1 A Teacher’s Guide Vietnam War in the Classroom Contrasts, Comparisons War Literature War Films Developed by D Hideo Maruyama El Camino College Compton Educational Center Fulbright Hays GPA 2010 1 Introduction This is a byproduct of a study of Vietnam and Cambodia as result of a Fulbright Hays Group Project Abroad grant in 2010. All of the materials were generated from research conducted both in Vietnam and also in the USA. The goal of this package is to help instructors to develop their own essay topics focusing around the topic of the Vietnam War. The materials are generally for developmental and transfer levels courses. More specifically, the sample topics in this package are designed to meet the SLO requirements for the relevant literature and writing courses. However, the topics can be adapted accordingly for whichever course that you decide to use this with. Many of the novels and films would work in a psychology class for example. Post Traumatic Stress disorder is also something that can be a part of the assignments. The goal is to stimulate critical thinking and analysis of the content. 1. Tim O’Brien’s The Things They Carried. 2. Duong Thu Huong’s Novel Without a Name. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. American Films Apocalypse Now Rambo First Blood Platoon Full Metal Jacket Casualties of War. Born on the Fourth of July The Green Berets The Deer Hunter Vietnamese Films 1. Three Seasons by Tony Bui 2. Scent of Green Papaya Literary Theory The core critical theory ideas in this project are Edward Said’s concept of Orientalism and Roland Barthes “Myth Today” from Mythologies. Although not essential, it will help to make the content more digestible with a ready made theory to use as a form of analysis and critical thought. Thematic elements: War, Ethics, Cultural Relativism, Semotics There is a corresponding blog as well. Tonal Influences Maruinseasia.blogspot.com Rhetorical modes: comparison/contrast, cause & effect, definition, process. Novels The more easily accessible resources are the following: I hope this finds you well. D Hideo Maruyama 2 Index 3. Vietnam Today 5. Why bother with the Vietnam War? 8. Sample assignment. Apocalypse Now and Joseph Conrad. 11. English 1B. Literature and Writing. Comparison Contrast of Novels 13 Bibliography 14. English 1C Critical Thinking 15. Film Based general assignment samples 16. Filmography of War and Vietnam 20. Uncle Ho Chi Minh in paintings. 21. Sculpture of Uncle Ho Chi Minh in his museum. 22. The Ho Chi Minh Mausoleum. 24. Timeline from American Modern Poetry 3 Vietnam Today Vietnam today is rapidly growing. It’s not all jungle. Everyone is not running around wearing the same clothes. Much of the overall population was born well after what they call “The American War.” Primarily Communist in government, they are taking the Chinese approach of incorporating a market economy into their system. Because of this, Vietnam is experiencing rapid economic growth and the quality of life has improved significantly. A visit to Vietnam yields very little in terms of animosity towards Americans. In fact, it was one of the more pleasant countries to visit. After President Bill Clinton normalized relations with Vietnam, it has become a destination for many Americans and Europeans. A visit to the country reveals several things. None of the devastation of the war is left. The country has rebuilt itself. Uncle Ho Chi Minh is everywhere. His image is everywhere. 4 My impressions of the country are more thoroughly documented in my blog called Tonal Influences. The title is a pun about the languages in this part of the world are tonal in nature. If you use the wrong tone, you got the wrong word. There are still lingering problems. Agent Orange is still an issue in Vietnam. Vietnam is still transitioning into a market economy, but occasionally the Communist central planning thing reemerges periodically. Actually, if you look at this part of the world, everyone doesn’t get along. Social services are not exactly the best in all areas. Education is a closed system, as you must test to get into the “right” university. Even their community colleges are not open enrollment. Things are renamed. The former location for the President of South Vietnam is now called Reunification Palace. 5 Why bother with the Vietnam War? Context and Potential for Writing Across the Curriculum Using Semiotics. So it is said that if you know your enemies and know yourself, you can win a hundred battles without a single loss. If you only know yourself, but not your opponent, you may win or may lose. If you know neither yourself nor your enemy, you will always endanger yourself. The Art of War, Sun Tzu. A science that studies the life of signs within society is conceivable; it would be a part of social psychology and consequently of general psychology; I shall call it semiology (from the Greek semeion 'sign'). Semiology would show what constitutes signs, what laws govern them. Since the science does not yet exist, no one can say what it would be; but it has a right to existence, a place staked out in advance. Linguistics is only a part of the general science of semiology; the laws discovered by semiology will be applicable to linguistics, and the latter will circumscribe a well-defined area within the mass of anthropological facts. (Saussure, cited in Hawkes 1977, 123) Writing across the curriculum is the current mantra of education in America today. In fact there are a number of website that focus purely on the discussion and presentation of ideas on how to implement writing across the curriculum in the classroom today. This guide is very specific in focus. I believe the Vietnam War is a good gateway topic for a number of subject areas for writing assignments and critical thinking exercises. In addition, it also forces the student to think more in terms of a global perspective. The primary theoretical approach that I prefer to use with the Vietnam War is the semiotic method as developed by UCLA professors, Sonia Maasik and Jack Solomon in their text, Signs of Life in the USA. Why? The Vietnam War has evolved into a cultural sign. American Vietnam War films are quite suitable to semiotic analysis in terms of analyzing the mythology that now defines this war in American culture. The topic also automatically requires writing across the curriculum in the assignment. To get behind the sign, you must study the history of the event to define the signifier. There is a lack of general knowledge in America, and more importantly a lack of historical knowledge. Many students today do not know the relationship between the Vietnam War and the Cold War. Many were born after the end of the Cold War so they don’t know the fear of mutual assured destruction. The problem with this lack of knowledge is that America has again gotten involved in world conflicts in the new millennium with the 2nd Persian Gulf War, the Afghanistan/NATO War, as well as the Libyan Civil War 2011. War now dominates the 2000 decade 6 and potentially a large portion of the 2010 decade. The Vietnam War is a gateway to a number of critical thinking exercises and critical. All English classes to a certain extent deal with a variety of topic areas like sociology, psychology and history. It can be a way to connect the contemporary American student with the global perspective. Essentially what you can do is use what Jack Soloman calls Six Principles of Semiotics: 1. Always question the "commonsense" view of things, because "common sense" is really "communal sense": the habitual opinions and perspectives of [what Solomon terms] the tribe. 2. The "commonsense" viewpoint is usually motivated by a cultural interest that manipulates our consciousness for ideological reasons. 3. Cultures tend to conceal their ideologies behind the veil of "nature," defining what they do as "natural" and condemning contrary cultural practices as "unnatural." 4. In evaluating any system of cultural practices, one must take into account the interests behind it. 5. We do not perceive our world directly but view it through the filter of a semiotic code or mythic frame. 6. A sign is a sort of cultural barometer, marking the dynamic movement of social history An analysis of lets say Rambo II or Missing in Action can offer a number of semiotic readings. We are still handicapped by our own cultural relativism. We also do not read the symbolic language of many of our cultural artifacts. In addition to this, we are still dealing with stereotypical perceptions of the East. Among the cultural issues is what Ronald Takaki calls the Caliban complex between the West and the “Other.” The “Other” could mean Vietnamese, Japanese, Mexican, Honduran, or Ethiopian. Perceptions of Vietnam in film and novels and other artifacts stem from earlier perceptions of Asia. Ronald Takaki states in Hiroshima: Why America Dropped the Bomb that: Rooted in the nineteenth century, anti-Asian prejudice contributed to the way Americans quickly racialized the Pacific war. When the first Chinese immigrants arrived, they were condemned as the “yellow peril.” Then came the Japanese immigrants. They, too, found themselves the targets of 7 stereotyping, discrimination, violence, and exclusion that would lead directly to the internment camps of World War II. (7) Any evaluation of the Vietnam War would require a full presentation of race and stereotypes. In addition to the race card component of the discourse is a more complex concept such as Orientalism: an inherent dialectical conflict between the Orient and Occidental as noted by Edward Said. Often in film, the Viet Cong or Vietnamese in general are shown in very 2 dimensional ways. Semiotic readings can be extended further. As of late, there have been Vietnamese novelists who have actually tried to address the Vietnam War or what they call the American War in a more critical nature. Duong Huong and Bao Ninh have both been translated into English, but there are still censorship issues in Vietnam. Huong’s texts are largely banned in Vietnam. In fact, most of my materials are US sourced as I could not locate adequate materials other than books that glorified Uncle Ho, or General Giap. Culturally in Vietnam, there still is a sense of a need to glorify the war. What specific approaches are possible? Film and novel combinations are easy ways to introduce students to broader themes. None of the sample assignments are simply a summary or book review. All of the assignments will require the use of critical thinking skills, which may require some level of scaffolding in order to achieve the desired effect. The student will be required to understand culture, cultural differences and to expand in the context of global knowledge. With all of them, you will have opportunities to incorporate deep critical readings of popular culture. Maasik, Sonia and Jack Soloman. Signs of Life in the USA: Readings on Popular Culture for Writers. New York: Bedford, 2002. ISBN: 9780312397845 Solomon, Jack. The Signs of Our Time: The Secret Meanings of Everyday Life New York: Harper & Row, 1988. ISBN: 0-06-097266-1 8 Sample Assignment Essay Prompt Apocalypse Now and Joseph Conrad’s The Heart of Darkness Read Joseph Conrad’s The Heart of Darkness. Watch Coppola’s film adaptation of the novel, Apocalypse Now. What are the commonalities and differences between the two texts? Why do you think Coppola set his film in the Vietnam War? What issues do you think are being addressed in these two texts? Explain. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. Steps Introduce the background of Joseph Conrad. Introduce the background of the Vietnam War and films about the war. Outline how Apocalypse Now was an adaptation of The Heart of Darkness, but set in Vietnam not Africa. Go over the history of colonialism. Go over the history of Vietnam and the Vietnam conflict. Have the read the novel first. Get into groups. Some sample start up questions are as follows: a. How is colonialism portrayed in the novel? b. What is this obsession over “darkness” in the novel? c. Do you think Conrad agrees with colonialism in Africa? d. What is the significance of the river in the novel? e. Who exactly is Kurtz? Show the film. Again group work questions should follow. a. How is the Vietnam War portrayed in the film? b. What role do the songs have in the film? c. What do you think of Captain Benjamin Willard? What is his journey? d. Marlon Brando reads T.S. Eliot’s poem, “The Hollow Men.” What is the significance of this poem? e. What does Kurtz represent in the film? Assign the paper. This is the most common and the most accessible assignment. A film is linked to a challenging novel. The module will introduce to the student the perception of the other versus an understanding of the other. A close reading between the two texts would generally reveal a critical analysis of 9 colonialism, but inherently, with both texts, contact with the other instantly will corrupt the Westerner. There are other discussion points that you can incorporate into this assignment. 1. Mythology. In many ways, the Vietnam War has created its own mythological aura in America. Vietnam is has taken a mythical element in American discourse. “America would have won if we let the generals handle it all.” Underlying this discourse is an inherent belief that America can win when it uses a bigger hammer. What America failed to realize was that they were in fact fighting their own shadow as the Revolutionary Army under General Washington was an army of insurrection using guerilla tactics. It seems that the Vietnam War coincided with the collapse of the 1950s self-image of America. We have become Kurtz talking about, “The Horror. The Horror.” 2. Past Present pattern recognition. In the Conrad’s novel, we are dealing with the darkness of the Congo, the darkness of colonialism and the darkness of humanity’s ability to be inhumane to their fellow human beings. The novella will allow you to set up the context for the Vietnam War— colonialism and global politics. One of the things that will be important to set up is a proper reading of The Heart of Darkness. Many will not find this novel to be very accessible, in favor of less difficult texts. You have to introduce to the students the colonialism in Africa. This will allow you to introduce history into a writing class. Show them the pattern, and then compare it with something contemporary. The political/colonial pattern is just as relevant today as it was when Joseph Conrad was composing it during the Victorian Era. We have gone up the rivers of the Tigris and Euphrates rivers. We have instead of being hit by spears, been hit by IED (Improvised Explosive Devices). Some of it might be based on our desire to secure the oil reserves of the Middle East, just as Kurtz was trying to secure the ivory in Africa. 3. Reading visual language and the language of film. Next, you must break the entertainment tendency of watching film. With Apocalypse Now, the portrayal of the Vietnam War can allow you to integrate a rich palate of academic opportunities especially with concepts of visual language. Why did Coppola show the sacrifice of the cow during the murder of Kurtz? Why did Coppola use The Heart of Darkness as the basis for his screenplay about the Vietnam War? Be also aware that there is a documentary about the making of Apocalypse Now ironically called, The Heart of Darkness. 10 For film studies classes, this can quite useful. As you can see, there is an opportunity to write across the curriculum. It can involve political science, history, film studies and of course literary and film analysis. Conclusion Page length issues and journaling components can be modified depending upon the student learning outcome of the course in which the materials are being used. Although there are a number of good books and films available to be used, I am going limit my list of content to specific books or films that are easily found in American bookstores. Unfortunately, there is a lack of translations of Vietnamese books. In advanced classes, you can integrate more theory. One of the more obvious theoretical candidates would be New Historicism. You can also use examples in these texts for psychology courses and sociology courses like PTSD in The Things They Carried, or the support system of the veterans in America in Born on the Fourth of July. A developmental class has different requirements than a critical thinking class. You can have them read excerpts of a Vietnamese novel and an excerpt from Tim O’Brien’s novel and have them compare the two. Many of the current English courses require the instructor to follow a modal approach. What I propose is to layer on top of the modal approach, a thematic arc to the course. I have found that if you integrate an approachable theme to the course, student response tends to be better. I don’t believe a thematic arc bars you from addressing any modes of rhetoric requirements. 11 English 1B (Literature and Writing) Comparison Contrast of Novels At El Camino College, many of our English 1B courses require the use of at least two novels. What is presented here is a sample of using war related novels in such a course. The core rhetorical mode is comparison contrast, and the core components of this exercise would be novels from different cultures. Because of the complex nature of getting translations from Vietnamese writers, the selection is somewhat limited. Due to rising censorship in Vietnam, it was difficult to find novels in translation other than the two that I have located. Preparation 1. Run a diagnostic to see what their general knowledge level would be. Do not assume that they have an idea about the war or the history. Potential Gateway Discussion Prompts: What do you know about the Vietnam War? Do you know when it occurred and for how long? Do you know who the key people were? Is all of your knowledge of the war from film? 2. Depending upon their level of knowledge, you will have to tailor the assignment accordingly. The most important part is preparation. You may have to prepare the students for the topic with extensive background information about the authors, the historical context, and perhaps information about such things as post-traumatic stress disorder. 3. Have them read the novels. For many of the English 1B courses, the textbooks contain excerpts from Tim O’Brien’s books; he writes extensively about the war. Some sample novels are listed on the next page. It is here that you can customize the experience. Here are some sample pairings The Sorrow of War by Bao Ninh For Whom The Bell Tolls by Hemingway. You are actually dealing with people of the same political side. However, when an American is siding against the Fascists and with Communists, the portrayal is different than let’s say more current novels. Novel Without a Name by Duong Huong The Things They Carried by Tim O’Brien. 12 Both of these books are set in the Vietnam War, but they offer you perceptions from the other side. You can see common themes surrounding the issue of war, leadership and the loss of innocence. The Red Badge of Courage by Stephen Crane The Sorrow of War or Novel Without a Name. Stephen Crane’s novel is considered to be premier work on the American Civil War. If you also view the Vietnam War as a civil war, then you can also use this as a comparison. Both of the main characters are traumatized by their experiences. 4. Evaluate the paper according to the El Camino College SLO Rubric or your own evaluation criteria. Again, the pairings above are only suggestions. 13 Bibliography Vietnam Huong, Duong Thu. Novel Without A Name. New York: Penguin, 1995. (ISBN: 0-14-025510-9) Ninh, Bao. The Sorrow of War. New York: Riverhead, 1993. (ISBN: 978-1-57322-543-4) Karlin, Wayne, ed. The Other Side of Heaven. Williemantic: Curbstone, 1995. (ISBN: 1-880684-31-4) USA O’Brien, Tim. The Things They Carried. New York: Broadway, 1990. (ISBN: 978-0-7679-0289-2) O’Brien, Tim. Going After Cacciato. New York: Broadway, 1999. (ISBN: 978-0767904421) Hemingway, Ernest. For Whom The Bell Tolls. New York: Scribner, 1995. (ISBN: 978-0684803357) Crane, Stephen. The Red Badge of Courage. New York: Tor, 1990. (ISBN: 978-0812504798) Germany Remarque, Erich Maria. All Quiet on the Western Front. New York: Fawcett, 1956. (ISBN: 978-0449213940) War Poetry Ward, Candice. Editor. World War One British Poets: Brooke, Owen, Sassoon, Rosenberg and Others (Unabridged). New York: Dover, 1997. (ISBN: 978-0486295688) Website resource of Vietnam War related poetry. War-Stories.com http://www.war-stories.com/aspprotect/warstory-vietnam-war-poetry-1.asp 14 English 1C (Critical Thinking and Writing) The Vietnam War and Contemporary Wars As of 2010-2011, the country has now gotten involved in three war conflicts—Iraq, Afghanistan and Libya. A study of the 2nd Iraq War indicates an obvious failure in understanding of the adversary as noted in the Vietnam War. The study of our War in Afghanistan exposes the same problems. There are even more complexities that parallel the Vietnam Experience. Given that we have a large number of veterans returning from conflict zones, it can allow for them to relate to the materials more tangibly. The Fog of War The Fog of War. Eleven Lessons from the Life of Robert S. McNamara. (2003) Dir Errol Morris This is a complex documentary of Robert McNamara, Secretary of Defense during the Kennedy and Johnson Administrations. He was the man in charge when we escalated the war in Vietnam. Website: http://www.sonyclassics.com/fogofwar/ The website also contain a separate lesson plan which focuses on the film as part of an overall study of why we should not go to war. It uses Flash, so be aware that your browser may need to be updated. The Just War G. E. M Anscombe is often cited for her Just War Theory. Jus Ad Bellum is often a criterion in which you justify something. In terms of an English 1C class, the example of the Vietnam War is quite suitable as an example. You can then discuss the current wars of the 2000s. Internet Encyclopedia on Philosophy—Just War Entry http://www.iep.utm.edu/justwar/ The Art of War One of the major texts to read would be the Art of War by Sun Tzu. A reading of this text and an analysis of what actually happened in Vietnam would offer some good material for discussion and writing assignments. Excerpts can be used as part of the discussion. There is an online version of this text here. 15 Film based assignments for other courses English C, B and A Non-Transfer Level writing courses You can still run comparison contrast assignments using the content, but you may have to scale back the complexity. English 1A (Reading and Composition) And other Transfer Level courses. Many often use the films as a beginning point to discuss the nature of war. You would have to tailor the assignment accordingly. Sample prompts: 1. What were the causes of Ron Kovic’s problems in Born on the Fourth of July? Did he properly resolve his problems by the end of the film? How? 2. The Hurt Locker and The Deer Hunter both portray soldiers who have an inability to adjust to life after their war experience. How do Michael, Steven and Stan adjust in the Deer Hunter? In the Hurt Locker, why does Sergeant First Class William James have a problem adjusting to mainstream American life versus the life as a combat soldier? Compare the two films and explain your character analysis. 3. Portrayals of War. What is the difference between The Green Berets versus The Hurt Locker? Explain. 16 Filmography of War and Vietnam There are obviously many films focusing on the Vietnam War. Many of the book references or sources are autobiographical in nature. The most common literary connections would be with Joseph Conrad’s The Heart of Darkness and Graham Greene’s The Quiet American. You can actually compare films portraying the ongoing wars in Iraq and Afghanistan with some of these texts. Behind Enemy Lines and Bat 21 are somewhat close, down to having the same actor, Gene Hackman involved. Any of these films might work with the classic film, All Quiet on the Western Front. Apocalypse Now (1979) Dir. Francis Ford Coppola Book Reference: The Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad. This is considered to be one of the key Vietnam War films that populated American popular culture. It is based upon Joseph Conrad’s The Heart of Darkness. Some of the lines in the novel are echoed in the film, such as the reference to being killed by a spear. You can’t interpret the film without a clear understanding of the Conrad novel. It is a good alternative to the comparison contrast of novels. The War Trilogy of Oliver Stone Platoon (1986) Dir. Oliver Stone Book Reference: None. Born on the Fourth of July. (1989) Dir. Oliver Stone Book Reference: Born on the Fourth of July by Ronald Kovic (autobiography) Heaven and Earth (1993) Dir. Oliver Stone. Book References: When Heaven and Earth Changed Places and Child of War, Woman of Peace, by Le Ly Hayslip Both of these films are Oliver Stone projects. The reason that I have lumped them together is that they have a common theme about the loss of innocence and the complexities of war and society. Platoon has a mythic component to the storyline, which often lends itself to a mythological/hero analysis. Born on the Fourth of July focuses on a real person named Ron Kovic. He is paralyzed and then through a number of events becomes an anti-war activist. You can interpret this film in many ways, but you can make connections to the Veterans of the Gulf Wars, Afghanistan. Heaven and Earth was less 17 successful in terms of recognition. It also portrays the post-traumatic stress disorder of Gunnery Sergeant Steve Butler. Full Metal Jacket (1987) Dir Stanley Kubrick This is a Kubrick film, which can be broken down into two halves. Like all Kubrick films the scenery and visuals are amazing. The beginning of the film focuses on the turning of men into soldiers. Many former soldiers consider R Lee Ermey’s Drill Sergeant character to be true to life. The second half of the film focuses on the war in Vietnam and the experiences that they have. The Green Berets (1968) Dir. John Wayne Book Reference: The Green Berets by Robert Lowell "Robin" Moore, Jr. (Screenplay apparently is very different than the book.) This is a John Wayne film. When this film was first produced, it was the Duke’s attempt to spin a more patriotic idea about the war in Vietnam. Largely based upon a popular song, it portrays how the Green Berets work in the theater. Some might interpret this film to be nothing more than any other John Wayne film with the exception of changing the American Indian into VC. Bat 21 (1988) Dir. Peter Markel. Book Reference: Bat 21 by William Charles Anderson This is a film about Lt. Col. Iceal "Ham" Hambleton. He was rescued from enemy capture, but there is a historical reference to this event. Bat 21 was the radio call sign. One of the dubious distinctions of this event is that it took many people’s lives to save him. Ultimately it was Lt. Tom Norris of US Navy SEALs and Nguyen Van Kiet of South Vietnamese Armed Forces that actually rescued this soldier. Hamburger Hill (1987) Dir. John Irvin Book Reference: None. This is a film that portrays the US Army’s 101st Airborne taking hill 937 in May of 1969. It is very violent, but it also portrays the difficulty of war and the illogical nature of taking a hill that would not be held afterwards. We Were Soldiers (2007) Dir. Randall Wallace Book Reference: We Were Soldiers Once… And Young by Lt. Gen. Harold G. Moore (Ret.) and war journalist Joseph L. Galloway 18 This is a Mel Gibson film. It is actually based upon an autobiography by Lieutenant Colonel Hal Moore with a little help of a war journalist named Galloway. The autobiography gives significantly more detail to the battle of La Drang, but the 2nd part of the battle outlined in the autobiography is not noted in the film. It portrays the development of the 7th Calvary into the 7th Air Calvary relying on helicopters to engage the enemy. November 14, 1965 was the first time the US Military engaged the Vietnamese in force. The Deer Hunter (1978) Dir. Michael Cimino Book Reference: None. This is a classic Robert DeNiro film. It is a film that portrays the Vietnamese almost as wooden sadists. What it does attempt to portray is the complexities of sending young men into war. In some ways, it would be a good film to review post-traumatic stress disorder as portrayed in film. Good Morning Vietnam (1987) Dir. Barry Levinson Book Reference: None. It is also based on true events of the DJ, Adrian Cronauer, who would run into trouble with the Armed forces Radio Network leadership. It outlines the sarcastic analysis of the war and the reasons behind it. Robin Williams does a good comic job in this film. What it does have is the strange tendency of the soldier trying to hook up with the cute Vietnamese girl. MASH (1970) Dir. Robert Altman Book Reference: MASH: A Novel About Three Army Doctors by Richard Hooker Technically, this film is about the Korean War, but many have interpreted this film as director, Robert Altman’s critique of the Vietnam War. What is interesting is the title of the theme song, “Suicide is Painless.” Rambo (1982) Dir. Ted Kotcheff Book Reference: First Blood by David Morrell This was the first of several films to be developed by Sylvester Stallone. In this film, you see how the former Special Forces soldier has difficulty adjusting to returning home. Many of his friends have died. Elements of post-traumatic stress disorder are portrayed in the film. The later films are fantasy exercises. One of them, Rambo III (1988) portrays him helping the 19 Mujahedeen in Afghanistan. This is sort of ironic in the context of the war against the Taliban and Al Qaida. The Quiet American (1958) Dir Joseph Mankiewicz Starring Audie Murphy and Michael Redgrave The Quiet American (2002) Dir. Phillip Noyce Starring Michael Caine, Brendan Fraser, Do Thi Hai Yen. Book Reference: The Quiet American by Graham Green Both of these films are based on the novel. It is up to you to either use the classic film or the updated film with Michael Caine. The problem with the classic film is that some of Green’s political elements are suppressed. What is also problematic is that the love interest is in yellow face. On the other hand, a comparison of the two films with each other may offer some insights into images of race in American film. Vietnamese Films or Films about Vietnam Many of the films listed here do not portray the war in any kind. The reason I am including them in this list is to give you an idea about how incidental the “American War” seems to the Vietnamese. Unlike the US film industry, there doesn’t seem to be an obsession. Many of the films however have French backing. Tran Trilogy The Scent of Green Papaya (1993) Dir Tran Anh Hung Cyclo (1995) Vertical Ray of the Sun (2000) Tran Anh Hung is a Vietnamese born French director. He is considered to be the forefront of the expat Vietnamese film industry. He is also slated to adapt Haruki Murakami's novel Norwegian Wood into a film. Three Seasons (1999) Dir Tony Bui This film portrays the evolution of Ho Chi Minh City/Saigon into what it is today, a bustling market driven city. It is the first American film to be filmed in Vietnam after Bill Clinton normalized relations. There is a story line of Harvey Keitel’s character, James Hager, trying to find his daughter in Ho Chi Minh City. The Lover (1992) Dir Jean-Jacques Annaud Book Reference: The Lover by Marguerite Duras 20 This is a difficult film to recommend since it does portray an illicit affair between and older man and an under-aged French girl. Care must be taken if this film is screened in a class due to very graphic sexual situations. Critic Roger Ebert compared it to soft porn. The novel is also controversial. Comparison studies with Nabokov’s Lolita may be more useful. Indochine (1992) Dir Regis Wargnier Book Reference: None. This film stars Catherine Deneuve, and it portrays the eventual fall of France’s rule in Vietnam. It is a story about a French plantation owner who adopts a Vietnamese girl. Eventually, the girl gets politicized and gets involved with the Communists. It had won the Academy Award for best foreign film. 21 Visual Readings Images from Vietnam What is the significance of this painting of Ho Chi Minh? Uncle Ho Chi Minh Speaks to the Ethnic Minorities 22 Visual Readings Images from Vietnam What is the significance of this Vietnamese Sculpture? This was taken at the Ho Chi Min Museum. 23 Visual Readings Images from Vietnam What is the significance of the Ho Chi Minh Mausoleum? Photographs of the body are not allowed. You are not allowed to wear a hat. The Vietnamese Government had actually devoted a lot of money for this. What does this say about the role of Uncle Ho to the Vietnamese? What is the significance of this? 24 Timeline A Vietnam War Timeline (From American Modern Poetry) [Note: This timeline is an abbreviated version of the more detailed timeline posted on the Public Broadcasting System's "Vietnam Online" section of The American Experience.] 1945 Ho Chi Minh Creates Provisional Government: Following the surrender of Japan to Allied forces, Ho Chi Minh and his People's Congress create the National Liberation Committee of Vietnam to form a provisional government. Japan transfers all power to Ho's Vietminh. Ho Declares Independence of Vietnam British Forces Land in Saigon, Return Authority to French First American Dies in Vietnam: Lt. Col. A. Peter Dewey, head of American OSS mission, was killed by Vietminh troops while driving a jeep to the airport. Reports later indicated that his death was due to a case of mistaken identity -- he had been mistaken for a Frenchman. 1946 French and Vietminh Reach Accord: France recognizes Vietnam as a "free state" within the French Union. French troops replace Chinese in the North. Negotiations Between French and Vietminh Breakdown Indochina War Begins: Following months of steadily deteriorating relations, the Democratic Republic of Vietnam launches its first consorted attack against the French. 1947 Vietminh Move North of Hanoi Valluy Fails to Defeat Vietminh: French General Etienne Valluy attempts, and fails, to wipe out the Vietminh in one stroke. 1949 Elysee Agreement Signed: Bao Dai and President Vincent Auriol of France sign the Elysee Agreement. As part of the agreement the French pledge to assist in the building of a national anti-Communist army. 1950 Chinese, Soviets Offer Weapons to Vietminh US Pledges $15M to Aid French: The United States sends $15 million dollars in military aid to the French for the war in Indochina. Included in the aid package is a military mission and military advisors. 1953 France Grants Laos Full Independence Vietminh Forces Push into Laos 1954 Battle of Dienbienphu Begins: A force of 40,000 heavily armed Vietminh lay seige to the French garrison at Dienbienphu. Using Chinese artillery to shell the airstrip, the Vietminh make it impossible for French supplies to arrive by air. It soon becomes clear that the French have met their match. Eisenhower Cites "Domino Theory" Regarding Southeast Asia: Responding to the defeat of the French by the Vietminh at Dienbienphu, President Eisenhower outlines the Domino Theory: "You have a row of dominoes set up. You knock over the first one, and what will happen to the last one is the certainty that it will go over very quickly." French Defeated at Dien Bien Phu 25 Geneva Convention Begins: Delegates from nine nations convene in Geneva to start negotiations that will lead to the end of hostilities in Indochina. The idea of partitioning Vietnam is first explored at this forum. Geneva Convention Agreements Announced: Vietminh General Ta Quang Buu and French General Henri Delteil sign the Agreement on the Cessation of Hostilities in Vietnam. As part of the agreement, a provisional demarcation line is drawn at the 17th parallel which will divide Vietnam until nationwide elections are held in 1956. The United States does not accept the agreement, neither does the government of Bao Dai. 1955 Diem Rejects Conditions of Geneva Accords, Refuses to Participate in Nationwide Elections China and Soviet Union Pledge Additional Financial Support to Hanoi Diem Urged to Negotiate with North: Britain, France, and United States covertly urge Diem to respect Geneva accords and conduct discussions with the North. Diem Becomes President of Republic of Vietnam: Diem defeats Bao Dai in rigged election and proclaims himself President of Republic of Vietnam. 1956 French Leave Vietnam US Training South Vietnamese: The US Military Assistance Advisor Group (MAAG) assumes responsibility, from French, for training South Vietnamese forces. 1957 Communist Insurgency into South Vietnam: Communist insurgent activity in South Vietnam begins. Guerrillas assassinate more than 400 South Vietnamese officials. Thirty-seven armed companies are organized along the Mekong Delta. Terrorist Bombings Rock Saigon: Thirteen Americans working for MAAG and US Information Service are wounded in terrorist bombings in Saigon. 1959 Weapons Moving Along Ho Chi Minh Trail: North Vietnam forms Group 559 to begin infiltrating cadres and weapons into South Vietnam via the Ho Chi Minh Trail. The Trail will become a strategic target for future military attacks. US Servicemen Killed in Guerilla Attack: Major Dale R. Buis and Master Sargeant Chester M. Ovnand become the first Americans to die in the Vietnam War when guerillas strike at Bienhoa Diem Orders Crackdown on Communists, Dissidents 1960 North Vietnam Imposes Universal Military Conscription Kennedy Elected President: John F. Kennedy narrowly defeats Richard Nixon for the presidency. Diem Survives Coup Attempt Vietcong Formed: Hanoi forms National Liberation Front for South Vietnam. Diem government dubs them "Vietcong." 1961 Battle of Kienhoa Province: 400 guerillas attack village in Kienhoa Province, and are defeated by South Vietnamese troops. Vice President Johnson Tours Saigon: During a tour of Asian countries, Vice President Lyndon Johnson visits Diem in Saigon. Johnson assures Diem that he is crucial to US objectives in Vietnam and calls him "the Churchill of Asia." 1962 US Military Employs Agent Orange: US Air Force begins using Agent Orange -- a defoliant that came in metal orange containers-to expose roads and trails used by Vietcong forces. Diem Palace Bombed in Coup Attempt 26 Mansfield Voices Doubt on Vietnam Policy: Senate Majority Leader Mike Mansfield reports back to JFK from Saigon his opinion that Diem had wasted the two billion dollars America had spent there. 1963 Battle of Ap Bac: Vietcong units defeat South Vietnamese Army (ARVN) in Battle of Ap Bac President Kennedy Assassinated in Dallas: Kennedy's death meant that the problem of how to proceed in Vietnam fell squarely into the lap of his vice president, Lyndon Johnson. Buddhists Protest Against Diem: Tensions between Buddhists and the Diem government are further strained as Diem, a Catholic, removes Buddhists from several key government positions and replaces them with Catholics. Buddhist monks protest Diem's intolerance for other religions and the measures he takes to silence them. In a show of protest, Buddhist monks start setting themselves on fire in public places. Diem Overthrown, Murdered: With tacit approval of the United States, operatives within the South Vietnamese military overthrow Diem. He and his brother Nhu are shot and killed in the aftermath. 1964 General Nguyen Khanh Seizes Power in Saigon: In a bloodless coup, General Nguyen Khanh seizes power in Saigon. South Vietnam junta leader, Major General Duong Van Minh, is placed under house arrest, but is allowed to remain as a figurehead chief-of-state. Gulf of Tonkin Incident: On August 2, three North Vietnamese PT boats allegedly fire torpedoes at the USS Maddox, a destroyer located in the international waters of the Tonkin Gulf, some thirty miles off the coast of North Vietnam. The attack comes after six months of covert US and South Vietnamese naval operations. A second, even more highly disputed attack, is alleged to have taken place on August 4. Debate on Gulf of Tonkin Resolution: The Gulf of Tonkin Resolution is approved by Congress on August 7 and authorizes President Lyndon Johnson to "take all necessary measures to repel any armed attack against forces of the United States and to prevent further aggression." The resolution passes unanimously in the House, and by a margin of 82-2 in the Senate. The Resolution allows Johnson to wage all out war against North Vietnam without ever securing a formal Declaration of War from Congress. Vietcong Attack Bienhoa Air Base LBJ Defeats Goldwater: Lyndon Johnson is elected in a landslide over Republican Barry Goldwater of Arizona. During the campaign, Johnson's position on Vietnam appeared to lean toward de-escalation of US involvement, and sharply contrasted the more militant views held by Goldwater. 1965 Operation "Rolling Thunder" Deployed: Sustained American bombing raids of North Vietnam, dubbed Operation Rolling Thunder, begin in February. The nearly continuous air raids would go on for three years. Marines Arrive at Danang: The first American combat troops, the 9th Marine Expeditionary Brigade, arrive in Vietnam to defend the US airfield at Danang. Scattered Vietcong gunfire is reported, but no Marines are injured. Heavy Fighting at Ia Drang Valley: The first conventional battle of the Vietnam war takes place as American forces clash with North Vietnamese units in the Ia Drang Valley. The US 1st Air Cavalry Division employs its newly enhanced technique of aerial reconnaissance to finally defeat the NVA, although heavy casualties are reported on both sides. US Troop Levels Top 200,000 Vietnam "Teach-In" Broadcast to Nation's Universities: The practice of protesting US policy in Vietnam by holding "teach-ins" at colleges and universities becomes widespread. The first "teach-in" -featuring seminars, rallies, and speeches -- takes place at the University of Michigan at Ann Arbor in March. In May, a nationally broadcast "teach-in" reaches students and faculty at over 100 campuses. 1966 B-52s Bomb North Vietnam: In an effort to disrupt movement along the Mugia Pass -- the main route used by the NVA to send personnel and supplies through Laos and into South Vietnam -- American B-52s bomb North Vietnam for the first time. South Vietnam Government Troops Take Hue and Danang 27 LBJ Meets With South Vietnamese Leaders: US President Lyndon Johnson meets with South Vietnamese Premier Nguyen Cao Ky and his military advisors in Honolulu. Johnson promises to continue to help South Vietnam fend off aggression from the North, but adds that the US will be monitoring South Vietnam's efforts to expand democracy and improve economic conditions for its citizens. Veterans Stage Anti-War Rally: Veterans from World Wars I and II, along with veterans from the Korean war stage a protest rally in New York City. Discharge and separation papers are burned in protest of US involvement in Vietnam. CORE Cites "Burden On Minorities and Poor" in Vietnam: The Congress of Racial Equality (CORE) issues a report claiming that the US military draft places "a heavy discriminatory burden on minority groups and the poor." The group also calls for a withdrawal of all US troops from Vietnam. 1967 Operation Cedar Falls Begins: In a major ground war effort dubbed Operation Cedar Falls, about 16,000 US and 14,000 South Vietnamese troops set out to destroy Vietcong operations and supply sites near Saigon. A massive system of tunnels is discovered in an area called the Iron Triangle, an apparent headquarters for Vietcong personnel. Bunker Replaces Cabot Lodge as South Vietnam Ambassador Martin Luther King Speaks Out Against War: Calling the US "the greatest purveyor of violence in the world," Martin Luther King publicly speaks out against US policy in Vietnam. King later encourages draft evasion and suggests a merger between antiwar and civil rights groups. Dow Recruiters Driven From Wisconsin Campus: University of Wisconsin students demand that corporate recruiters for Dow Chemical -- producers of napalm -- not be allowed on campus. McNamara Calls Bombing Ineffective: Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara, appearing before a Senate subcommittee, testifies that US bombing raids against North Vietnam have not achieved their objectives. McNamara maintains that movement of supplies to South Vietnam has not been reduced, and neither the economy nor the morale of the North Vietnamese has been broken. 1968 January Sihanouk Allows Pursuit of Vietcong into Cambodia North Vietnamese Launch Tet Offensive: In a show of military might that catches the US military off guard, North Vietnamese and Vietcong forces sweep down upon several key cities and provinces in South Vietnam, including its capital, Saigon. Within days, American forces turn back the onslaught and recapture most areas. From a military point of view, Tet is a huge defeat for the Communists, but turns out to be a political and psychological victory. The US military's assessment of the war is questioned and the "end of tunnel" seems very far off. February Battle for Hue: The Battle for Hue wages for 26 days as US and South Vietnamese forces try to recapture the site seized by the Communists during the Tet Offensive. Previously, a religious retreat in the middle of a war zone, Hue was nearly leveled in a battle that left nearly all of its population homeless. Following the US and ARVN victory, mass graves containing the bodies of thousands of people who had been executed during the Communist occupation are discovered. Westmoreland Requests 206,000 More Troops My Lai Massacre: On March 16, the angry and frustrated men of Charlie Company, 11th Brigade, Americal Division entered the village of My Lai. "This is what you've been waiting for -- search and destroy -- and you've got it," said their superior officers. A short time later the killing began. When news of the atrocities surfaced, it sent shockwaves through the US political establishment, the military's chain of command, and an already divided American public. March LBJ Announces He Won't Run: With his popularity plummeting and dismayed by Senator Eugene McCarthy's strong showing in the New Hampshire primary, President Lyndon Johnson stuns the nation and announces that he will not be a candidate for re-election. April MLK Slain in Memphis: May 28 Paris Peace Talks Begin: Following a lengthy period of debate and discussion, North Vietnamese and American negotiators agree on a location and start date of peace talks. Talks are slated to begin in Paris on May 10 with W. Averell Harriman representing the United States, and former Foreign Minister Xuan Thuy heading the North Vietnamese delegation. June Robert Kennedy Assassinated August Upheaval at Democratic Convention in Chicago: As the frazzled Democratic party prepares to hold its nominating convention in Chicago, city officials gear up for a deluge of demonstrations. Mayor Richard Daley orders police to crackdown on antiwar protests. As the nation watched on television, the area around the convention erupts in violence. November Richard Nixon Elected President: Running on a platform of "law and order," Richard Nixon barely beats out Hubert Humphrey for the presidency. Nixon takes just 43.4 percent of the popular vote, compared to 42.7 percent for Humphrey. Third-party candidate George Wallace takes the remaining percentage of votes. 1969 Nixon Begins Secret Bombing of Cambodia: In an effort to destroy Communist supply routes and base camps in Cambodia, President Nixon gives the go-ahead to "Operation Breakfast." The covert bombing of Cambodia, conducted without the knowledge of Congress or the American public, will continue for fourteen months. Policy of "Vietnamization" Announced: Secretary of Defense Melvin Laird describes a policy of "Vietnamization" when discussing a diminishing role for the US military in Vietnam. The objective of the policy is to shift the burden of defeating the Communists onto the South Vietnamese Army and away from the United States. Ho Chi Minh Dies at Age 79 News of My Lai Massacre Reaches US: Through the reporting of journalist Seymour Hersh, Americans read for the first time of the atrocities committed by Lt. William Calley and his troops in the village of My Lai. At the time the reports were made public, the Army had already charged Calley with the crime of murder. Massive Antiwar Demonstration in DC 1970 Sihanouk Ousted in Cambodia: Prince Sihanouk's attempt to maintain Cambodia's neutrality while war waged in neighboring Vietnam forced him to strike opportunistic alliances with China, and then the United States. Such vacillating weakened his government, leading to a coup orchestrated by his defense minister, Lon Nol. Kent State Incident: National Guardsmen open fire on a crowd of student antiwar protesters at Ohio's Kent State University, resulting in the death of four students and the wounding of eight others. President Nixon publicly deplores the actions of the Guardsmen, but cautions: "...when dissent turns to violence it invites tragedy." Several of the protesters had been hurling rocks and empty tear gas canisters at the Guardsmen. Kissinger and Le Duc Begin Secret Talks Number of US Troops Falls to 280K 1971 Lt. Calley Convicted of Murder Pentagon Papers Published: A legacy of deception, concerning US policy in Vietnam, on the part of the military and the executive branch is revealed as the New York Times publishes the Pentagon Papers. The Nixon administration, eager to stop leaks of what they consider sensitive information, appeals to the Supreme Court to halt the publication. The Court decides in favor the Times and allows continued publication. Nixon Announces Plans to Visit China: In a move that troubles the North Vietnamese, President Nixon announces his intention to visit The People's Republic of China. Nixon's gesture toward China is seen by the North Vietnamese as an effort to create discord between themselves and their Chinese allies. 29 Thieu Re-elected in South Vietnam 1972 Nixon Cuts Troop Levels by 70K: Responding to charges by Democratic presidential candidates that he is not moving fast enough to end US involvement in Vietnam, President Nixon orders troop strength reduced by seventy thousand. Secret Peace Talks Revealed B-52s Bomb Hanoi and Haiphong: In an attempt to force North Vietnam to make concessions in the ongoing peace talks, the Nixon administration orders heavy bombing of supply dumps and petroleum storage sites in and around Hanoi and Haiphong. The administration makes it clear to the North Vietnamese that no section of Vietnam is off-limits to bombing raids. Break-In at Watergate Hotel Kissinger Says "Peace Is At Hand": Henry Kissinger and Le Duc Tho reach agreement in principle on several key measures leading to a cease-fire in Vietnam. Kissinger's view that "peace is at hand," is dimmed somewhat by South Vietnamese President Thieu's opposition to the agreement. Nixon Wins Reelection 1973 Cease-fire Signed in Paris: A cease-fire agreement that, in the words of Richard Nixon, "brings peace with honor in Vietnam and Southeast Asia," is signed in Paris by Henry Kissinger and Le Duc Tho. The agreement is to go into effect on January 28. End of Draft Announced Last American Troops Leave Vietnam Hearings on Secret Bombings Begin: The Senate Armed Services Committee opens hearing on the US bombing of Cambodia. Allegations are made that the Nixon administration allowed bombing raids to be carried out during what was supposed to be a time when Cambodia's neutrality was officially recognized. As a result of the hearings, Congress orders that all bombing in Cambodia cease effective at midnight, August 14. Kissinger and Le Duc Tho Win Peace Prize: The Nobel Peace Prize is awarded to Henry Kissinger of the United States and Le Duc Tho of North Vietnam. Kissinger accepts the award, while Tho declines, saying that a true peace does not yet exist in Vietnam. 1974 Thieu Announces Renewal of War Report Cites Damage to Vietnam Ecology: According to a report issued by The National Academy of Science, use of chemical herbicides during the war caused long-term damage to the ecology of Vietnam. Subsequent inquiries will focus on the connection between certain herbicides, particularly Agent Orange, and widespread reports of cancer, skin disease, and other disorders on the part of individuals exposed to them. Communists Take Mekong Delta Territory Nixon Resigns Communists Plan Major Offensive: With North Vietnamese forces in the South believed to be at their highest levels ever, South Vietnamese leaders gird themselves for an expected Communist offensive of significant proportions. 1975 Communist Forces Capture Phuoc Long Province: The South Vietnamese Army loses twenty planes in a failed effort to defend Phuoc Long, a key province just north of Saigon. North Vietnamese leaders interpret the US's complete lack of response to the siege as an indication that they could move more aggressively in the South. Hue Falls to Communists Communists Take Aim at Saigon: The North Vietnamese initiate the Ho Chi Minh Campaign -- a concerted effort to "liberate" Saigon. Under the command of General Dung, the NVA sets out to capture Saigon by late April, in advance of the rainy season. 30 Ford Calls Vietnam War "Finished": Anticipating the fall of Saigon to Communist forces, US President Gerald Ford, speaking in New Orleans, announces that as far as the US is concerned, the Vietnam War is "finished." Last Americans Evacuate as Saigon Falls to Communists: South Vietnamese President Duong Van Minh delivers an unconditional surrender to the Communists in the early hours of April 30. North Vietnamese Colonel Bui Tin accepts the surrender and assures Minh that, "...Only the Americans have been beaten. If you are patriots, consider this a moment of joy." As the few remaining Americans evacuate Saigon, the last two US servicemen to die in Vietnam are killed when their helicopter crashes. 1976-80 Pham Van Dong Heads Socialist Republic of Vietnam: As the National Assembly meets in July of 1976, the Socialist Republic of Vietnam names Pham Van Dong its prime minister. Van Dong and his fellow government leaders, all but one of whom are former North Vietnamese officials, take up residence in the nation's new capital--Hanoi. Jimmy Carter Elected US President Carter Issues Pardon to Draft Evaders: In a bold and controversial move, newly inaugurated President Jimmy Carter extends a full and unconditional pardon to nearly 10,000 men who evaded the Vietnam War draft. Vietnam Granted Admission to United Nations Relations Between Vietnam and China Deteriorate Vietnam Invades Cambodia: Determined to overthrow the government of Pol Pot, Vietnam invades Cambodia. Phnompenh, Cambodia's capital, falls quickly as Pol Pot and his Khmer Rouge followers flee into the jungles. "Boat People" Flee Vietnam: Swarms of Vietnamese refugees take to the sea in overcrowded and unsafe boats in search of a better life. The ranks of the "boat people" include individuals deemed enemies of the state who've been expelled from their homeland. China Invades,Withdraws from, Vietnam US GAO Issues Report on Agent Orange: After years of Defense Department denials, the US General Accounting Office releases a report indicating that thousands of US troops were exposed to the herbicide Agent Orange. Thousands of veterans had demanded a government investigation into the effect that dioxin, a chemical found in Agent Orange, had on the human immune system. Ronald Reagan Elected US President 1981-85 Vietnam Memorial in Washington, DC Dedicated: Designed by Maya Ying Lin, a 22 year-old Yale architectural student, the Vietnam Veteran's Memorial opens in Washington, DC. The quiet, contemplative structure consisting of two black granite walls forming a "V", lists the names of the 58,183 Americans killed in the Vietnam War. The memorial itself stirred debate as some thought its presentation was too muted and somber, lacking the familiar elements of war-time heroics found in most war memorials. Reagan Promises to Make MIAs "Highest National Priority": For the family members of those still listed as Missing-In-Action, the war is not over. In an address to the National League of Families of American Prisoners and Missing in Southeast Asia, President Ronald Reagan pledges to make the finding of these individuals one of the "highest national priority." Dow Chemical Knowledge of Dioxin Revealed: Documents used as part of a lawsuit brought by 20,000 Vietnam veterans against several chemical companies reveal that Dow Chemical had full knowledge of the serious health risks posed by human exposure to dioxin, a chemical found in the herbicide Agent Orange. Evidence indicated that despite this information, Dow continued to sell herbicides to the US military for use in Vietnam. "Unknown Soldier" of Vietnam War Laid to Rest US Offers Asylum to Vietnamese Political Prisoners Vietnamese Forces Defeat Khmer Rouge Rebels: An offensive launched against refugee Khmer Rouge rebels spills over the Thai border and eventually comes to involve Thai troops. The Vietnamese are successful in suppressing the rebels and solidify their hold on Cambodia despite criticism from neighboring countries and the United Nations. 31 1986-90 George Bush Elected US President Vietnamese Troops Leave Cambodia: All Vietnamese troops exit Cambodia by September of 1989, paving the way for UN-sponsored elections in 1993. As a result of the elections, a coalition government is formed and work on a new constitution begins. 1991-97 Bill Clinton Elected US President Washington Restores Diplomatic Ties with Hanoi: As Communist Vietnam inched toward market reforms and pledged full cooperation in finding all Americans listed as still missing-in-action, the United States restores diplomatic ties with its former enemy in 1995. McNamara Calls Vietnam Policy "Wrong, Terribly Wrong": Former Defense Secretary Robert McNamara, one of the key architects of the US's war policy in Vietnam, admits grave mistakes in that policy in his 1995 memoir, In Retrospect. McNamara, in his book, says that "...We were wrong, terribly wrong. We owe it to future generations to explain why." US and Vietnam Exchange Ambassadors: Ushering in a new era of cooperation between the two former enemies, the United States and Vietnam exchange ambassadors. Douglas "Pete" Peterson, a prisoner of war for 6 years during the Vietnam War, is named US envoy to the Socialist Republic of Vietnam, while H.E. Le Van Bang assumes the position of Vietnamese ambassador to the United States. Yes, those Cu Chi tunnels are small. Additional Resources can be located at our Fulbright Hays GPA website at Long Beach City College.
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz