4/25/2016
Countering extremism in Minnesota: A beautiful goal, barely begun ­ StarTribune.com
EDITORIAL
Countering extremism in Minnesota: A
beautiful goal, barely begun
Local initiatives can be lauded, but funding is inadequate to support
Somali community. By Editorial Board Star Tribune
APRIL 23, 2016 — 9:31PM
Ducking, visitors quickly learn, is a valuable skill for spectators at Coach Ahmed Ismail’s
soccer practices at the Phillips Community Center in south Minneapolis.
Ismail’s West Bank Athletic Club, which serves about 180 kids in the Twin Cities’ large
Somali-American community, operates on a bare-bones budget. There are no goal nets
at today’s practice and just one soccer ball so worn its patches are barely visible. When
one of the long-limbed athletes is in scoring position, the ball whizzes by those on the
bleachers and smacks the wall behind them, earning a coveted “Gool qurux badan baa
dhalisey!” (Beautiful goal!) from Coach Ahmed, as his players call him with affection.
Many of those who come to play are sitting in the bleachers, too. With inadequate
funding to rent facilities elsewhere, Ismail, a father of three who drives in from suburban
Savage most days, has a partitioned half of the community center’s dated gym for his
athletes. That forces him to play the youths in shifts so that each of the 40-plus SomaliAmerican teen boys at this day’s practice gets a turn.
Even those waiting to play, however, are fortunate. There are 140 youngsters on a
waiting list who want to play, too, but the nonprofit club’s limited finances mean it can’t
expand, a situation that other Somali-American youth development programs struggle
with as well.
In other cities, this unmet need would be a local concern. But with poverty plaguing this
impoverished immigrant community — the nation’s largest Somali settlement — and
terrorist recruiters preying on its young people, the lagging support for organizations
directly aiding vulnerable young people is a national security crisis requiring swift
remedy. Research shows that social programs are critical in preventing radicalization,
yet the federal and state governments are failing to adequately fund basic steps to build
community resilience.
Congress and the Obama administration need to work together to get past gridlock and
boost funding that has fallen far short of the rhetoric from President Obama and others
about countering radicalization. But given federal inaction, and the economic challenges
facing Somali-Americans here, a Minnesota-made solution also is needed.
(http://stmedia.startribune.com/images/ows_146136808614057.jpg)
CA R LO S G O N Z A L E Z & # X 2 0 2 2 ;
C G O N Z A L E Z@ STA RT R I B U N E .C O M
Without a net: Ahmed Ismail's West Bank
Athletic Club could beneyt if additional state
money for community development is…
It’s increasingly urgent for the state’s lawmakers, business community and respected
nonprofits to take their support to the next level. A logical start on it is passing three
bills in the Legislature that currently face daunting headwinds in a short session where
there’s little time and when anti-immigrant rhetoric is shamefully shaping election-year
rhetoric. The bills would expand a vital Cedar-Riverside neighborhood center, boost
opportunities for youth employment and provide $2 million for Somali-American youth
development grants.
The West Bank Athletic Club would be eligible to compete for these additional grant
dollars. More funding would help the organization include kids on its waiting list, buy
better equipment, travel or host more tournaments, and perhaps even find alternatives
to having Ismail and his volunteer assistants use their own vehicles to pick up kids for
practice. “This is my dream,’’ he said.
(http://stmedia.startribune.com/images/ows_146136809029623.j
Imam Sheikh Sa’ad Musse Roble, with the World
Peace Organization, greeted U.S. Attorney
Andrew Luger alongside Imam Ahmed Burale…
Underfunded ‘model’
When presidential contender Hillary Clinton visited the Twin Cities in December, she
lauded the “Minnesota model” of combating radicalization in immigrant communities.
Visitors from other cities and countries also frequently visit here to learn how the state
and city are helping new citizens integrate and build new lives far from their war-torn
African homeland.
The Census Bureau estimates the state’s Somali-American population at 29,000 to
36,000, with other estimates much higher. Many live in crowded high-rise apartments in
the Cedar-Riverside neighborhood less than a mile from downtown Minneapolis. A
finding in a state task force report released in February illustrates why the state is on the
http://www.startribune.com/countering­extremism­in­minnesota­a­beautiful­goal­barely­begun/376797911/
1/4
4/25/2016
Countering extremism in Minnesota: A beautiful goal, barely begun ­ StarTribune.com
front lines when it comes to countering recruiting by terrorists in Syria and Iraq.
Between 2011 and 2015, “15 of the 58 publicly-identified U.S.-originating foreign fighter
recruits were from Minnesota,’’ the report said.
It comes as a shock after Clinton’s high-profile praise to realize what a work in progress
the “Minnesota model” still is and how much of the progress is due less to coordinated
federal support than to local officials and organizations stepping up on their own to aid
a struggling new immigrant community. Minnesota law enforcement in particular
stands out for its early work establishing communication channels, community liaisons
and adding Somali-American officers after concerns arose about a decade ago about
recruitment by Al-Shabab, an African terror organization. An estimated 22 Minnesotans
left to join the group. Now, of course, the outside threat is ISIL in the Middle East.
Many of the state’s best-known philanthropies and businesses — including the General
Mills Foundation, the Mayo Clinic, the McKnight Foundation, the Otto Bremer
Foundation and the Minneapolis Foundation — have for years consistently funded a
variety of Somali community health and development efforts. Still, between 2004 and
2014, annual support dropped from $948,500 to $127,800, according to an editorial
writer’s analysis of the Minnesota Grantmakers Online database, underscoring the need
for renewed private help, as well as federal and state aid.
These early local initiatives helped lay the foundation for a burgeoning community of
grass-roots organizations such as Ismail’s soccer club and innovative private nonprofits
such as Youthprise, whose mission is to bridge the gap between large philanthropies and
small groups, such as those within the Somali community, that often struggle connecting
with wealthy nonprofits. Youthprise’s aim is not only innovative grantmaking but
“building capacity” in such communities, helping them learn how to apply for grants, for
example, and track how funds are spent.
This strong, local foundation would have ensured that federal funds to bolster youth
development, education and economic opportunities in the Somali community would
have been put to work quickly and effectively — had these funds been appropriated. In
2011, the White House released a national strategy paper that called well-equipped
families, resilient communities and local institutions the “best defenses against violent
extremist ideologies.” In 2014, the U.S. Department of Justice named Minneapolis-St.
Paul one of three “Building Resilience” pilot cities, along with Boston and Los Angeles.
But it wasn’t until 2015 that the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) asked
Congress for dedicated grants funding, specifically for community organizations that
work with at-risk young people.
The amount Congress approved in the federal spending bill that passed in December? A
paltry $10 million. Considering that experts believe $5 million a year is needed just in
Minneapolis-St. Paul, the $10 million for grants to be distributed nationally, and not just
in the pilot cities, is shockingly low, especially compared with the overall DHS budget of
$41 billion.
Asked about the delay and the amount, agency officials provided an excerpt from a
recent speech by DHS Secretary Jeh Johnson. He called it a “modest” start and said his
agency would try to push a gridlocked Congress for more. At the same time, Johnson
urged the tech industry and philanthropies to aid these efforts, suggesting that future
federal dollars are far from certain. The U.S. Department of Justice has also sought
funding for nationwide efforts to counter extremism, but the money was not
appropriated by Congress.
Some federal money has already made its way to Minnesota, with credit due to U.S.
Attorney Andrew Luger, who is working to bridge the gap between the rhetoric and the
actual sums for building resilient communities. About $216,000 in U.S. Department of
Justice funds, combined with private contributions, allowed Youthprise to award
$300,000 in one-year grants to six Minnesota organizations to fight youth radicalization.
The nonprofit reserved $100,000 for technical assistance and capacity-building to help
applicants who didn’t get funded.
Requests for the grant money totaled more than $1 million, far outstripping the
available dollars. “Next time there will be even more qualified applicants,’’ said
Youthprise’s Karen Kingsley.
Motives questioned
U.S. Attorney Luger’s advocacy for funding has not come without controversy. Jaylani
Hussein, the executive director for the Minnesota chapter of the Council on AmericanIslamic Relations, is among those alarmed by the funding’s dual purpose: countering
http://www.startribune.com/countering­extremism­in­minnesota­a­beautiful­goal­barely­begun/376797911/
2/4
4/25/2016
Countering extremism in Minnesota: A beautiful goal, barely begun ­ StarTribune.com
extremism and improving social services. Refugees from a Somali government that
abused and killed its citizens fear there is government surveillance of funded programs.
They also worry that the negative spotlight stigmatizes young people and the
community, he said.
Hussein also wants to know why it’s taken so long to spotlight the community’s
economic struggles. Somalis have been emigrating to the state since the 1980s. Fiftyseven percent are living at or near the poverty level — the highest percentage of any of
the state’s ethnic communities, according to a new Minnesota State Demographic Center
report. Only 8 percent of Somali-Minnesotans own their own homes, the lowest rate of
any of Minnesota’s ethnic communities, and 27 percent do not have a vehicle.
Hussein said private organizations and local government need to diversify their staffs
and ensure they are meeting today’s needs. In particular, Hussein is critical of the
Minneapolis and St. Paul parks leadership, saying they are acting like “there are still
Polish kids running around northeast Minneapolis” by focusing on T-ball and hockey
when newer immigrant communities such as Latinos and Somali-Americans are
interested in soccer and other activities.
But Minneapolis Park and Recreation Board officials recently announced that they are
taking steps to improve parks in underserved areas — an overdue but nevertheless
welcome move. Hussein’s criticism also overlooks Minnesota’s long history of
welcoming refugees and the comparatively generous support provided by both the
public and private sectors. It’s true that the terror recruitment has highlighted the need
for improved support, but Hussein badly underestimates his home state if he thinks that
this is the only reason Minnesotans want to help the Somali community here succeed.
Passage of the bills championed in the Minnesota Legislature by Rep. Phyllis Kahn and
state Sen. Kari Dziedzic — both DFLers — would not solve all of the community’s
challenges. But the $2 million for youth and community development, much of which
would go through Youthprise, would nevertheless quickly benefit young SomaliMinnesotans while helping fill the federal anti-radicalization funding gap. Among those
that could benefit from the additional money if the bill is passed: Ismail’s West Bank
Athletic Club, which received a $25,000 grant this year through Youthprise and could
apply again. Ka Joog, another well-respected youth program that runs arts programs,
camping retreats and an urban 4-H program, could be another beneficiary.
Expanding the heavily used Brian Coyle Community Center would be another practical
and high-profile step to build trust and bolster the Somali community. The Coyle Center
is just across the street from the colorful Cedar-Riverside high-rise apartments. Every
last inch of space is used in the 23-year-old building, which houses offices for Somali
community organizations, classrooms for language classes and homework help, and a
food shelf that serves 1,500 families a month. Half its square footage is a gym that’s in
constant demand for youth sports, gym classes for a nearby school, community
gatherings and even weddings.
Legislators and other potential backers, especially those who are parents, would quickly
see the reason why the center’s expansion is so important for young SomaliMinnesotans. The Cedar-Riverside neighborhood, one of the metro’s most densely
populated, is nearly walled off from the surrounding areas by Interstates 35W and 94,
the Blue and Green light-rail lines, the Mississippi River, and large University of
Minnesota buildings.
Other than tiny Currie Park adjacent to the Coyle Center, there’s little space for young
kids to play or for older kids to hang out, especially in the winter. The Coyle Center is a
safe harbor for those who want to do something other than spend time online, and most
kids head there after school, staying until closing to play basketball or get homework
help. But the center is maxed out, even as a new apartment building rises on the last
scraps of green space across the street.
“The population is going up but the resources are going down ’’ said Abdirahman
Mukhtar, the Coyle Center’s youth manager.
State lawmakers passed legislation last year providing $250,000 for anti-terror efforts in
Minnesota, a sum that pales compared with the community’s needs. The bills
introduced this year are aimed more specifically at youth development and are big
enough to make a difference. The $2 million in grants and the $5 million to $6 million
for adding a second floor to the Coyle Center are manageable amounts — especially
when the state has a $1.03 billion surplus and Gov. Mark Dayton is taking aim at the
state’s long-standing racial disparities.
http://www.startribune.com/countering­extremism­in­minnesota­a­beautiful­goal­barely­begun/376797911/
3/4
4/25/2016
Countering extremism in Minnesota: A beautiful goal, barely begun ­ StarTribune.com
Disenfranchisement and hopelessness leave young people here and around the world
vulnerable to deceptive promises from afar. Minnesota must do more than the
minimum and hope for the best. It ought to fight back with targeted investments that
not only show young Somali-Americans that they matter, but help them realize their
dreams of a bright future in their new homeland.
http://www.startribune.com/countering­extremism­in­minnesota­a­beautiful­goal­barely­begun/376797911/
4/4