EUROPEAN COMMISSION DIRECTORATE-GENERAL JRC JOINT RESEARCH CENTRE Institute for Prospective Technological Studies Sustainability in Industry, Energy and Transport European IPPC Bureau Additional Information submitted during the information exchange on Large Volume Inorganic Chemicals – Solid and Others Industry June 2005 Edificio EXPO, c/ Inca Garcilaso s/n, E-41092 Sevilla - Spain Telephone: direct line (+34-95) 4488-284, switchboard 4488-318. Fax: 4488-426. Internet: http://eippcb.jrc.es; Email: [email protected] Additional Information submitted during the information exchange on Large Volume Inorganic Chemicals – Solid and Others Industry INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................................................................VII 1 SELECTED ILLUSTRATIVE LVIC-S INDUSTRY PRODUCTS ..............................................1 1.1 Aluminium chlorides ..................................................................................................................1 1.1.1 Polyaluminium chloride ...................................................................................................1 1.1.1.1 General information..................................................................................................1 1.1.1.2 Process description ...................................................................................................2 1.1.1.2.1 Aluminium hydroxy chloride............................................................................2 1.1.1.2.2 Aluminium hydroxy chloride sulphate .............................................................2 1.1.1.3 Current consumption and emission levels ................................................................3 1.1.1.3.1 Aluminium hydroxy chloride............................................................................3 1.1.1.3.2 Aluminium hydroxy chloride sulphate .............................................................3 1.1.2 Aluminium chloride (solution) .........................................................................................4 1.1.2.1 General information..................................................................................................4 1.1.2.2 Process description ...................................................................................................4 1.1.2.3 Current consumption and emission levels ................................................................5 1.2 Aluminium sulphate....................................................................................................................6 1.2.1 General information..........................................................................................................6 1.2.1.1 Introduction ..............................................................................................................6 1.2.1.2 Information on aluminium sulphate – inorganic coagulants.....................................6 1.2.2 Process description ...........................................................................................................7 1.2.3 Current consumption and emission levels ........................................................................8 1.2.3.1 Consumption of raw materials ..................................................................................8 1.2.3.2 Major environmental impacts ...................................................................................8 1.3 Chromium compounds..............................................................................................................11 1.4 Ferric chloride...........................................................................................................................12 1.4.1 General information........................................................................................................12 1.4.1.1 Introduction – ferric chloride (FeCl3) .....................................................................12 1.4.1.2 Background information on ferric chloride (FeCl3)................................................12 1.4.2 Process description .........................................................................................................13 1.4.2.1 Ferric chloride solution (scrap iron + chlorine) ......................................................13 1.4.2.2 Ferric chloride solution (scrap iron + hydrochloric acid + chlorine) ......................13 1.4.2.3 Ferric chloride solution (spent FeCl2 liquor + chlorine) .........................................14 1.4.2.4 Ferric chloride solution (iron ore + hydrochloric acid)...........................................14 1.4.2.5 Ferric chloride solution (iron ore + hydrochloric acid + oxidation) .......................15 1.4.3 Current consumption and emission levels ......................................................................16 1.4.4 Special features and limiting factors...............................................................................16 1.4.5 Techniques to consider in the determination of BAT .....................................................17 1.4.6 Emerging techniques ......................................................................................................17 1.5 Potassium carbonate .................................................................................................................18 1.6 Sodium sulphate .......................................................................................................................19 1.6.1 General information........................................................................................................19 1.6.1.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................19 1.6.1.2 Basic data on sodium sulphate production..............................................................19 1.6.2 Industrial processes used ................................................................................................21 1.6.2.1 Fibres process (Na2SO4 production from the viscose-fibre process) ......................21 1.6.2.2 MESSO process (from Glauber’s salt) ...................................................................22 1.6.2.3 Chromium process ..................................................................................................23 1.6.2.4 Mannheim furnace process (hydrochloric acid)......................................................24 1.6.2.5 Methionine process.................................................................................................25 1.6.2.6 Formic acid process ................................................................................................27 1.6.3 Current emission and energy consumption levels ..........................................................28 1.6.4 Techniques to consider in the determination of BAT .....................................................29 1.7 Zinc chloride.............................................................................................................................31 1.8 Zinc sulphate.............................................................................................................................32 1.9 Sodium bisulphate ....................................................................................................................33 2 PURIFICATION OF NON-FERTILISER GRADE WET PHOSPHORIC ACID (PARTIAL INFORMATION) .............................................................................................................................. 1 2.1 Inorganic Phosphates – Introduction .......................................................................................... 1 2.2 Purification of non-fertiliser grade wet phosphoric acid – the options....................................... 3 REFERENCES........................................................................................................................................... 5 GLOSSARY OF TERMS AND ABBREVIATIONS .............................................................................. 9 List of figures Figure 1.1: Figure 1.2: Figure 1.3: Figure 1.4: Figure 1.5: Figure 1.6: Figure 1.7: Figure 1.8: Figure 1.9: Figure 1.10: Figure 1.11: Figure 1.12: Figure 1.13: Figure 1.14: Figure 1.15: Figure 1.16: Process flow diagram – manufacture of aluminium hydroxy chloride...................................2 Process flow diagram – manufacture of aluminium hydroxy chloride sulphate ....................3 Process flow diagram – manufacture of aluminium chloride solution ...................................4 Process flow diagram of aluminium sulphate production ......................................................8 A chromium chemical complex ...........................................................................................11 Process diagram - production of FeCl3 based on scrap iron and chlorine ............................13 Process diagram - production of FeCl3 based on scrap iron, HCl and chlorine...................14 Process diagram - production of FeCl3 based on iron ore and hydrochloric acid.................15 Process diagram – production of FeCl3 based on iron ore and HCl and oxidation ..............16 Flow scheme of sodium sulphate production from the viscose-fibre process ......................22 Flow scheme of sodium sulphate production by the Messo process ....................................23 Flow scheme of the production of sodium sulphate from the chromium process ................24 Flow scheme of the production of Na2SO4 by the Mannheim furnace process....................25 Flow scheme of the production of sodium sulphate from the methionine process...............27 Flow scheme of sodium sulphate production in the formic acid process .............................28 Technological network of zinc chemical compounds ..........................................................31 List of tables Table 1.1: Table 1.2: Table 1.3: Table 1.4: Table 1.5: Table 1.6: Table 1.7: Table 1.8: Table 1.9: Table 1.10: Table 1.11: Table 1.12: Table 1.13: Typical consumption and emission values – aluminium hydroxy chloride ........................... 3 Typical consumption and emission values – aluminium hydroxy chloride sulphate ............. 3 Typical consumption and emission values – aluminium chloride solution............................ 5 Major applications of aluminium sulphate ............................................................................ 7 Typical energy consumption and emission values for liquid aluminium sulphate ................ 9 Typical energy consumption and emission values for solid aluminium sulphate .................. 9 Location and capacities of FeCl3 plants in the EU............................................................... 12 Consumption and emission values in the production of ferrous chloride ............................ 16 Sodium sulphate production in Europe................................................................................ 20 Sodium sulphate production – emissions to air (aggregated data: min – max).................... 28 Sodium sulphate production – emissions to water (aggregated data: min – max) ............... 29 Sodium sulphate production – solid residues (aggregated data: min –max) ........................ 29 Sodium sulphate production - energy consumption (aggregated data: min - max).............. 29 Introduction INTRODUCTION The information contained in this document was submitted as part of the information exchange on BAT for the production of Large Volume Inorganic Chemicals – Solid and Others (LVIC-S). However, it was either submitted very late in the process or insufficient information is available to draw BAT conclusions for the nine ‘selected illustrative’ LVIC-S industry products included in this document (see the content list). In order not to lose this partial information, it is made available here. It must be stressed, however, that this document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only. This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only 1 SELECTED ILLUSTRATIVE LVIC-S INDUSTRY PRODUCTS 1.1 Aluminium chlorides In principle, the information contained in this section relates to aluminium chlorides, which are used as inorganic coagulants. Aluminium chloride is also extensively utilised in its anhydrous form. In 1984 approx. 30000 tonnes was produced in the US and approx. 