What Else Does a Geologist Do?

What Else Does a Geologist Do?
A lesson for the How the...Got to the Museum book series
OVERVIEW
In this activity, students look at some of the traits geologists use to identify meteorites and
use these traits to determine whether or not a variety of rocks are meteorites. Students then write
a letter explaining how they made their decision. This handout is based on source material from
How to Identify a Meteorite (2008. University of New Mexico. http://epswww.unm.edu/iom/ident/)
CAN BE USED WITH
þ How the Meteorite Got to the Museum
CONNECTIONS TO THE STANDARDS
THIRD GRADE:
NGSS
4-ESS1-1. Constructing Explanations and Designing Solutions
Identify the evidence that supports particular points in an explanation.
CCSS/ELA
CCSS.ELA-Literacy.CCRA.W.1
Write arguments to support claims in an analysis of substantive topics or texts using valid reasoning
and relevant and sufficient evidence.
FOURTH GRADE:
NGSS
4-ESS1-1. Constructing Explanations and Designing Solutions
Identify the evidence that supports particular points in an explanation.
Look for more curriculum on the “Librarian & Educator” page at www.BlueAppleBooks.com.
1
CCSS/ELA
CCSS.ELA-Literacy.CCRA.W.1
Write arguments to support claims in an analysis of substantive topics or texts using valid reasoning
and relevant and sufficient evidence.
PREP
For this activity, you will need an assortment of the following rocks, and enough samples so that
each group of 2-3 students in your class can examine at least one rock at a time:
• round river rock
• pumice or some other porous rock
•sandstone
•quartz
•geode
•granite
For each group of 2-3 students, you will also need
a piece of ceramic tile, a magnet, and a ruler.
Optional: 1 index card/sample per group.
Place each sample rock in a small container
(such as a petri dish, small box, or yogurt cup).
Label each container with a unique letter that
will be used as a reference for the sample.
Finding Rock Samples to Purchase:
• Check with your building science
teacher.
• River rocks, sandstone, granite: Try
landscaping suppliers or friends with
chip stone driveways, etc. Ask for a
donation of a few rocks.
• Pumice: These rocks are used for
pedicures. Look in health/beauty
aisles of grocery stores or drug stores.
• Quartz: landscaping suppliers,
museum stores, some jewelers and
New Age stores.
• Geode: online science suppliers
and museum stores, some jewelers
and New Age stores.
Make 1 copy of the student handout, Rock or Meteorite?
LESSON (POST-READING)
1. Have students explain the job of the geologist in How the Meteorite Got to the Museum. Ask
students to infer from the book what the difference is between a rock and a meteorite. (For this
lesson’s purpose, it is enough for students to know that meteorites come from space. Rocks are
formed on Earth.) How do students think the geologist knew that the rock was a meteorite?
2. Tell students that they are going to think like geologists by figuring out whether if any of a
variety of rocks are meteorites.
3. Show students the Rock or Meteorite? handout. Review it so that students will be able to use it
independently in Step 4. After reviewing the handout, distribute at least one “sample” (rock) to
each group. Tell students they should figure out a way to record and organize their information.
(As an alternative, provide a table format, or have students make index cards with notes about
each sample.)
4. Have students work in groups to determine whether or not the rocks are meteorites by using the
tests described on the Rock or Meteorite? handout. When a group finishes assessing all of its
samples, it should switch samples with another group.
Look for more curriculum on the “Librarian & Educator” page at www.BlueAppleBooks.com.
2
As student groups work together, circulate around the room to listen in on and provide occasional
support to the groups.
F acilitation T ips
• Make sure that students are recording their observations and decisions about each rock.
• Students may not be sure whether a sample is a meteorite because the clue sheet leaves
room for ambiguity—an authentic part of science. The goal of this activity is to allow
students to use their observations to form an opinion about whether these rocks are
meteorites. If students are unsure what they think, push them to explain why they are
uncertain based on their observations.
• Keep in mind that the back matter of this book provides a little bit of extra information
about meteorites. Students may want to review this before making any final decisions.
(The idea here is not to push the students into a conclusion but to allow them exposure
to the idea that meteorite finds are rare. This may carry weight for some students.)
5. After students have examined several rocks, ask them to imagine that someone has sent them
one of the rocks and asked if it is a meteorite. Assign one rock to each student and have
students work independently to write a letter to the person who found the rock explaining
whether or not the rock is a meteorite and how they know (or why they are uncertain). The
students should cite evidence that they recorded in their notes, and indicate where in those
notes or book the information can be found. (For example, “In the third row of my group’s
lab notes, you will see this information,” or, “As you can see in the second paragraph…”
or “I know from reading the back of How the Meteorite Got to the Museum that…”
EXTENSIONS
• Have students use what they know about rocks to identify the rocks in this activity and explain
what evidence they used to make their decisions.
• Have students research some other methods geologists use to determine whether a rock is a
meteorite.
CURRICULM CREATOR
Carolyn DeCristofano, M.Ed., is a STEM education consultant who specializes in curriculum and
professional development with Blue Heron STEM Education, which she cofounded. She has an
extensive background in museum education, including exhibit interpretation, teacher and student
programs, and exhibit development and research for national traveling exhibitions with the Museum
of Science, Boston, and the Harvard Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics. She is also an author of
nonfiction books for children, including the acclaimed A Black Hole Is NOT a Hole (Charlesbridge
Publishing, 2012). For this lesson, Carolyn collaborated with educators Katy Laguzza and Deb Dempsey.
Look for more curriculum on the “Librarian & Educator” page at www.BlueAppleBooks.com.
3
Rock or Meteorite?
Geologists look at rocks for clues to help them determine whether or not a rock is a
meteorite. Here are some clues to get you started.
Clue 1: Is the rock round?
Rocks are usually only round if water has
eroded their edges. Meteorites, just like
most rocks, are usually NOT round.
Clue 2: Does the rock have holes?
Meteorites are very dense, and so
they do not have bubbles or holes.
Clue 3: Is the rock smooth?
Meteorites usually have a smooth surface.
The surface is smooth because it melted
and then cooled as it fell through
Earth’s atmosphere.
Clue 4: Is the rock magnetic?
Meteorites will attract magnets because
of the iron and nickel metals they have inside.
Clue 5: Does the rock have crystals?
Meteorites do not usually have crystals.
Most crystals people know of are formed
on Earth and can’t be formed in outer space.
Clue 6: Does the rock make a mark?
SOURCE: How to Identify a Meteorite
(2008. University of New Mexico.
http://epswww.unm.edu/iom/ident/)
Look for more curriculum on the
“Librarian & Educator” page at
www.BlueAppleBooks.com.
When you scrape the rock against the rough
side of a ceramic tile, does it leave a mark?
Most meteorites will not leave a mark, but
some Earth rocks will.