An interactive constraint-based system for drawing graphs
The Harvard community has made this article openly available.
Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters.
Citation
Kathy Ryall, Joe Marks, and Stuart M. Shieber. An interactive
constraint-based system for drawing graphs. In Proceedings of the
10th Annual Symposium on User Interface Software and
Technology (UIST), 1997.
Published Version
http://doi.acm.org/10.1145/263407.263521
Accessed
June 15, 2017 6:10:13 PM EDT
Citable Link
http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:2258867
Terms of Use
This article was downloaded from Harvard University's DASH
repository, and is made available under the terms and conditions
applicable to Other Posted Material, as set forth at
http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-ofuse#LAA
(Article begins on next page)
An Interactive Constraint-Based System
for Drawing Graphs
!
"#$!%&'($)+*,-/.$!0$)$1
2 3)4&5(4%$!)!&67./8:99;<=
>@?BADC <E A ; C 9 A 99<<
*!FHG'(JI %$)0$!$1I &'K7L
M7N5OPQRST
UWVYX#Z
9< ?[ K7\]*
2 ^
_`$1K70&67UW8a<9 ? =;
>@?BADb?c5ADb 9 ?BA4cd =E
^,e(fFg^&JhI GB^
&Hwyxz{r|(*(4&'^}$1(o,$)&JnGf$)%&#GB`(+$) A _`(4&5K
&5K A
$)~-K]\q$!0(^,! A 3K€^&'K7$!L^ A (4$!J&5K‚0ƒ`(…„ d <
7K7&5(o†-&J\‡&Jfˆ/`‡0$)'&'(/&$!&'Gf$!,$!‰
^Š&
GB)1_un$)%&g^,&J`$!ƒ&'%$)L`(q(4*7(4&'^('IŒ‹(K7$!( A
$!0L$!($!0Ž-&5L`&5(†&#%7GJ_L1*-v(ƒ3&5GB$1!$)'&'K,GJ A
(4n$!n(-‘0ƒ:K7n]\q$)036
3K:‚($)^ƒ!&’GJ`(4n$! A
($1(4-lGf$)‰^&'Gn3$1(4^“`q)!\#(Y&ŽL3(4&'Y^$!ƒL A
1&&HK7n]\q$)0
\q$)!&#&gGJ`(4n$!(Y&GB$!%&I/&5(4&
-&'L&'(&5(4L)
$!0nƒ` A K]\q$!0~&'K7$)3
$1(
(Lƒu& A
$)g$!Q^,*\]*(s`(&
_`(4&5KWQ^Š&Š0&'&Jn”`K
ƒu\Y&'4-LvGJ`(4n$! A ($1(+-lGf$)•^&B`K`(JI
ABSTRACT
– nƒK7n]\q$)036GB`(+$) A _`(4&5K,1]*L'6K7n]\q$)`0
!('6
GB)1_un$)%&$!&J-lGJ&'('I
KEYWORDS
&~K7^$!`@^&Jƒ`Š$)—&K7&'($!0—-#L`^ A GB^ A
ƒ L7&J”$)&JnGf$)Ž$!(r`&o%$)&'\˜-`GJ^ƒL7&Jy(†TJOJRf™'kDNRfI/8# A
`L0‰$!&J-lGJ&'(†_3(&'K•,`$!(‡%$)&'\€`]%&#ƒ%&'K•L`(4&J-L
$!@%&J*Ž^*(4&J4$!0(J6šL`)$)$!%&‡ƒ0&'((y$)@&#&5#L^, A GB^ƒL7&'r$!&JnGB$!Ž^,]*]\‡$tv&Y_$!)$)+*$! A
&'Gfo\q$)‰&HGB^Šƒ`L7&'Y(H›nN)mNRDNRfIoœ‘&H`]%&q_`L$))
(4*7(4&J^6GJ)!&'KŸžnwyxz{y|7 ¡„ – ƒ¡Z ]*L‘‹ &'Gf$!%&
¢ $!0n^£V K7$)nˆB6-Y$!&'Gf$!%&g0nƒ‰!]*L756¥¤`‡ A
0$!J&'(`&@$!&JnGB$!W$!‘s^&@GJ!!_3$!%&^,`&J
3‚$!‚ƒ`&'%$!L3(•0nƒ` A K]\q$!0—(*(4&'^,(JI£&—wrxz{r|
(*(4&'^¦$1(W§GB`(+$) A _`(4&5K‚K7n]\q$!0§&'K7$)WK7&'($)0&'K
(ƒ3&5GB$)¨3GJ)!*~‰&'`_`)&@L`(4&'(s&'(4$!)*~ƒ7K7L`GB&Š(4^,)/`K
^&'K7$!L^ A (4$!J&5K:K7$10n^,('I©&’L`(4&'‘$1(‘&5(4ƒu`($!_)&—-
ª4«u¬
­¯®f°±n²]³5´Yµ·¶y¸q¶±n¹ºh³]¶/¹5»'¼]¶D½¶+¼]®f¶Œ¹5¶+ºµ¾»f°¯¿¼]ÀÁ±n®f°¯±n¸qÂuµrÀ¥¼]¶+à ¬
Ä®f°Âh±n¶4¼Y²5³]º¯À¥»ŒÊ+ÂÅ'ËvÀ¥Â ÌvÄ ³]±nÃ¥¶+À¥°¯Æ+¶†¶vÀ¥Ç]ÂyÀ¥¹±#±nÊ+°l»f¬‡¹]°hÂh¶4À¥ÃÁ¼]±¶+ºh°À¥±n»fÇ]¹]Ã¥Â4¶†ÈJ±nÃ¥À ¹]ºh¼q¶+°¹]±º »nº·°¯±n¶†°h»fÇ]¹ŽÀ ºh°®f±n°°h±n¬o²5À¥³5¹5½É)¼]»f°¯°¯±4¸#µr±À¥¹]ºhÀ¥®q»f¹±n±nà ½ Ã
®f»f°¯À ºh³]¸qÂ4ÈÇ Ä ºyÀ º”²5°¯À¥¸#±n°¯À¥Ã ¬Ê4»f¹5Ê4¶+°h¹]Â/¹]»f¹]À¥Ä ¹Bºh¶4°¯±nÊDº¯À ÅB¶oº¯¶+ʍ³]¹5À¥Í Ä ¶+Â/É)»f°
± Ä ºh»f¸#±º¯À¥ÊŒ®f°¯±n²]³HÃÁ±+¬B» Ä ºYÎ Ï5ÈÐ5ÈÑfÑBÈÑ4ÏÈÑ4ÒÓË
OVERVIEW
i hj`Rf i 7klO'mnOJR
Vo0$!&'&J$)0,p7GJ$)&'`GB&5(qZr_
%Ks"#$!%&'($t+*
2 ^
_`$1K70&67UW8a<9 ? = C
>@?BADb?c5A E; d]A 9=EE
(4$!&J_u&JBFg&J&5GJ('I 3%]KvI &5K7L
Qƒ`ƒ]Ô7$!^,&Ž1]*L7-Œ&Š7K7&'('6¾`K-H(ƒu&'GB$)-*$)`0
K&'GB1n$)%&J!*‰&Š%&Jn!r%$1(4L3”0`$)5$!-†`&ŠK7$1 A
0^I”&GJ^ƒL7&J#GJ%&'4n(o&'(&%$!(L` A 0`$)5$!
&'šL$!&J^&J(”$!Žg(&BŒ-uGB`(4n$!n(”&BÔ7ƒ&'((4&5K$!
&J^(
-y(4$!^ƒ!&gƒ*7($!G'¾^K&J¯6`K~GJ!GJL!&5(†&ƒ3(4$)$!`(
-v0nƒ`$!G'_7Õ+&'GB(Y%$1Žƒ*7($!G'3($!^
L1$)vIŒ"#!$)e&# A
K$t$)`q&'Gf$!%&$!&J-lGJ&'(Š$!Ö\q`$!GnÖ`&L`(4&',^,e&5(
&'šL&5(+•`K\$)(Š-•…&5(4ƒu`(&6qwrxz{r|’$1(•‘-L!)*’$) A
&JnGB$!%&@(*7(+&J^×$!‘\q`$!Gn‘_3…L`(4&'H`KQGJ^ƒL7&JŽGJ
Øu&5Gf‡&(4&g-v`&HK7n]\q$!0
($)^@Ltn&'L`(!*IŒ&(4*7( A
&J^ÙK&5(‡qƒ`L`(4&H\q$!)&H&L`(4&'#KK`(Y^Š%&'(Y7K7&'(
`KÚ&'K0&'('6/
ƒƒ!$)&5(@K7&')&J&'(@GB`(+$)n(JIWZr$)e&J\q$1(4&6
&L3(4&'YGJ,$)&J%&J`&`K,GJ$!L&q$)&JnGfY\q$t,&
K]\q$!0‰(q`&Š(*7(+&J^×K]Õ+L3(+n(7K7&@ƒ3(4$)$!3($!Q‘ A
&J^ƒ7q•($1(+-*,&Ž%$)L`(‡L`(&J A (ƒ3&5GB$)¨`&'K~GB`(4n$!n(JI
UW&Q(4ƒu&'GJ$t¨uGJ!!*6wyxz{r|§$!`GBƒun&'(sGJ&J-L!)*ÛGn A
(&JÚ(&BŽ-Šž4^,GJ ‰GB`(4n$!n(J6·.$1(4L`YÜg0$!'$!
Ý`&'L&'(„.gÜHÝ/(nˆf6v\q`$!Gn…&@!$!(4&5KQ$!ÚÝy$!0L`& ?Þ &,ƒ A
ƒ`)$1GJ$!-Œ&5Gn.gÜHݒ$!($)!)L3(+&'K_*˜mnOlßBNROH`K—4ßnOJR
1]*L7('I àÛ&L`(4&' A (ƒ3&5GB$)¨`&'K.gÜHÝ/(Ž&Šƒƒ!$!&'K‘_*‘GB A
%&J$!0`&J^á$)@(4&J†-v(ƒ$!0 A !$)e&-nGB&5(†Ø¾&'GB$!0&
`K&'(H$)Ús0nƒQK]\q$!0`I8gKK7$)$!`/-nGB&5(g&Š$) A
KL`GB&5K,L7^,$!G'!)*Žƒ&'(&J%&(4*Gf$!GqGJ&5Gf`&'((/&qK7n]\q$)03Iy&L`(&JŒ^,]*!(Hƒƒ!*Ž-nGB&K7$!&5Gf)*ŽŽ
`K&_*sK7n00$!0$t\q$)&^L3(4&IY&`K&'('6`\q$1Gn
&g^K&J!&'K•(Yƒu$!Y^,((&'('6&^Š%&'K,$!@^Š$!$!^
L^ A
&'&J0*âGB¨`0Ln$)`(_*âۃ`*7($!G'($)^@L1$!ã_`(4&5K
~Š0&J&')$!J&5K•-GJ& A K7$)&'GB&5K‰!0$)`^åä dæ 6\q`(&H_u& A
3]%$!q$1(#&5($)!*sƒƒ&'GJ$!&'K`K$)ç`L&J3GB&'K_*s&
L`(4&''I
`&Š($)^@L1$!‘-†&ƒ*7(4$1GJ”^7K7&'”$1($!^,&'K…GB A
$)LL`()*6rL3(
ƒ%$!K$)0L3(4&J-Lo%$1(4L`†-&'&'K7_`GneW&
L3(4&'
ä ? 6 ?'bæ Iq8#)`L0•\Y&5e•^&'Gn3$1(4^Ù-($!(4-*$)`0
GJ`(4n$!('6&J`&J0*‰^$!$!^Š$!'$!L0ƒ`*7($!G'r($!^ A
L`!$!
3`K7!&'(y%&' A GB`(4n$!&'K(*(4&'^,(y0GB&J-L)!*6`K
ƒ`%$1K7&'(~&'(4$!!*•L`K7&'(47Ks^Š&Jƒ-&ŽL3(4&''I
è Ìv³]¶+¯¶Œé”ê”ëÂy³]±4ÅB¶†Ç¶4¶+¹ŽÀ¥¹]Ê+»f°h²»f°¯±º¯¶+¼²5°¯¶DÅ5À¥» ¯à ¬gÀ¥¹gºµ·»qDZºhʍ³
Âh¬'Âhºh¶4¸q¾É)»f°v®f°±n²]³ÃÁ±4¬B» Ä º‡Î ì5È]íÓË`Ìr³5¶Œ²]°¯¶+¯¶+¹BºrÂh¬'ÂhºhÄ ¶4¸À¥Â·º¯³5¶/î°¯Âlº·º¯»
±nå廵@À¥¹Jºh¶+°±nÊDº¯À ÅB¶3¯²¶+Ê+À îÊ4±º¯À¥»f¹Y±n¹]¼†¸#±n¹]À¥² ÃÁ±ºhÀ¥»f¹Œ»nÉ]²¶+°¯ÂhÀ¥Âhºh¶+¹Jº7³5À¥®f³5½
Ã¥¶+ÅB¶+ÃBé”ê”ë`ÂÂ Ä Ê³o±nºh³]¶+¯¶fË7ï¹o°¯¶+ÃÁ±ºh¶4¼Œµ·»f°h¿Ä Èðy¶+¹]°l¬†±n¹]¼oð Ä ¼]¯»f¹o³±4ÅB¶
¼]¶+¯Ê+°¯À¥Ç¶+¼±n¹gÀ¥¹Bº¯¶+°¯±nÊ+ºhÀ ÅB¶/®f°¯±n²]³5½ÃÁ±+¬B» Ä ºvÂh¬'Âhºh¶+¸—ºh³±º Ä Âh¶4Âv±†¼]À ñ¶+°¯¶+¹Bº
¯¶Dºr»nɹ]»f¹]²¶+°¯Â¯À¥Âlº¯¶+¹Bº”ÃÁ±+¬B» Ä ºy»f²¶+°¯±º¯»f°hÂYÎ òÓË
A
A
A
B
B
C
C
A
B
(a)
(b)
A
B
C
C
(c)
(d)
Figure 2: User intervention is required to find a globally optimal solution.
Alignment
Even Spacing
C
C
Sequence
A
A
D
D
B
B
Cluster
T−Shape
Zone
Symmetry
D‹ wrxz{r|¾6L`(&JY^,$!ƒL1$)`(o&#L3(4&J-L¾o!*@-o&JÔ A
ƒ`)$!0K7&'($)0Št&J`$)%&'(”_L7Œ-/ƒ%$1K7$!0sžK7%$1GB&5 #
&Ž(4*7(4&'^“\q&J$)¨``K(q$)(&J)-y$!Š)7GJ¾ƒ7$)^@L^I†Ýy$!0 A
L`&@9Š$1(H,(4$!^ƒ)&@&BÔ^ƒ!&I‹DWݔ$!0L&@9„hˆB6`\‡&
(4&'&Ž`&'&
`K&'('6yGB&5Gf&5KQ_*Q+\Y~&'K70&'('I•&,L`(&JŽ`(ŽKK&'K…
($!0!&8#!$)0^&J.gÜHݗ,&
(&B-”7K7&5(JI&
(*7(+&J^
4&J^ƒ7(#‰($!(4-*•$1(gGJ`(4n$!_*~^%$!0&Ž`&'&
`K&'(¾\‡KH$!^Šƒ`)$1GB$)r$!Jn!$)`&ŒL`$)`0qL`0
&%&'4$!G'·GB&'$!K‰-y&&'&7K7&'( Þ ^&'\q$!!&6&
(*GB$1GsGJ`(4n$!@ƒ`$)_$)$!0Ú%&'1ƒ˜ƒ`%$1K7&'(Š…& A
ƒ`L!($!%&Ž-GJ&_3&J+\Y&'&J7K7&5(g`K&'K0&'('Iq‹DQݔ$!0L&
9„l_3ˆf6
wyxz{r|`(†^%&5K7K7&g8âK7\qv6`K`K&'( [ `K 2 Lƒ A
\nK('Ir&‡`&'&Y7K7&5(/GJ`”_3&q!$!0&5K·6\‡&J%&''6K7L`&
&,&5K70&_u&B+\‡&J&' [ `K 2 I [ *Q^,L3!)*W^%$!0~8
*\q`&J&`&!&B-Y- [ „hÝy$!0L`&9`„lG'ˆˆf6&gL`(&J†_7$)`(
sƒ7$!^,rn`0&J^&'„lݔ$!0L&9„lK3ˆ4ˆfI
`&'(&‰$!&JnGB$!`(@7GJGBL`Š(&~($!^
L1$)—$!(@L$!0`6
`K!!\‚&@GJ^ƒL7&Jg`K(*(4&'^Ù0&B`&J#‰GB)1_ A
&•$!—¨3`K7$!0Q_u&B&J0)_`‡(4)L7$)`(
W&~$)^ƒ!$!GJ$t
GJ`(4n$! A ($1(+-lGf$)€ƒ_!&J^I×pL`GnãK7%$1GB&Ú$!(&5(4ƒu& A
GJ$!)!*—L`(&B-L`#$)ÛG'(&'(-%&' A ,L`K7&'GJ`(4n$!&'K’K7& A
($!0`('I‚‹-˜(&B‰-H.gÜHÝ/(,0&J&'&'(,Û%&'GJ`(4n$!&'K
1]*L7'6`wyxz{y|•\q$!!¾¨``K‰&Ž&5&'(4(4_!&HGJ7¨`0Ln$!r6
\q`$!GnÛ^,]*’($!(4-*§K7$tؾ&J&J‰.gÜHÝ/(•—%*$)`0—K7&J0&'&'('I
`&sL`(&J56Œ\qÚGB!(&K7&5(4$!0’ƒ7GJ&'((@Š‘0!_`
!&J%&J„&WGn$!GJ&-g.gÜHÝ/(,`K—&0((Šƒ1GB&'^&J,`K&'(†$!`&K7$10n^•ˆB6GJ&'($!)*@0L$1K7&q&GB^ƒL7&'†
¨3`KW^&@($!(4-lGB*(4)L$!`(H`K‘G'GB&Jƒ_`)&@!]*L7n(
_*~^%$!0•`K&'(gK]Õ+L`(4$!0‰.gÜHÝ/('I#‹DQGJ(4&
-ŒL`K7&' A
GJ`(4n$!&5K!]*L7n(r\q$)@^
L)$!ƒ!&‡(!L7$!3(J65`&YL`(&J/GJ
!(Šƒ%$1K7&ŽK7%$1GB&H&Jԃ`)&Ž)&'3$!%&5(JI
‹D•&g&Bԇ(&'GB$!•\‡&#$!)!L`(4n&#`&L`(&-rwyxz{r|_*,K7& A
(GB$!_$)`0•+*ƒ$!G'y$)&'Gf$)-^ ,L3(4&' (qƒu&Jn(4ƒu&'GB$!%&I
œ…&†&JŠK7&'(GB$!_3&o&YL`K7&'!*$)0HGB`(+$) A (ƒ3&5GB$)¨3GJ$!
`K A ($!(4-lGB$!~^Š&5Gn``$!(^,($)K7&Bn$!hI
Hub Shape
Figure 1: Visual Organization Features (after [9]).
ݔ$!0L&'(
= c (4`\á(`ƒ3(4(
-q%$)L`(Ž$!&J^&'K7$1&
(40&5(Œ$)&#ƒ7GB&5((Œ-¾K]\q$!00$!%&'0nƒvI/ݔ$)0L&#=
K&Jƒ$1Gfn(¾&YGB^ƒ!&B&o(*(4&'^‚$!&J-lGJ& Þ &J¾¨30L&'(v(\
!*,&G'%(&'`I
EXAMPLE INTERACTION
GaussianRandomNum
Particle
Ion
VirtualParallelMachine
ParticleDistribution
Electron
ClockTimer
wyxz{y|
Figure 3: Initial layout, with labeled nodes and edges,
interface.
shown in the context of the
Grid
Plasma
EnergyDiagnostic
j`m i `O
Ák ,O 3
Figure
5: User adds three
more VOFs:
and .
GaussianRandomNum
i ,OJhRf
GaussianRandomNum
Particle
VirtualParallelMachine
Particle
ParticleDistribution
ParticleDistribution
VirtualParallelMachine
Class
Inheritance
Use Relationship
Plasma
Ion
Ion
Electron
Plasma
Grid
Grid
Electron
EnergyDiagnostic
ClockTimer
ClockTimer
Auxiliary Class
EnergyDiagnostic
Figure 4: User adds an
ÁjTfOJRfk
tk O ` VOF to each row.
݆(4$!^ƒ!$!GJ$t+*Š-¾&BÔ7ƒu($t$)v6`&q&BÔ^ƒ!&q$)&JnGf$)ŠK& A
ƒ $1Gf&'K`&J&Y$1(r_3(&'KŽ@qn(eŽ$)@\q$1GnŽ&‡L`(&JŒ&'^Šƒ(
~GB&'&
‰ƒ`$1GBL1g!]*L7)&'K7*~&J%$!($)&'Kv63n&J
3Ö&BÔ7ƒ!$)0Ú)&'3$!%&~1]*L('IÖ&L`(&J,ƒ`!GB&'(
(&B-‡7K7&'($)˜ƒ`ƒ]Ô7$!^,&')*&•K7&5(4$!&5KQ1]*L7L`(4$!0
(43KnK‘K$)&'GB A ^$!ƒL1$!‘&5Gn$1šL&'('I,V†%&'…Ž$1(
(40&6u\‡&J%&''6&(4*7(4&'^ $1(`&J!ƒ$)`0‰Lg_*L7^,$ A
GJ)!*&J7-GJ$)`0
ƒ$!_$)$!`(Y-y%&J1ƒƒ$!0`K&'( Þ `K&'(
,GB!(&H0&B&Jq\q$!!v_3&Ž&Jƒu&J!!&'K‰-^“&'Gns&''I
VoK0&'('67K7$!&5Gf&5K•‡L``K7$!&5Gf&5K·67!$)&540`h6GJ
_u&…KK7&'K€_3&J+\Y&'&J€7K7&5(JI ݔ$)0L&‘=(\#(•&…!]*L7
-&J…$!$)$1†`K& A `KQ&5K70& A ƒ`!GB&J^&'Žƒ3(&I #&
†À¥ÂŒÂhº¯±n¹]¼±n°h¼ŠÀ¥¹
¼]°±+µyÀ¥¹5®gºh»'»fÃ¥Â4Ⱥ¯³5¶ ¯¶+°Œ³±nÂoÊ+»f¹Jºh°¯»fÃ3»ÅB¶+°‡±
Åf±n°hÀ¥¶Dº¬»nÉ®f°±n²]³]À¥Ê4±nò]°h»f²¶+°lº¯À¥¶+Âu»nɺh³]¶”¹]»J¼]¶+ÂÄ ÈJÀ¥¹]Ê+Ã Ä ¼5À¥¹]®ŒÂ¯³±n²¶fÈJÉ!»f¹BºÈ
DZnʍ¿J®f°¯» Ä ¹]¼#Ê4»fÃ¥»f°4ÈfÉ!»f°h¶+®f°¯» Ä ¹]¼‡Ê4»fÃ¥»f°4ÈBÇ»f°¯¼]¶+°uÊ+»fÃ¥»f°4ÈJ±n¹]¼¼]À¥¸q¶+¹]ÂhÀ¥»f¹]ÂË
Ìv³]¶+¯¶Y±n°¯¶†¼]¶+°¯À ÅB¶+¼É)°¯»f¸§Âl¬5Âlº¯¶+¸Û¼]¶DÉ!± Ä Ã ºhÂȵr³]À¥Ê³ŽÊ4±n¹ŽÇ¶YÂh¶Dº/ÇB¬Hºh³]¶
ı Âh¶4ºh°4»fÈ3¸#±n±¹]º¯¼,À¥Ê4±n¸qåà »'¬g¼5¯À À¥îÆ+¶+¶+¼,¼H±ºh»#ºq±n±nÊ4¹BÊ+¬Š»f¸qºhÀ¥¸q¸q¶»J¼Å5±ÀÁºh±¶o±À ºh”¼]ÀÁÃÁ±n±nåǻf¶+®Ã ÇÀ »É3±Ë ¹]¾»J¼]±nʍ¶ ³,”¹5ÃÁ±n»'Ǽ]¶+¶ÃÀ¥À¥ÂÂ
ʍ³Ä ±n¹5®f¶4¼Èºh³]¶†Âh¬'Âhºh¶+¸ÖµrÀ¥Ã¥Ã± Ä ºh»f¸#±ºhÀ¥Ê±nåà ¬g¶+¹]ÃÁ±n°¯®f¶o±¹]»J¼]¶Œºh»#±nÊ4Ê+»f¸½
¸q»J¼±º¯¶gÀ º¯Âq¹5¶+µ§ÃÁ±nǶ+Ã1ËsÌv³]¶+¯¶Ê4±n²±nÇ]À¥Ã¥À ºhÀ¥¶+Â#±n°¯¶g¹]»nº#¯³]»4µr¹sÀ¥¹,ºh³]¶
î® Ä °h¶+ÂË
‡™O i `›Jk
Ák ,O 3
Figure 6:!"User
adds
three
text labels,
andthree
VOFs:
$#
!"
and
.
&H03`&5K70&g_3&J+\Y&'&J‰&~ž Œ4$!GJ)&5¢$1(+$!_L7$)` `K…žVo)&5Gf3 7K7&5(JI/&(*7(+&J^}\q$)!^,$!$!Š& A
0`)$)+*‘GJ`(4n$!•„lGB^ƒ$1($)0W+\YW)$!0^&'ŠGB A
(4n$!(`K˜ƒ3^ 7K7& …(4&'&•_u&J!\ˆHL`0L7
&K7&5(4$!0~ƒGJ&'((JI
yKK€—.gÜHÝ¡&…1]*L'6‡&…L`(&J‰¨`(4~(&J!&'GB(s
(&B-#`K&'(ŠL`($)0…(+n`K`nK˜^L`(&•&'Gn$1šL&'(Š(L`Gn(
GJ)$1Gne$)`0W@&'0$! A K7n00$)`0`I&‰L3(4&'
^,]*…&'ƒƒ`)*
&#^&.gÜHÝ/(q•&Š(4&J_*~ƒ`&5(($)`0&Šƒƒƒ`$ A
&HƒL`(‰_L4`('67)7GJ&5K•‰&$)0Y-r&\q$!`K7\€$!
ݔ$!0L&Ž=I/‹DÝy$!0L`&E`6&ŽL`(&J`(qƒƒ!$!&'K
`$)'
8)$!0`^Š&'
.gÜHÝې&s(4&5GB3K·6r$!K·6/3K…-LÚ\#(
-y7K7&5(JIŒ8g(q.gÜHÝ/(‡&ƒ`ƒ)$!&'K‰Š&Ž`(GB&'K7$10^6
0ƒ$1GJ7$)`K$!G'(/-3&GJ`(4n$!(Œ&qKK&'K·I/‹DŠ&
$!^ƒ!&J^&J&5KW(*(4&'^63&
0ƒ$1GJv.gÜHÝÖ$)`K$!G'(g&
(\qÛ%$1(4L`)!*Ö_*ۗK*3^$!GQ$!0!$)0$!0—^&'Gn`$1(4^
`oG'`†_u&#&'ƒ!$!G'&5K
$!•(4$!G$!^,0&'('Irœ…&q&'&J-&
L3(4&(43K7&5(o-r0n]*
@$!`K7$1GJ&K7$)Øu&'&'.gÜHÝ/(‡$)‰&g¨`0 A
L`& Þ &0&J*&'Gfn0)&5(o$!Ýy$!0L`&HEŠ(&J%&H(‡
0ƒ$1GJ
$!`K7$1GJq-r&8#!$!0^&J#.gÜHÝ/('I
%
'&
ƒ`*7($!G'Œ($)^@L!$!vI‹DÚKK$t$)v6v\‡&!(K7&'(GB$!_3&Š\
&WGB`(4n$!n(,`K§GJ`(4n$! A ($1(+-lGf$!’ƒGJ&'((,&
^,K7&Žƒƒ`&'‡Š&ŽL`(&J5I
GaussianRandomNum
`&
-L3K^&Jn/)\ A !&J%&'yGJ`(4n$!g^&'Gn`$1(4^×$1(&5( A
(&J$!)!*•(4ƒ$!0Š`_3&'*7(q#e& (‡Zy]\ Þ 0nƒs7K7&'(
^%&G'GBnK7$!0ۂ&Ö(ƒ$)`0 A )$!e&˜-GJ&'(…Gn`&'Kã
&J^I ‰8Ö^,(( A (ƒ$!0#^7K7&'-/0nƒ@K7]\q$!0g\‡(v¨`n(4
ƒ`ƒ3(4&5Ks_*VoK7&'(
ä dæ 6u_L7H$)W`$!(g`K^(+g(L_`(&'šL&'
(*7(+&J^,('6¾&,(ƒ$!0s-nGB&5(HGJ&5(4ƒu3K~ƒ3)0$1GJy
0&J^Š&J$!Gƒƒu&J$!&'(‡-v&0nƒrI”‹D‰&
wyxz{y|‰(*7(+&J^
„h(o$)…ä E æ ˆf67
^Š&0&J`&Jn$!•-r(4ƒ`$!0Ž-GJ&#$!(YL`(&'K·I
2 `(4n$!n(0nƒ``(Ž-l)$!W+\‡Q^,$!’GJ!((&'('6Œ(4* A
nGB$1Gg`K•(&J^,$1GI†p*Gf$!GgGB3(+$)(Y&L`$)%&Jn(
&'šL$!&J^&J(/`&'GB&5((*-YŽK7$!0n^ãŽ_3&#\‡&J! A -^&'KvI
`&˜wyxz{y|€(*7(+&J^ &5(4ƒu&'GB(‰+\YÖ(4L3GnâGB`(4n$!n(Q„h(4&'&
ݔ$!0L& C ˆ
!N O#" u!N O—N™]OJRf) %$€\‡7K7&5((4L1K€~%&J!ƒvI
$!(GJ`(4n$!s$1(~&J7-GJ&'K€_*ۃ1GJ$)`0’Ö(4ƒ$!0’_u& A
+\Y&'&JQ&5GnWƒ3$!g-o7K7&'('IŽ&(4ƒ$!0 (&'(4g!&J`0‘$!(
&‘&5šL`$)&'KÖ^$)`$)^@L^ K7$!(4`GB&_u&B+\‡&J&'Û7K7&'('6q_L7
$t•1(Q`(
&ƒƒu&J+*‘`,$)((ƒ$!0ÚGB`(+n& A
K7L`GB&5('&J\q&J˜(4&BGn`&'K‘_3&'*3K‘$)(&5(+!&J0vI
&@(ƒ$)0•&'&J-&!*ƒƒ`)$!&'(#-nGB&\q&'`&
+\‡
7K7&'(/%&J!ƒv6GB^Šƒ`&5(($)`0&q(4ƒ$!0`I†Üg%&'1ƒƒ`$)0g$!(
L`(‡ƒ&J%&'&'Kv6_L‡^%&'^&J‡ƒ`Y$1(o`ƒ3&'`!$)'&'K·I
$!(#$!(q&Ž-Œ(&J%&'·\‡]*7(‡$!\q$!Gn~&(4$!^
L`!$!$!(
&'`K7&J&'K‘ƒ*7(4$1GJ”_*W0&J&')$!J$!0‰&,$!…-
(4ƒ$!0`I
!N O#"4&O OŽN™]OJRf) '$Y8€(4$!^$)1†(ƒ$)`0Ž$!(oƒ!GB&5K@_u&B+\‡&J&'
&'Gn’7K7& A &'K0&‰ƒ3$!'I K&'(&•&!*Ú_7Õ+&5Gf(@
\q$!GnW-nGB&
G'W_u&@ƒƒ!$)&5K·6·(4,&
0r-oƒƒ!*$)0s
-nGB&H,s&'K70&$!(qGfL3!)*•GJGB^ƒ)$1(&'Ks_*•ƒƒ!*$)`0
`)-Y&Š-nGB&Š&5GnQ-Y&Š+\Y7K7&5(Ž`&Š&5K70& (
&J`K7ƒu$!('I€$1(•K7$1(((7GB$1$!_3&J+\Y&'&JÖ&W(ƒ$)`0 (
GB3GB&JƒL`·&J`K7ƒu$!(#`K‰&Žƒu$!(-/ƒƒ`)$1GJ$!~&q(ƒ$!0 (v-nGB&‡$!(”&'y&JÔ^ƒ!&Y-\—L`y^7K7&J
K7$tؾ&Jn(g-^ ^Š&@ƒ*7(4$1GJ)!*~-l$)7-L/^,(( A (ƒ$)0s(4*7( A
&J^,('I
8ƒƒ!*$)0
&5(4&g+\‡
(4*Gf$!GgGB3(+$)(Y!&6&(4*7( A
&J^å&'7-nGB&5(g&,\‡&J! A -^&'K7`&'((g-‡K7$10^,(JI@p7&J^, A
$!GGJ`(4n$!('6·&BÔ7ƒ&'((4&5KQ(H.gÜHÝ/('6v&J3`GJ&@&%$!(L`
-^ 3KGB^^@L$1GJ$)%&Žƒ3\‡&J-Œ`&@K7n]\q$)`0`)I (Šxz{y|
(Lƒƒu(‡&Ž-)!\q$)`0Š.gÜHÝ/('67$)^ƒ!&J^&'&'K\q$)(&B(#0&J&')$!J&5K‰(ƒ$)0(q(K7&5(GJ$!_3&5Kڄl(&J&ŽÝ”$)0L& C ˆ *l`NRf,k +5N 3 ~™OJRfhkl›n OJk`OB.R -/$§&˜(&B Ák O `
7K7&'((L1K‘_3&GB)!$)`&'3K‘Ô$1( A )$!0&5K·IŽ8 (4ƒ$!0
\q$t—&5(+@)&'0˜J&J$1(
Gn&'KÚ_u&B+\‡&J&'˜&'Gn˜`K&
0 ðr»'»f¿f¶ 2
 17±4µ‚Âhº¯±ºh¶4º¯³]±ºÂhºh°±nÀ¥¹Èrºh³]¶°±ºhÀ¥»»nɆºh³]¶Ê³±n¹]®f¶
À¥¹
Ã¥¶4¹5®nº¯³•º¯»
º¯³5¶»f°¯À¥®fÀ¥¹±nÃvÃ¥¶+¹]®nºh³ÈvÀ¥Â²]°h»f²»f°hºhÀ¥»f¹±nÃyºh»@ºh³]¶Âlº¯°h¶4Âh‡ºh³±º
²]°¯»J¼ Ê+¶+ÂHÀ º4
Ë 3!4658797;:6<>=.?,@&A2=.?CBED&?=GFIH.Jâï¹~±n¼]¼]À ºhÀ¥»f¹~ºh»,¯²]°hÀ¥¹]®n½Ã¥À¥¿f¶
É!»f°hÊ4¶+Ä Â4ÈB±nÃ¥Ã5¹]»J¼]¶+Â3±n°¯¶¾Â Ä Ç!Kl¶+Ê+ººh»Œ±”®fÃ¥»fDZnÃ5¼±n¸q²]À¥¹]®rÉ!»f°hÊ4¶3É!»f°Âhº¯±nÇ]À¥Ã¥À º¬BË
Constraint Formulation
VirtualParallelMachine
ParticleDistribution
Particle
Class
Inheritance
Use Relationship
Ion
Electron
ClockTimer
Plasma
Auxiliary Class
Grid
EnergyDiagnostic
Figure 7: The finished layout.
&Q(*7(+&J^ ($1(+¨3&'(&'(&QGB`(4n$!n(,%$!…&‘($!^
L1 A
$!‘!0$)^ K7&'(GB$!_3&5K$)‘^&
K7&Bn$!y_u&J!\ŽIH‹D`K7&J&5K·6
^%&'^Š&'-r&Ž7K7&'(‡,($1(+-*,&GB`(4n$!n(‡\YL!K
+*ƒ$1GJ!!*,ƒ7GJ&J&'K‰\q$!)&g&L`(&J$1(KK7$!0Š^&g.gÜHÝ/('I
ݔ$)0L& d (\#(q&@(4_!&
GB7¨`0L`$!3g&'`(L&'(g- A
&'/&‡&'&‡8)$!0`^Š&'/.gÜHÝ/(/`]%&o_u&J&'($!(4¨`&5K·6!0
\q$)&J&‡^Š&Y.gÜHÝ/(r&‡L`(4&'/`(”KK&'K·I†ÜgŽ`&‡$!0'6
`&‰L`(&J3(
KK7&5K˜#L_’p7`ƒu&‰.gÜH݇6r$!`K7$1GJ&5K˜(
!$)0g0n]*sGB$!nGB!&I&@GB&J&Jg+\Y,7K7&5(@„hKe~0n]*7ˆ&
s_3&%&J$1GJ!!*~)$!0&5K·IÝy$!`)!*6¾&
-LH7K7&'(gQ&
!&B-#`]%&H3K~p7*^^&B*s.gÜHݗƒ`ƒ)$!&'Ks@&J^I
Üg`GJ&o0$!v6B&Y(*7(+&J^â4&J^ƒ7(rg($1(+-*H!-&YGJ A
(4n$!n(J6u_u‘1KW3K&J\Ž6¾$!QK7&J&J^$)`$)0~&'Gn7K7& (
ƒ1GJ&J^&J'I†Ý”$!0L& b (\#(Y`&ŽLƒuK`&5K~7K7&ƒ3(4$)$!`('I
VoGn\â$!(g(+$)!y)$!0&5K·63`K~`&&J\ã.gÜHÝ/(#3]%&Ž_u&J&J
($1(4¨`&'KÚ(\‡&J!¯I•‹D˜KK7$)$!r6v`&•L`(&JK`K(`&'&&BÔ
1_u&J1(ŽQ&‰!]*L75IWr&JÔ@!_3&'!(Š&•(4$!^ƒ!*ÚQ(4ƒu&'GJ$! A
$!J&'K•7K7&#+*ƒu&IŒ&L3(4&'o`(Yƒƒ!$)&5K&J&^Š&.gÜHݔ('6
\q$1Gn‘\q$!!”_u&B&'Žƒ3(4$)$!…&'GnQ-o&Š&JÔ1_u&J1('I@&
!$)0 A 0]*§7K7&5(â&˜!&B-Q&Ú(L_7Õ+&'GBÛ 2 )L3(+&J
.gÜH݇Iq&…K`e A 0n]*`K&'(~‚&…_34^ &‘Ö_3&
$!Jn!)*˜)$!0&5K·I—&~^$!KK)&~`&'&s7K7&5(J6Y(4`K7&'K
^&'K7$!L^å0]*6u&
s_3&&J%&J!*(4ƒ3GB&5K·IŽÝ”$)0L& c (\#(
`&¨``·1]*L7q0&'&Jn&'K•_*‰&-L!r(&Bq-/$!&Ž.gÜHÝ/(JI
Ý^×sL`(&J (gƒ3&'(ƒu&'Gf$)%&6ywyxz{y|$1(g~($)^ƒ!&@`$)0 A !&J%&J
!$ &J-lGJ&-K`K7$)`0s3KWK7&J!&B$)`0‰7K7&5(g`KW&5K70&5(J6¾`K
-sƒƒ!*$)`0Ú`KÖ&'^%$!0Ú%$)L`(.gÜHÝ/(J6Y`&J&J_*$! A
K7L`GJ$)`0Š`&J\ãK7]\q$!0(JI/$1(‡-lGJK7&$!(^,$)$)`&'Ks_*•&
L`K&J)*$!0
(*(4&'^6\q$1Gn,$!(YGB$)L`)!*@n`(!$!0ŽL`(&J
GB$!`($!˜!\ A !&J%&J#GJ`(4n$!(Š3•$)•&'Ö$)&5(
($1(4-*I†‹D~`$!(g(4&5Gf$!r6\Y&ŽK7&5(GJ$!_u&&&J1$)`($)ƒ~_u& A
+\‡&J&J&$!0 A !&J%&Jv.gÜHÝ/(`K~`&
!\ A !&J%&JvGB`(4n$!
^&'Gn`$1(4^,('6`KÖ\ &QGJ`(4n$!(,&($1(4¨`&'KÖ_*
Ìr³5
¶ Âl¬5Âlº¯¶+¸€À¥Â/µr°¯À ºlº¯¶+¹À¥¹ÌvÊ4à Ìv¿ÈµrÀ ºh³ºh³]¶ÂhÀ¥¸ Ä ÃÁ±ºhÀ¥»f¹
µr°¯À ºlº¯¶+¹sÀ¥
¹ ”˾Ìv³]¶Â¯À¥¸ ÃÁ±ºhÀ¥»f¹‰° ¹]ÂÊ+»f¹JºhÀ¥¹ ±nåà ¬JÈy²»fååÀ¥¹]®ŠÉ)»f° ¯¶+°
À¥¹]² Ä º Ä ÂhÀ¥¹]®Šºh³]¶ ŠÄ É1±nÊ+À¥Ã¥À º¬‰Ä ¼ Ä °hÀ¥¹]®ÂhÊ4°hÄ ¶+¶4¹ Ä ²¼±ºh¶4Â4˘ï¹~Ä ºh³]À¥Â
¸#±n¹]¹]¶+°4È Ä Âh¶+°ŒÀ¥¹]² Ä º†Ê4±n¹ŠÇ¶YÀ¥¸q¸q¶4¼5ÀÁ±º¯¶+à ¬°h¶¶+Ê+ºh¶+¼ŠÀ¥¹Žºh³]¶²]³B¬5ÂhÀ¥Ê4±nÃ
¯À¥¸ Ä ÃÁ±ºhÀ¥»f¹Ë
IMPLEMENTATION
`K•
%$)L`3Ô$1( A )$!0&5K)$!&L0&GB&'$1K&~7K7&'('I #&•`Š-nGB&5(@&‰ƒƒ!$)&5K˜`)*…Q&
7K7&'('6†`K—@&s%$!4L`‡Ô7$1(JIW‹D—&~GJ(&•-
$)'¾q%&'4$!G'·8#!$!0^&J#.gÜH݇6`&Ô7$!(q)$!0 A
^Š&'•$!(…&&'(ƒ3&5Gf$)%&~Ô$1('I§`&$!K§G'(&sL`(&'(
&,Ô7$1(g\q$1GnW`&Š`K&'(Ž&@)&'K7*^(4ŽGJ)(4&')*
!$)0&'K·I
Bj` i ›Bk *lNRf,k +5N `D v™OBRf¯kl›n -/$”&Œ7K7&5(r(L`!K
_3&Š(4ƒ`GB&5Ks&'%&')*!`0@&
0$)%&JÔ7$1(JI#pƒ3GB$!0•)0
&`0`”Ô7$1($1(HL`GB`(4n$!&'K·I8gK]Õ4GJ&JŽƒ`$!n(
-v7K7&5(Y&GJ`&'Gf&'K\q$)~(4ƒ$!0(Œ\q`(&#&5(+‡)&'0
$!(s`&ÚGJ^ƒL7&'Kâ]%&Jn0&WK7$1(+n`GJ&‘_u&B+\‡&J&'âKÕ4GB&'
7K7&'('I
i O Bj`O u›nO *l`NRf,k +5N 3 ™OBRf¯kl›n -/$Ž&Š7K7&5(H(L!KQ_3&
nK7&J&'K$!`&@GBL`&Jg(&'šL&'`GB&Š!0&
0$)%&JQÔ$1('I
pƒ$)0(q\q$)WŠ%&'*‰(4#&'(4#)&'0`K~\q$)W(*^ A
^Š&J$!G…(ƒ$!0GJ`(4…„'&J$)-7K7&'(&W$!‚ƒ`ƒ3&'
(4&5šL`&J`GJ&6vƒu($t$)%&`&J\q$!(&5ˆg&@ƒ`!GB&'KQ_3&J+\Y&'&JÚK A
Õ4GB&'#7K7&'($!~&(&'šL&'`GB&H,e&J&'ƒ‰&J^ $)nK7&''I
tjTnDOJ#R $r&Y(4&Jr-77K7&5(r(L1K_u&oGB!L`(4&J&'KH0&B`&J5I
pƒ$)0(
\q$)ÖW(@&'(4
!&J0’&‰ƒ!GB&5K˜ƒ`$!\q$!(&
^0Š&Ž7K7&'('I
N ¾O $Y&Ž_uL`K$)0_u]ԉ-”`&Ž7K7&'(q(L`!KGB$!
—&Js7K7&'('I:&W_uL``K7$!0_u]Ԓ$1(•&5&'KÛ(‰
ž(Lƒ3&' A 7K7&6 &Q7K7& A 7K7&W%&J!ƒ’^&B7K§$!(sƒ A
ƒ)$!&'Kv6”`KW&,&'(Lt$)`0s-GJ&'(Ž&ƒƒ`)$!&'K…&'šL`)!*
&Ž7K7&5(#GB^ƒ$1($)0@`&ŽJ`&I
i OJhRf *lNRf,k +5N `D Œ™OBRf¯kl›n -/$†`&#7K7&'(Y(4`L1K_3&
(4*^^&B$1G_uL7g&
0$!%&JWÔ7$!('IqVoGn7K7&
$!(ƒ`$!&5K
\q$t&
7K7&
GB!(&'(4q‰$tn(#&Bç`&5Gf$!_3L7#`&$ A
Jn/H%&'4$!G'”)$!&ŠL`0&,GB&J$!K-Y!”&
7K7&'('I‡„h8`K&‡^,]*_u&Yƒ`$)&'K
\q$t
$)(&J)-3$)-`$)/$1(/GB!(&'(4
$tn(Ž\q…&Jç`&'GB$!vI¥ˆ—VYšL3Œ`K…ƒƒ3(4$)&Š-GJ&'(&
&'‘ƒ`ƒ)$!&'K~•&
7K7&5($!W&5Gnƒ`$)•^,e&Ž`&J^
(4*^^&B$1GŽ_uL7`&Ž)$!&Ž-/&Bç`&5Gf$!rI
" i !O $&•7K7&5((L1K‘-^  A (43ƒu&6/(Ž$!˜
&J&‰K7$10^I~&sL`(&J
(ƒ3&5GB$)¨`&'(
\q$1Gn˜-&s7K7&'(
$!(H&,ƒ`&J5I@&, A (4`ƒ3&.gÜH݀G'‘_3&,&'7-nGB&5KQ(
GB^
_$!`$)-·8#!$)0^&J‡`KVošL`upƒ`GJ$)`0Ž.gÜHݔ(
-`&•Gn$)1K7&JÚ`KڅVYšL3†pƒ`GB$!0.gÜHݔ(H-&
)&J-^(4`K~$)0^(4Gn`$)1K7&J`Ksƒ`&'5I
j`m i ` `O $o&#7K7&5(o(L1KŠ_3&gƒ1GB&5KŠK7$!)!*
&5šL$ A
K7$!(4#GB$!GJ)&I†8aGB&J·7K7&Ž^,]*•ƒ7$)`!!*•_3&
(4ƒu&'GJ$t¨`&5KQ_*&L`(4&' Þ $t-‡&$1((4ƒu&'GJ$t¨`&5K·6rsƒ`^
7K7&H„hK7&'(GB$!_3&5K_u&J!\ˆ·$1(”KK7&5K”&GB&'&J5I”p7ƒ$!0(
&†ƒ1GB&5K_3&J+\Y&'&J`&J$!0_3(v`&oƒu&J$)^&B&J”`KŽ_u& A
+\Y&'&JW&GB&J&J`K&Š`KW&5Gnƒu&J$)^&B&J7K7&@\q$t
&5(+q!&J0&'šL`¾`&GJ1GBL`!&'K~]%&'0&#nK$)L`('I
#
Node-Node Overlap
Node-Edge Overlap
!
Alignment (horiz.)
Equal Spacing (horiz.)
Nodes
Edge
Rest length
Spring
Forces
Symmetry (vert.)
Legend
Figure 8: Reduction of some sample VOFs to systems
of generalized springs.
‹DKK$t$)v67`&-!)\q$!0.gÜHݗGJ_3&ŽL`(&'KsŠ0$!_ A
(!L7&ŽGB·%&'o&¨`& A 0$)`&'Ksƒ3(4$)$!~-/7K7&'( ¾›`N#R $‡8ã7K7&(L1K~_3&Ž!7GJ&'Kq&GJL&Jqƒu A
($t$)Ú&'0nK7!&'((H-\q`Ž&J-nGB&'(H$!Ú&,ƒ`*7($!G'
($)^@L1$!Û^,]*Ö_3&…GB$!0—‚$t5I¡&Q8`Gns.gÜHÝ
$1($)^ƒ!&J^&'&'K~_*•GJ!GJL!$!0!3-GJ&'('6_L7q`&J~
Lƒ¾K$!0H&‡ƒ3(4$)$!3(y-33Gn&'KŽ`K&'('Iy$1(/$!(/GJ A
GJ&Jƒ7L`!)*‰&'šL$!%])&'Y@0$)%$!0Š`Gn&5K,7K7&'(‰$!7¨ A
$)&
^(('I
8#)`L0&Š(4*7(4&J^ GJ#^Š%&`Gn`&'K~7K7&'('63&
L`(&J^,]*•(+$)!·^%&g&'^“%$!@&^ŠL`(&IŒ8L`(4&J-L¾&5Gn A
$1šL&@$1(-‰L`(&Jg~`Gn`#+\‡‰`K&'(g‰-L4&JŽGJ A
(4n$!sŠ(4&5GB3K•.gÜH݇I"#`K&Jq#L_p`ƒ3&.gÜH݇6-&BÔ A
^ƒ!&6'`&†K7$!L`(·-&†L_Ž$1(rK7&J&J^$)`&'KH_*HG'1GBL1$)0
`&
]%&'0&ŽK7$1(+n`GJ&_3&J+\Y&'&J&
GB&'&Jg7K7&
`K&'Gn
7K7&‰)0~&‰ƒ3&'$!ƒ&'*IsyW_7n$!˜(4ƒu&'GJ$t¨3G•K7$)L3(J6
`&sL`(&JGBL1K—`Gn`&GB&J&JŠ7K7&~)0W\q$)’&
7K7&WÖ&Wƒu&J$!ƒ&J*I&L`(&J‰G'Ö`&JÛ&'($)'&&
L__*•^%$!0&J$)`&Jq-”`&`Gn&5K•7K7&5(JI
ݔ$)3!)*6ywrxz{r|Qƒ%$1K7&5(gs(4$!0!&kl›JRfk¯kl›·.gÜH݇I¾8 K7$ A
GJ$)$1GJ.gÜHÝ:K7&'(Šƒ`%$1K7&~*—GB3(+$)’&
K7$10^~6¾_L^&'&')*WL0^&Jn(&K7$!0n^ \q$)ÚKK7$ A
$!3†0ƒ$1G&J!&J^&J(Ž$!&'K…‘(ƒ3&5Gf(-‡&‰K$!0n^
1]*L'I&ŠK7$1GB$)$1GJy.gÜHÝÖ$)^ƒ!&J^&J&'KQgƒ&'(&J$1(
`&Ýn^&.gÜHÝ R ,!O $@`&,_3L`K7$!0W_u]ÔQ-‡`&‰(4&J-7K7&'($!(K& A
^,nGJ&5KW\q$)‘~K7n]\q-n^&IŽ8(H&Š7K7&'(Hƒ`4$!GJ$ A
ƒ`$!0$!—Ýn^&.gÜH݀^%&6v`&-^Š&,&Jƒu($)$!`(
`KW&'($)'&'(g$tn(4&'t-‡GJGJnK7$!0!*IŽ&ŠL`(&JGB!(g(4L`Gn
ƒƒu&J$!&'(Y-r&g-^&g(Y$)(GB)'6ƒ`K`K7$)`0s„lK$!(4`GB&
KK7&'K~&
_3L`K7$!0•_u]Ôs_u&B-&Ž_u&J$!0‰K7n]\q3ˆB6``K
\q&J&'/&‡-n^&$!(/K7n]\q@(/ŠL7)$!&y¨`!)&5K@&'GB A
0!&I—
& u&‰.gÜHÝã&JÔ^ƒ!&s$!Öݔ$!0L& ? $1(@$!!)L`( A
&'K~L`($!0,Ýn^&.gÜHݔ('I
&‰GJ`(4n$!-^
L1$)Ú_3%&&5(4L)(
$)—ƒ`*7($!G'
(*(4&'^ GJ`($!(4$!0Ú-˜(4&J,-7K7&'(
W3KÖÚ(&B•0&'&Jn!$!J&'K’(4ƒ`$!0(
W,*—0$!%&'—$!^&fI K&'(
&‰ƒu($)$!&5K’…GJ%(@-g+*ƒ$!G'q($)'& ? <9
E cC <6
3K7K7&
^,((&'(g&
L$)-^)*(&Bg ? -g&'(&
-oGJ A
GBL`!$!vI &˜(4ƒ$!0ÖGJ`(4
( & ? I 9<`I <—-
(*nGf$!GHGB`(4n$!n(J6<I E@-q(4&'^,$1GgGJ`(4n$!(Y&J
3 2 )L3(+&J$)036q`K§<I < C - 2 )L`(4&'$!03I‚&Q(ƒ$)0
&'(4g!&J0`( &@K7&B&J^Š$!&5KW_*~&Š.gÜHݧGB%&Jn(4$!v6
(K7&'(GB$)_u&'K_3%&I&^,0$)L`K7&
-o(ƒ$!
0 (q-nGB&
$1
( „ ˆ_*’e& (•Zy]\Ž6\q&J
& $!(&QGfL3
!&J0‚-`&…(ƒ$)0Ö~$!^
& fI K
& $1(‰&J&B-&
ë»f°`¹5»nº±ºhÀ¥»f¹±nÃ]ÂhÀ¥¸q²]Ã¥À¥Ê+À º¬”µ·¶¾»f¹5à ¬†À¥¹]¼]À¥Ê4±º¯¶u¼]¶+²¶+¹]¼5¶4¹5Ê+¬‡»f"¹ !¶ '½
²]Ã¥À¥Ê+À ºhà ¬‡µr³]¶+¹H±†¼]À¥Âlº¯À¥¹]ÊDºhÀ¥»f¹#¸ Ä Âlº¾Ç¶/¸#±n¼]¶rǶ+ºµ¾¶4¶+¹g¼]À ñ¶4°h¶+¹Jº¾ºhÀ¥¸q¶+ÂÈ
¶fË ®]Ë¥#È !±n¹]$¼ !&%(')!Ë7«¾¶4Ê4± Ä Âh¶¾¹]»J¼]¶+±n¹]¼Œé”ê”ë`Âʍ³±n¹]®f¶v±nÂl¬5¹]ʯ³]°¯»f¹]» Ä Â¯Ã ¬
À¥¹†°¯¶+¯²»f¹]Âh¶uºh»”º¯³5¶ Ä Â¯¶+° ±nÊ+ºhÀ¥»f¹]Â3±n¹]¼†º¯»rº¯³]¶·ÂhÀ¥¸ Ä ÃÁ±ºhÀ¥»f¹È±nÃ¥ÃJºh³]¶¾Ån±n°¯À ½
±nÇ]Ã¥¶+ÂrÀ¥¹ºh³]¶†Â¯À¥¸ Ä ÃÁ±º¯À¥»f¹±n°h¶/º¯À¥¸q¶/¼5¶4²¶+¹]¼]¶+¹BºË
Constraint Satisfaction
(L_7Õ+&5Gfg‰•nr-nGB+
& *, .-0/ 214365798 *: „ ;#<>=4<# <? <# ˆ#
$)^&@f6Œ\q&J&@A#„B;+ˆ$1(
&(4&JŠ-(4ƒ`$!0(@ؾ&'GB$!0‘`K&
6r3K *: B„ ;C<>=D<C <E <# ˆf6·&
-GJ&@%&'GBH&'(Lt$)`0‰-^
&Gf$)•-r(ƒ$)`F0 ‰7K7G& 6$!(‡K7&B&J^$)&5K•_*Š&
&J!&J%q.gÜHݗGJ%&'($!‰(Gn&J^&I
– $!%&'
$1(†(4&JLƒr6V†L!&J (/^Š&J7K@$!(†L`(4&5KŽGB^ƒL&‡&
ƒu($)$! H * B„ 4ˆ†`K^^&'L^ *I B„ 4ˆŒ-·&'Gn7K7G& %&'
$)^& - <
-#!·7K7&'(J *I B„ 4ˆ - < Þ
&Jƒu&'
- > K Þ
-#!v7K7&5(L
*, M- / 2143N5998 *: „;C<O=4<# <? <E ˆ Þ
-P N9 Q ^,Ôv„O ˆ Þ
- q&' Gns`K&R *I „B4ˆ - *I „B K 4ˆ
> „ S*, P *I „B K 4ˆˆ K Þ
$)-S/ $1(L``Gn&'K
&J H * „B4 ˆ - H * „ K 4ˆ > *I „ 4ˆ K &J1(& H * „4 ˆ - H * „ K 4ˆ Þ
$t-/!(+(GB&J&'‰Lƒ¾K&Ž\(^&H` KT 0
`&JLƒ¾K&(GJ&'&Js&Jç`&'GBqƒ3(4$)$!`( H * „B4ˆ
L`$) / *I „4 ˆ+àU 9VXWY 7Z Þ
`&~K^ƒ$)`0…GJ`(4 P -&'Gn7K7&(L1K—$1K7&5!)*
_u&&@GJ$)$1GJ A K^Šƒ`$)0•GJ`(4#-`g7K7&63_L-
GJ^ƒL7n$)`($!^Šƒ`)$1GB$)+*6q\‡&Wƒƒ`]Ô7$!^&~`$!(‰_*&
GJ$)$1GJ A K^Šƒ`$)0GB`(4/-†&#(40&'(4/(ƒ$)`0H$!Š&
(*7(+&J^I‹D—ƒnGB$1GB&6r$!(ŠK^Š$)4&'K7!*…0((ƒƒ`]Ô7$!^ A
$)§`(,\‡e&5KšL$)&\‡&J!h6&')$!^$)`$!0˜(GB$!!!$!`($!
)^(+!G'(&'('I—&s$!^Š&$!`GB&J^&' K $1(Š<`I < ? 6†`K
(GB&J&',Lƒ¾K&'(‡7GJGBL`o&J%&J* KT - N< [ ? $!^&gL`$tn(JI/œÛ&'
&‡e$!&J$1G†&J`&J0*0&'(r_3&')\—
_$)n*g%)L)& W\Y 9Z]N< [ < ? ^_ `^t6&g($!^
L1$)‰(4L3(4ƒu&J`K`(o$)(&J)-v&'^ƒ3$!)*
L`$)v&Ž&JÔ#L`(4&'#GB$!vI
[ *…0&'&Jn!$)'$)`0s&•%$1(4L`Yƒƒ3&5n`GJ&-q0nƒÚ7K7&5(J6
&'•(ƒ3&5Gfn(-g0ƒ§K7]\q$!0ÚGJÖ!(‘_u&&BÔ7ƒ&'((&'K
\q$)s.gÜHÝ/(JI/ÝY$!`(43GB&6¾DEO a/)mOJ¥T†$!sK7$10^,(†GJ•_3&
$!^ƒ!&J^&J&5KW\q$)L7KK$t$)`”$)-(+L`GBL&IŽ8¡&JÔ
1_u&J‡$1(
^&J&J!*ÚW7K7&s\q$t’`(4ƒ3&J
_`Gne0L`K
`K€_unK7&''I Zr_3&'!(GJÛ`&J_3&ÚGn`&'K§’0ƒ$ A
G'†_7Õ+&'GB(ŽL3(4$!0W 2 !L`(+&J$)`0~.gÜH݂-Ž&JÔ^ƒ!&6/(Ž$!
ݔ$!0L& c I•p$!^$)1)*6y~7K7&\q$)Ú&J$)`&J_unK7&J56v_`Gne A
0L`K·6‡&Bԉ$1(•Úe$!`K§- ` `DN ¾N O3‰GJ
Visual Presentation
_u&sL`(&B-L`‡(
QGJYƒ3$)@-Š`&J
_7Õ+&'GB('6†(4L3Gn(
&'K0&'(•sÝ`^&.gÜHݔ('I ‹Dۃ3$1GBL156qÛ`0`
&'K0&‰G'Ú_3&s&Bؾ&'GB&'KÚ_*…$)&Jƒ3!$!0Wƒ`^ 7K7&
&
&5K70&
_3&J+\Y&'&J+\‡‰GB&'GB&5K7K7&'(H`K)$!0`$)0
`&‰ƒ`^ 7K7&•\q$)&'Gn˜-&s$)0$)`Œ7K7&'(
%$!
`0`¾8#!$!0^&J#.gÜHÝ/('I
‹DsKK7$)$!,&g0ƒ$1GJ3GB^ƒ3&J(o-v&gK$!0n^
$)(&J)- `&•7K7&'('6/&'K70&'('6”`K…-n^&'( &s$)&J-lGB&
L`(&'(%$1(4L`¾^Š&5`(‡ƒ&5(4&'Y@&ŽL`(&J‡`&GBL&'(&B
-3.gÜHݔ(r3Œ&o_u&J$!0Hƒƒ!$)&5KŽ#`&K$!0n^&J!&J^&J('I
VoGnQ.gÜHÝÛ$!`(4`GB&$1(Ž$)3K7$!G'&'K‘_*‘s0ƒ$1GJ‡k kl›n> "
DNRŠ$)’&WK$!(ƒ1]* Þ &W(`ƒu&-&.gÜHÝa$!`K7$1GJ,$1(
($)^$!!
W`&‰_$)^,ƒ’˜&GB&'(ƒ3`K7$!0ƒL`(_L A
Q-`Ž.gÜHÝY6v((4\q…$!…Ý”$!0L&,=I ‚8(H&,L`(&J
^%&5(v&^ŠL`(&Y%&J/ƒ`4$!GJL1”.gÜHݐ$)3K7$!G'”@&
GJ%](J6/wrxz{r|‘$!0!$!0(Ž)†ƒ3$1GB$!ƒ`$)07K7&5(JI 2 A
%&'(&J!*6ƒ!GB$!0`&#^L`(&q%&'†Ž7K7&q\q$!)3$)0!$)0o&
.gÜH݀$!`K7$1GJ(g-Ž.gÜH݂$)3(+n`GJ&'($!…\q`$!Gn…37K7&
ƒ`4$!GJ$)ƒ`&5(JI¡Ý”$!`!!*6ƒ`!GB$!0˜`&‘^L3(4&W%&J‰.gÜHÝ
ƒL`(§_L7§\q$!)$)0!$)0•)q.gÜHÝ¡$)`K$!G'(Š-g`
ƒ`4$!GJL!.gÜHݒ+*ƒ3&IH`&'(&
^&'Gn`$1(4^,(#&'`_`)&Š•L`(&J
&5($)!*‘K&B&'^$!&`&•&BÔ&'
`K…$!^Šƒ3Gf@-qƒ`$1G A
L1,(&B-g1]*L7ŠGJ`(4n$!('I&~.gÜHÝa0nƒ`$!G'(@&
$!&J`K&'K•(!&J!*ƒ%$1K7&q%$1(4L`-&'&'K7_`GneL`(&Jn( Þ &'*
&`'6-yGBL(&6$!`GB!L`K7&5K•$!•&H¨``¾L7ƒLK7n]\q$!0`I
(Šxz{r| (H$!^,$!Q$!(1(‰‘$)&'0nyƒ`g-o$tn(H%$1(L`
-&J&5K7_`GneuI [ ŠL`(&JŒ3K@(*7(+&J^¡Gf$!3(”&`$)^,&'KŠ(
`&g1]*L7o$1(YK7$1(ƒ!]*&'K$!,`&HG'%(o&5-v&g(*7(+&J^I
&ƒ*7($!G'q(4$!^
L`!$!§GB$)L`)!*—Lƒ¾K&'(&ƒ3(4$ A
$!Q-Œ`&@7K7&5($!&@1]*L7'Ig8#)L0&J*W&
&Jƒ&'(&J&5KŽ0nƒ`$!G'!)*65&Y-nGB&5(r@g7K7&Y_u&'GJ^&ƒ A
ƒ`&'·#L`(&Jn(·L0_`(4&'%$!Ž`K^,$)ƒ`L!$!vI
!
($!^Šƒ`)&W^&5Gn`$1(^(,-‰ÚL`(&J‰—KKÛ`K§K7&')&J&…GB A
(4n$!('6o3K’$!L$)$!%&^&B`K-•(!%$)`0W`&WGB A
(4n$!('IW‹DKK7$)$!v6/_*Ú$)`GJƒ3$!0W`$)^,$)˜$)
&‡ƒ7GJ&'((J6wrxz{r|
((4$1(4(·&‡L`(4&'y$!
L``K7&Jn(43K7$)`0#\
,Gn$!&J%&K7&5(4$!&'Ks!]*L75I
`&˜L`(4&-,ÛGB3(+$) A ($1(4-lGf$)â(Gn&J^&€„lƒ*($1GJ
($!^
L1$)3ˆ¾`”$!(y$)L$t$)%&Y`KŽƒ&'K7$1Gfn_!&6n&Jr`
&g`#$!(_u&B&J#¨``K7$!00!_`·(4)L7$)`('6$1(qK7&')$!_3&' A
&I (xz{y|$1(H$!&'`K7&'KW~_3&Š07KWH0)_`!)*( A
$1(4-*$!0ÚGB`(+$)n(
_*—$)(&J)-+I’X#&''6o$t,$1($)&'`K7&5K—
ƒ`%$1K7&‰$)&'4-lGB&,`,!!\#(WL`(&B-L`GJ!!_3$!
_u&B+\‡&J&'L`(&Jg`KWGJ^ƒL7&J$!Q(!%$)0&
1]*L7ƒ_ A
!&J^I†Ý`‡$1(ƒLƒu(&Hƒ`&5K7$!GB_$)!$)+*67(4$!^ƒ!$!GJ$t+*6``K•&
GJ^ƒu&J!)$!03L`&‘-&…$!^$!‚&Q-l~^&Q$!^ A
ƒuo3sGn$!&J%$)`0
0!_3uƒ7$)^,!$)+*•L7^,$!G'!)*I
ݔ$!`!!*6/`&‰_`(4$1G‰GJ`GJ&Jƒ7ŠL`K7&'!*$)0Q&wrxz{r|˜$)&' A
-lGB& $!0GJ!!_3$!%&#$!&'Gf$!‰_3&J+\Y&'&J‰L3(4&'‡`K
GJ^ƒL7&J‰(!%&Wփ7$!^$)5$)ۃ_!&J^6q\q$t§&
GJ^ƒL7&Jƒu&J-^Š$!0’)7GJgƒ7$!^$)5$)â3KÛ`&‘L`(&J
&'(ƒu`($)_`)&,-@0)_`‡GB ^,]*‘_u&sƒƒ!$!G'_!&•
&'q!]*L7567K7]\q$!036`K~K7&'($!0s(e7(JI
`$!(Œ\‡e
\(Œ(Lƒƒu&5K_*`& $!`3p7GB$!&J3GB&Ý`L A
K`$!ք – n #L^@_3&'(H‹+Xq‹ A ;= d < ? ;9•`KQ‹+Xq‹ A ; b?5CC E C ˆ
`K_*UWVoXZ 8áU$)(L_$1(4`$/Vo)&5Gf$1G
Xq&5(4&5nGnWZr_3 A
n*I
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
&
? I#Xq`!K [ &'Gne&J`K£‹+ p^,!hI 8#`$)^,$) &$!&J-lGJ&I§‹D [ &J3KÚZrL`&'h6Y&'K7$)'6 O Rf
N+ß j " N uj7DOJR 3OJRßB›nOŠOfTfk `I,8KK$!( A
œ‘&5(4!&J* oL_!$!($!0 2 `I!6Xq&'K7$!0`6UW8
6 ? ;;<`I
9I – $)L`(&Jƒ`ƒ3& ¢$ [ $1(+n6 /&B&J VYK7&5(J6 Xq_3&'4
y^(($16`K‹D$1(oy!)$1(JI·8)0$t^,(Œ-‡K7n]\ A
$)0~0nƒ``#( #‘n&'KW_`$)_!$!0nƒ`*I N ¾j7 "
hklN u #OnN ,OB¯Rf/ $ OnNRfW
uÁkl›n¯klN `Tf6vE ¥9= d
9 C 96 ? ;;E`I
=`I#Ýn
 `I [ `K7&'_`L036/&'K7$)'
I ‡RN5›nOn&O k TN4ßsO
i NTnkj áN R ` R Œk 6%!L^& ? <9 c - yO#› "
hj7RO NDOBTN N uj7DOJR i ›JklO ¾›OJIopƒ$!0&''6 ? ;; d I
E3I#VoK ¢g&J0)&''6 UWe Ý`$!&'K&J!h6 `
K &©UWe7('I
2 `(4n$! A K7$!%&'˜K7$!0n^ !]*L75IQ‹D
‡RN'›nOnO k T
i `N]Tfkj áN %yk1Tnj`$ r j` OfTf6
N+ßO "!"!$#
ƒ`0&'(==< == d 6 [ &J0&'v6 #\]*678#L`0L`(4 ? ;;=I
d I /&B&'VoK7&'('I8}&JL`$1(+$!GŽ-H0nƒWK7n]\q$!0`I N "
ROBTnTfjT j OJR 3hkj Š6E89 ? E; ?'b <6 ? ; C E`I
b I#U$!Gn3&J – !&J$1Gn&'Q`Kã8`K7&J\ œÛ$te$!vI ¢n]\q$!0
\q$tŠGJ`(4n$!('&I %rk1Tfj` N ¾j7OJRf6 ?? =; d7? 6 ? ;;E3I
c I#o*7(XŽI¾#&J`*`K‘p7GB4HVI3L`K(vI#‹D&JnGf$)%&
0nƒ—1]*L7'I’‹D
RN'›nOnO k TWN+
ß '( i *) !$6ƒ`0&5(
dd b E36$))&'K·6`p 2 6 %&J^@_3&' ? ;; ? I
REFERENCES
%
%
2 3(+$) A _`(4&5K˜&5Gn$1šL&'(`]%&s_u&J&'§L7$!)$!J&5KÖ$)§L A
^&JL`(K7n]\q$!0
&5K7$tn(J6&I 03I)6·ä b 6 C 6 ? <76 ? =76 ? E æ 67_L7&'*
`]%&‘(-l~&'Õ+*&5K€)*Û!$!^Š$)&5Kâ(L`G'GB&'((~$)â`$!(!&I
Üg&‘&5(Ö-‰$1(sƒƒ`&'‰-l$!)L&W$1(•&Q0&J&')$)+*
3K’GJ^ƒ!&BÔ7$t+*˜-g^(4,GB3(+$) A _`(4&5K—K7n]\q$)0‘&'K7$ A
( ·&#GB`(+$)Œ%7G'_L1$!&'(y`]%&‡-&J_3&'&J,Gn(4&'
-s0`!$t+*6‡GJ%&'0&6‡`KÖGfn_$!)$)+*6q_`L7s^,]*
Š_u&s&5(4ƒu&'GJ$!)!*˜GB%&J$!&JŠŠ&Bؾ&'Gf$)%&‰-@ƒ3$1GBL1
e$)3K(-K7]\q$!0‘(4e7('I’‹D§KK$t$)v6oL`(&Jn(-&JÖ`]%&
K7$ •GBL)+*sL``K7&Jn(43K7$)`0,\‰GB3(+$) A _`(4&5K‰(*(4&'^
\‡e('6]`K&J&B-&o\˜_3&5(+ygL7$!)$!J&‡$)'I”‹Dƒ`$1GBL`!'6
\q&'˜ƒ&5(4&'&'KÚ\q$)˜L``K7&J A %&' A GB`(4n$!&'KWK]\ A
$!0('6¾^*(*7(+&J^,(g_3&'`]%&@$)‘\‡]*7(`&ƒ`šL&
`&•L`(&J5I (Šxz{r|…$!^ƒ%&'(H˜0&J&'†GB`(+$) A _`(4&5K
(*(4&'^,(‰_*§ƒ%$1K7$!0’(4ƒu&'GJ$!)$!J&5K€(4&J~-
GB`(+$)n(J6
Ìr³5¶ Âh¶‡»nÉ3³]À¥¼]¼]¶+¹»f!Ç Kl¶+ÊDº¯Â/ºh»gÊ+»f¹Bº¯°h»fÃÊ4»f¹5Âhºh°±nÀ¥¹Bºh½Ç]±n¯¶+¼@ÃÁ±+¬B» º
³±nÂrǶ4¶+¹gÄ ²]°¯»f²»f¯¶+¼²5°¯¶DÅ5À¥» Ä Â¯Ã ¬BË'¶+¶BÈ5É!»f°vÀ¥¹]Âlº±n¹]Ê+¶fÈ]ºh³]¶†¼]À¥Â¯Ê Ä Âh¯À¥»f¹Ä »nÉ
±nÃ¥À¥®f¹]¸q¶+¹Bºv»f!Ç Kl¶4ÊDºh”ÇB¬ ”Ã¥¶4À¥Ê¯³]¶+°”±n¹]¼ ~À ºh¿JÀ¥¹ŠÎ ÓË
5±n®f®f¶4°¯±º¯¶+¼ŠÉ)»f°¯¸q”»nɾº¯³5¶é/ê”ë~À¥¹]¼]À¥Ê4±º¯»f°hÂo±n°¯¶Âh³]»µr¹
À¥¹
ëÀ¥®n½
ĵr°hÀ ¶4º¯Â³g씸qºh»f³]°¯°h¶r» Ä Å5®fÀ¥Â ³ 5±nÃË ï¹oÇ5º¯º¯³]Ã¥¶v¶Dº±n¬BÊDË º Ä ±nÃÂh¬'Âhºh¶+¸Èºh³]¶vÀ¥¹]¼]À¥Ê4±ºh»f°¯Â3±n°¯¶¾¼]¶+²]À¥ÊDºh¶+¼
Ä Ä
CONCLUSIONS
&
!"
!
!"
#
#
#
&
"
%
&
!
&
&
C Iq8)1 &J*7K7 `K – &J0 &J1(4vI & L9
GJ`(4n$! A _`(&'KsK7]\q$!0&'K$t5IYy&'Gn$1GJrXq&'ƒ34
? = ? `6¢g$!0$)”p7X 2 6 Œ!Š8t`6 2 8
6 ? ;;E`I
;I 2 &'
* (e¾6 &‰UWe7('6”`KpL`@U˜IŒp$!&J_u&J5I
8L7^$!0‘&~!]*L7Š-`&B+\‡eÚK$!0n^,(\q$)
(ƒ3&5GB$)¨`&'KÖ%$1(4L`#0$!'$)vI R TJ›B¯klN `T
N i ]TfO T ,PQ :
mOJR uOJ¯kl›fTf69Eu„l=ˆ EE E d E36
UWGn ? ;;=I
? <I – &J0 #&J1(vI L36H’GB3(+$)_`(&'KÛ0ƒ$1GJ(
(*7(+&J^I N ¾j7OJR R 7kl›fT * RN'›nOnO k TsN4ß i "
† ) -6 ? ;3„l=ˆ ¥9= d 79E=$6 L!* ? ; Cd I
?? I#p&Jƒ`&J #4v6v&'K$t5I ‡RN'›nOnO k T‰N+ߊO i N "
Tfkj N R R Œk 6%)L^& ?? ;<…- yOn›B¯j7RO
NDOfTN N ¾j7OJR i ›JklO u›nOBIop7ƒ$!0&J56 ? ;; b I
? 97Iq8g‘p7GJ'I@8 (L%&J*-Y0nƒ`QK7n]\q$)0~(4*7(4&'^('I
y&'Gn`$!G'•Xq&'ƒ34; d]ADb 6,"#$!%&'($)+*¡- #&'\‡G'(4!&6
8L`(+)$16 ? ;;E3I
? =I#p&J%&p$1(4&Iy‹D&JnGB$!,&'Gn`$!šL&5(Y$!sGJ`(4n$! A
_`(4&5KH0&J^&B$1Gy^7K7&')$!0`I‹D ‡RN'›nOnO k TN4ß R "
kl›B
T 3OJRßB›nO ) ! 6ƒ`0&'( Cd ;96 2 !0*6#8#!_3&'4n6
L& ? ;; ? I
? E`I‹D%
p7L7&'13K·I i SOJD› /$# , " ›7k uO R "
kl›n›nN Šj `kl›n¯klN Tf]TfO ŠI †3¢—&'($!('6U‹+6 ? ; b =I
?5d IqXq_3&'4—y^,((4$1Ú`K§‹D$1( – I‡r)!$!('6q&'K$tn(JI
‡RN'›nOnO k T•N+ßO i NTnkj N R R Œk 6
%!L^& C ;E- yOn›B¯j7RO NOBTHN N ¾j7OJR i ›BklO u›nOJI
pƒ`$!0&''6 ? ;;E3I
?'b I [ L`GB&—
Ig^(`K ŒL 2 1K7&''I 8#$!^,$!0
K7$!&'Gf•^,$)ƒ`L!$!Û$!&J-lGJ&'('I‚‹D ‡RN'›nOnO k T‘N+ß
' i ) ! 6/ƒ`0&'(Ž= ? 96 †$)4(_L0r6 ·86 #%&'^
_u&J
? ;; d I
%
#
#
#
&
!
&
!"
!"
!"
&
!"
!
!"
%
!"
&
%
%
%