IROQUOIS WATERFRONT CONSERVATION, PROTECTION AND ENHANCEMENT PLAN IROQUOIS WATERFRONT ADVISORY COMMITTEE APRIL 2013 _ revised TABLE OF CONTENTS PROLOGUE CONTEXT REPORT SUMMARY MANDATE WATERFRONT STUDY AREA A BRIEF HISTORY _ TRACES COMMUNITY INPUT – SURVEY RESULTS PRINCIPLES AND PLANS VISION AND GUIDING PRINCIPLES PLANS: AN ACCESSIBLE WATERFRONT _ CONCEPT PLAN SERVICES AND FACILITIES A WATERFRONT RECREATION TRAIL _ CONCEPT PLAN FRONT PARK CONSERVATION, PROTECTION AND ENHANCEMENT PLAN THE BEACH AREA IMPLEMENTATION CONCLUSION RECOMMENDATIONS ANNEX IROQUOIS WATERFRONT _ 03 IROQUOIS, GALOP CANAL LOCKS, POINT c. 1920 04 _ IROQUOIS WATERFRONT, FEBRUARY 2013 PROLOGUE We must have known, and then ignored for lack of real evidence, that Henry, and a few others that we saw regularly around the lake, could still remember that original town. That they perhaps even felt that it was to the old rather than to the new that they more fully belonged. But because they hardly spoke of it, they did not interrupt our dreaming, and perhaps were even instrumental in leading me, at that age, to the false presumption that a thing could, quite simply, be forgot. » Johanna Skibsrud, The Sentimentalists, 2009 This passage encapsulates clearly our community dilemma of contrasting views and competing interests. As a result the Iroquois Waterfront advisory committee has proceeded with a sensitive appreciation for and respectful treatment of, those attitudes and emotions that underlie this ill-defined and little understood controversy. Contained in the pages of this document are committee recommendations for short-term and long-term development enhancements, which, if they come to fruition, would re-invent Iroquois as the “most user-friendly recreational village“ for South Dundas residents and tourists alike. The recommendations included in this report reflect the survey results as well as our own determinations. Old Iroquois is one of the lost villages, demolished, burned and buried under acres of grassland and water. The grassland park now separates the inhabitants of the new village of Iroquois from the river. This was not intended originally. Published plans and illustrations in the Iroquois Post in 1954 distinctly showed that the waterfront aspect of the village would be recreated. That sense of separation has been a constant theme when people discuss waterfront development and public access. As any farmer knows, if you don’t plant the seeds (define a vision), fertilize (with community input and involvement) and provide water (financial and human resources), you can’t expect to reap a profitable product _in this case a sustainable quality waterfront experience for present and future generations. The proposed plan for the conservation, protection and enhancement of the Iroquois Waterfront as outlined in the pages that follow, plants the seeds and sets the framework for an optimal harvest of well being. In reference to the quoted passage, those of us who experienced living in the lost village of Iroquois and on Iroquois Point have not forgotten. Perhaps we, most of all, feel acutely that sense of separation from the river. As well, as witness to the demise of the old village, we can’t help but view this parkland respectfully as a memorial site to a lost village. This is not meant to suggest that anyone is against development per se; on the contrary, survey responses indicate that the community wants this public parkland to be beautified, with enhanced amenities, in such a way as to make it more user friendly and welcoming for all. The results of the questionnaire and survey (see annex) are statistically significant and, importantly, are representative of majority opinion. On behalf of the Iroquois Waterfront Committee and the Township of South Dundas, we thank all who participated in the Survey as well as those who contributed to our meetings. Howard Kirkby, chairperson, Iroquois Waterfront Committee IROQUOIS WATERFRONT _ 05 CONTEXT AND REPORT SUMMARY The following report presents the IROQUOIS WATERFRONT Advisory Committee’s mandate, introduces its members and defines the physical boundaries of the area studied. It sketches an historical portrait of the evolution of the site, briefly describes current site conditions and summarizes the results of the community survey before presenting the guiding principles that underlie a shared vision for the conservation, protection and enhancement of Iroquois’ unique waterfront. A conservationist approach to waterfront development, inspired by the history of place, is revealed through a series of conceptual and schematic plans at different scales of interest. In general, the plans promote better public access to the waterfront, the protection of significant natural and cultural components across the study area, better connections amongst the many attractions and points of interest, a quality experience and a greater appreciation and understanding of the sense of place. A preliminary program for enhancement initiatives in the park is developed as well as a proposal for improvements to the beach area, identified as a priority sector. The implementation strategy is followed by a series of recommendations that conclude the report and an ANNEX contains complementary illustrations, supplementary plans and a complete resumé of the public survey. 06 _ IROQUOIS WATERFRONT, FEBRUARY 2013 The report is not an indepth site and use analysis culminating in a step by step plan for the future. Instead, it offers a series of recommendations based on community needs (reflected by the survey results) and a reading of the opportunities for recreational and liesure activities within the existing cultural landscape. It is a plan aligned with current township policies as put forward in the recent strategic plan that identify the waterfront and heritage as key components for economic and tourism development. The Report is respectfully submitted to the Township of South Dundas and the community by the IROQUOIS WATERFRONT ADVISORY COMMITTEE in hopes that the essence and spirit of the report will be well recieved and that it will serve as a guide for future development on the Waterfront. One thing is certain, it is time to move forward. MANDATE The Iroquois Waterfront Advisory Committee was selected by Council, Township of South Dundas in June 2011 to investigate and determine a plan for development of the Iroquois Waterfront. The terms of reference provided by the township is summarized as follows: • • • • • • • Provide a forum for community input Consult with community organizations and government agencies Consider the use and enjoyment of the waterfront by people of all ages and abilities Recognize the community value of the waterfront as sites for events and festivals Review previous reports and studies related to the waterfront and integrate pertinent recommendations Recommend waterfront development ideas in keeping with an overall vision and approach Provide cost estimates and identify sources of funding when possible Current members include: Howard Kirkby, (elected chairperson) Carol Montgomery Jacques Asselin Jim Wilson Keith Poore Arnie Fader Marg Lee Howard Kirkby Jim Millard Wendy Graham, landscape architect and part time resident of South Dundas, contributed her services and assisted in the preparation of the plans and overall report. IROQUOIS WATERFRONT _ 07 Galop Ln 4 8 Colquho Salmon Rd Whipperwill Ln 1. Iroquois (Front) park and (John Ross) Airfield. S.D.G. 18 Froatburn Archer Riverside Heights Archer Rd Cre 41 Crowder Rd S.D.G. For overall planning purposes and in view of the many conservation, protection and enhancement opportunities on other waterfront sites in Iroquois vicinity the study area was enlarged to include: d dR stea Hay Pige on Is land R d 8 Archer Rd S.D.G. ek 28 Stevens Rd Rd n Wellingto Rd sh 2 11 Beckstead Rd Hoasic Na S.D.G. S.D.G. Dons Rd use Rd Prunner Rd Dejong Rd urn Crowder Rd 401 Salmon Rd Carr Rd Carr Rd Beckstead Rd Toonders Rd Boucks Hill Rd Saddlemire Rd Ferguson Rd Mels Ln Nudell Exit 758 Nudell Bush Bush Rd Plant Broder Island Murphy Island Crysler Memorial Park Filtration Clark Colquhoust S.D.G. The mandate of the waterfront committee was originally confined to the parkland bordered by Carman road on the west, to the Iroquois Golf club on the east, Elizabeth Drive to the north and the waterfront and Iroquois Marina to the south. This area, referred to as Iroquois Front Park remains the primary focus of the report and action plan. Roy Rd McBride Rd Hummel Rd Brooks Rd Rd Cassi e Dump Rd atb S.D.G. Grace Rd Salmon Rd MacKenzie Rd Riverside Dr Canada Island Ogden Ogden Island Island Waddington Historic WilliamsburgWells Fro Morrisburg Mariatown S.D.G. Beckstead Beckstead Rd Boucks Hill Rd Grantley Upper Canada Village 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Ault Is;land Rd Cr Whittaker Rd Exit 750 Muttonville Rd Flagg Rd Sweetwater Lakeshore Dr Whittaker Rd Rd Dr Stevens Dr Breezewood Av tley 8 Elma Young Rd Gran S.D.G. 18 Glen Becker Deeks Rd Orchardside Froats Rd Upper Canada Rd Zeron Rd Deeks Rd gg Fla Marcellus Rd Bank St Bank St Strader Rd Hutt Rd Dunbar S.D.G. Richmire Rd 31 Flagg Rd McInnis Rd S.D.G. ek Lightning St Hanes Grisd ale Bd 18 Tollgate Rd Rd Coyle Dr Dr Rd Dr Millar S.D.G. Shannette Rd Cre Rd Robertson Rd Flagg Rd aard 401 UNITED STATES Coughler Rd Bank St Heritage Rd Heritage Rd Williamsburg rg No 7 S.D.G. Pages Corners Rd Thunder Rd Flagg Rd Markell Rd Seeley Rd McIntosh Rd ugh o Garl WATERFRONT STUDY AREA Weegar Rd 7 Forest Rd Sullivan Rd Rd S.G.D Payne Rd Bell Rd Brinston Rd Saving St Strader Hill Rd Orvill Rd Zeron Rd CANADA Da m Stampville Rd Rowena Parlow Bridlewood Cr Sewage Treatment Plant Rowena Rd ge Rid Barkley Smiths Rd Bongers Rd Devries Rd Coons Rd Brinston Rd Cr ck Golf Course Ireno Irena l 18 Ogdenview 8 Birch Ln Binion Rd Bla S.D.G. Iroquois 2 Waddell Rd 16 Brook MeadowDr Marine Station Rd Rd Stampville 40 Rd S.D.G. d S.D.G. Exit 738 Broken Second Rd ond Rd Broken Sec Pa ra Billy Ln Dundela 18 eR Rusty Rd th S.D.G Parkedale Dr Kelly Rd English Rd English Rd 1 31 John Markell Rd rson Rd Smail Rd S.D.G. g Rid Barnhardt Rd Irena Rd S.D.G. Arlie Rd Safford Rd Haddo Smail Rd Bayview Ct Saver Rd Calium Rd Haddo Rd Historic Matilda McCaslin Rd eek S.D.G. lle Rd Rd Dixons Corners Cook Rd Dump Seibert Rd Cr 16 Golf Course Rd ck ee k Hanesville Chess Rd Bla 18 Coons Rd Fulton Rd S.D.G. S.D.G. Carman Rd Rd Irvine Rd Taylor Rd Carman Rd So reek hC ranc Cook Rd Brinston y To Winchester Springs Rd Winchester Springs Rd ill e H 45 Henderson Willow Gilmour Rd Nine Mile Rd Rd nch 1 Hanesville Carman Rd Webb Rd lle esvi 5 Toye Hill Hende Bylsma Rd Sou S.D.G. Bra 18 Cindy Crescent William St d R nch ra th B Glen Stewart S.D.G. Rd Snowbird Rd Kirker Rd Creek Sandy uth Byker Rd New Ross Rd Kirker Rd Sandy Creek Rd Levere Rd Hulbert Shaver Rd Fulton Rd Pleasant Valley Glen Stewart Rd hB S.D.G. Gary Rd 16 Branch Rd Han Sou S.D.G. Hulbert Rd Sout at th N Brinst Irish Headline Rd Wallace Rd B Nation River Rd Au Isla Willb D Willbruck Rd © 1999, 2006, 2010 • C & L Specialty Maps 613-342-1745 • May not be reproduced without permission Point St Lawrence Av Township of South Dundas and the waterfront communities of Iroquois and Morrisburg Old Galop Canal locks and Iroquois Marina Iroquois Island (lookout, Seaway Locks, OPG lands, cemetery) Sector West: private and publicly owned lands to the west of the park Iroquois Golf Course located east of the (Front) park Sector East: Private and publicly owned lands east of the Golf Course, south and east of Dr. Miller Drive and north of the shoreline. A planning process that takes the broader waterfront area into consideration allowed the committee to formulate long-term planning objectives that will ultimately direct the development of parcels of land along the waterfront to: • • • • 08 _ IROQUOIS WATERFRONT, FEBRUARY 2013 Conserve the natural and vulnerable ecosystems Protect and celebrate the area’s cultural heritage Provide integrated public access to the waterfront for recreational purposes Benefit the common good in both the short and long-term. STUDY AREA LOCATION STUDY AREA LIMITS 5 6 1 4 2 Imagery ©2012 TerraMetrics - 3 IROQUOIS WATERFRONT _ 09 10 _ IROQUOIS WATERFRONT, FEBRUARY 2013 A BRIEF HISTORY IROQUOIS was incorporated as a village in 1857, though it had a population of only 750 people. By law, 1,000 residents were required before a community could become incorporated however influential people of the town prevailed on the legislature of Upper Canada for a special Act of Incorporation and thus the village came into being…The town flourished as it stretched out along the river-front with its big pioneer homes built of stone, church steeples and a thriving business section which catered to the needs of the countryside for miles around. *Source: Iroquois History, Year of Celebrations, Village of Iroquois 140th Anniversary, New Iroquois 40th, 1857-1997, Anniversary Souvenir Book Up until the late 50’s, Iroquois was a picturesque and bustling southern Ontario town with a close connection to the river. The building of the Seaway (c. 1957) and the ensuing demolition and relocation of the town virtually erased the town and its vital connection to the waterfront. Iroquois was one of many villages lost to the Seaway Project. A new reality was created with the town center being relocated to a shopping plaza located on highway 2 that virtually turned its back to the river. Neighborhoods composed of new and moved homes were built on a suburban street grid that kept the river and imposing dam at a considerable distance. The vast green space that currently stretches from the existing shoreline to Elizabeth drive and from Carman Road to (and including) the golf course (1959) stands as a reminder of the town that once was and this open expanse has remained relatively unchanged over the last half century. The integration of an airfield (1967) contributed to the land remaining relatively untouched over time. Today, where the town once stood, are a small beach area and a beach-house including facilities. A pathway destined for pedestrian and bicycle use, fronts the river where Main Street used to bustle and the old Galop Canal and locks, now the Iroquois Marina, has become a popular venue for pleasure boaters. Many traces from the past are still etched in the landscape today. These traces can be identified, protected, restored and kept alive so that future generations can bear witness to a past that ultimately shaped the community they live in today. Here in lies the essence of a conservation and protection approach for the revitalization of the Iroquois Waterfront. IROQUOIS WATERFRONT _ 11 TRACES IN THE CULTURAL LANDSCAPE As illustrated on the adjacent plan, there are many tangible TRACES of the past still present in the landscape today. They include but not limited to: Carman road Brinston road Old county road no. 2 _ Main Street Iroquois Carman House (historic museum) Forward House (lawn bowling club house) Other ‘moved’ houses in the town (to be identified) Iroquois point Tindall House (The Lockmaster’s House) Cemetery Lieu. Col. Lorne Mulloy, Pt. Iroquois resident, Boer War hero Trees and plantings pre-existing the Seaway construction Grand Trunk Railway line Limits of the town c. 1957 Lot line orientation and street grid Iroquois Main Street Galop Canal Old Locks _ shed _ swing bridge Old highway no. 2 Lookout and Seaway Locks Public Park Iroquois and Harkness Island Carman House (historic museum) 12 _ IROQUOIS WATERFRONT, FEBRUARY 2013 Protecting and enhancing the traces and reminders of the past will keep the fascinating history of Iroquois and the impact of the Seaway alive. (see ALSO Heritage Analysis plans in ANNEX _ PLANS) Tindall House Av Ch ur ch Bridlewood Ct Bay St ² Carman Ct St Ann d Adair R S.D.G. County Rd 1 - Carman Rd S. D .G .C ou nt y R d 2 Iroquois Waterfront HERITAGE ANALYSIS _ CULTURAL LANDSCAPE ‘TRACES’ PRE-EXISTING THE SEAWAY_ IROQUOIS C. 2010 r th D a be Eliz 3. GRAND TRUNK RAILWAY LINE 2. FORWARD HOUSE 1. CARMEN ROAD c CARMEN HOUSE 4. IROQUOIS MAIN STREET us tho Boa d eR 5. OLD LOCKS 7. COUNTY ROAD 6. GALOP CANAL LEGEND g Hi hw 8. IROQUOIS POINT 2 (LT. COL. MULLOY) Hadley St ld O ay 10. CEMETARY TOWNSHIP OWNERSHIP LIMITS 9. TINDALL HOUSE IROQUOIS WATERFRONT PLANS FOR DISCUSSION _ PRELIMINARY ANALYSIS OF CULTURAL LANDSCAPE HERITAGE _ 0 50 100 PRE-EXISTING THE SEAWAY 200 300 400 Legend Meters 500 Township_Parcels IROQUOIS WATERFRONT _ 13 COMMUNITY INPUT _ SURVEY RESULTS Survey The expansive Iroquois park and golf course have changed little over the last 50 years despite the potential offered by their waterfront location. However, when a recent waterfront planning initiative realized for the township by Corush Sunderland Wright in 2010 promoted the possibility of building housing on the waterfront park site in order to stimulate growth and economic development, the community reacted strongly against the idea. This was a sacred place. To ensure that the community had input into a revised plan for the waterfront, the current committee conducted a survey. The purpose of the survey was to canvass residents of Iroquois about their support for – or opposition to – development options for the Iroquois waterfront. A complete copy of the questionnaire, results and analysis are included in the ANNEX SURVEY at the end of this document. A subsequent report submitted to council by then waterfront committee chairman Del Jones stated that there was little public support for any of the concepts presented in the plan for Iroquois with the exception of improving walking and biking trails and making improvements in the beach area. The residents of Iroquois were clear that they wanted to maintain the campsite, airport and tennis courts in their current locations and that there was no interest in developing any of the waterfront green space for residential or mixed development. It was also pointed out that there are restrictions on building on the flood plain required by Ontario Power Generation and that a covenant exists on some of the property that requires it to be used only for recreational purposes. The survey was mailed to 1266 households in Iroquois. Additional survey forms were available at the Iroquois Branch of the Stormont-Dundas-Glengarry Library System and at the Sears Depot at the Iroquois Plaza. The survey was also available on-line. There were 148 responses: 121 in hardcopy and 27 on-line. Basically, the survey confirmed the population’s commitment to maintaining the function and current configuration of the park. AS the adjacent graph illustrates there was no support for residential development in the waterfront lands of Iroquois. There was a strong consensus that both functional and esthetic improvements would enrich the user experience and contribute to the town identity. Improvements to the paths and trails, better signage, lighting and tree plantings were among some of the suggestions forwarded to the committee. The survey also revealed that the population was concerned with the lack of ongoing stewardship and maintenance of the park and were insistent that better security supervision was needed along with traffic calming measures to reduce speed of vehicular traffic in the park. 14 _ IROQUOIS WATERFRONT, FEBRUARY 2013 Survey suggestions... Respondents were asked to suggest development options for the waterfront in general. A representative sample of the suggestions includes: • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Encourage events like fishing derbies Beautify the shoreline – flower beds, etc. Improved maintenance Build a resort hotel Expand beach with additional picnic tables Build bandstand Build BBQ area Improve the path from the boathouses to the beach Plant more trees Install lighting along the path Build a proper boardwalk Build fishing pier Additional covered space Campsite Washrooms should be open from dawn to dusk Dog park Paintball arena Seniors housing and recreational facilities Summary Respondents to the survey strongly oppose residential development of the Iroquois waterfront, and a majority prefer that the waterfront be left as it is. GENERAL QUESTIONS GRAPH The first graph indicates that a majority of respondents support the following scenarios: • Leave the waterfront as it is • Leave the airstrip alone as long as it is user-supported • Enlarge the beach • The Iroquois waterfront should be a recreational resource for all of the township ZONE 1 QUESTIONS The second chart shows that the majority of respondents do not support residential development in Zone 1 (FRONT PARK) (see SURVEY ANNEX for full report) IROQUOIS WATERFRONT _ 15 GUIDING PRINCIPALS _ VISION Make the waterfront accessible, understandable and enjoyable to the public. Over the course of numerous work sessions, the committee met and discussed the many suggestions put forward by the community. They analyzed the potential for public use offered by Iroquois’ unique waterfront location taking into consideration its regional setting. Existing studies and strategies focusing the history, economic development, tourism and land use were also reviewed with many significant natural and cultural features identified within the study area. From this overview, Iroquois’ unique personality emerged, as did a series of Guiding principles that could shape and direct a shared vision for the future of the waterfront. The Iroquois - South Dundas waterfront sector contains a myriad of natural and cultural assets, like diamonds sparkling on the water. Ensuring access to these attractions involves creating a pathway network that links the destinations amongst themselves and to a broader regional recreational corridor. (see ANNEX_PLANS ) Providing facilities such as parking, rest rooms, refreshments, signage etc will in turn make this waterfront experience more welcoming, understandable and enjoyable. Interventions on the waterfront, in keeping with the natural and historic character of place, aim to support diverse activities across the four seasons. Look at the big picture In order to best ensure quality waterfront development for future generations planning strategies must consider the broader regional context. This scale of planning helps to identify significant and characteristic natural and cultural components of the landscape as well as ecological systems of interest for both conservation and recreational initiatives along the waterfront. Further and more in-depth studies are also required. Above and beyond more fully documenting existing site conditions, and project feasibility, this process will help identify potential partnerships with local, provincial and federal stakeholders. 16 _ IROQUOIS WATERFRONT, FEBRUARY 2013 Interventions on the waterfront, in keeping with the natural and historic character of place, aim to support diverse activities across the four seasons. Conserve, protect, enhance and enrich Responsible management and stewardship Iroquois’ (Front) park is a vast, open and beautiful green space that stands as a reminder of where the old town used to be _ it is a sacred place. Its scenic landscape character offering varied views and vistas to the river has most certainly shaped the identity of the Iroquois we know today. As such, the conservation of the park green space as a kind of living memorial to the area’s history and the old town is key to the planning strategy for the waterfront. History becomes the inspiration behind renewal efforts. Enhancement initiatives focus primarily on providing a more functional, safe, sustainable and aesthetic environment for greater public use and enjoyment in keeping with the sense of place. Responsible management and upkeep of the waterfront requires a continuous standard of care and maintenance. Best practices need to be set in place by the Township in collaboration with user groups and the community to ensure that the waterfront is always safe, clean and beautiful. Waterfront development must involve community action in tandem with the township and private + public partnership. When short and long-term goals are clearly identified, creative and win-win solutions can easily be found to enhance the overall quality of the environment, user experience and sense of place. The creation of an Iroquois Waterfront Conservancy will help ensure community stewardship into the future. Celebrate the past _ build for the future Fostering a better understanding of the history of place is a key component to the waterfront plan. Not only will celebrating the history inform current and future generations about the history of the town and impact of the Seaway, it can also guide development and design initiatives along the waterfront. At the same time Iroquois must embrace the future. User and recreation trends promoting health and well-being have evolved over the years. The natural and landscaped settings along the Waterfront provide a unique opportunity for a variety of recreation and leisure activities and increased public use. Fostering a better understanding of the history of place is a key component to the waterfront plan. IROQUOIS WATERFRONT _ 17 PLANS FOR THE WATERFRONT The plans that follow are conceptual and schematic drawings that illustrate a vision for the Waterfront. They provide a starting point for further study, discussion and design refinement and take into consideration the preceding guiding principles. There are 5 different plans. Each plan treats a different scale or dimension of the waterfront. 1. An accessible waterfront _ concept plan This plan identifies the component parts of the broader study area and indicates primary (proposed) access and recreational corridors. 2. Facilities and services This plan focusses on the strategic location of facilities required to serve the needs of visitors ‘across’ the waterfront area. 3. A waterfront recreation trail _ concept plan This plan examines the broader waterfront area and focuses on linking the various points of interest along the waterfront to the east and west of the (FRONT) park. This very schematic and preliminary plan revealed that more study is needed to better understand existing site conditions, land ownership and natural systems. It serves to illustrate the possibility of a pathway system linking different sites of potential interest. 4. Front park _ conservation, protection and enhancement plan This plan zooms in on the (Front) park green space. It proposes a series of project initiatives that would conserve, protect and improve the existing park. The plan also identifies historical <points of interest>, planting zones to screen and orient views, potential locations for parking areas and facilities and an extended pathway system. 5 _ Beach revitalisation concept _ existing situation and concept plan More site-specific concerns are addressed at the scale of the Beach Area. This very preliminary proposal that suggests improvements that will create a more dynamic and interesting destination on the water. 18 _ IROQUOIS WATERFRONT, FEBRUARY 2013 4. Front park _ conservation, protection and enhancement plan This plan zooms in on the (Front) park green space. It proposes a series of project initiatives that would conserve, protect and improve the existing park. The plan also identifies historical ‘points of interest’, planting zones to screen and orient views, potential locations for parking areas and facilities and an extended pathway system. 5. Beach revitalisation concept _ existing situation and concept plan More site-specific concerns are addressed at the scale of the Beach Area. This proposal suggests improvements that will create a more dynamic and interesting destination on the water. he ari o& Pr s tha int oe= t lin are utf kn vis -8& ex ibl cli. t to e o .. the n th ma e p. ACCESS TO THE WATERFRONT - CONCEPT ACCESS TO THE WATERFRONT - CONCEPT HWY N0. 2 LEGEND DORANS CREEK IROQUOIS IROQUOIS TOWN CENTER linked to the waterfront_ signage and pathways NORTH SOUTH WATERFRONT LINKS vehicular, bicycle + pedestrian pathways IROQUOIS GOLF COURSE SOUTH EAST SECTOR UNK OLD TLRINE RAIL FRONT PARK SEAWAY PARK SOUTH WEST SECTOR PROOPOSED EAST-WEST WATERFRONT RECREATION TRAIL connecting to regional context negotiated right of ways bicyle and pedestrian pathways shoreline protection IROQUOIS FRONT PARK AND JOHN ROSS AIRFIELD Including GALOP CANAL MARINA AND IROQUOIS POINT conservation, protection and enhancement IROQUOIS GOLF COURSE extending the heritage waterfront trail in partnership MARINA GALOP CANAL INTERSECTION ACCES TO WATERFRONT orientation and signage SOUTH EAST AND SOUTH WEST SECTORS extending the WATERFRPMT trail on private and public lands through negotiated agreements- shoreline protection and water access THE POINT IROQUOIS ISLAND LOCKS HARKNESS ISLAND IROQUOIS AND HARKNESS ISLANDS conservation and enhancement of rich varied cultural and natural features _ increased public access public private partnership opportunities (opg, seaway, township +) IROQUOIS WATERFRONT PLANS FOR DISCUSSION , W.GRAHAM Im ag er 1. An accessible waterfront y_©concept plan 20 1 Cn This plan identifies the component2 parts es of the broader study area and indicates /Sp primary (proposed) access and recreational ot corridors across the study area. Im ag e, Dig ita lG lob e, Ge oE ye ,U SD AF arm Se rvi ce Ag The plan proposes to: 1. Conserve and enhance the existing waterfront park in commemoration of the Old Iroquois (see also park plan) 2. Reinforce the north south access routes from 401 and County Road 2 to the primary waterfront destinations including: The Seaway Locks, the Point and Iroquois Marina along Carman road The beach via Adair road The Iroquois Golf Clubhouse along Golf Course Road Cemetery and wetlands via Old Brinston Road en cy - IROQUOIS WATERFRONT _ 19 CONCEPT PLANS THE concept plans for an accessible waterfront and a waterfront recreation trail across the broader study area propose : _ through negotiation and agreement, to extend the waterfront trail east and west of the park and connect with the regional waterfront heritage trail, _ develop win-win partnerships amongst the many stakeholders to ensure optimal (and shared) use of existing facilities _ provide necessary facilities and services where needed _ protect significant natural and cultural resources Exists Future 2. Facilities and services _ existing and proposed 20 _ IROQUOIS WATERFRONT, FEBRUARY 2013 A WATERFRONT RECREATIONAL TRAIL _ CONCEPT PLAN HWY NO. 2 P DORAN CREEK DR. MILLER DRIVE OLD BRINSTON RD. TOWN OF IROQUOIS IROQUOIS GOLF COURSE SECTOR EAST WETLANDS CEMETARY CLUB HOUSE PP WAY IVE LER DR NK RAIL DR. MGILRAND TRU OLD OLD HWY NO. 2 IROQUOIS FRONT PARK JOHN ROSS AIRFIELD PP P P OLD #2 ROAD SUBMERGE MEETS GRISDALE RD. WATER ACCESS PROPOSED RECREATIONAL TRAIL CONSERVATION AND PROTECTION OF NATURAL CULTURAL RESSOURCES SHORELINE PROTECTION WATERFRONT PUBLIC ACCESS AND FACLITIES P SECTOR WEST PROPOSED OLD TRUNK AND WATERFRONT RECREATIONAL TRAIL CONSERVATION AND ENHANCEMENT IROQUOIS FRONT PARK, GALOP MARINA AND IROQUOIS POINT P IROQUOIS ISLAND PUBLIC PARTNERSHIP P IROQUOIS WATERFRONT PLANS FOR DISCUSSION, W.GRAHAM, NOTE: THIS SCHEMATIC PLAN IS NOT TO SCALE 4. A waterfront trail _ east and west of Iroquois Front Park CONNECTNG TO THE REGION IROQUOIS WATERFRONT _ 21 A PLAN FOR THE PARK CONSERVATION, PROTECTION AND ENHANCEMENT The plan for the park is inspired by the past but looks to the future. It proposes that this vast green space stand as a memorial to the lost town of Iroquois. It also aspires to create an accessible waterfront destination for the community and visitors alike, offering a unique and scenic waterfront experience. Initiatives proposed in the park aim to : _ Maintain current park functions, activities and the John Ross Airfield _ Protect, restore and enhance historic features and traces from the past through innovative interpretation, signage and site furniture elements _ Improve the pathway system and link with adjacent sites _ Better connect the park with the town center _ Improve and diversify facilities for public use and enjoyment _ Make the waterfront beach and trail an interesting destination _ Manage natural systems such as water drainage and runoff _ Provide a variety of natural and landscaped environments to enhance the experience and enjoyment of the park _Ensure user safety _ Protect and improve ‘scenic’ quality. The plan identifies 12 different ‘project’ areas and develops a preliminary program compatible with the Waterfront Vision and guiding principles. 22 _ IROQUOIS WATERFRONT, FEBRUARY 2013 ELEMENTS IN THE LANDSCAPE _ objectives for landscape quality In order to improve and enhance scenic quality and user experience in the park efforts need to: _ Protect significant views to water _ Screen or filter less desireable views with plantings _ Provide a variety of different ambiences and atmospheres within the park and promote progressive discovery _ Identify and protect trees and vegetation predating the Seaway _ Define a vocabulary of site furniture elements in the landscape such as signage, waste and recycling containers, benches, interpretive signage, materials, paving, lighting etc. inspired by ‘sense of place’ _ seek Excellence in design and realisation. Bay St Ch ur ch Av LEGEND St Ann Carman Ct 12 6 d eR 12 12 hw ay parking ? BEACH 9 MEMORIAL PLACE g Hi information 3 7 us tho Boa future facilities P 8 P planting ? P 12 heritage markers 2 11 10 ? paths existing facilities r th D a be Eliz P ² connections 1 d Adair R S.D.G. County Rd 1 - Carman Rd D. G .C ou nt y Rd Bridlewood Ct 2 Iroquois Waterfront 55 4 12 PROPOSED 1. PARK ENTRANCE 2. ADAIR ROAD, BEACH TRAIL AND PARKING IMPROVEMENTS 3. BEACH REVITALISATION 4. WATERFRONT TRAIL AND MEMORIAL PLACE 5. MARINA _ GALOP CANAL 6. PARKING AND FUTURE FACILITIES 7. CARMAN HOUSE 8. CAMPING AREA 9. JOHN ROSS AIRFIELD 10. FORWARD HOUSE INFORMATION CENTER TENNIS COURTS AND LAWN BOWLING N 11. PATHWAYS _ A SYSTEM 12. CONNECTING TO THE REGION 2 Hadley St d 5. FRONT PARK _ conservation,Olprotection and enhancement plan IROQUOIS WATERFRONT _ 23 PARK IMPROVEMENTS _ A PRELIMINARY PROGRAM 1. ENTRANCE WAY Define a sense of ‘welcome’ at the main vehicular entrance to the park including a safer geometry, paving, identification signage and plantings. Name the park officially: Iroquois Front Park and John Ross Airfield This name is recommended by the committee after considering a series of other options. 2. ADAIR ROAD, BEACH TRAIL AND PARKING Create a more interesting approach to the beach along Adair Road with tree and shrub plantings to orient and screen views Manage drainage systems, provide park directional signage and execute general improvements to the main vehicular roadway. Improve geometry and widen bicycle and pedestrian path from Elizabeth Drive to the beach (+ extend link north to shopping plaza) Re-design the arrival area at waterfront to provide a drop off area, short term and long-term parking. Ensure no-conflict with recreational pathways Integrate interpretive signage especially at arrival points to tell the story of the old town Re-configure the large parking lot further from the beach and create a buffer zone between beach and parking area Add plantings for shade and interest Use permeable materials in parking lot for drainage 3. BEACH Enlarge and extend the beach sandy area Provide a variety of ways to access the water i.e. supervised swim, docks, stepping stones etc. Increase grass area north of beach and create planted buffer zone between beach and parking Create a formal picnic area between parking and beach Include play areas for children, benches, and beach volleyball with bleachers + shade shelter. Additional lifeguard chairs (historic feature!), lighting and interpretive signage Renovate and improve existing services and facilities (toilets and change rooms) Create an interesting architectural feature or focal point with addition of a 24 _ IROQUOIS WATERFRONT, FEBRUARY 2013 refreshment stand outlet with adjacent terrace and tables, Consider integrating tourist-heritage information counter, (refreshments to include ice cream, healthy snacks, local delicacies, smoothies etc.) Provide tree planting for shade and aesthetics, integrate information signage including rules, regulations, beach hours, environmental message, code of ethics, orientation map etc. Integrate site furniture such as lighting, benches, bicycle racks, waste and recycling containers 4. WATERFRONT TRAIL Widen existing trail along the waterfront to easily accommodate pedestrian and bicycle use _ recall the old Iroquois Main Street Connect waterfront trail with existing (or proposed paths) in park and on adjacent sites, extend trail to east (golf course) and connect west to Marina Rd. Determine shoreline treatment strategies for public access vs. stabilization, habitat etc., add trees for shade, comfort and diversity, maintain and enhance views, integrate lighting and benches Create a unique memorial to the town MAIN STREET along the path, at the edge of the river and integrate interpretive signage – a place where the history of the town can be told and celebrated 5. MARINA Protect, restore, operate, maintain and develop. The marina is a highly attractive and picturesque venue offering water related services and experiences that are complementary but independent from the park. Integrate parking for Marina and park use. Study potential for commercial development on Marina Road north side _ supplies, food, facilities, resto + . Restore the swing bridge and re-establish historic link to the Point and other attractions i.e. Seaway Locks, Tindall House, cemetery 6. PARKING AND FACILITIES Potential location for future parking area and commercial activities, toilet facilities etc. that could serve Carman house, marina users, recreational tourists and airport clientele Integrate plantings to screen negative views and direct users through the site Include interpretive signage about locks and Galop Canal Partnership potential 7. CARMAN HOUSE Conserve existing function of historic venue with in the park Improve views to and from this venue for better visibility from the road and improved integration in the park Ensure adequate and safe pedestrian access from Carman road Maintain pathway from marina and proposed parking lot with additional planting Integrate interpretive signage about the Carman House on the periphery of the site Integrate a planting buffer to screen from camping area Continue to improve and expand historic garden area and tap potential for community involvement and interpretation Partnership potential 12. CONNECTING TO THE REGION Develop a hierarchy of paths, trails and roads that connect to the town and to potential and existing networks on a regional scale Iroquois Waterfront Key plan Bay St Ch ur ch Bridlewood Ct Carman Ct Rd y S. D. G .C ou nt S.D.G. County Rd 1 - Carman Rd r th D a be Eliz ² 1 Adair Rd 2 11 10 8 12 3 7 9 12 4 6 us tho Boa d eR 55 12 12 ld O g Hi hw ay IROQUOIS WATERFRONT PLANS FOR DISCUSSION 2 Hadley St 10. FORWARD HOUSE, TENNIS COURT AND LAWN BOWLING Conserve and protect the Forward House and annex. Relocate the information Center and promote public use of building for park use, historical exhibits, facilities, stewardship activities and meeting center. Maintain and operate adjacent tennis and lawn bowling activities Integrate signage, pathways, furniture etc. 12 t 9. JOHN ROSS AIRFIELD Maintain and operate Improve and enhance Airport building for continued use. Av 2 FRONT PARK _ CONSERVATION, PROTECTION AND ENHANCEMENT PLAN S Ann 8. CAMPING AREA Maintain, reorganize, enhance and improve the camping area Relocate current lots let along Carman road to reduce visual noise along primary entrance road to Carman house, marina and locks Ensure minimal setback from tennis courts and lawn bowling areas to ensure public access and ownership Plant trees to define limits of the area to screen and filter views to and from the park Partnership potentials 11. PATHWAYS Study circulation patterns and destination points in the park and develop an overall pathway system-network in the park for both pedestrian and cycling needs. Build on existing pathways to develop a pathway system experience the will provide in an uninterrupted, safe and agreeable experience for the user IROQUOIS WATERFRONT _ 25 Legend 0 50 100 200 300 400 Meters 500 Township_Parcels THE BEACH and WATERFRONT TRAIL – CONCEPT Airfield _ constrains use parking lot _ too close to beach, in a state of disrepair, conflict with bicycle and pedestrian use In keeping with public input, the committee felt that improvements to the Iroquois Front Park _ BEACH AND WATERFRONT TRAIL _ was top priority especially considering its current ‘rundown’ state, high visibility and use. Upgrading the waterfront trail from the marina to the beach is considered as a strategic and exemplary project that could establish the tone and character of the revitalized park. Revitalisating a section of an existing path would also provide an opportunity set in place historic place markers with the creation of an ‘IROQUOIS MEMORIAL PLACE’ The plan entitled existing situation around the beach area. There are many problems with the current configuration. The concept plan for this area corresponds with preceding park program _ beach (no. 3) and waterfront trail (4). In summary, the plan proposes: existing path along water to Marina existing situation 26 _ IROQUOIS WATERFRONT, FEBRUARY 2013 _ A reorganization of parking facilities including an arrival area, drop off zone and short term parking, signage etc. _ facilities currently offered in the beach area be improved and diversified to eventually include a refreshment-info counter, terrace, seating etc. and better respond to user needs ( requires new building ) _ increase size of beach area (sand) _ new docks, lifeguard chairs + seating areas in sun and shade _ organize a formel picnic area between parking and beach _ beach volleyball and playground equipment to be upgraded _ site furniture and lighting for comfort and safety _ signage integrated to orient and inform _ heritage markers to increase public awareness about the history _ tree planting and shoreline protection Adair Road and BEACH trail Drop off area and short term parking Renovated Washroom Facilities and Storage + Beach House_ Ice Cream and information _ terrace and tables AIRFIELD BEACH PARKING PLAY PICNIC VOLLEY BALL TERRASSE BEACH PLAY PROPOSED waterfront trail to Marina _ including MEMORIAL PLACE _ celebrating Main Street and the Old town of Iroquois THE BEACH AND ARRIVAL AREA Concept plan IROQUOIS WATERFRONT _ 27 Iroquois Waterfront Ch ur ch Bay St Carman Ct S Ann 3 1. Main Entrance to IROQUOIS FRONT PARK and JOHN ROSS AIRFIELD 11 2 8 Officially naming the park and installing signage is both a functional and symbolic gesture. Redesigning the entrance road to ensure safety , identifying the park with appropriate signage for visitors and residents alike and creating a sense of entry and arrival are snall interventions that will confirm the public identiy of this green space and acknowledge the longstanding contribution of citizen John Ross. 3 7 9 12 4 4. SHORT TERM PRIORITY PROJECTS Dr 10 12 ² PRIORITIES _ Projects and Planning 2 t th a be Eliz 1 IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY 1 Adair Rd S.D.G. County Rd 1 - Carman Rd S. D. G .C ou nt y Rd Bridlewood Ct Av 2 FRONT PARK _ CONSERVATION, PROTECTION AND ENHANCEMENT PLAN 6 us tho Boa 2. Beach and waterfront trail _ Design development and build d eR 55 In keeping with the results of the public survey and site analysis, the committee recommends moving forward in the short-term on improvements to the beach area and waterfront trail - along the shoreline of Front Park. This is clearly a top priority for Iroquois. 12 12 hw ay IROQUOIS WATERFRONT PLANS FOR DISCUSSION 2 Hadley St ld O g Hi Key plan PRIORITIES Legend 0 50 100 200 300 400 Meters 500 For the project to be successful and considering that it will set the tone for the work to follow along the waterfront, it is essential to further refine the design concept, determine feasibility, evaluate cost and ultimately allocate adequate funding. Township_Parcels The committee strongly recommends hiring a consultant specializing in place making (multi-disciplinary firm including landscape architects, architect and engineers) to further develop the design for this sector of the waterfront park. The consultants would determine feasibility, prepare land survey if required, prepare conceptual plans for approval, evaluate cost as well as prepare guidelines and criteria for planting, signage, site furniture lighting etc. Ultimately working drawings for tender need to be completed before tendering out the work. Design development, based on the initial concept presented here, should be done in collaboration with the waterfront committee and the township. 28 _ IROQUOIS WATERFRONT, FEBRUARY 2013 Given the current state of the site (beach and existing waterfront path) the committee felt that measures should be undertaken as soon as possible to deal with security and safety issues around the beach. A table summarizing recommended initiatives in the park was prepared by the committee and can be found in ANNEX - IMPLEMENTATION of this report. While this proposed work schedule exists, it is important to emphasize that the Township should avoid a ‘band-aid’ or ‘piecemeal’ approach at all costs _ the area needs to be designed as a ‘whole’ as mentioned above. 3. The Forward House, Carman Road and camping area improvements – planning and collaboration Another short-term project that will have an important impact in that it would bring people to the park and closer to the waterfront is the relocation of the tourist information center to the existing heritage Forward House with appropriate signage indicating the route from the 401 and County Rd. no. 2. This appropriation of the Forward House for pubic use is the first step towards a public use building devoted to the <waterfront> ressource and history. The potentiel to accomodate other activities related to park use should be assessed for medium and long term development. Campground layout and use also should consider existing infrastructures and optimize campsites so that they do not overflow into the park. A planning exercise to determine the needs of user groups (campers, lawn bowling, tennis) should be defined in order to assess needs and use of the Airfield building and the Forward House. Establishing a work group to review the current situation would be helpful in guiding landscape and architectural improvements in this area. 4. Marina _ parking lot Taking into consideration that the Marina is a high use area and that this area could be developped further for commercial and recreational activties and given the proximity to other waterfront activities in the vicinity as well as the historical Carman House attraction it would be advantageous to integrate a bigger parking lot that would serve both the Marina and park. The integration of a parking lot would help decrease congestion during peak use periods and should be designed to carefully integrate in the park, respect drainage and water runoff constraints. Pathways to adjacent attractions should be done at the same time to ensure a topnotch user experience . Contingent with this move would be re-evaluating the layout of the camp ground in collaboration with township staff and others responsible for managing the site. Trailers currently parked on the Carman Road encroach on the visual right of way leading up to the Carman House and camping vehicles infringe on grounds adjacent to the lawn bowling area and tennis courts. Visual quality along Carman Road would be improved by having a greater setback of camping vehicles (out of the visual access corridor) This would be desirable given that Carman Rd is the main access road to the Locks, Point, Marina etc and therefore the ‘face’ of Iroquois to visitors coming into the area. De-cluttering and reducing the visual ‘noise’ along this road would be a simple, effective and low cost initiative to improve the scenic quality of this important roadway. IROQUOIS WATERFRONT _ 29 SHORT TERM PRIORITY PLANNING MID TO LONG-TERM PRIORITIES 1. Celebrating History – Research and community initiatives Mid to long-term priorities will emerge from the ongoing Waterfront Advisory Committee as opportunities present themselves and resources are made available. The preliminary plans identify a number of projects that would benefit the population. Logical sequence, available budgets, community involvement, safety or security issues and opportunity will play a role in the projects selected for protection or enhancement. The plan for the waterfront (more specifically the park) proposes an innovative approach to interpreting the history and evolution of the site based on the landscape ‘then and now’. This preliminary concept requires further development that involves historic research, comparison of plans, design of place markers (signage) that would relate the history of place, etc. The committee suggests that a task force devoted to compiling historic information (iconography, maps, written history) work in collaboration with the Advisory Committee to research and compile information related to Iroquois’ history. Information about Iroquois’ (past, present and future) could be made available to the public (online) and would help generate a greater community awareness about Iroquois’ heritage as well as provide useful info for interpretive signage etc. Under the theme of ‘heritage’, the project of erecting a cairn in recognition of Boer War Hero Lt. Col. Mulloy is an ongoing community initiative (Lions club) and project has already gained support and momentum and could be integrated as a part of the overall interpretation concept for the waterfront. The townships support in this significant endeavor is pertinent. 2. Planning _ Big Picture Task Force Establish a task force to further investigate and study the feasibility of extending the waterfront trail east and west of Front Park. Objectives would include identifying stakeholders, partners, landowners, land division, natural and cultural resources ect. Priorities will include : 1. Moving forward on the realisation of the Front park enhancement plan such as drainage, pathways, planting, signage etc. 2. Long-term implemention of the waterfront corridor recreational trail to the east and west of the PARK either on public lands or through 3. negotiated agreement with landowners. 4. Establishing partnership initiatives with private and public land owners along the waterfront including Iroquois Island and researching funding ressources. (OPG, Seaway Authority + ) To sc s ree 30 _ IROQUOIS WATERFRONT, FEBRUARY 2013 Im ag ery ©2 01 2C CONCLUSION In conclusion, the Iroquois waterfront is unique. It tells the story of the lost old Town and stands as a witness to the construction of the Seaway. Across the four seasons, its scenery and attractions offer a multitude of experiences for leisure and recreation along with beautiful vistas onto the St. Lawrence. The Iroquois Waterfront Advisory Committee has carefully studied the waterfront area and taken into consideration economic and tourism strategies set forth by the Township. They consulted the community before preparing this report that puts forth a vision and sets out conceptual plans for future development on the waterfront. The approach promotes the conservation, protection and enhancement of the BROADER waterfront area and includes a strategy of extending the waterfront trail for the benefit of future generations in the longterm. It proposes an approach and a series of projects for the Park and adjacent sites and identifies the principal priorities located at the 4 corners of the Park. With this report, the mandate of the Committee has been completed however, much work remains to be done to bring these plans and ideas they contain to fruition. A renewed mandate for a Waterfront Committee focusing on making things happen is the next best step. GENERAL RECOMMENDATIONS In summary, and consistent with the Township’s economic development, heritage and tourism strategies focusing on the waterfront and local history, the Iroquois Waterfront Committee respectfully submits this report to the Township of South Dundas with the following recommendations: > Approve in principle the essence and spirit of the Iroquois Waterfront Advisory Committee report, guiding principles and preliminary concept plans as a framework for the conservation, protection and enhancement of the Iroquois (and vicinity) Waterfront, > Officially name the Waterfront Park to commemorate the lost village of Iroquois, to promote a sense of place and history and to recognize the important contribution of John Ross in shaping the park for public use : IROQUOIS FRONT PARK AND JOHN ROSS AIRFIELD > Proceed with improvements in the park based on the 4 corner priorities as outlined in the plan including : 1. Park Entrance and signage 2 Beach area 3. Front House and campgrounds 4. Marina parking Proceed with the planning and preliminary design work and engage the services of a consulting firm specializing in waterfront parks (landscape architecture) to elaborate design proposals, execute cost analysis and determine project feasibility and phasing. > Support community initiatives for improvements and activities aligned with fostering better understanding the heritage of place and initiatives put forth or compatible with by the essence of the preliminary plans. > Create an innovative and pro-active taskforce of private and public stakeholders to focus on the opportunities and feasibility of extending a waterfront recreational trail both east and west of the existing FRONT PARK. > Allocate an annual budget for repairs and improvements in the park to ensure the safety and enjoyment of park visitors. > Ensure the continued stewardship of the park by renewing the mandate of the Iroquois waterfront committee and by supporting the creation of an IROQUOIS WATERFRONT CONSERVANCY (non profit organization dedicated to the conservation and improvement of the waterfront). IROQUOIS WATERFRONT _ 31 ANNEX IROQUOIS WATERFRONT _ 33
© Copyright 2025 Paperzz