Seacare Jurisdictional Coverage— Discussion Paper SEACARE JURISDICTIONAL COVERAGE—DISCUSSION PAPER 1 2 SEACARE JURISDICTIONAL COVERAGE—DISCUSSION PAPER Contents Introduction 4 Existing Coverage Provisions 5 Guiding Principles 6 Draft Coverage Provisions 6 Exemptions 9 Feedback 9 Attachment A—Legislative Extracts 10 10 11 13 Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 Occupational Health and Safety (Maritime Industry) Act 1993 Navigation Act 1912 Attachment B—Draft decision flowchart 14 SEACARE JURISDICTIONAL COVERAGE—DISCUSSION PAPER 3 Introduction 1. Seacare is a national scheme of occupational health and safety (OHS), workers’ compensation and rehabilitation arrangements which apply to defined seafaring employees and—in relation to OHS— defined third parties (ie suppliers, manufacturers and importers). 2. The Seafarers Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Authority (Seacare Authority) is responsible for regulating the Seacare scheme. 3. The jurisdictional coverage of the Seacare scheme is presently established by section 19 of the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (the Seafarers Act) and section 6 of the Occupational Health and Safety (Maritime Industry) Act 1993 (the OHS(MI) Act). Both the Seafarers Act and the OHS(MI) Act refer to ‘a prescribed ship’ (and ‘prescribed units’ in the case of the OHS(MI) Act) which are in turn defined as a ship (or offshore mobile unit) to which Part II of the Navigation Act 1912 (Navigation Act) applies. Extracts from the above Acts are at Attachment A. 4. On 5 June 2009, the Minister for Infrastructure and Transport announced that the Navigation Act would be rewritten as part of the Government’s maritime reform program. 5. Given that the Seacare scheme’s coverage provisions are presently linked to the Navigation Act by reference to Part II (section 10), the re-write of the Navigation Act necessitates a re-draft of the Seacare scheme coverage provisions and provides an opportunity to re-define Seacare coverage. 6. This discussion paper is drafted on the basis that the Seacare scheme will be ‘de-linked’ from the Navigation Act and other legislation to effectively operate independently. This will ensure that any consideration of coverage will be unfettered by the provisions of the Navigation Act and other legislation. 7. The Seacare Authority has a role to advise the Minister for Employment and Workplace Relations (the Minister) on matters relating to the occupational health and safety and workers’ compensation and rehabilitation of seafarers. In this context, the Seacare Authority is developing its views on its preferred jurisdictional coverage provisions for the Seacare scheme. 8. To assist in this process the Seacare Authority is seeking the views of stakeholders to help inform the development of a set of preferred coverage provisions. Once the Authority has agreed to a set of preferred coverage provisions these will be conveyed to the Minister. 9. This paper provides information on existing coverage provisions and problems associated with these provisions, some guiding principles to be taken into account in developing a set of preferred coverage provisions and a draft set of coverage provisions on which feedback is being sought. 4 SEACARE JURISDICTIONAL COVERAGE—DISCUSSION PAPER Existing Coverage Provisions 10. Existing coverage provisions are found in section 19 of the Seafarers Act and section 6 of the OHS(MI) Act. Both Acts apply to a prescribed ship (or prescribed unit in the case of the OHS(MI) Act) that is engaged in trade or commerce: a. between Australia and places outside Australia; or b. between two places outside Australia; or c. between the States; or d. within a Territory, between a State and a Territory or between two Territories. 11. In addition the two Acts apply to: a. an off-shore industry vessel in relation to which a declaration under subsection 8(A) of the Navigation Act is in force; or b. a trading ship in relation to which a declaration under subsection 8AA of the Navigation Act is in force. 12. A prescribed ship (or prescribed unit) is defined as a ship to which Part II of the Navigation Act applies. Part II (section 10) of the Navigation Act applies to: a. a ship registered in Australia; b. a ship (other than a ship registered in Australia) engaged in the coasting trade; or c. a ship (other than a ship registered in Australia or engaged in the coasting trade) of which the majority of the crew are residents of Australia and which is operated by any of the following: i. a person who is a resident of, or has his principal place of business in, Australia; ii. a firm that has its principal place of business in Australia; or iii. a company that is incorporated or has its principal place of business, in Australia. 13. The Seacare Authority has published coverage guidance notes to assist employers and operators to determine whether the Seacare scheme applies to their operations. The guidance can be found on the Seacare Authority’s website. 14. The existing coverage provisions are complex and not readily understood by maritime operators, employers and employees. The decision on whether a vessel is covered by the scheme is effectively in the hands of operators to determine based on a series of coverage tests. Some of the difficulties associated with the existing coverage provisions are outlined below. • There are conflicting views on whether references to Part II of the Navigation Act should be read in conjunction with the application provisions in section 2 of the Navigation Act. • Terms are not defined within the legislation, resulting in different interpretations as to their meaning. • There is potential for considerable jurisdictional churn as operators can theoretical move in and out of coverage depending on the nature of each voyage. • Intraterritorial voyages are treated differently from intrastate voyages. • There is potential for a coverage gap to exist in relation to non-self propelled vessels when declared under sections 8A or 8AA of the Navigation Act. 15. In addition, the Government’s shipping reform agenda means that changes will need to be made to the coverage provisions of the scheme to take account of proposals for the creation of an Australian International Shipping Register (AISR) and changes to the coastal trading licensing regime. SEACARE JURISDICTIONAL COVERAGE—DISCUSSION PAPER 5 Guiding Principles 16. In developing its draft scheme coverage provisions the Seacare Authority has been guided by a set of principles. It is not the intention of the Seacare Authority for the draft coverage provision to lead to a dramatic change in the jurisdictional footprint of the existing scheme but rather to provide clarity and certainty and to address shortcomings in the existing coverage provisions. 17. The following principles have been taken into account: • the interests of seafarers are paramount and coverage under the scheme should be available to all seafarers doing similar work in the same maritime industry sector • the coverage provisions should ensure that the same conditions extend to all operators and employers in the same maritime industry sector • the coverage provisions must be consistent with Commonwealth powers under the Constitution and consistent with Government’s policy • the coverage provisions should be clear and concise and remove ambiguities and uncertainties; • ideally commonality of coverage provisions should exist between the OHS and workers’ compensation components of the scheme • the coverage provisions should address any regulatory gaps and not result in any regulatory overlaps • the coverage provisions should be capable of accommodating an expanding maritime industry and any future changes in the maritime industry • the coverage provisions should reduce the potential for jurisdictional churn by allowing for opting in under certain conditions • the coverage provisions should result in scheme of sufficient size to remain viable to scheme participants • the coverage provisions should be acceptable to scheme stakeholders. Draft Coverage Provisions 18. The Seacare Authority’s draft coverage provisions have been developed with the above guiding principles in mind. While a large amount of commonality has been achieved in the proposed coverage provisions for the Seafarers Act and the OHS(MI) Act it has not been possible to develop a common set of coverage provisions. Existing legislation and Government policy positions particularly in regard to the proposed AISR have necessitated two sets of coverage provisions. 19. The draft coverage provisions take account of the rewrite of the Navigation Act and the coastal shipping reforms as outlined in the exposure drafts of the Navigation Bill 2012 and the Coastal Trading Bill 2012 and Coastal Trading (Consequential Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2012 released by the Department of Infrastructure and Transport on 19 December 2011. 20. The Seacare Authority notes that the exposure draft for the Australian International Shipping Register Bill has not yet been released by the Department of Infrastructure and the status of AISR vessels when engaged in the coastal trade is unclear. As such the draft coverage provisions are silent in this regard. Similarly the draft coverage provisions do not take a position on foreign registered vessels holding a Temporary Trading Licence. The Authority notes that Government policy in regard to coverage of these vessels is not as yet finalised. 21. The main features of the proposed coverage provisions are outlined below. 6 SEACARE JURISDICTIONAL COVERAGE—DISCUSSION PAPER Seafarers Act 22. The main features of the draft coverage provisions of the Seafarers Act are: • Employment of seafarers—all seafarers on the vessel are covered regardless of the nature of their employment contract. A seafarer is defined as an individual employed or engaged on the business of the ship, excluding pilots and persons temporarily employed on the vessel while the vessel is in port. • Declaration by Seacare Authority—a new provision in the Seafarers Act that allows the Seacare Authority to declare that the Act applies to a vessel on request of the operator under certain circumstances. This provision enables operators to seek a declaration to cover all vessels in their fleet to avoid jurisdiction churn and on cost efficiency grounds. The circumstances that the Seacare Authority would take into account in considering a declaration would be set out in regulations under the Act. • Australian registered commercial vessels (registered under the Shipping Registration Act 1981) which operate on international voyages or the coastal trade would be covered by the Act. • Australian registered commercial vessels that hold an ‘opt in’ declaration under the proposed Navigation Bill 2012 would be covered by the Act. • Foreign registered vessels engaged in coastal trade—these vessels would be covered when holding a Transitional General Trading Licence. • Offshore industry vessels—these vessels would be covered when operated by an Australian domiciled operator. The definition of Australian domiciled operator is sufficiently broad to capture operators that have a place of business in Australia. All offshore industry vessels would be covered regardless of where they operate. Offshore industry vessels are defined as vessels wholly or primarily engaged in exploiting or exploring the non-living natural resources of the seabed and subsoil of the seabed. 23. The following vessels or types of operations would not be captured by the draft coverage provisions: • Government vessels—currently not covered and status quo to remain • Australian Defence Force vessel—currently not covered and status quo to remain • Non-commercial vessels—not to be covered, to maintain consistency with the proposed Maritime Safety Act that only covers commercial vessels. • Intrastate voyages—not covered except where the voyage crosses the outer limits of the Exclusive Economic Zone. • Intraterritory voyages—not covered except where they cross the outer limits of the Exclusive Economic Zone to ensure consistency with intrastate voyages • Inland waterway voyages—not covered as outside the Commonwealth’s constitutional powers. 24. Further detail on the draft coverage provisions for the Seafarers Act are shown in the flow chart in Attachment B. SEACARE JURISDICTIONAL COVERAGE—DISCUSSION PAPER 7 OHS(MI) Act 25. The main features of the draft coverage provisions for the OHS(MI) Act are: • Declaration by Australian Maritime Safety Authority (AMSA)—a new provision in the OHS(MI) Act that allows AMSA to declare that the Act applies to a vessel on request of the operator under certain circumstances. This provision enables operators to seek a declaration to cover all vessels in their fleet to avoid jurisdiction churn and on cost efficiency grounds. The circumstances that AMSA would take into account in considering a declaration would be set out in regulations under the Act. • Australian registered commercial vessels (registered under the Shipping Registration Act 1981) which operate on international voyages or engage in the coastal trade would be covered by the Act. • Australian registered commercial vessels that hold an ‘opt in’ declaration under the proposed Navigation Bill 2012 would be covered by the Act. • Vessels registered under the proposed AISR vessel—these vessels would be covered to ensure appropriate OHS protection for seafarers and for compliance with Australian treaty obligations. • Offshore industry vessels—these vessels would be covered when operated by an Australian domiciled operator. The definition of Australian domiciled operator is sufficiently broad to capture operators that have a place of business in Australia. All offshore industry vessels would be covered regardless of where they operate. 26. The following vessels or types of operations would not be captured by the draft coverage provisions: • Government vessels—currently not covered and status quo to remain. • Australian Defence Force vessel—currently not covered and status quo to remain. • Offshore industry vessel when Act disapplied by the Offshore Petroleum and Greenhouse Gas Storage Act 2006 (OPGGS Act)—the OPGGS Act disapplies the Commonwealth OHS legislation when the vessel is a facility as defined by the OPGSS Act. • Non-commercial vessels—not to be covered, to maintain consistency with the proposed Maritime Safety Act that only covers commercial vessels. • Intrastate voyages—not covered except where the voyage crosses the outer limits of the Exclusive Economic Zone. • Intraterritory voyages—not covered except where the voyage crosses the outer limits of the Exclusive Economic Zone to ensure consistency with intrastate voyages. • Inland waterway voyages—not covered as outside the Commonwealth’s constitutional powers. 27. Further detail on the draft coverage provisions for the OHS(MI) Act are shown in the flow chart in Attachment B. 8 SEACARE JURISDICTIONAL COVERAGE—DISCUSSION PAPER Exemptions 28. Under the existing legislation, the Authority has the power to grant exemptions from the application of the Seafarers Act pursuant to s20A of the Act. This provision was introduced in 1997, due partly to the significant costs associated with obtaining insurance cover under the Seafarers Act for one-off voyages. 29. The Authority developed s20A exemption guidelines which establish the conditions of exemptions from the Seafarers Act. These guidelines also reflect the 2006 Ministerial Direction which prescribes that exemptions from the scheme are permitted where workers’ compensation insurance is available under a State or Territory scheme at a cost lower than that available under the Seacare scheme. The current Exemption Guidelines are available at the Seacare website. 30. The Authority proposes that under the draft coverage provisions there would still be a need to allow exemptions from the Seafarers Act in certain prescribed circumstances. However, any exemption process should not be a vehicle to undermine the integrity of the scheme and would be granted in exceptional circumstances only. To ensure greater certainty the Authority proposes that the grounds for exemptions should be prescribed in Regulation. 31. The Authority proposes that the following grounds for the granting of exemptions from the Seafarers Act are appropriate: • Proposed voyage does not constitute a regular trading pattern. • Proposed voyage is incidental to the primary operations of the vessel (i.e. relocation, delivery). • Proposed voyage is outside Australia for a period of twelve months or more and the majority of crew are non Australian residents. • Vessel is under 500 gross tonnes. 32. The Seacare Authority proposes that the granting of an exemption from the Seafarers Act would flow on to an exemption of the provisions of the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Levy Act 1992 and the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Levy Collection Act 1992 but not the OHS(MI) Act. Feedback 33. The Seacare Authority is keen to receive feedback from stakeholders and other interested parties on the proposed coverage provisions outlined in this paper. Feedback received will be taken into account in developing the Authority’s final position on scheme coverage. It should be noted that the Seacare Authority is not responsible for determining policy for the Seacare scheme but can play a role in the development of that policy by providing constructive and informed advice to the Minister. 34. Feedback on the issues in this paper should be sent to the Seacare Authority by 30 March 2012: • email to [email protected] or • post to Seacare Authority, GPO Box 9905 Canberra ACT. 35. If you have any questions regarding the issues in this paper please contact Gerard Newman, Director Seacare Management Team, on (02) 6275 0061 or email [email protected]. Seacare Authority 15 February 2012 SEACARE JURISDICTIONAL COVERAGE—DISCUSSION PAPER 9 ATTACHMENT A Legislative Extracts Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 19 Application of Act (1) This Act applies to the employment of employees on a prescribed ship that is engaged in trade or commerce: (a) between Australia and places outside Australia; or (aa) between 2 places outside Australia; or (b) among the States; or (c) within a Territory, between a State and a Territory or between 2 Territories. (1A)In addition, this Act applies to the employment of employees on any prescribed ship that is: (a) an off shore industry vessel in relation to which a declaration under subsection 8A(2) of the Navigation Act is in force; or (b) a trading ship in relation to which a declaration under subsection 8AA(2) of that Act is in force. (2) This Act also has the effect it would have if: (a) a reference to an employer were limited to a reference to a trading corporation formed within the limits of the Commonwealth; and (b) a reference to an employee were limited to a reference to an employee employed by a trading corporation formed within the limits of the Commonwealth. (3) This Act also has the effect it would have if: (a) a reference to an employer were limited to a reference to a financial corporation formed within the limits of the Commonwealth; and (b) a reference to an employee were limited to a reference to an employee employed by a financial corporation formed within the limits of the Commonwealth. (4) This Act also has the effect it would have if: (a) a reference to an employer were limited to a reference to a foreign corporation; and (b) a reference to an employee were limited to a reference to an employee employed by a foreign corporation. (5) Subsection (3) does not have the effect of applying this Act with respect to: (a) State banking that does not extend beyond the limits of the State concerned; or (b) State insurance that does not so extend. 10 SEACARE JURISDICTIONAL COVERAGE—DISCUSSION PAPER 3 General definitions prescribed ship means a ship to which Part II of the Navigation Act applies but does not include a Government ship. Occupational Health and Safety (Maritime Industry) Act 1993 6 Application of Act (1) This Act applies in relation to a prescribed ship or prescribed unit that is engaged in trade or commerce: (a) between Australia and places outside Australia; or (aa) between 2 places outside Australia; or (b) between the States; or (c) within a Territory, between a State and a Territory or between 2 Territories. (2) Without limiting the operation of subsection (1), this Act applies to: (a) the operator of a prescribed ship or prescribed unit described in subsection (1); and (b) employees employed on a prescribed ship or prescribed unit described in subsection (1); and (c) contractors and other persons working on a prescribed ship or prescribed unit described in subsection (1); and (d) manufacturers, suppliers and importers of plant used, or substances used or handled, on a prescribed ship or prescribed unit described in subsection (1). (3) This Act also applies in relation to: (a) an offshore industry vessel in relation to which a declaration under subsection 8A(2) of the Navigation Act 1912 is in force; and (b) a trading ship in relation to which a declaration under subsection 8AA(2) of that Act is in force. (4) Without limiting the operation of subsection (3), this Act applies to: (a) the operator of a vessel or ship described in subsection (3); and (b) employees employed on a vessel or ship described in subsection (3); and (c) contractors and other persons working on a vessel or ship described in subsection (3); and (d) manufacturers, suppliers and importers of plant used, or substances used or handled on, a vessel or ship described in subsection (3). (5) Without prejudice to its effect apart from this subsection, this Act also has effect as provided by subsections (6), (7) and (8). SEACARE JURISDICTIONAL COVERAGE—DISCUSSION PAPER 11 (6) This Act has, by force of this subsection, the effect it would have if: (a) a reference to an operator were limited to a reference to a trading corporation formed within the limits of the Commonwealth; and (b) a reference to an employee were limited to a reference to an employee of a trading corporation formed within the limits of the Commonwealth; and (c) a reference to a contractor were limited to a reference to a contractor working for a trading corporation formed within the limits of the Commonwealth; and (d) a reference to a manufacturer were limited to a reference to a manufacturer that is a trading corporation formed within the limits of the Commonwealth; and (e) a reference to a supplier were limited to a reference to a supplier that is a trading corporation formed within the limits of the Commonwealth; and (f) a reference to a person in sections 22, 23 and 24 were limited to a reference to a person working for a trading corporation formed within the limits of the Commonwealth. (7) This Act has, by force of this subsection, the effect it would have if: (a) a reference to an operator were limited to a reference to a financial corporation formed within the limits of the Commonwealth; and (b) a reference to an employee were limited to a reference to an employee of a financial corporation formed within the limits of the Commonwealth; and (c) a reference to a contractor were limited to a reference to a contractor working for a financial corporation formed within the limits of the Commonwealth; and (d) a reference to a person in sections 22, 23 and 24 were limited to a reference to a person working for a financial corporation formed within the limits of the Commonwealth. (8) This Act has, by force of this subsection, the effect it would have if: (a) a reference to an operator were limited to a reference to a foreign corporation; and (b) a reference to an employee were limited to a reference to an employee of a foreign corporation; and (c) a reference to a contractor were limited to a reference to a contractor working for a foreign corporation; and (d) a reference to a manufacturer were limited to a reference to a manufacturer that is a foreign corporation; and (e) a reference to a supplier were limited to a reference to a supplier that is a foreign corporation; and (f) a reference to a person in sections 22, 23 and 24 were limited to a reference to a person working for a foreign corporation. (9) This Act does not apply with respect to: (a) State banking that does not extend beyond the limits of the State concerned; or (b) State insurance that does not so extend. 12 SEACARE JURISDICTIONAL COVERAGE—DISCUSSION PAPER Navigation Act 1912 2 Application of Act (1) Except in so far as the application of this section is expressly excluded by a provision of this Act, this Act does not apply in relation to: (a) a trading ship proceeding on a voyage other than an overseas voyage or an inter State voyage; (b) an Australian fishing vessel proceeding on a voyage other than an overseas voyage; (ba) a fishing fleet support vessel proceeding on a voyage other than an overseas voyage; (c) an inland waterways vessel; or (d) a pleasure craft; or in relation to its owner, master or crew. 10 Application of Part Except so far as the contrary intention appears, this Part applies only to: (a) a ship registered in Australia; (b) a ship (other than a ship registered in Australia) engaged in the coasting trade; or (c) a ship (other than a ship registered in Australia or engaged in the coasting trade) of which the majority of the crew are residents of Australia and which is operated by any of the following (whether or not in association with any other person, firm or company, being a person, firm or company of any description), namely: (i) a person who is a resident of, or has his or her principal place of business in, Australia; (ii) a firm that has its principal place of business in Australia; or (iii) a company that is incorporated, or has its principal place of business, in Australia; and to the owner, master and crew of such a ship. Definitions overseas voyage, in relation to a ship, means a voyage in the course of which the ship travels between: (a) a port in Australia and a port outside Australia; (b) a port in Australia and a place in the waters of the sea above the continental shelf of a country other than Australia; (c) a port outside Australia and a place in the waters of the sea above the continental shelf of Australia; (d) a place in the waters of the sea above the continental shelf of Australia and a place in the waters of the sea above the continental shelf of a country other than Australia; (e) ports outside Australia; or (f) places beyond the continental shelf of Australia; whether or not the ship travels between 2 or more ports in Australia in the course of the voyage SEACARE JURISDICTIONAL COVERAGE—DISCUSSION PAPER 13 ATTACHMENT B Draft decision flowchart Seacare Jurisdictional Coverage Provisions Seacare Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 Does the Seafarers Act apply? YES Does the ship hold a Seacare Authority certificate? Is there employment of employees? NO NO YES YES YES Does the ship operate on international voyages or hold a General Training Licence? YES Is the ship an SRA commercial vessel? NO Is the ship a Government ship or an Australian Defence Force ship? YES NO Does the ship hold an ‘opt in’ declaration under the Navigation Act? Is the ship listed on the Australia international Shipping Register? NO YES NO YES NO YES Yes, the Act applies. Is the ship foreign registered? Does the ship hold a Transitional General Trading Licence? No, the Act does not apply. NO To be determined YES Does the ship hold a temporary trading licence? NO Is the operator domiciled in Australia? YES YES 14 Is the ship an offshore vessel? SEACARE JURISDICTIONAL COVERAGE—DISCUSSION PAPER NO NO ATTACHMENT B Draft decision flowchart Seacare Jurisdictional Coverage Provisions Occupational Health and Safety (Maritime Industry) Act 1993 Does the OHS(MI) Act apply? YES Does the ship hold an Australian Maritime Safety Authority certificate? Is the ship a Government ship or an Australian Defence Force ship? NO YES NO YES YES Does the ship operate on international voyages or hold a General Training Licence? Is the ship a commercial ship under the SRA? NO NO Is the ship listed on the Australian International Shipping Register? YES NO Yes, the Act applies. YES NO Does the ship hold an ‘opt in’ declaration under the Navigation Act? Is the ship foreign registered? NO No, the Act does not apply. YES YES Does the ship hold a Transitional Trading Licence? NO Is the operator domiciled in Australia? NO NO Does the ship hold a temporary trading licence? YES YES Is the ship an offshore vessel? NO YES NO Does the Offshore Petroleum and Greenhouse Gas Storage Act apply? YES SEACARE JURISDICTIONAL COVERAGE—DISCUSSION PAPER 15 16 SEACARE JURISDICTIONAL COVERAGE—DISCUSSION PAPER
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz