Characterizing the SPHINX Speech Recognition

!"#$ %&(')*+', .-0/1
2436587:9<;,2)=?>A@B365:36C DE7GFHJIJFKLM=N2#FPOQ;SR<F5 TUWVX@,Y$VJ5:@WF5
Z[]\#Ê_B`baQcd$cfe8gShi`bajeG`k_BckaAlnmSoqpraje8gSmB[]si[ntnuqvwlxJ[ncfl`b[ncku
ypgBaQ^zalck`kmS\#hinajaQm{cf`kh[nù|}Z~[n|[]\#paGÊB_Bln`baQcl`WeQdhiaj_SmSbeG`kajhm
eQlck`8eQQaj_Bm`b`baG[nBclnQZajoSgS_qlcf

(

Q
e
Q

B
_
b
`
G
a
B

n
l
Q

j
a
S
o
z
_
P

S
_
k

Q
a
f
c
8

Q
e
l
k
c
`
saj( [{[nckan 6aQcknaQc
ck[]_B^

(X 8¡f¢Q£]¤¥¡
¯Ë®®Ê§]Á¬j¦WÈjÉ8²{§n¨ÎÁj¨¨ª¾Î©?¯~¨ÎÁj«]¾i²{§]¬«]ÏÑ¬¥®f¾E¯¨ªÐ#©®°®©bÌ¬QÒN±Ëb©k²Wï¾¿Ä)²6¬Q®k²6¾i©´¾Î§]¨Î³n¬¥¬jµN¾ÆiÆ½$¶¸³nµr·ºÄQ¹}¨ ¶}Ô»~·º®k¹¸¯º¼J®f»Ó¬²{¾©bï½GÀ²q©k¯ºÁj¾¿®k«±"±.¬Q¯k¾iÀk¾Â§]¨ÎÁQ®Êf¯¸ÌnÊ©ÂÆÇÁQ¬Q«±¸¯º®¼A¬8«6ÃÌ]¬Q®k²W¾¿¯¸®fÄÕïË²6©<ÁjÄ¥«]Ìn®Å®²6«®Ä$®kÊ§.²WËÄ¥®f¯º®f²6®²{ÊÊ¾i§Áº¼?È¥±
ÆÇ²¬j¬Q¨¯Â¾Â¯ºÈP¨ÎÃQÁQ®¸©¸²0ÉQ¾iÁ:§]©bÊ¬j½G¬¾B©bËk¾¿§]Ìn®f¬jÆÍ±¬QÉG¯b©#®~½8¾Â¼ï¯º²,Ê¬¥ÁjÄjÈP²{¨®k¾Î¾Â¨Î²WïÁj²®k²6Ì¯¬j¬QÁjÆiÆ Ì¼AÆ½©wÄQÄj©<¨ª«¯b©<«6ï®ÉG®ÆÍ®f¬QÊ²§½
«ÆÍ¬QÁ¯Â«WÈPÌn®¸ÆÇ¬Q«6¯¯bïÊ±
Áj¬Q±}¯b«W½Ì]Úr¾<®fÁQ¯¯ºÃj©bï½G²P©kÈA¾<®f©f±Ó®8¾wÄ¬j®b²6©bÄ¨ÖÈ¥«]²{Á:ÏÁQ¯$³]µNÆÇÁ:¶}Ê¬j·¹}Æ¨¾Â»×½jÏ~¬·k«²«6Æ¾i¨Î§®k¨ª©©Ê«ÁQ¬²«©b®k¨Î¯$Ä¥®fÚr¯º¬¥®
ËfÛkÆÇ®Ì¬jÆÇ²{Á:¬¥¾Â¨ ÄÀ½(ÁQ¾i²Ø§]®k¾ª©k§®$®Ù¯º±
®k©b®kÌn±
ÆÖ¾ÎÁQ©¼}¯b½A¬Q²6§nÄ¨Î®k¯Ê¬QÁQ¯º¯bÊ¯§®kÆÇ½8¬¥¼¾<®Ú?¾i¨§]¾i§)®f± ¬
Ú?ï±¸¨¾i«6§*ÆÍ®k¾ª±
§®
®k²6©f¾<ÁQ¬¥Ìn¾Î¨Î¯ÁjÊ²*®ÊÄ¥Á8®8Ä¾<¬j®¼ïÆ©©º§]ÁÁjÀÚ?¾iï§]²P®¸È«6¾ª¯§Á8¬jÊ¾~®k©¾ª©f§Áj®k¯º½¼¸Áj¬Q¯¯º®¾ª§¬Ü®ÊÚrÁj²]¬Q½©f®¾ªÛk§Ì®®f²6¬Ê«¥®«WÆÁÝ¨ÎÀÙÊ¬j¾i¾Â§]¨ÎÁQ®²)¬Q¨ªÆ ÈP©ÁQÊ¯bÁ:¨¾iÄ¥§®±$ÄjÏ4©(¦WÌ§]©f®®Ä8Ìn¼~²j¯«6¬j¯º¾i§]®Ê®f®¯(Ä¥®f¾ª§²{¬Q¾¿®²*Ä$©ÂÈ¥«¯º®ÁQÊkÚN¨ Òw¾i§ Ê
ÚzÁÀ}§©<®k«²®®Ä¥Ê®k§A©b¨Ö¯ºÈj®²{ÊïÁº²PÈ¥È²¨¾ª¾Â§¨ÎÁQ®²Þ²W¬®º«¥°P«W¾XÆÈ¨ÎÊ®f¬j²6¾Â®f¨Î¯ºÁQ¬j²]¾Â©¨ÎÁQ±
²¬8ÁÝÃÀ®b©~ÊÁj¨±}¾J«Wï±}Ì]«¾<®f®k¯¯¬j©b¾Â½Gï©bÉG¾¿®®f±¾ª§©k¬jÏ ¾X©b½G©k¾<®f±ßÄ¥®k©b¨ÖÈj²W®k¯©~ÆÇ®k²WÄ¾ª§®k±ßÄjÌ®ÊÁQ²]©b¨ÎÄ®k¯º¬¥¾Î¨ÎÁj²
à Eá âãXä?åÙæ4çèwã?éfåâ
mÜhi`kcfgØajeGtnajckm[ùnhajmBltcfj_SSbba#^JhaQm,ajef`kggBa4ckaj\4eG[nlt]cfmSënhaQ`k`bhiÊ[]smlneG`banajefAgSdìmB[]Ps[nltnc8uhiaQ`gSu,ln[n|\Þbl[n`k|<`_Bckajlocka#|ÂcfÊ[]ln\êefëPlnlmqtnajl(ckaj|Â[nlcÙ[nb|r^JÊaQ_Baje8cfag.lnckeQajlneGoB[nt]aj\ÞmShih`kehi[]ckm.ajblajckla4cfe8l¥gPln`bhÎ[#sl[]xEmBsiaa
vrhm.aQc8`kmBgB[]a4_B\Þ`$öølnk
÷\4ln_Slbck^zënhiaQan`Ùï`b[WôóS[]l¥heGunaAwkù$_E^SefgícfajklnA ñªy úQûcfóÝlztnln[]mSmîo)6ü~u6gSk`bhsajhi\4^zQQïï ýSy cfaQcfal6tn^J[]m!aQajðefgElþn`kõØ_BcfñªlnújsÎÿPsióÝu.~6^JajajeGl[nëWt]hmSmBhití`kh[]ñòPm*óÝ lneQeQ_B cflnï(eQhôajhlgSô´l¥[]nhÎaAeGa,xJaQñõajóÝm
b`bajlnoShÎsiu)h\#^Scf[¥WhmBtÜln~ajssÅX`kgB[]_Bt]gíeQ_Sckckajm{`buWb`baj\4lcka#b`khÎssmS[n`lneQeQ_Bc8l`ba#ajmB[]_Bt]g.`b[`klëna4oSheG`kl`khi[]mNpgShQ
`beG[[]_B\4Êslajëno4ak^Xhi`kaQgÞaje8h\#g,^SlÞck^S[ncfhaj\Þ\#lajckm{uq`kg{h_SmÞ\Þ^Slnckmz[WPeG\4ajklnb[nefgEc~hbmB^Ja(aQajhm{oS`b¸aQckln|¿mSlnoÞeGa`kgBhÎmqa$s`k[{gB[]a\4mBhÎajmBltÙc$ck|¿aj_Bln`ks_Bh`cfuan [n|N m,_BxE`khgS6_hShieG`b[][]_Em{`báGeGW[]`Q\#X`kÊgS_BaQ`kckhamStBhÎ^SlÞck[]oS\Þajlhckb`kajg
[n[n|N|?`bhmB[W|<oS[nljcfun\4~lW`k^Xh[]ajm4eQhÎ[]lnmÜsªÝÊ`k_BgBcka$^J^J[]aQbcka|<[ngScfl\4c8oBln~mEleGacfa$[nl|rcfbe8^JgSaQhiaj`bajefgÜeG`kck_BajckeGaj[n~t]gSmSl¥hn`khia[]mÜxJaQlajÊmÞÊ^SshckeQ[nl^J`khi[][]bmEajó4[]|<m[nc`kbgB^Ja$aQeGaj[]ef\4g\4hm4[]`kmgBaeG[]s\4l`bÊa
_Bõ`kûWhmBït(ñÿÊó}slñ ¥`b|<óÝ[nWcfxE\4_B`
`ktngBajajmBbaQaÙcflnksi`kÝ_SÊoS_Bhickaj^J[]lbckaa(Ê[]sl_B`b`k|<oS[nlcf`b\4ajo)hÎlnmqmSoql4\AhÎmS_ElnsioB`ka hi^S6_ckS[nltn`bc8aÙlnh\4m\4`kgBhmBaÙteG[]ajm{m{6`baGhicf6[]`$mS[n\#|aj`bm{cfaj`QmS oS[n|tnck[¥$hmBtn[6eQlxz_SslcfhiajlnmEoq`kgBaÙ_Sba
[n|
m`kgShÊl^JaQcjW~aÙaGWln\ÞhmBa(6ü¸÷ ð$ùêñþPóÝSl#buWb`baj\ê|<[ncb^JajlënaQchmEoBaQ^JajmSoBajm{`Q6slcftna
n[6eQlxE_EslckunSeG[]m{`khm{_S[]_S
ckbaj^JeGaQ [najt]efmSgîh`kckhiaj[]eGm![nt]lnmEeQhieQ`k_Bhi[]cfm?lneQ haj(m[n| l,6nú:º[Wþ eQlxE_S´soBlckaQuí^Jaj[nmS|oS[¥hÎmBntÜaQcÞ[]ÿWm!úQûn`kgBûnaÞû.eG~[][n\#cfoSÊQsaG¸W6hi`ºüu.÷ [n |~ð$`kùMgSa4lne8tngScflnhiaQ\4naj\4#lb`k^JhÎeQajlnls}ënbaQ`bcbcf_ShÎmSeGoB`k_SaQ^JckaÞajmShoBm.aj`km{gB`ÙaÜ~b[najcfmWo
`bhm*ajmSÊeGlajckQ`k heQí_SasÎlbcj`kS_ElnoBmSuoØ6bü^J÷ aQaj efð$g,ù ckaj[]eGm[nt]\mS_Shi`ksi`khi[]hÊm,sia¸l^S^zÊsls`bhÎeQ|Â[nlc8`k\4hi[]mSlnmEhm*otn_EajkmBhmBaQt$cfln`sÅ~X[Ùlckkah\|<_S_SmEsloS`bln[n\#cfQaj m{`kln_BssicwuckajoSkh _SJsaQ`kckwajfmgB`[¥|Âck[]`k\ gSl`k`¸gB6a(üxJ÷ ajmSð$e8gWù
\4lckëW`kgSl`(gEljna4`bcflnoEhi`khi[]mSlnssu)oBcfhinajmØ^J[nÊ_Sslc
eG[]\#^z_B`baQc(buWb`baj\ oBajfhit]m?Wü¸÷ ðùÑgEln
lqslcktna#~[nckë6hÎmBtqbaQ`
[]mShi`ksiuqg!k^Xs[¥[6[nc(siu`bajln\4^XeQln[nefc8gBlnas¸sik[Wh QeQajln$shi`ºhu.mSeGlnckajmElno0ban\# ajíoSha[6eGeGck[naÞckckxSajcfslln`bmSaAe8g!`kgB^Sajbcka(ajoEcfhajeGk`k_Shi[]si`km?)xEZlneklnëqefgS`baÞ[Ü^J`kgBaQckaA|<[nbcf[]\4_S cflneGmSaneGzaÞlnmShÎÙo,^Jk[{gB[n[c¥ßln`kmSgSol`$h`k\#gB^SaQu)ck[nlajcka
mBlnsi[ntn`[ncflnhm)`kgSl\4cf`khi|<xElnlneG`baj[no)|[]`kgSm hÎÊhkleGckck`kaQh`beQa(_SsÎ÷lchoEhÎoB\#ajÊm siaj\#lajckm{ën`k[l `khi[]m?[WWoBxEaj_Ss`l¿÷ |<_SmEoSln \#k ajm{`klnsJ|Âajl`k_Bcfa
[n|eQ_Sckckajm{`k^XaQaje8gqckajeG[nt]mSh`khi[]m
y

Ø
`kgBaÞ msaQtnnajajmSs
aQcf[nln|sÅ¸lneQeQeQ_B_BcfcfcklnajmeGuíòBÊajckb[6ë6oE`b_S[neGÊajo.gSx{l¥u.na)^Scfk[n_ tnÜcflneQ\4hiajm{Ù`shckënajaÜb[]6_Bü¸cf÷eGaj ð`bù[íNoB÷$[.[oBajaQoSnhÎaQeQc¥l´`baj`kgBoaÞcfsiaj[]lnlnsªÝoí`kh`k\#gSaqaQuØb^J^zaQsajlnefeGgîa4[]ckajm!eG[n`kt]gSmEaÞhi`kbhiuW[]bm`bajl\ `
hoB~aQ^SWhckeG[]ajgEhixEhih`ksÎhisnxJaahm_SmSeQl_BxEckcksaajm{`b`[Ù\AgB[]_EsÎsio`khf_S_ bÜaQcGeQPhi\Aajm{_S`´s`k\#hi^Sajck\#[ntn[ncfcklnuA\Þ`b[
\4cfhmB_St
majbm{^J6aQhajckef[]g#mScf\#ajeGaj[nm{t]`kQmS´hi`kýShi[][nm#cl`kgS^SaÙ^zshh\4eQl\#`khiaj[]oSmShÎwl`ba$h`k|¿g_B`kln_Bm{ckuanBckgSajlnlnbmE[]oWmSlgBxEajssou
khi|´h Q`kajgBoanln[WeQeQeQl_BxEcf_SlnsÎeGluØckun[nE|}_S|¿mS_Bs`kaj_Bkck~a`kbgB^JaÙaQ\#ajefajgØ\#ck[najckeGu[nt]gSmShihaQ`kc8hil[]cfmSefg{uÜbuW[nbc`bajck\4ajeG[nlt]ckmSahi`k`bhi[][mqhÎmSlneGstnckaj[nlncfbhi`kangS?\4b[`be8[6gS[ÜlnmBtnhÎa(ssNoS`kcfgBlnab`k\#heQajln\#ssun[nćfu*ýE_BbckuW`kbgB`baQajc8\\#[nlnckmSano
eG[]\#Ê_S`kl`khi[]mSlnsNoBaj\ÞlnmSoS[]m)`kgSaÙbu6k`baj\q
peG[]m{`bgBaj\#a^Jckaj[nkcf`lck[nu|Ê`kgSslh`b|<Ê[ncfl\4^JaQQc
BlnhmSo[nckaQt]lnlnmSsh_SQlaj`boía
ln`kgBa
|<[]aGsWsi[`bajmQ`Ù`bý´[#hic8b`QgSJhe8gÜa#`kaGgSBaQlnuÜ\4oBhajmBsahnaQ`kgBc~a#[]m)^JaQ`kckgB|<a[ncf^S\4ck[]ln\4mSeGhaka$[n[n||wWckü¸ajln÷ sªÝ `kðh\4ùìa[]km.^XaQ|<[]aje8_Bg c
ckmSajlneG\4[nt]hÎemShe8`kgShi[]lm?cfln}eG6`baQajcfeGh[]kmS`kho?eQn´~[na|E`k_SgSba~a~Ê`~ck[n[tnfcfhln\A\q_E]slnlmS`b[nocfaG WÊBslnh\#hÎm(Ê`ksigBaBaeQoBlnuWslmScrlnln\4mShÎo4e¸|<Wajhl\ `k_BÙck{ajÝü¸x6üuAZ¸eG[n"ckcfhajm
sleG`k[]hmEmBeGtaQck`k`gBaj`b\ø[
aGWlnh`k\4gAhÎ`kmBgSaa`kkgS[]a~_BoBcfeGu{a
eG[WoBan uíoB[]hmBt)k[Br~aÞgB[n^Ja#`b[*^Scf[¥WhoBa4l)\#[ncfa4tnajmBaQcflns´^zheG`k_Bcka#[n|`kgBa4^JaQck|<[ncf\4lnmEeGa#[n|k^XaQaje8gíckajeG[nt]mSh`khi[]m
`kbgB[n|<a(`6lü ckaZ []m*ð`bp$[WÿoSûnljûnuXûAïxJbajuWmSbe8`bgSaj\4\4QlckëWpQgSWhilncfmSo?oB~kgBaA[eG []\4`kgSÊll`ckhia``kaGgBWa(aQcfaGeQWhkajajeQ_B`k`khigB[]a
mØbefu6gSkl`bajc8ln\ÑeG`beGaQ[]cfmEhbk`khhoBeQaQcf[nl|xzsi6u4üoS÷ h J ðaQckù×ajm{`ksiu4hi`kg)|<ck[]baQ\ÑnaQ`kc8gBlnajs\q[n|
ý´hoSmShlnJssaQunck {aj~m{` a
lnWkdbajk `kBgBh\#a
hÊ\4siaÊBlneQeGln`sl[ncj|rï`kgBü a
BhmSd k`bcfÅl_SeG`khi[]üm{baQs`hiënlacfe8hmSgSbhi`b`bajc8eG_S`keG_B`kckhi[]am.[]mbaQ^J` kaQNck|<`k[ngBcfa4\4dlnmSsiÊeGgEalWx6JuÜlnmEeG[]o.\#`kÊgBhÎa#shmBüt#[¥~6aQü¸ck÷ üZ¸ð ù ln|<mS[no c
cft] _SlnmEhmØmShhmBmSt#kht]`kgBgaj` \ mB[n[]`$mØ[]`bmE[nsiu)^.h[nm{|}`b[Ükh\`kgB_Sasl`b[nljcfu,$ k^XhiaQ`kajg*e8gØ`kgBck,aAajeG k[nlnt]\4mSahi`khi\4[]mØhÎeGckl[]^SlÊcfsÎefhgEeQlhi`b`kajhieG[]`kmS_BckanxX ajgE"ljnh`kag*[]`km.gBajoSkh aAJaQaGckWaj^JmaQ`cf\#h\#[WajoBm{aQ`kcfm,~ÊaslgS`b[n|<[n^XcfaA\4`bQ[
xE_B`wlnsb[hm{`b[$`kgBalnoBlnm{`kltnaj´lnmSooShklnoBlnm{`kltnaj[n|E`~[
[n|S`kgBakh\_Ssl`b[ncfwljlnhslxEsa¸`b[`kgBa~ckajbajlcfe8g#eG[]\4\A_EmShiù
hmqeG[]\#^z_B`baQclcfe8gShi`bajeG`k_Bcka(`b[6oSl¥un
¸è }è´å â#ébã?éfå
â åäNékã Z~[]m{naQck`khmBtÜ`kgBaAk^X[nënajm,~[ncfo*hm{`b[ÜlÞ`baG6`k_ElnsrckaQÊckajbajm{`kl`khi[]m,ln_S`b[]\4l`kheQlnssiuqcfa {_ShckajbaQnaQcflnsb`kltnajjXlnkgB[m
hmqý´hit]_SckaÞú Ål ký´hicfk`QElÞ\4hÎeGck[nÊgB[]mBaÙeG[]m{naQck`k`kgBa(lneG[]_Eb`kheQlns6hixEcfl`khi[]mShm{`b[Ülnm,lnmSlnsi[ntkhit]mSlnsÅ~pgShlnmElnsi[nt
[nkhi|t]mE|<cklna sz6_hB~aj`kmSgBeQajhiajm AX`ksigS`baQlck`#ajoÜ`kgB`ba[#g6aj_Ssh\4\4lnhmEmîl`bajalc4`kgBeQa
lnm+gShit]gBgÜajl|<cjck!a {_pSajgSmSaeGuÜzseG`b[]aQck\#ajo^J[]kmBhit]ajm{mS`kln~s~[nh|r`k`kgBgBa
ajmkht]oSmShit]lnhisX`khQajgSohe8gÜ_SfshhmBa$t,[]_Bl.`kfkhlnoB\4aÊ`kgBshamBtØcflnlnmBmStno a
[]6_mBSaÙlnm[n`k|´h jblaQ`knhiaQ[]c8mlns?ÊajgSmSlneGb[WanoShpmBt4gBa
ke8oSgBhiajt]\#hi`kh ajQQaj~oÞd`lj`kngSaQh|<[ncf^X\ []hÎmhÎ`QB`kgB^SajcfmaQ^SxEck[Wsi[WeGekajënkajko)hmBthÎm`bh[eG|<[]cfln\4\#ÊajsiaQQ`bBanEgElnhmSefo)gcklajckeGa
[n`kt]gBmSajhi`kmqhi[]eGm*[]\4`baj^SefckgSajmEkhb{_ajSoqaj_EkeQhlnmBmt
xJa
l^SÊshiajoÜ`b[#`kgShcfaQ^Sckajbajm{`kl`khi[]m[n|w`kgBaÙln_SoShi[hmB^z_B`Q y aQ`klnhÎs[n|`kgSalcfhi[]_Eb`kltnaj[n|^SckaQ^Sck[WeGajkkhÎmBtlÊÊshiajo
`b[][Þm,`k6gSüa(÷ hmSðeG[]ùA\4ShÎ$mBt#gShkefhigqt]mShÎln\#sNÊhÎmsiaj\#^SckajaQm{Ê`kl~cf`klgB`kah[]zmqmE|Âln[nsJc
ck6ajü¸eG[n÷ t]mSð$hi`kù×hi[]m*eQlnbm)`klxJtna
an |<[]_SmSo)hÎmvraQanEaQ`QlnsÅñþóÝ mq`kgSh^zl^XaQcaÙ|<[WeQ_S

`b[!6b^Jajm{aQ`bajajefmSgeGcfajajQeGî[nt]dMmShiÊ`khigB[][]mmSha~ëW\4mBl¥[¥u0xJmqalneG[]`kmSgSkahoBÊaQckcf[6ajeGoajfcf[][n_B|t]gSeG[]siuím{na aQ6_ckS`khhimBtlnsi|<ajcfm{ln`\#`baj[íl.`b[#kÊhmSgBt][]simSaÜajnQ[{^zajgBs[]mB[najc~eG`b[][#mEb[][nmSc8lnoSm{Q`4BlnbmS[]_SomSo?[n!c8oSd
`[nu6|Ê`khgBeQlna*soSújh òÜÝ~eQ_S[nsicf`ºoíuîbhajm m{`bbaj^JmSaQeGaja#efg hcfeGaj[]eG\#[nt]^JmS[]hib`kajhi[]oØm [nk|`blaj\4^S^SÞcf[j|<Bck[]h\4\ l`b`kajgSsia*u |¿nlnòÜeG`ÞÊgB`kgS[]lmS`4ajQ`k gSa*k_Slnsi`k\#hÊa,siaÙ|Âcf|<lncf\4ln\#a*aj\4|<lj[nu+cf\ [WeQlÞeQ_BÊcÞgShÎ[]m mBan\A _E si`khi_SÊe8sig a
ÊgB[]mSajQ{lnmSoÜlAfhmBt]siaÊgS[]mBa$\4l¥u4eG[]m`klnhÎmoEh XaQcfajm`¸ka {_BajmEeGaj¸[n|?|<cfln\#aj~oBaQ^JajmSoShmSt
[]mÞ`kgBa$ÊgB[]mBajlno klneGajm`~`b[
hib`Qa 6_B6ajü¸mS÷ eGa# ð[nù |~ÊckgBajeG[][nmBt]ajmSÙh Q`kajgSl`
l4xJbajajm{b`Ù`baj\4mSeGla(`kefx6gSuajÙ^J`kaQgBck|Âa4[nc8hmS\4Êh_BmB`t#|Âl#cflnxJ\4ajlna4\ ba k{_ajSlajcfmSefg*eGan`k#gBpck[]gB_BaÜt]g)6üln÷m,l4ð$^SùÑc8his[nhicfxShJc8lb`kcflhiaj`baAajmS\#aQ`Ê~si[[nu,ckëqoS|ÂhÎ[nkc$eGck`kaQgB`baa
÷lØ,baQ À[nQ}|"÷ !$#&,%'#)(*!8}lnlmScfa(oîeQln_Bmckckl,ajm{^S`ksicfuÜh[n`kcfgBh}aÙbaQ^S`ckaj[noS|[]#,\4+-%/h.0mS!ln1,m{#,`132/l.5^S^S46ck+-[]28ln7%8e8gq791;:<`b1,[Þ#,1&($b!A^JaQxJajaQef`ºg*ckaQajajeGmî[nt]`kmSgBajhi`k\qh[] m?}m+pgB6aQüu÷ lckð$a(ùe8gSrlajcflnlne8eGg`baQÊcfgBh Q[]ajmBo*ax{hu

\#[WoBajsiajox6ul4÷ Ø
ýgS´hÎefhig.t]_BeGck[]a\#ú ^J¿[]x b}a#k`kgBgB[¥a#$ÊgS`k[]gSmBaajb`bc8ln_SmSeGo.`k_B`kckgBaa#[naj|roBlAtnaj÷ ÙØlcfa#|<`k[ngBca#l`bcfflnhmBmSt]khsi`ka$hi[]ÊmØgB[]^SmBckan[n´xEplxEgBhÎashi`knhiaQajck`kh`keGgSajl`ÙhmÜeG[]`kmSgBmBaajtneG`
cfl`kÊgBga#l|<ckcfaln\#`kgBaja|Â$c8lnhi`k\#gSajhm
`k^SgBcka[nxzÊlgBxE[]hsmShi`kanhØajQppgEhgS(a$÷ hmSØeG[] \ÞhhmBtA_Skb`bajckoîajlnln\Ó#l,[n|N|Â^Scflnck\4aQÊaQck[6[neGajckëfbaj`bo[í|Â\4cflnln\4hm{aj`kC lnBzhm[¥sÎh~b`k`kAgBck[n[]|>_S=9t]?@gÞ+$+-aj(9ln.Ae8#gqb[n`k|Nl`b`kajgBQa¸ÊlngBmE[]omSa$`kgSmBajaQhic`ºln[nfckbëW[6eQhÎ|<lck`b[]aj\ o
siaQ|<``b[4cfhit]g{`Q¸dl#|<cfln\#aÙhckajlno)hm?Wajlne8g*[n|w`kgBa(eQ_Bcfckajm`k`kl`baj$hÊck[nÊlt]l`bajo*lns[]mBt4ajlnefg*[n|`kgBa(lcfeQsajlnoShmBt
B
Analog
Input
from
Microphone
M
E
Text
B
Low−Pass Sampling Frame
Encoding
Filter
and
Blocking
Quantization
1
M
2
M
3
5
M
B
Speech
Recognition
E
4
6
7
M
E
ÅpgSl hÎ~p^zlgB^XaaQcl|Âcf[Whi[]eQ_S_Sbajb`kl[]tnm)aj`kgBhamqzeG[]mSm{lnns?aQkck`k`klhtnmSantÜEb`k^JgSaQlajèf[ng)|`bb[4[n|<`bàG6l`Qck a ¿x pdgBc8e
a
s^zlgBxJ[]ajmBsaoB÷ ajØmB[n `baÙ_SÊbckaj[noqxElhÎm*xEh6sÎhiü¸`khi÷ajQ ðù
b^JaQajefg*ckajeG[nt]mShi`khi[]mN
ý´hit]_Bcfa4ú ¸d$m)[¥naQckWhiaQß[n|´b^JaQaje8gqckajeG[nt]mShi`kh[]m?
|<ck[]\ hi`QpgBaÞshÎb`[n|eQ_Sckckajm{`(b`kl`bajh
ckaQ^J[nÊ_SsÎl`bajo.hi`kgí`kgBaÜb`kl`bajAlÀ`kgBa4[n`kgBaQcAajmSoí[n|ajlnefg[n|`kgBajbaÞlc8eQQ
gShÎsiaeG[]\4Ê_B`khmBt#`kgSa
^Sck[nxElxEhÎshi`khiaj|Â[nc$ajlnefg?
|<[nc
m `bcflnlnmSoSkoShi`kh`kh[]hi[]mSm+`bxX[0aQ`º`kgSaQa*ajm!÷ Ê,gB []mBaj^zQgBN[]lnmBmEa*oí\#l [W: oB%/aj. s8j? % 6ü( ÷ ð2 ù (9:ÇgElnÜhi`kgílnm l%8^S= cf2/hi[n? c8!*hr#,1,^S= cf[nxE2 lxE(*h:Ísh`khiajhi`kg |<[ncÙl!`b^ScflncfhmS[nfcfhih`khi^S[]ckmS[n$xExJlaQxz`h~shi`kaQhiajajm
~\#[n[WcfoBoSajQsÅd×slnmB^St]ck_S[]lm6tn_SamSeQ\#hl[W`koBh[]ajm)sÅwoSlnhmSeGo0`khi[]ÊmEckl[]ckm{u)_EmS\4eQlhlÊ`k$hi[]Êm!gB[]oEmBheGa`khib[]a mS6_lBckajuímSeGeGaj[]mSk`b`k[Ühi`k~_B[n`bacfoØ`kgBbaÜ^Jaj\4sshl mSbt][nQcoSplgB`kl,a(^zk`bgBcf[]_SmBeG`ka(_B÷ ckajØA [n|$Q?6ülneG÷ []_Sð$k`kùhe
eGlÙ[]k\#hÎmB^St]c8sihakhg{mB_St(tn[¥anmBaQaQc$`~þû [nØckë# [n|Jlnsb`b`k[nltn`baQaj`k~gBlnaQmScj¸o#d`bcf`lncfmS_Sfm{hi`k`khih[]\#man^S6ck`k[ngBxzajlbxEa
hoSshil`kh`kajlQNb`bcf_EajeGeG[n`k_Bt]ckmEajhi`khieG[][]mÞ\(hÎ´xzhmBmB[¥a oSck_BajcfoShmS_St(eGajho#mShi`b`k"[ hÎlnzsh mSjoSl`khmShi[]t$m#`k`bgB[auWÊhilaj`ksgo
`kgBck[]_St]g)`kgSh$mBaQ`~[nckë)`kgEl`xJajb` z`k`kgBahmBÊ_B`fhit]mSlnsÅpg6_SQz`kgBaAb^JaQaje8g*ckajeG[nt]mEhi`khi[]m*lnstn[ncfhi`kgS\ eG[]mSkhb`k[n|¸l
[]mBgBaGaQÝcf`ka
h\4`kgBaaÙhmEhmShi`keGhln[]s\4h jhÎlmB`kt#h[]bm`bckÊajgSln\Mlnba$[n`b|´[bajsi[]m{ln`bajomS_BeGaj^Ü$`khgBa$^St]cks[W[neGxEajlnksEbajlAo)^Slcf`bhi[n[]c8\ÞhShoSeQlln`kssilubln`bcfmS_So)eG`kh_Bmqcfkaja Q{_{B|<[]ajsmEsi[eGa(aj_SoÞkhx{mSuÜtlÙlckxJajajeGln[n\Mt]mSkh`kajhil[]cfmÞefg?^z gSlnba
lkphmBgBt]asia
xJ ajlnv \ê ðÙbajZ lcf e8gqmB[Whi`boBaQancfl6`kh`¸hinckajajslnuÞoSxE~_SajhÎlnsoSe8gq¸lhmS`beGcf[]aQ\4a
h[nmS|tÙeQln|Âc8mSlnoS\#hÎoSalln`bmEaoÜÊlln`koSgSoE`kmBgBaQck []_Sbt]`kgÜl`b`kajgSQa
B`k÷ lØtntnajomSx6aQu4`~^S[ncf[nckëzxElxE6h`kslh`kckhi`kajhQmBnt`b[|<ck`k[]gB\ a
`bückaQaQcfa
hi[W[noS|h^XeA[]^Sfcfk_ShixEmEsihamBt4eQlnajmSsoShÎ\4hoEhlmS`bla`bajk[]seQ_Bln`kmShi[]oSmShÎoSjl`b a#nkaQ_BckuxS`bmBckaQ[6ajoSa`khgSml`k`ÙgBoSa
aQ`b6cfhaQlaÙ`ba4eG[nfckhickt]ajmSbh ^Jz[]eQmSlnm{oS`k~siuq`b[4|<ckl[]\b`kl`k`bgBa(ahÎmÜxJaj`kbgSàcfl_SmSÊmEcfhih[nmBcftÞhXmBb[]aQsÎ`_B~`k[nhi[]ckëXm?
d`4`kgBaajmSo[n|`kgBa)bajm{`bajmSeGan~`kgBaqxJajln\ bajlcfe8g h#siaQ|<`hi`kg+líbaQ`#[n|eQlnmSoShoEl`ba bsÎlnb`#|Âc8ln\#aj Wd b[eQlnsÎsiajo
%/.0 v ! (*ð
+"Z 79 ?@1;mB: [6(*oS+}a
baj`bsi[4ajeGck`kajeGck`kajgBla`baAeQln`kmSgBoSaÙhoSeGl[]`bmSa$b`bcf_Ehi`keGgÞ`baj`ko*gBa$bajgSm{h`bt]ajgBmSajeGban`} ^Scf[nxElxEhshùnlnmSoÞckaQ`bcflneGajhi`kÊl`kg4xzlnekë4`b[`kgBa[nc8hit]hmSlns
b`klW`ba(hmEheG`ka`keGgB[]am`bhmScfhhixE`kh_Bln`ksÎhih []jml`k`bhi[][#m#`kgBÊa
gEln^Sbcfa[6[WeGajeQkeQf_BhcfmBt[]`kmSh\#siu#a
[]|<mS[neGcal#lnkmShoÜmBt]`ksilaënbajajm{eG`b[]ajmSmSbeG`ka(lnhm{``klnh\#mShafgS|<[nhmBct]l(siu#t]khin\ÞajlnmssÅnB[WlneQmSloxE_S`kgBslacfunck6ajeGhmÜ[nt]bmS`bajh`klnhioB[]mu
ajlnm{sitn`k[nhickcfah`k÷ gS\øØ h´lnmSsaQ\#`~[]b[n`ckëAajm{|<`k[nhicckajajsilnuefg4efgSklajc8mln`beGaj`bmSaQeGcfanh Q{ajhio#àGx6Bu(gS`khixzgBahi`krxJaj^Jln[6\×[nc´bsiaj[6leQc8lnefsÎg#hiùnÊwgEvrlnb[WaneQ´lnBshih`ºmSuAeGha~w`ksgBhiënaajsixJu(aj`bln[\×f_bajXlaQcfcefg4|¿_Bcfckln`kgBmBaQtncajhm[¥n|¿_BaQc`k_B`kckgBana
lnN`kgSa}lnsitn[ncfhi`kgS\ÞJaQn[]sina¸`b[hÎ\#^Sck[na¸lneQeQ_BcflneGun´pgBaxJajb`NbuWb`baj\4r[n|{`b[WoSl¥uoS[mB[n`?unaQ`lÊ^Sck[]lnefgÙ`kgBa¸eQlÊlxEhÎshi`khiaj
[n`bcf|lnmSg{_Sfhi\Þ`khi[]lnm)m Êshckb[n`bxEajmSlxEaQcfhsÎQhiÓ`khiajd$)xJaQf`gB~[¥aQajmØmßlxX[ncf[oEnQan
p`b[6gSoEhÎljuXeGï[]*m`bslnaGWmB`Ùt]_Elnlssitn[a0\#`k[WgSoBajaj\ s`bh[mSeGoB[najckeQ^Jh[noScfaÙlxJ`ba!aQèG~[]aQm{aj`bmØaGWeQ`kln_SmElnoSs(hoShmSl|Â`b[najcf\Þshilën`ka hi[]m `b[ lnW
\4`bl[6t][ mSWh`k_S[noBc a4siàj~k[ÙW`k gSln m!m \4bÊlnhe8`bgSa*hmB[na#|ÙaQkck_Scfe8[ng cÙeGcf[]l`bm{aj`bAaG6[]`km!_Eln\4slnhÎmBm{u.|Â[nc8k\4^XaQlaj`ke8hi[]gím?`klnaQbëWckck[ncÜñªúnúQcflóÝ4`bajaj|Âb[najclc8g{ef_EgB\4aQcflnmSgSÞl¥lncfaÞaØ|<[]b`k_ShÎmSsso.ln`km gSl[n`Ùc8oBaQaQcfcÜck[n[ncb|
cfl`baj,hmSeGckajlnbaíx6u"ÿûnûPfúQûnûnû ñþóAgBajm lnm aGBhb`khmStku6b`baj\ hckaQ`bcflnhmSajo []m l+slcktnaQc)n[WeQlxE_SsÎlckunêvhiënajsu
cksln*a mBzt]mS_Eaj\#ltnaja*m`ktncfln`b\4[0\Þ`kgSlhcjlnlnsi4tn[n~cfhiaj`ksgEs\qlnheGm[]mb`baQaGaQWëW`kh_SmBlnt.s`bh[0mB|<hÎ[n\#cf\4^Sckl[`knhi[]am lneQleQ`Ü_Sbcf`klnheGssungEhhimSt]gBeQsaQ_Sc4oSsiaÜaQnhmSajseGj[ncf^XlneG[ncfc8[]lk`kÞhmB$t.gBh[]mBsi|<a)[ncfb\4ajm{l`b`kajhi[]mSmeGajlxJln[]mS_Bo `
Preprocessing
B
xJ\#aQ[nunck[]aAmSeGo?[]\#d$Êsi_B[]`kmSltÞ`khi[]mEhi`klng,ssiuÜhmShÎeGmck`bajajlnmSffhmBhint4aÙnb[WajeQllcfe8xEgS_ShsmBltBc8hi ajQX`kgBajba`bckajmSoS$hssreG[]m`bcfhxE_B`ba(`b[b`khsÎsrslcktnaQcoSl`klbaQ`kh QajlnmSo
ã åÙæ#å 8å
íaÙgSl¥nakajsiajeG`bajoqbaQnaQcflns?oShÎb`khmSeG`~\#aQ`kgB[WoShmÞ`kgEhk`k_SoBunBhm{n[]si6hÎmBtÙxJ[n`kgmSl`khina
lnmSokh\_Ssl`bajoÜaG6ajeQ_S`khi[]m?W`b[
~lnmSa(lnoBsiu ajQkaÙeGcf`khgBxXa(a
xXlnmSajgEoqljeGW[]hi[n\4cÊ[nl|¸ckaÙ6ü¸`kgB÷ a( ð$Plùcfh [] _Slne8\#g*aQ\#`kgBaQ[W`kgBoS[Wo*_SkgEajlno? _SmSh 6_Ba
lnoBlnm`kltnajlnmSo)oEhklnoBlnm`kltnajj mq`kgShkajeG`khi[]m
"!
ðl`khina)aGWajeQ_B`khi[]m h`kgSazmSlns`bajb`4[n|lnm l^S^zsheQl`khi[]m?ï^JaQck|<[ncf\4lnmSeGan÷[¥~aQnaQcjcf_SmEmShmBt,^Sck[ntncfln\4[]m ckajlns
gS\#lajcflnoSk~_Slcka(cka`kgBsha\4efh`kgS´l`kc8gBlneGa$`blaQxzcfhhbs`khi`ºheQu`b`k[gS^Slck`[nlxJckaaA`kaGgS6a$`baQxJcfajmEgSlnl¥s6siuhi[n6chÎ[nkhi|NxE`ksigBana lm*^SÊcfs_EheQmSlmS`khhmB[]tÞmÞ6hmÜü÷lAmBð[]ùmBhmSml`klnhiknhiajnsiaunX|<lnkagEhi\#[]m?aj lnkí_Bcfaa(eQ`klngBmaA[]cfmS_Ssmu
`kh\#aj¸lnmSo4\#aj\#[ncfu|<[6[n`b^Scfhm{`|Â[nc~oSh JaQckajm`}m6_S\AxJaQcf[n|Xkajm`b ajmSeGajj¸pgBabajm{`b ajmSeGajhmBÊ_B``b[Wü¸÷ ðù lckakgB[m
|<hm,[]ssid[¥$^S^JhmBajt#mSoEeG[]hªm@Edìt]_Blc8`l`k`kgShi[]aAmSaj mSo,[n|}`kgBaÊl^JaQcj ía^JaQck|<[ncf\ `kgBajbaaG6^JaQcfh\4ajm`k$[]$m #\#[WoBaQcfm,Êsl`b|<[ncf\4Qzhi`kg,`kgBa
ú ÿ] $
d S ûnJûnZ~ûí[]\#÷ ÊPûíhsaQWcaQcknt]aQeQc#e(ÿ6Öhiþn`kò6gúÙÿ #]û ÷ ) %# k ^Sck[WeGajkb[nc8Q %#'& v~ú %#'& Ñy vúòWújÿ& vÿ6

ÿ6 ' ÷ m{`bajsüwajm{`kh_S\ kk rú & ß v~úú & ßy v~úJÿnò & vÿ6Xÿnò Ø d ?Z[]\#ÊhsiaQct]eQeÿ6Öþnò6ú
( ##]û ÷ 4B_Sm)si`bcflq6Êlcfe f hÅwú & v~úú & ßy vúrÿ Ø vwÿ6 õ%# , d rZ~[]\#ÊhsaQct]eQe4ÿ6Öþnò6ú

#BZ[]\#Êl y 6fúQûv¸) # ÷ *d$sÊgSlíÿWújÿ %#0^Scf[6eGajkk[nc#hi`kg %#'& Ó vú %#'& Óy vúÿ , vÿ6ÿnò Ø
d XZ~[]\4ÊhsiaQc~¸t]eQeÿ6ÖþÝt]m{_BÊck[ºþnþPc¥ú

doSoShi`khi[]mElnsroSl`kleQlnmØxXaeG[]ssiajeG`bajo._SfhmBtÞgSlc8oB~lcfaA^JaQck|<[ncf\4lnmSeGaeG[]_Sm{`baQcflnmSo*Êck[/zshmSt4`b[{[]sÎQXf_Sefg.ln`kgBa
y[]mÜhit]`khigB`klna$s}dZ~siÊ[]m{gS`klhm6^z_Bsl[]`b_S|Â[nc8ü¸\ìcf/[ lnzmSsoÞhmBt hi `kmBgÞ|<cfflnh\4b`bhc8s_SleGc´`k`b_B[6ck[]a s¸y []mÞZ~ü`kgB a$Aüñ [¥óÝ~ aQícküaÞZ lcfÊasleQ`b_S|<[nckckcfaj\×m{`k`bsi[u)eGaG[nWck^XckajaQsÎc8lh\#`ba$aj`km{gB`kahmBmStl`khinhi`ka$gØck`kajgBk_Sajbsi`ka}`b[6hi[]`ksg
`kgB[]ba([nxS`klnhmBajoq|<ck[]\Mfh\A_Esl`khi[]m?
+*
,- ./0
1"!
Wh\_Ssl`kh[]m)h_SbaQ|¿_Ss?|<[ncb`k_EoBu6hÎmBt4^Sck[ntnc8ln\ e8gSlcflneG`baQcfhk`kheQ`kgSl`lcfamB[nc8\4lnssiuqmB[n`$6hfhixEsiaÙoS_ScfhmBt4mSl`khnaAaGWaG
eQb`b_Bcf`k_Ehi[]eGmN`k_BEckkaj_S
e8g*shiënlna`keQgBlna#efgB|<aQa`kefxJg ajgS6_ljBWajhi_B[ncjanE?oScfaQu6t]mShlnb`b\ÞaQcÙhe
_Bh^?mSoSb`blc8`b_Sa#eG`k_ShimS[]m)h`QX\4`khigS6aajQxEEcf`klngBmSa(efg.^JaQÊckck|<aj[noScf\4heG`klnhimS[]eGmØa
_S[nmS|´h`QXlcfaQhi`k[]e_E÷\4[¥h~eGckaQ[]nlaQc8cjefgSfhih`bmSajeGeGa`k_S`kcfgBlna s
_SdmSsboS[BaQzcfsimSuW[ÜhmBkt4hmS\4t]silnaÙe8gSkhh\mBa_Sshl$`b[naj\AceQ_SlnsÎlm*`baj^Soícf[¥hWm,hoBkaÙ[n|Â`k`ºgB~alck\#an?ajlnaGmSW$ajeQ|Â_B[n`kchi[]lnmíbëWkh^XmBtÞaQajlnoEs$srl`kgBcka#a k6_sB[¥~ajbaj`ko,h[]mSx6u*[]bmBaQnaaQeQc8lnlnm*s[n`kcfgEoBhaQmBcfë$[n[n||\4hi`klg)t]mEcfhiaQ`kt]_SloBcfano
`b[0`kgSa*^Sck[ntnc8ln\qï4xJajgSl¥6hi[nc¥ ýS[nc`kgBajka*ckajlnb[]mEQaØb`k_SoBu 6ü÷ ð$ù_SmEoBaQc4`~[kh\_Ssl`khi[]majm{6hck[]mS\#ajm{`kQ
Wh\ Ù{Ýü¸üZ lnmSo*Wh\#^zsiaWeQlnslcj6`kgSl`lcfa(eG[]\#Êsiaj\4ajm`klckuqhmq\Þlnmu~l¥u6j
Ge []\#Ê_S`baQcku6b`baj\ÞQ$hmEeQs_SoShmS t!Wlh\ |¿_SÙss"[n^Jñ PaQóAcflñªú `khmBóth#buWl!b`bkajh\\ _SslnlmS`ko h[]mlnss$ajm{lWÊhiÊck[]shmSeQ\#l`kajhi[]m{m`#eQ^SlckÊ[nltnxEc8lnsiaq\4[n|`k\#gSl[WòBajcfs_ShmSm tØ[]eGm []\#`b[n^z^ siaQ`b[na |
hvi`Ql xJ[nícfla,`b[n_Scfbuna. Ù{ÝüüZñªú #]óÝl!^X[ncf`4[n|(Wh\ Ù|<[nc4`kgBa,ü[¥~aQcküZ oBaQnajsi[n^Jajo l` ïÞd_Sb`khm+$ajbajlcfe8g
Wh\ Ù{Ýü¸üZ gEln4lím{_E\(xJaQc[n|$Êck[n^JaQck`khiaj`kgSl`4\4lëna*h`lí_EbaQ|<_Es~fh\A_Esl`khi[]mîajmWhick[]mE\#ajm`Q `4kh\_Ssl`baj
l[nn^Jm aQcf~l`k hmBt,ü[¥bu6~kaQ`bckajü\ZÓlnkaQck~najaQscÞs}lnhmîkl_ ^SÜÊseQhÎeQhajlm`k`#hi[]míoBaQxJ`klnajhgSs~lj`bW[íhi[ncfcj_E*mîWlnhÎ\ m+Ù_E{mSÝ\#ü[WüoSZ h E^Sajoícf[¥WnaQhoBc8kajhi([]m\_S[nsi|$`khd Êsia#ù kh[]\m+_Shis`Ql}`b[n`kcfg6A_S #lÀeQloS^Sh X`k_SaQckcfajhmBm{t `
silaQn~ajajsssª[noB|~ajoBkhaQt]`kmBlnajhsÅo.NlnhmmE`boØaQcff|<lnh\AeGa4_Eshl`bÊ[ncfck[¥WeQhlnoBmíajoØxJa#|<[ncÙbeGhi[]`kse8sigBajeGaj`ko.hmBht)mØoE`kgBla#`kleG[]`kgS_Blcfb`Ùa#ln[nssi|~[lqkhPmBlt]c8sihia[]_Scf_S
mNeGJ[]s_EsiajkheGmB`bt[nc8ef
gB[naj|efë{^Jl[]ckuWhm{hmB`kQtqsiýaQnhÎmSajslnssi[nun|
b[nÊgEhb`kheQl`khi[]m`b[ÞxXaÙl`b`klne8gBajo,naQckuajlnkhsiun
?
b

Q
a
b
`
k
`

h
B
m
#
t
k
`
S
g
j
a
b

(
a
n
l
B
o

n
l

m
k
`
l
n
t
j
a

l
k
c
Ù
a
b

Q
a
n

Q
a
8
c
n
l
r
s

h
Þ
\
i
h
k
`
l
k
`
i
h
]
[
S
m
Q

}

h
\
Ù
{

¸
ü
ü
Z
B
o
{
[
j
a

n
u
Q
a

h
S
m
Q
e

s
E
_
B
o
$
a
n
l
{
m
q
u
B
o
Q
a
k
`
n
l

h
i
s
j
a
q
o
4
\
Î
h
G
e
k
c
]
[
l
b
c

[nefoBgEcaQhi`k`b[]lnaj_BheGsàj`kÝo_B[ncf|ÂlnÝ\#[nscf[WkoBoBhaQ\ajc#sÞ_SaGsW|Âl[naj`kchieQ[]_BoSmN`khhik[]ë6m? QímEbeQp`blncfgB_Se8agBeG`kaí\#hi[]lnajmEmS\#Þo [nlcfcku0a.d gSlnhikaQkcf_Sll\4ckc8aØefajg{o mSu![n`bh`[îA\#hÎaG\#6[Waj^JoBeQaQaj_Scksiaj`b|Âaja.o eG`khÎhmsm u![na \#cf{_oB[6SaQoSlnc¥sajsiajoBo?aQhi`k `klngBh[]sÝ _SgS`ÞhýSslna[nmcWu aGh\ WmBln[nÙ\4`k{hi[]ÊÝmü¸sianü[nZ×|ÙxElnÊgSmEhiln^JoBajsnhhmSoBaQajck`kugo

eGhmS[]kmS`bbcf`b_Sc8eGln`khhim[]`kmSjlckaØmB[n`Ü\4lnhÎm`klnhmSajo? naQcku lneQeGajk`b[eQlnefgBaØ[nc\#aj\#[ncku+eG[]\#ÊsaQ`bajhÎm l0eG[]mSk`klnm`m{_E\(xJaQcÞ[n|
ía_SbaWhÎ\ Ù{ÝüüZ `b[b`k_SoBu`kgBa(oSu6mSln\Þhe
xJajgSljWhi[nc$[n|w`kgSa(lcfhi[]_S$siaQnajs[n|´`kgSaA\#aj\#[ncfugEhiaQcflcfe8gunJlnmSo
`kbgB[]_Ba,c8ÊeGaGl`bsi`baQaQncfajmSsXÜ|<_S[nmE|(eG`kbhi[]hmÞ`kefhgBmÜajaGÜWxJajeQaQ_B`~`khiaQ[]ajmm lën`~aQlAc8mBt]ajhinsajlnmmSeGo"uWeQ_SsibaaQclnmE\#oÞ[W`koBg6an_S eGW[nhck\ ckajÙsl{`bÝaü¸`kügBZÑaoBlnuWsmSb[ln\4lnshsie[xXajÞgE_SljWÜhi[n`bç[[noS|NaQ`k`bgSaQa$cf\4^ShcfmB[na,tncf`klngB\ a
hi`kg`kgSa(b[]_BcfeGaÙeG[WoBan
pgBa(xElnba(\4lne8gShmBaÙeG[]0m Et]_Bcfl`khi[]m)a_SbaÙhmq[]_Sckh\_Ssl`khi[]mEeG[nckckajb^J[]mSoS`b[lnm
S ûnûnû4÷ PûWaQcknaQc
hi`kgql #]û ÷ (
%# k ^Sck[WeGajkb[ncj %#'& v~ú %#'& y vúzÿ Ø vÿ6ElnmSo)òWújÿ Ø [n~|w $d
pgBaWh\4ÊsiaWeQlnslc`b[6[]swbaQ`ñ #nóhlÜk_Shi`baÙ[n|}fh\A_Esl`khi[]mq`b[6[]s`kgEl`$^JaQcb
|<`b [n[Þcf\`k!gS[]oBbaQ"a(`k#ln[n#hÎ|$siajW%o)&hÎ\'\4!ÙheG({cf#Ý[]ü)l*ücfefZgShE`bWajeGh\4`k%_B"ÊcfsilnasrWfeQhln\A sl_Ecsl^J`kaQhi[]ck|<m?[n~cf\4Bh\#oBÊaQsi`kalnBheQsiajlno,sl\4cjïheGbck`b[]cklajcfmSe8tngS`khigS`bajeGln`k_BmSc8o*lnsrkajhl\ëW_SmBsajlk`kkhaj[]$m?lBckahi`keGgB[][]\#_SÊ`siaj\#\4[WajoBmaj`kslhmBckut
`kkgBh\a#_S[ns^Jl`kaQhcf[]lm)`khmSht)xJbaju6hmSk`bt4aj\q^JaQ ck|Â [nmíc8\#^zlajcko*`khheQm*_Ss\Alc¥_SJe8g.lnsÎs´\#b[nu6ckkaA`bajoS\ aQ`klneQlnhsÅss
p`kgBlaëna \#QajaQ\#ck[*[nckeGu)uWeQgEsihiajaQQcf lcf e8`Ùghuq
h\A$_E\#ef[6g!oSkajssi[¥aj~o)aQcÙh`k`kgSg*lnmlÜckWajhÎln\ b[]ÙmSXlJxElnsu
gSlneGhit]ck[]gklneQxJeQ[n_B`kc8g)lneGhunmS+b`bc8ý_SheGcf`kbhi`[]m[ncfboBaQaQ`kc#xElnmElnmEoqoBgB[]hboB``kÊgsÎleG`b[]|ÂmS[nbcf`b\ÞcflnQhÎ m`k4lcfa)\#[6oSajsiajo?!ý´hmSlnsÎsiun~Wh\4ÊsiaWeQlnslch 6_Shi`ba^J[nck`klxEsia
ía_EbaWh\#^zsiaWeQlnslc`b[ aGBln\4hmBa0`kgBa!ltntnckaQt]l`ba+\4heGck[]lc8efgShi`bajeG`k_ScflnsÙlnmSo \4aj\#[ncku bu6k`baj\ xJajgSljWhi[nc)[n|
Ê6üsia÷BeQ lnð$slùclnlnsmEsi[o!`b[._SeG[]`b\#[ÜÊb`kl_SckaoBuÜhi`Ù`kgBa(h`khg0\#b^zaQlnneGaQ`cfln[ns| 6Wü d Zì[]mqZ^Jü¸aQck
|Â[nÿc8ûn\4ûnû,lnmSxJeGajanmSSe8lgS`b\4[n^,lcklÞëWQeG[]mSý´bh`kmSlnlnm{s`$sun\4h`keGgBcfaÜ[]l^Jcf[nefgSck`khl`bajxEeGh`ksh_B`ckuØan[n|$Wh\
pgBa$xElnbajshÎmBa$Wh\#^zsiaWeQlnslc}\4lne8gShmBaeG[]@m Et]_Bc8l`khi[]mÞgSlnoShb`khÎmSeG` %#'& + vú$lnmSo y v~ú$eQlne8gBaj ¿xEsi[Wekë4kh Qa %# k
òWújÿ& vwÿ ¿xEs[6efë4kh Qa(újÿnõ k?ú & ajm`bcku4ÿsiaQnajszxScflnmEefg4ÊckajoSheG`b[ncj{lnmÞ[]_B`¸[n|?[ncfoBaQceG[ncfan #AhoBahfk_BaPoBajeG[WoBan
õØhoSaeG[]\4\Þhi`Q #!hm{`baQtnaQcÞd$vrQ$úqhÎm`baQtnaQcÞ\_Ssi`khÊshiaQcjú BE[]l`khÎmBtÝ^J[]hm`d$vrú BE[]l`khmBtÝ^J[]hm{`#\A_Ss`khiÊshiaQc¥
ú Ýajm{`bcku pv SlnmSo)l)újÿnõÝajm{`bcku y pv
+
, .- 0/21Aé8åä×4
å 3 6587Ó"á 9.:
pgShÎbajeG`kh[]mqk_S\4\4lc8h Qaj~[]_Bc zmSoShÎmBt]}[]m`kgBa
e8gSlcflneG`baQcfhk`kheQ[n|Wü¸÷ ðùA ía
cf_EmqWü¸÷ ðù |<[ncÙújÿbajm`bajmEeGaj
hmØ`kgBajbaaGW^JaQcfh\#ajm{`kQ 6ajeQ_B`kh[]m.`kh\#acflnmBtnaj
|<ck[]\ú ºÿûqxEhsÎshi[]m*hÎmSb`bcf_SeG`kh[]mSQJoBaQ^JajmSoShmBtÞ[]m.`kgBa#Êsl`b|<[ncf\q
Speed (Number of phones)
30
phones per second
phones per 100 million cycles.
20
10
0
ý´m6_Shit]\(_BxJckaaQc~ÿ [n¸|rÊajgSsÎ[]l`kmBhiajn¸a(^J^SaQcfc[6beGajajeGk[]fhmSmBoNt#6b$^JgSaQajhsioSa`kgS[n|a6xzülcf÷ ~ []ðmÜù `kgS[]am*c8Phit]lgcfh`~[]_S|<[nc~Êajslnle8`bgq|<[nÊcf\4slj`b|<[npcf\ gBa(ÊxEsi[nl`~cf`kgB[]a
m*m{`k_EgB\(a(xJsiaQaQ|<c~`[nÊ|Nsi[nÊ`$gBb[]^JmBaQajaj~o)^JlnaQc
úQû ÙeGuWeQsiajQ
PPC
PIII
Sun
Alpha
Number of misses
8000
6000
4000
2000
0
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
ý´[n|hit]`k_BgSckha |¿ _SmSy eG`kuWhi[]mSmqln\4eG[]hehÎmS eQvhoBúAaj\4hkhk`kajgqQbajBmgS`blnajoBmEajeGoqa(xJckaQ[]t]_Sh[]mSmSoSlc8oBhiajajQmS [n`ba(aGWajeQ_B`khi[]m)[n|´`kgSa(lnmSb~aQc$xz_ShsoBaQc|¿_SmSeG`khi[]mN~pgSaÙajmSo
Time (billions of instructions)
eG[]hi\#`kgÊlnlmcfajü`kZ gBaÙ[n^J|aQlckck|<[][n_Scf\4mSolnmEûWeG {a
[n |}üWZ"ü¸÷gSlnðsnùøaj[]mqgBajajlnmef`kg,gB[na|[][]_B_B`cÝ[nÊ|ÂÝsÎ[nlcf`boB|Â[naQcfc\ÞeGQ[nSckaÙhmhÎ`baQcfcfaQ\4ÊslneG[naj|o`kgBx6aÙuÜcflnlmq`bahmBl[n`c8oBaQgSche8[]gqmSanÊ}gBý´[]mShit]aj_BcklaÙckÿa

^Sck[WeGajkbajoN¸pgBa
xElc[]mq`kgBa(siaQ|<`|<[ncajlnefg,Êsl`b|<[ncf\êkgB[`kgSaÙm{_S\AxJaQc[n|ÊgB[]mBajÊck[6eGajfbajoq^JaQcbajeG[]mSo?EgShsia
`kÊgBsla`bxE|<[nlcfc´\4[]¸mx{`ku#gBaeQsicf[Wht]ekëÞg`ćflkgB`ban["`kgEgBhasiam6`k_SgB\(a$xJcfaQljc [n^J|EaQ^zckgB|Â[n[]c8mB\4ajln^SmSckeG[WaeG[naj|?kb^zajsol`b^J|Â[naQc8c\4úQûn}ûÙh\4eGh[]sÎ\#shi[]Êm(lcfeGluWxEeQsisajanQ6ln`kmSg{oÞ_SmBaj[nsÎsSc8[¥\4nlnaQsch j`khgBmSa$tck`ka gB6_aS|<hi[]ckaj_Bo c
[¥b^JnaQaQcajo#l|<[nc}hoBckaajlncfsªlnÝ`kmBhÎtn\#a
a[nck|ajeQeGsi[n[Wt]ekmSëhi`kbh^J[]m4aQajloS`}`k`bgB[4alnsiefaQgEnhiajaQsSn[na(|Jhiln`QeQ}eQp_Scfg6ln_SeGQuW`k^SgBcka
[¥WühoB[ajoaQckx6üuÞZ"6ü¸Ê÷sl`bð$|<[nùcf\ên`kbgBaQaaj\Þlcfhi`b[][#_SxJa^zs\4l`b[]|Â[nb`c8\4a Ü[neQhi^JajaQm{cf`l`bhm a
`baQcf\4[n|~hmSb`bcf_EeG`khi[]mS^JaQceQsi[Wekë üZ kzgEhsia(`kgSa m`bajswüajm{`kh_S\ kk h$`kgBa#siajlnbà ÜeQhiajm{`Q y ajbë6`b[nÊ
lnsickajlnoBu
`kbgBaQaj[]\_Bt]gî`b[,lngSeQl¥eQn_BaÜcfln`keGgSuîaÞh^J[¥b~`khaQss¸c(^S`b[,ck[n^XxEaQsiajcf\Þ|Â[nlcf\`khe,b^JpajlgSënaÞaQcckajh\4mEoBlnaQhÎmS^JoBajmSaQc(oBaj[nm{|``kkgS^XhaQajbe8ajg0eG`kcfhi[]ajeGm[nt]_SmSbajhi`kAhi[]`km gBa1 . kh\% _Ss( l/`b1,[n=cf%'A#)( ^Sck[(*6. hoS1 aÜ+-2/lØ. \#(*[n.6ck#¿a
oBaQ`klnhsajo6hiaQß[n|w`kgSaÙoBu6mEln\4hexJajgSljWhi[nc[n|w`kgBa(l^S^zsheQl`khi[]m?
6ü÷ ðù h {_Sh`baÜ~ajssªÝxJajgSl¥najoîhÎm0`kgBahmSk`bcf_SeG`khi[]meQlnefgBan0pgBaÜxzlnbajshmBa %#'&
hmSvkú`bcf^J_S(aQeG ck`k&|<hi[n[]#cfmí\4 eQ#lne8lngBs\#a[]^XkaQ"`4cf |Â^J[n$cfaQ)\Þck |ÂajlneGmS`keGsuna#¸ gShih`ksg+a#^Sl0ck[W\4eGhajkkkÝhc8mBlt `baq)[nb|ajm{ajf`bbajajmSmeG`kajhÎQln}ssilnuÙû tnajmS aQcfý´lhi`bt]aj_Boîcka x{u0 WkhgS\ [¥Ù#{Ý`kü¸gSüa)Z`khr\#6a)ü¸÷ oBaQ^Jð$ajùêmSoSajmln `
^ScfhÎ\#ajohm`b[!k`bajlnoBuîk`kl`ba)x{uîcf_SmEmShmBt Ena)_B`b`baQcflnmSeGajÞxJaQ|Â[ncka`kgShÎ#oSl`kl.~lnÞeG[]ssiajeG`bajo? lnefg+^J[]hm{ `[]m+`kgBa
tncflÊgØhlÜfln\#ÊsiaÙ[n|$ú 6 Þ\Þhsshi[]mqeGuWeQsiajQpgBakgSlnoBajo,ckaQt]hi[]mE$oBajmS[n`baA`kgBa`kh\#aj$[n|}aGWajeQ_B`khi[]mØ[n|´`kgBalnmSb~aQc
10
Miss Rate (%)
Number of misses
3000000
2000000
5
1000000
0
0
Ål y uWmSln\4he y vú(\4hkbajjWgSlnoBajockaQt]h[]mSoBajmB[n`ba ¿x y vú hkl`ba(W$ZlÊlneQhi`ºun íaÙlcku y vúÙkh QaÙhi`kg
aGWajeQ_B`khi[]mq[n|`kgBaÙlnmEbaQc$xE_ShsÎoBaQc|¿_SmSeG`kh[]m?´pgBa
ajmSo
l4eG[]mSk`klnm`òWújÿ& vwÿ6
[n|w`kgSh|¿_SmSeG`khi[]mqeG[]hÎmSeQhoBajh`kgqbajm`bajmEeGa(xJ[]_SmSoSlc8hiajQ
ý´hit]_Bcka # ¸vraQnajs¸ú y l`klÜeQlnefgBa(xXajgEljWhi[ncj
xEb`k_SlhÎcksòBaQ[nç|w|¿`k_SgBmSa
eGmB`khaG[]Wm?`´kpajmgB`baajmS^SeGcfanh\4lpcfgBu4ajbbÊa
hilënckaja
lhmÜ`b`b`kcfgBhixza_Btn`bcfajloÊ`bgq[eG`k[ngBcfa
ckajhbmS^Jhi`k[]hmSlnosÎh j`bl[`khi`k[]gBma
WaGü¸Wh÷ `[nð|wùß`kgS^JhaQck|<_E|<[nmScfeG\4`khi[]mxJaQ|Â[ngSckha
e8goShh6hmSlnstAb[hmÜ`kgB`b[a
`kgBa(hÎmSmBaQcf\#[]k`s[{[n^N}pgBaÙbajeG[]mSoSlcfub^zhiënajeG[nckckajk^X[]mEo`b[4`kgBa(b`klcf`[n|`kgSh |¿_SmSeG`khi[]m?}pgSh Et]_BckaÙfgB[¥`kgSl`
xE6ü_ShÎ÷ soB aQð$cjùwptngB[{aajÙhmS`kbgB`bckcf[]_E_BeG`kt]hig![]mÞÿeQÊlngEe8gBlnajbaj
lckhmØa`k`k_BgBcfa4mSeGaj[]oÞ_B[cfnka#aQc[nl|¸`^Sajckln[WefeGgqajkÊkhÎgEmBlntba$lqxJk[]aj_SmmE`bajoSmSleGcka un(` kígBaa|ÂxX[]aj_SlnmE\oÞ`kkgSajllcfèfg!aQnajlnmmEo.cfaj`koSgB_Sa4eQhlnmBmStAb~`kgBaQac
vú
eQlnefgSaAeQlÊlneQhi`ºuq`b[ #'& []mSsuÜhmSeGcfajlnbaj`kgBa(\ÞhkÝcfl`ba
`b[ÜûWÖÿ
6ü÷ ð$ùøaGBgShixEh`k^X[6[ncoSl`klÜsi[WeQlnshiùnzhmSeQs_SoEhmBtAlÜ\4hkbÝcfl`baÙ[n| Óh`kg)l %#'& saQnajsªfú
o`kSgBla`klÙaGeQWlnaje8eQgB_Ban`k}hi[]ý´"mhit][n$(_B|cf`ka gS# aqÅckl ajeQ_BoS cfhkkÊhnsljauWlnmS`kkgBaaQ`kc#h\4xEaG_EÝhPsoBlckaQuWcAhmB|<_St
mExJeG`kajhigS[]l¥m6hl[n`#c}`k[ngS|za`kgSajamExEoln[nbaj|shÎajmBlna efg y v~bajúm^J`bajaQmEck|<eG[naGcfÝ\4^Sckln[WmSeGeGajankk]h[mBntíaQcfhis `blnaQhc8o4l`khi[]hi`km?g
lnln
mSbtn~ajaQmBcaQc8xzl_S`bhajso!oBaQx6c~uí|<[nWchÎ\ajlnÙefgØ{Ýbüajm{ü`bZajmSJeGpangShpgBtnaÙcfl^S^zc8gíh\4kgBlck[¥uÞ$k
Ê`khigSënajl`ÙhÎ`kmgBa4`kgBsaÙ[6eQtnlncfs´lÊ\4g*lPBeGh[n\4ckcklajb[n^J| []ymSoqvú#`b[Þ\4ajhÎmk`bbckaju)
hÎeGm[n`bck[#ckaj`kkgS^XhÎ[]mE|<o._EmS`beG[)`khi`k[]gBm?a
ln
lckajk_Ss`[n|¸`kgSaAxElnefë{`bc8lnekëWhmBtqcka 6_Shickajo,`kgBck[]_St]g,`kgSaAajm{`khickatnajmBaQcfl`bajoímSaQ`~[nckë,`b[tnajmBaQc8l`ba#`kgB>a zmSlnsÊl`kg?
p\4gShfl`Ýcfhl¸`bmBaj[n`¸l`bck[AaAkll¥ù#l4`kgSk_Blxz`¸b`k`kgBlna m`ky hÎlnv~s?úgShln¸si|\ÞajsÎhsªsÝsxJhi[]ajmÜgSlj^JnaQajcÙoÞú `k6gB a#ck\4ajbhÎ`¸sshi[n[]|?m`kgBhmSab`k`bhc8\#_SeGan`k hi[] m4mSQxJ aQ`~aQajmÜ`kgBalnmSb~aQcbÝxE_EhsoBaQcfj]\#ajlnm
eQlnefý´gShiaAt]_BeQckla Êln# eQhi¿`ºxu)(lk`$gBòW[újÿ4& `k gSza)ln`bmEajoq\#Ê^Jsi[n[ncf`ln`ksgBsiaA[WeQ\4lnhskhi`ºuîÝc8lhÎm `ba
6[nü¸|w÷ `kgS ða ùy v¸lnú
Þ\#gEhajsilnafP_BlckckajuWo+hmBx6t4u h`kWh\#kh QÊansa W eQmSlneGscklajcjln fhmBít a y EvîúÙ`kfgBh Qa*a
vw`b[ÿ
ÿnò & eQln_Sbaj\4hfÝcfl`ba`b[oBcf[n^Ü[]mSsu4\4lckt]hmSlnsÎsiuA`b[4ò6Öò mlAbaQ^zlcfl`baaG6^JaQcfh\4ajm`Q6Plcfu6hmStÙ`kgBakh Qa[n|N`kgBa
yvnaQú$c|Â `kcfgB[]\ak#'ln& \# acf`bln[mBú tnanØ üZckajoS_SlcfeGhajln~mE\4eGaAhkh¸cfmBlaQ`bt]ajs~hit]^ShckxE[nsi^JanS[ncktn`k[]hih[]mSmEtÜl`b|<ajck[]si un\ ûWhÖ`kògBû []Þ_B`b`¸[oBûWc8lnÖòW\4ú l`kÙhephÎg6\#_S^SckW[ü¸naj÷ \#ajðmù×`kaGlW`gElnhixEmhiuÞ`k^X^X[]hÎ[6m[n`Qc
`baj\#^J[ncflnsXsi[WeQlnshiùnWhmÞa X ajeG`gSl¥6hmStAlslcktnakhmBt]sia$siaQnajsE~[nckëWhmBtbaQ``kgEl`~h~mBaQ naQc 6_Shi`ba$eQlÊ`k _Bckajohm4`kgBaeQlnefgSan
6ü÷ ð$ùÑoB[6aj
aGWgEhixEhi`b[]\#a4b^zl`khlnssi[6eQlnsÎhiùnNxz_B`
hi`
h
mB[n`
lxEsia`b[*h\4^Sck[¥na^JaQck|<[ncf\4lnmSeGanpwlxEsiaqú#kgB[
`këngBaQaQa
Ê\4hmSht(f ¸`kcfgBla$`bavú[n|eQ`klgBÊa lneQy hi`v~uÜúeGln[]mSb\#`klnajm{ln`~k_Blck` ajo%#'x6& uWBhÎln\#mSÊo4siavWÿ(eQlneQsÎlnle8cjgBalneQl~^zalneQhil`ckuu4eG`k[]gSmSa b`ky lnv~m{`~ú$lxz`si[6òWefújëÜÿ & kh Qa$ |<ckmS[]eG\ cfajlnú khmB`btÙ[ `k%gS#BaBxEsigS[Wheksië a
kh Qa
[n|`kgBa y v~ú
ckajoS_SeGaj\4hkcfl`ban÷$[aQnaQc¥zaQnajm,lxEsi[Wekëkh Qa
[n| %#4ckajk_Esi`khmql4\4hÎk cfl `baÙ[n|
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
4
15
Time (billions of instructions)
8
16
32
64
128
256
DL1 Size (KB)
y vú si[Wekë)Wh Qa y vú hf$l`ba
ú
Wû újònÿnò
û
W

Q
ú
]
û
n
ÿ
õ
ÿ
%#
Wû û ÿnõ
plxzsia4ú y vú si[Wekë*Wh Qa
6 hk$l`ban
Miss Rate (%)
40
30
20
10
0
256
512
1024
2048
4096
8192
´ý hit]_Bcfa(ò }vwÿ hk$l`baÙW$ZlÊlneQhù
" $( pgBa`kgBaj\4a
[n|^J[6[nc\#aj\#[nckubu6k`baj\ê^JaQck|Â[nc8\4lnmSeGa
eQlckcfhiaj[¥naQc`b[#`kgSa
vwÿln~ajssÅ´pgBaxElnkajshmBa
vwÿ!eQlnefgBa.eQlÊlneQhi`ºu+[n|
òWújÿ& kgB[Þl0\4hkÝc8l`ba)[n| ' pgBa)oBuWmSln\4he`bc8lneGa*tnajmBaQcfl`bajo"x6u Wh\ Ù6Ýü¸üZ
kWgBh\4[Êsia_SWmEeQlnhi|Âs[nlc8c¥\ SlnxJaj~gSa(l¥6hl[nckcu)`kgBhi`kck$[]_BeQlt]ÊgBln[]eQ_Shi`~ù*aGWxXajaQeQ`º_B`kaQhi[]ajmNm.}ÿný´ò hit]& _Bcka(lnòmSko,gS[¥õ `k gSaÙ`\4`klhkënajcflln`bm,aÙvwhÎmÿ4`k[ngB|¸a
ÿ vwÿ6Eln`b[Þ\#xSajcflnhÎmBk_Bt#ck`kajgBoqaA_E\ÞkhhmBkt
,
cfl`baÙ`b[Ülck[]_SmSo!úQû naQc`kgBaAkln\#aÙcflnmStnan üZ Plc8hiaj |<ck[]\MûWØ # õ#`b [ÜûW %#B
`b ajss(_S `kgS l `$ën(aQcf%mB
ajsN)lnmE o*_SbaQ
csiaQ naj sNh)mEb`b cf_SeG`khin[]aQmEc8gBajaGln6o.ajeQoS_B_B`baja(o.`b[gSl¥`kngBaAaln[nm,^JaQljcfnlaQ`kcfhlmBtntabcfu6lk`k`bhiaj[Þ\ [n|hÎ$ú mBújaQò6t]~sÎhiý´t]hihixEt]si_Sancka W4h\ fgBÙ[¥6Ýü¸`kügBZ a
`k|¿_Sh\#mSeGa`koBhi[]aQm?^JajmSýSoBck[]aj\m{`¸[]xJ_BajcgSl¥ln6mShln[nsicuW[nkh|Nën[naQ|c8mBoSajhsJbëqsiaQnlnajeG`ksJhihWmShib``buncfJ_E~eG`kahi[]oSmSaQQ`baQcf\4mSheGmBaa(l`kt]gSlnlh`
m?\#Bln[]eGb`k`hiW[nhi|¸ùÜ`kgB^Xa ajl(ëW)lneGhi`k`kgShiWhmÞhi`ºu)`kgBoSa_BlncfmShmSbt4~aQaGc~6ajxzeQ_S_Sh`ksoBhi[]aQm c
hoS_Ba`b[.Êlt]hmBtB!6ü¸÷ ð$ù lns[]mBahÎ(ckajk^X[]mEkhixEsiaÞ|Â[nc`kgBab`bcflnhm[]mî`kgBaq\#aj\#[nckubu6k`baj\q "hi`kgîl.\#aj\#[ncku
L2 Size (KB)
Instructions in kernel mode
1000000
800000
600000
400000
200000
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
ý´phigBt]a
_Bckaja mEoq&[n
|aQ`kgEcfmShajsª|<_E\#mS[WeG`koBhia~[]mqhÎmSeGb[]`bcfhmS_SeQeG`khÎoBh[]ajmeG[]hi_E`kgqm`kkQajmB`bajgSmSlneGoBa(ajoxX[]ckaQ_Et]mShioS[]lmScf¸hiajoBjaj mB[n`baaGWajeQ_B`khi[]m#[n|X`kgBalnmSb~aQc}xE_EhsoBaQcw|<_EmSeG`khi[]m?
Time (billions of instructions)
6 ü÷ ð$ù t]eQe t jhi^ {Êc \#ajkl lck` a {_Slëna ln\Þ\#^ x jhi^Xÿ
WajeQ_B`khi[]m)ltntnckaQt]l`baj
Z~u6eQsaj búQû
ûW ÖúòWûú ûWònò6Öÿnûþ újúò6û]ûò ûWÿûW ûõ ûWõnÿ6újûþ ûWÿ {Öònûõ ÿ ûW û ûWnò6Öÿnûò úúÖÿnûò
üZ
pr[n`klns\#aj\#[nckulnssi[WeQl`bajo Ø
úQû]þ6û ÿ%#Bû újõ 6û {Öò únúû #B #Sú ÿnÿ6û újõ%#Bû
mSk`bcf_SeG`khi[]mq\4hi6aj
vr[]lnoS
ûWÖÿ ûWÖÿnò ûWÖÿû ûW û ûWÖÿ ûWÖÿû ûWÖÿ ûWÖÿnþ ûWÖÿWú
6`b[nckaj
ûWûWûújõ ûWûWÖÿújûò ûWûWû]ú þ ûWûWúQú û ûWûWúúnú ûWûWûú ûWûWû]újõÿ ûWûWúQújûÿ ûWûWûú
c8lnmSefgBaj
c8lnmSefg,\4hb^ScfajoSheG`khi[]mÜcfl`baj
ûWúQû ûWû ûWû]õ ûWû]þ ûWû ûWû ûWû]ÿ ûWû]ÿ ûWû]õ
ZlnefgBa\4hkc8l`baj
ûWûW û ûWûWû]û ÿ ûWûWû]û ÿ ûWûW û ûWûWûnú #û ûWûWÖ#ò ûWûW û û ûWûWÖûò ûWûWÖû]ÿ ÿ
yvwÿ v~ú
'
pv \4hfcfl`baj
ûWûW ûBú ûWûWûújÿ ûWûWûnúQûû ûWûWûúQ#û ûWûWûú ûWûWÖûnòûû ûWûWû]úQûÿ ûWûWûú # ûWûWûnúQûû
y ppv v
'
~ø[6eQeQ_SÊlnmSeGucfl`baj
#ÿ6 Pû õ6 Pû #þ6 û #ò6 Pû ÿ6Öònò WúÖòû
ÿnõ6Öõû ÿ 6Öÿû ##BÖõû
pxEwhlsÎxEshisi[]amÿ h¸ZmSb~`b[]cf_E\#eGÊ`khil[]c8mShb[]lnmmS[noq|r`k6gBü¸aA÷ W ü ð$ù"Z xXhi`kajg#mEefbgSajs\4ajeGl`bcfajë6o6aGüWaj eQZ+_B`kZ~hmBüt)ú ÿ4ûnxEûnhû(ssÎxJhi[]ajmÞmSefhmEgSb\Þ`bcfl_SckeGë6`kjhi][]mEQhi`k gÞ6ü÷ ðù"aGWajeQ_B`khmSt4újò6
|<[{[n`b^Sc8hm`~[n|rxJaQ`ºaQajmíúnúQû#lnmSo.újÿû Ø []m`kgBaPlcfh[]_S~Êsl`b|<[ncf\4QWhi`~`klënajÿnò , [n|$d `b[#ljn[]hÎoqb~lÊÊhmBt
[]_B``b[ÜoShbëX
)&
2 pgBa^SckajeGajoEhmBt.ckajk_Ss`kkaQcknaq`b[!kgB[M`kgSl`Ü6ü÷ ð$ù gBajljWhsiuaG6aQc8eQhbaj#\#aj\#[ncfunckajf_Ssi`khmBtØhm
^J[{[ncA_B`khsh jl`kh[]m.[n|~lnss¸siaQnajs
[n|`kgBaÞ\4aj\#[nckuígShiaQcflc8efg{unÜpgBa4oSu6mSln\ÞheÊl`b`baQcfmS([n|lneQeGajkAlnmEo!b`k_SoBuØ[n|`kgBa
b[]_Bc8eGakgS[¥ `kgSl``kgBa
slnekëÞ[n|si[WeQlnshi`ºu4hmS[n`lnmlck`kh|<lneG`[n|N`kgShÎ¸Êlcf`kheQ_Sslch\#Êsaj\#ajm`kl`kh[]m 6h`hlnmhmBaQWhi`klxEsia
eGhmq[]mSl4ba \Þ6_lnBmSajmSmBeGaQac[n`kgS|Xl`k`gBahÎxJgBajajlnlj\×Whbsiajulhcf@m e8Bzg4_SlnajsimStneG[najcfoh`kgSx{\4u`kgB`kgBaÙajh\4mSÊkaj_Bsi`Qn ajQ]`kgSl`}eQln_Eba`kgBaajm{`khicka÷ , mBaQ`~[nckë`b[
xJa`bcfljnaQcfkajo
å /äNé8â 65 7Ó"á 9.: øébã ã 65
5
- ¸âè /ä "
Wm*h\4`kgSÊhÎsiaWbeQajlneGs`klhi[]cmØhmS~k`bacf_SeGeG[]`k\4hi[]ÊmlckbaaQ``kgBlcfa(e8gSxJhiaj`bgSajl¥eG6`k_Bh[nckc$a [n¿ü|~WBü¸d ÷ } ðlnmSù×oq\4hihÎ`keGg,ck[]`klgScflef`gEhi[n`b|¸ajeGb`kaQ_BnckaQancf~lns}W6ü¸ü ÷ ðZ ùßÿûn`kûnlûënajxJ$ajlmSxXe8[]gS_S\4`lújckò6ëW |<xE[nchss`kh[]gBma
hmSk`bcf_SeG`khi[]mSÙ`b[,^Scf[6eGajkÜújÿ*kajm`bajmSeGajj.Z~[nckcfaj b^J[]mSoShmBt]sunrlnss}`kgSa6ü ZøxJajmSe8gS\4 lckëW(gEljnaxXaQajm0cf_Sm0|Â[nc`kgBa
Ecfk`ú xzhsshi[]mÜhmSb`bc8_SeG`khi[]mS[]mq`kgBa
ckaQ|<aQckajmSeGa ¿ckaQ| ~hmBÊ_B`~baQ`Q¸pwlxEsiaÙÿkgB[`kgBaÙgSht]gSshit]g{`kQwýSck[]\ê`kgShÎ`klxEsian
~a(baQaÙ`kgBa
|<[]ssi[hmBtckajf_Ssi`k
ð[]mBa[n|}`kgBa46ü Z xJajmSe8gS\4lckëW$gEln$lÜ|Â[6[n`b^ScfhÎm`lnmu6gBaQckamBajlclnslcktnaln
Wü¸÷ ðùAXpgBam{_S\AxJaQc$[n|
^zltnaj(lnssi[WeQl`bajo0hÎÙ\A_Eefg!slcftnaQcÙ`kgSlnm0lnm{u.[n|`kgSa4[n`kgBaQcfQaGWeGaQÊ`(|<[ncÙ`kgBaÞeG[]\#Êckajkkhi[]m.xJajmSe8gS\4lckëWQ m
`k`b[gSa(`kgBeQlnabkaÙh Q[na(|[nt |´jhi`k^*gSaAlnmEhmBo^zx _Bj`hi^zxJÿ6ajBhmB`kt4gBaÙ^SsÎcfl[6ckeGtnaja(kkm6aj_So?\(xJpaQg6c_S[nQ|wEÊ$lgStnha(sia
lnt ssj[6hi^ØeQlln`khimS[]o,mEx j[nhi|w^zlÿ#xJ_E[]b_Ba(`Ù\#újõ[]û bØ`[n |áj`kgBlne8ag*oShl`klkh\#k_SÊb`suÞ[]oSmS_BeGaa
xJaQ|<[nckaÙ\#[6hmSt#[]m?X6ü÷ ð$ù ckaQ^Jajl`bajoSsiulneQeGajkbajhi`k
úQû]õ Ø
Wü¸÷ ðùgSln4\#[ncka*xScflnmSe8gBaj#`kgSlnm lnm{u[n|`kgBaØ6ü Z xJajmSefgE\4lckëW#aGWeGaQÊ`4|Â[ncÜt]eQe ýE_Sck`kgBaQcjxScflnmEefg
ÊckajoSh eG`khi[]m,hkhit]mSh XeQlnm`ksiu)\4[nckahÎmSlneQeQ_Bcfl`ba|Â[nc(6ü÷ ðùìeG[]\#ÊlckajoØ`b[lnmu,[n|}`kgBa46ü Z xJajmSe8gS\4lckëWQ
`kpgSgSa(hhmBhÊ_Sl`~ckoSajlk`k_SlWsi` [n|~`kgBa#eG[]m`bck[]sioBcfhinajmímSl`k_Scka[n|¸`kgBa^Sck[ntnc8ln\qNhi`kg,`kgBa BE[×[n|eG[]m{`bck[]s}oBaQ^JajmSoSajm`[]m
v~[n|Nú
lnoSsÎsBl`k`kgBl#aeQxJlnefajgSmSa(e8gSln\4mSoqlckpëW´v aG BeG^JaQaQ^Sck`¸|<[n|<cf[n\4clnlnmS\ÞeG\#a
^Nh 6_Sphi`bv a^J[6^J[naQcjck´|<[npcf\4gBalnmEveGú
aoSh´l`k~l#[neQcflnba$e8gB`ka(gSln\4mÞhÎkln~ssScf`klgB`baÙahxJaj^JmS[{e8gS[n\4cfaQlc~ck`këWgE´lnaGmB`keGgSaQ^Sl``
y

|<[nclck`Q
dleG[]mSba 6_BajmSeGa.[n|Ù`kgBaígBajl¥{u"b`bcflnhm []m \#aj\#[nckun$~ [WeQeQ_BÊlnmEeGu h_B^"ln~ajssÅøpgBaØaQt]hÎb`baQc
^?oSl`bamEhi`[nc´øñªúQóBhÎwl\4hÎeGck[]lcfefgEhi`bajeG`k_BcflnsBb`bc8_SeG`k_Bckahm4Wh\#^zsiaWeQlnslcw`kgSl`´ln_B`b[]\4l`kheQlnsÎsiu(ckajmEln\#aj
m+lcfajhlkxzkajsiajmSQeGWa)ënaQ`kgBaQÊa)`bcflnefëeG[n[]|w\(oBxEaQhÎ^JmBajajmS#oS`kajgBmSa*eQhiajhÎmSQbW`blncfmS_SoqeG`khhk[]fmî_BajfefgBhmSajboS`b_Ecfs_EhmBeG`kt.hi[]mS~hmEoB[¥gBMajmln`kmSgBo ajhicckaQoS[naQcf^XoBajaQmEc4oBxzaj_mSXeQhiaQajc4hÎlmck`baÙ[!kl!l`khÎf hEmBajt]o?sia
\ÞheGck[]lcfe8gShi`bajeG`k_BcflnsWb`bc8_SeG`k_Bckanw$ [WeQeQ_BÊlnmEeGu(hwlnmhÎmSoSheQl`b[ncw[n|S`kgBam{_E\(xJaQcw[n|EhmSb`bc8_SeG`khi[]mSh"m BXhit]g`wl`
lnm{u(`khÎ\#an íaoBajoS_SeGa~`kgSl``kgBahmSeGckajlnkajoA`khÎ\#ab^Jajm`wx{uhmSb`bc8_SeG`khi[]mSwhmA`kgBa~ hÎwoE_Ba`b[ÙoSaQ^XajmEoBajmSeQhiaj
[]a Jm(aj[neG^J`khiaQncfajlnsimSunoS J|<ck[]\ß\4aj\#[nckunlnmSo
`kgBaQckaQ|<[ncka}`kgEl`r`kgBa¸sÎl`bajmSeGu[n|6`kgSa}\#aj\#[ncku
gShiaQc8lcfefg{uhÎNmB[n`NxJajhmBt\Þlnbënajo
`kgBaÙmÜ^J[6k_E[n\qckajWb`6üeQln÷ e8gB ðaAù lnmSeGoq[]\(pxEv hÎmBaj^J}aQ`kckgB|Âa[nc8s\4lcklntnmSajeGkaj`Q\#SeGaj[]\#\#[n^zcfu#lck|Âaj[6o)[n`b`b^S[4cfh`km{gSàAln6mEü o4`kZ"gBaxJ^Jaj[{mS[nefckgSaj\Þk`¸lckxSë6cfjln mEefg4ÊckajoSheG`khi[]m4hi`kgÞln\4[]mBt

á /âæ "å 4$é }ä Aá /èwã å$â 5 }ä 3jå$ä /âè ^JmaQck`k|<gE[ncfhA\4klnajmSeGeG`kanhi[] míaAacf_S|<[6m,eQ_SWü¸÷[]mð`kù gBa[]hm*mSk^J`b[ncf_Sck`keG`khi[n[]|¸mîWbhaQ\#`#^zlsiacfefWgEeQhiln`bsajleGc`k_Bckhiaq`kg lnmSoîoSh eGJ[]aQ\#ckajÊm{h`saQ|Âcjck}[]lnm{mS`ÝoajmSaGoSWjlnS\4|Â[nhÎmBca`kgB`kaÙgBajü hicWhdA\#EÊdlneGsiÊ`gS[]lWm

lneG[]mS\#oÊühÎsi[¥aQ~caQ_SckbüajZ oN pWd$gBa(j)ü d$Wsds¸^JxE[nhÎckmS`kl(ckugSl¥~nalnhÎoBeG[]ajm\#`kÊhÎeQhlnsajs¸oq\4x{hu)eGcflÞ[]l^Jcfef[ngSck`h`baj[neG|´`kt]_BeQckea }ÿ6`k 6gBÖaÿ6X[]`kmSgSsiuía(ü¸oSüh XZ aQckajxEmEhÎmSeGajl(ckulckx{auqht]m!eQe`kgSÿ6a Öþn ò6WdêúNlnlnmSmSoo
`kgBa(dsiÊgElAxzhmSlcku4x6ut] eQe(ÿ6ÖþÝt]m6_B^Sck[ºþnþPc¥úpgBa
[nÊ`kh\4h jl`khi[]mqsaQnajs?~ln$baQ``b[# |Â[nc$lnss?eG[]\#ÊhsaQcfQ
`kgB[napw`kg|ÂlaQxE`k~sigBa aja
b `d$gShsmShÊt]bgSgS`bl(c8shi_St]lneGg{mE`k`koÜhiw[]mSü`kgBQ[ aíhaQ\#cka#ü^JZk[n_Sck`kcfxEln\4hmSm{h`}lba
c8oShiajh`kJ}gEaQl~ck`$ajaQmSck`ka
gSeGajhÎeG$´[]hh\#mÊxJ`khgSajsajajeQoÜblna_S_Sbcffa_ShmEmB[nQtA|}r`ksÎülgB`baA aQWc~oEd"hnXaQhaQc8cfk`kajhigB[]mSa$mSeG~aA\#[nh[]m*|Nb^S`´`kcfgBa [6Üa oS{_eQ_EhiSeGajln`km{hisÎ`¸[]hi`m huqmE6_b[n`bS|}cfln_SeGs[]eGh``k\#u4hi[]^zeGmh[]si\#baQaQc$Ê`¸_EhÎsibaQajhicf`ko?Qg
gShÎsiaA`kgSa#ü Wd eG[]\#ÊhÎsiaQcÙhl^J[nck`[n|~lnmíajlc8shiaQcnaQcfkhi[]mNpgSa4mBaQaQcÙeG[]\4ÊhsiaQcflcka#^JaQcfgElÊlxEsia`b[)xJaQ`b`baQc
`kkgBe8gBaÙajoS_Ssi×a`klngBmSa oeG[6`kgBoSaÙav`b[[]ln`b[]ozsinaQ6c8l`b[n`baÙcka \#
aj_B\#aj[n_Bcka uÞ¿kv`klns sQk´ pgShÎ¸g{u{^J[n`kgBajkhÎhk_S^S^J[nck`bajo4x6uÞ`kgBasi[aQc[WeQeQ_BÊlnmSeGuÞcfl`bajhm
\4lnZ~mS[]eG\#an ^zlcfhhimB`kgít*lqpwleGxE[]si\4a \# []$m0hi`k\4g!heGýćkhi[]t]l_Bcfcfe8agShiÿ6`bajéG~`k_BacfanbaQNa`kgB`ka4gSld`siÊ\4gShleGck[]Wldìc8efgSgShiln`baj
eGlq`k_SgEckaÜhit]gBgSaQlnc lØükZß_BxE`kgSb`klnlnmím{`k`khgSlnls`
h\#[n|~Êln`kgBeGà#[]üm0[¥~^JaQaQckckü|<[nZcb
÷[¥~aQnaQcjý´hit]_Bcka*ÿ!kgB[¥$#`kgSl`Þ`kgSa)ü[¥~aQcküZêÊsl`b|<[ncf\ gSln4l\#[nckaqa ÜeQhajm`\4heGck[]lcfe8gShi`bajeG`k_Bcfan~lne8gShiaQWhmBt
xJ`kgBaQa(`b`b\ÞaQcln`kefgBgSckh[]mS_Sajt]gBÊa_BeG`~[]^JmSaQkchoSeGaQuWckeQajsio?anB `kgB|a(eGd[]_BsiÊcfgEkaÙl\4lne8hgSeGckhiaQ[]nlajcfo,e8gS`khigB`baja(eG`kgS_Bht]cfaÙgBajeGb[]`\#[¥ÊnaQsiaGc8Blnhis`sNu^JlnaQmSck|<oq[ncfeQ\4si[WlnekmSëeGancfl~`bd$aÙlckaGaÙ6^JeG[najckeGcf`bajajso?lz`bajeQo?lnefEgBlnamSolnmS[no |
\#aj\#[ncfuÜ^JaQck|<[ncf\4lnmSeGa
cfaj\4lnhmqmBajlcfsuhoSajm`kheQlns?lneGcf[]kÊsÎl`b|Â[ncf\ÞQ
S {Ýü Wd E{Ýü¸üZ E{d$sÊgSl
6ajeQ_B`kh[]m)ltntnckaQt]l`baj
heGmEuWbeQ`ksiaj búQbûúQû
újò6 újþ66Ö õ
újþ6ú
úû
úû
ûWÖòWú ûWÖò%#
ûW Wú
üZ
mSb`bcf_EeG`khi[]mq\4hªWaj
v6`b[][nlncfoSaj
ûWûWÖûÿ
ûWûWÖû]ÿ%#õ
ûWûWÖûÿ%#
ûWújõ ûWú #
ûWú #
cflnmSe8gBaj
p[n`klnsr\#aj\4[nckuqlnssi[WeQl`bajo ,
úQû]þ6û únúQûWû únú {û
6`bc8_SeG`k_Bcka
[WeQeQ_BÊlnmSeGucfl`baj

#ÿ6
#B
'
v´ ú 6Öõ újÿ6Öþ
únúÖþ
pwlxEsia ~Z~[]\4ÊlcfhmBtÞ6ü÷ ðù []m)\_Ssi`khÊsia Wd
å$âè:ç Xé8å$â
WhmEeGaÙkh\_Ssl`khi[]mqgSlnxJajeG[]\#a(lnm*hÎm`baQtncflnseG[]\#^J[]mBajm{`[n|éG[]\#Ê_B`baQcbu6k`baj\ oBajfhit]mq\#aQ`kgB[WoB[]si[ntnunXhi`heGc8hi`kheQlns
`bhi`k[
efxJgBaj[6gS[]l¥b6a.h[nckcÙaQ^S\Ack_Sajkkaj`
mxX`kla#`khi_SnmEaØoBaQxJcfajbmS`b[6efgE[6\4oílh|¸ckëW|¿Q_B `k_Bcka#hieG`k[]g"\#bÊ^J_SaQaj`baQefc(g bckuWajbeG`b[najt]\4mSÙhi`khil[]ckm aÞ`bsi[6[*[]k\4_ShbmS`klnt0hÎmílnk_ `kÜgBa,eQhimBajm{aG`W`^JaQë6ckh|ÂsÎ[nsiaQc8cÞ\4lln^SmSÊeGsÎa#heQ|<l[n`kc(hi[]him?`k
aGWBajheQb_B`khÎ`kmBhi[]tm?kÜh\ýE_S_Bsckl`k`bgB[naQcfNc8\#eQln[nmAckan^Sckf[h6\AhÎoB_Ea}sloS`klhi[]`klmí[]bmÙ`k_S[]oEmShisiaju
l[n|sh\ÞxXajhi`bmEajefo
gS\4baQl`Ncf[në6|S
lnbln^JmSajoeG`klrcf[nefgE|6hi`k`bgSaja}eG`kxJ_BajckmSajefAgSgS\ÞljlnckaÜëz`kgBoSaj_Bhiać
`b[¥[$$`km0gBa¸sheG\Þ[]@mhi`kBXlh`keGhi`k[]hmSmBQt
oBaj\4lnmEoS[n|´kh\_Ssl`khi[]mb^JaQajo)lnmSo)^SckajeQhkh[]m?
l^SÊm)sÎheQ`klgS`khhi[]m?b`k_SlnoBmSunoS~eGa([]\#lnoSÊoSlckcfaja!khi`qxJ[n`khigq`kg `kgSbaÙaQnxJaQajcfmSlnefsgS6\Þü lckëqZ lnxXmSo)ajmEkefhgS\\4_Slslcf`bë6[nc¥ `b[ íoSaAaQk`b`kaQ_Scf\4oBu*hmB6aíü¸gB÷ [ ð$ùckaQE^Sl4cfajbb^JajaQmaj`ke8lg)`khcknaja!eG[naGt]WmShÎbh`k`khih[]mBmt
xJ`b[*ajmS^JefaQgEck\4|<[nlcfck\ ëWr`klgSckha~Ù[nb|S`k_EloB|¿un_Bw`k_BhÎm0cfa¸lnlm!^SÊa JshÎeQ[nlck``khi[]`b[*m?xSZcf[][nlnt]oBmSajh jm!lnm{`kgB`ra[n|Sk`keGgB[na~^JaÞsh\4[n|h`k[]l_B`khic[]mShm{?n[naj|Sb[]`khi_St]cl`k`bhi[6[][]mSsQjP)Bah\#_SbÊa~sia\AB_EeQlnsi`kshilÊcÙsia}h(fh_E\Ab_EaQ|<sl_E`bs}[nlncf
lÞWhoS\ aQÙ`kln{hÝsiajü¸o*ü\ÞZíhheGck[]ll|¿cf_Se8sgSsªhib`buWajeGb`b`kaj_B\øcflnskhk\h\_Ss_Sls`bl[n`bcw[nc$`kgSu6lhi`ájsÎuWoShihajmBst#oSl`btncftnlnckmSaQft]hilaj`bma#`´bb`k`kll`k`khhÎkb`k`khheQeQw`k|<gS[nc$l`}\ÞklngBm[u) \4_ShÎeGgBck[¥[]+lcfefgElhicf`bhiaj[]eG_E`kw_Bkcfu6lnbsr`b|Âajaj\#l`kÝ_BcfhajoBQa
|<`baj[4lxJ`k_Ba
ckaj$lnsaQ_Snl[]xEsisina
a#hmqoS_B_EcfmShmSoBtaQcf`kbgS`kalnmEeGoS[]h_BmBc8tba(xJ[n[n|}`kglÞ`k^SgBcka([ntnoBcfuWlnmS\qln\4ï$haGeWlnajmSeQ_Bo*`klhi[]tnm?tnckaQt]lkh`bmSaAt4xJ`kajgBgSajl¥b6ah[n`c~[n[|´fWh\Aü¸_E÷ slð`b[nùAcf hÎm*eG[]mSeGaQck`^Sck[najo

pgShÎrb`k_SoSufgB[¥`kgSl`}6ü¸÷ ð$ù hwoSh JaQckajm{`r|<ck[]\ `kgSa6ü ZíxXajmEefgS\4lcfë6hmÙ`kgBa~aGW`bajm``b[gShe8g(hiàG6aQcfeQhÎbaj
`kgBa\#aj\#[ncku)ku6b`baj\) `gEln$lÜ [ncfë6hmStÜbaQ`[n|¸ÿnò Ø lnmEo, l\#ajoShi[WeGcka üZ [n|¸ûWÖòÜ[]mØlÜgEhit]gWÝajmSo,oBajbë6`b[n^Ø[n|
`b[WoSljun gShsa[]mSsiu#l #'& + vúhÎ¸cka 6_Shicfajo?l %#'& y vúgSln~lA\4hÎkÝcfl`ba$[n| {$gShsialòWújÿ& vwÿÙgElnl '
\xJ4ajhmSfefÝgEcf\4l`blanck ëWQćflnýSmSck[]efg.\ Ê[]ck_BajcoShlneGmS`khiln[]sim,uWkhhln[ns|b[`kgB^JaÙ[{ln[nsicjtn[nc8 himØ`kgSln\4sÎsr`k_EgBbajajko?aAWckajkaA^XbajaQeGaÙ`kjg{6unü¸¸÷ p gBða
ùì|¿_SoSmSh XoEaQlncf\#aj|Âmcf[]`kln\ s?mE`kgSl`ka4_BWcka
ü [n |Z `k gBða
pxJÿajûnlnûn\ û
bajlcfe8glnsitn[ncfhi`kgS\ eQln_Sbaj~`kgBa$ajm`khicfa÷ , mSaQ`~[nckë4`b[xXa$`bcfljnaQc8bajohmÞlA\4lnmSmBaQc~`kgSl`hÎgBajl¥6hÎsiu#h@m Bz_BajmEeGajo#x{u
`kgBa(hÎmBÊ_B`Q
hi`kgí^J[{[ncAoSl`kl)eQlnefgSaÞ^JaQck|<[ncf\4lnmSeGa#lnmSo!sÎlcktna4~[nckë6hÎmBt)baQ`Ùkh Qajjb^JaQajefg0ckajeG[nt]mShi`kh[]m!lnsitn[ncfhi`kgE\4^Sckajbajm{`
`kkg6_B_Sxzb`kcklna m{_`kEhÎlnhicfs
hmBefgStÞlncksajsajslmB`ktnhiajnqajsiu,`b[ khaG\#BÊhbs`ka(hmS^Stck[WleGc8ajefkgSbhi[n`bc8aj$eG`k`b_S[qckaj^JQaQ ck|<[npcf\ gSa.`kgBeG[]a#\4bajÊl_Bcf`ke8lg?`k(hi[]pmSlngBsÙackeGa cf{_hi`kEhÎhieQcklnajsw\#eGaj[]m{\4`kq^X[]lmSckaja!m`ckajhsÎl`k`khigBna#ajsiu\#ajf\#\4[nlnckssÅu
buWb`baj\q b^JajeQhlnssiuíhmî`kgBaeG[]m`baGW`4[n|`kgSahÎmSlnoBa 6_Sl`baÜ^JaQck|<[ncf\4lnmEeGaÜ[n|$`kgBajbaql^SÊshÎeQl`khi[]mSÙ`b[WoSl¥un¸a J[nck`k`b[
hln\#eQeQÊ_Bckcf[¥lnneQa#haj`b
cfln[nmE|k`keGgScfajhi^Sba`kh[]^Smíck[nlntneQcfeQln_B\4cflneGaGuíBeGlaQckajaÞoshþënû ajsiu*h`bm.[)baG[]B\#lneGa#aQckeQxElnlbaj`baQ`kgBa#ajb[naÞxE`bkckaQajckmSnoSa#Q`k gS lÀnaj6míü`k÷ gB[]ð$_BùÑt]g0h`kgB_Sa#mSl~xE[nscfaAoí`b[qckajckeGaj[neGt][nmSt]hmE`khih []Qm a

lnm{uxz_B``kgBa(kh\4Êsiajb`~[n|´bajm`bajmEeGaj$eG[]\#^zsiaQ`bajsiueG[nckckajeG`ksiun
\#^Sck[6hmStÙ`bcflnmSkeGc8hi^S`khi[]m#lneQeQ_Bc8lneGuÞh¸lAefgSlnsÎsiajmBtnan íaoS[(mB[n`¸unaQ`~ëWmB[¥ gB[¥"b^JaQajefgÜckajeG[nt]mShi`kh[]mÞlnsitn[ncfh`kgS\4
hsÎ sWaQn[]sina$`b[lnoSoBckajf´`kgShQ{[ncgB[ `kgSaefgSlnmStnaj$hssBl JajeG`^JaQck|<[ncf\4lnmSeGan m4`kgBajhic~eQ_Bckckajm{`}|<[ncf\q6b^JaQajefg4cfajeG[nt
mSl^Shi`kÊh[]sÎhm)eQll`k^Shi[]ÊmSshÎQeQ lí`khi[]amSlnm{l`kckheQahiÊ\#l[n`backa(`kgEf_Sl`}hi`blnajo)efgS`bhi[ÜaQW[ hmBÜhtÙmBgEa(hit]`b>g cflnzmSoBkajeGscfhh`^Su(`kbhi[]^Jm?aQajBe8cfg#l`kckgSajaQeGc$[nt]`kmSgShiln`km*h[]m?[]mS]saQhnmSaja
m4`b$cflnhimS`kgBkeG[]cf_Bh^S``k`khigB[]ameG[n[]cmSkhm`bcf`blnaQc8hm{ln`keG´`khi[]nm a
ck^Sajcflnh[nsi`kcfhÎhB\#÷ a(aGWajeQÊ_Bck`k[nhi[]xEm?lxEXhsÎhih`ksÎhis?ajckQaw6_pSgBhickaaÙxJkajht]lnmS\Ñh zbeQajlnlm{cf`$e8gb`b\Þ[nc8ljlu4tnaAxJa$`b[qlneQgBeG[]ajsso)aQcf`klgB`baajok`klhi`k`khgeAoEl(h\#eG`k[nhi[]cfmSa$la ckÜuqeQoShajlm`kl`~[nbck`bt]cf_ElneGmS`kh _Bjlckaj`kh[]lnmÜmE[no*|?`k`kgBgSaajbla
eGcfhi`khÎeQlns¸oS,l `klØb`bcf_SeG`k_SckajAlnmEo0gSlcfoS~lckalnkkhk`bajo0^ScfaQ|ÂaQ`ke8gShmBt,[ncb`bcfajln\4hmBt,`kgBaÜeG[]\#^J[]mBajm{`kcka 6_Shickajo!oE_BcfhmBt
`kkgB_ a(keQajhiajlmcfef`$g?lneQeQp_BgBcfajlnkeGa(u*\#lnmSaj\#o,[nbck^JuqaQajboquWb[n`b|}aj\ b^JaQoBajajefkg,hit]ckmqajeG`b[nc8lnt]oBmSaQh`k[ hiJ[]$m*\AlnmS_Eo*b`[nxJ`kgBa
aQaGc$Wklnaj\ÞlcfhmBefgWajo*ÝxzlnlnmEbajo)o._SlmS^SoBÊaQsc8heQb`bl[{`k[Wh[]oqmShmqhm)[nc8|¿oB_BaQ`kc_Bcf`baÙ[ÞsiÊ[¥øck[¥WlnhmSoBo a
gShit]gajmEo)eG[]\#Ê_B`baQc$bu6k`baj\4Q
ìè (âå }
æ ¸âã ía#`kgSlnmBë,pr[]\ &
ajsÎsiaQclnmEo.`kgBaAcfajb`[n|¸`kgBaÞWh\ Ù{Ýü¸üZ tnck[]_S^.l` ï
d_Sb`khÎm*$ajbajlcfefg!vlxJ[ncfl`b[ncfhiaj|<[nc
\4lëWhmBt*Wh\ Ù{Ýü¸üZ l¥PlnhÎslxEsia`b[*_S|<[nc
`kgSh
k`k_SoBun#pgSlnmBëWlnsb[q`b[)`kgSa4\#aj\(xJaQcf[n|~`kgBaÜZd$´p×tnck[]_B^í|<[nc
gB[]_Bc8[n|oEhkeQ_Skfhi[]mlnmSoqeG[]\4\#ajm{`k[]m*baQnaQcflnsroScfl|Â`k[n|`kgShÎÊl^JaQcj
3 ¸ä ¸âè µ¯ºÁ8Ê®®ÄQï²ÈQ©¸ÁÝÀ´¾i§]® ¾ª§ ²²Ì¬jÆj·b²{¾¿®f¯b²6¬j¾Â¨ÎÁQ²W¬QÆn³6½Q±}«ÁG©bïÌn± ÁQ² NÁQ±¸«6Ì]¾¿®f¯ ¯ºÊ§n¨¾<®Ê8¾ÎÌn¯®
µw¯Á8Ê®®ÄQï²PÈj©
ÁÝÀ¾i§]® ¾ª§ ²²{Ì¬QÆ·k²{¾¿®k¯b²W¬j¾Â¨ÎÁQ²6¬jÆB³{½Q±¸«ÁG©bïÌn±øÁj² NÁQ±¸«6Ì]¾¿®k¯ ¯ºÊ§n¨¾<®Ê8¾ÎÌn¯®
!#"%$
&'( ) *)!
+",-$.$
)/"
0$-
213&'456) 7
98:;<0&>=
&@?'&@3A(BC?'%
0ED3;F&' G) =&'
?>
2;+ =+&@;H%IJ
"7 *;HQHRSUTVHWX"
KHL M
ON
PM
<
;
=
<
;
!
Z
+
;
.
H
S
S
R
Y
XU\[6]ZV- % !
^
0O,_V,F&>&'
&à 0bc
;d
=<=;<?@;<
cBe_7Z;+;<=f;H=*&@&'^
?'*&@!cIJ
"7 *;HcX<k2TXXR"Z<Slk
hgi ^M
jN
.M
R2m< 0;+G/"noH,F;<="2m Y ;<
C"VU6;<!
UbF
+"HpqUr-;+s<&@ *;+<"UVHnC;<)* " Y 2&;<+"Upq<t:
E0;+4%0;"2u-<vw
?>0G7 ) *;+<"
E0xvycvz;<&@ ?{|uP%&')) \7} ?'&'* ~v;<;z U4;f
?'?;w=A=?';<*;H
[9;<=&>=<
?_-;<SS%U <k Y '& *&@
?
Q )&'7!\;<%uP7Z
2&'A3;+!c$;HG;H
=#uP;+%;+<" 8o
?'-?"ZuF
?@&@BJ@" m)?'AHSS%
Y )*,F)*;+d
0w[00wpw) G&'/^[c;G&'!\7?';H=<
?>
?Q;d4;+G&'zX[9;<= &'=<
?:$;<7EGHRX"uP!\7 );<
=+&@;< =;H Y ;<7 !\;<<" &'4;+G&@3AhBv&'= &@C"pO
0&>G/"vI"Zm);\<SS%
WU Y *^-
)
?'?'A7E;H
&'*"%G7/~DDUbbb.0
* A=!#
©bï²PÈ NÁQ±¸«6ÆÇ®8¾<®³{½G©k¾<®f±"³{ï±ÌnÆÇ¬j¾Â¨ÎÁQ²#¾¿Á ²6Ä®k¯©k¾¿¬Q²WÄ NÁQ±¸«6Ì]¾¿®f¯}³{½G©k¾¿®k± ®§¬QÉ:¨ÎÁQ¯
k2%;+7;<(r;<0V_
N
%
Be0^&'4;+G&@3A";<) A<SSl

8: Y ;HG&>+"
H\r-&>
{vw);+rC)4;+A5B 0bc
;_
=&@;<=);<Q0;<&@*;<0\BeG7Z;+;H=;<=+*&@&'/C[9;<= &'=<
?V$;+7Z_uFpO
uc%JS+HkS"uF
;+*&';_p;<?@?' &@4 ;+G&@3A"= %?/B:uP!\7);+=+&@;< =;" )*) Gd<SS l25I3,cpt_&>
to&>=+;_B>3bc
;"%G7C~]DDUbbbc &@ !# =+!D2B>bF
;2D2G7;+;H=ZD
·
¦]¯º¬Q²©k¬Êf¾Â¨ÎÁQ²©ÁQ² ÊÁQÌ©k¾Â¨ÎÊb©º¼N³j«®®Ê§4¬j²6ÄÙ³{¨ÖÈ¥²6¬jÆ6µw¯ºÁ:Ê®b©©bï²PÈ
S2\(
&@J)#nC;<;"/r-&'
`vz) ;+r/"V
0$
1$;<00A-O24;+4&@;<bBo;8PrI3-7E;<;<=;<=*&@&@A3;+!# :Q
"ERl~ R%WHT"V<SS
#M
<2\n (r¡to&'=+;+_7;H+"%G7C~]DDUbbb. ?@E=!DU4&>=;¢7;<D
\$&>= 0(8n&@7 7!
/$;H=*&@&'.Ad)!
9
0d!
=&';<+~C!\&'?';<V6*-Z;Be;cbF;F?';+;+7C
<l~XHTXWl" HSSk
³¥«]®®Ê§ NÁQ±±$Ìn²{¨ÎÊ¬¥¾Î¨ÎÁj²
^N
"
HXU\8: &@?'&'7 P;+;H7E;<;<= Sl"%G7C~]DDUbbb.G7Z;+;H=/ Z; 7&'?'&'7 + =+!D%
¦n¯¬Q²]©f¬Êf¾Â¨ÎÁQ²©Áj² ÞÁ:Ä¥®fÆiÆï²PÈ#¬j²6Ä NÁj±}«WÌ]¾<®f¯³{ï±ÌnÆÇ¬j¾Â ¨ÎÁQ²
<R2\p;< 0;+?o$%G;<?')!#" 0)E
0O,F)*&'/"/= Y ;+4&';"
0z%;<4;5r;+0/ -&@ * ;5&'!
5)E0;+3
0^=!\7?';¢AG;<! MN
N
#!
=&';d&@!h)?>
2
"Vm
) A#<SS%
+\$&>=j&'!\7 /"Q8o
5,F ;<+"P[9! .;<?'?@;<+":
0 d pqQpO
UA 0V &'! %J8Q8cu82bP;<8cuyBe) ?@?A3;+! &'!)?>
&'/"
7;<;+%
&'C"%%G7/~DDUbbb.=++ );+¢
;<0)ZDU) ;+D2=+
GD2&'! EDUG;<7DU-ZuP}E0;+&>
? =X2<SSSDU&@ 0;+¢Z %!^
Eá â 4çAã æ /~ã /
pgBaÙhÎmBÊ_BòSl`kl4baQ`|Â[nc`kgSaÙaG6^JaQcfhÎ\#ajm`khÎm`kgShÊl^JaQceG[]mSfhb`k[n|w`kgBaÙ|<[]ssi[hmBt#bajm{`bajmSeGaj
!#" " $&%'" (*)"
+ ,
-./0
1.2
+-$43 +51.26$783. #* 5( "
+.'3 .
/0$'$9-*2
+.2%85 -.23 5 5%:.2%7. # ;<%'.*/6.2$'$9*(=$7$7 .!)"
+ ,
)" $4" )$7> %8( 6 1.2(
( + .8 -?>)
+! ((/52@
.2- ( -."
#?0/6.2
+
A+:
,0%< . B3 . C( "
+.'3ED =
,$7( B)6 F .2 G:$'$7-?
=%
+( .G.2( -5)35%8" (6 2-. B" 2@
+'H .'30%8" (>
+$9
I.2
J?0) K
# (5 :"
+:%C -!.2
+K*( .2LH??LH
+" .2
I!. #$'$43!
+.7H8?LH
1 ?3 .K>%'" (
M (NN O$7?
+P)$7/Q2N" )$7P %8( RN R%8" (
6
, ?P("
<.'3N' S%8($93T2H
+2 (( (P$7
+U%8.2(83V2S
+(O ?/0
+F . W " .2
,(83ED C.2
G%'.P1
+U%8( $73V%'" (
C)"
+* *%8.(83S(?'
/W
+BD 5.2(3
X<5 &
<" -5" )$7 "$7?6
<" %8%8.2(5)3>%'( $735 E/5K0
E:/W
E%7.(0!%8
,
Y" C2!2
I $
<' K> !F 23 ,"- >O K>$7 .* ?)(3)"- *.
,$'(%8" (U( .2*%8.=Z%8( $73U?
6/0.-.2
[+"- ?/!
<9 . $9
+
+?" . (83R" K/5-$43U$9
+(U " .2
,(83U.
W%7. )" 0 " ( .2(U (U%'%83P%
%8( $73ED G/:N " ( .2(P (V- R%8" (
G UF 23N
+83
G. +2
G%8%'(V%8.2(83V/0.2U( ?O .2.2>.2
#/5 %8( $73.2LH(> %8.>> ?/0
+F .>( ($9 E/5 :/5.-(?' . $\3%8.2(83
H ] )" > ?(
+BD ! -: 0%<2> ?=
+0%8($93ED < .2=$7(. E/5.25$7(*H? .'3-*(-.2
#%: ?3
$'K(>?> .%8" (.2
* ?/0
+F .2
#$9
+0/5K(
^+ " ( %8(O%'( $73P$73/5V( * ( <P2S-=P/5V.2.R.2
:
+"$'(O
<$\3V 'H
$7
+( _
!'H8 $9 )$9
`+ ?V/6"$7(S)P
+7 ( . (S%8( $73T.( " .2O
< (Sa4 Ua\
,N
+ .PHO.2
+( O?S O)
+2N)
+(
F 23
cb+:%8( $73ED 6
<' KP (_1
+N% V
+$9%U( <.2(N)$7KZ?3
0
+" %'%8.2(T)3T P%8" (N( "
+.'3T 63 .
'H* * -VV=1V 3S"$7(O 'H)P.2?H (O% #$73
C2H2=$H(U/5.2*$983-P)3V ."$9
.V U%8" (T=F 9D? .2 $!."$7
:.V R."( V# S."$7U ?P
6
+" +(P2_-H.2V 2H
+ >%61 ?3* ."
+(>)3 5" )$952U$7$7-($\3>.%8
,
+ $C ?3 -. : 6.)$9N
# ?0! ):H.73>-*2*)(.!).2 K* :."$7
#> 6 6%
<'83-=#@
LH
d;<:' K0%'( $73ED <0
e $9

Download Report

Characterizing the SPHINX Speech Recognition

Paperzz.com

Your Paperzz