%FFQ 3PPUT
ćF 1PMJUJDBM -FHBDZ PG 4PVUIFSO 4MBWFSZ
"WJEJU "DIBSZB
.BUUIFX #MBDLXFMM
ćJT ESBę 'FCSVBSZ Ɗ ƊƈƉƎ
J
.BZB 4FO
$POUFOUT
$POUFOUT
JJ
-JTU PG 5BCMFT
WJ
-JTU PG 'JHVSFT
WJ
Ɖ *OUSPEVDUJPO
)PX $PVME UIF 1BTU 4UJMM .BUUFS )PX UIF 1BTU 1FSTJTUT )JTUPSJDBM 1FSTJTUFODF JO "UUJUVEFT *OTUJUVUJPOBM 1BUI %FQFOEFODF BOE
#FIBWJPSBM 1BUI %FQFOEFODF 0VS "SHVNFOU )PX ćJT #PPL JT 0SHBOJ[FE 1BSU * ćF $POUFNQPSBSZ &ČFDUT PG 4MBWFSZ 1BSU ** ćF 0SJHJOT PG UIF 64 3BDJBM 0SEFS JO &DPOPNJD BOE 1P
MJUJDBM *ODFOUJWFT 1BSU *** ćF )JTUPSJDBM 1FSTJTUFODF PG 1PMJUJDBM "UUJUVEFT 0VS .FUIPEPMPHJDBM "QQSPBDI $PODMVTJPO Ɖ
ƍ
Ɛ
Ɗ " ćFPSZ PG #FIBWJPSBM 1BUI %FQFOEFODF BOE UIF 1FSTJTUFODF PG 1PMJU
JDBM "UUJUVEFT JO UIF 64 4PVUI
ćF 3PPUT PG #FIBWJPSBM 1BUI %FQFOEFODF JO 1PMJUJDBM 4DJFODF 3FTFBSDI
)PX %PFT #FIBWJPSBM 1BUI %FQFOEFODF SFMBUF UP *OTUJUVUJPOBM 1BUI %F
QFOEFODF 8IBU BSF UIF 1PUFOUJBM 4PVSDFT PG #FIBWJPSBM 1BUI %FQFOEFODF *OUFSHFOFSBUJPOBM 4PDJBMJ[BUJPO BOE 5SBOTGFS PG "UUJUVEFT #FIBWJPSBM 1BUI %FQFOEFODF BOE *OTUJUVUJPOBM 3FJOGPSDFNFOU JJ
ƉƉ
Ɖƍ
ƉƎ
ƉƏ
Ɗƈ
ƊƉ
ƊƋ
Ɗƍ
ƊƏ
Ƌƈ
ƋƊ
ƋƎ
ƋƎ
ƌƈ
$0/5&/54
JJJ
#FIBWJPSBM 1BUI %FQFOEFODF BOE $SJUJDBM +VODUVSFT ćF *NQPSUBODF PG (FPHSBQIZ JO #FIBWJPSBM 1BUI %FQFOEFODF $PODMVTJPO ƌƉ
ƌƊ
ƌƌ
* ćF $POUFNQPSBSZ &ČFDUT PG "NFSJDBO 4MBWFSZ /PX
ƌƍ
Ƌ )PX 4MBWFSZ 1SFEJDUT 8IJUF 1PMJUJDBM "UUJUVEFT 5PEBZ
)JTUPSJDBM %BUB PO 4MBWFSZ .FBTVSFT PG $POUFNQPSBSZ "UUJUVEFT 1SPCMFNT XJUI 6TJOH &MFDUJPOT BOE 7PUFS 3FHJTUSBUJPO %BUB
6TJOH 4VSWFZ %BUB 1BSUJTBOTIJQ 3BDJBM 3FTFOUNFOU 4VQQPSU GPS "ďSNBUJWF "DUJPO #MBDL8IJUF ćFSNPNFUFS 4DPSFT )PX 4MBWFSZ 1SFEJDUT 4PVUIFSO 8IJUFT "UUJUVEFT *T 4MBWFSZ $BVTJOH ćFTF %JČFSFODFT 5BLJOH *OUP "DDPVOU "OUFCFMMVN %JČFSFODFT .BUDIJOH /FJHICPSJOH $PVOUJFT &YQMPJUJOH $PUUPO 4VJUBCJMJUZ UP "TTFTT $BVTBMJUZ 4MBWFSZT &ČFDUT PO 8IJUF "UUJUVEFT 4MBWFSZT .JYFE &ČFDUT PO 1PMJDJFT 6OSFMBUFE UP 3BDF $PODMVTJPO "QQFOEJY 4VSWFZ 2VFTUJPOT "EKVTUJOH $PVOUZ #PVOEBSJFT ƌƏ
ƌƑ
ƍƊ
ƍƋ
ƍƍ
ƍƎ
ƍƏ
Ǝƈ
ƎƉ
ƎƉ
ƎƎ
ƎƎ
ƎƑ
Əƈ
ƏƋ
ƏƎ
ƏƏ
ƏƑ
ƏƑ
Ɛƈ
ƌ )JTUPSJDBM 1FSTJTUFODF %FNPHSBQIJD 1FSTJTUFODF PS 3BDJBM ćSFBU
4MBWFSZT &ČFDUT PO "NFSJDBO %FNPHSBQIJDT ćF #MBDL $PODFOUSBUJPO )ZQPUIFTJT BOE 3BDJBM ćSFBU *T UIF $PODFOUSBUJPO PG "GSJDBO "NFSJDBOT 5PEBZ &YQMBJOJOH 4MBWFSZT
&ČFDUT $PVME #MBDL .JHSBUJPO "ČFDU %FNPHSBQIJD 1FSTJTUFODF 8IBU *T .PSF 1SFEJDUJWF PG $POUFNQPSBSZ 8IJUF "UUJUVEFT 4MBWFSZ PS
$POUFNQPSBSZ #MBDL $PODFOUSBUJPOT $PVME 8IJUF .JHSBUJPO "ČFDU %FNPHSBQIJD 1FSTJTUFODF $PODMVTJPO ƐƋ
ƐƏ
ƑƋ
ƑƏ
ƉƈƉ
Ɖƈƍ
ƉƈƏ
ƉƉƋ
JW
$0/5&/54
** ćF 0SJHJOT PG 4MBWFSZT &ČFDUT ćFO
ƉƉƏ
ƍ "OUFCFMMVN 1PMJUJDT PG 4MBWFSZ BOE 3BDF JO UIF 4PVUI
ćF 3JTF PG 4MBWFSZ JO "OUFCFMMVN 4PVUIFSO -JGF 4MBWFSZ BOE "OUFCFMMVN 1PMJUJDT "TTFTTJOH UIF &ČFDUT PG 1PMJUJDBM (FPHSBQIZ 7PUJOH GPS 6OJPOJTU $BOEJEBUFT JO )JHI4MBWF WFSTVT -PX4MBWF
"SFBT 4FDFTTJPO 7PUFT JO )JHI4MBWF WFSTVT -PX4MBWF "SFBT PG 5FOOFTTFF
&YBNJOJOH )JTUPSJDBM 1SFTJEFOUJBM &MFDUJPO 3FUVSOT " 6OJĕFE 'SPOU 8IJUF "OUFCFMMVN 7JFXT PO 3BDF "TTFTTJOH 3FHJPOBM 7BSJBUJPO JO "OUFCFMMVN 3BDJBM "UUJUVEFT 7BSJBUJPO JO 4MBWF .PSUBMJUZ 3FHJPOBM 7BSJBUJPO JO 4MBWF %XFMMJOHT $PODMVTJPO ƉƉƑ
ƉƊƋ
ƉƊƎ
ƉƊƑ
ƉƋƈ
ƉƋƊ
ƉƋƍ
Ɖƌƈ
ƉƌƋ
Ɖƌƌ
ƉƌƎ
ƉƌƐ
Ǝ &DPOPNJD BOE 1PMJUJDBM *ODFOUJWFT "ęFS &NBODJQBUJPO BOE UIF 3FJO
GPSDFNFOU PG B 3BDJBM )JFSBSDIZ
ƉƍƉ
&NBODJQBUJPO BT B $SJUJDBM +VODUVSF Ɖƍƌ
ćF /FX &DPOPNJD -BOETDBQF Ɖƍƍ
ćF /FX 1PMJUJDBM -BOETDBQF ƉƍƐ
8IJUF 3FTQPOTFT UP &NBODJQBUJPO ƉƎƊ
3FDPOTUSVDUJPO BOE 3FTUSJDUJPOT PO 8IJUF 3FTQPOTFT ƉƎƋ
&DPOPNJD BOE -BCPS $PFSDJPO BOE 7JPMFODF ƉƎƍ
'SBVE 7JPMFODF BOE *OUJNJEBUJPO BU UIF 1PMMT ƉƏƊ
$SJNJOBM +VTUJDF BT B 7FIJDMF PG 0QQSFTTJPO ƉƏƋ
%F +VSF BOE %F 'BDUP
4FHSFHBUJPO BOE 4PDJBM 3FTQPOTFT ƉƏƏ
$PODMVTJPO ƉƐƉ
*** 1BUI %FQFOEFODF PG 1PMJUJDBM "UUJUVEFT $POOFDUJOH ćFO
UP /PX
ƉƐƍ
Ə +JN $SPX 0QQSFTTJPO BOE 3FHJPOBM 1BUI %FQFOEFODF ƉƑƈƈoƉƑƌƈ
ćF 1PTU1MFTTZ &OWJSPONFOU BOE +JN $SPX 1PMJUJDBM 0QQSFTTJPO BOE 7PUJOH 3FTUSJDUJPOT &YBNQMF PG B 3FTUSJDUJWF 4UBUF $POTUJUVUJPO "MBCBNB JO ƉƑƈƉ 3BDJBM 7JPMFODF -ZODIJOH BOE 3BQF ƉƐƏ
ƉƑƈ
ƉƑƍ
ƉƑƐ
ƊƈƊ
$0/5&/54
W
&WJEFODF PG -PDBMJ[FE 'MVDUVBUJPOT JO -ZODIJOHT &DPOPNJD 0QQSFTTJPO 4UBUVT PG #MBDL 'BSNFST JO UIF #MBDL #FMU .FDIBOJ[BUJPO UIF %FNBOE GPS #MBDL -BCPS BOE "UUFOVBUJPO
$PODMVTJPO Ɗƈƍ
ƊƈƏ
ƊƉƊ
ƊƉƌ
ƊƉƏ
Ɛ $JWJM 3JHIUT "UUFOVBUJPO BOE 1BUI %FQFOEFODF ƉƑƌƈ5PEBZ
*OTUJUVUJPOBM BOE $VMUVSBM $IBMMFOHFT UP +JN $SPX -FHBM $IBMMFOHFT UP +JN $SPX ćF $JWJM 3JHIUT .PWFNFOU BOE UIF #MBDL #FMU ćF $JWJM 3JHIUT "DU PG ƉƑƎƌ BOE UIF 7PUJOH 3JHIUT "DU PG ƉƑƎƍ
*OTUJUVUJPOBM "UUFOVBUJPO BOE 1FSTJTUFODF 8JUIJO UIF #MBDL #FMU #SPXO UIF $3" BOE &EVDBUJPO JO UIF #MBDL #FMU 1PWFSUZ BOE *ODPNF *OFRVBMJUZ JO UIF #MBDL #FMU 1PMJUJDBM 4VQQSFTTJPO BOE 7PUJOH #FIBWJPSBM 1BUI %FQFOEFODF BOE &WJEFODF JO UIF #MBDL #FMU 1FSTJTUFOU 7PUJOH BOE 3FBMJHONFOU JO UIF #MBDL #FMU ćF 4PVSDFT PG 1FSTJTUFODF JO UIF 4PVUI $PODMVTJPO "QQFOEJY "SSFTUT PG "GSJDBO"NFSJDBOT ƊƉƑ
ƊƊƊ
ƊƊƋ
ƊƊƍ
ƊƊƏ
ƊƊƑ
ƊƋƈ
ƊƋƌ
ƊƋƏ
Ɗƌƍ
ƊƌƎ
ƊƌƐ
ƊƍƊ
Ɗƍƌ
Ɗƍƌ
ƊƍƏ
ƊƍƑ
ƊƎƉ
ƊƎƌ
ƊƎƎ
Ƒ $PODMVTJPO
8IBU -FTTPOT $BO 8F %SBX GSPN 4PVUIFSO 4MBWFSZ
1PMJUJDBM "UUJUVEFT $BO 1FSTJTU 0WFS 5JNF 4MBWFSZ BOE JUT $PMMBQTF 4IBQFE $POUFNQPSBSZ "UUJUVEFT PO 3BDF
*OUFSWFOJOH 'BDUPST .BUUFS BOE $BO -FBE UP "UUFOVBUJPO 8IBU 0VS 'JOEJOHT .FBO GPS "NFSJDBT 'VUVSF #JCMJPHSBQIZ
ƊƎƑ
-JTU PG 5BCMFT
ƐƉ
ƐƊ
ƐƋ
Ɛƌ
4IBSF PG #MBDL $IJMESFO "UUFOEJOH 4FHSFHBUFE 4DIPPMT "GSJDBO "NFSJDBO SFHJTUFSFE WPUFST CFGPSF BOE BęFS 4NJUI W "MMXSJHIU
/VNCFS PG 73" DIBMMFOHFT PSJHJOBUJOH GSPN IJHI BOE MPXTMBWF DPVO
UJFT 1SPQPSUJPOT BT GSBDUJPO PG UPUBM OVNCFS PG IJHI BOE MPXTMBWF
DPVOUJFT JO QBSFOUIFTFT &ČFDU PG TMBWFSZ PO 73"SFMBUFE MBXTVJUT ƊƋƉ
ƊƋƏ
ƊƌƉ
ƊƌƊ
-JTU PG 'JHVSFT
ƉƉ
8IJUF BUUJUVEFT PO SBDFSFMBUFE JTTVFT ƉƑ
ƋƉ
ƋƊ
ƋƋ
Ƌƌ
Ƌƍ
ƋƎ
ƋƏ
ƋƐ
ƋƑ
ƋƉƈ
4MBWF 4DIFEVMF GSPN UIF ƉƐƎƈ 64 $FOTVT )JTUPSJDBM 1SFWBMFODF PG 4MBWFSZ XJUI .PEFSO $PVOUZ #PVOEBSJFT 0CBNBT 4IBSF PG UIF 5XP1BSUZ 7PUF JO ƊƈƈƐ 3FMBUJPOTIJQ #FUXFFO 4MBWFSZ BOE 1PMJUJDBM "UUJUVEFT 5PEBZ &TUJNBUFE OPOCMBDL DPVOUZ WPUFTIBSF GPS 0CBNB JO ƊƈƈƐ &TUJNBUFE OPOCMBDL DPVOUZ WPUFTIBSF GPS 0CBNB JO ƊƈƈƐ .BQ PG DPUUPO TVJUBCJMJUZ JO UIF 4PVUI 3FMBUJPOTIJQ CFUXFFO DPUUPO TVJUBCJMJUZ BOE QSPQPSUJPO TMBWF ƉƐƎƈ &ČFDU PG TMBWFSZ PO XIJUF BUUJUVEFT &ČFDU PG TMBWFSZ PO XIJUF UIFSNPNFUFS TDPSFT PG XIJUFT BOE CMBDLT
ƍƈ
ƍƉ
ƍƌ
ƎƊ
Ǝƌ
Ǝƍ
ƏƉ
ƏƊ
ƏƋ
Əƍ
WJ
-JTU PG 'JHVSFT
WJJ
ƋƉƉ 8IJUF BUUJUVEFT PO OPOSBDFSFMBUFE JTTVFT ƋƉƊ "MBCBNB $PVOUZ #PVOEBSJFT JO ƉƐƎƈ WFSTVT Ɗƈƈƈ ƏƏ
ƐƉ
ƌƉ
ƌƎ
ƌƏ
ƌƐ
ƌƑ
$PNQBSJTPO PG "GSJDBO "NFSJDBO 4PVUIFSO QPQVMBUJPOT JO ƉƐƎƈ WT
5PEBZ 3FQSFTFOUBUJPO PG 4MBWFSZT &ČFDUT PO %FNPHSBQIJDT %JSFDU FČFDU PG TMBWFSZ PO XIJUF BUUJUVEFT DPOUSPMMJOH GPS QSPQPSUJPO
CMBDL JO Ɗƈƈƈ )PX UIF FČFDU PG TMBWFSZ WBSJFT CZ EFDMJOFT JO UIF CMBDL QPQVMBUJPO JO
UIF ƊƈUI DFOUVSZ %JSFDU FČFDU PG TMBWFSZ OFU QSPQPSUJPO CMBDL PO QSFTJEFOUJBM WPUF TIBSF
PWFS UJNF )PX SBDJBM UISFBU DBO CF FYQMBJOFE CZ TMBWFSZ $PNQBSJTPOT PG 8IJUF *O BOE 0VU.JHSBOUT ƉƑƋƍ BOE ƉƑƌƈ $PNQBSJTPOT PG 8IJUF .JHSBOUT UP 8IJUF /PO.JHSBOUT ƉƑƋƍoƉƑƌƈ
$PVOUZUP$PVOUZ NJHSBUJPO ƉƑƑƍoƊƈƈƈ Ɖƈƌ
ƉƈƎ
ƉƈƐ
ƉƉƈ
ƉƉƊ
ƍƉ
ƍƊ
ƍƋ
ƍƌ
ƍƍ
ƍƎ
ƍƏ
4MBWF 1PQVMBUJPO ƉƏƑƈoƉƐƎƈ (VCFSOBUPSJBM FMFDUJPOT BOE TMBWFSZ JO (" BOE .4 ƉƐƍƉ 5FOOFTTFF TMBWFSZ BOE WPUJOH ƉƐƍƊoƉƐƎƉ &ČFDU PG TMBWFSZ PO %FNPDSBUJD WPUF TIBSFT ƉƐƌƌoƊƈƈƐ 4MBWFSZ BOE UIF #SFDLJOSJEHF 7PUF ƉƐƎƈ &YBNQMF PG ƉƐƎƈ .PSUBMJUZ $FOTVT 4MBWFSZ SFMBUJWF TMBWF NPSUBMJUZ BOE EFOTJUZ PG TMBWF EXFMMJOHT
ƉƊƍ
ƉƋƊ
ƉƋƌ
ƉƋƏ
ƉƋƐ
Ɖƌƍ
ƉƌƏ
ƎƉ
ƎƊ
ƎƋ
4MBWFSZ BOE UIF %FDMJOF JO 'BSN 7BMVFT ƉƐƎƈoƉƐƏƈ 4MBWFSZ BOE UIF 3FBEKVTUFS 7PUF JO 7JSHJOJB ƉƐƐƉ 4MBWFSZ BOE $POWJDU -FBTJOH JO "- BOE .4 ƉƐƐƎ ƉƍƏ
ƉƎƉ
ƉƏƎ
ƏƉ
ƏƊ
ƏƋ
Əƌ
Əƍ
ƏƎ
&YBNQMF PG B -JUFSBDZ 5FTU "OBMZTJT PG WPUFT JO GBWPS PG "MBCBNB $POTUJUVUJPO PG ƉƑƈƉ -ZODIJOHT JO UIF 4PVUI ƉƐƐƊoƉƑƋƈ 4MBWFSZ BOE -ZODIJOHT QFS Ɖƈƈƈƈƈ $PVOUZ 3FTJEFOUT ƉƐƐƊoƉƑƋƈ
4MBWFSZ BOE UIF &DPOPNJD 4UBUVT PG #MBDL 'BSNFST ƉƑƊƍ .FDIBOJ[BUJPO BOE UIF &ČFDU PG 4MBWFSZ ƉƑƐ
ƊƈƉ
ƊƈƋ
ƊƈƎ
ƊƉƋ
ƊƉƎ
ƐƉ
ƐƊ
ƐƋ
4MBWFSZ BOE UIF FEVDBUJPO HBQ ƉƑƎƈ 4MBWFSZ BOE UIF FEVDBUJPO HBQ ƊƈƉƋ 4MBWFSZ BOE JODPNF JOFRVBMJUZ ƉƑƌƈ BOE ƊƈƉƈ ƊƋƊ
ƊƋƋ
ƊƋƍ
ƌƊ
ƌƋ
ƌƌ
ƌƍ
ƑƊ
ƑƐ
ƑƑ
ƉƈƊ
WJJJ
Ɛƌ
-JTU PG 'JHVSFT
3FMBUJPOTIJQ #FUXFFO 4MBWFSZ BOE "GSJDBO "NFSJDBO 3FHJTUSBUJPO ƉƑƎƌ
BOE ƉƑƎƏ Ɛƍ 3FMBUJPOTIJQ #FUXFFO 4MBWFSZ BOE #MBDL BOE 8IJUF 7PUFS 5VSOPVU
ƊƈƈƐoƊƈƉƌ ƐƎ &ČFDU PG TMBWFSZ PO %FNPDSBUJD WPUF TIBSFT ƉƑƈƈoƊƈƈƐ ƐƏ 4MBWFSZ BOE UIF XIJUF WPUF PWFS UJNF ƐƐ $PSSFMBUJPO DPFďDJFOUT CFUXFFO QBSFOUT XIJUF SBDJBM QSFGFSFODF JO ƉƑƎƍ
BOE UIFJS DIJMESFOT XIJUF SBDJBM QSFGFSFODF NFBTVSFE BU GPVS UJNF QFSJ
PET ƉƑƎƍ ƉƑƏƋ ƉƑƐƊ BOE ƉƑƑƏ 8IJUF SBDJBM QSFGFSFODF IFSF JT NFB
TVSFE BT UIF EJČFSFODF CFUXFFO UIF SFTQPOEFOUT UIFSNPNFUFS TDPSFT
GPS XIJUF BOE CMBDL QFPQMF ƐƑ 4MBWFSZT FČFDU CZ DIJMEIPPE FYQFSJFODF ƐƉƈ 4MBWFSZ BOE BSSFTU SBUFT CZ SBDF ƉƑƑƈ ƊƋƑ
Ɗƌƌ
ƊƌƏ
ƊƌƐ
Ɗƍƈ
ƊƍƊ
Ɗƍƍ
$IBQUFS Ɖ
*OUSPEVDUJPO
iƑƐŰ QSPCBCMZ PG XIJUF QFPQMF JO
.JTTJTTJQQJ XFSF TFHSFHBUJPOJTUT
.Z GBNJMZ XBT NZ GBUIFS XBT *
XBT FWFSZCPEZ XBT &WFSZCPEZ
UIBU * LOFX XBT GPS TFHSFHBUJPOw
(SFFOXPPE .JTTJTTJQQJ SFTJEFOU
(SFFOXPPE .JTTJTTJQQJ ƊƈƉƈ QPQ ƉƍƊƈƍ
JT CZ BMM BDDPVOUT B GBJSMZ UZQJDBM
UPXO JO UIF .JTTJTTJQQJ %FMUB *U JT OPU B CJH UPXO CVU JU GFFMT CJH FOPVHI ćF
HSJEEFE TUSFFUT MJOF VQ JO B SPVHIMZ OPSUITPVUI EJSFDUJPO BOE JUT UXP SJWFST
UIF 5BMMBIBUDIJF BOE UIF :B[PP QBSUT PG UIF XFC PG TNBMMFS SJWFST GPSNJOH UIF
.JTTJTTJQQJ GPPE QMBJOTSPVHIMZ FODJSDMF UIF UPXO /PSUI PG UIF :B[PP IJTUPSJD
NBOTJPOT MJOF (SFFOXPPET i(SBOE #PVMFWBSEw BOE DPUUPO BOE DPSO ĕFMET EPU UIF
SPBET MFBEJOH BXBZ GSPN UIF DJUZ 4PVUI PG UIF :B[PP JO UIF IJTUPSJD DJUZ DFOUFS
MPOHTUBOEJOH SFTUBVSBOUT BOE TIPQT TPNF PG XIJDI IBWF CFFO UIFSF GPS EFDBEFT
DPOUJOVF UP TFSWF %FMUB TQFDJBMJUJFT MJLF CSPJMFE TISJNQ BOE DSBCNFBU #VU QFSIBQT
(SFFOXPPET HSFBUFTU DMBJN UP GBNF BU MFBTU UPEBZ JT TFSWJOH BT UIF CJSUIQMBDF BOE
GPSNFS IPNF UP B OVNCFS PG HSFBU CMVFT BSUJTUT JODMVEJOH 3PCFSU +PIOTPO BOE
8BMUFS i'VSSZw -FXJT
-PPLJOH BSPVOE UIF UPXOBOE FMTFXIFSF JO UIF CSPBEFS .JTTJTTJQQJ %FMUB
SFHJPOJU JT FBTZ UP TFF SFNOBOUT PG PMEFS EJČFSFOU UJNFT ćF .JTTJTTJQQJ %FMUB
JT BO BMMVWJBM QMBJO BOE JUT TZTUFN PG SJWFST IBWF QSPWJEFE SJDI GFSUJMF TPJM GPS BHSJ
DVMUVSBM VTF GPS UXP DFOUVSJFT 5P DVMUJWBUF UIFTF MBOET JO UIF FBSMZ ƉƐƈƈT XIJUF
FOUSFQSFOFVST GPSDFE UIF USBOTQPSUBUJPO PG FOTMBWFE "GSJDBO "NFSJDBOT XFTUXBSE
Ɖ
Ɗ
$)"15&3 ƫ */530%6$5*0/
JOUP UIJT SFHJPO 5PHFUIFS UIF GFSUJMF MBOE UIF iJOFYQFOTJWFw XPSLGPSDF BOE UIF
OBWJHBCMF SJWFST NBEF DJUJFT MJLF (SFFOXPPE UIF FOHJOFT CFIJOE i,JOH $PUUPOw
XJUI .JTTJTTJQQJ QSPWJEJOH SPVHIMZ ƌƐƈ NJMMJPO QPVOET PG HJOOFE DPUUPO JO ƉƐƍƑ
BMNPTU B RVBSUFS PG BMM DPUUPO QSPEVDUJPO JO UIF 6OJUFE 4UBUFT UIBU ZFBSBOE IFMQ
JOH UP QSPQFM UIF OBUJPO UISPVHI UIF *OEVTUSJBM 3FWPMVUJPO JO UIF MBUF ƉƑUI DFOUVSZ
)BJOFT ƊƈƉƈ
*U JT FBTZ UP TFF UIJT JO (SFFOXPPET (SBOE #PVMFWBSE NBOTJPOT
BOE UIF XJEF USFFMJOFE TUSFFUT JO TPNF PG JUT OFJHICPSIPPET " TJHO PO UIF PVU
TLJSUT PG UPXO QSPVEMZ XFMDPNFT WJTJUPST UP UIF i(SFFOXPPE $PUUPO $BQJUBM PG UIF
8PSMEw "OE JU DFSUBJOMZ XBT TP
#VU BT DJUJFT MJLF (SFFOXPPE TIPX UIF UJNFT PG QMFOUZ EJE OPU MBTU JO UIF %FMUB
4UBSUJOH JO UIF ƉƑƌƈT UIF NFDIBOJ[BUJPO PG DPUUPO QSPEVDUJPO ESBNBUJDBMMZ SF
EVDFE UIF OFFE GPS BHSJDVMUVSBM MBCPS JO UBOEFN XJUI UIF (SFBU %FQSFTTJPO BOE
UIF NJHSBUJPO PG CMBDLT PVU PG UIF SVSBM 4PVUI DJUJFT MJLF (SFFOXPPE GFMM JOUP DZ
DMFT PG QPWFSUZ BOE SFDFTTJPO GVSUIFS FYBDFSCBUFE CZ SBDJBM WJPMFODF BOE UFOTJPOT
UISPVHI UIF ƉƑƍƈT BOE ƉƑƎƈT #FUXFFO ƉƑƌƈ BOE UIF QSFTFOU EBZ DMPTF UP IBMG PG
UIF QPQVMBUJPO PG UIF .JTTJTTJQQJ %FMUB MFę GPS PQQPSUVOJUJFT FMTFXIFSF BOE UPEBZ
(SFFOXPPE JT B DJUZ QFQQFSFE XJUI CPBSEFE VQ CVJMEJOHT BOE WBDBOU MPUT *O UIF
USBEJUJPOBMMZ "GSJDBO "NFSJDBO OFJHICPSIPPE PG #BQUJTU 5PXO KVTU PVUTJEF UIF DJUZ
DFOUFS NBOZ BCBOEPOFE iTIPUHVOwTUZMF IPVTFT MJOF UIF TUSFFUT DBMMJOH UP NJOE B
QBTU XIFO NPTUMZ CMBDL BHSJDVMUVSBM XPSLFST MJWFE UIFSF
5PXOT MJLF (SFFOXPPE BSF SFNJOEFST UIBU NBOZ QMBDFT BDSPTT UIF 4PVUIFSO
#MBDL #FMUSPVHIMZ UIF IPPL TIBQFE TXBUI GSPN UIF .JTTJTTJQQJ %FMUB UISPVHI
"MBCBNB (FPSHJB BOE JOUP UIF $BSPMJOBTBSF UPEBZ EJTQSPQPSUJPOBUFMZ QPPS BOE
EJTBEWBOUBHFE 8JUIJO (SFFOXPPE UIF VOFNQMPZNFOU SBUF GPS "GSJDBO "NFSJ
DBOT JT OFBSMZ UXJDF UIBU PG UIF TUBUF BWFSBHF XIJDI JT JO UVSO IJHIFS UIBO UIF OB
UJPOBM BWFSBHF *ODPNFT GPS "GSJDBO "NFSJDBOT JO (SFFOXPPE BSF BMTP MPXFS UIBO
TUBUF BOE OBUJPOBM BWFSBHFT UIF NFEJBO JODPNF IBT CFFO BSPVOE IBMG PG UIF OB
UJPOBM NFEJBO JODPNF GPS NPTU PG UIF MBTU EFDBEF "OE UIF PWFSBMM QPWFSUZ SBUF
JO (SFFOXPPE JT BCPVU UXJDF UIF PWFSBMM .JTTJTTJQQJ QPWFSUZ SBUF 4FHSFHBUJPO JT
QFSIBQT UIF TUSPOHFTU SFNJOEFS PG UIJT GPMMPXJOH EFTFHSFHBUJPO PG QVCMJD TDIPPMT
JO UIF ƉƑƎƈT NBOZ #MBDL #FMU UPXOT FTUBCMJTIFE QSJWBUF iTFHSFHBUJPO BDBEFNJFTw
GPS XIJUF TUVEFOUT MFBWJOH EFTFHSFHBUFE QVCMJD TDIPPMT CMBDL BOE TUBSWFE PG SF
TPVSDFT 5PEBZ (SFFOXPPE )JHI 4DIPPM JT ƑƑŰ "GSJDBO "NFSJDBO XIJMF OFBSCZ
1JMMPX "DBEFNZGPVOEFE JO ƉƑƎƎ UP QSPWJEF TFHSFHBUFE TDIPPMJOH GPS (SFFO
XPPET XIJUF DIJMESFOJT UPEBZ ƑƎŰ XIJUF
(SFFOXPPET IJTUPSJDBM USBKFDUPSZ DPOUSBTU XJUI BOPUIFS 4PVUIFSO DJUZ "TIFWJMMF
/PSUI $BSPMJOB ƊƈƉƈ QPQ ƐƋƋƑƋ
8IFSFBT (SFFOXPPET MBOE XBT JUT QSJNBSZ
OBUVSBM SFTPVSDF "TIFWJMMFT MPDBUJPO JO XFTUFSO /PSUI $BSPMJOB XBT CZ GBS MFTT
Ƌ
GSJFOEMZ UP MBSHFTDBMF BHSJDVMUVSF TFUUJOH JUT DPVSTF PO B EJČFSFOU QBUI *OEFFE
(SFFOXPPE XBT TFUUMFE QSJNBSJMZ BT B CBTF GPS UIF QSPEVDUJPO BOE TIJQNFOU PG
DPUUPO CVU "TIFWJMMF BOE #VODPNCF $PVOUZ B NPVOUBJOPVT SFHJPO OFTUMFE JO UIF
#MVF 3JEHF BOE 4NPLZ .PVOUBJOT XBT TFUUMFE QSJNBSJMZ BT B USBEJOH PVUQPTU 'PS
UIBU SFBTPO UIF DJUZ SFNBJOFE TNBMM BOE TFDMVEFE GPS NPTU PG UIF ƉƐUI BOE ƉƑUI
DFOUVSJFT BOE JU XBT POMZ VOUJM UIF BSSJWBM PG UIF #VODPNCF UVSOQJLF ƉƐƊƏ
BOE
QBSUJDVMBSMZ PG UIF SBJMSPBE ƉƐƐƈ
UIBU UIF BSFB TUBSUFE UP CMPTTPN 'PS UIF FBSMZ
QBSUT PG UIF ƊƈUI DFOUVSZ JUT SFMBUJWFMZ DSJTQ DMJNBUF BOE TDFOJD NPVOUBJO MPDBUJPO
NBEF JU BO JEFBM WBDBUJPO EFTUJOBUJPO GPS 4PVUIFSOFST GSPN IPUUFS MPXMBOE BSFBT
BOE PWFS UJNF JUT CPBSEJOHIPVTFT TUBSUFE IPVTJOH USBWFMFST GSPN BSPVOE UIF DPVO
USZ
5PEBZ "TIFWJMMF JT B EZOBNJD DJUZ XJUI BĒVFOU TVCVSCT BOE BO BUUSBDUJWF EPXO
UPXO ćF DJUZT GBNJMZ NFEJBO JODPNF BSPVOE ƒƌƍƈƈƈ JT WFSZ DMPTF UP /PSUI
$BSPMJOBT NFEJBO ćFTF OVNCFST XPVME QSPCBCMZ CF IJHIFS CVU GPS UIF QSFTFODF
PG MBSHF OVNCFST PG VOJWFSTJUZ TUVEFOUT GSPN UIF MPDBM DBNQVT PG UIF 6OJWFSTJUZ
PG /PSUI $BSPMJOB *O GBDU ƌƋƋŰ PG "TIFWJMMF SFTJEFOUT IBWF CBDIFMPST EFHSFFT PS
IJHIFS B ĕHVSF UIBU GBS PVUQBDFT CPUI UIF /PSUI $BSPMJOB BWFSBHF ƊƏƋŰ
BOE UIF
"NFSJDBO BWFSBHF ƋƈƌŰ
*O BEEJUJPO B UISJWJOH UPVSJTU JOEVTUSZ CSJOHT WJTJUPST
UP #VODPNCF $PVOUZT GBNPVT #MVF 3JEHF NPVOUBJOT BOE UP DVMUVSBM BUUSBDUJPOT
MJLF UIF IJTUPSJD #JMUNPSF &TUBUF UIF DJUZ JT BMTP IPNF UP B WBSJFUZ PG PUIFS JOEVT
USJFT JODMVEJOH IFBMUI DBSF HSPDFSZ BOE SFUBJM BOE IJHIFS FEVDBUJPO 1FSIBQT UIF
TUSPOHFTU TJHO PG "TIFWJMMFT QSPTQFDUT GPS QSPTQFSJUZ MJFT JO UIF GBDU UIBU JU JT B HSPX
JOH DJUZ XJUI ƉƋŰ SBUF PG HSPXUI GSPN Ɗƈƈƈ UP ƊƈƉƈ B SBUF UIBU CFTUT UIF 6OJUFE
4UBUFT BT B XIPMF ƑƏŰ
BOE QVUT UIF DJUZ PO QBS XJUI PUIFS QBSUT PG UIF i/FX
4PVUIw *U XPVME CF IBSE UP EFOZ UIF PQUJNJTN CFIJOE UIFTF OVNCFST XIJDI BSF
FDIPFE JO #VODPNCF $PVOUZT DBOEP NPUUP i1FPQMF UP .BUDI 0VS .PVOUBJOTw
ćJT JT OPU B IJTUPSZ CPPL OPS JT JU B CPPL BCPVU UIF HFPHSBQIJD EJWFSTJUZ PG
UIF 4PVUI ćJT JT B CPPL BCPVU QPMJUJDT BOE QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT "OE PVS SFB
TPO GPS EJTDVTTJOH UIFTF UXP DJUJFT(SFFOXPPE .JTTJTTJQQJ BOE "TIFWJMMF /PSUI
$BSPMJOBJT CFDBVTF BMUIPVHI UIFZ MPPL WFSZ EJČFSFOU UPEBZ UIFZ TIBSF BO JNQPS
UBOU USBJU JO DPNNPO UIFZ CPUI MFBO TUSPOHMZ %FNPDSBU JO UFSNT PG UIFJS QPMJUJDT
*O ƊƈƈƐ BOE ƊƈƉƊ GPS FYBNQMF #BSBDL 0CBNB MPTU CPUI .JTTJTTJQQJ BOE /PSUI $BS
PMJOB IBOEJMZ
CVU XPO CPUI -FĘPSF $PVOUZ BOE #VODPNCF $PVOUZ UIF IPNFT
PG (SFFOXPPE BOE "TIFWJMMF SFTQFDUJWFMZ #VU BT XF XJMM EJTDVTT JO UIJT CPPL UIF
SFBTPOT XIZ BSF WFSZ EJČFSFOU (SFFOXPPE XIJDI JT ƎƏŰ CMBDL IBT GPMMPXFE UIF
USBKFDUPSZ PG "GSJDBO "NFSJDBO QPMJUJDT NPSF HFOFSBMMZ BMUIPVHI BT XFMM EJTDVTT
UISPVHIPVU UIJT CPPL UIJT XBT OPU BMXBZT CFFO UIF DBTF
4JODF "GSJDBO "NFS
JDBO WPUFST UPEBZ UFOE UP PWFSXIFMNJOHMZ TJEF XJUI UIF %FNPDSBUJD QBSUZ UIJT
$)"15&3 ƫ */530%6$5*0/
ƌ
NFBOT UIBU (SFFOXPPEBT IBWF PUIFS NBKPSJUZCMBDL DPVOUJFT UISPVHIPVU UIF
#MBDL #FMUIBT TJEFE XJUI %FNPDSBUJD DBOEJEBUFT 0O UIF PUIFS IBOE BOE QFS
IBQT NPSF SFWFBMJOH #BSBDL 0CBNB XPO OFBSMZ OP TVQQPSU GSPN UIF BSFBT XIJUF
WPUFSTƉ /FBSMZ BMM PG -FĘPSF $PVOUZT XIJUF WPUFT XFOU UP 0CBNBT UXP 3FQVCMJDBO
PQQPOFOUT +PIO .D$BJO ƊƈƈƐ
BOE .JUU 3PNOFZ ƊƈƉƊ
ćJT JT B QBUUFSO TFFO
BHBJO BOE BHBJO UISPVHIPVU UIF #MBDL #FMU CMBDL WPUFST TVQQPSUJOH GPS %FNPDSBUJD
DBOEJEBUFT CVU XIJUF WPUFST PWFSXIFMNJOHMZ TVQQPSUJOH 3FQVCMJDBO DBOEJEBUFT
"TIFWJMMF PO UIF PUIFS IBOE BMTP MFBOT %FNPDSBUJD BT EP TPNF PUIFS BSFBT
JO UIF UIF 4PVUIFSO iVQDPVOUSZw #VU UIF BSFBT %FNPDSBUJD MFBOJOHT EP OPU GPM
MPX GSPN UIF QSFGFSFODFT PG B CMBDL NBKPSJUZPOMZ BSPVOE ƉƍŰ PG "TIFWJMMF BOE
ƎŰ PG #VODPNCF $PVOUZ JT CMBDL *OEFFE MPPLJOH BU UIF ƊƈƈƐ FMFDUJPO UIF SFM
BUJWFMZ TNBMM OVNCFST PG CMBDL WPUFST NFBO UIBU 0CBNB BDUVBMMZ EJE XFMM BNPOH
#VODPNCF $PVOUZT XIJUF WPUFST IF XPO XJUI ƍƏŰ PG UIF WPUF CVU CMBDLT POMZ
NBLF VQ ƎŰ PG UIF QPQVMBUJPO &WFO XJUI BMM ƎŰ PG "GSJDBO "NFSJDBOT UVSOJOH
PVU BOE WPUJOH GPS IJN 0CBNB BQQFBST UP IBWF QJDLFE VQ PWFS ƍƈŰ PG UIF XIJUF
WPUF BO VOVTVBMMZ IJHI ĕHVSF JO UIF 64 4PVUI .BOZ PG UIFTF WPUFT TVSFMZ DPNF
GSPN UIF SFUJSFFT BOE UIF TUVEFOUT XIP DBMM "TIFWJMMF IPNF #VU FWFO BDDPVOUJOH
GPS UIJT NPCJMF QPQVMBUJPO XIJDI XF EJTDVTT JO MBUFS QBSUT PG UIJT CPPL
XIJUFT
XIPTF GBNJMJFT IBWF MJWFE JO UIF "TIFWJMMF BSFB GPS HFOFSBUJPOT IBWF CFFO PO BWFS
BHF NPSF MJCFSBM UIBO SFTJEFOUT PG QBSUT PG UIF 4PVUI 8IBU FYQMBJOT UIJT
ćFTF DJUJFT(SFFOXPPE .JTTJTTJQQJ BOE "TIFWJMMF /PSUI $BSPMJOBBSF KVTU
JMMVTUSBUJPOT PG UIF CSPBEFS QV[[MF UIBU XF FYQMPSF JO UIJT CPPL 8IZ BSF XIJUFT JO
QMBDFT MJLF (SFFOXPPE .JTTJTTJQQJ TP NVDI NPSF DPOTFSWBUJWF UIBO XIJUFT XIP
MJWF JO QMBDFT MJLF "TIFWJMMF /PSUI $BSPMJOB 8IZ JT UIFSF HSFBUFS SBDJBM QPMBS
J[BUJPO JO QMBDFT MJLF (SFFOXPPE 8IZ EJE UIFTF EJČFSFODFT EFWFMPQ "OE XIZ
XPVME UIFTF EJČFSFODFT QFSTJTU
ćJT DPOUFNQPSBSZ QPMJUJDBM QV[[MF GPSNT UIF DPSF JORVJSZ JO UIJT CPPL #VU
FWFO UIPVHI UIJT JT B DPOUFNQPSBSZ QV[[MF XF CFMJFWF UIBU UIF BOTXFST UP UIFTF
RVFTUJPOT MJF JO UIF IJTUPSZ PG UIFTF QMBDFT 8F BSHVF JO UIJT CPPL UIBU QPMJUJDBM
BUUJUVEFT QFSTJTU PWFS UJNF NBLJOH IJTUPSZ B LFZ QBSU PG IPX XF VOEFSTUBOE DPOUFN
QPSBSZ QPMJUJDT -PPLJOH BU UIF 64 4PVUI XF GPDVT UIJT DPODFQUVBM BSHVNFOU PO
UIF iQFDVMJBS JOTUJUVUJPOw UIBU ESPWF UIF 4PVUIT FDPOPNZ BOE QPMJUJDT GPS OFBSMZ
Ɗƍƈ ZFBST DIBUUFM TMBWFSZ 8F BSHVF UIBU 4PVUIFSO TMBWFSZ IBT IBE B MBTUJOH MPDBM
FČFDU PO 4PVUIFSO QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT BOE UIFSFGPSF PO SFHJPOBM BOE OBUJPOBM QPMJUJDT
8IJUFT XIP MJWF JO QBSUT PG UIF 4PVUI UIBU XFSF IFBWJMZ SFMJBOU PO TMBWFSZ BOE UIF
JOFYQFOTJWF MBCPS UIBU UIF JOTUJUVUJPO QSPWJEFETVDI BT QMBDFT MJLF (SFFOXPPE
Ɖ
ćF FTUJNBUF PG UIF XIJUF WPUF GPS 0CBNB DPNFT GSPN PVS FTUJNBUJPO TUSBUFHZ JO $IBQUFS Ƌ
)08 $06-% 5)& 1"45 45*-- ."55&3
ƍ
.JTTJTTJQQJ BOE PUIFS QMBDFT JO UIF 4PVUIFSO #MBDL #FMUBOE BSF NPSF DPOTFSWB
UJWF UPEBZ NPSF DPPM UPXBSE "GSJDBO "NFSJDBOT BOE MFTT BNFOBCMF UP QPMJDJFT UIBU
NBOZ CFMJFWF DPVME QSPNPUF CMBDL QSPHSFTT #Z DPOUSBTU XIJUFT XIP MJWF JO QMBDFT
XJUIPVU BO FDPOPNJD BOE QPMJUJDBM USBEJUJPO SPPUFE JO UIF QSFWBMFODF PG TMBWFSZ
QMBDFT MJLF "TIFWJMMF /PSUI $BSPMJOBBSF CZ DPNQBSJTPO NPSF QSPHSFTTJWF QP
MJUJDBMMZ BOE PO SBDJBM JTTVFT ćFTF QBUUFSOT IBWF QFSTJTUFE IJTUPSJDBMMZ BOE BSF UIF
EJSFDU DPOTFRVFODFT PG UIF TMBWFIPMEJOH IJTUPSZ PG UIFTF BSFBT SBUIFS UIBO CFJOH
TJNQMZ BUUSJCVUBCMF UP DPOUFNQPSBSZ EFNPHSBQIJDT PS DPOUFNQPSBSZ QPMJUJDBM EF
CBUFT
5P HP CBDL UP PVS PSJHJOBM RVFTUJPO UIFO XIBU FYQMBJOT UIF EJČFSFODFT JO QPMJ
UJDT JO DJUJFT MJLF (SFFOXPPE WFSTVT QMBDFT MJLF "TIFWJMMF 8IZ BSF XIJUFT TP NVDI
NPSF DPOTFSWBUJWF JO UIF #MBDL #FMUT WFSTVT PUIFS QBSUT PG UIF 4PVUI 8IBU XF BS
HVF JO UIJT CPPL BOE XIBU XF TIPX VTJOH FNQJSJDBM FWJEFODF JT JT UIBU TPNF PG UIF
EJČFSFODFT JO UIF QPMJUJDT PG UIFTF UXP DJUJFT DBO JO QBSU CF USBDFE UP POF JNQPSUBOU
GBDU (SFFOXPPE XBT B QMBDF XIPTF FDPOPNZ XBT SPPUFE JO UIF IJTUPSJDBM QSFWBMFODF
PG TMBWFSZ BOE UIF QSPWJTJPO PG JOFYQFOTJWF CMBDL MBCPS XIFSFBT "TIFWJMMF XBT OPU
)PX $PVME UIF 1BTU 4UJMM .BUUFS
.BOZ QFPQMF NJHIU UIJOL UIJT JT BO PVUSBHFPVT DMBJN *U TFFNT QSFQPTUFSPVT UP
UIJOL UIBU TPNFUIJOH DPVME IBQQFO TP MPOH BHP DPVME QPTTJCMZ BČFDU QFPQMFT BUUJ
UVEFT BUUJUVEFT UPEBZ JUT FWFO KVTU BT MVEJDSPVT UP UIJOL UIBU BMM PG UIF UIJOHT UIBU
IBQQFOFE CFUXFFO ƉƐƎƈ BOE UPEBZ IBWFOU TFSWFE UP EJNJOJTI UIPTF TPSUT PG JO
ĘVFODFT 5P QVU JU TJNQMZ IPX DPVME TPNFUIJOH UIBU XBT BCPMJTIFE Ɖƍƈ ZFBST BHP
QPTTJCMZ BČFDU PVS QPMJUJDBM CFMJFGT UPEBZ
ćJT JT B TNBSU SFBTPOBCMF WJFXQPJOUPOF TIBSFE CZ NBOZ QPMJUJDBM PCTFSWFST
BOE TDIPMBST 4MBWFSZ FOEFE PWFS Ɖƍƈ ZFBST BHP B UJNF XIFO UIF 64 QPQVMBUJPO
OVNCFSFE BSPVOE ƋƉ NJMMJPO BCPVU UFO QFSDFOU PG XIBU JU JT UPEBZ *O UIF ƉƐƍƈT
SPBET JO UIF 64 XFSF NPTUMZ VOQBWFE IPSTFT BOE XBHPOT BOE IVNBO GFFU
XFSF
UIF NPEBM GPSN PG USBOTQPSUBUJPO BOE SBJMSPBET XFSF CFHJOOJOH UP SFQMBDF TUFBN
CPBUT BT UIF TUBOEBSE XBZ UP IBVM HPPET BDSPTT UIF DPVOUSZ "MFYBOEFS (SBIBN #FMM
XPVMEOU NBLF IJT ĕSTU UFMFQIPOF DBMM GPS BOPUIFS Ɗƍ ZFBST JO ƉƐƏƎ
BOE UIF 8SJHIU
CSPUIFST XPVMEOU UBLF UIFJS ĕSTU ĘJHIU GPS ƍƈ NPSF JO ƉƑƈƋ
8PNFO DPVMEOU
WPUF UIFSF XFSF POMZ ƋƋ TUBUFT JO UIF GSBHJMF
VOJPO BOE #VČBMP /FX :PSL XBT
"NFSJDBT ƉƈUI MBSHFTU DJUZ "T PG ƊƈƉƍ #VČBMP JT "NFSJDBT ƌƍUI MBSHFTU DJUZ
"OE UIJT ZPVOHFS 6OJUFE 4UBUFT XBT BMTP ZFU UP GBDF UIF XBWF PG JOUFSOBM BOE JOUFS
OBUJPOBM NJHSBUJPO UIBU XPVME DIBSBDUFSJ[F UIF ƊƈUI DFOUVSZ " MPU IBT DIBOHFE JO
Ǝ
$)"15&3 ƫ */530%6$5*0/
"NFSJDBO TPDJFUZ BOE DVMUVSF JO UIF Ɖƍƈ ZFBST TJODF TMBWFSZ XBT BCPMJTIFE
'SPN UIF WBOUBHF QPJOU PG QPMJUJDT BOE PG SBDF SFMBUJPOT UIFTF DIBOHFT BQQFBS
FTQFDJBMMZ TBMJFOU 'PS TUBSUFST UIF JOTUJUVUJPO PG TMBWFSZ XBT JUTFMG QFSNBOFOUMZ BOE
GBJSMZ RVJDLMZ BCPMJTIFE CPUI CZ UIF &NBODJQBUJPO 1SPDMBNBUJPO ƉƐƎƋ
BOE NPSF
GPSDJCMZ CZ UIF EFGFBU PG UIF 4PVUI JO UIF 64 $JWJM 8BS ƉƐƎƉoƉƐƎƍ
ćF TVC
TFRVFOU GFEFSBM JOWPMWFNFOU PG 3FDPOTUSVDUJPO ƉƐƎƍoƉƐƏƏ
CSPVHIU GPSUI NBT
TJWF TUSJEFT UPXBSE FRVBMJUZ JODMVEJOH UIF FOBDUNFOU PG UIF ƉƋUI ƉƌUI BOE ƉƍUI
"NFOENFOUT UP UIF 64 $POTUJUVUJPO XIJDI UPHFUIFS GPSNBMMZ BCPMJTIFE TMBWFSZ
HVBSBOUFFE OFXMZ GSFFE "GSJDBO "NFSJDBOT UIF SJHIU UP WPUF BOE CSPVHIU UP BMM
QFPQMF UIF SJHIU UP FRVBM QSPUFDUJPO PG UIF MBXT "MUIPVHI IJTUPSJBOT IBWF DIBM
MFOHFE IPX GPSDJCMZ UIFTF "NFOENFOUT XFSF FOGPSDFE BT XF XJMM MBUFS JO UIJT
CPPL
UIFSF JT OP EFOZJOH UIBU UIF GPSNBM JOTUJUVUJPO PG TMBWFSZ IBE DPMMBQTFE CZ UIF
ƉƐƐƈT NBSLJOH B TJHOJĕDBOU USBOTJUJPO QPJOU JO UIF "NFSJDBO SBDJBM PSEFS .BOZ
IBWF BSHVFE UIBU UIF JODMVTJPO PG "GSJDBO "NFSJDBOT JOUP QVCMJD MJGF NPWFE BU CFTU
JO ĕUT BOE TUBSUT FH ,MJOLOFS BOE 4NJUI ƊƈƈƊ
CVU JU XPVME CF FOUJSFMZ NJTMFBE
JOH UP TBZ UIBU UIFTF NBTTJWF QPMJUJDBM BOE FDPOPNJD GPSDFT EJEOU TVCTUBOUJBMMZ TIJę
BOE TIBQF QPMJUJDBM BOE TPDJBM BUUJUVEFT UISPVHI IJTUPSZ
&WFO HSFBUFS NPWFNFOUT UPXBSE FRVBMJUZ IBWF CFFO NBEF JO UIF ƊƈUI DFOUVSZ
GVSUIFS EJTUBODJOH UIF 6OJUFE 4UBUFT GSPN JUT TMBWF QBTU 'PS FYBNQMF BOE KVTU UP
OBNF KVTU B GFX UIJOHT
UIF ƉƑƊƈT BOE ƉƑƋƈT TBX UIF SFNBSLBCMF SJTF PG "GSJDBO
"NFSJDBO WJTJPOBSJFT JO EJTQBSBUF ĕFMET JODMVEJOH MJUFSBUVSF -BOHTUPO )VHIFT
;PSB /FBMF )VSTUPO
UIF BSUT .BSJBO "OEFSTPO +PTFQIJOF #BLFS
BOE BUIMFU
JDT +FTTF 0XFOT +PF -PVJT +BDLJF 3PCJOTPO
8JUIJO QPMJUJDT BT XFMM UIF WPJDF
PG CMBDL QPMJUJDBM BOE JOUFMMFDUVBM MFBEFST TVDI BT 8&# %V #PJT .BSDVT (BS
WFZ BOE #PPLFS 5 8BTIJOHUPO HVJEFE UIF OBUJPO UPXBSE B GBJSFS USFBUNFOU PG
"GSJDBO "NFSJDBOT BMUIPVHI UIFZ WPJDFE UIFJS PQJOJPOT JO EJČFSFOU XBZT
#Z UIF
ƉƑƎƈT UIFTF FČPSUT IBE DVMNJOBUFE OPU KVTU JO UIF GPSNBM DPOTUJUVUJPOBM EJTBWPXBM
PG TFHSFHBUJPO XJUI UIF 4VQSFNF $PVSU SVMJOH JO ƉƑƍƌ PG #SPXO W #PBSE PG &EVDB
UJPO
CVU BMTP XJUI UIF NBTTJWF HSBTTSPPUT NPWFNFOU UIBU XF OPX SFDPHOJ[F BT UIF
$JWJM 3JHIUT .PWFNFOU 5PEBZ BT NBOZ "NFSJDBOT QBZ UIFJS SFTQFDUT UP QSPNJ
OFOU "GSJDBO "NFSJDBO MFBEFST MJLF DJWJM SJHIUT WJTJPOBSZ .BSUJO -VUIFS ,JOH +S
BOE GPSNFS 4VQSFNF $PVSU +VTUJDF ćVSHPPE .BSTIBMM BT UIFZ EP QSPNJOFOU XIJUF
MFBEFST GSPN UIF TBNF UJNF QFSJPE *U XPVME CF TJNQMZ BCTVSE UP EFOZ UIF QSPHSFTT
BTTPDJBUFE XJUI UIFTF NPOVNFOUBM DIBOHFT BOE XJUI UIF TJHOJĕDBOU MFBEFSTIJQ BOE
JOUFMMFDUVBM WJTJPO XJUIJO "GSJDBO "NFSJDBO DPNNVOJUJFT
5BLFO UPHFUIFS UIFTF TPDJBM QPMJUJDBM BOE DVMUVSBM DIBOHFT IBWF NFBOU UIBU
"NFSJDBOT MJWF JO B NPSF JOUFHSBUFE NVMUJDVMUVSBM FOWJSPONFOU UIBO IBT FWFS CFFO
QPTTJCMF BMUIPVHI DIBMMFOHFT EP SFNBJO &YQMJDJU SBDJTN JT JO NPTU DPNNVOJ
)08 $06-% 5)& 1"45 45*-- ."55&3
Ə
UJFT TFSJPVTMZ DPOEFNOFE BT BSF BDUT PG WJPMFODF EJSFDUFE UPXBSE QBSUJDVMBS SBDJBM
PS FUIOJD HSPVQT *OTUJUVUJPOBM QSPUFDUJPOT PG NJOPSJUZ SJHIUT JODMVEF OPU KVTU UIF
GBSSFBDIJOH QSPWJTJPOT PG UIF $JWJM 3JHIUT "DU PG ƉƑƎƌ BOE UIF 7PUJOH 3JHIUT "DU
PG ƉƑƎƍ CVU BMTP UIF 'BJS )PVTJOH "DU UIF &RVBM 0QQPSUVOJUZ BOE &NQMPZNFOU
$PNNJTTJPO BOE UIF QSPNPUJPO PG NJOPSJUZ IJSJOH BOE BQQMJDBUJPOT CZ TUBUF BOE
GFEFSBM HPWFSONFOUT WJB UIF VTF PG BďSNBUJWF BDUJPO *O UFSNT PG DSJNJOBM KVT
UJDF NBOZ KVSJTEJDUJPOT IBWF TUSPOHFS TFOUFODFT GPS IBUF DSJNFT PS PUIFS LJOET PG
DSJNFT UBSHFUFE UPXBSE NJOPSJUZ HSPVQT ćF QPMJUJDBM JODMVTJPO PG "GSJDBO "NFS
JDBOT IBT FYUFOEFE OPU KVTU UP UIF ƊƈƈƐ FMFDUJPO PG UIF OBUJPOT ĕSTU CMBDL 1SFT
JEFOU #BSBDL 0CBNB
CVU BMTP UIF BQQPJOUNFOUT PG UXP 4VQSFNF $PVSU +VTUJDFT
$MBSFODF ćPNBT BOE ćVSHPPE .BSTIBMM
B 4FDSFUBSZ PG 4UBUF $POEPMFF[B 3JDF
UXP "UUPSOFZT (FOFSBM &SJD )PMEFS BOE -PSFUUB -ZODI
BOE OVNFSPVT PUIFS IJHI
MFWFM GFEFSBM BOE TUBUF PďDJBMT
ćF 4PVUI IBT CFFO OP FYDFQUJPO UP UIJT QSPHSFTT " WJTJUPS GSPN UIF ƉƐƎƈT
XPVME IBSEMZ SFDPHOJ[F UIF DJUZ PG "UMBOUB UPEBZ *O UIF ƉƐƎƈT "UMBOUB XBT B
TNBMM DJUZ QPQ Ƒƍƍƌ BCPVU UIF TJ[F PG (SFFOXPPE
NPTUMZ SFMJBOU PO MPDBM SBJM
SPBET GPS CVTJOFTT BOE USBEF 5PEBZ "UMBOUB JT B SFĘFDUJPO PG UIF i/FX 4PVUIw B
USVF NFUSPQPMJT GVMM PG DPOTUSVDUJPO DPSQPSBUF PďDFT BOE ĕOF SFTUBVSBOUT +VTU
BT JNQPSUBOUMZ "UMBOUB JT IPNF UP B MBSHF BOE HSPXJOH CMBDL NJEEMF BOE VQQFS
DMBTTPOF UIBU ESJWFT NVDI PG UIF MPDBM FDPOPNZ BOE QSPWJEFT TVCTUBOUJBM DVM
UVSBM DPOUSJCVUJPOT UP UIF DJUZ *O NPSF SFDFOU ZFBST DJUJFT MJLF "UMBOUB JODMVEJOH
/BTIWJMMF BOE .JBNJ IBWF MVSFE NBOZ NJEEMF BOE VQQFS DMBTT CMBDLT BXBZ GSPN
DJUJFT JO UIF /PSUI BOE CBDL UP UIF 4PVUI 'PS NBOZ "GSJDBO "NFSJDBOT UIJT i/FX
4PVUIw JT TJNQMZ B NPSF DPNGPSUBCMF XFMDPNJOH FOWJSPONFOU UIBO NBOZ QBSUT PG
UIF SBDJBMMZ TFHSFHBUFE /PSUI
8F BMTP OPUF UIBU B TUSPOH QBSU PG UIF "NFSJDBO DSFFE JT TJNQMZ UIBU UIF QBTU
JT UIF QBTU ćF 6OJUFE 4UBUFT JT B OBUJPO PG JNNJHSBOUT BOE NBOZ DBNF JO MBSHF
QBSU UP FTDBQF GBNJMZ IJTUPSJFT BMUIPVHI NBOZ "NFSJDBOTQBSUJDVMBSMZ "GSJDBO
"NFSJDBOTIBE OP DIPJDF
.BOZ "NFSJDBOT CFMJFWF UP VTF B GBNJMJBS FYQSFT
TJPO UIBU TJOT PG UIF GBUIFS TIPVME OPU QBTT POUP UIF TPOT ćFTF JEFBT IBWF CFFO
QVU JOUP QSBDUJDF CZ UIF OBUJPOT MFHBM TZTUFN 'PS FYBNQMF CBOLSVQUDZ MBX DMFBST
B EFCUPST TMBUF BęFS TFWFO ZFBST BOE TUBUVUFT PG MJNJUBUJPOT FOTVSF UIBU OP VOEVF
UJNF IBT QBTTFE CFUXFFO DSJNF BOE QVOJTINFOU 64 DPVSUT UBLF BT B TUBSUJOH
QSPQPTJUJPO UIBU EFGFOEBOUT TIPVME OFWFS CF QVU PO USJBM UXJDF GPS UIF TBNF DSJNF
BOE UIBU DJUJ[FOT TIPVME OPU CF QVOJTIFE GPS DSJNFT DPNNJUUFE CZ QBSFOUT PS SFM
BUJWFT "NFSJDBOT QVU TUSPOH NPSBM XFJHIU PO UIF JEFB PG JOEJWJEVBMJTNCPUI JO
UFSNT PG JOEJWJEVBM SFTQPOTJCJMJUZ BOE BMTP PO JEFB UIBU B QFSTPO DBO NPWF QBTU IJT
PS IFS GBNJMZ DJSDVNTUBODFT BOE NPWF GPSXBSE UISPVHI IBSE XPSL BOE FČPSU 6O
Ɛ
$)"15&3 ƫ */530%6$5*0/
EFSHJSEJOH UIJT JT UIF JEFB PG GPSHJWFOFTT BOE TJNQMZ MFUUJOH CZHPOFT CF CZHPOFT
)PX UIF 1BTU 1FSTJTUT
0O UIF PUIFS IBOE B SFBTPOBCMF QPTJUJPO JT UIBU UIF QBTU BDUVBMMZ IBT FOPSNPVT
DPOTFRVFODFT GPS PVS QSFTFOU 8F LOPX JOTUJUVUJPOT BOE OPSNT BOE QFSIBQT BMTP
QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT BT XF XJMM EJTDVTT
DIBOHF SFNBSLBCMZ TMPXMZ PWFS UJNF 4MBWFSZ
XBT BCPMJTIFE POMZ BSPVOE Ɖƍƈ ZFBST BHPXIJDI SFQSFTFOUT UIF MJGFUJNF PG UXP
ƏƍZFBS PMET QVU UPHFUIFS "T SFNJOEFST PG IPX DMPTF UIJT iQBTUw JT UP VT UIF MBTU
QFSTPO CFMJFWFE UP CF CPSO JOUP TMBWFSZ EJFE JO UIF ƉƑƏƈT XIJMF UIF MBTU SFDPHOJ[FE
MJWJOH DIJME PG GPSNFS TMBWFT EJFE POMZ SFDFOUMZ JO ƊƈƉƉ ćPVTBOET PG QFPQMF MJW
JOH EVSJOH UIF ƊƈƈƈT BOE ƊƈƉƈT XFSF CPSO EVSJOH UIF UJNFT PG TIBSFDSPQQJOH JO
UIF ƉƑƊƈT BOE ƉƑƋƈT NFBOJOH UIBU UIF JOUFSHFOFSBUJPOBM DPOUBDU FYUFOET POMZ B
GFX HFOFSBUJPOT CBDL ćF UFNQPSBM QSPYJNJUZ PG BMM PG UIFTF FWFOUT NFBOT UIBU
BMM "NFSJDBOT IBE DMPTF SFMBUJWFT XIP XFSF BMJWF EVSJOH UIFTF LFZ QFSJPET JO IJT
UPSZ 'PS NBOZ "NFSJDBOT MJWJOH JO UIF 64 4PVUI BOE BMTP GPS NBOZ "NFSJDBOT
XIPTF HSBOEQBSFOUT BOE QBSFOUT IBWF TVCTFRVFOUMZ NJHSBUFE UP PUIFS QBSUT PG UIF
DPVOUSZ UIFTF DPOOFDUJPOT GPSHF B DMPTF UFNQPSBM BOE HFOFSBUJPOBM DPOUBDU XJUI
TMBWFSZ BOE JUT BęFSNBUI ćF QBTU UIBU XF DPOTJEFS IFSF TJNQMZ XBT OPU WFSZ MPOH
BHP BOE DFSUBJOMZ OPU XIFO DPNQBSFE UP CSPBEFS FWFOUT JO IVNBO IJTUPSZ
*OEFFE XIJMF NBOZ UIJOHT IBWF DIBOHFE B MBSHF OVNCFS PG UIJOHT IBWF OPU
(SFFOXPPE JO NBOZ XBZT RVJUF MJLF JU EJE JO UIF ƉƑƍƈT BOE ƉƑƎƈT *O UIF DJUZ DFO
UFS UIF GBNPVT MPDBM SFTUBVSBOU -VTDPT IBT CFFO B UPXO NBJOTUBZ SVO CZ UIF TBNF
GBNJMZ TJODF ƉƑƊƉ 6OUJM EFTFHSFHBUJPO JO UIF ƉƑƏƈT UIF SFTUBVSBOU XBT iGPS XIJUFT
POMZw PUIFS SFTUBVSBOUT JO UPXO SFTQPOEFE UP EFTFHSFHBUJPO CZ UVSOJOH JOUP QSJWBUF
iTVQQFS DMVCTw
ćF UPXO TP DBQUVSFT UIF GFFMJOHT PG UIF QSF$JWJM 3JHIUT .PWF
NFOU %FFQ 4PVUI UIBU JU TUFQQFE JO GPS +BDLTPO .JTTJTTJQQJ JO UIF ĕMN ćF )FMQ
B ƊƈƉƉ NPUJPO QJDUVSF BCPVU "GSJDBO"NFSJDBO XPNFO XPSLJOH JO EPNFTUJD FN
QMPZNFOU *O UFSNT PG BO FWFO PMEFS QBTU KVTU PVUTJEF PG UIF DJUZ B WJTJUPS DBO TUJMM
TFF MPOHTUBQMF DPUUPO GBSNT PS TUPQ CZ UIF BCBOEPOFE TIPUHVO TUZMF IPNFT UIBU
IPVTFE UIPVTBOET PG "GSJDBO"NFSJDBO BHSJDVMUVSBM XPSLFST FBSMJFS JO UIF ƊƈUI
DFOUVSZ 8JUIJO UIF DJUZ USBEJUJPOBMMZ XPSLJOHDMBTT BOE TIBSFDSPQQJOH OFJHICPS
IPPET DPOUJOVF UP CF "GSJDBO "NFSJDBO OFJHICPSIPPET OFJHICPSIPPET OPSUI PG
UIF DJUZ DPOUJOVF UP CF XIJUF OFJHICPSIPPET *O QMBDFT MJLF (SFFOXPPE BT JO QMBDFT
UISPVHIPVU UIF #MBDL #FMU UIF SFNOBOUT PG B TFHSFHBUFE QBTU BSF JO QMBJO TJHIU
ćFSF JT BMTP B CSPBEFS QBUUFSO PG SBDJBM WJPMFODF XJUIJO UIF 4PVUIFSO 6OJUFE
4UBUFT (SFFOXPPE GPS FYBNQMF XBT UIF MPDBUJPO PG UIF ƉƑƍƌ LJEOBQQJOH BOE
)08 5)& 1"45 1&34*454
Ƒ
MZODIJOH PG ƉƌZFBS PME &NNFU 5JMM UIF "GSJDBO"NFSJDBO UFFO XIP XBT BMMFHFEMZ
DBVHIU XIJTUMJOH BU B XIJUF XPNBO 5JMMT CPEZ XBT GPVOE JO UIF 5BMMBIBDIJF 3JWFS
XJUI B DPUUPOHJO GBO UJFE BSPVOE IJT GSBNF )JT LJMMFST FWFO BęFS DPOGFTTJOH UP
UIF DSJNF XFSF BDRVJUUFE CZ BO BMMXIJUF KVSZ JO OFBSCZ 5BMMBIBUDIJF $PVOUZ .JT
TJTTJQQJ
"MUIPVHI JOTUBODFT TVDI BT UIFTF IBWF HSFBUMZ EFDSFBTFE JO OVNCFS BOE JO
UIFJS NPOTUSPTJUZ UIFZ IBWF OPU CFFO DPNQMFUFMZ FYUJSQBUFE *O ƊƈƉƍ GPS FYBNQMF
B ZPVOH XIJUF TVQSFNBDJTU TIPU BOE LJMMFE OJOF CMBDL DIVSDIHPFST JO $IBSMFTUPO
4PVUI $BSPMJOB ćF TIPPUFS GSPN OFBSCZ 3JDIMBOE $PVOUZ 4PVUI $BSPMJOB QSPQ
TMBWF JO ƉƐƎƈ ƈƎƈ
IBE XSJUUFO FBSMJFS UIBU IF iDIPTF $IBSMFTUPO CFDBVTF JU JT NPTU
IJTUPSJD DJUZ JO NZ TUBUF BOE BU POF UJNF IBE UIF IJHIFTU SBUJP PG CMBDLT UP 8IJUFT
JO UIF DPVOUSZw
ćF TUBUFNFOU GSPN UIF ƊƈƉƍ $IBSMFTUPO TIPPUFS BMTP JMMVTUSBUFT BOPUIFS OBS
SBUJWF UIBU XF FYQMPSF UISPVHIPVU UIJT CPPL XIJDI JT UIBU JU JT FBTZ GPS "NFSJDBOT
QBSUJDVMBSMZ UIPTF MJWJOH PVUTJEF PG UIF 4PVUI
UP PWFSMPPL JT UIF TIFFS JNQPSUBODF
BOE IJTUPSJDBM QSFWBMFODF PG TMBWFSZBOE JUT TVCTFRVFOU EFNPHSBQIJD MFHBDZ "U
JUT QFBL TIPSUMZ CFGPSF UIF $JWJM 8BS UIF 6OJUFE 4UBUFT IBE BO FOTMBWFE QPQVMBUJPO
PG ƌ NJMMJPO ćJT DPOTUJUVUFE OFBSMZ POFGPVSUI PG UIF FOUJSF QPQVMBUJPO PG UIF 64
4PVUI *O MPPLJOH BU UIF DPVOUSZ BT B XIPMF POF JO FJHIU "NFSJDBOT XFSF FOTMBWFE
*O UFSNT PG XIJUFT JOUFSBDUJPOT XJUI UIF JOTUJUVUJPO UIJT USBOTMBUFE JOUP NPSF UIBO
POF JO GPVS 4PVUIFSO GBNJMJFT IPMEJOH FOTMBWFE QFPQMF BT QSPQFSUZ BOE JO QMBDFT
MJLF .JTTJTTJQQJ UIJT OVNCFS SPTF UP BMNPTU POFIBMG PG 4PVUIFSO GBNJMJFT ćVT
OFBSMZ FWFSZ 4PVUIFSO XIJUF MJWJOH JO UIPTF QBSUT PG UIF TMBWFIPMEJOH 4PVUI FJUIFS
XBT EJSFDUMZ PS JOEJSFDUMZ MJOLFE UP UIF NBJOUFOBODF PG FOTMBWFE MBCPS 0G DPVSTF
UIF JNQBDU PG TMBWFSZ XBT OPU MJNJUFE UP UIF 4PVUIFSO 6OJUFE 4UBUFT .BOZ OPSUI
FSO DJUJFT SFBQFE UIF FDPOPNJD CFOFĕUT PG FOTMBWFE MBCPS JODMVEJOH JO UIF CVJMEJOH
PG SPBET CVJMEJOHT QBSLT BOE VOJWFSTJUJFT -BUFS PO JOEVTUSJBM DFOUFST BDSPTT UIF
/PSUI DJUJFT CFOFĕUFE GSPN UIF DIFBQFS QSPEVDUJPO PG DPUUPO B MBCPSJOUFOTJWF
BOE MVDSBUJWF DSPQ BOE PUIFS MBCPSJOUFOTJWF FYUSBDUFE SFTPVSDFT #VU JU XBT JO UIF
#MBDL #FMU PG UIF "NFSJDBO 4PVUI UIBU UIF JOTUJUVUJPO PG TMBWFSZ XBT UIF NPTU ĕSNMZ
FNCFEEFE BOE IBE JUT GVSUIFTU SFBDI
ćF JNQBDU PG TMBWFSZ PO UIF 4PVUIFSO FDPOPNZ BOE PO 4PVUIFSO QPMJUJDT IBSEMZ
FOEFE PODF UIF $JWJM 8BS XBT PWFS JO ƉƐƎƍ ćF CSJFG PQUJNJTN PG SBDJBM QSPHSFT
TJWFT EVSJOH UIF QFSJPE PG 3FDPOTUSVDUJPO ƉƐƎƍoƉƐƏƏ
TVDDVNCFE UP UIF 4PVUIFSO
3FEFNQUJPO GPMMPXJOH UIF $PNQSPNJTF PG ƉƐƏƏ BOE UIF TJHOJĕDBOU XJUIESBXBM PG
GFEFSBM JOWPMWFNFOU GSPN 4PVUIFSO QPMJUJDT 4PVUIFSO XIJUF FMJUFT DPOTPMJEBUFE
BOE SFHSPVQFE QPMJUJDBMMZ GPSHJOH OFX BMMJBODFT XJUI XIJUFT XIP IBE QSFWJPVTMZ
TVQQPSUFE GFEFSBM JOUFSWFOUJPO ćF QMBZFS MFę PVU PG UIJT OFX QPXFS EZOBNJD XBT
UIF CMBDL GSFFENBO XIP IBE MJNJUFE JOEFQFOEFOU QPMJUJDBM PS FDPOPNJD QPXFS *O
Ɖƈ
$)"15&3 ƫ */530%6$5*0/
UIF BCTFODF PG GFEFSBM HPWFSONFOU JOUFSWFOUJPO 4PVUIFSO XIJUFT NPWFE UPXBSE
B TZTUFN UIBU MPPLFE USFNFOEPVTMZ TJNJMBS UP TMBWFSZ CVU TUPQQFE MFHBMMZ TIPSU PG
WJPMBUJOH UIF ƉƋUI ƉƌUI BOE ƉƍUI "NFOENFOUT UP UIF 64 $POTUJUVUJPOBU MFBTU
BT JOUFSQSFUFE CZ 4PVUIFSO KVEHFT BOE CZ UIF 64 4VQSFNF $PVSU 7BMFMMZ Ɗƈƈƌ
ćSPVHIPVU UIF GPSNFS $POGFEFSBDZ B XBWF PG BOUJCMBDL MBXT NBEF JU EJďDVMU
JG OPU JNQPTTJCMF GPS "GSJDBO "NFSJDBOT UP QVMM UIFNTFMWFT VQ PVU PG QPWFSUZ BOE
FDPOPNJD EFQFOEFODZ ćFZ NBEF JU EJďDVMU GPS CMBDLT UP WPUF IPME KPCT USBWFM
GSFFMZ PS HBJO BDDFTT UP FEVDBUJPO 7BHSBODZ MBXT NBEF JU JMMFHBM UP CF VOFNQMPZFE
BOE UFOEFE UP CF UBSHFUFE BU CMBDLT BOUJFOUJDFNFOU MBXT NBEF JU JMMFHBM GPS XIJUFT
UP USZ UP SFDSVJU CMBDL XPSLFST GSPN PUIFS XIJUF NFOT MBOET 5PHFUIFS UIFTF MBXT
BOE QSBDUJDFT GPSNFE B OFUXPSL UIBU TUSPOHMZ MJNJUFE UIF BCJMJUZ PG GSFFE GPSNFS
TMBWFT UP CFDPNF FDPOPNJDBMMZ JOEFQFOEFOU BOE UP FYFSDJTF QPMJUJDBM SJHIUT *O UIJT
XBZ UIF JOTUJUVUJPO PG TMBWFSZ USBOTGPSNFE XJUIJO B QFSJPE PG Ƌƈ ZFBST JOUP B TZT
UFN PG XJEFTQSFBE TFHSFHBUJPO BOE TVCKVHBUJPOEJČFSFOU JO GPSN CVU JO NBOZ
SFTQFDUT KVTU BT EFWBTUBUJOH "T UIF IJTUPSJBO $ 7BOO 8PPEXBSE XSPUF i<V>OEFS
TMBWFSZ DPOUSPM XBT CFTU NBJOUBJOFE CZ B MBSHF EFHSFF PG QIZTJDBM DPOUBDU BOE BTTP
DJBUJPOw CVU UIF iUFNQPSBSZ BOBSDIZ UIBU GPMMPXFE UIF DPMMBQTF PG UIF PME EJTDJQMJOF
QSPEVDFE B TUBUF PG NJOE CPSEFSJOH PO IZTUFSJB BNPOH 4PVUIFSO XIJUF QFPQMFw QQ
ƊƊoƊƋ 8PPEXBSE ƊƈƈƊ <ƉƑƍƍ>
7JPMFODF TFHSFHBUJPO BOE DPNQMFUF EJTFOGSBO
DIJTFNFOU TPPO GPMMPXFE
#Z UIF FBSMZ ƊƈUI DFOUVSZ TMBWFSZ IBE USBOTGPSNFE JOUP B TZTUFN LOPXO BT
+JN $SPX B UJNF QFSJPE GSFTI JO UIF NJOET PG NBOZ "NFSJDBOT CPSO UISPVHI UIF
ƉƑƌƈT ƉƑƍƈT BOE FWFO ƉƑƎƈT 8SJUJOH JO UIF ƉƑƌƈT UIF 4XFEJTI TPDJPMPHJTU (VO
OBS .ZSEBM PCTFSWFE UIBU iUIF IJTUPSJDBM USBEJUJPO UISPVHI TMBWFSZ $JWJM 8BS 3F
DPOTUSVDUJPO BOE 3FTUPSBUJPOyUJFT UPHFUIFS UIF KVEHNFOUT PO UIF 4PVUI BOE PO
UIF /FHSPw 0CTFSWJOH UIF SFBDUJPOT PG XIJUF 4PVUIFSOFST IF XSPUF iB GSJFOEMZ
BUUJUVEF UPXBSE UIF 4PVUI DBSSJFT XJUI JU VOGBWPSBCMF WJFXT UPXBSE /FHSPFT PS BU
MFBTU B UFOEFODZ UP NJOJNJ[F UIF GBDU UIBU UIFZ BSF B TVCTUBOUJBM QSPQPSUJPO PG UIF
4PVUIT QFPQMF $POWFSTFMZ B TZNQBUIFUJD BUUJUVEF UPXBSE /FHSPFT UIFJS TIPSU
DPNJOHT UIFJS HSJFWBODFT BOE UIFJS QSPCMFNT BOE FTQFDJBMMZ UIF BUUFNQU UP FY
QMBJO UIFN PO BOZ CBTJT PUIFS UIBO SBDJBM JOGFSJPSJUZ XJMM CF UBLFO BT B DSJUJDJTN PG
UIF TPDJBM BOE NPSBM PSEFS PG UIF 4PVUIw QQ ƉƈƋƏ .ZSEBM ƉƑƌƌ
.PTU "NFSJDBOT
XIP XFSF BMJWF EVSJOH UIJT UJNF QFSJPE SFDPHOJ[F UIF TIPDLJOH SBDJTN BOE SBDJBM
IPTUJMJUZ UIBU DIBSBDUFSJ[FE NBOZ CMBDLXIJUF JOUFSBDUJPOT EVSJOH UIJT UJNF QFSJPE
-PPLJOH BU UIF 4PVUIFSO #MBDL #FMU UIF WFTUJHFT PG TMBWFSZ PG 3FDPOTUSVDUJPO
BOE PG +JN $SPX BSF TUJMM WJTJCMF JO QMBDFT MJLF -FĘPSF $PVOUZ .JTTJTTJQQJ BOE #BS
CPVS $PVOUZ "MBCBNB $PUUPO FOUSFQSFOFVST XFSF ESBXO UP UIFTF QMBDFT GPS UIF
MBOE XIJDI QSPWJEFE FYDFMMFOU HSPXJOH DPOEJUJPOT GPS UIF DVMUJWBUJPO PG DPUUPO
)*4503*$"- 1&34*45&/$& */ "55*56%&4 */45*565*0/"- 1"5)
%&1&/%&/$& "/% #&)"7*03"- 1"5) %&1&/%&/$&
ƉƉ
0WFS B QFSJPE PG UJNF JO UIF FBSMZ ƉƐƈƈT UIFZ GPSDFE UIF NPWFNFOU PG UIPVTBOET
PG FOTMBWFE QFPQMF GSPN UIF 6QQFS 4PVUI JOUP UIF %FFQ 4PVUI QBSUT PG UIF .JTTJT
TJQQJ %FMUB BOE #MBDL #FMU DPVOUJFT JO -PVJTJBOB .JTTJTTJQQJ BOE "MBCBNB .BOZ
PG UIFTF FOTMBWFE QFPQMF MJWFE PO SVSBM QMBOUBUJPOT CVU BęFS FNBODJQBUJPO UIPV
TBOET NPWFE UP TIPUHVO TUZMF EXFMMJOHT PO UIF PVUTLJSUT PG UPXOT MJLF (SFFOXPPE
*O UJNF GPSDFE EFTFHSFHBUJPO BOE UIF FČPSUT PG UIF $JWJM 3JHIUT .PWFNFOU BMMFWJ
BUFE TPNF JOFRVBMJUJFT CFUXFFO CMBDLT BOE XIJUFT CVU VMUJNBUFMZ GBJMFE JO SFEVDJOH
NBOZ SBDJBM EJWJTJPOT ćJT IJTUPSZ JT MJWJOH GPS UIF MBSHF OVNCFS PG XIJUFT BOE
"GSJDBO"NFSJDBOT XIP QBSUJDJQBUFE JO UIF $JWJM 3JHIUT .PWFNFOU *U JT OPU IBSE
UP TFF UIF UISFBET UIBU XFBWF UISPVHI UIF PWFSMBQQJOH HFOFSBUJPOT PG 4PVUIFSOFST
BOE CJOE UIF QBTU UP UIF QSFTFOU
)JTUPSJDBM 1FSTJTUFODF JO "UUJUVEFT *OTUJUVUJPOBM 1BUI
%FQFOEFODF BOE #FIBWJPSBM 1BUI %FQFOEFODF
ćF SJDI IJTUPSZ PG UIF 4PVUI QPJOUT UP UIF QPTTJCJMJUZ PG B SFNBSLBCMF IJTUPSJDBM
QFSTJTUFODF JO UIF QPMJUJDT PG UIFTF BSFBT ćJT NJHIU CF PCWJPVT MPPLJOH BU IJHIMZ
TFHSFHBUFE BOE FDPOPNJDBMMZ TUSVHHMJOH QMBDFT MJLF (SFFOXPPE .JTTJTTJQQJ BOE
&VGBMB "MBCBNB BOE XIFO DPOTJEFSJOH KVTU IPX TIPSU UIF UJNF IBT CFFO TJODF UIF
FOE PG TMBWFSZ )PXFWFS UP VOEFSTUBOE UIJT QFSTJTUFODF XF NVTU VOEFSTUBOE XIZ
BOE IPX UIF FDPOPNJD HFPHSBQIZ PG UIF ƉƑUI DFOUVSZ MFE JO QBSU UP UIF QPMJUJDBM
HFPHSBQIZ PG UPEBZ 5P EP UIJT XF XJMM CVJME BO BSHVNFOU UISPVHIPVU UIF CPPL
UIBU JT SPPUFE JO UIF IJTUPSJDBM EFWFMPQNFOU PG UIF 4PVUI
"T IJTUPSJBOT IBWF BSHVFE TMBWFSZ DSFBUFE BO FOUJSF XBZ PG MJGF UIBU XBT VUUFSMZ
BOE DPNQMFUFMZ EFQFOEFOU PO UIF QSPWJTJPO PG DIFBQ MBCPS 8IFO UIJT XBT GPSDJCMZ
SFNPWFE CZ UIF UISFBU PG XBS BOE FNBODJQBUJPO 4PVUIFSO XIJUFT XIP XFSF IFBW
JMZ SFMJBOU PO UIF JOTUJUVUJPO PG TMBWFSZ MPPLFE GPS PUIFS XBZT CZ XIJDI UP NBJOUBJO
BOE QSPUFDU UIF TPDJBM PSEFS %FQFOEJOH PO IPX SFMJBOU BO BSFB XBT PO CMBDL MB
CPS UIJT NFBOU UVSOJOH UP JOGPSNBM BOE MPDBM JOTUJUVUJPOT UP SFJHO JO OFXMZ FNBO
DJQBUFE CMBDL XPSLFST BOE QPUFOUJBM CMBDL WPUFST "ęFS BMM JG CMBDL XPSLFST MFę
UIFSF XPVME CF OP POF UP DVMUJWBUF MBOET NBJOUBJO JOGSBTUSVDUVSF CVJME SPBET BOE
SBJMXBZT PQFSBUF OFXMZ QSPĕUBCMF NJOJOH BOE UJNCFS QSPEVDUJPO BOE QSPWJEF EP
NFTUJD MBCPS "OE JG CMBDLT DPVME GSFFMZ WPUF UIFO UIF FOUJSF QPMJUJDBM TZTUFN PG UIF
4PVUIPOF CVJMU PO XIJUF EPNJOBODFXPVME CF UISPXO JOUP UVNVMU ćF FOUJSF
XBZ PG 4PVUIFSO MJWJOH XPVME JO B TFOTF CF VQFOEFE
ćF JOTUJUVUJPOT UIBU DBNF PVU PG TMBWFSZ BSF KVTU QBSU PG UIF TUPSZ IPXFWFS
ƉƊ
$)"15&3 ƫ */530%6$5*0/
'PS 4PVUIFSO XIJUFT DVMUVSBM JOTUJUVUJPOT BOE JOGPSNBM OPSNT SFJOGPSDFE EJČFSJOH
QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFTGPS TPNF SFJOGPSDJOH UIF JEFB UIBU CMBDLT XFSF TPNFIPX JOGF
SJPS MFTT EFTFSWJOH BOE NPSF XPSUIZ PG UIJT LJOE PG TVCKVHBUJPO ćFTF SFJOGPSDFE
BUUJUVEFT XFSF B OFDFTTBSZ DPNQBOJPO UP UIF MBXT BOE DVTUPNT UIBU JNQMFNFOUFE
UIFTF JEFBT JG XIJUFT USVMZ CFMJFWFE UIBU CMBDLT XFSF JOGFSJPS UIFO JU XPVME CF FBT
JFS UP JOĘJDU FDPOPNJD IBSETIJQ SBDJBM WJPMFODF BOE UIF EFOJBM PG CMBDLT QPMJUJDBM
SJHIUTBOE BMM PG UIFTF UIJOHT XFSF OFDFTTBSZ GPS XIJUFT UP NBJOUBJO UIFJS QPMJUJ
DBM BOE FDPOPNJD QPTJUJPOT ćJT PQFSBUFE JO UBOEFN XJUI JOGPSNBM BOE TPDJBMMZ
SPPUFE PSHBOJ[BUJPOT MJLF UIF ,V ,MVY ,MBO BOE PUIFS JOGPSNBM OFUXPSLT ćF HPBM
XBT UIF TBNF BT XJUI UIF GPSNBM JOTUJUVUJPOT UP LFFQ CMBDLT JO B TVCKVHBUFE QP
TJUJPO FDPOPNJDBMMZ BOE QPMJUJDBMMZ ćF OFU FČFDU PG UIJT XIJUF iIZTUFSJBw UP VTF
UIF QISBTF GSPN 8PPEXBSE
JT UIBU XIJUFT iEVH JOw DSFBUJOH BO FOWJSPONFOU UIBU
SFJOGPSDFE DVMUVSBMMZ TPDJBMMZ BOE QPMJUJDBMMZ UIF JEFB UIBU CMBDLT XFSF SBDJBMMZ JO
GFSJPS "T XF TIBMM TFF CFMPX UIJT XBT QBSUJDVMBSMZ UIF DBTF BNPOH UIPTF XIP IBE
UIF NPTU UP MPTFUIBU JT UIPTF XIJUFT MJWJOH JO UIF #MBDL #FMU
ćFTF JEFBT QPJOU UP UIF OPUJPO UIBU UIFSF BSF DIBOOFMT PG QFSTJTUFODF UIBU PQ
FSBUF WJB QBUI EFQFOEFODF ćJT QBUI EFQFOEFODF BT XF EJTDVTT UISPVHIPVU UIJT
CPPL DBO UBLF PO UXP GPSNT ćF ĕSTU JT UISPVHI JOTUJUVUJPOBM QBUI EFQFOEFODF BO
JEFB UIBU IBT CFFO EFWFMPQFE WJB TFWFSBM TDIPMBSMZ MJUFSBUVSFT FH 1JFSTPO Ɗƈƈƌ
ćJT UZQF PG QBUI EFQFOEFODF QPTJUT UIBU JOTUJUVUJPOT CFDPNF TFMGSFJOGPSDJOH
PODF XF TUBSU EPXO B QBUI JU CFDPNFT IBSEFS BOE IBSEFS UP FYUSBDU PVSTFMWFT GSPN
UIBU QBUI *O UIF #MBDL #FMU 4PVUI GPS JOTUBODF MPDBM HPWFSONFOUT UP UIF FYUFOU
UIFZ DPVME QBSUJDJQBUFE BOE TBODUJPOFE UIF FOGPSDFNFOU PG BOUJCMBDL MBXT UIF MP
DBMJ[FE CMBDL DPEFT HBWF XBZ UP TUBUFTBODUJPOFE +JN $SPX MBXT QVU JOUP QMBDF CZ
OVNFSPVT TUBUF DPOTUJUVUJPOT UIBU XFSF FOBDUFE BU UIF UVSO PG UIF ƊƈUI DFOUVSZ *O
UVSO BT NBOZ IBWF BSHVFE +JN $SPX MBXT IBWF HJWFO XBZ UP JODSFBTFE JODBSDFSB
UJPO SBUFT JODSFBTFE SBEJDBMJ[FE WJPMFODF BOE MBXT UIBU BSF PUIFSXJTF VOGBWPSBCMF
UP "GSJDBO "NFSJDBOT "T UIFTF JOTUJUVUJPOT HBJOFE IPME JO UIF 4PVUI SFWFSTJOH
UIFN BOE GVMMZ JOUFHSBUJOH CMBDLT JOUP TPDJFUZ CFDBNF JODSFBTJOHMZ EJďDVMU BOE UIF
JOTUJUVUJPOT CFDBNF NPSF JNQPSUBOU UP 4PVUIFSO XIJUFT 0G DPVSTF BOZ QBUI DBO
CF EJTSVQUFE BOE UIFTF JOTUJUVUJPOT FWFOUVBMMZ SBO VQ BHBJOTU UIF UIF $JWJM 3JHIUT
.PWFNFOU UIF $JWJM 3JHIUT "DU PG ƉƑƎƌ BOE UIF 7PUJOH 3JHIUT "DU PG ƉƑƎƍ ćFTF
MBXT XFSF IVHFMZ FČFDUJWF JO BEESFTTJOH SBDJBM JOFRVBMJUJFT QBSUJDVMBSMZ XJUI SFHBSE
UP FDPOPNJD JOEJDBUPST BOE TDIPPMJOH IPXFWFS BT XF TIPX CFMPX UIF WFTUJHFT PG
TMBWFSFMBUFE JOTUJUVUJPOT PO DPOUFNQPSBSZ QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT DBO TUJMM CF GFMU BDSPTT
NBOZ QBSUT PG UIF 4PVUI
)*4503*$"- 1&34*45&/$& */ "55*56%&4 */45*565*0/"- 1"5)
%&1&/%&/$& "/% #&)"7*03"- 1"5) %&1&/%&/$&
ƉƋ
#FIBWJPSBM 1BUI %FQFOEFODF
#VU UIFSF JT B TFDPOE LJOE PG QBUI EFQFOEFODF BU XPSL IFSF +VTU MJLF JOTUJUVUJPOBM
QBUI EFQFOEFODF JEFBT OPSNT BOE CFIBWJPST DBO CF QBTTFE EPXO BT XFMM BOE
UIFZ JOUFSBDU XJUI JOTUJUVUJPOT SFJOGPSDJOH FBDI PUIFS PWFS UJNF 8F DBMM UIJT JEFB
CFIBWJPSBM QBUI EFQFOEFODF ćBU JT TJNJMBS UP SFMJHJPO BOE MBOHVBHF BUUJUVEFT
JODMVEJOH QPMJUJDBM BOE SBDJBM BUUJUVEFTBSF QBTTFE EPXO GSPN HFOFSBUJPO UP HFO
FSBUJPO GPTUFSFE BOE FODPVSBHFE CZ GBNJMJFT BOE MPDBM JOTUJUVUJPOT TVDI BT TDIPPMT
BOE DIVSDIFT ćFTF JOTUJUVUJPOT BMPOH XJUI GBNJMZ NFNCFST FOTVSF UIBU UIF DVM
UVSBM OPSNT WBMVFT BOE BUUJUVEFT BSF SFDSFBUFE JO UIF OFYU HFOFSBUJPO "T TVDI
CFIBWJPSBM QBUI EFQFOEFODF EPFT OPU FYDMVEF JOTUJUVUJPOBM DIBOOFMT PG SFJOGPSDF
NFOU PWFS UJNF SBUIFS JU JODPSQPSBUFT JOTUJUVUJPOT BOE CFIBWJPS CZ FNQIBTJ[JOH
UIF JOUFSQMBZ CFUXFFO UIFN BOE UIF SFJOGPSDFNFOU NFDIBOJTNT UIBU TUSFOHUIFO
FBDI "MM PG UIJT JT OPU UP TBZ UIBU QFPQMF EPOU DIBOHF UIFZ EP $IJMESFO DIBOHF
UIFZ HSPX VQ BOE UIFZ NBSSZ CVUKVTU MJLF SFMJHJPOQPMJUJDT JT B DVMUVSBMMZ JO
HSBJOFE RVBMJUZ UIBU FYUFOET BDSPTT NVMUJQMF HFOFSBUJPOT BOE DIBOHFT POMZ TMPXMZ
BOE JO SFTQPOTF UP TJHOJĕDBOU MJGF FWFOUT (SFFO 1BMNRVJTU BOE 4DIJDLMFS ƊƈƈƊ
"U JUT DPSF CFIBWJPSBM QBUI EFQFOEFODF TVHHFTUT UIBU UIF QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT PG
B QMBDF DBO BDUVBMMZ MBTU B MPOH UJNF OVSUVSFE CZ CPUI JOTUJUVUJPOT BOE MBXT BOE
BMTP CZ GBNJMJFT BOE DPNNVOJUJFT ćJT JEFB PG QBUI EFQFOEFODF JO QPMJUJDT NPSF
CSPBEMZ TVHHFTUT UIBU TJHOJĕDBOU IJTUPSJDBM GPSDFT BOE UIF BUUFOEBOU QPMJUJDBM FDP
OPNJD BOE QPMJUJDBM JODFOUJWFT UIBU UIFZ DSFBUF DBO DSFBUF QBUUFSOT UIBU DBSSZ EPXO
GPS HFOFSBUJPOT PWFS UJNFBOE UIFTF QBUUFSOT DBO PVUMBTU UIF PSJHJOBM JOTUJUVUJPOT
BOE JODFOUJWFT 'PS FYBNQMF MPPLJOH BU (SFFOXPPE B QPTTJCMF FYQMBOBUJPO JT UIBU
JUT IJTUPSZ PG TMBWFSZ BOE JUT TVCTFRVFOU SFMJBODF PO CMBDL MBCPS IBT DPOUSJCVUFE UP
UIF EFWFMPQNFOU PG NPSF DPOTFSWBUJWF QPMJUJDBM BOE SBDJBM BUUJUVEFT BNPOH XIJUFT
8F UIJOLBOE XF XJMM TIPX JO UIJT CPPLUIBU UIFTF BUUJUVEFT IBWF QFSTJTUFE PWFS
UIF DPVSTF PG UIF ƊƈUI DFOUVSZ ćVT XIJUFT MJWJOH JO (SFFOXPPE BOE JO PUIFS
QBSUT PG UIF 4PVUIFSO #MBDL #FMU BSF NPSF DPOTFSWBUJWF UPEBZ UIBO BSF XIJUFT MJWJOH
FMTFXIFSF FWFO UIPVHI UIPTF JOTUJUVUJPOT UIBU JOJUJBMMZ TQVSSFE PO UIFTF BUUJUVEFT
TMBWFSZ TIBSFDSPQQJOH EJTFOGSBODIJTFNFOUBSF OP MPOHFS JO FYJTUFODF
)PX #FIBWJPSBM 1BUI %FQFOEFODF *T %JČFSFOU GSPN 0UIFS
"QQSPBDIFT
-PPLJOH BDSPTT UIF 64 4PVUI UIF QBUI EFQFOEFODF PG QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT TVHHFTUT
UIBU TPNF QBSU PG UIF WBSJBUJPO JO QPMJUJDBM BOE TQFDJĕDBMMZ SBDJBM BUUJUVEFT UIBU XF
TFF UPEBZ JO UIF 64 4PVUI BSF GVOEBNFOUBMMZ SFMBUFE UP FWFOUT UIBU IBQQFOFE JO
Ɖƌ
$)"15&3 ƫ */530%6$5*0/
UIF EJTUBODF QBTU ćJT JT B CSFBL GSPN XIBU SFTFBSDI JO QPMJUJDBM TDJFODF BOE TQFDJG
JDBMMZ PO QVCMJD PQJOJPO 0G DPVSTF UIF RVFTUJPOT PG IPX "NFSJDBOT GPSNVMBUF
UIFJS QPMJUJDBM CFMJFGT BSF OPU OFX %VSJOH FBDI FMFDUJPO DZDMF UFBNT PG KPVSOBMJTUT
QVOEJUT BOE TDIPMBST TFU PVU UP VOEFSTUBOE XIZ DFSUBJO QMBDFT WPUF UIF XBZ UIFZ
EP BOE XIBU UIJT NFBOT GPS OBUJPOBM BOE TUBUF FMFDUPSBM NBQT )PXFWFS NPTU PG
UIFTF QSFEJDUJPOT BOE BOBMZTFT IJOHF PO DPOUFNQPSBSZ GBDUPST 'PS FYBNQMF XIBU
JT BO BSFBT MFWFM PG VOFNQMPZNFOU 8IBU JT JUT BWFSBHF JODPNF 8IBU JT UIF SBDJBM
HFOEFS BOE BHF DPNQPTJUJPO PG B QBSUJDVMBS DJUZ 8IP XPO JO UIF MBTU FMFDUJPO BOE
CZ IPX NVDI 1FSIBQT UIF NPSF TPQIJTUJDBUFE JORVJSJFT VTF TVSWFZ EBUB UP NBLF
QSFEJDUJPOT BCPVU QPMJUJDBM PVUDPNFT 'PS FYBNQMF XF LOPX UIBU XFBMUIJFS QFP
QMF UFOE UP CF NPSF DPOTFSWBUJWF TP XIBU JT B QFSTPOT JODPNF &NQMPZNFOU PS
NBSJUBM TUBUVT 3BDF PS HFOEFS ćFTF TPSUT PG DPOUFNQPSBSZ FDPOPNJD BOE QPMJU
JDBM GBDUPST BOE UIFTF TPSUT PG JOEJWJEVBM DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT DBO UFMM VT B MPU BCPVU UIF
QPMJUJDBM MFBOJOHT PG B QMBDF
ćJT BQQSPBDI JT JO DPOUSBTU XJUI XIBU XF EP JO UIJT CPPL 'PS FYBNQMF DBN
QBJHO TUSBUFHJTUT QPMJUJDBM TDJFOUJTUT BOE KPVSOBMJTUT BSF WFSZ DPODFSOFE XJUI XIBU
JU UBLFT UP DIBOHF QFPQMFT NJOET $BNQBJHOT IBWF TQFOU NJMMJPOT PG EPMMBST BOE
NPCJMJ[FE DPVOUMFTT WPMVOUFFS IPVST USZJOH UP NPCJMJ[F WPUFST USZJOH UP QSFEJDU
UIFJS CFIBWJPS BOE BTTFTTJOH XIBU LJOET PG BQQFBMT XPSL BOE XIBU EPOU /VNFS
PVT TUVEJFT IBWF MPPLFE BU UIF TBNF RVFTUJPOT USZJOH UP VTF SBOEPNJ[FE DPOUSPMMFE
USJBMT UP BTTFTT UIF NPTU FČFDUJWF TPSUT PG NBJMFST UFMFQIPOF TPMJDJUBUJPOT PS SPCP
DBMMT
BOE JOQFSTPO TPMJDJUBUJPOT ćF SFTVMU PG BMM PG UIJT *O UFSNT PG JODSFBTJOH
WPUFS UVSOPVU UIF NPTU QPXFSGVM LOPXO JOUFSWFOUJPOT IBWF NBOBHFE UP JODSFBTF
WPUFS UVSOPVU CZ BSPVOE OJOF QFSDFOUBHF QPJOUT (FSCFS BOE (SFFO Ɗƈƈƈ (FSCFS
(SFFO BOE -BSJNFS ƊƈƈƐ
*O UFSNT PG DIBOHJOH QFPQMFT NJOET UIF NPTU JNQBDU
GVM TUVEZB TUVEZ PO XIFUIFS HBZ DBOWBTTFST DPVME DIBOHF QFPQMFT NJOET BCPVU
HBZ NBSSJBHFTIPXFE B MBSHF JNQBDU CVU XBT MBUFS QSPWFE UP CF GSBVEVMFOU -B
$PVS BOE (SFFO ƊƈƉƌ
ćF CVML PG UIJT SFTFBSDI JNQMJFT UIBU MBSHF DIBOHFT JO UIF
QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT BOE CFIBWJPST PG "NFSJDBOT BSF CPUI SBSF BOE DPTUMZ
ćFTF TUVEJFT BSF JNQPSUBOU FTQFDJBMMZ TP HJWFO UPEBZT QPMJUJDBM DMJNBUF )PX
FWFS XF BSF OPU TVSQSJTFE CZ FJUIFS UIF MBDL PG ĕOEJOHT PS JG UIFSF BSF ĕOEJOHT
ĕOEJOHT UIBU BSF TP TVCTUBOUJWFMZ TNBMM .BJMFST QIPOF DBMMT PS WPMVOUFFS DBO
WBTTFST XPVMEOU TJHOJĕDBOUMZ BMUFS UIF FČFDUT PG B DFOUVSZ BOE B IBMG PG IJTUPSZ JO
QMBDFT MJLF (SFFOXPPE .JTTJTTJQQJ PS "TIFWJMMF /PSUI $BSPMJOB "OE JU DFSUBJOMZ
XPVMEOU BČFDU IJTUPSZT SPMF JO TIBQJOH BUUJUVEFT PO MPOHTUBOEJOH RVFTUJPOT PO
SBDF SFMBUJPOT BďSNBUJWF BDUJPO PS WPUJOH SJHIUT 8F EP UIJOL BT XF XJMM TFF MBUFS
JO UIJT CPPL UIBU JNQPSUBOU JOUFSWFOUJPOT UISPVHIPVU UIF ƊƈUI DFOUVSZJODMVEJOH
UIF NBTT NPCJMJ[BUJPO PG UIPVTBOET PG "GSJDBO "NFSJDBOT EVSJOH UIF DPVSTF PG UIF
063 "3(6.&/5
Ɖƍ
$JWJM 3JHIUT .PWFNFOUIBWF IBE QPXFSGVM FČFDUT PO BUUFOVBUJOH JOTUJUVUJPOBM
PVUDPNFT BOE BMTP UIF FYQSFTTJPO PG SBDJBM IPTUJMJUZ PWFS UJNF )PXFWFS BU UIF
SPPU PG PVS BSHVNFOU JT UIF JEFB UIBU CFIBWJPSBM QBUI EFQFOEFODF NFBOT UIBU BUUJ
UVEFT DIBOHF RVJUF TMPXMZ $PVOUJFT MJLF -FĘPSF $PVOUZ .JTTJTTJQQJ PS #BSCPVS
$PVOUZ "MBCBNB BSF QMBDFT XJUI Ɖƍƈ ZFBST PG UFOTF SBDF SFMBUJPOT BOE B SFTQFD
UJWF XIJUF EPNJOBODF PWFS B TVCKVHBUFE "GSJDBO "NFSJDBO QPQVMBUJPO ćFTF IBWF
TQVSSFE PO DFSUBJO LJOET PG QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT "OE UIFTF IBWF CFFO SPPUFE JO UIF
IJTUPSJDBM GPSDFT UIBU TIBQFE UIFTF BSFBT *O PUIFS XPSET DPOUFNQPSBSZ GBDUPST DBO
POMZ UBLF VT TP GBS JO FYQMBJOJOH UIF HVMG CFUXFFO QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT JO UIF .JTTJT
TJQQJ %FMUB BOE QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT JO PUIFS QBSUT PG UIF 4PVUI
0VS "SHVNFOU
*OTUFBE XF UIJOL UIBU UIF QBUI EFQFOEFODF PG QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT JT B NPSF MJLFMZ
FYQMBOBUPSZ NFDIBOJTN #FDBVTF PG UIBU BMUIPVHI UIJT JT OPU B IJTUPSZ CPPL XF
UBLF "MFYJT %F 5PDRVFWJMMF (VOOBS .ZSEBM BOE 8&# %V #PJT BT PVS FYBNQMFT
BOE ESBX PVS FYQMBOBUJPO GPS 4PVUIFSO BUUJUVEFT PO SBDFBOE CZ FYUFOTJPO BUUJ
UVEFT PO QPMJUJDTGSPN UIF 4PVUIT EJTUJODUJWF SBDJBM QBTU ćJT XBT B QBTU TPMJEMZ
HSPVOEFE JO UIF FDPOPNJD BOE QPMJUJDBM JNQPSUBODF PG TMBWFSZ BOE PODF JU XBT
BCPMJTIFE UIF JOTUJUVUJPOBM BOE DVMUVSBM GFBUVSFT PG UIF +JN $SPX FSB -JLF .ZSEBM
XF CFMJFWF UIFTF IJTUPSJDBM GPSDFT TIBQF UIF SBDJBM PSEFS PG UIF 4PVUI BT XFMM BT
UIF XBZ UIBU 4PVUIFSOFST UIJOL BCPVU SBDF QPMJUJDT BOE QPMJDZ *O PUIFS XPSET
"NFSJDBOT QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT BSF JO QBSU B EJSFDU DPOTFRVFODF PG HFOFSBUJPOT PG
JEFBT UIBU IBWF CFFO DPMMFDUJWFMZ QBTTFE EPXO PWFS UJNF WJB JOTUJUVUJPOT TVDI BT
TDIPPMT BOE DIVSDIFT BOE BMTP EJSFDUMZ GSPN QBSFOUT BOE HSBOEQBSFOUTUIBU JT
WJB CFIBWJPSBM QBUI EFQFOEFODF 0VS IPQF JT UIFSFGPSF UIBU XF QVTI PVS DPMMFD
UJWF VOEFSTUBOEJOH PG XIBU TIBQFT BOE GPSNT DPOUFNQPSBSZ QPMJUJDBM PQJOJPO BOE
DPOUFNQPSBSZ QPMJUJDBM CFIBWJPS GVSUIFS CFZPOE DPOUFNQPSBSZ GBDUPST 8F BMTP
IPQF UIBU JO TP EPJOH UP EFWFMPQ UIF JEFB UIBU PVS QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT UPEBZ BSF JO
UJNBUFMZ JOUFSUXJOFE XJUI BOE TIBQFE CZ UIPTF QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT PG PVS QBSFOUT
BOE HSBOEQBSFOUT OVSUVSFE CZ IJTUPSJDBM JOTUJUVUJPOT BOE CZ JOUFSHFOFSBUJPOBM TP
DJBMJ[BUJPO
"T XF XJMM EJTDVTT UISPVHIPVU UIJT CPPL WJFXJOH DPOUFNQPSBSZ QPMJUJDBM BUUJ
UVEFT BT EFWFMPQJOH BOE CFJOH TVTUBJOFE PWFS UJNF BOE BDSPTT HFOFSBUJPOT SFQSF
TFOUT B OFX XBZ PG UIJOLJOH ćJT BDDPVOU GPDVTFT OPU PO DPOUFNQPSBSZ GBDUPST UIF
TUVEZ PG XIJDI DBO POMZ HFU VT TP GBS JO VOEFSTUBOEJOH UIF EFFQ QFSTJTUFODF PG QP
MJUJDBM DMFBWBHFT *OTUFBE XF TUBSU XJUI UIF QFSIBQT SBEJDBM QSPQPTJUJPO UIBU XIFSF
ƉƎ
$)"15&3 ƫ */530%6$5*0/
QFPQMF MJWF XIP UIFJS GBNJMJFT BSF BOE XIFSF UIFZ HSPX VQ BMM DPMMFDUJWFMZ IBWF B TJH
OJĕDBOU SPMF UP QMBZ JO UIF PO UIF LJOET PG QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT UIFZ FYQSFTT BT BEVMUT
ćBU JT EFFQ QPMJUJDBM QSFEJTQPTJUJPOT BOE TPDJBM BUUJUVEFT BSF JO QBSU UIF QSPEVDU
PG IJTUPSJDBM GPSDFT UIBU TVCTFRVFOUMZ DSFBUF BOE ESJWF UIF JOUFSHFOFSBUJPOBM USBOT
NJTTJPO PG BUUJUVEFT OPSNT BOE QSFGFSFODFT 1VU TJNQMZ NBOZ PG PVS BUUJUVEFT
JODMVEJOH BUUJUVEFT PO QPMJUJDTBSF TIBQFE CZ PVS GBNJMJFT CZ PVS IJTUPSZ BOE CZ
PVS FOWJSPONFOUT BOE UIFTF BUUJUVEFT BSF QBTTFE EPXO PWFS UJNF BOE UISPVHI HFO
FSBUJPOT SFJOGPSDFE CZ CFIBWJPSBM QBUI EFQFOEFODF 'PS UIBU SFBTPO XF UIJOL UIBU
MPPLJOH BU UIF IJTUPSZ PG QMBDFT MJLF (SFFOXPPE .JTTJTTJQQJ JT WFSZ JNQPSUBOU JO
USZJOH UP VOEFSTUBOE XIZ UIF XIJUFT PG UIFTF TPSUT PG #MBDL #FMU DJUJFT BSF BNPOH UIF
NPTU DPOTFSWBUJWF JO UIF DPVOUSZ BOE NPSF DPOTFSWBUJWF UIBO PUIFS XIJUFT MJWJOH
FMTFXIFSF JO UIF 4PVUI
6MUJNBUFMZ UIF BSHVNFOU PG UIF CPPL DPODFSOT UIF DPSF JEFB UIBU UIF GPSNB
UJPO PG QVCMJD PQJOJPO NPSF CSPBEMZ DBO IBWF IJTUPSJDBM SPPUT *O UVSO BUUJUVEFT
DBO QFSTJTUFOU PWFS UJNF BOE BDSPTT NVMUJQMF HFOFSBUJPOT WJB CFIBWJPSBM QBUI EF
QFOEFODF )JTUPSZ DBO TIBQF DPOUFNQPSBSZ QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT
0WFS UIF DPVSTF PG UIJT CPPL XF XJMM JMMVTUSBUF UIJT DPSF JEFB CZ MPPLJOH BU UISFF
DPNQPOFOUT 'JSTU JO MPPLJOH BU UIF 64 4PVUI XF EPDVNFOU UIBU 4PVUIFSO XIJUFT
XIP MJWF JO BSFBT XIFSF TMBWFIPMEJOH XBT NPSF QSFWBMFOU BSF UPEBZ NPSF DPOTFSWB
UJWF NPSF DPPM UP "GSJDBO "NFSJDBOT BOE NPSF MJLFMZ UP PQQPTF SBDFSFMBUFE QPMJ
DJFT UIBU NBOZ GFFM DPVME QPUFOUJBMMZ IFMQ CMBDLT 4FDPOE UIFTF BUUJUVEFT XF BSHVF
BSF SPPUFE JO IJTUPSJDBM JODFOUJWFT UP TVCKVHBUF "GSJDBO "NFSJDBOTJODFOUJWFT UIBU
TUSFOHUIFOFE UISPVHI UIF BOUFCFMMVN QFSJPE BOE UIBU NPSQIFE JO UIF QPTUCFMMVN
QFSJPE JOUP TJHOJĕDBOU JOTUJUVUJPOBM BOE TPDJBM DVTUPNT EFTJHOFE UP LFFQ CMBDLT JO
TPDJBMMZ QPMJUJDBMMZ BOE FDPOPNJDBMMZ NBSHJOBMJ[FE QPTJUJPOT ćJSE UIFTF BUUJ
UVEFT IBWF CFFO QBTTFE EPXO PWFS UJNF UISPVHI B WBSJFUZ PG EJČFSFOU JOTUJUVUJPOBM
BOE DVMUVSBM DIBOOFMT JODMVEJOH WJB CFIBWJPSBM EFQFOEFODF "T XF TIBMM TFF IPX
FWFS TPNF PVUDPNFT IBWF BUUFOVBUFE PWFS UJNF XJUI FČFDUJWF JOUFSWFOUJPOT TVDI
BT UIF $JWJM 3JHIUT "DU BOE UIF 7PUJOH 3JHIUT "DU CVU UIF HVMG JO QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT
BNPOH XIJUFT MJWJOH JO UIF 4PVUI DPOUJOVFT UP FYJTU UPEBZ
)PX ćJT #PPL JT 0SHBOJ[FE
" CSJFG SPBENBQ XJMM PSJFOU UIF SFBEFS UP PVS CPPLT PSHBOJ[BUJPO 8F TUBSU UIJT
CPPL JO $IBQUFS Ɗ CZ QSFTFOUJOH BO PWFSWJFX PG UIF LFZ UIFPSFUJDBM DPODFQU VOEFS
MZJOH PVS BOBMZTJT OBNFMZ UIBU PG CFIBWJPSBM QBUI EFQFOEFODF ćJT $IBQUFS BJNT
)08 5)*4 #00, *4 03("/*;&%
ƉƏ
UP TJUVBUF UIJT UIFPSZ XJUIJO UXP CSPBEFS MJUFSBUVSFT J
UIF MJUFSBUVSF PO IJTUPSJDBM
JOTUJUVUJPOBMJTN XIJDI BSHVFT UIBU EJTUBOU FWFOUT DBO IBWF MBTUJOH JNQBDU PO QPMJ
UJDT CZ BČFDUJOH UIF XBZ JO XIJDI QPMJUJDT VOGPMET PWFS UJNF BOE JJ
UIF MJUFSBUVSF
PO "NFSJDBO QPMJUJDBM CFIBWJPS UIBU JODMVEFT DPOUFNQPSBSZ TUVEJFT PG QBSUJTBO
TIJQ BOE SBDF QPMJUJDT BT XFMM BT TUVEJFT PG 4PVUIFSO QPMJUJDBM CFIBWJPS PSJHJOBUJOH
JO ,FZT TFNJOBM CPPL 4PVUIFSO 1PMJUJDT "MUIPVHI QSFWJPVT TUVEJFT IBWF BMMVEFE
UP UIF GBDU UIBU BUUJUVEFT DBO QFSTJTU PWFS UJNF PVST JT UIF ĕSTU UP EFWFMPQ GVMMZ UIJT
DPODFQU XJUIJO UIF DPOUFYU PG QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT BOE CFIBWJPSBM QBUI EFQFOEFODF
8F MBZ UIF HSPVOEXPSL GPS UIJT UIFPSZ CZ FYBNJOJOH IPX OPOQPMJUJDBM DVTUPNT
BOE OPSNT DPVME CF USBOTNJUUFE PWFS UJNF BOE CZ DPOTJEFSJOH PUIFS FYBNQMFT PG
UIJT LJOE PG USBOTNJTTJPO PVUTJEF PG "NFSJDBO QPMJUJDT JODMVEJOH TPNF JNQPSUBOU
SFDFOU TUVEJFT JO UIF QPMJUJDBM FDPOPNZ MJUFSBUVSF
ćF SFTU PG UIF CPPL JT UIFO PSHBOJ[FE JOUP UISFF 1BSUT 1BSU * i/PXw
EFWFM
PQT UIF NBJO BOBMZTJT EPDVNFOUJOH QBUI EFQFOEFODF PG QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT BNPOH
XIJUF 4PVUIFSOFST 4QFDJĕDBMMZ XF FYBNJOF UIF i/PXw PG PVS ĕOEJOHT TIPXJOH
UIF QFSTJTUFOU QSFEJDUJWF QPXFS PG TMBWFSZ PO DPOUFNQPSBSZ QPMJUJDT ćJT GPSNT
UIF DPSF QBSU PG UIF FNQJSJDBM QV[[MF UIBU XF FYQMPSF JO MBUFS TFDUJPOT PG UIF CPPL
1BSU ** ićFOw
UIFO UBLFT UIF SFBEFS CBDL JO UJNF UP BOUFCFMMVN 3FDPOTUSVD
UJPO BOE QPTU3FDPOTUSVDUJPO QFSJPET )FSF XF BSHVF UIBU UIFTF FČFDUT NJHIU
IBWF UIFJS SPPUT JO UIF FDPOPNJD BOE QPMJUJDBM JODFOUJWFT HSPXJOH PVU PG TMBWFSZ
BOE BMTP JNQPSUBOUMZ JUT DPMMBQTF 1BSU *** i*O #FUXFFOw
UIFO UBLFT VQ IPX QBUI
EFQFOEFOU GPSDFT TIBQFE UIF EFWFMPQNFOU BOE USBKFDUPSZ PG QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT BU
UIF MPDBM MFWFM BDSPTT HFOFSBUJPOT *U GPDVTFT PO IPX JODFOUJWFT TIBQFE CPUI BD
UJPOT BOE BUUJUVEFT BNPOH 4PVUIFSO XIJUFT BOE IPX UIFTF JODFOUJWFT BUUFOVBUFE
JO TPNF DJSDVNTUBODFT EVF UP FYUFSOBM JOUFSWFOUJPOT CVU IPX PUIFS BUUJUVEFT IBWF
SFNBJOFE ćSPVHIPVU XF IJHIMJHIU UIF JNQPSUBOU SPMF UIBU UIF USBOTNJTTJPO PG
CFMJFGT WJB CPUI JOTUJUVUJPOBM BOE CFIBWJPSBM QBUI EFQFOEFODF QMBZFE JO UIF SFHJPOBM
EFWFMPQNFOU PG 4PVUIFSO SBDJBM BUUJUVEFT
1BSU * ćF $POUFNQPSBSZ &ČFDUT PG 4MBWFSZ
1BSU * FTUBCMJTIFT PVS NBJO FWJEFODF GPS UIF QBUI EFQFOEFODF PG QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT
SFMZJOH PO TFWFSBM EBUBESJWFO BOBMZTFT UP TIPX UIBU UIF 4PVUIT TMBWF QBTU QSFEJDUT
SFHJPOBM QBUUFSOT UPEBZ ćF HPBM PG UIJT 1BSU JT UP TIPX VTJOH EBUB BOE FYBNQMFT
UIBU IJTUPSJDBM QBUUFSOT DBO QSFEJDU DPOUFNQPSBSZ BUUJUVEFT
$IBQUFS Ƌ QSFTFOUT UIF DPSF FNQJSJDBM FWJEFODF GPS UIF QPTTJCJMJUZ PG QBUI EF
QFOEFODF JO QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT )FSF XF TUBSU XJUI UIF PCTFSWBUJPO UIBU UIF 4PVUI
$)"15&3 ƫ */530%6$5*0/
ƉƐ
JT NPSF DPOTFSWBUJWF UIBO UIF /PSUI BDSPTT B IPTU PG JNQPSUBOU JTTVFTƊ 8F TIPX
UIBU 4PVUIFSO DPVOUJFT UIBU IBE IJHIFS TIBSFT PG TMBWF QPQVMBUJPOT JO UIF UJNF QF
SJPE CFGPSF UIF $JWJM 8BS BSF UPEBZ BSFBT XIFSF XIJUFT BSF Ɖ
NPSF MJLFMZ UP CF
DPOTFSWBUJWF JO UFSNT PG UIFJS QBSUJTBO TFMGJEFOUJĕDBUJPO BOE Ɗ
NPSF MJLFMZ UP
PQQPTF QPMJDJFT UIBU NBOZ CFMJFWF DPVME CFOFĕU "GSJDBO "NFSJDBOT TVDI BT BG
ĕSNBUJWF BDUJPO ćFTF BSF BMTP BSFBT PG UIF 64 4PVUI XIFSF WBSJPVT NFBTVSFT
TIPX UIBU Ƌ
XIJUFT IBWF UIF DPPMFTU WJFXT UPXBSE CMBDL BT B HSPVQ 'JHVSF ƉƉ
QSFWJFXT UIF EBUB BOE ĕOEJOHT GSPN UIJT $IBQUFS BOE TIPXT NFBTVSFT PG XIJUF
QPMJUJDBM QSFGFSFODFT EJTBHHSFHBUFE CZ SFHJPO PG UIF DPVOUSZ OPO4PVUI XIJDI
JODMVEFT UIF .JEXFTU /PSUIFBTU 8FTU $PBTU
GPSNFSMZ MPXTMBWF 4PVUIFSO DPVO
UJFT BOE GPSNFSMZ IJHITMBWF 4PVUIFSO DPVOUJFTƋ ćF 'JHVSF TIPXT UIBU BDSPTT BMM
NFBTVSFT OPO4PVUIFSOFST BSF NPSF SBDJBMMZ MJCFSBMUIFZ BSF NPSF MJLFMZ UP JEFO
UJGZ BT %FNPDSBU NPSF MJLFMZ UP TVQQPSU BďSNBUJWF BDUJPO BOE NPSF MJLFMZ UP TBZ
UIBU TMBWFSZ IBT IVSU UIF BCJMJUZ PG CMBDLT UP XPSL UIFJS XBZ PVU PG UIF MPXFS DMBTT
8JUIJO UIF 4PVUI GPSNFSMZ MPXTMBWF BSFBT BSF NPSF MJLFMZ UP FYQSFTT UIFTF WJFXT
BT XFMM *U JT XJUIJO GPSNFSMZ IJHITMBWF BSFBT UIBU XIJUFT BSF UIF NPTU MJLFMZ UP PQQPTF
UIF %FNPDSBUJD QBSUZ PQQPTF BďSNBUJWF BDUJPO BOE FYQSFTT TFOUJNFOUT UIBU DPVME
CF DPOTUSVFE BT SBDJBMMZ SFTFOUGVM 8F QSFTFOU UIFTF BOE PUIFS SFTVMUT JO $IBQUFS Ƌ
"OE BT XF TIPX BMUIPVHI UIFTF SFTVMUT NBZ CF TVSQSJTJOH UIFZ IPME VQ FWFO JO
UIF GBDF PG B CBUUFSZ PG TUBUJTUJDBM UFTUT
$IBQUFS ƌ BEESFTTFT RVFTUJPOT UIBU NBOZ TLFQUJDBM SFBEFST XJMM IBWF XIJDI JT
XIFUIFS UIFTF SFTVMUT BSFOU TJNQMZ CFJOH ESJWFO CZ DPOUFNQPSBSZ GBDUPST TVDI BT
DPOUFNQPSBSZ EFNPHSBQIJDT 'JSTU XF BEESFTT UIF JNQPSUBOU DPVOUFSBSHVNFOUT
UIBU UIFTF ĕOEJOHT BSF TJNQMZ CFJOH ESJWFO CZ DPOUFNQPSBSZ CMBDL DPODFOUSBUJPOT
PS QPQVMBUJPO NPCJMJUZ PWFS UJNF 8F BSF NPUJWBUFE JO UIFTF RVFTUJPOT CZ UIF TFN
JOBM XPSL PG ,FZ XIP OPUFE UIBU POF PG TMBWFSZT MFHBDZ XBT JO UIF IJHI TIBSFT PG
"GSJDBO "NFSJDBOT MJWJOH JO UIJT QBSU PG UIF DPVOUSZ UPEBZ " WPMVNJOPVT MJUFS
BUVSF GPMMPXJOH ,FZ IBT NBEF UIF QPJOU UIBU XIJUF QPQVMBUJPOT CFJOH UISFBUFOFE
CZ IJHI DPODFOUSBUJPOT PG CMBDL QPQVMBUJPOT EFWFMPQ NPSF DPOTFSWBUJWF WJFXT BOE
TUSPOHFS BOUJNJOPSJUZ BUUJUVEFTB NFDIBOJTN UIBU UIF MJUFSBUVSF SFGFST UP BT iSBDJBM
Ɗ
8F VTF UIF UFSN i4PVUIw UP NFBO "MBCBNB "SLBOTBT 'MPSJEB (FPSHJB ,FOUVDLZ -PVJTJBOB
.JTTJTTJQQJ .JTTPVSJ /PSUI $BSPMJOB 4PVUI $BSPMJOB 5FOOFTTFF 5FYBT 7JSHJOJB BOE 8FTU 7JS
HJOJB ćJT SFQSFTFOUT UIF ƉƉ DPOGFEFSBUF TUBUFT QMVT ,FOUVDLZ .JTTPVSJ BOE 8FTU 7JSHJOJB UIPVHI
UIF JODMVTJPO PS PNJTTJPO PG UIF MBUUFS UISFF BSF OPU JNQPSUBOU UP UIF CSPBE DPODMVTJPOT PG UIF CPPL
Ƌ
5P EJWJEF UIF GPSNFSMZ MPX BOE IJHITMBWF QBSUT PG UIF 4PVUI UIF ĕHVSF VTFT ƊƍŰ QPQVMBUJPO
FOTMBWFE BT UIF DVUPČ QPJOU UIJT SFQSFTFOUT SPVHIMZ UIF NFEJBO ćBU JT BQQSPYJNBUFMZ IBMG PG
DPVOUJFT JO UIF 4PVUI IBE GFXFS UIBO ƊƍŰ PG UIF QPQVMBUJPO FOTMBWFE JO ƉƐƎƈ BOE SPVHIMZ IBMG IBE
NPSF
)08 5)*4 #00, *4 03("/*;&%
0.35
Non-South
Low-Slave South
High-Slave South
0.30
Proportion of County
ƉƑ
0.25
0.20
0.15
0.10
0.05
0.00
Identifies as a Democrat
Supports Affirmative Action
Slavery Hurt Blacks?
'JHVSF ƫƫ 8IJUF BUUJUVEFT PO SBDFSFMBUFE JTTVFT -PXTMBWF SFGFST UP DPVOUJFT JO UIF 64
4PVUI UIBU IBE GFXFS UIBO ƊƍŰ PG UIF DPVOUZ QPQVMBUJPO FOTMBWFE IJHITMBWF SFGFST UP
DPVOUJFT UIBU IBE NPSF UIBO ƊƍŰ PG UIF QPQVMBUJPO FOTMBWFE
UISFBUw "T XF TIPX JO $IBQUFS ƌ IPXFWFS UIJT FYQMBOBUJPO EPFT OPU GVMMZ FYQMBJO
UIF EJTUJODUJWFOFTT PG UIF #MBDL #FMU 0ODF XF BDDPVOU GPS UIF QSFWBMFODF PG TMBWFSZ
JO UIF 4PVUIFSO #MBDL #FMU UIF FČFDUT PG DPOUFNQPSBSZ CMBDL QPQVMBUJPOT EJTBQ
QFBS ćJT JT BO JNQPSUBOU QPJOU BOE CFDBVTF JU DBTUT EPVCU PO B TJHOJĕDBOU QPSUJPO
PG MJUFSBUVSF JO "NFSJDBO QPMJUJDT XF EJTDVTT JU BU MFOHUI 8F BMTP DPOTJEFS XIFUIFS
PVS ĕOEJOHT BSF CFJOH ESJWFO CZ TVCTUBOUJBM QPQVMBUJPO TPSUJOH PWFS UJNF MFBEJOH
UP EFNPHSBQIJD DIBOHFT JO UIF #MBDL #FMU "MUIPVHI UIF FWJEFODF PO UIJT QPJOU
JT UIJOOFS XF OPOFUIFMFTT ĕOE UIBU UIJT FYQMBOBUJPO EPFT OPU BQQFBS UP CF GVMMZ
ESJWJOH PVS SFTVMUT *OTUFBE XF BSHVF UIBU UIF GPSDFT BU QMBZ EP OPU PSJHJOBUF JO
DPOUFNQPSBSZ EFNPHSBQIJDT CVU SBUIFS JO UIF IJTUPSJDBM FDPOPNJD JODFOUJWFT GPS
PQQSFTTJPO BOE BOUJCMBDL QPMJDJFT XIJDI WJB CFIBWJPSBM QBUI EFQFOEFODF DPO
UJOVF UP TIBQF BUUJUVEFT UPEBZ
Ɗƈ
$)"15&3 ƫ */530%6$5*0/
1BSU ** ćF 0SJHJOT PG UIF 64 3BDJBM 0SEFS JO &DPOPNJD BOE
1PMJUJDBM *ODFOUJWFT
1BSU ** BEESFTTFT UIF RVFTUJPOT MFę PQFO CZ UIF FNQJSJDBM ĕOEJOHT JO 1BSU *JG PVS
ĕOEJOHT UIBU XIJUFT XIP MJWF JO GPSNFS QBSUT PG UIF TMBWFIPMEJOH 4PVUI BSF NPSF
SBDJBMMZ DPOTFSWBUJWF BSFOU FYQMBJOFE CZ EFNPHSBQIJD GBDUPST UIFO XIBU FYQMBJOT
UIJT QBUUFSO 8F BSHVF JO UIJT QBSU PG UIF CPPL UIBU UIF BOTXFS MJFT JO UIF DPN
QMJDBUFE IJTUPSJDBM JOTUJUVUJPO PG TMBWFSZ JUTFMG UIBU JT UIF FDPOPNJD BOE QPMJUJDBM
TZTUFN PG TMBWFSZ BOE JUT DPMMBQTF MFE XIJUFT MJWJOH JO UIPTF BSFBT NPTU EFQFOEFOU
PO TMBWFSZ UP CF NPSF DPOTFSWBUJWF NPSF DPPM UPXBSE SBDFSFMBUFE QPMJDJFT BOE
NPSF SBDJBMMZ IPTUJMF UPXBSE "GSJDBO "NFSJDBOT
)PX JT JU UIBU TMBWFSZ IBT MFE UP XIJUFT XIP XFSF SFMJBOU PO JU UP CFDPNF NPSF
SBDJBMMZ DPOTFSWBUJWF "OE XIFO EJE UIFTF EJČFSFODFT DPNF UP MJHIU $IBQUFS ƍ
FYBNJOFT UIF IJTUPSJDBM QSPHSFTTJPO PG QPMJUJDBM EJČFSFODFT CFUXFFO UIF TMBWFIPME
JOH #MBDL #FMU BOE PUIFS QBSUT PG UIF 4PVUI "T UIF $IBQUFS TIPXT TMBWFSZ BG
GFDUFE NVDI PG BOUFCFMMVN QPMJUJDT MFBEJOH UP TPNF DMFBWBHFT CFUXFFO UIF #MBDL
#FMU BOE OPOTMBWFIPMEJOH BSFBT JO UIF BOUFCFMMVN QFSJPE #VU UIFTF EJČFSFODFT
XFSF NPTUMZ SPPUFE JO FDPOPNJDT SBUIFS UIBO PWFS UIF RVFTUJPO PG TMBWFSZ *O FMFD
UJPOT UIBU GPDVTFE PO 4PVUIFSO 3JHIUT BOE UIF GVUVSF PG TMBWFSZ MPXTMBWF BSFBT
XFSF KVTU BT MJLFMZ UP TVQQPSU UIF JOTUJUVUJPO BT UIF IJHITMBWF DPVOUJFT 4JNJMBSMZ
PO SBDF BOE UIF USFBUNFOU PG FOTMBWFE QFPQMF XF BSF VOBCMF UP EJTUJOHVJTI NFBO
JOHGVM EJČFSFODFT CFUXFFO IJHI BOE MPXTMBWF BSFBT JG BOZUIJOH JU BQQFBST UIBU
XIJUFT MJWJOH JO MPXTMBWF BSFBT TBX TMBWFIPMEJOH BT B NFBOT PG FDPOPNJD VQXBSE
NPCJMJUZ *U XBT OPU VOUJM UIF ZFBST JNNFEJBUFMZ QSFDFEJOH UIF XBS BOE JO UIF TVC
TFRVFOU ZFBST UIBU XF DBO EFUFDU UIPTF NFBOJOHGVM QBSUJTBO EJČFSFODFT CFUXFFO
GPSNFS TMBWFIPMEJOH BOE OPOTMBWFIPMEJOH BSFBT 4MBWFSZ IBE B NBTTJWF JNQBDU PO
4PVUIFSO TPDJFUZ BOE QPMJUJDT JO UIF BOUFCFMMVN QFSJPE CVU UIF QPMJUJDBM HFPHSBQIZ
XF ĕOE UPEBZ POMZ CFHJOT UP EFWFMPQ JO UIF ZFBST MFBEJOH VQ UP UIF $JWJM 8BS BOE
JNNFEJBUFMZ BęFS TVHHFTUJOH UIF JNQPSUBOU SPMF UIBU UIF UISFBU PG UIF DPMMBQTF PG
TMBWFSZ QMBZFE JO FYBDFSCBUJOH BOE GPNFOUJOH QPMJUJDBM EJČFSFODFT BOE EJČFSFODFT
PWFS UIF USFBUNFOU PG "GSJDBO "NFSJDBOT
ćJT BEESFTTFT XIFO UIF QPMJUJDBM HFPHSBQIZ PG TMBWFSZ TPMJEJĕFE JOUP UIF QBU
UFSOT XF TFF UPEBZ #VU IPX EJE UIFTF EJČFSFODFT DPNF BCPVU $IBQUFS Ǝ UBDLMFT
UIFTF RVFTUJPOT DPODFQUVBMMZ CZ MPPLJOH NPSF DMPTFMZ BU UIF FOE PG TMBWFSZ BOE UJNF
QFSJPE TVSSPVOEJOH 3FDPOTUSVDUJPO BOE 3FEFNQUJPO 8F TIPX UIBU UJNF QFSJPE
BSPVOE FNBODJQBUJPO BOE 3FDPOTUSVDUJPO XFSF DSJUJDBM KVODUVSFT GPS UIF 6OJUFE
4UBUFT BOE GPS SBDFSFMBUJPOT JO UFSNT PG XIJUFT Ɖ
FDPOPNJD JODFOUJWFT BOE Ɗ
QPMJUJDBM JODFOUJWFT UP FOHBHF JO CMBDL TVQQSFTTJPO *OEFFE 4PVUIFSO XIJUFTBOE
)08 5)*4 #00, *4 03("/*;&%
ƊƉ
QBSUJDVMBSMZ 4PVUIFSO #MBDL #FMU FMJUFTIBE DSFBUFE B CVTJOFTT FDPOPNZ UIBU XBT
SFMJBOU PO MBCPSJOUFOTJWF BHSJDVMUVSF BOE FYUSBDUJPO ćF TVDDFTT PG UIFTF JOEVT
USJFT XBT QSFEJDBUFE PO UIF HFOFSPVT QSPWJTJPO PG JOFYQFOTJWF BOE SFOFXBCMF MBCPS
)PXFWFS UIF FOE PG TMBWFSZ NFBOU GPS UIFTF XIJUFT UIF FOE PG UIJT TUFBEZ TVQQMZ
PG XPSLFST #MBDL XPSLFST DPVME OPX BU MFBTU JO UIFPSZ EFNBOE UP CF QBJE PS
FWFO XPSTF QJDL VQ BOE NPWF *O UFSNT PG QPMJUJDBM JODFOUJWFT XJUI UIF QBTTBHF PG
UIF ƉƋUI ƉƌUI BOE ƉƍUI "NFOENFOUT OFXMZ GSFFE CMBDLT DPVME JO UIFPSZ
WPUF
ćJT QSFTFOUFE B QSPCMFN GPS 4PVUIFSO #MBDL #FMU XIJUFT UIBU XBT VOQSFDFEFOUFE JO
OBUVSF JO TPNF QPMJUJDBMMZ QPXFSGVM QBSUT PG -PVJTJBOB .JTTJTTJQQJ BOE "MBCBNB
CMBDLT PVUOVNCFSFE XIJUFT Ɖƈ UP Ɖ 3BUIFS UIBO BDDFEF UP B GSFF CMBDL WPUF UIFTF
BSFBT UVSOFE UP WPUFS TVQQSFTTJPO BOE CBMMPU TUVďOH VTJOH UIF OVNCFST PG CMBDLT
MJWJOH JO UIFTF BSFBT BT XBZT UP BDDVNVMBUF HSFBUFS QPMJUJDBM QPXFS ćFTF FDPOPNJD
BOE QPMJUJDBM JODFOUJWFT MFE 4PVUIFSO XIJUFT UP FOHBHF JO XJEFTQSFBE SBDJBM TVQ
QSFTTJPO JOUJNJEBUJPO OPU KVTU WJB MFHBM NFBOT FH CMBDL DPEFT
CVU BMTP FYUFO
TJWF MPDBMJ[FE SBDJBM WJPMFODF BOE JOUJNBUJPO ćVT B LFZ QPJOU JO UIJT EJTDVTTJPO
JT UIBU FDPOPNJD BOE QPMJUJDBM JODFOUJWFT DBO BOE EJE MFBE UP SBDJTU BDUJPOT
1BSU *** ćF )JTUPSJDBM 1FSTJTUFODF PG 1PMJUJDBM "UUJUVEFT
1BSU *** UVSOT UIF RVFTUJPO UPXBSE FYBNJOJOH UIF GPSDFT UIBU IBWF MFE UP QBUI EF
QFOEFODF CPUI WJB JOTUJUVUJPOBM QBUI EFQFOEFODF BOE CFIBWJPSBM QBUI EFQFOEFODF
)PX DBO XF FYQMBJO UIF GBDU UIBU FDPOPNJD BOE QPMJUJDBM JODFOUJWFT EBUJOH CBDL
Ɖƍƈ ZFBST DPOUJOVF UP BČFDU QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT JO UIF QSFTFOUEBZ QFSJPE ćJT 1BSU
BUUFNQUT UP ESBX UIF MJOF CFUXFFO QPJOU " TMBWFSZ
BOE QPJOU # UPEBZ
CZ MPPLJOH
BU UIF FWFOUT PG UIF ƊƈUI DFOUVSZ BT XFMM BT JNQPSUBOU JOUFSWFOUJPOT UIBU PDDVSSFE
CPUI CFGPSF BOE BęFS UIF $JWJM 3JHIUT .PWFNFOU
$IBQUFS Ə CFHJOT UIJT EJTDVTTJPO CZ MPPLJOH BU UIF QPTU3FDPOTUSVDUJPO FOWJ
SPONFOU BOE UIF FBSMZ ƊƈUI DFOUVSZ NPWFNFOU UPXBSE +JN $SPX %SBXJOH PO
JEFBT PG JOTUJUVUJPOBM QBUI EFQFOEFODF JU EJTDVTTFT IPX TMBWFSZ XBT QSFEJDUJWF PG
B OVNCFS PG FBSMZ BOUJCMBDL JOTUJUVUJPOT TVDI BT WPUFS TVQQSFTTJPO MBXT JODMVE
JOH UIF TUBUF DPOTUJUVUJPOT FOBDUFE BSPVOE UIF UVSO PG UIF DFOUVSZ
FDPOPNJD QPMJ
DJFT BOE NPSF DPOTFSWBUJWF WPUJOH PO /FX %FBM FSB JOUFSWFOUJPOT ćFTF JOUFSWFO
UJPOT XPSLFE JO UBOEFN XJUI B NPSF DPOTFSWBUJWF SBDJBM DVMUVSF POF UIBU FNQIB
TJ[FE TPDJBM TFHSFHBUJPO JO IPNFT TDIPPMT DIVSDIFT BOE CVTJOFTTFT 8F BMTP TIPX
IPX JO DPOUSBTU UP XIBU SBDJBM UISFBU UIFPSJFT XPVME QSFEJDU UIBU JODSFBTJOH CMBDL
NPCJMJUZBOE CMBDLT EFQBSUVSF GSPN UIF SVSBM 4PVUI WJB UIF (SFBU .JHSBUJPOT
HSFBUMZ BMBSNFE XIJUFT BOE MFE UP GVSUIFS SFTUSJDUJPOT PO MBCPS NPCJMJUZ JODMVE
JOH BOUJFOUJDFNFOU BOE BOUJWBHSBODZ MBXT ćF $IBQUFS EPFT IPXFWFS SBJTF UIF
ƊƊ
$)"15&3 ƫ */530%6$5*0/
QPTTJCJMJUZ UIBU BUUJUVEFT DPVME BUUFOVBUF XJUI XFBLFOJOH SPPU FDPOPNJD JODFOUJWFT
4QFDJĕDBMMZ XF TIPX UIBU BT UIF 4PVUI NPWFE NPSF BOE NPSF UPXBSE UIF NFDIB
OJ[BUJPO PG BHSJDVMUVSFBOE UIVT BXBZ GSPN UIF OFFE GPS JOFYQFOTJWF CMBDL MBCPS
XIJUFT BOUJCMBDL BUUJUVEFT BUUFOVBUFE NPSF RVJDLMZ ćJT TVHHFTUT BUUFOVBUJPO JO
CFIBWJPSBM QBUI EFQFOEFODF
ćJT BUUFOVBUJPO TFUT UIF TUBHF GPS $IBQUFS Ɛ XIJDI UBDLMFT UIF SFHJPOBM EJČFS
FODFT XJUIJO UIF 4PVUI EVSJOH BOE BęFS UIF $JWJM 3JHIUT .PWFNFOU JODMVEJOH UIF
JNQPSUBOU JOUFSWFOUJPOT PG UIF $JWJM 3JHIUT "DU PG ƉƑƎƌ BOE UIF 7PUJOH 3JHIUT "DU
PG ƉƑƎƍ ćFTF JOUFSWFOUJPOT BT UIF $IBQUFS EPDVNFOUT XFSF NBTTJWFMZ JNQBDU
GVM BOE TVHHFTU B WFSZ PQUJNJTUJD WJFX BCPVU XIBU PVS ĕOEJOHT NFBO GPS "NFSJ
DBO QPMJUJDT UPEBZ 0VS FYQFSJFODF TIPXT UIBU DIBOHF DBO DPNF GSPN XJUIJO UIF
6OJUFE 4UBUFT BOE BČFDU CPUI CFIBWJPSBM BOE JOTUJUVUJPOBM PVUDPNFT ćF $JWJM
3JHIUT .PWFNFOU IFMQFE DIBOHF UIF XBZ UIBU NJMMJPOT PG QFPQMF UIJOL BCPVU SBDF
BOE SBDF SFMBUJPOT XIJMF UIF $JWJM 3JHIUT "DU PG ƉƑƎƌ IFMQFE TFDVSF UIF QSPUFDUJPO
PG MBXT GPS NJMMJPOT PG "GSJDBO "NFSJDBOT BOE UIF 7PUJOH 3JHIUT "DU PG ƉƑƎƍ NBEF
JU QPTTJCMF GPS NJMMJPOT PG CMBDLT UP FYFSDJTF UIFJS SJHIUT VOEFS UIF ƉƍUI "NFOENFOU
GPS UIF ĕSTU UJNF "MUIPVHI XF ĕOE UIF QFSTJTUFODF PG IJTUPSJDBM QBUUFSOT XF TFF B
DFSUBJO LJOE PG EFDBZ PWFS UJNF BT XFMMJO QBSU UIBOLT UP UIFTF PSHBOJ[FE FČPSUT
8F TFF UIJT EFDBZ QBSUJDVMBSMZ JO UFSNT PG UIPTF BSFOBT JO XIJDI UIF GFEFSBM HPWFSO
NFOU IBT UIF $POTUJUVUJPOBMMZ FOVNFSBUFE QPXFS UP BDUFH JOTUBODFT JOWPMWJOH
DPNNFSDF GFEFSBM TQFOEJOH FH FEVDBUJPO
BOE JO TPNF DBTFT WPUJOH
ćJT SBJTFT UIF GVOEBNFOUBM DPODFQUVBM RVFTUJPO PG IPX BUUJUVEFT BSF QBTTFE
EPXO PWFS UJNF *T JU CZ JOTUJUVUJPOBM NFDIBOJTNT PS CZ DVMUVSBM POFT $POTJTUFOU
XJUI UIF UIFPSZ PG CFIBWJPSBM QBUI EFQFOEFODF XF BSHVF UIBU CPUI JOTUJUVUJPOT
BOE DVMUVSFJODMVEJOH DVMUVSBM USBOTNJTTJPOT GSPN QBSFOUT UP DIJMESFOQMBZ BO
JNQPSUBOU SPMF JO UIF QSPQBHBUJPO PG QPMJUJDBM QBUUFSOT BOE BUUJUVEFT 6MUJNBUFMZ
IPXFWFS JOTUJUVUJPOBM JOUFSWFOUJPOT BSF FČFDUJWF XIFO JU DPNFT UP JOTUJUVUJPOBM
PVUDPNFT UIFZ BSF MFTT FČFDUJWF XIFO JU DPNFT UP DIBOHJOH IFBSUT BOE NJOETUIBU
JT UIF BSF MFTT FČFDUJWF XIFO DIBOHJOH CFIBWJPS 'FEFSBM JOUFSWFOUJPOT IBWF TVD
DFFEFE JO UIJOHT MJLF PQFOJOH VQ FEVDBUJPOBM BOE FDPOPNJD PQQPSUVOJUJFT MFWFMJOH
UIF QMBZJOH ĕFME JO UFSNT PG QPMJUJDBM QBSUJDJQBUJPO BOE FODPVSBHJOH CMBDL NJHSB
UJPO ćFZ IBWF CFFO MFTT TVDDFTTGVM BU DIBOHJOH BU B GVOEBNFOUBM MFWFM IPX QFPQMF
PG EJČFSFOU SBDJBM HSPVQT WJFX POF BOPUIFS 8F QSFTFOU FWJEFODF UIBU QBSFOUUP
DIJME USBOTNJTTJPO PG SBDJBM BUUJUVEFT IBT PDDVSSFE JO UIF MBTU ƍƈ ZFBST IJHIMJHIUJOH
BU MFBTU POF TPVSDF PG DVMUVSBM USBOTNJTTJPO PG CFMJFGT
8F DPODMVEF JO $IBQUFS Ƒ CZ DPOTJEFSJOH UIFTF RVFTUJPOT JO UIF CSPBEFS DPO
UFYU PG OBUJPOBM QPMJUJDT 8F BSHVF IFSF UIBU "NFSJDBT TMBWF IJTUPSZ IBT BČFDUFE
PVS QPMJUJDT PO B CSPBEFS MFWFM NBLJOH UIF 6OJUFE 4UBUFT JO QBSU NPSF DPOTFSWB
063 .&5)0%0-0(*$"- "1130"$)
ƊƋ
UJWF PO SBDJBM JTTVFT JODMVEJOH SFEJTUSJCVUJPO XFMGBSF BOE MBX BOE PSEFS 8F BMTP
DPOTJEFS XIBU PVS ĕOEJOHT NFBO GPS UIF GVUVSF PG QPMJDZ JOUFSWFOUJPOT 0VS DPO
DMVTJPO JT OPU OFDFTTBSJMZ XJUIPVU PQUJNJTN PVS IJTUPSZ IBT TIPXO UIBU UIFSF BSF
FČFDUJWF NPEFT PG JOUFSWFOUJPO QBSUJDVMBSMZ XIFO JU DPNFT UP FDPOPNJD JOFRVBM
JUZ BOE FEVDBUJPOBM EJTQBSJUJFT &ČFDUJWF JOUFSWFOUJPOT NJHIU IBWF BO JNQPSUBOU
SPMF UP QMBZ JO UIF BUUFOVBUJPO PG QBUI EFQFOEFOU BUUJUVEFT )PXFWFS PVS SFTVMUT
BMTP TVHHFTU UIF JNQPSUBODF PG WJHJMBODF JO UIF BCTFODF PG JOUFSWFOUJPOTCPUI
JOTUJUVUJPOBM BOE DVMUVSBMUIFSF JT B QPTTJCJMJUZ PG SFUSFODINFOU
0VS VMUJNBUF DPODMVTJPO IPXFWFS JT TUSBJHIUGPSXBSE IJTUPSZ QMBZT B EFFQ BOE
JNQPSUBOU SPMF JO IPX XF VOEFSTUBOE DPOUFNQPSBSZ QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFTBOE CZ
FYUFOTJPO DPOUFNQPSBSZ QPMJUJDT
0VS .FUIPEPMPHJDBM "QQSPBDI
ćJT CPPL SFMJFT PO EBUB BOBMZTJT BOE RVBOUJUBUJWF NFUIPET 8F VTF EBUB GSPN B
WBSJFUZ PG QVCMJD PQJOJPO TVSWFZT JODMVEJOH UIF $PPQFSBUJWF $POHSFTTJPOBM &MFD
UJPO 4VSWFZ $$&4
UIF "NFSJDBO /BUJPOBM &MFDUJPO 4VSWFZ "/&4
BOE 1FX
3FTFBSDI 8F BMTP VTF EBUB GSPN PUIFS LJOET PG FDPOPNJD JOEJDBUPST BOE EFNP
HSBQIJD TUBUJTUJDT JODMVEJOH UIF 64 $FOTVT UIF 6OJUFE /BUJPOT BOE PUIFS PVUMFUT
#FDBVTF XF BUUFNQU UP BOBMZ[F MBSHF RVBOUJUJFT PG EBUB XF PęFO UVSO UP SFHSFT
TJPO BOBMZTFT BOE PUIFS LJOET PG TUBUJTUJDBM NPEFMJOH JODMVEJOH NBUDIJOH JOTUSV
NFOUBM WBSJBCMFT BOBMZTJT BOE PUIFS LJOET PG DPSSFMBUJPOT BOE DPSSFDUJPOT ćJT
NBLFT PVS BQQSPBDI GVOEBNFOUBMMZ EJČFSFOU GSPN UIF BQQSPBDI UBLFO CZ IJTUPSJ
BOT )JTUPSJBOT XIP IBWF MPPLFE BU UIFTF RVFTUJPOT IBWF EPOF TP UISPVHI UIF MFOT
PG IJTUPSJDBM OBSSBUJWFT DBSFGVMMZ QJFDJOH UPHFUIFS UIF FWFOUT PG UIF QBTU BOE USBD
JOH UIFJS QSPDFTT NPWJOH GPSXBSE ćF XPSL PG IJTUPSJBOT MJLF &SJD 'POFS #BSCBSB
'JFMET 4UFWFO )BIO BOE $ 7BOO 8PPEXBSE IBT NBEF DBSFGVM BOE UIPVHIUGVM
QSPHSFTT JO VOEFSTUBOEJOH NPNFOUT PG UIF QBTU UFMMJOH JNQPSUBOU TUPSJFT BCPVU
IPX BOE XIZ TMBWFSZ BQQFBST UP IBWF IBE MPOHMBTUJOH FČFDUT XJUIJO JOEJWJEVBM
UJNF QFSJPET
0VS HPBM JT OPU UP SFQMBDF BO IJTUPSJDBM BDDPVOU CVU SBUIFS UP MFBSO GSPN BOE BEE
UP IJTUPSJDBM OBSSBUJWFT )JTUPSZ JO JUT SJDI EFTDSJQUJPOT PG QBSUJDVMBS JOEJWJEVBMT PS
FWFOUT QSPWJEFT NBOZ PG UIF TUFQQJOH TUPOFT GSPN BO JOTUJUVUJPO MPOH BCPMJTIFE
UP BUUJUVEFT JO UIF NPEFSO QFSJPE 8F VOEFSTUBOE UIBU PVS NPEFSO TPDJFUZ JT B
QSPEVDU PG IJTUPSJDBM GPSDFT TP UP VOEFSTUBOE NPEFSO TPDJFUZ CFUUFS XF NVTU MPPL
UP UIF QBTU #VU XF IPQF UIBU PVS TUPSZ JT CSPBEFS UIBO BOZ DPMMFDUJPO PG TUPSJFT PS
Ɗƌ
$)"15&3 ƫ */530%6$5*0/
FWFOUT BOE TP PVS GPDVT JT OFDFTTBSJMZ CSPBEFS UIBO BO IJTUPSJDBM BDDPVOU ćBU JT
IJTUPSZ JOGPSNT PVS TUPSZ CVU JU JT OPU UIF TUPSZ JUTFMG
'PS UIBU SFBTPO UIJT JT OPU B IJTUPSZ CPPL JU JT B CPPL BCPVU DPOUFNQPSBSZ QPM
JUJDT UIBU ESBXT MFTTPOT BOE FYQMBOBUJPOT GSPN IJTUPSZ 0VS BQQSPBDI JT UP FYBNJOF
RVBOUJUBUJWF SFMBUJPOTIJQT CFUXFFO UIJOHT PG UIF QSFTFOU BOE UIJOHT PG UIF QBTU 8F
USZ UP NBLF TFOTF PG MBSHF RVBOUJUBUFT PG JOGPSNBUJPO USZJOH UP UIF FYUFOU QPTTJCMF
UP MFU UIF EBUB UFMM VT QBUUFSOT BCPVU IJTUPSZ 4PNFUJNFT XF MPPL BU WFSZ MPOHUFSN
QBUUFSOT TVDI BT CBTJD SFMBUJPOTIJQT CFUXFFO UIJOHT UIBU IBQQFOFE JO ƉƐƎƈ BOE
UIJOHT UIBU BSF IBQQFOJOH UPEBZ PUIFS UJNFT XF MPPL BU NPSF NJDSPMFWFM EBUB UP
UFMM B TUPSZ BCPVU B QBSUJDVMBS UJNF QFSJPE 8F BMTP OPUF UIBU TJHOJĕDBOU BEWBODFT
JO i#JH %BUBw JODMVEJOH NBTTJWF EBUB DPMMFDUJPO BOE TVSWFZ UFDIOJRVFT NFBO UIBU
UIFTF TPSUT PG BQQSPBDIFT XFSF GBS GSPN GFBTJCMF FWFO BT MJUUMF BT UXFOUZ ZFBST BHP
0VS BQQSPBDI BMTP EJČFST GSPN UIF USBEJUJPOBM BQQSPBDI PG FDPOPNJD IJTUPSJ
BOT .BOZ FDPOPNJTUT IBWF MPPLFE BU RVFTUJPOT SFMBUFE UP TMBWFSZ BOE "NFSJDBT
TMBWF MFHBDZ JODMVEJOH 4UBOMFZ &OHFSNBO (BWJO 8SJHIU $MBVEJB (PMEJO /BUIBO
/VOO BOE PUIFST #VU UIJT JNQPSUBOU XPSL NPTUMZ MPPLT BU UIF FDPOPNJD MFHBDZ PG
"NFSJDBO TMBWFSZ SBUIFS UIBO JUT QPMJUJDBM MFHBDZ *OEFFE NPTU PG UIFTF XPSLT MPPL
BU (%1 QFS DBQJUB JODPNF JOFRVBMJUZ CMBDLXIJUF HBQT FUD NVDI PG JU BMTP JO B
IJTUPSJDBM SBUIFS UIBO DPOUFNQPSBSZ
DPOUFYU ćFTF RVFTUJPOT BSF PCWJPVTMZ JN
QPSUBOU BOE XF EJTDVTT UIFN UISPVHIPVU #VU XIBU DPODFSOT VT JT IPX "NFSJDBT
TMBWF MFHBDZ IBT MFę B MBTUJOH QPMJUJDBM JNQSJOU IPX JU IBT TIBQFE QPMJUJDBM EJČFS
FODFT XJUIJO UIF 4PVUI BOE IPX JU IBT QPUFOUJBMMZ RVFTUJPOT PG OBUJPOBM QPMJDZ
0VS VMUJNBUF JOUFSFTU JO PUIFS XPSET JT IPX TMBWFSZ IBT BČFDUFE PVS DPOUFNQP
SBSZ QPMJUJDBM DMJNBUF #FDBVTF PG UIBU BMUIPVHI PVS UFDIOJRVFT NJHIU CF TJNJMBS UP
UIPTF VTFE CZ FDPOPNJTUT XF QSJNBSJMZ MPPL BU NFBTVSFT UIBU FDPOPNJTUT VTVBMMZ
EP OPU MPPL BU JODMVEJOH QVCMJD PQJOJPO JOEJDBUPST BOE PUIFS NFBTVSFT PG "NFSJ
DBOT DPOUFNQPSBSZ QPMJUJDBM BOE DVMUVSBM BUUJUVEFT
8F EP OPUF UIBU CFDBVTF XF VTF RVBOUJUBUJWF EBUB BOE RVBOUJUBUJWF BQQSPBDIFT
TPNF PG XIBU XF EP NJHIU CF VOGBNJMJBS UP TPNF SFBEFST GPS FYBNQMF UIPTF XJUI
PVU GBNJMJBSJUZ XJUI TUBUJTUJDBM BOBMZTFT ćSPVHIPVU XF IBWF BUUFNQUFE UP UBLF
PVS RVBOUJUBUJWF BOBMZTJT BOE USBOTMBUF JU JOUP TUSBJHIUGPSXBSE TVCTUBOUJWF JOUFSQSF
UBUJPO *U JT PVS WJFX UIBU RVBOUJUBUJWF BOBMZTFT BEE MJUUMF VOMFTT UIFZ DBO CF JO
UFSQSFUFE JO NFBOJOHGVM TVCTUBOUJWF XBZT 8F UIFSFGPSF PQU JO GBWPS PG HSBQIJDBM
SFQSFTFOUBUJPOT BOE PUIFS NPSF JOUVJUJWF XBZT PG QSFTFOUJOH UIJT LJOE PG JOGPS
NBUJPO MFBWJOH UIF NPSF UFDIOJDBM NBUFSJBM UP WBSJPVT BQQFOEJDFT BOE PVS PUIFS
QVCMJTIFE XPSL
$0/$-64*0/
Ɗƍ
$PODMVTJPO
8F DPODMVEF UIJT CSJFG JOUSPEVDUJPO CZ IJHIMJHIUJOH XIBU XF CFMJFWF UP CF UIF DPSF
DPOUSJCVUJPOT PG UIJT CPPL ćF ĕSTU JT UIBU XF TIPX UIBU QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT BSF QBUI
EFQFOEFOU NBLJOH IJTUPSZ BO JNQPSUBOU DPNQPOFOU UP UIF TUVEZ PG QPMJUJDT )FSF
XF TIPX UIBU "NFSJDBT IJTUPSZ XJUI TMBWFSZ FNBODJQBUJPO BOE 3FDPOTUSVDUJPO
IBT GVOEBNFOUBMMZ BČFDUFE XIJUF 4PVUIFSOFST QPMJUJDBM BUUJUVEFT NBLJOH TPNF
NPSF DPOTFSWBUJWFQBSUJDVMBSMZ PO SBDJBM JTTVFTUIFO UIFZ PUIFSXJTF XPVME IBWF
CFFO #VU UIJT JT KVTU POF FYBNQMF )JTUPSZ NBUUFST BOE TIBQFT PVS QPMJUJDT CFMJFGT
BOE BUUJUVEFT "OE EPFT TP WJB UIF JNQPSUBOU DIBOOFMT PG CPUI JOTUJUVUJPOBM QBUI
EFQFOEFODF BOE BMTP CFIBWJPS QBUI EFQFOEFODF
4FDPOE XF TIPX UIBU "NFSJDBOT BUUJUVEFT PO SBDF DBO JO QBSU USBDF UIFJS PSJHJOT
UP UIF FDPOPNJD BOE QPMJUJDBM JODFOUJWFT CPSOF PVU PG UIF NBTT FOTMBWFNFOU PG "GSJDBO
"NFSJDBOT 8F VTF EBUB BOE PUIFS RVBOUJUBUJWF UFDIOJRVFT UP TIPX UIBU 4PVUIFSO
XIJUFT IBE IVHF JODFOUJWFT UP VTF JOGPSNBM JOTUJUVUJPOT BOE MPDBMJ[FE DVTUPNT UP
USZ BT NVDI BT QPTTJCMF UP SFDSFBUF UIF TZTUFN PG JOTUJUVUJPOBMJ[FE TVCKVHBUJPO UIBU
TMBWFSZ IBE PODF QSPWJEFE 8F TIPX UIBU PODF TMBWFSZ FOEFE PUIFS JOTUJUVUJPOT
TPNF GPSNBM BOE TPNF JOGPSNBMBSPTF UP UBLF JUT QMBDF )PXFWFS BMUIPVHI XF VTF
UIF FYBNQMF PG TMBWFSZ BOE CMBDLXIJUF SFMBUJPOTIJQT IFSF XF CFMJFWF UIBU FDPOPNJD
BOE QPMJUJDBM JODFOUJWFT NBUUFS TJHOJĕDBOUMZ JO TUSVDUVSJOH SBDF SFMBUJPOT OPU KVTU UIF
6OJUFE 4UBUFT CVU BDSPTT PUIFS TPDJFUJFT BT XFMM
ćJSE BOE NPSF PQUJNJTUJDBMMZ XF TIPX UIBU EJČFSFODFT JO BUUJUVEFT DBO BUUFO
VBUF PWFS UJNF XJUI JOTUJUVUJPOBM JOUFSWFOUJPOT "T XF TIPX JO PVS BOBMZTJT JNQPS
UBOU MFHJTMBUJPO MJLF UIF $JWJM 3JHIUT "DU PG ƉƑƎƌ BOE UIF 7PUJOH 3JHIUT "DU PG ƉƑƎƍ
BMPOH XJUI UIF TPDJFUBM DIBOHF JOTUJHBUFE BOE NPWFE GPSXBSE CZ UIF $JWJM 3JHIUT
.PWFNFOU BOE TVCTFRVFOU MFBEFSTIJQ GSPN "GSJDBO "NFSJDBOT BOE PUIFS HSPVQT
IBWF CFFO NBTTJWFMZ TVDDFTTGVM JO FMJNJOBUJOH TZTUFNBUJD JOFRVBMJUJFT CFUXFFO GPS
NFS TMBWFIPMEJOH BOE OPOTMBWFIPMEJOH QBSUT PG UIF DPVOUSZ )PXFWFS UIFTF JO
TUJUVUJPOBM JOUFSWFOUJPOT BOE BQQBSFOUMZ DVMUVSBM JOUFSWFOUJPOT BSF MFTT FČFDUJWF
BU DIBOHJOH BUUJUVEFT TVHHFTUJOH UIF QFSTJTUFODF PG CFIBWJPSBM QBUI EFQFOEFODF
-BXT DBO DIBOHF FDPOPNJD JOEJDBUPST BOE WPUFS SFHJTUSBUJPO PODF FDPOPNJD JO
DFOUJWFT IBWF DSFBUFE B DVMUVSF PG SBDJBM IPTUJMJUZ IPXFWFS UIFZ DBOOPU TP FBTJMZ
DIBOHF QFPQMFT IFBSUT BOE NJOET ćFTF DPNQPOFOUT UBLF MPOHFS UP DIBOHF BOE
UIF ESBNBUJD QFSTJTUFODF PG UIFTF BUUJUVEFT XF CFMJFWF BSF B DPOUSJCVUJOH GBDUPS UP
POHPJOH SBDJBM JOFRVBMJUZ XJUIJO UIF 6OJUFE 4UBUFT
© Copyright 2025 Paperzz