A Model of the Phonological Loop: Generalization and

 "!
#$&%'(*)+,-* . /0..*
13254768259:9<;+=?>&@A1+BCD9:9FE
IG HKJMLONQPQRSHUT*PWVYX8Z\[Q]_^a`5VYbAVYc]
dIT5eAfYHUNa[QegPh]VYXjikVblVNmLn_VpoqVr5bAn5HUN
sOt*u dviqo
oqVr5bAn5HUNxw5i<y{zY| s |}
~Kh€mg‚ƒ‚…„*†q‡*ˆ‰„YŠŒ‹Ž Ša~x‚ƒ~UŒx~Y €‘’
1+“”68“•9D–‰“—˜“Ž™K“
šG HUJMLYNŒPmRpHKT*P›VYXœZk[Œ]_^a`5VblVcY]
dWT5eAfYHKNm[QegPh]+VOX\ikVYbAVYNaLYn_VpokVr5bn_HUN
sOtu d-iqo
okVr5bn_HUNxwŽi<y.z| s |}
ž Ÿv¡Y¢_£5¤j¥•¢
¦,H-J5NmHK[QHUT*PWL§T5HUr5NaLOb¨TMH©PhªqVYNm«pRSV_n_HKb¬PQ`MLOPI[Œ`5V­ªW[q`5V­ªPQ`5HJ5NmH©XFNmVYT*PaLOb
^©VNŒPmH©®¨wYeAT*PQHUNaLY^©PQeAT5cª<elPQ`¯Pm`5HW°ML[QLYb5cLYT5cYbAeALMw^KLOTSR¯LOeATPaLOeATL'[QHK±*r5HUTŽ^©H
VOµ XvJ5`5VYTMVYbAVYcYe^ULYbkeAT_XFVNQR¯L­PmelVTeATLY^©PQeAf²LOPQeAVYT_³‰°ML[ŒHxn´ªkVNQ«eAT5c(RpHKRSVYNm]
e·¶ H¶lw”PQ`5Hp¸M¹5º­»¬º­¼lºm½Y¾D¿mÀO¼k¼AºKºa¸_Á‘¶¯Â›`5HSJ5NmeARSLYNQ]&XFrMTM^‘PmelVT(VYX\Pm`5eA[-JM`5VYT5VY³
blVcYe^ULYbšbAVVYJÃR¯L²]°•HÄPmVÅPQNaLOTM[QelHKT*PQbA]ÅHKTM^©V_n_H´LYNQ°5elPQNaLONm]Ű5elTŽn_elTMc[ÆVOX
elT5XFVYNmRSLOPQeAVYTÇT5HK^UHK[m[QLYNQ] XFVN&PmL[Œ«_[3È Pm`5HÉ^©VRʰ5eATML­PmVYNmeALYb-H©®_J5NmHK[m[ŒeAfYH
JŽV­ªqHUN§VOXWbLOT5crMLOcHHUTŽLO°5bAHK[ÊfYHUNm],ËMH©®_eA°5blHư5eATMn_eAT5cÄVYXWHK[m[ŒHKT*PQeLObAbl]LONQ³
°5elPQNaLONm]ÄJ5eAHK^UHK['VYX<elT_XFVNQR¯LOPQeAVYT”¶,yšr5NÊRpV_n_HKb\PaLO«HK['Ln_f­LOT*PmLYcYH¯VOX›Pm`5H
^©bAV[QHKn³Ì^©bLY[m[?TŽL­PQrMNQHvVOX˜JM`5VYT5HKRSHK[Kw*ª<`MeA^a`ÆLObAblV­ªW[qn_el͕HKNQHKTP›T5HKr5NmLYb¬NQHKJ_³
NQHx[ŒHKT*PmL­PmelVTM[jVYX¨LYblbŽJŽV*[Q[QeA°5blHIJ5`5VYTMHURSHK[kL­P\HxLY^a`[QHK±*r5HUT*PmeALYb5JŽV*[ŒelPQeAVYTSPmV
°ŽHHKTM^©V_n_Hxn¨¶?Â7V¯RSLY«YHvPQ`MeA[<ªqVYNm«¬wªkH[Qr5cYcHK[ŒPqPm`ML­P<Pm`5H°ML[QLYb¨cLOTMcYbAeAL
J5NmV­f*en_HL¯NmHUcelVT_³‰[QJ•HK^©elΎ^vr5J¬n5L­PmHÊ[QelcTMLOb¨Pm`ML­PILYblbAV_^ULOPQHK[WJ5`5VYTMHURSHK[›PmV
PQ`5H§LOJ5J5NmVYJMNQeL­PmH-[QHK±*r5HKT*PQeLOb7^UV_n_elTMc[ŒbAVOPx¶›Â7Vn_HKRpVTM[ŒPQNaL­PQH-Pm`ML­PšËMH©®_el³
°5bAHYwMLYNQ°5elPQNaLONm]S°5eATMn_eAT5c¯VOXœT5V­fYHKb”[ŒHx±*r5HUTM^UHK[<^KLOTưŽH'[Qr5J5J•VYNQPQHxn+°]Pm`5e[
RSHK^a`MLYT5eA[QR&wkªqHÏ[Q`5V­ªÐPm`ML­P¯Pm`5HRSVn5HUbI^KLOT cYHKT5HUNaLObAelÑKH+PmV´T5V­fYHKbW[ŒHU³
±*r5HUTM^UHK[<LOXÒPQHUN<RSV_n_HKNmLOPQHLORSVYrMTPa[›VOX8PQNaLOeAT5eAT5cM¶
Ó Ô Õ ¢_£5Ö<×IØI¥•¢5ÙŒÖ Õ
Ú Hx±rMHUT*PQeLObœ°5eATMn_eAT5c&eA[L3fYHKNm[QeAVYTÏVYX\PQ`MHp°MelTMn5elT5c&J5NmVY°MblHKRNQHx±rMelNmelTMcPQ`ŽL­P-PQ`5HSen_HUT*PmegPh]
VOX?LYTÆelPQHKRÛLYTMn&elPm[WJ•V[QelPQeAVYTª<elPQ`5eATÏL¯[ŒHx±*r5HUTM^UH'°•H'°ŽVr5TMn¨¶›Ü5VNIHU®_LYRSJ5blHw_PQV+HUTM^UVn5H'L
J5`5VT5HSTr5Rʰ•HUN µ H¶ c޶lw t }Ý­³‰|| uOt Á‘wŽVYT5HSR§rM[hPNmHURSHUR§°ŽHKN-T5VOP-VYT5bA]Pm`5H¯n_elcegPa[Uw˜°5r_P-PQ`5HKelN
VYNan_HKNvª<elPQ`MelT(PQ`MH[ŒHx±rMHUTM^UHY¶SމP'`MLY[-°•HUHKT´[Œr5ccYHx[hPmHKnPm`ML­PPm`5H¯°5NaLOeAT,R¯L²]Ï`ŽL²fYHSn_HUfHUbl³
VYJ•HKn´L[QJ•HK^©eLObAeAÑUHKn´[Q]_[hPmHURXFVYNPm`5eA[ÊXFVYNmRVYX<°5elTŽn_elTMcÏelTPm`5H+n_VR¯LOeAT(VYX<J5`5VYTMVYbAVYcYe^ULYb
[QHK±*r5HUTŽ^©HK[Kw_eAT3Pm`5H-XFVYNmRVYX7Pm`5Hv¸5¹Mº­»¬º­¼lºm½O¾D¿aÀO¼8¼AºKºa¸ µ o›LYnMn_HUbAHU]w”ßK}zYà5á_o›LYnMn_HUbAHU]wMâ-L­PQ`MHUNQ³
^©VblHw_ãäZjLOJMLYcYT5VŽwŽßx}Y}z5áoqr5NmcYHx[Q[qã{åIegPa^a`”w¨ßK}}Y}*Á‘¶œÂ›`5HšJM`5VYT5VblVcYe^ULYbŽbAVVYJ+e[›cYHKT5HUNaLObAbA]
^©VTM^©HKelfHKn¯VYX7LY[›L§[Œ]_[ŒPQHURæPm`ML­P<^ULYT3±*r5e^a«bl]¯HKTM^©V_n_H-LÊ[QHK±*r5HKTM^©HvVOX˜JM`5VYT5HKRSHK[›LOTMnPQ`5HKT
NmHUJ•HKL­P+PQ`5e[+[QHK±*r5HKTM^©HϰŽLY^a«NmHUJ•HKLOPQHxn_bl]¶ Ú PmLYTMn5LONanÅHK[ŒPQeAR¯L­PQHx[J5bLY^UHPQ`MHÄ^ULYJMLY^UegPh]VOX
PQ`MeA[-bAVVYJ,LOP'LO°•VYr_PÊÝ_¶ u [ŒHx^©VYTŽn5[IVYX§çQµ elT5TMHUN[ŒJ•HUHx^a`”w èÆLYTMn,egPe[-ª<eAn_HKbl]NmHUc*LONan_HKnÄLY[-n_H©³
J•HUTMn_eAT5c(VYTPm`5H3JMNQHUXFNQVTPaLObq^©VYNQPQHU® HY¶ cM¶Aw8ZjLYr5bAHK[Qr”w7ÜMNQelPQ`”wjãéÜ5NaLY^a«V­ª<eALY«¬w?ßK}} s Á©¶Ï¦(H
`ML²fHÊn_HUfHUbAVYJ•HKnL¯RSV_n_HKb7VYXjPQ`5H§J5`5VYTMVYbAVYcYe^ULYb”bAV*VJ°MLY[QHKn&VTÏVYrMNIH©®_e[hPmelTMc¯XFNmLYRSHUªqVYNm«
XFVYNvr5TMn5HUNa[hPaLOTMn_eAT5c`MV­ªPQ`5H§J5NQHUXFNQVT*PmLOb8^©VNŒPmH©®ÏLOTMnϰMLY[mLOb7cLOTMcYbAeAL¯eAT*PQHKNmL^‘PWPmV3[Qr5J5J•VYNQP
LY^©PQeAf­L­PQeAVYT5³·°ML[ŒHxn+ªqVYNm«elTMc§RSHURSVNQ] µ Ü5NaLOT5«¬w ˜VYr5c`5Nm]Yw5ãy <HKelbAbA]YwŽÝY|Y|5ß²Á‘¶?›`5e[<RSV_n_HUb
J•HUNQXFVYNmRS[p°5eATMn_eAT5c(°]´rM[ŒeAT5cn_el͕HKNQHKTP¯T5HKr5NaLOb›[Œr5°Ž[hPmNmLOPQHK[§XFVN§Pm`5H&n_egͬHUNmHUT*P[QHK±*r5HUT*PmeALYb
J•V[QegPmelVTM[¯VOXJ5`MVYT5HKRpHx[U¶Â›`5e[e[L´feLO°5bAHÏ[ŒVblr5PQeAVYTÅXFVYN+L[ŒR¯LObAb·w›^UblV*[ŒHxn³Ì^©bLY[m[p[QH©P3VOX
elPQHUR¯[qbAel«HIJ5`5VT5HURSHx[U¶jåWV­ªqHUfHUNxwOPm`5NQVr5cY`PQ`5Hv^©VYR§°5eATML­PmVYNmeALYbMJ•V­ªkHKN\VOX7bALYT5cYrMLYcYHwOPQ`MHK[QH
J5`5VT5VYbAVYceA^KLOb›[ŒHx±*r5HUTM^UHK[¯^KLOTÅNQHKJ5NQHx[ŒHKT*PSL(`r5cYH&Tr5R§°ŽHKN¯VOXn_eA[ŒPQeATM^©P+^©VYR§°5eATML­PmelVTM[pVOX
^©VTM^©HKJ_Pm[K¶I›`5HKNQHUXFVYNmHYwMPQ`5e[I°ŽLY[QeA^ÊRSLYelT*PmHUTMLYTM^©H'RSHx^a`MLOT5e[QRÛ^KLOTϰ•HÊbAHUfHUNaLOcYHxnÆelTÏR¯LYT*]
n_el͕HKNQHKT*Pj^UelNa^©rMRS[ŒPmLYTM^©Hx[8PQV-°5eATMn§elT_XFVNQR¯LOPQeAVYTpT5HUHxn_HKnÊXFVYNjeARSRpHxn_eL­PQH<rŽ[ŒH µ H¶ c޶lwYelT \º ¾Ò»*½ ¯º šPmL[Œ«_[aÁ‘¶
cYVV_nHU®5LORSJ5bAHvVYX7Pm`5e[qXFVYNmRÐVOX8PQNaLOTM[QeAHUT*PKw_J5`MVYT5VblVcYe^ULObAbA]³Ìn_HKJŽHKTMn_HUT*Pq°5elTŽn_elTMc^©VYRSHx[
XFNmVYRLPaLY[Q«p[ŒPQrMn5elHxn°] el]*LO«HILOTMn Ú VOPmV µ eATJ5NmHUJŽLONaL­PQeAVYT•Á‘¶8ÞÌT¯PQ`5e[kPmL[Œ«¬w*JMLONQPQe^©eAJMLOT*Pa[
[mL²ª[ŒHx±rMHUT*PQeLObAbl]*³‰J5NmHK[QHUT*PQHxnp^UVYbAVYNmHKnSbAH©PQPQHUNa[qVYT5HvL­P›LPQeARSHšVT3L§^©VYRSJ5r5PQHUN›n_e[ŒJMbAL²]w*LYTMn
`MLn¯PQVSNmHK[QJŽVTMn¯PmV ‰À :½ ?VOX8L§NmHKn VN›L§cYNmHUHKT pw_°5r_P<T5VOPqPQV¯LYT*]¯VYPQ`5HKN<^©VYbAVYNQ³‰blHUPŒPQHKN
^©VRʰ5eATMLOPQeAVYT µ H¶ c޶lw²cNQHKHUT [7LYTMn-NmHKn [Kwxª<`MeA^a`ªqHUNmH\LOb[QV<J5NQHx[ŒHKT*PQHKnŽÁ‘¶ XÒPQHKN8LYTelT5elPQeLOb
[QHUNmelHx[šVYX\PmNQeLOb[-ª<egPm`(PQ`5e[[ŒHUPVOXqPmLONmcYHUPm[Kw¬PQ`5HpPaLONmcYH©Pa[-ªkHKNQHS[Qª<egPa^a`5HKnÄPQV&°•HL+cNQHKHU!T LOTŽn¯LNQHx"n §¶Â›`rM[UwPQ`MH<PmL[Œ«S^©bAHKLYNQbA]ÊNmHK±*r5eANQHx[j°5eATMn_eAT5cÊVYX”^©VYbAVYNkLOTMnSbAH©PQPQHUNqeAT_XFVYNmR¯L­PQeAVYT˜w
LOTŽnÉr5J¬n5L­PmelTMcÄVOXIPQ`5Hx[ŒHư5eATMn_eAT5c[pL­XÒPmHUNpPQ`5H&[Qª<egPa^a`^©VTMn_elPQeAVYT”#¶ eA]LY«YH3LYTMn Ú VYPQV µ eAT
J5NmHUJMLYNmLOPQeAVYTŽÁœXFVYr5TMnPQ`MLOPqelX”µ Pm`5HU][QelRSJ5bA]¯`MLn¯JMLONQPQe^©eAJMLYTPa[\NmHUJ•HKLOP\Pm`5HšªqVYNan´çŒPQ`5Hxè'V­fYHKN
LOTŽnÄV­fHUN-n_r5NmelT5cÆPm`5HpPmLY[Q« e:¶ HY¶AwkÀ ·¾D¿ $_¼lÀ ̺ %$x¸&¸ 'a¾DºO»*Á©w˜elP-eAT*PQHKNŒXFHKNQHxn,[QelcT5elΎ^ULYTPmbl]
ª<elPQ`J•HUNQXFVYNmRSLYTM^©H¶kÞÌTÏ^UVYT*PQNaLY[ŒPKwMJŽHKNŒXFVNQRSeAT5c+L¯[QelRSeAbALYNWNQHKJŽHxL­PmHKn&RSVOPmVYNWNmHK[QJŽVTM[QH-PQ`MLOP
n_µ enT5VOP'eATfYVblfH§Pm`5H¯J5`5VT5VYbAVYceA^KLOb?[Q]_[hPmHUR µ NQHKJŽHxL­PmHKn,XFVVOPPmLYJ5J5eAT5c*Á'n_eAn(T5VYPÊeATPmHUNQXFHUNmH
°Mr_P\Pm`5eA[jPmLY[Q«§n5eAnSeAT*PQHUNQXFHUNmHWL­P\PQ`5HI[mLORSH<bAHUfHUbML[?LONQPQe^©r5bL­PmVYNm]Ê[Qr5J5J5NmHK[m[ŒeAVYTpeATL^©VYT*PmNQVb
feA[QrMLYbŽ[QHKLONa^a`§PmLY[Q«¬w[QV'VYTMHI^ULYT5T5VOP\LYNQcr5H›PQ`ŽL­P?Pm`5µ HIeAT*PQHUNQXFHUNmHUTŽ^©H<ª›LY[?[QelRSJ5bA]¯L-R¯L­PŒPmHUNkVOX
n_el͕HKNQHKT*PQeLObŽPmLY[Q«Sn_)e (^Ur5bgPh]5Á©*¶ Ïel]*LO«YHšLOTMn Ú VOPQV eATJ5NmHUJMLYNmLOPQeAVYTŽÁœeAT*PQHKNQJ5NmH©P\PQ`5e[\JŽL­PŒPmHUNmT
VOXqNQHx[ŒrMbgPa[LY[[Q`5V­ª<elTMc+Pm`ML­PPm`5H¯J5`5VT5VYbAVYceA^KLOb8blVVYJ[Qr5J5J•VYNQPm[vPQ`MH¯°5elTŽn_elTMcVOXq[ŒPQeARÊrMblrM[
XFHKLOPQr5NmHK[ µ HY¶ cM¶Aw5JMLYNŒPmeA^UelJMLYT*Pm[qNQHKJŽHxL­PmHKn_bA]3[mL²]SPQVSPm`5HUR¯[QHUbAfYHK[SçQNQHxn §w5cYNmHUHKT p¶l¶A¶ èMw5ª<`5e^a`
e[Ê[Qr5J5J•VYNQPQHKn(°]n_HU°5NmeAH©ÎMT5cNmHUJ•VYNQPm[aÁ‘wœLOTŽn(PQ`MLOP'PQ`5H+rM[ŒH+VOXqPQ`5e['J5`MVYT5VblVcYe^ULOb?[Q]_[hPmHUR
XFVYN&r5TMNQHKbALOPQHKnÃelT5XFVYNmRSLOPQeAVYTÇn_r5NmelT5c LONQPQe^©rMbALOPQVYNm] [Œr5JMJ5NQHx[Q[QeAVYTÃbAHKLn5[3PQVPQ`5HV°M[ŒHKNQfHKn
J•HUNQXFVYNmRSLYTM^©Hn_HUΎ^©elPm[K¶
›`5e[-XFVYNmRVYX<J5`5VYTMVYbAVYcYe^ULYbœ°5elTŽn_elTMcÄ^ULYT,°•H+^©VT*PQNaLY[ŒPQHKn,ª<elPQ`´VOPm`5HUN'XFVYNmRS['VOX›°5elTŽn_elTMc
PQ`ŽL­P<^ULOT+°ŽHvrM[QHKn¯eAT+VYPQ`5HKNk[QegPmrML­PmelVTM[kLYTMn+[Qr5°M[Qµ HUNmfYHxnS°]pVYPQ`5HKNk°MNmLYelT+LYNQHxLY[j°•HK[Qen_HK[kPQ`MH
J5NmH©XFNmVYT*PmLYb5^©VNŒPmH©®¨¶jy <HKelbAbl]woqrM[Q°]YwYLYTMn Ú VOPmV eAT¯J5NmHK[m[mÁ8en_HUT*PmegXF]§PhªkVVYPQ`5HKN?eARpJ•VYNQPmLYT*P
°5eATMn_eAT5cvRpHx^a`MLOTMeA[QR¯[8LYTMnPm`5HUeANœT5HUrMNmLYb[Qr5°M[ŒPQNaL­PmHK[7elTpLYn5n5egPmelVT'PQVvPm`5HkJM`5VYT5VblVcYe^ULYbYbAV*VJ
RSHK^a`MLYT5e[ŒR+
» /­¾Ò»½ 9§Â›`5e[-eA[ª<`MHUNmHpHxLY^a`(T5HUrMNmLYb8rMT5egP
,.- º ·¾D¿mÀO¼q¿aºxÀ 'Œ¿a0º /1'/Ä¿aºO» 2$_»•¿ ·4¾ 3576©¾Ò8
^©V_n_Hx[elTL&cYNaLYn_HxnÄXDL[Œ`MelVT,XFVN§L&bLONmcYH¯Tr5R§°ŽHKNÊVOX<NmHUbL­PmelfHUbA]ÏblV­ª›³‰VYNan_HKN'^©VYT5³
: r5TM^©PQeAVYTM[Kw_LOTMn¯R¯LYT*]¯[QrM^a`r5TMegPa[qLYNQHšrM[QHKnSPmVÊNmHUJ5NmHK[QHUT*PqLYT]§celfHUTeAT5J5r_P µ H¶ c޶lw
¦eA^a«HUbAcYNmHUT”w˜ßK}Yà}5á ÏHUb7ãÜ8e[ŒHKNKw¬ÝO||Y|5áŽy <HKelbAbl]ãæoqrM[Q°*]w•ÝY|Y|ÝÁ‘¶<›`5e[<XFVNQR
VOX˜°MelTMn5elT5cpPaLO«YHx[qJ5bAL^©Hvª<egPm`5eAT+Pm`5H-°MLY[QeA^šNmHUJ5NmHK[QHUT*PmLOPQeAVYTM[keAT+Pm`5H-T5H©PhªqVYNm«pPQ`MLOP
LONmHš[Q`MLOJ•HKn3°]¯cYNaLYn_rŽLOb•blHxLONmT5elTMc§J5NmV_^©Hx[Q[QHK[qLOTMn+J5NmV­f*en_Hx[kL§blVT5cO³‰bLY[ŒPQeAT5c µ T5VYT_³
PQNaLOTM[QeAHUT*PaÁšXFVNQR VOX<°5eATMn_eAT5cM¶&ÞÌTÉ[Q`5VYNQPKw7PQ`MHK[QH«elTMnM[VOXWn_e[hPmNQeA°5r_PmHKn´NmHUJMNQHx[ŒHKT_³
PmLOPQeAVYTM['L²fVYenPm`5H°5eATMn_eAT5cJ5NmVY°5bAHUR elTPm`5HSÎMNa[hP'JMbAL^©H¯°]ÄHKTM[ŒrMNQeAT5cÆPQ`MLOPÊNmHUbl³
HUf­LOT*P§^UVYT : rMTM^‘PmelVTM[ÊLYNQH¯HKTM^©V_n_Hxn¨w7eATM[ŒPQHxLYµ nVOX<NmHUJ5NmHK[QHUT*PmelT5cÏn5egͬHUNmHUT*P'XFHxL­PQrMNQHx[
rM[QelT5c&HKTPmelNmHUbA]Ï[QHUJMLYNmLOPQHYw¨bAV_^ULYble[hP-r5T5elPm[ ª<`5e^a`,e[-ª<`MLOP-celfHK[vNmeA[QHÊPmV&°5elTŽn_elTMc
J5NmVY°5bAHUR¯[<eAT&PQ`5HÊÎMNa[hPIJMbAL^©HxÁ©¶<åWV­ªqHUfYHKNKwPm`5e[<XFVYNmRÛVOXj°5eATMn_eAT5c+^ULYT5T5VYPINmLYJ5en_bl]
HUTM^UV_n_H§TMV­fYHUbœ°5eATMn_eAT5c*[šNmHK±*r5eANmHKnXFVN[ŒJ•HK^UegΎ^§PaLY[Q«[WÈ PQ`MHpJM`5VYT5VblVcYe^ULYb˜bAV*VJ
RSHK^a`MLYT5eA[QRä^ULYT'Pm`*rŽ[j^©VYRSJ5bAHURSHKTP8PQ`MHq°ŽLY[QeA^q^©VNŒPmeA^KLOb*RpHx^a`MLOTMeA[QR.°]J5NQV­fen_eAT5c
ËMH©®_eA°5bAHYw_PmNmLYTM[ŒeAHUT*P<°5eATMn_eAT5c[›VTÆLYTLYn³‰`5V_^v°MLY[QeA[K¶
¼ ̸•>¾ U?º /O¾D¿¿aº­» 2$_»¬¿ ·4¾ 3@6U¾Ò&» /O¾Ò»*A½ 9ÄLOT]PQ`MHUVYNmeAHK[vVOX›`5eAJ5JŽV_^KLORSJMLOb
,<; ¾ ¸¸5ºx¿aÀ I¸5ÀO=
XFr5TM^©PQeAVYT^©VT*fHUNmcYHWVT+Pm`5Hen_HKLÊPQ`MLOPWegP<°5eATMn5[<PQVYcH©Pm`5HUN›eATMn_eAf*en_rMLYb¨HUbAHURSHUT*Pa[›VOX
LOT¯HU®J•HUNmeAHUTM^UH<elT*PQV§Lr5T5elPmLYNQ]§NQHKJ5NQHx[ŒHKT*PmL­PmelVT”wOª<`5e^a`^ULYTSXFVYNkH©®5LORSJ5bAH<°ŽHšbALOPQHKN
NQHx^ULYblbAHKnXFNQVRÐJMLONQPQeLOb”^Ur5HK[ µ [ŒHKH§y WHUeAblbA]+B
ã WrMn_]Yw•ÝO|Y|MßWXFVNWL§NmHUfeAHUªIÁ©¶œÂ›`MHK[QH
`5eAJ5JŽV_^KLORSJMLObW^UVYT : rMTM^‘PmelfHÆNmHUJMNQHx[ŒHKTPaL­PmelVTM[§LYNQHÆ`5eAcY`5HKNŒ³‰VYNan_HKNpLYTMnRSVNQH&[ŒJ•H©³
©^µ elΎ^IPQ`MLYTPQ`MHšbAV­ªkHKNŒ³‰VYNan_HKN\^©V*LONa[ŒHU³‰^UVn5HKnS^©VNŒPmeA^KLOb¬^©VYT : r5TM^‘PmelfHšNmHUJMNQHx[ŒHKTPaL­PmelVTM[
e·¶ H¶lw•Lp`5elJMJŽV_^ULYRSJMLOb˜^UVYT : rMTM^‘PmelVTÆHKTM^©V_n_Hx[›PQ`MHÊ^©VRʰ5eATML­PmelVT3VYX8R¯LYT*]XFHKL­Pmr5NmH
HUbAHURSHUT*Pa[Uwœª<`5eAblH3LÏ^©VNŒPmeA^KLOb?^©VT : r5TM^©PQeAVYTÉHKTM^©V_n_Hx[NmHUbL­PQeAfYHKbl]ÄXFHUªIÁ©¶Ï›`*rŽ[Uw8PQ`MH
`5eAJ5JŽV_^KLORSJ5rM[q^ULYT¯°ŽHv[ŒHKHUTLY[kLÊ[QJŽHx^©eLObAelÑKHKn¯[Q]_[hPmHUR XFVYNkn5VYeAT5c'bAVYT5cY³:PmHUNmR °5eATMn³
elTMcÄVOXI[QJ•HK^©elΎ^3HUJ5e[QVn5HK[Kwœ^UVYRSJ5bAHURSHUT*PmelT5cÄPQ`5HÆRSVYNmHcYHKT5HUNaLObAeAÑUHKn´^UVYT : rMTM^‘PmelfH
°5eATMn_eAT5c3J•HUNQXFVYNmRSHKnİ*]ÆPm`5H¯^©VYNQPQHU®¨¶vÞÌRSJ•VYNQPmLYTPmbl]w•PQ`5Hp`5eAJ5JŽV_^KLORSJ5rM[^KLOTÄLYbA[QV
HUTM^UV_n_H<PQ`MHK[QHI^©VT : r5TM^©PQeAVYTM[\NmLYJ5eAn5bl]wLOTŽnpPQ`5HKNQHUXFVYNmH<egP›[Œ`MLYNQHx[?[QVYRSH<VOX¬PQ`MHš[mLORSH
XFr5TM^©PQeAVYTMLYblelPh]L[SPQ`5HJM`5VYT5VblVcYe^ULYbqbAVVYJ RSHK^a`MLYT5e[ŒR µ e·¶ H¶lw›NaLOJ5en_bA]ÉHUTM^UV_n_elTMc
LONm°5elPQNaLONm]Æ^UVYT : r5TŽ^‘PQeAVYTŽ[-NQHx±rMelNmHKn&XFVNvPmLY[Q«_[mÁ©¶§Â›`rM[Kw¨egPe[vbleA«YHKbl]&Pm`ML­P-PQ`MHp`MelJ_³
JŽV_^KLORSJ5rM[qLOTMnPQ`5HvJ5NmH©XFNmVYT*PmLYbg³‰RSHKn_eL­PmHKnSªqVYNm«elT5cÊRpHKRSVYNm]S[Q]_[hPmHUR µ elTM^UblrŽn_elTMc
PQ`5HSJ5`MVYT5VblVcYe^ULOb7blVVJŽÁILYNQHpJMLYNŒPmeALYblbA]&NQHxn_r5TMn5LYT*Pvª<elPQ`(HKL^a`ÄVOPm`5HUNxw¨LOTMn,ªqVYNm«
PQVcYH©Pm`5HUN<eATÆRSLYT]¯PmL[Œ«_[ µ ikV`5HUTãæy <HKelbAbA]Yw”ßx}Y}Yà*Á‘¶
¤ (Ö?£_
¢ Ф Õ × ¤j¡*¤ ¤ Õ QÙh¤äÙ £a£5Ö Õ ¢_
Õ Ö\£ <Ù Õ Ö?
£ yšr5NœRSV_n_HUb5VYXMPm`5H›J5`5VYTMVYbAVYcYe^ULYbblVVYJÊPmLY«YHK[œLn_f­LOT*PmLYcYHqVOXŽNmHK^UHUT*PjªkVNQ«[Q`5V­ª<eAT5cš`MV­ªÉPQ`MH
J5NmH©XFNmVYT*PmLYb*^UVYNQPQHU®LYTMn'°ŽLY[mLOb*cLOTMcYbAeALW^KLOT§elT*PQHKNmL^‘P7PQV-[Œr5JMJŽVNŒPjLY^©PQeAf²LOPQeAVYT_³‰°ML[ŒHxnªkVNQ«eAT5c
RSHURSVYNm] µ Ü5NaLOT5«§H©P\LOb·¶AwÝO||5ßxÁ©¶7›`5HW^UNQelPQe^ULYb5J5NmelTŽ^©eAJ5blHx[œ°ŽHK`5eATMnpPQ`5e[?ªqVYNm«'LONmHWLY[8XFVblbAV­ªW?[ +
, Z?NmH©XFNmVYT*PmLYbj^©VYNQPQHU® µ Z\Ü8i›Áve[Ê[QJ•HK^©eLObAeAÑUHKn(NmHUbL­PmelfH§PmV&PQ`5H+JŽV*[hPmHUNmelVN'^©VYNQPQHU®ÄXFVN
Q1º 6$ qÀO&
» /mÀm¸•¾ /_¼ $x¸ /YÀ Ì1À 6U¼ WRSLYelT*PmHUTMLYTM^©H-VOX8elT5XFVYNmRSLOPQeAVYT3elTLOT&LY^©PQeAfYH-[hPaL­PmH
µ e·¶ H¶lwœfeLJŽHKNm[Qe[hPmHUT*P'ÎMNmelTMcÏVOX<T5HKr5NQVTM[aÁ‘¶Â›`rM[UwjZkÜ8i ^ULYTɱrMeA^a«bA]Är5J¬n5L­PmHPmV
R¯LOeATPaLOeATT5HUªeAT_XFVYNmR¯L­PmelVT µ elTÏPQ`5e[š^KLY[QHYw_Pm`5HÊVT5H'HU®J•V[Qr5NmH-PQV+L¯[QHK±*r5HKTM^©HÊVOX
J5`5VT5HURSHK[aÁ‘w˜ª<`5elbAH¯°•HUeAT5cLO°5bAHpPQVLOb[ŒVÆJ5µ NmVOPmHK^‘PR¯LOeAT*PmLYelT5HxnÄeAT_XFVNQR¯L­PmelVTÏXFNmVYR
elT*PmHUNQXFHUNmHUTM^UHWXFNmVYRæVYT5cVYeAT5cÊJMNQV_^©Hx[Q[QeAT5c [QHUH'y <HUeAblbA]YwoqNmL²fHUNxwã{ikV`5HUT”w¬ßx}Y}Y}Má
ikVY`5HKT”w­oqNmL²fHUNxwxã y <HKelbAbl]w_ßK}}Yà55á eAblbAHUN?ãÇikVY`5HKT”wYÝO||5ß?XFVNœHUbLO°•VYNaL­PQeAVYTŽ[7LYTMn
NQHKfelHKªW[kVYX8NmHUbAHUf­LYTPWn5LOPmL*Á‘¶
, <VY°MrM[hPR¯LOeAT*PQHKTMLOTM^UHpLYTMnÏNaLOJMeAnÄr5J•nML­PQeAT5cLONmHpelT,XFr5TMn5LYRSHUT*PmLYb?^©VYT5ËMeA^©PKw”LYTMn
NQHx±*r5elNmH&L /­»•À §¾D¿3½µ À :¾Ò»#½ m¿a¹5ÀO»M>¾ Pm`ML­P^KLOT [Œª<elPm^a`ێHUPhªkHKHUTPQ`5Hx[ŒHÆPhªqV
RSVn5HK[›VOXœVYJ•HUNaL­PmelVT y <HKelbAbA]+H©PILYb:¶Aw¨ßK}}Y}Má5ikV`5HUTÆH©PILYb:¶Aw”ßx}Y}Yà*Á‘¶
, ›`5HưMLY[mLObqcLYT5cYbAeAL µ o<âÁÊ^KLOTJ5NQV­fen_HPm`5e[pn5]*TŽLORSeA^+cLOPQeAT5cÄRSHK^a`ŽLOT5e[ŒR feL
RSVn5r5bALOPQVNQ]wWn_eA[QeAT5`5eA°5egPmVYNm]^©VYTMT5HK^©PQeAf*elPh]Ū<egPm`PQ`5HZ\ܜiš¶kÜMr5NŒPm`5HUNmRSVYNmHYw›Pm`5eA[
o<⚳·°ML[ŒHxnc*L­PQeAT5cRpHx^a`MLOTMeA[QR J5NmV­feAn_Hx[ U¼ a¿ ·4¾ 3x4¾ ­w[QrM^a`ÃPm`ML­PÏ[QHUJMLYNmLOPQH,NQHU³
cYeAVYTM[+VOX'Pm`5HZ\Ü8iÛ^KLOT°•H(elTMn5HUJ•HUTMn_HKT*PQbA]r5J•nML­PQHxnVNÆLYblbAV­ªkHxnÅPQVÅJŽHKNŒXFVNQR
NQV°5rM[ŒP'R¯LOeATPmHUTMLYTM^©H¶ J•V[m[ŒeA°5bAHLOTMLOPQVYRSe^ULYb?[Œr5°Ž[hPmNmLOPQHSXFVYN-Pm`5HK[QH+[QHUJMLYNmLY°5bA]
r5J¬n5L­PaLO°5bAHIZ\ܜi´NmHUcelVTMµ [jLONmH›PQ`MH ‘¾ ¸ ?[ŒPQNmrM^‘Pmr5NmHK[jen_HUT*PmegÎMHxnS°] ”HKfegPQPKw ˜HUª<e[Uw
?V[Q`5eAVY«­L5w5LYTM@
n ˜r5TMn ßx}Y} s Á‘¶
, ^©PQeAfYHWR¯LOeAT*PQHKTMLOTM^UHWeATSPQ`5HvZ\Ü8iÉe[\eARSJ5blHKRSHUT*PQHxnSf*eL'L'^UVYR§°5elTŽL­PQeAVYTSVYX¬NmHK^Ur5NQ³
NQHKT*P?H©®5^©elPmLOPQVYNm]'^©VT5T5Hx^‘PQeAVYTŽ[?LOTMnpeAT*PQNaLY^©HKblbAr5bLONœH©®5^UegPaL­PQVNQ]ÊelVT5eA^<^UVYTMn5rM^‘PaLOTM^UHK[K¶
›`5e[ÊLObAbAV­ªW[vPQ`5HÆZ\Ü8iär5T5elPm[ÊPQVcHUT5HKNmLYblbA]ÄNmH©ËŽHK^‘PPm`5H3^Ur5NmNQHKTP'eAT5J5r5Pm[Kw8HU®5^©HUJ5P
ª<`5HUTPm`5HK[QH+rMT5egPa['`ML²fHSPQ`5HKelNpeATPmNmL^©HKblbAr5bLONR¯LOeAT*PQHUTŽLOTM^UH+^©r5NmNmHUT*Pm['L^‘Pmelf­L­PmHKn¨w
ª<`5e^a`+µ ^ULYrM[ŒHx[œPQ`MHURæPQVÊNQHUËMHK^©PkJ5NmHUfeAVYrM[Qbl]§R¯LOeATPaLOeAT5HKnelT_XFVNQR¯LOPQeAVYT”¶ Ú HUHvÜ5NaLOT5«
H©PILYb:¶ ÝO|Y|MßxÁ?XFVYN<RSVYNmHn_H©PaLOeAbA[WVYT3PQ`5HeARSJŽVNŒPaLOTM^UHvVYX7Pm`5e[›RpHx^a`MLOTMeA[QR&¶
Ö ŒÖ ٌ¥¬¤ '֛"Ö ! Ö<#× Ö Õ Â›`5HÄLY°ŽV­fH&RpHx^a`MLOTMeA[QR¯[¯RSVOPQeAf­L­PmHKnÅVYr5N+RpV_n_HKbleAT5c´VYXvPm`5HÏJ5`MVYT5VblVcYe^ULOb›bAVVYJLY[pXFVbg³
bAV­ªW[ µ [QHUH+Ü8eAcYr5NmHßxÁ©¶Ü7eANa[hPxw8[QHUJMLYNmLOPQHZkÜ8i{[hPmNQeAJŽHx[ÊLYNQH¯rM[QHKn(PmVÏHUTŽ^©V_n_HHxLY^a`´[hPmHUJ´eAT
PQ`MHÆ[QHK±*r5HKTM^©H¶(›`rM[Kwj°5eATMn_eAT5cÄVYXIJ5`5VT5HURSH+en_HKTPmegPh]´LYTMn[QHK±*r5HKTPmeALYb\VNmn_HKNÊV_^U^Ur5Na[ÊeAT
PQ`MeA[IRpV_n_HKb˜°]ÆrM[ŒeAT5cn_e[ŒPQeATM^‘PvT5HUr5NaLOb7[Œr5°Ž[hPmNmLOPQHK[qPmVNmHUJ5NmHK[QHUT*P<PQ`MHÊ[ŒHx±*r5HUT*PQeLOb˜elT_XFVNQR¯LO³
PQeAVYT˜¶Ê›`5e[še[vHUT*PQeANmHUbA]&XFHKLY[QeA°5blHp°•HK^ULYrM[QH§HxLY^a`Ä[ŒPQNmelJ•H¯^ULYTÄNmHUJ5NmHK[QHUT*PvLYblbœVYX?PQ`5HpJ•V[m[ŒeA°5bAH
J5`5VT5HURSHx[UwOcelfHUTÊPQ`MLOP8Pm`5HU]ÊNQHKJ5NQHx[ŒHKT*P8Lv^©bAV[QHKnÊ^UbAL[Q[8VYXŽelPQHUR¯[K¶ Ú HK^©VTMn¨w­Pm`5H<[hPmVYNaLOcH\VOX•L
Hidden
Time
Context
Output
8Ü elcr5NmH'ß1+ ‹*~~x‚ƒ~KƒŠ‘K‚5‚ƒ~­~x‡~O€a‚ҍ•€§Y
5€mh€œ*‡’7ˆ‰„_~x‚ƒˆ8Uh€\‡_~xˆÌˆÌ*‚ƒ€<œ€‘UŠQ‹h€
ˆ­h„p€a‡‡YhҀa~ˆÌ*€€qh’*?h~K‹’€'?!~*‡h’€ShU~Šxh€hx‹€mh)€‘§(?h‹*h‹h‹€ €<!ˆÌ€+‡*&­’’*œ€‚gah„­g€mK#‚Ž"Q‚g%~­$Ša,hˆÌƒ€~&O’€**Šmh€›‹*€'ƒˆ\œ€*Ša~O€WY€‘*§‡*’p?~‚g‘*„²€›€m)‡*KA~KˆÌˆ
€‘­U„ ŠQ‹+3, ˆšh€a ‡ˆÌ-Šmhhƒ‹‡ €ššˆÌŠa€+~O&­’€ €"W*’*Ša€KˆÌ€a''ˆ œh‹*‹*€š4€ ˆÌh. š’*€‚g, *h€a‡/’ '*Kh*~ˆhÛhx x€Qx-‚ƒg0 ̲ŒKhŠa.€a‚ƒ‚ƒ’*‚g©€m4 ŠQ‹*'K* ƒˆ1h2€ Ò, *Ša‡*€‚ƒ€Šm’̀h€ h€‘h ˆ
5h‹*€Šm~KÌh€aˆÌ‡_~  +ˆ Ìhƒ‡_€-h€ Kƒ~ Ï~ h‹€Ša~ h€ 67 %89 "›‚la„­€Q0 ҈ Ìhƒ‡_€aˆšUh€'ˆÌ‹*+~ (:U;ˆ h‹€
h‹h€m€+ˆÌ€m‡UŒh€Uh~x’‡*ˆp~,I’*hˆ(?h‹*<h‹*€ 9 ~h€67§‚g‘„²€m+=WOg’*K‚qŠm~h€67p’*hˆ§K‚ƒˆÌ~
‹€ KŠaÆ~O, Æ4€ h€ ‹*6Y4€ Ša Œ3, hhˆ ~Uš̄Ɓ ‡*ˆÌ€m’ ‚ +?>DA¬Ša€~ hŠx*/ €aŠ !h4ƒ~ 5€a~Ug@ , h'€a‚…U„3 7, h?€ h€m- € Ša*€ Ša"Q~O Yœ. ‹O’ADˆ hAB‹h4€ ‹€*€ 3*Eh(œˆ ~KWC ˆF3Ìhƒƒ@ˆ ‡_4€h‹*v€ 5’ˆ Ì<ŒK‚ƒ€‘ *U€aC 5hh~~
‡Ihh‹*~O€?Y’*UŠŠah€G xh ‹h€-ƒ~ Ša-~Ü hŒ€a ŠhI€\ˆÌ~x‹’+~ h(:‡*’-Wƒˆ Æh‹h€ €mˆÌ*‡_€ ~E*(œˆÌ~K€GC FWh~Ša~Uh̋*h€G€aŠ hh‚…„v€-h€mŠ‘*K‡‚ƒ‚ƒ’ +AHJ(?h‹*hK€ ‹h~x‹’ƒvŒI,­h„€ E*. ‡-’qWˆÌU+€ Š&­h’*x€ hŠag€~"Q 
‡*œ‹*‹*K€\ˆÌ€x‹*MgNq€€ '€m‚gŒaK„­‚ƒ€mO‘K šhg~’**ˆ hh€a‹*ˆ€mhh#€ ~Kh7€k²‚ƒ~x€‘‚U²C €a4Êh‡Y~šh€aˆÌ€a€Ša~OhYL€-h‹’€k7ŠmÌ~ŒUh*€ €‘67Ê7ˆÌh€+€m‡&­’*h€a€ˆÌ€ Ša€aŒˆa  hg~ *Mˆ A~KK h‹ƒˆ8h€aŠ‘U‚g‚
Input
T5HKªÅ[QHK±*r5HKTM^©H<eATfYVYbAfYHx[7PQ`5HW°ŽLY[mLOb_cLYT5cYbAeLIc*L­PQeAT5c-RSHK^a`MLYT5e[ŒR{PQNmelccYHUNmeAT5cšrMJ•n5LOPQHx[?VOX•PQ`MH
n_el͕HKNQHKT*P›ZkÜ8iÅ[ŒPQNmelJ•HK[kelT+PQ`5H-LOJMJ5NQVJ5NmeALOPQHWVNmn_HKNK¶7¦,H-LY[m[Qr5RSHWPQ`MeA[›^ULYT°•HšbAHKLYNQT5Hxn¯V­fYHKN
H©®_J•HUNmelHKTM^©Hw”LOTMn,ªqHpLYNQHS^©r5NmNmHUT*PQbA]&ªkVNQ«eAT5c+VT(n_HKfYHKblVJ5elTMc+J•V­ªkHKNŒXFr5bœbAHKLYNQT5eAT5cÆRSHK^a`MLO³
T5e[ŒR¯[-XFVN'LYn5LYJ_PQeAT5cÆPQ`MH¯°MLY[mLObjc*LOT5cbleL+c*L­PmelT5c&RSHK^a`ŽLOT5e[ŒRelT(PQ`MeA[ª›L²]Y¶¯Â›`5e[«eATMn(VOX
cLOPQeAT5c-^©VYT*PmNQVb*ªqVYrMbAnpLOb[ŒV-bAel«HUbA]NQHx±*r5elNmH<[ŒVRSHk«eATMnpVOXMPmHURSJ•VYNaLOQb P­[QHK±*r5HUT*PmeALYb*eAT5J5r5PjPQ`MLOP
eATMn_e^UL­PmHK[8Pm`5H<blV_^KL­PQeAVYTpª<elPQ`5eATSPQ`5HW[QHK±*r5HKTM^©HkÈ [QrM^a`SelT5XFVYNmRSLOPQeAVYTpRSelc`P?^UVYRSHqXFNQVRäPQ`MH
^©HKNQHK°ŽHKblbAr5R µ HY¶ cM¶Aw_ÞÌfNQ]w¨ßK}}YàÁ©¶
ÞÌT+Ln_f­LOTM^UHIVOX”`ŽL²f*eAT5cÊn5HUfYHKblVJŽHxnSNQHxLObAeA[ŒPQe^WLYTMn^©VRSJ5r_PmLOPQeAVYTMLYblbA]pJŽV­ªqHUNQXFr5b•RpHx^a`MLOTMeA[QR¯[
XFVYN¯°•VOPm`ÅPQ`5HbAHKLYNQT5eAT5cLOTMnPQ`MH&PQHURSJ•VYNaLOQb P­[QHK±*r5HKTPmeALYb<^©VYT*PmNQVb›L[ŒJ•HK^©Pm[SVYXIPQ`MHRpV_n_HKb:w
ªqHÏ[ŒeARSJ5bl]ÅeARpJMblHKRpHKT*PQHKnÅPm`5HK[QH°]ΕL­PeAT PQ`5HÄ[QeARÊr5bL­PmVYNx¶ÃÜ5VN¯PQ`5HÏPQHURSJ•VYNaLObI[QeAcYTMLYb
eATMn_e^UL­PmelTMc+bAV^KL­PmelVTª<egPm`5elTÄPQ`5Hp[ŒHx±*r5HUTM^UHYw•ªkHp[ŒeARSJ5bA]&L^‘Pmelf­L­PmHKnL3n_egͬHUNmHUT*PvelTMn5elfen_rMLOb
PQeARSH§rMT5egP-XFVNšHxLY^a`ÏJ•VYeAT*PšeATÏPQ`MHp[QHK±*r5HKTM^©H µ Pm`5Hp›eARSH§eAT5J5r5PvbL²]YHKNIeAT,Ü8elcr5NmH+ßxÁ©¶Â›`5eA[
[QelcTMLObŽªqL[jPQ`MHUT+rŽ[ŒHxn¯°]pL§[ŒeARÊr5bL­PmHKn¯c*L­PmelT5cÊRpHx^a`MLOTMeA[QR µ elRSJ5bAHURSHKTPmHKn+elTÆ[Q^UNQeAJ_Pk^UVn5H
eAT¯PQ`5Hš[ŒeARÊr5bL­PmVYN‘Á8PQVÊr5J•nML­PQHIPQ`5Hv^©VNQNmHK[QJŽVTMn_eAT5c[hPmNQeAJ•HWelT+J5NQHUXFNQVT*PmLObŽ^©VYNQPQHU®¨¶ bgPm`5VYr5c`
PQ`MHÊNmHK[Qr5bgPmelTMcRSVn5HUb˜ª›LY[WPQ`5HKNQHUXFVYNmHÊ[QelRSJ5bAegΎHKn¨w•egPvT5HUfHUNQPQ`5HKblHx[Q[I[hPmelbAb7`ŽLYnL^a`MLYblbAHUTMcYeAT5c
bAHKLONmT5eAT5c(PmL[Œ«PQVÉJ•HUNQXFVYNmR&¶ Ú J•HK^UegΎ^KLObAbl]wqPQ`5HÄ[ŒPQNmeAJŽHÄ^UVYT*PQHU®PbAL²]HUNa[S`MLYnPQV´bAHKLYNQTÅPmV
HUTŽ^©V_n_HšLYTMn¯R¯LOeAT*PmLYelT¯Pm`5H-^©r5NmNQHKT*P\elTMJ5r_P<f­LObAr5HIJ5NmVYJ•HUNmbA]YwLOTMnSPm`5HšåIeAnMn_HUT3bAL²]HUN\`ŽLYnSPmV
°•HqLY°5blH\PQVvn_HK^UVn5H\Pm`5Hk^UVYT*PQHU®*P8bAL²]HUN7elT_XFVNQR¯LOPQeAVYTÊL[7LWXFr5TM^‘PmelVTÊVYX_PQ`5HkPQeARSHkeAT5J5r_Pœf­LObAr5HY¶
›µ `5HšRpV_n_HKb¬ªqL[?eARpJMblHKRpHKT*PQHKn+rM[QelT5cÊPQ`5H ”HxLO°5NaL'LYblcVYNmegPm`5R ª<elPQ`3[hPaLOTMn5LYNmnJMLONaLORSH©PmHUNa[
y <HKelbAbl]w”ßK}}YzMá5y <HKelbAbl]3B
ã r5TŽLO«­L­PaL5wMÝO||Y|*Á‘¶
Phonological Loop Generalization
Generalization Error
0.3
0.2
0.1
0.0
100
200
300
800
Number of Training Events
Ü8elcr5NmH-Ý + qN €* €mŒU‚ƒ.aO ,h ƒ~S h€aˆÌ’‚h ˆK ~K:h ‹€q‡*‹~ ~x‚ƒ~KgŠaK‚•‚ƒ~­~K‡*~O€a‚5Uˆ?;A’*Š#hg~p~,DO’_€Q
ÌŒK.S‡1h€mC*ˆa*Nq€€mŒK‚ƒO‘,hƒ~gˆI~²€m Ša~KÌh€mŠ@(?h‹5ÌŒU*S~&‚ƒ€aˆÌˆ'h‹ ~,
h‹*€q‡_~xˆÌˆÌ* ‚ƒ€W* ‡*’?
‡1h €mC* ˆa
O
= B*™Ê“­25CD48CD4
›`5HTMH©PhªqVYNm«Äª›LY[-PmNmLYelT5Hxn´LY[-XFVblbAV­ªW[K¶ Ú HK±*r5HUTŽ^©HK[ µ VYX›bAHUTMcOPQ` s XFVYN'Vr5NÊeAT5elPQeLOb\ªqVYNm«5Á
ªqHUNmHWJ5NmHK[QHUT*PQHxnS°*]¯[QHK±*r5HKTPmeALYblbA]SLY^‘Pmelf­LOPQeAT5c§LYTelTMJ5r_PSçŒJ5`5VT5HURSHxè'LOTMn¯L§^©VNQNmHK[QJŽVTMn_eAT5c
[QHK±*r5HUT*PmeALYbIbAV^KL­PmelVTelTMJ5r_P µ elTÃPQ`5H(›elRSH(elTMJ5r_P3bL²]YHKNaÁ©¶ä¦(HÄVYTMbl] rM[QHKn.ßx|Én_el͕HKNQHKT*P
J5`5VT5HURSHx[Uw­HxLY^a`'VYXMª<`5e^a`'ªqL[˜HKTM^©V_n_Hxn'bAV_^ULObAbA]vª<elPQ`pLšn5egͬHUNmHUT*Pœr5T5elP8eAT'Pm`5HkÞÌTMJ5r_PjbAL²]HUNx¶
Ü5VN›H©®5LORSJ5bAHYwPm`5H-T5H©PhªqVYNm«¯^©VYrMbAn3cYHUP›Â›eARSH ä|5wÞÌT5J5r5P .Ý_wPm`5HUT&›elRSH ßw_ÞÌT5J5r_P !w¬Pm`5HUT´Â›eARS"
H Ý_w¨ÞÌT5J5r5P s PmV3HKTM^©V_n_HpPm`5H¯[ŒHx±rMHUTM^UHSÝ5#w !_w s ¶ÊGIrMNQeAT5c3PQ`5e[-HUTM^UV_n_elTMc
J5`ML[ŒHw5Pm`5H'T5HUPhªkVNQ«3ªqL[›PQNaLOeAT5HKn3PmV+LY^©PQeAf²LOPQHPm`5HÊ^Ur5NQNmHUT*PWÞÌT5JMr_PšVT&PQ`5Hpyšr5PQJ5r_PvbAL²]HUNxw
LOTŽn(PQ`5H+[QeARÊr5bL­PmHKn(cLOPQeAT5c&XFr5TM^©PQeAVYT[QelRSJ5bA]LY^‘Pmelf­LOPQHKn,Pm`5HeATPmNmL^©HKblbAr5bLON'R¯LOeAT*PQHKTMLOTM^UH
^©rMNQNmHUT*Pm[IXFVYNvPm`5HSr5T5elPm[-eATÏPQ`MHS[ŒPQNmeAJŽHSeATÏPQ`MHikVT*PQH©®P µ ZkÜ8i›ÁIbAL²]HUNšPQ`MLOP^UVYNmNQHx[ŒJ•VYTŽn_HKn
PQV+PQ`5Hp›elRSH§elT5JMr_P µ e:¶ HY¶Aw¨[hPmNQeAJŽHp|¯XFVNšÂ›eARp$H v|5w•H©Pa^KÁ‘¶šÂ›`5HUT”w•Pm`5HÊT5HUPhªkVNQ«Æª›LY[›PmNmLYelT5Hxn
PQV,NQHx^ULYblb\PQ`5e[§[QHK±*r5HKTM^©Hw?n_r5NmelTMcϪ<`5e^a`´PQeARSH3T5VÄÞÌT5J5r_P¯LY^©PQeAf²LOPQeAVYTɪ›LY[ÊJ5NmHK[QHUT*PK¶Ä›`MH
T5HUPhªkVNQ«ÆNQHx^©HKelfHKn3PQ`5HS[QHK±*r5HUTŽ^©H'VYX\›elRSHpelT5JMr_Pm[ µ |Mwlßw ÝÁ‘w¬LOTMnª›LY[WPQNaLOeAT5HKnPQVJ5NmV_n_rM^UH
PQ`MHÊ^©VNQNmHK[QJŽVTMn_eAT5cyšr_PQJ5r5PWXFVYN<Pm`ML­PšblV_^ULOPQeAVYT&eAT3Pm`5HÊ[QHK±*r5HKTM^©H µ HY¶ cM¶Aw•Ý_%w !w s Á©¶\›`5HÊZkÜ8i
^©VT*PQH©®P›bAL²]HUNa[ : rŽ[hPWR¯LOeAT*PmLYelT5Hxn¯Pm`5HUeANWLY^©PQeAf²LOPQeAVYTÆ[hPaL­PQHx[›°MLY[QHKn+VYT3PQ`5H-eAT*PQNaLY^©HKblbAr5bLONqelVT
^©rMNQNmHUT*Pm[<L^‘Pmelf­L­PmHKnn_rMNQeAT5c¯HUTŽ^©V_n_eAT5c µ LYTMn&NQHx^©r5NmNmHUT*PWLY^‘Pmelf­LOPQeAVYTŽÁ\È VYTM^UH-PQ`5HT5HUPhªkVNQ«
`ML[›°ŽHKHUTÆPQNaLOeAT5HKn”wPQ`5H'L^‘PQeAfYHZkÜ8i[ŒPmLOPQHNmHUJ5NmHK[QHUT*Pa[\Pm`5HHUT*PmelNmH[ŒHx±rMHUTM^UHY¶
'= & (ÆB48)B ²2M9DC *2_™KC:“Ž413,B +-89F™ +
^©NmegPmeA^KLOb”PmHK[ŒPvVYXjPQ`5H§RSVn5HUbœeA[IPQVÆn_H©PmHUNmRSelT5H§ª<`5H©Pm`5HUNvelP-^KLOTJ•HUNQXFVYNmRé[Q]_[hPmHUR¯L­PmeA^KLObAbl]
ª<elPQ`¯T5V­fHUbM[QHK±*r5HKTM^©Hx[8È VYTMbl]pegX¨elPkn_HKRpVTM[ŒPQNaL­PQHx[8PQ`5e[\^KLOJML^©elPh]§^KLOTSegPq[ŒHKNQfH›L[?LRSHK^a`5³
LOTMeA[QRXFVYN›NaLOJ5en_bA]¯°5eATMn_eAT5cLONm°5elPQNaLONm]peAT_XFVNQR¯L­PmelVT µ [ŒrM^a`&LY[kPm`5HvPmLY[Q«+n_HKR¯LOTMn5[<[ŒPQrŽn_elHxn
°<] eA]LY«YHã Ú VOPQVŽw?eATJ5NQHKJMLONaL­PmelVTŽÁ‘¶¦elPQ`.ßx|(elT5JMr_P+J5`5VT5HUµ RSHx[LOTMn [QHK±*r5HKTM^©Hx[SVOX
bAHUT5cYPQ`PQ`MNQHKHYw8PQ`5HKNQH+ªkHKNQHßw ||Y|n_el͕HKNQHKT*P§[ŒHx±*r5HUTM^UHK[ÊJŽV*[Q[Qel°MblH ªkHÆLObAblV­ªqHKn,J5`5VT5HURSHK[
PQVÄNQHKJŽHxL­PaÁ©¶&¦,H¯PmNmLYelTMHKnVYT ßx|Y|5wœÝO||5w s |Y|Mw7LYTMn´zY||3VYX›PQ`5Hx[ŒH+[QHK±*r5HKTM^©Hx[UwœLOTŽn(PQHK[ŒPQHxn
cYHKT5HUNaLObAeAÑKL­PmelVTVYTÉPm`5H+NmHUR¯LYelT5eAT5c([ŒHx±rMHUTM^UHK[K¶(›`5H3cYHKT5HUNaLObAelÑxL­PmelVT´NQHx[Œr5blPm[§LONmH3[Q`5V­ª<T
eATÜ7eAcYrMNQHÄÝ5w<ª<`5eA^a`^UblHxLONmbl][Œ`5V­ªW[¯PQ`MLOPPQ`5H,T5H©PhªqVYNm«ÉbAHKLYNQT5HxnPQ`5Hx[ŒHÄ[QHK±*r5HKTM^©Hx[¯eATL
[Q][ŒPQHKR¯L­PQe^R¯LYT5T5HUNSLOTŽn^©Vr5bnPQNaLOTM[ŒXFHUNpelPm[§PQNaLOeAT5eAT5cÄ«T5V­ª<bAHKn_cHPmVÄT5V­fHUb›[ŒHx±rMHUTM^UHK[K¶
ÞÌT*PQHKNQHx[hPmelT5cbl]wYPm`5HUNmHšLYJ5J•HKLONa[œPmVʰ•HvL'^UNQelPQe^ULYbMPmNmLYTM[QegPmelVT¯°ŽHUPhªkHKHUTÏßx|Y|LOTŽn+ÝO||-PQNaLOeAT5eAT5c
[QHK±*r5HUTŽ^©HK[È ßx|Y|[QHK±*r5HUTŽ^©HK[§^©VNQNmHK[QJŽVTMn5[vPmVÏHKL^a`´egPmHUR ª<egPm`5eATÉHKL^a`[QbAVOPʰ•HUeAT5cÄJMNQHU³
[QHUT*PQHxn+NmVYr5c`5bA]Æßx|§PQeARpHx[Uw_ª<`MeA^a`&LOJ5J•HKLYNm[kPmV§J5NmV­feAn5Hv[Qr (^©eAHUT*PW[hPaL­PmeA[ŒPQe^ULYb¨elT_XFVNQR¯LOPQeAVYT
NmHUcLYNmn5elT5cÊPQ`5HeATMn_HKJŽHKTMn_HKTM^©H'VYX7eATMn_eAfeAn_rŽLOb˜[QblVYPm[K¶
LÁ
°ŽÁ
Hidden
^KÁ
Context
Time
Input
Hidden
Output
Context
Time
Hidden
nMÁ
Context
Time
Input
Hidden
Output
Context
Time
Ü8elcr5NmH s +
‚g a „­"\€mh€ˆ *"QŠa~OY €aˆW›lSÆY€ 
5W"k€Q’ h€*€ ¬Ša<~OhˆÌ€a’‡Y€ahˆ €aˆÌˆÌ€h€‹<€š~Œœ,Šm~hƒh~ €·’:ˆ ˆ<Šxh,UƒJ~‚g’+h€a~ˆ¨j€©h'­€KˆÌ (œ’Ò€aЁˆÌx"k€‹<€h*ˆ¨~,Ša8~OYh*~›€a‡ˆ<\’‹*h©€g~x*’Yˆ<h€‡š~’²’q€m* h h€lh~ˆ›€aˆ , ʏUh‚g‚Y.~h€‹€mYO 
Fp "œh€a‹*Š‘KUˆ ‚ƒ‚•~ ~-¬ˆÌ h€a€ ‚ƒ€aŠ hˆ? O, :·„¯h  *€›hˆ‹h€<€a‡ . O‡* ’ +A *’ k~­€aˆk‡h~
‰€aŠ)h~Gh‹*€<~K’h‡*’kS‚ƒF²€a‚…„p‡U1hƒŠaƒ‡*,h€aˆ
= 472M9FE +xC +¯“•–<1+B ­,B +xB*4¬™x2_™KC:“Ž4 +
Â7V¯r5TMn_HKNm[ŒPmLYTMn&`5V­ª PQ`5H'`MeAn5n5HUTr5T5elPm[šHUTŽ^©V_n_H'LOTŽn&NQHUPQNmelHKfYH-elT5XFVYNmRSLOPQeAVYT&eAT&PQ`5H'R¯LYelT_³
PmLYelTMHKnÏ^UVYT*PQHU®*PšbAL²]HUNWeATÄL[Q]_[hPmHUR¯L­PmeA^-XDL[Œ`MelVT&PQ`MLOPv[Qr5J5J•VYNQPm[<Pm`5HÊcVVn&cHUT5HKNmLYbleAÑKLOPQeAVYT
VY°Ž[ŒHKNQfHKn¨w*ªkHšH©®5LORSeAT5HKn¯PQ`5HvJML­PQPQHKNQTM[qVYX”blHxLONmT5HKn¯ªqHUeAcY`*Pa[U¶ Ú VRpHšNQHKJ5NmHK[QHUT*PmLOPQeAfYHWHU®_LYRp³
J5bAHK[-LONmHÊ[Q`5V­ª<TÏeAT,Ü8eAcYr5NmH s ¶våIHUNmHYw¬ªkHS[QHUHÊHKfeAn_HKTM^©H§VOXk^UVLYNm[QH©³Ì^©V_n_Hxn3NmHUJMNQHx[ŒHKTPaL­PmelVTM[
PQ`ŽL­PšHKTM^©V_n_H§L[ŒrM°M[ŒHUPšVYXœelPQHKR¯[IeATHUelPQ`5HKNšVT5HPmelRSHÊJ•VYeAT*PIeATPQ`5Hp[ŒHx±*r5HUTM^UH'VYNšL^©Vr5J5bAH
VOX¬PmelRSHIJ•VYeAT*Pm[K¶ bA[QV'ªqH<XFVYrMTMnSr5T5elPm[\PQ`MLOP\ªqHUNmH<RpVNQHš^©bAHKLONmbA]§LY[m[QV^UeALOPQHxnʪ<elPQ`NmH©PmNQeAHUf­LYb
LOTŽnT5VYPHUTM^UV_n_elTMcM¶Â›`5HK[QH&Ph]JŽHx[SVOX-NQHKJ5NmHK[QHUT*PmLOPQeAVYTM[pLONmH^©VYTŽ[Œe[hPmHUT*P¯ª<egPm` VYr5N¯VYPQ`5HKN
ªqVYNm«&[Q`5V­ª<eAT5c+`MV­ª.PQ`5Hx[ŒHS«eATMn5[-VOXkNQHKJ5NQHx[ŒHKT*PmL­PmelVTM[v^ULOT([ŒrMJ5JŽVNŒP-cYVV_nÏcHUT5HKNmLYbleAÑKLOPQeAVYT
µ y <HKelbAbl]Æã{oqrM[Q°]YwMÝO||ÝÁ‘¶
ٌ¡¥¨ØI¡¡ÙhÖ Õ
¦(H `ŽL²fYH J5NQHx[ŒHKT*PQHKn LRSV_n_HKb´VOX[QHK±*r5HKTPmeALYbHUTM^UVn5elT5céVYXJ5`5VT5HURSHK[Kw°ŽLY[QHKn VT
eATMn_HUJ•HUTŽn_HUT*PQbA]*³·RSVYPQeAf²LOPQHxn^©VRSJ5r_PmLOPQeAVYTMLYbkLYTMn´°5eAVYbAVYceA^KLOb\^UVYTM[QeAn5HUNaL­PQeAVYTŽ[Uw7XFV_^©rM[QHKn´VT
PQ`MHWT5HUrMNmLYbM[ŒrM°M[hPmNmLOPQHx[jVOX•PQ`5HšJ5NmH©XFNmVYT*PmLYb5^©VYNQPQHU®pLYTMnp°MLY[mLOb5c*LOT5cbleL µ ÜMNmLYT5«ÊHUPkLOb·¶lwÝO||5ßxÁ©¶
IeAHUªqHKn,eAT,RSVYNmHSLO°M[ŒPQNaLY^©PKw¨XFr5TŽ^‘PQeAVYTŽLObœPQHKNQR¯[Kw”`5V­ªqHUfHUNxw•Vr5N-RSVn5HUbje[ : rM[hPÊLYT5VOPm`5HUN-eAT
LÆblVT5cÆbleAT5HSVOX›^©VYRSJ5r5PmL­PmelVTMLObjRSV_n_HKbA[-VYXk`5V­ªäJ•HUVJ5bAHpRSeAcY`*PHUTM^UV_n_H¯[ŒHx±rMHUT*PQeLObœVYNan_HKN
eAT_XFVYNmR¯L­PQeAVYT˜¶8›`5HKNQHšLONmH›PhªkV'^UbAL[Q[QeA^WRpV_n_HKbA?[ + µ LÁI5À 'UºK¿U¾DÀ ·4¾ 35§¿m¹MÀ­¾Ò»Ž¾Ò»*½Yw*ª<`MHUNmH<PQ`5HvLY^©PQel³
Input
Output
Input
Output
f­L­PmelVµ T3VYX8LpcYeAfYHKT+elPQHURPQNmelccYHKNm[kPQ`MH-L^‘Pmelf­L­PmelVT3VYX˜Pm`5HT5H©®P<elPQHUR"feALSLY[m[QV^UeALOPQeAfYHšbleAT5«_[Uw
LOTŽn °ŽÁ'4¾ A¸M5º ‘4¾ ·¾Dº­»´5À 'UºK¿U¾DÀ ·¾Dº­»ÆRSV_n_HUb[Wª<`5HKNQHÊegPmHUR¯[ILYNQH'L[Q[QV_^©eL­PQHxn+ª<elPQ`ÏPQ`5HKelNv[ŒHU³
±*r5HUT*PmeALYb?JŽV*[ŒelPQeAVYTŽ[LOTMn(NmHK^ULYblbAHKn,XFNmVYR J•V[QelPQeAVYT´^©r5Hx[ µ H¶ c޶lw ”HUH
ã \[ŒPQHx[Uwjßx)} ! !OÁ‘¶Â›`MH
°ML[Œe^'LY[m[QV^UeALOPQeAfYH'^a`MLYelTMelT5c3RSVn5HUb8`MLY[I°ŽHKHUT,n5HK^©e[QelfHUbA]3Nmr5bAHKn&VYr5Pš°ML[ŒHxnVYTHKNQNmVYNWJŽL­PŒ³
PQHKNQTŽ[ µ åIHUTM[QVYT˜w IVYNmNQe[UwœZjLOcHYw˜ão›Ln5n_HUbAHU]w\ßx}Y}Yà*Á‘w8°5r_PpRpV_n_elÎMHxn´fYHKNm[QelVTM[VYXWegPpRSL²]
L²fYVeAnÄPQ`MHK[QHJ5NmVY°5bAHUR¯[ µ HY¶ cM¶Aw ”HKªqLYTMn_V­ªW[Q«]Äã r5Nan_V_^a«•w\ßK}Yz}Á©¶3Z?NmVY°ŽLO°5bA]PQ`MHRSV[ŒP
LY^K^©VRpJMble[Œ`MHKn´^©rMNQNmHUT*P§RSV_n_HKb:w?oqr5NmcYHx[Q[§LOTMnÉåIegPa^a` µ ßx}Y}}Á‘wœe[§LÄfYHKNm[QelVTVOX<PQ`MH3elPQHKR§³
J•V[QegPmelVT&L[Q[QV_^©eL­PmelVT3RSV_n_HUb7ª<egPm`ÏL¯^©VRpJ•H©PmegPmelfH'±*r5HUr5eAT5cRSHx^a`MLOT5e[QRЪ<`5HUNmH-PQ`MH'RSV[ŒP
LY^©PQeAfYHWelPQHKRæeA[kVYr_PmJ5r_PkÎMNm[ŒPkLYTMn¯e[?Pm`5HUT+[Qr5J5JMNQHx[Q[QHKnpPmVÊLObAblV­ª VYPQ`5HKN\elPQHUR¯[\PQV'°•HIVr_PQJMr_PK¶
ikVYRSJMLYNQHxnÏPmVÆPQ`5Hx[ŒH¯HU®e[ŒPQeAT5c&RpV_n_HKbA[Kw˜Vr5NRSV_n_HUb?e[-r5T5e±*r5H¯eAT(TMVOP'NmHK±*r5eANQeAT5c3XDLY[ŒPÊLY[Œ³
[QV^UeALOPQeAVYTMLYb?bAelT5«_[ÊPQVÏHKTM^©V_n_H3egPmHUR¯[§ª<egPm`5elTÉPQ`5HÆ[ŒHx±rMHUTM^UHY¶ÄÜMVYNÊHU®5LORSJ5bAHYw8PQ`5HÆoqr5NQcHK[m[
LOTŽnpåIegPa^a` µ ßx}Y}Y}*Á7RpV_n_HKbMrM[QHK[?NmLYJ5eAnpªqHUeAcY`*P?^a`MLOTMcYHK[jPQV'LY[m[QV^UeALOPQH›elPQHUR¯[\ª<egPm`SL^UVYT*PQHU®P
NmHUJ5NmHK[QHUT*PmLOPQeAVYT&Pm`ML­P-XFr5TM^©PQeAVYTM[vR§rM^a`ÄbAel«H'Pm`5HpPQeARpHpeAT5J5r_PeAT,Vr5NšRSV_n_HKb:¶ÞÌT(^©VYT*PmNmL[hPxw
elPQHUR¯[<LYNQHvR¯LOeATPaLOeAT5HKnÆ[ŒPQNmeA^©PQbA]¯f*eLpJŽHKNm[Qe[hPmHUT*P›L^‘Pmelf­L­PmelVT3eATÆVYr5N›RSV_n_HUb·w5LOTMn+PQ`MHv°ŽLY[mLObl³
cLYT5cYbAeLS°MLY[QHKnÆcLOPQeAT5c¯RSHK^a`MLYT5e[ŒRÛJ5NmV­f*en_Hx[WL¯RSHKLYTM[<VOXjHKTM^©V_n_eAT5celPQHKRS[šeATPmV+[QHUJMLYNmLOPQH
T5HKr5NmLYb\[QblVYPm[-Pm`ML­PÊeARSJ5bAeA^UegPmbl](NQHKJ5NmHK[QHUT*P'[ŒHx±rMHUT*PQeLOb?VNmn5HUNx¶+›`rM[Uw7PQ`MH¯PQeARSHelTMJ5r_Pm[§LY^©P
eATMn_HUJ•HUTŽn_HUT*PQbA]VYTPm`5H+°ML[QLYb?cLYT5cYbAeL5w8ª<`5eA^a`Pm`5HUTVYJ•HUNaL­PQHx[cYHKT5HUNme^ULObAbA]ÄVYT´ª<`ŽL­PQHKfYHKN
J5`5VT5HURSHeAT_XFVYNmR¯L­PmelVTe[SJ5NmHK[QHUT*PQbA]LY^©PQeAf­L­PQHxnÅelTÅPQ`MHÏLOrMn_elPQVNQ]elT5JMr_PKw›VY°feL­PQeAT5c(PQ`MH
T5HKHKn3XFVYNW[QJŽHx^©elΎ^-elPQHURp³Ì^©VTPmH©®P<bleAT5«_[K¶
›`5Hq^©bAHKLON8°•HUT5HUÎ5P8VYX5T5VOP8NQHx±*r5elNmeAT5cILY[m[QV^UeALOPQeAVYTMLYbObAelT5«_[8e[”Pm`ML­P8egPœR¯LO«YHx[¨Pm`5HkRSV_n_HKbR§rM^a`
RSVYNmHÊˎH©®_el°MblHSµ LOTMn,^ULYJMLO°5bAHpVOXkcHUT5HKNmLYbleAÑKLOPQeAVYT&PmV3T5V­fHUbj[QHK±*r5HUTŽ^©HK[vLY[vªqH§`ŽL²fYH§n5HURSVYT_³
[ŒPQNaL­PQHxnS`5HUNmH [ŒHKHvy WHUeAblbA]pã rMTMLO«­L­PaL5wÝY|Y||vXFVYN\HU®PQHUTŽn_HKn¯n_e[m^©rM[m[ŒeAVYT¯VYX¬PQ`5e[?cHUT5HKNmLYb
e[Q[Qr5HxÁ©¶Â›`rM[Uw˜ªkHS°•HUbAelHKfYH¯VYrMNvRSV_n_HKb?eA[-rMT5eA±*r5HKbl],ªkHKblb?[Qr5elPQHxnÄXFVNH©®_J5bLOeAT5eAT5cÆPQ`5H¯NmVYbAH
VOX\PQ`5HpJ5`5VT5VYbAVYceA^KLOb˜bAVVYJ,elT,NmLYJ5eAnϰ5elTŽn_elTMcÆVYX\T5V­fHUb”PaLY[Q«elT5XFVYNmRSLOPQeAVYT”¶ IHUfYHKNŒPm`5HUbAHK[m[Kw
PQ`MH'J5NmHK[QHUT*PWelRSJ5bAHURSHKTPaL­PmelVTVOX8PQ`5H'RSV_n_HKb˜`ML[<Tr5RSHUNmVYrM[W[Q`5VNŒPa^©VYRSeAT5c[<LYTMn&[ŒeARSJ5bAegÎ5³
^ULOPQeAVYTM[Kw¨LOTMn,n_VHK[vT5VYPv°•HUcelT,PQV&LOJ5JMNQV*LY^a`&PQ`MHpªqVYNm«ÆVOXqoqr5NmcYHx[Q[šLOTMn,åWelPm^a` µ ßx}Y}Y}*Á<eAT
LY^K^©Vr5T*PQeAT5cÆXFVYNÊNmHUbAHUf­LYTP'JŽ[Œ]_^a`5VblVcYe^ULObjn5LOPmLM¶3›`rM[Kw˜XFr_Pmr5NmHªkVNQ«,ª<elbAb\°•H¯XFV_^©rŽ[ŒHxn,VT
NmHURSHKn_]eAT5c&PQ`MHK[QHbleARSegPaL­PmelVTM[U¶ÏyšT5H¯eARSJŽVNŒPaLOT*PÊe[Q[Qr5HSPQ`ŽL­PʪqH¯J5bLOTPQV,LYn5n_NmHK[m[-e[PQ`MH
eATPmHUNmJ5bL²]3°•H©PhªqHUHKTÏPQ`MH§J5NmHK[QHUT*PIRSV_n_HKb8°ŽLY[QHKnVTPQ`5HpJ5NmH©XFNmVYT*PmLYb7^UVYNQPQH©®ÏLYTMn&PQ`MH§°5eATMn³
eAT5cÏPm`ML­PpPQ`5HÆ`5eAJ5J•V^KLORSJ5rM[S^KLOTJMNQV­fen_HSÈ ªkHÆ[ŒrŽ[ŒJ•HK^©P§Pm`ML­PpPQ`5HÆ`5eAJ5J•V^KLORSJ5rM[pª<eAblb
^©VT*PQNmel°5r5PQH-egPmHURp³‰JŽV*[ŒelPQeAVYTLY[m[QV^UeALOPQeAVYTM[›LYTMn3PQ`5HKelNWL[Q[QV_^©eL­PQHxn+HKNQNmVYN›JMLOPŒPmHUNmTM[<LOTMnÆVYPQ`5HKN
J5`5HKT5VYRSHKTMLSLY[<n_e[Q^UrM[m[ŒHxn+eATokrMNQcHK[m[qLYTMn&åWelPm^a` µ ßx}Y}}Á‘¶
”48,“ ¯9DB6 ÉB4¬™ +
›`5e[ʪqVYNm«(ªqL[§[Qr5J5J•VYNQPQHxn´°]Éy ÐcNmLYT
P I|Y||5ß t ³Ì|Y|­³aß©³Ì|Ý t àLYTMn Ú ÜcYNaLOT*PÊÞho <³
}Y,z ! sYt }Ý5¶ <V_n_VYblXFV Ú VOPmV3n_eAHKn&PmNmLYcYe^ULYblbA]ÆLOP-L+NQHKbALOPQeAfYHKbl]Æ]YVr5T5c3LYcYHÊn5r5NQeAT5c+PQ`5HpJ5NmHUJMLO³
NaL­PQeAVYTÆVOX7PQ`5e[<R¯LOTrM[m^©NmeAJ_PqÈ PQ`5e[<ªqVYNm«¯eA[<n5HKn_e^ULOPQHKn3PmVp`MeA[<RSHKRpVNQ]¶
˜£ Õ ¥ 7¡
K*€m‚g€Q„ A$W A N› h‹*€mhŠm~x‚ƒ€ A_ A U‡, *~ A 9 H "Q% œ‹*€›‡‹*~ ~x‚ƒ~ KƒŠ‘K‚M‚ƒ~­~x‡¯Uˆ?v‚g K’, x€
K‚ƒ*€‘©C€m*‚g€Q„A '$WY" €9šOgŠm€x:"Q < "!;
#$!!'%'=?&(>8&A)@B#%D*,CE+.-/+.&0CD+.1 !'A3= K25G 4Fq6BA7#€ (I 8H7Y ~KC FKJL)67~UŒ )* ²€mhˆÌ ·„ h€aˆÌˆa
’YC x€aˆÌˆ AFš A  hŠŒB‹ AMNšN MY: "QP Op€ ~KÌ5„ A~KˆÌ€QhlU‚?~KŒ€Q/ J$ € !(8~KC F ~OY€a‚8,~ )h‹€
‡‹*~ ~x‚ƒ~ KƒŠ‘K‚¬‚ƒ~­~K‡¯ *p h:ˆ h  Y "!#$!%'&()#K*,+.-/&(+.1AQ2545RHA,S.T 'UK
9 ~x‹€ BAKMV 9v A Œ+ ²€m+ A qK 5 AKWLYX Zk€mg‚ƒ‚…„ AVZW 9  : "QL
 $Ša~ ‡’ Œ, hƒ~ K‚•K‡‡h~²UŠQ*‹ h~‡Yh€ >
lh~ ŒK‚”Ša~U1 h€ 6 AŽŠm~  h. x€vŠa~ 7Ìh~K‚ A¬, ¯ˆÌŠQ‹ Oa~x‡‹h€ lB JZ\€aŠa€ ›€ ²€m‚g~K‡ € hˆk *+Ša’YÌh€ ŠŒ‹U‚g‚ƒ€x€aˆa"B&[#$!8\! ]"B&()#_^=?)8@.)5\`[&(!'@"a!b`c"+*!')#SdK!/\&0+.`[ecf!'@Vg5!'@hai:ABjS652HA" B /TV 'kO
9 ~x‹€ BAVM" 9v AKlLYX Zk€mg‚ƒ‚…„ AVZW 9  :"Q
‡YEPh€O3Ah~ 7 ŒUŒ‚­ Ša*~K1 h€#6W~ h*€ WA ‹Nšƒ‡*G ‡_Lš~­Q Š‘,m” *‡*ˆ ’*h€aˆ  hB‹ A$Ån¬Ša‡YO3~h€a ̂ƒh $I.Q .’*OphU€ ÌoŠ h„ 9<~kh, ‡‹**‚g€mƒ€a~K‚ ̄§(m˜~ \ ˆah ‹*"#A€<W. ‡Y=hh!'~x€m(ˆÌŒ]"‡_U+?€aŠ \Š#h`[ƒh&A~ .-'x+
€%)ˆ CE_€+.€EC(œ!8~U€a=.̀ 5„­ p
^7+?!'= <)'@Kgq).]5]V# &()'`[&(!'@" ҇‡Ž, ':5koT : "Q OSK‹ (jUB‹ AVFk€ (rMx€mhˆÌ€m„ Jm¨h.‚ *K’ S
LYX Z 'Z
O 8M
U
J
G!%'@&A`[&A-'+ +?\`[&A-'+
)'@VgDi +")'-/&(!'=)# + B=?!'.\&0+.@V.+ N2 7 5koTV/:
_Z JNF m F 79
QO
9 : ")'= ` +.=.# ! B= @K)#3!b .]"+.= &ACE+.@"`0)#K 5 U!#$!%'Sp BC)'@ .]"+.=.&AC+.@`0)#V "!#$!%' "e h K T
Z ':U= =+.@"` 3]V&c@&(!'@ &c@ + B=?! \&(!#$!%' GR B TB k
a! B=.m @V)#Q!b +.= )#Vf3+? )'5k= '@k &A@Sr%
L)'@Kg +.= )#Ki +")'-/&[!'= Q25R oT U/
M Q9 _H
Q 7M 5:
! B= @K)#3!b G!'C ]U)'=)'`[&A-'+ + B =?!#$ !%' 3jj ': /T 5k8:
' "O
B "!#$!%'&()#5*,+.-/&(+.1
SR oT 'k 5 O
O
7+ B =?)'# G!'C ]M B`0)'`[&(!'@ ND2 O Vk B.TBk':
O ,@"@ "m )#*a+.V-/&0+.1! b + KBM =?"!'9.\&0+.@V + U 7/:5koT
O
3 7Z
LYX Z VZ ^'=+.@Vg' &A@ G!%'@&c`[&A-'+ dV\&0+.@K +. ' oT :
LYX Z UZ " SO "M UU9 U (m !/gS+\# !b,1!'=?>8&A@S%YCE+.C!8=.5p
+? ")8@&AC! b )5\`[&c-'+C)'&c@` +.@K)8@K + )'@Kg + S+? B`[&A-'+ !'@`[=!# 5k oT U ,F H KJ
LYX Z aZ Z ,g'-8)8@K +. &A@ + B=?)# @/bo!'= C)8`[&(!'@< =?!/ +. &c@B%Ed"'` +.CY
e dh U4542
LYX Z 'Z oJ Z ' 5 5Z
!'@"\\&[! B @K+.opai&A@Kg'&c@B% &c@` +(%'=?)'`[&[!'@ N)8@KgDg'&c .!/\&()8`[&(!'@ SL JGL (m a^7+ U@"&A`[
!b
LYX Z .\&0+.@V._+/Zp _@Kg57+.=.`0O)'@Vg'&A@B%E`c+ CYH &A@Kg \D&AC G"#$!8)8C `[&A] @BB%D`0)'`c`[&(+ !8@K\=))'#&A@+ .]K#$!'=)'`[&(!'@"D&A@ KO !%'@"JV&AO `[&A-'+@+ B=!
LYX Z _J UZ Z SM
B
"!#$!%'&[ )'#3*a+.-/&0+.1 G254 U'.T
m
N9 Z )'` B =N+ QM jBR oT
: "!#$!%'&()#K*,+.-/&(+.1 R _.T
8 Œ,F A 3 AM~x’K‹̄A A
9
,5*KˆhK‚%²,x‚ƒ
g¯ (œ~KCFO# kA €mHgA‚ƒ€‚…„A ~KI̍„ 'Y$Ǎ Ša~ +"Q‡*7’!Œ,hh€mƒŒ~U*ŠKhƒ‚~*ˆ~O_€€a!‚Ò(8€a€'h‹*€ Ah~ŒU ‚YŠm~K1h€6 € * ˆÌ€~ H~UA ÌI„  I”̍HhI$ ~UqA ‡*k,1~Kh ̀mhCƒˆ A ˆjvh’*B‚ƒšN€<~xA ’k ,ŠŒx ‹€UA * 3 4H$W~OY.A €a‚ƒˆj~”K4*Y€a‚ƒ€‘€m„gAB$Ih€› ˆÌv€mh gK ‚•h€mŠ‘K"Q‚ƒ ‚ҍ)*Ša‚gK€‘
,A A ­
!­ ̄A W) Q"  œ ‹*€¯h€a‡h€mˆÌ€Œ ,h ƒ~´
~,Jh €
‡_~KŒU‚kA ~KC'
h g~´

‡_€mhŠa€a‡h ƒ~´
,  ~,h ~K
Ša~9 Ì h~x‚ҍ "!
$#
,A HA O
Ž€m€ˆÌ A h%K ˆa˜ A ”ˆh€aˆ)A& ( *# '-L "Q kŒ+Y€m( '**# ,‡_~KˆÌhƒ~#A (H‡A h' ©-Ì,„ Y €~K̄ A~Kʂƒ€1h€m
Ž€YK1‚D+A * €m’ h~+A M€Ì ?( h.ƒ ˆˆÌA ƒŠvvŠaH~I$ * A €m8Šh ~KƒˆÌ~‹** ƒˆq~KF .-A' q KAŠa.­& ’*M’€;  ~A²F€m „S5‡Yh €A h~ Q" Œ 4K‚”• Ša~x~K‡_1~h €#K 6 ŒKF‡U‹­h„3€‘U~,ˆ j ‡­„O/Œ, Q"> 
0
1
,A 2A Y
Ž€#j( *A ~+ ?( ˆ1O­F  „A 5A p’ŒY~­Š#F A   "Q p€ ~K̄ A ~K”ˆÌ€mhgU‚Y~UŒ€m‘
A
p€ah ‚ ’YA h€aˆaH$I
A 8 ƒ ˆÌ€m+A  "QA  43 pA  .Oa­0 **'€mÌh~Uhˆ<’*ˆÌÊ‚ƒ€‘UC€‘+Šm~·’Šh²€;A€‘,>
pƒ‚ƒ‚g€Q+6A ?5'-A 9 ~K‹*€
HA  vB # 7A 38Q" %%A$Lp h €K OŒ h .x € h ‹*€a~Ūp~,¨ ‡h€l h~Œ K‚ŽŠa~K1h €#6A ’ Šh ƒ~Ž 
p…Ša„O~xF Ì €hA ~xW$‚ҍ A O~h ~A W%Ò + ‡h€a‡*UŒh g~ Q" œ ‹€vh~x‚ƒ€-~,Kh ‹*€š‡*‹~* ~K‚ƒ~x ƒŠ‘U‚8‚ƒ~­~x‡Æ.3 €Y6 €aŠa’h .x €
kh ƒŠ‘€mUg‚ƒ‚•‚…„ŠaA ~W*  9h ƒ~ M  "Q O6§+‡h Šaƒ‡*‚ƒ€aˆ)A~K)*ƒ~x‚ƒ~Cx7A ƒŠ‘3DK‚ƒ‚…„7> "#5A K,$ˆÌ€a+-,Ša~O ‡*’Œ,hƒ~*K‚~OY€a‚ƒˆk~,˜Ša~K1>
k €m~OgY‚ƒ‚…€a„‚*A ~,IH 8( 9 ~KCA OF Œ'+² €m+€A q ~U ̄­5A E4I$ 9  ~xp‹€ƒB„­A ²F € A vH  O‹"KQ‹0 $ 7 Yƒˆa~x ‚ƒ"#~:A K 9 gŠaK‚ƒ‚…„* UˆÌ€‘§Šm~ ‡*’Œ ,h ƒ~* K‚
9
; <
>='Ò ‡‡Ž -, Q"  k€( 7~KCF
9 ,hgx€ ²€mhˆÌ·„ h€aˆÌˆa
kŠa~O€mYg‚ƒ€‘‚…„pA YWƒˆÌ h9 . ’A h €‘h€a’‡Yˆ1hO €a„ˆÌA €IŒ ,h 5ƒ~) ˆa% Q"  qN € €m?ŒK
‚ƒ‘O , * ‚ƒ€+A@h€m‚lh ƒ~ U‚ * * -A h~ Ša~xUhˆÌ€>
@
83
U
kˆÌ’€m* g‚ƒˆ‚…Ì„ŒA ,Ih €m ˆ 9 Lk$ A ‚h ’*€mCˆ1­ „Ah I² €a ˆ)_h A ~4h €O ~h‡_~~UA ŒWK‚¬7ˆ‰Ò.„I ‡ŠQ‹Yh€mh~ˆÌˆ ­ "Q„­:œ!‹/h€aW$ €M A~K9 C‚ƒ€a€mˆ¬h€~,' ,.* *ˆ ˜kM "#*A 'h‹€a… *€a’YŒK‚
6
* )67 ~KŒ )67 ~UŒ .x €mhˆÌ· „ h€aˆÌˆa
k€mg‚ƒ‚…„A I? D 9 A p’FK,Œ7A v E# "QBF F# ;  9 Y hgx €A *$ 0! h €aˆÌ$ˆaC 
k~Ùm„ g‚ƒ‚…„A hI*  Šm9 g‡‚ƒA €aˆ›~\˜ ’ŠaY~U„1h A ƒŠ‘KG‚˜& *HS ‹*ƒ‡*‡_Q" ~­Ša9 ~ ‰‡’U* ‚BŠA h’*² Š#€\h hg~€a‡Ž h €mˆÌ€Œ ,h ƒ~ ˆj.§ ‚ƒ€‘UC .- A , 42A €G>
4 ,$O
K²’€Q‚ƒ€aCˆÌ ’BKA‚MŠa?~ A 8‡_h~*h‹B€7A œ 9 ~ Dvœ( ~UA COF .8 GŒUŠ#€F² ~+(?~Ug̏„­F A IH _#A :8 3 A4 ,$"Q  œ,O‹* €*€a’YŒK‚jŠa~UÌh€a‚g,h€aˆ~,)h‹€
9
&´ƒŠ ²F €a‚K h€H5
 Ò ˆÌ‡_€a€mŠQA‹ &Å"M_ €aW$ ‹+HO ƒ~K‘ Q"  ~7h €#61D> ˆÌ€ ˆÌh .x €›ŠaA ~OI HA *A KOˆÌˆÌ ~­Šag,h ² €' € ~ŪYA * ÊˆÌ€mhgU‚•~KŒY€m