50000 tonnes in Western Europe [48, W. Buchner et al, 1989]. Anhydrous aluminium chloride is mainly used as a catalyst in organic chemistry, essentially as an alkylation catalyst, either in fine chemistry, or in the production of commodity organics like ethylbenzene in competition with e.g. solid catalysts. Its significance in the petrochemical industry has strongly decreased with the advent of zeolite-based catalysts [6, CEFIC, 2002]. It can be produced by two process routes: From aluminium This process is based on the reaction of gaseous chlorine injected into a molten aluminium bath at a typical temperature of 800 °C. The equation of the reaction is: 2 Al + 3 Cl2 F 2 AlCl3 The chlorine conversion is very rapid and complete. Aluminium chloride leaves the reactor as a vapour, which is condensed to a solid on a cooled surface. The solid aluminium chloride is conditioned by crushing and sieving, then stored in bulk or packaged and finally shipped. Air emissions from the vent in the aluminium chloride condensation reactor and from the conditioning, handling and storage systems contain chlorine, hydrochloric acid and aluminium chloride. Emissions to water are essentially from the vents scrubbers, and include hydrochloric acid and dissolved/suspended aluminium compounds. Waste generation is very small and includes essentially aluminium hydroxide sludge recovered from waste water treatment. From aluminium oxide This process, which is no longer used in Europe, is based on the carbo-chlorination of aluminium oxide according to the following reaction: 2 Al2O3 + 3 C + 6 Cl2 F 3 CO2 + 4 AlCl3 In addition to the environmental issues of the aluminium process, generic CO, SOx and NOx air emissions occur, while the formation of some chlorinated organics is possible [6, CEFIC, 2002]. 1.1.1 1.1.1.1 Polyaluminium chloride General information Product Name : CAS number : Polyaluminium chloride 1327-41-9 (Aluminium hydroxy chloride) and 39290-78-3 (Aluminium hydroxy chloride sulphate) Polyaluminium chloride is a very common aluminium salt, the major uses of which are: Use Water Treatment Paper Additive Application As a coagulant for drinking, industrial waste and municipal waste water As a retention and fixing agent, and a sizing additive 1 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only Due to different types of polyaluminium chloride (PAC) with different aluminium contents, all tonnage related data are normalised to one common PAC with a content of 9 % aluminium and are calculated on this basis. About 520000 tonnes of PAC were produced in Europe in 2002 at about 17 locations [89, CEFIC-INCOPA, 2004]. 1.1.1.2 Process description 1.1.1.2.1 Aluminium hydroxy chloride Aluminium hydroxy chloride is formed directly by the digestion of aluminium hydroxide and hydrochloric acid in an under-stoichiometric reaction. The reaction is carried out at a temperature between 140 and 160 °C and pressure between 3 and 5 bars. After the reaction, insoluble aluminium hydroxide is removed by filtration and is used again at the beginning of the process. The clear liquid is conditioned with water to become the finished product of a well defined quality. Al(OH)3 + HCl F Alx(OH)yClz + H2O The process diagram of the manufacture of aluminium hydroxy chloride is given in Figure 1.1. Al(OH)3 Reaction Filtration PAC HCl Unreacted Al(OH)3 Figure 1.1: Process flow diagram – manufacture of aluminium hydroxy chloride [89, CEFIC-INCOPA, 2004] 1.1.1.2.2 Aluminium hydroxy chloride sulphate Aluminium hydroxy chloride sulphate is formed by the digestion of aluminium hydroxide with hydrochloric acid and sulphuric acid. The reaction is carried out at a temperature between 105 and 115 °C. The reaction solution is partially neutralised by CaCO3 slurry to remove excessive sulphate by forming gypsum (CaSO4.2 H2O). The mother liquor is separated from the gypsum by filtration. The gypsum is washed and the washing water is used to condition the product. Al(OH)3 + HCl + H2SO4 + CaCO3 F Alp(OH)qClr(SO4)s + H2O + CaSO4 + CO2 The process diagram of the manufacture of aluminium hydroxy chloride sulphate is given in Figure 1.2. 2 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only Al(OH) 3 H 2SO 4 CaCO 3 Reaction Neutralisation HCl Washing water Filtration Conditioning Water Mother liquor PAC CaSO 4 *2H 2 O Figure 1.2: Process flow diagram – manufacture of aluminium hydroxy chloride sulphate [89, CEFIC-INCOPA, 2004] 1.1.1.3 Current consumption and emission levels 1.1.1.3.1 Aluminium hydroxy chloride Typical consumption and emission values are given in Table 1.1. Consumption of energy and water Energy consumption kWh/t product 600 Water consumption m3/t product 1.5 Emissions to air Chemical Emission kg/t product Emission concentration limit HCl 0.01 500 mg/Nm3 Emissions to water Chemical Emission kg/t product Comments HCl 0.8 Water is mostly recycled Waste to land Chemical Waste kg/t product Comments Al(OH)3 12 Mostly recycled Table 1.1: Typical consumption and emission values – aluminium hydroxy chloride [89, CEFIC-INCOPA, 2004] 1.1.1.3.2 Aluminium hydroxy chloride sulphate Typical consumption and emission values are given in Table 1.2 Consumption of energy and water Energy consumption kWh/t product 200 Water consumption m3/t product 15 Emissions to air Chemical Emission kg/t product Emission concentration limit HCl 0.2 500 mg/Nm3 Emissions to water Chemical Emission kg/t product Comments HCl 35 Scrubber water CaSO4 3800 Water with gypsum Waste to land Chemical Waste kg/t product Comments Gypsum, Al(OH)3 1.5 Table 1.2: Typical consumption and emission values – aluminium hydroxy chloride sulphate [89, CEFIC-INCOPA, 2004] 3 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only There are no special features or limiting factors to be mentioned [89, CEFIC-INCOPA, 2004]. There is a wide range of air and water emissions. This depends on the type of gas scrubber. Some scrubbers can recycle water by concentrating hydrochloric acid and re-using it in the process. Therefore, waste water emission from scrubber water is minimised. 1.1.2 Aluminium chloride (solution) 1.1.2.1 General information Product Name : CAS number : Aluminium chloride solution Not established for aluminium chloride solution Aluminium chloride is a very common aluminium salt, the major uses of which are: Use Water treatment Application As a coagulant for drinking, industrial waste and municipal waste water About 25000 tonnes of aluminium chloride (as inorganic coagulant) were produced in 2002 at three locations. 1.1.2.2 Process description Aluminium chloride solution is formed directly by the digestion of aluminium hydroxide and hydrochloric acid in a stoichiometric reaction. The reaction is carried out at a temperature between 100 and 110 °C. After the reaction, insoluble aluminium hydroxide is removed by filtration and is used again at the beginning of the process. The clear liquid is conditioned with water to become the finished product of a well defined quality. Al(OH)3 + 3HCl F AlCl3 + 3H2O The process flow diagram for the manufacture of aluminium chloride solution is given in Figure 1.3. Al(OH)3 Reaction Filtration HCl Unreacted Al(OH)3 Figure 1.3: Process flow diagram – manufacture of aluminium chloride solution [89, CEFIC-INCOPA, 2004] 4 AlCl3 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only 1.1.2.3 Current consumption and emission levels Typical consumption and emission values are given in Table 1.3. Consumption of energy and water Energy consumption kWh/t product Water consumption m3/t product Emissions to air Emission kg/t product Chemical HCl 0.02 Emissions to water Chemical Emission kg/t product HCl 0.1 Waste to land Chemical Waste kg/t product Al(OH)3 0.1 100 3 Emission concentration limit 10 mg/Nm3 Comments Comments Undissolved raw material Table 1.3: Typical consumption and emission values – aluminium chloride solution [89, CEFIC-INCOPA, 2004] There are no special features or limiting factors to be mentioned [89, CEFIC-INCOPA, 2004]. There is a wide range of air and water emissions. This depends on the type of gas scrubber. Some scrubbers can recycle water by concentrating hydrochloric acid and re-using it in the process. Therefore, waste water emission from scrubber water is minimised. 5 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only 1.2 1.2.1 Aluminium sulphate General information 1.2.1.1 Introduction With a worldwide production of 2.9 million tonnes in 1982, aluminium sulphate is the most important aluminium compound after aluminium oxide and hydroxide, these latter compounds are already covered in the Non-Ferrous Metals BREF. The most important producers are the US (with 1.1 million tonnes in 1984 on the basis of 17 % Al2O3, Western Europe (with 0.9 million tonnes per year) and Japan (with 0.8 million tonnes per year on the basis of 14 % Al2O3) [48, W. Buchner et al, 1989]. Aluminium sulphate is a substance essentially used in water treatment as a flocculating agent and in the paper industry. Aluminium sulphate is also the starting material for other aluminium compounds [13, EIPPCB, 2000]. The commercial product is either a solid hydrated salt, whose formula is typically Al2(SO4)3.13 to 15 H2O. It is shipped in flakes, powder or blocks, or as an 8 % (as Al2O3) solution in water [6, CEFIC, 2002]. Aluminium sulphate is industrially produced by the reaction of aluminium hydroxide (or other aluminium raw materials such as bauxite or kaolin) with sulphuric acid. In Europe, the largest part of aluminium sulphate is produced by the reaction of sulphuric acid with wet or dry aluminium hydroxide according to the following reaction: 2Al(OH)3 + 3 H2SO4 F Al2(SO4)3 + 6H2O This reaction is the common trunk of all processes, and it is typically carried out in a stirred batch reactor at a temperature of 110 – 120 °C and under atmospheric pressure. The resulting solution is treated differently according to the shipment mode: • • for shipment as a solution, the Al2O3 concentration of the mixture leaving the reactor is simply adjusted, and the resulting solution is clarified (by filtration). This process only generates minor air and water emissions for shipment as a solid, the mixture leaving the reactor is sent either to a crystalliser, a flaker or a solidification box according to the shape required. Further treatments may include crushing, milling, sieving before packaging. This process generates almost clean waste water from the concentration steps and air emissions containing particulate from solid handling. Other feedstocks e.g. bauxite or clays, are industrially used, but as they are not as pure as aluminium hydroxide, their processing either leads to a less pure aluminium sulphate (e.g. containing soluble iron sulphate or suspended solids) or generates solid wastes. Also, spent aluminium salts solutions (e.g. from aluminium surface treatment activities) can be a source of small amounts of aluminium sulphate used for the local markets [6, CEFIC, 2002]. 1.2.1.2 Information on aluminium sulphate – inorganic coagulants The substances covered are all based on aluminium sulphate in a solid or liquid pure form or containing additives, mainly iron, in the form of iron sulphate. In both the solid and liquid form, the categories can be split into three groups: • • • 6 iron free low iron iron blends. This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only Solid products have a concentration of between 7 – 9.3 % Al with a typical concentration of 9.1 % equivalent to 14 crystal water. Concentration in liquid products is 3.5 – 4.5 % Al. The iron content in the substances can typically vary between 0 – 3 % as Fe. Solid products are produced in every fraction from fine powder up to blocks of about 10 kg. Product Name : Derivatives: Aluminium sulphate Al2(SO4)3 Low iron aluminium sulphate, iron containing aluminium sulphate, aluminium basic sulphate. As illustrated in Table 1.4, aluminium sulphate is a very common product that is used in the following major areas: Use Drinking water treatment Sewage water treatment Paper industry Other applications Share ~ 30 % ~ 10 % ~ 40 % ~ 20 % Application Coagulant for purification Coagulant for purification and phosphorus removal Coagulant for water purification and paper sizing Pigment production, cement industry, detergent, fire extinguishers, etc. Table 1.4: Major applications of aluminium sulphate [50, CEFIC-INCOPA, 2004] Due to its low value and high production volumes, aluminium sulphate is produced in most European countries to cover the local demand. The number of production units within Europe is about 65 plants. From these, about 15 units are outside the EU-15. The total capacity is at the level of 1.2 million tonnes calculated as solid equivalents of 9.1 % Al. The capacity utilisation is on average 50 %, which would bring the total European market to about 600000 tonnes, i.e. 20 – 25 % of the total world market [50, CEFIC-INCOPA, 2004]. 1.2.2 Process description Aluminium sulphate comes directly from the digestion of aluminium containing raw materials with sulphuric acid. 2Al(OH)3 + 3H2SO4 F Al2(SO4)3 + 6H2O The most common aluminium raw material is by far aluminium hydroxide, a product originating from the Bayer process, where bauxite is used as a raw material for the production of pure aluminium hydroxide or oxide. For the production of iron containing aluminium sulphate products, bauxite is also used as a source for aluminium raw material. The digestion with sulphuric acid normally takes place at atmospheric pressure and at a temperature between 110 – 120 ºC. In some cases pressure digestion is also used with a temperature up to about 170 °C. The heat necessary for the process comes from the exothermic reaction. The normal Al-concentration in the digester is in the ratio of 7 – 9 %, which means that the boiling temperature is around 120 °C and the crystallisation temperature 105 – 110 °C. A small amount of steam is sometimes used to avoid crystallisation and prolong the reaction. Otherwise the energy consumption of the process is limited to pumps and agitators. After digestion, the product is either diluted with water for a liquid product or, in a solidification unit, cooled directly or indirectly with air or water to a solid form, which is then ground and screened to the required particle size. Dust coming from this process is handled by filters or scrubbers. This dust is commonly recycled through a dilution step in the production of aluminium sulphate solution. 7 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only The use of alternatives to aluminium hydroxide, like bauxite, will create a waste coming out of the process mainly consisting of an insoluble silica rest. This is, however, less than when bauxite is used for the production of aluminium hydroxide [50, CEFIC-INCOPA, 2004]. In the production of aluminium sulphate products containing iron, the iron either comes directly from the raw material (bauxite), or is separately added to the reactor, or is mixed with the final product. The process flow diagram of aluminium sulphate production is given in Figure 1.4. H2SO4 Al (OH)3 Reaction Liquid production Dilution Water Solid production Crystallisation Cooling (water or air) Dust to process Rest Filtration Screening Grinding Storage Storage Gas cleaning Figure 1.4: Process flow diagram of aluminium sulphate production [50, CEFIC-INCOPA, 2004] If air is used in direct contact with the product, the air is cleaned in a gas cleaning system. All dust that is separated is returned to the process [50, CEFIC-INCOPA, 2004]. 1.2.3 1.2.3.1 Current consumption and emission levels Consumption of raw materials Consumption figures for solid aluminium sulphate are about: 50 % sulphuric acid, 30 % aluminium hydroxide, and 20 % water. The consumption figures for liquid products are about: 20 – 25 % sulphuric acid, 12 – 15 aluminium hydroxide and 60 – 65 % water. The reaction is almost complete, the yield of the raw materials being nearly 100 % [50, CEFIC-INCOPA, 2004]. 1.2.3.2 Major environmental impacts Typical energy and water consumption figures and emissions values for liquid aluminium sulphate are given in Table 1.5. 8 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only Energy consumption kWh/tonne product <300 <40 Electricity Other energy (estimated LPG) Water consumption Water consumption (m3/tonne product) Cooling water (kWh/tonne product) Emissions to air Type of emission H2SO4 Particles Al and its compounds Carbon dioxide Emissions to water Type of emission Waste to land: Type of waste Filter cake (active waste) Comments 0.7 – 1.4 (kg/tonne product) <0.01 <0.002 <0.0002 <10 Comments (kg/tonne product) Comments The process operates in a closed system (kg/tonne product) <0.7 Comments Emissions of the product Emissions of raw materials Table 1.5: Typical energy consumption and emission values for liquid aluminium sulphate [50, CEFIC-INCOPA, 2004] If bauxite is used as a raw material for liquid aluminium sulphate, this generates a waste to land at the plant. Otherwise, there is no significant difference between iron free and low iron or iron containing aluminium sulphate regarding consumption figures, and waste and emissions levels. Typical energy and water consumption figures and emissions values for solid aluminium sulphate are given in Table 1.6. Electricity Other energy Energy consumption kWh/tonne product Comments <50 Minor energy may be used for preventing crystallisation in the process Water consumption Water consumption (m3/tonne product) 0.26 – 0.46 Cooling water (kWh/tonne product) Emissions to air Type of emission (kg/tonne product) Comments Dust <0.01 H2SO4 <0.003 Carbon dioxide <0.005 Al and its compounds <0.01 Emissions to water Type of emission (kg/tonne product) Comments The process operates in a closed system Waste to land Type of waste (kg/tonne product) Comments Al sulphate <0.01 Table 1.6: Typical energy consumption and emission values for solid aluminium sulphate [50, CEFIC-INCOPA, 2004] There are no significant differences in consumption figures, emissions and waste if it is iron free, low iron or iron containing aluminium sulphate. 9 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only The following are special features and limiting factors relating to the production of aluminium sulphate [50, CEFIC-INCOPA, 2004]: • • • • 10 the digestion process of aluminium hydroxide with sulphuric acid gives a yield of practically 100 %, which means that the only emission from the production is some steam coming from the reactor as the process is exothermic, the energy consumption is negligible grinding, screening and bagging the solid form of aluminium sulphate creates dust, but this is taken care of by filters or scrubbers and is recycled back into the process, or sold as a fine powder only in the case of using bauxite as a raw material in liquid production, will there be a waste stream coming from the process in the form of insoluble silica, which is, however, less than when the same amount of bauxite is used for the production of aluminium hydroxide. This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only 1.3 Chromium compounds The following chromium compounds are economically important [48, W. Buchner et al, 1989]: • • • • • dichromates and chromates – (basic intermediate, fireworks, dyes, chromate pigments) chromium(VI) oxide (chromic anhydride) – (metal alloys, refractory bricks, dyes) chromium(III) oxide (the green pigment in glass, porcelain, and oil paint) basic chromium(III) sulphate (chrome tanning agents) chromium(VI) and(III) compounds and chromium(IV) oxide (pigments: ceramics, textiles, magnetic pigment). Production pathways to the important chromium compounds lead from chromium ore via the commercially most important chromium (VI) compound sodium dichromate (dihydrate) Na2Cr2O7.2H2O, to which the capacities of chromium chemicals are usually referred. A chromium chemical complex is illustrated in Figure 1.5 below [85, EIPPCB, 2004]. Chromium ore (chromite Cr2O 3.FeO) 8000 TPY Sodium dichromate plant (Na2Cr 2O 7) 5000 TPY (1 kiln) + dolomite + soda ash + sulphuric acid + fuel oil Chromium waste (chromium mud and sodium sulphate) 5000 TPY 550 TPY Basic chromium sulphate Cr(SO 4)OH plant 1000 TPY 1000 TPY Sodium chromate (Na2CrO 4) plant 1000 TPY 1000 TPY Potassium dichromate K 2Cr 2O 7 plant 1000 TPY 1000 TPY Chromic acid anhydride (CrO 3) plant 700 TPY 700 TPY 4450 TPY 650 TPY Leather tanning, alloys, catalysts Chromate pigments, chromium dyes 3800 TPY 1400 TPY Engraving chemicals, fireworks, dyes 2400 TPY 1200 TPY Chrom. metal alloys, refractory brick, dyes 1200 TPY 700 TPY Sodium dichromate for salecommodity producttanning, dyeing Optional chromic acid plant 500 TPY 500 TPY Timber preservation, catalysts production Note: Other chromium compounds may be manufactured at the request such as (NH 4)2 Cr2O 7, ZnCrO 4, PbCrO 4, BaCrO 4. Figure 1.5: A chromium chemical complex [EIPPCB, 2004 #85], based on [BIPROKWAS, 1985-1995 #79] No further information submitted. 11 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only 1.4 1.4.1 1.4.1.1 Ferric chloride General information Introduction – ferric chloride (FeCl3) Of the halides of iron, only iron(II) chloride (ferrous chloride FeCl2) and iron(III) chloride (ferric chloride FeCl3) have become commercially important [87, Ullmann's, 2001]. Ferric chloride is muchP more important industrially than ferrous chloride. Anhydrous iron(III) chloride (FeCl3) is industrially produced by a high temperature reaction of dry chlorine with scrap iron (direct chlorination). Ferric chloride is also aP by-product of some metallurgical and chemical processes, such as the chlorinating decomposition of ironbearing oxide ores. Its ready availability and cheap feedstock (iron and chlorine) have made iron(III) chloride, especially its aqueous solution, a significant raw material for many industries, in particular for water treatment and for the production of iron oxides or other iron compounds – refer to the BREF on Ferrous Metals Processing Industry (FMP). 1.4.1.2 Background information on ferric chloride (FeCl3) Product Name: Chemical Formula CAS number: Ferric chloride 40 % FeCl3 7705-08-0 (Ferric chloride solution 40 %) Ferric chloride can be used in different applications. A. Principal uses include: • • • • • • • turbidity reduction colour elimination coagulation sludge reduction filter conditioning arsenic removal metal etching. B. Waste water treatment: • • • • phosphate precipitation and removal sedimentation dewatering sulphide based odour elimination. The major EU ferric chloride capacities are listed in Table 1.7: Location of the FeCl3 plants in the EU Area 1: Benelux, Germany, Austria and Switzerland Area 2: Italy, France, Spain, Portugal Area 3: Nordic countries (Finland, Denmark, Sweden, Norway), UK, Ireland, Slovenia, Hungary Total Number of sites 10 14 6 Capacity 550000 500000 250000 30 1300000 Table 1.7: Location and capacities of FeCl3 plants in the EU [CEFIC-INCOPA, 2004 #112] 12 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only 1.4.2 Process description Ferric chloride can be manufactured according to the following five major process routes: 1.4.2.1 Ferric chloride solution (scrap iron + chlorine) 1. Reactions: Fe + 2 FeCl3 3 FeCl2 2. 3 FeCl2 + 3/2 Cl2 (g) 3 FeCl3 The scrap iron is added to a dissolving tank with a solution of ferric chloride and converted into a ferrous chloride solution. In the second step, the ferrous chloride solution is oxidised in a chlorination tower using Cl2 (g). The product is divided, about 2/3 is recycled to the first stage, and about 1/3 is withdrawn as a final FeCl3 product. A process flow diagram illustrating the production of FeCl3 based on scrap iron and chlorine is given in Figure 1.6 below: W ater Scrap iron 2/3 FeCl3 (recycled) RE AC TO R (Ferrous C hloride (FeC l 2 )) Sludge FILT R ATIO N C l 2 (g) CH LO R IN ATIO N 1/3 Ferric C hloride (FeC l 3 ) Figure 1.6: Process diagram - production of FeCl3 based on scrap iron and chlorine [CEFIC-INCOPA, 2004 #112] 1.4.2.2 Ferric chloride solution (scrap iron + hydrochloric acid + chlorine) Reactions: 1. 2. Fe + 2HCl FeCl2 + ½ Cl2 (g) FeCl2 + H2 FeCl3 FeCl2 is produced by the reaction of scrap iron with hydrochloric acid at a temperature of >80 °C, hydrogen being released to the atmosphere. This solution is also converted into ferric chloride by using Cl2 (g) in a chlorination tower. 13 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only A process flow diagram illustrating the production of FeCl3 based on scrap iron, hydrochloric acid and chlorine is given in Figure 1.7 below: Water HCl Scrap iron H2 Reactor (Ferrous Chloride (FeCl2) Spent liquor Cl2(g) Filtration Sludge Chlorination FeCl3 Figure 1.7: Process diagram - production of FeCl3 based on scrap iron, HCl and chlorine [CEFIC-INCOPA, 2004 #112] 1.4.2.3 Ferric chloride solution (spent FeCl2 liquor + chlorine) Reaction: FeCl2 + ½ Cl2 (g) FeCl3 The spent liquor (FeCl2 + free HCl) recovered from different industries (for example: steel industry, galvanising industry, wire industry, …) can be added to a reactor with iron to neutralise free HCl (in case when the concentration of free HCl >1 %), and then oxidised to ferric chloride by chlorine (see Figure 1.7 above) or, alternatively, directly converted into ferric chloride by chlorination if the concentration of free HCl <1 % (see Figure 1.7 above). A combination of processes described in Sections 1.4.2.1 and 1.4.2.2 above may also be used to produce ferric chloride solution at a fixed concentration from spent acid (pickle liquor) of varying concentrations. 1.4.2.4 Ferric chloride solution (iron ore + hydrochloric acid) Reaction: Fe2O3 + 6HCl 2FeCl3 + 3H2O FeCl3 is prepared by the dissolution of iron ore (hematite containing Fe >70 %) in hydrochloric acid (HCl >33 %). The reaction takes place at the temperature of 80 – 120 °C and under ambient pressure, reaction time being 1 – 2 h. A process flow diagram illustrating the production of FeCl3 based on iron ore and hydrochloric acid is given in Figure 1.8 below: 14 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only Iron ore HCl REACTOR Sludge FILTRATION FeCl3 Figure 1.8: Process diagram - production of FeCl3 based on iron ore and hydrochloric acid [CEFIC-INCOPA, 2004 #112] 1.4.2.5 Ferric chloride solution (iron ore + hydrochloric acid + oxidation) Reactions: Dissolution of iron ore in hydrochloric acid: Fe3O4 (Fe2O3 + FeO) + 8HCl 2FeCl3 + FeCl2 + 4H2O Oxidation of ferrous chloride using chlorine, hydrogen peroxide, or sodium chlorate: or or FeCl2 + ½ Cl2 FeCl2 + HCl + ½ H2O2 FeCl2 + ½ NaOCl3 FeCl3 FeCl3 + H2O FeCl3 + ½ NaOCl The iron ore (magnetite: 2/3 Fe2O3 + 1/3 FeO) is dissolved in a reactor with hydrochloric acid (HCl >33 %) at the temperature of >80 °C, to obtain a mixture of ferric chloride and ferrous chloride. In turn, this solution can be totally oxidised to form FeCl3 using Cl2 (g) or NaClO3 or H2O2 as oxidants. In the different processes (Sections 1.4.2.1, 1.4.2.2, 1.4.2.3, 1.4.2.5), chlorine – as the oxidation agent – can be replaced with oxygen together with hydrochloric acid. In some cases, it then gives a more diluted FeCl3 solution. A process flow diagram illustrating the production of FeCl3 based on iron ore, hydrochloric acid and oxidation is given in Figure 1.9 below: 15 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only Iron ore HCl REACTOR 2/3 FeCl 3 , 1/3 FeCl2 Sludge FILTR ATION Chlorination tow er Cl2 (g) Oxydising reactor H 2 O 2 or NaClO 3 FeCl 3 Figure 1.9: Process diagram – production of FeCl3 based on iron ore and HCl and oxidation [CEFIC-INCOPA, 2004 #112] 1.4.3 Current consumption and emission levels Consumption and emission values in the production of ferrous chloride are given in Table 1.8: Energy and water consumption Energy consumption GJ/t product 0.012 to 0.3 Water consumption m3/t product 0.25 to 13 Emissions to air Emission kg/t product CO2 2 to 12 Hydrogen 0.73 to 13 Hydrogen chloride 0.0007 to 0.01 Emissions to water Emission kg/t product Iron 0.05 to 5 Zinc 0.005 to 1.5 Heavy metals <0.0005 to 0.6 Waste to land Waste kg/t product Solid waste 5 to 35 Table 1.8: Consumption and emission values in the production of ferrous chloride [CEFIC-INCOPA, 2004 #112] 1.4.4 Special features and limiting factors There are no special features to be mentioned. 16 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only 1.4.5 Techniques to consider in the determination of BAT Ferric chloride can be made by a variety of processes. This leads to a wide range of environmental performances. The process based on the use of spent acid (pickle liquor) and the process using iron ore are the most common technologies. In the case of ferric chloride, the variety of equipment used is limited as the processes are generally simple. Therefore, within a particular process, the type and the technology of a particular item of equipment (i.e a filter) can greatly affect the overall performance of the process from an environmental point of view. 1.4.6 Emerging techniques As filtration is used in almost every process, the equipment that minimises emissions to water can be considered and, if possible, included in a new plant set-up. The manufacturing of ferric chloride is exothermic, therefore heat recovery options can be examined and, if possible, included in a new process scheme. Emissions to air can be controlled via a scrubbing technique. An area for future research and development would be the recycling of the hydrogen. 17 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only 1.5 Potassium carbonate Potassium carbonate (K2CO3) finds its major application in the speciality glass industry e.g. in television screens where it performs better than glass made with soda ash [6, CEFIC, 2002]. Potassium carbonate is produced by reacting potassium hydroxide with carbon dioxide, as follows: 2KOH + CO2 F K2CO3 + H2O It is shipped both as an aqueous solution, or it is crystallised and shipped as crystals. Air emissions are due to the handling of solid materials. Water emissions are due to the water evaporated during the crystallisation step. Waste generation is negligible [6, CEFIC, 2002]. Potassium carbonate (potash) was formerly produced by the ashing of wood and other raw materials from plants. Since the middle of the XIX century, the saline residues from the rock salt industry and salt deposits have been the raw materials used for the production of potassium carbonate. Currently, the most important process is the carbonation of electrolytically produced potassium hydroxide as described by the reaction above [48, W. Buchner et al, 1989]. Potassium hydroxide solutions (50 % KOH) are saturated with CO2, the solution is partially eveporated and the potassium carbonate hydrate K2CO3.1.5 H2O which precipitates is separated off. After drying, the product is either marketed as potash hydrate or is calcined in a rotary kiln at temperatures of 250 to 350 ºC. Anhydrous potassium carbonate is also produced using a fluid bed process, in which KOH is reacted with CO2 gas countercurrently in a fluidised bed reactor. In Russia, potassium carbonate is also produced from deposits of alkali aluminosilicates (e.g. nepheline) together with aluminium oxide, cement and sodium carbonate. The main applications of potassium carbonate include [48, W. Buchner et al, 1989]: • • • • • • • glass manufacture (special glasses, crystal glass, CRT-tubes for TV) soaps, detergents enamels food industry pigment manufacture other downstream K compounds (potassium hydrogen carbonate, potassium silicate) synthesis of many organic chemicals and pharmaceutical products. Since no information was submitted on potassium carbonate, therefore, the ‘Techniques to consider in the determination of BAT’ relevant to the production of potassium carbonate could not have been analysed in this document. No further information provided. 18 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only 1.6 1.6.1 Sodium sulphate General information The production of natural sodium sulphate (like the production of natural NaCl or CaSO4) is based on the extraction of a mineral with high content of sodium sulphate and its recovery in a high purity grade through successive crystallisation/separation stages. This type of extractive industry is not classified by the IPPC Directive and, therefore, it is not included in this document. There are four producers of natural sodium sulphate in the EU-15, all of them located in Spain and their emission values have not been included in this section. 1.6.1.1 Introduction The world production of sodium sulphate (anhydrous or as Glauber’s salt – sodium sulphate decahydrate Na2SO4.10H2O) was reported to be at the level of 4.2 million tonnes per year in 1985, out of which almost 50 % was produced from natural deposits [48, W. Buchner et al, 1989]. The production of pure sodium sulphate or Glauber’s salt from natural minerals such as thenardite Na2SO4 or glauberite Na2SO4.CaSO4 is still important in Spain, Canada, the US, Russia and China. Other production processes of sodium sulphate from salt lakes, salt brines and potassium salt deposits (in this latter case via reaction of kieserite MgSO4.H2O with sodium chloride NaCl), and in particular, sodium sulphate by-produced in large quantities in various chemical and metallurgical processes are increasing [48, W. Buchner et al, 1989]. Sodium sulphate is a solid salt having wide range of applications in miscellaneous industrial sectors like detergents, glass production or cellulose fibres [6, CEFIC, 2002]. Half of the production is extracted from natural deposits while the remaining part is a by-product of other industrial chemical processes, usually resulting from the neutralisation of excess sulphuric acid. Therefore, the production of sodium sulphate may, in some places, exceed the commercial demand, and processes have been developed to address this issue, using e.g. an electrochemical decomposition route. The direct production processes based on the reaction of solid sodium chloride with sulphuric acid or sulphur dioxide/oxygen have become less important [EIPPCB, 2004-2005 #85]. Chemical processes like viscose-fibre spinning, ascorbic acid synthesis or sodium dichromate production, deliver aqueous solutions of sodium sulphate which are, if necessary, concentrated, and then directed to a crystallisation system which produces either directly anhydrous sodium sulphate crystals or Glauber salt crystals (sodium sulphate decahydrate Na2SO4.10H2O) that are further dehydrated. Electrolysis and electrodialysis processes intended to decompose sodium sulphate into sulphuric acid and sodium hydroxide solutions, have been largely developed, but their operational cost (e.g. the consumption of electricity) is an obstacle to their implementation. Dust emissions to the atmosphere are the result of handling the solids. Water emissions include dissolved salts.The generation of wastes is not an issue. Organic contamination of air, water and wastes is to be considered, depending on the organic process generating the sodium sulphate solution [6, CEFIC, 2002]. 1.6.1.2 Basic data on sodium sulphate production Sodium sulphate is a non toxic, hygroscopic white powder. It derives from natural deposits or is recovered as a by-product from various industrial processes. Natural sodium sulphate is extracted from sodium sulphate-rich brines or lakes, while the most common industrial sources are the production of man-made fibres, hydrochloric acid, chromium chemicals, formic acid, desulphurisation of flue-gases or lead battery recycling [64, CEFIC-SSPA, 2004]. 19 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only A major outlet for sodium sulphate is the detergent and cleaning agent industry, where their free-flowing and preventive anti-caking properties are highly appreciated. Other significant end uses are in the glass, textile, food and pharmaceutical industries. The estimated world production of sodium sulphate is 6 million tonnes per year. Total capacity is probably around 9 million tonnes. European production amounts to slightly more than 2 million tonnes and about half of the European production is from mining operations (natural sodium sulphate). In Europe, approx. 40 producers of sodium sulphate can currently be identified. Amongst them, four companies are located in Spain and produce natural sodium sulphate by mining operations. The total European production of sodium sulphate is at the level of approx. 2100 kt – see Table 1.9, however, no data have been submitted on the production amounts originating from each of the mentioned process routes. Sodium sulphate producing countries/locations in Europe FRANCE Commentry, Roussillon, Loos BELGIUM Tessenderlo, Lommel THE NETHERLANDS Delfzijl SPAIN Toledo, Burgos, Madrid, Burgos, Torrelavega, Almeria PORTUGAL Valongo-Porto UNITED KINGDOM Eaglescliffe, Dalry GERMANY Obernburg, Kelheim, Düsseldorf, Marl, Milden Hütte, Schwedt AUSTRIA BMG, Lenzing, Glanzstoff Austria ITALY Bergamo, La Porto, Tonno GREECE Piraeus FINLAND Valkeakoski, Lappeenranta SWEDEN Perstorp SWITZERLAND Pratteln POLAND Alwernia, Gorzow TURKEY Alkim, Sisecam, Kaprasama CZECH REPUBLIC Lovosice SLOVAKIA Senica SERBIA Loznica BULGARIA Svistov Origin/Estimated combined production for Europe Number of plants 3 Methionine (2), Mannheim (1) 2 Mannheim (1), Viscose (1) 1 Messo (from Glauber’s salt) (1) 6 Natural (4), Viscose (1), Unknown origin (1) 1 Rayon (1) 2 Sodium dichromate (1), Ascorbic acid (1) 6 Rayon (2), Desulphurisation (1), Low grade – ex fibres (1), Battery (1), Flue-gas desulphurisation (1) 3 Battery (1), Rayon (2) 3 Unknown origin (1), Pigments (2) 1 Natural (1) 2 Rayon (1), Unknown origin (1) 1 Formic acid (1) 1 Battery recycling 2 Sodium dichromate (1), Rayon (1) 3 Natural (1), Chromecake (2) 1 Rayon (1) 1 Rayon (1) 1 Rayon (1) 1 Rayon (1) TOTAL EUROPE 41 Approx. 2100 kt Notes: 1. Data estimation for non-CEFIC-SSPA Members, 2. For ‘natural’ production in Spain yearly capacities were estimated instead of typical production volumes. Table 1.9: Sodium sulphate production in Europe [64, CEFIC-SSPA, 2004] 20 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only According to most sources, the total sodium sulphate consumption in Europe is estimated at 1.6 million tonnes. Industry experts feel that overall consumption will remain stable or will slightly decline over the next five years, with detergents remaining the dominant market. In recent years, the capital investment in sodium sulphate production in Europe has decreased. Some productions have been stopped among others in Italy, some plants have been debottlenecked, but no new plants have been built. 1.6.2 Industrial processes used Sodium sulphate is produced either from the mining of natural sodium sulphate or as a byproduct from various kinds of processes. As previously mentioned, mining process is not included in this section. The six major production processes covered are sodium sulphate as a by-product from: • • • • • • fibres (rayon/viscose) Messo process (from ‘Glauber’s salt’, the same as fibres) chromium Mannheim furnaces (HCl is considered the main product) [64, CEFIC-SSPA, 2004] methionine formic acid. Of the above processes, the production of fibres is the dominating route for the production of sodium sulphate as by-product in the EU. Example plants most characteristic to the sodium sulphate recovery and production are: • • • viscose process – sodium sulphate plant in Lenzing, Austria Mannheim furnace process – sodium sulphate plant of the Tessenderlo Group, Belgium chromium process – sodium sulphate plant Elementis Chromium, Eaglescliffe, UK. There is much less information available on the other process routes (ascorbic acid, desulphurisation, battery recycling). The starting materials for sodium sulphate depend on the main process, but in common to all processes the production of sodium sulphate starts with Glauber’s salt (sodium sulphate decahydrate Na2SO4.10H2O) or sodium sulphate in solution, which has to be separated from the main product by, or followed by, crystallisation and drying. The different process steps can be applied in a numerous of ways and with a large variety of equipment, which depend mainly on the main production process used. The different processes for producing sodium sulphate as a by-product, the variations within each process and the varying raw materials, yield sodium sulphate with different purity, particle size and contents of impurities. 1.6.2.1 Fibres process (Na2SO4 production from the viscose-fibre process) Fibres are produced by spinning viscose in a sulphuric acid precipitation bath in which the following reaction takes place – refer to the BREF for the Manufacture of Polymers (POL): 2 Cell–OCS2Na + H2SO4 2 Cell–OH + 2CS2 + Na2SO4 (Cell = cellulose) 21 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only A flow scheme of the production sodium sulphate from the viscose-fibre process is given in Figure 1.10. Fibre production process Spinbath crystallization NaOH Steam Water Calcination melting, dehydration Vapour Condensate Water Water Centrifuge Air Steam/gas/ brine Dryer / cooler Filter Exhaust air Sieve Na2SO4 product storage Figure 1.10: Flow scheme of sodium sulphate production from the viscose-fibre process [64, CEFIC-SSPA, 2004] The raw material for the production of sodium sulphate is Glauber´s salt coming from spinbath crystallisation as a by-product of the viscose fibre process according to the equation above. The principle of the crystallisation process is to cool the spinbath from the production fibre to <20 °C, causing Glauber's salt, Na2SO4.10 H2O, to crystallise. Glauber's salt is recovered by centrifuging and is then calcined to form anhydrous sodium sulphate (thenardite). Glauber's salt "melts" in its own water at 32.38 °C, forming a saturated solution of sodium sulphate that contains anhydrous sodium sulphate as a solid phase in the melter. To neutralise the adherent acid from the spinbath, caustic soda (NaOH) is added to control the pH. To remove the water, evaporative crystallisation (dehydration) of the saturated sodium sulphate solution obtained on melting Glauber's salt is used. The consumption of energy is reduced by using multistage evaporation, in which the vapour was employed as a heating steam for the following stage within the calcination and/or for other heating purposes in the fibre process. The separated solid sodium sulphate from the centrifuge is washed with water to improve its quality and is dried by hot air, which is heated up with steam or natural gas and can hereafter be cooled with dry cold air in a cooler. The exhaust air is treated by a filter, and the residue is incorporated in the final product. The final product is screened by sieves and stored in silos and bagged or shipped as bulk. 1.6.2.2 MESSO process (from Glauber’s salt) In the Messo process, brine saturated with sodium sulphate is cooled in a number of steps. Due to the cooling, the sodium sulphate crystallises as Glauber’s salt, and is a form of sodium sulphate complexed with water molecules. The crystals are separated from the mother liquid using centrifuges. 22 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only To change the sodium sulphate into the anhydrous thenardite form, the separated crystals must be suspended and heated with steam in a remelting vessel. Thus, the water leaves the sodium sulphate crystals. The crystals are separated from the mother liquid using centrifuges. The separated crystals are dried in a flash dryer and stored in different silos. For reasons of efficiency, the mother liquid from the sodium sulphate centrifuges is cooled and the additional crystallised Glauber’s salt is also brought to the remelting vessel. The primary mother liquid and part of the secondary mother liquid are purged to effluent. Steam is produced on the site using natural gas. The dryers are heated directly with natural gas. A flow scheme of sodium sulphate production by the Messo process is shown in Figure 1.11. Steam Salt purge Cooling Purge Remelting Natural gas Drying Sodium sulphate Recovery Purge Figure 1.11: Flow scheme of sodium sulphate production by the Messo process [64, CEFIC-SSPA, 2004] 1.6.2.3 Chromium process Crude sodium sulphate, a by-product from the sodium dichromate plant containing sexivalent chromium compounds (Cr+6), is dissolved and transferred into treatment tanks. At this stage, the solution is acidified in order to facilitate the chemical reduction of the solution using sulphur dioxide. After reduction, the pH is raised leaving an insoluble species of chromium suspended in a solution of sodium sulphate. This is filtered and the resulting solids are recycled back to the primary process of the production of sodium dichromate. The purified sodium sulphate solution goes forward subsequently into a crystalliser, centrifuge, dryer and classifier to form pure sodium sulphate crystals. A flow scheme of the production of sodium sulphate from the chromium process is given in Figure 1.12. 23 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only C austic s oda S ulphur diox ide C rude S odium s ulphate from evaporation plant S ulphuric ac id D is solv er T reatm ent tank s C rystalliser F ilter C entrifuge P rec ipitated s olids Fine m aternal returned to proc ess Liquor rec yc led to crys talliser C las sifier E x haus t gas es P ure sodium S ulphate to s ilos A ir D ryer C yc lone F uel A ir Figure 1.12: Flow scheme of the production of sodium sulphate from the chromium process [64, CEFIC-SSPA, 2004] 1.6.2.4 Mannheim furnace process (hydrochloric acid) As mentioned in Section 1.6.1, direct production processes based on the reaction of solid sodium chloride with sulphuric acid or sulphur dioxide/oxygen, have become less important, as – apart from the natural product – a by-product sodium sulphate from other processes is readily available. However, in some locations synthetic sodium sulphate may be by-produced by the Mannheim furnace process jointly with hydrochloric acid [64, CEFIC-SSPA, 2004]. Approximately two tonnes of 100 % Na2SO4 are produced per one tonne of 100 % HCl, equivalent to approximately three tonnes of HCl solution which is in fact obtained in the process. Hydrochloric acid is widely applicable in various industries, including the chemical, tannery, textile, ceramic and pharmaceutical industries. In the Mannheim furnace process, sulphuric acid reacts with sodium chloride producing sodium sulphate and a 32 % hydrochloric acid solution obtained through absorption. Combustion gases, obtained as intermediate products, are used to heat up the combustion air. Producing sodium sulphate, that is free of sulphuric acid and hydrochloric acid, requires equivalent amounts of acid (approx. 0.73 t of 100 % H2SO4 per tonne of Na2SO4) and salt (approx. 0.83 t of 100 % NaCl per tonne of Na2SO4). The salt is measured out by means of a screw, the quantity of acid is measured by flow. Based on raw material analyses, the quantity ratio of the materials is then controlled by an operator. The reaction between sulphuric acid and sodium chloride requires a long reaction time and a high temperature. This is achieved in a muffle furnace with a hearth which is heated with burners to approx. 600 °C. The air volume/oil ratio is kept constant. To prevent any problem of exhaust gas after the HCl absorption, the air is not blown into the process. 24 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only The hot air produced in the upper part of the Mannheim furnace (combustion chamber) is not in contact with the lower part of the Mannheim furnace (reaction chamber). Indirect heating takes place through a special wall. The HCl gases coming from the reaction in the lower part of the furnace do not come into contact with the combustion gases in the upper part of the furnace. The first stage of the reaction produces acidic sodium sulphate, or sodium hydrogen sulphate, which then reacts with sodium chloride during the second stage to generate the end-product, sodium sulphate. Mechanical rakes rotate in the muffle furnace, pushing the sulphuric acid and sodium chloride to the centre of the furnace and the produced sulphate to the outer edge. The hot, acidic, and partly caked sodium sulphate is transferred through a conveyor belt to the subsequent treatment operations of: grinding, cooling, stabilisation, and sieving. The final product is of homogeneous quality, stored in a closed warehouse and sold in bulk form or packed into 25 kg bags or 1000 kg big bags. The basic chemical reaction governing the process is: 2NaCl + H2SO4 - Na2SO4 + 2HCl A flow scheme of the production of Na2SO4 by the Mannheim furnace process is given in Figure 1.13. S u lp h u ric a c id S o d iu m c h lo r id e W ATER HCl FUR N ACES A B S O R P T IO N N E U T R A L IS A T IO N & C O N D IT IO N IN G S o d iu m s u lp h a t e H y d r o c h lo r ic a c id Figure 1.13: Flow scheme of the production of Na2SO4 by the Mannheim furnace process [64, CEFIC-SSPA, 2004] 1.6.2.5 Methionine process Methionine synthesis leading to sodium sulphate production involves: • • saponification with caustic soda neutralisation with sulphuric acid. 25 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only Sodium sulphate is recovered from the solution called “mother liquor” by concentration and water evaporation in a multi-effects evaporator. With temperature increase and concentration, sodium sulphate solubility decreases and leads to the precipitation of the sodium salt while methionine remains in solution. The solid phase is separated from the solution by decantation then filtration on a centrifuge in which the cake is washed by water. At the outlet of the centrifuge, sodium sulphate is dried in a hot air stream heated by steam. Then the solid is separated from the gaseous phase by cyclone and sent by pneumatic transport to the bulk storage silos from which it is loaded in bulk onto trucks to deliver to customers. Downstream the dryer, airflow is cleaned in a scrubber supplied with process water to remove thefine particles. During the drying, the humidity of sodium sulphate and the organic sulphur compounds dissolved in the water, are transferred to the air. Before being released to the atmosphere, the airflow is deodorised by contact with bleach in air-mix equipment in which a chemical oxidation of the organic compounds is carried out. Part of the production is purified in order to obtain a white coloured solid without odours. The process treatment is performed in three steps: • • • humidification and spraying with sodium chlorate (NaClO3) oxidation by calcination in a rotary kiln cooling by air in a rotary mixer. The off-gases from the calcination have to be purified before they can be released to the atmosphere. In the first step, the solid particles are kept by a cyclone and recycled into the process. The gaseous effluent is sent to a scrubber fed with water in order to eliminate residual dust. The liquid waste only contains sulphate and chloride in such a low concentration that it can be released to the environment. A flow scheme of the production of sodium sulphate from the methionine process is given in Figure 1.14. 26 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only Sodium Calcination on rotary kiln Liquid waste Purified sodium sulphate Figure 1.14: Flow scheme of the production of sodium sulphate from the methionine process [64, CEFIC-SSPA, 2004] 1.6.2.6 Formic acid process In the formic acid process, sodium formate is chemically reacted with sulphuric acid in the presence of formic acid. The solution from the reactor, containing formic acid and sodium sulphate, is fed to a centrifuge where sodium sulphate crystals are separated from the solution. The mother liquor is pumped into an evaporator where an additional amount of sodium sulphate is crystallised. This step is followed by another centrifuging step. The sodium sulphate crystals are sent to a multi-coil dryer heated by steam, followed by cooling and sieving before the material is packed into bags or stored in bulk silos. 27 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only The basic chemical equation governing this process is: 2Na – COOH + H2SO4 2HCOOH + Na2SO4 A flow scheme of the production of sodium sulphate in the formic acid process is given in Figure 1.15. Sodium formate Sulphuric acid Combustion gases Reactor Cooling water Centrifuge Evaporator Formic acid Condensate Steam Drier Combustion gases Air Cooling water Cooler Cooling water Sieve Na 2 SO 4 Figure 1.15: Flow scheme of sodium sulphate production in the formic acid process [64, CEFIC-SSPA, 2004] 1.6.3 Current emission and energy consumption levels The current levels of emissions to air and water, as well as of emissions of solid residues and energy consumption levels are briefly summarised in the following Tables. Aspects of key environmental issues are also addressed. Emissions to air are given in Table 1.10. Process Volume Cl2 exhaust gas m3/t Na2SO4 kg/t HCl kg/t All SSPA except natural 131 – 5000 0 – 0.0007 0 – 0.063 *No data available for some processes SOx NOx NH3 CO2 Dust kg/t kg/t kg/t kg/t 0 – 1.1 0 – 0.46 0 kg/t 0 – 24 * 0.0003 – 0.66 Table 1.10: Sodium sulphate production – emissions to air (aggregated data: min – max) [64, CEFIC-SSPA, 2004] 28 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only Emissions to water are given in Table 1.11. Volume of Clwaste water m3/t Na2SO4 kg/t Process All SSPA except natural 0–5 kg/t kg/t kg/t ppm Suspended matter mg/l 0 0 0 0 – 60 * 0–5* NO3- NH4+ F- SO42kg/t 0 – 1.1 0.00006 – 20.0 COD *No data available for some processes Table 1.11: Sodium sulphate production – emissions to water (aggregated data: min – max) [64, CEFIC-SSPA, 2004] Emissions of solid residues are given in Table 1.12. Solid waste tonne/tonne Na2SO4 All SSPA 0 – 0.002 except natural in total Process Nature of residue Contaminated salts Various solid waste Metals Destination/ Re-use Landfill Landfill/Incineration Recycling Table 1.12: Sodium sulphate production – solid residues (aggregated data: min –max) [64, CEFIC-SSPA, 2004] Energy consumption in the production of sodium sulphate is given in Table 1.13. Process Electricity kWh/t Na2SO4 All SSPA except natural 0.17 – 237 Others (coal, fuel, gas, hydrogen, etc.) kWh/t Na2SO4 0 – 1540 Total energy consumption kWh/t Na2SO4 120 – 1660 Table 1.13: Sodium sulphate production - energy consumption (aggregated data: min - max) [64, CEFIC-SSPA, 2004] Production of sodium sulphate as a by-product has a positive impact on the environment. All the processes described in this section are treating a stream from its primary process and turning it into a useful product (or by-product). It is a classic example of sustainable development where a potential waste from one industry has useful applications in other fields. 1.6.4 Techniques to consider in the determination of BAT Apart from being produced from naturally occurring sources (mining), sodium sulphate is produced as a by-product from different chemical processes such as rayon production, chromium chemicals, hydrochloric acid, methionine, and formic acid. As the sodium sulphate derived from these chemical processes could be considered as a by-product, the six main processes described in Section 1.6.2 have been taken into account when analysing techniques to consider in the determination of BAT for the production of sodium sulphate. This is because all of them – except the Mannheim furnace process, dedicated for the co-production of HCl as a main product and sodium sulphate as a co-product – are, in principle, recovery processes and their application in the industrial practice reduces the impact of several other industries on the environment [64, CEFIC-SSPA, 2004], [EIPPCB, 2004-2005 #85]. 29 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only The production of sodium sulphate should itself be considered as a pollution control process, as the waste stream would otherwise go to effluent [64, CEFIC-SSPA, 2004]. The quantity of the sodium sulphate by-product depends on the production capabilities of the primary product and, in principle, all these processes use Glauber’s salt as the raw material. The calcination of Glauber’s salt, followed by the crystallisation and drying of the sodium sulphate always depends on the individual layout and technical arrangements of the installations, as well as linkages to various sources of energy. Pollution of the environment during the production of sodium sulphate from Glauber’s salt is very low. It should be noted, however, that the six main process routes for Na2SO4 production which have been formerly described as ‘Techniques to consider in the determination of BAT’ in the LVIC-S BREF section on sodium sulphate, have, in principle (with some exception regarding the Mannheim process), the same environmental benefit (i.e. they use a by-product Na2SO4 which otherwise would have to be discharged to waste waters). This means that they reduce the environmental impact of the industries in which Na2SO4 is formed as a waste (or by-product) stream. They are, therefore, techniques to consider in the determination of BAT for the industries in which Na2SO4 is formed as a waste stream. They do not reduce the emission and energy consumption levels of the Na2SO4 production processes themselves (as given in the ‘Current emission and energy consumption levels’ Section above) and, therefore, they are NOT techniques to consider in the determination of BAT for the production of sodium sulphate. As no clear BAT conclusions could be drawn for the production of sodium sulphate, it was considered reasonable to remove the six ‘Techniques to consider in the determination of BAT’ from the BAT Reference Document on LVIC-S, and to move the whole section on sodium sulphate from the BREF on LVIC-S to this “Additional Information submitted during the information exchange on Large Volume Inorganic Chemicals – Solid and Others Industry” document, which is associated with and closely related to the BREF on LVIC-S. 30 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only 1.7 Zinc chloride Zinc chloride (ZnCl2) is one of several important members of the Zn-family of inorganic compounds. The technological network of zinc chemical compounds, illustrating the linkages among the Zn-family members (ZnCl2, ZnO and ZnSO4 among them) and major applications of the Zn-based final products is shown in Figure 1.16, [83, UNIDO, 1988]. Zinc chloride is produced and shipped either as a 47 % solution in water or as an anhydrous solid salt. Among its uses, wood preservation, electric batteries and minor applications in fibres treatment, etc. should be mentioned [6, CEFIC, 2002]. Zinc chloride is produced by the reaction of a hydrochloric acid solution with zinc metal, zinc scraps or zinc oxide. If needed, the solution leaving the reactor is freed from its heavy metals contaminants by chemical reactions with an alkali or an alkali plus oxidant which results in their precipitation under the form of hydroxide and are removed by filtration. When solid zinc chloride is needed, this is obtained by further evaporation and cooling of the solution, until zinc chloride crystallises [6, CEFIC, 2002]. Air dust emissions are due to the handling of the zinc chloride crystals and may include particles. Water streams arise from the evaporation, and have traces of contaminants. Generation of solid wastes is negligible [6, CEFIC, 2002]. H3PO4 Paint primer Zn (H2PO4)2 Stearic acid HCI NaOH ZnCl2 HNO3 Zn (OH)2 Redphosphor Zn5P2 (O2) Pure ZnO Cadmium salts H2S Electrolysis ZnSO4 H2O2 H2SO4 Rat poison (C) and heat O2 ZnO Zn H2SO4 Intermediate Filler in rubber Galvanising Cellulose Disinfectant Textile Textile Catalyst Ore Conc. Zn Ore Conc. ZnCO3 Dryer Stabiliser Zn(NO3)2 CO2 Heat C36H70O4Zn ZnO2 Filler Glass Pigment Enamel Alloys Coating Medicine Cosmetics Herbicide Galvanisation Pigment Disinfectant Figure 1.16: Technological network of zinc chemical compounds Based on [83, UNIDO, 1988] No further information provided. 31 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only 1.8 Zinc sulphate As submitted by CEFIC in April 2005 32 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only 1.9 Sodium bisulphate As submitted by CEFIC in April 2005 33 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only 2 PURIFICATION OF NON-FERTILISER GRADE WET PHOSPHORIC ACID (PARTIAL INFORMATION) 2.1 Inorganic Phosphates – Introduction In order to bridge the information to Section 2.2 “Purification of non-fertiliser-grade wet phosphoric acid – the options” below, it was considered reasonable to present here first key information included in the introduction to Inorganic Phosphates, Chapter 6 of the BREF on LVIC-S, as follows. The application of inorganic phosphates as fertiliser is addressed in the BREF on Large Volume Inorganic Chemicals – Ammonia, Acids and Fertilisers (LVIC – AAF), whereas the BREF on Large Volume Inorganic Chemicals – Solid and others (LVIC-S) covers the production of inorganic phosphates (refer to Chapter 6 of the BREF on LVIC-S). In general terms, all inorganic phosphates can be seen as indirectly derived from phosphate rock, Ca5(PO4)3F. The process from phosphate rock to final product may schematically be seen to involve four major steps: • • • • dissolution of phosphate from the rock to yield phosphoric acid purification of phosphoric acid to a varying degree of purity neutralisation of phosphoric acid by reaction with sodium, calcium, ammonium and/or other ions to produce the required inorganic phosphate dehydration, drying or calcination plus optional finishing to give a product in the required form (eg. dry powder). These steps may be carried out in one location, but quite commonly intermediate products are used as the starting material for downstream steps. Therefore, when comparing several production routes to manufacture a given inorganic phosphate product it is important to consider the different strategies, process boundaries and starting points of the production. Although strong mineral acids, such as sulphuric, hydrochloric and nitric acid are used for the dissolution of the phosphate from the rock, by far the most commonly used is sulphuric acid. Unpurified (merchant grade), usually called “green”, phosphoric acid is a market commodity used by many producers as the starting point for further processing. Invariably, the resulting phosphoric acid stream contains impurities originating from the phosphate rock, including a number of metals and fluoride. For most applications, these impurities need to be removed from the acid to obtain a certain level of purity of the product. The required level of purity is largely determined by the final use of the phosphoric acid product. In some cases, the purification takes place in a dedicated plant by employing solvent extraction, this leading to the production of a high quality phosphoric acid. Optionally, additional techniques (for removal of arsenic, sulphate or fluoride) may be applied. Depending on the required degree of purity of the final product, this can provide a feedstock for the production of detergent, animal feed or human food phosphates. Consequently, the purification of ‘green’ phosphoric acid may be quite shallow (e.g. ‘green’ acid pretreatment, virtually by desulphation only) or deep (concentration, desulphation, fluoride and arsenic removal, and the purification of the ‘green’ acid by solvent extraction in a number of steps – not necessarily in this order). 1 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only In other cases (for instance in some of the sites producing detergent phosphates), the purification (starting from unpurified “green”, merchant commodity phosphoric acid) takes place in the same process as the production of a given inorganic phosphate. Phosphoric acids of various degrees of purity are available as global merchant commodities or, in some cases, can be produced at the same site where both acid purification installations and inorganic phosphate production plants are situated. Operators will purchase purified acid of the degree of purity required for the range of inorganic phosphates they are manufacturing, or will purify phosphoric acid onsite to the degree of purity required in downstream operations. Depending on the purity of the acid used, some sites can manufacture inorganic phosphates for different applications (detergent, animal feed, food). A high purity phosphoric acid may also be obtained by the thermal route. White phosphorus, derived by thermal reduction from phosphate rock or other phosphate sources, is combusted in air, followed by the absorption of phosphorus pentoxide (P2O5) in water (refer to the BREF on LVIC-AAF). In general, this process route is seldom used in Western Europe for the production of detergentgrade STPP or for the production of inorganic feed phosphates, as the phosphoric acid produced from elemental phosphorus is of a high purity, not required for detergent or animal feed applications. Some inorganic phosphate products have a range of uses which require different levels of purity: for example STPP, which is used in detergents and cleaning products, but also as a human food and pharmaceutical ingredient which requires higher grades of purity. In some cases, the same installation can be used to manufacture an inorganic phosphate product for various purposes; different quality grades being achieved by using different quality feedstocks (phosphoric acid or phosphate rock of different levels or purity) and/or by additional purification steps operated optionally within the production process. The purification of phosphoric acid has not been described in the BREF on LVIC-AAF as, for most fertiliser production processes, such a step is not necessary. Also, data and information on the purification of phosphoric acid have not been submitted during information exchange on the BREF on LVIC-S and, therefore, detailed information on consumption and emission levels from the phosphoric acid purification step is not available. As the description of processes and unit operations applied in the purification of non fertiliser grade wet phosphoric acid was not covered in detail either in the BREF on LVIC-AAF or in the BREF on LVIC-S, there is, therefore, a clear information gap in this area between the two large volume inorganic chemical industry BREFs. In order not to loose partial information from the BREF on LVIC-S (Chapter 6), it was considered important to include in this document one of the “Techniques to consider in the determination of BAT” (deleted from the BREF on LVIC-S upon the recommendation of the TWG on LVIC-S), as it may be of value in future for the revision of one of the LVIC BREFs and information exchange on the routes available for the purification of “green” phosphoric acid, either by a chemical process or a physical process (solvent extraction). It should be noted that as the purification of the phosphoric acid, typically (but not always) takes place upstream of the site of the inorganic phosphates plants, therefore, in most cases (but not always), the main environmental benefits are outside of the scope of the feed phosphates sector. 2 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only 2.2 Purification of non-fertiliser grade wet phosphoric acid – the options Description Since, in most cases, the purified non-fertiliser-grade wet phosphoric acid is selected for the production of inorganic phosphates, the techniques available for the purification of “green” phosphoric acid (to remove sulphate, arsenic, fluoride and other impurities) need to be analysed and compared in detail from the technical, economical, and environmental point of view in order to reduce the impact of the production of feed-phosphates on the environment in the whole chain of operations, starting from the intermediate phosphoric acid product and ending at the final food-grade phosphate product. Such a comparison needs to be carried out for two typical cases A and B pertaining to the plant location, and for two alternative process routes X and Y available to achieve the different degree (depth) of purification of “green” phosphoric acid: • • A. Phosphoric acid purification at the wet phosphoric acid production site, typically (but not always) outside of the inorganic phosphates production site B. Phosphoric acid purification at the inorganic phosphates production site (in some cases it may also be the site of the phosphoric acid plant), and • • X. Desulphation (adding lime), neutralisation (adding NaOH/Na2CO3) and purification by precipitation, involving various techniques available for chemical purification of the wet phosphoric acid, dependent on the required degree of acid quality Y. Concentration, desulphation, and very deep purification of the wet phosphoric acid by solvent extraction, involving more elaborate physico-chemical techniques. Wet process phosphoric acid is purified by numerous methods and to a wide variety of standards depending on the further application of the acid. The most basic method, and the one which all suppliers of merchant-grade acid carry out before shipment, is clarification, by settling or other mechanical means, to remove suspended solids. In case the acid is used for the production of fertilisers no further treatment is usually applied. Chemical purification methods can be employed if the acid is to be used for specific purposes, not requiring a high quality. Active carbon treatment is the usual means of removing organic impurities. Fluorine is removed by adding reactive silica and distilling off silicon tetrafluoride. Phosphate rock or lime may be added to the impure acid to remove excess sulphate. Metals ions can be selectively precipitated by various chemicals. By adding a Na2S solution to the acid, arsenic can be precipitated as arsenic sulphide. Removal of other cationic impurities, especially Fe, Al, Mg and Ca, can be achieved by neutralising the acid with sodium carbonate or caustic soda. The phosphoric acid in this process is converted to a phosphate salt solution. More elaborate techniques involving (organic) solvent treatment are used to obtain purer acid such as that required for animal feed supplements (mainly cadmium removal) and especially the food industry. Liquid/liquid extraction processes are most commonly used. Processes are operated for the separation of single components (e.g. uranium and cadmium) as well as of practically all impurities in wet phosphoric acid. The quality of such purified acid nearly equals that of thermally produced acid. Besides liquid/liquid extraction processes, precipitation processes are also being employed. 3 This document has not been fully peer reviewed and the information within is not validated nor endorsed by the TWG on LVIC-S or by the European Commission, it is meant for information, only Achieved environmental benefits The selection of both the location (option A vs. B) and the route for the purification of nonfertiliser grade wet phosphoric acid (option X vs. Y) may benefit in the minimisation of the impact of the production of inorganic phosphates on the environment. Optimum solutions can be selected with regard to the usage of raw materials, energy sources, the recycling of by-products, and waste utilisation, including the advantage of the economy of scale in order to reduce the impact of the production of inorganic phosphates on the environment in the whole chain of operations, starting from the intermediate phosphoric acid product and ending at the final feed, food, and detergent-grade phosphate product. Cross-media effects To be analysed in detail for the location (option A vs. B) and the route for the purification of non-fertiliser grade wet phosphoric acid (option X vs. Y). Operational data No detailed data available, as typically (but not always) the purification of the acid takes place upstream of the inorganic phosphate process. Moreover, specific data and information on more elaborate techniques for the purification of wet phosphoric acid are, to a certain degree, subject to confidentiality. Applicability To varying degrees, applicable to the plants producing feed, food and detergent-grade phosphates by the phosphoric acid route, depending on the long-term strategies set for the supply of phosphoric acid and the manufacture of final feed phosphate products. Driving force for implementation Reduced impact on the environment in the whole chain of operations, beginning with the intermediate phosphoric acid product and ending with feed, food and detergent-grade phosphate product. Reduction of the manufacturing cost. Product quality improvement. Example plants Food and detergent-grade phosphate plant in Huelva, Spain (based on purified wet phosphoric acid). Food and detergent-grade phosphate plant in Engis, Belgium (based on purified wet phosphoric acid). Feed-grade phosphate plants in the EU based on the supplies of purified wet phosphoric acid from outside of the feed phosphate production sites. Reference literature [65, CEFIC-IFP, 2004], [84, A. Davister, 1981], [85, EIPPCB, 2004-2005], [93, CEFIC-CEEP, 2004], [101, RIZA, 2000], [102, UNIDO, 1980]. 4 References REFERENCES 6 CEFIC (2002). "IPPC BAT Reference Document, Best Available Techniques for Producing Large Volume Solid Inorganic Chemicals - Generic Part". 8 CEFIC (2004). "CEFIC Chemistry Sectors". 9 CEFIC (2004). "The European chemical industry in a worldwide perspective - Facts and Figures 2004". 11 The Council of the EU (1996). "Council Directive 96/61/EC of 24 September 1996 concerning integrated pollution prevention and control". 12 European Environment Agency (2004). "The European Pollutant Emission Register EPER". 13 EIPPCB (2000). "Inorganic Chemical Sector", Version 1. 14 EIPPCB, S., Spain (2003). "Meeting Report of 23 September 2003 - Record of the Kick-off Meeting held in Sevilla on 7-8 July 2003, TWG on BAT for the manufature of LVIC-S". 20 CEFIC-TDMA (2004). "Process BREF Titanium Dioxide Background Document". 21 The Council of the EU (1992). "Council Directive 92/112/EEC on procedures for harmonising the programmes for the reduction and eventual elimination of pollution caused by waste from the titanium dioxide industry". 22 Euratom (1996). "European Directive 96/29/EEC". 23 The Council of the EU (1996). "Council Directive 96/82/EC of 9 December 1996 on the control of major accident hazards involving dangerous substances". 24 Tioxide Group Ltd (1995). "Synopsis "Making Better Choices - How Tioxide uses Life Cycle Assessment"". 25 D.G. Heath (1996). ""A Life Cycle inventory comparison of process and feedstock options for the production of TiO2" by D.G Heath and M.J. Richards". 26 EIPPCB (2003). "Mission Report - Visits of two sites in the UK for the production of TiO2 according to chloride route - Greatham and sulphate route - Grimsby". 27 N.L. Glinka (1981). "Problems and Exercises in General Chemistry". 28 UNIDO (1982). "A Programme for the Industrial Development Decade for Africa". 31 R. N. Shreve (1945). "The Chemical Process Industries", Chemical Engineering Series. 33 CEFIC-ESAPA (2004). "IPPCB BAT Reference Document Large Volume Solid Inorganic Chemicals Family, Process BREF for Soda Ash", Issue No: 3. 39 S. Leszczynski et al (1978). "Soda i produkty towarzyszace". 40 CEFIC-ESAPA (2003). "IPPCB BAT Reference Document Large Volume Solid Inorganic Chemicals Family, Process BREF for Soda Ash", Issue No. 2. 5 References 41 Solvay S.A. (2003). "Process BREF for Soda Ash - Presentation". 42 UBA-Germany (2001). "German Notes on BAT for the production of LVSIC Titanium Dioxide". 43 UBA - Germany (2001). "German Notes on BAT for the production of LVSIC Sodium Silicate". 44 UBA - Germany (2001). "German Notes on BAT for the production of LVSIC Sodium Perborate". 45 UBA - Germany (2001). "German Notes on BAT for the production of LVSIC - Soda". 46 CEFIC-TDMA (2001). "Process BREF Titanium Dioxide Background Document". 47 InfoMil (2002). "Dutch Notes on BAT for the Carbon Black industry", ISBN 90-7632307-0. 48 W. Buchner et al (1989). "Industrial Inorganic Chemistry", 3-527-26629-1. 49 CEFIC-ASASP (2002). "BREF Working Group - Synthetic Amorphous Silica". 50 CEFIC-INCOPA (2004). "Mini-Process BREF for Aluminium Sulphate". 53 EIPPCB (2004). "Mission Report - Visit of Soda Ash production plant site in Torrelavega, Santander, Cantabria, Spain". 54 EIPPCB (2004). "Mission Report - Carbon Black - Visits of two sites in Botlek and Rozenburg, Rotterdam area, the Netherlands". 56 InfoMil (2004). "Dutch Fact sheet on Magnesium compounds". 57 CEFIC-PEROXYGENES (2004). "Process BREF - Sodium Percarbonate". 58 CEFIC ZEAD-ZEODET (2004). "Mini-BREF Synthetic Zeolites for LVIC-S". 59 CEFIC-TDMA (2004). "Mini-Process BREF for Copperas and Related Products". 60 UBA-Austria (2004). "Mini BREF Calcium Carbide". 61 Entec UK Limited (2004). "Mini-BREF for Sodium Sulphite and related products". 62 CEFIC-ZOPA (2004). "Mini-BREF Zinc Oxide Production". 63 CEFIC-PEROXYGENES PERBORATE Sub Group (2004). "Process BREF Sodium Perborate". 64 CEFIC-SSPA (2004). "Mini-BREF Sodium Sulphate Production". 65 CEFIC-IFP (2004). "BRF LVIC-S Inorganic Feed Phosphates". 66 CEFIC-Sodium Chlorate (2004). "Mini-process BREF for Sodium Chlorate". 67 InfoMil - Dutch Authorities (2004). "Factsheet on Production of Silicon Carbide". 68 Norwegian Pollution Control Authority (2003). "BAT for Al fluoride production". 6 - References 69 Environment Agency (1999). "Processes Subject to Integrated Pollution Control Inorganic Chemicals", S2 4.04. 70 Environment Agency (1999). "Processes Subject to Integrated Pollution Control Inorganic Acids and Halogens", S2 4.03. 71 CITEPA (1997). "Best Available Techniques for the Chemical industry in Europe Workshop on 14-16 May 1997 in Paris". 73 G.V. Ellis (1979). "Energy Conservation in a Large Chemical Company", Proceedings No. 183. 75 J. A. Lee (1985). "The Environment, Public Health and Human Ecology - a World Bank Publication", 0-8018-2911-9. 76 Union of Inorganic Industry (1977). "Soda Industry in Poland - Guidebook". 78 World Bank (1991). "Environmental Assessment Sourcebook - Volume III", World Bank Technical Paper Number 154. 79 BIPROKWAS (1985-1995). "Bid Letters for Inorganic Chemicals", 511.171-TR-XYZ. 82 UNIDO (1988). "Study on the Manufacture of Industrial Chemicals in the Member States of SADCC - Part II Inorganic Industry", DP/RAF/86/013. 83 UNIDO (1988). "Study on the Manufacture of Industrial Chemicals in the Member States of SADCC - Part IV, Annex XII - Utilization of Chemical Metals, Minerals and Wastes", DP/RAF/86/013. 84 A. Davister, G. M. (1981). "From Wet Crude Phosphoric Acid to High Purity Products", Proceedings No. 201. 85 EIPPCB, C., MS, (2004). "Process BREFs, Mini-BREFs, Presentations, Papers, Notes and Documents concerning the BREF on LVIC-S". 86 The Council of the EU (2004). "Council Directive 2004/8/EC of 11 February 2004 on the promotion of cogeneration based on a useful heat demand in the internal energy market". 87 Ullmann's (2001). "Ullmann's Encyclopedia of Industrial Chemistry". 88 UBA - Germany (2004). "Mini-BREF on the Production of Carbon Disulphide". 89 CEFIC-INCOPA (2004). "Mini-Process BREFs for Polyaluminium Chloride, Aluminium Chloride". 90 CEFIC-INCOPA (2004). "Mini-Process BREF Ferrous Chloride". 91 Takuji Miyata (1983). “Soda ash production in Japan and the new Asahi process", Chemistry and Industry, pp. 4. 92 EU DG Environment (2002). "Phosphates and Alternative Detergent Builders", WRc Ref: UC 4011. 93 CEFIC-CEEP (2004). "CEEP STPP BREF (BAT)". 94 CEFIC-SOLVAY S.A. (2004). "Process BREF for Precipitated Calcium Carbonate". 7 References 95 CEFIC-Brunner Mond (2004). "Process BREF for Calcium Chloride". 96 CEFIC-ELOA (2004). "BAT Notes for the Production of Lead Oxide". 97 The Council of the EU (2004). "Regulation (EC) No 648/2004 of the European Parliament and the Council of 31 March 2004 on detergents". 98 CEFIC (2003). "CEFIC Note No. 295 - Criteria for the selection between LVIC and SIC industries". 99 Polimex-Cekop S.A. (1995). "Some strategic suggestions towards enhancing the cooperation between the MW Kellogg Company and Polimex-Cekop S.A.". 100 Environment Agency (2004). "Guidance for the Inorganic Chemicals sector IPPC S4.03", Draft 1.1. 101 InfoMil (2000). "Dutch notes on BAT for the phosphoric acid industry". 102 UNIDO (1980). "Fertilizer Manual", Development and Transfer of Technology Series No. 13. 8 Glossary GLOSSARY OF TERMS AND ABBREVIATIONS Abbreviations commonly used in this document BAT BL BOD BREF CAS CFC CHP COD DBM DC DCP ELV EMS EOP EPER ESP EURO FCCR FSA GDP GHG HEPA HHV HM HP IPPC LCA LHV LP LPG LVIC-S MAP MCP MDCP MSP NA NeR PAHs PI PCC ROI R&TD SCR SNCR Best Available Techniques Battery Limits Biochemical oxygen demand: the quantity of dissolved oxygen required by micro-organisms in order to decompose organic matter. The unit of measurement is mg O2/l. In Europe, BOD is usually measured after 3 (BOD3), 5 (BOD5) or 7 (BOD7) days. BAT reference document Chemical Abstract Service Chlorofluorocarbon Co-generation of Heat and Power Chemical oxygen demand: the amount of potassium dichromate, expressed as oxygen, required to chemically oxidize at ca. 150 °C substances contained in waste water. Dead Burned Magnesia Direct Current Dicalcium Phosphate Emission limit values: the mass, expressed in terms of certain specific parameters, concentration and/or level of an emission, which may not be exceeded during one or more periods of time. Environmental Management System End-of-pipe European Pollutant Emission Register Electrostatic precipitator European currency unit Fluid Catalytic Cracker Residue Fluosilicic Acid Gross Domestic Product Greenhouse gases High-efficiency Particulate Arresters High Heating Value Heavy Metals High Pressure Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control Life Cycle Assessment Low Heating Value Low Pressure Liquefied Petroleum Gas Large Volume Inorganic Chemicals – Solid and Others Monoamonium Phosphate Monocalcium Phosphate Monodicalcium Phosphate Monosodium Phosphate New Asahi soda ash process Netherlands emission Regulations Polyaromatic hydrocarbons Process-integrated Precipitated Calcium Carbonate Return on Investment Research and Technical Development Selective Catalytic Reduction Selective Non-Catalytic Reduction 9 Glossary SS STPP TOE VOC WR WWTP Suspended Solids (content) (in water) Sodium Tripolyphosphate Tonne of Oil Equivalent Volatile Organic Compounds Weight Ratio Waste water Treatment Plant Abbreviations used for the organisations and countries quoted in this document ASASP BSI CEEP CEES CEFIC CITEPA EA EC EIPPCB EFMA EFPA ELOA ENTEC EPPAA ESAPA EU EU-15 EU-25 HT ICBA INCOPA IEF InfoMil IFP IPTS ISO NGOs SFT SSPA TDMA TWG UNIDO US EPA UBA UBA-Austria US VROM ZEAD ZEODET ZOPA 10 Association of Synthetic Amorphous Silica Producers British Standard Institute Centre Européen d’Etudes des Polyphosphates Centre Européen d’Etudes des Silicates European Chemical Industry Council Centre Interprofessionnel Technique D’Etudes de la Pollution Atmospherique Environment Agency European Commission European Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control Bureau European Fertilisers Manufacturers Association European Food Phosphate Producers Association European Lead Oxide Association Entec UK Limited European Pure Phosphoric Acid Producers Association European Soda Ash Producers Association European Union European Union (15 Member States) European Union (25 Member States, including 10 new Member States) Huntsman Tioxide International Carbon Black Association Inorganic Coagulants Producers Association Information Exchange Forum (informal consultation body in the framework of the IPPC Directive) The Dutch Information Centre for Environmental Licensing Inorganic Feed Phosphates Institute for Prospective Technological Studies International Standards Organisation Non-Governmental Organisations Norwegian Pollution Control Authority Sodium Sulphate Producers Association Titanium Dioxide Manufacturers Association Technical Working Groups United Nations Industrial Development Organization U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Umweltbundesamt (Federal Environmental Agency - Germany) Umweltbundesamt (Federal Environment Agency - Austria) United States of America Dutch Ministry of Housing, Spatial Planning and Environment Zeolite Adsorbents Association of Detergent Zeolite Producers Zinc Oxide Producers Association Glossary Abbreviations of units of measure bar °C g h J K kg kPa kt kWh l m m2 m3 mg Nm3 pH ppb ppm ppmv s t vol-% W bar (1 bar = 100 kPa, 1.013 bar = 1 atm) degree Celsius gram hour Joule Kelvin (0 °C = 273.15 K) kilogram (1 kg = 1000 g) kilo Pascal thousand tonnes kilowatt-hour (1 kWh = 3600 kJ = 3.6 MJ) litre metre square metre cubic metre milligram (1 mg = 10-3 gram) Normalised m3 (gas, 273 K, 101.3 kPa) scale for measuring acidity or alkalinity parts per billion parts per million parts per million (by weight) second metric tonne (1000 kg or 106 gram) percentage by volume Watt (1 W = 1 J/s) Prefixes n b m c k M G nano 10-9 micro 10-6 milli 10-3 centi 10-2 kilo 103 mega 106 giga 109 Chemical formula commonly used in this document (refer also to Annex 1 – Basic classes of inorganic compounds) Al AlCl3 AlF3 AlNaO2 Al2O3 Al(OH)3 Al2(SO4)3 Alx(OH)yClz Alx(OH)yClz(SO4)q As Ba BaCl2 B C Ca Aluminium Aluminium chloride Aluminium fluoride Sodium aluminate Aluminium oxide Aluminium hydroxide Aluminium sulphate Aluminium hydroxy chloride Aluminium hydroxy chloride sulphate Arsenic Barium Barium chloride Boron Carbon Calcium 11 Glossary Ca2+ CaC2 CaCl2 CaF2 CaCO3 CaCO3.MgCO3 CaO Ca(OH)2 CaHPO4 Ca3(PO4)2 CaSO3 CaSO4 Cd CH4 CxHy C2H6 C2H4 C2H2 ClCl2 ClOClO3CNCo CO CO2 CO32-COS Cr Cr3+/Cr6+ CrO CS2 Cu CuO CuSO4 F FFe Fe2+ Fe3+ FeCl2 FeCl3 FeClSO4 FeO Fe2O3 FeO.TiO2 FeSO4 FeSO4.H2O FeSO4.7H2O Fe2(SO4)3 H2 HCl HClO HCN HCOOH HCO3Hg 12 Calcium ion Calcium carbide Calcium chloride Calcium fluoride (flourspar) Calcium carbonate (limestone) Dolomite Calcium oxide Calcium hydroxide Dicalcium phosphate Calcium phosphate Calcium sulphite Calcium sulphate Cadmium Methane Hydrocarbons Ethane Ethene Acetylene Chloride Chlorine Hypochlorite Chlorate Cyanide Cobalt Carbon monoxide Carbon dioxide Carbonate Carbonyl sulphide Chromium Chromic ions Chromium oxide Carbon disulphide Copper Copper oxide Copper sulphate Fluorine Fluoride Iron Ferrous ion Ferric ion Ferrous chloride Ferric chloride Iron chloro sulphate Iron (II) oxide Iron (III) oxide Ilmenite Ferrous sulphate Ferrous sulphate monohydrate Ferrous sulphate heptahydrate (copperas) Ferric sulphate Hydrogen Hydrogen chloride Hypochlorous acid Hydrogen cyanide Formica acid Bicarbonate Mercury Glossary HF H2O H2O2 HNO2 HNO3 H3PO4 H2S H2SO4 H2SiF6 K KCl KClO3 K2CO3 KOH Mg Mg2+ MgCl2 MgCO3 MgO Mg(OH)2 MgSO4 Mn Na Na+ NaBO3.H2O Na2B4O7.5H2O NaCl NaClO NaClO3 Na2CO3 Na2CO3.1.5H2O2 Na2Cr2O7 NaHCO3 NaH2PO4 Na2HPO4 NaNO2 NaNO3 Na2O NaOH NaHSO3 Na2SO3 NaHSO4 Na2SO4 Na2SO4. 10H2O Na2S2O3 Na2S2O5 Na5P3O10 Na2S Nax(AlO2)y(SiO2)z N2 NH3 NH4+ NH4OH NH4Cl NH4HCO3 (NH4)2CO3 NH4HSO4 Hydrogen fluoride Water Hydrogen peroxide Nitrous acid Nitric acid Phosphoric acid Hydrogen sulphide Sulphuric acid Flousilicic acid Potassium Potassium chloride Potassium chlorate Potassium carbonate Potassium hydroxide Magnesium Magnesium ion Magnesium chloride Magnesium carbonate Magnesium oxide Magnesium hydroxide Magnesium sulphate Manganese Sodium Sodium ion Sodium perborate monohydrate Borax Sodium chloride Sodium hypochlorite Sodium chlorate Sodium carbonate Sodium percarbonate Sodium dichromate Sodium bicarbonate Monosodium phosphate Disodium phosphate Sodium nitrite Sodium nitrate Sodium oxide Sodium hydroxide Sodium hydrogensulphite (sodium bisulphite) Sodium sulphite Sodium hydrogensulphate (sodium bisulphate) Sodium sulphate Sodium sulphate decahydrate (Glauber’s salt) Sodium thiosulphate Sodium metabisulphite Sodium tripolyphosphate Sodium sulphide Zeolite Nitrogen Ammonia Ammonium ion Ammonium hydroxide Ammonium chloride Ammonium bicarbonate Ammonium carbonate Ammonium bisulphate 13 Glossary (NH4)2SO4 Ni NO NO2 NO3NOx O2 OClOHP P2O5 Pb PbO Pb3O4 R-NH2 S S2SO2 SO3 S2O32SO32SO42SOx Si SiC SiO2 n(SiO2).Na2O Ti TiO2 TiO(OH)2 TiOSO4 TiCl4 V VOCl W Zn ZnCl2 ZnCO3 ZnO ZnS ZnSO4 14 Ammonium sulphate Nickel Nitrogen monoxide Nitrogen dioxide Nitrate Nitrogen oxides Oxygen Hypochlorite Hydroxide Phosphorus Phosphorus pentoxide Lead Lead oxide (litharge) Lead oxide (red lead) Amine Sulphur Sulphide Sulphur dioxide Sulphur trioxide Thiosulphate Sulphite Sulphate Sulphur oxides Silicon Silicon carbide Silica Sodium silicate Titanium Titanium dioxide Titanyl hydroxide Titanyl sulphate Titanium tetrachloride Vanadium Vanadium oxychloride Tungsten Zinc Zinc chloride Zinc carbonate Zinc oxide Zinc sulphide Zinc sulphate
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz