Chapter 4 Judicial Federalism

&KDSWHU
-XGLFLDO)HGHUDOLVP
:
E49391<VUTUbQ\Yc]bU\YUc_^dXU`bY^
SY`\UdXQddXUcdQdUQ^TVUTUbQ\S_ebdc
d_WUdXUbS_]`bYcUQ^Y^dUWbQdUTcicdU]
V_bdXUTU\YfUbi_VZecdYSUY^dXUE^YdUT
CdQdUc8Ycd_bYSQ\\idXUdg_S_ebdcicdU]c
XQfU`\QiUTTYVVUbU^dRedUaeQ\\icYW^YVYSQ^d
b_\UcY^_ebVUTUbQ\cicdU]DXUcdQdUS_ebdc
XQfUcUbfUTQcdXU`bY]QbiV_be]cV_bbU
c_\fY^WSYfY\TYc`edUcQ^TdXUSXYUVdbYRe^Q\c
V_bU^V_bSY^WdXUSbY]Y^Q\\QgDXUVUTUbQ\
S_ebdcY^S_^dbQcdXQfUXQTQ]eSX]_bU
\Y]YdUTZebYcTYSdY_^DXUc_ebSUQ^T^QdebU
_VVUTUbQ\ZebYcTYSdY_^TUbYfUVb_]Q^e]RUb
_VS_^cdYdedY_^Q\`_gUbcfUcdUTY^3_^WbUcc+
Q^TdXU^_dY_^_VQ\Y]YdUTVUTUbQ\S_ebd
ZebYcTYSdY_^Yc`bU]YcUT_^dXU]_bUVe^TQ
]U^dQ\S_^cdYdedY_^Q\`bY^SY`\UdXQddXU
^QdY_^Q\W_fUb^]U^dYcQW_fUb^]U^d_V
TU\UWQdUT`_gUbcY^gXYSXdXUbUcYTeQ\
`_gUbbU]QY^cY^dXUcdQdUc
9dV_\\_gcVb_]dXYcVe^TQ]U^dQ\
fYUg_VdXU^QdebU_V_ebVUTUbQ\cicdU]_V
W_fUb^]U^ddXQddXUZebYcTYSdY_^_VdXU
VUTUbQ\S_ebdccX_e\TS_]`\U]U^d^_dce`
`\Q^ddXQd_VdXUcdQdUS_ebdc1\dX_eWX
1bdYS\U999CUSdY_^"_VdXU3_^cdYdedY_^`_
dU^dYQ\\iUhdU^TcVUTUbQ\ZeTYSYQ\`_gUbd_Q
gYTUbQ^WU_VSQcUcQ^TS_^db_fUbcYUc
dXU6bQ]UbcgYcU\i\UVddXUQSdeQ\cS_`U_V
\_gUbVUTUbQ\S_ebdZebYcTYSdY_^d_3_^WbUcc
TYcSbUdY_^DbQTYdY_^Q\\i3_^WbUccXQcbU
VbQY^UTVb_]TYcdebRY^WdXUZebYcTYSdY_^_V
cdQdUS_ebdcQ\\_SQdY^WQ^Qbb_gUbZebYcTYS
dY_^d_dXU\_gUbVUTUbQ\S_ebdcdXQ^dXU
3_^cdYdedY_^`Ub]Ydc!Q^TQ\\_gY^WcdQdU
!
6_bUhQ]`\UdXUTYfUbcYdiZebYcTYSdY_^S_^VUbbUTRicdQd
edU"(EC3’!##"!)((cUUY^VbQBUS_]]U^TQdY_^
'Yc^Qbb_gUbdXQ^dXQdQedX_bYjUTRi1bdYS\U999CUSdY_^"
S_ebdcd_bUdQY^S_^SebbU^dZebYcTYSdY_^Y^
^e]Ub_ecSYfY\S_^dUhdc9^TUUTV_b
^UQb\idXUVYbcdSU^debi_VdXUBU`eR\YSdXU
VUTUbQ\S_ebdcTYT^_dXQfUWU^UbQ\_bYWY^Q\
ZebYcTYSdY_^Y^]QddUbcQbYcY^We^TUbdXU
3_^cdYdedY_^\QgcQ^TdbUQdYUc_VdXUE^YdUT
CdQdUc"Q^TQ]Y^Y]e]Q]_e^dY^S_^db_
fUbcigQcbUaeYbUTV_bc_]UVUTUbQ\
aeUcdY_^SQcUce^dY\VQYb\ibUSU^d\i#6_b
dXQdbUQc_^YdYc`_ccYR\Ud_TYcdY^WeYcXRU
dgUU^VUTUbQ\Yc]Y^dXU\UWYc\QdYfUS_^dUhd±
dXURbUQTdX_V3_^WbUccc`_gUbd_\UWYc\QdU
e^TUb1bdYS\U9CUSdY_^(±Q^TY^dXUZeTY
SYQ\S_^dUhd±dXUQ``b_`bYQdUQ\\_SQdY_^_V
ZebYcTYSdY_^d_dXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdce^TUb1bdY
S\U999
2Ui_^TXYcd_bYSQ\`bQSdYSUdXUQ\\_
SQdY_^_V\Y]YdUTZebYcTYSdY_^d_dXUVUTUbQ\
S_ebdcYcZecdYVYUTRiR_dXdXU_biQ^T`bQS
dYSUE^\UccQTYcdY^SdYfUb_\UV_bdXUVUTUbQ\
S_ebdcicdU]Yc`bUcUbfUTdXUbUYc^_c_e^T
ZecdYVYSQdY_^V_bXQfY^Wdg_`QbQ\\U\ZecdYSU
cicdU]c9VVUTUbQ\S_ebdcgUbUd_RUWY^Uh
UbSYcY^WY^dXU^_b]Q\S_ebcUdXURb_QT
bQ^WU_VceRZUSd]QddUbZebYcTYSdY_^dbQTY
dY_^Q\\iQ\\_SQdUTd_dXUcdQdUcdXUig_e\T
\_cUR_dXdXUYbTYcdY^SdYfU^QdebUQ^TTeUd_
RebWU_^Y^WT_S[UdcdXUYbQRY\Ydid_bUc_\fU
_VdXU3_^cdYdedY_^CdQdU6Qb]6YbU3QceQ\di3_f
DQcXYbU#(&EC%"#%# %#!!)&'
"
CUU1Sd_V=Qb#!('%SX!#'’!!(CdQd$' ^_g
S_TYVYUTQd"(EC3’!##!Q!)((
#
DXUWU^UbQ\Q]_e^dY^S_^db_fUbcibUaeYbU]U^dV_b
VUTUbQ\aeUcdY_^SQcUcgQcU\Y]Y^QdUTY^!)'&V_b
QSdY_^KcMRb_eWXdQWQY^cddXUE^YdUTCdQdUcQ^iQWU^Si
dXUbU_V_bQ^i_VVYSUb_bU]`\_iUUdXUbU_VY^XYc_VVYSYQ\
SQ`QSYdi1Sd_V?Sd"!!)'&@eR<>_)$%'$’")
CdQd"'"!Q^TY^Q\\SQcUcV_ebiUQbc\QdUb6UTUbQ\AeUc
dY_^:ebYcTYSdY_^Q\1]U^T]U^dc1Sd_V!)( @eR<>_
)&$(&’"Q)$CdQd"#&)
7KH-XGLFLDO&RQIHUHQFHRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVKDVDSSURYHGWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGLPSOHPHQWDWLRQVWUDWHJLHVLQWKLV/RQJ5DQJH3ODQWRJXLGHIXWXUH
DGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQDQGSROLF\GHYHORSPHQWE\WKH&RQIHUHQFHDQGRWKHUMXGLFLDOEUDQFKDXWKRULWLHV$OORWKHUWH[WLQWKLV3ODQLQFOXGLQJFRPPHQWDU\RQ
LQGLYLGXDOUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGVWUDWHJLHVH[SODLQVDQGVXSSOHPHQWVWKHDSSURYHGLWHPVEXWGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\UHIOHFWWKHYLHZVRIWKH&RQIHUHQFH
æ /21*5$1*(3/$1)257+()('(5$/&28576
VQYb\iQ^TUVVYSYU^d\idX_cUSQcUc_VS\UQb^Q
dY_^Q\Y]`_bdQ^TY^dUbUcddXQd`b_`Ub\iVQ\\
gYdXY^dXUcS_`U_VVUTUbQ\S_^SUb^E^TUb
dXQde^V_bde^QdUcSU^QbY_Q\\S_ebdc±VUTUbQ\
Q^TcdQdU±]YWXdQcgU\\RUS_^c_\YTQdUT
Y^d_QcY^W\UcicdU]d_XQ^T\UQ\\ZeTYSYQ\
RecY^UccD_V_\\_gdXYcS_ebcU±d_gQbT
UYdXUbQcY^W\U^QdY_^Q\S_ebdcicdU]_bdg_
cicdU]cU^WQWUTY^UccU^dYQ\\iYTU^dYSQ\
RecY^Ucc±g_e\TRUTYcQcdb_ec
DXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdcX_gUfUbXQfU
`b_SUUTUTgU\\_^dXUYbgQiT_g^dXU\QddUb
`QdX1c3_^WbUccS_^dY^eUcd_VUTUbQ\YjU
SbY]Uc`bUfY_ec\i`b_cUSedUTY^dXUcdQdU
S_ebdcQ^Td_SbUQdUSYfY\SQecUc_VQSdY_^
_fUb]QddUbc`bUfY_ec\ibUc_\fUTY^dXUcdQdU
S_ebdcdXUfYQRY\Ydi_VZeTYSYQ\VUTUbQ\Yc]Yc
e^aeUcdY_^QR\iQdbYc[
DXUV_\\_gY^WbUS_]]U^TQdY_^cQd
dU]`dd_QbdYSe\QdUQ^T`bUcUbfUQc_e^T
ZeTYSYQ\VUTUbQ\Yc]Q^U^TdXQdSQ^RUQd
dQY^UTY^\QbWU`Qbd±
•
VYbcddXb_eWXcU^cYR\U\Y]YdQdY_^c_^VUT
UbQ\SbY]Y^Q\Q^TSYfY\ZebYcTYSdY_^
•
cUS_^TRi]UQ^c_VQS__`UbQdYfUVUT
UbQ\Yc]Y^gXYSXdXUVUTUbQ\W_fUb^]U^d
Q^TdXUcdQdUcg_b[d_WUdXUbd_`b_]_dU
UVVUSdYfUSYfY\Q^TSbY]Y^Q\ZecdYSUcic
dU]c
•
dXYbTdXb_eWXdXUSQbUVe\\iS_^db_\\UT
Wb_gdX_VdXUVUTUbQ\ZeTYSYQbi
•
V_ebdXdXb_eWXY]`b_fU]U^dY^cdQdU
ZecdYSUcicdU]cgXYSX]QibUaeYbUcYW
^YVYSQ^dVUTUbQ\VY^Q^SYQ\QccYcdQ^SUd_
cdQdUS_ebdc`b_cUSed_bcQ^T\QgU^
V_bSU]U^dQWU^SYUc
1SXYUfY^WdXUcUV_ebW_Q\cgY\\
`b_TeSUQTeQ\RU^UVYd*VUTUbQ\S_ebdcU]
R_TiY^WdXUYbS_bUfQ\eUcQ^TcdQdUS_ebdc
bU]QY^Y^WfYdQ\Q^TUVVYSYU^dV_be]cd_QTZe
TYSQdU]QddUbcdXQdRU\_^WdXUbUY^dXU\YWXd
_VXYcd_biQ^TQc_e^TTYfYcY_^_VQedX_bYdi
=_bU_fUbbUTeSUTVY\Y^Wc_VSQcUcdXQdT_
^_dbUaeYbUQVUTUbQ\V_be]gY\\U^XQ^SUdXU
VUTUbQ\S_ebdcQRY\YdYUcd_fY^TYSQdUbYWXdcY^
_dXUbQbUQc_V^QdY_^Q\Y^dUbUcd
DXUVYbcdW_Q\±\Y]YdY^WdXUVUTUbQ\
S_ebdcZebYcTYSdY_^±cX_e\TRUS_^cYcdU^d
gYdXQ^TV\_gVb_]Q^e^TUbcdQ^TY^W_VdXU
RU^UVYdc_VXQfY^WTeQ\cicdU]c_VW_fUb^
]U^d9^WU^UbQ\dXUVUTUbQ\W_fUb^]U^d
SQ^WbQ``\UgYdX`b_R\U]cUhdU^TY^WRU
i_^TdXUR_bTUbc_VY^TYfYTeQ\cdQdUc
`b_R\U]cdXQdbUaeYbUe^YV_b]dbUQd]U^dQ^T
`b_R\U]cdXQdQbUd__cU^cYdYfU_bf_\QdY\U
gYdXY^Q\_SQ\S_]]e^YdiV_bUVVUSdYfU\_SQ\
bUWe\QdY_^_bU^V_bSU]U^dCdQdUW_fUb^
]U^dcY^S_^dbQcdQbURUddUbQR\Ud_bUc`_^T
d_]QddUbc_V\_SQ\S_^SUb^±V_SecY^W_^dXU
Y]`QSddXQdQ`b_R\U]]QiXQfUY^QTYcSbUdU
bUWY_^QcgU\\QcQ^i\_SQ\Y^dUbUcdc^UUTc
_bcdQ^TQbTcdXQd]QiRUY]`\YSQdUTDXU
cQ]U`bY^SY`\UcSQ^Q``\ic`USYVYSQ\\iY^dXU
ZeTYSYQ\S_^dUhd±RedgYdXU]`XQcYc_^bU
cUbfY^WVUTUbQ\S_ebdZebYcTYSdY_^V_b]QddUbc
bUaeYbY^WQTZeTYSQdY_^Y^dXQdV_be]
=UUdY^WdXUcUS_^TW_Q\_VQS__`
UbQdYfUVUTUbQ\Yc]YcUccU^dYQ\RUSQecUdXU
]YccY_^c_VdXUVUTUbQ\Q^TcdQdUZecdYSU
cicdU]cgXY\Ue^T_eRdUT\iTYcdY^Sd^UfUb
dXU\Ucc_fUb\Q`5QSXcicdU]SQ^ceSSUUT
_^\iRiS_]]e^YSQdY^WQ^TS__`UbQdY^W
gYdXdXU_dXUbBUS_]]U^TQdY_^c$Q^T!$
cdbYfUd_`b_]_dUQXUQ\dXiVUTUbQ\Yc]Y^
gXYSXR_dXZeTYSYQ\cicdU]cQbU]QTURUddUb
_VVdXb_eWXdXUYbS_\\USdYfUUVV_bdc
DXUdXYbTW_Q\±S_^db_\\Y^WdXU
Wb_gdX_VdXUVUTUbQ\ZeTYSYQbi±V_\\_gc
Vb_]\Y]YdQdY_^c_^Wb_gdX_VdXUVUTUbQ\
S_ebdcZebYcTYSdY_^DXUQ``b_`bYQdUcYjU_V
dXUVUTUbQ\ZeTYSYQbiYc^USUccQbY\iQVe^SdY_^
_VYdcZebYcTYSdY_^9VY^dXUS_]Y^WiUQbc
3_^WbUccQ^TdXU1]UbYSQ^`U_`\UbU]QY^
S_]]YddUTd_dXU`bY^SY`\U_VZeTYSYQ\VUTUb
Q\Yc]dXUigY\\bU]QY^fYWY\Q^dY^\Y]YdY^W
7KH-XGLFLDO&RQIHUHQFHRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVKDVDSSURYHGWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGLPSOHPHQWDWLRQVWUDWHJLHVLQWKLV/RQJ5DQJH3ODQWRJXLGHIXWXUH
DGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQDQGSROLF\GHYHORSPHQWE\WKH&RQIHUHQFHDQGRWKHUMXGLFLDOEUDQFKDXWKRULWLHV$OORWKHUWH[WLQWKLV3ODQLQFOXGLQJFRPPHQWDU\RQ
LQGLYLGXDOUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGVWUDWHJLHVH[SODLQVDQGVXSSOHPHQWVWKHDSSURYHGLWHPVEXWGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\UHIOHFWWKHYLHZVRIWKH&RQIHUHQFH
&+$37(5-8',&,$/)('(5$/,60æ
dXUZebYcTYSdY_^±Q^TS_^cUaeU^d\idXU
cYjU±_VdXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdc
6Y^Q\\idXUV_ebdXW_Q\±Y]`b_fY^W
cdQdUZecdYSUcicdU]c±YcQ^USUccQbiS_^TY
dY_^V_b`bUcUbfY^WdXU`b_`Ubb_\Uc_VdXU
cdQdUQ^TVUTUbQ\S_ebdc1SdYfUUVV_bdcd_
Y]`b_fUdXUaeQ\Ydi±`UbSUYfUTQ^TQS
deQ\±_VcdQdUZecdYSUcicdU]c]QiRU_^U_V
dXU]_cd`b_TeSdYfUS_ebcUc_VQSdY_^V_b
dX_cUS_^SUb^UTQR_edVUTUbQ\YjQdY_^Q^TdXU
Wb_gdX_VdXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdcSQcU\_QT$9]
`b_fY^W`UbSU`dY_^YcY]`_bdQ^dRUSQecU
]Q^i\QgiUbcQ^T\YdYWQ^dce^VQYb\i_b^_d
XQfU\UccS_^VYTU^SUY^dXUcdQdUS_ebdcdXQ^
dXUYbVUTUbQ\S_e^dUb`Qbdc9]`b_fY^WdXU
QSdeQ\SQ`QSYdi_VdXUcdQdUS_ebdcRUS_]Uc
ebWU^dRUSQecUYdYce^VQYbd_c_\fUdXUVedebU
SQcU\_QTRebTU^c_VdXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdcRi
V_YcdY^WdXU]_VV_^d_dXUcdQdUc%DXYcYc
`QbdYSe\Qb\idbeU^_gQc]Q^iVY^UcdQdU
S_ebdcicdU]cVQSUWbQfUVYcSQ\SbYcUc6UT
UbQ\`_\YSiSebbU^d\ibUS_W^YjUcdXU^UUTd_
`b_fYTUQTTYdY_^Q\bUc_ebSUcd_cdQdU\QgU^
V_bSU]U^dQWU^SYUc1^UVVUSdYfU`_\YSi_V
ZeTYSYQ\VUTUbQ\Yc]]UQ^cdXQd3_^WbUcc
]ecdQ\c_S_^cYTUb]Q[Y^WcYW^YVYSQ^dbU
c_ebSUcQfQY\QR\Ud_dXUcdQdUS_ebdcc_dXQd
dXUiQbUQR\Ud_]QY^dQY^dXUYbUVVUSdYfUb_\Uc
Y^_ebY^dUbTU`U^TU^dZecdYSUcicdU]
DXUcdQbdY^W`_Y^dY^QbdYSe\QdY^WQ
c_e^TZeTYSYQ\cicdU]YcYTU^dYViY^WdXUUc
cU^dYQ\c_VVUTUbQ\S_ebdZebYcTYSdY_^9^dXU
V_\\_gY^WcUSdY_^cdXU`\Q^bUS_]]U^Tc
`beTU^dYQ\WeYTU\Y^UcV_b\Y]YdY^WVUTUbQ\
ZebYcTYSdY_^Q^TY]`\U]U^dY^WQc_e^TZeTY
SYQ\VUTUbQ\Yc]1^iceSX`b_`_cQ\c\Y[U
dXU_^UcTYcSeccUTXUbU_b_dXUbcg_e\TVQ
f_bSUbdQY^Y^dUbUcdc_fUb_dXUbcQ^T]Qi
dXUbUV_bURUcUU^Ric_]Ud_S_^cdYdedUQ^
$
CUU1bdXeb48U\\]Q^@Q`Ub@bUcU^dUTd_dXU:eTYSYQ\
3_^VUbU^SU3_]]YddUU_^<_^WBQ^WU@\Q^^Y^W%?Sd
"!!))!
%
GY\\YQ]8BUX^aeYcdCUU^Y^Q7\Qcc4Qb[\i*DXU6e
debU_VdXU6UTUbQ\3_ebdc!))#GYc<BUf!
;QcdU^]UYUb<USdebUE^YfUbcYdi_VGYcS_^cY^<Qg
CSX__\CU`d!%!))"
Y^YdYQdYfURUi_^TdXU`b_fY^SU_VQ^_^
]QZ_bYdQbYQ^Q`_\YdYSQ\Y^cdYdedY_^8_gUfUb
cU^cYR\U`\Q^^Y^W`bUce``_cUcQc_e^TQ\\_
SQdY_^_VZebYcTYSdY_^S_^cYcdU^dgYdXdXU
_fUbQbSXY^WS_^cdYdedY_^Q\cSXU]UQ^TgXQd
U^ceUcYcQ`bY^SY`\UTUVV_bdd_bUS_]]U^TQ
`b_`UbRQ\Q^SUDXU3_^WbUcc^UUT\Uccd_
cQigY\\XQfUdXUVY^Q\g_bT
'HILQLQJDQG0DLQWDLQLQJ
$/LPLWHG)HGHUDO-XULVGLFWLRQ&
S 5(&200(1'$7,213_^WbUcc
cX_e\TRUU^S_ebQWUTd_S_^cUbfUdXU
VUTUbQ\S_ebdcQcQTYcdY^SdYfUZeTYSYQ\
V_be]_V\Y]YdUTZebYcTYSdY_^Y^_eb
cicdU]_VVUTUbQ\Yc]3YfY\Q^TSbY]Y
^Q\ZebYcTYSdY_^cX_e\TRUQccYW^UTd_
dXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdc_^\id_VebdXUb
S\UQb\iTUVY^UTQ^TZecdYVYUT^QdY_^Q\
Y^dUbUcdc\UQfY^Wd_dXUcdQdUS_ebdcdXU
bUc`_^cYRY\YdiV_bQTZeTYSQdY^WQ\\
_dXUb]QddUbc
DXUbUS_]]U^TQdY_^cdXQdV_\\_gQbU
UVV_bdcd_Y]`\U]U^ddXYc_fUbQbSXY^W`bY^SY
`\U+Y^dXQdcU^cUQSXYUfY^WdXUW_Q\c_VdXYc
VYbcdbUS_]]U^TQdY_^QRc_\edU\iTU`U^Tc_^
Y]`\U]U^dY^WdX_cU]_bUc`USYVYSbUS_]
]U^TQdY_^c>_^UdXU\UccdXUW_Q\_VQ
\Y]YdUTVUTUbQ\S_ebdZebYcTYSdY_^YcT__]UT
e^\Ucc3_^WbUccU]RbQSUcdXUVe^TQ]U^dQ\
`XY\_c_`XiTUcSbYRUTQR_fU
&
=Q^i_VdXUbUS_]]U^TQdY_^cS_^dQY^UTY^dXYcSXQ`
dUbQcgU\\QcdXUce``_bdY^WbQdY_^Q\UQbURQcUT_^
cY]Y\QbbUS_]]U^TQdY_^cQ^TbQdY_^Q\UcTUfU\_`UTRidXU
6UTUbQ\3_ebdcCdeTi3_]]YddUUQ^TS_^dQY^UTY^dXQd
3_]]YddUUcBU`_bdQ^TG_b[Y^W@Q`UbcCUU96545B1<
3?EBDCCDE4I3?==9DD55G?B;9>7@1@5BC1>4
CE23?==9DD55B5@?BDC)$$&(:e\i!!)) 7KH-XGLFLDO&RQIHUHQFHRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVKDVDSSURYHGWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGLPSOHPHQWDWLRQVWUDWHJLHVLQWKLV/RQJ5DQJH3ODQWRJXLGHIXWXUH
DGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQDQGSROLF\GHYHORSPHQWE\WKH&RQIHUHQFHDQGRWKHUMXGLFLDOEUDQFKDXWKRULWLHV$OORWKHUWH[WLQWKLV3ODQLQFOXGLQJFRPPHQWDU\RQ
LQGLYLGXDOUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGVWUDWHJLHVH[SODLQVDQGVXSSOHPHQWVWKHDSSURYHGLWHPVEXWGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\UHIOHFWWKHYLHZVRIWKH&RQIHUHQFH
æ /21*5$1*(3/$1)257+()('(5$/&28576
&ULPLQDO3URFHHGLQJV
S 5(&200(1'$7,219^`bY^SY`\U
SbY]Y^Q\QSdYfYdicX_e\TRU`b_cU
SedUTY^QVUTUbQ\S_ebd_^\iY^dX_cU
Y^cdQ^SUcY^gXYSXcdQdUS_ebd`b_cUSe
dY_^Yc^_dQ``b_`bYQdU_bgXUbU
VUTUbQ\Y^dUbUcdcQbU`QbQ]_e^d3_^
WbUcccX_e\TRUU^S_ebQWUTd_Q\\_SQdU
SbY]Y^Q\ZebYcTYSdY_^d_dXUVUTUbQ\
S_ebdc_^\iY^bU\QdY_^d_dXUV_\\_g
Y^WVYfUdi`Uc_V_VVU^cUc*
QDXU`b_cSbYRUTQSdYfYdiS_^cdYdedUc
Q^_VVU^cUQWQY^cddXUVUTUbQ\W_fUb^
]U^dYdcU\V_bQWQY^cdYdcQWU^dc_b
QWQY^cdY^dUbUcdce^aeUcdY_^QR\iQcc_
SYQdUTgYdXQ^QdY_^Q\W_fUb^]U^d+_b
dXU3_^WbUccXQcUfY^SUTQS\UQb`bUV
UbU^SUV_be^YV_b]VUTUbQ\S_^db_\
_fUbdXYcQSdYfYdi
>__^UcUbY_ec\iTYc`edUcdXQdS_^
TeSdTYbUSd\iY^ZebY_ecd__bQVVUSdY^WdXU
VUTUbQ\W_fUb^]U^d_bYdcQWU^dccX_e\TRU
ceRZUSdd_dXUUhS\ecYfUZebYcTYSdY_^_VdXU
VUTUbQ\Y^fUcdYWQdYfU`b_cUSed_bYQ\Q^TZe
TYSYQ\RbQ^SXUcDbUQc_^Q^TS_e^dUbVUYdY^W
QbUUhQ]`\Uc_VSbY]UcgYdXTYbUSdY]`QSd
_^dXUVUTUbQ\W_fUb^]U^d1^_dXUbUhQ]
`\UYcSbY]Y^Q\QSdYfYdigYdXY^VUTUbQ\
U^S\QfUcY^S\eTY^W`b_cUSedY_^_V]QZ_b
SbY]UcY^9^TYQ^S_e^dbi
2idXUcQ]Ud_[U^VUTUbQ\SbY]Y^Q\
ZebYcTYSdY_^cX_e\TQ\c_bUQSX_VVU^cUcY^
gXYSX3_^WbUccY^dXUY^dUbUcdc_Ve^YV_b]
^QdY_^Q\bUWe\QdY_^XQcdQ[U^_fUb_b`bU
U]`dUTQ^U^dYbUbUWe\Qd_biVYU\T9^dUbcdQdU
U^fYb_^]U^dQ\S_^SUb^c^eS\UQbbUWe\QdY_^
Q^TgY\T\YVU`bUcUbfQdY_^]YWbQd_biRYbTc
UdSQbUUhQ]`\Uc_VdXU\QddUb
6Y^Q\\idXYcSbYdUbY_^Q\c_YcY^dU^TUT
d_SQ`debUdX_cU_SSQcY_^cgXU^\_SQ\]Qd
dUbcbUaeYbU^QdY_^Q\QddU^dY_^Q^TbUc_ebSUc
9^]_cdSYbSe]cdQ^SUcdXUVUTUbQ\W_fUb^
]U^dcY^f_\fU]U^dY^]QddUbcdXQdY^_^U
cU^cUQbU`ebU\i\_SQ\RedY^Q^_dXUbcU^cU
XQfUWQb^UbUTdXU^QdY_^cY^dUbUcdgY\\RU
dQbWUdUTd_`QbdYSe\Qb`b_cUSedY_^cUc`U
SYQ\\i\_SQ\]QddUbcdXQdQbURUi_^TdXUbUQSX
_VUVVUSdYfUQSdY_^RidXUcdQdUS_ebdc
$SSURSULDWHVXEMHFWVRIIHGHUDOFULPLQDOMXULVGLFWLRQ
‡
RIIHQVHVDJDLQVWWKHIHGHUDOJRYHUQPHQWRULWV
LQKHUHQWLQWHUHVWV
‡
FULPLQDODFWLYLW\ZLWKVXEVWDQWLDOPXOWLVWDWHRU
LQWHUQDWLRQDODVSHFWV
‡
FULPLQDODFWLYLW\LQYROYLQJFRPSOH[FRPPHUFLDO
RULQVWLWXWLRQDOHQWHUSULVHVPRVWHIIHFWLYHO\
SURVHFXWHGXVLQJIHGHUDOUHVRXUFHVRUH[SHUWLVH
‡
VHULRXVKLJKOHYHORUZLGHVSUHDGVWDWHRUORFDO
JRYHUQPHQWFRUUXSWLRQ
‡
FULPLQDOFDVHVUDLVLQJKLJKO\VHQVLWLYHORFDOLVVXHV
RDXU`b_cSbYRUTQSdYfYdiY^f_\fUc
ceRcdQ^dYQ\]e\dYcdQdU_bY^dUb^QdY_^Q\
Qc`USdc
CY]`\iRUSQecUSbY]Y^Q\QSdYfYdiY^
f_\fUcc_]UY^SYTU^dQ\Y^dUbcdQdU]_fU]U^d
T_Uc^_d]UQ^dXQdcdQdU`b_cUSedY_^Yc
^USUccQbY\iY^Q``b_`bYQdU_bY^UVVUSdYfU
1SdYfYdiXQfY^Wc_]U]Y^_bS_^^USdY_^gYdX
Q^TUVVUSd_^Y^dUbcdQdUS_]]UbSU]YWXd
`UbXQ`cRUS_^cdYdedY_^Q\\iceVVYSYU^dd_
`Ub]YdVUTUbQ\Y^dUbfU^dY_^RedYdcX_e\T^_d
RUU^_eWXRiYdcU\Vd_bUaeYbUQVUTUbQ\S_ebd
V_be]9^S_^dbQcdcYW^YVYSQ^dY^dUbcdQdU
QSdYfYdiRiQSd_bcU^WQWUTY^Q]QccYfUU^
dUb`bYcUceSXQcQ]e\dYcdQdUTbeW_`UbQdY_^
_bQ]e\dYcdQdUVbQeTcSXU]UcX_e\T^_b
]Q\\iSQ\\V_bdXUbUc_ebSUcQ^TbUQSX_VdXU
VUTUbQ\W_fUb^]U^d
7KH-XGLFLDO&RQIHUHQFHRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVKDVDSSURYHGWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGLPSOHPHQWDWLRQVWUDWHJLHVLQWKLV/RQJ5DQJH3ODQWRJXLGHIXWXUH
DGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQDQGSROLF\GHYHORSPHQWE\WKH&RQIHUHQFHDQGRWKHUMXGLFLDOEUDQFKDXWKRULWLHV$OORWKHUWH[WLQWKLV3ODQLQFOXGLQJFRPPHQWDU\RQ
LQGLYLGXDOUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGVWUDWHJLHVH[SODLQVDQGVXSSOHPHQWVWKHDSSURYHGLWHPVEXWGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\UHIOHFWWKHYLHZVRIWKH&RQIHUHQFH
&+$37(5-8',&,$/)('(5$/,60æ
SDXU`b_cSbYRUTQSdYfYdiUfU^YVV_
SecUTgYdXY^QcY^W\UcdQdUY^f_\fUcQ
S_]`\UhS_]]UbSYQ\_bY^cdYdedY_^Q\
U^dUb`bYcU]_cdUVVUSdYfU\i`b_cUSedUT
RiecU_VVUTUbQ\bUc_ebSUc_bUh`Ub
dYcUGXU^dXUcdQdUcXQfU_RdQY^UT
ceVVYSYU^dbUc_ebSUcQ^TUh`UbdYcUd_
QTUaeQdU\iS_^db_\dXYcdi`U_VSbY]U
dXYcSbYdUbY_^cX_e\TRUbUS_^cYTUbUT
9^QTTYdY_^d_]e\dYcdQdU_`UbQdY_^c
dXUbUQbU\_SQ\SbY]Y^Q\U^dUb`bYcUcdXQdQbU
c_S_]`\UhdXQddXUiXQfUWU^UbQ\\ibU
SUYfUTdXUbUc_ebSUcQ^TQddU^dY_^_VdXU
^QdY_^Q\W_fUb^]U^dC_]US_]]UbSYQ\
SbY]UY^f_\fY^WQ^Y^dUb`\Qi_VRecY^Ucc
VY^Q^SYQ\Q^TW_fUb^]U^dY^cdYdedY_^c±ceSX
QcdXUbUSU^dcQfY^WcQ^T\_Q^Y^fUcdYWQ
dY_^c±VQ\\cY^d_dXYcSQdUW_biDXUbQdY_^Q\U
V_bVUTUbQ\Y^f_\fU]U^dXUbUYc^_ddXQdQ
VUTUbQ\b_\UYcUccU^dYQ\ReddXQdcdQdUSbY]Y
^Q\ZecdYSUbUc_ebSUcXQfURUU^c_bU\i
_fUbdQhUTD_dXUUhdU^ddXQddXUcdQdUcbU
SUYfUceVVYSYU^dbUc_ebSUcQ^TTUfU\_`dXU
Uh`UbdYcUd_XQ^T\UdXUcUSQcUcVUTUbQ\Y^
f_\fU]U^dcX_e\TTY]Y^YcX
TDXU`b_cSbYRUTQSdYfYdiY^f_\fUc
cUbY_ecXYWX\UfU\_bgYTUc`bUQTcdQdU
_b\_SQ\W_fUb^]U^dS_bbe`dY_^
dXUbURidU^TY^Wd_e^TUb]Y^U`eR\YS
S_^VYTU^SUY^dXUUVVUSdYfU^Ucc_V\_SQ\
`b_cUSed_bcQ^TZeTYSYQ\cicdU]cd_
TUQ\gYdXdXU]QddUb
8Ycd_bYSQ\\iVUTUbQ\`b_cUSed_bYQ\
Q^TZeTYSYQ\bUc_ebSUcXQfURUU^edY\YjUT
VbUaeU^d\iY^cdQdUQ^T\_SQ\`eR\YSS_bbe`
dY_^SQcUcDXUbQdY_^Q\UV_bVUTUbQ\
Y^f_\fU]U^dXQcRUU^^_dc_]eSXdXQd
cdQdUbUc_\edY_^_VdXUcU]QddUbcg_e\TRU
Y^UVVUSdeQ\ReddXQdVUTUbQ\`b_cUSedY_^Q^T
QTZeTYSQdY_^`b_]_dUQXYWXUb\UfU\_V`eR
\YSS_^VYTU^SUY^dXUS_e^dbiccicdU]_V
ZecdYSU
UDXU`b_cSbYRUTQSdYfYdiRUSQecUYd
bQYcUcXYWX\icU^cYdYfUYcceUcY^dXU\_
SQ\S_]]e^YdiYc`UbSUYfUTQcRUY^W
]_bU_RZUSdYfU\i`b_cUSedUTgYdXY^dXU
VUTUbQ\cicdU]
4ebY^WdXUXUYWXd_VdXUSYfY\bYWXdc
UbQdXUbUgQcQ]Q^YVUcd^UUTY^c_]U`Qbdc
_VdXUS_e^dbiV_bdXUVUTUbQ\W_fUb^]U^dd_
`b_cUSedUQSdc_VfY_\U^SUQWQY^cdSYfY\bYWXdc
g_b[UbcgXU^\_SQ\\QgU^V_bSU]U^dXQT
]_fUTbU\eSdQ^d\iQWQY^cddXUfY_\Qd_bc
5fU^d_TQic_]USYfY\bYWXdcQSdY_^cRU
SQecU_VdXUYb`_dU^dYQ\V_bUh`\_cYfU^UccY^
dXUS_]]e^Ydi]QiRU]_bUUVVUSdYfU\i
XQ^T\UTRidXU^QdY_^Q\W_fUb^]U^d
3XQbWUc_VQcicdU]QdYSecU_VUhSUccYfU
V_bSURi`_\YSU_VVYSUbc_bSbY]Y^Q\Y^dUbVUb
U^SUgYdXdXUUhUbSYcU_VS_^cdYdedY_^Q\
bYWXdcQ\c_VQ\\gYdXY^dXYcSQdUW_bi
S 5(&200(1'$7,213_^WbUcc
cX_e\TRUU^S_ebQWUTd_bUfYUgUhYcd
Y^WVUTUbQ\SbY]Y^Q\cdQdedUcgYdXdXU
W_Q\_VU\Y]Y^QdY^W`b_fYcY_^c^_
\_^WUbcUbfY^WQ^UccU^dYQ\VUTUbQ\
`eb`_cU=_bURb_QT\iQdX_b_eWX
bUfYcY_^_VdXUVUTUbQ\SbY]Y^Q\S_TU
cX_e\TRUe^TUbdQ[U^c_dXQdYdS_^
V_b]cd_dXU`bY^SY`\UccUdV_bdXY^
BUS_]]U^TQdY_^"QR_fU9^QTTY
dY_^3_^WbUcccX_e\TRUU^S_ebQWUT
d_S_^cYTUbecU_Vce^cUd`b_fYcY_^c
d_bUaeYbU`UbY_TYSbUUfQ\eQdY_^_VdXU
`eb`_cUQ^T^UUTV_bQ^i^UgVUTUbQ\
_VVU^cUcdXQd]QiRUSbUQdUT
DXUbUQbUW__TbUQc_^cV_bQS_]
`bUXU^cYfUbUS_TYVYSQdY_^_VdXUVUTUbQ\
SbY]Y^Q\\QggX_\\iQ`QbdVb_]Q^iS_^cYT
UbQdY_^c_VQ``b_`bYQdUVUTUbQ\ZebYcTYSdY_^
1cdXU6UTUbQ\3_ebdcCdeTi3_]]YddUU
^_dUT*
7KH-XGLFLDO&RQIHUHQFHRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVKDVDSSURYHGWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGLPSOHPHQWDWLRQVWUDWHJLHVLQWKLV/RQJ5DQJH3ODQWRJXLGHIXWXUH
DGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQDQGSROLF\GHYHORSPHQWE\WKH&RQIHUHQFHDQGRWKHUMXGLFLDOEUDQFKDXWKRULWLHV$OORWKHUWH[WLQWKLV3ODQLQFOXGLQJFRPPHQWDU\RQ
LQGLYLGXDOUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGVWUDWHJLHVH[SODLQVDQGVXSSOHPHQWVWKHDSSURYHGLWHPVEXWGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\UHIOHFWWKHYLHZVRIWKH&RQIHUHQFH
æ /21*5$1*(3/$1)257+()('(5$/&28576
K6MUTUbQ\SbY]Y^Q\\QgYcXQbTd_
VY^TXQbTd_e^TUbcdQ^TbUTe^TQ^d
Q^TS_^V\YSdY^W9]`_bdQ^d
_VVU^cUcceSXQc]ebTUbQ^T[YT^Q`
`Y^WQbUS_]]Y^W\UTgYdXdbYfYQ\
_VVU^cUc\Y[UbU`b_TeSY^WdXUY]QWU
_VC]_[Ui2UQbgYdX_ed`Ub]Yc
cY_^!(EC3’'!!Q^TdQ[Y^W
VQ\cUdUUdXY^d_QcdQdUgYdX_eddXU
Q``b_fQ\_VQ\_SQ\TU^dYcd!(EC3
’!("!<QS[_VQbQdY_^Q\
SbY]Y^Q\S_TUXQcQ\c_XQ]`UbUTdXU
TUfU\_`]U^d_VQbQdY_^Q\cU^dU^SY^W
cicdU]'
1TTYdY_^Q\\iRiY^f_\fY^WYdcU\VY^Q
S_]`bUXU^cYfUbUTbQVdY^W_VdXUSbY]Y^Q\
S_TU3_^WbUcc]YWXdRUS_]U]_bUcU^cY
dYfUd_dXUgYcUecU_VUhUSedYfUQ^TZeTYSYQ\
RbQ^SXbUc_ebSUc9VU^S_ebQWUTd_`Y^`_Y^d
_^\idX_cU_VVU^cUcg_bdXi_V`b_cUSedY_^Y^
VUTUbQ\S_ebd3_^WbUcc]YWXdRU`UbceQTUT
d_gUUT_edSebbU^d_VVU^cUc^_dQ``b_`bY
QdUV_b`b_cUSedY_^Y^dXQdV_be]9Vce^cUd
`b_fYcY_^cQbUY^S\eTUTY^Q^i^UgSbY]Y^Q\
\UWYc\QdY_^dXU`b_SUccgY\\RUQ^_^W_Y^W
_^U1TTYdY_^Q\\iS_^dY^eUTcSbedY^i_VdXU
SbY]Y^Q\S_TU]YWXd`b_fYTU\UWYc\Qd_bcgYdX
QRb_QTUbfYUg`_Y^d_^SbY]Y^Q\ZecdYSUY^Q
VUTUbQ\cicdU]dXQdgY\\bUcdbQY^3_^WbUcc
Vb_]SbUQdY^W]Q^icY]Y\Qb_VVU^cUcY^dXU
VedebU
S 5(&200(1'$7,213_^WbUccQ^T
dXUUhUSedYfURbQ^SXcX_e\TRUU^
S_ebQWUTd_e^TUbdQ[US__`UbQdYfU
UVV_bdcgYdXdXUcdQdUcd_TUfU\_`Q
`_\YSid_TUdUb]Y^UgXUdXUb_VVU^cUc
cX_e\TRU`b_cUSedUTY^dXUVUTUbQ\_b
cdQdUcicdU]c
'
B5@?BD?6D856545B1<3?EBDCCDE4I3?==9DD55! &
!)) ,PSOHPHQWDWLRQ6WUDWHJLHV
D
DXUbUcX_e\TRUQ^Y^SbUQcUY^
VUTUbQ\bUc_ebSUcQ\\_SQdUTd_cdQdU
SbY]Y^Q\ZecdYSUcicdU]cV_b`b_cUSedY_^
_V]QddUbc^_gXQ^T\UTRiVUTUbQ\`b_cU
Sed_bcRUSQecU_V\QS[_VcdQdUbUc_ebSUc
E
DXU`bQSdYSU_VSb_ccTUcYW^QdY^W
R_dXVUTUbQ\Q^TcdQdU`b_cUSed_bcd_
WQY^UVVYSYU^SYUc_V`b_cUSedY_^cX_e\TRU
Y^SbUQcUT
F
CdQdUS_ebdccX_e\TRUQedX_bYjUT
d_QTZeTYSQdUSUbdQY^VUTUbQ\SbY]UcV_b
gXYSXdXUbUSebbU^d\iYc^_cdQded_bi
WbQ^d_VS_^SebbU^dZebYcTYSdY_^
DXUWb_gY^WVUTUbQ\YjQdY_^_VcdQdU
SbY]UcYcTeUY^`Qbdd_3_^WbUccRU\YUVdXQd
cdQdUbUc_ebSUc±`b_cUSed_bYQ\ZeTYSYQ\Q^T
`U^Q\±QbU_fUbdQhUT_bY^QTUaeQdU3_^
WbUccXQcQSX_YSUX_gUfUbY^bU]UTiY^W
`UbSUYfUTcdQdUY^QTUaeQSYUc?^UQ\dUb^Q
dYfUdXQdSX_cU^Y^bUSU^diUQbcYcd_SbUQdU
]_bUVUTUbQ\SbY]UcQ^TY^SbUQcUdXUbU
c_ebSUcV_bSbY]Y^Q\\QgU^V_bSU]U^dY^dXU
VUTUbQ\cicdU]DXYcXQcXQTdXUe^V_bde^QdU
S_^cUaeU^SU_VSXQ^WY^WdXU^QdebU_VVUT
UbQ\Yc]Q^TXebdY^WdXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdc
BQdXUbdXQ^SX__cY^WdXYc_`dY_^gYdXYdc
e^Y^dU^TUTS_^cUaeU^SUc3_^WbUccS_e\T
QSS_]`\YcXdXUcQ]U`eb`_cURiY^SbUQcY^W
VUTUbQ\QccYcdQ^SUd_cdQdUSbY]Y^Q\ZecdYSU
cicdU]cQ^TU^S_ebQWY^WS__`UbQdYfUUVV_bdc
Q]_^WVUTUbQ\Q^TcdQdU`b_cUSed_bc
@bUcU^d\i\QgU^V_bSU]U^dXQcRUU^
U^XQ^SUTRiSb_ccTUcYW^QdY_^c_VVUTUbQ\
Q^TcdQdU`b_cUSed_bcQcgU\\Qc_dXUbS__b
TY^QdUTfU^debUcRUdgUU^cdQdUQ^TVUTUbQ\
\QgU^V_bSU]U^dQWU^SYUcGYdXSb_cc
TUcYW^QdY_^dX_cUbUc`_^cYR\UV_bQSbY]Y^Q\
Y^fUcdYWQdY_^SQ^`b_SUUTgYdXQSQcUbU
WQbT\Ucc_VgXUdXUbdXUbUce\dY^W`b_cUSedY_^
YcRb_eWXdY^QVUTUbQ\_bcdQdUS_ebdDXUV_
7KH-XGLFLDO&RQIHUHQFHRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVKDVDSSURYHGWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGLPSOHPHQWDWLRQVWUDWHJLHVLQWKLV/RQJ5DQJH3ODQWRJXLGHIXWXUH
DGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQDQGSROLF\GHYHORSPHQWE\WKH&RQIHUHQFHDQGRWKHUMXGLFLDOEUDQFKDXWKRULWLHV$OORWKHUWH[WLQWKLV3ODQLQFOXGLQJFRPPHQWDU\RQ
LQGLYLGXDOUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGVWUDWHJLHVH[SODLQVDQGVXSSOHPHQWVWKHDSSURYHGLWHPVEXWGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\UHIOHFWWKHYLHZVRIWKH&RQIHUHQFH
&+$37(5-8',&,$/)('(5$/,60æ
be]SQ^RUcU\USdUT_^dXURQcYc_VgXUdXUb
VUTUbQ\_bcdQdUY^dUbUcdcQbUY]`\YSQdUT
bQdXUbdXQ^_^Q]_^W_dXUbbUQc_^cQVUT
UbQ\_bcdQdU`b_cUSed_bµcWbUQdUbVQ]Y\YQbYdi
gYdXdXUVQSdcDXYc`bQSdYSU]QhY]YjUcdXU
UVVUSdYfUecU_VQfQY\QR\UbUc_ebSUcgYdX_ed
R\ebbY^WdXU^USUccQbiTYcdY^SdY_^RUdgUU^
dXUdg_S_ebdcicdU]c
2iQedX_bYjY^WS_^SebbU^dcdQdUQ^T
VUTUbQ\ZebYcTYSdY_^_fUbSUbdQY^VUTUbQ\
SbY]Uc3_^WbUccS_e\TVebdXUbdXYcS__`UbQ
dY_^RiU^S_ebQWY^W`b_cUSedY_^_VVUTUbQ\
SbY]UcY^cdQdUS_ebdc6_bUhQ]`\UVUTUbQ\
`b_cUSedY_^c_V\_SQ\TbeWQSdYfYdiQ^Tc_]U
fY_\U^dSbY]US_e\TdQ[U`\QSUY^cdQdUS_ebd
UYdXUbRidXUEC1dd_b^Uic?VVYSU
dXb_eWXSb_ccTUcYW^QdY_^_bdXUcdQdUc
Qdd_b^Ui9^SQbSUbQdY_^V_bfY_\QdY_^_VQ
VUTUbQ\SbY]Y^Q\cdQdedU]YWXdcdY\\bUce\dY^
Y]`bYc_^]U^dY^QVUTUbQ\`bYc_^_bQTTY
dY_^Q\VUTUbQ\bUc_ebSUcS_e\TRUTUf_dUTd_
QYTY^WcdQdU`bYc_^c
1T_`dY^WdXYc`b_`_cQ\g_e\TbUaeYbU
bU`UQ\_V!(EC3’#"#!gXYSX]Q[Uc
VUTUbQ\SbY]Y^Q\ZebYcTYSdY_^Q^UhS\ecYfU\i
VUTUbQ\]QddUbQ^TYdcbU`\QSU]U^dgYdXQ
cdQdedUWbQ^dY^WdXUcdQdUS_ebdcS_^SebbU^d
ZebYcTYSdY_^_fUbc_]UVUTUbQ\SbY]Uc9d
g_e\TQ\c_bUaeYbUS_^Vb_^dY^WQ^TbUc_\f
Y^W]Q^i`b_SUTebQ\YcceUcQbYcY^WVb_]dXU
S_]`\UhYdi_V`b_cUSedY^W_^UcicdU]c
\QgcY^QcUS_^TcicdU]cS_ebdc>_dgYdX
cdQ^TY^WdXUcUTYVVYSe\dYUcdXUe^TUb\iY^W
YTUQYcQc_e^TgQid_U^XQ^SUS__`UbQdYfU
Y^YdYQdYfUcRUdgUU^dXUVUTUbQ\Q^TcdQdUZec
dYSUcicdU]c
S 5(&200(1'$7,21DXUUhUSedYfU
RbQ^SXcX_e\TRUU^S_ebQWUTd_TU
fU\_`cdQ^TQbTc_^gXYSXdXU:ecdYSU
4U`Qbd]U^dgY\\RQcUdXU`b_]e\
WQdY_^_V`b_cUSed_bYQ\WeYTU\Y^Uc
C`USYVYSQ\\icdQ^TQbTccX_e\TRUS_^
cYTUbUT±
QdXQdQbUS_^cYcdU^dgYdXc_e^TZe
bYcTYSdY_^Q\R_e^TQbYUcV_bVUTUbQ\
SbY]Y^Q\`b_cUSedY_^QcTUcSbYRUTY^
BUS_]]U^TQdY_^"+Q^T
Re^TUbgXYSXdXU`_dU^dYQ\V_b
XQbcXUbVUTUbQ\cU^dU^SY^W`_\YSYUcQ^T
WbUQdUbSQ`QSYdiY^dXUVUTUbQ\`bYc_^c
g_e\TRUY^ceVVYSYU^dWb_e^TcRi
dXU]cU\fUcd_gQbbQ^d`b_cUSedY_^
e^TUbQVUTUbQ\bQdXUbdXQ^QcdQdU
SbY]Y^Q\cdQdedU
DXUTUSYcY_^c_VVUTUbQ\`b_cUSed_bc
_^gXQd_VVU^cUcd_`b_cUSedUY^VUTUbQ\
S_ebdbQdXUbdXQ^cdQdUS_ebdQbUQcSbeSYQ\d_
dXUceSSUcc_VZeTYSYQ\VUTUbQ\Yc]QcQ^i
S_^WbUccY_^Q\QSdY_^9^bUSU^diUQbcUh
USedYfURbQ^SX`_\YSYUcXQfU_SSQcY_^Q\\i
Q\\_gUT`b_cUSed_bcd_RbY^WVUTUbQ\SbY]Y
^Q\SQcUcRQcUT_^VQSd_bce^bU\QdUTd_dXU
Q``b_`bYQdU^Ucc_VQVUTUbQ\V_be]1^
UcdQR\YcXUTUVVUSdYfUcUd_VWeYTU\Y^UcY^
V_b]UTRiVUTUbQ\Yc]`bY^SY`\UcS_e\T\Y]Yd
`b_cUSedY_^cY^VUTUbQ\S_ebdcd_dX_cU]Qd
dUbcgXUbU^QdY_^Q\Y^dUbUcdcQbU`QbQ]_e^d
Q^TQf_YTecY^WdXUVUTUbQ\cicdU]]UbU\iQc
QceRcdYdedUV_bcdQdU`b_SUUTY^Wc1]_^W
dXUWeYTU\Y^Uc]YWXdRUdXUV_\\_gY^WSbYdU
bYQV_bVUTUbQ\`b_cUSedY_^*
! _VVU^cUcS_]]_^\i`b_cUSedUTY^cdQdU
S_ebdUWVYbUQb]_bTbeW_VVU^cUc
cX_e\T^_dRUVUTUbQ\\i`b_cUSedUTQR
cU^dQTU]_^cdbQdUTVUTUbQ\Y^dUbUcd
RUi_^TdXU]UbUfY_\QdY_^_VQVUTUbQ\
cdQdedU+
" `bY_bYdYUccX_e\TRUcUdY^bUS_W^YdY_^_V
\Y]YdUTVUTUbQ\S_ebdbUc_ebSUcQ^TX_g
dXUiSQ^RUecUT]_cdUVVUSdYfU\i+Q^T
# dQbWUdcV_bVUTUbQ\Y^fUcdYWQdY_^cX_e\T
RUcU\USdUTY^QSS_bTQ^SUgYdX`b_cUSe
d_bYQ\`_\YSYUcYUY^fUcdYWQdU_^\idX_cU
7KH-XGLFLDO&RQIHUHQFHRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVKDVDSSURYHGWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGLPSOHPHQWDWLRQVWUDWHJLHVLQWKLV/RQJ5DQJH3ODQWRJXLGHIXWXUH
DGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQDQGSROLF\GHYHORSPHQWE\WKH&RQIHUHQFHDQGRWKHUMXGLFLDOEUDQFKDXWKRULWLHV$OORWKHUWH[WLQWKLV3ODQLQFOXGLQJFRPPHQWDU\RQ
LQGLYLGXDOUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGVWUDWHJLHVH[SODLQVDQGVXSSOHPHQWVWKHDSSURYHGLWHPVEXWGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\UHIOHFWWKHYLHZVRIWKH&RQIHUHQFH
æ /21*5$1*(3/$1)257+()('(5$/&28576
QSdYfYdYUcdXQd]YWXd`b_`Ub\iRUdXU
ceRZUSd_VVUTUbQ\`b_cUSedY_^
&LYLO3URFHHGLQJV
S 5(&200(1'$7,213_^WbUcc
cX_e\TRUU^S_ebQWUTd_UhUbSYcU
bUcdbQY^dY^dXUU^QSd]U^d_V^UgcdQd
edUcdXQdQccYW^SYfY\ZebYcTYSdY_^d_dXU
VUTUbQ\S_ebdcQ^TcX_e\TT_c__^\id_
VebdXUbS\UQb\iTUVY^UTQ^TZecdYVYUT
VUTUbQ\Y^dUbUcdc6UTUbQ\S_ebdZebYc
TYSdY_^cX_e\TUhdU^T_^\id_SYfY\
]QddUbcdXQd±
QQbYcUe^TUbdXUE^YdUTCdQdUc3_^
cdYdedY_^+
DXUbUYc^_cUbY_ecTURQdUdXQddXU
VUTUbQ\S_ebdccX_e\TRUSXQbWUTgYdXdXU
S_bUTedi_VU^V_bSY^WQ^TY^dUb`bUdY^WdXU
VUTUbQ\S_^cdYdedY_^?^U_VdXUVUTUbQ\
S_ebdc`bY^SY`Q\b_\UcYcd_QbdYSe\QdUdXU
^QdY_^cVe^TQ]U^dQ\cdbeSdebU_VW_fUb^
]U^dQ^TYdce^TUb\iY^WfQ\eUcY^S\eTY^W
dXU`bUcUbfQdY_^_VY^TYfYTeQ\bYWXdcQ^T
\YRUbdYUcV_e^TY^dXU2Y\\_VBYWXdcQ^TceR
cUaeU^dQ]U^T]U^dc1^_dXUbcY]Y\Qbb_\U
YcdXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdc`b_dUSdY_^±dXb_eWX
dXUgbYd_VXQRUQcS_b`ec±_V`Ubc_^cXU\T
Y^fY_\QdY_^_VdXU3_^cdYdedY_^_bVUTUbQ\
\Qg
RTUcUbfUQTZeTYSQdY_^Y^QVUTUbQ\
ZeTYSYQ\V_be]RUSQecUdXUYcceUc
`bUcU^dUTSQ^^_dRUTUQ\dgYdXcQdYc
VQSd_bY\iQddXUcdQdU\UfU\Q^TY^f_\fU
UYdXUb!Qcdb_^W^UUTV_be^YV_b]Ydi
_b"`QbQ]_e^dVUTUbQ\Y^dUbUcdc+
1cYW^YVYSQ^d`UbSU^dQWU_VdXUVUT
UbQ\S_ebdcT_S[UdY^f_\fUcS\QY]cQbYcY^W
e^TUbVUTUbQ\cdQdedUcDXYc`Qbd_VdXU
T_S[UdXQcWb_g^cdUQTY\i_fUbdXUiUQbc
TeUY^\QbWU`Qbdd_dXUdU^TU^Si_V3_^WbUcc
d_SbUQdUQTTYdY_^Q\VUTUbQ\SQecUc_VQSdY_^
Q^Td_`b_fYTUQVUTUbQ\ZeTYSYQ\V_be]DXYc
SbYdUbY_^YTU^dYVYUcdg_WU^UbQ\SYbSe]
cdQ^SUcY^gXYSXVUTUbQ\cdQded_bi\QgcX_e\T
`b_fYTUQ^1bdYS\U999V_be]
DXUcdb_^W^UUTV_be^YV_b]Ydi
cdQ^TQbTU^S_ebQWUc3_^WbUccd_RUSQedY_ec
Y^VUTUbQ\YjY^WUfUbi]QddUbdXQdSQ`debUc
dXU^QdY_^cQddU^dY_^9dSQ\\cV_b3_^WbUcc
d_T_c__^\igXU^e^YV_b]bUc_\edY_^YcbU
aeYbUT_^Q^YcceUdXQdXQc^_dRUU^Q^T
S\UQb\iSQ^^_dRUbUc_\fUTcQdYcVQSd_bY\i
QddXUcdQdU\UfU\DXURebTU^d_cQdYcVidXYc
cX_gY^WcX_e\TRUQXYWX_^UYVdXUS_bU
fQ\eUc_VdXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdcQbUd_RU`bU
cUbfUT3QcUcRb_eWXde^TUbdXU`QdU^d
dbQTU]Qb[Q^TS_`ibYWXd\QgcQbUZecdQVUg
UhQ]`\Uc_VSQdUW_bYUc_VSQcUccQdYcViY^W
dXYcXYWXcdQ^TQbT
DXU`QbQ]_e^dY^dUbUcdcdQ^TQbTYc
Y^dU^TUTd_QSS_e^dV_bdX_cUQbUQcY^gXYSX
dXUZecdYVYSQdY_^V_bQVUTUbQ\ZeTYSYQ\V_be]
YcdYUT^_dc_]eSXd_Q^UUTV_be^YV_b]Ydi
Redd_dXUSbYdYSQ\Y]`_bdQ^SU_ebVUTUbQ\
W_fUb^]U^dQddQSXUcd_SUbdQY^c_SYUdQ\fQ\
eUc
<UWYc\QdY_^`b_dUSdY^WdXUU^fYb_^
]U^dQ^TdXUVbUU]Qb[UdcicdU]Q^T
QedX_bYjY^WVUTUbQ\S_ebdZebYcTYSdY_^XQc
QbYcU^Y^bUc`_^cUd_dXU^QdY_^ccdb_^W
Y^dUbUcdY^dXUcU]QddUbc<UWYc\QdY_^`b_
dUSdY^WVe^TQ]U^dQ\bYWXdcQ^T\YRUbdYUcQ\c_
VQ\\cgYdXY^dXYcSQdUW_bi6_bUhQ]`\UdXU
VUTUbQ\S_ebdcXQfU`\QiUTQfYdQ\b_\UY^
`b_]_dY^WSYfY\bYWXdcQ^TY^U\Y]Y^QdY^WY^
fYTY_ecTYcSbY]Y^QdY_^Y^Q\\`Qbdc_Vc_SYUdi
DXYcb_\UcX_e\TS_^dY^eU1ddXUcQ]UdY]U
3_^WbUcccX_e\TbUS_W^YjUdXQdQ\\cdQdU
ZeTWUcdQ[UQ^_QdXd_e`X_\TdXUEC3_^
cdYdedY_^Q^TdXUce`bU]QSi_VVUTUbQ\\Qg
1RcU^dQcX_gY^WdXQdcdQdUS_ebdcSQ^^_d
cQdYcVQSd_bY\iTUQ\gYdXQ^YcceU
3_^WbUcccX_e\TRUXUcYdQ^dd_U^QSd^Ug
\UWYc\QdY_^U^V_bSUQR\UY^dXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdc
7KH-XGLFLDO&RQIHUHQFHRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVKDVDSSURYHGWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGLPSOHPHQWDWLRQVWUDWHJLHVLQWKLV/RQJ5DQJH3ODQWRJXLGHIXWXUH
DGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQDQGSROLF\GHYHORSPHQWE\WKH&RQIHUHQFHDQGRWKHUMXGLFLDOEUDQFKDXWKRULWLHV$OORWKHUWH[WLQWKLV3ODQLQFOXGLQJFRPPHQWDU\RQ
LQGLYLGXDOUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGVWUDWHJLHVH[SODLQVDQGVXSSOHPHQWVWKHDSSURYHGLWHPVEXWGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\UHIOHFWWKHYLHZVRIWKH&RQIHUHQFH
&+$37(5-8',&,$/)('(5$/,60æ
Q^TcX_e\T^_dT_c_Y^Q^iUfU^dgYdX_edQ
S_^S_]YdQ^dbUTeSdY_^_VVUTUbQ\ZebYcTYSdY_^
Y^_dXUbQbUQc
dY_^cU^cebUcdXQddX_cUQb]c_VdXUVUTUbQ\
W_fUb^]U^dSQ^RUS_^VYTU^d_VQV_be]V_b
dXUe^YV_b]Y^dUb`bUdQdY_^Q^TQ``\YSQdY_^_V
VUTUbQ\\Qg
$SSURSULDWHVXEMHFWVRIIHGHUDOFLYLOMXULVGLFWLRQ
UY^f_\fUTYc`edUcRUdgUU^_bQ]_^W
dXUcdQdUc+_b
‡
FDVHVDULVLQJXQGHUWKH86&RQVWLWXWLRQ
‡
PDWWHUVGHVHUYLQJRIIHGHUDODGMXGLFDWLRQWKDW
LQYROYHHLWKHUDVWURQJQHHGIRUXQLIRUPLW\RUD
SDUDPRXQWIHGHUDOLQWHUHVW
‡
PDWWHUVLQYROYLQJIRUHLJQUHODWLRQVRIWKH8QLWHG
6WDWHV
‡
DFWLRQVLQYROYLQJWKHIHGHUDOJRYHUQPHQWLWV
DJHQFLHVRURIILFLDOV
‡
GLVSXWHVEHWZHHQRUDPRQJVWDWHV
‡
VXEVWDQWLDOLQWHUVWDWHRULQWHUQDWLRQDOGLVSXWHV
SY^f_\fUdXUV_bUYW^bU\QdY_^c_VdXU
E^YdUTCdQdUc+
6_bUYW^`_\YSiYcdXU`bUb_WQdYfU_V
dXUVUTUbQ\W_fUb^]U^dQ^TdXUVUTUbQ\
S_ebdccX_e\TRUdXUUhS\ecYfUdbYRe^Q\V_b
bUc_\fY^WTYc`edUcdXQdd_eSXe`_^bU\QdY_^c
_VdXUE^YdUTCdQdUcgYdX_dXUbS_e^dbYUc
TY^f_\fUdXUVUTUbQ\W_fUb^]U^d
VUTUbQ\_VVYSYQ\c_bQWU^SYUcQc`\QY^
dYVVc_bTUVU^TQ^dc+
1c_fUbUYW^]QiQ\gQicceUY^
Ydc_g^S_ebdc@b_fYTY^WQV_be]V_bbU
c_\fY^WQ\\TYc`edUcY^f_\fY^WdXUVUTUbQ\
W_fUb^]U^dYcS_^cYcdU^dgYdXdXU`_\YSi_V
`b_dUSdY^WdXUY^dUbUcdc_VdXUVUTUbQ\W_f
Ub^]U^dQcQc_fUbUYW^6UTUbQ\S_ebdcQ\c_
XQfUQ\gQicXQTZebYcTYSdY_^_fUbQSdY_^c
Rb_eWXdRi_bQWQY^cdQWU^SYUcQ^TVUTUbQ\
_VVYSUbcQbYcY^W_ed_VdXUYb_VVYSYQ\TedYUc
5hUbSYcU_VdXQdZebYcTYSdY_^_fUbceSXQS
1RcU^dQ^UedbQ\V_be]V_bbUc_\fY^W
TYc`edUcRUdgUU^_bQ]_^WdXUcdQdUccdQdU
W_fUb^]U^dc_SSQcY_^Q\\i]YWXdRUdU]`dUT
d_bUdQ\YQdUQWQY^cdUQSX_dXUbgXU^Q
TUSYcY_^Y^_^UcdQdUcS_ebdcicdU]XQTQ
cYW^YVYSQ^d^UWQdYfUY]`QSd_^dXU_dXUb9^
_bTUbd_`b_]_dUdXUc_\YTQbYdi_V_ebe^Y_^
QVUTUbQ\V_be]Yc^USUccQbid_bUc_\fUS_^
db_fUbcYUcRUdgUU^Q^TQ]_^WdXUcdQdUc
VQVVUSdceRcdQ^dYQ\Y^dUbcdQdU_bY^
dUb^QdY_^Q\TYc`edUc
:ecdQcdXUVUTUbQ\W_fUb^]U^dQ^T
YdcS_ebdcicdU]cX_e\TRUY^f_\fUTY^dXU
SbY]Y^Q\`b_cUSedY_^_VcYW^YVYSQ^d]e\dYcdQdU
_bY^dUb^QdY_^Q\QSdYfYdYUcYdYcQ``b_`bYQdU
V_bdXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdcd_bUc_\fUQ^TQTZeTY
SQdUSYfY\]QddUbccYW^YVYSQ^d\iQVVUSdY^W
Y^dUbcdQdUQ^TY^dUb^QdY_^Q\S_]]UbSU6_b
UhQ]`\UVUTUbQ\S_]]_^\QgZebYcTYSdY_^
_fUbTYc`edUcbU\QdY^Wd_^QfYWQR\UgQdUbc
TUbYfUcVb_]dXUVUTUbQ\W_fUb^]U^dc\U
WYdY]QdUY^dUbUcdY^ceRcdQ^dYQ\Y^dUbcdQdU
QSdYfYdYUc9^Qc]eSXQc_^U_VdXU`eb`_cUc
_VdXUVUTUbQ\W_fUb^]U^dYcd_V_cdUbQ^T
bUWe\QdUY^dUbcdQdUQSdYfYdidXUVUTUbQ\S_ebd
cicdU]YcQ^Q``b_`bYQdUV_be]V_bbUc_\fY^W
SYfY\TYc`edUc_fUbdX_cU[Y^Tc_VQSdYfYdYUc
S 5(&200(1'$7,213_^WbUcc
cX_e\TRUU^S_ebQWUTd_cUU[bUTeS
dY_^Y^dXU^e]RUb_VVUTUbQ\S_ebd
`b_SUUTY^WcY^gXYSXZebYcTYSdY_^Yc
RQcUT_^TYfUbcYdi_VSYdYjU^cXY`
dXb_eWXdXUV_\\_gY^W]UQcebUc*
7KH-XGLFLDO&RQIHUHQFHRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVKDVDSSURYHGWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGLPSOHPHQWDWLRQVWUDWHJLHVLQWKLV/RQJ5DQJH3ODQWRJXLGHIXWXUH
DGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQDQGSROLF\GHYHORSPHQWE\WKH&RQIHUHQFHDQGRWKHUMXGLFLDOEUDQFKDXWKRULWLHV$OORWKHUWH[WLQWKLV3ODQLQFOXGLQJFRPPHQWDU\RQ
LQGLYLGXDOUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGVWUDWHJLHVH[SODLQVDQGVXSSOHPHQWVWKHDSSURYHGLWHPVEXWGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\UHIOHFWWKHYLHZVRIWKH&RQIHUHQFH
æ /21*5$1*(3/$1)257+()('(5$/&28576
QU\Y]Y^QdY^WTYfUbcYdiZebYcTYSdY_^
V_bSQcUcY^gXYSXdXU`\QY^dYVVYcQSYdY
jU^_VdXUcdQdUY^gXYSXdXUVUTUbQ\
TYcdbYSdS_ebdYc\_SQdUT+Q^T
R_dXUbgYcU\Y]YdY^WTYfUbcYdiZebYc
TYSdY_^Ri

! Q]U^TY^WdXUcdQdedUcS_^VUbbY^W
_bYWY^Q\Q^TbU]_fQ\ZebYcTYSdY_^
_^dXUTYcdbYSdS_ebdcY^TYfUbcYdi
QSdY_^cd_bUaeYbUdXQd`QbdYUcY^
f_[Y^WTYfUbcYdiZebYcTYSdY_^
`\UQTc`USYVYSVQSdccX_gY^WdXQd
dXUZebYcTYSdY_^Q\Q]_e^dY^
S_^db_fUbcibUaeYbU]U^dXQc
RUU^cQdYcVYUT+
" bQYcY^WdXUQ]_e^dY^S_^db_
fUbci\UfU\Q^TY^TUhY^WdXU^Ug
V\__bQ]_e^dd_dXUbQdU_VY^V\Q
dY_^+Q^T_b
# Q]U^TY^WdXUcdQded_bic`USYVYSQ
dY_^_VdXUZebYcTYSdY_^Q\Q]_e^d
d_UhS\eTU`e^YdYfUTQ]QWUcVb_]
dXUSQ\Se\QdY_^_VdXUQ]_e^dY^
S_^db_fUbci
E^TUb1bdYS\U999_VdXU3_^cdYdedY_^
Q^T"(EC3’!##"dXUTYcdbYSdS_ebdcQbU
fUcdUTgYdX_bYWY^Q\ZebYcTYSdY_^_fUbS_^
db_fUbcYUcRUdgUU^±
! SYdYjU^c_VTYVVUbU^dcdQdUc+
" SYdYjU^c_VQcdQdUQ^TSYdYjU^c_bceRZUSdc
_VQV_bUYW^cdQdU+
$ QV_bUYW^cdQdUQc`\QY^dYVVQ^TSYdYjU^c_V
QcdQdU_b_VTYVVUbU^dcdQdUc
9^ceSXQSdY_^cdXUUhUbSYcU_VVUTUbQ\ZeTY
SYQ\`_gUbYcRQcUTc_\U\i_^dXUYTU^dYdi_V
dXU`QbdYUc^_d_^Q^iceRcdQ^dYfUbYWXdc
`bYfY\UWUc_bY]]e^YdYUcS_^VUbbUTRiVUT
UbQ\\QgE^TUbdXUT_SdbY^UUcdQR\YcXUTY^
5bYUBQY\b_QT3_fD_]`[Y^c(dXUceR
cdQ^dYfU\Qgd_RUQ``\YUTRidXUVUTUbQ\
S_ebdcY^ceSXSQcUcYcdXUcdQded_bi_bS_]
]_^\Qg_VdXUcdQdUY^aeUcdY_^
)URPWKURXJKGLYHUVLW\FDVHVDQQXDOO\
KDYHFRPSULVHGEHWZHHQSHUFHQWDQGSHUFHQW
RIDOOFLYLOFDVHVILOHGLQWKHIHGHUDOGLVWULFWFRXUWV
$SSUR[LPDWHO\SHUFHQWRIDOOFLYLOWULDOVLQWKH
IHGHUDOFRXUWVLQYROYHGLYHUVLW\DFWLRQV
4YfUbcYdiZebYcTYSdY_^SebbU^d\iQS
S_e^dcV_b]_bUdXQ^_^U_VUfUbiVYfUSYfY\
SQcUcVY\UTY^dXUVUTUbQ\TYcdbYSdS_ebdc
QR_ed_^U_VUfUbidg_SYfY\dbYQ\cQR_ed
_^U_VUfUbidU^Q``UQ\cQ^T]_bUdXQ^_^U
_VUfUbidU^T_\\QbcY^dXUVUTUbQ\ZeTYSYQ\
ReTWUd)DXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdcTYfUbcYdi
T_S[UdS_^cdYdedUcQ]QccYfUTYfUbcY_^_V
VUTUbQ\ZeTWU`_gUbQgQiVb_]dXUYb`bY^SY
`Q\Ve^SdY_^±QTZeTYSQdY^WSbY]Y^Q\SQcUc
Q^TSYfY\SQcUcRQcUT_^VUTUbQ\\Qg
@UbXQ`c^__dXUb]QZ_bS\Qcc_VSQcUc
XQcQgUQ[UbS\QY]_^VUTUbQ\ZeTYSYQ\
bUc_ebSUc=Q^iRU\YUfUdXU_bYWY^Q\ZecdYVY
SQdY_^V_bTYfUbcYdiZebYcTYSdY_^d_`b_dUSd
QWQY^cd\_SQ\`bUZeTYSUY^cdQdUS_ebdc^_
\_^WUbUhYcdc_bdXQdYdUhYcdcY^fUbiVUg
(
# SYdYjU^c_VTYVVUbU^dcdQdUcY^gXYSXSYdY
jU^c_bceRZUSdc_VQV_bUYW^cdQdUQbU
QTTYdY_^Q\`QbdYUc+Q^T
# $EC&$!)#(
DXU$)&)#TYfUbcYdiSQcUcVY\UTY^!))%]Qb[QTUS\Y^U
Vb_]dXU`UQ[_V&(""$VY\Y^WcY^!)((4YfUbcYdiZebYc
TYSdY_^X_gUfUbS_^dY^eUcd_`b_fYTUQceRcdQ^dYQ\`Qbd_V
dXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdcµSYfY\SQcU\_QTDXUbUQc_^V_bdXUbUSU^d
TUS\Y^UY^TYfUbcYdiVY\Y^WcYc^_dU^dYbU\iS\UQbdX_eWXQ
cYW^YVYSQ^dVQSd_bYcdXU!)()Y^SbUQcUY^dXUZebYcTYSdY_^Q\
Q]_e^dY^S_^db_fUbcibUaeYbU]U^dVb_]! d_
% )
7KH-XGLFLDO&RQIHUHQFHRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVKDVDSSURYHGWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGLPSOHPHQWDWLRQVWUDWHJLHVLQWKLV/RQJ5DQJH3ODQWRJXLGHIXWXUH
DGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQDQGSROLF\GHYHORSPHQWE\WKH&RQIHUHQFHDQGRWKHUMXGLFLDOEUDQFKDXWKRULWLHV$OORWKHUWH[WLQWKLV3ODQLQFOXGLQJFRPPHQWDU\RQ
LQGLYLGXDOUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGVWUDWHJLHVH[SODLQVDQGVXSSOHPHQWVWKHDSSURYHGLWHPVEXWGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\UHIOHFWWKHYLHZVRIWKH&RQIHUHQFH
&+$37(5-8',&,$/)('(5$/,60æ
SQcUc! 7YfU^dXUTYVVYSe\dYUcdXQdVUTUbQ\
ZeTWUcVbUaeU^d\iU^S_e^dUbY^`bUTYSdY^W
cdQdUceRcdQ^dYfU\QgQ^TdXUe^Qf_YTQR\U
Y^dbecY_^_VdXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdcY^dXYc\Qg
]Q[Y^WVe^SdY_^_VdXUcdQdUS_ebdc!!dXU
dXU_bUdYSQ\ZecdYVYSQdY_^cV_bTYfUbcYdiZebYc
TYSdY_^QbUUhdbU]U\igUQ[Y^S_]`QbYc_^d_
_dXUbQbUQc_VVUTUbQ\S_ebdQSdYfYdi!"
&KDQJHVLQWKHDPRXQWLQFRQWURYHUV\
UHTXLUHPHQWIRUGLYHUVLW\DFWLRQV
‡
HVWDEOLVKHGDW
‡
LQFUHDVHGWR
‡
LQFUHDVHGWR
‡
LQFUHDVHGWR
‡
LQFUHDVHGWR
CY^SU!)''dXU:eTYSYQ\3_^VUb
U^SUXQcce``_bdUTQR_\YdY_^_VVUTUbQ\
ZebYcTYSdY_^RQcUT_^TYfUbcYdi_VSYdYjU^
cXY`!#DXUbUXQcRUU^bU\QdYfU\i\Ydd\U
]_fU]U^dd_gQbTQddQY^Y^WdXQdW_Q\
4ebY^WdXUcQ]U`UbY_TdXU3_^VUbU^SU
XQc`ebceUTQfQbYUdi_VY^dUb]UTYQdU
]UQcebUcTUcYW^UTd_^Qbb_g_b\UccU^dXU
Y]`QSd_VTYfUbcYdiSQcUc_^dXUVUTUbQ\
S_ebdc1]_^W_dXUbdXY^WcYdXQcU^
!
CUU96545B1<3?EBDCCDE4I3?==9DD55G?B;9>7
@1@5BC1>4CE23?==9DD55B5@?BDC$"&#%
!!
CUU4_\_bUc;C\_fYdUb16UTUbQ\:eTWUFYUgc4YfUb
cYdi:ebYcTYSdY_^DXb_eWXdXU<U^c_V6UTUbQ\Yc]'(F1<
B5F!&'!!))"
!"
DX_cU_``_cY^WU\Y]Y^QdY_^_VTYfUbcYdiZebYcTYSdY_^
QbWeUYdc`UbSUYfUT`bQSdYSQ\RU^UVYdc*!SbUQdYfUY^dUb`\Qi
RUdgUU^VUTUbQ\Q^TcdQdUZebYcdcY^TUfU\_`]U^d_V
S_]]_^\Qg+Q^T"QfQY\QRY\Ydi_VQ\dUb^QdYfUV_be]cd_
U^XQ^SUUVVYSYU^dQT]Y^YcdbQdY_^_VZecdYSUd_\YdYWQ^dc
!#
CUUB5@?BD?6D85@B?35549>7C?6D85 :E49391<
3?>65B5>35?6D85 E>9D54CD1D5C()=Qb!)''+YT
Qd%"CU`d!)''+YTQd'=Qb!)'(+YTQd&&CU`d
!)')+YTQd!'=Qb!)(&+YTQd'"CU`d!)('CUU
Q\c_3_^VUbU^SU_V3XYUV:ecdYSUcBUc_\edY_^9%3
!)''Uh`bUccY^WcdQdUS_ebdcµgY\\Y^W^Uccd_bU\YUfU
VUTUbQ\ZeTWUc_VQ\\_b`Qbd_VdXUYbTYfUbcYdiSQcU\_QT
T_bcUTbU`UQ\_VTYfUbcYdiZebYcTYSdY_^V_b
SQcUcRb_eWXdRi²Y^cdQdU³`\QY^dYVVcUc
dQR\YcX]U^d_VXYWXUbcdbYSdUbQ]_e^dY^
S_^db_fUbcibUaeYbU]U^dcQ^TdbUQd]U^d_V
S_b`_bQdY_^cQc²SYdYjU^c³_VUfUbicdQdUY^
gXYSXdXUiQbU\YSU^cUT_bbUWYcdUbUTd_T_
RecY^Ucc!$
1\dX_eWXdXU3_^VUbU^SUµce^TUb\i
Y^W`_cYdY_^_^dXUYcceUbU]QY^ce^SXQ^WUT
dXYc`\Q^T_Uc^_dYTU^dYVid_dQ\U\Y]Y^QdY_^
_VdXUTYfUbcYdiT_S[UdQcQcdbQdUWYSW_Q\
DXYcYcc_V_bdg_bUQc_^c 9^dXUVYbcd`\QSUdXUVUTUbQ\Yc]
`bY^SY`\UcS_e^cU\Y^WQWQY^cdVUTUbQ\\YdYWQ
dY_^_VcdQdU\Qg]QddUbcT_^_dbUaeYbU
QR_\YdY_^_VTYfUbcYdiZebYcTYSdY_^Y^Q\\
SQcUc9^TUUT]_cdS_]]U^dQd_bcRU\YUfU
dXQddXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdccX_e\TbUdQY^TYfUbcYdi
ZebYcTYSdY_^Qd\UQcdY^QSdY_^cY^f_\fY^WQ\Y
U^c_bY^dUb`\UQTUb!%9dXQcQ\c_RUU^
ceWWUcdUTdXQd3_^WbUccS_^cYTUbUhdU^TY^W
TYfUbcYdiZebYcTYSdY_^Y^gQicdXQdS_e\T
VQSY\YdQdUdXUUVVYSYU^dS_^c_\YTQdY_^Q^T
bUc_\edY_^_V]Qccd_bd\YdYWQdY_^!&
CUS_^T\idXUbUQbU]Q^iR_dXY^
cYTUQ^T_edcYTUdXUVUTUbQ\ZeTYSYQbigX_
RU\YUfUdXQddXUXYcd_bYSQ\`eb`_cU_VTYfUb
!$
CUUB5@?BD?6D85@B?35549>7C?6D85 :E49391<
3?>65B5>35?6D85 E>9D54CD1D5C%&1`b!)'&+YTQd
'"CU`d!)('+YTQd"""#=Qb!)((+YTQd& CU`d
!)) +YTQd$($)CU`d!))#
!%
"(EC3’!##%!)((
!&
GXY\U_dXUbgYcUcUU[Y^Wd_SebdQY\_bU\Y]Y^QdUTYfUbcYdi
ZebYcTYSdY_^dXU:eTYSYQ\3_^VUbU^SUce``_bdcUcdQR\YcX]U^d
_V²]Y]Y]Q\³TYfUbcYdiSbYdUbYQd_Q\\_gVUTUbQ\S_ebd
S_^c_\YTQdY_^_V]e\dY`\U\YdYWQdY_^Y^f_\fY^W`Ubc_^Q\
Y^Zebi_b`b_`UbdiTQ]QWUQbYcY^W_ed_VQcY^W\UUfU^d CUU
B5@?BD?6D85@B?35549>7C?6D85 :E49391<3?>
65B5>35?6D85 E>9D54CD1D5C"!""=Qb!)((9^dXYc
S_^^USdY_^Q>QdY_^Q\3_]]YccY_^_^dXU6UTUbQ\3_ebdc
`b_`_cUTY^9]`\U]U^dQdY_^CdbQdUWi)!TY^VbQcX_e\T
S_^dY^eUdXUg_b[_VdXU1]UbYSQ^<Qg9^cdYdedUc3_]
`\Uh<YdYWQdY_^`b_ZUSd9dcX_e\TcdeTiQ^TbUS_]]U^T
Q``b_`bYQdU\UWYc\QdY_^Q^Tbe\UcbUfYcY_^cd_`b_fYTU*
!V_bdXUQWWbUWQdY_^_bS_^c_\YTQdY_^_VS\QY]cV_b`bU
dbYQ\Q^TdbYQ\+Q^T"V_bUh`UTYdUT]UQ^c_VRbY^WY^W
S\QY]cd_dbYQ\Y^gQicdXQdQbUS_^cYcdU^dgYdXdXUCUfU^dX
1]U^T]U^dQ^T`b_dUSddXUbYWXdcQ^TY^dUbUcdc_VdXU`Qb
dYUc
7KH-XGLFLDO&RQIHUHQFHRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVKDVDSSURYHGWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGLPSOHPHQWDWLRQVWUDWHJLHVLQWKLV/RQJ5DQJH3ODQWRJXLGHIXWXUH
DGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQDQGSROLF\GHYHORSPHQWE\WKH&RQIHUHQFHDQGRWKHUMXGLFLDOEUDQFKDXWKRULWLHV$OORWKHUWH[WLQWKLV3ODQLQFOXGLQJFRPPHQWDU\RQ
LQGLYLGXDOUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGVWUDWHJLHVH[SODLQVDQGVXSSOHPHQWVWKHDSSURYHGLWHPVEXWGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\UHIOHFWWKHYLHZVRIWKH&RQIHUHQFH
æ /21*5$1*(3/$1)257+()('(5$/&28576
cYdiZebYcTYSdY_^`b_dUSdY_^_V_ed_VcdQdU
\YdYWQ^dcVb_]\_SQ\`bUZeTYSUcdY\\XQc\Y]
YdUTfYQRY\Ydi1\dX_eWXdXQd`b_dUSdY_^
]YWXdRUQVV_bTUTY^dXU_biRi\Y]YdY^WTY
fUbcYdiZebYcTYSdY_^d_dX_cUSQcUcY^gXYSXQ
bUQc_^QR\U^UUTV_bQVUTUbQ\V_be]Yc
S\UQb\iTU]_^cdbQdUTceSXQc_\edY_^`_cUc
`bQSdYSQ\`b_R\U]c9dg_e\TbUaeYbUVUTUbQ\
S_ebdcd_TUdUb]Y^UdXUcecSU`dYRY\Ydi_VcdQdU
S_ebdcd_\_SQ\`bUZeTYSUQTYVVYSe\dY^aeYbi
gYdX_RfY_ec^UWQdYfUS_^cUaeU^SUcV_bVUT
UbQ\cdQdUbU\QdY_^c5fU^]_bUcUbY_ec\iYd
g_e\TcXYVdVb_]3_^WbUccd_dXUZeTYSYQbi
dXU`_gUbd_]Q[U²\UWYc\QdYfU³`_\YSi
SX_YSUcQR_edQ``b_`bYQdUQSSUccd_VUTUbQ\
S_ebdQ^TYd]YWXdc`Qg^²cQdU\\YdU³\YdYWQ
dY_^dXQdg_e\Te^TUbSeddXUTUcYbUT
bUTeSdY_^Y^VUTUbQ\ZeTYSYQ\g_b[\_QT!'
DXUQR_fUbUS_]]U^TQdY_^dXUbU
V_bUY^S_b`_bQdUcdXU`b_`_cQ\c_^TYfUbcYdi
ZebYcTYSdY_^Y^dXU!)) BU`_bd_VdXU
6UTUbQ\3_ebdcCdeTi3_]]YddUU!(DXYc
V_\\_gcdXU`bQW]QdYSfYUgdXQddXUTYfUbcYdi
T_S[UdgY\\RUU\Y]Y^QdUTYVQdQ\\dXb_eWXQ
WbQTeQ\`b_SUccGXY\U^_dQRQ^T_^Y^WdXU
dXU_bUdYSQ\W_Q\dXYc`\Q^cUU[cd_[UU`dXU
ZeTYSYQbiµcUVV_bdcV_SecUTQcdXUiXQfU
RUU^V_bcUfUbQ\iUQbc_^QddQY^]U^d_V
`bQSdYSQ\_RZUSdYfUcdXQdgY\\cUbfUdXU
Rb_QTUbY^dUbUcdc_VR_dXdXUVUTUbQ\Q^TcdQdU
S_ebdc3_^cYcdU^dgYdXBUS_]]U^TQdY_^
!$Q^iceRcdQ^dYQ\bUTeSdY_^_VdXUTYfUbcYdi
T_S[UdgY\\bUaeYbUQd\UQcdV_bQ\Y]YdUT
dY]UdXUS_^WbUccY_^Q\dbQ^cVUb_VbUc_ebSUc
!'
9dYc_VS_ebcUQ``b_`bYQdUd_U\Y]Y^QdUTYfUbcYdi
ZebYcTYSdY_^gXUbU`bUZeTYSUS\UQb\iYc^_dQ^YcceU9VQ^i
fUcdYWU_VdXUXYcd_bYSQ\`eb`_cU_VTYfUbcYdiZebYcTYSdY_^
bU]QY^c±YU`b_dUSdY^W\YdYWQ^dcQWQY^cd\_SQ\`bUZeTYSUY^
cdQdUS_ebdc±dXQdbQdY_^Q\UYcgX_\\iY^Q``\YSQR\Ud_dXUY^
cdQdU`\QY^dYVV1R_\YcXY^WTYfUbcYdiZebYcTYSdY_^Y^dXQd
Y^cdQ^SUYcVe\\iS_^cYcdU^dgYdX"(EC3’!$$!RgXYSX
Q\bUQTi`b_XYRYdcQ^Y^cdQdUTUVU^TQ^dVb_]bU]_fY^WQ
SQcUd_VUTUbQ\S_ebd_^dXURQcYc_VTYfUbcYdiZebYcTYSdY_^
9dcX_e\T^_dX_gUfUb`bUS\eTUQ^_ed_VcdQdUTUVU^TQ^d
Vb_]bU]_fY^WQTYfUbcYdiSQcUY^gXYSX_^U_b]_bU_VdXU
`\QY^dYVVcYcQSYdYjU^_VdXUcdQdUY^gXYSXdXUVUTUbQ\TYc
dbYSdS_ebdYc\_SQdUT
!(
B5@?BD?6D856545B1<3?EBDCCDE4I3?==9DD55#(
$"!)) d_dXUcdQdUS_ebdcc_dXQddXUiSQ^QSS_]
]_TQdUdXUY^SbUQcUTg_b[\_QT!)
,QWKHPRQWKSHULRGHQGLQJ-XQH
PRUHWKDQFDVHVEURXJKWXQGHUGLYHUVLW\
MXULVGLFWLRQ
³DSSUR[LPDWHO\SHUFHQWRIWKHWRWDOQXPEHURI
GLYHUVLW\ILOLQJVLQWKDWSHULRG³
ZHUHILOHGDVRULJLQDODFWLRQVE\LQVWDWHSODLQWLIIV
S 5(&200(1'$7,21DXUcdQdUc
cX_e\TRUU^S_ebQWUTd_QT_`dSUbdYVY
SQdY_^`b_SUTebUcgXUbUdXUiT_^_d
SebbU^d\iUhYcde^TUbgXYSXVUTUbQ\
S_ebdcR_dXdbYQ\Q^TQ``U\\QdUS_e\T
ceR]Yd^_fU\_bTYVVYSe\dcdQdU\Qg
aeUcdY_^cd_cdQdUce`bU]US_ebdc
CdQdUS_ebdSUbdYVYSQdY_^`b_SUTebUc
RU^UVYddXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdcRi_SSQcY_^Q\\i
bU\YUfY^WdXU]_VdXUdY]US_^ce]Y^WdQc[
_VTUSYTY^WaeUcdY_^c_V\Qg]_bUgYcU\i
\UVd±_^VUTUbQ\Yc]`bY^SY`\Uc±d_dXUcdQdUc
9^$#cdQdUcdXU4YcdbYSd_V3_\e]RYQQ^T
!)
3_]`\UdUU\Y]Y^QdY_^_VTYfUbcYdiSQcUcVb_]dXUVUTUbQ\
S_ebdcg_e\TQTTQ``b_hY]QdU\i% SQcUcQ^^eQ\\id_
dXU^UQb\i!%]Y\\Y_^SYfY\SQcUcUhS\eTY^WT_]UcdYSbU
\QdY_^c]QddUbcdXQdcdQdUS_ebdcXQ^T\UUQSXiUQbY^SbUQc
Y^WdXUYbSQcU\_QTRi_^\iQdXYbT_V_^U`UbSU^dCUU
14=9>9CDB1D9F5?66935?6D85E>9D54CD1D5C3?EBDC
:E49391<2EC9>5CC?6D85E>9D54CD1D5C3?EBDC±!))$
1>>E1<B5@?BD?6D8549B53D?B'DQR\U$+>1D9?>1<
35>D5B6?BCD1D53?EBDC5H1=9>9>7D85G?B;?6
CD1D53?EBDC!))#1>1D9?>1<@5BC@53D9F56B?=
D853?EBDCD1D9CD93C@B?:53D!!!))%1\dX_eWX
U\Y]Y^QdY^W²Y^cdQdU³`\QY^dYVVSQcUcQ^TY^SbUQcY^WdXU
Q]_e^dY^S_^db_fUbcibUaeYbU]U^dcg_e\TbUce\dY^Q^
UfU^c]Q\\UbY^SbUQcU`b_RQR\i\UccdXQ^_^UdU^dX_VQ
`UbSU^dcdQdUS_ebdVY\Y^Wc]Qi^_dY^SbUQcUe^YV_b]\iY^
^e]RUbQ^TS_]`\UhYdiQb_e^TdXUS_e^dbibUce\dY^WY^
TYc`b_`_bdY_^QdUg_b[\_QTRebTU^cY^c_]U\_SQdY_^cCUU
BU`_bd_VdXU:eTYSYQ\3_^VUbU^SU3_]]YddUU_^6UTUbQ\
CdQdU:ebYcTYSdY_^#($ 1``4CU`d!))#+FYSd_b5
6\Q^W_3bQYW2_UbcU]Q3XQ^WUcY^6UTUbQ\4YfUbcYdi
:ebYcTYSdY_^*5VVUSdc_^CdQdU3_ebd3QcU\_QTc!%E
41ID?><B5F$ %!)) 7KH-XGLFLDO&RQIHUHQFHRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVKDVDSSURYHGWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGLPSOHPHQWDWLRQVWUDWHJLHVLQWKLV/RQJ5DQJH3ODQWRJXLGHIXWXUH
DGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQDQGSROLF\GHYHORSPHQWE\WKH&RQIHUHQFHDQGRWKHUMXGLFLDOEUDQFKDXWKRULWLHV$OORWKHUWH[WLQWKLV3ODQLQFOXGLQJFRPPHQWDU\RQ
LQGLYLGXDOUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGVWUDWHJLHVH[SODLQVDQGVXSSOHPHQWVWKHDSSURYHGLWHPVEXWGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\UHIOHFWWKHYLHZVRIWKH&RQIHUHQFH
&+$37(5-8',&,$/)('(5$/,60æ
@eUbd_BYS_dXUS_ebd_V\QcdbUc_bdXQcUY
dXUb]Q^TQd_bi_bTYcSbUdY_^QbiZebYcTYSdY_^
d_S_^cYTUbcdQdU\QgYcceUce`_^SUbdYVYSQ
dY_^Vb_]QVUTUbQ\S_ebd" C_]URed^_d
Q\\_VdXUcUcdQdUc`Ub]YdS_^cYTUbQdY_^_V
aeUcdY_^cSUbdYVYUTRiQ^i1bdYS\U999S_ebd
1\\% cdQdUccX_e\TQedX_bYjUdXUVUTUbQ\
S_ebdcR_dXdbYQ\Q^TQ``U\\QdUd_U]`\_i
dXUcU`b_SUTebUcV_b_RdQY^Y^WQedX_bYdQdYfU
Y^dUb`bUdQdY_^c_VcdQdU\Qg
3bYdYSYc]XQcRUU^\UfYUTdXQdSUbdYVY
SQdY_^`b_SUTebUcU^WU^TUb\_^WTU\QicY^
dXUVUTUbQ\Q``U\\QdU`b_SUccQ^TXU^SUdXQd
dXUWQ]UYc^_dg_bdXdXUSQ^T\U3UbdYVY
SQdY_^`b_SUTebUccX_e\TRUQddU^dYfUd_
dXYc`b_R\U]Q^TVUTUbQ\ZeTWUccX_e\TRU
Q\UbdUTd_dXUQTfYcQRY\Ydi_VUhUbSYcY^WbU
cdbQY^d
S 5(&200(1'$7,213_^WbUccQ^T
dXUQWU^SYUcS_^SUb^UTcX_e\TRUU^
S_ebQWUTd_dQ[U]UQcebUcd_Rb_QTU^
Q^TcdbU^WdXU^dXUQT]Y^YcdbQdYfU
XUQbY^WQ^TbUfYUg`b_SUccV_bTYc
`edUcQccYW^UTd_QWU^SiZebYcTYSdY_^
Q^Td_VQSY\YdQdU]UTYQdY_^Q^TbUc_\e
dY_^_VTYc`edUcQddXUQWU^Si\UfU\
,PSOHPHQWDWLRQ6WUDWHJLHV
D
<UWYc\QdY_^cX_e\TRUbUaeUcdUT
d_Y]`b_fUdXUQTZeTYSQdYfU`b_SUcc
V_bC_SYQ\CUSebYdiTYcQRY\YdiS\QY]cRi
UcdQR\YcXY^WQ^Ug]USXQ^Yc]V_bQT
]Y^YcdbQdYfUbUfYUg_V1<:TUSYcY_^cQ^T
\Y]YdY^WdXUcS_`U_VQ``U\\QdUbUfYUg
Y^dXU1bdYS\U999S_ebdc
E
<UWYc\QdYfUQ^T_dXUb]UQcebUc
cX_e\TRU`ebceUTd_WYfUQWU^SYUcdXU
"
:?>17?<4C38=94D35BD96931D9?>?6AE5CD9?>C?6
<1G*6545B1<9C=9>@B13D935!%!(1]:eTYSQdebU
C_Si!))%TUcSbYRY^WdXUQedX_bYdiQ^TcS_`U_VcdQdU
SUbdYVYSQdY_^be\Uc
bUaeYcYdUQedX_bYdiQ^TbUc_ebSUcd_bU
fYUgQ^TgXUbU`_ccYR\UQSXYUfUVY^Q\
bUc_\edY_^_VTYc`edUcgYdXY^dXUYbZebYc
TYSdY_^
DXU\Y]YdUTbUc_ebSUc_VdXUVUTUbQ\
S_ebdcSQ^RUS_^cUbfUTY^`QbdRibUTeSY^W
dXUS_ebddY]UTUf_dUTd_VQSdVY^TY^WQ^T
bUfYUg_VQT]Y^YcdbQdYfUTUdUb]Y^QdY_^cdXQd
_VdU^deb^`bY]QbY\i_^VQSdeQ\YcceUc9V
QT]Y^YcdbQdYfUQWU^SYUcQbUd_cSbUU^Q^T
gXUbU`_ccYR\UbUc_\fUTYc`edUcRUV_bUdXUi
UfUbbUQSXQVUTUbQ\S_ebdYd]QiRU^USUc
cQbiY^c_]UY^cdQ^SUcd_Uh`Q^TQ^T
Y]`b_fUdXUQWU^Si`b_SUccY^dUb]c_V
c`UUTQSSebQSiQ^TS_]`\UdU^Ucc
3_^WbUccV_bUhQ]`\UcX_e\TRU
U^S_ebQWUTd_U^QSd\UWYc\QdY_^d_Y]`b_fU
bUc_\edY_^_VTYcQRY\YdiS\QY]ce^TUbdXU
C_SYQ\CUSebYdi1SdQc`b_`_cUTRi:eTWU
:_cU`X6GUYc:bQ^Tdg__dXUbTYccU^d
Y^W]U]RUbc_VdXU6UTUbQ\3_ebdcCdeTi
3_]]YddUU"!DXQd`b_`_cQ\S_^dU]`\QdUcQ
dX_b_eWXQT]Y^YcdbQdYfUbUfYUg_V1<:TUSY
cY_^cV_\\_gUTRi_``_bde^YdYUcV_bbUfYUg
_VQ\\YcceUcY^dXUTYcdbYSdS_ebdbUfYUg_V
S_^cdYdedY_^Q\YcceUcQ^T]QddUbc_VcdQded_bi
_bbUWe\Qd_biY^dUb`bUdQdY_^Q^TTYcSbU
dY_^QbibUfYUg_VceRcdQ^dYQ\UfYTU^SU
aeUcdY_^cY^dXUS_ebd_VQ``UQ\cQ^TTYc
SbUdY_^QbibUfYUgY^dXUCe`bU]U3_ebd
9]`b_fU]U^dYc^UUTUTY^_dXUb`b_
WbQ]QbUQcQcgU\\2USQecU_VcUbY_ec
e^TUbVe^TY^WdXU55?3V_bUhQ]`\UQS
S_bTcS\QY]c_VU]`\_i]U^dTYcSbY]Y^QdY_^
_^\iSebc_bibUfYUgRUV_bUYcceY^WbYWXd
d_ceU\UddUbc9VdXUbUc_ebSUcgUbU`b_
fYTUTV_bdXU[Y^T_VSQbUVe\Y^fUcdYWQdY_^
UfQ\eQdY_^Q^TS_^SY\YQdY_^_bYWY^Q\\iS_^
dU]`\QdUTRi3_^WbUccdXU^e]RUb_V
U]`\_i]U^dTYcSbY]Y^QdY_^SQcUcbUaeYbY^W
VUTUbQ\S_ebdQSdY_^]YWXdRUbUTeSUT9^
TUUTQ\\QWU^SYUcgYdXZebYcTYSdY_^_fUb
"!
B5@?BD?6D856545B1<3?EBDCCDE4I3?==9DD55%(
%)!)) 7KH-XGLFLDO&RQIHUHQFHRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVKDVDSSURYHGWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGLPSOHPHQWDWLRQVWUDWHJLHVLQWKLV/RQJ5DQJH3ODQWRJXLGHIXWXUH
DGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQDQGSROLF\GHYHORSPHQWE\WKH&RQIHUHQFHDQGRWKHUMXGLFLDOEUDQFKDXWKRULWLHV$OORWKHUWH[WLQWKLV3ODQLQFOXGLQJFRPPHQWDU\RQ
LQGLYLGXDOUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGVWUDWHJLHVH[SODLQVDQGVXSSOHPHQWVWKHDSSURYHGLWHPVEXWGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\UHIOHFWWKHYLHZVRIWKH&RQIHUHQFH
æ /21*5$1*(3/$1)257+()('(5$/&28576
fQbY_ec[Y^Tc_VTYc`edUccX_e\TRUU]`_g
UbUTQ^TbUaeYbUTd_S_^TeSd]_bUdX_b_eWX
bUfYUgQ^TU^S_ebQWUTd_bUc_\fUTYc`edUc
RUV_bUdXUi]QiRURb_eWXdd_dXUVUTUbQ\
S_ebdc
9]`\U]U^dQdY_^_VdXYcbUS_]]U^
TQdY_^X_gUfUbTU`U^Tc_^`b_fYTY^W
QTUaeQdUVe^TY^Wc_dXQdQWU^SYUcSQ^UVVUS
dYfU\ibUc_\fUQc]Q^iTYc`edUcQc`_ccYR\U
QddXUQWU^Si\UfU\UYdXUbdXb_eWXQ^QT
]Y^YcdbQdYfU`b_SUcc_bdXb_eWX`bYfQdU
]UTYQdY_^Q^TQbRYdbQdY_^cUbfYSUc9dQ\c_
bUaeYbUcS\UQbcdQded_biQedX_bYdiDXU
`bUcU^d1T]Y^YcdbQdYfU4Yc`edUBUc_\edY_^
1Sd""S\QbYVYUcQWU^SiQedX_bYdid_U]`\_i
Q\dUb^QdYfUTYc`edUbUc_\edY_^]UdX_Tc
Q^TU^S_ebQWUcdXUecU_VceSX]UdX_Tc 1\dX_eWXdXQdcdQdedUUh`YbUcdXYciUQb"#
3_^WbUcccX_e\TRUebWUTd_UhdU^TYdQcQ^
Y]`_bdQ^d]UQ^c_V`b_]_dY^WVY^Q\bUc_\e
dY_^_VTYc`edUcRUV_bUdXUibUaeYbUVUTUbQ\
S_ebdbUfYUg
QZebidbYQ\e^TUbdXUCUfU^dX1]U^T]U^d
DXYcQ``b_QSXYcTUcYbQR\UY^ceRZUSdQbUQc
gXUbUQS_^cYcdU^d\i\QbWUf_\e]U_VSQcUc
YcUh`USdUTQ^TY^YdYQ\S_^cYTUbQdY_^Y^Q
cY^W\UV_be]YcY]`_bdQ^dd_dXUe^YV_b]Ydi
_V`b_WbQ]QT]Y^YcdbQdY_^9dXQcRUU^edY\
YjUTY^QfQbYUdi_VS_^dUhdcV_b]Q^i
iUQbc"%
DXYcbUS_]]U^TQdY_^ebWUc3_^
WbUccgXU^U^QSdY^WRU^UVYdQ^TbUWe\Qd_bi
cSXU]Ucd_V_\\_gdXUXYcd_bYSQ\ceSSUcc_V
dXUUhYcdY^WcSXU]UcdXQdXQfU`b_fYTUT1b
dYS\U9S_ebdc_bQT]Y^YcdbQdYfUQWU^SYUcQc
dXUVYbcddYUbVQSdVY^TUbcDXUQ``b_QSX
S_^cUbfUcZeTYSYQ\bUc_ebSUcRi`b_fYTY^W
1bdYS\U999bUfYUgUbcgYdXQ^UcdQR\YcXUT
UfYTU^dYQbibUS_bTQ^T\Y]YdY^WdXUcS_`U_V
bUfYUg1\c_gYdXQ]_bUcdbUQ]\Y^UT
]USXQ^Yc]V_bY^YdYQ\TYc`edUbUc_\edY_^Yd
cX_e\TRU`_ccYR\UV_bQWU^SYUcd_U^V_bSU
Y]`_bdQ^dVUTUbQ\]Q^TQdUc]_bUUh`UTY
dY_ec\i
S 5(&200(1'$7,21GXUbUS_^cdY
dedY_^Q\\i`Ub]YccYR\U3_^WbUcc
cX_e\TRUU^S_ebQWUTd_QccYW^d_QT
]Y^YcdbQdYfUQWU^SYUc_b1bdYS\U9
S_ebdcdXUY^YdYQ\bUc`_^cYRY\YdiV_bQT
ZeTYSQdY^WdX_cUSQdUW_bYUc_VVUTUbQ\
RU^UVYd_bbUWe\Qd_biSQcUcdXQddi`Y
SQ\\iY^f_\fUY^dU^cYfUVQSdVY^TY^W
S 5(&200(1'$7,213_^WbUcc
cX_e\TRUU^S_ebQWUTd_U^QSd\UWYc\Q
dY_^d_±
9^QTTYdY_^d_cdbU^WdXU^Y^WdXU
UhYcdY^WQTZeTYSQdYfU`b_SUccUc_VVUTUbQ\
QWU^SYUc"$3_^WbUcccX_e\TRUU^S_ebQWUT
d_U]`_gUbQWU^SYUc_b1bdYS\U9S_ebdcd_
QTZeTYSQdUY^dXUVYbcdY^cdQ^SUdX_cUdi`Uc
_VSQcUcY^f_\fY^WW_fUb^]U^dRU^UVYdc_b
bUWe\QdY_^dXQdb_edY^U\ibUaeYbUceRcdQ^dYQ\
VQSdVY^TY^WQ^TT_^_dY]`\YSQdUdXUbYWXdd_
RbUaeYbUQWU^SYUcd_TU]_^cdbQdU
c`USYQ\SYbSe]cdQ^SUcV_bbU\YdYWQdY^W
Q^YcceUY^Q^QTTYdY_^Q\SYbSeYdgXU^Q
e^YV_b]`bUSUTU^dXQcRUU^UcdQR\YcXUT
Q\bUQTiY^]e\dY`\US_ebdc_VQ``UQ\c
""
%EC3’’%'!%(#!))$
@eR<>_! !%%"’!!! $CdQd"'#&"'$'$(
!)) QWU^SiQedX_bYdid_ecUTYc`edUbUc_\edY_^`b_SU
TebUce^TUbdXU1SddUb]Y^QdUc?Sd_RUb!!))%
"$
CUUBUS_]]U^TQdY_^)ce`bQ
"#
QWU^UbQ\\i`b_XYRYdQWU^SYUcVb_]
QT_`dY^WQ`_\YSi_V^_^QSaeYUcSU^SU
d_dXU`bUSUTU^dUcdQR\YcXUTY^Q`Qb
dYSe\QbVUTUbQ\SYbSeYd+Q^T
"%
CUUUW!%EC3’"!!))$6UTUbQ\DbQTU3_]
]YccY_^Q^T_dXUbQWU^SYUc+")EC3’!& !)((
>QdY_^Q\<QR_bBU\QdY_^c2_QbT+YT’&%)?SSe`QdY_^Q\
CQVUdiQ^T8UQ\dXBUfYUg3_]]YccY_^+#(EC3’'"%"
!)((Ce``F!))#3_ebd_VFUdUbQ^c1``UQ\c+$"
EC3’%(%!R!)((Ce``F!))#QTZeTYSQdY_^_V
^eS\UQbY^TecdbigXYcd\UR\_gUbS_]`\QY^dcRidXUCUSbU
dQbi_V<QR_b
7KH-XGLFLDO&RQIHUHQFHRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVKDVDSSURYHGWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGLPSOHPHQWDWLRQVWUDWHJLHVLQWKLV/RQJ5DQJH3ODQWRJXLGHIXWXUH
DGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQDQGSROLF\GHYHORSPHQWE\WKH&RQIHUHQFHDQGRWKHUMXGLFLDOEUDQFKDXWKRULWLHV$OORWKHUWH[WLQWKLV3ODQLQFOXGLQJFRPPHQWDU\RQ
LQGLYLGXDOUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGVWUDWHJLHVH[SODLQVDQGVXSSOHPHQWVWKHDSSURYHGLWHPVEXWGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\UHIOHFWWKHYLHZVRIWKH&RQIHUHQFH
&+$37(5-8',&,$/)('(5$/,60æ
1`_\YSi_V^_^QSaeYUcSU^SUd_
`bUSUTU^dUcdQR\YcXUTY^Q`QbdYSe\QbSYbSeYd
gXYSXc_]UQWU^SYUcceSXQcdXU4U`Qbd
]U^d_V8UQ\dXQ^T8e]Q^CUbfYSUc
dXU4U`Qbd]U^d_VdXUDbUQcebiQ^TdXU
>QdY_^Q\<QR_bBU\QdY_^c2_QbTXQfU
c_]UdY]UcV_\\_gUTe^TUb]Y^UcdXUVe^
TQ]U^dQ\`bY^SY`\UdXQdQ^Q``U\\QdUS_ebdc
TUSYcY_^_^Q`QbdYSe\Qb`_Y^d_V\QgYcS_^
db_\\Y^W`bUSUTU^dV_b_dXUbSQcUcbQYcY^W
dXUcQ]UYcceU9^TUUTQ`QbdVb_]YdcaeUc
dY_^QR\U`b_`bYUdiQ^TY^UVVYSYU^Si^_^
QSaeYUcSU^SUYce^VQYbd_\YdYWQ^dc]Q^i
_VgX_]QbU`b_cUgX_VbUaeU^d\iQbUe^
QgQbU_V`bUSUTU^dVQf_bQR\Ud_dXUYbSQcUc"&
3_^WbUcccX_e\TRUebWUTd_W_RU
i_^TcY]`\ibU`eTYQdY^WdXU`_\YSi_V
Y^dbQSYbSeYd^_^QSaeYUcSU^SU9dcX_e\TRU
Qc[UTd_U^QSd\UWYc\QdY_^dXQdUhSU`de^TUb
SUbdQY^c`USYVYUTUhSU`dY_^cWU^UbQ\\i`b_
XYRYdcQVUTUbQ\QWU^SiVb_]bU\YdYWQdY^WQ
`bUSUTU^dUcdQR\YcXUTY^Q`QbdYSe\QbSYbSeYd
bUZUSdY^WQWU^Si`_\YSiDX_cUUhSU`dY_^c
cX_e\TY^S\eTUSYbSe]cdQ^SUcgXU^QVUTUbQ\
QWU^SiYce^QR\Ud_cUU[bUfYUg_VQ`Qb
dYSe\QbTUSYcY_^±V_bUhQ]`\URUSQecUdXU
SQcUXQcRUS_]U]__d_^Q``UQ\Q^TfQSQdeb
XQc^_dRUU^WbQ^dUT_bRUSQecUdXUTUSY
cY_^_dXUbgYcUbUQSXUcQVQf_bQR\U_edS_]U
V_bdXUQWU^Si9^ceSXSYbSe]cdQ^SUcY^
dbQSYbSeYd^_^QSaeYUcSU^SUQ\\_gcQ^
QWU^Sid_SXQ\\U^WUQ^e^VQf_bQR\U`bUSU
TU^dY^Q\QdUbSQcUY^dXUcQ]USYbSeYd
dXb_eWXU^RQ^S_bCe`bU]U3_ebdbUfYUg
3_^WbUcccX_e\TQ\c_RUU^S_ebQWUT
d_UcdQR\YcXcdQ^TQbTcV_bTUSYTY^WgXU^Q^
QWU^SicX_e\TRU`Ub]YddUTd_bU\YdYWQdUQ^
YcceUY^Q^QTTYdY_^Q\SYbSeYdgXU^Qe^YV_b]
`bUSUTU^dXQcRUU^UcdQR\YcXUTY^]e\dY`\U
S_ebdc_VQ``UQ\c3_^WbUcc]YWXdbUaeYbU
Q^QWU^Sid_]Q[Uc_]UQTTYdY_^Q\cX_g
Y^W±V_bUhQ]`\USXQ^WUcY^c_SYUdQ\_b
"&
CUUB5@?BD?6D856545B1<3?EBDCCDE4I3?=
=9DD55%)& !)) TYcSeccY^WdXU`b_R\U]_V^_^
_dXUbbU\UfQ^dSYbSe]cdQ^SUc_bU]`YbYSQ\
TQdQ±RUV_bUbU\YdYWQdY^WY^Q^_dXUbSYbSeYd
Q^YcceUdXQdXQcbUSUYfUTdXUSQbUVe\cSbe
dY^iUW`eR\YcXUT_`Y^Y_^cQ^Te^YV_b]
Y^dUb`bUdQdY_^RicUfUbQ\`UbXQ`cdXbUU_b
]_bUQ``U\\QdU`Q^U\c3_^WbUccQ\dUb^Q
dYfU\iS_e\TbUaeYbUQ^QWU^Sid_`UdYdY_^dXU
Ce`bU]U3_ebdV_bSUbdY_bQbYRUV_bUbU\YdY
WQdY^WY^Q^_dXUbSYbSeYdQ^YcceUdXQdXQc
bUSUYfUTdXUSQbUVe\cSbedY^iQ^Te^YV_b]
Y^dUb`bUdQdY_^_VQ^e]RUb_VSYbSeYdc
S 5(&200(1'$7,213_^WbUcc
cX_e\TRUU^S_ebQWUTd_bUVbQY^Vb_]
`b_fYTY^WVUTUbQ\TYcdbYSdS_ebdZebYc
TYSdY_^_fUbTYc`edUcdXQd`bY]QbY\i
bQYcUaeUcdY_^c_VcdQdU\Qg_bY^f_\fU
g_b[`\QSUY^ZebYUcgXUbUdXUcdQdU
S_ebdcXQfUceRcdQ^dYQ\Uh`UbYU^SU
5hYcdY^WVUTUbQ\ZebYcTYSdY_^Y^dXUcU
]QddUbccX_e\TRUU\Y]Y^QdUTY^VQf_b
_VTYc`edUbUc_\edY_^_bS_]`U^cQdY_^
]USXQ^Yc]cQfQY\QR\Ue^TUbcdQdU\Qg
,PSOHPHQWDWLRQ6WUDWHJLHV
D 3_^WbUcccX_e\TRUU^S_ebQWUT
d_U\Y]Y^QdUVUTUbQ\S_ebdZebYcTYSdY_^
_fUbg_b[bU\QdUT`Ubc_^Q\Y^ZebiQS
dY_^cceSXQcdXQd`b_fYTUTRidXU
6UTUbQ\5]`\_iUbc<YQRY\Ydi1SdQ^TdXU
:_^Uc1SdgXUbUdXUcdQdUcXQfU`b_fU^
UVVUSdYfUY^bUc_\fY^Wg_b[UbS_]`U^cQ
dY_^TYc`edUcY^_dXUbY^TecdbYUcQ^T
_SSe`QdY_^c
E DXUZebYcTYSdY_^_VdXUVUTUbQ\
S_ebdcd_QTZeTYSQdUb_edY^US\QY]cV_b
RU^UVYdce^TUb5B9C1U]`\_iUUgU\VQbU
RU^UVYd`\Q^ccX_e\TRUQR_\YcXUTUhSU`d
gXU^Q``\YSQdY_^_bY^dUb`bUdQdY_^_V
VUTUbQ\cdQded_bi_bbUWe\Qd_bibUaeYbU
]U^dcQbUQdYcceU
QSaeYUcSU^SU
7KH-XGLFLDO&RQIHUHQFHRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVKDVDSSURYHGWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGLPSOHPHQWDWLRQVWUDWHJLHVLQWKLV/RQJ5DQJH3ODQWRJXLGHIXWXUH
DGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQDQGSROLF\GHYHORSPHQWE\WKH&RQIHUHQFHDQGRWKHUMXGLFLDOEUDQFKDXWKRULWLHV$OORWKHUWH[WLQWKLV3ODQLQFOXGLQJFRPPHQWDU\RQ
LQGLYLGXDOUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGVWUDWHJLHVH[SODLQVDQGVXSSOHPHQWVWKHDSSURYHGLWHPVEXWGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\UHIOHFWWKHYLHZVRIWKH&RQIHUHQFH
æ /21*5$1*(3/$1)257+()('(5$/&28576
F 1^i^UgS__`UbQdYfUVUTUbQ\cdQdU
`b_WbQ]d_UcdQR\YcX^QdY_^Q\cdQ^TQbTc
V_bU]`\_iUURU^UVYdcUWXUQ\dXSQbU
cX_e\TTUcYW^QdUcdQdUS_ebdcQcdXU`bY
]QbiV_be]V_bbUfYUg_VRU^UVYdTU^YQ\
S\QY]c8_gUfUbQ^iceSX`b_WbQ]
cX_e\TY^S\eTUUcdQR\YcX]U^d_VQ^QT
]Y^YcdbQdYfUbU]UTYQ\`b_SUccdXQd]ecd
RUUhXQecdUTRUV_bUQcdQdUS_ebdQSdY_^
]QiRUVY\UT
?fUbdXUiUQbc3_^WbUccXQc
`b_fYTUTV_bVUTUbQ\S_ebdbUc_\edY_^_VQ
fQbYUdi_Vg_b[bU\QdUTTYc`edUcdXQdY^f_\fU
UccU^dYQ\\icdQdU\QgaeUcdY_^cBQdXUbdXQ^
U^cebY^WQ^Uh`Ubde^YV_b]Y^dUb`bUdQdY_^
Q^TQ``\YSQdY_^_VVUTUbQ\\QgdXUQfQY\
QRY\Ydi_VQVUTUbQ\V_be]Y^dXUcUSQcUc
ceWWUcdc±Ubb_^U_ec\i±dXQdcdQdUS_ebdc
Q^TQWU^SYUcQbUY^QTUaeQdUd_dXUdQc[_V
`b_fYTY^WVQYbQTUaeQdUbU]UTYUc
5Qb\iUhQ]`\UcSQ^RUV_e^TY^dXU
6UTUbQ\5]`\_iUbc<YQRY\Ydi1Sd65<1
Q^TdXU:_^Uc1Sd±\UWYc\QdY_^dXQd_`U^UT
dXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdcd_g_b[UbY^ZebiS\QY]cY^
dXUbQY\gQiQ^T]QbYdY]UY^TecdbYUcbUc`US
dYfU\iDXUcUcdQdedUcgUbUU^QSdUTQdQdY]U
gXU^g_b[UbcS_]`U^cQdY_^cSXU]UcTYT
^_dUhYcd_bgUbUbUWQbTUTQcY^QTUaeQdU
DXQd`UbSU`dY_^Yc^_\_^WUbfQ\YTQ^T^_d
gYdXcdQ^TY^WdXQddXUcUSQcUcQbUc]Q\\Y^
^e]RUbdXUZebYcTYSdY_^_VdXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdc
e^TUbdXUcUcdQdedUccX_e\TRUU\Y]Y^QdUT
Q\\_gY^WS\QY]cRibQY\gQiU]`\_iUUcQ^T
cUQ]U^d_RUceRce]UTe^TUbcdQdU\Qg
1\dUb^QdYfU\iYVe^YV_b]VUTUbQ\bU]UTYUc
QbUbUWQbTUTQcTUcYbQR\UdXUicX_e\TRU
`b_fYTUTdXb_eWXVUTUbQ\\iQT]Y^YcdUbUT
g_b[UbcS_]`U^cQdY_^cicdU]c
1cY]Y\QbcYdeQdY_^UhYcdcgYdXbU
c`USdd_SUbdQY^\YdYWQdY_^QbYcY^We^TUbdXU
5]`\_iUUBUdYbU]U^d9^S_]UCUSebYdi1Sd
_V!)'$5B9C19^QTTYdY_^d_`b_fYTY^W
UhS\ecYfUVUTUbQ\S_ebdZebYcTYSdY_^d_U^
V_bSUVYTeSYQbi_R\YWQdY_^c`\Q^Ve^TY^W
'XULQJWKHVWDWLVWLFDO\HDUHQGLQJ-XQH
(5,6$DFWLRQV)(/$DFWLRQVDQG
PDULWLPHLQFOXGLQJ-RQHV$FWDFWLRQVZHUH
ILOHGLQWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWV,QWKHVDPH\HDUFLYLO
ILOLQJVLQWKRVHFRXUWVWRWDOOHG
Q^TfUcdY^WbUaeYbU]U^dcQ^T_dXUbS_^
WbUccY_^Q\]Q^TQdUc±]_cd_VgXYSXQ``\i
UhS\ecYfU\id_`U^cY_^`\Q^c±5B9C1
Q\\_gc`QbdYSY`Q^dcQ^TRU^UVYSYQbYUc_VU]
`\_iUUgU\VQbUUWXUQ\dXY^cebQ^SUQ^T
cUfUbQ^SU`Qi`\Q^cd_RbY^WQSdY_^cY^UY
dXUbVUTUbQ\_bcdQdUS_ebdd_bUS_fUbRU^UVYdc
TeUe^TUbdXUdUb]c_VdXU`\Q^Q^Td_U^
V_bSU_bS\QbYVi`\Q^dUb]c"'BUc_\edY_^
_VdX_cUSQcUcdeb^^_d_^dXUc`USYVYS
ceRcdQ^dYfU`b_fYcY_^c_V5B9C1_bYdce^
TUb\iY^WbUWe\QdY_^cRed_^S_^dbQSdQ^T
dbecd\Qg`bY^SY`\UcU]R_TYUTY^Q²VUTUbQ\
S_]]_^\Qg³TUfU\_`UTVb_]cdQdU\UWYc\Q
dY_^Q^TS_]]_^\QgE^TUbQcicdU]_V
ZeTYSYQ\VUTUbQ\Yc]dXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdccX_e\T
^_dRUY^f_\fUTY^dXUQTZeTYSQdY_^_VTYc
`edUcdXQdT_^_dbUaeYbUdXUYb`QbdYSe\Qb
Uh`UbdYcURUSQecUdXUiUccU^dYQ\\iY^f_\fU
Q``\YSQdY_^_VcdQdU\Qg
DXUcQ]UX_\TcdbeUV_bQ^i^QdY_^Q\
XUQ\dXY^cebQ^SU_b_dXUbU]`\_iUURU^UVYd
`b_WbQ]dXQd3_^WbUcc]QiUcdQR\YcXY^dXU
VedebU1`QbdVb_]SQcUcY^gXYSXc`USYVYS
VUTUbQ\bUaeYbU]U^dcUWQ^i`b_XYRYdY_^
_^TYcSbY]Y^Qd_biQT]Y^YcdbQdY_^_V`\Q^
RU^UVYdcQbUQdYcceUQcdQdUS_ebdcX_e\TRU
dXUc_\UV_be]V_b\YdYWQdY_^_Vb_edY^U
S\QY]cbU\QdY^Wd_RU^UVYdU^dYd\U]U^dD_
`bUfU^dQ^e^TeURebTU^_^dXUcdQdUZeTYSYQ\
cicdU]cQ^i`b_WbQ]_VdXYc[Y^TcX_e\T
Y^S\eTUQ^QT]Y^YcdbQdYfUTYc`edUbUc_\edY_^
`b_SUccdXQd]ecdRUS_]`\UdUTRUV_bUQ
S\QY]SQ^RU`ebceUTY^QcdQdUS_ebd
9^UQSX_VdXUcUcYdeQdY_^c3_^WbUcc
cX_e\TRUebWUTd_`b_fYTUQTUaeQdUbU
"'
CUU")EC3’!!#"QT!)((
7KH-XGLFLDO&RQIHUHQFHRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVKDVDSSURYHGWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGLPSOHPHQWDWLRQVWUDWHJLHVLQWKLV/RQJ5DQJH3ODQWRJXLGHIXWXUH
DGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQDQGSROLF\GHYHORSPHQWE\WKH&RQIHUHQFHDQGRWKHUMXGLFLDOEUDQFKDXWKRULWLHV$OORWKHUWH[WLQWKLV3ODQLQFOXGLQJFRPPHQWDU\RQ
LQGLYLGXDOUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGVWUDWHJLHVH[SODLQVDQGVXSSOHPHQWVWKHDSSURYHGLWHPVEXWGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\UHIOHFWWKHYLHZVRIWKH&RQIHUHQFH
&+$37(5-8',&,$/)('(5$/,60æ
c_ebSUcd_cdQdUZecdYSUcicdU]cc_dXQddXUi
SQ^XQ^T\UQ^iY^SbUQcUTRebTU^dXUcU^Ug
SQcUcgY\\RbY^W
&RQIURQWLQJWKH(IIHFWVRI$OORFDWLQJ
-XULVGLFWLRQ
,PSDFWRI/HJLVODWLRQ
S 5(&200(1'$7,21GXU^\UWYc\Q
dY_^YcS_^cYTUbUTdXQd]QiQVVUSddXU
VUTUbQ\S_ebdcTYbUSd\i_bY^TYbUSd\i
3_^WbUcccX_e\TRUU^S_ebQWUTd_
dQ[UY^d_QSS_e^ddXUZeTYSYQ\Y]`QSd
_VdXU`b_`_cUT\UWYc\QdY_^Y^S\eTY^W
dXUY^SbUQcUTSQcU\_QTQ^TbUce\dY^W
S_cdcV_bdXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdc
>UgSbY]Y^Q\\UWYc\QdY_^Y^UfYdQR\i
Y]`_cUcVY^Q^SYQ\Q^T_dXUbRebTU^c_^dXU
ZeTYSYQ\RbQ^SXQcc_SYQdUTgYdXdXUY^fUcdY
WQdY_^`b_cUSedY_^bUc_\edY_^Q^T
`e^YcX]U^d_VdX_cU_VVU^cUcGXY\UZeTWUc
VUU\dXUcURebTU^cTYbUSd\iYdYc_dXUb`Qbdc
_VdXUZeTYSYQ\cicdU]±`b_RQdY_^Q^T`bU
dbYQ\cUbfYSUc_VVYSUbc`eR\YSTUVU^TUbcQ^T
`Q^U\Qdd_b^UicQ^TS_ebdbU`_bdUbcY^dUb
`bUdUbcQ^TS\Ub[c±gX_QbU]_cdQVVUSdUT
<Y[UgYcUdXUU^QSd]U^d_V^UgSYfY\SQecUc
_VQSdY_^`b_TeSUcQTTYdY_^Q\S_cdcd_dXU
S_ebdcgXU^\YdYWQdY_^YcRb_eWXdd_QccUbd_b
TUVU^T^Ug\iSbUQdUTbYWXdc
1\dX_eWXc_]U_VdXUY^SbUQcUcY^
g_b[\_QTQbUQ\c_QddbYRedQR\Ud_Y^dUb`bUdQ
dY_^c_V\UWYc\QdY_^RidXUS_ebdcdXU]cU\fUc
dXUe\dY]QdU`_\YSi]Q[Y^WQedX_bYdi\YUc
gYdX3_^WbUcc9VdXUcQ]UY^cdYdedY_^dXQd
`b_fYTUcQReTWUdV_bdXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdc
dQ[UcdXUS_cdcQcc_SYQdUTgYdXZebYcTYSdY_^Q\
Q^T`b_SUTebQ\SXQ^WUcY^d_QSS_e^dg_b[
\_QT]QiRUQ\\_SQdUTd_dXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdcY^
Q]_bUbUQc_^UTbUc`_^cYR\U]Q^^Ub
2Ui_^TZebYcTYSdY_^Q\Uh`Q^cY_^c
3_^WbUccXQcY]`_cUTc`USYVYSTUQT\Y^UcV_b
ZeTYSYQ\QSdY_^Q^T_dXUb`b_SUTebQ\_bbU
`_bdY^WbUaeYbU]U^dc±UWdXUC`UUTiDbYQ\
1Sd_V!)'$Q^TdXU3YfY\:ecdYSUBUV_b]
1Sd_V!)) ±dXQdbUaeYbUdXUS_ebdcd_cXYVd
`bY_bYdYUcX_\TQTTYdY_^Q\XUQbY^Wc_b_dXUb
`b_SUUTY^WcQ^TQ\dUb]UdX_Tc_VSQcU
]Q^QWU]U^d1\dX_eWXdXUcUcdQded_bi
]Q^TQdUcT_^_dSbUQdU^Ugg_b[\_QTQc
ceSXdXUi`b_V_e^T\iQVVUSddXUQ\\_SQdY_^
_VZeTYSYQ\dY]UQ^T_dXUbbUc_ebSUc
'XULQJWKHSDVWTXDUWHUFHQWXU\ERWK&RQJUHVV³
WKURXJKPRUHWKDQSLHFHVRIQHZRUDPHQGHG
OHJLVODWLRQ³DQGWKHIHGHUDOFRXUWV³WKURXJKLQWHU
SUHWDWLRQRIFRQVWLWXWLRQDODQGVWDWXWRU\SURYLVLRQV
³KDYHFRQWULEXWHGWRDQHQRUPRXVH[SDQVLRQRI
IHGHUDOMXGLFLDOZRUNORDG
CY^SU!))!dXU1T]Y^YcdbQdYfU?V
VYSU_VdXUE^YdUTCdQdUc3_ebdcXQcce``\YUT
3_^WbUccgYdXZeTYSYQ\Y]`QSdcdQdU]U^dc_^
\UWYc\QdY_^`_dU^dYQ\\iQVVUSdY^WVUTUbQ\S_ebd
g_b[\_QTQ^TReTWUdcDXYc`b_SUcccX_e\T
RUS_^dY^eUTY^dXUX_`UdXQdbU]Y^TY^W
\UWYc\Qd_bc_VdXUS_cd_VdXUYb`_\YSiY^YdYQ
dYfUcgY\\bUce\dY^VUgUbQ^T]_bUdQY\_bUT
Uh`Q^cY_^c_VVUTUbQ\ZebYcTYSdY_^Q^TQbUS
_W^YdY_^dXQddXUS_ebdcSQ^^_dSQbbi^Ug
RebTU^cgYdX_edS_^S_]YdQ^dbUc_ebSUc_b
dXUbUTeSdY_^_VZebYcTYSdY_^Y^_dXUbQbUQc
DXYc`bY^SY`\UQ``\YUcQ\c_gYdXbUc`USdd_
dXU`_ccYR\UY]`QSd_VVUTUbQ\\UWYc\QdY_^_^
cdQdUZeTYSYQbYUccUUBUS_]]U^TQdY_^!$
Y^VbQ
S 5(&200(1'$7,219^S_^cYTUbY^W
]UQcebUcdXQdg_e\TcXYVdZebYcTYSdY_^
QgQiVb_]dXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdc_b`b_
fYTU^UgZebYcTYSdY_^dXb_eWXdXU
UcdQR\YcX]U^d_VS_^SebbU^dZebYcTYS
dY_^3_^WbUcccX_e\TQ\c_RU
7KH-XGLFLDO&RQIHUHQFHRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVKDVDSSURYHGWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGLPSOHPHQWDWLRQVWUDWHJLHVLQWKLV/RQJ5DQJH3ODQWRJXLGHIXWXUH
DGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQDQGSROLF\GHYHORSPHQWE\WKH&RQIHUHQFHDQGRWKHUMXGLFLDOEUDQFKDXWKRULWLHV$OORWKHUWH[WLQWKLV3ODQLQFOXGLQJFRPPHQWDU\RQ
LQGLYLGXDOUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGVWUDWHJLHVH[SODLQVDQGVXSSOHPHQWVWKHDSSURYHGLWHPVEXWGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\UHIOHFWWKHYLHZVRIWKH&RQIHUHQFH
æ /21*5$1*(3/$1)257+()('(5$/&28576
U^S_ebQWUTd_S_^cYTUbQ^TQTTbUcc
dXUY]`QSd_VdXU`b_`_cUT\UWYc\QdY_^
_^dXUcdQdUcC`USYVYSQ\\iYdcX_e\TRU
ebWUTd_

QS_^ce\dgYdXcdQdUQedX_bYdYUcQ^T
cdQdUZeTYSYQ\\UQTUbcY^TUVY^Y^WQ^i
^Ug\Y]Ydc_^VUTUbQ\ZebYcTYSdY_^+Q^T
R`b_fYTUVUTUbQ\VY^Q^SYQ\Q^T_dXUb
QccYcdQ^SUd_cdQdUZecdYSUcicdU]cd_
`Ub]YddXU]d_XQ^T\UdXUY^SbUQcUT
g_b[\_QTdXQdg_e\TbUce\dVb_]dXU
bUTeSdY_^_bU\Y]Y^QdY_^_VUhYcdY^W
VUTUbQ\S_ebdZebYcTYSdY_^_bdXUSbUQ
dY_^_V^UgS_^SebbU^dZebYcTYSdY_^
1cUh`\QY^UTQR_fUS__`UbQdY_^
RUdgUU^VUTUbQ\Q^TcdQdUQedX_bYdYUc
\UWYc\QdYfUUhUSedYfUQ^TZeTYSYQ\Yc
UccU^dYQ\d_ZeTYSYQ\VUTUbQ\Yc]±d_]QY^
dQY^Y^WdXUXQb]_^Y_ecQ^TS_^cYcdU^d
G8?<5dXQd8Q]Y\d_^U^fYcY_^UT"(DXU
`eb`_cU_V\Y]YdY^WVUTUbQ\ZebYcTYSdY_^Ycd_
`bUcUbfUR_dXdXUTYcdY^SdYfUb_\U_VdXUVUT
UbQ\S_ebdcQ^TdXUSbYdYSQ\b_\U_VdXUcdQdU
S_ebdcQcWU^UbQ\TYc`edUbUc_\edY_^V_be]c
9VR_dXU^TcQbUd_RUQSXYUfUT^_bUTeSdY_^
Y^VUTUbQ\ZebYcTYSdY_^_bUh`Q^cY_^_VS_^
SebbU^dcdQdUS_ebdZebYcTYSdY_^cX_e\TRU
e^TUbdQ[U^gYdX_edQ\c_U^cebY^WdXUcdQdUc
SQ`QSYdid_XQ^T\UdXUUhdbQRebTU^DXYc
bUaeYbUcR_dXUVVUSdYfUVUTUbQ\cdQdU
S_]]e^YSQdY_^")Q^TQS_]]Yd]U^dRi
3_^WbUccd_`b_fYTUcdQdUcgYdXdXU^USUc
cQbiVY^Q^SYQ\bUc_ebSUc
*URZWKRIWKH$UWLFOH,,,-XGLFLDU\
S 5(&200(1'$7,21DXUWb_gdX_V
dXU1bdYS\U999ZeTYSYQbicX_e\TRU
"(
D856545B1<9CD>_("Qd$)!1\UhQ^TUb8Q]Y\d_^
3\Y^d_^B_ccYdUbUT!)&!+cUU3XQ`dUb!ce`bQ
")
CUU3XQ`dUb)BUS_]]U^TQdY_^)"Y^VbQ
SQbUVe\\iS_^db_\\UTc_dXQddXUSbUQ
dY_^_V^UgZeTWUcXY`cgXY\U^_d
ceRZUSdd_Q^e]UbYSQ\SUY\Y^WYc\Y]
YdUTd_dXQd^e]RUb^USUccQbid_
UhUbSYcUVUTUbQ\S_ebdZebYcTYSdY_^
,PSOHPHQWDWLRQ6WUDWHJLHV
D DXU\Y]YdUTZebYcTYSdY_^_VdXU
VUTUbQ\S_ebdccX_e\TRU`bUcUbfUT
QcTUcSbYRUTY^BUS_]]U^TQdY_^c!
dXb_eWX!"
E DXU:eTYSYQ\3_^VUbU^SUcX_e\T
U]`\_ie`d_TQdUS_]`bUXU^cYfU]UdX
_Tcd_UfQ\eQdUZeTWUcXY`^UUTc
F DXU^UUTV_bQTTYdY_^Q\ZeTWU
cXY`ccX_e\TRUbUTeSUTdXb_eWXS_^db_\
_VVUTUbQ\S_ebdSQcU\_QTcQcTUcSbYRUT
Y^dXYc`\Q^Y^S\eTY^WdXUQ``b_`bYQdU
bUQ\\_SQdY_^_VSQcUcd_cdQdUS_ebdcQ^T
_dXUbV_be]cQ^TRi_`UbQdY_^Q\Y]
`b_fU]U^dcY^dXUS_ebdcdXQdY^SbUQcU
UVVYSYU^SigYdX_edcQSbYVYSY^WUYdXUb
aeQ\YdiY^dXUZeTYSYQ\g_b[`b_TeSd_b
QSSUccd_dXUbU]UTYUcQfQY\QR\U_^\iY^
QVUTUbQ\V_be]
9^bUc`_^cUd_Q^UfUbY^SbUQcY^WZe
TYSYQ\g_b[\_QTc_]UY^S\eTY^W\UWQ\
cSX_\QbcbU`bUcU^dQdYfUc_VdXURQbQ^TQd
dY]UcdXUVUTUbQ\ZeTYSYQbiYdcU\VXQfUcUU^
QTTYdY_^Q\ZeTWUcXY`cQcdXU[Uid_U^cebY^W
S_^dY^eUTQSSUccd_VUTUbQ\ZecdYSUDXU`_
dU^dYQ\bYc[c_VdXQdQ``b_QSXX_gUfUb
cX_e\T^_dRUYW^_bUTGXY\U^_QfQY\QR\U
TQdQY^TYSQdUQ`bUSYcU`_Y^dQdgXYSXdXU
VUTUbQ\ZeTYSYQbig_e\TbUQSXdXUVUQcYR\U
\Y]Ydc_^YdcWb_gdXYdYcQ``QbU^ddXQde^
\Y]YdUTY^SbUQcUcY^1bdYS\U999ZeTWUcXY`c
QbUVQbVb_]RUY^WQS_]`\UdU]eSX\UccQ^
Q``b_`bYQdUQ^cgUbd_g_b[\_QT`bUccebUc
D_dXUS_^dbQbiQVedebU_Ve^bUcdbQY^UT
7KH-XGLFLDO&RQIHUHQFHRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVKDVDSSURYHGWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGLPSOHPHQWDWLRQVWUDWHJLHVLQWKLV/RQJ5DQJH3ODQWRJXLGHIXWXUH
DGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQDQGSROLF\GHYHORSPHQWE\WKH&RQIHUHQFHDQGRWKHUMXGLFLDOEUDQFKDXWKRULWLHV$OORWKHUWH[WLQWKLV3ODQLQFOXGLQJFRPPHQWDU\RQ
LQGLYLGXDOUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGVWUDWHJLHVH[SODLQVDQGVXSSOHPHQWVWKHDSSURYHGLWHPVEXWGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\UHIOHFWWKHYLHZVRIWKH&RQIHUHQFH
&+$37(5-8',&,$/)('(5$/,60æ
,QWKHUHZHUHDXWKRUL]HGMXGJHVKLSVLQWKH
JHRJUDSKLFFRXUWVRIDSSHDOVDQGDXWKRUL]HG
GLVWULFWMXGJHVKLSV%\WKRVHILJXUHVKDG
JURZQWRFLUFXLWMXGJHVKLSVDSHUFHQWLQ
FUHDVHDQGGLVWULFWMXGJHVKLSVDSHUFHQW
LQFUHDVH
'XULQJWKHVDPH\HDUVDQQXDOGLVWULFWFRXUWILO
LQJVLQFUHDVHGE\SHUFHQWRQWKHFULPLQDO
GRFNHWDQGQHDUO\SHUFHQWRQWKHFLYLOGRFNHW
$QQXDOFRXUWRIDSSHDOVILOLQJVLQFUHDVHGE\
SHUFHQW
Wb_gdXg_e\TQ\dUbYbbUf_SQR\idXU^QdebU
_VdXUZeTYSYQ\Y^cdYdedY_^Q^TY]`_cUQceR
cdQ^dYQ\RebTU^_^dXUVUTUbQ\dbUQcebiY^
dUb]c_VQTTYdY_^Q\S_cdcV_bce``_bd`Ubc_^
^U\\_WYcdYSQ\ce``_bdQ^Tc`QSUQ^TVQSY\Y
dYUc
9dXQcQ\c_RUU^ceWWUcdUTdXQddXU
]_cdUVVUSdYfU]UQ^c_VSebRY^WWb_gdXY^
dXUVUTUbQ\ZeTYSYQbig_e\TRUQ^Y^V\UhYR\U
SQ`_bSUY\Y^W_^dXU^e]RUb_V1bdYS\U
999SYbSeYdQ^TTYcdbYSdZeTWUcXY`cGXY\UdXQd
Q``b_QSX]QiRU]UbYd_bY_ecY^dXU_biYd
g_e\T^_dQ\\_gdXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdcd_]QY^
dQY^R_dXdXUUhSU\\U^SUV_bgXYSXdXUiQbU
[^_g^Q^TQ``b_`bYQdUQSSUccd_VUTUbQ\
bU]UTYUc1^ic`USYVYS\Y]Ydg_e\TRUQbdY
VYSYQ\Q^T_VaeUcdY_^QR\UedY\YdiY^TUdUbbY^W
dXU\UWYc\QdYfUQ^T`b_cUSed_bYQ\`_\YSYUcdXQd
Y^SbUQcUdXUg_b[\_QT_VdXUVUTUbQ\S_ebdc
DXURUcdcdbQdUWiV_bU^cebY^WR_dX
QSSUccQ^TUhSU\\U^SUYcd_dbUQTQ]YTT\U
`QdXdXQdbUZUSdce^\Y]YdUTUh`Q^cY_^iUd
Qf_YTcQ`_\YSi_VjUb_Wb_gdXDXYc`QdX
]QiRUV_\\_gUTY^\QbWU`QbdRiS_^db_\\Y^W
Uh`Q^cY_^_VVUTUbQ\S_ebdZebYcTYSdY_^Qc
TUcSbYRUTUQb\YUbY^dXYcSXQ`dUb1ddXU
cQ]UdY]UdXUbU]ecdQ\c_RUbUcdbQY^dY^dXU
SbUQdY_^_V^UgZeTWUcXY`cDXUS_ebdcic
dU]]ecdUfQ\eQdUYdcZeTYSYQ\bUc_ebSU^UUTc
ecY^WV_b]e\QcQ^TcdQ^TQbTcdXQdQbUSebbU^d
Q^TdQ[UY^d_QSS_e^dQ\\bU\UfQ^dTQdQQ^T
VQSd_bc1TTYdY_^Q\ZeTWUcXY`ccX_e\TRU
bUaeUcdUT_^\iQVdUb_dXUbQ``b_`bYQdUQ\dUb
^QdYfUcXQfURUU^UhXQecdUTY^S\eTY^W
Y]`b_fU]U^dcY^SQcU]Q^QWU]U^dQ^TbU
Q\\_SQdY_^_VUhYcdY^WbUc_ebSUc
7KH-XGLFLDO&RQIHUHQFHRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVKDVDSSURYHGWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGLPSOHPHQWDWLRQVWUDWHJLHVLQWKLV/RQJ5DQJH3ODQWRJXLGHIXWXUH
DGPLQLVWUDWLYHDFWLRQDQGSROLF\GHYHORSPHQWE\WKH&RQIHUHQFHDQGRWKHUMXGLFLDOEUDQFKDXWKRULWLHV$OORWKHUWH[WLQWKLV3ODQLQFOXGLQJFRPPHQWDU\RQ
LQGLYLGXDOUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVDQGVWUDWHJLHVH[SODLQVDQGVXSSOHPHQWVWKHDSSURYHGLWHPVEXWGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\UHIOHFWWKHYLHZVRIWKH&RQIHUHQFH