Clinical Science (1985) 69, 681-686 68 1 The calmodulin content of the epidermis in psoriasis S . MAC NEIL, W . F . G . TUCKER*, R . A. DAWSON, S . S. BLEEHEN* A N D S . TOMLINSON Deparrmenr of Medicine, Clinical Sciences Cenrre, Norrhern General Hospital, Sheffield, U.K., and *Deparrmenr of Dermarology, Royal Hallamshire Hospiral, Sheffield, U.K. (Received 29 April128 June 1985; accepted 2 J u 1985) ~ Summary 1. The calmodulin content of epidermis was determined by assay of biologically active and radioimmunoassayable calmodulin in epidermal biopsy samples of 16 normal control subjects and 36 patients with psoriasis. 2. Calmodulin levels in the involved epidermis of patients with psoriasis were significantly greater than in epidermis of control subjects, with both methods of calmodulin measurement. Levels of calmodulin in the uninvolved epidermis were also elevated but to a lesser degree, achieving statistical significance only when measured by radioimmunoassay. However, the degree of correlation between the two measurements of calmodulin was poor for the patient samples, suggesting that each may measure a different form of calmodulin. 3. The specificity of the elevated calmodulin in psoriatic epidermis was investigated by measuring calmodulin in another unrelated tissue. Calmodulin activity in circulating peripheral blood lymphocytes of seven patients with psoriasis was similar to that found in the lymphocytes of ten normal volunteers. 4. The relationship between calmodulin and the hyperproliferative state of the psoriatic epidermis was investigated. No significant increase in calmodulin activity was found after mitogen stimulation of lymphocyte proliferation or after Sellotape-stripping of the epidermis by a protocol which has been shown to cause hyperproliferation of the epidermis. Correspondence: Dr Sheila Mac Neil, Department of Medicine, Clinical Sciences Centre, Northern General Hospital, Sheffield S5 7AU, U.K. 5. Elevated calmodulin in psoriatic epidermis therefore appears to be a localized phenomenon of the disease and does not appear to be a consequence of the hyperproliferative state of the epidermis. Key words. calmodulin, epidermis, lymphocytes, psoriasis. Abbreviation: PHA, phytohaemagglutinin. Introduction Psoriasis, a disease characterized by hyperproliferation of the epidermis, affects up to 2% of the U.K. population. The cause of psoriasis remains unknown but many biochemical abnormalities have been described in the involved (and to a lesser extent in the uninvolved) epidermis of patients with psoriasis. Several of these features of psoriasis, greatly increased cellular proliferation [ 1,2], abnormal cyclic nucleotide metabolism [3], increased phospholipase A2 activity [4] and increased polyamine synthesis [S], are dependent on the action of the calcium dependent regulatory protein, calmodulin. Calmodulin is involved in the regulation of the enzymes governing all of these different processes [6]. Accordingly, an abnormality in the synthesis, activity or degradation of calmodulin could be a common denominator for these diverse biochemical abnormalities in psoriasis. Recently, immunoassayable levels of calmodulin were reported to be grossly elevated (30-fold) in the involved epidermis in psoriasis. Levels in the uninvolved epidermis were normal [7].Because of the potential importance of this finding, we recently sought to confirm it by measuring the 682 S. Mac Neil et al. levels of biologically active calmodulin, rather than immunoassayable calmodulin, in psoriatic epidermis. We found a sixfold increase in the levels of calmodulin activity present in both the involved and uninvolved epidermis of 16 patients with psoriasis compared with the epidermis of 12 control volunteers [8]. It was thought that this more modest increase in calmodulin might be attributable to the different assays used as discrepancies between calmodulin levels measured by radioimmunoassay and by activity assay have been reported previously [9]. There is also evidence that both assays may be underestimates of the absolute calmodulin content present in a tissue [ 101. The aims of the present study were threefold. Firstly, to explore the differences between the two reports of elevated epidermal calmodulin in psoriasis [7, 81 by comparing calmodulin levels measured by radioimmunoassay and by calmodulin activity assay in a larger group of patients. Secondly, to investigate the specificity of this increase in epidermal calmodulin by comparing the calmodulin levels in an unrelated tissue, peripheral blood lymphocytes, in control volunteers and in patients with psoriasis. Finally, we wished to investigate whether the increased calmodulin of psoriatic epidermis is related to the hyperproliferative state of the epidermis. For the latter, calmodulin levels were measured in control volunteers’ lymphocytes induced to proliferate by phytohaemagglutinin and in control volunteer epidermis induced to proliferate by means of Sellotape-stripping. Subjects and methods Subjects Epidermal biopsies were obtained from 36 patients with psoriasis (18 male, 18 female, mean age 44.5 years) and 16 normal controls (eight male, eight female, mean age 52 years). Etlucal Committee approval was obtained for this study. Of the patients, two had erythrodermic psoriasis, two had severe near-erythrodermic psoriasis affecting over 90% of the skin surface, two had stable plaque psoriasis affecting less than 5% of their skin, and the remainder had extensive chronic plaque psoriasis covering between 10 and 30% of their skin surface area (estimated by the rule of nines method). Only patients who had not had any form of systemic anti-metabolite or retinoid treatment were entered in the study and 14 patients had been off all treatment for over 1 week before biopsy. The remaining patients had used topical corticosteroid [ 101 and tar prepara- tions [ 1 13 before biopsy. None of the patients was receiving known calmodulin inhibitors. Venous blood for lymphocyte preparation was obtained from seven patients with chronic plaque psoriasis (three male, four female, mean age 37 years), three of whom had earlier given skin biopsies, and from 10 normal controls (six male, four female, mean age 34 years). Skin biopsy sampling Epidermal shave biopsies approximately 3 mm in diameter were cut freehand using a scalpel blade under local anaesthetic from clinically uninvolved skin and from psoriatic plaques. The forearm was the selected site in all patients and volunteers. Superficial scale was routinely removed before taking biopsy samples since, in pilot studies, psoriatic scale had been found to contain some calmodulin activity. Sellotape-stripping Epidermal biopsies were taken from six of the normal control volunteers from the medial aspect of the left forearm immediately before and 24 h after removal of the stratum corneum by 20 repeated applications and removal of standard cellulose tape (Sellotape). After this procedure, the skin had a glistening appearance indicative of removal of the stratum corneum. This stimulus has been shown to result in increased epidermal proliferation, as evidenced by increased [3H]thymidine uptake into interfollicular epidermal cells [ l l , 121, with the maximum increase in mitotic index occurring approximately 24-48 h post-stripping [ 131. Normal skin and non-involved psoriatic skin are known to react in a similar manner [ I l l . Calmodulin sample preparation Skin biopsy and lymphocyte samples were each stored and homogenized in 1 ml of 40 mmol/l Tris-HC1, pH 7.4, with 100 p o l l 1 CaC12, containing 50 mg/l phenylmethylsulphonyl fluoride and SOp1/1 pepstatin A, with approximatel-y 20 strokes of a tight glass Dounce homogenizer at 4°C. Aliquots of this homogenate were taken for protein determination by the method of Lowry et al. [ 141. (A rapid Coomassie blue protein assay we had used previously [8] for this purpose we have since found to underestimate the amount of protein present without prior solubilization and neutralization of homogenates.) The remainder of the homogenate was heated to 90°C for 6 min Elevated epidermal calmodulin in psoriasis and denatured protein removed by centrifugation. Recovery of [3H]calmodulin (Amersham International Ltd, Bucks., U.K.) in the supernatant was 95 k 1.3% (mean f SEM, n = 6) for epidermal samples homogenized and incubated with [3H]calmodulin before extraction. Supernatants were stored at -20°C before assay, which was usually within 7 days for assay of biologically active calmodulin. Radioimmunoassays for calmodulin were also performed in batches on these supernatants [after appropriate dilution with radioimmunoassay buffer] within 2-3 months of sample preparation. The stability of calmodulin in stored supernatants was confirmed by comparing calmodulin activity in seven supernatants assayed within 7 days of storage at -20°C (3.0620.9 pg of calmodulin activity/mg of protein, mean k SEM) with supernatants assayed after a minimum of 6 months storage at -20°C (3.27 k 1.27 pg of calmodulin activity/mg of protein, mean f SEM). Lymphocyte preparation 683 these lymphocytes (details as previously described [161). Assay of biologically active calmodulin Biologically active calmodulin was assayed as previously described [17] with a beef heart calmodulin-sensitive phosphodiesterase (Boehringer Mannheim, London). Assays contained, in a fiial reaction mixture of 400 A, 40 mmol/l Tris-HC1, pH 7.0 at 37"C, 4 mmol/l 2-mercaptoethanol, 5 mmol/l MgClz, cyclic [3H]AMP (2 x lo5c.p.m./ tube), 100 pmol/l cyclic AMP, 25 pnol/l CaClz and calmodulin or epidermal extract as required. Calmodulin activity was determined at three dilutions of each sample and samples were usually assayed in at least two assays within 7 days of storage. The interassay coefficient of variation for the assay was 17.7% for one normal epidermal sample (mean value f SD of 0.34 k 0.06 pg of calmodulinlmg of epidermal protein) assayed in seven consecutive assays. The amount of calmodulin activity present was related to the protein content of the original homogenate. Assays were performed in triplicate. Lymphocytes were prepared as in [ 151. Venous blood (15 ml) was taken from each subject into a sterile 20 ml plastic tube containing 500 units of Assay of immunoreactive calmodulin preservative-free heparin. Approximately 1 g of Immunoreactive calmodulin was determined by carbonyl iron powder (G.A.F. Ltd, Manchester, U.K.) was then added, followed by 5 m l of using a commercially available radioimmunoassay Dextran 150 in sodium chloride solution (154 (Amersham International Ltd). Supernatants, prepared as described previously, were diluted tenfold mmol/l) (Fisons plc, Sussex, U.K.). Samples were (or greater as required) with radioimmunoassay gently inverted and then placed in a water bath at 37°C with further inversion of each tube every buffer (125 mmol/l borate buffer, pH 8.4, con5 min until 30 min when samples were removed taining 1 mmol/l EGTA and 75 mmol/l NaC1). After initial confirmation that epidermal superand placed on a magnetic field for a further 30 min. Supernatant was removed to another tube natants diluted in parallel to the standard curve and 10 ml of a lymphocyte separation medium for pure calmodulin, samples were assayed at a (Flow Laboratories, Herts., U.K.) carefully layered single dilution in one assay only. Assays were underneath and the tubes centrifuged at 800 g performed in duplicate. for 10 min. Supernatants were discarded and the deposits washed with sodium chloride solution Statistics (154 mmol/l) and centrifuged as before. This Values are expressed as the means k SEM. washing step was repeated once more and then the lymphocyte pellet was resuspended in 1 ml of 40 Differences between means were compared by mmol/l Tris-HC1, pH 7.4, with 100 /.moll1 CaC12, paired, non-paired t-test or by Mann-Whitney Utest as appropriate. Values of P < 0.05 were taken containing 50 mg/l phenylmethylsulphonyl fluoride and 5Opl/l pepstatin A, and stored at as statistically significant. Correlation coefficients -20°C until assay of biologically active cal- of the relationship between calmodulin levels measured by radioimmunoassay and by assay of modulin (usually within 7 days). For seven of the normal control volunteers, biologically active calmodulin were determined. lymphocytes were prepared as described and then cultured for 72 h with an optimally stimulating Results concentration of phytohaemagglutinin (PHA) (Wellcome Diagnostics, Dartford, U.K.) and [3H]- Epidermal calmodulin levels were significantly thymidine (Amersham International Ltd, Bucks., greater in the involved epidermis of patients with U.K.) uptake was assessed in parallel cultures of psoriasis compared with levels in the epidermis S. Mac Neil et al. 684 of normal volunteers, irrespective of the method of calmodulin measurement (Fig. 1). However, for the uninvolved epidermis, calmodulin levels although higher than in control skin achieved statistical significance only when measured by radioimmunoassay . The mean value k SEM (n) for biologically active calmodulin was 0.72 kO.12 (16) pg of calmodulin/mg of epidermal protein for normal volunteers, 2.29 f0.38 (36) (P< 0.005 by Mann-Whitney U-test) for the psoriatic plaque of 36 patients and 1.42 f 0.26 (36) (N.S.) for the uninvolved epidermis. For calmodulin levels measured by radioimmunoassay calmodulin was 0.82k0.16 (14) for normalvolunteers, 1.97kO.26 (28) (P<0.005)for psoriatic plaque and 1.29* 0.14 (29) (P< 0.05) for the uninvolved epidermis. 'Or -Biologically Immunoreactive active calmodulin calmodulin c . E? M i v I - -- Psoriatic epidermis Psoriatic epidermis FIG. 1. Comparison of calmodulin content in normal and psoriatic involved and uninvolved epidermis determined by assay of biologically active calmodulin and of radioimmunoassayable calmodulin. Biologically active calmodulin was determined in samples from 16 normal volunteers and in the psoriatic plaque of 36 patients and in the uninvolved epidermis of 36 patients. Radioimmunoassayable calmodulin was determined for 14 of the normal volunteer samples, 28 of the psoriatic plaques and 29 of the uninvolved epidermis samples. Statistical significance was determined as described in the Results section. The correlation between calmodulin levels measured by activity assay and by radioimmunoassay was examined for nine of the control volunteers and 28 of the patients with psoriasis. Calmodulin levels in control volunteer samples were similar when measured by radioimmunoassay and by activity assay, with a good degree of correlation between the two (r = 0.91). For psoriatic epidermis, however (whether involved or uninvolved), the values obtained for levels of radioimmunoassayable and biologically active calmodulin agreed closely for 23 out of the 55 comparisons possible (correlation coefficient of r = 0.88), but there was little agreement for the remainder, radioimmunoassayable levels appearing either much higher or much lower than calmodulin activity levels. There was n o obvious correlation between the severity or extent of the disease and the amount of biologically active calmodulin present in the epidermis. For example, for the four patients with erythrodermic or nearerythrodermic psoriasis calmodulin activity in the plaque was 4.66 l .43 (4) pg/mg of protein, not significantly greater than for the other patients sampled. Calmodulin levels were also similar in the plaque of patients receiving topical steroids at the time of the study [3.30f 0.80 (10) pg/mg of protein] and in those who had been without any form of treatment for over 1 week at the time of biopsy I2.89k0.68 (14)pg/ mg of protein]. In an attempt to determine whether elevated levels of calmodulin are a generalized defect in psoriasis, calmodulin activity was measured in peripheral blood lymphocytes (see Table 1). Calmodulin levels in lymphocytes proved similar for control volunteers and patients with psoriasis [0.60 kO.16 (10) pg of calmodulin/mg of lympho- * TABLE 1. Epidermal and lymphocyte calmodulin activity in patients with psoriasis and in normal volunteers Results shown are means f SEM ( n ) . Calmodulin activity (pg/mg of protein) Epidermis Psoriasis patients Plaque Uninvolved Normal volunteers Untreated 2.29+-0.38(36) 1.42 i 0.26 (36) 0.88i0.18 (6) Post Sellotape- 1.15r0.3 (6) stripping Lymphocytes Psoriasis patients No additions 0.5420.12 (7) Normal volunteers No additions 0.60 t0.16 (10) PHA-stimulated 0.72i0.07 (7) Elevated epidermal calmodulin in psoriasis cyte protein for controls and 0.54k0.12 (7) for patients]. (Of this group of patients with psoriasis, three had previously given skin biopsy samples and the calmodulin levels in these were higher than in normal epidermis.) In investigating whether increased levels of calmodulin are a feature of hyperproliferation, calmodulin activity was determined in PHAstimulated lymphocytes and in Sellotape-stripped epidermis in normal volunteers. PHA stimulation of lymphocyte proliferation increased ['HIthymidine uptake by 375 & 77-fold (mean SEM, n = 7) but did not significantly increase calmodulin activity. Similarly, when Sellotape-stripping was used in a protocol which has elsewhere been shown to induce epidermal cell proliferation [ 11131, a paired t-test on six control volunteers showed no significant increase in calmodulin activity after this procedure (see Table 1). * Discussion Calmodulin occupies a pivotal role in the regulation of many intracellular processes, several of which are known to be abnormal in psoriasis [l-51. An alteration in calmodulin activity could, therefore, explain many of these apparently unconnected features of psoriasis. Increases in epidermal calmodulin of 30-fold [7] and sixfold [8] have previously been reported by measurement of radioimmunoassayable calmodulin and calmodulin activity respectively, although we now believe the increased calmodulin levels in the latter report to be an overestimate based on the use of inappropriate protein assay (see the Subjects and methods section). In the present study a relatively modest (two- to three-fold) increase in calmodulin was found irrespective of whether calmodulin was measured by radioimmunoassay or by assay of calmodulin activity. Thus, the discrepancy between our studies and that of Van de Kerkhof & Van Erp [7] does not appear to be explained by the different assay methods used. Moreover, there are few studies in which calmodulin levels have been measured by both activity assay and radioimmunoassay. We would suggest that the relatively poor correlation found between the two for the patient samples in the present study argues for caution in comparing these assay values in any quantitative sense. It is possible that the two assays measure different forms of calmodulin. Both may also underestimate the actual amount of calmodulin present, as suggested by studies using gel electrophoresis methodology [ 101. Perhaps more interesting than the degree of elevation in calmodulin levels in the psoriatic 685 plaque is our finding that calmodulin levels are also slightly elevated in the clinically uninvolved epidermis in psoriasis. Van de Kerkhof & Van Erp [7] found calmodulin levels in the uninvolved skin to be normal. The uninvolved skin in psoriasis, while appearing clinically and histologically normal, can show a number of abnormalities including subtle ultrastructural changes, an increase in the free mitotic index [ l , 21 and increased phospholipase A2 levels [4]. Therefore, if a specific defect is present in psoriasis, it is perhaps not surprising that it should manifest in both the involved and uninvolved epidermis. At present, we cannot explain the discrepancy between the studies but it is possible that patient selection and the site of sampling may go some way towards explaining these results (P. C. M. Van de Kerkhof, personal communication). The choice of expressing calmodulin content relative to tissue DNA [7] rather than to tissue protein [8] is also unlikely to explain this discrepancy as one would expect psoriatic plaque to be proportionately DNA-rich compared with uninvolved epidermis, hence calmodulin values expressed relative to DNA would seem lower in the plaque. To investigate whether increased calmodulin activity is specific to the epidermis in psoriasis, we measured the calmodulin activity present in an unrelated and accessible tissue, peripheral blood lymphocytes. There was no significant difference in calmodulin activity between lymphocytes prepared from normal volunteers and from patients with psoriasis. This suggests either that elevated calmodulin activity in psoriasis may be a specific defect of the epidermis or that calmodulin may be elevated in dividing cell populations. Since calmodulin is known to be particularly important in mitosis [ 101, a raised calmodulin level might be expected to occur in hyperproliferative tissue such as the psoriatic plaque. The relationship between calmodulin and cellular proliferation was examined in normal lymphocytes induced to proliferate with PHA and in normal epidermis treated with a regimen of Sellotape-stripping, which has been shown to induce epidermal proliferation [ 11-1 31. Neither procedure caused a proportional increase in calmodulin over the other cellular protein present. This is very much in accord with the picture which is currently emerging of calmodulin being elevated after cellular transformation but not under conditions of normal cellular proliferation [lo]. The calmodulin levels we have found in psoriatic plaque and in the much less proliferating uninvolved epidermis are consistent with the levels reported for several neoplastic tissues and transformed cells [lo]. 686 S. Mac Neil et al. In conclusion, in the present study we demonstrate that calmodulin levels, determined by either radioimmunoassay or activity assay, are elevated in the involved epidermis in psoriasis. Calmodulin levels in the uninvolved epidermis are also slightly elevated, although to a lesser degree. This defect appears specific t o the epidermis and does not appear to be simply a consequence of the hyperproliferative state of the epidermis. The relevance of the increased calmodulin to the aetiology of the disease remains unknown but such an increase in calmodulin could be responsible for many of the diverse biochemical abnormalities known to occur in psoriatic epidermis. Note added in proof Since submission of this manuscript similar values for psoriatic epidermal calmodulin in involved and uninvolved skin have been reported by Fairley, Marcelo, Hogan & Voorhees (Journal of Znvestigative Dermatology (1985) 84,195-198). Acknowledgments We are grateful to the MRC, the Smith Kline Foundation, the Psoriasis Association and the Wellcome Trust for financial support. S.T. is a Wellcome Trust Senior Lecturer. We thank Dr K. Gelsthorpe and Mrs L. Cawood for their assistance with the lymphocyte preparations and culture and Mr S. Quayle for provision of normal abdominal epidermis. References 1. Weinstein, G.D. & Frost, P. (1968) Abnormal cell proliferation in psoriasis. Journal of Investigative Dermatology, 50,254-259. 2. Goodwin, P., Hamilton, S. & Fry, L. (1974) The cell cycle in psoriasis. British Journal of Dermatology, 90,517-523. 3. Marcelo, C.L., Duell, E.A., Stawiski, M.A., Anderson, T I . & Voorhees, J.J. (1979) Cyclic nucleotides in psoriatic and normal keratomed epidermis. Journal of Investigative Dermatology, 12, 20-24. 4. Forster, S., Ilderton, E., Summerly, R. & Yardley, H.F. (1983) The level of phospholipase A, activity is raised in the uninvolved epidermis of psoriasis. British Journal of Dermatology, 108,103-105. 5. Russell, D.H., Combat, W.L., Duell, E.A., Stawiski, M.A., Anderson, T.F. & Voorhees, J.J. (1978) Glucocorticoid inhibits elevated polyamine synthesis in psoriasis. Journal of Investigative Dermatology, 7 1, 177-181. 6. Tomlinson, S., Mac Neil, S., Walker, S.W., Ollis, C.A., Merritt, J.E. & Brown, B.L. (1984) Calmodulin and cell function. Clinical Science, 66,497-508. 7. Van de Kerkhof, P.C.M. & Van Erp, P.E.J. (1983) Calmodulin levels are grossly elevated in the psoriatic lesion. British Journal of Dermatology, 108, 217-218. 8. Tucker, W.F.G., Mac Neil, S., Bleehen, S.S. & Tomlinson, S. (1984) Biologically active calmodulin levels are elevated in both involved and uninvolved epidermis in psoriasis. Journal of Investigative Dermatology, 82,298-299. 9. Chafouleas, J.G., Dedman, J.R., Munjaal, R.P. & Means, A.R. (1979) Development and application of a sensitive radioimmunoassay . Journal of Biological Chemistry, 254,10262-10267. 10. Veigl, M.L., Vanaman, T.C. & Sedwick, W.D. (1984) Calcium and calmodulin in cell growth and transformation. Biochimica et Biophysica Acta, 114, 84-92. 11. Wiley, H E . & Weinstein, G.D. (1979) Abnormal proliferation of uninvolved psoriatic epidermis: differential induction by saline, propranolol and tape stripping in vivo. Journal of Investigative Dermatology, 73,545-547. 12. traun-Falco, O., Christopher, E. & Kurban, A. (1967) Abnormes verhalten der epidermalen regeneration bei patienten mit psoriasis vulgaris. Archives Klinical patienten mit psoriasis vulgaris. Archiv fuer Klinische und Experimentelle Dermatologie, 229,276-284. 13. Pinkus, H. (1951) Examination of the epidermis by the strip method of removing horny layers. 1. Observations on the thickness of the horny layer and on mitotic activity after stripping. Journal of Investigative Dermatology, 16, 383-386. 14. Lowry, O.H., Rosebrough, N.J., Farr, A.L. & Randall, R.J. (1951) Protein measurement with the Folin phenol reagent. Journal of Biological Chemistry, 193,265-275. 15. Van Rood, J.J., Van Leeuwen, A. & Zweehus, R. (1970) The 4a and 4b antigens. Do they or don’t they? In: Hisrocompatability Testing, pp. 93-103. Ed. Tersaki, P.1. Munksgaard, Copenhagen. 16. Mac Neil, S., Walker, S.W.,Brown, B.L. & Tomlinson, S. (1982) Evidence that calmodulin may be involved in phytohaemagglutinin-stimulated lymphocyte division. Bioscience Reports, 2, 891-897.
© Copyright 2025 Paperzz