Return to stao.org CRUCIBLE online Practical Labs that Work for Grade 11 and Grade 12 Chemistry: Properties of Liquids and Properties of Solids Labs ««« By John Dragert John Dragert is a teacher at Stouffville District Secondary School in the York Region District School Board. He has been teaching for 7 years in the areas of chemistry and science. He completed his B.Ed at OISE/UT. For fun, John likes to stay active by playing sports, camping and dancing. He may be contacted at [email protected] . Curriculum Connection: Grade 12 Chemistry. This lab is an excerpt from a session delivered by Mr. Dragert at the STAO 2007 conference. The full set of handouts from his session may be found on the STAO website: http://www.stao.org . The presentation details a series of three labs to be used in the properties section of the atomic structure unit of the grade 12 university level chemistry course. In this series of chemistry labs, you will have the students complete “The Properties of Liquids” lab first. The Properties of liquids Lab is intended to review the idea first taught in grade 11, of using electronegativity values to rate bonds within molecules as covalent, polar covalent or ionic. The lab then extends into using the bond types to identify intermolecular forces between the molecules and asks the students to use that information to explain the properties tested in the lab. To help identify the intermolecular forces, the students can refer to a chart on page 195 of the McGraw Hill Ryerson Chemistry 12 textbook. This “Properties of Liquids” lab leads into a “Properties of Solids” lab, which may be found on page 202 of the McGraw Hill Ryerson Chemistry 12 textbook. The students will practice the same analysis using solid samples. The students refer to a chart on page 201 of the textbook to help them with their analysis. This lab was not developed Practical Labs that Work by me, and is copyrighted by the McGraw Hill authors for that section of the textbook. The sequence culminates in the evaluation lab where the students analyze a set of five unknown solid samples; A, B C, D, or E. There are 15 sets, so a group could receive samples 1A, 1B, 1C, 1D, 1 E or 6A, 6B, 6C, 6D and 6E or another set. The students first have to use their observations to determine the type of solid represented by each of the 5 samples; non-polar covalent, polar covalent, network solid, ionic or metallic. They match up their observations with a chart on page 201 of the textbook. They then are given the names and the formulae of each sample according to a key that the teacher has (see figure 1). The formulae are not given in the correct order. The students have to use electronegativity values to identify the type of solid represented by each formula and match it up to the correct sample A, B, C, D or E. Now they have the name and solid type for each sample. Safety note Due to the melting point test, the plastic samples in the key need to be replaced with alternatives which would still be non-polar molecular solids. The plastics tend to burn and produce very bad smelling, irritating fumes. This was a problem in our lab, even in our brand new school with state-of- the-art ventilation. Volume 40 • 1 September 2008 Return to stao.org CRUCIBLE online It takes about seven days to have the students complete the whole sequence from the properties of liquids through both properties of solids labs. I am sure it could be shorter if some of the labs are done as demonstrations. However, the expectations surrounding intermolecular forces and properties of materials are very abstract and hard for even grade 12 students to grasp. We have found that the properties labs are the most effective way of teaching these expectations. Without the labs I don’t believe the students would have a chance at grasping the concepts. Even with the labs they still find it tough. With the exception of the one McGraw Hill lab, the rest of these were developed by me. The “Properties of Liquids” lab is not intended as an evaluation, but rather, just a practice. If you would like further information on these labs, please feel free to contact me at [email protected] . Properties of Liquids Lab and Properties of Solids Labs Objectives Expectations Covered 1. To allow students to practice calculating DE.N. with specific molecules 1. Predict the polarity of various substances using molecular shape and the electronegativity values of the elements of the substances. 2. To allow students to practice using the DE.N. calculations to identify the bond types and intermolecular forces present in various liquids. 3. To give students experience with concrete examples in order to help them understand the ideas of intermolecular forces more completely. 4. To give students the chance to apply the knowledge gained by completing the first three objectives, to explaining the properties of various materials. 2. Explain how the properties of a solid or liquid depend on the nature of the particles present and the types of forces between them. 3. Conduct experiments to observe and analyze the physical properties of different substances and to determine the type of bonding present. Further information on Three Labs For the Atomic Structure Unit The atomic structure unit requires the teaching of the following ideas: a) Electronegativity b) ∆ E.N. and bond type (Covalent, Polar Covalent and Ionic) c) Strength and characteristics of different bonds d) Intermolecular forces e) Properties of materials based upon the bond types present in the molecules and the intermolecular forces holding molecules together. Practical Labs that Work – Page 2 These are complex and abstract ideas that are hard for the students to understand. Lab exercises are great teaching tools. Labs give the students real experiences and concrete examples to help them work through these complex ideas. In this presentation is a suggested sequence of three labs: 1) The Properties of Liquids Lab 2) Lab 4-A Properties of Substances McGraw Hill, Chemistry 12, Page 164 3) The Properties of Solids Lab. This is the Culminating lab for the unit. Volume 40 • 1 September 2008 Return to stao.org CRUCIBLE online Properties of Liquids Lab In this lab the students will study various liquids. The liquids studied are ethanol, water, butanol, 2-methyl-2propanol and vegetable oil. This lab will help students analyze substances based upon the ∆ E.N. between the atoms, the bond type and the polarity of the substance. They will also identify and study the intermolecular forces 3) The students will use what they have learned about intramolecular and intermolecular forces to explain the properties of the solid: i.e. any covalent substances do not conduct electricity since the electrons are trapped in the bonds. Metallic substances conduct electricity since metallic bonds contain loosely held electrons. present. • Lab 4-A Properties of Substances In this lab, from page 164 of McGraw Hill’s Chemistry 12 textbook, the students will repeat the process with 5 different solids. They will conduct various tests to identify the substances as non-polar molecular, polar molecular, ionic, covalent network, or metallic solids. The Properties of Solids Lab After completing the previous two labs, the students are ready for this lab. Here they are given a set of five unknown solids. There are three main parts to the lab: 1) Repeat the tests from Lab 4-A in order to: a) Identify the type of solid in each sample b) Explain what results led them to their identification 2) Identify the exact name of each compound as follows: a) The students are given the names and chemical formulae of all five of their solids in no particular order from a teacher key (see figure 1) b) The students will calculate the ∆ E.N. of the main type of bonds between the atoms in each of the given names/formulae (see summary page with results) c) Using the ∆ E.N., and other information such as the position in the periodic table of the atoms in the molecule or any charges in the formula, the students will match up the names to the solid type. The students will explain their choices. Practical Labs that Work – Page 3 • • Ionic substances are harder since ionic bonds are so strong. Polar substances are fairly hard since the dipole – dipole Hydrogen bonding forces of attraction are fairly strong. The non-polar substances are soft since the molecules stick to one another with weak dispersion forces. Polar and ionic substances tend to dissolve in water due to dipoles and charges that are attracted to the dipoles in water. Non-polar substances do not have these dipoles and are not attracted to water. Properties of Solids lab Example The student is given 5 solids (see teacher key- figure 1). Part 1 Solid B is a soft material, with a low melting point that does not conduct electricity nor dissolve in water. The student identifies this as a non-polar molecular solid since these properties match those of a non-polar molecular solid. Part 2 The student is told that wax C24H50 is one of their solids. The student calculates the ∆ E.N. C -H 2.55 - 2.20 0.35 The ∆ E.N. shows that the bond is a covalent bond and the student rates wax as a non-polar molecular substance. The student concludes that Solid B, the non-polar molecular substance, is wax. Volume 40 • 1 September 2008 Return to stao.org CRUCIBLE online Part 1 New Solids In the same set the student is given solid C and solid D. Solid C is a shiny substance that is hard, conductive as a solid, insoluble and hard to melt. Solid D is a black substance that is hard, nonconductive, insoluble and doesn’t melt. Based upon these results, the student identifies solid C as a metallic substance and solid D as a network covalent substance. Part 2 The student is told that coal and tin are two of the solids. He/she does not need to complete the ∆ E.N. calculations for the solids. However, he/she remembers from the previous lab, that network solids are made from group 14 elements. Coal is a form of carbon – a group-14 element. The student concludes that the network solid is coal and that coal is the identity of solid C. He/she concludes that tin is the metal, since tin is found in the metal part of the periodic table. Consequently, solid D is identified as tin. Possible Wrinkles In the sets where silicon is used, it is used as the covalent network solid. Network solids are not supposed to conduct electricity, but silicon, a metalloid is conductive. This may confuse it with the metal. However, using an obvious metallic solid, such as a strip of silver or aluminium in the same set, will resolve this confusion. As well, by looking at the periodic table, the student will see that silicon is a metalloid and therefore able to be a conductor. Don’t mix a strip of lead in with the set that has silicon as the network solid. Definitions and Properties Non-Polar Molecular Solid These are molecules that are formed between atoms with a small electronegativity difference. They are generally non-conductive, soft, have low melting/boiling points and are not soluble in water. They possess weak dispersion forces of attraction. Polar Molecular These are asymmetrical molecules formed by atoms with electronegativity differences between 0.5 and 1.7. They are nonconductive, fairly hard, soluble in water, and have medium melting/boiling points. They have dipole-dipole and hydrogen bonding forces of attraction. Covalent Network These are molecules that consist of continuous networks of covalent bonds. They are non-conductive (exception Si), very hard, insoluble in water and have high melting/boiling points. Ionic These are formed between cations and anions due to electrostatic attraction. They are soluble, conductive as a solution, very hard yet brittle, and have high melting/ boiling points. Metallic These are formed by metals. They all have a lustre, are conductive, are insoluble, range in hardness and have high melting/boiling points. continued... Practical Labs that Work – Page 4 Volume 40 • 1 September 2008 Return to stao.org CRUCIBLE online Figure 1: Teacher Key (created by John Dragert) SCH 4U1 Set Number 1 2 Sample Key for Properties of Solids Lab A Al Aluminum K3 Fe(CN)6 4 5 7 Potassium Iodide Polystyrene Zn Zinc Na2S2 O3 C Coal Polyvinyl Alcohol Polyethylene KI C12 H22 O 11 Sucrose FeS Iron (II) Sulfide KCl Potassium Iodide 6 Butyne-1,4diol Polystyrene Potassium Chloride 8 Na2S2 O3 9 FeS Iron (II) Sulfide Butyne-1,4diol 10 11 12 13 Mica (Silicate Rock) Rubber NaCl Sodium Chloride 14 15 C Urea SiC Silicon Carbide Potassium ferricyanide 3 B KI Sn Tin C12 H22 O 11 Sucrose Al Aluminum C6 H12 O6 Glucose Paraffin Wax Zn Zinc Si Silicon Orthoclase (Silicate Rock) KCl Potassium Chloride Polyethylene Atomic Structure Unit D Mica (Silicate Rock) C12 H22 O 11 Sucrose E S8 Sulfur Sn Tin NaCl C6 H12 O6 Glucose Rubber Sodium Chloride FeS Iron (II) Sulfide Ag Silver CuSO4 Copper (II) Sulfate Orthoclase (Silicate Rock) Si Silicon K3 Fe(CN)6 Al Aluminum Si Silicon Sn Tin Polypropylene Cr Chromium Paraffin Wax Polyacrylamide Polyethylene Polyethylene Potassium ferricyanide C12 H22 O 11 Sucrose Zn Zinc Sn Tin C Coal Potassium Iodide KI KI Polyethylene Urea CuSO4 Al Aluminum S8 Sulfur Polypropylene Potassium Iodide C12 H22 O 11 Sucrose Polyvinyl Alcohol SiC Silicon Carbide Al Aluminum Copper (II) Sulfate Zn Zinc Polyacrylamide KI Potassium Iodide FeS Iron (II) Sulfide Notes 1) The Polymers and rubber tend to burn in the melting point test releasing irritating fumes. These should be replaced with other non-polar molecular solids. A large organic acid such as Lauric Acid will work. Even though it has a polar acid group, the large covalent end will make act like a non-polar molecular solid. 2) FeS is a network solid. This is despite the fact that neither of the atoms is in group 14. The McGraw Hill Ryerson definition of a covalent network solid states that these solids usually contain group 14 elements. To avoid the confusion, any form of quartz rock (SiO2) can be used instead as Si is in group 14. As well, you could substitute coal, silicon or Silicon carbide for FeS. 3) Solid Silicon is a covalent network solid. These types of solids are not supposed to conduct. However, silicon does conduct. Point the students to the position of Silicon on the periodic table to help with the confusion. Silicon is a group 14 element so it should form covalent network solids. As well it is a metalloid, which explains the ability of silicon to conduct. Practical Labs that Work – Page 5 Volume 40 • 1 September 2008 Return to stao.org CRUCIBLE online Student activity Lab: Properties of Liquids Purpose To determine the properties of various liquids and explain them using Intermolecular forces and bond types. Hypothesis The type and strength of intermolecular forces and bonds will determine properties such as solubility, sensitivity to electric charges, and melting/boiling points. Materials • • • • • • • Methanol* Ethanol Butanol Dodecanol Distilled water Vegetable Oil Ice • • • • • • • Food Colouring Ebonite Rods Fur/cotton Test Tubes 1 Burette 1 Large beaker 1 400 mL beaker Note from the STAO Safety Committee Methanol is toxic. It can cause blindness. For this reason, goggles MUST be worn. Ethanol, if denatured Ethyl Alcohol, contains methanol. Boiling alcohol is not a safe activity and therefore this lab should be run as a demonstration at the teacher’s desk. Each group can run one liquid, under the direct supervision of the teacher. Procedure Electrical Sensitivity Test (or Electrostatics) 1. Half fill a burette with water. Place a large beaker below it. 2. Place a static charge on the ebonite rod. 3. Open the burette to get a fine stream of water flowing into the beaker 4. Move the ebonite rod close to the stream and record observations. 5. To test ethanol, drain the burette and repeat steps 1 – 4 with 50 mL of ethanol in the burrette. 6. To test oil, do not use the burette. Instead, take two beakers. Place 50 mL of oil in one beaker. Pour a fine Practical Labs that Work – Page 6 stream of oil from one beaker to another. Move the rod near the stream. Repeat as necessary and record observations. Solubility Test 1. Obtain 4 test tubes. Fill each test tube to about 1/3 with water. Place 2 drops of food colouring in each test tube. 2. Add 2 pipette squirts of liquid to each tube according to the list (about 4 mL – enough to see a difference between the liquids). #1 Methanol #2 Ethanol #3 Butanol #4 Vegetable Oil 3. Record Observations. Boling Point 1. Half fill a 400 mL beaker with water and place it on a hot plate. 2. Place 5 mL of ethanol in a small test tube. Hold the test tube in the water using a clamp attached to a stand. Place a thermometer in the water. 3. Turn the hot plate to a setting of 5 – 7 in order to heat the water. 4. Record the temperature at which the ethanol boils. Record any other observations. 5. Remove the ethanol. Keep heating the water and record the temperature at which water boils 6. Repeat steps 1 – 4 with Butanol in the test tube. Freezing/Melting Point 1. Set up a water bath at room temperature and place it on the hot plate. Place a sample of dodecanol in a test tube. Place the test tube in the water, record observations. Volume 40 • 1 September 2008 Return to stao.org CRUCIBLE online Student activity 2. Increase the temperature of the water by 5°C and repeat. Keep increasing the temperature of the water by 5°C each time and repeat until the melting point of dodecanol is determined. 3. Create an ice water bath in a small beaker. Record the temperature. You want it to be as close to zero as possible. Place 5 mL of ethanol in a test tube and hold the test tube in the ice water bath for several minutes. Record observations. 4. Repeat Step 3 with tert-butanol (2-methyl-2-propanol) 5. Look up the melting point of regular butanol. Questions 1. Draw the Lewis dot structural diagram for each molecule used in the experiment. On each diagram identify: i) The type of bond present in each part. Label any charges or partial charges present on the diagram. ii) Any polar parts and any non-polar parts of the molecule iii) The type and strength of any intermolecular forces that could be present in each part of the molecules. 2. a) Draw the hydrogen bonding that is present in water (draw at least 3 molecules bonded together). b) Draw the hydrogen bonding that is present in ethanol. How many molecules can you join together? Practical Labs that Work – Page 7 c) What difference do you notice about the hydrogen bonding in an alcohol vs. the hydrogen bonding in water? d) Why is it technically incorrect to call hydrogen bonding hydrogen bonding? Is it really a bond? If not what is it? Is it as strong as an ionic, polar covalent or covalent bonds? Explain. e) Why do you think that they call it a bond? (Hint think about the strength of hydrogen bonding compared to other dipole forces) 3. Use the results from questions 1 and 2 to answer the following: a) Explain the electrical sensitivity results. b) Explain the solubility results. c) Explain the boiling point results. d) Explain the freezing/melting point results. Conclusions State: i) Generally, what type of materials are sensitive to electricity, and dissolve in water. ii) How intermolecular forces increase the boiling/melting points of materials. iii) Even though they are weak forces, how dispersion forces can sometimes be stronger than other forces. Volume 40 • 1 September 2008 Return to stao.org CRUCIBLE online These pages give a summary of the Typical Results for the Properties of Liquids lab. The summary refers back to Table 1 below, for the ∆ E.N. calculations and the rating of the different bonds. TABLE 1: ∆ E.N. 0 0.5 Covalent 1.7 Polar Covalent 4.0 Ionic Table 1: ! E.N., Bond Type and Charge Type Material Main Bond ! E.N. Bond Type Oil C-H Water O–H Ethanol C–C C–H C–O O–H Practical Labs that Work – Page 8 2.55 -2.20 0.35 3.44 -2.20 1.24 2.55 -2.55 0.00 2.55 -2.20 0.35 3.44 -2.55 0.89 3.44 -2.20 1.24 Charge Type Which Atom Is + - Covalent None N/A N/A Polar Covalent Partial H O Covalent None N/A N/A Covalent None N/A N/A Polar Covalent Partial Charges C O Polar Covalent Partial Charges H O Volume 40 • 1 September 2008 Return to stao.org CRUCIBLE online Electrical Sensitivity (Electrostatics Test) Boiling Point Results • Water: Water is a polar substance with partial charges. The ebonite rod is negative. The positive partial charges on the hydrogen atoms in the water are attracted to the rod. • • Ethanol: Ethanol is a substance with a polar OH group on the end. The ebonite rod is negative. The positive • Water Butanol: Water can H – Bond on both sides and Butanol only on one side. However, Butanol has a longer carbon chain than Ethanol. The extra dispersion forces add up to hold Butanol molecules together even more strongly than water. partial charges in the ethanol will be attracted to the rod. • Ethanol Water: B.P. increases. Ethanol can H – bond on one side, whereas water can H – bond on both sides. Therefore water molecules are held together more strongly. Oil: The main bond type in the oil is the non-polar C – H bond. It is not attracted to the rod. Melting/Freezing Point Results • Note: There are polar C – O bonds in the oil. In small drops these can interact with the rod. Therefore this test is best done with a thick stream rather than in a burette. • Ethanol Butanol Dodecanol: M.P. increases due to the extra CH2 groups. This causes an increase in the dispersion forces that adds up to hold the molecules together more strongly. More energy is needed to break them apart. Solubility • Table 1 can be repeated for all of the alcohols, but the result will be the same as Ethanol. • Methanol and Ethanol will dissolve in water. They have a polar O – H bond with partial charges that will be attracted to partial charges in the polar water and will cause the molecule to dissolve. • In Butanol, the non-polar side is long enough to pull the molecule out of the water, despite the polar O – H bond. • In oil, the vast majority of the bonds are non – polar. Therefore it will not dissolve. • Ethanol and 2 – methyl – 2 – propanol: Ethanol won’t freeze in the ice water bath, but 2 – methyl – 2 – propanol will become slushy. This is due to the arrangement of the OH groups in the propanol. They are arranged to H – Bond better and thus hold the molecules tighter than the OH groups in Ethanol. Therefore 2-methyl-2-propanol will freeze at a higher temperature than Ethanol. Boiling Point and Freezing/Melting Point Table 2 Substance Ethanol Water Butanol Dodecanol 2-methyl-2-propanol Boiling Point ºC 78.0 100.0 117.3 255.0 82.2 Practical Labs that Work – Page 9 Freezing Point ºC - 117.0 0.0 - 89.5 + 26.0 + 25.5 Volume 40 • 1 September 2008 Return to stao.org CRUCIBLE online Student activity Lab: Properties of Solids Introduction In this unit you have learned about atomic orbitals, molecular orbitals, electronic configuration, molecular shapes, bond types, intra and intermolecular forces of attraction and properties of liquids and solids. Today you will test different unknown solids to identify the type of solid and identify the actual compound using a key. You will then explain the properties of each solid using the knowledge you’ve gained during the unit. Purpose Write your own using the introduction. Hypothesis: (Pick one of the following two possibilities for your hypothesis) a) State whether you think that you will be able to identify the types of solids you have and how you think you will be able to do this. Or, b) Take a brief look at all of your samples. Take an educated guess at the type of compound represented by each sample. Give one reason to support each guess. Materials Decide on the test you will need to use and list all materials you will need. You can make this list up as you go along. Note the following: i) For every chemical you use you do not need to give the amount. That will be done in the procedure; ii) You will need to give the concentration, if applicable, and the name Example: 1 molar HCl or Zinc Metal powder; iii) For each type of equipment used you will need to give the number of pieces used and the size, if applicable. Example: 1 scoopula or 4, 250 ml beakers; Practical Labs that Work – Page 10 Also, put the list as a series of short 4- or 5-line columns ____________ ____________ ____________ ____________ ____________ ____________ ____________ ____________ ____________ ____________ ____________ ____________ Procedure Write a step-by-step procedure for the lab. Write it as if it is a recipe and I am an inexperienced person who doesn’t know what I’m doing. Write it so I could repeat the experiment without you there to explain it to me. Include the amounts of substances used. For example if you are using a small scoop, then write “take a small scoop.” If you are using 2 grams, write “take 2 grams.” At every step where an observation is taken, write “record observation” in that step. Observations Create a chart for your observations. Remember to decide the number of tests you are going to do and how many chemicals you are going to test. One will set the number of columns and the other will set the number of rows. Discussion 1. For each type of solid on page 201 of the McGraw Hill Ryerson textbook, answer the following. You may also use the preceding pages in the textbook: a) Give a proper definition of each type of solid: Nonpolar molecular (Covalent molecular), Polar molecular, Covalent network, Ionic solid, and Metallic. b) Identify and describe the key properties of each type of solid. 2. For each sample in the lab, answer the following: a) Correctly identify the properties of the solid sample and use the properties to identify the type of solid it is. Properties include; hardness, solubility in water, conductivity in water, conductivity as a solid, and melting point. Volume 40 • 1 September 2008 Return to stao.org CRUCIBLE online Student activity b) Once the type of solid has been identified, use your c) For further help, use the position on the periodic table knowledge of that solid to explain: the hardness of each sample, the melting point of each sample, the solubility of each sample and the conductivity of each sample. of the atoms in your compounds. For instance compounds with atoms in group 14 on the table are likely (not always) network solids. 4 3. Your teacher will provide you with the name and formula of each of the samples in your set. They will not be in order. You will have to use the formulae given to you and the information from #2 to identify the names of the compounds in your set as follows: a) Calculate the electro-negativity difference (DE.N.) between the atoms in each bond in the compounds. Use this information to rate the bonds in the solid and determine the type of solid represented by each formula given. b) Match the type of solid determined for the formulae in part A above with the type of solid that you determined for each sample in question #2. Now you will have the name and formula for each sample in your set. Practical Labs that Work – Page 11 a) Why would wax (a non-polar molecular solid) or salt (an ionic solid) be a poor a poor choice for the outside of a building while bricks (made of clay and sand, both network solids) would be a better choice? b) Use the electronic configuration and the number of electrons available to bond in order to explain why iron is a much stronger metal than copper and is a better a choice for making bridges and buildings. In your answer, draw out the electronic configuration for each metal. Identify the number of electrons available to bond in each metal based upon the electronic configurations. Use this to explain why iron is the stronger metal. Conclusion State the identities and type of solid for each sample tested. Volume 40 • 1 September 2008
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz