibits long-distance transport of carbohydrates and amino acids in tobacco plants. Plant Cell Environ 1996, 19:43-55. This paper describes the metabolic effects caused by the expression of an Escherichia coli gene encoding inorganic pyrophosphatase behind the phloem-specific rolC promoter in tobacco plants. Careful physiological (determinations of biomass, respiration rate, photosynthesis) and biochemical (measurements of sugars, amino acids, nitrate, metabolites) analyses were performed in seedlings, sink and source leaves, as well as in different root zones. The results suggest that pyrophosphate is essential to maintain phloem function both in long-distance transport as well as at the initial site of phloem loading. Transport of carbohydrates and amino acids was inhibited by phloem-specific hydrolysis of pyrophosphate which is likely to be caused by an impairment of pyrophosphate-dependent sucrose breakdown and thus of energy metabolism. Growth inhibition varied with the organ and condition analyzed, for instance, roots were strongly inhibited because they are absolutely dependent on imported carbohydrates whereas sink leaves may locally synthesize assimilates. 16. Ruan YL, Patrick JW, Brady C: Protoplast hexose carrier activity is a determinate of genotypic difference in hexose storage in tomato fruit. Plant Cell Environm 1997, 20:341-349. Tomato genotypes with different fruit hexose content were compared with respect to transport processes. Short term 14C hexose uptake revealed a genotypic difference in Vmax for glucose, fructose and 3-O-methylglucose. These results suggest that control of hexose accumulation in tomato is exerted via uptake mechanisms and not by sucrose unloading from the phloem and subsequent hydrolysis by extracellular invertase. 24. Sun J, Loboda, T, Sung SS, Black CC Jr.: Sucrose synthase in wild tomato, Lycopersicon chmielewskii, and tomato fruit sink strength. Plant Physiol 1992, 98:1163-1169. 25. Wang F, Sanz A, Brenner ML, Smith A: Sucrose synthase, starch accumulation, and tomato fruit sink strength. Plant Physiol 1993, 101:321-327. 26. • Schaffer AA, Petreikov M: Sucrose-to-starch metabolism in tomato fruit undergoing transient starch accumulation. Plant Physiol 1997, 113:739-746. Measurements of maximal in vitro activities showed that four enzymes involved in sucrose to starch metabolism are co-ordinately regulated during early development of tomato fruits. The activities of sucrose synthase, fructokinase, ADP glucose pyrophosphorylase and starch synthase decrease concomitantly when starch levels decline. In addition, these enzymes appear to be potentially limiting to flux into starch. Activities of invertase, UDP glucose pyrophosphorylase, nucleoside diphosphate kinase, phosphoglucoisomerase and phosphoglucomutase are in excess of starch accumulation and are not subject to developmental changes. 27. Kanayama Y, Dai N, Granot D, Petreikov M, Schaffer A, Bennett AB: Divergent fructokinase genes are differentially expressed in tomato. Plant Physiol 1997, 113:1379-1384. 28. Ross HA, Davies HV, Burch LR, Viola R, McRae D: Developmental changes in carbohydrate content and sucrose degrading enzymes in tuberising stolons of potato (Solanum tuberosum). Physiol Plantarum 1994, 90:748-756. 29. Appeldoorn NJG, de Bruijn SM, Koot-Gronsveld EAM, Visser RGF, Vreugdenhil D, van der Plas LHW: Developmental changes of enzymes involved in conversion of sucrose to hexosephosphate during early tuberisation of potato. Planta 1997, 202:220-226. 30. Viola R: Hexose metabolism in discs excised from developing potato (Solanum tuberosum L.) tubers. Planta 1996, 198:186196. 31. Zrenner R, Salanoubat M, Willmitzer L, Sonnewald U: Evidence of the crucial role of sucrose synthase for sink strength using trangenic potato plants (Solanum tuberosum L.) Plant J 1995, 7:97-107. Oparka KJ, Prior DAM: Movement of Lucifer Yellow CH in potato tuber storage tissues: a comparison of symplastic and apoplastic transport. Planta 1988, 176:533-540. 17. Tanner W, Caspari T: Membrane transport carriers. Annu Rev • Plant Physiol Plant Mol Biol 1996, 47: 595-626. The authors give an informative overview of cloned and characterized carriers from plants and fungi and discuss their general properties, paying particular attention to their structure, regulation and kinetics. 18. • Prioul JL, Quarrie S, Causse M, de Vienne D: Dissecting complex physiological functions through the use of molecular quantitative genetics. J Exp Bot 1997, 48:1151-1163. The principle of QTL analysis, QTL mapping methods as well as application of QTL analysis to physiological traits and carbohydrate metabolism are discussed. Trials to identify QTLs in recombinant inbred lines using candidate genes such as ADP glucose pyrophosphorylase, sucrose phosphate synthase, sucrose synthase and invertase are presented. The authors conclude by saying it is time for physiologists to start studying marker-characterized segregating populations and marker-specific near-isogenic lines instead of varieties. QTL analysis should be the physiologist’s ‘tool of the future’. 19. Ho LC: The mechanism of assimilate partitioning and carbohydrate compartmentation in fruit in relation to the quality and yield of tomato. J Exp Botany 1996, 47:1239-1243. 20. Ruan YL, Patrick JW: The cellular pathway of post-phloem sugar transport in developing tomato fruit. Planta 1995, 196:434-444. 32. • Sonnewald U, Hajirezaei MR, Kossmann J, Heyer A, Trethewey RN, Willmitzer L: Increased potato tuber size resulting from apoplastic expression of a yeast invertase. Nature Biotechnol 1997, 15:794-797. In order to evaluate the significance of sucrose cleavage by invertase for sink strength, the yeast that encoded invertase was expressed tuber-specifically. Cytosolic expression was performed because of the generally accepted view that sucrose unloading in tubers proceeds symplastically. Apoplastic expression was performed to reveal a putative apoplastic unloading step. This paper provides evidence for the presence of sucrose in the apoplast of tubers and for the importance of regulated hexose production to maintain normal tuber development. 33. Doehlert DC: Distribution of enzyme activities within the developing maize (Zea mays) kernel in relation to starch, oil and protein accumulation. Physiol Plantarum 1990, 78:560-567. Molecular determinants of sink strength Herbers and Sonnewald 34. • King SP, Lunn JE, Furbank RT: Carbohydrate content and enzyme metabolism in developing canola siliques. Plant Physiol 1997; 114:153-160. The authors present fundamental data on photosynthetic carbon partitioning, carbohydrate content and sucrose metabolizing enzymes in silique walls, and seeds (testa, endosperm and embryo) during different stages of development. 35. 36. 37. Ruan Y-L, Chourey PS, Delmer DP, Perez-Grau L: The differential expression of sucrose synthase in relation to diverse patterns of carbon partitioning in developing cotton seed. Plant Physiol 1997, 115:375-385. Müller-Rsber B, Sonnewald U, Willmitzer L: Inhibition of the ADP-glucose pyrophosphorylase in transgenic potatoes leads to sugar-storing tubers and influences tuber formation and expression of tuber storage protein genes. EMBO J 1992, 11:1229-1238. Antisense experiments revealed that this starch isoform could be suppressed to undetectable levels as analyzed in zymograms. Transgenic tubers displayed similar results as described in [42•]. The altered shape of starch granules was accompanied by a 70% increase in phosphate covalently linked to the C6 position of glucose in starch. 44. Wolswinkel P: Transport of nutrients into developing seeds: a review of physiological mechanisms. Seed Science Res 1992, 2:59-73. 45. Weber H, Borisjuk L, Heim U, Buchner P, Wobus U: Seed coatassociated invertases of Faba bean control both unloading and storage functions: Cloning of cDNAs and cell type-specific expression. Plant Cell 1995, 7:1835-1846. 46. Weber H, Buchner P, Borisjuk L, Wobus U: Sucrose metabolism during cotyledon development of Vicia faba L. is controlled by the concerted action of both sucrose- phosphate synthase and sucrose synthase: expression patterns, metabolic regulation and implications for seed development. Plant J 1996, 9:841850. 47. Eschrich W: Free space invertase, its possible role in phloem unloading. Ber Deutsch Bot Ges 1980, 93:363-378. Stark DM, Timmerman KP, Barry GF, Preiss J, Kishore GM: Regulation of the amount of starch in plant tissues by ADP glucose pyrophosphorylase. Science 1992, 258:287-292. Sweetlove LJ, Burrell MM, ap Rees T: Characterization of transgenic potato (Solanum tuberosum) tubers with increased ADP glucose pyrophosphorylase. Biochem J 1996, 320:487492. Potato plants (cv. Prairie) were transformed with the same chimeric gene construct as used by Stark et al. [37]. Major enzymes involved in sucrose and starch metabolism were found to possess unaltered activities proving that no pleiotropic changes were induced in the transgenic tubers. Furthermore a linear relationship between AGPase activity and protein amount was demonstrated. These results provide a solid basis for further analysis on the role of AGPase in starch metabolism [39••]. 38. • 39. • Sweetlove LJ, Burrell MM, ap Rees T: Starch metabolism in tubers of transgenic potato (Solanum tuberosum) with increased ADP glucose pyrophosphorylase. Biochem J 1996, 320:493-498. Together with [38••] this paper is an excellent analysis of starch metabolism in transgenic potato plants expressing mutant E. coli AGPase. The analysis includes contents of starch, sugars and metabolites and pulse-chase experiments to estimate fluxes to and from starch. Flux from [U-14C] sucrose, supplied externally to tubers attached to the plant, to starch increased roughly in proportion to the increase in AGPase activity giving rise to a calculated response coefficient close to 1. It was shown that increased flux into starch in the transformed tubers was accompanied by an increased rate of starch turnover. 40. • Giroux MJ, Shaw J, Barry G, Cobb BG, Greene T, Okita T, Hannah LC: A single gene mutation that increases maize seed weight. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 1996, 93:5824-5829. The maize endosperm-specific gene shrunken 2 (Sh2) encodes the large subunit of ADP glucose pyrophosphorylase. The author exploited an in vivo site-specific mutagenesis system, the transposable element dissociation to create insertions of 3 or 6 bp in the region of allosteric regulation. Each insertion revertant reduced total AGPase activity. One revertant containing an additional tyrosine and serine residue (rev6) increased see weight by 11–18% which was not solely due to increased starch levels. The authors suggested that an overall stronger sink was induced by changing a few amino acids of AGPase large subunit in maize. 41. Hawker JS, Siwek K, Jenner CF: The synthesis of [14C] starch from [14C] sucrose in isolated wheat grains is dependent upon the activity of soluble starch synthase. Aust J Plant Physiol 1993, 20:329-335. 42. • Marshall J, Sidebottom C, Debet M, Martin C, Smith AM, Edwards A: Identification of the major starch synthase in the soluble fraction of potato tubers. Plant Cell 1996, 8:1121-1135. The major starch synthase has been purified from potato tubers. This isoform was found to account for 80% of soluble starch synthase activity in tubers. Surprisingly, no effect on starch or the amylose-to-amylopectin ratio was observed in tubers with suppressed activity of this starch synthase isoform. Instead the shape of starch granules in transgenic tubers was altered. 43. • Abel GJ, Springer F, Willmitzer L, Kossmann J: Cloning and functional analysis of a cDNA encoding a novel 139 kDa starch synthase from potato (Solanum tuberosum L.). Plant J 1996, 10:981-991. Cloning of a soluble starch synthase was performed by means of an antibody raised against a peptide sequence highly conserved in starch synthases. 215 48. • Cheng WH, Taliercio EW, Chourey PS: The Miniature1 seed locus of maize encodes a cell wall invertase required for normal development of endosperm and maternal cells in the pedicel. Plant Cell 1996, 8:971-983. The authors present data collectively showing that the Miniature 1(Mn1) seed locus in maize encodes an endosperm-specific isoform of cell wall invertase, CWI-2. About 90% of the enzyme was dispensable without a significant change in seed phenotype. Yet at lower activities sink strength of the developing embryo was reduced as evidenced from reductions in mature seed weight and, moreover, the endosperm cells withdrew from the maternal pedicel resulting in gap formation at 9 to 10 days after pollination. This work strongly arguments for an invertase-dependent metabolic status that governs developmental processes with consequences for sink strength (see also [45,50•]). 49. • Weber H, Borisjuk L, Heim U, Sauer N, Wobus U: A role for sugar transporters during seed development: Molecular characterization of a hexose and a sucrose carrier in Fava bean seeds. Plant Cell 1997, 9:895-908. cDNAs encoding a sucrose (VfSUT1) and a hexose transporter (VfSTP1) were cloned and their expression analyzed by in situ hybridization during different stages of development. 50. • Weber H, Borisjuk L, Wobus U: Controlling seed development and seed size in Vicia faba: a role for seed coat-associated invertases and carbohydrate state. Plant J 1996, 10:823-834. Two genotypes of Vicia faba differing in seed size were compared for the temporal in situ expression of VfCWINV1 (Vicia faba cell wall invertase 1) [45], for seed coat and embryo cell number, morphology, carbohydrate and storage protein content. The large cotyledons were correlated with prolonged VfCWINV1 activity, high hexose conditions, extended mitotic activity and a concomitant delayed switch to the storage phase. Bathing mitotically active embryos in hexose solution maintained cell divisions whereas bathing in sucrose led to nuclear expansion and starch accumulation. These data (together with [45]) point to metabolic signals determining the switch from the cell division phase to the storage phase. 51. • Ehneß R, Roitsch T: Co-ordinated induction of mRNAs for extracellular invertase and a glucose transporter in Chenopodium rubrum by cytokinins. Plant J 1997, 11:539-548. The authors showed that a cell wall invertase as well as a hexose transporter from Chenopodium rubrum were specifically inducible by cytokinins in cell suspension cultures. Glucose and sucrose uptake (via hexose monomers) were found to be enhanced upon treatment with cytokinins. The authors suggest that higher levels of extracellular invertase and hexose transporters could be one of the molecular changes required for the stimulation of growth and cell division by cytokinins. 52. Stitt M, Sonnewald U: Regulation of metabolism in transgenic plants. Annu Rev Plant Physiol Plant Mol Biol 1995, 46:341-368. 53. Kuiper D: Sink strength: Established and regulated by plant growth regulators. Plant Cell Environm 1993, 16: 1025-1026. 54. • Ogas J, Cheng J-C, Sung R, Somerville C: Cellular differentiation regulated by gibberellin in the Arabidopsis thaliana pickle mutant. Science 1997, 277: 91-94. 216 Physiology and metabolism A mutant is described that is defective in a gibberellin signaling pathway that promotes transition of the primary root from an embryonic to an adult differentiation state. Mutant roots contain triacylglycerols indistinguishable from those of seeds as well as oil bodies, starch granules and 2S1 storage proteins implying that mutants resume or retain some degree of embryonic differentiation after germination. 55. • Tanksley SD, Nelson JC: Advanced backcross QTL analysis: a method for the simultaneous discovery and transfer of valuable QTLs from unadapted germplasm into elite breeding lines. Theor Appl Genet 1996, 92:191-203. The authors propose advanced backcrossing QTL analysis as a method to discover valuable QTLs of unadapted land races or wild species and to rapidly develop new varieties in elite breeding lines carrying these QTLs. Despite inferior phenotypes of wild accession, crosses between the latter and an elite line have repeatedly been found to display transgressive variations, that is to say, the phenotype of the elite parent was improved. 56. Koch KE: Carbohydrate-modulated gene expression in plants. • Annu Rev Plant Physiol Plant Mol Biol 1996, 47:590-540. This review compiles genes regulated by carbohydrates; carbohydrate accumulation leads to the down-regulation of genes for photosynthesis, remobilization and export of assimilates and to the up-regulation of genes for storage and utilization. These modulations are discussed with respect to assimilate partitioning at the organism level, and possible sugar sensing mechanisms are presented. 57. • Mita S, Murano N, Akaike M, Nakamura K: Mutants of Arabidopsis thaliana with pleiotropic effects on the expression of the gene for amylase and on the accumulation of anthocyanin that are inducible by sugars. Plant J 1997, 11:841851. The authors describe the identification of an ethyl methane sulfonate mutated locus (lba1) in Columbia-O and an lba2 locus in Landsberg erecta leading to loss of sugar-inducible amylase gene expression and accumulation of anthocyanin in leaves. Both lba1 and lba2 did not affect starch or sugar levels and lba1 also did not affect sugar-inducible gene expression in general (chalcone synthase, chalcone flavanone isomerase and dihydroflavonol 4-reductase were analyzed). 58. • Ehness R, Ecker M, Godt DE, Roitsch T: Glucose and stress independently regulate source and sink metabolism and defense mechanisms via signal transduction pathways involving protein phosphorylation. Plant Cell 1997, 9:18251841. The authors studied the mRNA expression of cell wall invertase (CIN1) and PAL as sink specific and stress genes, respectively, as well as RbcS as a photosynthetic gene in photoautotrophically growing suspension cultures of Chenopodium rubrum. An inverse regulatory pattern of gene expression was observed for CIN1 and PAL as compared to RbcS by treatment with glucose, the fungal elicitor chitosan, benzoic acid and the phosphatase inhibitor endothall. Different intracellular signaling pathways stimulated by glucose and stress-related stimuli were uncovered by means of the protein kinase inhibitor stauroporine. Zymograms revealed a fast and transient induction of kinases by glucose, chitosan and endothall.
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz