Public Report To: Community Services Committee From: Ron Diskey, Commissioner, Community Services Department Report Number: CS-17-12 Date of Report: April 13, 2017 Date of Meeting: April 20, 2017 Subject: Approval of Respect Check Policy: Code of Conduct for Parks, Recreation and Cultural Facilities File: F-1000 1.0 Purpose The purpose of this report is to present and obtain approval for the Respect Check Policy: Code of Conduct for Parks, Recreation and Cultural facilities, aimed at promoting a positive, safe and supportive environment for all who visit any City recreation and culture facilities and parks and trails. Attachment 1 is the proposed policy: Respect Check Policy: Code of Conduct for Parks, Recreation and Cultural Facilities. 2.0 Recommendation That the Community Services Committee recommend to City Council: 1. That based on Report CS-17-12, dated April 13, 2017, the attached Respect Check: Code of Conduct Policy for Parks, Recreation and Culture facilities be approved as presented in Attachment 1; and, 2. That Council support the application for the City of Oshawa to become a ‘True Sport’ community. 3.0 Executive Summary In October 2008, Community Services Committee approved report CS-08-116, which endorsed the first Code of Conduct Policy for Recreation and Culture Services Facilities. Since its original adoption, changes and updates to the Policy have been required. 44 Report to Community Services Committee Meeting Date: April 20, 2017 Item: CS-17-12 Page 2 The City of Oshawa is committed to fostering a safe and welcoming environment at its facilities and properties where there is respect for others, and ownership for all actions by all users. Updates to the Policy, now called Respect Check, include the following: - introducing a definitions section to the policy outlining in greater detail the roles and responsibilities of staff, patrons and user groups inclusion of Parks Services programs and outdoor facilities and services linking with the Trespass By-law 98-2013 The Respect Check Policy is intended to be a precursor and companion to the Council approved Trespass By-law, as it will be used to better inform staff and the public about what behaviors are expected in our recreation facilities and parks. The Trespass By-law will continue to be used to enforce conduct that cannot be controlled by education and communication. Subject to Council’s endorsement, staff proposes to create and update procedures and forms, promote the policy through education and awareness initiatives (e.g. signage in facilities, a promotional campaign) and to train staff. These steps will help to ensure behavioral expectations are understood by all and that issues will be assessed and addressed in an immediate, timely, appropriate and consistent manner. 4.0 Input From Other Sources The following have provided input to this report: • • • • • Community Services Operations Legal Services Municipal Law Enforcement and Licencing Services Cultural Leadership Council Oshawa sports user groups including: o Robert McLaughlin Gallery o Durham Speed Skating Club o Oshawa Lady Blue Knights o Oshawa Kicks Soccer Club o Oshawa Minor Hockey Association (OMHA) o Neighbourhood Association of Sports Committees: Hockey, Softball & Soccer (NASC) o Oshawa Storm Ringette (OSR) o Oshawa Church Hockey League (OCHL) o Oshawa Skating Club (OSC) o Oshawa Girls Hockey Association (OGHA) In addition, staff have consulted with the following in preparation of the policy and report: • City of London 45 Report to Community Services Committee Meeting Date: April 20, 2017 • • • • • • • Item: CS-17-12 Page 3 Town of Oakville City of Guelph City of Waterloo City of Coquitlam City of Burlington True Sport Foundation Ontario Recreation Facilities Association Inc. (O.R.F.A.) 5.0 Analysis 5.1 Purpose of the Respect Check Policy A Code of Conduct policy is a best management practice, which educates users of City Recreation and Culture facilities, parks and trails as to what the behavioral expectations are while they are within the City facilities or property. The Respect Check Policy outlines what is inappropriate behavior, the purpose and scope of the behavioural policy and program, responsibilities for all involved, education and awareness strategies, and consequences when a violation of the policy has occurred. The City of Oshawa will not tolerate any form of inappropriate behaviour in its facilities or properties. For the purposes of Respect Check, inappropriate behavior is defined as, but not limited to: • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Loud verbal assaults directed at participants, officials, members of the public or City staff deemed to be aggressive, intimidating or having the potential of inciting violence; Threats and/or attempts to intimidate; Throwing of articles in a deliberate or aggressive manner; Aggressive approaches to another individual including physical or verbal assault; Attempts to goad or incite violence in others; Theft of property; Possession of weapons; Vandalism to a City building or property; Refusal to abide by facility rules and/or posted notices in City of Oshawa facilities; Racial or ethnic slurs; Illegal consumption of alcohol or drugs; Harassment “engaging in a course of vexatious comment or conduct that is known or ought reasonably to be known to be unwelcome” as defined by the Ontario Human Rights Code; Contravention of City By-Laws or Policies; Engagement in a course of annoying comment or conduct; 46 Report to Community Services Committee Meeting Date: April 20, 2017 • • • Item: CS-17-12 Page 4 Displaying of abusive or offensive materials, words, images; The use of all cell phones, cameras, video recording devices, personal digital devices, or any other equipment with video or photographic abilities in change rooms and public washrooms Additional situations that may arise where it is expected that conduct becoming a reasonable person and in the spirit of this policy shall apply. Additionally, as many user groups utilize City spaces such as sports fields, baseball diamonds and trails, the Policy includes the addition of Parks and Trails as facilities and property to streamline behavioral expectations across all leisure spaces. Nothing in this policy is intended to diminish the scope of authority conferred by Council pursuant to Trespass By-law 98-2013, as amended. The Trespass By-law 98-2013, as amended, prevails to the extent of any inconsistency between it and the Respect Check policy. 5.2 Municipal and Community Comparators Many municipalities have behaviour and respect programs. These policies and programs set a standard for people’s actions. The Town of Oakville, City of Guelph, and the City of London, plus numerous other municipalities, have developed and implemented similar Code of Conduct Policies such as RZone (Oakville and London) – all with the aim to decrease unsafe behaviours among participants, volunteers, staff, coaches, officials and spectators. Recreation and Culture Services staff reviewed policies from other municipalities as well as reached out to their staff who oversee the behavior program. Various sport user groups utilizing City of Oshawa facilities and property also have organizational Codes of Conduct, which were also considered for the purpose of the review. 5.3 Next Steps 5.3.1 Procedure Development Recreation and Culture Services staff, in collaboration with other City branches and departments, will create the necessary procedures and forms that compliment Respect Check. 5.3.2 Educational Awareness and Promotion Recreation and Culture Services staff, in collaboration with other City branches and departments will conduct educational and awareness initiatives including: • • Signage to advise the public on Respect Check at all Recreation and Culture’s facilities and some parks and trails. Promotion of the Respect Check Policy in future activeOshawa guides, through social media campaigns and e-newsletters. 47 Report to Community Services Committee Meeting Date: April 20, 2017 • • • Item: CS-17-12 Page 5 Incorporation of the Respect Check in the Conditions of Use portion of all rental contracts Incorporate as part of the Branch’s Event Guidelines Communication to all affiliated and non-affiliated sport users, stakeholders and community groups 5.3.3 Staff Training Training will be provided internally for Recreation and Culture Services and Parks & Environmental Services staff on the Respect Check Policy and the administrative procedures and tools to implement the policy including their role, responsibilities and rights. Where applicable, Recreation and Culture Services staff will work with the Durham Regional Police Services, Canadian Mental Health Association and other agencies on related and relevant training. 5.3.4 True Sport Community True Sport is a nationwide charitable organization that develops initiatives and programs that promote the sport virtues of inclusion, fun, fairness and excellence. True Sport has created seven principles for participation in sport: - Go For It: Always strive for excellence and rise to the challenge, but never at the expense of others. Discover how good you can be. - Play Fair: Play honestly and obey the rules, in letter and spirit. Winning is only meaningful when competition is fair. - Respect Others: Show respect for everyone involved in creating a sporting experience, both on the field and off. Win with dignity and lose with grace. - Keep it Fun: Find the joy of sport and have a good time. Keep a positive attitude and look to make a positive difference, on the field and in your community. - Stay Healthy: Place physical and mental health above all other considerations and avoid unsafe activities. Respect your body and keep in shape. - Include Everyone: Share sport with others, regardless of creed, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation or ability. Invite everyone into sport to make it more meaningful for the whole community. - Give Back: Always remember the community that supports your sport and helps make it possible. Find ways to show your appreciation and help others get the most out of sport. These seven principles have assisted in informing the Respect Check Policy and are a positive reinforcement to how individuals should behave while using recreation and culture 48 Report to Community Services Committee Meeting Date: April 20, 2017 Item: CS-17-12 Page 6 facilities and parks and trails. Many municipalities have become “True Sport” communities and have adopted these seven principles. By adopting these principles and becoming a ‘True Sport’ community, the City of Oshawa is able to reinforce the ‘True Sport’ message, in combination with its own Respect Check Policy as well as link to a greater nationwide strategy around positive and inclusive spaces. Upon approval of this report, Recreation and Culture Services staff will take the necessary steps and register the City of Oshawa as a True Sport community. 6.0 Financial Implications The cost of implementing Respect Check and can be funded from the 2017 Operating Budget. There are no cost implications to becoming a ‘True Sport’ community. 7.0 Relationship to the Oshawa Strategic Plan This report addresses the Oshawa Strategic Plan by responding to the goal of “Social Equity” with the theme of “An Active, Healthy and Safe Community” by expressing a commitment to ensure recreation, culture, parks and trails space are positive, safe, and supportive environments for the entire community. Julie MacIsaac, Director, Recreation & Culture Services Ron Diskey, Commissioner, Community Services Department Attachment 49 Item: CS-17-12 Attachment 1 Corporate Policies: Recreation & Culture Policy: Respect Check – Recreation and Culture Services Code of Conduct Issued: April, 2017 Revised: Page: 1 of 8 Number: Related Policies: Respect in the Workplace- LR14.10; City of Oshawa, Code of Conduct Policy – AG10.80; Ontario Health and Safety Act, City of Oshawa Trespass Act; Trespass By-law 98-2013, as amended Respect Check Code of Conduct Policy 1.0 Purpose/Background The City of Oshawa is committed to creating and promoting a safe, healthy, respectful and welcoming environment where there is respect for others and responsibility for all actions. Respect Check is a code of conduct policy, which enforces a set of expectations to address inappropriate behaviours, violence, and vandalism that negatively affects the experience of individuals or creates unsafe conditions. The Respect Check policy identifies how these behaviours will be addressed when it occurs within any City facility or in association with any service, program or event provided by, or associated with, the City of Oshawa and outlined in this document. The City encourages and supports all organizations using City facilities to take primary responsibility for developing, implementing and managing their specific behaviour management policies to align with the City policy. The Corporation will make its best effort to mitigate all situations, however in the course of public service, events may be beyond the Corporation’s control. The policy is aligned with the following policies, acts and regulations: • • • • • 2.0 City of Oshawa - Respect in the Workplace – Harassment and Violence Policy LR14.10; Trespass to Property Act City of Oshawa – Trespass By-Law 98-2013 Occupational Health and Safety Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. 0.1; The True Sport Movement: Canadian Centre for Ethics in Sport Policy Statement The City’s recreation, culture and parks programs, facilities and properties are places that promote learning and support leisure opportunities for members of the community. In keeping with the True Sport initiative, a patron’s experience with us is based on the values of fairness, excellence, inclusion and fun. All persons (members of the public, staff and volunteers) have the right to be safe and to feel safe while attending or working at a program, facility or property so that they can enjoy their activity sport, or interest. With this right comes the responsibility to be accountable for actions or behaviours that put at risk the safety of others and encourages an environment where there is respect for others. The City of Oshawa has zero tolerance for any form of 50 Issued: April 2017 Revised: Page 2 of 8 Number: violence, vandalism, or inappropriate behavior in its recreational programs, facilities or properties. 3.0 Definitions City Facility: includes both indoor and outdoor facilities, owned, leased, rented, allocated, programmed, operated or managed by the City, intended for public or staff use. This includes, but is not limited to City Hall, Civic Square, recreation facilities, arenas, pools, sports facilities and fields, parks, playgrounds, staff offices, meeting rooms, reception desks, community meeting spaces, trails and parks. Harassment: engaging in a course of vexatious comment or conduct against another person in a public place that is known or ought reasonably know to be unwelcome, with some or all of the following components: it is generally repetitive, although a single, serious incident may constitute workplace harassment if it undermines the recipient’s psychological or physical integrity and has a lasting harmful effect; it is hostile, abusive or inappropriate; it affects the person’s dignity or psychological integrity and it results in a poisoned work environment. Behaviour that intimidates isolates or discriminates against the recipient may also be included. Letter of Warning: explanation in written format the details of what happened, what was said and done; issues stemming from misconduct, identify City’s policy and provide statement of future expectations to correct the misconduct, description of the action to be taken if problem not corrected, provide any required supporting documents (photos,) Ontario Health and Safety Act: an Act to promote occupational health and safety among employers, workers and others. Ontario Human Rights Code: is a law in the province of Ontario that gives all people equal rights and opportunities without discrimination in specific areas such as housing and services Senior Staff Person: means the City Manager, each Commissioner and each Director of the City. Structured Activity: facility permit issued; registered or scheduled drop-in recreation program Trespass to Property Act: a provincial law in Ontario dealing with illegal entry into private and public property. Trespass Notice: is authorized under the Trespass to Property Act and is a written notice prohibiting an individual from entering specific City facilities for a specific duration and is issued to an individual for the purpose of imposing a ban. 51 Issued: April 2017 Revised: Page 3 of 8 Number: Trespass By-law: is a City of Oshawa By-law that establishes a system for administering notices and other matters under the Trespass to Property Act. Respect Check is intended to act as a precursor, and does not replace, the Trespass By-law. Unstructured Activity: no permit issued; drop-in programs, events. Vandalism: means the malicious, willful and deliberate destruction, damage, defacing of property owned, leased, or permitted through the City. Violence: physically threatening behaviour such as shaking a fist at someone, finger pointing, destroying property, throwing objects; verbal or written threats to physically attack a worker, client or patron; leaving threatening notes or threatening emails; wielding a weapon at work; stalking someone; and physically aggressive behaviours including hitting, shoving, standing excessively close to someone in an aggressive manner, pushing, kicking, throwing an object at someone, physically restraining someone or any other form of physical or sexual assault. 4.0 Scope/Application 4.1 Properties and Users The Respect Check policy applies to all staff, contractors employed by the City of Oshawa and users of Parks, Recreation and Culture programs, municipally owned or leased facilities or properties. Users are, including but not limited to, patrons, guests, spectators, fans, coaches, players, parents, volunteers and staff (which includes all full time, part-time and students). Nothing in this policy is intended to diminish the scope of authority conferred by Council pursuant to Trespass By-law 98-2013, as amended. The Trespass By-law 98-2013, as amended, prevails to the extent of any inconsistency between it and this policy. 4.2 Structured and Unstructured Activites The Respect Check policy covers structured (i.e. facility use permit issued, registered programs) and unstructured (i.e. no permit issued, drop-in programs, events) activities. This policy applies to in-person interactions and all forms of verbal communication and written communication (email/letters). 4.3 Inappropriate Behaviours and Violence Inappropriate behaviours and violence for the purpose of this policy includes, but is not limited to, the following: a. b. c. d. Loud verbal assaults directed at participants, officials, members of the public or City staff deemed to be aggressive, intimidating, or having the potential of inciting violence. Threats and/or attempts to intimidate; Throwing of articles in a deliberate or aggressive manner; Actual or attempted aggressive approaches to another individual including physical or verbal assault; 52 Issued: April 2017 Revised: Page 4 of 8 Number: e. Sexual harassment. Examples include but are not limited to sexual advances or demands; threats, leering, sexually suggestive or obscene comments or gestures, unwelcome remarks, jokes, innuendoes, propositions or taunting, unwanted attention, physical contact of a sexual nature, sexual assault. f. Attempts to goad or incite violence in others; g. Theft of property; h. Possession of weapons; i. Vandalism of any kind to a City building or property; j. Refusal to abide by facility rules and/or posted notices in City of Oshawa facilities and/or on City of Oshawa property; k. Racial or ethnic slurs; l. Illegal consumption of alcohol or drugs or other substances; m. Harassment which may include the wearing of attire, the displaying of material or the use of language that is intolerant of human rights; n. Contravention of City By-Laws or Policies; o. Contravention of any provincial or federal laws e.g. any illegal activity; p. Engagement in a course of annoying comment or conduct; q. Displaying of abusive or offensive materials, words, images; r. The use of all cell phones, cameras, video recording devices, personal digital devices, or any other equipment with video or photographic abilities in change rooms and public washrooms; s. Criminal behaviour of any kind whatsoever. 5.0 Responsibilities Staff and attendees at City recreation facilities, parks and trails are responsible for acting and behaving in a manner that respects the rights of others and enables the enjoyment of individual and public benefits of recreation to promote an environment that can be enjoyed by all. A fair, safe and open atmosphere increases accessibility and opportunities for participation in all levels and types of activities, while providing a welcoming, culturally diverse community. 5.1 Role of City Staff Recreation and Culture Services and Parks Operations staff are responsible for overseeing and implementing the Respect Check policy and program. Responsibilities include: a. b. c. d. e. f. g. h. i. Review Respect Check policy annually and update as needed Developing all procedural aspects related to this policy (e.g. forms, processes) Developing Respect Check signage to be posted at all city facilities Including a requirement to abide by the respect Check policy as a term and condition for use of a facility Following and implementing the Respect Check policy and procedure Monitoring and identifying violations of the policy and/or procedure Reporting all incidents to their immediate supervisor or manager promptly Completing appropriate forms to document incidents and/or in response to a complaint from members of the public, volunteers or other individuals. Participating in investigation processes as required 53 Issued: April 2017 Revised: Page 5 of 8 Number: j. Providing training and education to staff to support both the policy and procedure k. Including promotion of Respect Check in ongoing promotional vehicles i.e. activeOshawa guide, website and other media advertising l. Applying Respect Check in all City programming to provide participants and visitors a safe and positive environment. m. Bringing awareness to inappropriate behaviour demonstrated; engage police or security if an individual or group continues to be uncooperative. Recreation and Culture Services and Parks Operations staff will also work in partnership with the community to ensure everyone has the opportunity to enjoy a respectful and positive environment. Staff will work collaboratively and in consultation with community sport and recreation organizations/groups to create Respect Check environments at City parks and trails. 5.2 Role of Organizations Organizations and user groups making use of City facilities, parks and trails are responsible for: • Educating their attendees about the Respect Check policy and appropriate behaviour • Compliance of requirements of City contracts and permits regarding Respect Check • Applying Respect Check to their programs, including being willing to address Respect Check violations with their attendees. Included in this commitment is an understanding that organizations that rent city facilities must take primary responsibility for the behaviours of participants, instructors, players, coaches, officials and spectators. Organizations will be expected to abide by the Respect Check policy as a term and condition for use of a permitted facility When an organization experiences ongoing or unresolved issues when dealing with associated participants, volunteers, parents, spectators etc., they are urged to assign a delegate to meet with a City representative to review the issues and develop approaches to assist the organization in or City will have final say into any decision, which may result in a ban or trespass ban. 5.3 Role of Individuals The City’s primary concern is the safety of the users, staff and contracted employees. If at any time users or staff feel personally threatened, they are to call the Police immediately. It is not the expectation that staff or patrons put themselves at risk or jeopardize one’s safety in dealing with any perceived or real situation. Program participants, spectators, parents, guests, volunteers, officials and the public are responsible for: • Creating and encouraging opportunities for people to get together through sport or activity; creating safe places and spaces that are hospitable and conducive to the safe enjoyment of all while visiting our city facilities, programs, parks and trails. 54 Issued: April 2017 • • • • Revised: Page 6 of 8 Number: Behaving and acting in a manner that respects the rights of others in order for the services to be used and enjoyed by all Complying with requirements of City contracts and permits regarding Respect Check and/or promote the Respect Check policy with their program attendees. Reporting acts of violence, vandalism or inappropriate behaviours and incidents witnessed to a City staff member and/or a designated person. Provide details to staff for completing a written report immediately following the incident 5.4 Role of City Council Oshawa City Council is responsible for approving, promoting and complying with the Respect Check policy. 6.0 Practice/ Procedures 6.1 Education The City, with community sport organizations and other stakeholders, will conduct promotional and educational campaigns with the goals of: • • • • • • Raising awareness of the policy for attendees, and appropriate City employees, contractors or agents Outlining how attendees/organizations/users can support the Respect Check policy (e.g. through attendees setting positive example, encouraging organizations to have internal policies consistent with the Respect Check policy; how attendees can report inappropriate behaviour, etc.) Outlining the potential consequences of non-compliance with the Respect Check policy Reviewing promotional materials and work together with volunteer organizations to raise awareness of the policy. Providing initial Respect Check orientation sessions with staff and annual training sessions Promotional and educational campaigns will include: o The promotion of the True Sport four values: fairness, inclusion, excellence and fun o The promotion of the True Sport seven principles: strive for excellence, play fair, respect others, keep it fun, stay healthy, include everyone and give back. o Posting Respect Check policy and related information on the City website o Posting Respect Check policy signage at City recreation facilities o Making information pamphlets available at City recreation facilities and promoting in activeOshawa guide o Including Respect Check policy awareness in City employee training programs 55 Issued: April 2017 Revised: Page 7 of 8 Number: o Referencing Respect Check policy within Conditions of Use/Rules and Regulations for Permit Holders 6.2 Violation of Respect Check Policy 6.2.1 Staff The City’s primary concern is the safety of members of the public, employees and volunteers. Parks, Recreation and Culture Services employees who observe inappropriate behaviour, or have reason to believe inappropriate behaviour has occurred on a City recreational property or facility will report incidents of prohibited inappropriate behaviours to their immediate supervisor or manager (who may subsequently report the incident to City Security) as soon as possible or immediately following the event. Acts of workplace violence against staff are to be reported to the employee’s supervisor immediately following the event and in accordance with the City’s Respect in the Workplace – Harassment and Violence Policy. City employees who are advised of or receive a complaint of prohibited inappropriate behaviour from a patron will report it to their supervisor or manager as soon as possible. Depending on the severity, incidents occurring on weekends and beyond regular business hours will be reported to the appropriate on-call supervisor or manager. Staff reporting incidents at outdoor parks and facilities, will contact the on-call Operations supervisor. All employees are to contact Durham Regional Police Services and/or City Security if an individual refuses to cease the behaviour when asked. If, at any time, staff feel physically threatened, Durham Regional Police must be contacted immediately. It is NOT the expectation that staff put themselves at risk or jeopardize one’s safety in dealing with any perceived or real situation. Staff are not to engage in physical confrontations when addressing inappropriate behaviours The Trespass By-law 98-2013, as amended, establishes a process for issuing trespass notices. 6.2.2 Patrons Patrons at City parks, recreation and culture facilities who observe prohibited inappropriate behaviour under the Respect Check policy should report it to a City employee as soon as possible upon witnessing the behaviour. Patrons will be asked to provide detailed information to staff to assist in the completion of an incident report. If, at any time, facility patrons feel physically threatened, Durham Regional Police must be contacted immediately. It is NOT the expectation that patrons put themselves at risk or jeopardize one’s safety in dealing with any perceived or real situation. Patrons are not to engage in physical confrontations when addressing inappropriate behaviours. 56 Issued: April 2017 Revised: Page 8 of 8 Number: 6.2.3 Documentation Staff will complete incident reports when a violation of the Respect Check policy has occurred. Incident reports are required to formally keep track of occurrences encountered in the workplace, repeat offenders, or an escalating situation. All documented incidents and files will be retained by Recreation and Culture Services Branch, and a copy forwarded to Manager, Human Resources Services and Safety to distribute to the Joint Health and Safety Committees for their review, regardless if the incident occurred inside facilities or at outside facilities. 6.2.4 Investigations In addition to documenting incidents, an investigation may occur which could include: • conducting interviews of relevant individuals to gather all of the facts and circumstances relevant to the complaint, including date(s) and location(s) • reviewing any related documentation • making detailed notes of the investigation and maintaining them in a confidential file Once an investigation is complete, the investigator(s) will prepare a detailed report of the findings. This report will be submitted to the manager for further direction and followup. 6.2.5 Penalties Where a finding has been made of a violation of the Respect Check policy, consideration will be given as to the appropriate remedies collaboratively through the appropriate branch Managers / Directors 6.3 Monitoring and Evaluation Recreation and Culture Services will regularly monitor and evaluate the effectiveness of the Respect Check policy with staff and organizations. Approved Date Signature 57
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz