662 Transient Cerebral Ischemic Attacks in the Young and Middle Aged A Population Study STURLA E. JOHNSON, M.D.,* AND HA YARD SKRE, M.D.t SUMMARY During an investigation of coronary risk factors, a population 20 to 54 years old in Troms0, Northern Norway was screened for transient ischemic cerebral attacks. Three simple screening questions were used. Sixteen thousand six hundred and twenty-one subjects participated in the study. Among the responders, a sample of 501 were evaluated neurologicaliy and 10 men and 16 women identified as TIA cases. Mean age for men was 41.3 years, for women 33 years. Five women (mean age 24.4) had the events during pregnancy, pointing to pregnancy as a period of risk. Five-year incidence was found to be 2.5. per 1000. Clinical expressions and ratio carotid to vertebral-basilar TLA hardly differed from that found hi materials of older patients. All 26 remained stroke-free during a mean observation period of 55 months. Known risk factors like hypertension, carotid stenosis and cardiac disease were found in only a few. Five women had low blood pressure. It is suggested that TLA in younger age groups may constitute a separate entity where, among other, haemodynamk factors and pregnancy play a role. Stroke Vol 17, No 4, 1986 Downloaded from http://stroke.ahajournals.org/ by guest on June 15, 2017 TRANSIENT ISCHEMIC ATTACKS, the most important warning sign of brain infarction in old age, is occasionally seen even among young and middle aged subjects. The cause and pathogenesis of this potentially hazardous condition remain unknown, but hypertension and atherosclerosis are thought to play a major role. Other suspected causes include mitral valve prolapse, lipid abnormalities, increased coagulability and polycythemia.1-2 Earlier investigations of TIA frequency deal mainly with subjects over 60 years. Estimates of incidence stem from data gained from records and diagnostic registers.3"7 There are no known studies of TIA from screenings of defined populations under 50-55 years. Knowledge is sparse concerning the frequency, clinical course and prognosis of the condition in these younger age strata. Such knowledge may give clues to pathogenesis and ultimately aid prevention. A recent survey of coronary risk factors in a population in Norway* gave us the opportunity to study TIA in males 20 to 54 years and females 20 to 50 years old. Material and Methods The study took place in the municipality of Troms0 in Northern Norway 1979-80 and was linked to the mass chest x-ray examination carried out that year by the National Mass Radiography Service. The followup was completed by July 1981. Eligible were all men born 1925 to 1959 and women bom 1930 to 1959, registered in the municipality, in all 21,329 persons. With the invitation went a 2-page questionnaire asking for information mostly on symptoms related to heart disease, but including a question on stroke. This questionnaire was delivered when the participants reFrom the Department of Neurology, University Hospital, N-9012 Troms0, Norway,* and Department of Neurology, Akershus Central Hospital, N-1474 Nordbyhagen, Norway. Sturla E. Johnson, M.D.* is a Consultant. Havard Skre, M.D.t is Professor and Chairman. Address correspondence to: Dr. Sturla E. Johnson, Consultant, Department of Neurology, University Hospital, N-9012 Troms0, Norway. Received July 9, 1985; accepted December 3, 1985. ported for the first screening. In addition to chest xray, this consisted of weight, height and blood pressure measurement and collection of venous non-fasting blood samples for assessment of total cholesterol, HDL cholesterol, triglycerides and glucose levels. The participants were now given a second questionnaire with 45 questions on past and present health, previous illnesses, dietary habits, cigarette smoking, alcohol consumption, as well as social conditions. They were asked to fill in the form at home and return it by mail. A separate section had questions aimed at detecting transient ischemic attacks in the brain. These were: "Have you ever had: 1. Sudden paralysis or numbness in one side of body or face, in hand or foot? 2. Sudden loss of ability to speak? 3. Sudden loss of eyesight, completely or partially, or sudden double vision?" A yes/no reply was required in each instance. A random sample of 50% of those giving an affirmative answer were chosen for the follow-up study. They received a letter in which we explained the object of the study and invited them to come for an interview and medical examination by either one of the authors. The guide-lines set down by the Study Group of Heyman et al9 were used for the identification of cases, TIA being defined as episodes of temporary focal cerebral dysfunction of vascular origin. Symptoms commonly last 2 to 30 minutes and clear rapidly leaving no residue. There may be only one attack or multiple attacks at different intervals. TIA are classified according to which vascular territory is involved, the carotid artery or the vertebral-basilar artery system, each giving rise to different symptoms. In practice this differentiation can be difficult. Each person was thoroughly questioned about the incident(s). Symptoms were recorded as accurately as possible, as were general health and other circumstances around the event. Special note was made of illness at the time and any use of pharmaceutical drugs and alcohol was recorded. Whenever the history suggested focal cerebral ischemia, a full clinical neurological examination was carried out. This included a general medical examination focusing on signs of car- A POPULATION STUDY/yo/i/iTon and Skre Downloaded from http://stroke.ahajournals.org/ by guest on June 15, 2017 diovascular and haeraatological disorders in particular. Blood pressure was measured with the patient recumbent for 2 minutes. All subjects met fasting. A venous blood sample was drawn from the cubital vein. A total of 275 samples, including all stroke and TLA cases, have been analysed for lipoproteins and lipoprotein markers. The results will appear elsewhere. Identification of TLA in the present study was made after a close scrutiny of data collected during the interview. Whenever available, hospital records were checked. Our hospital is the only one in this area and records existed for 50% of those interviewed. Vertigo alone as symptom was considered too unspecific to merit inclusion, as were syncope and drop attacks. Headache before or after the event or a history of recent migraine attacks also meant exclusion although headache can be a feature of TLA. There was one exception: A 35 year old women with classical migraine over 9 years whose attacks were stable and uniform and occurred 2-3 times a year. She was included on the basis of an episode with complete halfsided sensory loss of 10 minutes duration and without headache. Identification was in some cases difficult and required a second telephone interview in order to get more details. When in doubt, two or more identical episodes would mean inclusion. One episode was accepted when there could be little doubt about the ischemic nature like in transient hemiparesis or monocular blindness. Results Of the 21,329 persons summoned for the mass x-ray examination, 16,621 responded, delivering their answers to the 2 page primary questionnaire. Twenty-six replied affirmatively to the question referring to stroke. All of these were invited for a follow-up with the intention of verifying the diagnosis. Twenty-one were seen and examined. An overview of numbers is given in table 1. The results appear in table 2. Five of the 12 patients with thromboembolic stroke reported episodes of TLA in addition. Since these cases are not randomly selected, they were not included in the subsequent TLA group. Fourteen thousand six hundred and sixty-seven of the 16,621 persons participating in the mass x-ray examination returned the second questionnaire. One thousand, one hundred sixty-seven had given an affirmative answer to one or more of the TLA questions. Half of these, 588 persons, all born on even dates, were invited for further medical investigations, TABLE 1 The Tromsj Study. Sixteen Thousand Six Hundred and Twenty-one Men and Women 20 to 54 Years Old Attended first screening 16621 Self-reported stroke 26 Postal questionnaires returned 14667 Affirmative answers to TIA questions 1167 Selected for follow-up 588 Attended foUow-up (85%) 501 TIA-cases found 26 663 TABLE 2 Verification of 26 Self-reported Strokes in 17 Men (32-54 years) and 9 Women (28-50 years). Results of Follow-up and Review of Records Thromboembolic infarction 12 Transient ischemic attack 1 Subarachnoid haemorrhage 7 Traumatic brain haemorrhage 1 Non-cerebrovascular conditions 4 Unknown 1 Total 26 and 501 (85%) responded. Four hundred ninety-four subjects were seen personally by the authors while 7 could not attend for different reasons, but were interviewed by telephone. Of the 87 non-responders, one had died of coronary heart attack before the follow-up, 15 had moved and 11 declined. As expected a large majority of those seen had no history suggesting transient cerebral ischemia. Table 3 summarizes the diagnoses of this false positive group. The group includes 3 persons with previously unrecognized minor strokes. In the same group were a number of patients with specific non-cerebrovascular neurological conditions which had been diagnosed during earlier admissions to the hospital. Twenty-six cases of TLA, 10 men and 16 women, were identified. Six of these already had the diagnosis from earlier admissions or visits to the outpatient clinic. For 25 subjects the events took place between 1969 and 1980. The exception was a woman whose event occurred during pregnancy 30 years earlier. Age at the time of first TLA averaged 41.3 years for men (range 29-54) and 33 years for women (18-48). Five young women had TLA during the second half of pregnancy. If we leave out these who pathogenetically may belong to a different category, mean age rises to 36.8 years and equals that of men born after 1930 (37.2 years). Incidence of TLA over age is given in figure 1. Only men and women born after 1st of January 1930 with first events 1975 through 1979 were considered for the estimation of incidence, in allfivemen and nine TABLE 3 Classification of "False Positives" in Response to TIA Questions Acute or intermittent numbness/weakness due to cervical spondylosis, shoulder conditions, nerve entrapment, myosis 31.5 Sensory/motor symptoms due to lumbar disc lesions or ortopedic/rheumatic conditions 7.0 Migraine 8.9 Facial palsy (Bell's) 7.6 Psychoneurosis, hyperventilation syndrome 11.4 Eye disorders e.g. squint, refraction errors 9.5 Dizziness, near-syncope w/visual disturbances 5.5 Specific neurological disorders, e.g. stroke, epilepsy, traumatic and neoplastic brain lesions, MS, poliomyelitis, meningitis, polyneuropathy and myotonic dystrophy 7.0 Unrelated or non-classifiable disorders 11.6 Total 100.0 n = 473. STROKE 664 VOL 17, No 4, JULY-AUGUST >3 3.4 1986 JL,>3.7 2.5 >2.4 1.5 M Age <25 30 35 40 45 50 54 FIGURE 2. TIA episodes over age. Figures on top of columns denote mean number of attacks. In 50—54 year group men only. Age <25 30 35 40 45 50 54 Downloaded from http://stroke.ahajournals.org/ by guest on June 15, 2017 FIGURE 1. Age at the time of first TIA. 10 men, 16 women (shaded). Figures on top of columns indicate total numbers. Age 50-54 years covers men only. women. A 5-year overall incidence (first event) of TIA for men and women between 20 and 50 years was estimated to be about 2.5 per 1000. In the TIA group, the majority were in good health at the time of the event. Four were being treated for hypertension and two of these had coronary heart attacks within five years of the cerebral event. In two of the others cardiac murmurs were heard on auscultation and one of these had rheumatic fever as a child. Six were markedly overweight, one of whom had undergone jejuno-ileal bypass surgery. The rest were generally healthy (table 4). None of the women were using contraceptive pills. Five young women (mean age 24.6) had TIA during pregnancy, four of them during the last trimester. One woman experienced similar TIA during 2 successive pregnancies. The examination revealed a bruit over the corresponding carotid artery. In two of the others were found possible bruits. None were under the influence of alcohol when the TIA occurred. Mostly, multiple attacks occurred within a few days, but 4 subjects reported recurrent episodes over more than four years. Figure 2 shows mean attack number over age. There were no overall sex differences. Ten subjects experienced only one attack whereas 4 subjects had more than five. TABLE 4 Follow-up Study of 26 TIA-cases20-54 Years: Some Clinical Findings Systolic BP, (mm Hg) mean Systolic Systolic BP ^ 145. n = BP 5 110. n = 131.3 (160-105) 6 5 Diastolic Diastolic BP, mean BP S 110. n = 85.0 (110-70) 3 Heart disease Overweight Carotid bruit, definite possible impalpable pulse 2 6 1 2 2 All the common manifestations of TLA were seen, like monocular blindness, hemiparesis, hemianesthesia and aphasia (table 5). Seventeen subjects experienced sensory symptoms either alone or in combination with other symptoms. In 20 subjects symptoms were thought to come from ischemia in the carotid artery territory. The vertebral-basilar territory was implicated in theremaining6. Although the events might have taken place several years earlier, all remembered them well and could give detailed accounts. A similar experience of good patient memory is reported from the Evans County Study.12 In 17 out of 23 symptoms had caused sufficient alarm to make them consult a doctor. Eight were soon afterwards referred to our department where 6 underwent extra- and intracranial vessel angiography. Another 2 have since the study been admitted for angiography because of recurrent TIA. In all 8 angiographies were performed. Bilateral carotid aneurysms were demonstrated in one person with fibromuscular dysplasia. Another had extensive atheromatous lesions and stenosis in both internal carotids. Endarterectomy was carried out as an emergency. No abnormality was seen in the other 6. At the time of neurological evaluation mean observation time was 55 months (range 12-132) without occurrence of stroke in 25 subjects. One person, a woman, has remained stroke-free for 30 years. Over the last ten years an average of 60 patients TABLE 5 Symptoms Due to TIA in 26 Subjects 20-54 Years 8 Numbness in half of face + arm, half of body 2 Numbness in half of face + arm with reduced vision 1 Numbness in half of face + arm with loss of speech 2 Parestesia and numbness in half of face + arm 2 Hemiparesis 3 Paresis and numbness in face and arm 3 Paresis and parestesia in tongue, arm and leg 1 Paresis and numbness in one arm, with dysarthry Amaurosis fugax (1st event). Hemianopia and parestesia 1 in one arm (2nd event) 2 Bilaterally reduced vision or blindness 1 Hemianopia 26 Total A POPULATION STUDY/Johnson and Skre annually have been admitted to the neurological, medical and surgical departments under the diagnosis TLA (ICD no.435.99). The hospital's databased diagnostic register has been checked to see if any TLA-cases admitted who were eligible for the follow-up study, had in fact been missed. None were found. Downloaded from http://stroke.ahajournals.org/ by guest on June 15, 2017 Discussion Two methods are available if one wishes to study the occurrence of TLA in a population. Most studies so far have made use of data from medical records or, indirectly, from diagnostic registers. This means that only persons who seek medical attention for their symptoms are included. One would expect such estimates to be too low since a number of patients presumably never report their incidents. TLA symptoms, as the present study shows, are often sensory, very short-lived, appear only once and may not cause much alarm. One can safely assume that the younger the patient, the less regard he pays such symptoms. A population screening with the use of self-administered questionnaire is equally open to error. The form may have been incompletely filled in, misunderstood or lost or events may have been forgotten. It is impossible to say to what extent this affects results. From our experience the general public is motivated for health screenings once the object is made clear and people take care to answer the questions correctly. A great many said they welcomed the chance to get a medical check. This is also reflected in the good tum-out. As for the 1954 subjects (11.8%) who did not respond to the second questionnaire, these do not differ in age from the rest. We suspect that a lower incidence of TLA would have been found in this group had it been followed up. Persons who experience symptoms are probably more alert to the need for a medical check than others and therefore likely to be found among the responders. The questions used in the Troms0 Study may seem few and unspecific if compared with those used and recommended by other investigators.'110 In a Danish study in some ways similar to the present, 5 simple questions were used." The nature of the Troms0 Study ruled out the use of additional questions. In our view too many and detailed questions can also cause errors and lead to higher non-response rate. It was decided instead to use few questions and to follow up with a personal evaluation of a large number of the responders. This was done by qualified neurologists with access to hospital records. We therefore believe a high degree of case ascertainment was achieved. As expected the Troms0 Study showed transient ischemic attacks to be rare in persons under 50-54. Earlier population studies differ from the present in method and age selection and directly comparable estimates of incidence are not available. The Danish Study linked to an investigation of heart disease in a Copenhagen suburb gives an estimate of 4/1000/year for the age 50-59 years." The Evans County survey covers subjects over 40 years and a sample of 15 to 39 year olds. Prevalence of TLA at the time of follow-up was 665 8/1000 under 54 years. There was a racial difference, whites having a higher rate than blacks.12 Japanese men in Hawaii over 45 years had an incidence of 0.7/1000 in the 45-49 year group.13 A recent Swedish survey based on data from hospital admissions, suggests an incidence as low as 4/100000/year under the age 55.6 The authors assume that nearly all TLA cases are referred for specialist evaluation, a view which is clearly open for debate. In comparison, The Rochester Study,3 also based on medical records, gives an incidence of 16/100000/year in the 45-54 year group. Allowing for the uncertainties connected with population screenings like the present and the small number of TLA cases found, our estimate of a 5-year incidence of 2.5/1000 seems reasonable. It must, however, be taken only as a pointer. The real incidence is likely to be higher for reasons stated earlier. Also, the figure does not include persons who suffered stroke or died after TLA. An interesting detail is the comparison between male/female ratios in the Swedish and Troms0 materials. There seems to be a trend towards a female dominance in the younger age strata and the reverse in the older age groups in both materials. Since our cases are so few, this must be taken with all due reservations. A surprising number (17 out of 26) experienced sensory deficits, either alone or in combination with other symptoms. Karp12reported8 with sensory symptoms out of 28 but 18 of these were over 55 years old. This could imply that sensory TLA make up a larger proportion of cases in the young than in those of higher age. The number of cases with paresis of the limbs corresponds well in the two materials (9 in the Troms0 Study against 8 in the other). The attacks were mostly short, lasting less than 30 minutes in 20 subjects. In 11 the duration was less than 5 min. The ratio of carotid to vertebral/basilar territory TLA was 4:. This differs from the 2:1 ratio found in a middle and old age patient material in Rochester,14 and in a Dutch material of similar age" but is equal to that found in a retirement community in Seal Beach.4 In contrast to the attention given stroke, not much is found in the literature concerning transient ischemic attacks during pregnancy. Sporadic cases have been described but more often regarded as manifestations of migraine than TLA.1316 None of our cases suffered from migraine during or after the pregnancy. In our experience TLA during the latter half of pregnancy is not uncommon. We have since the study encountered several additional cases, referred from the Department of Obstetrics. A report is about to be published.l7 This very interesting phenomenon should, in our view, be further investigated with regard to pathogenesis and prognostic implications. All the five women in the study had uneventful deliveries. There is a puzzling trend towards a higher TLA incidence in the age groups around 40 years, corresponding roughly with the highest mean recurrence rate. There is also a high incidence and TLA recurrence rate in age group 25-29, corresponding to the peak of TLA incidence in pregnancies. Since the number of cases is so small, such trends should not be overemphasized, STROKE 666 Downloaded from http://stroke.ahajournals.org/ by guest on June 15, 2017 but they suggest two possibilities: Causes leading to TIA episodes in the actual age groups exert their maximum influence around the 40 years mark, or during the childbearing periods in the female. Further, these episodes are evidently of a more benign type than those occurring in older age, where approximately one third of TIA cases may experience a stroke later, half of them within the following month.18 Also other observations suggest that our "young" TIA cases constitute special etiological groups, since risk factors like hypertension, overweight, carotid stenosis, cardiac diseases, etc., were largely non-existent and hardly different from the population average. This is in line with findings in another Norwegian study of cerebrovascular accidents, which comprised non-hypertensive males younger than 55 years of age admitted to hospital. TLA incidence peaked around 40 years, while stroke incidence prevailed later. In this study the antigen Ag(x), which is of a lipoprotein nature (Beta fraction), was abundant in TLA cases (59% positive, as against 35% in the population.20 Lack of this factor is regarded a risk factor in cardiac infarction, its role in TIA is obscure. Another possible risk factor in TLA may be low blood pressure in affected women. Of the 16 females in our series with TIA, 5 had systolic blood pressures =Sl 10 mm Hg, while such lowfigureswere not found in 14 age-matched controls (women with Bell's palsy from the same study). In a Dutch study from 1981,19 comprising 225 women (28% below 55 years), significant correlation was observed between low BP and TLA risk in all age groups. On the basis of our ownfindingsset in a context with other observations, it is reasonable to believe that early TIA mayrepresenta rather benign condition, and perhaps constitute a separate entity(ies), where, among other, haemodynamic factors and pregnancy play a role. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. References 1. Marshall J: The cause and prognosis of strokes in people under SO years. J Neurol Sci S3: 473-488, 1982 2. Mettinger KL, Sdderstrom CE: Pathogenetic profile of TIA before 55. J Neurol Sci 36: 341-348, 1978 3. Whisnant JP: A population study of stroke and TIA: Rochester, 20. VOL 17, No 4, JULY-AUGUST 1986 Minnesota. In: Stroke. Proceedings of the 9th Pfizer Intern. Symp. Gillingham, Mawdsley & Williams (eds.). Churchill Livingstone, Edinburgh pp 21-39, 1976 Friedman GD, Wilson WS, Mosier JM, Colandrea MA, Nihaman MZ: Transient ischemic attacks in a community. JAMA 210: 1428-1434, 1969 Terent A: A prospective epidemiological survey of cerebrovascular disease in a Swedish community. Uppsala J Med Sci 84: 235-246, 1979 Mettinger KL, Sdderstrom CE, Allander E: Epidemiology of acute cerebrovascular disease before the age of 55 in the Stockholm County 1973-77: I. Stroke 15: 795-801, 1984 Zupping R, Roose M: Epidemiology of cerebrovascular disease in Tartu, Estonia, USSR, 1970 through 1973. Stroke 7: 187-190, 1976 Thelle DS, Amesen E, F0rde OH: The Tromsd Heart Study: Does coffee raise serum cholesterol? N Engl J Med 308: 1454-1457, 1983 Heyman A (Chairman) and The Study Group on TIA criterion and detection: Transient focal cerebral ischemia: Epidemiological and clinical aspects. Stroke 5: 277-287, 1974 Wilkinson WE, Heyman A, Burch JG, Ostfeld A, Labarthe DR, Leviton A, O'Fallon WM, Whisnant J: Use of self-administered questionnaire for detection of transient cerebral ischemic attacks: I. Ann Neurol 6: 40-46, 1979 Boysen G, Jensen G, Schnohr P: Frequency of focal cerebral transient ischemic attacks during a 12 month period. Stroke 10: 533-534, 1979 Karp HR, Heyman A, Heyden S, Bartel AG, Tyroler HA, Hames CG: Transient cerebral ischemia. Prevalence and prognosis in a biracial rural community. JAMA 235: 125-128, 1973 Rhoads GG, Popper JS, Kagan A, Yano K: Incidence of transient cerebral ischemic attack in Hawaii Japanese men. Stroke 11: 21-26, 1980 Cartlidge NEF, Whisnant JP, Elveback LR: Carotid and vertebralbasilar transient cerebral ischemic attacks. Mayo Clin Proc 52: 117-120, 1977 Hart RG, Miller VT: Cerebral infarction in young adults: A practical approach. Stroke 14: 110-114, 1983 Fisher CM: Cerebral ischemia — less familiar types. Clin Neurosurg 18: 267-336, 1971 Johnson SE, Monstad P, Mellgren SI, Verelst M: Transient ischemic attacks related to pregnancy and puerperium. 1985 (Submitted for publication) Hier DB, Caplan LR: Stroke — who is at risk? Sandorama 29-32, HI, 1981 Herman B, de Waard F, Collette HJA: Unexpected trends in the analysis of a questionnaire and interview procedure to detect transient cerebral ischemic attack in a female population. Clin Neurol Neurosurg 83-4: 225-237, 1981 Skre H, Berg K, Nyland H, Kobro G: Some lipoprotein markers and other variables in males aged 20-55 years with cerebro-vascular accident (CVA). Proceedings of the Norwegian Neurological Society, September 20, 1984. Acta Neurol Scand, 1985 (in press) Transient cerebral ischemic attacks in the young and middle aged. A population study. S E Johnson and H Skre Stroke. 1986;17:662-666 doi: 10.1161/01.STR.17.4.662 Downloaded from http://stroke.ahajournals.org/ by guest on June 15, 2017 Stroke is published by the American Heart Association, 7272 Greenville Avenue, Dallas, TX 75231 Copyright © 1986 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Print ISSN: 0039-2499. Online ISSN: 1524-4628 The online version of this article, along with updated information and services, is located on the World Wide Web at: http://stroke.ahajournals.org/content/17/4/662 Permissions: Requests for permissions to reproduce figures, tables, or portions of articles originally published in Stroke can be obtained via RightsLink, a service of the Copyright Clearance Center, not the Editorial Office. Once the online version of the published article for which permission is being requested is located, click Request Permissions in the middle column of the Web page under Services. Further information about this process is available in the Permissions and Rights Question and Answer document. Reprints: Information about reprints can be found online at: http://www.lww.com/reprints Subscriptions: Information about subscribing to Stroke is online at: http://stroke.ahajournals.org//subscriptions/
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz