Global J Res. Med. Plants & Indigen. Med. | Volume 2, Issue 1 | January 2013 | 30–39 ISSN 2277-4289 | www.gjrmi.com | International, Peer reviewed, Open access, Monthly Online Journal Research article A CLINICAL STUDY TO COMPARE VIRECHANA AND JALAUKAVACHARANA PROCEDURES IN THE MANAGEMENT OF VICHARCHIKA Dass Ranjip Kumar¹, Nayak Annada Prasad²* ¹ Assistant Professor, Dept. of Panchakarma, M.S.M. Institute of Ayurveda, B.P.S. Mahila Vishwa vidyalaya, Khanpur Kalan, Sonipat, Haryana, India ² Assistant Professor, Dept. of Kayachikitsa, M.S.M. Institute of Ayurveda, B.P.S. Mahila Vishwa vidyalaya, Khanpur Kalan, Sonipat, Haryana, India *Corresponding Author: E-Mail: [email protected] Received: 10/12/2012; Revised: 27/12/2012; Accepted: 03/01/2013 ABSTRACT Now-a-days, Vicharchika (one among 11 types of mild skin diseases as per Ayurveda) has become one of the prime skin diseases at general O.P.D. level due to offensive diet habits, fast life style, industrial and occupational hazard, repeated use of chemical additives etc. Ayurveda has a lot to offer in this regard since times immemorial. Virechana (Purgation) is the chiefly advocated, purificatory measure in this disease and so it was taken in the present study for treatment purpose. Considering Rakta dushti (vitiation of blood) in all types of skin diseases, Jalaukavacharana (bloodletting by Leech) provides excellent results by its ideal method to expel out the vitiated blood safely, quickly and effectively. In this study total 28 patients were randomly distributed into two groups, as Group – A, where the patients were given Virechana (purgation) by classical method followed by Gandhaka Rasayana (an Ayurveda medicine prepared from purified Sulphur) for 1 month and Group– B, where the patients were given four sittings of Jalaukavacharana for 1 month followed by Gandhaka Rasayana for 1 month. It was concluded that although Virechana (purgation) has provided significant relief in the symptoms of Vicharchika yet, Jalaukavacharana (bloodletting by Leech) has provided relatively better relief in most of the symptoms. KEY WORDS: Virechana (purgation), Jalaukavacharana Karma (bloodletting by Leech), Vicharchika (one among 11 types of mild skin diseases as per Ayurveda), Shamana drug (Palliation drugs) Cite this article: Dass Ranjip K, Nayak A P (2013), A CLINICAL STUDY TO COMPARE VIRECHANA AND JALAUKAVACHARANA PROCEDURES IN THE MANAGEMENT OF VICHARCHIKA, Global J Res. Med. Plants & Indigen. Med., Volume 2(1): 30–39 Global Journal of Research on Medicinal Plants & Indigenous Medicine || GJRMI || Global J Res. Med. Plants & Indigen. Med. | Volume 2, Issue 1 | January 2013 | 30–39 INTRODUCTION The skin is a highly complex organ which plays vital role in the body‟s general functioning. Skin is described as an ornament of the body in classics. The study of Indian medical classics reveals that all skin diseases were described under the broad heading of “Kushtha” (Skin diseases). According to Vagbhattaa(who wrote astanga hridaya), Kushtha (skin disease) (Vagbhatta, 4th AD) is a disease which involves breakage in the charm of skin. Sushruta (who wrote Susruta sahmita) has described Vicharchika (one among 11 types of mild skin diseases as per Ayurveda) as one of the Kshudra Kustha (11 mild skin diseases) (Susruta, 2000 BC). The Vicharchika simulate with Eczema. It is one of the blazing problems in the society as accurate medicament is not available to treat the disease and to control its reappearance. The Shodhana (Purification) therapy and Shamana (palliative medicines) treatment forms the core of this reputed discipline of medicine. Because of preventive, promoting, prophylactic and rejuvenating properties as well as providing a radical cure; Panchakarma (five purification procedures) is a very unique therapeutic procedure, serving as a Shodhana (purification) therapy. Virechana (Purgation) procedure has been selected for the present study, is chiefly advocated for purification measure in Vicharchika (one among 11 types of mild skin diseases as per Ayurveda) (Charaka, 200 BC). Though the pathology of kustha (Skin diseases) establishes raktadusti (vitiation of blood), Jalaukavacharana (bloodletting by Leech) is being advocated here to expel out the vitiated blood safely. With this point of view, a study was undertaken to evaluate the effects of virechana (purgation) and Jalaukavacharana (bloodletting by Leech) in the management of Vicharchika. MATERIAL AND METHODS A. Selection of Patients Total 28 patients fulfilling the criteria for diagnosis (mentioned below) of the disease were registered for the present study irrespective of the age, sex, religion, etc. Among these, 8 patients left full course of the treatment before the completion of the therapy. All patients were selected from the O.P.D. and I.P.D. of the Department of Panchakarma (five purification procedures). Institutional ethics committee has approved the trial on 24.05.11 with letter no. Inst. Ayu. /11/2447. B. Criteria for Diagnosis The patients were diagnosed on the basis of classical signs and symptoms (Kandu (itching), Pidaka (Eruption)), Shyavata (darkness of skin), Srava (secretion) etc.) of Vicharchika (one among 11 types of mild skin diseases as per Ayurveda) described in Ayurvedic classics. Inclusion criteria: Age less than 15 years and more than 70 years. Patients fulfilling the symptomatology of Vicharchika (one among 11 types of mild skin diseases as per Ayurveda), like Kandu (itching), Pidaka (Eruption), Shyavata (darkness of skin), Srava (secretion) etc. Exclusion criteria: Patients suffering from Diabetes Mellitus, Hypertension with hyperlipidemia, age less than 15 years and more than 70 years and patients having any other systemic disorders. Scoring criteria: Table -1, Kandu (Itching) Score 1 2 Grade Often mild type of itching (1–2 times in a day Moderate itching along with mild itching episode (1–2 times in a day) 3 Moderate itching along with moderate itching episode (3–4 times in a day) Severe itching episode (more than 5 times a day even) 4 Global Journal of Research on Medicinal Plants & Indigenous Medicine || GJRMI || Global J Res. Med. Plants & Indigen. Med. | Volume 2, Issue 1 | January 2013 | 30–39 0 1 2 3 Table -2, Daha (Burning sensation) No burning sensation even after rubbing Mild type of burning sensation, sometime and not disturbing normal activity After rubbing mild type of burning sensation Severe burning sensation disturbing normal activity 0 1 2 3 Table -3, Shrava (secretion) No discharge Moisture on the skin lesion Weeping from the skin lesion Weeping from the skin lesion followed by crusting 0 1 2 3 Table -4, Rukshata (Dryness/Roughness) No dryness (Snigdha) Dryness with rough skin (Ruksha) Dryness with scaling (Khara) Dryness with cracking (Parushang) 0 1 2 3 Table -5, Pidika (Eruption) No eruption in the lesion Scanty eruption in few lesion Scanty eruption in at least half of the lesion All the lesions full of eruption 0 1 2 3 Table -6, Vaivarnya (De-pigmentation) Nearly normal skin color Brownish red discoloration Blackish red discoloration Blackish discoloration Table -7, Raji (Thickening Of Skin) No thickening of the skin Thickening of the skin but no criss-cross marking Thickening of skin with criss-cross marking Severe lichenification 0 1 2 3 Grouping Pattern: The patients were randomly distributed in to 2 groups. Table -8, Distribution of 28 patients of Vicharchika (one among 11 types of mild skin diseases as per Ayurveda) in both groups Patients Total No. of Patients Group A Group B Completed 10 10 20 LAMA 05 03 08 Total 15 13 28 Global Journal of Research on Medicinal Plants & Indigenous Medicine || GJRMI || Global J Res. Med. Plants & Indigen. Med. | Volume 2, Issue 1 | January 2013 | 30–39 Group-A (Virechana (purgation) + Shamana (Palliative) drugs): Method of Virechana (purgation) (Dwivedi Acharya Mukundilal, 2008): Virechana (Purgation) was carried out as per classical indications. Purva Karma (preparatory procedure): Abhyantara Snehapana (Internal oleation) was carried out by Shuddha Ghrita (pure ghee)in increasing dose starting from 30 ml then in multiplication for a maximum of 7 days as per the conditions of Agni (digestive capacity) and Koshtha (bowel habit) of patient till the occurrence of Samyak Snigdha Lakshana (symptoms of proper oleation). Sarvang Abhyanga (whole body massage) and Mrudu Vaspa Sweda (mild fomentation by steam) were performed after getting the Samyak Siddha Snehapana lakshanas (symptoms of proper oleation) for 3 days in morning and evening the dose of 5 gm/day in Capsule form into three divided doses for the duration of 30 days with water as Anupana (adjuvant during intake of medicine). Group-B (Jalaukavacharana (bloodletting by Leech) + Shamana (palliative) drug ): Jalaukavacharana (bloodletting by Leech): In this group one sitting of Jalaukavacharana (bloodletting by Leech) was carried out on every week for four weeks. Number of Jalaukas (leeches) used per sitting were decided depending upon the condition of affected lesion. Shamana (Palliative) drugs: After completion of four sittings of Jalaukavacharana (bloodletting by Leech) the patients were given powder of Gandhaka Rasayana as a Shamana Yoga (palliative formulation) in the dose of 5 gm/day in Capsule form into three divided doses for the duration of 30 days with water as Anupana (adjuvant during intake of medicine). Criteria for Overall Effect of Therapy Pradhana Karma (main procedure) (Kasture H. S., (2004): After proper Snehana-Swedana (Oleation and fomentation), patients were given Virechaka Yoga (purgation drugs) on empty stomach. Virechana Yoga (medicines for purgation) (Charaka, 200 BC) was prepared by Triphala + Trivrita + Danti along with Eranda Taila and Icchabhedi Rasa (if needed). Pashchat Karma (post purification procedure): Samsarjana Krama (special dietary regimens after purgation) was given as per type of purification and in sequence mentioned by classics. Shamana (Palliative) drug: After completion of Virechana (purgation) process and Samsarjana Krama (special dietary regimens after purgation), the patients were given powder of Gandhaka Rasayana (Shastri Laxmipati, 2004) as a Shamana Yoga (Palliative formulation) in The total effect of the therapy was assessed considering the following criteria. Cured: 100% relief in the sign and symptoms with plain skin surface and significant changes in color of the affected skin lesion towards normal were considered as cured. Complete remission: More than 75% relief in the signs and symptoms were recorded as complete remission with marked improvement in pigmentation and thickening of the skin. Marked Improvement: 51–75% relief in sign and symptoms were considered showing marked improved with moderate improvement in pigmentation and thickening of the skin. Improvement: Patients showing improvement in between 26–50% in sign and symptoms with slight improvement of pigmentation and thickening of the skin was taken as improvement. Unchanged: Below 25% relief in sign and symptoms was considered as unchanged. Global Journal of Research on Medicinal Plants & Indigenous Medicine || GJRMI || Global J Res. Med. Plants & Indigen. Med. | Volume 2, Issue 1 | January 2013 | 30–39 Statistical Analysis: The information gathered on the basis of classical symptomatology was subjected to statistical analysis in term of mean (X), standard deviation (SD) and standard error (SE). Paired „t‟ test was carried out at P < 0.10, P < 0.05, P < 0.01, P < 0.001 significance level. The obtained results were interpreted as – Insignificant - P > 0.05 Significant - P < 0.05 Highly significant - P < 0.01, P < 0.001. DRUGS CONTRIVE: Snehapana (internal oleation): by Suddha Ghrita (pure ghee) 30ml/day increasing dose Abhyanga (oil massage): by Bala taila q.s. for twice 3 days Swedana (fomentation): by Baspa Sweda (steam bath) for 20 mins for twice 3 days Virechana Yoga (formulation for purgation) contains:- Triphala Kwatha (decoction of three herbal fruit): 100 ml - Trivrita Churna (powder of Operculina turpethum): 50 gm - Danti Churna (powder Baliospermum Montanum): 25 gm - Eranda Taila (castor oil): 50 ml - Ichchabhedi Rasa (an Ayurvedic medicine): 2 Tab. (S.O.S.) Samsarjan karma (special dietary regimens after purgation): by Peya, Vilepee (recipe made from rice) etc as per texts. For Virechana (purgation), drug was attributed in accordance with Charaka (the author of Charaka Samhita) in which combination of Triphala, Trivrit, Danti, Eranda Taila was given after considered necessary Snehapana (internal oleation) by Suddha Ghrita (pure ghee). Here Combination of medicine taken for Virechana (purgation), act like: Triphala (fruit of Terminalia chebula, Terminalia bellirica, and Emblica officinalis) is mild laxative in action, Trivritta (Operculina turpethum) has property to liquefy the Mala (fecal matter) of Annarasa (chyle), Danti (Baliospermum Montanum) acts as strong Virechaka (purgative) which cleans Annavaha Srotas (alimentary canal) by removing sticking Mala also and Eranda Taila (castor oil) provides soothing effect to intestinal mucosal membranes to ease Virechana (purgation). Jalaukavacharana (bloodletting by Leech) (Charaka, 200 BC) is the safest and scientific method amongst Raktamokshana (bloodletting) procedures. Merely Panchakarma (five purification procedures) is not the complete treatment, but it is just a preparatory procedure for application of medicaments; hence Gandhaka Rasayana (Shastri Laxmipati, 2004) (an Ayurveda medicine prepared from purified Sulphur) in the dose of 5 gm/day for 30 days for both groups is chosen as a Shamana (palliative) drug after the completion of Shodhana (purification) procedure. RESULTS Observations Observations of Group-A: Samyaka Snehana (proper oleation) was found on 7th day in 70.00% of patients. Total amount of Abhyantara Snehana (Internal oleation) was about 840 ml in 70.00% of cases. 40.00% of the patients showed Madhyama Shuddhi (medium purification). Observations of Group-B: Maximum 40% patients were used nearly 16–20 Jalauka (leech) during full course of treatment, whereas 30% patients were used 21–25 number of jalauka (leech), 10% patients were used 25–30 Jalauka (leech) and 20% patients were used 11–15 jalauka (leech). . Maximum 55% of Jalauka (leech) have been sucked for 1–2 h. The effect of both therapies in various symptoms of the diseases can be highlighted as follows - Global Journal of Research on Medicinal Plants & Indigenous Medicine || GJRMI || Global J Res. Med. Plants & Indigen. Med. | Volume 2, Issue 1 | January 2013 | 30–39 Sr. No. Table no.-9, The Effect of Therapies on Individual Signs and Symptoms Symptoms % of Relief Group-A 48.15 (>0.05) 57.15 (<0.05) 36.85 (<0.001) 61.89 (<0.01) 25.64 (<0.01) 61.11 (<0.01) 33.33 (>0.05) 24.98 (<0.05) Kandu (Itching) Daha (Burning sensation) Pidika (eruption) Srava (Secretions) Vaivarnya (De-pigmentation) Shotha (Inflammation) Rukshta (Dryness) Raji (Thickening Of Skin) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Group-B 69.70 (<0.001) 76.31 (<0.001) 58.35 (<0.05) 75.00 (<0.01) 38.24 (<0.001) 87.50 (<0.001) 55.17 (<0.01) 66.67 (<0.01) Graph No.-1, The Effect of Therapies on Individual Signs and Symptoms Table No.-10 : Overall effect on symptoms of Virechana Karma (Purgation) + Shamana Chikitsa (Palliative treatment) in Group-A Sr. No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Symptoms BT AT X % SD SE T P Kandu(n=10) Daha(n=10) Pidika(n=6) Srava(n=8) Vaivarnya(n=10) Sotha(n=10) Rukshta(n=10) Raji(n=9) 2.700 2.000 2.111 2.333 3.900 1.800 2.625 2.222 1.400 0.857 1.333 0.889 2.900 0.700 2.250 1.667 1.300 1.143 0.778 1.444 1.000 1.100 0.875 0.555 48.15↓ 57.15↓ 36.85↓ 61.89↓ 25.64↓ 61.11↓ 33.33↓ 24.98↓ 0.823 0.900 0.441 1.014 0.816 0.748 1.356 0.527 0.260 0.340 0.147 0.338 0.258 0.233 0.479 0.176 1.300 3.360 5.292 4.274 3.873 4.714 1.823 3.162 >0.05 <0.05 <0.001 <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 >0.05 <0.05 Global Journal of Research on Medicinal Plants & Indigenous Medicine || GJRMI || Global J Res. Med. Plants & Indigen. Med. | Volume 2, Issue 1 | January 2013 | 30–39 Table No.-11 Overall effect on symptoms of Jalaukavacharana Karma (Leech therapy) + Shamana Chikitsa (Palliative treatment) in Group-B Sr. No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Symptoms BT AT Kandu(n=10) Daha(n=10) Pidika(n=6) Srava(n=8) Vaivarnya(n=10) Sotha(n=10) Rukshta(n=10) Raji(n=9) 3.300 2.330 2.000 1.500 3.400 1.600 2.900 2.667 1.000 0.552 0.833 0.375 2.100 0.200 1.300 0.889. _ X 2.300 1.778 1.167 1.125 1.300 1.400 1.600 1.778 It can be observed from the above mentioned table that although Virechana (Purgation) has provided significant relief in the symptoms of Vicharchika (one among 11 types of mild skin diseases as per Ayurveda), yet, Jalaukavacharana (bloodletting by Leech) has provided relatively better relief in most of the symptoms. % SD SE t P 69.70↓ 76.31↓ 58.35↓ 75.00↓ 38.24↓ 87.50↓ 55.17↓ 66.67↓ 0.789 0.440 0.753 0.835 0.675 0.699 1.350 1.202 0.249 0.146 0.307 0.295 0.213 0.221 0.427 0.401 8.820 12.090 3.796 3.813 6.091 6.331 3.748 4.438 <0.001 <0.001 <0.05 <0.01 <0.001 <0.001 <0.01 <0.01 result in Group-B, Unchanged was noted in 30% patients of only in Group-A as shown on table no.13 and Graph no.2. The effect of all the therapies viz. Jalaukavacharana (Leech therapy) on the cardinal signs and symptoms of the disease was remarkable; however, Virechana (purgation) provided comparatively better relief. Overall effect of therapy This showed that Jalaukavacharana Karma (Leech therapy) is more effective in curing the disease in comparison to Virechana (purgation). Complete remission was found in 30 % patient of Group-B, Marked improvement was noted in 40% patients of Group-A and only 10% patients of Group-B, Moderate improvement was observed in 30% patient in Group-A where 60% shows improved effective Sr. No. 1 Table No.-13- Overall Effect of therapy in both groups Result Group-A % Group-B Complete remission 0 00 3 % 30 2 Marked improvement 4 40 1 10 3 Improvement 3 30 6 60 4 Unchanged 3 30 0 00 Global Journal of Research on Medicinal Plants & Indigenous Medicine || GJRMI || Global J Res. Med. Plants & Indigen. Med. | Volume 2, Issue 1 | January 2013 | 30–39 Graph No.-2, Total Effect of therapy in both groups Total Effect of Therapy in Both Groups 70 60 60 50 Complete Remission 40 40 30 30 30 Marked Improvement 30 Improvement 20 10 10 0 0 Unchanged 0 Group-A DISCUSSION Commonest age of occurrence of Vicharchika has been reported between 41–50 years. Cool atmosphere is much susceptible for eczematous patients. Vicharchika (one among 11 types of mild skin diseases as per Ayurveda) is Kaphapradhana Vyadhi. (Kapha dominant disease) (Charaka, 200 BC). So humid, cold, watery contacts may increases the symptoms of Vicharchika (one among 11 types of mild skin diseases as per Ayurveda). Excessive intake of Lavana (salty diet), Katu (pungent diet) and Madhura rasa (sweetening diet) are common causative factors for Vicharchika (one among 11 types of mild skin diseases as per Ayurveda). Viharaja Nidana (unlawful habit) like allergic factors and industrial pollutants can be considered as main causative factors behind the increasing incidence of Vicharchika. Same as Kushtha (skin disease), Vicharchika (one among 11 types of mild skin diseases as per Ayurveda) is also Tridhoshik (three basic constituent of body as vata, pitta and kapha) in which Kapha (one among three basic constituent) and Vata (one among three basic constituent) are dominant involved. Disturbed sleep is interesting symptoms of Vicharchika (one among 11 types of mild skin diseases as per Ayurveda), which leads Vata prakopa (vitiation of vata) and may further deteriorate the diseased condition. Hence, it becomes a vicious cycle. Leech saliva, contains Hirudin, which has property of anti coagulants. So it may be helpful in other skin diseases, Group-B obstructive blood disorders like Thrombosis, Hemangioma, and Gangrene etc. Probable Mode of Action of Virechana karma (Purgation): Snehapana (oleation) by virtue of its Doshotkleshana (vitiation of dosha) effects separates toxins accumulated in the patient‟s body by Nidanas (causes) like Viruddha ahara (food ingestion either in inappropriate way or quantity etc. and the separated Utklilshta Doshas (vitiated humours) are eliminated by Virechana (purgation). Virechana (purgation) might have removed the toxins from the cellular level, improving Jatharagni (Digestive fire) and Dhatvagni (hormones and enzymes), so that metabolism is normalized. Probable mode of action of Jalaukavacharana (bloodletting by Leech): Vicharchika (one among 11 types of mild skin diseases as per Ayurveda), is a type of Kushtha (Skin diseases) having Tridosha prakopa (vitiation of all the three doshas), pradhana Raktadushti (vitiation of blood dominantly) and Chirakari (chronic) manifestation. Sushruta (the author of Susruta Samhita) has given great emphasis to Jalaukavacharana (bloodletting by Leech) in the treatment of Raktapradoshaja Vyadhi (Blood originated disease), Tridosha Prakopajanya (vitiated all three body humours) and Chirakari (chronic) diseases. Jalaukavacharana (bloodletting by Leech) is Global Journal of Research on Medicinal Plants & Indigenous Medicine || GJRMI || Global J Res. Med. Plants & Indigen. Med. | Volume 2, Issue 1 | January 2013 | 30–39 better for the superficial blood (Avagadha grathita Rakta). Vitiated Rakta (blood) may be washed-out by application of Leeches after slight scraping on the lesion of Kushtha (skin disease). Thus; it is well proved that Jalauka (leeches) gives better effect in Raktaja Roga (Blood originated disease), or Kushtha (skin disease) on the basis of classical references. Jalauka (leech) sucks the impure blood only with ideal example of Swan by Vagbhatta (the author of Astanga Hridaya). Leeches when applied to the skin, sucks the blood at superficial level might be from capillaries or extra-cellular so it may be more impure than other body channels, Jalauka (leech) (Vridha Vagbhatta, 4th AD) can easily suck impure blood due to superficial distribution of veins. Leech application has counter irritant effect on the lesion, which creates new cellular division after removing dead cell layer, and result in reduction of local Swelling and Lichenification. Leech sucks blood from restricted area. When leech applied in only pathogenic area, then it can be said that leech expelled blood from where the pathological state is more. So ultimately blood of that area comparatively more vitiated than other area. Hence, it can be said that leeches give best effect in Vicharchika (one among 11 types of mild skin diseases as per Ayurveda) by expelling the morbid, vitiated Doshas (three basic constituent of body) and Dhatus (7 types of body tissues). The effect of therapy is not only by expelling the vitiated blood but also by leech that emits some enzymes in the wound. CONCLUSION It can be observed from the table number10 and 11 that although Virechana has provided significant relief in the symptoms of Vicharchika yet, Jalaukavacharana (bloodletting by leech) has provided relatively better relief in most of the symptoms. Most of the patients had reported in the chronic stage of Vicharchika. Negligence in early stage of eczema is common phenomenon observed in patients. Most of the affected sites for Vicharchika are lower feet, axilla and neck like skin folds regions. Relapsing nature of Vicharchika is most common, which suggest that, long term intensive therapy is necessary for eradication of the disease. Virechana (purgation) provides comparative better result in symptoms of Shushka Vicharchika (dry eczema) like, Shotha (oedema), Shyavata (secretion), Pidika (eruption), Raji (Thickening of Skin) etc. Jalaukavacharana (bloodletting by leech) is a choice of therapy for Sravi Vicharchika (wet eczema) symptoms like, Kandu (itching), Srava (secretion), Daha (burning) etc. Markedly improved was obtained in 40% of group-A, 10% of group-B. Improved was found in 30% in group-A, 60% in group-B. Only 30% of patients of group –A remain unchanged. The effect of all the therapies viz. Jalaukavacharana on the cardinal signs and symptoms of the disease was remarkable; however the Virechana therapy was provided comparatively better relief. ACKNOWLEDEMENT We acknowledge gratitude to Prof. Vijay Kaushik, Dean and superintendent of M.S.M. Institute of Ayurveda & Hospital, Khanpur Kalan for his extensive support in providing all resources in the OPD & IPD of the hospital. We express our gratitude to Dr. K.V.Singh, H.O.D, M.S.M. Institute of Ayurveda & Hospital, Khanpur Kalan for his inspiring spirit and parental affection besides his subject knowledge and direction that helped in accomplishing this work. We owe our thanks to our friends, hospital staffs, laboratory staffs, library staffs of M.S.M. Institute of Ayurveda and patients for their sincere support in this clinical trial. Global Journal of Research on Medicinal Plants & Indigenous Medicine || GJRMI || Global J Res. Med. Plants & Indigen. Med. | Volume 2, Issue 1 | January 2013 | 30–39 REFERENCES Charak, (200 BC), Charak Chandrika Hindi Byaksha, Tripathy Brahmananda, Charak Sahmita, 4th edition, Chaukhamba Surabharati Prakasana, 1995, Varanasi, Vol-I & II, Sutra Sthan24; Chikitsa Sthan-7, Dwivedi Acharya Mukundilal, Sharma Tarachanda and Mishra Bhairava, (2008) Ayurvediya Panchakarma Chikitsa: Chaukhambha Sanskrit Pratishthan, Delhi. PP-444–448 Kasture H. S., (2004), Ayurvediya Panchakarma Vijnan:, 8th edition, Shri Vaidyanath Ayurved Bhawan Limited, PP.294–300 Source of Support: Nil Shastri Laxmipati, (2004), Vidyotini Hindi Commentary, Shastri Brahmasankar, Yog Ratnakar, PP-501 Susruta, (2000 BC), Ayurveda Tatwa Sandeepika Hindi Commentary, Shastree Kaviraj Ambikadatta, Susruta Sahmita, 11th edition, Chaukhamba Sanskrit Bhawan, 1997, Varanasi, VolI, Nidan Sthana.- 5/5, PP -247. Vagbhatta, (4th AD), Vidyotini Bhasa commentary, Gupt Kaviraj Atridev, Astanga Hridaya, twelfth edition, Chaukhamba Sanskrit Bhawan, 1997, Varanasi, Nidan Sthana, 14/3,PP 271 Vriddha Vagbhata, (4th AD), Soroj Hindi commentary, Tripathy Ravidutta, Astanga sangraha, Chaukhamba Sanskrit pratisthana, 1996, Delhi, Sutra sthan-35/4, PP.600 Conflict of Interest: None Declared Global Journal of Research on Medicinal Plants & Indigenous Medicine || GJRMI ||
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz