Analysis of Lead (Pb) in Antacids and Calcium Compounds for Proposition 65 Compliance Ruth E. Wolf The Perkin-Elmer Corporation 761 Main Avenue, Norwalk, CT 05859-0324 USA INTRODUCTION The Safe Drinking Water & Toxic Enforcement Act of 1985, or the law more commonly referred to as “California Proposition 65”, applies to all companies with more than 10 employees doing business in the state of California (1). Proposition 65 is a voter initiative passed to address citizen concerns regarding exposure to chemicals which cause cancer or reproductive toxicity. Under this law, businesses are prohibited from: (a) discharging listed chemicals to potential sources of drinking water; and (b) exposing people in the state to listed chemicals without prior warning. Lead is one of the elements identified by the State of California as both a cancer-causing agent and a reproductive toxin (2). Under California Proposition 65, the “no significant risk level” or NSRL established by the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment for lead exposure is 0.5 µg/day (3). One of the more common areas of concern is that people who routinely use calcium-containing dietary supplements and antacids may exceed this limit. Since antacids and dietary supplements are commonly ingested by people in significant amounts on a daily basis, many manufacturers of supplements and the calcium-containing compounds used in them are now testing these materials for lead content. Since the actual dose may vary due to intake rate, the level of lead present in a material is generally reported in units of µg lead per gram material (µg/g). Since the NSRL level established for lead is given as a total exposure of 0.5 µg/day, it is necessary to determine what detection levels are AS ABSTRACT Compliance with California Proposition 65 requirements for the monitoring of lead in calcium-containing compounds used in dietary supplements requires the analytical methodology used to have detection limits below 0.05 µg/g in the solid material. The analytical capabilities of Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS) make it one of the techniques of choice for performing lead analyses at these low levels. Data are presented showing the accuracy and precision of analyses performed using ICP-MS. Interferences that can occur during sample analysis and the suitability of simple acid dissolution techniques for various calcium-containing matrices are also discussed. needed for monitoring purposes. For example, the U.S. RDA (Recommended Daily Allowance) for calcium in the adult diet is 1000 mg. If the entire RDA were to be obtained from a single calciumcontaining supplement, the lead concentration in that supplement must be less than 0.5 µg/g. In order to state that a material has a Pb concentration less than 0.5 µg/g, the detection limit of Pb by the selected analytical technique must be significantly below 0.5 µg/g to ensure reliable and accurate results. Ideally, the Limit of Detection (LOD) should be a minimum of 10 times lower than the required quantitation limit. For this example, an analytical detection limit of 0.05 µg/g or lower would be necessary to perform reliable quantitation of lead at the required level. As a result, suggested methods for analysis of lead at these low levels include Graphite Furnace Atomic Atomic Spectroscopy Vol. 18(6), November/December 1997 169 Absorption (GFAA) and Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS). Of the two methods, comparison work done by a commercial laboratory has shown that ICP-MS has better detection limits, precision, and accuracy than GFAA (4). This paper will discuss the ICP-MS determination of lead in a variety of calcium sources, including calcium carbonate, anhydrous dicalcium phosphate, dicalcium phosphate dihydrate, and tricalcium phosphate. EXPERIMENTAL Instrumentation For this work, the Perkin-Elmer SCIEX ELAN® 6000 ICP-MS (PerkinElmer SCIEX Instruments, Concord, Ontario, Canada), equipped with a Ryton® spray chamber, cross-flow nebulizer, and a Perkin-Elmer® AS-91 autosampler, was used to perform the analysis of several calcium compounds after dissolution in nitric acid. The instrument conditions used are given in Table I. For most of the analyses reported in this work, only lead was determined in order to illustrate the applicability of ICP-MS for this particular analysis and the speed with which it can be performed. Additional analytes including arsenic, cadmium, chromium, and others may be determined simultaneously using ICP-MS and will be the topic of a future publication. The total acquisition time for each sample was 18.5 seconds. Including sample uptake, stabilization, and washout time, a new sample was analyzed approximately every 2 minutes. The use of the autosampler and automated quality control software allowed complete unattended operation, including monitoring of replicate precision, check standards and internal standards. Reagents and Standard Solutions Optima® (Fisher Scientific, Pittsburgh, PA USA) nitric and hydrochloric acids were used to prepare all samples and standards. Reagent water (18 MΩ or better), prepared by mixed-bed ion exchange (Continental Water Systems), was used to prepare all dilutions, blanks, and standards. Stock multi-element standard solutions including PE Pure AS Standards from Perkin-Elmer (Norwalk, CT USA), High-Purity Standards (Charleston, SC USA), and from Inorganic Ventures (Lakewood, NJ USA) were used to prepare all standards, spikes, and internal standard solutions. Certified standard reference materials SRM 1400 Bone Ash and SRM 1486 Bone Meal were obtained from the National Institute TABLE I Operating Conditions ICP RF Power: 1200 W Cones: Nickel Nebulizer gas flow: 0.92–0.96 L/min Analog detector voltage: –2200 V Pulse stage detector voltage: 1200 V Lens voltage: AutoLens™ Sample uptake rate: 1 mL/min ++ Ba /Ba ratio: <3.0% CeO/Ce ratio: <3.0% 159 Isotopes monitored: Tb, 165Ho, 209Bi, 206Pb, 207Pb, 208Pb Scanning mode: Peak hopping Dwell time: 100 ms Total integration time: 1 s per isotope Number of replicates: 3 Total analysis time: 18.5 s of Standards and Technology (NIST, Gaithersburg, MD USA). All standards were prepared in pre-cleaned polypropylene autosampler tubes (Sarstadt, Germany) using prerinsed metal-free tips and mechanical air displacement pipettes (Fisher Scientific, Pittsburgh, PA USA). Sample Preparation Samples of antacid tablets, calcium carbonate, anhydrous dicalcium phosphate, dicalcium phosphate dihydrate, and tricalcium phosphate were obtained from various manufacturers for testing. The samples were prepared using a simple acid dissolution procedure. Although some of the samples were heated gently for 5–10 minutes to aid dissolution, they were not rigorously digested for an extended period of time. The samples were either obtained in powder form or crushed to produce a fine powder. For the antacid A, antacid B, calcium carbonate, tricalcium phosphate-Lot A, NIST SRM 1400, and NIST SRM 1486 samples, a 0.5-g portion was accurately weighed into a pre-cleaned, acid-soaked Erlenmeyer flask. A second portion of the tricalcium phosphate-Lot A, antacid A, SRM 1400, and SRM 1486 samples was weighed out for the purpose of performing a pre-dissolution spike. A small amount of water was used to rinse the samples into the flask and 5 mL of concentrated nitric acid was added to each flask. To prepare the spikes, 500 µL of a 10-mg/L stock standard solution was added to the second portion of tricalcium phosphate-Lot A, antacid A, SRM 1400, and SRM 1486, giving a final spike concentration of 10 µg/g. The flasks were put onto a hot plate and gently warmed for 5–10 minutes to aid dissolution. The antacid A, calcium carbonate, tricalcium phosphate Lot A, and NIST SRM 1400 dissolved immediately. The antacid B sample required an additional 5 mL of nitric acid before dissolving and SRM 170 1486 Bone Meal required both an additional 5 mL of nitric acid and 5 mL of hydrochloric acid to go into solution. After the samples were dissolved, the flasks were cooled and transferred into cleaned polypropylene 50-mL autosampler vials and diluted to 50 mL. The total dissolved solids content of these samples after dissolution was approximately 1%. The samples of anhydrous dicalcium phosphate, dicalcium phosphate dihydrate (Lots A, B, and C), and tricalcium phosphateLot B were obtained in a powdered form from the manufacturer. A 2.5-g portion of each powder was accurately weighed and transferred into a pre-cleaned 50-mL autosampler tube using reagent water to rinse the powders into the tube. Approximately 20 mL of reagent water and 10 mL of nitric acid were added to each tube. After the powders dissolved, the samples were taken up to 50 mL using reagent water. The total dissolved solids content of these samples was approximately 5%. Interferences Two of the significant advantages of ICP-MS include the sensitivity and selectivity of the technique. Any isobaric spectral overlaps that occur when elements have isotopes at the same nominal mass-to-charge ratio are predictable and can generally be avoided by proper isotope selection or corrected for using interference correction equations. Lead is a naturally occurring element that has four isotopes: 204 Pb (1.4% abundant) 206 Pb (24.1% abundant) 207 Pb (22.1% abundant) 208 Pb (52.4% abundant) The abundance of the Pb isotopes may vary depending on the source of the lead. Isotopes that originated as part of the formation of the galaxy are considered “stable” and their isotopic composition has AStomic pectroscopy Vol. 18(6), Nov./Dec. 1997 remained constant throughout geologic time (5). The second source of lead is radiogenic lead or lead that results from the radioactive decay of an unstable parent. Three of the isotopes of lead, 206Pb, 207Pb, and 208Pb, are radiogenic decay products of either uranium or thorium. The fourth lead isotope, 204 Pb, is considered “stable”, but is rarely used for quantitation because of its low abundance and isobaric overlap with the 204Hg isotope. 208 Pb is the most abundant and most frequently used isotope for quantitation; however, different sources of lead may have slightly different 206Pb, 207Pb, and 208Pb abundances. In order to avoid problems caused when the isotope abundances of 206Pb, 207Pb, and 208Pb vary due to differing sources, the isotopes of 206Pb, 207Pb, and 208Pb were added together using the interference equation in Table II to perform the lead calculations. This is a commonly used elemental correction and is recommended by the U.S. EPA in Methods 200.8 and 6020 for regulatory analysis of environmental samples by ICP-MS (6,7). TABLE II Interference Equations Element Interference Equation Pb 208c = Pb 208u +Pb 207u+Pb 206u where c = corrected intensity and u = uncorrected intensity Another type of interference that can occur in ICP-MS includes signal enhancement or suppression due to the presence of matrix species. This type of interference can be corrected for by using internal standards and/or dilution of the sample matrix. One such interference discovered in the course of this work was that the calcium phosphate sample matrix caused a delay in achieving stable analyte and inter- nal standard signals. It was found that even in the diluted samples, the presence of high levels of Ca and POx (x=1–4) ions in the sample matrix caused a delay in the stabilization of the analyte signal. One of the results of this delay, if the analyst is not aware of its occurrence, is that the analyte and internal standard element signals appear to be significantly suppressed. This can lead to over-correction of the results by the internal standard response and poor reproducibility between individual replicates during the analysis, because the signal is not at a steady state. Indeed, this kind of temporal suppression was observed due to the calcium matrices and the initial indications were of severe (up to 70%) suppression of the internal standards. Upon closer examination, it was shown that the signal maximum was slow to occur and that the analytical readings were taken during the stabilization period, leading to low average signal levels and poor replicate standard deviations. The solution in this case was a simple one. The read delay time or the waiting time between the introduction of a new sample and the reading of the signal level by the ICP-MS was increased from 10 seconds to 20 seconds. The result of the extra read delay time was excellent precision between replicates and the internal standard signals were no longer artificially suppressed. The cause of this type of matrix-induced interference is beyond the scope of this work, but has been recently researched and discussed by others (8). Sample Analysis A 1:20 dilution was performed on all the dissolved samples using reagent water as the diluent. After this dilution, the total dissolved solids content of the samples was 0.1–0.5% depending on the dissolution procedure used. All calibration blanks, standards, and diluted sam- 171 ples were spiked with 20 µg/L of Bi, In, Tb, and Ho as internal standards. The samples were capped and shaken well to mix before placing on the autosampler. SRM 1486 had some grease residue formation after cooling. The aliquot taken from this sample for dilution was obtained by inserting the pipette tip well into the autosampler vessel and withdrawing an aliquot away from the surface layer of residue. This aliquot was diluted 1:20 with reagent water. The instrument was calibrated for Pb at 0.1, 1, 5, and 10 µg/L using calibration standards prepared in 1% nitric acid. The correlation coefficient obtained for the Pb calibration curve using a linear through zero curve type was 0.9999. Check standards were run every 10–15 samples and the internal standard levels were monitored throughout the course of the analysis by the automated native ELAN NT quality control software. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Detection Limits The detection limits were calculated by analyzing 1% nitric acid blanks, tricalcium phosphate (Ca3PO42), and calcium carbonate (CaCO3) matrices. The Instrument Detection Limit (IDL) is a measurement of the best achievable detection limit of an instrument and is defined by IUPAC (International Union of Pure and Applied Chemists) as the concentration that produces a net intensity equivalent to three times the standard deviation of the background signal. Since IDLs are typically measured in clean solutions, such as nitric acid blanks, they may be unrealistically low for most practical analyses. They may, however, be useful in comparing different techniques and instrumentation. The IDL was calculated by the following: IDL = 3(σ1% nitric acid Pb concentration ) where σ is the standard deviation of a minimum of seven replicate measurements. Since most of the measurements made for this application are on solid samples, it is appropriate to determine the detection limit in the solid. The IDL in the solid was calculated based upon the analytical dilution (1:20) used during the analysis and the sample preparation method. In this case, the IDL (µg/g) was calculated as: IDL in µg/g = (IDL in µg/L)(20)(1L/1000 mL) (50 mL final volume/2.5 g sample) Since the determination of lead in calcium-containing matrices is the goal of this study and the detection limits may differ from that in a clean nitric acid solution, the Method Detection Limits (MDLs) for the calcium phosphate and calcium carbonate matrices were determined. The Pb concentration in eight individual aliquots of each matrix was measured. The MDL was calculated as follows: MDL = 3(σblank matrix Pb concentration ) The MDL in the solid was calculated based upon the 1:20 analytical dilution used during the analysis and the sample preparation method. In this case, the MDL (µg/g) was calculated as: MDL in µg/g = (MDL in µg/L)(20)(1L/1000 mL)(50 mL final volume/2.5 g sample) Based on the data in Table III, it can be concluded that the detection limits for Pb using ICP-MS are well below the limit necessary for the analysis of Pb in calcium matrices, assuming the adult dosage of 1000 mg/day. In fact, when the ratio of the NSRL of 0.5 µg/g to the MDL is calculated, the method detection limits are between 60 and 250 times below the NSRL. Method Validation and Accuracy In order to assess the accuracy of the method, two NIST Standard Reference Materials (SRMs) were prepared and run along with the samples. SRMs are useful in assessing overall method accuracy and evaluating potential method bias, because they are prepared as homogeneous materials and are certified for element concentrations using more than one analytical technique. The two SRMs used for this work were SRM 1400 Bone Ash and SRM 1486 Bone Meal. The results obtained are shown in Table IV. Each result is the mean value of three replicate measurements of the prepared sample and the error listed is the standard deviation of the replicate measurements in concentration units. The agreement between the ICP-MS results for SRM 1400 and the NIST certified value for lead is excellent, indicating that the dissolution and analytical methods used will give an accurate, non-biased result. Since the matrix in SRM 1400 is essentially an inorganic matrix composed primarily of calcium phosphate, it can be concluded that the ICP-MS method discussed here will work well for this type of sample. In addition, the pre-dissolution and post-dissolution spike recoveries are excellent, indi- cating that no analyte was lost in the dissolution procedure and that no matrix effects have biased the results. Although the values obtained for SRM 1486 are not within the stated confidence levels, they are within 90% of the stated mean value. It is believed that the result is lower than the stated value due to the sample preparation method used. It is possible that some of the Pb remained in the residue which was not sampled when the digestate was prepared for analysis. Again, the pre-dissolution and postdissolution spike recoveries for SRM 1486 are excellent. It can be concluded from this data that for materials having some organic components, a more rigorous digestion procedure will have to be employed to obtain more accurate results. Further studies are planned to verify this conclusion. The results for the nine individual samples are shown in Table V. Each result shown is the average of three measurements. The Relative Standard Deviation (%RSD) is also given as a measurement of the precision of the analyses. In all cases, better than 3% RSDs were obtained for each matrix, indicating the excellent precision obtained using ICP-MS. Two samples were selected to have pre-dissolution TABLE III – Detection Limits for Lead Calcium Phosphate Calcium Carbonate Matrix IDL =(3)(σ1% nitric acid) MDL =(3)(σsample matrix) MDL =(3)(σsample matrix) Solution 0.0008 µg/L 0.005 µg/L 0.008 µg/L Solid 0.0003 µg/g 0.002 µg/g 0.003 µg/g Sample ID SRM 1400 SRM 1486 TABLE IV – SRM Results Measured NIST Certified 10 µg/g preconcn value dissolution (µg/g) (µg/g) spike recovery 9.10 ± 0.11 9.07 ± 0.12 106% 1.207 ± 0.008 172 1.335 ± 0.014 101% 0.1 µg/g postdissolution spike recovery 109% 99% AStomic pectroscopy Vol. 18(6), Nov./Dec. 1997 spikes performed on them. These samples were dissolved with the addition of acid and mild heating as discussed in the sample preparation section. The spike recoveries are excellent and are generally within ±10% of the spiked value. The post-dissolution spike recoveries are also excellent and are all within ±11% of the spiked value, indicating that the matrix is not affecting the detection of small amounts of lead or changes in concentration to any significant extent. Long-Term Stability One of the known limitations of ICP-MS is the ability of the instrumentation to handle high levels of dissolved solids for a long period of time. Since the commercial development of the technique in 1984, instrument manufacturers have recommended that users keep the total dissolved solids content of the samples run on ICP-MS below 0.1–0.2% total dissolved solids for best instrument performance and long-term stability. Because of the use of interface cones with small orifices (0.8–1.1 mm) between the Table V – Sample Results Sample Tricalcium Phosphate-A Tricalcium Phosphate-B Calcium Carbonate Antacid - A Antacid - B Anhydrous Dicalcium Phosphate Dicalcium Phosphate Dihydrate-A Dicalcium Phosphate Dihydrate-B Dicalcium Phosphate Dihydrat -C 10 µg/g predissolution spike recovery (%) 0.05 µg/g postdissolution spike recovery (%) Measured concn (µg/g) %RSD n=3 0.105 0.108 0.315 0.114 0.259 0.88 0.60 1.03 2.84 1.28 0.089 0.62 89 0.093 0.70 90 0.159 0.89 101 0.168 0.75 102 99 99 92 90 93 106 90 Percent of original value Internal Standard Response 120% 100% 80% 60% Ho 165 40% 20% 0% 0:00 1:12 2:24 3:36 Elapsed Time (hours:minutes) 4:48 Fig. 1. Internal Standard Response vs Time. 173 ICP and the entrance to the ion optic region of the mass spectrometer, running samples with high levels of dissolved solids can eventually cause buildup and blockage of the cone orifices. For this reason, the use of internal standards to correct for instrument drift as the material slowly builds up on the interface cones is a commonly used and necessary practice in ICP-MS analysis. For this work, holmium (Ho) was used as the internal standard for Pb because it is similar in mass to lead and was not already present in the samples. Figure 1 shows the Ho signal measured in a 0.1-ppb calibration check solution as a function of elapsed time as the calcium samples were analyzed. The response in a check standard is used for this drift determination because there is no matrix in the check standard that may cause additional suppression of the signal, giving an indication of the degree of material present on the interface cones. The y-axis shows the Ho signal as a percent of the original signal level measured in the calibration blank. This value is automatically calculated and monitored by the ELAN NT quality control software. The dissolved solids levels of the samples analyzed in this study varied between 0.1–0.5% which is at the upper limit of what commercial ICP-MS instrumentation is designed to tolerate. A total of 123 samples were analyzed during the nearly five-hour time period shown in Figure 1. As illustrated by Figure 1, there was indeed a gradual drop in the internal standard signal as material built up on the interface cones. This decrease in internal standard intensities down to approximately 80% of the original value measured in the calibration blank is typical for the analysis of these types of samples over several hours. Indeed, the internal standard is still well within its ability to measure low level concentrations accurately as is illustrated by Figure 2. CONCLUSION It has been shown that the use of ICP-MS can provide accurate and precise results for the determination of lead in a variety of calcium matrices. Selection of suitable sample uptake and read delay rates was critical in obtaining reproducible and accurate data. Compared to clean nitric acid matrices, it was necessary to increase read delay times in order to deal with delayed signal response times caused by the sample matrix. Even with the use of long sample uptake and read delay times, the total time for each sample analysis was less than two minutes. Simple acid dissolution with 0.1 ppb Calibration Check Recovery Recovery (%) 120 Check Standard Figure 2 shows the percent recovery of the 0.1 ppb calibration check standard over the same time period as Figure 1. As illustrated by Figure 2, even though the internal standard response is only 80% of the original value, the measured concentration of the check standard remains stable at ±10% of the true value for the duration of the analysis. In fact the measured values stay within 99–107% of the actual value of the 0.1 ppb standard for nearly five hours. The internal standard response in the samples varied during this time period from 60–80% of the value measured in the calibration blank. The additional suppression seen during the analysis of the samples indicates some suppression of signal is also occurring due to the sample matrix. Although the overall signal intensities dropped over the course of the four hours, the precision of the three replicate measurements was not degraded. Furthermore, the excellent spike recoveries obtained in the sample matrices indicate that this suppression is being correctly compensated for by the internal standards and that the accuracy of the results is not being adversely affected by the matrix suppression. 110 Pb 208 100 90 80 0:00 1:12 2:24 3:36 4:48 Elapsed time (hours:minutes) Fig. 2. Check Standard Recovery vs. Time. and without heating was shown to be an effective sample preparation method for all matrices except SRM 1486 Bone Meal which appeared to have significant organic content present as fats. The detection limits obtained in calcium phosphate and calcium carbonate are suitably low for the determination of lead in calcium supplements below the NSRL of 0.5 µg/day. 6. “Method 200.8, Determination of Trace Elements in Water and Wastes by Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry,” in Methods for the Determination of Metals in Environmental Samples, Supplement I, EPA/600/R-94/111, USEPA Monitoring Systems Laboratory, Cincinnati, OH (May 1994). REFERENCES 8. “Fundamental Investigations of Steady State and Transient Acid Effects in ICP-AES and ICP-MS,” Ian Stewart and John W. Olesik, The Ohio State University, Paper No. 662, 24th Annual Conference of the Federation of Analytical Chemistry and Spectroscopy Societies (FACSS), Providence, RI (October 1997). 1. “Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986,” California Code of Regulations, Sections 25249.5 and 25249.6. 2. “List of Chemicals Known to the State to Cause Cancer or Reproductive Toxicity,” California Code of Regulations, Title 22, Section 12000, August 26, 1997. 3. “Method of Detection Argument in the Crystal Glassware Case,” Prop 65 News 9 (7) (July 1994). 4. “Lead in Calcium Supplements,” Application Note, West Coast Analytical Services Inc., 9840 Alburtis Avenue, Santa Fe Springs, CA 90670 USA (1997). 5. Handbook of Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry, K. E. Jarvis, A.L. Gray, and R.S. Houk, Blackie & Son Ltd., London (1992). 174 7. “Method 6020, Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Splectrometry,” in Test Methods for Evaluating Solid Waste, Physical/Chemical Methods, SW-846, Third Edition, U.S. Government Printing Office, Springfield, VA (1994).
© Copyright 2026 Paperzz